This page features recent additions to the playlist, presented in reverse chronological order – programme notes for the latest 'day' appearing at the top.
Scroll down or click/tap one of the icons, as desired.
For older entries, you can more quickly locate specific programme notes
by switching to Playlist View
and selecting the appropriate day in the left‑hand column.
Day 610: Groven, Eivind (1901-77)
Symphony No 1 (Time: 30 minutes)
For me, one of the joys of putting together these postings is that they don’t just focus on the sort of composers and repertoire that would turn up on concert schedules or on the radio. And for me – and I know, perhaps I ought to get out more – it’s always a particular joy when I discover someone new, because having been a classical music obsessive for over half a century, it’s easy to assume that one has come across all the composers worth knowing about already and that, as they say, there’s nothing new under the sun. Well, I’m glad to say that discoveries keep coming, as when I accidentally stumbled across a YouTube video about someone entirely new to me a couple of weeks ago. Fortuitously, it’s also the 125th anniversary of his birth next week, which is as good a pretext as any for featuring him today (2/10/26). So let’s hear it, folks, for Eivind Groven. ‘Who?’ you ask. Well, read on… Eivind Groven (1901-77) was a Norwegian composer. Because there’s always a tendency to try to ‘place’ composers by comparing them to others, perhaps the best over-simplification of an answer to the question ‘Who was Eivind Groven?’ is to say ‘He was the Norwegian Vaughan Williams.’ Like all over-simplifications, there’s some truth in it, but it does Groven a disservice at the same time, as I hope to show. Groven was born in eastern Norway in the rural area of Telemark, which provides one clue as to what motivated him as a composer, because he and his family were deeply rooted in traditional Norwegian folk music. And the Vaughan Williams comparisons hold true at least in that Groven also collected regional folk songs and dance tunes, was part of a huge national project to preserve, record and catalogue them, and employed many of their characteristics in his own compositions. Early in life he had planned to become a teacher, but the music bug bit hard, and by his mid-twenties he was studying composition at Oslo Music Conservatory. By his late twenties he was employed by the Norwegian equivalent of the BBC to put together a 30 minute broadcast each week of Norwegian folk music. The result – such music being deeply unfashionable in allegedly musically cultured circles in Norway – was that he got quite a lot of abuse for it, but that simply made him more determined to safeguard the music’s past and promote its present. He collected over 2000 tunes himself, writing them down in ways he developed to try to reflect their distinct intervals and rhythmic structures. He notated recordings made of the Nuniamut people of Alaska, who used scales and harmonies entirely different from Western harmonic understanding. This led to experiments in acoustics and instrument construction, notably building an organ with the possibility of up to 36 tones per octave, rather than the 12 we’re used to in Western music, in order to accommodate the non-diatonic qualities of such folk music in performance. He composed throughout his life, and though there are identifiable phases of development across his output, the most obvious thread linking all his work is its use of the sorts of modal harmonies and unusual tunings that were present in Norwegian folk music but which had been ‘tidied up’ in the classical realm. I’ve come across a lovely quotation from the 20th century Norwegian composer Arne Nordheim about Groven, which says a great deal about his art: ‘If anyone asks the way to Groven’s place, they will receive the answer that they only have to follow their longing. It is to the east of noise, and to the west of today’s insane tempo – just by a forest lake. And on the other side there is someone playing.’ Groven rejected entirely the concept of ‘absolute music’ – all music, he said, was ‘about something’, and it’s interesting that the piece of his that I’ve chosen for today, his Symphony No 1, is evidence of that, even if, theoretically, the symphony is above all an abstract rather than a narrative concept. He wrote the symphony in the mid-1930s, though it was revised in 1950. It has a sub-title, ‘Towards the Mountains’, and its initial inspiration was a play by Norwegian playwright Hans E Kinck, called ‘The Cattleman’, which preoccupied Groven for over a decade before the symphony began to emerge. The 1937 version was heavily indebted to folk dance forms but Groven’s post-war revision removed the symphony’s third and fourth movements (he used them instead in his ‘Symphonic Dances’), and rearranged the remainder into the symphony’s final four movement structure. The most striking feature of the finished work, I think, is its sense of continuous development, transformation unfolding on many levels simultaneously, albeit at different rates – whether that’s melodic transformation or harmonic development or larger structural patterns. All that makes it sound a bit daunting and technical, but the experience of listening to it is anything but daunting. On the other hand, it’s also not anodyne or predictable – the melodic shapes you expect, the harmonic progressions you might be anticipating, and so on, are subverted … but ‘organically’, as it were, so that there’s a surprise round every corner. You might feel that this is identifiably ‘Scandinavian’ music (hints of Sibelius or Nielsen, say) but to my ears too there’s plenty of North American ‘wide open spaces’ stuff going on here – suggestions of Copland, or Hovhaness. To finish, here’s another quotation from Arne Nordheim: ‘While others made instrumentations of folk tunes, Groven created sounds, for example in his symphonies, which in my opinion are quite unique.’ (I’m working here on the assumption that nobody is going to write in to complain that you can’t have degrees of uniqueness…) YouTube has yet to come up with a video recording of Groven’s Symphony No 1, so for now we’re in audio-only territory. The recording I’ve chosen is by the Oslo Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by Sverre Bruland. You’ll find it here: Groven: Symphony No 1.
Day 609: Haydn, Joseph (1732-1809)
Trumpet Concerto (chamber version) (Time: 15 minutes)
Today’s edition needs no special pleading on my part, exploring as it does one of the greatest composers in the history of Western music (if you don’t believe me, you’re wrong!) and one of his most famous and regularly played works. The prompt for this is a concert to be given early next month by members of Ensemble 360, with guest trumpeter Matilda Lloyd, winner of the Young Artist Category in the 2026 Royal Philharmonic Society Awards earlier this year. A quick check of the archive of these playlist postings suggests that music by Haydn has appeared on 11 other occasions prior to today (25/9/26), which is only as it should be for a composer whose music spreads joy and good-health to all listeners. However, I’m aware that so far I’ve featured nothing of Haydn the composer of concertos (or ‘concerti’, if you prefer). There are some good reasons for this, the most obvious of which is that, for a composer so prolific in other fields, Haydn wrote very little in concerto form, and the vast majority of the pieces that do exist come from relatively early in his career, and so don’t fully reflect the mature composer’s dazzling range of skills. From the 1760s, in the very early years of his employment at the Esterhazy court, there are several keyboard concertos (only one, with its ‘Hungarian’ finale, gets any exposure these days), a handful of violin concertos, and from a little later in his life there are five concertos for that rather quirky solo instrument, the ‘lire organizzate’ – a kind of hurdy-gurdy. If I were promoting Haydn the composer of concertos to you (I am, in case you hadn’t noticed!) I’d suggest you listen to either of the two cello concertos that are verifiably by him (assumed to be lost until scores were found in the 1950s), which are wonderful … and also the Trumpet Concerto, which is where (see above) Matilda Lloyd comes in. Trumpet concertos in general have had a patchy historical life, their popularity being dependent in part on the development of the instrument. Like all brass instruments, the trumpet was originally to be found in military or ceremonial contexts, and like the horn (though not the trombone, which had a ‘slide’ to allow its performers to access a wider range of notes) the trumpet was originally just a metal tube, usually over two metres long, with a mouthpiece at one end and a ‘bell’ at the other. Being restricted by this arrangement to playing only notes of the harmonic scale, in which accessible notes at the lower end were more widely spaced apart, only getting much closer together at the very high end of the range, the trumpet was, in the Baroque period, very useful for flashy top-end virtuosity (listen to the Brandenburg Concerto No 2 by Bach, for example), but entirely unable to play notes spaced much more closely together at the lower end. Still, ingenuity (like necessity) being someone’s mother, attempts were made to get round this technical problem, and we owe Haydn’s Trumpet Concerto to one such solution. A friend of Haydn’s, and a member of the Vienna Court Orchestra, one Anton Weidinger experimented with a range of different designs in the 1790s, eventually coming up with what is now a museum piece only, the keyed trumpet. As the name suggests, the instrument’s tube had keys attached, in the manner of keys on a wind instrument, which allowed the player to create a wider range of notes. Just to conclude the technical bit, it’s worth saying that Weidinger’s instrument fell out of use about a couple of decades later, replaced by the altogether more reliable valved trumpet, which is what we have today … and one consequence of that was that Haydn’s concerto fell out of the repertoire, and didn’t really get rediscovered until the 1930s. However, back in 1796, when the keyed trumpet was at the cutting edge of technological change, Haydn was so inspired by its possibilities that he wrote a concerto – his first in many years – to show off what it could do. The concerto is in the familiar three movements (fast – slow – fast) and lasts about 15 minutes, Haydn being sensitive to the needs of a performer’s lungs and lips. Haydn, as those who’ve read of my enthusiasm for him in previous postings will know, was a bit of a card, and the concerto opens with an orchestral introduction which the trumpet joins in with, during the course of which all the notes it plays are ones that could have been played on a ‘natural’ trumpet of old. ‘So what?’ an audience member might think. But then the soloist gets the spotlight (or its late 18th century equivalent), and starts to perform tricks – a run up and down a C Major scale, a sinuous melody in the instrument’s lower range, as well as the familiar repertoire of trips and jumps, and the odd fanfare or two, as if to say ‘Yes, this really is just a trumpet’. But it’s the slow movement that really displays what Weidinger’s instrument could do. Although we might think the trumpet is at times reduced to an accompanying role here, its listeners would surely have felt like they were listening to the impossible: melodies of a sort that might have been played on an oboe, say. The last movement is one of Haydn’s familiar scampering rondos, mixing fanfare-like interjections with some innovative song-like melodies. In Haydn’s original scoring of the concerto, the trumpet was backed by a body of strings, and also pairs each of flutes, oboes, bassoons, horns and (orchestral) trumpets, and timpani. However, in Ensemble 360’s performance, the forces will be considerably reduced, to five solo strings. This ‘chamber’ arrangement, by Jan Leontsky, was made just over a decade ago, and – courtesy of YouTube – that’s what you have here, performed by trumpeter Daniel Schinnerl-Schlaffer (now a member of the Vienna Philharmonic) and the string players Hannah Cho, Ulisse Masson, Samuel Mittag, Benedikt Sinko and Hana Jeong. You’ll find the performance here: Haydn: Trumpet Concerto (chamber version).
Day 608: Liszt, Franz (1811-86)
Les Preludes (Time: 18 minutes)
Later this month, the Hallé Orchestra and its Principal Conductor Kahchun Wong open the 2026/27 orchestral season here in Sheffield, and the piece that opens the Hallé’s programme, Liszt’s symphonic poem ‘Les Preludes’, is my musical choice for today (18/9/26). We’ve had music by Liszt on five occasions to date, and back on Day 424 I featured his symphonic poem ‘Mazeppa’, so I’d encourage you to find your way there if you want any discussion of Liszt the orchestral innovator and ‘inventor’ of the symphonic poem. I’ll restrict today’s discussion to ‘Les Preludes’ itself, there being, as you’ll see, quite a lot to say. It’s by some distance the most popular and most regularly performed of Liszt’s 13 symphonic poems, largely because it has one particular ‘banging tune’, which in various guises features again and again through it’s (roughly) 18 minute span. An awful lot of Liszt’s works had complex gestation periods, and ‘Les Preludes’ is no exception. It seems to have started life in 1844 when Liszt was still a Europe-trotting virtuoso megastar. He had planned to write a choral cantata called ‘The Four Elements’, based on the verse of the French poet Joseph Autran. By a year later, as Liszt was on tour in the Iberian Peninsula, he’d put together an overture for this choral work, and this is the first sighting of the music that was to become ‘Les Preludes’. In 1848 Liszt officially retired from performing life (aside from special performances at charity fundraisers, or for special audiences like, say, the Pope) and took up a post in the German state of Weimar, where, ideally for him, he had the court orchestra at his disposal, with which he could try out new musical ideas. This period (1848-58) saw the emergence of all but one of Liszt’s symphonic poems, and of these ‘Les Preludes’, although it is labelled ‘No 3’ in the catalogue of these works, seems to have been the first to be completed – at least in some form, though, Liszt being Liszt, it was then revised somewhat over the years. By 1853-54 the original cantata overture had acquired a new name, although all the evidence suggests that the piece was complete before Liszt gave it its extra-musical title and narrative. This took its inspiration from an ode (called, funnily enough, ‘Les Preludes’) by the French poet Lamartine. Someone – that someone may have been Liszt, but more probably was his then mistress and subsequent life companion Carolyne zu Sayn-Wittgenstein – prefaced the music with these somewhat portentous words: ‘What is our life but a series of preludes to that unknown song whose first solemn note is tolled by death? The enchanted dawn of every life is love. But where is the destiny on whose first delicious joys some storm does not break? ... And what soul thus cruelly bruised, when the tempest rolls away, seeks not to rest its memories in the pleasant calm of pastoral life? Yet man does not long permit himself to taste the kindly quiet that first attracted him to nature’s lap. For when the trumpet sounds he hastens to danger’s post, that in the struggle he may once more regain full knowledge of himself and his strength.’ Make of that lot what you will, but it does at least offer some sort of narrative (an emotional journey rather than a ‘plot’ as such) for the development of the music Liszt had composed. It’s conventional to see the work as consisting of five sections, though (this is the key thing for Liszt in terms of thematic transformation) they run continuously. These sections have the titles ‘Question’, ‘Love’, ‘Storm’, ‘Bucolic Calm’ and ‘Battle and Victory’, but the whole piece is derived from a single theme that, after a couple of pizzicato chords, is heard at the outset, or at least from portions of that theme that are in various ways reshaped and developed. I could at this point analyse the work’s structure in more detail, but I think it’s more satisfying simply to experience its various phases and to notice, as you listen, the ways in which Liszt ties its various ideas together thematically, harmonically and rhythmically. (Or just let it wash over you, as you prefer…) It’s worth saying that for the several performances of ‘Les Preludes’ that were given over the following 25 years, Liszt kept changing the ‘programme’, until it seems to have been shorn of all its Lamartine-related poetic apparatus, with Liszt simply focusing on the music’s interest in cyclic form – so that each statement of the core theme is a ‘prelude’ to the next, in a continuous thematic transformation. In more recent times, the music has had an unhappy relationship with Nazi Germany (its main theme was used to preface Nazi news bulletins), and at around the same time as theme music for the 1940s American serial 'Flash Gordon Conquers the Universe'. You may also have come across it if you've had an unfortunate addiction to 'The Lone Ranger' as serialised on the radio, and on at least one episode of 'Tom and Jerry'. (That's quite a lot of extra-musical baggage to carry around, none of which is Liszt's fault...) YouTube has a fair number of decent recordings of Liszt’s ‘Les Preludes’, so if you don’t like the one I’ve chosen there are plenty of others out there. But I’ve gone for a video recording of a concert given by the Orchestre de Paris, conducted by the one-time principal conductor of the BBC Phil, Gianandrea Noseda. You’ll find their performance here (and don’t be confused by the fact that the first 30 seconds of the recording are actually of the start of Bruch’s Violin Concerto No 1!): Liszt: Les Preludes.
Day 607: Muffat, Georg (1653-1704)
Sonata V (from 'Armonico Tributo') (Time: 20 minutes)
Imminently, the renowned period instrument ensemble The English Concert will be in Sheffield, playing music by, amongst others, the composer I’m featuring today (11/9/26), Georg Muffat. There are good reasons why Muffat isn’t as well known as he should be, mostly a consequence of the political and military disruptions of the age he lived through. Life was frequently messy for inhabitants of Passau (now in Bavaria, Germany, but in the late 17th/early 18th centuries a city that was part of the Austrian Empire), and particularly so during the implausibly complex disruptions of the War of the Spanish Succession, when troops of the Elector of Bavaria laid siege to it. It was Muffat’s misfortune to be living and working in Passau at the time, when the city was starving and a typhoid plague was raging. Though he lived to see the city surrender in early 1704, he died a few weeks later, and in the chaos of the era almost all his manuscripts and possessions were lost. Consequently only a few publications bear his name, but those few contain some impressive music, as I hope to illustrate below. Muffat (1653-1704) is a contemporary of other composers who have come to be better known: Charpentier and Marais in France, Biber and Pachelbel in Germany, Blow and Purcell in England, Corelli and Torelli in Italy. What makes Muffat interesting, I think, is that he’s emphatically ‘pan-European’, subscribing to no particular national style but aiming to blend their characteristics into a richer whole. In a letter of 1695 he wrote: ‘The notes, the strings, the dear sweet music tones give me my tasks in life, and here [in his collection ‘Florilegium Primum’] I mingle the French style with the German and the Italian styles, foment no war, but perhaps exemplify in my music the harmony and dear peace desired by these peoples.’ (You can tell he lived and worked in turbulent times.) He was born in Megève, in what is now the Haute-Savoie region of south-eastern France, into family that traced its roots back to Scotland. Between the ages of 10-16 he appears to have studied with Lully in Paris, and by the age of 20 was organist at a ‘cathedral in exile’ (religious wars, eh?) in Alsace. In these decades of conflict he moved regularly – to Vienna, then Prague, then Salzburg, before finally settling in Passau in 1690. However, in musical terms, probably the key event of his life came in 1680 when the Archbishop of Salzburg gave him permission to leave his employment there to study for a time in Rome with the leading organist of the day, Pasquini. But it was not Pasquini who shaped his development so much as Corelli, whom Muffat met and studied with briefly. Crucially, Muffat was inspired by Corelli’s Concerti Grossi, Op 6 (not actually published until after Corelli’s death in 1713, but circulating in manuscript in the early 1680s). Muffat’s debt to Corelli is evident in letters written once he was back in Salzburg, such as this one: ‘I heard with great enjoyment and amazement some such beautiful concertos by the master artist Mr Arcangelo Corelli… When I observed many a difference in them, I composed some of these contemporary concertos myself, which were tried out at the home of the abovementioned Mr Corelli (to whom I feel obliged and from whom I profited owing to the many useful observations opportunely communicated by him to me concerning this style), and with whose blessing … I became the first to introduce into Germany some trial pieces in this harmony still unknown in these parts.’ Dating Muffat’s works with any precision is tricky, because he tended to accumulate pieces over a period and then publish them in collections later. There are two substantial suites of orchestral music (the Florilegium Primum of 1695 and the Florilegium Secundum of 1698), a compendium of works for organ (the Apparatus Musico-Organisticus – what a title! – of 1690), and a set of 12 Concerti Grossi published in 1701. This last collection contains in part a re-working of one of his earliest publications, the ‘Armonico Tributo’ of 1682. It is this early set of sonatas which is his direct tribute to the genius of Corelli. It’s a volume made up of five Sonatas, as he called them, but which are in effect pieces in ‘concerto grosso’ form – that is, for a mixture of solo performers underpinned by a larger ensemble of variable size and instrumentation. (One of the set’s selling points, noted Muffat, was that it could be performed by pretty much any combination of forces from three performers upwards.) The last of the pieces from ‘Armonico Tributo’, the Sonata V, is in five movements. The first is an Allemanda Grave, a solemn part-French, part-German dance movement. Then there’s an Adagio movement, showing the sort of harmonic richness Muffat learned from Corelli. The third movement is a Fuga, a complex and taut movement full of imaginative counterpoint. Fourthly there is another Adagio movement, which, like the second, features the sort of ‘walking bass’ underpinning that was a regular feature of baroque music. But it’s the fifth and final movement, a Passacaglia, that is the crowning glory of this Sonata. We’ve met passacaglias before – a set of variations on a repeated bass pattern – and Muffat composes 25 such variations, in music of almost hypnotic power. Opinions may vary on the relative quality of the various compositions in this form that emerged in the Baroque era. I don’t think Muffat’s Passacaglia here is in the same league as, say, the Chaconne (a term, like ‘Canon’, that was pretty much interchangeable with Passacaglia, unless you’re being very picky about it!) at the end of Bach’s Violin Partita No 2 from a few decades later, or even the Passacaglia for solo violin that concludes Biber’s set of ‘Mystery Sonatas’. But those, folks, are the pinnacles of the music of the era, and the last movement of Sonata V from Muffat’s Armonico Tributo is nevertheless very very fine indeed. And if you don’t believe me, listen for yourselves! YouTube has plenty of audio recordings of this Muffat sonata, but there’s also a fine video performance (shot in ‘atmospheric’ black and white!) given by the Kore Orchestra (about whom I can tell you little except that they appear to be Polish), led from the first violin by Aira Maria Lehtipuu, and with the harpsichord continuo part played by Marianna Henriksson. You’ll find it here: Muffat: Sonata V (from 'Armonico Tributo').
Day 606: Campagnoli, Bartolomeo (1751-1827)
String Quartet No 6 - 1. Largo (Time: 9 minutes), 2. Allegro Maestoso (6 minutes) and 3. Allegro Moderato (3 minutes); Caprice No 41 for Solo Viola (3 minutes); Sinfonia Concertante for Flute, Violin and Orchestra (19 minutes)
Today (4/9/26), I want to mark an impending anniversary of a birthday. The birthday in question will be the 275th, and the composer is one Bartolomeo Campagnoli, who will achieve that grand old age next Thursday. Now, you may (if you were feeling uncharitable) regard this as just one more example of my obsession with obscure composers – and in some ways you’d be right. However, I think there is a case to be made for Signore Campagnoli, even if at the end of this posting he continues to be a composer you wouldn’t go a long way out of your way to hear. Apart from the birthday anniversary thing, my main reason for wanting us to spend time with Campagnoli is that he illustrates a minor but often overlooked phenomenon: the development of what we generally regard as ‘Classical’ period musical forms outside the Austro-German mainstream. If you were to do a simple thought experiment and try to name the people you associate with, say, the development of the string quartet in the period 1770-1830, I suspect that all the people you might come up with are core members of the Viennese-based tradition: Haydn, Mozart, Beethoven, Schubert. Now, it’s not that people elsewhere in Europe weren’t writing string quartets. They were, whether in France (Pleyel), or Sweden (Kraus) or even England (Marsh or Wesley). But what about Italy? Well, Italian music was obviously well to the fore during the Baroque era, with its long list of names associated with the Italian violin tradition, from Corelli, through Vivaldi, to Torelli, Locatelli, Geminiani, Tartini and so on. But as the Baroque era gave way to the Classical one, Italian composers tended (clearly an over-simplified view, but the overall argument stands, I think) to shift from violin-based chamber music to opera, and those Italian figures who emerged as great opera composers in the first half of the 19th century (Rossini, Bellini and Donizetti are obvious examples) may have served an apprenticeship writing string music but were quickly lured away by the pull of the stage. At which point, enter Campagnoli, who is a perfect example of a sort of ‘transitional’ composer, neither Baroque nor Classical, but existing on the cusp of the two. Campagnoli (1751-1827) had a relatively obscure upbringing, but he quickly became one of the leading exponents of the Italian violin school in the latter half of the 18th century. The composer Tartini (1692-1770) taught several generations of composer/performers, one of the more notable being Pietro Nardini (1722-93 … and we’ll get to him one day). Campagnoli studied with them both, albeit briefly with Tartini just before the latter died, and more extensively with Nardini. But then, in his late 20s, Campagnoli did something relatively unusual: he travelled extensively and subsequently settled in northern Europe, taking up musical posts in several German states and even in Sweden, where he became a member of the Swedish Royal Academy of Music, before, in 1797, becoming Concert-master of the Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra, a post he held for 20 years before retiring to act in his last years as manager for the musical careers of his daughters. Does any of this matter? Well, I think it does, in that what we have in Campagnoli’s music is not just a meeting of the Baroque and Classical styles, but also a meeting of the Italian and Germanic musical traditions. I thought I’d try to illustrate this stylistic marriage by looking at three different pieces that Campagnoli wrote. First, a string quartet. Campagnoli wrote a set of six, although it’s not at all clear when. There’s a case to be made for a date in the 1780s (there are copies of the music in Frederick the Great’s library in Potsdam) or maybe in the 1790s. The quartets are all in three movements, so they’re evolving in a way which is different from the four-movement pattern of Haydn and Mozart in Vienna, and they lack the sort of complexity of musical argument that you’ll find in Haydn. I think the last of the six quartets is particularly interesting, with its substantial Largo first movement, a largely sombre set of variations that alternates vigorous virtuosity with more restrained and languid passages. The two remaining movements are much more brief and superficial, and Campagnoli had a particularly perfunctory way with endings, but nevertheless this is interesting stuff, I think. You won’t find a video recording, I’m afraid, and audio ones come only with links to individual movements, played here by the group Ensemble Symposium: Campagnoli: String Quartet No 6 - 1. Largo; 2. Allegro Maestoso and 3. Allegro Moderato. Campagnoli was also a teacher, and a promoter of his own ‘Method’ of playing string instruments. He wrote a set of 24 Preludes in all the major and minor keys for solo violin, and also (a more unusual undertaking) a set of 41 Caprices for Solo Viola in 1815, which turn up not just to polish the technique of violists, but also as concert encores in their own right. As an example picked pretty much at random, this is the last of them, the Caprice No 41, performed by Kristina Giles in a video recording which you’ll find here: Campagnoli: Caprice No 41 for Solo Viola. And finally, to demonstrate that Campagnoli had one foot in the ‘Classical’ camp, even if the other was firmly planted in the Baroque, here is a concerto that Campagnoli wrote in the last decade of the 18th century (probably!), in this case for flute and violin. It’s a piece of no great profundity, I think, but no little charm, and it demonstrates the sort of early Classical ‘elegance’ often associated with the generation before Beethoven. It’s in three movements, following the familiar fast-slow-fast pattern, and it’s performed here (audio only again, I’m afraid) by the Orchestra di Padova e del Veneto, conducted by Giancarlo Andretta. The soloists are Mario Folena on flute and Francesco Manara on violin: Campagnoli: Sinfonia Concertante for Flute, Violin and Orchestra.
Day 605: Süssmayr, Franz Xaver (1766-1803)
Quintet for Flute, Oboe, Violin, Viola and Cello (Time: 18 minutes)
Early next month, Ensemble 360 get their Music in the Round concerts underway for the autumn with an event that includes my composer in the spotlight for today (28/8/26), Franz Xaver Süssmayr. Now, regular readers will know that from time to time I like to introduce composers well off the beaten track. So, within the past year, you’ve had postings about Henri Tomasi, Philipp Jakob Riotte, Josef Bohuslav Foerster, Johann Bernhard Bach, Pierre Villette, Orlando Gough, Juan Crisostomo Arriaga, William Hurlstone, Tomas Breton, Uuno Klami and George Frederick Bristow … none of whom, I’d submit, are household names – even, as the quip has it, in their own households. But if, as I suspect, most would not have heard of many of the names on that list, today’s choice occupies a very different place on the musical map. Because I’m willing to wager (metaphorically, of course) that there will be quite a few who have heard of Franz Xaver Süssmayr … but at the same time, I suspect pretty much none will ever have heard any of the music he published under his own name. I’ll explain… Süssmayr (1766-1803) was a friend of Mozart. In fact, not just a friend. He was one of Mozart’s pupils, one whom Mozart evidently held in high esteem. Now Mozart, as I suspect everyone will know, died relatively young, and (unsurprisingly for one so prolific) with a number of incomplete works to his name at the time of his death. As far as his widow Constanze was concerned, the most pressing of those unfinished works was a setting of the Requiem Mass. This is *the* Mozart Requiem, the one that probably we all know, and many of us will have sung. What is also general knowledge is that the composer to whom Constanze Mozart turned to finish the job was Süssmayr, and almost all the performances of Mozart’s Requiem that you are likely to hear in your lifetime will be in the edition as completed by Süssmayr. (In recent decades a number of other versions have entered the repertoire, purporting to be more ‘authentic’, but Süssmayr’s was the first, and remains the most enduring.) If you are interested in a little bit of tittle-tattle, you may know that Mozart’s youngest child, born just a few weeks before Mozart died, was christened Franz Xaver Mozart. Why? Probably because of the esteem in which Mozart held Franz Xaver Süssmayr … but possibly because he was actually the child of Constanze and Süssmayr, who had been having an affair in the year before Mozart’s death. I leave that bit of idle gossip with you, and move on to higher things. How much of ‘Mozart’s Requiem’ is actually pure Mozart? Well, of the eight movements (and it was Süssmayr who decided on the structure), Mozart fully completed just the first (about five minutes’ worth), though the next movement, the Kyrie (another three minutes or so) was fully written out in terms of vocal parts, though it wasn’t orchestrated, and most of the dramatic ‘Sequenza’ section (maybe another 14 minutes) was written in vocal score, but with no orchestration at all. The rest of it – and we’re talking about roughly 27 minutes, in a typical performance – is not by Mozart at all, but by Süssmayr. So, when I claim that you’re very unlikely to have heard any music by Süssmayr, it’s strictly not true, assuming you’re not one of the half a dozen people in the world who’ve never heard Mozart’s Requiem. But – apart from that – have you ever heard any other music by Süssmayr? I doubt it very much, which is why the Ensemble 360 concert gives me the opportunity to rectify that omission. Süssmayr’s early musical education was from his father, then after a period in the employment of a Benedictine Abbey in northern Austria, he arrived in Vienna in his early twenties. He knew Mozart for roughly three years, got on well enough to help Mozart with his opera ‘La Clemenza di Tito’ (Süssmayr composed the recitative sections) and was, as they say, in the right place at the right time to make Mozart’s Requiem the work it is today. After that Süssmayr worked as music director in various theatres in Vienna, but by 1803 – as a result of what Wikipedia euphemistically describes as ‘an unregulated lifestyle’(!) – he was dead. He left to posterity quite a substantial amount of church music – including two settings of the Requiem mass other than the Mozart one – some half a dozen operas and a handful of orchestral and chamber works. The piece to be performed by Ensemble 360 is his Quintet for Flute, Oboe, Violin, Viola and Cello, an unusual, though not unique scoring. Dating the work is tricky, but some time just before 1800 seems likely. It is, perhaps unsurprisingly given Süssmayr’s musical experiences, a quite Mozartian work, particularly, I think, in its opening movement. This is an elegant sounding Allegro con brio, in which the flute and oboe are prominent but not obviously ‘soloists’. They weave in and out of the texture, and share the spotlight with the strings. The middle movement, a brief Adagio, is lyrical, and even operatic in character. Here the wind players do function more like soloists, in a kind of operatic duet, supported by the underpinning string sound. Finally the Rondo Allegretto third movement brings the work to a dancing conclusion. Each of the performers has an opportunity to shine, before they unite to round off the work in genial fashion. Is it any good? Well, it’s not Mozart, obviously, but as an example of the sort of music composed for the aristocratic palaces and burgeoning concert halls of early 19th century Vienna, it’s entirely typical. Süssmayr’s reputation faded fairly quickly after his death. His entry in the ‘Biographical Encyclopedia of the Austrian Empire’, written in the 1880s, notes: ‘While his friends called him a "second Mozart", more unbiased music critics find in his creations neither originality nor poetic depth; but they do not deny that they have melody and a charming, even folksy character, by means of which they met with a reasonably enthusiastic reception on the part of the public.’ It’s not what you’d call a ringing endorsement, but, well, we can’t all be Mozart, can we? For a work of such relative obscurity, there are a reasonable number of performances on YouTube to choose from. If you want a video recording (and feedback suggests most of you do), I can offer you this one, in which the performers are Cheng-Yu Wu (flute), Hsiao-Hsuan Chung (oboe), Ting-Shuo Chang (violin), Cheng-Hung Tsai (viola) and Shang-Hua Chou (cello), which you’ll find here: Sussmayr: Quintet for Flute, Oboe, Violin, Viola and Cello.
Day 604: Schumann, Robert (1810-56)
Waldszenen, Op 82 (Time: 22 minutes)
Today (21/8/26), I want to explore some music being heard in Sheffield next month by British pianist Sarah Beth Briggs, including ‘Waldszenen’ by Schumann. I’ve selected his work five times on this list to date, and so far I’ve featured just one of his famous collections of short piano pieces (one of Schumann’s favourite formats), the one called ‘Kinderszenen’ or ‘Scenes from Childhood’. Although Schumann employed large-scale forms during certain periods of his creative life (the symphonies, say, or the string quartets), he was at heart a miniaturist, either in songs or solo piano pieces, and the idea of evoking a mood, a location or a character in just a couple of minutes of music clearly appealed to him greatly. When it comes to his solo piano works, there are generally regarded as being nine of these collections that are at the forefront of his oeuvre: Papillons, Op 2; Davidsbundlertanze, Op 6; Carnaval, Op 9; Fantasiestucke, Op 12; Kinderszenen, Op 15; Kreisleriana, Op 16; Novelleten, Op 21; Nachtstucke, Op 23; and Waldszenen, Op 82. What stands out from just a cursory glance at that list is that the final collection, ‘Waldszenen’ (‘Forest Scenes’) has a much higher opus number – and thus dates from much later in his creative career – than the other sets. All of the collections except ‘Waldszenen’ were written in the 1830s, whereas that final set dates from the very end of 1848 and the start of 1849. In other words, these ‘Forest Scenes’ are not a product of Schumann’s youthful, early Romantic enthusiasm, but are instead from a considerably darker period of Schumann’s relatively short life. I’ve mentioned before that Schumann’s life was shadowed by mental illness. Conventional thinking is that he was bipolar, and the ‘downs’ in his life tended to be particularly extreme. There’s also evidence that he contracted syphilis, and this in turn affected his mental state. In the years 1848/49 Schumann was battling against a debilitating depression, and against that backdrop he was also struggling to hold down reliable employment, though his final, disastrous position, as director of music in Düsseldorf, was not to commence until 1850. One encouraging sign for him in 1848 was that he completed his opera ‘Genoveva’ – it didn’t fare well at its first, or subsequent, performances, and these days only the overture gets the occasional outing – and Schumann valued particularly its final act, which is set in a (medieval) German forest. As I’ve probably mentioned on many occasions during the writing of these notes, the idea of the forest was central to Germanic folklore, and this concept of ‘wild nature’ was particularly important to the Romantics, painters and writers as well as composers. For Schumann, and he was not alone in this, the idea of the forest signified not just ‘wild nature’, but explored man’s position in relation to the natural world (and thus, by extension, aspects of man’s nature, as it were, itself). Consequently, one can see at least some of the movements in this collection of nine short pieces as being abstract, conceptual, rather than just bucolic ‘scene painting’. Following his own and the general romantic tenor of the age, Schumann intended to preface many of the pieces with short snatches of poetry, but later he abandoned the idea … mostly – the verses remain at the head of one piece, the fourth in the set, the extraordinary ‘Verrufene Stelle’ (‘Haunted Spot’). Interestingly this movement was one that Clara Schumann, generally a passionate advocate of her husband’s music, refused to play, even in the decades after his death. However, though the poetry was largely dispensed with, Schumann did append descriptive titles to the nine movements, though even here he acknowledged their kind of ‘damned if you do, damned if you don’t’ quality: ‘The titles for pieces of music, since they again have come into favour in our day, have been censured here and there, and it has been said that “good music needs no sign-post.” Certainly not, but neither does a title rob it of its value; and the composer, by adding one, at least prevents a complete misunderstanding of the character of his music. What is important is that such a verbal heading should be significant and apt. It may be considered the test of the general level of the composer's education.’ Perhaps our response to the music should allow us to be the judge of that last point! The first movement, ‘Eintritt’ (‘Entrance’) clearly has a functional title, offering a rather bouncy initial exploration of the landscape. Then comes ‘Jäger auf der Lauer’ (‘Hunter in ambush’), with its sinister but not overtly threatening mood. Third is ‘Einsame Blumen’ (‘Lonely Flowers’), charming but tinged with sadness. However, the fourth piece, the troubling ‘Verrufene Stelle’, is seriously dark, disturbed by abrupt shifts of mood and dissonant harmonies. (The poetry attached to this movement, lines by the Romantic poet Friedrich Hebbel, reads: ‘The flowers, so high they grow, Are pale here, like death; Only one in the middle Stands there in dark red. Its colour is not from the sun: Nor from its heat; It is from the earth, And it drank human blood.’) The next couple of movements, ‘Freundliche Landschaft’ (‘Friendly Landscape’) and ‘Herberge’ (‘Wayside Inn’) are more innocuous, but then comes the collection’s other stand-out piece, ‘Vogel als Prophet’ (‘The Prophet Bird’). By any standards this is extraordinary. It’s weirdly ethereal music, somehow out of its mid-19th century time. It has an extensive life outside this collection, often being used as an ‘atmospheric’ encore by pianists in recital. The penultimate movement is ‘Jagdlied’ (‘Hunting Song’), bringing us back to the superficial, with its depiction of jolly ‘child-friendly’ hunters. Finally, there is ‘Abschied’ (‘Departure’), which attempts to return us to the seeming innocence with which we started out on our forest journey … though clearly we’ve been to some pretty dark places in between. ‘Waldszenen’ is pretty well served on YouTube, and from the options I’ve gone for a pianist that I don’t think I’ve featured in the years I’ve been making these postings, the Russian-born French pianist Arcadi Volodos, performing here in recital in Vienna in 2009: Schumann: Waldszenen, Op 82.
Day 603: Tomasi, Henri (1901-71)
Saxophone Concerto (Time: 18 minutes)
Welcome, today (14/8/26), to yet another posting exploring some of the more obscure reaches of the musical repertoire, prompted in this case by the fact that this coming Monday (August 17th) it will be the 125th anniversary of the birth of Henri Tomasi. He’s a composer we don’t hear a great deal about these days – in fact, he’s a composer that not a lot was heard about during his lifetime – but I’d suggest that he’s a very interesting composer, and while not as obviously front rank as we might consider his near contemporary Francis Poulenc, he is nevertheless definitely worth a moment in the faltering spotlight provided by the St Tim’s (etc.) Classical Playlist. What, then, of Monsieur Tomasi? Well, a consideration of his dates (1901-71) suggests that he was part of that generation (what one might call the ‘Les Six’ generation, made up of Poulenc, Milhaud, Honegger, Durey, Auric and Tailleferre), and for a time he found common ground with others from this era – he was a member of the loose array of composers in the 1930s called the Triton group, which consisted, alongside those I’ve named already, of figures like Martinu and Prokofiev, a collective founded by Pierre-Octave Ferroud (see Day 522). But Tomasi’s work suggests that he was nothing if not eclectic, and an overview of his output shows it’s almost impossible to pigeonhole him as a composer of a particular ‘school’. He was born in Marseille, where his father was a postal worker who had originally been a musician of, it seems, no little skill, and it was at his father’s insistence that he enrolled at the Conservatoire de Musique de Marseille as a seven-year-old. Despite the fact that as a teenager he seems to have wanted to be a sailor (life in a port city, eh?), he continued his studies, after the First World War, at the Paris Conservatoire. But his hand-to-mouth existence, playing the piano in cinemas, brothels, restaurants and the like to make ends meet, suggests a performer (and later a composer) who saw music as practical and often functional. In the 1920s, study in Paris led to appointments as a conductor as well as a pianist, but also these years saw his first compositions, pieces for winds being a particular feature of his musical language. He was one of the first composers to embrace radio – he was conductor of the Radio Colonial Orchestra of French Indochina from 1930-35, and later of the Orchestra of Radio France – and he pioneered not just studio and concert broadcasts, but also compositions which exploited the opportunities offered by ‘radiophonic’ music. In terms of his temperament, the Second World War seems to have had a deeply disturbing impact on his later decades. He lost his religious faith and seems to have become very sceptical of ‘solutions’ to the horrors of mid-20th century existence. For example, his final piece for the stage was called ‘In Praise of Madness (the Nuclear Era)’, and his rejection of European imperialist power in the third world led to the writing of his rather polemical ‘Third World Symphony’. He stopped conducting in the mid-1950s due to increasing deafness, but continued to compose right up to his death at the age of 69. His music is stylistically diverse – I think it would be hard to hear a piece of his and go, ‘Ah, yes, that sounds like Tomasi’ – and that eclecticism meant he embraced a lot of the different stylistic fashions of the first half of the 20th century, but he would use them as he saw fit (Debussyan impressionism, twelve-tone music like Schoenberg, jazz, and so on) rather than being hemmed in by any kind of doctrinal commitment. This comment, I think, is typical: ‘Although I haven't shirked from using the most modern forms of expression, I've always been a melodist at heart. I can't stand systems and sectarianism. I write for the public at large. Music that doesn't come from the heart isn't music.’ Alongside music for the theatre and opera house, there’s a great deal of chamber music, but also several concertos, such as those for violin (1940), trumpet (1949), saxophone (1949), horn (1954), trombone (1956), clarinet (1956), bassoon (1957) and flute (1966). Out of that selection, I thought I’d choose his Saxophone Concerto as the piece to illustrate Tomasi’s musical voice. It was actually written in part as an exam piece for the Paris Conservatoire in 1949, but its first performance in the concert hall came a year later under the famous French saxophonist Marcel Mule, to whom it was dedicated. It’s in two movements, and is scored for essentially a conventional symphony orchestra, though with an extensive percussion section. Tomasi was Mule’s exact contemporary, and like others who wrote for him (Milhaud, Ibert, Françaix), Tomasi responded vividly to Mule’s blending of the languages of classical and jazz. The opening movement has a jazzy mood, a bit like a work by Duke Ellington, maybe, though the subsequent livelier section has something of the feel of Ravel in its orchestration. After a long saxophone cadenza (accompanied in passing by the harp) the first movement surges to a dramatic conclusion. The second movement is marked ‘Gyration’, and this reflects the quick, circling motifs which make up the bulk of its ideas, before the work ends with a variant of the theme with which it began (but inverted – Tomasi’s music may feel fun but it plays some serious musical games), so that the ending is more majestic than bitter-sweet. There aren’t a lot of performances of Tomasi’s Saxophone Concerto on YouTube, but there’s one in particular that seems to me to capture the vitality and energy of the work. It’s by the Schleswig-Holstein Festival Orchestra (an ad hoc collection of international music students, in this case the 2024 iteration) conducted by Duncan Ward. The soloist is the very impressive German saxophonist Asya Fateyeva. You’ll find the performance here: Tomasi: Saxophone Concerto.
Day 602: Riotte, Philipp Jakob (1776-1856)
Symphony No 1 (Time: 26 minutes)
Today (7/8/26), we have another edition of this playlist which focuses on a composer so far off the beaten track that the route is probably impassable to all except the hardiest of travellers … which of course you all are, or you wouldn’t still be persevering with this weekly gift lighting up your inbox (or something). Anyway, as you’ll know by now, I have a great fondness for composers outside the mainstream, those unlucky enough to be born at the wrong time, or in the wrong place, those whose music has been lost to posterity because of war, or political censorship, or those whose moment in the spotlight was instantly usurped by someone whom history has deemed to be much more famous or influential or ground-breaking. So it is today with the almost certainly unknown Philipp Jakob Riotte, whose 250th birthday falls nine days from now, on 16th August. I’ve only recently come across his music myself, so I can’t claim any particular insights about his overall output, but the other day I listened to – and liked very much – a symphony by Mr Riotte, and so I thought I’d share the discovery with you all. So, what can I tell you about Riotte? Truthfully, not a lot, and almost everything that follows I’ve lifted from the Wikipedia entry about him, so you’re going to be a bit short-changed this week. Riotte (1776-1856) was born in the small town of St Wendel, which is in the far west of what is now Germany, close to Saarbrücken. About his family background I can tell you little, beyond the fact that his forebears seem to have been French Huguenots. After a fairly uneventful musical education (apart from the fact that he was expelled from his local church choir as a youth – can’t tell you why…), he seems to have spent his twenties as an organist and director of music at a number of smaller German and Polish courts, including time in Frankfurt, Gdansk and Magdeburg. However, by the time he was thirty he seems to have become an established musical figure in Vienna. It would be nice to think he rubbed shoulders with Beethoven (who was six years older), or that he knew the young Schubert, or had some other connection with what are now the famous names from that era in Vienna … but all that is merely speculation, because there’s no evidence for it (as far as I know). He remained in Vienna for the last fifty years of his life, most of that time being the chief conductor (or assistant to that figure) in various Viennese opera houses and theatres. According to Wikipedia, he had more than 300 performances of his works in Vienna, but almost all of those works have not found modern publishers or recordings. I’m aware that there’s a symphony (more on that in a moment) and also at least four concertos (one for flute, one for piano, two for clarinet), and a set of three string quartets. Even more obscurely still, there’s a piece for piano from 1810 called ‘Europens Wonnetag’ (‘Europe’s Day of Bliss’), which seems to have been prompted by a Napoleonic victory in the wars ravaging Europe at the time, and there’s a ‘Notturno’ for harp and violin. Getting a bit closer to the Vienna we know from Beethoven’s music, Riotte also composed a Piano Septet, dedicated to the Archduke Rudolf, a patron of Beethoven’s. You may know that Beethoven’s 33 Variations on a Waltz by Diabelli grew out of a scheme to publish a collection of single variations on that theme by 50 composers in Vienna at the time. Contributors included Liszt (only a boy back then!), Schubert, Czerny, Moscheles, Hummel … and Riotte! Of Riotte’s later life I can tell you even less than I’ve sketched out so far. He died without heirs (he seems never to have been married), which is almost certainly another reason why his music disappeared without trace … until the advent of the CD and music labels devoted to digging around in the musical undergrowth beyond the famous names of any era. That’s why I can turn up a recording of Riotte’s Symphony No 1 (I should say that I can find no trace of a ‘No 2’), a lively and good-natured four movement work which appears to date from around 1812. If you compared it to famous symphonies doing the rounds in Vienna in those years, it’s obviously not a patch on Beethoven (who was working on his 7th and 8th at the time), but I think it stands up well against the early symphonies of Schubert, say, or those of the early Romantics like Weber. The first movement starts with a brooding slow introduction, before the main body of the movement skips away with an almost (almost!) Schubertian grace. The graceful Andante con Moto second movement features some lovely writing for the winds, over a gentle string background. The third movement is a Scherzando marked ‘Presto’, and this seems to me to be the most forward-looking of the four movements. In fact, just occasionally I feel like I’m listening to something that threatens to turn into a Bruckner scherzo! Finally, the symphony ends with a Rondo marked ‘Allegro Molto’, full of touches that feel like they’re echoes of Schubert … but Schubert’s Symphony No 1, you may be surprised to know, post-dates this piece. I think it’s really sad that works like this (and composers like this) rarely get their day in the sun – so, in a minimal way, this is my attempt to rehabilitate him and his delightful symphony. As far as I know, there’s only ever been one commercial recording of this piece, so (audio only of course) that’s the one you’re going to get, played by the Stuttgart Chamber Orchestra, conducted by Gernot Schmalfuss. You’ll find it here: Riotte: Symphony No 1.
Day 601 – Silvestrov, Valentin (b.1937)
The Messenger - 1996 (Time: 11 minutes) and Hymne - 2001 (7 minutes)
Today (31/7/26), I’m marking the last (for now) of a series of postings which pick up on suggestions from others on this list. This time around the stepping off point is a proposal from Pete Dutton for a piece by the contemporary Ukrainian composer Valentin Silvestrov, whose music I am just beginning to explore. The work Pete wants us to hear is a short piece for string orchestra called ‘Hymne – 2001’, but as that lasts barely seven minutes I’m going to link it to another work by the same composer. But first, a few words about the man himself. Silvestrov is, by common consent, the leading Ukrainian composer, and the ‘grand old man’ of Ukrainian classical music. He’s now 88 years old, having been born in Kyiv in 1937. In some ways, his trajectory as a composer can be compared to that of his Estonian contemporary Arvo Pärt, who is a couple of years older. Both of them started out employing the prevailing musical language of the avant-garde ‘orthodoxy’, if you like, as they emerged from years of conservatory training and started to put new work before the public in Soviet-dominated Eastern Europe. And, like Pärt, Silvestrov came in his middle years to regard such music as unsatisfying – both to write and to listen to – and from the early 1970s Silvestrov began to radically simplify his style, and to root it, in terms of its identity and ‘meaning’, in relation to the music of the past. As you’ll know from what I’ve written about Pärt (see Days 33, 83 and 249, for example) this involved the development of what he called ‘tintinnabulation’, in which his music ‘echoed’ with recurring sonorities like the ringing of bells. In Pärt’s case this evolution came linked with his embrace of a contemplative Orthodox Christianity. There isn’t the same faith-based conceptualisation behind Silvestrov’s music, though – speaking just for myself here – I think there’s a definite sense of spirituality behind it. Curiously, Silvestrov wasn’t initially going to be a composer – or even a musician – and his early training was due to lead to a career as a civil engineer. However, whilst engaged in that training, he also enrolled in evening classes in music, leading to further study at Kyiv Conservatory with Boris Lyatoshynsky (one day, folks, one day – he’s definitely worth spending time with) and then a few years teaching music himself. However, from 1970 he has been a freelance composer. Until the Russian invasion of Ukraine in 2022 he was the figurehead of a cultural movement promoting an ‘independent’ Ukrainian musical identity (independent, most obviously, of the Russian tradition); in that year he fled Ukraine for Berlin (a hasty car ride to the Polish border, having failed to get onto any of the packed trains heading west from Kyiv), where he currently lives, though recent compositions are committed to the ongoing promotion of a distinct Ukrainian identity – musically, culturally and politically – such that he is in effect the leading musical spokesperson for his homeland. If there’s a particularly useful ‘way in’ to Silvestrov’s music, I think it might be this quotation: ‘I do not write new music. My music is a response to and an echo of what already exists.’ The past, in other words, exerts a very powerful gravitational pull on Silvestrov’s compositions. This force began to shape Silvestrov’s work in pieces like his String Quartet No 1, his ‘Music for Children’, and his ‘Three Pieces in Olden Style’ (all from the years 1970-75), and from then on the ‘olden style’ is evident in his compositions, echoes of and responses to a past that shapes his present. In the past three decades, if not longer, he has developed what you might see as his own version of post-modernism in music, something he describes as ‘metamusic’ (a shortened version of ‘metaphorical music’). Without getting too philosophical, I think you can hear in Silvestrov’s music a deliberate attempt at creating music which is sensitive to other, previous musics, to which it acts as a kind of postlude. I thought two pieces by Silvestrov might illustrate well his distinctive style. The first is a work from 1996 called ‘The Messenger’. This has a deeply personal inspiration, for in that year his wife died. Of her, Silvestrov wrote: ‘In my life there were a number of meaningful meetings … but the most meaningful was with my wife, musicologist Larissa Bondarenko. She was my first listener, understanding and very critical – without even a tiny drop of flattery…. I do not know what kind of music I would have written without Larissa. Even when I am writing my surname, I feel that I am some kind of impostor – this is how great a role she played in my life.’ ‘The Messenger’ takes its title – and its predominant idea – from the writings of the existentialist Soviet philosopher Yakov Druskin, whose ‘messenger’, a fictional character, represents a link between this world and the world beyond. In the piece as Silvestrov conceived it, the opening and closing sounds are played on a synthesiser, depicting the whispering evidence of the arrival and departure of this messenger. The messenger’s message – the main body of the piece – is a kind of shimmering contemplation of fragments of Mozartian melody, marked to be played ‘as if enveloped in mist’. The whole work is slow, hushed, almost trance-like. YouTube has several performances of the piece, and from them I’ve gone for this one by the French pianist Hélène Grimaud, supported by the strings of Camerata Salzburg (and a synth? – if it’s there, I can barely hear it!). You’ll find the recording here: Silvestrov: The Messenger - 1996. And finally to Pete’s suggestion, for a performance of Silvestrov’s ‘Hymne’ (sometimes ‘Hymn’) from 2001. Silvestrov himself provided an introduction to the piece: ‘My “Hymne” is enveloped in silence although it appears like a customary string setting on the outside. The paradox of Cage’s 4’33 [a piece ‘composed’ of the silence just before a soloist begins to play], is also present in latent form, but this is the ‘silence of new music.’ All melodic content from my other compositions can also be found here. A rest does not only constitute a lack of sound, but is also a state of retardation and paralysis or a suspension of time. In early music, there was an occasional need for silence, but here it is a fundamental feature.’ This is, I think, an emotional but absolutely not sentimental piece of music. Yes, it tugs at the heart-strings, but it’s the way the dissonances and harmonic clashes are generated and then resolved that stops it being saccharine in any way. The work performs a familiar ‘journey’, starting out from the main body of strings but unfolding into a tender solo violin melody, which leads the music, always on the edge of becoming static but never quite reaching stillness, to its quiet and peaceful conclusion. Once more, YouTube has a good few performances to choose from, but I quite like this one by the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra conducted by Juraj Valčuha (sadly the solo violinist remains uncredited): Silvestrov: Hymne - 2001.
Day 600: Williams, John (b.1932)
Bassoon Concerto (The Five Sacred Trees) (Time: 28 minutes)
Welcome to (pause for contemplation of the scale of it all…)
the 600th edition of the St Tim’s (etc.) Classical Playlist.
Time flies, does it not? (My favourite linguistic joke, which I used to set my
A-level Language classes to get them to explore semantic and grammatical ambiguity:
‘Time flies like an arrow. Fruit flies like a banana.’
Oh, they had hours of fun with that…)
Anyway, apart from noting that it was not even remotely conceivable to think,
when I started out, that this list might get as far as its 600th edition,
who knows how far we might get in the next few years…?
But, back to the here and now, the subject matter of today’s 600th
posting comes courtesy of Peter Wigglesworth, who emailed me a very long time ago
(so long ago that I’ve no idea when it was)
with a list of composers he thought might fit the brief of this playlist,
and gradually I’ve been finding space for them.
Today (24/7/26), we come to John Williams. This isn’t John Williams the
guitarist, famous in the last decades of the 20th century.
Instead, this is John Williams ‘the film composer’. You probably all have
your favourite John Williams film score (I refuse to call it a ‘movie’, even
though both my daughters deride me for being so ‘old school’). For me, it
would be the music for ‘Schindler’s List’, though I can no longer separate film
and music, so listening to the score without mentally seeing the images is
pretty much impossible. Still, as some of you may not know, there’s a lot
more to Mr Williams than scoring films for Steven Spielberg or George
Lucas. He is also what you might call a ‘classical composer’. Not
classical, obviously, in the sense of a historical period, but in the sense
that this is concert music, played by something close to a conventional
symphony orchestra. That being the case, I thought I’d use today’s
posting to explore one of Williams’ orchestral works, of which there are
many. Way back in the mid-1960s there was even a symphony – known rather
optimistically as the Symphony No 1, although to the best of my knowledge there
isn’t yet a ‘No 2’. Other large-scale concert music includes a
substantial number of concertos, Williams obviously being attracted to the
interaction of soloist and orchestra. There are concertos for flute, for
tuba, for clarinet, for cello, for trumpet, for horn, for viola, for harp, for
oboe, for piano, and two of them for violin. However, simply because we
haven’t had one of these on the playlist so far, today I want to feature a
composition by Williams sub-titled ‘Five Sacred Trees’, which is a concerto for
bassoon and orchestra. This was written in 1995 for Judith LeClair, then
principal bassoonist of the New York Phil, and those forces, conducted by Kurt
Masur, gave the first performance. The work is in five movements, though
the last two of these run together without a break. The notes Williams
himself wrote for the first performance of the piece get quoted extensively in
pretty much everything that’s been written since about this concerto, so I’m
going to hand over most of what follows to him. ‘As we become
increasingly aware of the damage done by the destruction of our forests, it is
illuminating to discover that our ancestors, many thousands of years ago, prayed
to the spirits before felling a tree. One prayer was appropriate for a maple,
another for an elm, an ash and so on. The English poet, Robert Graves,
writes of these prayers, which moved me to compose this music about trees
featuring the bassoon, itself a tree… The first movement, Eó Mugna,
references the great oak whose roots extend to Connla's Well in the
"otherworld," and stands guard over what is the source of the River
Shannon and the font of all wisdom. The well is probably the source of all music,
too. The inspiration for this movement is the Irish Uilleann pipe, a distant
ancestor of the bassoon, whose music evokes the spirit of Mugna and the sacred
well. The second movement, Tortan, conjures a tree that has been
associated with witches and as a result, the fiddle appears, sawing away, as it
is conjoined with the music of the bassoon. The Irish Bodhrán drum
assists. Movement three, Eó Rossa (or The Tree of Ross) evokes a
yew; the yew is often referred to as a symbol of death and destruction, but the
Tree of Ross is the subject of much rhapsodizing in the literature, where it is
referred to as "a mother's good," "Diadem of angels," and
"faggot of the sages." [Not sure about that last one…] Hence,
the lyrical character of this movement, wherein the bassoon incants and is
accompanied by the harp. Movement four, Craeb Uisnig, refers to an
ash which has been described by Robert Graves as a source of strife. Thus, a
ghostly battle, where all that is heard as the phantoms struggle is the
snapping of twigs on the forest floor. The final movement, Dathi,
is named for a tree which purportedly exercised authority over the poets and
was the last tree to fall. The bassoon soliloquizes as it ponders the secrets
of the trees.’ All that said, I’m not sure there’s much I’d add.
The music is tonal, by and large, but certainly not anodyne (Williams is
definitely not a ‘school of Philip Glass’ or a ‘school of Joe Hisaishi’-type
composer). The bassoon has an exceptionally challenging part (Williams
worked closely with LeClair in composing the piece, to be sure of what the
bassoon could and couldn’t achieve), but at various points orchestral
performers get their ‘soloistic’ spot, notably the harp in the third movement
and the flute in the second and fifth movements. We end, perhaps
unsurprisingly for a piece about the mystical significance of trees, with a
kind of brooding silence, in a place of mystery rather than affirmation.
Perhaps because the composer is who he is, there are actually quite a few
performances to choose from on YouTube. Out of the options I’ve gone for
this one, given by the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra, conducted by
Christoph Koncz. The soloist is the young German bassoonist, Theo Plath.
You’ll find the performance here: Williams:
Bassoon Concerto (Five Sacred Trees).
Day 599: Ireland, John (1879-1962)
Piano Concerto (Time: 24 minutes), The Holy Boy (version for chorus) (3 minutes) and Minuet (from 'Downland Suite') (3 minutes)
Welcome to the first of (at least) three ‘audience request’ postings, which I’m featuring partly so that you, dear reader, will realise that if you propose something for this list you may (eventually) get your request answered, and partly because the summer months are ‘down time’ when it comes to classical music in Sheffield, a city which has nothing remotely like a ‘Proms’ tradition to occupy its summer evenings. And so it is that the audience member in the spotlight today (17/7/26) is Malcolm Lambert, once of this parish, who wrote to me back in October last year suggesting that I’d covered almost all the well-known and considerably less well-known British composers of the first half of the 20th century – almost all, that is, apart from John Ireland (1879-1962). I shall remedy that omission forthwith. Actually, Malcolm was very helpful in his request because he suggested three works by Ireland that he’d like to share with us all, and even located YouTube links for particular performances, even if one of the three links has since been taken down from the site. So, what of Mr Ireland? Well, as you can see from the dates, he’s part of that generation (see also Holst, Hurlstone, Vaughan Williams, Moeran, Coleridge-Taylor and so on) who were pupils of Stanford at the end of the 19th century and beginning of the 20th. He was by birth a Mancunian, and the son of a musical and literary household, both his parents having interests in the arts (his father was a publisher who edited the works of Hazlitt, Carlyle and Emerson, while his mother edited the letters of Jane Welsh Carlyle and wrote her biography). His parents died while Ireland was in his mid-teens, but by then he’d already taken himself off to London (as you do) to enter the Royal College of Music as a student of piano and organ, and later as a composition pupil with Stanford. In some ways the events of his life seem to suggest a quiet existence – his principal employment after his studies was as a church organist and choir master, and he spent a lot of time in Guernsey before the Second World War and in rural Sussex after it – but it seems to have been a life of cautious (one might hazard a guess at ‘closeted’) intimacy with close male companions – and rather like Tchaikovsky in this, that existence seems to have in some ways tormented him to the point where he had a brief and very ill-advised marriage to a 17-year-old pupil when he himself was 47. They separated almost instantly and the marriage seems to have been unconsummated. Then there was another pupil for whom he seems to have been smitten – the pianist and composer Helen Perkin, for whom he wrote his only piano concerto, but that relationship too ended in bitterness when she married a wealthy architect, with the result that Ireland withdrew the work’s dedication to her and refused all her attempts at reconciliation. There were longer-lasting relationships with male companions – in fact the heterosexual romantic episodes came off the back of the end of a decade spent with a former chorister, 30 years or so his junior, called Arthur Miller (not that Arthur Miller, obviously!). His music is identifiably British, though his ‘pastoral’ tendencies have perhaps an overlay of French impressionism at times (Debussy was an early influence). His oeuvre does not contain many large-scale works, his preferred creative channels being songs and choral works, short piano pieces and chamber music. In fact one of his few substantial orchestral works is a piece chosen by Malcolm, Ireland’s aforementioned Piano Concerto. It dates from 1930 and was written as I’ve noted for the pianist Helen Perkin (he quotes a melody from a work of hers in the finale of the piece). The concerto was a great success at its first performance, and made both composer and soloist almost instantly considerably better known. In fact, there were regular performances (by the likes of Clifford Curzon and Arthur Rubinstein) in the years that followed. It’s essentially a sunny work, and relatively conventional in its language, even if its use of a muted trumpet (very ‘jazz age’) and some unorthodox percussion caused a stir initially. You pretty much know where you are with this concerto from the outset: there’s little attempt at showiness or virtuosity, but instead much of the writing has the gentle lyricism of Ireland’s picture-painting solo piano works (consider the piano’s first entry and compare it with most other piano concertos you might have come across). The slow movement is lovely – a yearning, tender love song (even if we don’t see it as Ireland’s infatuation for his then 19-year-old piano pupil). The finale is by some distance the most energetic of the movements, and after reminiscences of the earlier movements and a slightly regretful solo violin melody it’s cheery all the way to the end. Malcolm has requested a performance from the BBC Proms in 2019, given by the BBC Concert Orchestra conducted by Bramwell Tovey. The soloist is pianist Leon McCawley. You’ll find it here: Ireland: Piano Concerto. Alongside the concerto, Malcolm has suggested two other shorter works. One is probably Ireland’s most famous piece, ‘The Holy Boy’, which exists in an extraordinary number of versions. It was originally written for solo piano, appearing in 1918 as the third of Four Preludes for piano, though it seems to have been written before the First World War. But it very quickly took on an independent life (versions for organ, for violin and piano, and for cello and piano all emerged within a year of its first publication). It acquired words in the late 1930s, a poem by Herbert S Brown (‘Lowly, laid in a manger,/ With oxen brooding nigh’), who was, curiously, the Ireland family’s solicitor. There is some discussion of who may have been the original ‘holy boy’ that inspired Ireland (allegedly perhaps a chorister at St Luke’s Church, Chelsea, where Ireland was organist and chorus master, called Bobby Glassby, another of Ireland’s covert homosexual infatuations), but regardless of its origin, the choral version has long been a favourite, especially at Christmas. Malcolm has asked for a performance by the Choir of Trinity College, Cambridge, conducted by Stephen Layton, which you’ll find here: Ireland: The Holy Boy (version for chorus). Finally, Malcolm writes that as a player in brass ensembles of one sort or another, he’d like us to hear something from Ireland’s Downland Suite, which Ireland wrote as the test piece for the 1932 National Brass Band Championships. It’s a sunny, largely genial four movement work (though with a poignant ‘Elegy’ at its emotional heart) more often heard these days in an arrangement for string orchestra made by Ireland and fellow composer Geoffrey Bush. However, it’s played here, in this historical and necessarily audio-only performance, by the winning performers, and indeed the winning performance, at the 1932 championships, the Fodens Motor Works Band: Ireland: Minuet (from 'Downland Suite').
Day 598: Schoenberg, Arnold (1874-1951)
Suite for Piano, Op 25 (Time: 13 minutes)
Somehow, for some of you at least, I suspect I ought to
preface my posting for today (10/7/26) with a health warning: this music is,
as they say, ‘challenging’, because it’s atonal, serialist (‘twelve tone’) stuff
from the pen of the most ‘rule-breaking’ iconoclast of early 20th
century music, Arnold Schoenberg. And the reason for inflicting this
on you sharing this with you is that on 13th July, this coming
Monday, it will be 75 years exactly since Mr Schoenberg breathed his last, and
was subsequently buried in the USA, his adopted homeland. Now, we’ve had
two pieces of original Schoenberg on this list – see Day 205 for the shimmeringly
beautiful ‘Verklärte Nacht’, and Day 507 for the ‘mock 18th century’
Suite in G for Strings, along with examples on Days 150 and 248 of Schoenberg
the arranger – and today we have what might be seen, after all that ‘softening
up’, as authentic modernist Schoenberg. As experienced listeners (which
you must surely be if you’ve travelled all this way with me for 597 days and
counting), I know you’ll take today’s music on board with confidence and
contextual awareness. Well, that’s my hope… In fact, though, as you
might suspect from Day 507’s Suite for Strings ‘In the Olden Style’, Schoenberg
was a very particular kind of modernist iconoclast – that is, one with a keen
awareness of the past, and his own position in relation to it. And this
is especially relevant to today’s work, which is Schoenberg’s Suite for Piano,
Op 25, which was composed in the years 1921-23. So, a bit of
history. Schoenberg had already embraced a kind of expressionism before
the First World War – you can see (hear!) his ‘Pierrot Lunaire’ as the sound
equivalent of Picasso’s ‘Les Demoiselles de Avignon’, say – so the ‘fracturing’
of order in music, as Picasso and Cubism fractured representational art, was
well established before 1914. Schoenberg wrote very little in the years
1914-20, and no doubt the war had much to do with that, but by 1920 in the
fertile (febrile?) atmosphere of Vienna, he arrived at the next step. He
saw (I simplify, obviously!) that if there’s no relationship between any note
and any other note, so that the concepts of keys, or harmony, or tonality
disappear, it’s a recipe for chaos. But what to replace it with?
This is where the concept of the ‘tone row’ comes in. There are 12
‘tones’ in conventional Western music (play a scale on all the white and black
notes starting at middle C on the piano and stopping just before you get to the
next C an octave higher, and there are your 12 tones – actually ‘semitones’ in
conventional musical language). So, Schoenberg’s recipe to ward off chaos
was to give each of those ‘tones’ equal status, by not playing any of them a
second time until you’ve used them all once. It is, evidently, a
‘mechanical’ solution to the avoidance of chaos, but it did at least provide
Schoenberg with a way forward. The Suite for Piano, Op 25, was the first
composition he produced using this method. At the heart of this music is
the following ‘tone row’: E-F-G-Db-Gb-Eb-Ab-D-B-C-A-Bb. Now, in
Schoenberg’s ‘system’, you could then do what you liked with that row (turn it
upside down, play it back to front, transpose the whole thing up or down,
change its rhythm, play some of its notes simultaneously, etc.) but this gave
the music a sense of ‘rootedness’, an orientation around something, a sense, if
you like, of ‘home’, however tenuous. So far, then, so
iconoclastic. But Schoenberg with an eye to the past uses that serialist
technique to write something that, formally, Bach might have written 200 years
previously; that is, a Baroque Suite, a series of dance movements that followed
on from an introductory Prelude. (See Day 259 for Bach’s Cello Suite No
3, if you want a typical Baroque example.) But here’s a thing: all that
I’ve described so far has been to explain ‘how something is made’.
Schoenberg hated that. Here’s one of his more forthright observations: ‘I
cannot often enough warn against the overrating of analysis since it invariably
leads to what I have always fought against: the knowledge of how something is
made; whereas I have always tried to promote the knowledge of what something is.’
And so, to say that the Suite for Piano is serialist, that its organisation is
governed by a ‘method of composition with twelve notes related only to each
other’ doesn’t really tell you what this music is, only how it was
made. So, what is it? Well, it’s a suite in six movements:
Präludium, Gavotte, Musette, Intermezzo, Menuett & Trio and Gigue.
The whole thing lasts about 13 minutes, so the movements are necessarily short.
Only the fourth movement Intermezzo (not a term you’d have found in a
Baroque suite anyway!) lasts more than a couple of minutes.
I don’t really want to say any more about it, but rather just get you to listen to it.
But I would say this: I went to a concert in late 2025 when Tim Horton
(resident pianist with Ensemble 360) gave a recital as part of a series
called ‘Viennese Masterworks: Brahms and More’, which used the music of Brahms
as the focal point, but also looked backwards to the ‘first Viennese school’
(Haydn, Mozart, Beethoven, Schubert) and forwards to the Second Viennese School
(Schoenberg, Berg, Webern). And as part of that concert, he played this
Schoenberg suite. I found the experience of listening to it for the first
time fascinating (fascinating enough to have listened to it again quite a few
times), because what struck me the most was that while my ears were initially
saying ‘this is chaos, and none of it makes sense,’ another bit of my brain was
saying ‘this is like a Baroque suite, and I can hear patterns that are almost
(almost!) like hearing 18th century Bach.’ See what you
think! YouTube has several performances of this work, but it requires
fearsomely accurate technique, and my ‘go to’ pianist for this sort of thing is
the inimitable Yuja Wang. You’ll find her performance of it here: Schoenberg: Suite for Piano,
Op 25.
Day 597: Finzi, Gerald (1901-56)
Clarinet Concerto (Time: 27 minutes)
July 14th, a week and a half from today (3/7/26), marks the 125th anniversary of the birth of Gerald Finzi. His music seems to me to conjure at least something of a consolatory mood. So to add to the couple of pieces by Finzi on this list already – his Eclogue for Piano and Strings in Day 206, and his stirring Anglican anthem ‘Lo, the Full Final Sacrifice’ on Day 491 – I thought that I’d mark Finzi’s 125th birthday by sharing with you the work of his that I love the most, his lyrical and tender Clarinet Concerto. The material I’ve written about Finzi already for this Playlist covers most of the biographical ground that I think is most pertinent to an understanding of his music (so do go back and read those two earlier pieces again!), and so all I’d like to expand on here is what happened to Finzi in the years after the Second World War and before his untimely death in 1956 at the age of only 55. Finzi spent his wartime years in London, working at the Ministry of War Transport (and opening up his home to German and Czech refugees), but after the war he returned to the home he and his wife had created for themselves in Hampshire, where he revisited the pastoral interests (such as growing obscure varieties of English apple) that had preoccupied him in the 1930s. However, rather than fading into gentle semi-retirement, he seems to have become creatively inspired in the final decade of his life. The commissioning of ‘Lo, the Full Final Sacrifice’ in 1946/47 gave Finzi the opportunity to write for choir on a larger scale than he had before, and the years that followed generated the Three Anthems for chorus and organ, music to accompany a performance of Shakespeare’s ‘Love’s Labour’s Lost’, the substantial settings of Wordsworth’s poetry in his ‘Intimations of Immortality’, ‘For Cecilia’ which set verse by Edmund Blunden in 1947, a good many smaller-scale choral settings, and the very substantial Cello Concerto, his last completed orchestral work, which dates from 1955. This might not appear like a massive amount of music, but in the context of Finzi’s earlier somewhat leisurely approach to composition, it seems like something of a flood. And, in the midst of that burst of creativity, we find the Clarinet Concerto, which dates from 1949. Finzi had been commissioned by the Three Choirs Festival (that venerable English institution based on the cathedrals of Hereford, Gloucester and Worcester), but rather than the work for strings that had been planned, Finzi was moved by the playing of the English clarinettist Frederick Thurston to turn his ideas for a string piece into a Clarinet Concerto (the forces accompanying the soloist here being a string ensemble rather than a full orchestra), and work on the concerto proceeded unusually quickly for Finzi. The first performance took place at the Three Choirs Festival in 1949, after which Finzi made minor adjustments to the work (Vaughan Williams persuaded him to write a cadenza for the soloist just before the end of the opening movement), but it would be fair to say that in the couple of decades that followed the concerto pretty much disappeared from view. What brought it back into the limelight was the fact that from the 1970s onwards it became a popular choice for young soloists taking part in the BBC Young Musician competition, which led in turn to a number of commercial recordings being made by clarinettists (people like Thea King, Emma Johnson, Robert Plane, Andrew Marriner, Michael Collins and Janet Hilton), and now its popularity is firmly re-established. It’s a piece in the conventional three movements, with the slow movement (by some distance the most substantial of the three) placed second. Emma Johnson’s website includes some illuminating musings on playing this work, and on Finzi’s musical language in general. Apparently one of Finzi’s hobbies was the collection of old music manuscripts, saying that holding onto the copies of music written by composers of the past was like shaking hands with kindred spirits, and it was with this mindset that he set about publishing his own catalogue of completed works: ‘The pressing forward of new generations will soon obliterate my small contribution. Yet I like to think that in each generation might be found a few responsive minds, and for them I would like to have my work available’, he wrote by way of introduction. The echoes of the past (not direct quotation, but via a kind of generalised mood of pastoral nostalgia) are certainly present in the Clarinet Concerto. Johnson observes of the rather turbulent mood that keeps shaking up the tranquillity of the first movement: ‘there is a robust edginess which gives the work urgency and strength and which eventually works itself up into a tempestuous climax marked “con furia”- with anger,’ and notes that this is achieved in particular by the addition of ‘a kind of “grit” in the harmony: normal diatonic chords have a semitone discord added to create tension and to destabilize the harmony until it can be resolved.’ If the first movement remains restless, the ‘Adagio ma senza rigore’ slow movement is plaintive and anguished, and it includes a melody first heard in his setting of ‘Lo, the Full Final Sacrifice’. The programme notes for an American performance of this work described this movement as ‘about endless longing with no solution,’ which I think nails the mood very impressively. The last movement offers relaxation and an unwinding of the tension. It’s playful, built on a folk-song like melody (not a direct quotation, as far as I can tell) and the geniality of the music – not sure you could ever label Finzi’s music ‘high spirited’ – brushes away any tendency to be drawn back towards the solemnity or introspection of the earlier movements. The final flourish, as Emma Johnson notes, suggests that life is joyful as well as transient. YouTube offers a lot of amateur performances of the work, but among the few professional video recordings is one from a distinctly non-English source, the Reykjavik Chamber Orchestra, directed by Mirian Khukhunaishvili. The soloist is Rúnar Óskarsson. You’ll find their performance here: Finzi: Clarinet Concerto.
Day 596: Shotakovich, Dmitri (1906-75)
String Quartet No 7 (Time: 13 minutes)
My choice of work today (26/6/26) is another piece from this year’s Bradfield Festival, performed by the Woolf Quartet. Shostakovich has had six outings on this playlist already, and one of those outings (Day 108) explored Shostakovich’s most famous and regularly-played work in this medium, the String Quartet No 8. Tonight the Woolf Quartet will play the immediately preceding quartet, the String Quartet No 7 in F# Minor, Op 108. Given that Shostakovich is famous for large-scale orchestral works, it’s illuminating to see what he does in the quartet medium, where pared down forces and – a cliché I know, but true nevertheless – the more obvious ‘purity’ of the quartet’s sound often led Shostakovich to generate music at the opposite extreme, pithy and direct, with nothing wasted. The quartet was written in 1960, and it has an intensely personal genesis. It was dedicated to the memory of his first wife Nina Vassilyevna Varzar, who died suddenly in 1954 after an emergency operation for a previously undetected cancer. It was first performed in May 1960, which (for a composer with Shostakovich’s well developed sense of significant patterns and coincidences) was a meaningful month for him in terms of his relationship with his first wife: they were engaged in May 1929, married in May 1932, had their first child, Galya, in May 1936, and their second, Maxim, in May 1938. For a composer whose music, and whose comments about his music, were always carefully masked, this is a composition of seemingly searingly personal expression, from its ‘In Memoriam’ dedication to the raw directness of its musical unfolding. The marriage had been, as they say, ‘complicated’ (but then, aren’t all marriages, in their way?), and Shostakovich and Nina Varzar went through regular periods of turbulent antagonism as well as, lest we think of Shostakovich as always deploying a mask of introverted gloom, some intense joy as well as simple contentment. But after her death, the years 1954-60 were, one might say, rather messy. Shostakovich fell into a period of profound depression, tried to sidestep it by marrying Margarita Kainova, a Communist Youth League worker, in 1956, but it was a profoundly ill-matched relationship and they separated quickly and divorced in 1961. There were other relationships – affairs with two of his pupils, Elmira Nazirova (whose musical ‘motto’ theme, and Shostakovich’s fantasised relationship with her, features heavily in his Symphony No 10) and the composer Galina Ustvolskaya, to whom he apparently proposed twice, without success. (If you know any of Ustvolskaya’s small in number but unremittingly brutal compositions, it might lead you to wonder what sort of relationship this might have been!) Anyway, as always with Shostakovich, it’s hard to tell if any of this personal turbulence is really evident in his music, or whether the mask of ambiguity keeps us all at arm’s length. (I don’t think there’s a right answer to that conundrum.) The String Quartet No 7 is in three movements which play without a break, and lasts in most performances little over 13 minutes, making this his shortest string quartet. One of the curious things about the quartet is how sparse its texture often is – in most string quartets all four players tend to play together most of the time, but in this quartet passages for just one solo instrument are almost as frequent as passages where all four play at the same time, and in the second movement for example there’s only one brief moment where all four are involved simultaneously. Does any of that matter? Possibly not, but it gives an indication of the sparse, intimate, rather shape-shifting quality of the work. The first movement is a nervous, rather twitchy Allegretto, which seems to me to be always trying to hide from darker emotions by pretending to a sort of casual, almost superficial quality, although the mood gets darker and more troubled as the movement goes on. The second movement, a Lento, is pretty astonishing, I think – eerie, haunted, terribly lonely stuff. Sometimes, rather oddly, it reminds me of Philip Glass-style minimalism, motifs shifting slowly and hypnotically as time passes. The finale starts with wild anger and ferocity. The music is derived from the previous two movements, but you can hardly tell, given how unbearable the anguish feels. But then, suddenly, the mood passes, and the quartet ends in a strange, cryptic state, an odd little waltz, a dream motif, a return of the first movement’s pizzicato, and then a collapse into silence, that might, of course, be death. Not cheery, I know, but a work of exceptional condensed intensity, hiding behind the apparently nonchalant and casual. As you may be able to tell, I’m a great fan of Shostakovich’s music, largely because deceptively simple material is used to communicate ideas and feelings of intense depth. Some disagree … but then, as you might expect, they’re wrong! YouTube isn’t badly served when it comes to this quartet, and from the options I’d be happy to live with this performance, by the Jerusalem Quartet, which you’ll find here: Shostakovich: String Quartet No 7.
Day 595: Mozart, Wolfgang Amadeus (1756-91)
Trio for Clarinet, Viola and Piano ('the Kegelstatt') (Time: 19 minutes)
Today (19/6/26), my subject is music by Mozart, and the reason for choosing Mozart now is that next week at the Bradfield Festival the rather splendidly named Trio Meister Raro (named after one of Schumann’s journalistic alter egos, and – in another guise – three members of Ensemble 360) are giving a concert of music played on their chosen instruments: clarinet, viola and piano. Now, music for this particular instrumental combination is not what you’d call thick on the ground. There are, it’s true, an increasing number of recent and contemporary composers who have favoured these forces – at least 24 such pieces have been composed in the past three decades – but if you were to go back to before the First World War there’s really not a lot out there. Bruch wrote ‘Eight Pieces for Clarinet, Viola and Piano’ in 1910, Reinecke’s Trio in A Op 264 dates from seven years before that, and Schumann’s ‘Märchenerzählungen’ (‘Fairy Tale Stories’) dates from 1853. Go back for nearly another 70 years still and you get to (as far as I know!) the first ever piece written for these instruments, the Trio in Eb, K 498, by Mozart. I guess it’s possible (this being a work of endearing charm, as I hope to show) that this would be a popular piece anyway, but I’m certain that what has helped it on its way is its nickname, the ‘Kegelstatt Trio’. So, I should deal with the nickname first. ‘Kegelstatt’ means ‘skittle alley’, and there’s a story that Mozart wrote the work ‘while playing skittles’, as if to demonstrate that if you’re a genius you can multi-task quite happily and still produce the goods. Alas, like many such good stories, it would be nice if it were true, but unfortunately it isn’t. It’s true that playing skittles was one of Mozart’s favourite leisure activities, and it’s also true that he did in fact compose a work while engaged in such an activity – 12 Duos for Two Horns, K 487, which has, inscribed on the title page of its manuscript, ‘Vienna, 27 July 1786, while playing skittles’ – but by a process lost in the mists of time, by the point at which Köchel got round to making his thematic catalogue of Mozart’s works in the 1860s, that particular appellation found itself attached to a trio for clarinet, viola and piano that Mozart wrote about 10 days later than the duos for horns. And so, erroneously but indelibly, this is now the ‘Kegelstatt Trio’. Even though the skittles story isn’t true about this trio, it doesn’t stop it being a wonderful work – and a piece that at the time (and until Schumann’s composition came along in 1853) was the first and only composition for these forces. That in itself, I think, is remarkable. The instruments sound lovely in combination, which makes you wonder why Mozart was the first to write for them, and also why nobody else took up the challenge for so many decades. As you may know, although Mozart was a sensational pianist (and premiered very many of his piano concertos in the 1780s), his favourite instrument was the viola, which was his preferred choice when making chamber music in private houses. He wrote the clarinet part for his friend (and fellow Mason) Anton Stadler – who also prompted the creation of the later, sublime Clarinet Concerto and Clarinet Quintet. On piano was the work’s dedicatee Franziska von Jacquin, one of his pupils and the daughter of Nikolaus von Jacquin, at whose house Mozart regularly socialised, playing music and games (though possibly not skittles). Anyway, enough background. This is a work in three movements, and lasts just under 20 minutes in most performances. The opening movement is a gentle Andante, a genial and essentially monothematic piece in which everything, pretty much, is derived from the keyboard theme that is set out in the opening bars. One of the things I love about this movement is that when this opening is reprised towards the end of the movement the silences that were present at the outset are now filled in, almost as if what Mozart were doing here was to continuously elaborate on the material as he went along. The second movement is a moderately paced Menuetto, but in many ways rather than a simple three/four time dance movement this is actually quite sophisticated writing, both in terms of the way Mozart explores different dynamic contrasts and also the way he elaborates on the ‘dialogue’ between the instruments by writing some more than just routine counterpoint. The middle section of the movement, the Trio, shifts into the minor key, creating drama and contrast, and there’s a nice twist at the end of the movement when the trio’s main theme returns briefly. The final movement is a ‘Rondeaux’, though whether the French title signifies anything in particular I can’t tell you. Einstein, always good for a quotation when it comes to Mozart’s music, said of this finale that ‘it sings from beginning to end’, and it’s a movement full of variety, lots of episodic contrasts, including a shift into the darker mood of the minor key for a while, before the entirely joyful ending. There’s a familiar quotation of Mozart’s that’s often applied to his music, that it’s ‘for beginners and connoisseurs alike’, and that seems to me to be a perfect fit when it comes to this trio. One of the comments in the liner notes for the recording of this music that I’ve got describes it as ‘delicious on the outside and quite intriguing on the inside’. I think that’s spot on. As for a recording, YouTube has plenty to choose from, but I really like this one, which features a starry line-up: Martin Fröst on clarinet, Maxim Rysanov on viola and Roland Pöntinen on piano. You’ll find their performance here: Mozart: Trio for Clarinet, Viola and Piano ('the Kegelstatt').
Day 594: Beethoven, Ludwig van (1770-1827)
Violin Sonata in F, Op 24 ('Spring') (Time: 24 minutes)
At the end of this month in lovely High Bradfield, there’s a festival of chamber music, which will feature amongst other things a Beethoven violin sonata. We’ve had music by Beethoven on 16 occasions over the years, and some might think that’s quite enough. ‘Some’, I hasten to add, would be wrong! You can surely never have enough Beethoven, and so today (12/6/26), we have some more. And although one of those sixteen postings was of a Beethoven violin sonata (the Op 30 No 3, on Day 217), another one wouldn’t go amiss, particularly one that's as all-round amiable as the Violin Sonata No 5 in F, Op 24 – better known perhaps by its nickname, the ‘Spring’ sonata. (Like many descriptors attached to Beethoven’s works, this one had nothing to do with him, being affixed to the sonata after Beethoven’s death, but it’s one of those labels that feels particularly apt.) Beethoven wrote ten violin sonatas all told, and the Op 24 is the last of the five that Beethoven wrote in the run-up to the crisis that afflicted him – initially a crisis specifically focused on his deteriorating hearing, but turning into something more existential – in the early years of the 19th century. Beethoven actually wrote this piece as one of a pair, and they were to be published together as a contrast to each other, one in A Minor, the other in F Major. However, a publishing cock-up meant that they were eventually sent into the world with separate opus numbers – the A Minor as Op 23, this F Major sonata as Op 24. It first saw the light of day in 1801, which puts it thus right on the cusp of the transition from Beethoven’s ‘early’ period works (essentially conventional, not breaking too many rules!) to the ‘middle’ period stuff, which is much more heroic and revolutionary. The ‘Spring’ Sonata was Beethoven’s first violin sonata to have four movements, breaking with the three-movement pattern that Beethoven inherited from Mozart’s mature violin sonatas, on which Beethoven modelled his early explorations of the genre. But there’s something almost Mozartian about this work, in that like much of Mozart’s music it feels almost effortless, as though it’s unfolding with a kind of elegant fluidity, and without any of that wrestling with fate that is so much a feature of Beethoven’s works in the years to come. If you read pretty much anything about this sonata, you’ll find recurring allusions to its geniality, its good-humoured ‘sunny’ disposition, and (my favourite) its ‘forthright and winsome limpidness’. Almost always with Beethoven, you know what sort of work you’re going to encounter from its opening bars, and that’s definitely the case here. The first movement starts with a fresh and innocent violin melody while the piano plays something almost stereotypically conventional for its period. Then the instruments reverse roles, violin accompanying piano – and this points up the extent to which this is a partnership of equals, rather than the 18th century model (sonatas ‘for pianoforte with violin accompaniment’). There is the odd moment where one or other of the instruments raises its voice, as it were, but those moments of bluster are fleeting, and the predominant musical quality is extreme lyricism. The almost entirely unruffled slow movement brings the violin to the fore, and again the piano accompaniment feels deliberately ‘old-fashioned’, with much use of the so-called ‘Alberti bass’ – the figuration you find in the left hand of the piano part. The third movement, actually labelled ‘Scherzo’, is a joke (the literal meaning of the Italian term) in more than one way. A joke because it’s so short; blink and you’ll miss it. But a joke too because of the comic syncopation of the piano and violin parts, never quite being in time with each other. And then the finale brings us back into the effortlessly lyrical world of the work’s opening. Yes, the movement heads off into some unusually distant keys, and yes, there are points before the end when we seem to be galloping rather than gently trotting, but the work ends, unsurprisingly, ‘happily ever after’. I’m aware that all this description might make it seem a bit twee or sentimental, but I’d go for something more like ‘contented’ or ‘serene’. Beethoven was to write nothing so good-natured ever again. As for a recording, YouTube has several, but I’m very impressed by the now long-running partnership between Alina Ibragimova on violin and Cédric Tiberghien on piano, and that’s whom you’ll find as my choice, in a video recording which also includes the slow movement of the Violin Sonata Op 30 No 2 as an encore. You’ll find it here: Beethoven: Violin Sonata in F, Op 24 ('Spring').
Day 593: Weber, Carl Maria von (1786-1826)
Der Freischutz (Overture) (Time: 10 minutes) and Konzertstuck for Piano and Orchestra (17 minutes)
Exactly 200 years ago today (5/6/26), the German composer Carl Maria von Weber died from tuberculosis (or at least from deteriorating health caused by that condition) in London, at the age of 39. We’ve had one appearance by Weber on this list to date – see Day 115 for what is almost certainly his most popular composition, ‘Invitation to the Dance’ (in Berlioz’s orchestration) – and at least this anniversary of his demise offers another opportunity to explore a little further the music of this ground-breaking composer, by looking at one of his opera overtures and one of his concerto-style pieces. Carl Maria Friedrich Ernst von Weber – if we’re being formal – is usually regarded, as I noted back on Day 115, as being one of the first generation of ‘Romantic’ composers. Of Weber’s life, perhaps the key descriptor would be ‘itinerant’. Due to his father’s challenges in holding down stable employment, by the time Weber started his first job in Breslau (now Wrocław in Poland) as a 17-year-old, the family had moved from one city to another at least nine times. In the couple of decades of his adult life, Weber was scarcely more rooted: two years in Breslau were followed by three in Stuttgart, another four somewhat itinerantly in the region of Württemberg in the service of the Duke there, then three in Prague, one in Berlin, until finally in 1817 he ended up in Dresden, where he became director of the prestigious opera house. Opera – conducting, running opera houses, and composing operas – was the focus of Weber’s life. He started ten of them, and finished five, though really only three – ‘Der Freischutz’, ‘Euryanthe’ and ‘Oberon’ – still see the light of day. The earliest of these three, ‘Der Freischutz’ (literally ‘The Freeshooter’, though perhaps ‘The Marksman’ is better) is usually regarded as the first authentically ‘German’ Romantic opera, and it paved the way for the operas of Wagner three or four decades later. One way in which Weber enriched the operatic scene was by creating overtures that were a kind of miniature ‘tone poem’, a journey through the emotional world of the opera to come. (You could argue that Beethoven had started that particular ball rolling with his various attempts to find the right way to start his opera ‘Fidelio’, but it was Weber who perfected the art.) The overture to ‘Der Freischutz’ is a case in point, and helps to explain why, at its first performance in 1821, ‘Der Freischutz’ made Weber famous overnight. You can see why Wagner was impressed by it. The piece opens with a slow introduction, and strings followed by horns evoking the deeply-rooted Germanic sense of the forest world. But this isn’t just picturesque; there’s also darkness and evil spirits in its thudding drums and diminished seventh chords (think ‘heroine tied to train tracks in 1920s silent movies…’). What follows is the interplay of several musical themes from the opera, a clear tussling of light and darkness for the upper hand, and at the end the music associated with the redeeming love of Agathe, our heroine, sweeps all before it and points the way to the overture’s thrilling finish. YouTube has several decent performances of this work, and from them I’ve gone for this one by the SWR Symphony Orchestra, Stuttgart, conducted by the then almost 80-year-old Christoph Eschenbach, which you’ll find here: Weber: Der Freischutz (Overture). On the very morning of the premiere of ‘Der Freischutz’ in June 1821, Weber also put the finishing touches to a piece he’d been working on since 1815, his Konzertstück for Piano and Orchestra. By that point he had already composed two piano concertos, attractive enough display pieces but not works that have found a foothold in the repertoire. Initially the Konzertstück was going to be his ‘Piano Concerto No 3’, but what makes it interesting – ground-breaking, even – is that what we have here is a ‘one movement’ piece, with episodes corresponding to the conventional structure of a three-movement concerto, but now linked together into a single span. Again, it’s a step towards something that will flourish later in the 19th century, in this case leading pretty directly to Liszt’s two piano concertos, with their ‘cyclic’ form. Apparently there was a programme for the piece (another very ‘Romantic’ idea – music ‘telling a story’), which goes like this: ‘A châtelaine sits alone on her balcony, gazing off in the distance. Her knight has gone on a Crusade to the Holy Land. Years have passed, battles have been fought; is he still alive? Will she ever see him again? (‘Larghetto affetuoso’) – ‘Her excited imagination summons a vision of her noble husband lying wounded and forsaken on the battlefield. Could she not fly to his side and die with him? She falls back, unconscious. Then from the distance comes the sound of a trumpet. There in the forest something flashes in the sunlight as it comes nearer and nearer’ (‘Allegro passionato’) – ‘Knights and squires, with the Crusaders' cross and banners waving, are acclaimed by the crowd. And there her husband is among them! She sinks into his arms.’ (‘Tempo di marcia’) – ‘Happiness without end! The woods and waves sing a song of love, while a thousand voices proclaim its victory’ (‘Presto gioioso’). Utter tosh, of course, but it says something about the underlying sensibility of the age, and of Weber’s attempts to tap into it. Shorn of all that cheesy romantic drivel, the composition itself is both lovely and, more to the point, a precursor of ‘programme’ music of the coming decades. For a performance, I’m sticking with the same orchestra as before, the SWR Symphony Orchestra, Stuttgart, conducted here by Dima Slobodeniouk. The pianist is Alexei Volodin. You’ll find the performance here: Weber: Konzertstuck for Piano and Orchestra.
Day 592: Foerster, Josef Bohuslav (1859-1951)
String Quartet No 4 in F (Time: 23 minutes)
Exactly 75 years ago to this very day (29/5/26), Josef Bohuslav Foerster (sometimes spelt ‘Förster’) died at his home in the tiny central Bohemian village of Nový Vestec at the grand old age of 91. It’s entirely possible that you have never heard of him, because although he lived to a great age and composed a great quantity of music, his is by and large a gentle and undemonstrative musical voice – which is sometimes, by those less than sympathetic to it, seen as meandering and dull. Needless to say, I’d want to argue that such a view does Foerster no favours, and is not a remotely accurate view of his music. Finding halfway decent video performances of his works on YouTube is not easy, so my choice of piece to accompany a potted biography of Foerster is not necessarily what I’d see as his ‘best’ work, but it is at least a work that gets a good performance. Anyway, Foerster (1859-1951) is difficult to place in the ‘story’ of Czech music. He was born about halfway between the generation of Dvorak (b.1841) and that of Josef Suk (b.1874), so one might expect his music to be late Romantic, probably ‘nationalist’ in an identifiably Czech way – and both those things are kind of true, though he’s one of the less obviously Czech of Czech composers of that time. One thing that’s extraordinary about him, as a consequence of his long life, is that he outlived many more identifiably ‘modern’ Czech composers – not just Suk (d.1935), but Janacek (d.1928) and Novak (d.1949). Even Martinu, a much more obviously ‘20th century’ figure, only outlived him by eight years. Foerster was born in Prague; his father taught at the music conservatory there. In some ways that might seem to give him a head start, and it’s true that he readily found employment as organist and music critic after graduation. He married a renowned soprano, Berta Lautererova, and followed her to Hamburg for a decade from 1893, and then to Vienna until the end of the First World War, as she pursued her career. All that might make it appear that Foerster himself was not necessarily making musical waves, but while in Hamburg he became both a friend and a kind of mentor to Mahler (of Mahler, Foerster wrote that ‘he needed someone who was convinced of his extraordinary talent and who was capable of bolstering up his sometimes faltering faith’), and he followed Mahler – and Berta, whom Mahler invited to sing at the Vienna Opera – to Vienna in 1903. Those years were probably the most successful of Foerster’s career, seeing the composition of four of his five symphonies, including his most well-known (not that that’s saying much), his Symphony No 4, ‘Easter Eve’. He had also written three string quartets, several instrumental sonatas, much piano and choral music, and an opera, ‘Eva’, that actually still lingers in the repertoire, at least in central Europe. He returned to Prague in 1918, teaching there for the rest of his professional life. What can one say of his music? Well, as I noted at the start, it’s pretty understated stuff. You’d never guess, from things he wrote from the 1920s onwards, that Mahler’s music had existed, not to mention Stravinsky’s or Schoenberg’s or Bartok’s. In the 1940s he summed up his sense of the musical world around him like this: ‘We are living in a time of transition. Such times always suffer from a preponderance of rationality, prefer artificiality to art, construction and complication to simplicity, obscurity and audacity to clarity and comprehensibility. For a time, the brain dominates the heart.’ I find all that quite touching – it’s the voice of a man out of step with his times. He was – ethically, religiously, musically, culturally – a deeply conservative man, and though when he died in 1951 his passing was marked respectfully by the authorities in the newly created Czechoslovakia as the loss of a ‘national artist’, he and his music were soon forgotten. It’s taken the CD revolution, and the rise of independent music labels devoted to uncovering more obscure corners of the repertoire, to bring his works back into circulation, and these days you can get his symphonies and most of his chamber music in very decent recordings. For a taste of Foerster the composer, I’ve gone for his String Quartet No 4 – as I mentioned near the start, largely because there’s a more than adequate video performance of it on YouTube. Foerster’s first three string quartets date from 1888, 1893 and 1907. There then followed a massive gap until his String Quartet No 4 in F appeared in 1943-4. (There was to be one more, left almost complete at his death in 1951.) The 4th Quartet is in three movements. Would you know that the horrors of the Second World War were raging around him from this music? Possibly not, though it’s worth saying that he’d just attended a very successful revival of his opera ‘Eva’, and – this is a man in his eighties at this point, don’t forget – there’s both nostalgia and comfort in this music alongside a degree of uncertainty about the times (both political and musical). The first movement, Allegro Grazioso, starts with a theme for viola, before the other instruments explore a rich, late Romantic idiom. Sometimes the harmonies suggest an awareness of musical modernism, but not much more than an awareness. The second movement is a song-like Adagio, which encloses a middle section marked Allegretto Malinconico, which contrives to be both dark and dancing at the same time. The last movement, a bright and lively Allegro, comes with reminiscences of how the quartet began. It’s not music that’s remotely revolutionary. It’s inward, almost mystical in its reflective quality. I think it needs to be listened to several times to reveal its secrets. As for that YouTube performance, it’s by the Stamic Quartet, and it was given at the Levoca Festival in Slovakia in 2012. The image quality is a bit blurry, but the sound is more than adequate, I think. You’ll find the performance here: Foerster: String Quartet No 4 in F.
Day 591: Bach, Johann Bernhard (1676-1749)
Orchestral Suite No 3 in E Minor (Time: 23 minutes)
Today (22/5/26), I’m celebrating the 350th birthday of a member of the Bach family. Now, if your only Bach-related experiences are those where the music comes from Johann Sebastian, I should break to you gently the news that there are, literally, dozens of Bachs – mostly living in German lands in the 17th and 18th centuries – and almost all of them, thanks to genealogical work carried out by JS himself, when, presumably, he had the odd moment off from writing the well over 1000 works that came from his pen, we know were related to each other in some way. Today’s Bach is a new name on this list, though to be fair that doesn’t narrow down the options all that much, given that apart from Johann Sebastian the only Bach I’ve otherwise featured is one of his sons, Carl Philipp Emmanuel. Anyway, JS Bach had a second cousin – well, in fact, he had a lot of them – but one of them is the relatively little-known Johann Bernhard Bach. What is there to say about Johann Bernhard? His dates – 1676-1749 – reveal him to be a little older than JS (born in 1685), though they died within a year of each other. He was born in Erfurt, in the region of Thuringia, and was educated, musically at least, by his father, who it won’t surprise you to know was also a professional musician. By the age of 18 he was already appointed organist at a church in Erfurt, and subsequently his career took him to Magdeburg and then, in his late twenties, to Eisenach, where he remained employed from 1703 until his death. His main role was as harpsichordist in the court orchestra, a position he maintained until the orchestra was dissolved in 1741, but in addition he was organist and choirmaster at St George’s Church in Eisenach – a role in which he had succeeded yet another member of the Bach family, the slightly better-known Johann Christoph Bach. (Don’t confuse him – I’m sure you wouldn’t! – with Johann Sebastian’s son Johann Christoph Friedrich Bach. I should also tell you that there’ll be a test on all this later…) The reason we know the little we do about Johann Bernhard is, as I mentioned above, that JS Bach wrote about him in his survey of the sundry Bachs to whom he was related. But in fact JS and JB were on familiar terms throughout their lives. JS was godfather to JB’s son Johann Ernst; JB returned the favour by being godfather to JS’s son Johann Gottfried Bernhard – the latter having the distinction of not turning into a composer … though he was a professional musician. But the ties between JS and JB were not just familial. Johann Sebastian also performed some of Johann Bernhard’s music, and in fact the very little of JB’s music that survives today actually does so because JS performed it in Leipzig, and the orchestral parts to some of JB’s music were retained in the archives there. In particular, in 1730 or thereabouts, JS and his Leipzig music society orchestra performed the four orchestral suites by Johann Bernhard that have survived. The orchestral suite – or ‘Overture Suite’ as they were often known – was a very popular musical form in 18th century Germany. You may know that JS wrote (at least) four orchestral suites, which get regular performances these days, either in whole or in part, such as the ‘Air in G’ from the 3rd Suite. Probably the most fashionable and prolific of the various composers of orchestral suites was Telemann, who produced dozens of them, often with ‘character dances’ following a large-scale first movement in the style of a ‘French ouverture’ (slow, stately introduction in a heavily dotted rhythm, leading to a lively middle section, before the slow music returns at the end). This pattern is followed to the letter in the four orchestral suites by Johann Bernhard Bach that survive. We can infer that there were originally many more than these four, because there are contemporary descriptions of ‘the many beautiful overtures’ that JB produced ‘in the manner of Telemann’. YouTube provides us with video performances of all four of Johann Bernhard’s orchestral suites, and I wondered which might best show this composer as a worthy creative mind in his own right, and not just someone doing, if you like, Baroque ‘composing by numbers’. In the end, I think that 3rd suite, the one in E Minor, is perhaps the most consistent and imaginative of the set. It is in seven movements. After the initial substantial Ouverture, there follow two Airs, separated by a lively movement called ‘Les Plaisirs’, and subsequently there’s a Rigaudon, a Gavotte, and a Courante en Rondeau. This demonstrates that, like JS in his orchestral suites, not to mention his works for solo violin, solo cello, the English and French Suites for keyboard, and so many more, Johann Bernhard’s music is, fundamentally, dance music … or at least the idea of dance music underpins its composition. As for the recording, this is a bit off piste, but there’s an interesting performance made by the Bach Society of Brazil, playing on period instruments. The performers are directed from the harpsichord by Fernando Cordella, and the prominent flute part is played by Ricardo Kanjy. You’ll find the performance here: Johann Bernhard Bach: Orchestral Suite No 3 in E Minor.
Day 590: Sibelius, Jean (1865-1957)
En Saga (chamber version reconstructed by Gregory Barrett) (Time: 24 minutes)
Today (15/5/26) is the last of four postings that I’ve been putting together to mark this year’s Sheffield Chamber Music Festival (15-23 May) and I’m going to finish by considering a septet. The work in question is part of the programme for the last night of the festival, when Ensemble 360 will be playing a work by Sibelius, in a version which will be, allegedly, closer to its original scoring. This is his tone poem ‘En Saga’. Unless you have developed an interest in Sibelius’ music over time, it may be a surprise to you to know how much he actually wrote. These days what we tend to hear are just the symphonies (and really only Nos 1, 2, 5 and 7 with any regularity), plus the Violin Concerto (see Day 577), ‘Finlandia’ and the Karelia Suite. In fact, Sibelius wrote something like 550 works (the exact number is tricky to define precisely, because Sibelius, and/or his publishers, had a tendency to group smaller works into composite publications). Over the years 2007-11, the Swedish music label BIS produced a comprehensive ‘Sibelius Edition’, aiming to record every note that Sibelius composed. It runs to 68 CDs, amounting to over 80 hours of music! So, there’s a lot more to Sibelius than we might generally assume. Why bother to tell you all this? Well, because the rather labyrinthine nature of Sibelius’ oeuvre plays its part in the back-story to ‘En Saga’. In 1890, when Sibelius was in his mid-20s, he went to Vienna to study composition and orchestration with Fuchs (see Day 268) and Goldmark (one day, folks…), and one of the earliest tasks he was set was to study Mozart’s writing for clarinet. This may seem like an obscure place to start a discussion of ‘En Saga’, but in the following 18 months Sibelius started work on a septet, almost certainly scored for flute, clarinet, string quartet and double bass. The exact nature of this proto-piece is the subject of much conjecture, because the original manuscript has been assumed to be lost, but what is known is that it was re-worked over the next couple of years as the first version of the orchestral piece we know as ‘En Saga’. ‘En Saga’, as a title, might evoke Scandinavian or maybe Icelandic thoughts, given the literary tradition of these northern countries, but in fact a simple translation of the title would be ‘A Story’ or, if you want something a bit more poetic, ‘A Fairy Tale’. But, as you may know, Sibelius was fascinated all his life by the Finnish national text the ‘Kalevala’ – source material that eventually generated a dozen different works from Sibelius’ pen. The first of them, a sprawling symphonic structure for soloists, choir and orchestra, the ‘Kullervo Symphony’, was begun in Vienna and first performed in Helsinki in 1892. Its success prompted Sibelius’ friend (most of the time!) and conductor Robert Kajanus to ask Sibelius to write another ‘Kalevala’-based piece, but one that ‘would not make too great demands on the powers of concentration and comprehension’ of the audience (which Sibelius initially interpreted as a loaded criticism of the 80-minute long ‘Kullervo’). Whatever the intention behind Kajanus’ suggestion, Sibelius responded quickly – and the result was ‘En Saga’. This is odd amongst Sibelius’ eventually extensive collection of a dozen or so tone poems in that it has no overt story attached to it. In fact, Sibelius went to some lengths to stress the very definite absence of a narrative for the work. The closest he came was much later, when he said that ‘It represents an expression of a state of mind. I had recently undergone several painful experiences, and in no other work have I revealed myself so completely.’ Now, a comment like that begs lots of questions, but what those painful experiences were, and in what ways he might have revealed himself in ‘En Saga’, are questions that (unless Sibelius scholarship uncovers some new source material in the future) remain enigmatic. It is, as one commentator whom I’m afraid I can’t put a name to called it, ‘an adventure in an inner landscape’. The work, in its full orchestral garb, had its first performance in 1893. Almost a decade later, in 1902, Sibelius was invited to conduct a performance in Berlin of some of his work, and for that occasion he returned to the 1893 version of ‘En Saga’ and made some radical cuts to its length (seemingly as much as four minutes when compared to the revised version that usually lasts around 18-19 minutes) and also revised its orchestration. The pressure to amend and subsequently check the proofs of this ‘new’ version seems to be the reason for the disappearance of the original manuscript of the chamber version of ‘En Saga’, since Sibelius refers in comments at the time to using some pages of the original manuscript because they needed relatively little change to be made to them. Does all this matter? Not really (so, sorry to waste your reading time!), except that it explains the act of ‘reverse engineering’ on the part of the American clarinettist and musicologist Gregory Barrett, who worked backwards, as it were, from the revised orchestral score to get to the chamber version Sibelius might have first had at the start of this story. Structurally the piece is actually quite simple. After a short introduction, the rest of the work is constructed in sections we might label ABCBCBCA – that is, an extended ‘middle section’ made up of the treatment of themes ‘B’ and ‘C’, which alternate with each other three times, and that whole portion wrapped around with a kind of ‘intro/outro’ ‘A’ section. The work’s changing moods – now brooding, now decisive, now anguished – don’t really need ‘a story’ to explain them (so feel free to invent your own!), though from the somewhat bleak way in which the piece closes, it doesn’t seem to conclude with a happy ending… If you want to hear what the familiar full orchestral version of ‘En Saga’ sounds like, there are lots of performances on YouTube, including this one by the WDR Symphony Orchestra, Cologne, conducted by Ariane Matiakh, which you’ll find here, but I thought, in the light of the imminent performance of this by Ensemble 360, it might be interesting to encounter the chamber version, which you’ll find here, as played by the French performers of the Quatuor Zaide, alongside Irena Kavcic on flute, Tommaso Lonquich on clarinet, and Iztok Hrastnik on double bass: Sibelius: En Saga (chamber version reconstructed by Gregory Barrett).
Day 589: Brahms, Johannes (1833-97)
Horn Trio in Eb, Op 40 (Time: 29 minutes)
In recent instalments, I’ve been exploring pieces of music being played at this year’s Sheffield Chamber Music Festival and today (8/5/26), I’m looking at a trio. The trio in question features in a concert on the penultimate evening of the festival, when members of Ensemble 360 will be performing a work by Brahms. Brahms wrote three piano trios (that is, works for three performers playing violin, cello and piano), a clarinet trio (clarinet, cello and piano, written near the end of his life as part of the ‘Indian summer’ of chamber works inspired by the playing of clarinettist Richard Muhlfeld) and then one other piece for a trio of performers, the Horn Trio, Op 40. It’s this last piece that turns up in Ensemble 360’s concert, and is my focus for today. If you’ve had more than a passing acquaintance with this list over the years, you’ll know how very special the music of Brahms is for me, and that it moves me in ways that aren’t really true of any other composer, except maybe Schubert. He’s not generally what you’d call an innovative composer in the sense of breaking new ground; it’s more often the case that he took existing forms and structures and worked his magic on them. However, the Horn Trio is a bit of a curiosity, in that many discussions of it give the impression that nobody had written one until Brahms came along. Without wishing to spoil a good story, I don’t think that’s quite true, in that pieces for horn, violin and piano do exist in the repertoire before this work, but they’re pretty obscure. The earliest I’ve been able to track down is by Jan Ladislav Dussek (not to be confused – see Day 453 – with Franz Xaver Dussek), who wrote a ‘Notturno Concertante’ for these forces as early as 1809. The first to write a work that takes the sort of approach we’d expect of a piece labelled ‘Horn Trio’ is by that wonderful innovator Carl Czerny (see Day 493), a composer who deserves a lot more limelight than is currently the case. Czerny’s Trio No 1 of 1827 is for the same forces that Brahms wrote for, and is a substantial three-movement work. All this hasn’t stopped Brahms’ Horn Trio being described as the first of its kind, presumably because it established itself almost immediately in the repertoire of 19th century horn players, and is clearly one of Brahms’ major chamber works. One curiosity of the piece is not so much its scoring as the fact that it was written for a ‘natural horn’ (in German, a ‘waldhorn’), an instrument without valves, so that if you wanted to play a note that wasn’t part of its natural harmonic scale – in practice, you had a choice of only 16 notes – you could only do it by stuffing your hand to a greater or lesser extent in the bell of the instrument. Brahms would have heard his musician father playing such an instrument regularly as a child. Valved horns (Ladybird Book of Musical Instruments summary: ones that could play a full range of notes equivalent to chromatic scales on a piano) began to appear in around 1815, though it was only about thirty years later that composers began routinely to write for them. Brahms’ Horn Trio was begun in 1865, so Brahms was being distinctly ‘retro’ in writing the work for the natural horn. Apparently, he preferred the sound of the natural horn, considering it more ‘authentic’ and (an important consideration) reminiscent of the musical sounds of his childhood, which, in terms of this work’s genesis, was particularly important. Nobody knows for sure what prompted the work, but he began to sketch it only three months or so after the death of his mother in February 1865. A lot of time is often spent trying to pry under the surface of Brahms’ rather curmudgeonly personality, particularly in terms of his relationship with women. There’s obviously the long-running saga of his connection with Clara Schumann, and the 1860s and 70s featured at least one abortive love affair that he’d hoped would lead to marriage. But there are grounds for saying that the woman he was closest to in his life was his mother, and her death (she was taken suddenly ill and died before Brahms could get from Vienna to Hamburg to see her) caused him great grief. It was on a kind of retreat in the Black Forest in the summer of 1865 that he finally began to come to terms with his distress, and to turn it in a musical direction. Its most powerful expression is in this trio, particularly the first and third of its four movements, which are poignant and nostalgic. The four movement form (slow/fast/slow/fast) occurs nowhere else in Brahms’ chamber output, and seems reminiscent of the ‘church sonata’ structure of 18th century chamber works by Corelli and the like, which again gives the piece a kind of ‘backward-looking’ feel. The first movement is an oddity in Brahms’ chamber compositions – his only first movement not in sonata form, with its rigorously worked-out formal structure. Instead it consists simply of two themes, alternated in an A-B-A-B-A way. The first theme is a close relation of one of Brahms’ favourite folk songs as a child, ‘In der Weiden steht ein Haus’ (‘In the meadow there stands a house’) – more nostalgia! The primary use of the horn, historically, was as a ‘hunting’ instrument, and in the faster movements Brahms writes strikingly in this vein. So, the second movement’s outer sections are dominated by a fanfare-like theme, enclosing a lovely, mellifluous folk-like middle section. The emotional heart of the piece is its ‘adagio mesto’ (‘sad adagio’) third movement – not, in some simplistic way, a ‘funeral march’, but nonetheless a deeply introspective, intensely felt movement, a musing on mortality that never tips into sentimentality or mawkishness. It was, contemporary references made clear, an elegy for his mother. The finale, another brisk, fanfare-led movement, clears the air and rounds off the work in vigorous high spirits. Its scoring was, as I’ve said, unusual – which might explain why Brahms also prepared a performing edition in which the cello replaces the horn (so that it’s scored like a conventional piano trio), and why later still he sanctioned the publication of a version in which the viola takes what had been the horn part. But in its horn/violin/piano form it strikes an (almost) unique note in 19th century music, and it is, I think, a masterpiece! (But then I would, wouldn’t I…?) There are many really quite impressive video recordings of the piece on YouTube. Almost everyone these days plays it on a ‘modern’ valved horn, but if you want to hear what the work sounds like on the natural horn, there’s a good performance, played by Javier Bonet on horn, with Mario Pérez on violin and Miriam Gómez-Morán on piano, which you’ll find here, but after listening to a few performances elsewhere on YouTube I’d finally recommend this one, by one of the contemporary legends of the horn, Radovan Vlatkovic, alongside Jakub Haufa on violin and Ilya Rashkovskiy on piano. You’ll find their performance here: Brahms: Horn Trio in Eb, Op 40.
Day 588: Walton, William (1902-83)
Piano Quartet (Time: 28 minutes)
Today (1/5/26), another posting of music being played at this year’s Sheffield Chamber Music Festival, and this time it’s a piano quartet. Assuming the conventional combination of instruments for compositions with these titles, the difference between a piano quintet and piano quartet is – and try not to be too stunned by this revelation – that the latter requires one fewer player, and typically that means that instead of having a string quartet alongside the piano we have a string trio (violin, viola, cello). Over the past 250 years or so, there have been quite a lot more piano quartets written than piano quintets, and that is evident these days in terms of performing groups – there are many more piano quartet ensembles than piano quintet ensembles (performances of piano quintets usually involve an established string quartet playing with a guest pianist) simply because they have a wider repertoire to choose from. Anyway, today’s piano quartet is the one by William Walton. It’s a very early work, and it reminds me that if we consider early 20th century English composers who hit their stride very young, as it were, the stand out figure is obviously Benjamin Britten. However, although he had fewer works under his belt at the end of his teens (and in fact fewer works under his belt, full stop), Walton too was something of a musical prodigy. Walton was often self-deprecating about his past. There’s a poignant comment he made in a TV documentary about his life, just before he died in 1983, in which he said, of his time as a boy chorister at Christ Church, Oxford, that by the age of 14 ‘I had to make myself interesting somehow or when my voice [broke] I [would] be sent back to Oldham,’ adding, ‘I was very lucky, I was so damned stupid, all I could do was write music.’ His Piano Quartet was written in 1918/19, so most of it emerged before his 17th birthday, although he revised it several times over the decades – in 1921, and again in 1924 before its publication, prior to its first public performance in Liverpool that year, and then yet again in 1974, prompted by a performance at the Aldeburgh Festival in 1973, although this final revision seems to focus largely on clarifying and simplifying the piano part in the last movement, rather than being a fundamental re-composition. The immediate stimulus for the work seems to have been the fact that he was impressed by a piece for the same forces by Herbert Howells, and thus Walton responded to the challenge of writing his own piano quartet. Later (more of his familiar self-deprecation), he said of the work that it was ‘my first composition to show any kind of talent; it was written when I was a drooling baby but it is a very attractive piece.’ As one might expect of any work written by someone in their mid teens (apart from Mozart, maybe) it’s a composition that reveals a lot about the impact of the composers Walton was aware of in the environment around him at the time: commentators have at various times written about the influence of Howells, Elgar, Vaughan Williams, Ireland, Bridge, Brahms, Fauré, Ravel and Stravinsky – but one thing’s for sure, and that is that you can hear a great deal of mature Walton in it as well. The Piano Quartet has four movements. The first is probably the one that most clearly shows his debt to Howells’ own piano quartet, particularly the rather modal (vaguely ‘folk song’) quality of the opening themes. The piano comes to the fore in more dramatic, staccato passages, but for the most part, there’s more lyricism and rather less of the rhythmic jaggedness that was to become Walton’s trade-marked style as the 1920s unfolded. You hear rather more of this rhythmic attack in the spiky ‘Allegro scherzando’ second movement, which also includes Walton’s first published use of fugal writing as a formal device. There are echoes of the main theme of the first movement; this turns up again in both the slow movement and the finale, and is part of Walton’s strategy to unify the work as a whole. If we’re playing ‘spot the influences’ here, I think I’d say the rhythmic quality is Walton’s own, while melodically it all feels a bit Elgarian. The influential composer in the ‘Andante tranquillo’ third movement, however, is Ravel: Walton quotes directly from the piano part to one of Ravel’s songs, and more generally the whole harmonic ‘feel’ of the movement owes a lot to Ravel. For me, this is the finest movement; it’s tender, gentle stuff, a little elegiac in places, and though there’s a darker, more brooding passage later (cello and viola play versions of the work’s opening theme), we end in stillness and calm. In many ways, though, the finale looks forward to mature Walton (and, if you’re looking for influences, the language of Stravinsky, and even Bartok, whose ‘Allegro Barbaro’ Walton had been studying at the time, apparently) with its choppy rhythms and off-kilter fugue. In a way that’s very familiar in the works of all sorts of composers, there are moments of stillness just before the close of the movement, and one last recall of how the whole work began, before the emphatic, whirlwind conclusion. YouTube has a number of decent performances of the work, and from them I’ve gone for this one by the Notos Quartett, a Germany-based ensemble made up of Sindri Lederer on violin, Andrea Burger on viola, Philip Graham on cello and Antonia Köster on piano. The video itself is a bit odd in places – some of the camera angles aren’t terribly sensitive to the music – but the performance is engaged and committed. You’ll find it here: Walton: Piano Quartet.
Day 587: Korngold, Erich (1897-1957)
Piano Quintet, Op 15 (Time: 33 minutes)
Today (24/4/26), the first of four postings that I’m going to devote to pieces being played at next month’s Sheffield Chamber Music Festival, on the first weekend of which Ensemble 360 will play a chamber composition by Korngold, his Piano Quintet, Op 15. We’ve had two pieces by Korngold (1897-1957) on this list already (see Day 276 for his popular Violin Concerto and Day 295 for his terrific Symphonic Serenade for Strings), but so far nothing for chamber music forces, and chamber music was a medium to which Korngold returned regularly during his composing career. As you may know, Korngold’s musical life is the classic ‘game of two halves’. In the first, he was a Viennese musical prodigy of extraordinary talent – producing the ballet ‘The Snowman’ at age 11, his brilliant and substantial Sinfonietta at 14, having two one-act operas conducted by no less a figure than Bruno Walter before he was 16, before his Europe-sweeping opera ‘Die tote Stadt’ (‘The Dead City’) emerged by the age of 22. In the 1920s he had more operas performed in opera houses across Europe than anyone except Richard Strauss. Korngold, however, was Jewish, and with the rise of Fascism across Europe he moved to America, where his second career, as a Hollywood film composer, began in the mid-1930s with ‘Captain Blood’, and led to 22 film scores, two of which won Oscars. For most of the rest of the 20th century the fact that he was perceived as having ‘sold out’ to Hollywood meant that his concert music and operas were ignored, and it’s only in the past 30 years or so that Korngold has been rehabilitated as one of the great composers of the first half of the 20th century, and you can now get almost all his major scores in front-rank recorded performances. The Piano Quintet is a product of peak ‘first career’ Korngold. He wrote it in 1921, and it was premiered two years later. One feature of the rhythm, if you like, of Korngold’s compositional career is that he tended to write chamber scores immediately after large-scale operatic pieces. Thus, ‘Die tote Stadt’, after its simultaneous premieres in Hamburg and Cologne in 1920, went on to be performed at opera houses across the continent over the next few years, and in its wake, as a way of ‘taking stock’, as it were, he began work on two substantial chamber pieces, a first string quartet, and his Piano Quintet in E, Op 15. The latter is a substantial work in three movement, full of lush, late Romantic harmonies and some really challenging writing for all five players. There are links connecting this work to the recently-composed ‘Die tote Stadt’, and also to a song cycle of a few years earlier, ‘Abschiedlieder’, his ‘songs of farewell’. In the song cycle, and thus in the piano quintet that followed, there are coded references to the growing love affair between Korngold and Luise von Sonnenthal, his beloved ‘Luzi’, whom he eventually married in 1924, after a long courtship and against the wishes of his parents. The key song from the cycle, the title of which might be translated as ‘Moon, thus you rise once more’, which Luzi suggested contained references to the sound of her voice, forms the basis for the emotional core of the piano quintet, where it is made the foundation for a set of nine free variations on the song material that make up the slow movement. However, before that, there’s a swirling, impassioned opening movement (Korngold gives the movements quite elaborate titles, and this first one he labels ‘Moderate speed, with blossoming expression’), one that feels very operatic and full of very Richard Strauss-like harmonic richness. It’s a movement that teems with ideas, from the expansive, upward-leaping opening motif, followed by a gentle, almost simple (but distinctly Mahlerian) second theme. However, it’s the extensive slow movement that really steals the show for me. As I’ve noted, it’s a set of variations, but the experience of listening to this might not make it easy to hear when one variation ends and the next starts, because the thematic ideas undergo almost constant growth and elaboration in one long, unbroken arch. As a declaration of love for the woman who was to become his wife, it’s a movement of great tenderness, moving from dream-like raptness to deep introspection, before concluding mysteriously but luminously (if you’ll allow the mixed metaphor) on an unresolved chord. The last movement starts with apparent seriousness, with a dramatic violin cadenza, but then it opens out into something more light-hearted, bubbling over with unpredictable energy. There are moments towards the close of the work that feel almost orchestral in texture, such is the density and complexity of the instrumental writing. Before the end the opening theme of the first movement is restated, but then there’s a thrilling (and trilling) dash to the finish line. For a work that doesn’t get that many outings in the concert hall, there turn out to be really quite a lot of video recordings of this piece on YouTube. Out of the options I’ve gone for this one, by an ad hoc collection of exceptional performers, brought together for a chamber festival in Amsterdam in early 2021. So, here are Daniel Rowland on first violin, Tijmen Huisingh on second violin, Joël Waterman on viola, Maja Bogdanovic on cello and Natacha Kudritskaya on piano. The performance is preceded by a slightly meandering introduction by Daniel Rowland, so the music starts after about two and a half minutes, but I thought a link to the whole video was worthwhile, if only because Rowland makes the (to me) somewhat outrageous claim that this is the greatest of all piano quintets. What, greater than the Schumann or Brahms piano quintets, or the Dvorak, or Franck, or (from the 20th century) the piano quintets by Shostakovich or Weinberg? Not for me, anyway… But still, it’s a very fine piece of music, and you’ll find it here: Korngold: Piano Quintet, Op 15.
Day 586: Tchaikovsky, Pyotr Ilyich (1840-93)
Symphony No 2 (Time: 35 minutes)
Early next month, the Hallé will be at the City Hall in a programme including music by Tchaikovsky, and he is my focus for today (17/4/26). If I said the work in question was one of Tchaikovsky’s symphonies, one might almost certainly expect it to be a performance of the 4th, 5th or 6th symphonies, because, let’s face it, it’s almost always true. (When it isn’t, it’s usually because the orchestra is playing the ‘Manfred’ Symphony instead.) The reality is that Tchaikovsky’s first three numbered symphonies almost never appear in the concert hall, which seems to me to be a great shame, not because they’re masterpieces – they aren’t, really – but because they offer another side to the composer than the ‘tortured soul’ we’ve come to expect, symphonically. And for me, particularly, the opportunity to encounter a performance of the Symphony No 2 is especially exciting, because this was the first of Tchaikovsky’s symphonies that I fell in love with. That might require a bit of explanation, so I should point out that I was 12 or 13 at the time, and with hindsight I suspect it’s probable that I simply wasn’t ready, emotionally, for the turbulence of any of the final three symphonies as a 12-year-old, not yet having encountered teenage angst, and what I really wanted was a really good tune or two, played as loudly as possible, and maybe even over and over again. In this respect, Tchaik 2 ticks all the boxes, as they say. As you may know, Tchaikovsky did not find composing symphonies to be an easy task, being daunted by the Germanic tradition in this field. He respected Haydn and Beethoven, but absolutely adored Mozart, whose late symphonies cast a long shadow. There were later 19th century composers in the Germanic tradition that he valued (and took ideas from), notably Mendelssohn and Schumann, but in truth the biggest stumbling block to overcome was the simple fact that ‘the symphony’ was not a form with any history in Russia at all. Glinka started, but didn’t finish, two of them. In the generation before Tchaikovsky, there’s Anton Rubinstein (who wrote six of them, that don’t sound very Russian at all), and among his contemporaries there’s Borodin (who wrote two – and the 2nd is particularly wonderful), Balakirev (who also wrote two) and Rimsky-Korsakov (three). What those last three composers shared was a belief that ‘the Russian symphony’ should draw its inspiration, in large measure, from Russian folk song, and its melodic and harmonic conventions. For Tchaikovsky, wanting to face westwards, as it were, to write a ‘European’ symphony at least as much as a ‘Russian’ one, squaring that particular circle was a hard task. He struggled with his Symphony No 1 in his mid-twenties, and its mixed response led him to revise it, over and over, for the next 20 years or so, and even then it was a piece he regarded as deficient, structurally, even if it was, he said, ‘a sin of my sweet youth’ for which he always retained ‘a soft spot’. However, it was to be six years before he tried the symphony as a form again, and this time, like his nationalist peers, he found inspiration in Russian folk song. This has led to the symphony acquiring a label which, in contemporary terms, is problematical. He wrote almost all of it in draft form in the summer of 1872, while staying on the estate of his married sister in the region of Russia that was then known as ‘the Ukraine’, or ‘Little Russia’. Obviously these days, when Ukraine is a separate sovereign nation, this might feel like a rather contentious label, but (wishing to avoid historical revisionism) back in the late 19th century the country we now know as Ukraine was, for better or worse, part of Russia, and in that sense, its folk melodies were ‘Russian’ ones, and Tchaikovsky’s use of them was, in the 1870s, very popular. The symphony was enthusiastically welcomed on its first performance, but (typical Tchaikovsky) he had second thoughts, and the version that’s heard these days, when we encounter it at all, is Tchaikovsky’s revision, first heard in 1881, which tidied up some of the clunky transitional passages and made ‘an enormous cut’ (Tchaikovsky’s own description) in the finale. What gives the 2nd Symphony its character, I think, is that you’ll find in it none of the angst-laden morbidity that features elsewhere in his symphonies (even the 1st, and the really rather dull 3rd, succumb to that at times), and the result is consistently genial and often playful. The first movement has a slow introduction, which uses the folk song ‘Down by Mother Volga’, before the main Allegro Vivo follows a more conventionally symphonic course. The slow movement isn’t really slow at all, but rather it’s a gentle march, which started life as the Bridal March in his rejected opera ‘Undine’, written three years earlier. There’s a central section that makes use of another folk song, ‘Spin, O my Spinner’ (catchy, huh?), that Tchaikovsky had encountered a little earlier when he was putting together an anthology, ’50 Russian Folk Songs’, that he had arranged for piano duet. The third movement Scherzo is quite like an extract from a Tchaikovsky ballet (especially the middle section, which foreshadows ‘The Sleeping Beauty’), and it’s a very rhythmically driven movement, with lots of use made of bars in 2/8 time played simultaneously against other instruments playing in 3/8 time. It’s the last movement, though, that’s the ‘folkiest’ of all, a set of variations (one might uncharitably say ‘repetitions’) on the folk song ‘The Crane’, which, apparently, Tchaikovsky first encountered on his sister’s estate, sung by the butler! There are some contrasts in the movement – there’s a quirky little syncopated dance tune that’s Tchaikovsky’s own invention – but essentially the finale focuses on the folk song theme, which is varied not so much in terms of developing the melody, but rather presenting it, or phrases from it, in different keys or played by different combinations of instruments. Eventually there’s a loud climax, a crash on the tam-tam, and then a helter-skelter ‘presto’ coda which takes us to a breathless conclusion. As I say, my 12-year-old self loved it. Now I can see it as a stage in Tchaikovsky’s journey towards finding a voice that would allow him to express something more personal, more intimate, but I still think it’s a work that’s lots of fun to listen to, and one that should see the light of day far more often than it does. As for a performance, YouTube is pretty well stocked, and out of the options I’ve gone for this one, performed by the London Symphony Orchestra, conducted rather unexpectedly (not his usual repertoire) by Sir John Eliot Gardiner. You’ll find it here: Tchaikovsky: Symphony No 2.
Day 585: Ravel, Maurice (1875-1937)
Bolero (Time: 14 minutes)
Today (10/4/26), I have a very mainstream choice, one of the most popular compositions in the whole of the repertoire. The reason is because imminently at Sheffield City Hall there’s a rare visit from a Spanish orchestra, the Spanish Galicia Symphony Orchestra, playing a programme of works celebrating the light and colour of their homeland, including this piece by Ravel. This music has some claim to being Ravel’s most famous composition. In fact, when the rather corny romantic comedy ‘10’ appeared in cinemas in 1979, starring Bo Derek and (somewhat bizarrely) Dudley Moore, a film in which Ravel’s music was used for its, shall we say, orgasmic effect, the result was that for a little while Ravel became the best-selling classical composer in the world. That popularity increased further in 1984 when the ice skaters Torvill and Dean used ‘Bolero’ in their gold medal-winning performance at that year’s Winter Olympics. It is in many ways an odd work, and Ravel tended to describe it in, for want of better, ‘anti-musical’ terms. It began life as a commission from the dancer (and actress and general cultural icon of the early decades of the 20th century) Ida Rubinstein for Ravel to orchestrate some of the music from Albeniz’s piano suite ‘Iberia’ for a ballet. Discovering that the Spanish composer Enrique Arbós had already made a start on this, Ravel decided to orchestrate a work of his own instead, and later still to write something original from scratch. There are conflicting visions of the scene that the music might have portrayed. In Rubinstein’s version, premiered with sensational success in November 1928, this note appeared in the programme: ‘Inside a tavern in Spain, people dance beneath the brass lamp hung from the ceiling. In response to the cheers to join in, the female dancer has leapt onto the long table and her steps become more and more animated.’ This is not remotely what Ravel had had in mind. In his view, the music is deliberately, overtly mechanistic, and he had imagined the setting as an open-air space in front of a factory, so that the insistent rhythm and repetitive patterns of the piece exemplify the relentless drive of machinery in operation. As is well known, it’s a work with lots of repetition and virtually no musical development. Composers are, often, perverse creatures, and perhaps it was the work’s exceptional popularity that caused Ravel to be so dismissive of it. Interviewed by The Daily Telegraph in 1931 he said, ‘It constitutes an experiment in a very special and limited direction, and should not be suspected of aiming at achieving anything different from, or anything more than, it actually does achieve. Before its first performance, I issued a warning to the effect that what I had written was a piece lasting seventeen minutes and consisting wholly of "orchestral tissue without music"—of one very long, gradual crescendo. There are no contrasts, and practically no invention except the plan and the manner of execution.’ It has to be said that not everybody liked what they heard. The composer and writer Constant Lambert, in his 1930s book ‘Music Ho!’, wrote: ‘There is a definite limit to the length of time a composer can go on writing in one dance rhythm (this limit is obviously reached by Ravel towards the end of “La Valse” and towards the beginning of “Boléro”).’ Lambert, though, is in a minority, and ‘Bolero’ is a work that seems able to satisfy almost all listeners at whatever level of engagement they choose to take it on. The work is one of many in Ravel’s oeuvre that reveal his Spanish, or at least Basque, roots (his mother was from the Basque region), though famously he didn’t visit Spain until after most of his ‘Iberian’ works had been written, so what we have here is the Spain of his imagination (and the songs his mother sang to him as a child from her time living and working in Madrid). One of the things that interests me most about Ravel is the usually cool precision of his orchestration, and the orderly – sometimes quite fastidious – nature of his compositions. In that sense his music reveals not just his Basque maternal roots but the ‘Swiss watch-maker’ precision (a cliché, I know, but all clichés have a grain of truth in them) he inherited from his Swiss father. And so, though we can see ‘Bolero’ as the journey from foreplay to climax (and I think it’s really difficult not to feel that this music is consciously sexual – and I’m sure that’s not just me!), on another level it’s about how you build a musical edifice out of the most basic materials by concentrating on, if you like, its design features. The work lasts, in most performances, around 14-15 minutes (though really slow ones can take up to 17, and at the other end of the scale Ravel fell out with the conductor Arturo Toscanini because the conductor took it too fast, making a recording that takes just over 13). It starts with a snare drum, pianissimo, playing a two-bar rhythm, which its player then repeats unchangingly 169 times – well, unchanging apart from getting progressively louder. Over it, there are two melodies, identical in length, which are repeated in turn. The first has a narrower range from high to low, the second a much wider one, and the latter has a far more ‘bluesy’ feel because some of the notes of its scale are flattened. (It doesn’t matter, I think, if the musical jargon means little to you – you can feel the effect in performance.) Then the melodies are repeated 18 times, in pairs – melody A, melody A repeated, melody B, melody B repeated, and so on – as the orchestration fills out: flute, then clarinet, then other wind instruments, until by repetition no.7 we meet the trumpet, then saxophone, then, by repetition no.11, we get trombones added to the mix, and so on and so on. By repetition no.17 the full orchestra is playing fortissimo, and you might think, well, how can it be ended? This is Ravel’s masterstroke, because having been in C Major throughout, there’s a sudden shift at repetition no.18 into E Major, just for eight bars, before it drops back into C Major and comes crashing, via some crunching dissonances, to a close. (And again, if the ‘C to E’ shift and back again means nothing, just feel the experience as a listener!) As one programme note I once read about this work remarked, ‘never in the field of musical composition have so many enjoyed so much made from so little.’ YouTube, perhaps unsurprisingly, has very many video and lots more audio recordings of this work, so you can find a performance that suits you easily enough. I’ve gone for this one, recorded at the BBC Proms in 2014, performed by the West-Eastern Divan Orchestra, conducted by Daniel Barenboim. I pick this partly because Barenboim’s orchestra is one of the great achievements of musical/political diplomacy, but also because the flute player who takes the initial melody is Guy Eshed, who those with a long-ish memory will remember as one of the founder members of Ensemble 360 back in 2005, before the chance of working with Mr Barenboim lured him away to something more in the global spotlight. You’ll find the performance here: Ravel: Bolero.
Day 584: Danzi, Franz (1763-1826)
Wind Quintet in Bb, Op 56 No 1 (Time: 13 minutes) and Quintet for Piano and Winds, Op 41 (25 minutes)
Today (3/4/26), there’s another new name to add to the by now pretty extensive list of composers you can explore on this list. The reason for my choice is that on 13th April it will be 200 years exactly since the death of Franz Danzi, a composer of some note in his day, but whose reputation has only really recovered in the CD era over the past 40 years or so. Franz Ignaz Danzi (1763-1826) – and so with a birth date exactly midway between those of Mozart and Beethoven – was born in Schwetzingen, near Mannheim, which pretty clearly makes him a German composer. However, his father, an Italian, was in Mannheim when Franz was born because he was principal cellist in the famous Mannheim orchestra at the time. It’s not pushing things to say that Danzi’s music has a foot in both ‘national’ styles. If you’re not familiar with 18th century orchestral history, by the way, it’s worth saying that the Mannheim orchestra in the latter half of the 18th century, when Johann Stamitz was its leader, had a reputation as the top rank orchestra in German lands, famous notably for its brilliantly drilled string and woodwind sections, and in particular for two musical ‘effects’, the so-called ‘Mannheim rocket’, when the strings would perform fast rising scales (see the opening of Mozart’s Symphony No 31, for instance) and the orchestra’s steadily growing crescendo at moments of climax, of the sort that Rossini made famous in subsequent decades. Franz himself was primarily a cellist, and he joined the orchestra as a teenager in 1778, taking over from his father as principal in 1784. He later worked in Munich, Stuttgart and finally Karlsruhe. Danzi was famous in his day as a writer of music for woodwind ensembles, though his back catalogue contains the typical range of symphonies, string quartets and concerti as well. However, it’s the wind band that I’m going to explore today. Although wind ensembles had had a place at the various European courts for many decades, their development from the mid-1700s onwards is as striking, in its way, as that of the string quartet or the symphony under Haydn and his many Austro-German contemporaries. If there’s one name associated with early 19th century wind music it’s Anton Reicha (the Germanic spelling – you’ll find lots of variants, like Antonin or Antoine Rejcha). Reicha’s wind quintets raised the wind ensemble from being purveyors of light, ‘entertainment’ music to something closer to chamber music that placed higher demands on performers and audiences, the equivalent in many ways of the string quartet. (I’ll get round to Reicha one day, I hope…) Reicha was based in Paris, and Danzi first discovered Reicha’s wind quintets via the contemporary music press, and on exploring the written scores of some of them he set out to model his work on their rich sonorities, a mixture of an ensemble approach where all instruments sound together and the more individualistic, quasi-soloistic approach where particular instruments have a concerto-like role. Danzi wrote three sets of three wind quintets, scored (as you might expect) for flute, oboe, clarinet, bassoon and horn. They all seem to have been written in the first half of the 1820s – so, very much at the end of his life – though there’s little concrete evidence to suggest why he wrote them at that point in particular. Of the nine, I’ve chosen the Wind Quintet in Bb, Op 56 No 1, as a typical example of his musical ‘voice’. The Op 56 set was published in 1821 and dedicated to Reicha. It’s sparky and good-humoured writing, very ‘Classical’ in style (a big debt to Mozart, I think), but what I like most is the way Danzi captures the individual characters of the five instruments in a genuinely idiomatic way. There are four movements. The first is neatly organised and amiable, but the second shows something more pensive, in the minor key, where the lead is often the oboe or the bassoon, giving the music a less ‘bright’ character. The minuet third movement is typically ‘dancing’, and I especially like the playful dialogue of the instruments in the trio section in the middle of the movement. The finale is a good-humoured rondo with an identifiable ‘bounce’ to it. YouTube has a nice performance of the work in its catalogue, given by the Monet Wind Quintet, a group who met first as members of the German National Youth Orchestra, and who have performed as a quintet for over a decade. You’ll find their performance here: Danzi: Wind Quintet in Bb, Op 56 No 1. Danzi also wrote three quintets for wind and piano, which largely date from around a decade earlier than the wind quintets. Even with our ’40 minute rule’, there’s opportunity for another work by Danzi today, so I’ve chosen the first of these pieces, the Quintet for Piano and Winds in D Minor, Op 41, which dates from 1810. (Danzi published a version for strings and piano – his Op 40 – at the same time, which suggests a composer with an eye for as many audiences as possible!) Compared to the wind quintets, the piano here replaces the flute, which gives the whole ensemble a slightly darker sonority. It’s also clear that it’s the piano that has the most obviously ‘soloistic’ role, though there’s still the sort of ‘dialogue of equals’ at times between the piano and the various wind instruments that you’ll find in Mozart’s Quintet for Piano and Winds (see Day 538!). I make no claims for the Danzi in comparison to the infinitely superior Mozart piece, but it’s a good illustration of music of this era from the pen of a capable workman, as opposed to a genius! Danzi’s Op 41 is in three movements, though the first has a solemn slow introduction before we arrive at its genial Allegro main section. The Andante slow movement is the sort of thing that attracts an adjective like ‘charming’, while the finale burbles happily. There’s a nice video performance of it on YouTube, given by the Spanish chamber music group the Azahar Ensemble, with Rosalia Gómez Lasheras as the elegant and poised pianist. You’ll find their performance here: Danzi: Quintet for Piano and Winds, Op 41.
Day 583: Schumann, Robert (1810-56)
String Quartet Op 41 No 3 (Time: 31 minutes)
Today (27/3/26), my composer is Robert Schumann, and the reason for my choice is that imminently the Fibonacci Quartet, who have been accumulating prizes all across Europe in the past three or four years, are playing here in Sheffield – a concert that includes this Schumann quartet. Although Schumann gets a reasonable amount of exposure in concerts and broadcasts, this tends to be mostly either piano music or orchestral works. His three string quartets hardly get a look in, which is a state I intend to remedy right now. So, Schumann has appeared four times on this list already, looking at two of his major piano works, plus a movement from one of his symphonies and the vigorously bucolic Konzertstuck for Four Horns and Orchestra. However, the absence of any chamber music is another reason for exploring some today. Schumann’s character, a topic harder to separate from his compositions than is the case with almost all other composers, was one of extremes. There’s evidence of what today we might call ‘bipolar’ characteristics (mood swings so extreme that Schumann had his own names – Florestan and Eusebius – for these two ‘sides’ of his character), and also of a temperamental obsessiveness that meant that he often got ‘hooked’ on a particular musical idea, which he then pursued relentlessly. You can see some of this obsession in things like the fact that 1840 was his ‘year of song’ – he wrote over 150 of them in that year – and 1841 was his ‘year of orchestral music’. 1842 became his ‘year of chamber music’, of which he’d written almost nothing up to that point. But in 1842 he wrote his only string quartets (there are three of them), his piano quartet, his piano quintet and a set of fantasy pieces for piano trio. In 1842 his emotional state was ambivalent. He was blissfully happy at being married, at long last, to Clara, but in the early part of the year he also struggled a little with being ‘second fiddle’ in the relationship, accompanying Clara, world-famous concert pianist, on her latest tour around Europe – plenty of ‘And what do you do, Mr Schumann?’ moments. Returning home alone while Clara finished the final legs of her tour, he began to have what he described as ‘quartet-ish thoughts’, and returned to a previous study of the quartets of Haydn, Mozart and especially Beethoven. Then, in the summer of 1842, in the space of about three weeks (obsessive focus or what?) he wrote all three of his string quartets. The one I’m going to focus on, the A Major, Op 41 No 3, seems to have been completed in less than a week! There’s plenty of evidence that Schumann in fact saw the three quartets as a cycle, giving them linked themes and key relationships, and indeed writing short ‘transitional’ segments of music to join the quartets together into one continuous performance. They very rarely get played in the same concert, however, and in fact it’s quite a novelty to find one of them in concert at all. His String Quartet No 3 is the sunniest of the three, and it has some quirky and unusual features. The first movement starts with a tender, falling two-note figure – plenty of evidence here that he saw this as a ‘Clara’ motif – and that downward interval comes to dominate not just this ‘Andante espressivo’ slow introduction, but much of the whole piece. Interestingly, for someone whose piano music is often wildly romantic and given to flights of fancy, this quartet (like the other two) is remarkably concise and almost ‘classically’ structured – the result of his prefatory study of the work of his great predecessors. The movement isn’t monothematic, but pretty much all the material comes back to this sighing figure with which the movement started, and with which it finishes. The second movement, a theme and variations, is especially curious, because it’s only really with the third of the four variations that we get to what you might see as a statement of the actual theme itself. The opening of the movement, where we might expect to hear the theme, is instead given to a kind of shadowy, half-remembered version of it, almost like a singer gasping for breath. Another oddity of the movement is that we hardly ever know where the ‘down beat’ is – much of the time what we think is the down beat is actually an up beat. After it there’s another variation, full of churning forward momentum, and then a very curious coda which, in one discussion I’ve read, is described as ‘wandering like a sleepwalker through various keys before settling to a standstill.’ The emotional core of the work is the ‘Adagio molto’ third movement. To quote again from the analysis I’ve come across, it’s part hymn, part declaration of love, but – Schumann being Schumann – there’s then a central section which feels much more nightmarish, with the initially consoling theme subjected to troubling transformation. One might see the movement’s conclusion as the reassertion of stability, but darker undercurrents remain. The last movement is a rondo – actually a ‘double rondo’, in that there are two ‘A’ sections which find themselves interspersed with contrasting ‘B’ and ‘C’ sections. Like the second movement, this finale leaves you guessing throughout as to where the first beat of the bar is, and like the first movement this last one begins with exactly the same chord, though transformed by its different context. The quartet ends more or less jubilantly – more or less because even in the whirling coda it’s still hard to know where the down beat comes to mark the start of each bar until we get right to the very end of the work. Looking back over the quartet as a whole, you could say that Florestan (the ‘sunny’ side of Schumann’s identity) wins the day … but only just. As I’ve suggested, Schumann’s quartets don’t get out much, but on YouTube there’s a lovely performance by the wonderful Quatuor Ebène, which you’ll find here: Schumann: String Quartet Op 41 No 3.
Day 582: d’Indy, Vincent (1851-1931)
Symphony on a French Mountain Air (Time: 27 minutes)
Exactly one week from today (20/3/26), it will be 150 years since the birth of Vincent d’Indy so this posting should shine some light on (in my opinion) this still far too easily overlooked late 19th/early 20th century composer. And for his impending birthday I’d like to introduce you, if you don’t know it already, to d’Indy’s most famous work. Paul Marie Théodore Vincent d'Indy, in full, has appeared once before on this list – see Day 174 for his nostalgic, elegant Cello Sonata of 1925. As I wrote back then, d’Indy doesn’t get much of a look in these days, though the music label Chandos has a fine series of recordings devoted to his orchestral music, and you can even find quite a bit of his chamber music if you look hard enough. It would be fair to say that although he was massively important to the development of French musical studies in the period 1870-1910 in particular – as Secretary and then President of the Société Nationale de Musique that was founded immediately after the terribly humiliating Franco-Prussian War of 1870-71, as co-founder of the Schola Cantorum de Paris, set up to promote greater intellectual musical rigour than was allegedly on offer at the Paris Conservatoire, and as the teacher of an authentic ‘who’s who’ of later generations of composers (Magnard, Roussel, Honegger, Milhaud, Canteloube, Satie – though he claimed to have learned nothing from the experience – and, implausibly, Cole Porter) – it’s still a rare thing to encounter a work by d’Indy in the concert hall, or even on the radio. It’s hard to escape the thought that d’Indy’s time in the spotlight never quite came to pass. He was (like his mentor César Franck) in love with Wagner’s music at a time when all things Germanic were shunned in France after the 1870 war. He managed the Schola Cantorum in an essentially backward-looking way, focusing on technique and the lessons of the past at a time when Debussy and Ravel were pushing the boundaries of harmonic invention in the direction of the future. He could make nothing of the subversive wit of Poulenc and his contemporaries in the years after the First World War so that by his death in 1931 he was so far from the musical spotlight that he had effectively disappeared from musical life years before. Add to this the fact that after the death of his first wife in 1905 he seems to have become something of an outspoken hard-line, very right wing and often overtly anti-Semitic Catholic traditionalist, losing the moderating influence that she apparently had on him, and you can see why he was often at odds with his age. And yet… Well, for me the ‘and yet…’ is that his music is superbly crafted, often very impressively orchestrated, wearing its influences (Beethoven, Wagner, Gregorian chant, regional folk music) lightly enough to be able to allow him to forge his own voice out of them. And the piece I’ve chosen for today is, I hope, proof of that. It’s the Symphonie sur un Chant Montagnard Français – the Symphony on a French Mountain Air, in English – though it’s also sometimes known as the Symphonie Cévenole, because it’s principal theme was one that d’Indy heard while staying in the area around Périer in the Cévennes mountains. It’s a work that’s hard to categorise, in that although d’Indy called it a ‘symphony’, it’s not a symphony in the conventional 19th century sense. And although it has a prominent part for piano, it’s not really a piano concerto (or at least, only as much as, say, Falla’s ‘Nights in the Gardens of Spain – see Day 240!). It might be described as a set of variations, in that the principal theme is explored in all three movements, though it’s not a ‘theme and variations’ in the conventional sense either! All this means it doesn’t fit neatly into any kind of box, which might explain at least some of its neglect over the past 50 years or so. d’Indy wrote it in 1886 – which makes it contemporary with pieces like Saint-Saens’ Symphony No 3 or Franck’s Symphony in D Minor – and, sticking my neck out, I’d describe it as a kind of little sibling of those two huge masterpieces. Part of d’Indy’s assertive patriotism can be found in his dedication to regional folk music, and the tune that dominates this work has both a precise regional identity and yet (like Franck’s work) it is treated ‘cyclically’. That is, it undergoes varieties of transformation so that the work as a whole has a (symphonic?) unity. There are other reasons to love it, beyond the fact that it’s great fun to listen to. For one, listen out to the way d’Indy employs the dialogue between piano and harp – it’s very original and forward-looking. I wondered about offering some kind of analytical breakdown of the structure of each of its movements, but (though the work’s organisation, both within and between movements, is complex) I think the thing I’d most want you to do in relation to this piece is just to enjoy it! And happy birthday, M. d’Indy! One of the challenges with this work on YouTube is that the only video recording is of an orchestra made up of music students en route to their first professional placements, a body called The Orchestra Now, based at Bard College in the USA. If a video recording is what you want, you’ll find it here. However, for me it’s a performance that has some ragged edges, and for something more cohesive and elegant, we’re in audio-only territory. There’s a classic old(er) recording – that is, it’s from the 1970s, which it’s sobering to note is now quite some time ago – featuring the Orchestre de Paris, conducted by Serge Baudo, and the solo pianist is the aristocratic Aldo Ciccolini. You’ll find their version here: d'Indy: Symphony on a French Mountain Air.
Day 581: Wiren, Dag (1905-86)
Serenade for Strings (Time: 17 minutes)
Today (13/3/26), there’s another new name to add to the list of those I’ve considered over the past nearly six years(!), the Swedish composer Dag Wirén (1905-86). The reason for my choice is that later this month, the English Chamber Orchestra will be at the City Hall performing his Serenade for Strings. I’m confident that those of a certain age will recognise some of the Wirén piece, even if you couldn’t have attached his name to it. He’s a composer who has rarely featured on concert programmes or radio broadcasts, but I’m absolutely certain that he deserves his moment in the spotlight, and maybe if you read this lot and follow the YouTube link you’ll think so too. A number of the composers I’ve featured on this list are often regarded as ‘one-hit wonders’. I really don’t think Dag Wirén deserves to be in that category, even though I realise I’m perhaps encouraging it with today’s selection. So, who was Dag Wirén? Well, he belongs to a generation of Swedish composers who seem to have acquired the collective label ‘Composers of the Thirties’, simply because that decade of the 20th century was when they first came to prominence. But though there are links between him and others in this category, like Lars-Erik Larsson (one day, folks, one day…), it’s clear that as he aged Wirén became more and more his own man. In fact, as well as writing a relatively small amount of music, Wirén is also interesting because he’s so very quotable about music and the process of writing it. He was born into a music-loving but by no means privileged household, but his musical bent was evident from a very early age (conducting and writing music for his school orchestra, for example). He was initially an organ student, though he wrote nothing at all for the instrument and never played it in public, but his musical imagination really blossomed during the years 1931-4, when he lived in Paris and studied with the exiled Russian teacher Leonid Sabaneyev. A lot of his early music was influenced by those in vogue in Paris at the time – Stravinsky, Prokofiev, the composers of the group ‘Les Six’ (Poulenc and Milhaud in particular) – but very soon he turned away from ‘modern’ trends and evolved a musical style of his own. He was always, seemingly, a ‘Neo-Classical’ composer – a maker of brisk, lively music with no trace of Romanticism to wallow in. But when he returned to Sweden in 1934 he developed a considerably more functional approach to music-making. So, some quotable quotes. In 1945, asked to define his identity as a composer, he said, ‘I believe in Bach, Mozart, Nielsen and absolute music.’ I think it’s this focus on the ‘purity’ of absolute music that is key here. Music was there to do a job, of course, but it should stand on its own terms, almost contextless. He was fond of saying that his first desire was to entertain and to please, to create listener-friendly ‘modern’ music. He wrote in many of the, if you like, ‘absolute’ forms – the symphony, the string quartet, the sonata and sonatina, the concert overture. Interestingly, he also wrote ballet music, as well as scores for 11 plays and nine films (including those by Ingmar Bergman), but even here, where you might think context is pretty crucial, the music has a kind of detachment to it. Perhaps the neatest illustration of this is that he wrote the music for the 1965 Swedish entry to the Eurovision Song Contest(!), but he wrote the music first (absolute, you see!) and then his associate wrote lyrics to fit. His music, never very complex after his early 1930s flirtation with Stravinskyan neo-Classicism, gradually got more and more pared down with time. He said (and I’m sure this is self-deprecating irony), ‘When you have as few ideas as I have, you have to make the most of them.’ A lot of his later works are pretty monothematic, and employ a technique he described as ‘metamorphosis’, a kind of continual slow development of an idea as a piece evolves. Interestingly, he once met Sibelius, who said to him, ‘You don’t look like your scores’! Equally interestingly, Wirén stopped composing long before his death in 1986. A final nice quotation: ‘One should stop in time, while one still has the sense to stop in time.’ His Serenade for Strings, Op 11 is in four movements, a Preludium, an Andante Espressivo, a Scherzo and Trio and a March. The writing throughout is sparkling, with clean, unfussy lines, instantly approachable (I think) but absolutely not superficial. For instance, isn’t the climax to the second movement thoughtful and even profound, even though on the surface it seems to be simply (as in, innocently) beautiful? The finale is the movement you’ll know, if your television watching stretches back to that old BBC current affairs programme ‘Monitor’, for which this movement provided the theme tune. I should say, though, that although the movement is a vaguely militaristic march, it’s sunny good humour means we’re never inclined to take it solemnly. Lots of composers wrote fairly dark ‘music reflecting the times’ in the 1930s. I don’t think Wirén was one of them. There are a small number of video recordings on YouTube of Wirén’s Serenade for Strings. It’s clearly the sort of music that appeals to small-scale string orchestras. From the options available, I think you should find a lot of enjoyment from this performance by the New York Chamber Players, directed by Dongmin Kim. It’s a 2020 Covid-influenced performance, but I think the liveliness of the music still comes across. You’ll find it here: Wiren: Serenade for Strings.
Day 580: Britten, Benjamin (1913-76)
Variations on a Theme of Frank Bridge (Time: 27 minutes) and Courtly Dances (from 'Gloriana') (11 minutes)
Today (6/3/26), I want to highlight two works by probably the foremost British composer of the middle years of the 20th century. I suspect that for many, if we take the longer view, Vaughan Williams has now eclipsed Britten as the 20th century British composer, but there was a time – say from the 1930s to the 70s – when Britten was regarded as the principal creative figure from these islands, particularly on the international stage. Later this month, there are two opportunities to catch works by Britten in orchestral concerts at the City Hall, and as they’re both easily able to be fitted within our notional ‘40 minute rule’, I’m going to feature both of them in today’s discussion. We’ve had five pieces by Britten on this list already, so I’m not about to rehearse substantial biographical stuff about Britten here – if you want more context, check out those pieces from Days 82, 149, 186, 277 and 468. On the English Chamber Orchestra’s programme later in the month will be Britten’s Variations on a Theme of Frank Bridge. Although Britten’s name and reputation had been advancing steadily since his breakthrough works from the early 1930s – the Phantasy Oboe Quartet, the choral piece (still very popular with amateur choirs) ‘A Boy was Born’ and the early set of songs ‘Friday Afternoons’ – it was really the Frank Bridge Variations that put Britten on the international map. His first meeting with Bridge came in 1927 when Britten was a mere 11 years old, and Bridge took him on as a private composition pupil almost immediately. In that sense, Bridge functioned very clearly as Britten’s mentor, both personally and musically, and Britten’s sense of debt to the older composer remained for the rest of his life. For example, it was at Bridge’s prompting that Britten gained his first substantial job, as a composer for the BBC Film Unit, in 1935 when he had completed his studies at the RCM. These middle years of the 1930’s were very fertile for Britten, alongside some key events in his personal life (the death of his mother, and his first meeting with the man who would be his life’s companion, Peter Pears). The key work in making Britten’s name at this time was the set of Variations on a Theme of Frank Bridge. In May 1937 the conductor Boyd Neel, who had a renowned string orchestra under his baton, was invited to bring three works to that year’s Salzburg Festival – with a key stipulation being that one of the works should have been previously unperformed. Britten wrote the piece very fast, in around 10 days for the first draft, and it was ready for its first performance at the Salzburg Festival in August the same year. It’s a set of ten variations (the last a fugue leading to a finale) on a theme taken from one of Bridge’s ‘Three Idylls’ for String Quartet. What makes this piece so wonderful can be summarised in two ways. Firstly, Britten insisted that each of the variations illustrated an aspect of Bridge’s character: the Adagio represented Bridge's integrity; the March was his energy; the Romance his charm; the Aria Italiana his humour; the Bourrée his tradition; the Wiener Walzer his enthusiasm; the Moto Perpetuo his vitality; the Funeral March his sympathy; the Chant was his reverence; the Fugue was his skill (it contains a number of references to other works by Bridge); and their mutual affection appears in the Finale. But, alongside this, if you like, private set of allusions, Britten also revealed the richness and diversity of his imagination in exploring, in each of the variations, aspects of European classical music from the past and the (1930s) present. So, you’ll find imitations/parodies of Rossini, say, or Ravel or Stravinsky. What’s also interesting is how Britten’s irony, which he often wore as a kind of mask to hide deeper emotion, is present even in this early work. For example, the March (Variation 2) is exaggeratedly military, which is at odds with Bridge’s avowed pacifism. Similarly, the Funeral March (Variation 8) is dedicated to Bridge’s ‘vitality’, a sorrowing lament of death for a person brimming with life. The final Fugue is a musically academic tribute to the man who taught Britten so much, but the piece ends, pretty evidently, with an outpouring of love. There are plenty of decent performances of this work on YouTube, and from them I’ve chosen this one by the reduced forces of the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra directed by Duncan Riddell, given in 2021 under social distancing conventions. You’ll find the performance here: Britten: Variations on a Theme of Frank Bridge. Also in Sheffield this month, the first work on the Halle’s programme will be Britten’s Courtly Dances (from his opera ‘Gloriana’). I thought this was worth a brief look, simply because it’s an interesting glimpse into the way Britten’s career developed from the pre-Second World War days when he was first making waves. By the end of the war, and especially with his opera ‘Peter Grimes’ of 1945, Britten had established himself as the leading British composer. In the years that followed his reputation as an opera composer achieved greater heights, and he began to be commissioned as a kind of ‘establishment’ figure, writing music that had a distinctly public role. These two aspects came together in 1953 when he was commissioned to write an opera to celebrate the coronation of Queen Elizabeth II. The result was ‘Gloriana’, and it was, to put it bluntly, something of a disaster. Some of that is clearly because it was at odds with the national mood. It’s about Elizabeth I – an ageing Elizabeth I and the end of her relationship with her one-time favourite the Earl of Essex. Britten made a set of ‘complete recordings’ of his work for Decca, but it pointedly didn’t include ‘Gloriana’, and it wasn’t recorded at all until the 1980s. Though the opera disappeared, Britten rescued from it two orchestral pieces. There's a 25-minute Concert Suite, which gets a very occasional outing, but from within that suite there’s the roughly 10-minute ‘Courtly Dances’, a kind of pastiche of the Elizabethan musical idiom of the late 16th century. The critic Arnold Whittall noted that ‘Britten's imaginative use of allusions to Elizabethan dances and lute songs create not only local colour but also a sense of ironic distance from the 20th century.’ Irony again, you see. For me, it’s one of the defining characteristics of Britten’s music. Not that that makes his work insincere. It's just that ‘mask wearing’ – notably in relation to the emotionally repressed Britten’s complex relationship to the public expression of his homosexuality – was, if you like, baked into the man and his music. Anyway, if you want to listen to a recording of the Courtly Dances on YouTube, it's an audio-only experience, I'm afraid. This is a slightly stodgy performance of the dances, given by the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra again, but conducted here by André Previn: Britten: Courtly Dances (from 'Gloriana').
Day 579: Suk, Josef (1874-1935)
Piano Trio in C Minor, Op 2 (Time: 17 minutes)
To open the concert to be given by Ensemble 360 here in Sheffield next month will be the Piano Trio in C Minor Op 2 by Josef Suk. Consequently, it’s this early piece of chamber music which is my focus for today (27/2/26). We’ve had two works by Suk on this list already – see Day 341 for the Meditation on an Old Czech Hymn and Day 442 for the Serenade for Strings – and those postings contain almost all the biographical information I’d want to include to understand Suk’s place in Czech musical history, so explore those if you want more background. For today, I just want to consider the context and content of this very early work by Suk, which is in some ways at odds with the picture of the composer and his work that I’ve painted in those two previous postings. One of the interesting things about Suk is the fact that he had a ‘voice’ of his own from quite an early age, and even though he came under the direct influence of Dvořák from the age of about 15, an influence that was deeply personal (he became a kind of honorary family member and at the age of 24 married Dvořák’s daughter) as well as musical, there’s evidence that before that initial contact Suk was already developing a musical identity of his own. Perhaps the best illustration of this is to be found in this very early Piano Trio – Suk was only just 15 years old when he finished the first version of it. It is, though, a bit of a challenge to pin down what that voice was like in this work because the trio underwent at least two substantial revisions, the latter very heavily influence by Dvořák. So, at its first appearance, Suk’s Piano Trio in C Minor had four movements. He wrote it, apparently, for a father and daughter (Dr and Ms Hersch) with whom Suk used to play piano trios at amateur gatherings. This was in 1889. The movement that disappeared entirely between Suk’s first and last thoughts on the work was a scherzo that seems to have blended folksy Czech rhythms with something a bit more like the third movement of Beethoven’s ‘Eroica’ Symphony. Anyway, Suk showed this first version to Karel Stecker, his composition teacher at the Prague Conservatory, who recommended some revisions – not just excising the Scherzo movement, but cutting a chunk of the first movement too. Eventually this revised version was performed in public in 1891, which seems to have been the point at which Dvořák took an interest, telling the still teenage Suk to ‘continue your seeking’. Later in 1891, Suk joined Dvořák’s composition class, essentially on the basis of this work, and yet more revision of the piece took place. Now the first movement got longer again (more development of its themes in the central section) and the slow movement acquired a more dramatic middle section too. But the main impact of Dvořák’s ‘encouragement’ was felt in the finale, which now acquired a livelier tempo and an all-round spark that made it more satisfying as a conclusion. So, the finished version of Suk’s Piano Trio shows very definitely the fingerprints of his father-in-law-to-be, and yet for all that there’s still evidence for some other identity – the one that would emerge a decade and a bit later after the terrible impact of the deaths of Dvořák and Otilie Dvořák, Suk’s wife – even when Suk was so young. For one thing, there’s Suk’s fondness for minor keys, evident right at the outset of this work in the strongly stated solemnity of the first movement’s opening theme. Even if things become more conventional from then on, it’s a movement that’s tightly argued and which retains its focus throughout. But it’s the slow movement, I think, that takes this piece furthest away from the influence of Dvořák. Instead, what we have is something that feels almost like a kind of habanera, rather than the folk dances of his Czech homeland. The movement leads towards a central climax and then back to something gentler to close. The final movement, perhaps more coloured by Dvořák’s influence than it had been originally, is a Vivace in 6/8 time, but even here there’s something else going on. It might just be me, but the rising-then-falling expansive march-like second theme feels much more like early Richard Strauss (or even, at a push, Elgar) than Dvořák. The conclusion shifts, perhaps inevitably, from C Minor to C Major, and we end in optimistic assertion. This isn’t, by any stretch, a lost masterpiece, but it’s more than just a student work, I think, and it shows us quite a lot of where Suk’s music would end up, even if it isn’t yet touched by tragedy. There are some video performances of Suk’s Piano Trio on YouTube, though none, I think, by any real front-rank performers. Still, the recording I’ve chosen, by the Korean-American group Ensemble Ari, is attractive and lively. You’ll find it here: Suk: Piano Trio in C Minor, Op 2.
Day 578: Dowland, John (1563-1626)
Eight Pieces for Solo Lute (Time: 17 minutes)
In this posting, I’m focusing on the music of John Dowland (1563-1626) for the very good reason that today, 20th February, it is exactly 400 years since his death. (Well, since the recorded date of his burial, to be precise, but that’s the best we can do in terms of his demise.) Anyway, 400 years seems like a significant anniversary, so consequently I’m going to explore a handful of his works here, all for solo lute. Dowland has been the subject of this playlist once before (see Day 163 for three of his pieces for viol consort, and also one of his most famous songs, ‘Flow My Tears’), and on that occasion I summarised most of the significant details that we have (there’s a very great deal that simply remains unknown) about Dowland’s life and creative output – so go back to that to refresh your memories! Today’s YouTube link is to an extract from a TV programme from 1987, when the lutenist/guitarist Julian Bream performed a number of Dowland’s works alongside readings from Shakespeare by Peggy Ashcroft. There’s no denying the rather dated impression the programme generates, but that shouldn’t blind us to the impressive playing on show here, and (of course) to the way the extracts from the programme showcase the talents of Dowland himself. The first piece Julian Bream plays in this recital is titled ‘Mignarde’. (Elsewhere it’s sometimes referred to as ‘Mignarda’.) This is a galliard, a very popular dance form in 16th/17th century Europe. Typically it’s a lively dance, involving lots of high kicking and leaps, but Dowland’s instrumental galliards range from very extrovert dances to compositions at the other end of the spectrum like this one, which is very much more introverted and sweet-sounding. It would appear that the manuscript for this particular piece comes from a collection of 17 works by Dowland held by Cambridge University Library. After this, Bream plays another galliard, this one titled ‘The King of Denmark’s Galliarde’ (or, to give it its full title, ‘The Most High and Mighty Christianus the Fourth, King of Denmark, His Galliard’). As I wrote back on Day 163, Dowland spent around eight years at the end of the 16th/beginning of the 17th centuries working for King Christian IV – though it’s possible that he was also functioning as a spy in the service of Elizabeth I and later James I at the same time. This piece exists in variant forms – as a solo instrumental, as Bream plays it here, but also as a five-part piece for viol consort. The piece was first published in 1610, by Robert Dowland (John Dowland’s son), in a collection called ‘A Varietie of Lute Lessons’. The third item in Bream’s programme is ‘Loth to Departe’, which, like the ‘Mignarde’ discussed earlier, appears in the Cambridge University Library collection. As might be inferred from the title, this may have originally been a song rather than an instrumental piece, and Dowland later produced a substantial (by his standards) set of variations on the melody, though in this recording Bream simply plays the lute song unadorned. The fourth item in Bream’s recital is the famous Lachrimae Pavan. As I mentioned in the previous posting on Dowland, in 1604 he published the instrumental collection ‘Lachrymae, or Seaven Teares’, which included a set of variations on the original ‘Lachrymae’ piece that he had written earlier, and which can be found in a different manuscript collection in the Cambridge University Library. Dowland’s most famous song, ‘Flow my Teares’, finds its source in this original ‘Lachrymae’ composition. The fifth item Bream plays is the rather curiously titled ‘Tarletone’s Riserrectione’. This appeared in a collection of pieces for lute called the Wickhambrook Lute Manuscript, music by various composers and, seemingly, of only middling difficulty, as though it might have been a compilation of pieces for amateur players. Richard Tarleton was an actor, musician, poet and favourite performer of Queen Elizabeth I. His sudden death prompted a flurry of musical tributes by various composers of the time, and this is Dowland’s contribution to the preservation of his memory. Next comes ‘A Fancy by Mr Dowland BM’. This is another piece archived in an anthology, this time the Cosens Lute Book. Dowland wrote at least seven pieces which he called ‘A Fancy’, and several others with the related title ‘A Fantasia’. As the ‘fanciful’ name suggests, there’s something improvisatory and expressive in these pieces, and this particular one is no exception. The penultimate piece that Bream plays on this recording is the famous ‘Semper Dowland Semper Dolens’ (‘Always Dowland, always doleful’). As I wrote back on Day 163, it’s not clear whether Dowland was actually temperamentally morose, or whether this was just a kind of artistic pose, the adoption of the sort of ‘tortured genius’ persona we may more familiarly associate with the Romantic era. Whatever the case, this piece, collected in yet another contemporary anthology, the Euing Lute Book, expresses a dark melancholy, whether in its guise as a song or, as here, an instrumental. Finally, Julian Bream plays ‘Orlando Sleepeth’, which may, it is said, be the shortest instrumental piece Dowland ever wrote. In fact, there’s some debate as to whether this is an original composition, or whether Dowland was arranging a pre-existing tune. It’s not even clear why the piece has the title that it does, though the favourite explanation that I’ve read suggests that it was prompted by a moment in a play, ‘Orlando Furioso’ by the now barely-known Elizabethan playwright Robert Greene, in which our hero is charmed asleep, at which point, according to the stage directions, ‘satyres enter with music and plaie about him, which done they staie, he awaketh and speakes.’ Here then are these eight pieces for solo lute by Dowland, played by Julian Bream: Dowland: Eight Pieces for Solo Lute.
Day 577: Sibelius, Jean (1865-1957)
Violin Concerto (Time: 36 minutes)
Later this month, the predictably Czech-sounding Janáček Philharmonic Orchestra, Ostrava, will be performing a largely Czech programme here in Sheffield, but also on the menu is one of the great violin concertos, the one by Jean Sibelius, and it’s this piece which is my choice for today (13/2/26). Sibelius has featured only three times on this list to date, which seems to me definitely not enough for a composer of his greatness. So far, I’ve considered a couple of the symphonies, which are after all the core of his output, and also the short piece for strings and timpani, ‘Andante Festivo’, the last of these for the purely self-indulgent reason that I’d like a recording of it to be played at my funeral! (My beloved may of course have other ideas, and I suppose I won’t be around to make suggestions…) Anyway, Sibelius’s only violin concerto – indeed, his only concerto for any instrument – marked a significant step in his musical development, and with hindsight it sounds like one of the last flourishes of Sibelius the ‘Romantic’ composer, before something more austere, and more unrelentingly Finnish, if you like, came to dominate his musical voice. He did start making draft sketches for a second concerto in about 1915, but abandoned them; much of that music ended up in his Symphony No 6. As you may know, Sibelius harboured ambitions to be a concert violinist as a young man, a goal he only finally abandoned in around his mid-20s: he wrote to a friend, ‘My tragedy was that I wanted to be a celebrated violinist at any price. Since the age of 15 I played my violin practically from morning to night. I hated pen and ink—unfortunately I preferred an elegant violin bow. My love for the violin lasted quite long and it was a very painful awakening when I had to admit that I had begun my training for the exacting career of a virtuoso too late.’ But though he gave up that idea, his fascination with the violin and its potential as a solo instrument remained, and found its expression in this concerto. He started work on it in 1902 and the piece had its first performance in early 1904. However (and this is not uncommon for Sibelius) that version was not the final one, and he revised the work over the following 18 months or so, and the revision had its first performance late in 1905. The differences between the two versions are not huge. In essence, the earlier version is about five minutes longer, the later cuts being in the first and last movements. It’s also the case that the earlier version is considerably more difficult to play (not that the piece as we hear it today is easy!), and it was the fact that the first performance of the early version didn’t go well (to be brutal, it seems that the soloist wasn’t up to the work’s demands) that led Sibelius to tone down the challenges. The concerto is in some ways one of the last ‘big Romantic’ concertos, in the vein of Tchaikovsky or Saint-Saens. However, not everyone liked it. Joachim, the celebrated violinist who premiered Brahms’ Violin Concerto (and much else for the violin in the latter half of the 19th century) described it as ‘abominable and boring’. What’s interesting about it, I think, is the way it combines the display quality of the late 19th century concerto with Sibelius’ characteristic intense seriousness – at least in his major works, for he wrote a lot of rather lightweight salon-type music too, though we rarely get to hear that stuff performed these days. When he was composing (and re-composing) it, Sibelius seems to have written in a state of high excitement. He told his (long-suffering) wife Aina, ‘I have got wonderful themes for the violin concerto,’ and subsequently she wrote to a mutual friend: ‘Jean has been on fire all the time, and this time there has once again been an “embarras de richesse”. He has such a multitude of themes in his head that he has been literally quite dizzy. He stays awake all night, plays incredibly beautifully, cannot tear himself away from the delightful melodies - he has so many ideas that it is hard to believe it. And all the themes are so capable of development, full of life.’ The concerto is in the conventional three movements, though in many ways its structure is unorthodox. In the long first movement the soloist introduces the main theme right at the start, rather than giving this to the orchestra while the soloist waits politely for this exposition to be completed. But the most controversial ‘rule-breaking’ feature is that the ‘development’ section (the bit in the middle of the movement where usually the themes which have been introduced are manipulated and played around with) is replaced with the cadenza for the soloist (which is normally placed just before the end of a movement for maximum ‘show-off’ impact). This first movement makes it obvious that Sibelius saw the concerto as essentially a ‘symphonic’ work, giving instrumental groups within the orchestra (clarinets, bassoons, trombones) a prominent role, rather than simply being an ‘accompaniment’ to the soloist. After this long, minor key first movement, the melancholy slow movement provides something of a respite, and the melody that dominates this still point at the centre of the concerto is rich and lyrical. The final Allegro is a kind of polonaise. Sibelius himself described the movement as ‘a danse macabre’. I feel a kind of obligation to note (because every discussion of this concerto does!) the British musicologist (and composer!) Donald Tovey at this point: he called the movement ‘a polonaise for polar bears’. Actually, and I think much more interestingly, he also wrote of Sibelius that ‘his forms are hewn out of the rocks of his native and Nordic mountains.’ For me, it’s this sort of rugged, solid, beautifully intransigent quality that best sums up both this concerto and Sibelius’ major works as a whole. YouTube carries lots of video recordings of this concerto by many of today’s leading soloists, and choosing which one to listen to will be largely a matter of personal taste. I quite like this version by the Radio France Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by Mikko Franck. The soloist is the American virtuoso Hilary Hahn. You’ll find the performance here: Sibelius: Violin Concerto.
Day 576: Villette, Pierre (1926-98)
Hymne a la Vierge Op 24, Ave Verum Corpus Op 3 and Salve Regina Op 5 (Time: 11 minutes) and O quam amabilis es, Op 71 (4 minutes)
Today (6/2/26), my contribution to our ever-developing appreciation of all things ‘classical’ is devoted to an anniversary composer. On 7th Feb 1926 – and so, as you’ll no doubt have already realised, 100 years ago tomorrow – the French composer Pierre Villette was born in Duclair, a small port on the Seine, in Normandy. I’ve sung only one piece of music by Villette in my life – a piece I’ll explore later – but I remember well its attractive, dreamy quality. Pierre Villette (1926-98) is not all that well known these days, and in fact there wasn’t really a time when his music was fashionable. If you’ve come across him at all, the likelihood is that it will be in relation to liturgical music in church. I’ve found a nice quotation from a piece extolling the memory of Villette, written a couple of years after his death on behalf of the music conservatoire in Besançon (of which Villette was director for around a decade from the mid-1950s). I like it because it shows just how resistant Villette was to the (musical) fashions of the 20th century: “Pierre Villette's music cares little for passing fads, which does not mean that it is backward-looking. A solid training in the disciplines of writing has anchored him in a tradition drawn from the sources of rigour. The obvious quality of this production lies in the care that presides over its production. A refined harmony, without excesses or anachronisms, using a subtle chromaticism, although clearly tonal or even modal, and above all a melodic imagination of great richness, of an obvious naturalness, constitute one of the clearest aspects. But it is obvious that an inner gravity most often presides over his creative process.” (That’s an online translation of the original French, which might account for its clunkiness, but I hope you get the sentiment behind it.) He was born into a musical family – his father played piano, organ and violin, and dabbled in composition; his mother was a pianist; other relations sang semi-professionally, or played in regional orchestras. Early studies with Duruflé (see Day 18 for a movement from his Requiem) were due to lead to enrolment at the Paris Conservatoire, but the war intervened, and it was the later 1940s before he completed his studies, though by then he had also written a fair bit of music, some of which you’ll hear below. However, another (and more long-lasting) career derailment was that Villette suffered from ill-health all his life, having one of his lungs removed in the late 1940s and spending considerable amounts of time in the Alps recuperating. His main professional appointments were as director of the Besançon Conservatoire (as already mentioned) from 1956-67, and – moving to the south of France for health reasons – as director of the Music Conservatoire d’Aix-en-Provence from 1967 until his death. He seems to have been a diligent teacher and administrator, and there are many devoted testimonies to his care for his students, not to mention points when his life overlapped with other (now more famous) musical names. In Paris, he was a student alongside Pierre Boulez (and how differently from each other they turned out!), and he ran a major music festival in Aix, rubbing shoulders with the likes of Dutilleux and Lutoslawski. What, then, of his music? He wrote a small amount of orchestral music, mostly as a young man. The only substantial piece that gets any performances these days is a Violin Concerto. There’s also, very improbably, an operetta, ‘Qu'il est bon, mon oncle Léon’ (written under a pseudonym!), and a very small amount of solo piano music. But the two fields in which he worked throughout his life were chamber music and choral music. I had hoped to illustrate at least something of the former strand in his output, but even YouTube reveals pretty much nothing of his chamber compositions. However, if you want music for voices, there’s lots of it about, so that’s what I’m going to focus on from here onwards. His first completed work for 4-part choir, a setting of the Latin hymn ‘Ave Verum Corpus’, was completed by 1944, when Villette was still a teenager. It has become one of his most-performed works. The liner notes for the CD of Villette’s choral music that I’ve come across describe how typical of future Villette compositions this work is. Though it’s clearly tonal (as all his compositions were) the harmonies are often chromatic, and there are particular moments where the word-painting is vivid and dramatic, such as where the hushed women’s voices at the end are echoed by the men, before the piece ends on an unresolved chord. (Simple definition: so that it doesn’t sound ‘finished’, and we don’t feel as though we’ve come to rest in a place that feels like ‘home’.) At the same time – 1944 – Villette also made a setting of the Salve Regina. This is a lovely, gentle piece. I particularly like the way he uses voices to refer poignantly to tears in the text. Moving on a decade or so, probably Villette’s most famous piece of choral music is his ‘Hymne à la Vierge’, written in 1955 and dedicated to his future wife, whom he met while convalescing in the Alps. As the title suggests, it extols the Virgin Mary. It’s a setting of a poem by Roland Bouhéret, and it has a lovely, almost innocent simplicity – a direct, even naïve melody in the soprano line, and interesting but not obtrusive stuff going on underneath in the other three parts. The final work of Villette’s I’d draw to your attention comes from much later in his life – from the early 1990s, in fact, when Villette was beginning to pare down his style to something even more ‘innocently’ beautiful. This is the motet ‘O quam amabilis es’, and I’ve chosen this because about 15 years ago, Escafeld Chorale, the choir I sing with, performed it as part of a Christmas concert, and it’s stuck with me ever since. It’s a setting of a text extolling the beauty and gentleness of Christ, and what I love about it are the soft, fleeting dissonances that punctuate its flow. As I said, above, YouTube is generously stocked with Villette’s choral music, so I’ve picked out two links for us to explore. First, here are the voices of the choir of West German Radio, directed by Peter Dijkstra. They perform, in this order, Villette’s ‘Hymne à la Vierge’ Op 24, his ‘Ave Verum Corpus’ Op 3, and finally his Salve Regina Op 5. You’ll find all the pieces here: Villette: Hymne a la Vierge Op 24, Ave Verum Corpus Op 3 and Salve Regina Op 5. And, in an audio-only recording I’m afraid, here is the late motet ‘O quam amabilis es’, performed by the Holst Singers, directed by Stephen Layton: Villette: O quam amabilis es, Op 71.
Day 575: Gough, Orlando (b.1953)
Birds on Fire [1] (Time: 6 minutes), Birds on Fire [2] (8 minutes) and Birds on Fire [3] (11 minutes)
Next month, the viol consort Fretwork will be in Sheffield, and in their programme will be a movement from the work and the composer I’ve chosen for today (30/1/26), Orlando Gough. In 2008, Fretwork released a CD called ‘Birds on Fire’. It consisted, for the most part, of Fantasias and Pavans for viols by composers at the courts of Elizabeth I and James I, composers such as Thomas and Joseph Lupo, and Augustine and Hieronymus Bassano, whose Jewish identity was not established until the 1980s. (Jewish figures were officially banished from England from the late 13th century through to the 1660s, so the identity of these composers was, as it were, a coded secret.) But what gave the CD its title was a work by the modern British composer Orlando Gough, written specifically for Fretwork to play, called ‘Birds on Fire’. Gough is an interesting composer. Born in 1953, he has composed music for a great variety of ensembles and contexts. He was a member of the band (or, as he describes it, a ‘chaotic collective’) The Lost Jockey in the 1970s, and in the 80s of another somewhat anarchic group of musicians, Man Jumping. Probably his name and music are most often associated with the worlds of ballet and contemporary dance, though there are also operas, such as ‘The Mathematics of a Kiss’ and ‘The Finnish Prisoner’. A lot of his work is site-specific – that is, it’s written for particular performers in particular spaces, such as two pieces written to be performed on (both in the sense of that being their location, but also in the sense of using parts of the ship as ‘instruments’) HMS Belfast, a museum ship moored on the Thames in London. His most recent site-specific piece is ‘Herd’, a 2023 work in West Yorkshire that was ‘scored’ for a thousand performers, composers, sound artists, volunteers, and 23 sheep. He’s clearly a man of diverse interests and specialisms. He published ‘The Complete A-Level Mathematics’ in the later 1980s (he’s a maths graduate), and has also published recipes as a result of his interest in cooking, a book about Brighton, and, most recently, a book about bell-ringing. Now, all this might make him seem like just another English eccentric – albeit of a very extreme kind – but ‘Birds on Fire’ is a very striking piece indeed. He has written at some length about it in the liner notes to the Fretwork CD of the same name, from which I see no reason not to quote. ‘In Aaron Appelfeld's wonderful novel “Badenheim 1939”, a group of middle-class Jews gather in an Austrian holiday resort for their summer holidays. As they enjoy the gentle pleasures of the resort, organised by the local impresario Dr. Pappenheim, and settle into their old friendships and enmities, the town gradually, almost unnoticeably, becomes a ghetto. They persuade themselves that the sinister changes are improvements and continue their holiday amusements as the town closes in. Summer turns to autumn; life becomes very hard. The food runs out and they are reduced to eating indigestible delicacies from the hotel stores. And at this desperate stage, they begin to take pride in their Jewishness. The band plays Jewish tunes secretly at night. A pair of twins give a reading – “their words were like birds on fire”. The book ends as a train arrives to take them away. “Because the carriages are so dirty,” says Dr. Pappenheim, “it must mean we haven't far to go.”’ Gough adds to this the mental image he had when composing the music: ‘My mental picture of ‘Birds on Fire’ is of a group of musicians daring to play Jewish tunes at night in a small hotel room. The piece is based on two klezmer tunes: Kandel's Hora and Odessa Bulgarish.’ In fact, the origins of the work, both musically and in terms of inspiration, came much earlier. In the early 1980s he began collaborating with the dance company Second Stride, and for them he wrote the music for a theatre piece, ‘Badenheim’, in 1994. It was some of this music, developed and adapted to the unique sound world of a five-part viol consort, that eventually emerged as the three-movement piece ‘Birds on Fire’. The three different sections are marked only by numerical titles, and Gough has offered no commentary on the piece other than to describe its origins in the manner I’ve quoted. It’s fair to say that responses to Fretwork’s CD were mixed. For every review that was enthralled by the way Gough’s piece fitted into the aural picture of the compositions by the Lupos and the Bassanos, there was another that ‘tut-tutted’ at the intrusion of 20th music into the rarefied sound world of Renaissance viols. For what it’s worth, I bought a copy of the CD on its release precisely because of its historical material, and knowing nothing of Orlando Gough or his music, but I have to say that I play this CD a lot these days, and find Gough’s ‘Birds on Fire’ a rich blend of modern minimalism, a hint of jazz and generous amount of klezmer music. As you might expect, there are no video performances of this work on YouTube, so we are yet again in audio-only territory, but you’ll find the three movements of Orlando Gough’s ‘Birds on Fire’, performed by Fretwork, here: Gough: Birds on Fire [1], Birds on Fire [2] and Birds on Fire [3].
Day 574: Grieg, Edvard (1843-1907)
Piano Concerto in A Minor (Time: 29 minutes)
This evening, the Hallé are playing a Scandinavian programme here in Sheffield, and from it, I’ve chosen music for today (23/1/26) by Grieg, the filling in the familiar overture-concerto-symphony sandwich, and one of the most regularly performed of any 19th century piano concertos, the Piano Concerto in A Minor. It’s a piece that’s so well known that it’s hard to imagine that there’s anyone on this list who isn’t familiar (and maybe over-familiar) with it. Those of a certain age will remember when André Previn was chief conductor of the LSO, and featured on the Morecambe and Wise 1971 Christmas Show, when Eric Morecambe repeatedly failed to perform the opening bars of the piano’s first entry to this concerto (saying afterwards that he was ‘playing all the right notes … just not necessarily in the right order’), but even if you’re too young for that, there will have been other opportunities for the Grieg concerto’s melodies to have embedded themselves in your consciousness – in the musical humour of sketches by Bill Bailey, for example. Grieg’s reputation, these days, essentially rests on a small handful of works – the Piano Concerto, of course, but also shorter suites of pieces, like the ‘Peer Gynt’ incidental music and the Holberg Suite (see Day 192). After that, most of his music that features in concerts or is broadcast tends to be from his many collections of piano miniatures (see Day 501 for a selection of his ‘Lyric Pieces’). It’s not that Grieg was unable to conceive of music in large-scale forms, but more that those works come primarily from his early years as a composer, and in his maturity he tended to focus on shorter works, often for piano, that he, as a gifted concert pianist, could play. But there was a time when he did, in fact, aspire to the construction of substantial compositions. As early as 1863, when he was just 20 years old, he began work on a Symphony in C Minor. It was finished the following year and performed several times in Scandinavia, either whole or in part, over the next few years. But he suppressed it in 1867 (‘Must never be performed’, he wrote on the front of the manuscript), and although there’s no definitive explanation for this, the most common thinking is that he felt the work bore too obvious a debt to the Germanic composers whose music he’d studied during his years in Leipzig (especially Mendelssohn and Schumann), and in his early twenties it was becoming more important to Grieg to pay attention to the voice of musical nationalism in his creative consciousness. This, surely, is why the Piano Concerto has survived (indeed, thrived) where the Symphony disappeared. It’s also worth saying that in 1868, when Grieg composed the concerto, he was both deeply happy, having married his first cousin, the singer Nina Hagerup, the year before, and also financially secure. And yet, if we see Grieg’s concerto as successful because it was indebted to the idioms of Norwegian folk music, where the Symphony wasn’t because its roots were in Germanic symphonic traditions, we miss at least one of the major sources of his Piano Concerto, namely the concerto by Robert Schumann. The similarities between the two, in terms of their first movements in particular, are so evident that it’s almost as though Grieg were tracing over a template prepared beforehand. It’s no surprise that the two works are often coupled in recordings released on disc. And yet, they are, in atmosphere, really very different, and those descriptive observations – sometimes loaded with slightly pejorative overtones – about Grieg’s work, focusing on its freshness and vitality of melodic idea, are surely why this concerto is still played over and over again, even 150 years and more later. If we’re brought up on Mozart, Beethoven and Brahms, say, for our model of the piano concerto, we may think that what matters in these large-scale works is not so much the ideas themselves as what happens to them, how they’re developed. But you can’t ask those questions, as it were, of the Grieg concerto. Its themes barely develop at all, but are simply restated literally when they recur. What matters instead are the tunes, the clarity and character of their orchestration, and the way the contrasts between them give the piece its musical dynamism. After the famous opening flourish, the first movement follows all the ‘rules’ of sonata form, but I imagine that what we remember from it are the engaging march-like initial theme and the sighing, yearning cello melody that stands in contrast to it. The slow movement has a simple A-B-A structure, introspective at the beginning and end, but with a more passionate middle section. It’s the finale, though, that allows Grieg the greatest freedom to exploit the folk-music of his homeland. None of this is direct quotation, but rather in the vein of the Norwegian folk dance the ‘halling’, an energetic manoeuvre regularly performed by young men at weddings, apparently. There’s a tender interlude featuring a lovely solo flute melody, and the work closes with a broad sweeping restatement of this theme for full orchestra. Grieg never wrote another concerto – there are sketches in the 1880s for a second one, but they came to nothing – and maybe, in the context of his whole career, the Piano Concerto is best regarded as a happy accident, a moment of youthful genius. And I don’t think I speak only for myself in saying that if, faced with the prospect of yet another performance of this concerto, we might sigh a little, it only takes the opening bars to remind us why we love it, and will go on doing so. There are several more than acceptable video recordings of Grieg’s Piano Concerto on YouTube, and out of the options I’ve gone for this one, by the Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra conducted by Riccardo Chailly. But the main reason for choosing it is as a tribute to the German pianist Lars Vogt, who died of cancer in 2022 in his early 50s. He gave quite a few memorable performances of concertos and solo piano works here in Sheffield. You’ll find the recording here: Grieg: Piano Concerto.
Day 573: Arriaga, Juan Crisóstomo (1806-26)
Symphony in D (Time: 28 minutes)
Today (16/1/26), I’m back on the anniversary trail, because tomorrow, 17th January, marks the 200th anniversary of the death of a composer whose loss to the musical world is difficult to calculate precisely, given that he wasn’t even 20 years old when he died, but it’s a fair bet that Arriaga (1806-26) would have been destined for something close to musical greatness, had he lived. There will no doubt be many on this list that have never even heard of Arriaga, let alone heard anything he’s written, so here’s a link to what is by some distance his most recorded work, in the hope that you’ll derive as much pleasure from his music as I have. So, a bit of biography to start. Arriaga – or, in full, Juan Crisóstomo Jacobo Antonio de Arriaga y Balzola(!) – was a Basque composer, born in Bilbao. I guess whether you want to file him as ‘Basque’ or ‘Spanish’ (you’ll find both in discussions of him) might depend on how you feel about the regional separateness of various areas of the Iberian peninsula. The epithet ‘The Spanish Mozart’ follows him around in pretty much all materials about him, and it has to be said that the formula ‘The + (national marker) + Mozart’ is a pretty common one in musical history, generally to indicate that the composer in question was a) something of a musical prodigy, and b) died young. You’ll find the now virtually unknown Thomas Linley referred to as ‘The English Mozart’, for instance, or the somewhat better known Joseph Martin Kraus as ‘The Swedish Mozart’ – though actually in Kraus’s case, there’s a very impressive composer hiding behind that label, and one who’ll feature on this list before too long, I hope. Thus, Arriaga is ‘The Spanish Mozart’. There’s a coincidental bonus, if you’re looking for further reasons for this label, in that he was born on 27th January 1806 – the exact date on which Mozart would have been 50 years old, had he lived that long. The known facts of Arriaga’s life are few. We know he was a child prodigy, encouraged by his merchant father, and that by his mid-teens he was resident organist at a couple of local churches. The big step in his musical education came at the age of 16, when his father supported him to go to Paris to study. One of his mentors at the Conservatoire there was the Director of the institution, the composer Luigi Cherubini. On hearing Arriaga’s setting of the ‘Stabat Mater’, and on asking who the composer was, he’s alleged to have said, ‘Amazing! – you are music itself’. Soon Arriaga was not only studying at the Conservatoire, but functioning as a teaching assistant in the classes of his tutors, such was his instinctive ability. Arriaga spent just over four years in Paris, but he was consistently troubled by ill-health, and in January 1826, just ten days before his 20th birthday, he died – of what is thought to have been tuberculosis – and, sadly, he was buried in an unmarked grave in Montmartre. As you might expect given his brief life, almost nothing of Arriaga’s music survives, though what remains is tantalising in its hints of lost potential. At 13 he wrote an opera (the somewhat implausibly titled ‘The Happy Slaves’), but only the overture and some fragments remain. There’s a small amount of church music and similarly of chamber music. There are – and they’re worth seeking out – three string quartets, in which you can hear some of that characteristic ‘Spanishness’ that’s such a feature of most music from this part of the world. However, by a large margin his most regularly performed work is a symphony, the Symphony in D, which dates from either 1824 or 1825, though it only seems to have had its first performance in 1888, and it wasn’t published until 1933. As you might expect from a composer in his late teens, it’s a work which reveals at least some of its influences: Mozart, inevitably, but also hints of Schubert, in its shifting from light to shade and back again in the interplay of major and minor keys, and every now and then there’s a hint of Rossini, who was all the rage pretty much all across Europe at this time. Occasionally, you might even sense the shadow of Beethoven falling across this music, though the early (pre-‘Eroica’) Beethoven rather than anything more ‘heroic’. The symphony is in four movements, with the first having a slow introduction. This seems to be taking us towards a movement in the major key, but in fact the first movement is mostly in D Minor, rather angry-sounding and even despairing, perhaps. The coda that ends the movement is particularly furious. The second movement – back in the major key, and with a couple of lovely themes to distinguish it – follows. This section shows how instinctively well Arriaga handled writing for winds. The third movement, Minuetto, is possibly the least impressive of the four movements, but with the ‘Allegro con moto’ finale the work’s forward drive and agitated mood return. Is it a lost masterpiece? Possibly not – but it’s both impressive in its own right (and not just because it’s the work of a teenager) and another example of how Romanticism in music might have developed, had its composer lived longer. There’s a handful of video performances of Arriaga’s Symphony in D on YouTube, and from the options I’ve gone for one that is at least authentically Spanish. It’s by the Orquesta Sinfónica de Galicia, conducted on this occasion by Jesús López Cobos. You’ll find it here: Arriaga: Symphony in D.
Day 572: Mozart, Wolfgang Amadeus (1756-91)
String Quintet in G Minor, K516 (Time: 32 minutes)
Later this month, Ensemble 360 will play three different quintets by Mozart: the Horn Quintet K407 (scored for horn, one violin, two violas and one cello); the glorious Clarinet Quintet K581 (clarinet, two violins, one viola and one cello); and finally one of the short series of string quintets that Mozart wrote towards the end of his life, the String Quintet in G Minor, K516 (two violins, two violas and one cello). I make a point of mentioning the scoring not just because it promises to be a fascinating evening of contrasting musical textures, but particularly because the scoring of the string quintet – my choice of music for today (9/1/26) – is, in Mozart’s hands, very striking. If you’ve spent any amount of time exploring the music I’ve posted on this forum, you’ll know that ‘the string quartet’ was, as it were, an established sub-set of chamber music since this combination of instruments gradually superseded the viol consort in the late 17th century. Haydn (‘father of the string quartet’, as the cliché has it) above all others made this ensemble the vehicle for music of wit, complexity and profundity during the second half of the 18th century. Mozart wrote 23 string quartets, though only the last ten of these are, as it were, ‘mature’ works. It’s hard sometimes to know how seriously to take Mozart’s comments about the process of composition, but, if we take him at his word, the six quartets he wrote that he dedicated to Haydn were ‘the fruit of long and laborious toil’. However, if (and it’s a big ‘if’) Mozart found writing for the string quartet more than usually challenging, there’s no doubt that the addition of a second viola, to make a string quintet, was hugely liberating. He wrote six of them. The first is a very early work, and the second is a transcription for string quintet of the Serenade for Wind Octet, K388 (see Day 181!). However, the other four are late works, and they are, to quote Charles Rosen, the American pianist and musicologist, ‘by general consent, Mozart's greatest achievement in chamber music.’ The G Minor Quintet, K516 was originally one of a pair, being written concurrently with the quintet in C Major, K515. Mozart was very fond of writing like this, particularly two works in contrasting major and minor keys. There’s the Piano Concertos, Nos 20 in D Minor K466 and 21 in C K467. Or take the pair of Piano Concertos in A Major K488 and C Minor K491. In relation to the two string quintets though (C Major and G Minor) perhaps a more striking connection is with Mozart’s final two symphonies – No 40 in G Minor and No 41 in C Major (exactly the same keys as these two string quintets!). Just a coincidence? Maybe … though my view is that this particular combination of light and shade triggered something powerfully expressive in Mozart’s musical imagination. What did Mozart get out of adding a second viola to the familiar string quartet line-up? Well, for instance, Mozart could explore different combinations of instruments – groups of two against three, or solo cello harmonised by both violas in a deeper, more sonorous mix of voices. In particular, the viola lines (and don’t forget the viola was Mozart’s own favourite instrument to play) give a special richness to the string sound compared to listening to a string quartet. A biographical thought: I’ve expressed caution before (see Day 555 for the Violin Sonata in E Minor, K304, allegedly the product of Mozart’s grief over the death of his mother) about linking what Mozart wrote to what was going on in his life, but he wrote the G Minor String Quintet during the final illness of his father, Leopold (he finished it in May 1787, and Leopold died 12 days later), and it could be argued that this piece, written by an estranged son who knew his father was dying, is the most grief-laden work in Mozart’s oeuvre. A month earlier Mozart had written in a letter, ‘death, when we come to consider it closely, is the true goal of our existence, I have formed during the last few years such close relations with this best and truest friend of mankind that his image is not only no longer terrifying to me, but is indeed very soothing and consoling!’ Some critics see the work as full of resignation and despair … though that is to overlook the fourth and final movement. Before that, though, things stay pretty dark almost all the time. The opening Allegro is a melancholy, often subdued thing, with two initial themes that feel broken and plaintive, underpinned by the same sort of ‘chugging’ chords you find in the famous opening movement of the Symphony No 40. The ‘sliding’ effect of chromatic melody lines (just listen to the second bar of the movement!) feels pretty heart-breaking. The second movement is allegedly a Minuet, but this is no ornate or formal dance, but sombre, and punctuated by sharp, angry outbursts. The slow movement, marked Adagio, drew a striking (and revealing!) comment from Tchaikovsky when he heard a performance of it: ‘No one else has ever known how to interpret so beautifully and exquisitely in music the feeling of resignation and inconsolable sorrow....I had to hide in the farthest corner of the concert-room so that others would not see how much this music affected me.’ (All a bit Fotherington-Thomas, if you recognise the cultural allusion, but you can hear what he means in the music.) Then there’s the finale, which, it has to be said, divides opinion. It starts in yet more gloom, but after the slow introduction the sun comes out and the tension relaxes. Some see irony and hollowness under the apparently jolly surface. Who knows? There are several more than decent performances to choose from on YouTube, and from them, I’ve gone for one by regular visitors to Sheffield under the auspices of Music in the Round, the Dutch ensemble the Van Kuijk Quartet, with the addition here of Adrien La Marca on second viola. You’ll find their performance here: Mozart: String Quintet in G Minor, K516.
Day 571: Hurlstone, William (1876-1906)
Fantaisie-Variations on a Swedish Air (Time: 22 minutes)
Today (2/1/26), I’m consdering the life and music of William Hurlstone, who was born on 7th January 1876, and whose 150th anniversary thus falls next Wednesday. Hurlstone is only really a name familiar to devotees of late 19th/early 20th century British music, and maybe only to slightly nerdy enthusiasts (no comments at the back there, please) within that select grouping. This seems to me to be a great shame, which is why I’d like to introduce Mr Hurlstone to those who may know nothing of him or of his music. I’d like to suggest that there are two possible reasons why Hurlstone is barely known these days: one is that there’s a lot of competition for prominence among those who came up through the teaching classes of Stanford or Parry in the Victorian/Edwardian era, and if you’ve got Holst, Ireland, Howells, Moeran, Butterworth, Bridge, Coleridge-Taylor and the rest jostling for prominence then other composers who maybe wrote far less might not get their 15 minutes of fame; and the other reason for missing out on Hurlstone and his music is that he lived to be only 30 years old, being plagued almost from birth by the bronchial asthma which killed him in 1906. But while he lived, Hurlstone was very highly thought of, and evidently had the potential to achieve exceptional things, a little of which is evident in the works he left behind that were written during his twenties. He was born in the exotic location of Fulham (fortunately neither he nor any of his forebears came from the village of Glasshouses in North Yorkshire – sorry: I’ll leave a moment or two for that to sink in, and then just quietly move on…) into a family prominent in both arts and sciences during the 19th century but who, by Hurlstone’s generation, were falling on more challenging times. He won a scholarship to study piano and composition at the Royal College of Music as an 18-year-old, where Stanford, his composition teacher, saw him as the most brilliantly gifted of all that generation of pupils that he taught. Incidentally, Elgar too noted Hurlstone’s talent, particularly his skills in variation form – and coming from the writer of the ‘Enigma’ Variations that seems like high praise. After graduating he scraped together a living as a piano teacher, choirmaster and accompanist, to help the family cope with increasing penury, and it seems like a generous benefactor and family friend, one Capt. Alexander Beaumont, funded much of the music Hurlstone was able to produce, given the intrusions of his ill health, before his early death. Almost all of Hurlstone’s music is either orchestral or for chamber forces – this makes him something of an oddity in his era, when most tyro composers were writing songs or works for solo piano. Although he wrote steadily from his early teens, Hurlstone’s extant music mostly comes from the decade after 1895. It hardly ever features on concert programmes, and even on CD there’s not an awful lot out there. If you can find recordings of them, I’d warmly recommend much of his chamber music. There’s a Piano Quartet and a Piano Trio, along with a Violin Sonata, a Cello Sonata and a Bassoon Sonata (you’ll find videos of the last of these on YouTube – it’s evidently popular nowadays with bassoonists). Most of these works were published posthumously as a tribute to Hurlstone’s unfulfilled talent. However, I thought I’d devote this posting to one of Hurlstone’s handful of orchestral works. There’s a Piano Concerto that he performed a couple of years before his death, and a great many works in variation form: Variations on an Original Theme, Variations on a Hungarian Air, and the work I want to encourage you to listen to here, his Fantaisie-Variations on a Swedish Air. This seems to have started life as a piece for piano duet, but by the summer of 1903 it was finished in its orchestral guise, and it got its first performance, conducted by Stanford, in May of the following year. There was another performance in 1906 just before Hurlstone’s death, but it wasn’t published until 1910. The work is indeed based on a Swedish melody, ‘De Rosor, och der Blader de göra mig så glader’ – which I’m sure you don’t need me to translate (though I will…) as ‘The roses, the leaves, they make me so happy’. (The Swedes in Fotherington-Thomas mode there...) Despite its rather dilettante-sounding title, the ‘Fantaisie-Variations’ is generally considered to be Hurlstone’s masterpiece among his orchestral works, and it’s certainly a long way from the approach to writing sets of variations that finds a nice tune and then decorates it with increasing ornamentation through the variations that follow. What you get from Hurlstone is, instead, something that feels much more ‘symphonic’ in scope. Partly, as Hurlstone himself noted, this is because the variations are ‘for the most part continuous, with a view to avoiding that tendency to patchiness which this form of composition is apt to create.’ The melody itself is a gentle, rather pastoral thing, and in and of itself it surely wouldn’t sustain a substantial 20-minute work. What’s fascinating about Hurlstone’s approach is that so much of what follows the statement of the theme is actually an exploration of counterpoint (that is, counter melodies that could run alongside the folk theme) – and in many of these variations the original theme is left almost as just an idea, a couple of chord changes, or a bit of interesting harmony. By the time we get to Variations 12-15 the effect is, I would suggest, seriously impressive. It will surprise you not at all to know that YouTube has no video recordings of this (or indeed of any other orchestral works by Hurlstone), so it’s audio-only territory yet again, which is a shame. Still, one of the landmark early recordings of Hurlstone’s orchestral music was a disc made by the London Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Nicholas Braithwaite, and it’s their version that you’ll find here: Hurlstone: Fantaisie-Variations on a Swedish Air.
Day 570: Bretón, Tomás (1850-1923)
String Quartet No 3 - 1. Allegro comodo (Time: 10 minutes), 2. Andante (6 minutes), 3. Allegro no mucho (7 minutes) and 4. Allegro deciso (5 minutes)
Today (26/12/25), for my final posting of the year, I want to mark (as last week) the 175th anniversary of a composer’s birth. This time out, the composer in question is Tomás Bretón. Who he? You may well ask. He’s not what you’d call a famous composer, though he was undoubtedly that in his time, at least within the somewhat parochial world of late 19th/early 20th century music in Spain. I’ve developed a mild curiosity about him since discovering one of his more flamboyant orchestral works, ‘Salamanca’, whilst disappearing down an online rabbit hole in search of other Spanish composers of the period. Is his music worth your consideration? I hope so… and at any rate, I’ll spend a little while here trying to make a case for it. So, Tomás Bretón (1850-1923) was born on December 29th, which means his 150th anniversary falls this coming Monday. From a brief trawl of the interweb, there’s not a lot of biographical detail out there beyond the basic outline. He was born in Salamanca, began to develop a reputation as a violinist from an early age, and by his mid-teens he had moved to Madrid to study performance and composition at the Conservatory there, funding himself by playing in theatre orchestras around the capital. He wrote much (I suspect essentially to pay his way) in the popular Spanish genre the ‘zarzuela’ – which regular visitors to Spanish restaurants might know as a kind of stew, often with lots of seafood, but which is also the name of a kind of musical genre that’s a bit closer to a musical or a folk opera than a regular opera. They were (and are) immensely popular in Spain, and Bretón wrote one of the most famous of them, ‘La Verbena de la Paloma’ (‘The fair of the Virgin of La Paloma’), which seems to have been an instant hit not just in Spain but all over the Spanish-speaking world. This was in 1894, and in many ways it made Bretón’s reputation (and financial security). However, he also had aspirations to write in more statusful genres, and devoted a lot of his creative life to operas, of which he wrote nine. He was also very active as a musical administrator – he became director of the Madrid Conservatory from 1901 onwards, and in that sense you can see his story as one of the inexorable rise of the provincial outsider arriving at the heart of the musical establishment. In later years his fame as a composer began to wane somewhat, and certainly by his death in the 1920s his ‘serious’ music was all but forgotten – and it’s really only in the past couple of decades that more of it has begun to appear on disc and online. The appeal of Spanish music has largely been a niche thing, with occasional exceptions when some figures emerged into the European mainstream, largely from the decades after Bretón’s generation: Albeniz was a decade younger than him, Granados 17 years younger, de Falla (the one truly breakout star) 26 years younger. Later still of course you’ve got people like Turina or Mompou or Rodrigo … but even so they tend to be written about as being on the margins of European ‘classical’ music, perhaps because Spain itself is on the margin of the continent. Anyway, if you dig around enough in Bretón’s back catalogue, you’ll find him (like so many others across Europe of his generation) trying to balance a respect for ‘tradition’ – which tended, regardless of an individual’s geographical origin, to mean ‘Germanic tradition’ – and the rather more flamboyant assertiveness of local music that gave pride of place to national forms, melodies and idioms. It would perhaps be fair to say that people like Turina put their emphasis on nationalism; others, like de Falla, retained their ‘Spanishness’ but looked to integrate themselves with more modern trends, especially those coming out of France. Bretón’s route was to steer a kind of middle course, and maybe it’s the fact of being ‘neither one thing nor the other’ that has led to his music falling out of favour. I wondered about what to choose to give a flavour of this rather neglected figure. He wrote three symphonies, but the echoes of Beethoven and Mendelssohn are louder than the sounds of anything individual in them, I think (though the 3rd is interesting and worthwhile). In the first decade of the 20th century he wrote a fair bit of chamber music: three string quartets, a piano quintet (which uses the same basic musical material as the Symphony No 3), and a sextet for piano and winds. Of these, I think the most interesting is the String Quartet No 3, a substantial work in four movements dating from 1909. I think this is more than just a curiosity, largely because in it you can hear the tension I’ve suggested exists in his work between mainstream European tradition and local colour. As far as I can tell it seems to have had only two performances in Bretón’s lifetime, a premiere in 1910 and another outing in 1913. He did adapt its third movement into a piece for piano trio, which he called his ‘Scherzo Andalou’, and which has the fantastic tempo marking ‘Allegro no mucho’! The quartet’s first movement has Mendelssohn’s thumbprints all over it, though glimpses of Spanish colour break through from time to time. The second movement Andante is the lyrical core of the work, with its long, winding, rather mournful melody. Then, after the previously mentioned scherzo, the finale, marked Allegro deciso, is both ‘academic’ in approach (a nice fugal section) but also quite original, with a distinctively Spanish feel. Sadly, YouTube offers no video performances of this piece, and it’s not even possible (as far as I know) to get the whole quartet via one online link, so I’m going to have to post this out as four separate links, one to each movement. Sorry. Anyway, here it is, Bretón’s String Quartet No 3 in E Minor, played by his namesakes, the Bretón String Quartet: Breton: String Quartet No 3 - 1. Allegro comodo, 2. Andante, 3. Allegro no mucho and 4. Allegro deciso.