|
|
|
This document is an archive of music chosen as part of the St Tim’s Classical Music Lockdown (and Post-Lockdown) Playlist, sorted alphabetically by composer surname. Comments about ‘the 15 minute rule’ in relation to days 1-100 refer to my theoretical goal of not listing anything over 15 minutes long. From day 101, this ‘rule’ was replaced by another (also theoretical) that no consecutive odd+even numbered days will list music totalling more than 40 minutes in length, while from day 501 onwards, the 40-minute limit applies to music listed in any individual (weekly) posting.
◄
►
A · B |
C-G
C · D · E · F · G
|
H-L
H · I · J · K · L
|
M-Q
M · N · O · P · Q
| R-S R · S
·
T-V
T · U · V
|
W-Z
W · X · Y · Z
Abel, Carl Friedrich (1723-87)
Day 440: Symphony in Eb, Op 7 No 6 (Time: 12 minutes)
The subject of my posting for today (22/12/23) is, at this very moment,
someone whose 300th birthday we might want to celebrate.
If you were unaware of the significance of the date to Mr Abel
– and indeed, maybe, unaware of the existence of Mr Abel at all – then I hope
that these comments might generate greater interest in a quite prolific composer.
Carl Friedrich Abel (1723-87) was born on 22nd December in Köthen, a
location that has an enduring connection with JS Bach and his family.
Bach led the court orchestra there until his move to Leipzig in –
coincidentally – 1723. In Bach’s orchestra during his time in Köthen was
Abel’s father, who led the orchestra. It seems that when ‘our’ Abel was
growing up, links with JS Bach continued: although the claim that Bach gave
young Abel lessons in the early 1740s seems now not to be true, it is the case
that Bach recommended Abel to the Saxon court orchestra in Dresden, where Abel
became director of music from 1743 until he moved to London (a consequence of
the disruption caused by the Seven Years War, it seems) in 1759.
Although nowadays Abel is famous (if indeed he is famous at all) because
of the time he spent in London, the point worth making is that even before his
arrival in this country, Abel was one of the foremost composers and performers
(on the viola de gamba – in effect, the cello) in Europe at the time.
London in the mid-18th century was a thriving and prosperous
location, with a rapidly developing middle-class population who had, by the
standards of the time, considerable disposable income. One consequence of
that is that the city became a location where musicians and impresarios could
promote their work by establishing subscription concerts which attracted
wealthy audiences. (This is, as previous postings on this list have
mentioned, what brought Haydn to London in the 1790s, where he earned more in a
few years than in all his decades working for the Esterhazys beforehand.)
Abel gave his first concert in England in March 1759, just a couple of weeks
after the death of Handel. He was evidently a hit with London audiences,
and wider London society. By 1764, he was appointed chamber musician to
Queen Charlotte, wife of George III. By that time, he had already met and
established a close friendship with Johann Christian Bach (the youngest son of
JS), who arrived in London in 1762. But in 1764 (or 1765 – the details
aren’t entirely reliable here) Bach and Abel established their hugely
successful subscription concerts in Soho (then a considerably more aristocratic
milieu than is the case today!). The Bach-Abel Concerts ran until Bach’s
death in 1782, and were renowned across Europe, helping to establish London as
a musical capital on a par with Paris or Vienna. To tidy up the rest of
Abel’s life, he toured France and Germany in the early 1780s, before returning
to London where he died (there is some evidence that his demise was hastened by
his enthusiasm for food and drink!) in 1787. I thought I’d mark Abel’s
tercentenary by considering a work that is now known to be by Abel, although for
a long time it was attributed to Mozart. In 1764, Mozart arrived in London
(he was seven years old at the time, hawked around European musical capitals by
his father) and was introduced to Abel. As was Mozart’s practice at the
time, he learned a great deal about how music ‘worked’ by copying out the compositions
of others, and while in London he copied out Abel’s Symphony in Eb, Op 7 No
6. This manuscript, in Mozart’s hand, was discovered in the 19th
century, and this led to the misattribution of the work as Mozart’s ‘Symphony
No 3, K18’. In fact, it is now known to be the last symphony in Abel’s
set of six, Op 7. Abel wrote 46 symphonies (at least, 46 that are
currently known about – there may be more…), all of them in the familiar three
movement fast-slow-fast pattern that was the convention of the time. His
symphonies date from the early 1760s to the mid-1780s, so they’re contemporary
with the first 70 or so of Haydn’s symphonies, or the works in this genre by
CPE Bach. It’s sad, I think, that like so many other fine composers of
the time, he is now almost completely overshadowed by his more illustrious
contemporaries, but the fact that the Op 7 No 6 symphony was thought to be by
Mozart (and therefore, one can assume, not rubbish!) does at least tell us
something of Abel’s quality as a composer. It’s a work that makes quite
Mozartian use of wind instruments, especially oboes and bassoons, and it has a
lovely sombre middle movement in C Minor. Abel’s Symphony in Eb, Op 7 No
6 is the subject of a decent video performance on YouTube by the endearingly
named Orchestra dei Pomeriggi Musicali (literally ‘Orchestra of Musical
Afternoons’), a chamber orchestra based in Milan that was founded at the end of
the Second World War. It’s conducted in this performance by Vanni Moretto,
and you’ll find it here: Abel:
Symphony in Eb, Op 7 No 6
Adams, John (b1947)
Day 267: The Chairman Dances (Time: 13 minutes) and Short Ride in a Fast Machine (5 minutes)
Seventy-five years ago today (15/2/22), on February 15th 1947, John Coolidge Adams was born in Worcester, Massachusetts. This is his first appearance on this list. As I’ve noted on other occasions, he is often lumped together with Steve Reich (see Days 32 and 227) and Philip Glass (see Day 261) as a ‘minimalist’ composer, although I think the more of his music you hear, the less relevant that label seems to be. I guess one thing his music does share with that of Glass and Reich is its interest in maintaining a steady pulse throughout its duration. But, more than these other composers might be, Adams seems interested in the musical language of later Romanticism, from Brahms through to Mahler and Richard Strauss. He grew up in a musical family – his mother sang with jazz bands, his father played the clarinet – and pursued music as a career, studying for his degree at Harvard, where (echoes again of the early years of Glass and Reich) he was a card-carrying modernist, fully subscribing to the Boulez/Stockhausen/Maderna approach to the ‘progress’ of modern music. Interestingly, his subsequent reaction against that idea of what he called ‘the composer as scientist’ was prompted by reading the seminal book ‘Silence’ by John Cage – also demonstrably ‘modernist’ in intent, but coming at the issue of music from a wholly different perspective – and really from the mid-1970s onwards, his music has taken what the layperson might regard as an altogether more amenable route. You can hear this in an early piano work like ‘Phrygian Gates’ from 1977 or the string sextet ‘Shaker Loops’ from the year after. Over the past forty years, he has produced music in most of the major conventional genres, though his reputation probably rests most obviously on his work in the opera house. His first opera, ‘Nixon in China’, dates from 1987, and it reveals a distinct preference for basing his operatic scores on real events – in this case, the then President Nixon’s visit to China in 1972. Subsequent operas have included ‘The Death of Klinghoffer’, from 1991 (based on the murder of a disabled Jewish passenger by PLO terrorists during the hijacking of the ship the ‘Achille Lauro’) and ‘Doctor Atomic’ from 2005 (about J Robert Oppenheimer and the development of the atomic bomb). His compositions appear to maintain a sustained after-life in performance after their premieres, not something one can often say about contemporary composers and their work. To mark his birthday, and to give a taste of Adams’ music at its most vivid and accessible, I’ve chosen two compositions for orchestra that date from the mid-1980s. First there is ‘The Chairman Dances’, dating from 1985. Adams describes this as ‘an “out-take” from Act III of “Nixon in China”’. Its subtitle is ‘Foxtrot for Orchestra’ (more evidence of that interest in maintaining a steady pulse that I commented on above). In the opera, Madame Mao gatecrashes a formal dinner banquet, performing a sensual and seductive dance. The image of Chairman Mao steps down from his walled portrait, and the two of them dance a foxtrot. The ending of the piece is like the slow winding down of an old-fashioned gramophone player. It’s performed here by the BBC Philharmonic under the baton of an un-named conductor whom I’m afraid I don’t recognise: Adams: The Chairman Dances. The year after he wrote that piece, Adams was commissioned by the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra to write a fanfare for their ‘Great Woods’ Summer Festival. ‘Short Ride in a Fast Machine’ was the result. This is one of the most popularly performed pieces of new music of the last few decades. It has the dubious distinction of being scheduled to be performed at the Last Night of the Proms in 1997 and in 2001, and being cancelled both times (by the death of Princess Diana in the first case, and the September 11th attacks in New York in the second). Adams’ wry comment on the title is: ‘You know how it is when someone asks you to ride in a terrific sports car, and then you wish you hadn't?’ As with ‘The Chairman Dances’, here again you can hear the repeated, insistent rhythmic patterns so characteristic of Adams’ music. It’s played in this recording by the BBC Symphony Orchestra conducted by Marin Alsop, at a performance from the Proms which did successfully take place, in 2014: Adams: Short Ride in a Fast Machine
Albeniz, Isaac (1860-1909)
Day 27: ‘El Corpus en Sevilla’ (from ‘Iberia’) (Time: 9 minutes)
Along with his contemporary, Granados, Albeniz was one of the leading Spanish composers of the period before the First World War. He is renowned particularly as a composer who wrote in an idiom heavily influenced by Spanish folk music – the influence of the guitar is audible in most of his compositions, even though he never wrote for it. So today (18/4/20), I thought it would be nice to go for something warm and sunny, and archetypally Spanish. And, for me, in classical music terms, you can’t get much more Spanish than the music of Isaac Albeniz. His epic twelve movement piano work ‘Iberia’ summarises many of the different facets of Spanish music, culture, faith, geography, etc.. The movement I’ve chosen is the third piece in the set, and it has a variety of titles – usually ‘El Corpus en Sevilla’ – celebrating the Feast of Corpus Christi. (I realise we’re nearly two months too early for that, but still…) This is played here by, for me, the greatest exponent of Spanish piano music, the late Alicia de Larrocha, and you’ll find it here: Isaac Albeniz – ‘El Corpus en Sevilla’ (from ‘Iberia’)
Day 338: Asturias ('Leyenda') (Time: 6 minutes) and Asturias ('Leyenda') (arr. Tarrega) (6 minutes)
We’ve only had one piece by Albéniz on this list so far (see Day 27 for a movement from ‘Iberia’). Albéniz was, by training, a pianist, and the vast majority of the works he produced before his untimely death from kidney disease at the age of 48 were for solo piano. Apart from some pieces that he wrote when he was quite young, which model themselves on more mainstream Germanic repertoire of the late 19th century, almost all his keyboard pieces are infused with the sounds and rhythms of Spain. He was born in Catalonia, close to the Spanish/French border, and was an evident prodigy on the piano. He passed the entrance exams to go to the Paris Conservatoire as a child, but was refused entry because he was too young. This determination to make his mark elsewhere extended to running away from home several times in his first decade, before touring Spain under his father’s care. He even performed in North and South America before he was 15. After study at several European centres, he moved to Madrid in his mid-20s, and a considerable amount of music, including today’s choice, was written there in the next five years or so. For someone from whom music seems to have poured in a relentless stream, Albéniz was not necessarily too bothered about cataloguing his work or keeping a close eye on it after agreeing to its publication. That’s the reason the work for today (28/10/22) - usually known as ‘Asturias’ - turns up in two different places with different titles. Its first incarnation was supposed to be in the ‘Suite Española’, a set of eight originally separate pieces planned to be pulled together in 1887 to cover the different characteristics of music from all around Spain (and Cuba, which was still Spanish at the time). In this version, ‘Asturias’ (a region of north-west Spain) was the fifth of the set, but stylistically it is music much more typical of Andalusia in the south, and so its sub-title (‘Leyenda’, or ‘Legend’) is perhaps more impressionistically apt. However, having agreed to publish the eight pieces, only four of them (not including ‘Asturias’) appeared in print in 1887. In fact, it wasn’t until 1911 - after Albéniz’s death - that the ‘original’ Suite Española was published complete. Meanwhile, during the years 1891-4, Albéniz produced another collection, ‘Cantos de España’ (‘Songs of Spain’), a suite of three (later expanded to five) pieces, of which the first, ‘Prélude’, was actually exactly the same as the previous ‘Asturias’. Tangled, eh? One fascinating thing about this work is just how much it feels like music for the guitar, even though Albéniz did not play the instrument – not that you’d think that, given the way the piece is written! You can hear in it the characteristics of Andalusian flamenco – so much so that almost instantly the work was arranged for guitar (there’s also an orchestral version) by the Spanish guitarist Francisco Tárrega, and subsequently popularised by the legendary guitarist Andrés Segovia. There’s time in this week’s allocation to hear two versions of the work. First, the original piano version of the piece, played (audio only, I’m afraid) by the incomparable Alicia de Larrocha, which you’ll find here: Albeniz: Asturias ('Leyenda'). In its guitar arrangement, it’s all over YouTube, particularly in video performances by photogenic young female guitarists shot in exotic locations, but I’ve gone instead for a performance by that legend of the guitar, John Williams (still in an exotic location!), which you can find here: Albeniz (arr. Tarrega): Asturias ('Leyenda')
Alfvén, Hugo Emil (1872-1960)
Day 288: Swedish Rhapsody No 1 ('Midsommarvaka') (Time: 14 minutes) and Symphony No 2 (4th movement) (11 minutes)
Today (29/4/22), it’s time to mark a big birthday anniversary, though I suspect some of you won’t be familiar with the composer’s name… even if I’d pretty much guarantee that you’re familiar with the tune of his most popular work. Two days from now, on 1st June, it will be 150 years exactly since the birth of Hugo Alfvén (1872-1960). As a figure in the musical landscape, Alfvén is to Swedish music pretty much what Vaughan Williams is to British music (and in the same way that orchestras and Radio 3 are gearing up to mark the 150th anniversary of VW’s birth, so you’ll find the same sorts of celebrations going on in Sweden just now). He was born in Stockholm and studied at the Royal College of Music there, writing his first symphony at the relatively young age of 23. He was a violinist as well as a composer and conductor… and also a painter of some note as a sideline. Even though he lived well into the 20th century, he is in musical terms a late Romantic. Early work shows the influence of the Norwegian composer Johan Svendsen, and as he found a stronger voice, you can hear traces of the likes of Richard Strauss and Sibelius behind some of his compositions. Alongside Stenhammar (see Day 160), he is generally regarded as the leading Swedish composer of the first half of the 20th century. However, I don’t think it’s straining credulity to claim that Alfvén has a distinctive sound world of his own – rather dark, a little melancholy, but always very pictorially descriptive, even in the more ‘abstract’ music like his symphonies. He has written of seeing music in terms of colours, but also of seeing the correspondence between music and the natural world. In his memoirs he writes vividly of the experiences of his childhood and youth in the Stockholm archipelago, particularly about stormy nights in small boats. Indeed, there is a case to be made for Alfvén being more of an expert on the sea than any of those composers at the end of the 19th and start of the 20th centuries who wrote ‘sea’ music (Glazunov, Elgar, Debussy, Bridge, Vaughan Williams, Sibelius). ‘In the depths of my soul I am an archipelago-dweller,’ he wrote. I have been wondering which music by Alfvén I could choose to illustrate this fine if rather underrated composer. My first choice would have been the work that I’ve come to think of as his masterpiece, his Symphony No 4, but unfortunately it’s written in a single musical span of (in most performances) between 45-50 minutes, so it won’t work in the format we have for this playlist (but do seek it out – it’s definitely worth it!). Instead, I’ve gone for two different ‘faces’ of Alfvén’s output. First, we might consider his most popular composition, the ‘Midsommarvaka’ (Swedish Rhapsody No 1), which was written in 1901. It was regarded at the time as a slightly frivolous piece for a composer developing a reputation for being serious and academic. Alfvén depicts the Swedish midsummer night with an often rather burlesque humour. It has a detailed programme, for those who like such things: it’s about a group of high-spirited young people on their way to a midsummer dance. There are attempts at singing, and also at dancing, but an excess of drink leads to a quarrel and brawl. A young couple who’ve headed off into the woods for reasons possibly best left to the imagination return at the break of dawn for a final, even wilder dance. Those of a certain vintage whose adolescence was enriched/scarred by too much prog rock might recognise the main melody from Deep Purple’s album ‘Made in Japan’. (Sorry about that.) You’ll find an audio-only recording of the work played by the Iceland Symphony Orchestra conducted by Petri Sakari here: Alfvén: Swedish Rhapsody No 1 ('Midsommarvaka'). However attractive that piece might be, it doesn’t give a true picture of Alfvén’s work, if only because his most powerful writing emerges in his symphonies. Consequently, I’d like to suggest we listen to a movement from his Symphony No 2. This was completed in 1899. Rather dramatically, Alfvén describes his plan for its programme thus: ‘My original intention was that the entire symphony should well forth in a flood of light and harmony. But Fate wished otherwise. Already after the first movement the sun disappears among the clouds and twilight sets in; thereupon follows a stormy night during which, figuratively speaking, I had to fight a battle for my life, in order not to go under in the course of the inner conflicts which were at that time close to destroying me completely.’ (These seem to be references to the fact that the Swedish Academy of Music had rejected his applications for the continuation of his scholarship.) His response was to write a Finale of unusual power and strength. This movement perhaps gives a better sense of Alfvén the ‘serious’ composer. You’ll find the audio recording of it given by the Royal Stockholm Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by Neeme Järvi, here: Alfvén: Symphony No 2 (4th movement)
Alkan, Charles Valentin (1813-88)
Day 402: Le Chemin de Fer (Study in D Minor, Op 27) (Time: 5 minutes) and Le festin d'Esope, Op 39 No 12 (Time: 9 minutes)
Today (4/8/23), I thought it would be interesting to hear a couple of pieces by a piano virtuoso of the 19th rather than the 20th century, one of which is also, like the Rzewski piece from the previous posting, a depiction of machinery in action. So, we have yet another new name to add to the playlist. This is Charles-Valentin Alkan (1813-88). When I were a lad (some considerable time ago, believe it or not), about the only thing I knew about Alkan was that his name was part of that roll call of ‘famous’ composers who had died in variously implausible ways. Some fell off bicycles, some hit themselves on the foot whilst conducting, and Alkan… well, Alkan was killed by a falling bookcase. It turns out, as is often the way, that this is something of an urban myth, and as far as we know there is no evidence that this was true except for one source that has now been largely discredited. It is possible that Alkan died after tangling with some household furniture, in that he was found flat out in his kitchen under a metal coat/umbrella rack which apparently he pulled down on top of himself as he collapsed with a heart attack. Still, when has the truth got in the way of a good story? However, there’s far more to Alkan, and his music, than novel ways of meeting one’s maker. Alkan was actually born Charles-Valentin Morhange, the son of a Jewish musician who ran a music school in Metz in north-eastern France. The fluidity of his surname seems to be a feature of Alkan’s childhood. His father was called Alkan Morhange, and young Charles-Valentin seems to have been variously ‘Valentin Alkan’ and ‘Valentin Morhange’, before he and his siblings settled on using their father’s first name as their surname. As is the way of these things, Alkan was another in that long line of extraordinary keyboard prodigies: he auditioned for the Paris Conservatoire at the age of five(!) (‘having a pretty little voice’) and enrolled to study piano at six (‘This child has amazing abilities’). The 1830s was a period dominated, in Paris at least, by the public showing-off of piano pyrotechnics, and Alkan was well placed to flourish in this setting, meeting both Chopin and Liszt at this time without being shown up by either in terms of technique. However, Alkan was, one could say, a complex personality, and he appears to have been particularly unhappy in the public gaze. He withdrew from public life for six years, from 1838-44, and then again, more dramatically still, from 1848-72. Not a lot is known about his life during these periods, though he appears to have continued to compose music – almost all of it for the piano as a solo instrument. However, there is plenty of evidence in his correspondence to suggest that this disappearance from the public realm was not chosen deliberately, so much as being a consequence of a sense of personal despair. In a letter of 1861 he wrote: ‘I'm becoming daily more and more misanthropic and misogynous ... nothing worthwhile, good or useful to do ... no one to devote myself to. My situation makes me horridly sad and wretched. Even musical production has lost its attraction for me for I can't see the point or goal.’ But re-emerging into public life at the age of around 60, he once more amazed another generation of young composers (Vincent d’Indy was particularly stunned), and he seems to have been popular as both performer and composer up until his death. Alkan’s music has a reputation for being formidably difficult to play – and in fact much of it (though not all of it) is. The early works of the 1830s require exceptional technique, and he wrote several sets of studies that push that technique to the limit. But by the 1840s his pieces begin to marry creative subtlety to this flair, though the pieces don’t hide their ability to dazzle. One such work – and this is where the depiction of mechanisation comes in – is his piano piece ‘Le Chemin de Fer’ (‘The Railway’), Op 27, which dates from 1844. By the mid-1840s, the ‘railway craze’ had gripped much of western Europe – certainly in France as much as in England, where the building of railways in that decade meant they usurped canals as the main means of transporting goods and, increasingly, people. Alkan’s short piano piece is marked ‘vivacissamente’ (that is, really brisk indeed!), and it’s underpinned by a relentless left-hand pattern, a pace that doesn’t slow until the end when, as one might expect, the train pulls finally into the station. This is, as far as I know, the first piece of music ever to depict a train or its journey, beating Villa Lobos and Honegger and all the rest by nearly 100 years! It has to be said that not all critics value this piece all that much, though the pianist Ronald Smith, who did much to instigate the Alkan revival in the second half of the 20th century, is in no doubt as to its quality: ‘Le Chemin de fer, which depicts a railway journey, is probably the first ever example of ‘mechanised’ music. It is a brilliant concert study of the toccata genre. A fuliginous stream of semiquavers flickers and surges above the hypnotic beat of wheel-upon-track. From time to time a confident song springs up to confront the danger and anxiety of rail travel in the 1840s. There is even a strident, stylised realisation of the locomotive’s whistle. Clusters of acciaccaturas, Alkan’s speciality, add extra thrust to the relentless pace which never slackens until a final deceleration brings the momentum to a controlled standstill.’ As for a performance of this piece, although I don’t usually go for this sort of thing there’s something hypnotic, not to say jaw-dropping, about watching the piece unscroll in front of your eyes, so here is a digitised depiction of the work: Alkan: Le Chemin de Fer (Study in D Minor, Op 27). However, in case you are persuaded that there’s nothing to Alkan except the 19th century equivalent of the ’20 notes per second guitar solo’, you really ought to listen to something from Alkan’s massive set of ‘Twelve Studies in the Minor Keys’, his Op 39, finally published in 1857, though several years in the making. These, as so much of the rest of Alkan’s work, form a mammoth undertaking. Of the 12 studies, numbers 4-7 form a four-movement ‘Symphony for Solo Piano’ (taken together the four studies last around 30 minutes), and numbers 8-10 form a three-movement ‘Concerto for Solo Piano’, lasting well over 50 minutes! On a rather smaller scale, but nevertheless lacking nothing in impressiveness, is the final piece in the set, the study Op 39 No 12, which is a set of variations called ‘Le Festin d'Ésope’ (‘Aesop’s Feast’). It’s a set of 25 variations and a coda on an original theme, and it forms a summation of all the skills required for the Op 39 studies. For me it’s one of the most perfect pieces he wrote, in which virtuosity and musicality are in ideal balance. Naturally, only exceptionally gifted pianists take on this sort of work, so here you have a recording by the Canadian virtuoso Marc-André Hamelin, in concert in Sweden 20 years ago: Alkan: Le Festin d'Esope, Op 39 No 12
Allegri, Gregorio (c1582-1652)
Day 20: ‘Miserere’ (Time: 12 minutes)
Today (11/4/20), I thought there was probably a need for something devotional, reflective, contritional even, at this point before Easter Day bursts on us. To that end, I’ve selected the tried and tested, send-shivers-down-your-spine option which is the ‘Miserere’ by Gregorio Allegri, one of many ‘one hit wonders’ in the world of classical music. Not a great deal is known about the life of Allegri, and although quite a lot of his music survives, in practice only this single piece gets any kind of airing. It always strikes me as astonishing that something as utterly beautiful as this should come from the pen of someone who is not, probably, on anybody’s list of ‘great composers’. Still, we should be very grateful that the inspiration for this piece landed where and when it did. (Some mystery surrounds the piece in that Vatican authorities forbade copies to be made of the music. There is a story that, in 1770, a 14-year-old Mozart heard it twice and afterwards wrote it out from memory, thus making it more accessible. Sadly, whilst few doubt Mozart’s feat of memory, copies of the work were in circulation before then.) You’ll find the Tallis Scholars’ performance of it here: Gregorio Allegri – ‘Miserere’
Anon/Trad.
Day 161: Remember Me, My Dear (Time: 4 minutes)
Welcome today (9/2/21) to the first of two pieces chosen by Malcolm in the run up to Valentine’s Day, which (stating the really rather obvious) falls on this coming Sunday. About today’s piece, there is really not a great deal that I can tell you. It’s an anonymous poem dating from the mid-1500s, set to an equally anonymous melody (and harmony? – I have been unable to establish this) from around the same time. Both verse (‘Remember me, my dear’ - actually ‘my deir’ in the original spelling) and music were found in the Commonplace Book (a kind of scrapbook of usefully accumulated knowledge) belonging to one Robert Edward (c1614-c1697), a Scottish Episcopal minister, author and musician, which is now held in the National Library of Scotland. From this source, we can infer that both words and music were obviously in the public domain by the time Edward noted them down. The poem is, as far as I can tell, in five stanzas, though the performance Malcolm has requested uses only the first four of these. YouTube searches uncover a number of performances, by amateur choirs and folk singers, but Malcolm's choice is a setting by The Hilliard Ensemble, a quartet of male singers who performed for four decades (1974-2014), and who were at the forefront of promoting what one might loosely call ‘early music’ during that time. Interestingly, the Hilliards have had a kind of ‘double life’ – they have recorded and performed, as it were, ‘straight’ early music, but they have also become exceptionally popular performing alongside the Norwegian jazz saxophonist Jan Garbarek. (I surely can’t be the only one to have a copy of the gold-disc acquiring CD ‘Officium’ from 1994, or its two follow-ups, ‘Mnemosyne’ and ‘Officium Novum’.) The reason for mentioning all this is that the track ‘Remember Me, My Dear’ – featuring the Hilliards and Garbarek – turns up on the ‘Mnemosyne’ album, and it’s also the title track of the CD ‘Remember Me, My Dear’ which they recorded live in 2014 as their ‘farewell’ performance. So, if you’re interested in finding out how this music sounds with an improvisatory soprano sax line swirling in and out of the texture, those are the ways you could chase this up. However, what Malcolm wants to hear is a performance of this piece for voices alone. The poem is in some ways a fairly conventional ‘unrequited love’ text, in which the cruel beloved's words and actions have wounded the narrator … but who nevertheless proclaims to his inamorata that ‘Yet shall ye find me true and kind’. The plea, ‘Remember me’, echoes through all four stanzas. You’ll find the performance (illustrated rather bizarrely by what looks like a video shot from an aircraft window) here: Anon: Remember me, my dear
Day 354: 'Alleluya. A nywe werke is come on honde' (Time: 6½ minutes)
Today (23/12/22), I want to pick up another suggestion from the invisible Pete Dutton for some more Advent/Christmas music, in this case an idea left over from this time last year but one that I didn’t want to leave behind permanently. It’s for a medieval carol, ‘A nywe werke is come on honde’. The source for this carol is a collection called the Selden Carol Book, which is kept in the Bodleian Library in Oxford. If you were keen on searching out 15th and early 16th century carols, this is one of the main places you might go to for your material. It’s a really important document because, unusually, it contains music as well as words for these pieces. It’s called the Selden Carol Book because before it arrived at the Bodleian it belonged to Sir John Selden (1584-1654), though as a document it can be traced back at least as far as someone called John Alcock (1430-1500) who was for a time Bishop of Worcester and then of Ely. It’s not clear whether there might have been previous owners. It consists of 32 pieces. Not all of them are carols as we know the term today: there’s a rather raucous drinking song, ‘Tapster fill another ale’, for example. But for the most part these are ‘religious’ pieces, in celebration of the Virgin Mary or of the birth of Jesus, though some cross the line into rather more political/military matters – the volume is the key source for the Agincourt Carol, for instance, which celebrated the victory of Henry V against the French in 1415. The carol ‘A nywe werke is come on honde’ has a typical verse and chorus structure, where the repeated refrain (‘Alleluya’) divides up the narrative line of the text. The words are as follows (though depending on the device you’re reading this on, some of the Middle English letter forms may not appear properly): ‘Alleluya, alleluya, alleluya.// A nywe werke is come on honde/ Þorw my3t & grace of Godys sonde:/ To saue Þe lost of euery londe,/ For now is fre Þat erst was bonde:/ We mowe wel synge, alleluia.// By Gabriel by-gunne hit was;/ ry3t as the sunne shone thorwe the glas,/ Ihesu Cryst conceyued was/ of Mary moder, ful of grace./ Nowe synge we here, alleluya.// Nowe is fulfylled the prophecie/ of Dauid and of Jeremie/ and also of Ysaie./ Synge we ther-fore, both loude & hye,/ alleluya, alleluya.// Alleluya, this swete songe,/ oute of a grene branche hit spronge./ God sende vs the lyf Þat lasteth longe;/ nowe ioye & blysse be Þem a-monge/ Þat thus cunne synge, alleluya.’ (If you’re a bit scared by the spellings, a fairly literal translation of the text goes like this: ‘Alleluia, alleluia, alleluia. A new work has come on hand Through might and grace of God's messenger,To save the lost of every land. For he is now free who was once in bondage; We may well sing, alleluia! By Gabriel it was begun; just as the sun shone through the glass, Jesus Christ was conceived of Mary, mother full of grace. Now sing we here, alleluia! Now is fulfilled the prophecy of David and of Jeremiah, and also of Isaiah. Sing we therefore, both loud and high, alleluia, alleluia! Alleluia, this sweet song, out of a green branch has sprung. God send us the life that lasts long; Now joy and bliss be among those who thus can sing, alleluia.’) As for a performance of this carol, YouTube has a range of performance styles to choose from, from the now ‘classic’ 1980s recording by Gothic Voices (pioneers of the pre-Renaissance ‘early music’ revival) to performances by larger choral forces, or to smaller-scale settings for a handful of singers. I have to confess that I tend to like my medieval music a little rough and ready round the edges, in the style of the ensemble Joglaresa (with its blend of medieval and folk influences) but one of the better quality video performances on YouTube is by the American trio Trobár Medieval, three women who sing and play a range of medieval instruments (though in this performance they are unaccompanied). You’ll find their recording here: Anon: 'Alleluya. A nywe werke is come on honde'
Antheil, George (1900-59)
Day 546: Ballet Mecanique> (Time: 15 minutes) and Jazz Sonata (Time: 2 minutes)
Perhaps the posting for today (11/7/25) should come with a health warning, or one of those ‘parental advisory’-type triggers, because this week we have the self-styled ‘bad boy’ of 20th century American music. In fact, the 125th anniversary of the birth of Antheil passed relatively unmarked (at least on Radio 3) three days ago, so you might not have even been aware of this milestone, but though some of his music is occasionally rather difficult to listen to, he is actually a pretty interesting composer, and one whose music is really only recently starting to be explored by major recording labels. First, though, a word about ‘bad boys’, especially those adopting the label for themselves. The sceptical (or Freudian) might see it as a kind of ‘self-compensation’ strategy, and conclude that all this showmanship amounts to not much more than a lot of hot air. American culture, after all, has often been a platform for those who want to compete to be the ‘baddest’ of them all. Also, perhaps unsurprisingly given the nation’s relative youth, and its development from the late 19th century onwards as a centre for ‘modern’ culture, American classical composers have been busy doing iconoclastic things, whether or not they’ve been accompanied by self-promoting fanfares, since the days of Charles Ives (see Days 90, 299, 439 and 512). In no particular order of significance, rebellion against the established musical norms might equally be a description of the music of Conlon Nancarrow (Day 39), or Milton Babbitt, or John Cage, or Terry Riley, or Elliott Carter, or Morton Feldman, or George Crumb, or Harry Partch, or Frederic Rzewski (Day 401) … or whoever! So, what makes Mr Antheil a candidate for this role? Well, for a start, he strove for it from the outset. His upbringing was, by the standards of the time, unusually free – he graduated from neither high school or college, but seems to have gone his own way (with family acquiescence, if not approval) from a young age. His big ‘discovery’, in his mid-teens, was of Dadaism (essentially a challenge to all established conventions of the arts, in music, painting, literature or wherever), following the example of Marcel Duchamp. In Antheil’s case, this seems to have taken the form of a fascination with ‘mechanical’ music. The American literary editor and publicist Margaret Anderson, an early champion of Antheil, described his work from the early 1920s as ‘compelling mechanical music’ which used ‘the piano exclusively as an instrument of percussion, making it sound like a xylophone or a cymballo.’ In 1922 he headed to Europe, to embrace (and be embraced by) the European avant-garde, his concerts being billed as introducing ‘a new ultra-modern pianist composer’ or a ‘futurist terrible’. He achieved a degree of notoriety – as was his plan! Works performed at his Parisian debut included his ‘Airplane Sonata’, his ‘Sonata Sauvage’, and an odd(er) composite work called ‘Mechanism’. Unsurprisingly, a riot broke out. Antheil’s memoir records: ‘People were fighting in the aisles, yelling, clapping, hooting! Pandemonium! ... the police entered, and any number of surrealists, society personages, and people of all descriptions were arrested ... Paris hadn't had such a good time since the premiere of Stravinsky's “Sacre du Printemps”.’ From what I’ve read, it seems at least in part an engineered thing – it was filmed, which suggests, shall we say, a degree of pre-planning. During the 1920s reviews of his work tended to be pretty consistently awful, but he seems not to have cared, playing up the ‘bad boy’ image – pulling a revolver out of his pocket and placing it on top of the piano before starting to play, and so on. The next decade continued in much this vein, but by the mid-1930, unwelcome in Germany after the rise of Nazism, he returned to America for good and started to write music which is considerably more tonal, and his later career was marked by the writing of film scores (‘Angels over Broadway’ with Douglas Fairbanks Jr, ‘In a Lonely Place’ with Humphrey Bogart, ‘The Pride and the Passion’, with Cary Grant and Frank Sinatra) as well as a growing number of symphonies (a major recording series on the Chandos label) and other orchestral pieces. By the time of his death from a heart attack in 1959 he had made his mark not just as a composer and pianist, but also via his autobiography (called, you may not be surprised to know, ‘The Bad Boy of Music’), and pseudonymous fiction … and (most bizarrely) scientific endeavour: he and the actress Hedy Lamarr patented a radio guidance system for torpedoes, that employed a technique slightly beyond my remit called ‘frequency hopping’ which is (or so I’ve read) one of the bases of modern telecommunications. Who’d have thought…? Anyway, how to mark Antheil’s anniversary? Well – health warning! – I’m going to save his tonal, accessible stuff for another time, and go for what was Antheil’s most famous work, his ‘Ballet Mécanique’. Not actually a ballet at all, this is music to accompany a film of the same name. The original score is, one might say, bonkers – it’s for 16 specially synchronized player pianos, two grand pianos, electronic bells, xylophones, bass drums, a siren and three aeroplane propellers! Now, you may choose not to click on the link here(!), but I hope you will, because once your ears have adjusted themselves to the experience, the piece becomes absorbing and varied. It’s not just noise! The original 1924 film has been digitally restored, and it’s this, with Antheil’s ‘mechanical’ music, which you’ll find here: Antheil: Ballet Mécanique. And, for dessert, here’s another, to my mind rather endearingly lovely Nancarrow-esque 1920s work, the Jazz Sonata, played as an encore by the jaw-droppingly virtuosic Canadian pianist Marc-Andre Hamelin, which you’ll find here: Antheil: Jazz Sonata
Arensky, Anton (1861-1906)
Day 165: Piano Trio No 1 (2nd movement) (Time: 7 minutes)
Today (23/2/21), I thought I’d offer you a slice of gentle Slavic gloom, which is not the sort of thing that’s featured on this playlist very much at all. It comes courtesy of Anton Stepanovich Arensky, who is in some ways ‘the missing link’ between Tchaikovsky and Rachmaninov. Of all the Russian composers who came in the generation after Tchaikovsky, Arensky is the one who is closest to him stylistically (Glazunov is ‘smoother’, less obviously ‘Russian’; Liadov is more like Rimsky-Korsakov and the nationalist composers; Taneyev was far too interested in Brahms for a Russian!). Rachmaninov was Arensky's most important pupil, but Rachmaninov soon found his own particular melancholic niche and stayed firmly in it for the rest of his life. Arensky (1861-1906) is the one whose compositions have at least some of Tchaikovsky’s flair for colourful orchestration, his attraction to the dance (the ‘Arensky waltz’ became, as it were, a thing) and his depiction of the emotional extremes of what one might think of as ‘the Russian soul’, even if Arensky never plumbed the depths of psychological desolation that haunted Tchaikovsky in his greatest compositions. As you can see, Arensky was not long lived, dying in his mid-forties from tuberculosis, encouraged (if Rimsky is to be believed) by the excessive consumption of vodka. (There is a rather crushing quotation about Arensky from Rimsky-Korsakov: ‘In his youth, Arensky did not escape some influence from me; later, the influence came from Tchaikovsky. He will quickly be forgotten.’) Although he produced music in most major forms and genres, Arensky wrote relatively little – two symphonies, three operas, a piano concerto, a violin concerto, a handful of orchestral suites (which are probably where the influence of Tchaikovsky can be most strongly felt), some solo piano music aimed at the salon rather than the concert hall, and some really very fine chamber music. In this last category, Arensky wrote two string quartets, a piano quintet and two piano trios – and it’s the first of these that I want to home in on today. Arensky’s Piano Trio No 1 in D Minor was written in memory of the Russian cellist Karl Davidov, founder of the ‘Russian school’ of cello playing, who had died in 1889. This trio, written five years later, was Arensky's tribute to him. It’s a substantial four-movement work, but for today I want to focus solely on the third movement, the lyrical ‘Elegia’. It begins with a conversation between the muted cello and the violin, backed by the darker accompaniment of dotted rhythms on the piano. There is a lighter central section in which the piano comes to the forefront, before the movement ends as it began in a kind of haunted stillness. This isn’t great music, I suspect, but it’s tender and eloquent, and I’d argue that it (and much of the rest of the output of this rather overlooked composer) deserves to be better known. As for a performance, there’s an attractive video of just this movement alone given at the Menlo Festival in California by Paul Huang on violin, Clive Greensmith on cello and Gloria Chien on piano. You’ll find it here: Arensky: Piano Trio No 1 (2nd movement)
Armstrong, Craig (b.1959)
Day 123: Ballantyne (movement 8) from ‘The Edge of the Sea’ (Time: 4 minutes) and Martyrdom Variations (movement 7) from ‘The Edge of the Sea’ (4 minutes)
This week is ‘Highlands and Islands Week’, jointly curated by Malcolm and me, and first up, today (29/9/20) a suggestion from Malcolm, for music which is both very new (the album was only released at the end of August) and yet also very old, in that it has its roots in a musical style that goes back to the 17th century, and which is very different from music of the mainstream Western ecclesiastical tradition. The inspiration for today's suggestion is Gaelic psalm singing, which survives these days essentially on the Isle of Lewis and Harris. Malcolm suggests we might start today's shared experience with a bit of ethno-musical research, so here is a short introduction to the extraordinary sound world of Gaelic psalm singing, in a recording from Back Free Church on Lewis, made in 2003: Gaelic psalms at Back Free Church, Lewis The producer of that recording, Calum Martin, had participated in Gaelic psalm singing all his life, and was precentor at Back Free Church. ‘Psalm singing was like another language you learned,’ he has written. In 2005, he met the primary composer of today's choices, Craig Armstrong, at an event to promote psalm singing. Armstrong (b.1959) too had vivid memories of participating in this culture as a young person, though his career subsequently took him in very different directions. He is best known these days as a composer of film music: he scored the two Baz Luhrmann films ‘Romeo + Juliet’ and ‘Moulin Rouge’, for example. However, in 2015 Armstrong's father died, and it led him to consider composing something as a fitting memorial, and he renewed his contact with Martin, and over the following years the music for the album ‘The Edge of the Sea’ evolved. The recording is an amalgam of pre-composed and improvised music, and consists of two extended suites, ‘Ballantyne’ and ‘Martyrdom’, each in several movements. Performing on the album are members of the Lewis and Harris Gaelic Psalm Singers choir (ten singers, including some from Martin's own congregation), alongside the strings of the Scottish Ensemble, and a range of soloists including both Armstrong and Martin. The music on the album is predominantly slow, and makes extensive use of drones. To give a flavour of this unique sound world, here are two tracks from the album: Armstrong: Ballantyne (movement 8) from 'The Edge of the Sea' and Armstrong: 'Martyrdom Variations' (movement 7) from 'The Edge of the Sea'
Arnold, Malcolm (1921-2006)
Day 233: Guitar Concerto (Time: 22 minutes) and Symphony No 5 (2nd movement) (11 minutes)
For today (19/10/21), the attention switches to one of the most underrated and (in my opinion) most misunderstood British composers of the 20th century, whose centenary is imminent. So, in two days’ time, it will be 100 years exactly since the birth of Malcolm Arnold. Arnold (1921-2006) was an immensely prolific composer, but one who has only recently started to receive the sort of attention his music deserves, after several decades effectively in the musical wilderness. There are several reasons for this neglect, some a consequence of Arnold's own personality and temperament, others a product of the musical times in which his work appeared. To deal with the latter issue first, although Arnold wrote nine symphonies in the four decades after the Second World War, they rarely got a hearing during that period when the BBC's music output, in particular, was in thrall to the heirs of Schoenberg and contemporaries such as Pierre Boulez. In that context, Arnold might have appeared lightweight – a composer of popular sets of orchestral suites (two sets of English Dances, plus subsequent Scottish, Cornish, Irish and Welsh Dances) and of immense quantities of film music (he wrote the music for the St Trinians films and the Oscar-winning ‘The Bridge on the River Kwai’ amongst over 100 other film scores), not to mention the comic compositions he produced for the Hoffnung concerts, such as his ‘Grand Grand Overture’, featuring an array of vacuum cleaners and other industrial appliances. These days we tend to be more accepting of the fact that composers are versatile and multi-faceted in their output, but back in the 50s and 60s, say, a ‘serious’ composer would not be found writing such things. However, it’s also true that temperamentally Arnold rarely seemed to help himself to engage with those around him. It seems likely that his mental breakdowns, extensive alcohol abuse and several suicide attempts were the product of severe mental illness that, one hopes, might have been more sympathetically treated, had such experiences happened today. But after about the age of 40 he seems simply to have been unable to engage with others (family, friends, work colleagues) without (often apparently wilfully) destroying those relationships. It might go without saying, therefore, that alongside Arnold the writer of sunny ‘light music’, there is an awful lot of darkness in his work, in the symphonies and chamber music in particular. One interesting aspect of his life is that in the mid-1940s he was a trumpet player in the LPO and in the BBC Symphony Orchestra, an experience that showed him, from the inside, how orchestral music works, as he observed: ‘If you don’t pick up a few things from being principal trumpet of a great symphony orchestra, you’re no use.’ Most of his music has now been recorded (there are three different recordings of his full set of symphonies, for instance) and we can begin to get a more rounded picture of the troubled, lonely spirit that lies behind the laughter in his work. I thought that, to mark his centenary, I’d pick a complete performance of one of the 20 concertos that he wrote for many of the leading performers of the second half of the 20th century, and a movement from what I think is his greatest symphony, the Symphony No 5. To take the Guitar Concerto first, he wrote this in 1959 for Julian Bream. It’s skilfully scored for guitar and string orchestra, with the addition of a flute, clarinet and horn, and as a consequence the balance never overwhelms the guitar. The second movement Lento is the core of the piece, a bluesy nod in the direction of Django Reinhardt, whom both Arnold and Julian Bream admired. There is a video on YouTube of the concerto's first performance at the BBC Proms in 1991, again with Julian Bream, and the BBC Concert Orchestra, conducted by Barry Wordsworth. It’s preceded by a three-minute clip of Bream being interviewed about the concerto by a startlingly young-looking David Owen Norris. You’ll find it here: Arnold: Guitar Concerto. Finally, of his nine symphonies, it is probably the 5th Symphony that is closest to being his masterpiece. It dates from 1961, and though it fits the conventional four movement format, it’s music that is by turns questioning, ominous, brutal and deeply uncertain. Even its apparently triumphant ending is undercut by tragedy, in what the liner notes to my CD copy say is ‘a brilliantly successful study in aspiration and failure.’ The heart of the symphony is its slow movement, Mahlerian in some ways, particularly in the way the hushed opening tune leads on to a grinding dissonance, and a sense of uncertainty, before finally we arrive at a rather exhausted but peaceful close. You’ll find an audio recording of it, given by the BBC Concert Orchestra conducted by Charles Hazelwood, here: Arnold: Symphony No 5 (2nd movement)
Arriaga, Juan Crisótomos ... (1806-26)
Day 573: Symphony in D (Time: 28 minutes)
Today (16/1/26), I’m back on the anniversary trail because tomorrow, 17th January, marks the 200th anniversary of the death of a composer whose loss to the musical world is difficult to calculate precisely, given that he wasn’t even 20 years old when he died, but it’s a fair bet that Arriaga (1806-26) would have been destined for something close to musical greatness, had he lived. There will no doubt be many on this list that have never even heard of Arriaga, let alone heard anything he’s written, so here’s a link to what is by some distance his most recorded work, in the hope that you’ll derive as much pleasure from his music as I have. So, a bit of biography to start. Arriaga – or, in full, Juan Crisóstomo Jacobo Antonio de Arriaga y Balzola(!) – was a Basque composer, born in Bilbao. I guess whether you want to file him as ‘Basque’ or ‘Spanish’ (you’ll find both in discussions of him) might depend on how you feel about the regional separateness of various areas of the Iberian peninsula. The epithet ‘The Spanish Mozart’ follows him around in pretty much all materials about him, and it has to be said that the formula ‘The + (national marker) + Mozart’ is a pretty common one in musical history, generally to indicate that the composer in question was a) something of a musical prodigy, and b) died young. You’ll find the now virtually unknown Thomas Linley referred to as ‘The English Mozart’, for instance, or the somewhat better known Joseph Martin Kraus as ‘The Swedish Mozart’ – though actually in Kraus’s case, there’s a very impressive composer hiding behind that label, and one who’ll feature on this list before too long, I hope. Thus, Arriaga is ‘The Spanish Mozart’. There’s a coincidental bonus, if you’re looking for further reasons for this label, in that he was born on 27th January 1806 – the exact date on which Mozart would have been 50 years old, had he lived that long. The known facts of Arriaga’s life are few. We know he was a child prodigy, encouraged by his merchant father, and that by his mid-teens he was resident organist at a couple of local churches. The big step in his musical education came at the age of 16, when his father supported him to go to Paris to study. One of his mentors at the Conservatoire there was the Director of the institution, the composer Luigi Cherubini. On hearing Arriaga’s setting of the ‘Stabat Mater’, and on asking who the composer was, he’s alleged to have said, ‘Amazing! – you are music itself’. Soon Arriaga was not only studying at the Conservatoire, but functioning as a teaching assistant in the classes of his tutors, such was his instinctive ability. Arriaga spent just over four years in Paris, but he was consistently troubled by ill-health, and in January 1826, just ten days before his 20th birthday, he died – of what is thought to have been tuberculosis – and, sadly, he was buried in an unmarked grave in Montmartre. As you might expect given his brief life, almost nothing of Arriaga’s music survives, though what remains is tantalising in its hints of lost potential. At 13 he wrote an opera (the somewhat implausibly titled ‘The Happy Slaves’), but only the overture and some fragments remain. There’s a small amount of church music and similarly of chamber music. There are – and they’re worth seeking out – three string quartets, in which you can hear some of that characteristic ‘Spanishness’ that’s such a feature of most music from this part of the world. However, by a large margin his most regularly performed work is a symphony, the Symphony in D, which dates from either 1824 or 1825, though it only seems to have had its first performance in 1888, and it wasn’t published until 1933. As you might expect from a composer in his late teens, it’s a work which reveals at least some of its influences: Mozart, inevitably, but also hints of Schubert, in its shifting from light to shade and back again in the interplay of major and minor keys, and every now and then there’s a hint of Rossini, who was all the rage pretty much all across Europe at this time. Occasionally, you might even sense the shadow of Beethoven falling across this music, though the early (pre-‘Eroica’) Beethoven rather than anything more ‘heroic’. The symphony is in four movements, with the first having a slow introduction. This seems to be taking us towards a movement in the major key, but in fact the first movement is mostly in D Minor, rather angry-sounding and even despairing, perhaps. The coda that ends the movement is particularly furious. The second movement – back in the major key, and with a couple of lovely themes to distinguish it – follows. This section shows how instinctively well Arriaga handled writing for winds. The third movement, Minuetto, is possibly the least impressive of the four movements, but with the ‘Allegro con moto’ finale the work’s forward drive and agitated mood return. Is it a lost masterpiece? Possibly not – but it’s both impressive in its own right (and not just because it’s the work of a teenager) and another example of how Romanticism in music might have developed, had its composer lived longer. There’s a handful of video performances of Arriaga’s Symphony in D on YouTube, and from the options I’ve gone for one that is at least authentically Spanish. It’s by the Orquesta Sinfónica de Galicia, conducted on this occasion by Jesús López Cobos. You’ll find it here: Arriaga: Symphony in D
Atterberg, Kurt (1887-1974)
Day 454: Suite No 3 for Violin, Viola and Strings, Op 19 No 1 - 1. Prelude (Time: 3 minutes) and 2. Pantomim (4 minutes); 3. Vision (5 minutes)
We’re in Scandinavia (metaphorically) today (9/2/24), marking the 50th anniversary – actually next Thursday, but there’s something else to fit in before then – of the death of Kurt Atterberg. This is his first appearance on this list, and not before time, I think. He’s an interesting composer (often a euphemism for ‘a not very interesting composer’, but absolutely not the case here), though one with a degree of tarnished moral ambiguity which perhaps explains why it’s really only in the past 30 years or so that his music has gained a major foothold on disc, even if it still rarely appears in the concert hall. Swedish classical musical history is not as well-known as, I think, it ought to be. Some examples have featured before on this list – the 18th century Johan Roman on Day 159, the 19th century Franz Berwald on Day 208, the early 20th century Wilhelm Stenhammar on Day 160 and Hugo Alfven on Day 288 – but there are many more to explore if this list survives long enough. I’ve been interested in the music of Atterberg (1887-1974) since I discovered his symphonies about a decade ago. If you consider Swedish music from the generation after Stenhammar and Alfven, there are two stand-out composers, Ture Rangstrom (one day…) and Atterberg, and then some more from the generation after that, of which probably Lars-Erik Larsson is the most interesting (and again, one day, I'd hope…). What I’m trying to get at is that this is a rich musical culture, and Atterberg’s place in it as – most would argue – Sweden’s primary 20th century symphonic composer is pretty established. To deal with the previously mentioned moral ambiguity head on, there is an unresolved dispute – by which I mean that an explicit public investigation into it concluded that it could neither be confirmed nor denied – about the extent to which Atterberg collaborated with the Nazis in the 1930s and early 40s. He certainly engaged with German musical authorities during these years, had his music performed approvingly by German orchestras, and wrote (though many did this at the time) remarks which could be seen as anti-Semitic. For none of this would I seek to defend him. But neither, I think, does it make him ‘persona non grata’ to the general music-loving public. And besides, the post-Second World War investigation by the Royal Swedish Academy of Music did not prove collaboration conclusively. What one can say, positively, about Atterberg and his music is that it vividly illuminated the Swedish music scene during the first half of the 20th century. Not that he was, as it were, a ‘full time’ composer. He’s an interesting figure in that for the whole of his life he had an entirely different day job – from 1912 until his retirement in 1968 he worked for the Swedish Patent and Registration Office. Musically, he is a kind of ‘late Romantic’ composer. In other words, there’s little in his work that suggests any attachment to the ‘modernist’ currents in early 20th century music. If you were looking for any kind of equivalent figure, musically, then maybe someone like Arnold Bax comes to mind. Atterberg’s main reputation these days is as a symphonist. There are at least three sets of his symphonies in recording catalogues these days, which suggests a genuine market for such things. He wrote nine numbered symphonies (like Beethoven, his ninth is for orchestra plus vocal soloists and choir), and also a lovely Symphony for Strings. There are half a dozen operas, six concertos, and an awful lot of music for the stage, which will take me to today’s choice. He also wrote nine orchestral suites, an unusual practice for this period. Atterberg seems to have seen these as a kind of ‘light’ (but not lightweight!) music compared to the drive – and for the unsympathetic, the bombast – of his symphonies. Most of these suites are for chamber-sized orchestras, usually strings with the occasional scoring for additional woodwind. Some of them were adaptations of music originally written for the stage. A production of Maeterlinck’s play ‘Sister Beatrice’ (a rather sensational item about a nun’s ‘fall’ from moral integrity in giving up her vows for her lover) was staged in Stockholm in 1918, and for it Atterberg wrote some very small-scale incidental music – the original scoring was for violin, viola and harmonium, that being all that could fit into the theatre’s space! The play didn’t go all that well, but Atterberg rescued some of the music, rescored it for violin, viola and string orchestra, and it has subsequently, in its guise as his Suite No 3, Op 19 No 1, become one of his best-known and most loved compositions. There are three movements, marked (these are theatrical titles rather than musical ones) Prelude, Pantomim and Vision. The middle movement, I think, is particularly lovely, a sort of chorale (suggesting the sacred mood of the play) with a middle section which is a more romantic episode, indicating something of the relationship of the play’s lovers. The final movement is a waltz fantasy. If you know Sibelius’s ‘Valse Triste’, we’re in the same sort of territory. The whole work has a wistful, slightly melancholy air, but I think it’s lovely to listen to, and hauntingly expressive in places, beautiful without being sentimental. On YouTube you’ll find (frustratingly as three separate links) a performance of Atterberg’s Suite No 3 for Violin, Viola and Strings by the Norwegian Chamber Orchestra, directed from the solo violin by Terje Tønnesen, and with the solo viola played by Lars Anders Tomter. You’ll find the recordings here: Atterberg: Suite No 3 for Violin, Viola and Strings, Op 19 No 1 - 1. Prelude, 2. Pantomim and 3. Vision
Auric, Georges (1899-1983)
Day 456: Trio for Oboe, Clarinet and Bassoon (Time: 12 minutes) and Beauty and the Beast (Belle arrives at the castle) (3 minutes); Beauty and the Beast (Les Couloirs Mysterieux) (4 minutes)
Today (16/2/24), we have another anniversary to mark, this time of a composer whose star has waned a little over the past 50 years or so, but who nevertheless made a significant mark on the development of music in a particular medium that we now take pretty much for granted, that of incidental music for film. Though, as you’ll see, there’s quite a lot more to Georges Auric than that. Auric (1899-1983) had, as it were, an early career and then a later career. He was born in the south of France on 15th Feb, 1899, which means it was actually the 125th anniversary of his birth yesterday. He was a composer from an early age, having songs and music for the theatre performed while he was still in his teens. The first major influence on him was Erik Satie, and as a consequence he became associated with the iconoclastic group of (mostly) French composers who, as the cliché goes, scandalised Paris in the years immediately after the First World War. These postings have on several occasions mentioned the loose collection of composers who became known as ‘Les Six’ (by analogy with ‘The Five’, as they were sometimes known, the group of Russian nationalist composers in the later 19th century). Well-known members of ‘Les Six’ were Poulenc (featured on this list very regularly, on account of him being a brilliant composer!), Milhaud (see Days 197-8), and Honegger (no idea why we’ve got this far without any Honegger, but there you go – I’ll rectify that as soon as I have opportunity). However, there were – you’ll no doubt not be surprised to know – another three figures in this short-lived collective, whose reputations have faded a little over the past century: Louis Durey (1888-1979), Germaine Tailleferre (1892-1983) … and today’s composer, Georges Auric. ‘Les Six’ were, in fact, an invention of a French music critic, Henri Collet, and though they did briefly collaborate with each other on some composite works (a set of piano pieces called ‘L’Album des Six’ in 1920, and a surrealist ballet score ‘Les Mariés de la Tour Eiffel’ the year after), inevitably they pulled in very different directions as they developed as composers. Auric was, for a while, probably closest stylistically to Poulenc, writing music of droll wit and irony. I thought I’d illustrate this side of Auric’s output by choosing the Trio for Oboe, Clarinet and Bassoon that he wrote in 1938. If you remember the piece by Ibert that I featured on Day 452, then this work by Auric will seem formed from the same metaphorical cloth. By the later 1930s Auric was already on the way to establishing himself in his ‘second career’, but this lovely little wind piece harks back to the sparkling sound world of the previous decade. It’s in three movements: a vividly dancing first movement, marked ‘Décidé’, in which the clarinet regularly takes the lead role; a lyrical ‘Romance’ with languid, intertwining melodies; and finally (marked ‘Final’!) a movement that contrasts insistent triplet figures with quieter and more sedate interludes. An early reviewer (sorry – can’t trace a name) summarised the work thus: ‘A first lively movement, sparkling with malice and mischief; a romance, seductive by its nonchalant grace; and a tense finale, with a brilliant rhythmic and thematic freshness.’ It’s played on this video recording by three members of a San Francisco-based woodwind quintet called Avenue Winds. You’ll find their performance here: Auric: Trio for Oboe, Clarinet and Bassoon. Another influential figure in Auric’s life was the French polymath Jean Cocteau (poet, playwright, novelist, film director, set designer, visual artist, etc.), who first came into contact with Auric in the early 1920s. In the 1930s, Auric began to distance himself somewhat from the more subversive elements in his own work from the immediately post-First World War period, and during the first half of the 1930s he wrote almost nothing. During this time his views about music, and the place of the arts in society, became more populist; he began to see music as part of a political struggle to promote left-leaning views throughout society. Although a lot of these ideas were disseminated via Auric’s developing career as a music critic, it was even more the case that he saw writing music for film as an essential feature of his identity. He scored his first film in 1930 (Cocteau’s avant-garde film ‘Le Sang d'un Poète’), and between then and 1962 (at which point he stopped writing film scores and worked the rest of his life as a music and arts administrator) he wrote the music for over 100 films, many of them still well-known today. A few titles to be going on with: Caesar and Cleopatra (1945), Hue and Cry (1947), Passport to Pimlico (1949), Orpheus (1950), The Lavender Hill Mob (1951), Moulin Rouge (1952), Roman Holiday (1953), The Titfield Thunderbolt (1953), Father Brown (1954), The Good Die Young (1954), Rififi (1955), The Hunchback of Notre Dame (1956), The Crucible (1957), Bonjour Tristesse (1958) and The Innocents (1961). But I thought I’d add to your appreciation of Auric as a composer by selecting a scene from another of his famous scores, that to Cocteau’s 1946 surrealist fantasy drama ‘Beauty and the Beast’. So here are two clips from the film for you to watch while Auric’s music plays in the background. First, here is the scene where Belle arrives at the mysterious castle: Auric: Beauty and the Beast (Belle arrives at the castle), and the sequence ‘Les Couloirs Mysterieux’: Auric: Beauty and the Beast (Les Couloirs Mysterieux)
Bach, Carl Philipp Emanuel (1714-1788)
Day 118: Sonata for Solo Flute in A Minor, Wq 132 (Time: 15 minutes)
Welcome to the second of this week's emails exploring music for the flute by various Bachs. Unlike Tuesday's choice, though, there’s no reason to doubt the authorship of what you’re hearing today (11/9/20). It’s the music of Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach (1714-88). But first, a bit of history... Frederick II of Prussia (generally known these days as Frederick the Great) ruled his initially rather fragmented domains from 1740-86. Notionally an advocate of enlightened despotism (in practice sometimes just despotism), under Frederick's rule, Prussia became the leading military power in Europe after a series of wars and invasions, which served to consolidate both his territory and his military and political power. The ‘enlightened’ bit is broadly a consequence of his interest in the theories of the ‘Enlightenment’, but in our area of investigation it revealed itself in Frederick's lively interest in music (and the arts more generally). He was more than merely proficient as a flautist, composing extensively for the instrument. (He also apparently composed at least four symphonies, though I must confess I’ve never heard one.) His court musicians included Quantz, the king's personal flute teacher (see Day 117), but also other now less than household names (Graun and Benda, for instance), and the subject of today's musical choice, Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach. CPE became a member of Frederick's court orchestra, and harpsichordist to the king, on Frederick's accession to the throne in 1740, and remained there until 1768. He was by many accounts the leading keyboard player of his era throughout Europe. He spent the last 20 years of his life in Hamburg, where he succeeded Telemann (also his godfather – it’s interesting how these links between composers work out!), but before that the 28 years at the court of Frederick the Great produced not just symphonies, many dozens of keyboard sonatas, songs and oratorios, but also (not surprisingly) music for flute. Which brings us to today's piece of music. Jenny has suggested we listen to CPE Bach's Sonata in A Minor for Solo Flute. Bach wrote it in Berlin in 1747, and there is some suggestion that it was written specifically for Frederick to play. If so, he must have been an impressive performer. Jenny is particularly enamoured of the slow first movement, which has a rather melancholy beauty. It’s succeeded by two further movements, a quick second movement and an even quicker finale. It’s played on this recording by Emmanuel Pahud, the Franco-Swiss flautist who is one of the leading performers on the instrument of the last 30 years. You’ll find it here (with a rather less than interesting blank screen to watch as you listen): CPE Bach: Sonata for Solo Flute in A Minor, Wq 132
Bach, Johann Bernhard (1676-1749)
Day 591: Orchestral Suite No 3 in E Minor (Time: 23 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 591st playlist entry - in your email inbox.
Bach, Johann Sebastian (1685-1750)
Day 2: Violin Sonata No 1, BWV 1001 (played on mandolin!) (Time: 15 minutes)
In the opinion of most music critics, Bach is the greatest composer who ever lived, and his music across an immense range of genres achieves a consistency and complexity that has rarely been matched and surely never bettered. He wrote a vast amount of church music in his role as Cantor at St Thomas’ Church in Leipzig, along with instrumental compositions, notably but not only for keyboard, and concertos. He will no doubt feature heavily on this list as the days pass, but for today (24/3/20), here is something rather unusual. Malcolm, whose choice this is, provides the following note: “This is the Bach Sonata No. 1 in G Minor, BWV 1001, played by Chris Thile (pronounced ‘Theelie’ with a soft th as in ‘thin’). He is a bluegrass / folk mandolin player from the US who has started to explore the classical repertoire. So, a well known piece, originally for solo violin, but here played on mandolin. For those who don't know, the violin and mandolin are very similar instruments. They are the same size and have exactly the same tuning (G,D,A,E low to high), and you finger the two instruments using exactly the same left hand pattern. The differences are that the mandolin is plucked with a pick, whereas the violin is bowed with a bow; the violin has one string at each pitch, where the mandolin has four pairs of strings; the mandolin has frets like a guitar or a viol, whereas the violin has no frets, allowing the player to make minute adjustments in tuning.” You’ll find the performance here: Bach – Violin Sonata No 1 (on mandolin!)
Day 6: ‘Sanctus’ (from Mass in B Minor) (Time: 6 minutes)
Bach's setting of the Mass in B Minor was completed in 1749, the year before he died, though it was substantially based on music he had composed already, and today’s choice, the ‘Sanctus’ from the Mass, was originally composed 25 years earlier. For a Lutheran composer, it was unusual for Bach to compose a full mass setting – normally at that time, a setting of the mass would have consisted of only the ‘Kyrie’ and ‘Gloria’. So today (28/3/20), it’s some more lovely Bach. I know we had a Violin Partita (on mandolin) a few days ago, but I’m confident that you can never have too much Bach at any time, but especially at a time like this. So, for no reason other than the fact that it makes the hairs on the back of my neck stand up, and also makes me cry occasionally, here is the ‘Sanctus’ from his B Minor Mass. There are lots of versions out there on the interweb, but I’m a sucker for John Eliot Gardiner in this repertoire, so here is his recording, with the Monteverdi Choir and English Baroque Soloists: Bach – ‘Sanctus’ (from the Mass in B Minor)
Day 19: ‘Erbarme Dich’ (from St Matthew Passion) (Time: 6 minutes)
What else, today (10/4/20 – Good Friday) except Bach? You may just have listened to the St John Passion on Radio 3, and be about to make a date with the same station for this evening's performance of the St Matthew Passion. OK, just me then... Bach wrote the St Matthew Passion in 1727, setting Chs 26-27 of Matthew’s Gospel, along with chorales and arias that provide a commentary on the Biblical text. Selecting a single item from such a work is unfair, but in the end I’ve gone for the alto aria ‘Erbarme dich, mein Gott’ (‘Have mercy, my God, for the sake of my tears…’) from the St Matthew Passion, in a performance by the period instrument ensemble Les Siècles, with Delphine Galou as the soloist. How Bach manages to do beauty and anguish simultaneously is one of the happy mysteries of music. You’ll find it here: Bach – ‘Erbarme dich’ (from ‘St Matthew Passion’)
Day 30: Goldberg Variations (Aria and Variations 1-3) (Time: 10 minutes)
So, with the thirtieth edition of this extensive series (21/4/20), we return (and almost certainly not for the last time) to the music of JS Bach. Martin Hill has written in requesting that we listen to Murray Perahia playing the aria and first three variations from Bach's Goldberg Variations, BWV 988. The work was first published in 1741, and is generally regarded (alongside Beethoven’s ‘Diabelli Variations’) as one of the pinnacles of variation form in the whole canon of classical music. The piece is unusual in that these are variations not on the theme of the ‘Aria’ but on its bass line and chord progression. Every third variation (and so, the last of the three on the extract chosen here) is a canon. There are so many great performances of this sublime music on YouTube, but Perahia brings a lifetime’s experience to this recording. You’ll find it here: Bach – Goldberg Variations (‘Aria’ and variations 1-3)
Day 63: Chaconne (from Violin Partita No 2, BWV 1004) (Time: 16 minutes)
I thought it would be good to mark the end of the ninth week of this list (24/5/20) by going back to Bach (there is surely never a good reason not to go back to Bach!), and also to remind ourselves of the riches of live music that, in normal times, we might take for granted from Ensemble 360 and their friends and colleagues. So, today’s recording is of Ben Nabarro, the first violin of Ensemble 360, playing the great Chaconne from Bach’s Partita No 2 for Solo Violin. This partita is one of six works for solo violin that Bach wrote sometime in the second decade of the 18th century. The Chaconne forms the last movement of the Partita No 2, and consists of a sublime set of variations. As with the video I linked earlier this week featuring the guitarist Craig Ogden, the link here is for a longer recital (Ben playing Bach, and then his partner, Ensemble 360’s cellist Gemma Rosefield playing Casals' ‘Song of the Birds’), so if you want to hear the Bach only, scroll forwards until you’re 0'40" into the video; the Bach ends at approx. 16'30". The link is here: Bach – Chaconne (from Violin Partita No 2)
Day 117: Flute Sonata in Eb, BWV1031 (attrib.) (Time: 12 minutes)
As trailed last Friday, this week is ‘Bach and the Flute’ week, courtesy of choices from Jenny. I suspect that if, in a ‘Pointless’ kind of way, you asked 100 people what Bach’s first names were they’d almost all say ‘Johann Sebastian’. But then, there were an awful lot of Bachs, and if you’d asked that question at different times between, say, 1650 and today, you’d have got different answers. So in part this week’s music is a challenge to the default assumption that ‘Bach’ must mean ‘JS’. The starting point for Jenny’s choices was a conversation in the Holt household (you may think their domestic discourse exists on a somewhat higher plane, at least some of the time) about who was the ‘best’ Bach, and how one could tell. Do we assume it’s JS because he’s now the famous one, the towering musical genius to whom almost all music historians now defer? (Short answer: ‘yes’ … but let’s not spoil the debate.) The Holts pursued their discourse further: does it change the way we listen to a piece of music, if we know who it’s by? (Jenny contextualised this by pointing out that Tom Service on Radio 3 recently introduced a piece as being something relatively mediocre by Salieri, only to reveal after it had been played that it was actually by Mozart. If we’d known it was by Mozart, would we have listened differently, or ‘appreciated’ it more?) And that brings us to today’s choice: the Flute Sonata in Eb, BWV1031 by Bach. Or is it..? Perhaps we should say ‘attributed to JS Bach’. There is apparently a manuscript copy of this sonata in the handwriting of Bach’s son Carl Philipp Emanuel, which attributes the sonata to his father, but it’s entirely possible that it’s by CPE himself. Or, alternatively, it’s by, or at least very firmly based on, a previously existing sonata by the now relatively obscure Johann Joachim Quantz (of whom more on Friday). What we can say is that stylistically the piece has a lot in common with the ‘galant’ style in music that was emerging in the 1730s/40s, and which was a feature of the sort of music composed by people like CPE Bach and Quantz and others at the court of Frederick the Great of Prussia (of whom more on Friday). So maybe this is JS ‘moving with the times’. Or maybe not. And in the end, it almost certainly doesn’t matter. The piece is in three movements (and not the four movement structure that Bach was otherwise using in his sonatas of the time) and in the slow movement in particular the harpsichord part feels more decorative, less ‘organic’, than one might expect of Bach. It is, nonetheless, very beautiful. It’s played on today’s recording by Stephen Preston on baroque flute (and I realise that in all this discussion of ‘which Bach is it?’ we haven’t even touched on ‘what sort of flute is it?’) and Trevor Pinnock on harpsichord. You’ll find it here: Bach: Flute Sonata in Eb, BWV1031 (attrib.)
Day 129: Cello Suite No 2 in D Minor, BWV 1008) (Time: 22 minutes)
JS Bach is already the most regularly-appearing name on this playlist (see Days 2, 6, 19, 30, 63 and 117 (above) – the last of those by attribution only), but here he is again. Bach wrote six suites for solo cello. They date from his time serving at the court of Leopold, Prince of Anhalt-Kothen, where he was Kapellmeister (that is, Director of Music) from 1717-23. At this point in his career, Bach (still a relatively young man in his thirties) wrote many of the secular works for which he is now most famous – the six Brandenburg Concertos, the four Orchestral Suites and, in the field of solo chamber music, the six Sonatas and Partitas for Solo Violin, and these six Cello Suites, the second of which is the focus of the posting for today (20/10/20). What all of the works I’ve just listed have in common is that they make great play with what we might these days call ‘dance music’, a very powerful influence on so much of Bach’s work. In the typical fashion of a Baroque suite, each of the cello suites opens with a stately Prelude, but the other five movements in each suite (it will not surprise you to know that Bach’s mathematical modelling is in play even here – six suites with six movements each!) are different types of Baroque dance form. There are no original manuscripts of these pieces, though there is a hand-written copy made by Bach’s wife Anna Magdalena. What makes it tricky is that the copy contains virtually no directions about how to play the music (bowing, fingering, phrasing, tempo marking, etc.) which means performers have a lot of leeway to make their own judgments. The cello suites pretty much disappeared in the two centuries after they were written; and where they were known about at all, the assumption was that they were merely studies, the kind of cello exercises a player might use as a work-out before tackling some ‘proper’ music. Only when the legendary early 20th century cellist Pablo Casals began to perform them in public did their greatness begin to be recognised. The Cello Suite No 2 in D Minor, BWV 1008, begins with a substantial Prelude that ends in a scale-like passage. The other five movements are an Allemande (as the name suggests, a German dance, though slightly slower in Bach’s day than it originally was), a Courante (a ‘running’ dance), a Sarabande (a stately dance of vaguely Spanish origin), a pair of Minuets (a dance in three/four time) and a final Gigue (or, as we might know it in English, a ‘jig’) which ends the suite in a vigorous fashion. Martin originally requested a performance by Ralph Kirshbaum (the recording he got to know first and still, for him, the best) but unfortunately those recordings have been uploaded onto YouTube a movement at a time, and each movement is prefaced by an intrusive advert, which does not make it the ideal way to listen to this music. If one wants to listen to the suite entire, in one go, there are limited choices, but Martin has very impressively gone the whole ‘Building a Library’ hog on this one, and reviewed the options for us all. Thus, I can tell you that we have passed over Yo-Yo Ma (too slow), Mischa Maisky (too so-so), Pablo Casals (of historical interest only), and a period instrument performance by Eva Lymestull (interesting… but not quite interesting enough). That leaves a performance which, in Martin’s view, is ‘beautifully rich and resonant’. It’s by the iconic Russian cellist Mstislav Rostropovich, and you’ll find it here: Bach: Cello Suite No 2 in D Minor, BWV 1008
Day 130: Toccata, Adagio and Fugue in C, BWV 564 (Time: 16 minutes)
Today (23/10/2020), it’s the second of Martin’s selections of the music of Johann Sebastian Mighty Bach, as Dylan Thomas described him. And today, it’s something of a first for the playlist, in that we have a piece of organ music. It’s the Toccata, Adagio and Fugue in C, BWV 564. Unlike Tuesday’s selection, this piece is rather harder to date than the Cello Suite No 2, though it seems likely that it comes from the time of Bach’s return to Weimar in 1708, when he became organist (and, from 1714, director of music) at the court of Duke Johann Ernst III. Bach’s compositions during this period show a lot of influence of Italian musicians (Vivaldi and Corelli in particular), and today’s piece is evidence of an Italianate taste for dramatic openings and exciting rhythmic passages. The opening Toccata in many ways feels like a movement from a concerto, with ‘soloistic’ passages set against other sections that are more ‘orchestral’ in feel. (The movement also, so I’m informed, has the longest introductory pedal solo of any composition for organ in the 18th century.) The second movement, Adagio, is again rather unusual – it’s rare for these ‘Toccata + succeeding movement’ pieces to contain a full-blown slow movement. Finally there is a Fugue (a movement in which a dominant melodic/rhythmic idea is introduced at the outset, before being re-introduced in succession in different ‘voices’ in a precisely imitative manner as the movement goes on – a very noddy definition!), which leads to an extended coda. The performance Martin has chosen is by the famous blind German organist Helmut Walcha, who made ground-breaking recordings of Bach’s complete organ works twice – a mono set just after the second world war, and stereo recordings in the 1960s, which is what you’re getting here. Unfortunately, YouTube doesn’t have the three movements available via a single link, but fortunately there are no irritating adverts at the start of each movement so it’s easy to click on each succeeding link without disruption of the musical argument. So here are Walcha’s performances of the work: Bach: Toccata, Adagio and Fugue in C, BWV 564 - 1. Toccata, 2. Adagio and 3. Fugue
Day 143: Nun komm, der Heiden Heiland, BWV 61 (Time: 16 minutes)
Today (8/12/20), it’s the turn of JS Bach. First, I should say that last time out (Day 142) I quoted Harry Christophers on the slightly contentious view that James MacMillan, Tomas Luis de Victoria and Francis Poulenc were the three foremost composers of sacred music, like, ever! Well, I should clarify: he meant Catholic composers… which might explain how it’s possible not to include Bach in any such esteemed company. It’s surely impossible to contemplate the music of this season and not have some Bach in there somewhere. Initially, I had thought I’d save him until Christmas Day, and zap you all with a chunk from the Christmas Oratorio, but then I reflected on the quality of Bach’s Advent Cantatas, and decided I’d go with one of those instead. So today, it’s the cantata ‘Nun komm, der Heiden Heiland’ BWV 61. Bach has featured more times on this list than any other composer (with, general consensus seems to suggest, good reason), but not, so far, as the writer of sacred cantatas for liturgical use. A cantata (Ladybird Book of Classical Music definition) is a composition for voice(s) (‘cantata’=’sung’), usually accompanied by instruments and often by a choir. They seem to have evolved from the Renaissance madrigal into pieces that could be either secular or, when used as part of the liturgy of church services, sacred. Bach wrote over 200 such works, sacred and secular, including a whole cycle of cantatas for use throughout the liturgical year. (This wasn’t a feat unique to him: it seems to have been not unusual in early 18th century German states in particular.) So, in the BWV catalogue of Bach’s works, BWV 1-200 are sacred cantatas, BWV 201-16 are secular cantatas. (There are others, attributed to Bach but whose authorship is not known for sure, and some of those 216 once assigned to Bach are now seen as doubtful.) Bach wrote two cantatas called ‘Nun komm, der Heiden Heiland’ (BWV 61 and 62 in the catalogue). The former was written for a very specific occasion. In 1703, after graduating from St Michael’s School in Luneberg, Bach took a series of posts at courts in Weimar, Arnstadt and Muhlhausen, before, in 1708, returning to Weimar as organist, and in 1714 he became music director at the court. He wrote the cantata specifically for the first Sunday in Advent 1714 (it is one of very few Bach works that has an autographed date) and it seems to have assumed a significance for Bach not just because it marked the start of that liturgical year – he is known to have performed it to mark the same occasion when he moved to St Thomas’ Church in Leipzig in 1723. The cantata is in six movements. The opening movement is for four-part choir, a setting of the words ‘Nun komm, der Heiden Heiland’ (‘Now come, Saviour of the heathen’ or thereabouts) from the main hymn for Advent, composed by Martin Luther. It has the feel of a French overture, a solemn slow introduction, followed by a more animated fugue, before the slow section returns. The middle four movements are for soloists. The second and third movements are a recitative and aria for tenor, and they are essentially about the fact that at Christmas Jesus comes to his church. They are, if you like, about public, communal faith. The fourth and fifth movements, a recitative for bass and an aria for soprano, are much more personalised: ‘behold, I stand at the door and knock’, says the bass, in the voice of Christ, before the soprano sings of how she will ‘open my whole heart’. Finally there is a closing chorale (‘Amen, amen! Komm, du schone Freudenkrone’), in which Bach sets a verse by the hymn writer Philipp Nicolai. There are several excellent performances of this work on YouTube, and out of those I’ve gone for one by Concentus Musicus Wien, and the Arnold Schoenberg Choir, conducted by Nicolaus Harnoncourt. The soloists are Christine Schafer, Ian Bostridge and Christopher Maltman. You’ll find the recording here: Bach: Nun komm, der Heiden Heiland, BWV 61
Day 210: Prelude and Fugue No 1 in C Major, BWV 846 (from ‘The Well-Tempered Clavier’, Book 1)
(Time: 4 minutes)
and
Prelude and Fugue No 1 in C Major, BWV 870 (from ‘The Well-Tempered Clavier’, Book 2) (Time: 4 minutes)
Next month here in Sheffield, the British pianist Libby Burgess is giving a remarkable series of four concerts in one day in which she’s performing the complete ‘Bach 48’ – that is, both books of ‘The Well-Tempered Clavier’. This is part of her ‘Project 48’ – the plan to play the complete 48 Preludes and Fugues in 48 different venues over the course of a year, taking in all the 48 ceremonial counties of England. (I realise the concept of a ‘county’ is a bit of a moveable feast, but the ceremonial counties are the ones to which Lord-Lieutenants are appointed.) So today (30/7/21), I thought I’d mark this rather daunting undertaking by exploring a couple of the Preludes and Fugues. Bach’s music has featured often on this playlist (see above Days 2, 6, 19, 30, 63, 117, 129, 130 and 143), though not for some time. Bach’s two books of ‘The Well-Tempered Clavier’ were composed about 20 years apart. Each set consists of 24 preludes and adjoining fugues to cover the 24 major and minor keys which form the harmonic basis of modern western music. Bach’s first collection dates from the early 1720s, when he was Kapellmeister at Kothen. This period also saw the composition of many of the secular works for which he is famous (the Brandenburg Concertos, the four Orchestral Suites, the six Cello Suites, the six Violin Partitas, and so on). It was obviously a very fertile period in his compositional life. On the title page, he described the set of Preludes and Fugues as ‘for the profit and use of the studious musical young, and also for the special diversion of those who are already skilful in this study.’ Twenty years later, when Bach was well established at the court in Leipzig, he produced a second set of 24 Preludes and Fugues. Bach was not the first to compose sets of pieces in all the major and minor keys, but, given that the whole concept of ‘keys’ as we know them today only achieved a settled form in the 50 years or so before Bach’s time, he was one of the first. (There’s a very scholarly debate to be had about what the ‘well-tempered’ of the title might actually mean, which I’m going to carefully sidestep because it will become very technical very quickly. Suffice it to say that we can be sure that Bach didn’t write the pieces for the piano, which did not exist in his day, but that the piano’s ‘well-tempered’ or ‘equal temperament’ tuning system means that you can play in any key and not sound out of tune (assuming the piano has been tuned beforehand, of course!) – unlike the ‘meantone temperament’ system of tuning of Bach’s day, in which playing in certain ‘keys’ would sound more ‘out of tune’ than others). What I thought might be interesting today would be to listen to the Prelude and Fugue No 1 in C Major from Book 1 of ‘The Well-Tempered Clavier’, and to compare it with its parallel piece, the Prelude and Fugue No 1 in C Major from Book 2. (Both sets make the same journey in terms of key signatures, starting in C Major, then C Minor, C# Major, C# Minor … and so on, ending in B Minor.) The C Major Prelude and Fugue from Book 1 is undoubtedly the most famous piece in the set, from its instantly recognisable Prelude, which has, in effect, no melody at all, but is simply a series of arpeggios (that is – Ladybird Book of Musical Terms definition – where the notes of a chord are sounded not simultaneously, but one at a time, producing a sort of ‘rippling’ effect). The Fugue which follows is in four ‘voices’ – that is, when it’s up and running, there are four independent ‘lines’ of music. Where the Prelude in C Major from Book 1 is all harmony, the Prelude in C Major from Book 2 is a continuously unfolding melody. You may or may not know it, but this Prelude and the subsequent three-voice Fugue were recorded by the Canadian pianist Glenn Gould and sent off into space on both the Voyager 1 and Voyager 2 space probes, which are, even as you read this, heading ever deeper into interstellar space! For a recording of these pieces, I thought I’d go for Sir András Schiff’s performances at the BBC Proms in 2017 (Book 1) and 2018 (Book 2). You’ll find them here: Bach: Prelude and Fugue No 1 in C Major, BWV 846 (from 'The Well-Tempered Clavier', Book 1) and here: Bach: Prelude and Fugue No 1 in C Major, BWV 870 (from 'The Well-Tempered Clavier', Book 2)
Day 247: Magnificat in D, BWV 243 (Time: 29 minutes)
Today (7/12/21), we have a major work by, according to most estimates, the major composer of the past five centuries. JS Bach has featured on this playlist more times than any other composer (see Days 2, 6, 19, 30, 63, 117, 129, 130, 143 and 210!), with good reason, I think. There is a wealth of biographical and contextual information in the entries for those dates, which you can access via the Index below, so I’ll limit my comments today to the work under discussion. This is a suggestion from the invisible list member Pete Dutton, who would like us to mark the Advent season by listening to a performance of the Magnificat in D, BWV 243. This is a favourite among amateur choirs (or, at least, its opening chorus is), and professional ensembles often programme the work for this time of year. It sets the familiar verses from Luke Ch 1 Vs 46-55, which are Mary’s hymn of praise to God (‘My soul magnifies the Lord’), and is in twelve movements. Interestingly, the piece as we know it today, in D Major, seems to be a later version, dating from around 1733. Bach apparently originally wrote it a decade earlier, in 1723, and it seems to have been one of a handful of works on which he lavished special effort to ‘lay down a marker’, as it were, at the start of his new job as Kantor at St Thomas’s Church, Leipzig. This older version was written a semitone higher, in Eb, and (an entirely new discovery for me) may well have been intended not for Advent but for the Feast of the Visitation, which occurs on 2nd July – so, not so ‘seasonal’ after all. However, even in its first year, apparently, Bach performed the piece on Christmas Day 1723, with four short additional movements featuring interpolated texts that directly referenced the Christmas season, and since then its association with this time of the year has been firmly fixed. It’s a ‘festive’ piece in terms of its instrumentation, including trumpets and drums which add splashes of colour to the more ceremonial moments. It is unusual in being set for five-part choir (SSATB), in addition to a requirement for solo singers for some of the sections. It devotes a separate movement to each of the ten verses from Luke (except verse 48, which is set across two movements, allowing the ‘all generations’ passage to be set for wider choral forces), and the piece is rounded off by a final doxology (‘Gloria Patri…’) for the complete forces that Bach uses. Structurally, as one might expect from Bach, the piece has a careful organisational balance. Of the eleven movements that are devoted to Luke’s text, nos 1, 4, 7 and 11 are for full chorus, and these provide the ‘pillars’, as it were, of the structure. Interpolated between these sections are solo arias (movements 2, 3, 5, 8 and 9), a duet for alto and tenor (movement 6), and a movement for three soloists (two sopranos and alto, movement 10). The result provides moments of contrast between large scale movements of ‘public’ celebration and more introspective periods of reflection and contemplation. There are exquisite moments of word-painting throughout, but if I try to unpick them all this will be a very long entry indeed, so suffice it to say that there’s plenty of further reading on the interweb for those that might like to dig it out. As for a recording, YouTube has several that are, I think, very impressive, but pushed to select one I’ve gone for a live performance by the period instruments of the Concentus Musicus Vienna and the Arnold Schoenberg Choir, conducted by Nikolaus Harnoncourt. The soloists are a starry line-up: sopranos Christine Schäfer and Anna Korondi, alto Bernarda Fink, tenor Ian Bostridge and bass Christopher Maltman. You’ll find the recording here: Bach: Magnificat in D, BWV 243
Day 259: Cello Suite No 3 in C, BWV 1009 (Time: 22 minutes)
Bach has been pretty inescapable on this list (see Days 2, 6, 19, 30, 63, 117, 129, 130, 143, 210 and 247!), including, on Day 129, the Cello Suite No 2 in D Minor, the choice at the time of Martin. Given that I wrote in some detail about the context for these suites in that posting, I suggest you look back at that day’s notes rather than simply repeating what I’ve written before. Perhaps the most obvious thing to say about the choice for today (18/1/22), the Cello Suite No 3 in C, BWV 1009, is that its ‘C Major-ness’ gives the whole piece an open, sunny, affirmative air, certainly compared with its D Minor predecessor. It has the same structure as all the other cello suites – an imposing and dramatic Prelude, followed by five shorter ‘dance’ movements, an Allemande, a Courante, a Sarabande, a fifth movement that differs from suite to suite, and a closing Gigue. In the third suite, the fifth movement consists of a pair of Bourrées – a French dance with a broadly dactylic (‘dah-di-di’) rhythm. Like many of the other cello suites, the Suite No 3 starts with a Prelude that is dominated by scales, sometimes very overtly and at other times embedded into the passage-work. The following Allemande, in 4/4 and with a strong emphasis on the first beat, is an orderly and calm affair, with a strong sense of continuous flow. The Courante is in three-four and with an entirely uncomplicated rhythmic pattern; scales feature prominently here too. Then we have a Sarabande, graceful and dignified, before the pair of Bourrées takes us back into something more obviously akin to rustic simplicity. This is probably the most famous movement in the suite, joyous and free. Finally the suite ends with the Gigue (compare the English ‘jig’), bouncing and lively with prominent use made of a kind of underlying ‘drone’, as though there were bagpipes in the background! As for a performance, YouTube offers several, and much will depend on how you like your Bach to be served up. Even though I’m a bit of a period instrument chap myself, I do like a strong performance that will dominate a big space too, and they don’t come much bigger than a packed Albert Hall for the Proms. So here is Yo Yo Ma, recorded at the 2015 Proms when he played all six suites. It won’t be to everyone’s taste, and yes, it’s over the top in places, and the musical gestures are necessarily big ones, to fill the space, but I find it powerfully life-affirming. You’ll find it here: Bach: Cello Suite No 3 in C, BWV 1009
Day 265: Goldberg Variations (arr. Sitkovetsky) - Aria and Variations 1, 5, 6 and 19 (Time: 11 minutes)
There has been more Bach than any other composer on this list since it began back in March 2020, a fact for which I make no apology. He is the foundation stone on which over 300 years of subsequent music making has been built. Amongst the many pieces of his music featured so far, we’ve heard sections of choral masterpieces such as the B Minor Mass and the St Matthew Passion, core chamber works such as two of the Suites for Unaccompanied Cello, and dipped a toe or two into his vast repertoire of solo keyboard music, such as a couple of the Preludes and Fugues and (see Day 30) the Aria and Variations 1-3 from the Goldberg Variations, BWV 988. In that sense, I’m breaking an unwritten rule of this playlist in featuring the same music twice – but I hope the ‘twist’ below will justify this as a choice for today (8/2/22). As I wrote back on Day 30, this piece (along with Beethoven’s ‘Diabelli’ Variations) is in most people’s view one of the two greatest pieces of music in variation form in the whole classical canon. The implausible story of its genesis has been around since the early 19th century, though you won’t find many these days who believe it. Allegedly the insomniac Count Kaiserling, Russian ambassador to the Court of Saxony, engaged the famous harpsichordist Johann Gottlieb Goldberg to set up his keyboard in an ante room and play for him through the long hours of the night. And, allegedly, the Count asked Bach to compose something for Goldberg to play, the result being this set of variations, for which Bach was rewarded with a golden goblet filled with French ‘louis d’or’. There are a couple of spanners in the works here. The first is that when the music was published there was no dedication to the Count on the title page (which surely would have happened given the prestige involved in the commission); the second is that Goldberg, keyboard virtuoso though he might have become, was only 14 (some sources say 13) at the time! Still, let’s not let any of that get in the way of a good story. The variations are not on a theme, but on a bass line and/or the chord progression of the ‘Aria’ that Bach composed as his theme. The piece is elaborately constructed: every third variation (so, numbers 3, 6, 9 and so on) is a canon – think of ‘Frère Jacques’ or similar – though Bach adds to his own challenges by making each successive canon start a second, then a third, then a fourth, and so on, above the main theme. (Too much information, maybe, but imagine it like this: if the theme were ‘Frere Jacques’ and we were in C Major, in the first canon every new entry starts on the same note, C; in the next canon, the first entry is on C but it’s then followed by the same theme starting on D; in the next canon, the first entry is on C, but then followed by the same theme starting on E … and so on. I do love the way Bach’s mind works!) Meanwhile, the intervening variations have their own patterns and subtly evolving interconnections. Still, I’m conscious that (mostly) I’m writing for enthusiasts, not musicologists, so I’ll leave it at that. And so to the performance. In 1984, the Russian violinist, conductor and arranger Dmitry Sitkovetsky reworked the Goldberg Variations for string trio (that is, violin, viola and cello). He has gained an extensive reputation in the past four decades as an arranger, working on pieces by Haydn, Beethoven, Brahms and dozens of others. Sitkovetsky has written of the work: "When I first wrote my transcription of Bach's Goldberg Variations for String Trio, in 1984, it was both a labour of love and an obsession with the 1981 Glenn Gould recording [for piano]. For two months I probably had the time of my life, musically speaking, being in the constant company of Johann Sebastian Bach and Glenn Gould. Generally, at that time, transcriptions were out of fashion and I recall that my own colleagues and managers were sceptical about such an audacious idea… I hope listeners will share in my life-long journey through the Goldberg Variations and my love of the music. Indeed, in the very first publication of the Variations, in 1742, J S Bach states that the spirit of the piece is ‘for the enjoyment of music lovers’." Which seems as good a reason as any for making the effort. Clearly. I can’t fit in the whole work in the time allocation that the playlist works to, but here are the Aria and four of the variations, performed by the young British string players of the Teyber Trio: Bach: Goldberg Variations (arr. Sitkovetsky) - Aria and Variations 1, 5, 6 and 19
Day 446: Brandenburg Concerto No 3 (Time: 11 minutes)
The piece by Bach on Arcangelo’s programme in their concert to be given in Sheffield this month is the Brandenburg Concerto No 3, which is my choice for today (12/1/24). Now, discussion of Bach’s Brandenburg Concertos can easily take us down a rabbit hole and into a kind of parallel universe where musicologists concoct all sorts of arcane theories. What we actually know about them is fairly minimal. They were presented by Bach to Christian Ludwig, Margrave of Brandenburg, in 1721, though most evidence points to the fact that they had been written across several years before that, and pulled together as a ‘set’ for the occasion. Bach called them ‘Six Concerts à plusieurs instruments’, which is a pretty functional title, maybe pointing to the fact that he was writing concertos for multiple soloists, in the style of the fashionable Italian concertos of the day. Bach’s dedication is a lovely example of the sort of grovelling necessary in such a culture; the opening sentence reads: ‘As I had the good fortune a few years ago to be heard by Your Royal Highness, at Your Highness's commands, and as I noticed then that Your Highness took some pleasure in the little talents which Heaven has given me for Music, and as in taking Leave of Your Royal Highness, Your Highness deigned to honour me with the command to send Your Highness some pieces of my Composition: I have in accordance with Your Highness's most gracious orders taken the liberty of rendering my most humble duty to Your Royal Highness with the present Concertos, which I have adapted to several instruments; begging Your Highness most humbly not to judge their imperfection with the rigour of that discriminating and sensitive taste, which everyone knows Him to have for musical works, but rather to take into benign Consideration the profound respect and the most humble obedience which I thus attempt to show Him.’ Which is brilliant in its way, I suppose… Anyway, in effect the concertos then disappeared from the repertoire, and there are no subsequent references to them by Bach in the remaining 30 years of his life, which doesn’t suggest that he regarded them as uniquely perfect examples of his art. Bits and pieces of several of the concertos existed in other guises before and after 1721, so again it seems not to point to anything ‘unified’ about them. That hasn’t stopped lots of people building all sorts of musical, ideological, philosophical and it has to be said often quite eccentric theories about them, their interconnectedness, and their ‘meaning’. An example book title: ‘The Social and Religious Designs of J. S. Bach’s Brandenburg Concertos’. An example theory: that the six concertos describe a series of Greek myths woven into numerological designs which, together, point to an underlying Christian message. Hmmm… Anyway, what we can say is that the Brandenburg Concerto No 3 has some ‘numerological’ design: as the third concerto it is for three groups of three instruments (three violins, three violas, three cellos – underpinned by a continuo section, as was conventional). It’s the shortest of the set, usually coming in at about 10 minutes (though see below!). Another oddity is that although it has three ‘movements’, the middle one consists only of two chords. It’s fairly usual these days simply to play it like that, so it’s a kind of ‘punctuation mark’ between the two outer movements. However, lots of performers insert a slow movement from elsewhere in Bach’s output at this point – the ‘Largo’ from the Violin Sonata in G, BWV 1021 is a favourite because it’s in the ‘right’ key. Wendy (formerly Walter) Carlos had three goes at this in her recordings, inserting a different movement in each recording. Personally, I prefer the unadorned chords, a kind of ‘re-set’ of the emotions before the helter-skelter finale. Both outer movements make much of the small group of players as ‘soloists’, with their individual lines, contrasting with moments when the violins, say, or violas play as one. Now, choosing a recording, given the varieties on offer on YouTube, is going to be a matter of personal choice. I’d have to confess that the way I ‘heard’ this concerto as a young man in the 1970s is very definitely not the way I want to hear it now. Then, the fashion (I saw the ensemble ‘I Musici’ play all six concertos in Manchester in my teens) was for a kind of driven uniformity, so the pieces chugged along with what now seems like little light and shade. If you want that ‘old school’ Bach, try the YouTube recording of the Munich Bach Orchestra recording under Karl Richter – it’s about two minutes slower than most performances these days! There are lots of others out there, but my preference is for something lively, sinewy, fleet of foot. For that reason I’ve gone for a performance by the Freiburg Baroque Orchestra. It may have been recorded over 20 years ago, but this is how I like my Bach! You’ll find it here: Bach: Brandenburg Concerto No 3
Day 526: Concerto for Two Violins and Strings in D Minor (Time: 14 minutes) and Orchestral Suite No 3 in D (20 minutes)
In a concert in Sheffield next month, the Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment are performing, amongst other things, Bach’s Double Concerto for Two Violins in D Minor and his Orchestral Suite No 3. So those two works are my choices for today (24/1/25). Bach has appeared 14 times already on this list, though it’s over a year now since the last time, so we’re overdue another occasion to celebrate this greatest of all composers (not, I think, too controversial a comment). My choices to date have largely focused on Bach’s choral and solo instrumental music; his Brandenburg Concerto No 3 is the only orchestral piece to appear so far. In fact, Bach wrote a considerable number of concertos in his lifetime, starting in the second decade of the 18th century by transcribing other composers’ concertos into solo pieces for organ or harpsichord (a lot of Vivaldi, but also Marcello and Telemann). As for original compositions in concerto form, there are famously the six Brandenburg Concertos, three concertos for violin (one of these – more below – for two violins), and at least sixteen concertos featuring a solo harpsichord or combinations of two, three or four harpsichords. (You can add to that lot at least a dozen concertos once attributed to Bach but now thought to be of dubious origin, and another dozen or so ‘reconstructed’ concertos from authentic Bach sources for which no original manuscript exists.) So, as you can see, the concerto form was a major focus of Bach’s compositional efforts. The Concerto for Two Violins in D Minor, BWV1043, was once thought that to be an early work, part of Bach’s output from his time as music director in Köthen, where he was based from 1717-23. However, recent scholarship suggests it was written around a decade later. Bach’s longest-lasting and most prestigious post was in Leipzig (1723-50), and for the first half-dozen years or so his creative life was mostly taken up with composing sacred music for the city’s church services and festivals. However, in 1729 alongside his other jobs Bach took over the running of Leipzig’s Collegium Musicum, a mix of professional and university-based musicians who gave weekly concerts at two of Leipzig’s coffee houses. It seems likely that Bach wrote this Double Concerto (and the two concertos for a single violin) for these players. The work is interesting in part because the two soloists don’t really engage in any kind of competitive behaviour; instead, it’s as though they work together in opposition to the orchestra (actually just a body of string players, supported by the usual keyboard continuo). And here’s a new word for the playlist: ‘ritornello’. I mention this because it defines the structure of the first movement here (and in lots of other places in Baroque music), characterised by a recurring ‘chunk’ (not a technical term) of music for the full ensemble, that acts like a kind of ‘refrain’; these episodes are separated by passages for the soloists, who are only lightly accompanied by the supporting cast. The rather relentless drive of the D Minor opening movement contrasts brilliantly with the serene and lyrical slow movement (in the much ‘warmer’ key of F Major), a movement that has become one of the most famous pieces in all of Bach’s output, music of tenderness and sensitivity, in which the two violins wind in and out of each other’s lines. The final Allegro returns to the ‘ritornello’ pattern of the opening movement, and it has the same intense focus on forward movement, ending in solemn D Minor. YouTube has several decent performances of this work on video, and from the options I’ve gone for this account by the Netherlands Bach Society, directed from the solo violin by Shunske Sato, while the second soloist is Emily Deans. You’ll find the performance here: Bach: Concerto for Two Violins and Strings in D Minor. Turning to today’s other work, Bach wrote four orchestral suites (there’s a fifth in his catalogue, but now pretty definitely regarded as not being by Bach) – or ‘Ouvertures’, as he called them – and these too seem to date from the very early years of his time in Leipzig, though again it could be that they existed in some form beforehand and were reworked for his Leipzig audience. Unlike the Brandenburg Concertos, there’s no evidence that Bach composed them as a set, or expected them to be performed together. They are scored for differing forces (the second, for example, is for solo flute and strings) and seem to have been created with different performance contexts in mind. The Suite No 3 in D is scored for three trumpets, two oboes, timpani and strings – forces that suggest a big, almost ‘open air’ sound, as though created for a festive occasion – and like all the others it consists of a substantial opening movement (or ‘Ouverture’) followed by a series of dances. This form can be found elsewhere in Bach’s work (the Suites and Partitas for solo violin, or the Suites for solo cello, for example) and it’s a common feature of Baroque music from the late 17th century onwards. Its precise origins are obscure, but probably the French tradition initiated by Lully has the best claim here. After the opening movement’s grandeur comes what is another of those pieces that has escaped its immediate context and developed an independent reputation, the Air in G (often souped up by other hands as the ‘Air on a G String’), with its almost vocal violin line over a ‘walking bass’. The three remaining movements are a gavotte, a bourrée and a gigue: the first of these (actually a pair of gavottes) is initially courtly and stately, and then more ‘countrified’; the second is more lively and agile; the last, making much of the high bright sound of the trumpets, brings the suite to a joyous conclusion. YouTube offers a range of possibilities here, and this time I’ve gone for a period instrument performance by the Amsterdam Baroque Orchestra, conducted from the keyboard by Ton Koopman, which you’ll find here: Bach: Orchestral Suite No 3 in D
Day 548: Italian Concerto (on harpsichord) (Time: 13 minutes) and Italian Concerto (on piano) (13 minutes)
Today (25/7/25), after several weeks of exploring composers of relative obscurity, my survey returns to (for most people) the pinnacle of musical expression. This coming Monday will be the 275th anniversary of the death of Johann Sebastian (Mighty) Bach, so for me at least, there wasn’t much debate about this week’s focus. We’ve had appearances by Bach 15 times before now on this list, so there’s already been a pretty extensive biographical survey of the key incidents of his life – and therefore I’m not going to add to that discussion here. But when I was wondering what to choose to mark this anniversary, it occurred to me that there has been quite a lot of choral, orchestral, organ and solo cello/violin Bach prior to today’s posting, but not actually a great deal of his keyboard music, which is such a substantial part of his output. I’ve featured a couple of the Preludes and Fugues from The Well-Tempered Clavier (see Day 210) and a sampling of the awesome Goldberg Variations (see Day 30 and – in an arrangement for string trio – Day 265), but no whole works, whether played on the harpsichord (which would have been Bach’s practice) or the piano (which is statistically more common these days). And therefore I’ve decided to plug this particular gap by choosing today one of Bach’s most popular keyboard works, his Italian Concerto, BWV 971. There are a couple of logical questions one might ask of this work: why ‘Italian’ and why ‘concerto’? Taking them in that order, Bach (or in some cases other interested parties after his death) named a number of his works with ‘national’ markers in their titles. Aside from the Goldberg Variations and The Well-Tempered Clavier, the most substantial pieces of keyboard music he wrote are the six English Suites, the six French Suites and the six Partitas – each for solo keyboard performer. Now, there’s a rabbit hole here I’m not going to fall down, when it comes to trying to define the ‘Englishness’ or ‘Frenchness’ of the first two sets of six I’ve just mentioned. (Maybe I’ll come back to that if I ever feature anything from either set.) However, the ‘Italian’ quality of the Italian Concerto is a much more explicit and obvious signal on Bach’s part of what he was trying to achieve with this work. Bach published it in 1735, so it’s quite a late composition, though it seems possible that it was written a little earlier, at the beginning of the 1730s. It was one of two pieces that he had published in 1735 as volume two of his ‘Clavier-Übung’ (literally ‘keyboard practice’ or ‘exercise’). The rather grand title page is worth a quotation: ‘Keyboard Practice Consisting in a Concerto after the Italian Taste and an Overture after the French Manner for a Harpsichord with Two Manuals, Composed for Music Lovers, to Refresh Their Spirits, by Johann Sebastian Bach, Kapellmeister to His Highness the Prince of Anhalt-Cöthen and Director Chori Musici Lipsiensis.’ So, two works, one after the Italian style and the other the French. Bach had a long history when it came to his interest in Italian composers and their music – not only, but most commonly, the music of Vivaldi. Earlier in his career Bach copied out several of Vivaldi’s violin concertos, and reworked them as pieces for harpsichord or organ. Shifting the focus slightly to the ‘concerto’ question I raised earlier, the default form of the concerto, as developed in Italy from the late 17th century onwards, was the ‘concerto grosso’. Ladybird Book of Musical Terminology definition: a concerto for orchestra (the ‘ripieno’, or main body of performers, and basically a string orchestra in such works) and one or more soloists (the ‘concertino’). Listen to pretty much any concerto by Vivaldi or any of his contemporaries (Corelli or Albinoni, say) and you can hear this interplay of forces as the driving dynamic in these works. So, Bach takes the Italian concerto grosso form and uses it here. But if the concerto grosso pits soloists against orchestra, how does this square with the fact that Bach’s work is for just one player? Well, what Bach does is to imitate the interplay of opposing forces – the ‘bigger’ sound of the orchestra and the ‘soloistic’ display of the individual performer – on his two-manual harpsichord that this work was explicitly written for. The Italian Concerto is in the conventional three movements, with the slow movement coming second. Bach’s most obvious imitation of the orchestral/soloistic dynamic occurs in the outer movements, where – especially if the work is being played on a two-manual harpsichord – one keyboard performs the role of the fuller sound of the ripieno and the other the more individualistic role of the concertino. Not wishing to burden you with too much jargon, these outer movements take the form of a ‘ritornello’ (where orchestral ‘blocks’ of music recur and are interspersed with alternating passages for the soloists). Listen to the first movement of this work (particularly in the link below for harpsichord) and you should see what I mean. Interestingly, the Italian Concerto is one of the few works Bach wrote in which he explicitly indicated ‘soft’/’loud’ markings, thus making the ‘soloist v orchestra’ idea more obvious still. The middle movement gives the ‘orchestral’ role to the player’s left hand, while the right hand is given a richly-ornamented and finely spun song-like melody in a (by contrast) tender and soulful minor key. The whole work is, for me anyway, roughly 13 minutes of pure joy. Of course, one of the perennial debates about Bach’s keyboard music is whether to play it on the piano or the harpsichord. Obviously Bach would never have encountered anything like the modern concert grand piano, so to play his work on such an instrument is manifestly ahistorical. However, you don’t need to be as overtly critical as pianist Angela Hewitt (who’s recorded all of Bach’s solo keyboard music … twice) is about the tedium of listening to a harpsichord for any length of time to know that you can achieve effects on the piano that a harpsichord can’t match – though the piano, having only one keyboard, isn’t set up like the two-manual harpsichord is for this piece, so the pianist has to work much harder on the contrasts within it. Anyway, given that the work isn’t all that long, I’ve decided to offer performances on both instruments, and you can make your own mind up. First, here is the renowned German harpsichordist Christine Schornsheim playing the work on the harpsichord: Bach: Italian Concerto (on harpsichord), and then here it is played by the famous Bach specialist Sir Andras Schiff on piano: Bach: Italian Concerto (on piano)
Barber, Samuel (1910-81)
Day 102: Violin Concerto (Time: 23 minutes)
Today (17/7/20), I thought I’d flag up what is for me one of the most beautiful and tender of 20th century violin concertos, the one composed by Samuel Barber (1910-81). Barber became a household name pretty early on in his career, with the work that is likely to be the enduring foundation for his reputation, the Adagio for Strings. Originally the second movement of his String Quartet, he made the string orchestra arrangement in the same year, 1936, and a subsequent unaccompanied choral version, a setting of the ‘Agnus Dei’, in the 1960s. It has been a fixture at state funerals and other solemn occasions in the USA and indeed elsewhere ever since. For some composers, such success in his mid-twenties might have been daunting, but Barber produced a range of major works over the following decades, winning the Pulitzer Prize twice (for his opera ‘Vanessa’ and for his Piano Concerto), and only towards the end of his career (no doubt affected by depression and alcoholism, and finally the cancer that killed him) did the creative flow dry up. The work of his that most moves me (apart from the Adagio of course – it’s hard to imagine anyone listening to that without misting up towards the end) is his Violin Concerto. He completed this in 1939, and it has a rather tangled history, in that its initial dedicatee apparently found the first two movements not sufficiently virtuosic to show off his talents, and requested something more ‘show-stopping’ in the finale. He certainly got his wishes, and there seems to be some evidence that the final product was actually too difficult for him to play. It seems to me that this piece reveals that Barber was, in some ways, a composer not quite in tune with his times, in that this is very clearly ‘romantic’ (if not ‘Romantic’) music, where lyricism and tenderness seem more foregrounded than one might expect of a composition written on the eve of the second world war. I’d also argue that it has something of the structure of the ubiquitous Bruch Violin Concerto No 1 – not in its musical language, but rather in the sense that its first movement has an essentially ‘introductory’ feel, leading into the slow movement which is clearly the emotional heart of the work, before the dance-like finale rounds things off. There are several recordings on YouTube, but I’ve gone for one by the soloist Gil Shahan, for whom this concerto is something of a calling card. In this performance from the BBC Proms, he’s accompanied by the BBC Symphony Orchestra conducted by David Robertson. You’ll find it here: Barber – Violin Concerto
Day 204: Summer Music (Time: 12 minutes)
Last time out, I went for a ‘summer’ piece from the very popular end of the spectrum (Mendelssohn’s Overture to ‘A Midsummer Night's Dream’), so I thought it would be interesting today (9/7/21) to go for something much more obscure, though (a familiar refrain) unjustifiably neglected, in my opinion. The composer Samuel Barber (1910-81) has appeared once before on this list (see Day 102, above), when we encountered his meltingly lyrical Violin Concerto. That work dated from 1939. Barber’s musical interests in the couple of decades that followed extended from other concertos (a Cello Concerto of 1945) to full-length ballets (notably ‘Medea’, from 1946) to many works for voice (the lyrical ‘Knoxville: Summer of 1915’ for soprano and orchestra, written in 1948, for example), and in the 1950s, he produced his only work for wind ensemble, the ‘Summer Music’ of 1955, a single movement composition written for the conventional wind quintet line-up: flute, oboe, clarinet, bassoon and horn. Though we’ve had music for wind instruments before on this list, this is the first example of a piece for the wind players’ equivalent of the string quartet, the core combination of wind instruments. The piece was commissioned by the Chamber Music Society of Detroit, and Barber’s intention in writing it was to evoke a languid and dreamy mood. In fact, in putting the piece together, he borrowed from an earlier and unpublished orchestral piece called ‘Horizon’, particularly the lazy melody for horn and bassoon at the start of the work. One of the reasons for the ‘dreamy’ quality of the piece is that Barber continually changes the time signature, so that the piece feels, initially at least, rhythmically vague. The episodic quality of what we’re listening to is highlighted by sudden eruptions of activity – a rapid, chattering passage in semi-quavers, for instance, or the later quicker section which sounds like a folk tune. Barber’s favourite woodwind instrument was the oboe, and I think you can tell that from the piece, even if he makes characteristic use of each of the instruments’ 'personalities'. The work concludes with a quick recap of its principal themes, before ending, according to the writer of the notes for my CD version of the work, ‘with a soft but self-satisfied and witty burble’. ‘Summer Music’ is pretty well served on YouTube, and out of the several possible versions, I’ve gone for this one given by the Chamber Music Society of Lincoln Center, New York. The performers are Tara Helen O’Connor on flute, Stephen Taylor on oboe, Sebastian Manz on clarinet, Peter Kolkay on bassoon and Radovan Vlatkovic on horn – all major performers with orchestras across the USA and Europe. You’ll find it here: Barber: Summer Music
Day 377: Cello Sonata (Time: 17 minutes)
Today (5/5/23), I’m considering a work to be played later this month at the Sheffield Chamber Music Festival 2023, by Samuel Barber. Barber has featured on this playlist twice to date: Day 102 for his lyrical Violin Concerto and Day 204 for his dreamy piece for wind quintet ‘Summer Music’. On both occasions, the music I’d selected led me to describe Barber’s work not just as ‘lyrical’ and ‘dreamy’ but also, variously, as ‘romantic’, ‘tender’, ‘emotionally rich’ and so on. The music I’ve chosen for today is his Cello Sonata, Op 6. That opus number suggests an early work, and it dates from 1932, when Barber was 22 and he was still studying at the Curtis Institute of Music in Philadelphia. It’s reasonable, then, to conclude that this is a young man’s work, and we might expect to encounter music to make a splash, to announce a new and exciting ‘voice’ on the musical scene. There is some truth in this … but only some. By the age of 22 Barber had already written quite a lot – many solo piano pieces and songs emerged in his teens and very early twenties, along with organ works, one orchestral work (the Overture ‘The School for Scandal’) and his setting of Matthew Arnold’s poem ‘Dover Beach’ for baritone and string quartet, which has remained in the repertoire ever since. In the field of chamber music, he’d written a Serenade for string quartet and a prize-winning Violin Sonata (which he subsequently destroyed), but the Cello Sonata was the first piece he composed where the cello was the focus of attention. (For a bit more context, his String Quartet – which is the original source of the famous Adagio for Strings, Barber’s enduring masterpiece – was still four years into the future.) The Cello Sonata was mostly written during the second half of 1932, when Barber was on an extended study trip to Europe, much of it spent at the Menotti family villa near Lake Lugano, where he was staying with his fellow Curtis student (and life partner) Gian-Carlo Menotti. One curiosity: Barber had no access to a piano at the time, but this did not stop him composing the entire first movement and most of the second at that point; the work was completed when he returned to Philadelphia. It was the last work Barber wrote while he was studying composition with his Curtis teacher, Rosario Scalero. The work made sufficient impression to gain for Barber a Pulitzer Travel Stipend and the Prix de Rome of the American Academy in Rome in 1935. The Cello Sonata is in three movements, with the familiar fast-slow-fast pattern, and probably the most obvious comment one might make about the piece is how very unlike most of the music being made by his American contemporaries this sonata is. I’m fairly confident that if you were listening ‘blind’, with no contextual knowledge at all, you wouldn’t think this was a piece from the 1930s, and you’d be far more likely to think it was by a European composer. It’s clear that Barber had sufficient immersion in 19th century compositions for cello and piano – notably Brahms’s two Cello Sonatas – and also a more than passing knowledge of Debussy’s Cello Sonata. The first movement shows a lot of the influence of Brahms, especially in the lyrical second theme. There’s also a strong indication of how concise Barber’s writing could be, in the way he makes the recapitulation of the movement’s opening themes compact and yet completely coherent. The song-like slow movement is interrupted by a kind of ‘perpetual motion’ scherzo, before the lyricism returns, and builds to quite an impassioned climax. There’s yet more of the shadow of Brahms looming over the finale, especially in its heroic ending. Apart from a Cello Concerto of 1945, Barber wrote nothing else which features the cello in a solo role, which, on the basis of the Cello Sonata, seems a real shame. Performances of Barber’s Cello Sonata are not that common on YouTube (or in real life, for that matter), but there is a nice video of the work being performed by Guy Johnston (winner of the BBC Young Musician of the Year award in 2000), accompanied impressively by Chiao-Wen Cheng on piano. You’ll find it here: Barber: Cello Sonata
Bartók, Bela (1881-1945)
Day 3: Six Romanian Folk Dances (Time: 7 minutes)
Today’s offering (25/3/20) is Bartók’s ‘Six Romanian Folk Dances’. It’s Bartók's birthday today (he would have been 139!) and as he’s one of my absolute favourite composers, I thought I’d share this as a glimpse into at least one aspect of his fascinating (if occasionally rather challenging) approach to music. It’s probably fair to say that there are (at least) two sides to Bartók’s musical nature. There’s the ‘modernist’ experimental strand that’s as aggressive and expressionist as anything written in the first half of the 20th century (try the 3rd, 4th or 5th String Quartets … but if not live, then in a video recording so you can see the immense physicality required to perform them); but then there’s Bartók the folk music collector, the Hungarian/Romanian equivalent of Vaughan Williams, if you like. Today’s choice is very definitely at the ‘folky’ end of Bartók’s spectrum. The ‘Six Romanian Folk Dances’ were originally written for piano, and there is a recording on YouTube of Bartók himself playing them on a piano roll recording. However, I’ve chosen Bartók’s later arrangement for small string orchestra, which you’ll find here, played by the Norwegian Chamber Orchestra, led by Terje Tonnensen: Bela Bartók – Six Romanian Folk Dances
Day 173: Dance Suite (Time: 18 minutes)
Today (23/3/21), to mark the Playlist’s first birthday, I wanted to highlight another birthday coming up imminently. Bela Bartók was born on 25th March 1881, which means that in two days’ time, we will reach the 140th anniversary of his birth. Bartók has appeared only once on this list before, almost a whole year ago (see Day 3, above), when I suggested dipping a toe into the rather gentle waters of his Six Romanian Folk Dances, which is definitely at the 'user-friendly' end of the spectrum when it comes to Bartók’s music. Today, you get a tiny bit more grit in your oyster with his Dance Suite. Bartók is, in most people’s books, Hungary’s greatest composer after Liszt (even if his birthplace is now in Romania). Like so many composers growing to maturity in the years running up to the first world war, Bartók was influenced by at least two of the prevailing musical influences of the age, the harmonic language of the music of Debussy, and the lush orchestration of the music of Richard Strauss. However, like Vaughan Williams in the UK, the key ingredient of what turned out to be his mature musical style was his embrace of his native folk music: once he and Kodaly (see Day 93) took their portable phonograph and started collecting the traditional Magyar songs and dance melodies of Hungary, Romania and Bulgaria, their spiky (often asymmetric) rhythms and unconventional harmonies began to appear in his compositions for the concert hall. Although the First World War curtailed much of this active ethnomusicology, the echoes of such music remained with Bartók for the rest of his life. Bartók wrote his Dance Suite in 1923, for the 50th anniversary of the unification of the cities of Buda, Obuda and Pest into a single city (Budapest, funnily enough) in 1873. It is a suite of six movements (linked by a ‘ritornello’), which in most performances run together into a single structure, with a gradually increasing sense of liveliness and animation. It’s a simple framework for dances that exploit styles drawn from Hungarian, Romanian and even Arabic sources, though it is difficult to say which melodies are authentic ethnic material and which are ‘home made’ folk-style themes. If your view of Bartók is that he’s a composer of ‘difficult’ and occasionally indigestible music, this piece might persuade you that his compositions can be a lot of fun. As for a recording, there’s a lively performance on YouTube given by the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra conducted by Juraj Valčuha. You’ll find it here: Bartók: Dance Suite
Day 373: Violin Concerto No 2 (1st movement) (Time: 16 minutes)
We’ve had two examples of Bartók’s music on this list already (see Days 3 and 173, above), in both cases works heavily influenced by Bartók’s fascination with Hungarian (and other eastern European) folk music. I wrote a little about Bartók’s life and musical development in relation to those earlier postings, so in biographical terms all I want to focus on today (21/4/23) is the context in which the 2nd Violin Concerto came into being. When it was first performed, in 1939, Bartók was at the height of his powers as a composer, being regarded as Hungary’s foremost creative musical force, and not yet troubled by the health problems that would cause his death from leukemia by 1945. However, this was not (as anyone with knowledge of European political developments of the 1930s would know) a period when creative artists could ignore the dark forces spreading across the continent. Bartók had refused to cooperate with the Nazi powers in Germany, turning down the opportunity to give concerts there after 1933, and was strongly opposed to the pact Hungary signed with Germany in 1940, the event that precipitated the departure for America of Bartók and his second wife in October of that year. But even before that Bartók’s anti-fascist views put him at odds with the political (and musical) establishment in Hungary. If we take into consideration Bartók’s deep love of the folk music of this whole area of eastern and south-eastern Europe (Hungary, Romania, Slovakia, Bulgaria, and even Turkey), the pain of parting from these geographical roots to start life again in the USA should be evident. However, what’s not evident is that this political turmoil casts major shadows over the work that we now know as the Violin Concerto No 2, or those from the same time. A look at Bartók’s compositions from the second half of the 1930s – the Music for Strings, Percussion and Celesta (1936), the Sonata for Two Pianos and Percussion (1937), ‘Contrasts’ for Violin, Clarinet and Piano (1938), the Divertimento for Strings (1939) and his String Quartet No 6 (also 1939) – reveals something of the creative flow of his work in those years, given that all those compositions are established masterpieces. It’s as though the vividness and sheer dynamism of these pieces was an act of defiance against the suffocating censorship of spreading fascist culture. In August 1936 the violinist (and close friend) Zoltán Székely asked Bartók to compose a concerto for him. (At the time of its first appearance it was simply ‘the’ Bartók Violin Concerto, because the work we now know as ‘No 1’, written in 1907-8 but then set aside, was not published until 1956, well after Bartók’s death.) Interestingly, Bartók asked his publisher to send him examples of new violin concertos being written at the time – and he received scores of such works by Berg, Weill and Szymanowski. I get the sense that, along with the abiding obsession with folk music, Bartók was keen to make this work attuned to the most ‘modern’ contemporary examples. Maybe the most obvious illustration of this in the Violin Concerto No 2 is the use Bartók makes of ‘twelve tone’ themes (nodding to the serialist ‘system’ of composition espoused by Schoenberg and his followers, in which all twelve ‘tones’ of the Western musical system – play a scale of C to C on a piano using all black as well as white notes – are given equal ‘status’), but always within a sound world which is essentially ‘tonal’. Bartók’s original plan was a single-movement work which was in essence a set of variations, but Székely insisted on the conventional three-movement structure, with particular opportunities for display of violin pyrotechnics in the faster outer movements. Amusingly, in a sense Bartók ‘won’ the argument, since the second movement is a set of variations, and also the third movement is a kind of free variation on the music of the first movement. The whole work is one of the longest Bartók produced – several performances on YouTube last longer than 40 minutes, and as that’s my self-imposed limit for a whole week’s (Tue + Fri) recordings, I’ve decided simply to select a performance of the first movement of the work. The opening is direct – a strongly folk-like melody on the violin over shifting orchestral chords – and it sets the tone for the apparently improvisatory quality of the whole movement. Bartók being Bartók, of course, the whole thing is very meticulously planned and patterned. That interplay between strict organisation and seeming spontaneity is most evident in the fully written-out cadenza for the violin, with its startling use of ‘quarter tones’ (that is, notes that don’t ‘exist’ in western music – they’re the notes halfway between the semitones you might find by playing consecutive notes on a piano). As for a performance, there’s a nice one in which the soloist is the young Ukrainian violinist Georgii Moroz, and the Finnish Radio Symphony Orchestra is conducted by Dima Slobodeniouk. You’ll find it here: Bartók: Violin Concerto No 2 (1st movement)
Day 441: Romanian Christmas Carols (Time: 11 minutes)
By way of minimal recompense for the fact that there has been no Advent and Christmas selection of choices this year, today’s selection is a Christmas special, and two sets of very short piano miniatures by – or at least arranged by - Béla Bartók. We’ve had three appearances by Bartók on this list to date – see Day 3 (Six Romanian Folk Dances), Day 173 (Dance Suite) and Day 373 (1st movement of the Violin Concerto No 2). Today (26/12/23), I want to home in on a work (technically two works, in that the pieces are grouped into two ‘series’) from that phase in Bartók’s life – the early years of the First World War – when you can hear his ‘early’ rather modernist phase (music with echoes of Debussy and Richard Strauss) starting to give way to a musical language which is an amalgam of Eastern European folk music and a much more pared back and raw ‘primitivism’. Before the 1914 outbreak of war, Bartók had already started collecting regional songs and dance melodies, and from 1910-14 he worked largely in Transylvania (at that point Hungarian territory mostly populated by native Romanian speakers). Then, after war broke out, he started to feed these discoveries into a series of compositions – the popular ‘Romanian Folk Dances’ (see Day 3) and his Sonatine for piano, and also two sets of Romanian Christmas carols, which he arranged for piano solo. In fact, at that point he was also much preoccupied with writing music that children (or at least relative beginners) could play, and these sets of carols tend to be marketed as suitable for those playing to Grade 4 standard or thereabouts. The music he collected was from a traditional source, ‘Colinde’ singing. Bartók wrote extensively about this in an article called ‘Romanian Folk Music’ in 1931, which I paraphrase here: ‘Several weeks before Christmas the Colinda singers form into groups of eight to ten young men and women . . and carols are selected for 'study' under the supervision of each group leader. On Christmas Eve the groups set out on a carolling tour of the village; they stop in front of each house to inquire whether the host will receive them, and – if they gain admittance - they perform four or five carols.... At the end of the performance the carollers receive gifts and then move on to another house.’ In other words, much like the sort of ‘wassailing’ practised as part of English village life for centuries past. One interesting feature – and it’s something Bartók sets out to mimic in the way he puts these collections together – is also remarked upon in Bartók’s article on Romanian folk music: ‘there is an impression of eager haste on the part of the performers: as if they . . . cannot, for sheer impatience, await the end of the stanza; indeed, that they must start the new stanza during the closing portion of the preceding one in order to reach the end of the - usually quite long - Colinda text and thus be able to visit more houses.’ Compared to carols from the British tradition, there’s very little sense of a ‘verse and chorus’ structure, and the tunes themselves are really quite short. In order to make the music suitable for (inexpert) performers at the piano, Bartók simplifies the original pieces he’d recorded, by making them more obviously in a particular ‘key’ rather than the original ‘accidental’ appearances of sharps and flats created in the singers’ performances, and also by adding bar lines and time signatures, again to regularise something more free and spontaneous. A lot of this, I think, can be explained by the fact that Bartók was writing for the piano, where (assuming the piano is in tune!) the notes themselves are ‘fixed’ – if he’d been writing for a violin, say, there would have been a lot more flexibility to ‘bend’ the notes. Also, there’s a case for saying that though these pieces bill themselves as ‘folk’ music, what Bartók is doing here generates a finished product which is more like ‘art’ music (if that distinction is valid). As I mentioned at the start, the carols are arranged by Bartók into two ‘series’: Series 1 is a shorter selection (usually lasting under 5 minutes in performance), while Series 2 is a little more extensive (usually just under 7 minutes). There are ten carols in each set. YouTube’s collection of performances is largely audio-only, but there is a rather gloomily-shot video recording dating from 1994 of the legendary and much missed Zoltán Kocsis (he died in 2016) performing these lovely little pieces. You’ll find the recording here: Bartók: Romanian Christmas Carols (Series I & II)
Bax, Arnold Edward Trevor (1883–1953)
Day 286: Spring Fire (Time: 32 minutes)
Today (22/4/22), as trailed last time out, another spring-themed piece, and as it happens, another new name on the playlist – the name in question belonging to Arnold Bax (1883-1953). Bax is an interesting figure in British music, and one whose reputation has waxed and waned in rather extreme ways during his lifetime and after his death. His dates should put him firmly in the same historical frame as the familiar roll-call of early 20th century figures from these islands, living in the aftermath of Elgar’s rise to fame: Vaughan-Williams, Holst, Bridge, Delius, Howells, Moeran, Finzi, Ireland and so on. What makes Bax stand out from those composers is that he had not the remotest interest in the traditions of English folk music that, in varying degrees, motivated the musical imaginations of his contemporaries. (I have just discovered that Bax is, allegedly, the originator of that witticism, ‘You should try every experience once, except for incest and folk-dancing.’) One of the reasons why his work was out of step with his peers is that Bax grew up in a family that was, to put it mildly, loaded – and therefore he never had to work for a living or have any need to pursue an ‘academic’ career by studying as a musician or composer. He simply wrote what he wanted, when he wanted, with almost no reference to the musical trends of his age, apart from those he discovered for himself along the way. Of course, no man is an island, and all that, and undoubtedly Bax had his influences: Wagner overshadows his early pieces, and later Debussy, Sibelius and Richard Strauss can be heard in the background of his works. But more powerfully than any composer, the shaping influences on Bax’s work are literary and political. He was smitten at an early age by all things Celtic. He moved to Ireland, wrote (not very impressive) poetry under a pseudonym, and had no doubt about whose side he was on in Ireland’s struggles for independence in the early 20th century. Musically, he is best known today as a symphonist. Indeed, during the 1920s (so before Walton got in on the act, and even allowing for Vaughan-Williams’ work) he was briefly regarded as Britain’s leading symphonic composer after Elgar. You’re very unlikely to hear much Bax on concert programmes; even his most popular work, the tone poem ‘Tintagel’, only gets the occasional outing. Well before his death his work was very definitely out of fashion, and though he has had his advocates in the last four decades (there are at least three full sets of recordings of his symphonies out there) he rarely gets an outing unless a conductor takes up his work as a kind of personal crusade. Which is where today’s choice comes in. This is ‘Spring Fire’, a quasi-symphony that Bax wrote immediately before the First World War. Written under the influence of Swinburne’s rather overheated verse, it was due to have its first performance at the Norwich Festival of 1914, which was cancelled on the outbreak of war. There were other non-performances planned and cancelled in 1916 and 1919 … and at that point the score was thought lost, the last surviving copy seemingly burnt in a catastrophic fire at his publisher’s offices. Fortunately, another copy was discovered, and the first performance took place as late as 1970. The work is in five movements, and there is a programme, of sorts, evident in the movement titles and explored a little in this short introductory talk by the Hallé’s conductor, Sir Mark Elder, who is evidently a fan. You’ll find the comments here. The first movement, ‘In the Forest before Dawn’, is full of pattering raindrops and the slow-breathing earth. Then comes ‘Daybreak and Sunrise’, in which the music shakes off its dreamy torpor and springs to life. It leads directly to the third movement, ‘Full Day’, in which Swinburne’s poetry, quoted in the score, makes explicit the eroticised nature of the landscape. (There is a strong sense here that this couldn’t have been written without Debussy’s ‘l’Apres Midi…’) The fourth section, ‘Woodland Love’, takes this sensuality to a dreamily ecstatic conclusion. Finally, we reach ‘Meanads’, in which a horde of dryads and satyrs, egged on by Pan and Bacchus, engage in a wild riot of sensual indulgence. Over the top, of course, but a fascinating snapshot of the rather feverish sound-world of early 20th century orchestral music, given an English spin. As for a performance, this is definitely audio-only territory. The Hallé’s performance is on YouTube, but only via five separate links, so instead I’ve gone for Mark Elder’s recording with the BBCSO, given at the 1996 Proms. You’ll find it here: Bax: Spring Fire
Beamish, Sally (b.1956)
Day 124: Seavaigers (Time: 22 minutes)
On Tuesday, Malcolm's choice took us to that unique place of overlap of Gaelic language and Christian faith that is Gaelic psalm singing, and its recent adoption by Craig Armstrong on his album ‘The Edge of the Sea’. Today (2/10/20), I want to look at a rather more familiar aspect of ‘highland and island’ culture, its traditional folk music, and its expression in a contemporary concerto for Shetland fiddle and clarsach (Scottish harp) by the composer Sally Beamish. Beamish (b.1956) initially achieved recognition in the world of classical music as a performer (she played viola in the Raphael Ensemble for many years), but after moving to Scotland in 1990, her compositions increasingly developed a ‘folk-tinged’ quality, although her collaborations with other musical traditions have been quite extensive (such as with sax players Branford Marsalis and Tommy Smith, for example). She has written many works in the concerto form – two percussion concertos, three viola concertos, a saxophone concerto, a concerto for classical accordion, amongst others – and one such piece is the concerto ‘Seavaigers’, which she wrote specifically for the Scottish folk musicians Chris Stout and Catriona McKay. (Many of you may know Ms McKay from her regular appearances in Sheffield when the Elias Quartet were founder members of Ensemble 360, and the Elias’s second violin, Donald Grant, performed in his ‘Scottish folk fiddler’ role rather than as a member of a classical quartet.) The concerto dates from 2014 and is in three movements. If you’d like to watch a short promotional video about the making of the recording, you’ll find it here. The liner notes to my copy of the CD tell me that ‘seavaigers’ is a regional dialect term meaning ‘seafarers’. The first movement, ‘Storm’, begins with shimmering stillness before becoming increasingly unsettled and harmonically dark. The second movement, ‘Lament’, consists of a single melody which repeats with overlapping ornamentation. Finally, 'Haven' is, unsurprisingly, about the exhilaration of homecoming. The concerto has been recorded by Stout and McKay, accompanied by the Scottish Ensemble (who we also heard in Tuesday’s music) under its director Jonathan Morton. Unfortunately there isn’t a single YouTube link to the whole concerto, so instead there are links to the three separate movements, which you’ll find here: Beamish: 'seavaigers' - 1. Storm, 2. Lament and 3. Haven
Beethoven, Ludwig van (1770-1827)
Day 11: String Quartet in C# Minor, Op 131 (6th and 7th movements) (Time: 9 minutes)
Today (2/4/20), I’ve attached a link to the Endellion String Quartet playing the last two movements of Beethoven's String Quartet Op 131. Beethoven's final major compositions were a series of five string quartets, having been financially supported by one of his patrons, Prince Nikolai Galitzin to write them. There are many subtle interconnected links between the quartets, notably the three Opp 130-132, but for me, the Op 131 quartet is Beethoven's greatest, and he’s the greatest writer of string quartets, so I think this is pretty special. It was also, apparently, Beethoven's own favourite, and he regarded it as his most perfect single work. If you have the 39ish minutes required, the whole quartet will prove a powerful and revelatory experience, moving as it does from a kind of anguished disorder to (in the seventh and last movement) a rather rugged and hard-won triumph. So what you have here is the beautiful, soulful slow movement, and then the wrestling match which is the finale: Beethoven – String Quartet Op 131 (movements 6&7)
Day 40: Piano Sonata in C Minor, Op 111 (2nd movement) (Time: 19 minutes)
Today (1/5/20), in occasionally familiar fashion, I’m breaking my self-imposed 15 minute rule, but I hope I’ll be forgiven for it, given the quality of the music on offer. Having offered you some (sort of) boogie-woogie yesterday (music by Conlon Nancarrow), I thought you might like to experience one of the first places you can hear boogie-woogie in the ‘classical’ era, in the final movement of Beethoven's final piano sonata (about six and a half minutes into the recording below). I doubt I’m going to get shouted down if I say that Beethoven is the greatest composer of piano sonatas, as he is of string quartets and, arguably, of symphonies. The Sonata in C Minor, Op 111, is the last of his 32 sonatas, and a wonderful place to end an epic journey. In the final group of sonatas, Beethoven became increasingly obsessed with some recurring musical features – softly still song-like themes, sets of variations, trills, silences, amongst others – and the Op 111 sonata ends with a movement that explores all these things in a way that takes you from contemplation to energetic action and back to contemplation again. There are dozens of exceptional performances out there, but I’ve gone for one by Mitsuko Uchida, and you’ll find it here: Beethoven – Piano Sonata No 32, Op 111 (2nd movement)
Day 81: Sonatine for Mandolin and Piano (played on recorder and guitar) (Time: 3 minutes)
Today (11/6/20), there’s something simple and straightforward. It’s a suggestion from Malcolm for a piece of relatively early Beethoven. It’s a Sonatina, as performed here for Recorder and Guitar (originally for Mandolin and Piano, WoO 43a, for those who like all the small print!), and it appears to date from 1796, so Beethoven was in his mid-twenties and had already moved from Bonn to Vienna, the centre of the musical universe at the time. Beethoven wrote a good many works that did not acquire ‘official’ opus numbers, so the catalogue of ‘works without opus number’ (the ‘WoO’ catalogue, created in the mid-1950s) is really quite extensive. A great many of these are, as might be expected, small pieces that Beethoven wrote in his adolescence and young adulthood, but also pieces that perhaps he regarded as not ‘important’ enough to be seen as major works and given official opus numbers. It’s interesting (I think!) to note that by the time Beethoven wrote half a dozen works for mandolin in 1796, he had already written Piano Concertos 1&2, the String Trio Op 3 No 1, the Op 4 String Quintet, all three of the Piano Trios Op 1, all three Piano Sonatas Op 2 and the song ‘Adelaide’, finally published as Op 46. In other words, this is not the work of a beginner! It’s just, for want of a better term, ‘easy listening’ music of the period. Although originally written for mandolin and piano, the version Malcolm has chosen is by the famous recorder player Michaela Petri, accompanied by Lars Hannibal on guitar. I hope it provides a moment of quiet contentment in the course of your day. You’ll find it here: Beethoven – Sonatina for Mandolin and Piano (played on recorder and guitar)
Day 128: String Quartet in C# Minor, Op 131 (4th movement) (Time: 15 minutes)
I want to focus today (16/10/20) on Beethoven's String Quartet, Op 131. Beethoven has featured on this playlist before (see Days 11, 40 and 81), and on Day 11 itself, I featured this particular quartet, focusing then on the final two movements of its epic seven-movement structure. I noted then that this was the third of a series of five quartets (in terms of publication – it was actually the fourth to be written) that Beethoven was commissioned to write towards the end of his life, creating works that were profoundly different from anything that he, or anyone else, had produced in this medium before. They are not necessarily easy to listen to, and the threads, both within and between the quartets, that bind them together are many and complex. They have inspired critics and thinkers in the two centuries that have followed. My personal favourite response to them is the cycle of poems ‘Four Quartets’ by TS Eliot, writing that repays a lifetime’s contemplation. There isn’t sufficient time available, within our current dispensation of 40 mins listening time per week, to consider all of the quartet, so I want today to look simply at its fourth movement, a substantial but varied extended slow movement that lies at the centre of this quartet. In form, it is in effect a set of variations, a structure Beethoven had been fascinated by throughout the final period of his compositional life. The theme itself seems actually quite simple at the outset, as it is presented by the quartet’s two violins, but after that Beethoven weaves rich and often surprising patterns as it is transformed through its various incarnations that follow. Beethoven, with what might seem to us to be startling humility, given his status as a composer, said of this quartet that it showed ‘less lack of imagination than before’! As Schubert remarked, after listening to a performance of the quartet, ‘After this, what is left for us to write?’ I have been unable to find a video performance of just the fourth movement, so we’re in audio-only territory this time round, but I’ve chosen the classic early 1960s performance by the Amadeus Quartet. You’ll find it here: Beethoven: String Quartet Op 131 (4th movement)
Day 139: String Quartet in A, Op 18 No 5 (Time: 32 minutes)
Ludwig van Beethoven has featured four times on our playlist already (see Days 11, 40, 81 and 128!), and today (24/11/20) his fifth appearance is courtesy of his String Quartet in A, Op 18 No 5. Beethoven wrote his set of six quartets, Op 18, in his late 20s, and they were finally published in 1801 when he was 31. They were commissioned by Prince Lobkowitz, who (see Day 127) also commissioned some quartets from Haydn at the same time. The A Major quartet was actually the fourth of the six to be written, but even though these were Beethoven's first published quartets, they were preceded by an extensive apprenticeship, if you like, before he tackled what was by then regarded as the pinnacle of chamber music forms. He had already written the String Trio Op 3, the three String Trios Op 9, the Serenade for String Trio Op 8, and the String Quintet Op 4, thus developing extensive experience in writing for strings alone; in addition, there are the three Violin Sonatas Op 12, the two Cello Sonatas Op 5, and the three Piano Trios Op 1, evidence of Beethoven exploring chamber music forms underpinned by his own instrument, the piano. Another point worth noting about the Op 18 string quartets is that they mark almost the end of what is generally regarded as Beethoven's ‘early’ period of composition – the transition point into his second, ‘heroic’ phase is usually taken to be the profound existential crisis he underwent in the early 1800s as he began to come to terms with his increasing deafness, with its impact on not just his compositional style but also his sense of his life’s purpose as a composer. I guess what I’m trying to get at here is that these six string quartets are the high point of Beethoven's early ‘classical’ style, when he was still manifestly inhabiting the same musical universe as, say, Haydn or Mozart, and before the works of heroism and struggle that we might see beginning with, for the sake of argument, the ‘Eroica’ Symphony. What to say, then, about the quartet Op 18 No 5? For me, it’s most evident characteristic is how ‘Mozartian’ it is. The first movement uses a single chord to attract our attention, and then the main theme of the movement is based on notes of a rising scale. The whole movement is graceful and almost ‘transparent’. This quartet is the only one of the six to put the Menuetto movement second rather than third, another way in which Mozart (particularly Mozart's A Major quartet K464) was his guide. As so often, the heart of the work is the slow movement, a set of variations on a disconcertingly simple theme – not much more than a descending scale. Finally, the last movement is lively and energetic, its second theme pretty much nicked wholesale from Mozart's K464 quartet. Overall, this seems to be Beethoven at his most unruffled – quite a contrast to his gruff stereotype. There are some impressive performances out there on YouTube, but I’ve gone for one of my favourites, the French ensemble Quatuor Ebene, recorded at the Wissembourg Festival in 2018. You’ll find it here: Beethoven: String Quartet in A, Op 18 No 5.
Day 217: Violin Sonata in G, Op 30 No 3 (Time: 20 minutes)
Next month (September 2021) here in Sheffield, Ensemble 360's pianist, Tim Horton, teams up with one of the violinists, Claudia Ajmone-Marsan, to play an hour-long concert of violin sonatas by Bach, Beethoven and Janacek, along with Bartók's Violin Rhapsody No 1. It’s from that concert that I want to select the work to explore today (24/8/21), Beethoven's Violin Sonata in G, Op 30 No 3. Beethoven wrote ten violin sonatas in all, the vast majority from relatively early in his career. When Beethoven has featured before on this playlist (see Days 11, 40, 81, 128 and 139), the focus has been substantially on his string quartets. The violin sonata as a form emerged during the classical period. Haydn wrote relatively little for the combination of violin and keyboard, but Mozart wrote 16 ‘mature’ violin sonatas (a relative term – he wrote almost all of them in his 20s), so the form was well established by the time Beethoven came to it. It’s conventional (if not always helpful) to divide Beethoven's output into ‘early’, ‘middle’ and ‘late’ periods. The ‘hinge’ dividing early and middle phases is usually placed at about 1800, when Beethoven turned 30. It was (I over-simplify crudely) a time when his work took on a new seriousness, as he started to stretch the forms he inherited (the symphony in particular, but also the piano sonata, string quartet and violin sonata) in ways that challenged convention. Behind this turbulent forcefulness is, undoubtedly, Beethoven's realisation of his devastating deafness. The so-called ‘Heiligenstadt testament’ (a letter he wrote to his brother about his hearing loss and its impact on his sense of identity and purpose – a letter he never sent, but which he did keep for the rest of his life) dates from 1802. Of the ten violin sonatas he wrote, the first five pre-date this fateful realisation, and only the last of the ten clearly post-dates it, by a decade. The remaining four – Op 30 Nos 1-3 and the epic ‘Kreutzer’ Sonata, Op 47 – were written during and immediately after this tragic time. In their different ways, you can hear Beethoven asserting himself here in a spirit of challenge and defiance. The Op 30 set was written in 1801-2, and dedicated to Tsar Alexander I of Russia. Even though these works were invariably published as being ‘for the fortepiano with a violin’, what is evident in the sonatas written after 1800 is that violin and piano are now definitely equals, partly because of structural changes in the violin at the time (longer neck, higher bridge, greater tension on the strings), giving the instrument greater range of volume and tone. Having said all that, the sonata Op 30 No 3 in G is a genial and ‘sunny’ work for the most part. G Major was not a common key for Beethoven. Probably the most important work in that key is the Piano Concerto No 4. Otherwise, only one (of ten) of his violin sonatas, one (of sixteen) of his string quartets, one (of seven) of his piano trios and three (of thirty-two) piano sonatas are in that key. Like his other G major works, this sonata is characterised by high spirits and a feeling of unspoiled calm amid the natural world. After a regular sonata-form first movement with its two strikingly contrasting themes, the ‘slow’ movement isn’t really slow at all, but a kind of minuet, a series of restatements of a theme underpinned by an accompaniment of an almost rococo charm. The last movement is a bubbling rondo, behind which you can hear the drone of a rustic bagpipe. As for a performance, there are several on YouTube featuring major violinists (and pianists) of our time. From the choices, I’ve gone for a recording of a concert given by the violinist Renaud Capuçon, accompanied by the pianist Martha Argerich. You’ll find it here: Beethoven: Violin Sonata in G, Op 30 No 3
Day 263: String Quartet Op 95 in F Minor ('Serioso') (Time: 21 minutes)
Beethoven has been a regular fixture on this list (Days 11, 40, 81, 128, 139 and 217), and so far those selections have included an ‘early’ quartet, the Op 18 No 5, and three of the seven movements of a ‘late’ quartet, Op 131. Today (1/2/22), I thought it would be fitting, therefore, to focus on a ‘middle’ period quartet, the String Quartet Op 95 in F Minor, known as the ‘Serioso’. It is conventional to divide Beethoven’s quartet output into this threefold early/middle/late pattern. Of his sixteen quartets, six of them date from the period 1798-1800 and were published as his set of six quartets Op 18. From other notes I’ve written about Beethoven previously, you’ll know that these pre-date the significant turning point in his output, the public recognition in 1802 of his deafness, with all the emotional and psychological trauma that that entailed. At the other end of his oeuvre, he wrote five quartets in the period 1825-6, at the end of his life, when he was in failing health: for many listeners (myself included) these are Beethoven’s greatest works, and amongst the most profound compositions in the history of Western music. Between these two ‘early’ and ‘late’ bursts of creativity stand the remaining five quartets, from his so-called ‘middle period’ (roughly from 1802-1812, though for some the transition to ‘late period’ Beethoven comes rather later, towards the end of the second decade of the 19th century). The five ‘middle period’ quartets consist of the three ‘Razumovsky’ quartets Op 59 (so called because they were dedicated to Count Razumovsky, the Russian ambassador to Vienna) and two works which stand, unusually in this genre, isolated from the rest, the quartet Op 74 (known as ‘The Harp’ for its pizzicato opening), and the work I want to consider today, the String Quartet in F Minor, Op 95. It appears to date from 1810-11, though it didn’t receive its premiere until 1814. It’s the shortest of Beethoven’s quartets, with a concentrated and dynamic focus throughout. Beethoven himself wrote of it in 1815 that it ‘was written for a small circle of connoisseurs and is never to be performed in public’ (so you can consider yourselves very honoured to be listening to it today!). The piece has a somewhat experimental feel, with lots of sudden outbursts and dramatic pauses. Some critics see in this work a reflection of the political and cultural disturbances going on in Vienna at the time: Napoleon’s forces had re-invaded the city in 1809 and though many of his aristocratic patrons fled, Beethoven remained in Vienna under conditions that were (especially for someone with his extremely fragile hearing) not at all easy. The quartet begins as it means to go on, with a rather gruff unison outburst, followed by spiky octave leaps in reply. The whole first movement is barely five minutes long, into which Beethoven compresses this intense drama. The second movement Allegretto eases the tension somewhat, though the movement remains musically complex, including a theme on viola which is treated as a fugue. The third movement Scherzo returns to the angry driving force of the quartet’s opening. The movement’s ending is like a door slamming shut! The finale starts with an expressive slow introduction before the movement as a whole wrestles with contrasting feelings of optimism and agitation. In the end, we hit F Major and an ending which feels, after the struggle, pretty close to triumphant, with its scurrying scales and breathless energy. Beethoven’s quartets in general are pretty well served on YouTube, and this Op 95 quartet is given some fine performances. I’ve chosen one by the contemporary Belcea Quartet, one of the leading ensembles of our time when it comes to Beethoven. You’ll find their performance here: Beethoven: String Quartet Op 95 in F Minor ('Serioso')
Day 321: Wind Octet, Op 103 - 4. Finale: Presto (Time: 4 minutes) and Sextet Op 71 - 4. Rondo: Allegro (4 minutes)
Although music by Beethoven has featured on this playlist on seven different occasions already, it’s over six months since the last time, so it’s good to get back to some mainstream repertoire – or at least, to a mainstream composer, since the music I’ve selected isn’t played all that often. I want to home in today (30/8/22) on two pieces for wind ensemble, both of which feature in Ensemble 360’s concert in Sheffield next month. We’ve had examples of this sort of instrumental combination before now; back on Day 181 I chose Mozart’s Wind Serenade in C Minor K 388, and at that point I discussed the origins and characteristics of ‘harmoniemusik’, compositions for wind band that were popular in 18th century aristocratic circles at a time when most, even minor, dukedoms would have their own ‘harmonien’, or house band. Music in this vein does not form a major part of Beethoven’s output, but there are a number of works that fall into that category, almost all of them dating from very early in his career, either when he still lived and worked in Bonn, or from the years just after he moved to Vienna (in 1792, when Beethoven was 22). One of the earliest pieces of wind music by Beethoven that still exists has an implausibly high opus number – his Octet for Winds, Op 103, which seems like it ought to place it somewhere between his final Cello Sonata and the ‘Hammerklavier’ Piano Sonata, in around 1815-16 – but in fact it comes from 1792 and was written before the move to Vienna. The reason for the high opus number is because it wasn’t actually published until 1830, after Beethoven’s death, and so it has ended up being catalogued alongside much later works. Actually, the music was published earlier than that, or almost: he took the Wind Octet, rewrote some of it, rescored it for string quintet, and published it as his String Quintet, Op 4, back in 1795. In 1792, when Beethoven was still in service at the court in Bonn, he tried his hand at the ‘harmoniemusik’ genre. The scoring of the Octet is for the familiar line-up of the time, two each of oboes, clarinets, bassoons and horns (though it’s conventional often to underscore the bass line with the addition of a double bass). Like much of the ‘harmoniemusik’ of the day, it was considered light entertainment to be played at dinner parties, and its four movements move in a typical pattern of sonata allegro, andante, minuet (although it really wants to be a scherzo), and a presto finale. His handling of the instruments demonstrates remarkable maturity for a 21-year-old, though the rather scary challenges of the final movement suggest that even at that age Beethoven was driven by what was in his head, rather than by the conventional capabilities of the players at his disposal. I thought that from this work I’d highlight the finale, a helter-skelter romp of extreme good humour. It’s played with great virtuosity on this recording by the period instruments of the French-based Sarbacanes (literally ‘Blowpipes’) Ensemble, which you’ll find here: Beethoven: Wind Octet, Op 103 - 4. Finale: Presto. After that piece, Beethoven’s early years in Vienna showed him trying his hand at a wide range of musical genres and combinations of instruments. Most of what survives in terms of wind music exists on the fringes of the repertoire, works without opus number that remained unpublished during his lifetime and which did not make the cut in terms of his main catalogue of compositions. However, one work that did get its own opus number is the Sextet for Wind, Op 71, which despite its high opus number probably dates originally from about 1795, though it was reworked a little a decade later at its time of publication. Its scoring (two clarinets, two bassoons, two horns) is a little more typical of instrumental combinations popular in Revolutionary France in the 1790s rather than the more aristocratic wind band formations with oboes to the fore that were common in Austro-Hungarian lands. At the time of its publication, Beethoven claimed to his publishers that he wrote the whole piece in a single night. Its first performance in 1805 garnered this review: ‘a composition which shines resplendent by reason of its lively melodies, unconstrained harmonies, and a wealth of new and surprising ideas’ – a bit ironic since the music was already a decade old at the time. The piece is in the typical four movement format, and again I’d like to select the last movement for our listening pleasure. It’s a piece that’s easy on the ear, a rondo in which the main theme returns regularly, interspersed with other episodes. You’ll find it in another period instrument performance, this one by the Winds Unlimited ensemble, here: Beethoven: Sextet Op 71 - 4. Rondo: Allegro
Day 362: Cello Sonata in G Minor, Op 5 No 2 (Time: 26 minutes)
The cello sonata as a genre does not boast a very wide repertoire – certainly not when compared with violin sonatas. In part, this is a question of balance and sonority. There are early 18th century sonatas by the likes of Vivaldi and Geminiani, at a time when the supporting keyboard in question would have been a harpsichord, but in truth not a great deal was written for the cello and keyboard combination in the decades that followed. To 18th century ears, the cello would usually have been heard as an ‘accompanying’ instrument (part of the ‘continuo’ that played a supportive role behind the much flashier violin or flute, say) and not really as a solo instrument in its own right. Neither Haydn nor Mozart wrote for these forces. As models of piano became more powerful in the later 18th and early 19th century, the question of balance became even more challenging in that it became easy for the piano to overpower the cello, and because of the cello’s largely lower register, its sound didn’t cut through in the way that, for example, a violin might. Consequently, Beethoven’s five cello sonatas are really the first major works for this instrumental combination in the classical period. (Subsequently, many major composers of the 19th and 20th centuries composed cello sonatas – you might try works by Mendelssohn, Chopin, Brahms, Saint-Saens and Rachmaninov from the 19th century, and Reger, Debussy, Faure, Martinu, Poulenc, Prokofiev and Britten from the 20th, to see how different composers dealt with the challenges of this instrumental combination.) Beethoven hastily wrote two early cello sonatas, Op 5, as a response to an invitation to visit the court of King Frederick William II of Prussia, who ruled from 1786 to 1797 and who played the cello to a high standard. Beethoven played these pieces at court with one of the Duport brothers, Frederick William’s star cellists. (Nobody seems quite sure which one.) Beethoven’s answer to the problem of instrumental balance was to avoid having cello and piano play in the same register at the same time, and also to omit a ‘proper’ slow movement in either of these sonatas, because challenges of balance became more acute in music of a slow, sustained character. Consequently, both the Op 5 cello sonatas are effectively two-movement works, where the first movement is given a slow – and, to be fair, often quite substantial – introduction. Such is the case with the work which is my focus for today (14/3/23), the Cello Sonata in G Minor, Op 5 No 2. You know where you are in terms of mood from the outset – the introduction is marked ‘Adagio Sostenuto ed Espressivo’ – and a sense of drama dominates the opening exchanges. In fact, in some ways one can see this not as a ‘slow introduction’ but as a fully-fledged slow movement in its own right, such is its weight. Another ‘dramatic effect’, if you like, is that at the end of this slow section, Beethoven exploits the tension accumulated by a striking use of silence, before the main ‘Allegro’ section gets under way. Once this is up and running, we are very definitely in a world of drama and agitation, Beethoven very clearly wanting his music to make an impact on his royal host. The other movement is in the relatively more ‘relaxed’ key of G Major, and it’s in ‘rondo’ form. (Don’t panic: a noddy definition of the ‘rondo’ might be a structure with, usually, one recurring section separated by other contrasting interludes. The result is a structure that might be described as A-B-A-C-A, or variations on that, where we keep coming back to the ‘A’ material.) After straying into some wayward keys towards the end, the work ends emphatically (one might even say obstinately, given how much it’s reiterated) in G Major. YouTube lists several impressive performances by some first-rank cellists (and pianists!), so you’ll have no difficulty finding a performance to suit you if you don’t like the one I’m suggesting. My choice is a video recording by the Brazilian cellist Antonio Meneses (perhaps best known as the cello player in the Beaux Arts Trio, for the final ten years of its existence) and one of my absolute favourite pianists, Maria João Pires. You’ll find it here: Beethoven: Cello Sonata in G Minor, Op 5 No 2
Day 376: Piano Sonata Op 27 No 2 ('Moonlight') (Time: 17 minutes)
Later this month, members of Ensemble 360 are performing a concert called ‘Moonlight Sonata’, which (you’re probably ahead of me here) means that the Beethoven work on the programme is his Piano Sonata Op 27 No 2, which is popularly known as the ‘Moonlight’ – and that’s my choice for today (2/5/23). We’ve been way out of the mainstream roll-call of composers for much of the past month or so, so it’s about time we got back to something more familiar. Beethoven has featured nine times already on this list (see ‘The Menu’ for how to access the details), including one dip into the world of his piano sonatas, the final movement of the final sonata, Op 111. You may know that Beethoven wrote 32 piano sonatas (well, 32 that have the official imprimatur of having opus numbers; there are a few more that Beethoven either didn’t think deserved that status or never got round to editing for such formal publication), and they span almost the whole of his creative life. You may also know that it’s conventional to divide his output, retrospectively, into three periods (called, with stunning originality, his ‘early’, ‘middle’ and ‘late’ periods). If we accept the convenience of hindsight, the usual point at which ‘early’ becomes ‘middle’ period Beethoven is generally taken to be around 1800, when Beethoven turned thirty years of age. But, as I wrote back on Day 217, in relation to the Violin Sonata Op 31 No 3, perhaps a better ‘turning point’ is 1801-2, in that it was at about this point that Beethoven was beginning to come to terms with his realisation of his own deafness, and the impact this might have on him as a human being as well as a composer. His ‘Heiligenstadt testament’ – the unsent letter he wrote nominally to his brother but also clearly to posterity – revealing his anguish at this state of affairs, dates from 1802. The ‘Moonlight’ Sonata sits right on the cusp of this transition, being written in 1801 and first published the following year. It’s his fourteenth sonata, one of five to be published in that year, and one of a pair to have the same descriptive title attached to them: ‘Sonata quasi una fantasia’ (usually translated as ‘Sonata in the manner of a fantasy’). That suggests that the two Op 27 sonatas have something rather ‘experimental’ about them. Back on Day 257, discussing Mozart’s Fantasia in C Minor for Piano, I tried to explain the implications of ‘fantasy’ in the title of works that feature it, and for me the key issue is that the focus is more on the creative play of the imagination than any tautness of musical structure, where volatility and emotional turbulence matter a great deal. The element of ‘fantasy’ in Beethoven’s two Op 27 sonatas is largely to do with their unexpected structures, and the often ‘improvisatory’ feel they seem to have for listeners. Op 27 No 2 was famous in Beethoven’s own day (he was a bit curmudgeonly about that; not that he didn’t rate the work, but he just didn’t rate it quite that highly), but has certainly become one of his most famous sonatas in the time since his death, in no small part due to the contribution of the German critic and poet Ludwig Rellstab, who claimed the experience of listening to the first movement was like observing the moonlight on Lake Lucerne (allegedly; actually Rellstab’s comments make no mention of Lake Lucerne – that detail was embroidered later by a subsequent musicologist, Wilhelm Lenz). That has led to the work being called ‘Mondschiensonate’, which literally translates as ‘Moonshine sonata’ – you can see why ‘Moonlight’ is a happier English translation! Anyway, the whole ‘Moonlight’ business has nothing at all to do with Beethoven. So it goes… Without getting too biographical, the sonata was dedicated to Julie ‘Giulietta’ Guicciardi, an aristocratic 16-year-old young lady, who in 1800 was being given piano lessons by Beethoven. In a way familiar in his life story, Beethoven seems to have developed an infatuation with her, and seems to have contemplated marriage, before she was subsequently married off to a socially appropriate Count. So may we be forgiven for hearing the first movement not depicting the still reflections of the moon on some romantic lake, but a funeral march, perhaps, a lament for something longed for and lost? Who knows? Beethoven’s pupil Czerny wrote that this movement calls to mind ‘a nocturnal scene, in which a mournful ghostly voice sounds from the distance’, which at least feels a bit more suited to the movement’s minor key solemnity. The second movement is a brief three-four time interlude, a calming antidote to the first movement’s emotion. The third and final movement is the most substantial of the three (maybe another way in which the ‘fantasia’ bit can be understood is in the sense that Beethoven is shifting the ‘weight’ of the work, unusually, to the end of the piece rather than the beginning) – and it’s also phenomenally difficult to play. It’s marked ‘Presto agitato’, and it has a kind of angry ferocity. Whether we’re hearing the personal anguish of the composer or just a kind of ‘look at me’ demonstration of Beethoven’s exceptional gifts as a pianist can be left to the listener to decide. Lots of pianists have recorded the ‘Moonlight’ sonata, and different listeners will have different tastes. For me, it’s important not to wallow in that first movement, but rather to keep the tempo pushing along. My favourite interpreter of Beethoven’s piano works is Alfred Brendel, but on YouTube, you can only get audio recordings of Brendel playing this piece, and knowing that, in general, my readers would prefer to see the performance rather than just listen to it, I’ve gone instead for a version by a pianist whose playing is very reminiscent of Brendel’s. This is the young(ish) British pianist Paul Lewis, from a recital given in New Jersey in early 2020. You’ll find it here: Beethoven: Piano Sonata Op 27 No 2 ('Moonlight')
Day 385: Symphony No 7 (Time: 34 minutes)
After a great many postings recently, dwelling on some pretty obscure composers, the selection today (2/6/23) of one of the most popular symphonies by a very clearly popular composer means that I may well be able to assume that many of you are familiar with this work without me having to write much about it. However, for those who might not be able to hum the themes from all four movements from memory, let me sketch in a few details. Beethoven has appeared on this list eleven times already (more than anyone else except JS Bach) – but never, so far, featuring any of his orchestral music. Given that his symphonies are core repertoire for all major orchestras, this seems an appalling gap, so let’s do something about it. The Symphony No 7 in A, Op 92, seems to have been started in 1811 and finished during the following year. One interesting contextual issue is that (like the 5th and 6th Symphonies before them) Beethoven wrote the 7th Symphony alongside the 8th Symphony (which has the next opus number, Op 93, in the catalogue of his works). Although in character they are very different, what they share is an extraordinary sense of rhythmic drive and forward propulsion. The 7th Symphony received its premiere in late 1813 at a charity concert in Vienna for soldiers injured at the then recent Battle of Hanau, a confrontation between some of Napoleon’s forces and Austro-Bavarian troops. Given Beethoven’s previous early idolisation of Napoleon, followed by his rage when Napoleon declared himself Emperor in 1804, this symphony’s appearance at an event marking a direct rejection of the destruction Napoleon was continuing to wreak on the European continent seems to mark a final break in the connection between Beethoven and Napoleon. Beethoven’s comments about the music he composed for the charity event suggest, if you like, that he was very definitely ‘on message’ about what was at stake: ‘We are moved by nothing but pure patriotism and the joyful sacrifice of our powers for those who have sacrificed so much for us.’ In fact, two works by Beethoven featured at the concert, the other being the initially immensely popular orchestral mish-mash, ‘Wellington’s Victory’ (a work which, mercifully, has faded almost completely from the repertoire – it must rank as probably the worst piece of music Beethoven ever wrote). The event was also one of the last times Beethoven, close to being entirely deaf by this stage, conducted an orchestra in public. The 7th Symphony is many people’s favourite Beethoven symphony, and the reasons for this are very evident when listening to the work. Its defining quality, as mentioned above, is its rhythmic focus – pounding, usually dotted rhythms dominate all four movements. Pretty much every commentator on the piece foregrounds this. To pick two examples, Wagner described the work (specifically the final movement) as ‘the apotheosis of the dance’, and I also like the very quotable Thomas Beecham’s comment about the third movement: ‘What can you do with it? It’s like a lot of yaks jumping about.’ The first and longest movement starts with a slow introduction, a thing of scales and repeated notes – in the transition between the introduction and the main body of the movement, Beethoven repeats the note E sixty nine times! Once we get going, the spirit of the dance is very evident. Incidentally, the coda to this movement (the bit at the end!), where Beethoven repeats the bass line again and again, did not, apparently, cause the composer Weber to claim that Beethoven was ‘ripe for the madhouse’. (It seems to have been an invention of one of Beethoven’s more aggressively protective early biographers.) The second movement is a thing of perfect and tenderly poignant beauty, an ‘allegretto’ in which the main theme is passed around the orchestra and set against counter-themes which intertwine serenely. With the third movement, the rhythmic propulsion is pretty galumphing, if you like, though the contrasting trio section is more stately. And then we get to the finale, about which one can only say that it’s like nothing that had ever been composed before – a relentless, breakneck dance of whirlwind energy. The strings in particular are worked incredibly hard. I suspect that even people who don’t like Beethoven (if such exist) must surely love this symphony. It’s a celebration of the life force in a way that, I think, you don’t encounter in music again for another century or so, until we get to Nielsen’s Symphony No 4. Performances of Beethoven’s 7th Symphony are reasonably well stocked on YouTube, so selecting one is tricky in that I’m sure people have different preferences. Given that the ‘period instrument’ revolution over the past 50 years or so has transformed so dramatically how we perform and hear this music, more traditionally heavy-footed full symphony orchestra versions are not generally in favour much these days. However, the elusive, reclusive Austrian conductor Carlos Kleiber, who performed in public rarely and laid down recordings even more rarely, is generally renowned for his Beethoven performances, so it’s one of his, with the Amsterdam Concertgebouw Orchestra, that I’ve gone for. You’ll find it here: Beethoven: Symphony No 7. And I realise that if you add this timing to that for Otto Malling’s Piano Quartet last time out, I’ve exceeded the 40 minute rule by three minutes, but you know what? I don’t care!
Day 420: Overture: Leonore No 3 (Time: 16 minutes)
We’ve had a great deal of Beethoven’s music over the three and a half years of this list’s existence: all of eleven occasions when this has happened. However, only once before during that time have we had any orchestral music by Beethoven, the Symphony No 7 on Day 385. Given that his works are core orchestral repertoire, this seems like an oversight, so today (13/10/23) I want to redress that imbalance a bit. Beethoven wrote only one opera, and it has to be said that it cost him an immense amount of time and energy. Although in other genres Beethoven had both fertile and fallow periods, in the end, whether we think of symphonies or concertos or piano sonatas or string quartets, Beethoven’s contributions to these forms are immense, both in quality and quantity. Writing for the opera house, however, seems to have come less easily. There are large-scale choral works, like the Missa Solemnis, and another earlier Mass in C and an oratorio; then on the more intimate level there are several collections of songs, notably ‘An die ferne Geliebte’ (‘To the Distant Beloved’), which lays some claim to being the first proper ‘song cycle’ in the history of music. However, when it comes to opera, there’s just the one, ‘Fidelio’. Its ‘final’ version dates from 1814, but it started life at least ten years earlier, with a fragment of an abandoned opera called ‘Vestas Feuer’. Beethoven salvaged a couple of numbers from it that eventually found their way into a new work, provisionally entitled ‘Leonore, or the Triumph of Married Love’. This appeared in a version in three acts in 1805 (at which point its title had changed to ‘Fidelio’), and Beethoven immediately revised it for a two-act version the following year. The earlier incarnation didn’t go well in performance, the most readily attributable reason being the French invasion of Vienna at the time, which disrupted rehearsal and performance, and deprived Beethoven of much of his audience. The 1806 version went better, but things fell apart, apparently, after rows between Beethoven and the theatre management. (Nerdy footnote: these days it’s usual to refer to the 1805/1806 versions, when they’re occasionally performed, as ‘Leonore’, to distinguish them from the final text.) In 1814 he had another go, with a change of librettist, and this time, at last, the work was a great success – and has been in the repertoire of most major opera houses for the past 200 years. Nevertheless, one can see why he vowed never to write another opera! The same degree of heartache can be found in Beethoven’s struggles to find the right note to sound from the outset in the opera’s overture. Some composers don’t really get very excited by the overtures to their operas. Many 19th century opera overtures are simply a pot pourri of the main tunes from the opera to come, to enable the audience to have a preview of things they’ll become familiar with later, whilst settling down, chatting to their neighbours and generally waiting for the action to begin. In fact, some composers care so little for their opera overtures that the same music might be used in more than one context: Rossini is famous (is that the word?) for using the same piece of music to preface four different operas! Beethoven stands at the opposite extreme: there are four different overtures to this one opera. The 1805 version was prefaced by the overture we now know as ‘Leonore No 2’ (don’t ask why!), similar to but less expansive than his reworking for the 1806 version, which is what we now label ‘Leonore No 3’. This was so impressive that it overshadowed the opening scenes of the opera that followed it, so for a hypothetical but never actually staged performance of the opera in Prague in 1808 he scaled things down considerably, producing the overture we now know (though actually we don’t, very much, because it’s hardly ever heard) as ‘Leonore No 1’. Finally, in 1814, he started afresh musically, and rather than adapting any of the three ‘Leonore’ overtures, he came up with a new overture entirely, which we now know as ‘Fidelio’, and it is this that is almost always heard at the start of performances of the opera. So, what of ‘Leonore No 3’? Well, in some ways it feels a bit more like a ‘symphonic poem’ than an overture. It’s like a wide-ranging emotional and psychological journey through the opera’s narrative in short form before any performers open their mouths to sing. We start with dark brooding music for the opera’s ‘hero’, the political prisoner Florestan and we end up with the celebratory triumph of the opera’s conclusion in a whirling coda with fanfares and dashing scales on the strings. It’s the same ‘darkness to light’ journey that we find in, say, the Symphony No 5 or No 9, including the offstage trumpet calls that signal help for the prisoners of injustice (not just Florestan but a whole jail full of political prisoners – Beethoven’s revolutionary message is on full show here). The result is something too massive, too overwhelmingly dramatic, to work in the opera house – but in the concert hall it’s one of the great manifestations of Beethoven’s perennial urge to write music to stand up for the dignity and nobility of ‘everyman’ (women included too!) in the face of oppression. YouTube has several decent performances of this piece on its books, but the one I’ve gone for is at least in part selected with a nod to the hideous (and, as I write this, ongoing) barbarity in Israel and Gaza. It’s from a concert given by the West-Eastern Divan Orchestra, conducted by one of its founders, Daniel Barenboim. The orchestra is the product of Barenboim’s discussions with the late Palestinian author and scholar Edward Said. It started as a music workshop to being together Jewish and Palestinian (and Egyptian, Iranian, Lebanese, etc. etc.) musicians, exposing each to the other’s humanity and finding shared, common values. The orchestra has been a shining testimony to the fact that there’s a better way to find peaceful coexistence in the region than any of the posturing of politicians and military leaders or the barbarity of armed groups. Founded in 1999, the orchestra’s performance on this video is from 2006, so this is still quite early in its history. It’s a young orchestra in terms of the ages of its members as well as it’s organisational past, but what might be lacking in polish in this performance is more than made up for in passion. You’ll find it here: Beethoven: Overture - Leonore No 3
Day 490: Symphony no. 8 (Time: 24 minutes)
I’ve featured one complete Beethoven symphony on this list so far: see Day 385 for the Symphony No 7, Op 92. Today (18/6/24), we have what is in some ways its companion piece, the Symphony No 8 in F, Op 93. The former had its first performance in December 1813; the latter was first heard two months later. The two symphonies form an interesting study in comparisons and contrasts. Both have an obsession with rhythm, in some ways at the expense of melody. But where the 7th is urgent and driven, the 8th is more playful, and it feels lighter somehow. Beethoven himself often referred to it as ‘my little symphony in F’, to distinguish it from the 6th Symphony, also in F Major, and not little at all. But it’s not lightweight, though, even if it is among the least regularly performed of his symphonies in concert (I suspect the Symphony No 2 wins the prize for rarity value). Why the 8th should be so overlooked is open to debate. Because it’s not a ‘big’ work, it’s not going to bring the house down at the end of a concert, like the 3rd, 5th, 6th, 7th or 9th. And it doesn’t have the ‘upstart’ quality of the 1st Symphony, which often features as the opening work in concerts to show how Beethoven was taking the conventions of the ‘classical’ symphony and already bending them to his will. In fact, its relative lack of popularity was evident from the outset. Beethoven, asked why the 8th Symphony was less popular than the 7th, said ‘because the 8th is so much better.’ That too is open to debate! But what can definitely be said is that the Symphony No 8 is a work that is deceptively simple, so one might not immediately recognise its strengths in the way that one surely can at a single hearing of its predecessor. It’s also humorous, and I have the feeling that this geniality might lead us not to take it so seriously. In 1811 Beethoven, whose health had rarely been fantastic, was seriously ill and took a ‘cure’ at the spa town that is now Teplice in Czechia. He repeated the experience the following year, which is where he seems to have finally got round to finishing both 7th and 8th Symphonies. Was he ‘happy’ at this time? It’s hard to say, though from 1813 on, his health deteriorated even more, he became embroiled in family troubles, and his production of music slowed dramatically over the following years. So in some ways the 8th Symphony feels as though it marks the end of an era in his work, and I don’t think he would go on to write anything so carefree in the remaining decade and a half of his life. The 8th is a work that gets on with things from the outset – no throat-clearing introduction, just a happy-sounding theme, though one with subversive pauses, and often sounding like it’s part of the ending of something rather than its beginning. The first movement’s structure is deliberately unbalanced in relation to the Haydn/Mozart models, so that the weight falls on the coda, where Beethoven pounds out rhythmic repetition at a very loud volume, and then, when we think the movement will end with these hammer blows, gives us a throwaway ending of hushed restraint. It’s a symphony without a proper slow movement, the second movement ticking along briskly, almost metronomically. It’s often said that Beethoven is parodying here the ticking of a metronome, which is a nice idea except for the fact that Maelzel did not produce the device until after the symphony was written. But the ‘clockwork’ idea is certainly there, so one could see Haydn’s ‘Clock’ Symphony’s slow movement as a forerunner. As you might know, one of Beethoven’s trademark developments was to replace the classical symphony’s minuet with something rougher and tougher, a scherzo, as the third movement. But here in the 8th Symphony we have what might seem like a throwback to older times – were it not for the fact that Beethoven keeps messing up the ‘three in a bar’ rhythm, so that the accents fall in the wrong places. And then we get to the finale, breathless and relentless, though full of contrasts of loud dissonant interruptions cutting across softer skipping repeated phrases tossed to and fro across the orchestra. But it’s the final three minutes or so that really show Beethoven playing games, in the most outsize and over-the-top coda for a work whose primary quality has been a sort of filigree clarity. The work concludes, if you like, as a kind of parody of the ‘big rock ending’. If you know the closing moments of Beethoven’s 5th symphony – 29 bars of C major chords, all marked ‘fortissimo’ – then the ending of the 8th feels like someone blowing a raspberry at the same idea, stringing out our anticipation of the final chord to implausible lengths. YouTube is well stocked with performances of this symphony, though not all of them are as light on their feet as one might wish. One conductor who seems to me to have the measure of this symphony is the Estonian Paavo Jarvi. There are at least three video recordings by him on YouTube – two with the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra, and one with the Deutsche Kammerphilharmonie of Bremen. This last one uses a smaller orchestra and, for my money, is the best of the three. You’ll find it here: Beethoven: Symphony No 8
Day 515: Piano Sonata in F Minor, Op 57 ('Appassionata') (Time: 25 minutes)
Today (8/11/24), Tim Horton, resident pianist of Ensemble 360, is beginning a new series of recitals focused on music written in and around Vienna, rounding things off with what is clearly one of Tim’s party pieces – Beethoven’s ‘Appassionata’ Sonata. It’s this last work that is the focus of today’s exploration. Beethoven has appeared on this list 13 times already, and two of those occasions have featured his piano sonatas: the whole of the so-called ‘Moonlight’ Sonata on Day 376, and the astonishing final movement of Beethoven’s last sonata, the Op 111, back on Day 40. If you’ve read even a fraction of the notes I’ve written on Beethoven before now, you’ll be aware of the conventional division of his output into ‘early’, ‘middle’ and ‘late’ works. Thus, the ‘Moonlight’ Sonata is from the end of Beethoven’s ‘early’ period, and the Op 111 sonata is very definitely late Beethoven. And conveniently the work Tim Horton is playing tonight, the Sonata in F Minor, Op 57, which acquired the nickname ‘Appassionata’ quite a bit after Beethoven’s death, is a definitive representative of Beethoven’s ‘middle’ period. Broadly, middle period Beethoven is usually defined as stretching from 1802-12, and if there’s a conventional adjective applied to the works of this decade, the one you tend to meet most often is ‘heroic’. Stereotypes almost always have a grain of truth behind them, and in Beethoven’s case the stereotype is that he took the conventions of ‘classical’ music (which reached their apogee in the works of Haydn and Mozart) and almost single-handedly shook them to the foundations, building something bigger, wilder, more expressive (in a word, more ‘Romantic’) in their stead. Now that’s obviously an over-simplification: not everything that Beethoven wrote is either emotionally turbulent or on a massive scale during these years, and nor was Beethoven the only one sensing a change in the musical environment in the years following the French Revolution and the ongoing Napoleonic wars. But it is the case that in pretty much all genres Beethoven’s music in these years contains a work or works that are, indeed, revolutionary. Take the symphony, for example: the decade 1802-12 encompasses the epic scale of the ‘Eroica’ Symphony, the rhythmic intensity of the Symphony No 5 and the image-painting vividness of the ‘Pastoral’ Symphony. Or the string quartet, where the three so-called ‘Razumovsky’ Quartets Op 59 are bigger, reaching a wider range of emotional extremes, than any quartets written before this time. In the realm of the piano concerto, you’ll find the expressive intensity of the Piano Concerto No 4 and the heroic sweep of the Piano Concerto No 5, the so-called ‘Emperor’ concerto. And, to bring us back to today’s work, the same sense of framework-bursting power can be seen in the field of the piano sonata. Beethoven had written 20 published sonatas up to and including 1802, but in the following three years there appeared two works that shifted the dial, if you like, in terms of what the piano sonata was capable of expressing. There’s the Piano Sonata Op 53 (the ‘Waldstein’) of 1804 and then, the following year, the ‘Appassionata’ Sonata, Op 57. Although it only got its nickname from a publisher as late as 1838, the label is actually pretty apt. The word (‘passionate’ in Italian) perfectly describes its tempestuous and violent nature. Beethoven wouldn’t write a sonata as wildly turbulent as this again until we get to the late period ‘Hammerklavier’ Sonata from 1818. On the surface, there are features that make it seem at least superficially conventional: it’s in the usual three movements, with a fast-slow-fast pattern. You could even argue that it’s not all that startling in terms of its harmonic patterns – the two outer movements in the ‘home’ key of F Minor, the gentle middle one in the related key of Db Major. But the revolution – and I don’t think that’s too strong a word – consists in its sonic violence (and the dynamic contrasts between hushed tension and ear-shattering aggression), and the way in which that plays out, particularly in the last movement, with a relentlessness that must have wrought havoc with the less robust pianos of Beethoven’s day. It starts with an ominous hush, up and down a chord of F Minor, before a nagging four-note rhythm (a close friend here of the 5th Symphony, not to mention the 4th Piano Concerto – it must have been an obsession of Beethoven’s at the time) and then a sudden explosion of violence that rips any sense of order to shreds. And that’s just the introduction. The rest of the first movement is probably most noteworthy for its dramatic contrasts, sudden shifts from pianissimo to fortissimo, before the movement ends ‘pianississimo’ – really, really quiet! The slow movement gives us a little breathing space, a set of variations that seems to proceed in a quite orderly manner, until the end, when (you’ll spot it easily enough) the movement breaks off on a fortissimo diminished seventh chord. Don’t worry if that means nothing – you’ll recognise its expressive impact readily enough. And that sets up the finale: relentless, whirling, virtuosic, a cascade of notes seemingly unable to be played faster or with more urgency, until we reach the coda, where the pace ratchets up again before the work ends in the depths. We often associate Beethoven’s pieces with a journey from darkness to light. Not here: this is a genuinely tragic (but maybe defiantly tragic?) ending. The musical world had heard nothing remotely like it. As for a performance, YouTube is actually quite well stocked with video recordings, and though some of them seem to me to be too ‘safe’ (not just a matter of tempo) and others too fast to avoid being just a blur of notes, you’ll no doubt be able to find one that suits you better if you don’t take to my choice. One of my favourite Beethoven interpreters is Murray Perahia, and this is his take on the Piano Sonata in F Minor, Op 57: Beethoven: Piano Sonata in F Minor, Op 57 ('Appassionata')
Day 523: Piano Concerto No 5 (Time: 40 minutes)
There’s been an unsurprisingly large quantity of Beethoven’s work on this list, today (3/1/25) being the fifteenth time he’s featured. However, though there have been a couple of symphonies and a large amount of chamber music, I’ve never actually previously featured a piano concerto by Beethoven, so now we can plug that particular gap. Beethoven was, as you may know, a phenomenal pianist. His early reputation in Bonn and after he moved to Vienna was primarily as a performer, often in those sorts of ‘duels’ between virtuosi keyboard players that remained in fashion for an alarmingly long time through the 19th century. He almost always came out on top. Many of his early works featured the piano, usually written for his own performance. As early as his 14th year, in 1784, Beethoven attempted a piano concerto. This is the so-called ‘Piano Concerto No 0’. Only the solo part has survived, and if you find recordings of it (Howard Shelley and Ronald Brautigam have made ones) the orchestral parts have been created rather speculatively from cues in the piano score. However, what this shows is that even as a teenager Beethoven was looking to create larger-scale works featuring his instrument. However, he didn’t make another attempt for at least 15 years, about a decade after he moved from Bonn to Vienna. Why he waited so long isn’t obvious, but presumably lack of opportunity to perform with an orchestra must be a large part of it: almost everything that predates his next attempt at a concerto is for solo piano or chamber forces – music that was a whole lot easier to put before the public. Still, by 1801 he had published two ‘official’ piano concertos – though oddly ‘No 2’ was written before ‘No 1’; it’s just that the Piano Concerto No 1 was published slightly earlier in 1801. They stretch the boundaries of the concerto form as it had existed up to that time (in essence, the sorts of concertos Mozart had written 10-15 years earlier) without doing anything too radical to them. This is, if you were to see them existing within the three basic ‘early’, ‘middle’ and ‘late’ phases of Beethoven’s output, very definitely ‘early Beethoven’. You could say that they’re a bit like his first two symphonies, which are similarly disruptive but not revolutionary in musical terms. However, if we buy into the theory that by 1802 or so, we start to see ‘middle period’ Beethoven emerging, then the 3rd Piano Concerto (in Beethoven’s favourite ‘gruff’ C Minor) of 1803/4 really is starting to emerge from Mozart’s shadow in concerto terms – even if there’s a great deal of similarity between Beethoven’s work and Mozart’s own C Minor concerto, No 24. Between the 3rd and 4th Piano Concertos, there’s a little diversion – he published the not often performed ‘Triple Concerto’ (solo parts for piano, violin and cello) in 1807, but then in 1808, we get the really radical Piano Concerto No 4, which breaks so many of the ‘rules’ for how piano concertos were supposed to behave, and which was premiered at that famous four-hour concert in 1808 that also saw the first performances of the 5th and 6th Symphonies. It’s my favourite among the concertos, and I’d hope to have the chance to explore it in a posting one day, but (to get to the point, at last!) it was followed by just one more piano concerto before Beethoven (presumably mostly because his deafness made performing in public with others too difficult) gave up the concerto form altogether. And so we arrive at the Piano Concerto No 5 in Eb, with its wholly dubious nickname ‘The Emperor’. It was the first of Beethoven’s concertos not to feature himself as soloist. Why ‘Emperor’? Well, definitely not because Beethoven had any love for Napoleon (that phase was over by 1804 when Beethoven scrawled out the dedication to Napoleon of his 3rd Symphony), and there are probably apocryphal stories of French troops in Vienna celebrating its first performance by calling out ‘C’est l’Empereur!’ or some such. There’s perhaps more plausible ground for seeing it as a ‘selling point’ of the composer/publisher Cramer, who published the score in London with that title attached. What’s undeniable is that it’s a work on a large scale – by some distance the longest piano concerto to that date – and ‘heroic’ in idiom and gesture too. It has a definite ‘military’ feel, maybe unsurprisingly in that Beethoven wrote it while Vienna was under siege by Napoleon’s troops. The concerto goes a long way towards establishing the sort of convention that continued for more than the next century which sees concertos as a ‘struggle’ between soloist and orchestra, a conflict that the soloist usually wins. The first movement is Beethoven’s longest to that date in the concerto form, and opens with a powerful demonstration of the pianist’s power in the work’s first few bars. (Conventionally the soloist sits quietly while the orchestra lays out the musical material.) However, if the first movement feels very ‘public’ and outward-facing, the slow movement is a lovely, intimate song-like piece. Echoes of it resonate down the decades since – it’s hard to listen to the slow movement of Shostakovich’s Piano Concerto No 2, or ‘There’s a place for us’ from Bernstein’s ‘West Side Story’ without feeling like there would be grounds for copyright infringement were Beethoven’s piece not about 150 years old at the time. And finally (and joined to the slow movement without a break, another Beethoven novelty) the pounding and athletic finale ends the work triumphantly. It’s been in the repertoire of every major pianist for the past 200 years, and shows no signs of falling out of fashion. As for a performance, YouTube has many to pick from, but I thought it would be interesting to watch this one, in which Daniel Barenboim (a devotee of Beethoven’s work as pianist and conductor) combines both roles with the Berlin Staatskapelle, the orchestra of which he was principal conductor for over 30 years, until he resigned due to ill-health in 2023. You’ll find the performance, which dates from 2007, here: Beethoven: Piano Concerto No 5
Day 532: Symphony No 6 (Time: 42 minutes)
My choice for today (4/4/25) is a work on the programme of the first visiting orchestra from Turkey to play in Sheffield, the Borusan Istanbul Philharmonic Orchestra, who will be at the City Hall later this month: Beethoven’s Symphony No 6, universally known as the ‘Pastoral’. There’s been a lot of Beethoven on this list so far – something for which I make no apology – including the iconoclastic 7th and 8th Symphonies. With the 6th Symphony, though, we have another example of Beethoven breaking musical ‘rules’ – though not quite in the ways we might expect from him. The stereotypical image of Beethoven (as man and musician) is the ‘heroic’ figure, overturning the safe pieties of ‘classical’ period music via an almost single-handed assault on its conventions. Indeed, it’s a cliché that many of the notes about Beethoven on this playlist buy into. And you only need listen to, say, the 3rd or 5th Symphonies to hear that dynamism in action. However, with the 6th, the rules that are being broken are rather different. If you’ll permit the somewhat noddy over-simplification, prime ‘Classical’ era symphonic music (the work of Haydn and Mozart particularly) is ‘pure’, abstract, music that may move the heart as well as satisfy the head, but via complexities of symphonic structures that had evolved over the course of the mid-late 18th century. (Haydn, in his own way a rule-breaker too, had in fact written symphonies that depicted ‘extra-musical’ things – times of the day in Symphonies Nos 6-8, or the fashionable ‘military’ music in Symphony No 100 – but always contained within a formal structure that accepted the tenets of symphonic pattern, something that Haydn himself codified, if not invented.) In contrast, if we look at ‘Romanticism’ in music, it tends to be associated with extra-musical things (depictions of events, or locations, or people, or aspects of the natural world). In this way, it’s easy to see Beethoven himself as the trail-blazer, the transitional figure turning classical order into romantic subversion. And in this context, the Symphony No 6 is as revolutionary as its immediate predecessor – just in a less violent way! It’s in five movements rather than the conventional four (OK, Haydn wrote a symphony in six movements – No 60 – but that was an adaptation of some of his theatre music). More unusually still, the symphony is explicit in its ‘scene painting’. Beethoven gave the movements titles (‘Awakening of cheerful feelings on arrival in the countryside’; ‘Scene by the brook’; ‘Merry gathering of country folk’; ‘Thunder, storm’; ‘Shepherd’s song: cheerful and thankful feelings after the storm’) and some of the sounds he conjures feel very literal indeed – the nightingale, quail and cuckoo that appear at the end of the second movement, the parody of the rural village band – where the bassoon player can only play three notes – in the third movement, and of course the storm, illustrated from early raindrops to lashing downpours and ear-splitting thunder, in the fourth movement. It’s tempting to say that nothing like it had been heard in music before … except that it had, sort of. You may, but probably will not, be familiar with the music of Justin Heinrich Knecht, who in 1783 (so, 25 years before the ‘Pastoral’ had its first performance at that mad four-hour concert in December 1808 when a freezing audience heard the premieres of the 5th and 6th Symphonies, as well as the 4th Piano Concerto, big chunks of the C Major Mass and that hybrid of a piano concerto and a dry run for the choral finale of the 9th Symphony, the Choral Fantasia) wrote his Grande Symphonie: Le Portrait Musical de la Nature, a piece in, surprise surprise, five movements, evoking pastoral sentiments and the disruption and peaceful recovery from a storm. Did Beethoven know the work? Almost certainly – he had musical theory texts by Knecht in his possession. Did it shape his own ‘Pastoral’ symphony? Probably… but only in outline. There’s nothing in Knecht’s work to match the range of emotion or the ferocity of description that you get in Beethoven’s 6th. The last word should go to Beethoven: writing to his friend Therese Malfatti (the probable dedicatee of the famous little piece ‘Für Elise’), he noted: ‘Anyone who has an idea of country life can make out for himself the intentions of the author without a lot of titles’, and, as someone who cherished his daily walks and annual holidays in the countryside around Vienna, ‘How happy I am to be able to wander among the bushes and grass, under trees and over rocks; no man can love the country as I love it.’ And maybe it’s this aspect of the ‘Pastoral’ – nature as restorer of equilibrium to the troubled soul – that means the most to us these days. There are plenty of performances of this symphony on YouTube. Many of them exceed this list’s self-imposed ’40 minute rule’, some of the more sluggish by quite a large margin. Clearly, how long the symphony lasts is in part down to decisions like whether a conductor plays all the potential repeats, especially in the first movement, but for me, you can get a performance around 40 minutes that doesn’t feel rushed if you dig around a little. The recording I’ve chosen, by the Deutschekammerphilharmonie, Bremen, directed by Paavo Jarvi, seems to me to be alive to the music’s moods. See what you think: Beethoven: Symphony No 6
Bell, William Henry (1873-1946)
Day 404: Viola Concerto ('Rosa Mystica') (Time: 30 minutes)
Today (18/8/23), my posting is another anniversary marker, so let’s hear it for the exceptionally obscure William Henry Bell (1873-1946), the 150th anniversary of whose birth falls this coming Sunday, 20th August. It’s unlikely that any of you will have heard any of his music, except for the occasional anthem that might have turned up in an Anglican service on very rare occasions. He is one of those composers whose work has been blindsided by changing musical fashions and some accidents of geography. He’s a product of the ‘golden generation’ of English composers (the likes of Vaughan Williams, Howells, Ireland, Delius, Moeran, Finzi, Bax, Coleridge Taylor, Gurney, Clarke, Smyth and so on) who often studied with Stanford or Parry and flourished in the generation after Elgar was in his prime. (There is an alternative view of many of these people that would lump them together as part of the ‘cowpat’ school of English pastoral composers, but I wouldn’t give house room to such views!) Anyway, Bell also was a student of Stanford, though most of his musical study was actually at the Royal Academy of Music, where Bell subsequently was employed as Professor of Harmony from 1909-12. The significant event in Bell’s professional life was his decision to emigrate to South Africa in 1912 to take up the role of director of the South African College of Music in Cape Town, where he remained as Principal until 1935. For most of that time he was also Professor of Music at the University of Cape Town. (There is a W H Bell Music Library at the University of Cape Town that commemorates his role there.) Apart from the occasional family visit, he never returned to the UK, dying just outside Cape Town in 1946. Now, even by the standards of this playlist, Bell is a decidedly obscure composer. As I mentioned, some of you may know him as the composer of the hymn tune ‘Cathcart’, to which the words of the hymn ‘Fling out the Banner!’ are sometimes sung. Apparently, there are at least a couple of other hymns, ‘Hail, Harbinger of Morn’ and the Easter anthem ‘I Will Magnify Thee, O Lord’, that Bell wrote the music for. However, he wrote a considerable amount of music for orchestra, for chamber music ensembles, for piano and for the voice, most of which is almost completely neglected these days. Probably the decision to move to South Africa is significant here, in that before that date Bell’s music had a substantial public profile in the UK, several works receiving performances at the Proms in the years before the First World War. Although he continued to compose throughout the rest of his life, performances of his music in England effectively dried up from roughly 1920 onwards. He is the composer of five numbered symphonies, ten symphonic poems (or other similarly titled works), five operas, three ballet scores, a quantity of chamber music (including two string quartets, a piano quintet, at least three violin sonatas and a cello sonata), a great deal of choral music, both sacred and secular, and at least a dozen song cycles. And, since you may be wondering where this is leading in terms of choices for the playlist, he wrote one concerto, the Concerto for Viola and Orchestra (subtitled ‘Rosa Mystica’). This dates from 1916, and is thus a ‘wartime’ work, though (and Bell was by no means alone here among composers writing in those years) you’d be pushed to hear any of that social and military cataclysm in the music itself. The ‘Rosa Mystica’ title may be explained by the fact that Bell quotes two verses from the Medieval carol ‘The Flower of Jesse’ at the head of the score, and which emerges musically as a tender theme (presumably depicting the Virgin Mary) that occurs several times in the first movement, and again towards the end of the concerto. There is also a quotation from Palestrina’s motet ‘Assumpta est Maria’ in the first movement. Probably the most turbulent music is found in the first of the concerto’s three movements, driven by an initial horn theme, and in which music connoting fear and drama is juxtaposed with something more sweetly pastoral. The second movement Adagio is tender, indeed passionate, and it seems that it might have been the depiction of a lost love affair. The final movement is essentially peaceful (though again with turbulent episodes) fading in intensity as it reaches its close. Some pieces of music are so obscure that YouTube is stocked with only a single recording of the work. That’s the case here. I know there was a commercial CD of Bell’s Viola Concerto on the Dutton Epoch label (paired with – to my ears – the even more impressive Viola Concerto by Stanley Bate, who is probably equally obscure) but it’s been deleted from the catalogue for several years. The recording you’ve got here was, I think, broadcast on Radio 3, in a performance by the BBC Concert Orchestra conducted by Stephen Bell, with Roger Chase on viola. You’ll find it here: Bell: Viola Concerto ('Rosa Mystica')
Bellini, Vincenzo (1801-35)
Day 406: 'Mira O Norma' (from 'Norma') (Time: 4 minutes) and 'Son geloso del zefiro errante' (from 'La Sonnambula') (7 minutes)
Today (25/8/23), my posting is devoted to the selection of a couple of short
‘bel canto’ extracts chosen by Jenny, who wants to redress the (im)balance
on this list when it comes to opera. I’ve owned up before
to not finding most opera to be my cup of cocoa (honourable exceptions for the
major Mozart operas, plus a handful of others – ‘Fidelio’, ‘Der Rosenkavalier’,
‘Peter Grimes’, ‘Dialogues des Carmélites’), and my CD shelves register a
complete blank when it comes to Italian opera of any era. However, it’s
more than likely that the rest of you out there on this list are more of
Jenny’s persuasion than mine, so this is for all of the opera-starved among you.
Unsurprisingly then, this is the first appearance of Vincenzo Bellini
(1801-35) on this list. For me, two things stand out when it comes to his
contribution to musical history. One is that, here again, we’re looking at
a composer who died young, and thus who knows where his art may have taken him
had he lived beyond the age of 34? The second is that into those brief
years – and, in reality, into just the last ten years of his life – he crammed
the creation of ten operas, including four that have maintained their place on
the stage since they first appeared: ‘I Capuleti e I Montecchi’, ‘La
Sonnambula’, ‘Norma’ and ‘I Puritani’. In fact, Bellini wrote almost
nothing else except opera. There is a handful of songs, plus some short
apprentice orchestral works (an occasionally still played Oboe Concerto and
some ‘symphonies’ that are in practice more like opera overtures) and – a
little more substantially – apparently at least 40 sacred works, including five
settings of the Mass. However, it’s really in the field of opera that
Bellini stands out. He was approximately contemporary with Rossini and Donizetti
(though nowhere near as long-lived as the former), and these three dominate
Italian opera of the first half of the 19th century.
Bellini’s contribution is essentially the stuff of melodrama and tragedy –
exaggerated characterisation, sensationalised plots and a highly-developed
sense of stage drama.
Jenny suggests that we listen to two examples of his work,
and I’m going to hand over to her entirely at this point, given that
she’s been kind enough to write her own programme notes!
First, she writes, ‘I would suggest from ‘Norma’ the duet, ‘Mira O Norma’.
Norma (druid high priestess, in love with occupying Roman, Pollione, and mother of
his children) has found out he has been seeing Adalgisa (another druid
priestess). In despair, Norma wants to send Adalgisa and the children away with
him and kill herself. However, Adalgisa begs her to think of the children and
(in this duet and what follows) asks Norma to let her go and persuade Pollione
to return to her (Norma, that is). Not only is it a very beautiful piece of music,
but also a rare moment of female solidarity: as you might expect from pieces
written a while ago, most operas are not particularly enlightened in how their
female characters are treated - even if they do get lots of the good singing.
I picked this recording because (a) it's quite short and (b) I really like Joan Sutherland.’
To that, I’d merely add that the YouTube video Jenny has chosen is not from the
opera house but the television studio – it’s Joan Sutherland and Marilyn Horne
singing this duet on what I guess these days we’d call a ‘variety show’:
The Ed Sullivan Show, which ran in the USA from 1948-71.
It seems rather extraordinary to me that one might encounter singing like this
in such a context. You’ll find the extract here: Bellini: 'Mira O Norma' (from 'Norma').
The second Bellini extract, writes Jenny, ‘is from ‘La Sonnambula’
which I only bought because it was what was on to watch around my
wedding anniversary, but have very much grown to like as it is also full of
beautiful singing (bel canto after all…). This is basically a ‘make up’
duet between Amina (pure, beautiful, idealised woman who pretty much only sings
about how happy she is that she’s getting married tomorrow and how much she
loves Elvino - see comment above re: female characterisation) and Elvino who is
jealous because another guy looked at her in the previous scene (this Elvino
will subsequently ditch Amina and hook up with his ex within minutes because
Amina sleepwalks into someone else’s bedroom…but there you go). Luckily all
ends happily (if you think marrying someone who trusts you that much counts as
happily…) This is a nice recording because it’s actually of the opera in
performance - which always makes it come alive in a different way - so you can
see it sung and acted.’ In this extract, Juan Diego Flores plays the role
of Elvino, and Amina is played by Natalie Dessay. You’ll find their duet,
though sadly the video quality is less than perfect, here: Bellini:
'Son geloso del zefiro errante' (from 'La Sonnambula')
Benda, Jirí Antonín (1722-95)
Day 304: Harpsichord Concerto in G Minor (Time: 21 minutes)
In my posting for today (1/7/22), I want to remember yet another obscure composer, and this time it’s someone whose 300th birthday fell (almost certainly unremarked) yesterday. His name (and you may recall the same issue in my previous posting) is either Jiří Antonín Benda or Georg Anton Benda, depending on whether you’re considering his Czech birth name or the Germanic form of address he adopted during the pursuit of his career. His dates (1722-95) make him ten years or so older than Haydn, and in his work you can hear music in transition, from the baroque style (typified in the music of Bach, Handel and Vivaldi, say) to the classical (Haydn, Mozart and early Beethoven). There’s clearly some logic to this; after all, it’s not as though composers woke up one morning and thought ‘Ah, the baroque. That’s so outmoded these days. I ought to be writing in the classical style. That’ll sell better.’ Labels are things we impose after the event, when we can see (hear!) how stylistic conventions developed. And so Benda is representative of music on the cusp – to our ears today, maybe, neither entirely this nor that (though for my money he’s much closer to what will become the classical idiom than he is to what was the baroque) … but not for that reason unworthy of our attention. There are in fact an awful lot of musical Bendas around, not just in the 18th century, but still today. However, there is an 18th century dynasty of Bendas prolific enough to rival the Bachs. So (using Czech spellings) the father of them all is Jan Jiří Benda, whose sons (all composers) were Franz Benda, Jan Jiří Benda (the 2nd!), today’s subject Jiří Antonín Benda, Josef Benda … and there was a daughter, Anna Franziska Benda, who was a famous soprano. The next generations down included at least ten other grandchildren or great-grandchildren of the original Jan Jiří Benda who were professional musicians and composers. And that’s before you extend the family tree sideways to the many composing cousins and so on: a prolific lot! Of Jiří Antonín not a very great deal is known, but we know that his older brother Franz worked first at the court in Dresden and then got his big career break by being employed by the Crown Prince Frederick of Prussia, who would go on to be Frederick II of Prussia (‘the Great’). Jiří Antonín followed in his metaphorical (and probably almost literal) footsteps, being appointed to Frederick the Great’s court orchestra at the age of 19. However, unlike his brother, he did not serve long at the Prussian court, spending 30 years from 1749 onwards at the court of the Duke of Gotha, before being sufficiently financially secure to spend his last 15 years in retirement. Benda’s main musical interest was in opera and musical melodrama: Mozart himself wrote to his father that ‘Benda has always been my favourite amongst Lutheran Kapellmeisters’, and claimed to carry the scores of two of Benda’s melodramas around with him at all times, which must have been inconvenient every now and then. Sadly, almost all Benda’s music has disappeared without trace in performance these days, even though his other works include several concertos and around 30 symphonies. Probably his most famous works (and ‘famous’ is, necessarily, a relative term) are his harpsichord concertos, and out of them I’ve chosen this one, in G Minor, to give you an aural glimpse of this particular niche musical world. It’s in the familiar three movements, in a fast – slow – fast arrangement. The harpsichord is backed by a small string ensemble. As for a performance, once more we’re in audio-only territory. In this recording the harpsichordist is Zuzana Růžičková, with the Talich Chamber Orchestra conducted by Jan Talich. You’ll find it here: Jiří Antonín Benda: Harpsichord Concerto in G Minor
Bennett, Richard Rodney (1936-2012)
Day 71: Partita for Orchestra (Time: 18 minutes)
Today (1/6/20), we have another suggestion from Malcolm, this time for a piece of orchestral music by Richard Rodney Bennett (1936-2012). (He appears to have kept both forenames in his performing life, after discovering that there was already a ‘Richard Bennett’ who was active in 20th century music before him.) Bennett was one of the most versatile composers and performers of the second half of the twentieth century, being active in a wide variety of fields. There is a quotation of his that I think sums him up: he described the fact that he wrote so much music in so many different styles as being as though the composing went on ‘in different rooms, albeit in the same house’. He was an exceptional jazz pianist, accompanist and arranger. He made albums with a range of (usually female) jazz singers, notably Claire Martin and Marion Montgomery. Meanwhile, he was a prolific film and television composer (you may have memorable themes from ‘Nicholas and Alexandra’, ‘Murder on the Orient Express’ and ‘Four Weddings and a Funeral’ nagging away at the back of your brain). Finally, and not remotely negligibly, there is the music Bennett wrote for the concert hall and the opera house. His compositional life started in what we might now see as rather aggressive 1950s/60s modernism, Bennett having spent some time studying with Pierre Boulez in Paris at the end of the 1950s. However, his later works became rather more tonal, though still with their spiky and subversive edge. Malcolm has suggested that we listen to Bennett's Partita for Orchestra, a three-movement work of breezy good cheer and the occasional shadow playing across its landscape. For me, its attraction lies in the long, unravelling melodies, particularly of the middle movement ‘Lullaby’. The performance Malcolm has chosen is by the BBC Concert Orchestra, conducted by that great champion of Bennett's music John Wilson, and you’ll find it here: Richard Rodney Bennett – Partita for Orchestra
Berio, Luciano (1925-2003)
Day 320: Folk Songs (Time: 23 minutes)
Today (26/8/22), in a suggestion from the invisible Pete Dutton, we have one of the most popular works by the 20th century composer Luciano Berio. And, for those who associate Berio with scarily indigestible atonal music of the post-Second World War period, don’t be intimidated by today’s choice. It has its abrasive moments, but the arrangements are never less than fascinating. Luciano Berio (1925-2003) is a new name on this playlist. Born in Italy, he was (and Wikipedia is so helpful with these snippets of information!) conscripted into the Italian army during the Second World War but injured his hand on his first day in uniform, which might make one think it was an ‘accident’ in name only, were it not for the fact that it seems to have put paid to what might have been a very promising career as a pianist. After the war, he studied at the Conservatory in Milan, but then followed the sort of route that brought him into contact with card-carrying modernist composers of the 1950s and 60s: studying in America with Dallapiccola, and then at the hub of European musical iconoclasm in Darmstadt, where he interacted with the likes of Boulez, Ligeti and Stockhausen, and then to Milan to follow up his burgeoning interest in electronic music with Maderna and Cage. So far, so scary – at least for those who regard music as something that should have a tune and be in something at least vaguely recognisable as a key. He remained at what one might regard as the cutting edge of musical experimentation for the rest of his life. His music, however, is interestingly diverse. Yes, there are plenty of pieces which are a daunting listen, constantly pushing at the boundaries of what instruments (and their players!) are capable of producing, most notably in a series of fourteen works for various solo instruments, called ‘Sequenze’, produced over more than 40 years right up to the end of his life. But there are other strands to Berio’s music. Despite his uncompromisingly forward-looking music, he was also fascinated by music of the past, and he made a number of arrangements and reworkings of the compositions of earlier composers. For instance, there are arrangements of music by Monteverdi and Purcell; he manipulated the unfinished fragments of Schubert’s 10th Symphony into a rather haunting piece called ‘Rendering’; there’s an orchestration of Brahms’ Clarinet Sonata Op 120 No 1 for clarinet and orchestra, in effect a clarinet concerto. Perhaps his most regularly-performed work in the concert hall is his thrilling orchestration of a movement from a string quintet by Boccherini, a piece of ‘programme music’ describing the marching around the city of Madrid by the local militia doing their night watch; in Berio’s hands the vivid depiction of the crescendo/decrescendo of the marching militia band getting closer and then moving away again in his ‘Ritirata notturna di Madrid’ is quite riveting. Then there’s today’s work. In 1950, he married the American/Armenian mezzo-soprano Cathy Berberian, and from the beginning of their relationship (and indeed for a couple of decades after their divorce in 1964, right up to Berberian’s death in the 1980s) he wrote many works with her very idiosyncratic voice in mind. His ‘Folk Songs’ of 1964 is one such work. It started life as a piece for voice and seven other performers: flute/piccolo, clarinet, harp, viola, cello and two percussionists; Berio rearranged it for a full orchestra a decade later, but the chamber version is, in my view, considerably more vivid. It’s a set of 11 songs, collected from the USA, Armenia, France, Italy, Sardinia and Azerbaijan. All the songs have original ‘folk’ words. Some of the songs also retain the melody from their original sources, but some of them take their melodies from elsewhere. The first two songs, ‘Black is the Colour’ and ‘I Wonder as I Wander’, use melodies from the American folk singer John Jacob Niles; the sixth and seventh songs, ‘La Donna Ideale’ and ‘Ballo’, have original melodies by Berio himself. Interestingly, the ninth and tenth songs, ‘Malurous qu'o uno fenno’ and ‘Lo Fiolairé’, were also set by Canteloube and feature in his ‘Songs of the Auvergne’ – not surprisingly they sound very different in Berio’s hands! The final song in the collection, ‘Azerbaijan Love Song’ provides a rousing and vivid conclusion. The original was found by Berberian on an old Soviet ‘78’ RPM record, and she sang the words by learning them by rote without having any idea what the original Azerbaijani text meant! YouTube has quite a lot of performances of this piece in its archives. There’s a video of a Spanish TV performance by Berberian, with Berio conducting, which I’d suggest because of its ‘authenticity’, but the sound quality is pretty dreadful. There’s a very interesting performance with a male singer (the first time I’ve ever come across this). However, I thought a video recording for female voice and chamber ensemble might give the best impression of this fascinating work. There are quite a lot to choose from, but even though you don’t get the rather abrasive, almost ‘untrained voice’ quality you get from Berberian’s performance, I think the recording by the Norwegian soprano Stina Steingrim Levvel, with members of the Oslo Philharmonic, will give you a reasonable demonstration of this work’s qualities. You’ll find it here: Berio: Folk Songs
Day 561: Rendering (Time: 35 minutes)
Today (24/10/25), an introduction to a work by one of the 20th century’s most compellingly ‘modernist’ composers, Luciano Berio. The reason he’s on my list now is that he was born exactly 100 years ago this very day. We’ve had one appearance by Berio on this list already – see Day 320 when I examined and directed us all to a performance of his ‘Folk Songs’ for soprano and chamber orchestra. Now, I’ve tended to be somewhat cautiousin my selections of music for us to listen to (partly because I’m concerned for your delicate sensibilities, and partly because I find some of the ultra-modernist stuff from the mid/later 20th century entirely indigestible), so please be reassured that today’s music is not about to assault your eardrums in ways that might put you off your next meal. For biographical details about Berio, I would refer you back to what I wrote on Day 320. Today, I simply want to write about one work in particular, that had its gestation in the years after 1978, and which had its first performance in 1990, the year after it was completed. The work in question is called ‘Rendering’, and it takes as its starting point sketches for a notional Symphony in D that Schubert left incomplete at his death in 1828. Back on Day 320, I highlighted Berio’s fascination, for all his avant-garde tendencies, with the music of the past, so in some ways it was no surprise that working with raw materials sourced from Schubert’s manuscripts should appeal so much to him. But before considering the work, a thought or two about the word ‘rendering’, and its meanings. It has a variety of contemporary meanings, but the two principal ones are directly relevant to this music, and what Berio was up to when he put it together. One meaning is roughly equivalent to the idea of ‘performance’, in the sense that we might talk about a particular performer and her/his ‘rendering’ of a written text or a score. But then there’s another common meaning, broadly ‘the action of applying plaster to a wall’. This might seem to have nothing at all to do with anything quite so high-flown as 20th century art music, but you’d be surprised, dear reader, because this is exactly (well, metaphorically exactly!) what’s going on. There’s a short, rather old-fashioned introduction to the piece on YouTube (the link is here) which focuses on what Italian renovation of the Coliseum in Rome looks like – the original centuries-old structure is basically held together with plaster laid on in a contrasting colour and texture. The whole is less likely to fall down, but we’re in no doubt as to what is the ‘original’ Coliseum, and what isn’t. OK – what has this to do with Berio and ‘Rendering’? Well, in 1978, to mark the 150th anniversary of Schubert’s death, the City and State Library of Vienna made available to the wider world the sketches for a ‘Symphony No 10’ that Schubert was intermittently working on in the weeks before his death. Now, not finishing symphonies (in fact, not finishing lots of compositions that he started) is very much a Schubert thing. When he got ‘stuck’, his most common solution was simply to stop, set the piece aside, and start something else. Hence, there are five or six other proto-symphonies that Schubert didn’t finish, besides the ‘Unfinished’ Symphony that we all know. But the ‘10th Symphony’ is a different thing: incomplete because Schubert was on his deathbed, as it were, when he was writing it. Various ‘completions’ of the work followed, of which the most regularly performed is by the British musicologist Brian Newbould, whose ‘realisation’ fills in the ‘gaps’ in Schubert’s source material with music that is intended to sound like the sort of thing Schubert might have done had he lived. (In many ways, this is precisely what happened with Mozart’s incomplete Requiem, or Mahler’s incomplete Symphony No 10. The results sound more or less convincingly like the composer of the original raw material.) Now, what Berio does is strikingly different. He has written at length about this, so let me quote some chunks of his ‘author's note’ that accompanied the first performance: ‘I have never been attracted to those operations of philological bureaucracy which sometimes lead musicologists to pretend they are Schubert … and “complete the Symphony as Schubert himself might have done”… [instead] I set myself the target of following those modern restoration criteria that aim at reviving the old colours without however trying to disguise the damage that time has caused, often leaving inevitable empty patches in the composition.’ In particular, Berio was attracted by those passages that seemed to show Schubert creating music that looked forward to the future: ‘There are brief episodes in the musical development which seem to lean towards Mendelssohn and [my] orchestration naturally follows suit. Furthermore, the expressive climate of the second movement, an Andante, is stunning: it seems inhabited by Mahler’s spirit.’ But what to do about all the ‘gaps’? ‘In the empty spaces between one sketch and the next, I have composed a kind of connective tissue constantly different and changing, always pianissimo and “distant”, intermingled with reminiscences of late Schubert… and crossed by polyphonic textures based on fragments of the same sketches. This delicate musical cement that comments on the discontinuities and the gaps between one sketch and the other is always announced by the sound of a celesta.’ The result – Berio’s orchestration of Schubert sketches stuck together with ‘delicate musical cement’ – has become one of Berio’s most performed works, and once your ears have got used to what Berio is doing in the ‘cement’ sections, the experience is, I think, quite thrilling. The work is in three movements, an opening Allegro, the Andante that Berio felt was imbued with the spirit of Mahler, and a final Scherzo. The orchestration, apart from the use of the celesta, is pretty much what Schubert would have recognised – the same forces as for Schubert’s ‘Unfinished’. As for a performance, I really don’t think one can do better – well, one could do better in terms of sound quality, I guess – than Berio himself conducting what he called ‘this homage to Schubert’. It’s the work’s first Italian performance, and the orchestra is the Alessandro Scarlatti, Naples Orchestra of Italian Radio, recorded back in 1992. Be warned that nothing happens for almost the first minute! You’ll find the recording here: Berio: Rendering
Berlioz, Hector (1803-69)
Day 363: Le Carnaval Romain (Overture) (Time: 9 minutes)
I’ve chosen the piece for today (17/3/23) because, shockingly, we’ve reached Day 363 of this playlist without featuring a work by Berlioz, and I really ought to change that right now. (Actually, the more pedantically-minded among you might note that back on Day 115 we encountered Berlioz’s orchestration of Weber’s ‘Invitation to the Dance’ – but today will be our first piece of original Berlioz.) If one were to imagine what the archetypal ‘Romantic composer’ might be like, Hector Berlioz (1803-69) fits the bill pretty impressively. For me, the two ideas that best characterise his music (and in many ways his life) are ‘drama’ – and for that, frequently, one might substitute ‘melodrama’ – and ‘excess’. But behind all the ‘over-the-top-ness’ that one finds in many of his compositions, there’s a really fascinating and highly original composer. One of the commonplace observations about his music is that it came out of nowhere and led to nowhere – that is, he has no obvious predecessors from whom he learnt his trade, and there are no obvious successors, no ‘school of Berlioz’ running on through the 19th century. Like most clichés, there’s some truth to this, but if his music feels like the work of a ‘one off’ eccentric, it nevertheless reflects the spirit of its age, especially in its response to art, literature, politics and social upheaval. Berlioz was supposedly going to become a doctor (after his father) but though he graduated from medical school at the age of 21 he abandoned medicine as a career thereafter and pursued music obsessively – despite the fact that at the time he knew relatively little about music theory and was competent on flute and guitar but could not play the piano or any other keyboard instrument, which was the starting point for most composers over the previous couple of centuries. There are good reasons for seeing this lack of pianistic skill reflected in the music he composed, which tends not to approach ideas of harmony or melodic patterns the way others had before him, composing at the keyboard and thinking about harmony in terms of what might recognisably lie comfortably ‘under the fingers’. He seems to have been a person of, shall we say, vivid emotional responses: he became besotted with the Irish actress Harriet Smithson after seeing her as Ophelia in a performance of ‘Hamlet’, and his hallucinatory ‘Symphonie Fantastique’ dramatizes her impact on him. They eventually married, not in the end all that happily. Before that marriage he was engaged to a young woman who, while he was in Italy (having won the prestigious ‘Prix de Rome’ competition for composition) broke off the engagement in favour of someone older and wealthier; Berlioz hatched a plan to buy a pistol, travel from Rome to Paris in disguise (as a lady’s maid!), kill both his ex-fiancee and her new man, and then himself. Fortunately when he’d got as far as Nice he abandoned the plan! He acquired a reputation as a writer of massive works: his five-hour opera ‘Les Troyens’ takes two evenings to perform in full (this rarely happens); his ‘Symphonie Funebre et Triomphale’ is for a giant brass and woodwind band, strings and chorus; his ‘Grande Messe des Morts’ (‘Requiem’) asks for well over 100 string players, over 20 woodwind (including 8 bassoons), similar quantities of brass (12 horns!), a huge array of percussion (16 timps, 10 pairs of cymbals), a chorus of over 200, and, erm, four separate offstage brass ‘orchestras’. Performances with these forces are, unsurprisingly, not common. I’m aware that all these figures might lead one to think that Berlioz is just an eccentric addicted to excess, but that doesn’t take into account his startling originality as an orchestrator (Richard Strauss wrote that Berlioz ‘invented the modern orchestra’) or musical thinker. So, what might illustrate at least a little of his flair as a composer? Well, the Hallé’s concert in Sheffield this evening includes what is, after his exceptionally original ‘Symphonie Fantastique’, his most popular and well-known composition, his Overture ‘Le Carnaval Romain’. This had an odd gestation. In 1838 Berlioz’s second opera, ‘Benvenuto Cellini’, was first performed in Paris and was a dismal failure: seemingly performers couldn’t cope with its relentless rhythmic energy. However, in 1844 Berlioz extracted from the music of the opera a section that had been based largely on the exhilarating ending to Act I, which depicts a carnival in Rome. Berlioz himself had attended such an event a decade or so earlier. What we have in the ‘Roman Carnival’ Overture is a free-standing orchestral piece, a kind of small-scale symphonic poem or tone poem. It opens with a burst of flashing energy before we settle into a slow lyrical section with a prominent cor anglais part. The main ‘Allegro vivace’ section of the overture fizzes along at a great pace, and reveals all of Berlioz’s gifts for dazzling orchestration. As for a performance, YouTube has several that I could quite happily live with. Out of them, I’ve gone for one that is at least authentically French, being played by the Orchestre Philharmonique de Radio France, conducted by Myung-Whun Chung. You’ll find it here, prefaced by almost a minute’s tuning up and preamble, and followed by extensive applause: Berlioz: Le Carnaval Romain (Overture)
Bernstein, Leonard (1918-90)
Day 58: Chichester Psalms (Time: 20 minutes)
Today (19/5/20), a suggestion from Martin, which has been prompted by the Stravinsky ‘Symphony of Psalms’ that we had recently. Martin is keen that we hear the ‘Chichester Psalms’ by Leonard Bernstein (1918-90). Bernstein's influence on the development of American music in the 20th century is immense, both in terms of his own compositions across a range of genres, and also in terms of his championing of many composers in his role as pianist, conductor and music educationalist and TV presenter. (I have vivid memories still of watching a series of his Norton lectures on music, broadcast on the BBC in the mid-1970s, when I was a teenager. His skills as a communicator were exceptional.) The ‘Chichester Psalms’ were commissioned in 1965, and along with his Symphony No 3 this is probably one of Bernstein's most overtly Jewish compositions. It’s rhythmically quite spiky, and a lot of Bernstein's typical harmonic traits that you might recognise from, say, ‘West Side Story’ are present here too. Though the second movement sets Psalm 23 in a reflective mood, the dominant characteristic of the piece is its sense of vitality and energy. There are quite a lot of performances of the piece on YouTube, but I thought I’d go for one conducted by Bernstein himself, here in a live performance by the Israel Philharmonic Orchestra and the Vienna Boys’ Choir: Leonard Bernstein – ‘Chichester Psalms’
Day 315: Prelude, Fugue and Riffs (Time: 9 minutes)
Today (9/8/22) I want to look at probably the American composer of the 20th century who knew or worked with or performed the music of pretty much everybody else during that period – and that is the inescapable Leonard Bernstein. Bernstein (1918-90) was an extraordinary, larger than life figure. He was not just a composer, as I’m sure most of you know. Born Louis Bernstein (in deference to a grandmother’s wishes) but known in the family as Leonard – and he changed his name legally at 18 on his grandmother’s death – he was, for the thousands of musicians he came into contact with, and the millions around the world who encountered his concerts, broadcasts and recordings, simply ‘Lenny’. Initially, he began his career as a pianist. He studied music at Harvard and at the Curtis Institute in New York – where, incidentally, he became life-long friends with the man who is the subject of my next posting (that’s your teaser for the day!) – and began composing seriously in the early 1940s. In 1943, by then a newly-appointed associate conductor of the New York Philharmonic, he made his debut with the orchestra at short notice and without any rehearsals when the planned conductor, Bruno Walter, fell ill – and the rest, as it is conventionally said, is history. He became Music Director of the New York Phil in 1957, Conductor Laureate in 1969, and he was enduringly associated with the orchestra for the rest of his life. He was also a phenomenal communicator, probably the first classical musician to use television as a medium to reach vast audiences, particularly via the televised Young People’s Concerts, which ran from the late 1950s to the early 70s. Another strand of Bernstein’s life concerns his commitment as a social activist, in terms of his engagement in a variety of broadly left-wing causes, though interestingly he never fell foul of the House Un-American Activities Committee and its oppressive treatment of those blacklisted by McCarthyism. As a composer, Bernstein kept a very open mind about compositional technique. He’s probably best known in ‘non-classical’ circles as the composer of the musicals ‘West Side Story’, ‘On the Town’ and ‘Wonderful Town’. Those who encounter him in the opera house will have almost certainly heard his operetta-style work ‘Candide’. There are film scores, such as his work for ‘On the Waterfront’. In terms of more mainstream ‘classical’ works, there are three symphonies, which draw strongly on Bernstein’s Jewish identity, but also more ‘abstract’ works in the field of chamber music like the early Clarinet Sonata or his last completed work, the ‘Dance Suite’ for Brass Quintet. He wrote extensively for voices – perhaps most famously the ‘Chichester Psalms’ (see Day 58), and most notoriously his Mass of 1971. However, I thought that today, out of all the possible options for illustrating the endless creativity of this remarkable musician and composer – indeed, this remarkable human being, though one should be careful to avoid hagiography: it seems evident that he treated his wife, at some stages in their lives, particularly badly – the work I’d choose is his Prelude, Fugue and Riffs for Clarinet and Jazz Ensemble, written in 1949. The relationship between jazz and classical music is present, I think, in almost every American composer, and Bernstein made little attempt to disguise the impact of jazz on his own writing. The idea of ‘Preludes and Fugues’ is foundational in classical music from the late 17th century onwards, perhaps most enduringly demonstrated in Bach’s ‘Well-Tempered Clavier’ (‘the 48’). Subsequent composers might add further to this idea of a pair of movements – an improvisatory ‘prelude’ and a tautly-constructed ‘fugue’: famous examples from the 19th century might be Cesar Franck’s ‘Prelude, Chorale and Fugue’ or his ‘Prelude, Fugue and Variation’. What Bernstein does in his ‘Prelude, Fugue and Riffs’ is to take this somewhat cerebral classical form and meld it with the rougher, more improvisatory world of jazz. He wrote the work with the clarinettist Woody Herman in mind, but it was eventually dedicated to Benny Goodman (‘the King of Swing’!), who is generally identified as being the soloist in the first performance of the work. This first performance came (and how characteristic of Bernstein the iconoclast is this!) during his illustrated TV lecture ‘The World of Jazz’ in 1955, devoted to breaking down the barriers between ‘popular’ and ‘classical’ music. The Prelude is scored for five trumpets, four trombones, percussion and bass, and it sets the energetic ‘pizazz’ of the opening against the slower, slightly dragging central section. The Fugue that follows, for five saxophones, could scarcely be called ‘academic’ music, but it is nevertheless a piece of considerable technical accomplishment. Finally, we reach the Riffs, driven by a solo clarinet, underpinned by piano and then by the whole band, creating the strong impression that the music is being improvised as it goes on, though it is in fact a fully written-out score. There are a number of audio-only recordings featuring American performers, but for me the best video performance comes from the ‘Big Band’ of the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Andrés Orozco-Estrada, with Jochen Tschabrun as the clarinet soloist in the final section. You’ll find the piece here: Bernstein: Prelude, Fugue and Riffs
Bertini, Henri (1798-1876)
Day 423: Nonetto. Op 107 (1st movement) (Time: 14 minutes) and (2nd movement) (8 minutes)
Henri Jérôme Bertini (1798-1876) was born on 28th October 1798, which means that this coming Saturday will mark the 225th anniversary of that event. If Bertini is remembered at all these days, it is as a composer of piano studies. If you put his name into the search box on YouTube, what will emerge are literally hundreds of audio and video recordings of these piano studies. He wrote a ‘piano method’, ‘Le Rudiment du Pianiste’, and 20 books of studies, totalling over 500 such pieces in all. Now, it’s true that some composers wrote studies for piano that transcend their narrow focus on technique and become, as it were, ‘proper’ music, that people might actually want to pay to listen to: Chopin and Debussy are the most obvious examples, I suppose. But somewhere in that hinterland between ‘proper music’ and ‘music for students to learn techniques’, there are many other composers whose works help performers to develop their skills, but probably such performers might not programme these pieces in their recitals once they’ve left the classroom behind them, as it were. So (and this may be a disappointment to you … or not) I’m not intending to select any of Bertini’s piano exercises for your listening pleasure today (24/10/23) – though do feel free to find them for yourselves should you wish! I’m not actually sure that the epithet ‘the French Czerny’, which Bertini acquired in later life, does him any favours at all. But what I would like to try to demonstrate is that Bertini was more than a mere pedagogue. He had, I think, an evident gift for melody, and at its best his musical imagination extended well beyond the merely formulaic. Despite his name, Bertini was actually a Londoner by birth, though he only lived in Britain for about six months, before his folks returned to Paris. His route into performance was a familiar one: a child prodigy hawked around the concert halls and salons of Europe. However, he wasn’t just a kind of show pony. He was a gifted performer of chamber music, eschewing the facile flamboyance of many performers of the 1830s and 40s. One biographer recalled: ‘Living in an age of garish virtuosity, and hailed as a brilliant executant himself, he maintained nevertheless the most rigorous standards of musicianship in his playing.’ Bertini’s life story, though, appears to have been singularly devoid of incident, though marrying at the age of 16 and becoming a parent before he was 18 is a fairly unusual phenomenon, even for those days – the first of three marriages, his first two wives dying young. He also arranged, and took part in the performance of, Beethoven’s 7th Symphony for eight hands at two pianos, barely a year after Beethoven’s death. He ‘disappeared’ from the Parisian music scene in the mid-1850s, though he lived on for a couple of decades in retirement. Despite the relative uneventfulness of his existence (domestic disruptions aside) Bertini has garnered a couple of quotable quotes from other mid-19th century composers. Schumann observed, not I think uncharitably, ‘One cannot be unkind to Mr. Bertini, no matter how hard one might try: he can bring one beside oneself with his friendliness and all the fragrant Parisian formulations; his music has the feel of pure satin and silk’ – though the sting in the tail comes when Schumann continues, about the work in question: ‘all the movements, excepting at most the scherzo, could have been shortened by a half and would achieve the same effect and even much more’! However, the work I want to draw to your attention today, the Nonetto in D, Op 107, has more than simply superficial charms, I think. Nonets in classical music tend not to be scored for fixed combinations of instruments. Probably the most common scoring is for the five players of a wind quintet (flute, oboe, clarinet, bassoon, horn) plus string quartet. However, Bertini’s ‘Nonetto’ is for flute, oboe, bassoon, horn, trumpet, viola, cello, double bass and piano. It’s a substantial work, usually lasting about 35 minutes in performance, so I’m going to select just the first two movements. The opening ‘Allegro Vivace’ shows traces of Beethoven (though probably more still of Rossini) in its treatment of its themes. It’s a lively and occasionally sparkling exploration of the textures open to him given the combination of instruments at Bertini’s disposal. However, the gem of the second movement is of a higher standard altogether. Its title, ‘La Mélancolie’, perhaps suggests a sentimental piece, but Berlioz (never one to undersell anything!) wrote of this movement that it is ‘so grandiose, at times so majestically sombre, that the sentiment of melancholy one expects is overshadowed by ideas of a much higher and rare order. ...this admirable work is not only melancholic, but also much more,’ and that ‘more’ turns out to be ‘without question a noble and magnificent inspiration whose sombre poetry reminds us of the sublime greatness of Beethoven's Sonatas’. Even taking Berlioz’s tendency to gush into consideration, this remark suggests it’s a movement worthy of serious consideration. For those who might want more, the remaining two movements are a scampering light-touch Scherzo and a Finale that gives all instruments their moment in the spotlight without just being a series of ‘turns’. You may not be surprised to know that video performances of this work on YouTube are notable by their absence, so this is audio-only stuff again. The first two movements of Bertini’s Nonetto are played by the chamber group the Linos Ensemble, and you’ll find their recordings here: Bertini: Nonetto, Op 107 (1st movement) and here: Bertini: Nonetto, Op 107 (2nd movement)
Berwald, Franz (1796-1868)
Day 208: Symphony No 3 (‘Sinfonie Singulière’) (Time: 26 minutes)
225 years ago to the very day (23/7/21), Franz Berwald (1796-1868) was born in Stockholm to several generations of musicians. His life story would make a fairly melodramatic novel, a saga of occasional musical successes and mostly musical failures, not to mention a life spent doing lots of other things. Some composers have ‘another life’ because they are professionals in that field (like Borodin, a chemist) and musical composition is a strictly amateur pursuit. However, others (like Berwald) end up having ‘another life’ because music just won’t pay the bills or support the family. His early musical life was promising – playing violin concertos at the age of 11, joining the ranks of the Swedish Court Orchestra at 16 – but after several years of struggle he moved to Berlin in 1829, where (as you do) he made his living in orthopaedics and physiotherapy for the next ten years. However, in the early 1840s he returned to Stockholm, and it is these years that saw the production of the four symphonies that are probably his major musical legacy. (There is some lovely chamber music too, notably a couple of string quartets from the late 1840s.) Permanent success in music however continued to elude him – he was turned down as Director of Music at Uppsala University, and as conductor of the Swedish Court Orchestra – and consequently (again, as you do) he became the manager of a glass factory in northern Sweden, and later still the owner and manager of a saw mill. The result of all this is that Berwald's output really falls into three phases: the youthful stuff (1815-25ish), a creative ‘middle period’ (1840-50) and a handful of late works from the mid-1860s. This neglect is all the more sad if you listen to Berwald's mature music. It’s lithe, ‘transparent’ and full of vitality. The slow movements are lyrical, the faster ones full of vigour. The musicologist Robert Layton (obviously a fan) writes of Berwald: ‘It is the quality of Berwald's thematic invention, his transparent textures and expert orchestration, and the generosity of spirit that informs his musical personality, that make his music engage both our sympathies and our affection.’ Of his four symphonies, it’s the Symphony No 3 (the ‘Sinfonie Singulière’ – all four symphonies have these rather fanciful titles, though the ‘uniqueness’, the ‘singularity’ of the Third Symphony is very evident) that is the best known (and, probably, the best). You can hear bits of Schubert in it, and some startling pre-echoes of Bruckner and Sibelius, but from beginning to end it’s definitively Berwald. Astonishingly, it had to wait 60 years for its first performance, which came in 1905. It has three movements. The first is optimistic and open, the second is a lyrical adagio which encloses a more mercurial scherzo, and the finale is a whirlwind of occasionally stormy but mostly sunny energy. As you might expect, video performances of the complete work are thin on the ground, so today’s link is to an audio recording only. It’s by the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by Ulf Björlin. You’ll find it here: Berwald: Symphony No 3 ('Sinfonie Singuliere')
Biber, Heinrich (1644-1704)
Day 12: Sonata No 6 (‘Jesus at the Mount of Olives’) from 15 Mystery Sonatas for Violin and Continuo (Time: 7 minutes)
The suggestion for today (3/4/20) comes from Malcolm. It’s for the sixth of the 15 Mystery (or Rosary) Sonatas by Heinrich Ignaz Franz von Biber (1644-1704). As Malcolm notes about this piece: “The 6th of Biber's complete set of mystery sonatas for solo violin comes from a set of 15 sonatas for violin and continuo. These were commissioned as music to accompany prayers and meditations on events from the life and death and resurrection of Jesus. This is therefore appropriate music to listen to during Holy Week and Easter. One of the unusual features of the music is that it requires the violin to be tuned differently for each sonata. By retuning the violin strings, Biber made it possible for the soloist to play chords and arpeggios that are literally unplayable on a standard-tuned violin. Only the First Sonata uses standard tuning. The music is written so that the violinist reads the score as if in standard tuning, but this bears a constantly shifting relationship to the notes that sound. Very disconcerting!” You’ll find the piece, in a performance by Musica Alchemica, and the violinist Lina Tur Bonet, here: Heinrich Biber – Sonata No 6 (‘Jesus at the Mount of Olives’) from 15 ‘Mystery’ Sonatas
Bingen, Hildegard von (c1098-1179)
Day 245: Five Hymns and Sacred Songs (Time: 22 minutes)
Today (30/11/21), we go back further in time than ever before on this playlist, for the music of Abbess Hildegard von Bingen (c1098-1179). She was one of the most extraordinary women in the history of the era, a polymath – she wrote music, of course, but also about theology, medicine, science, politics, linguistics and much more – and a force of nature, impressive by the standards of any human being, but even more remarkable given the pervasive gender bias of the age. She was a visionary (that is, literally, she had visions – which we might understand these days as being divinely inspired or, more mundanely, a product of severe migraines, depending on our world view), apparently affecting her from early childhood, but not shared or made public until much later. She entered the enclosed Benedictine monastery at Disibodenberg in south-west Germany sometime between the ages of 8-14 (sources vary) but by 1136 had become a prioress, and by 1150 had, with her nuns, built a new priory at nearby Rupertsberg. From here (and later from a second monastery at Eibingen near Hesse) she expanded her influence notably through her extensive writings. A considerable amount of her work has survived, including three volumes of visionary theology, hundreds of letters, records of sermons, what might be the oldest surviving musical morality play, two volumes of scientific and medicinal writing, evidence of a completely new alphabet that she invented and used as a kind of secret code with fellow nuns, and an enormous quantity of music – ‘Ordo Virtutem’ (the musical morality play consisting of 82 songs) and another 69 pieces of music complete with her texts that were used as part of the liturgy. These pieces were collected together in a volume called ‘Symphonia Armoniae Celestium Revelationum’ (roughly ‘The Symphony of the Harmony of the Celestial Revelations’). In common with what limited evidence we have of other music from this period, Hildegard’s works are monophonic – that is, they consist of only a single musical line (no harmony, or simultaneous and different musical parts, though that convention is bent a little in the performance below), although these single lines were often underscored by a drone, vocal or instrumental. The music is, at risk of overwhelming you with too much terminology, very melismatic – that is, where a single syllable of text is ‘stretched’ across several notes of music. This choice of music has been suggested by Malcolm, who wanted us to listen to some of the Marian compositions that Hildegard produced. I’ve expanded this suggestion a little to accommodate a YouTube clip from a concert given by the American (very) early music Ensemble Vocatrix. This extract from a live performance consists of five of Hildegard’s hymns and sacred songs: ‘O Viridissima Virga’ (‘O branch of freshest green’), which images Mary as a sacred tree which brings forth holy fruit; ‘O Frondens Virga’ (‘O blooming branch’), which explores the same theme; ‘O Quam Mirabilis’ (‘O how wonderful it is’), about the wonders of creation, reaching its peak in humanity; ‘O Virga Ac Diadema’ (‘O branch and diadem’), another hymn of praise to Mary as the mother of Jesus; and finally ‘O Viriditas Digiti Dei’ (‘O green finger of God’), an ecstatic hymn to creation. You’ll find the performances here: Hildegard von Bingen: Five Hymns and Sacred Songs
Day 412: De Spiritu Sancto – sole (Time: 2 minutes) and De Spiritu Sancto – choir (4 minutes)
Abbess Hildegard von Bingen would be 925 years old tomorrow, if she were still with us. As it is, here’s a posting today (15/9/23) celebrating her and a little bit of her extraordinary music. Hildegard has appeared once before on this list, on Day 245. There’s quite a lot of biographical information about her there, so I won’t repeat it now. ‘The Sybil of the Rhine’, as she was posthumously known, was a visionary and creative force without parallel during the early 12th century, and she certainly seems not to have been the sort of person to let the fact that she was ‘only’ female get in her way. It may well be that like me your first introduction to her music was the ground-breaking CD by Gothic Voices called ‘A Feather on the Breath of God’ back in 1983. Christopher Page, who directed Gothic Voices on that disc, points out how little we know of this music, or its process of composition: ‘We don’t know if Hildegard is sitting and humming the songs, or if she’s perhaps humming and writing them down on a white tablet, with a final version then being written by someone else on slate or parchment. We don’t know if the words come first, or if the words and the music grow together in an organic development. We don’t know how much hand in it her male helpers – male secretaries and priests – had. None of that is clear.’ One consequence of this is that although there are some accepted conventions among the various performing groups that put on concerts of her music, there is nevertheless a great deal that is open to interpretation. The recordings I’ve chosen today are striking in their own ways – but may be nothing like the sort of experience one might have heard in the communities she founded in Rupertsberg and Eibingen nine centuries ago. The piece I’ve chosen is a text celebrating the Holy Spirit, written (as far as I can tell: please correct me if you know better!) by Hildegard herself. The original Latin text is as follows: ‘Spiritus sanctus vivificans, vita movens omnia, et radix est in omni creatura ac omnia de inmunditia abluit, tergens crimina ac ungit vulnera, et sic est fulgens ac laudabilis vita, suscitans et resuscitans omnia.’ For those whose Latin is a little rusty(!), an approximate translation might be: ‘The Holy Spirit is the life-giving force behind all things, and is the root of every creature, and washes away all corruption, wipes away crimes and anoints wounds, and thus is a shining and praiseworthy life, raising and resurrecting all things.’ As for performances, I have two to share to give some sense of what people do with Hildegard’s music. Firstly, here is the text as performed by the solo singer and actor Alexandra Marisa Wilcke, whose primary career seems to be ‘dubbing’ film soundtracks into German, but she clearly has a significant interest in Hildegard’s music too: her first CD was made up of this material. From a live performance, here is her version of ‘De Spiritu Sancto: Hildegard von Bingen: De Spiritu Sancto (solo). And now, by way of comparison and contrast, here is a massed female voice version of the piece, performed by the St Stanislav Girls’ Choir, from Ljubljana, Slovenia, accompanied on the hurdy-gurdy by Janez Jocif. You’ll find that version here: Hildegard von Bingen: De Spiritu Sancto (choir)
Bizet, Georges (1838-75)
Day 400: Symphony in C (Time: 32 minutes)
It seems odd not to have featured Georges Bizet (1838-75) until now, given how remarkably popular he is. Well, I suppose one could say, how remarkably popular one of his works is. He is by no means a ‘one hit wonder’ – the opera ‘The Pearl Fishers’ gets regular outings (and one duet from it gets far more than that), and the suites of incidental music for the stage play ‘L’Arlesienne’ turn up from time to time in concert performance, but in truth if it weren’t for his opera ‘Carmen’ I suspect Bizet would be little more than a footnote in the history of 19th century French music. Well, without wishing to spoil the surprise, it’s not ‘Carmen’ that you’re going to get to consider today (28/7/23). Bizet was a mere 36 years old when he died, but that life was filled with enough false starts and unfinished drafts of pieces to last, well, a lifetime. Although christened ‘Georges’ he was actually registered at birth as Alexandre César Léopold Bizet, the son of a hairdresser turned singing teacher father and a piano playing mother. The world of classical music is full of prodigies, but Bizet deserves his place in that list – he was nine when admitted to the Paris Conservatoire, where his progress was by any standards remarkable. He developed a particular friendship with Gounod, twenty years his senior, but also with his contemporary Saint-Saëns. In his teens he produced an initial flurry of compositions – of which more later – before winning the prestigious ‘Prix de Rome’ (the goal of all young French composers during the years of its existence, 1803-1968). Entirely unsurprisingly, given French musical tastes in the 19th century, his goal was to make his mark as an opera composer, but in this area, as in fact in all others, he struggled. Once the funding for the Prix de Rome ran out, he was forced to spend his time teaching piano (he was by all accounts a brilliant pianist – brilliant as in Liszt-standards of brilliance – but disliked performing in public), writing music reviews and slogging away as a music copyist reproducing the scores of far less talented contemporaries. He continued to make friendships with other musicians – he particularly adored Rossini, by then well into his retirement years in Paris – but on a professional level his life story seems to be one of perpetual missed chances. He began at least 15 operas, seven of which were left incomplete, with three others not performed during his lifetime. None of those that did make it to the stage was a major success, not even ‘Carmen’. Its first performance, in 1875, occurred just three months before Bizet’s death from a heart attack, and initial reviews were not at all kind. Bizet died believing it to be a failure – which, given its subsequent history and popularity, is all very sad. His funeral was a huge event, and his passing seen as a great loss to French music even though little of his work had thus far made a major impact. Gounod gave the funeral eulogy (the same Gounod who had fallen out with Bizet over ‘Carmen’, claiming its ‘Spanish’ qualities had been stolen from him) and on the night of the funeral a special performance of ‘Carmen’ was put on in Bizet’s memory, the press declared it a masterpiece, and the rest, as they say, is history. But even after his death Bizet’s misfortunes continued – his wife remarried, and seems to have taken little care of her first husband’s scores, giving many of them away seemingly randomly. Which is how we get to the story of the work I’ve chosen for today, Bizet’s Symphony in C. He began it four days after his 17th birthday, and completed it within a month. At that time he was studying with Gounod, and part of that study was to take apart and analyse Gounod’s Symphony No 1, which had been written the year before. Bizet produced a version of it for piano four-hands (one of the most common ways for orchestral music to find an audience in the 19th century). The consequence was that he knew the symphony inside out, and no doubt this spurred him on to try his hand at a symphony of his own. The resemblances between Gounod’s symphony and the work Bizet produced are very marked indeed – scoring and orchestration, organisation of individual movements, even the direct lifting of some themes. It has been speculated that this is why Bizet never published the work, and why it disappeared. Mme Bizet gave it some years after her husband’s death to Reynaldo Hahn (see Day 22), who in turn left it to the Paris Conservatoire archives, where it sat undisturbed until 1933, when it was discovered by a French musicologist, and passed to Bizet’s first British biographer, who subsequently handed the score to the conductor Felix Weingartner. A first ever performance followed in 1935, and it’s maintained an existence in terms of occasional performances and recordings ever since. Its resemblance to Gounod’s symphony notwithstanding, Bizet’s work is a piece of youthful brilliance – on a par, I’d say, with something like Mendelssohn’s ‘A Midsummer Night’s Dream’ Overture (see Day 203!) in terms of its freshness, vitality and all-round precocity. The work is in the traditional four movements, with the scherzo placed third. The symphony opens with an effervescent Allegro Vivo, with its dashing first theme and lyrical Mozartian second subject. The slow movement is particularly tender, with a yearning oboe solo. It’s just about possible to hear faint pre-echoes of ‘Carmen’ here, if you strain hard enough. The scherzo follows, with a trio section that employs a rustic ‘drone’ in the manner of some of Haydn’s more obviously bucolic ‘minuet and trio’ movements. The finale is a kind of ‘perpetuum mobile’ which gallops to its end with a sparkle that seems to me to retain its freshness no matter how often one hears it. A ‘rediscovered masterpiece’? I think so! As for a performance, YouTube is quite well stocked, and from the options available I’ve gone for this concert recording by the Netherlands Chamber Orchestra, led from the front desk by the violinist Gordan Nikolić. You’ll find it here: Bizet: Symphony in C
Day 540: ‘L'Arlesienne’ - Suites Nos 1 and 2 (Time: 37 minutes)
Today (30/5/25), in honour of the fact that next Tuesday it will be 150 years to the day since the death of Georges Bizet, I want to go back to this composer, who has made one appearance on this list already, and consider what (for me at least) is some of his most successful music. Back on Day 400, I added Bizet’s Symphony in C to this list – a work of Bizet’s precocious youth, and one not performed in public until about 60 years after his death. As I wrote back then, Bizet’s musical career was full of false starts, misfortunes and general lack of success. Because he was French, and because French musical tastes – and especially Parisian musical tastes – were in thrall to opera above everything else, Bizet, like his contemporaries, was desperate for a stage success. Hence the fact that even though there are unfinished (in many cases barely started) fragments of operas littering Bizet’s brief career (he died at 36) and even those operas that did reach the stage during his lifetime turned out generally to be less than successful, it never stopped Bizet from trying, and then trying again. Even ‘Carmen’ suffered that fate … at least, that was what Bizet believed at the time of his death shortly after its first performance. In fact, you have to look pretty hard amongst Bizet’s works to find any compositions that were resounding successes from the outset. However it’s not opera but incidental music that I want to home in on today. As far as I’ve been able to tell, Bizet made just one attempt at this sort of thing. The stage play in question was ‘L'Arlesienne’ (‘The Girl from Arles’), which had its first performance in 1872, three years before Bizet’s death. The play was based on a short story of the same name by the French writer Alphonse Daudet, which had appeared in the late 1860s. The story was based on a real-life event, the suicide of the nephew of the writer Frédéric Mistral after what one might call an ‘inappropriate’ love affair. In the short story (and in the play from which it was adapted) a young man from a simple rural background becomes infatuated by an older (and evidently more sexually experienced) woman from the ‘big city’ (Arles). The woman never appears in the play, but her impact on the central character, and those around him, is profound, and in the central character’s case, fatal. Bizet wrote 27 pieces of music for the staging of the play. Most of these pieces are very short – under 20 bars long – and are designed to be played, as it were, ‘behind’ the action, in the way that music for film or TV dramas is used today. However, there are also some more substantial pieces, such as the introductory prelude and several entr’actes, which covered scene changes and set the location and mood for the scene to follow. True to form for Bizet, the play did not fare well. It closed after 19 performances, Daudet complaining bitterly and with scathing irony, ‘It was clear from the beginning that a drama of passion from the Camargue would not appeal to the sophisticated tastes of the Paris boulevards.’ However, though the play disappeared from view, the music seems by and large to have been welcomed, and it was not long after this that Bizet was encouraged to fillet his incidental music for a short orchestral suite. This was first performed later that same year, and it provided Bizet with one of the relatively few unqualified successes of his life. His original plan was a suite in five movements, but he eventually selected just four pieces from his original score. First comes what was in fact the prelude to the entire stage action in the theatre, 144 bars of music that introduced three of the principal musical themes that recur elsewhere in the music for the play; the march theme that opens the work will be perhaps more famously employed later. One other interesting feature of this movement is the use Bizet makes of the saxophone, an instrument invented only a couple of decades earlier, and which had only just started to be employed as part of the orchestra’s woodwind section. The second movement is a Minuetto, a graceful dance-like interlude which marked the gap between the second and third acts in the theatre. Then comes an Adagietto, a movement that Bizet scored just for a muted string quartet in the theatre, but which in the suite is expanded for full string orchestra. Finally, we have a Carillon, easily identifiable by its relentless bell-like ostinato. This movement has a slower middle section, again featuring the sax, before the bells return and the suite ends emphatically. As I mentioned earlier, Bizet died in 1875, but after his death his music for the play was thought suitable for further public exposure. In 1879, the music publisher Antony Choudens commissioned Bizet’s friend Ernest Guiraud to put together a second suite. This sort of posthumous tinkering is not as unusual as you might think. In this case, it was well meaning, rather than simply for commercial exploitation, and one imagines Bizet would have trusted Guiraud, given that the latter was responsible, for instance, for the ‘recitative’ sections (the sort of declamatory ‘sung’ speech between arias and choruses) in ‘Carmen’. Guiraud, however, cast his net a little wider in making this second suite, and also engaged in a little re-orchestration and expansion of Bizet’s original pieces as composed for the theatre. So, the Suite No 2 (again in four movements) begins with a Pastorale – scored by Bizet for chorus but with the sung parts distributed around the orchestra by Guiraud – that originally separated the first and second acts of the play. Then comes an Intermezzo. Guiraud was evidently fond enough of this music to rework it again after the second suite had had its public outing, in that he re-scored it and added the Latin text of the Agnus Dei … and attempted to pass it off as a posthumously rediscovered ‘new’ work by Bizet! For the third movement of the second suite, Guiraud turned not to any of the music Bizet wrote for the staging of ‘L'Arlesienne’, but rather he went back to one of the orchestral interludes in Bizet’s earlier opera ‘The Fair Maid of Perth’, selecting from that work a Minuet that he re-scored for saxophone (replacing the original vocal line) alongside other woodwind instruments and strings. The final movement of the Suite No 2 is the famous Farandole, which ingeniously combines two striking melodies, the ‘March of the Kings’ theme that opened the Suite No 1 and the jig-like ‘farandole’, a popular communal dance from Provence. Thus we end up with two suites of four movements each, shorn entirely of their dramatic context but standing up (at least, that’s what I’d argue) as vivid, engaging and satisfying pieces in their own right, even if Bizet himself had nothing directly to do with the second suite. YouTube has some decent recordings of the first and second suites, though fewer of both of them being performed as a single concert item. However, there’s a lovely concert performance of both suites given by the Royal Stockholm Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by Nathalie Stutzmann. You’ll find it here: Bizet: ‘L'Arlesienne’ - Suites Nos 1&2
Bliss, Arthur (1891-1975)
Day 534: A Colour Symphony (Time: 32 minutes)
The focus for today (18/4/25) is on Sir Arthur Bliss (1891-1975), a composer whom playlist member Alan Harrison summarised as ‘perhaps not in the first rank of composers but certainly not far behind’ – which seems to me to be pretty much spot on. You don’t hear much Bliss on concert platforms these days, though there’s plenty on disc, notably on that trustily wide-ranging label, Naxos. So, for those who might not have heard his music (and maybe not even heard of him), here’s an introduction to Bliss, and a link to what is still probably his most popular work. I watched a YouTube clip the other day about the changing fashions in British classical music during the 20th century, and the ways in which there were evident ‘winners and losers’ in a pretty competitive field. After the Elgar/Vaughan-Williams generation, the next group of composers contained many who might, in a less crowded environment, have become major figures in their own right, but who have instead become rather more marginal – think of Howells or Ireland or Finzi, for example. After the First World War any of these might have become ‘the next big thing’ in British music, but in the 1920s and 30s that role instead was briefly the property of William Walton, but then taken instead by Benjamin Britten… and really Britten’s position remained pretty much unchallenged for the rest of his life (he died in 1976). No room there for people like Arnold, or Rubbra, or Alwyn… or for the slightly older figure of Arthur Bliss. That’s not to say that Bliss didn’t have a public role: he was Director of Music at the BBC in the early 1940s, and Master of the Queen’s Music from 1953 until his own death in 1975. But I suspect it’s fair to say that Bliss was somewhat happier out of the public eye, even if he was very good at the sort of ‘ceremonial music’ that was required from someone in his establishment role. His life story is interesting largely for the ‘bumps in the road’ that occasionally derailed him. He was born in 1891 to an American father and British mother, though the latter died when Bliss was four, and he and his brothers were brought up by their culturally engaged and music-loving father. At Cambridge he read Classics but also Music, after which he went briefly to the Royal College of Music, where he got nothing much out of Stanford, his teacher, but lots from his fellow students, especially Howells. Time at the RCM was short because in 1914 he enlisted in the army, where he was both wounded and gassed, and evidently brave enough to be mentioned twice in despatches. More soberingly, his younger brother was killed, and Bliss was haunted (nightmares and general PTSD, as we’d know it now, for decades) by these experiences. His conversion to Catholicism just after the war can be seen as part of some kind of accommodation with the trauma of wartime experience. In the 1920s, he was briefly a bright new face in British classical music, very heavily influenced by Stravinsky and Poulenc, but gradually, from about 1930 or so, he shifted into someone more conservative (small ‘c’) and reflective as a composer. A great deal of his output is for theatre and film; ‘I have always found it easier to write “dramatic” music than “pure” music,’ he wrote in his autobiography. ‘There is only a little of the spider in me, spinning his own web from his inner being. I am more of the magpie type.’ So, what to choose as an introduction to Bliss? Well, I really love his chamber music (string quartets, the oboe quintet and the clarinet quintet), but I’m going to go with what was the first work by Bliss to cause a big stir in the musical world, ‘A Colour Symphony’. Given what I’ve just quoted from his autobiography about not being a writer of ‘pure’ music, how does this square with writing a symphony? Well, he was invited by Elgar to write a work for the 1922 Three Choirs Festival, and apparently spent ages not getting anywhere, until he came across a book about heraldry, and the significance of different colours in heraldry, and (to quote his autobiography again) ‘at once I saw the possibility of so characterising the four movements of a symphony, that each should express a colour as I personally perceived it.’ The first movement, ‘Purple’, depicts ‘The Colour of Amethysts, Pageantry, Royalty and Death’; it’s a slow processional march, almost funereal in tone. Then comes ‘Red’: ‘The Colour of Rubies, Wine, Revelry, Furnaces, Courage and Magic’. It’s a scherzo, explosive, occasionally jazzy and very ‘fiery’. The third movement is ‘Blue’: ‘The Colour of Sapphires, Deep Water, Skies, Loyalty and Melancholy.’ This is a pensive slow movement, often melancholy. Finally we have ‘Green’: ‘The Colour of Emeralds, Hope, Youth, Joy, Spring and Victory’. This is a real show-stopper of a finale, a double fugue (that is to say, a fugue based on the interweaving of two different themes), which ends with an exultant climax. Frustratingly, there are no video recordings of ‘A Colour Symphony’ on YouTube, so we’re in audio-only territory this week. The recording of the work I have at home is by the English Northern Philharmonia (the orchestra of Opera North) conducted by David Lloyd-Jones, and that’s what you’ve got here: Bliss: A Colour Symphony
Bonis, Mel (1858-1937)
Day 41: Flute Sonata (Time: 17 minutes)
Today (2/5/20), a suggestion from Jenny Holt, and I’m really pleased to get this because it’s a piece (and a composer!) I’ve not only never heard, but never heard of! That’s what I like about doing all this sharing of music – that we get discoveries alongside the more familiar stuff. Anyway, the composer is Melanie Bonis (though I understand that during her career she adopted the name ‘Mel’ because sadly it was easier to get her work taken seriously when people didn’t know she was a woman), and she was a French composer who lived from 1858-1937. Her music has that ‘typically French’ elegance and fluidity, but also a feeling of slight melancholy and yearning. It feels to me, on the basis of this one piece, that she was influenced by people like Fauré or Gaubert, but also Franck or Chausson in the last movement. Definitely one to explore, I think. The link to the performance that Jenny has sent me, by Liz Lieffort and Tiffany Yeh, is here: Mel Bonis – Flute Sonata
Borodin, Alexander (1833-87)
Day 390: String Sextet (Time: 10 minutes)
The closing concert at this year’s Bradfield Festival contains this short work by Borodin. In some ways it’s a bit shocking that I’ve got to Day 390 before finding space for a work by Alexander Porfiryevich Borodin (1833-87). Although he didn’t write a huge amount, for reasons I’ll explain in a minute, there are some very popular pieces out there that really deserve some playlist time: the vividly exciting ‘Polovtsian Dances’ from his opera ‘Prince Igor’, the beautifully lyrical String Quartet No 2 (especially its slow movement) and that delicate piece of Russophile propaganda which is the orchestral tone poem ‘In the Steppes of Central Asia’. (I’d add one more personal favourite to that lot, his excellent Symphony No 2, which really ought to brighten a lot more concert programmes than it does.) What you have today (23/6/23), though, simply because it’s on the Bradfield Festival programme, is a short chamber work from Borodin’s early days as a composer, the only two movements of his String Sextet. But first, a bit of back story. Borodin’s origins and upbringing have a sort of whiff of the 19th century novel about them. He was the illegitimate child of a then 62-year-old nobleman from Georgia (in the Caucasus, not the southern USA) and a 25-year-old married Russian woman. Perhaps unsurprisingly, the child was registered as the offspring of one of the nobleman’s serfs, Porfiry Borodin – hence the composer’s name. Rather madly, this meant that the child was officially his father’s serf, rather than his son, at least until the seven-year-old Alexander was ‘emancipated’ by his father, who then provided a home and financial support to the child and the child’s mother – though, weirdly, Borodin was brought up referring to his mother as his ‘aunt’. As I say, it’s all a bit 19th century novel. Anyway, Alexander was a bright and able young man, a skilled amateur cellist but even more of a whizz-kid at science and mathematics, and consequently Borodin’s lifetime career was as a chemist. (This is spectacularly out of my field of expertise, but apparently his work on aldehydes is still referred to today.) In the late 1850’s, he spent three years in Heidelberg doing post-doctoral research (amongst other things, as we’ll see) and then returned to Russia as a chemistry professor for the rest of his life. What, then, about music? Well, Borodin always styled himself a ‘Sunday composer’, a cultured amateur. On his return to Russia in 1862, he met Balakirev, the leading figure of the group of composers keen to evolve a ‘nationalist’ school of Russian musical composition (we’ve heard from most of the others – Mussorgsky, Rimsky-Korsakov, Cui – on this list already) and started to take lessons in composition from him. Over the next 20 years, he produced a very slow but steady stream of works, though at his death much was left unfinished, and tidied up by Rimsky and Glazunov. Tchaikovsky, never one to pass up an opportunity to diss these ‘barbaric’ composers (Tchaikovsky very firmly faced west in musical terms, even if his music sounds deeply ‘Russian’ to us), said of Borodin, ‘Oh Borodin, a good chemist, but he cannot write a proper measure without Rimsky helping him.’ And in some ways Borodin himself encouraged this perspective. As he drolly noted, ‘Respectable people don’t write music or make love as a career’! But though Borodin’s mature work may not be ‘polished’ in a conservatory-trained sort of way, there is a very definite sense in which it articulates a passionate high Russian Romanticism, emotional, sensuous, occasionally wild. But – and here is another of those curiosities – he was also attracted to chamber music, the ‘abstract’ forms that Balakirev’s circle so scorned for being academic and soulless. In fact, that attraction began significantly before he met Balakirev and started learning how to be a composer … because he was already doing it! There exists in Borodin’s back catalogue a collection of ‘student’ works, most of them dating from the late 1850s, and largely written while he was in Heidelberg doing his post-doc chemistry research. It seems he spent his evenings and weekends in convivial playing of chamber music (his cello playing was at the top end of the ‘gifted amateur’ spectrum) and then, tentatively, composing it. This is where the two-movement String Sextet comes in. It did not appear in print until 1946, but the manuscripts show that it cannot date from later than 1860. Borodin himself wrote of it that it was ‘very Mendelssohnian in character and written to please the Germans’. For someone with, at this stage, no formal training, it’s really rather impressive, with a quite sophisticated awareness of the different textures possible when working with six string instruments. The melodies are clearly not prime Borodin (there’s nothing here of the sensual and yearning music of later-stage Borodin that made his work so easily adaptable to the 20th century musical theatre era in ‘Kismet’), but I’d like to suggest that embedded in all this stylistic homage to Mendelssohn, there are some of the ‘Russian’ motifs that he’d make so much of later in his career. The two movements are a genial Allegro that makes a lot of use of canonic entries, where the instruments copy each other in turn, and a short but tender Andante with its roots in Russian folksong. Unsurprisingly for such an obscure piece, YouTube isn’t overrun with versions to choose from, but there’s a video recording from what appears to be a scratch ensemble of string players who are (or were) performers from the front desks of the string sections of the Gulbenkian Orchestra, based in Lisbon. It’s a more than capable performance of an engaging and attractive work, and you’ll find it here: Borodin: String Sextet
Boulanger, Lili (1893-1918)
Day 444: Nocturne, for Violin and Piano (Time: 4 minutes) and D'un Matin de Printemps, for Violin and Piano (5 minutes)
There have been 14 mentions of Mme Boulanger on this playlist to date – I counted them, so don’t feel like you have to check! – in almost all cases referring to composers taking composition lessons in Paris from her (and just occasionally mentioning a composer working in France without taking lessons from her). That will no doubt have confirmed for you that Nadia Boulanger (1887-1979) pretty much dominated the music teaching scene in France for a very great deal of the 20th century. However, the posting for today (5/1/24), and the pieces being played in a recital here in Sheffield by Jennifer Pike this month, are not by Nadia Boulanger but by her younger sister Lili Boulanger (1893-1918). The main reason we hear so relatively little about Lili Boulanger and her music is that, as you can see from her dates, she died at the age of 24 after a lifetime troubled by severe ill-health (from contracting bronchial pneumonia at the age of two until she eventually died from complications attendant on having what we now know as Crohn’s Disease). This means that her active compositional life was curtailed to a period of around eight years – nothing survives that predates 1910, and she died in the spring of 1918. However, Lili (or, if we’re being formal, Marie-Juliette Olga Lili Boulanger) crammed a significant amount of impressive work into that short period of time, amongst other things becoming at the time the first female composer to win the Prix de Rome in 1913 – though she was too ill to enjoy the whole three years residence in Italy that the prize supported. One other extraordinary thing about Lili Boulanger, before turning to her music, is that her father was a mere 77 years old when she was born – all those assuming that the Mick Jaggers of this world didn’t exist in previous eras should think again! Lili appears to have been devoted to her father, and when he died in 1900 she was devastated, and it appears as though the prevailing tendency toward a melancholy state of mind (and thus a tendency to write often melancholy music) shaped a lot of her ideas in the years that were left to her. As you might expect, Lili was something of a musical prodigy, taking singing lessons at the age of two(!), sitting in on classes at the Paris Conservatoire from five years old, and being a more than proficient singer, pianist, organist, harpist, violinist and cellist while still in her teens. Her musical output adds up to around a couple of dozen works, three quarters of them being for voice and/or chorus accompanied by piano (or sometimes orchestra). However, there is also a small handful of chamber works, including four pieces for violin and piano. One, ‘Nocturne’, is actually only the second piece Boulanger had published, dating from 1911. As the title suggests, this is ‘night music’. You can hear quite a lot of Debussy’s influence in Lili Boulanger’s music (it’s a striking if sad coincidence that they died in the same year), and sometimes that influence feels very present – witness the half-quotation from Debussy’s ‘Prélude à l'Après-Midi d'un Faune’ as this piece unfolds. The music has a slow and dream-like quality, the violin for the most part floating sensuously above the piano accompaniment, but there are dark moods here too. This is no untroubled night-time scene. The work is reasonably well-represented on YouTube, and from the options available, I’ve chosen this video recording by the young violinist Savitri Grier, accompanied by Richard Uttley on piano. You’ll find it here: Boulanger: Nocturne, for Violin and Piano. The other piece by Lili Boulanger for today is the last work that Boulanger was able to complete before her final illness, though after that her sister acted as her amanuensis for the pieces she was working on at her death. This is ‘D’un Matin de Printemps’ (‘Of a Spring Morning’), which exists in a variety of scorings, but was originally for violin and piano. (There are versions for flute and piano, but also for piano trio, and another for full orchestra; interestingly, these are not, as it were, identical pieces apart from their scoring, but rather they are ‘variant’ treatments of the core piece, and Boulanger seems to have seen them as though looking at an object from a variety of different angles.) She began work on the piece in the spring of 1917, and it was finished just a couple of months before her death. It is actually one of a pair of works that she was working on at the time; the other, intended for orchestra and with the scoring completed by her sister Nadia after her death, is ‘D’un Soir Triste’. The two pieces share some common musical material, though their very contrasting moods show what she could do with these musical ideas. ‘D’un Matin de Printemps’ is a bright and festive piece. Again you can hear a lot of Debussy’s influence here (especially in the orchestral version). What’s interesting about the work, I think, is the way it has a basic A-B-A form, but rather than encountering repetition, there is subtle and continuous development as the original material returns. It shows, if you like, that spring is a season of growth, change and transience. Most of the YouTube recordings are of the orchestral version, but there’s a video recording of the piece in its original piano and violin guise, played here by the young violinist Laura Colgate, accompanied by Andrew Welch on piano: Boulanger: D'un Matin de Printemps, for Violin and Piano
Day 516: Psalm 130 ('Du fond de l'abîme') for Soloists, Chorus and Orchestra (Time: 25 minutes)
Today (15/11/24), I have one of Lili Boulanger’s most substantial works, her setting of Psalm 130, ‘Du Fond de l'Abîme’, better known perhaps either by its Latin title ‘De Profundis’ or the English ‘Out of the Depths…’. I’ve posted once before about Lili Boulanger (1893-1918), the younger sister of the famous music teacher Nadia Boulanger. Back on Day 444 I wrote about her in relation to two short pieces for violin and piano, her ‘Nocturne’ and ‘D’un Matin de Printemps’. Most of what I’d want to say about her biography I noted on that occasion. Probably the most significant details about her are her very brief life, a consequence of long-term ill-health, which dogged her from early childhood, and the fact that in the mere eight years of her composing career (effectively 1910-18) she produced just 24 works – but what works! There are three pieces for piano solo, three for violin and piano, a single wholly orchestral work – and then everything else is vocal or choral, accompanied by piano or orchestra. This focus on the human voice is, I think, a product of Lili’s fascination with setting texts, and the ways in which words can be illuminated by their musical colouring. She had a (highly personal, somewhat idiosyncratic) Catholic faith, and religious texts feature prominently when it came to choosing what she might set to music. In particular, there are three psalm settings, all of which date from the final couple of years of her life: Psalm 24 for Chorus, Organ and Orchestra; Psalm 129 for Baritone soloist and Orchestra; and today’s work, Psalm 130 for two soloists (a mezzo-soprano and a tenor), Chorus, Organ and Orchestra. In some ways one can see readily why Psalm 130 is attractive to composers. Here it is in the familiar New International Version, short enough to quote in full: ‘Out of the depths I cry to you, Lord; Lord, hear my voice. Let your ears be attentive to my cry for mercy. If you, Lord, kept a record of sins, Lord, who could stand? But with you there is forgiveness, so that we can, with reverence, serve you. I wait for the Lord, my whole being waits, and in his word I put my hope. I wait for the Lord more than watchmen wait for the morning, more than watchmen wait for the morning. Israel, put your hope in the Lord, for with the Lord is unfailing love and with him is full redemption. He himself will redeem Israel from all their sins.’ The initial cry of anguish, the contemplative waiting on God, and the final decision of the writer to put his trust in the Lord – all these can be shaped to vivid and contrasting musical ends. Boulanger’s handling of the words also contains her own additional comments – ‘I cry to you’, ‘I hope in you’, and so on – and this reflects both the intensely personal inspiration for the composition, and the social context in which it was written. She dedicated the work ‘à la mémoire de mon cher papa’, even though her father died back in 1900 when she was only six years old; nevertheless, her sense of loss at his passing stayed with her throughout her life. But there’s also a wider dimension, in that in 1916, when she began the work, France (and much of the rest of Europe) was deep in the cataclysm of the First World War, and it’s hard not to hear this work as a cry of anguish for a world busy destroying itself. Poignantly, Boulanger did not live to see the war come to an end, so the fact that this is a cry ‘out of the depths’ was almost literal for her. The psalm is often used in funereal contexts, and interestingly Boulanger occasionally mentioned the urge to write a Requiem. This piece is as close as she got to fulfilling that aim, and in many ways it could be seen as her own requiem. In musical terms, there’s a sense at times of the influence of Gregorian Chant on the work, but elsewhere you can feel the language of Debussy in particular in its chromatic and symbolist (rather than, say, impressionist) qualities. It’s in five sections, though running continuously, and like the psalm itself the work pivots at the line ‘But with you there is forgiveness’. There’s a slow and darkly brooding orchestral introduction, a contemplation of a penitent state of mind. That penitential mood continues with the first statement by the chorus of a cry for help in deep distress, and in the third section the music develops the themes, until we reach the words ‘Lord, who could stand?’ The fourth section (‘But with you there is forgiveness’) introduces the mezzo soloist (and, more briefly, the tenor) and a shift in mood to something more consolatory, if not necessarily hopeful. Finally the work ends with a mixture of hope and despair, echoing the music with which it began. It’s a powerful piece, and rarely performed, which seems a terrible shame given its intensity and quality. By the time she finished this music, Boulanger was bedridden with her final illness, and in fact the work was only completed with her sister Nadia acting as her amanuensis. I think this is an astonishing composition, an intensely human lament for comfort and consolation in a shattered world. YouTube has a particularly good video recording of this work, by the Dutch Radio Chorus and Radio Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by James Gaffigan. The soloists (and I’d have to say I’m really impressed by the mezzo here) are Judit Kutasi and Fabio Trumpy. You’ll find the performance here: Boulanger: Psalm 130, for Soloists, Chorus and Orchestra
Braga, Gaetano (1829-1907)
Day 42: ‘La Serenata’ (Time: 4 minutes)
Today (3/5/20), another suggestion from Claire, this time for a piece which seems to be another of those ‘one hit wonder’ items. The composer in question is the 19th century Italian Gaetano Braga. He wrote operas (he was Italian, after all) and works for cello, but today the only piece that gets much of an outing is this, ‘La Serenata’ (also sometimes known as ‘Angel's Serenade’). Originally scored for soprano and piano, with a violin or cello playing the third part, it is actually quite creepy – a ‘dialogue’ between mother and daughter (the soprano ‘playing’ the mother, the string soloist playing the angel's voice), in which despite the mother's worries the girl follows the angel's voice in the end, presumably to her death. It’s a bit like Schubert's ‘Erlkonig’ (‘The Earl King’). However, the version Claire has asked for is for flute and piano, and it’s much more serene and beautiful as a result. The performance by Yuyu Kanda on flute and Yuka Narita on piano is here: Gaetano Braga – ‘La Serenata’
Braga Santos, Joly (1924-88)
Day 480: Concerto for Strings, Op 17 (Time: 19 minutes)
Today’s entry is devoted to a composer who was absolutely new to me when I first came across one of his works earlier this year. I may just be a bit slower on the uptake than the rest of you out there, but somehow I think that quite possibly the music of Joly Braga Santos may be new to all of us. And the reason for picking his music now? He was born on 14th May 1924 … which, as I’m sure you’re aware, means he was born exactly 100 years ago today (14/5/24). Braga Santos (1924-88) was a Portuguese composer. One of the reasons, undoubtedly, that some composers get overlooked while others hit the headlines pretty early on is that there are fashionable places to come from as a musician and composer, and then there are less fashionable places. It’s very definitely the case that Portugal’s turn in the musical spotlight came in the 16th and 17th centuries. If you’ve not come across the Renaissance choral music of Duarte Lobo (not to be confused with the equally wonderful – but Spanish – Alonso Lobo) or Cardoso, then there’s some extra homework for you there! However – and in some ways you could see this as similar to the apparent fate of music here, which was richly stunning in the Tudor and Jacobean period but, allegedly, led to ‘the land without music’ in the 250 years that followed – the spotlight shifted away from Portugal after that, and one might argue that it never shifted back. But there was a kind of renewal in Portuguese music in the late 19th century, and there is a handful of composers in the early/middle years of the 20th century who took Portuguese music out of the backwaters and towards, if not necessarily into, the mainstream of European music. And of those composers – and I say this on the basis of having listened to only about a dozen of his works – Joly Braga Santos may well be the finest. He was born and died in Lisbon, and spent almost his entire life in Portugal. His life story is relatively uneventful. He studied with the leading Portuguese composer of the previous generation, Luis de Freitas Branco, whose brother Pedro just happened to be the founder and first conductor of the Portuguese Radio Symphony Orchestra. In that sense, Braga Santos got a kind of ‘leg up’ when it came to prompt performances of the works he wrote in his early 20s. But another key event in Braga Santos’s life happened in 1945, when he came to England at the end of the 2nd World War and met Vaughan Williams. The latter encouraged Braga Santos to find in Portuguese folk music and culture the sort of modal richness that Vaughan Williams imbued his own works with, and I think if you want to find echoes of one composer’s work in that of another, Braga Santos (or at least the Braga Santos of the 1940s and 50s) feels like a ‘Portuguese Vaughan Williams’. Back in Portugal, Braga Santos wrote a substantial body of work in his 20s and early 30s. Most significantly, there were four symphonies written by the time Braga Santos was only 27 (the 3rd and 4th seem to me to be the best of them, and very very fine indeed), to which one might add three ‘Symphonic Overtures’, the ‘Variations on an Alentejo Theme’, the Nocturne for Strings, a couple of string quartets and a piano quartet … and the work I’ve chosen to illustrate Braga Santos’s distinctive voice as a composer, his Concerto for Strings of 1951. To wrap up his musical biography briefly, he had a kind of compositional crisis in the late 1950s, and from the later 1960s onwards he shifted to a more astringent, even acerbic, style – less like Vaughan Williams or Howells, and more like a cross between Bartók and Berg, though still with a kind of Portuguese ‘flavour’. (It’s a bit like the shift in approach I’ve explored before in the music of Ginastera.) Professionally he was a conductor, critic and academic as well as a composer. He died suddenly, of a stroke, at the age of 64. The Concerto for Strings in D, Op 17, has the sort of modal quality you’ll find in Vaughan Williams or Moeran, or if you want to look further afield, in Respighi or Kodaly for that matter. It feels very much like it has its roots in folk song, even if Braga Santos doesn’t quote any directly. The work is in three movements, and at its core is the tender and elegiac slow movement (the piece was played at the composer’s own funeral), though the lively 5/4 time finale runs it close for memorability. It may not be the best piece he ever wrote, but I thought a complete work would be a better illustration of his output than to take just a movement from one of the symphonies. And I do think that once heard, it’s not a work that’s easily forgotten. So let’s hear it for the music of Joly Braga Santos, whose moment in the spotlight may be about to return. Recordings on CD of Braga Santos’s music are not as rare as they were 20 years ago, but concert performances are rarer. However, I’ve come across one by a young orchestra from the USA playing Braga Santos’s Concerto for Strings. It’s performed by the CMI Orchestra (which I *think* is also sometimes known as the Orchestra San Antonio), a body of players resident at the Classical Music Institute at San Antonio, Texas. The conductor on this video recording is José Luis Gomez. You’ll find the piece here: Braga Santos: Concerto for Strings, Op 17
Brahms, Johannes (1833-97)
Day 31: Four Pieces for Piano, Op 119 (Time: 16 minutes)
Today (22/4/20), it’s time to take Brahms out of his self-isolation and enjoy the pieces
he wrote at the very end of his life.
Brahms is close to my heart (as you may have noted me saying before), and the
piano music he wrote in the last three or four years of his life has an inward,
contemplative quality that feels like a distillation of all that 19th
century ‘Romantic’ sensibility into something very pure and reflective.
He wrote four sets of short pieces (Opp.116-119) – most of them are slow and
thoughtful, leavened by occasional more extrovert movements.
Like most Brahms, it requires engagement – the pieces are rhythmically and harmonically
elusive, and they need to be listened to as opposed to just heard, if you see…
But the rewards are well worth it.
I toyed with selecting a range of movements from all four collections of pieces,
but in the end (and still coming in at just over 15 minutes!) I’ve gone for the complete
Op 119 Piano Pieces – three slow Intermezzi and a final ‘heroic’ Rhapsody.
And the performance I’ve chosen is by the American pianist Richard Goode (usually
more famous for playing Bach and Beethoven, but wonderful here, I think).
You’ll find his performance here:
Brahms – Four Piano Pieces, Op 119
(A footnote: Richard Goode is one of those pianists who sings/burbles as he plays.
Back when the Lindsay String Quartet were running Music in the Round in Sheffield,
Richard Goode came and played a recital in the Crucible Studio, which I enjoyed hugely,
but his ‘grumbling along’ was quite striking.
If you watch his lips on the video, you can see it’s obviously the habit of a lifetime!)
Day 51: String Sextet No 1, Op 18 (2nd movement) (Time: 10 minutes)
Today (12/5/20), I think it’s probably time for more Brahms. (I’m aware that for some of us, any day is a good day for more Brahms, but I’m trying to keep this under control!) Last time Brahms featured, I chose the last pieces of solo piano music that he wrote. This time, I thought I’d go for something at the opposite end of his career. Being aware of the long shadow that Beethoven cast over 19th century German music, Brahms was initially reluctant to commit himself to the two major forms that Beethoven revolutionised, the symphony and the string quartet. Famously, Brahms took over 20 years to get from his first sketches for a symphony to the first performance of his Symphony No 1, and in the meantime produced two lovely orchestral serenades, the first piano concerto and the ‘St Anthony Chorale’ variations for orchestra – a lot of ‘preparation’, in other words. The same is true for the string quartet (he’s known to have destroyed at least 20 string quartets before allowing one to be published in his name), and part of the preparation for writing quartets was to write a string sextet (a very unusual chamber music combination, with no predecessors apart from works by Boccherini in the classical period). Anyway, enough background! I’ve chosen the second movement of the String Sextet No 1 in Bb, Op 18. Brahms made a version of this movement for solo piano (Variations in D Minor, Op 18b), but the original string version plays wonderfully with changes in texture in its combination of forces. There’s a lovely recording of this by the augmented forces of the Danish String Quartet (and if you don’t know the Danish String Quartet, try searching for their CD ‘Wood Works’, arrangements of Danish folk music, which is an absolute joy). You’ll find their performance of the Brahms here: Brahms – String Sextet No 1, Op 18 (2nd movement)
Day 121: Clarinet Sonata in F Minor, Op 120 No 1 (Time: 24 minutes)
This week, as trailed last Friday, is Clarinet Sonata Week. Partly I chose the theme because I love the ‘singing’ sound of the clarinet; also, it seemed like a nice contrast to the flute of two weeks ago. Finally, it enables me to select two of my favourite clarinet sonatas … and, today (22/9/20), to find another excuse to select a piece by Brahms to go on this list. One of the interesting things about composers’ motivations, I think, is the role that gets played by performers of the day – think about Mozart's writing for the horn, say, which surely wouldn’t have featured so significantly in his oeuvre were it not for Joseph Leutgeb, a virtuoso on the horn, Mozart's partner in what these days I guess we’d call ‘bantz’, and apparently a cheesemonger in Vienna in his spare time. (This last one is an urban myth, sadly.) Anyway, what Leutgeb was to Mozart, the clarinettist Richard Muhlfeld was to Brahms. Brahms (1833-97) seemed to be settling into an essentially leisured retirement. As the 1880s turned into the 1890s, he appeared almost to have stopped composing altogether. He had written nothing for orchestra after 1885, no concertos after 1887, no piano music after 1879. He appeared to have made the decision that his String Quintet Op 111 of 1890 was to be his last work. But then, in the next year, he heard Muhlfeld play Mozart's Clarinet Quintet, established a friendship with the player and decided to come out of retirement to write for him. The result is this rich autumnal vein in Brahms’ music – and in fact after the clarinet pieces there are four sets of piano pieces (see Day 31, for example!), the ‘Four Serious Songs’ and the 11 Chorale Preludes for Organ too. For Muhlfeld, Brahms wrote a Clarinet Trio, a beautiful and nostalgic Clarinet Quintet (both in 1891), and two Clarinet Sonatas, which date from 1894, three years before Brahms’ death. What I’ve chosen for us to listen to today is the first of these, the Clarinet Sonata in F Minor, Op 120 No 1. (Brahms also arranged both sonatas for the viola instead of clarinet, but for me the clarinet versions are richer and more sonorous.) The F Minor sonata is in four movements. The first of them establishes the equal relationship between clarinet and piano – this isn’t just a showpiece for the wind soloist. The emotional heart of the work is the tender, yearning slow movement that follows. The third movement is a typical Brahms ‘scherzo’ – that is, not a scherzo at all, but a kind of gentle, lilting allegretto. Finally, the last movement raises the emotional temperature via a range of episodes, before its impassioned and triumphant ending. It is played on this video by the clarinettist Francois Benda, accompanied by Rolf-Dieter Arens. You’ll find the performance here: Brahms: Clarinet Sonata in F Minor, Op 120 No 1
Day 125: Piano Trio No 3 in C Minor, Op 101 (Time: 22 minutes)
Today (6/10/20), I want to explore Brahms’ Piano Trio No 3 in C Minor, Op 101. The ‘piano trio’ is not, as one might naively think, a work for three pianos (or three pianists) but, conventionally at least, for piano, violin and cello. Like so much else in the classical tradition, one might look to ‘Papa’ Haydn as the composer who is not just ‘Father of the Symphony’, ‘Father of the String Quartet’, ‘Father of the Piano Sonata’ … but also ‘Father of the Piano Trio’ too – although in most of Haydn's works for this combination of instruments, the cello part is essentially subordinate, and functions largely to underpin what the left hand of the keyboard part was doing, at a time before the greater power of the piano as we know it today existed. Mozart's late piano trios begin to see the instruments treated as equals, a process even more evident in Beethoven's six piano trios. Throughout the 19th century the form continued to grow in popularity, largely because it was a combination of instruments that lent itself to performances in the home as well as the concert hall. Brahms’ third piano trio dates from the mid-1880s, when Brahms was at the height of his fame. All three of Brahms’ completed piano trios (there is a fourth, published posthumously, whose authorship is doubtful) are in four movements, and have a ‘symphonic’ feel to them. The first is a very early work, from the mid-1850s, but it was in the 1880s that he focused his interest on the form: the second trio dates from 1882, the third as I’ve noted from 1886, and then in 1889 Brahms went back to that early trio and revised it so thoroughly that in many ways it seems like a new work. Brahms (like Beethoven!) used C Minor as a key for ‘weighty’ music (the Symphony No 1 and String Quartet No 1 as well as the Piano Trio No 3), but this trio is also very condensed, and considerably shorter than Brahms’ other works in the form. The first movement is full of tension, with what feel like explosive outbursts at times. The second movement is an oddly haunted creation. It’s quiet pretty much throughout, with a mysterious, almost ghostly feel. In contrast, the third movement is tender, with what seems like a deliberate simplicity – though that does not apply to the time signatures, mostly in 7/4 and with a central section in 15/8! With the last movement we return to the grim-faced drama of the opening, though in a familiar way the sternness of C Minor gives way to a ‘sunny’ C Major in the closing moments. The piece is played in this video recording by the ATOS Trio (BBC New Generation Artists about 10 years ago). You’ll find it here: Brahms: Piano Trio No 3 in C Minor, Op 101
Day 279: Variations on a Theme of Haydn, Op 56a (Time: 19 minutes)
This week’s primary focus is on the music of Brahms, not just because almost all his compositions are wonderful (he was ruthless in destroying not just drafts, so that we rarely have any evidence of ‘work in progress’, but also whole pieces if they didn’t meet his standards: it’s claimed that he disposed of around 20 string quartets before he composed one that he felt was worthy of the name), but specifically this week because this coming Sunday, April 3rd, will mark the 125th anniversary of Brahms’ death. Consequently, I’ve chosen two works by him from roughly the ‘middle period’ of his career. On Friday, I’ve an extract from a piece that will also pick up on the Lenten theme I’ve got running at the moment; today (29/3/22), I have a complete work that is one of the most graceful and coherent pieces in this genre that exists. So, Brahms has made four appearances so far on this list (see Days 31, 51, 121 and 125), and the primary focus has tended to be on his chamber music, which seemed as good a reason as any to diversify the approach this time, and examine a piece for orchestra instead. But first, and this isn’t a digression, who do we think of in terms of being composers of the greatest sets of variations? For me, if you’re thinking of big pieces in variation form, it’s a toss-up between Bach’s ‘Goldberg’ Variations and Beethoven’s ‘Diabelli’ Variations (with maybe a respectful nod to that 20th century masterpiece, Rzewski’s Variations on ‘The People United Shall Never Be Defeated!’ – which, if you don’t know it, is well worth seeking out). However, if the question is reframed as something more like ‘Which composer produced the greatest number of masterpieces in variation form?’, then I’m pretty sure Brahms would be in with a shout at winning that game. In the early/middle period of his career, Brahms wrote a string of them for solo piano: the Variations on the Theme by Schumann, Op 9; the Variations on an Original Theme, Op 21 No 1; the Variations on a Hungarian Melody, Op 21 No 2; the Variations and Fugue on a Theme by Handel, Op 24; the Variations on a Theme of Paganini [yes, that theme], Op 35. Then there are individual movements in variation form within larger works: the slow movement of the String Sextet No 1, and the Finale of the Symphony No 4, to take just two examples. I suppose what I’m getting at is that for Brahms, sets of variations weren’t just ‘showpiece’ creations, where the work’s attractiveness is essentially decorative, a matter of producing rabbits out of hats, but rather, Brahms composed these works to reflect the same sense of densely argued and complex structure that informed all his other works. Which brings me to today’s work: the so-called ‘Variations on a Theme of Haydn’, otherwise known as the ‘Variations on the St Anthony Chorale’, Op 56a. He wrote these initially for two pianos (now his Op 56b), but orchestrated the work almost immediately. The attribution of the theme to Haydn is now known to be in error: the tune was the melody of the slow movement of a wind divertimento attributed to Haydn. Who actually wrote it is (as far as I’m aware) still not known, though one of Haydn’s contemporaries, Ignaz Pleyel, seems a possibility. Anyway, the melody in question is a lovely, stately affair, but no doubt appealed to Brahms because it’s structurally interesting: rather than being in regular four-bar phrases, the first two phrases are five bars in length, before the rest of the theme is in four-bar chunks. Does this matter? Probably not, except that it gives the whole structure an imperceptibly ‘lopsided’ quality that Brahms then explores in his work. He keeps the ‘wind serenade’ scoring for the first statement of the theme, but underpinned by pizzicato lower strings, to give a sense of where we’re going. Then there are eight variations and a finale. There are lots of fascinating games being played here, but I’ll just mention two. One is the ‘playing off’ of rhythms in twos against rhythms in threes, so that we’re forever crossing triplet patterns against quavers or semiquavers. The other fascinating thing is what Brahms does in the finale: this is a passacaglia (a very old form of variations dating from the Baroque period), and what Brahms does is gives us a set of ‘variations within variations’, in that he writes a (five-bar!) bass theme, which is then itself varied. The liner notes for a box of Brahms CDs that I’ve got describes this wonderfully: ‘The bass is five bars long, and hearing it is like looking at a child that resembles both its parents: we aren’t sure whether we are reminded more of the melody or of its bass.’ Finally, on top of this, Brahms brings back the theme itself in quietly joyful triumph (Brahms is never one for crude over-statement), and plays out the game of rhythms of threes and twos all the way to the end. You may infer from all this that I really love this piece of music – a piece of compositional virtuosity without any ostentation at all. As for a recording, I’ve gone for this live concert performance by the WDR Symphony Orchestra, Cologne, conducted by Cristian Măcelaru. You’ll find it here: Brahms: Variations on a Theme of Haydn, Op 56a
Day 280: A German Requiem (7th movement: 'Selig sind die Toten') (Time: 13 minutes)
Today (1/4/22), we have more Brahms – and, fittingly, some Brahms that picks up, in his own idiosyncratic way, the theme of music for Lent. You’re probably ahead of me in realising that I’ve selected a movement from his ‘Ein Deutsches Requiem (‘A German Requiem’). This isn’t, in any sense, a conventional requiem. It opts not to use the usual texts of the Catholic Requiem Mass, but instead Brahms chooses texts from a variety of Biblical sources that focus not so much on the fact of the death of an individual, or hopes for eternal life, but rather on consolation for the bereaved. A familiar comment from Brahms in the run-up to the first Bremen performance of the work on Good Friday, 1868: ‘I could easily dispense with the word “German” and replace it with “Human”.’ The trigger for the work’s creation was the death in January 1865 of Brahms’ mother. By April of that year, he had sketched out the material for what would be the first and fourth movements of the piece, and used material excised from what had been an early draft of his 1st Piano Concerto to function as the second movement. It was first performed as a six-movement work in 1867, and then revised with an aria for solo soprano added as the fifth movement of a seven-movement ‘arch’ structure in 1868. At this point in his career, Brahms had, if you like, been through his ‘boy wonder’ phase, fêted by the Schumanns as the saviour of German music, and through the later 1850s and early 1860s, he consolidated that reputation with a series of major works, including (eventually and after much struggle) his Piano Concerto No 1, the first version of his Piano Trio No 1, his two Serenades for Orchestra, his two Piano Quartets, the incredibly popular Hungarian Dances, his two String Sextets, and a vast number of songs and choral works. His Horn Trio is pretty much contemporary with the German Requiem, and it too was shadowed by his mother’s death. However, the German Requiem itself was by some distance on a greater scale than anything Brahms had written before – it remains the biggest work in his output. Performances typically last around 75 minutes. Brahms’s faith is a complex thing to understand. Dvorak, whose Catholicism was much more ‘innocent’, said of Brahms: ‘Such a great man, and such a great soul, but he believes in nothing.’ This is surely not true: Brahms wrote a considerable amount of what we might regard as ‘sacred’ music, and the necessity of faith as the basis for consolation, if not necessarily happiness, in human life runs through pretty much all of these works. What you don’t get, in the German Requiem, is any focus on the place of Jesus as Redeemer, or really any projection of the idea that for Christians death is the gateway to eternal life. The work closes with a peaceful passage from Revelation: ‘Blessed are the dead which die in the Lord from henceforth; Yea, saith the Spirit, that they may rest from their labours; and their works do follow them.’ It is this last movement that I’ve chosen to illustrate this magnificent work. (I should also add that some months ago there was a brief discussion on this playlist about music we’d like to have played at our funerals. Steve Joseph of this list – a friend of mine from my choir – wants Brahms’ Requiem at his. It’s clearly going to be a substantial affair!) Obviously, if we weren’t constrained by the ’40 minutes per week’ rule, I’d find a link to the whole work (and in any case, if you don’t know this piece very well, do explore one of the complete recordings on YouTube – it’ll repay your time and contemplation). As it is, here is the seventh movement, ‘Blessed are the dead’, in a recording by the Vienna Philharmonic and the Vienna Singverein, conducted by Herbert von Karajan. Normally, I’m not all that fond of Karajan as a conductor – my sense is that everything is smoothed out and covered in a layer of varnish – but I really quite like this! You’ll find it here: Brahms: A German Requiem (7th movement: 'Selig sind die Toten')
Day 426: Symphony No 4 (3rd movement) (Time: 6 minutes) and (4th movement) (14 minutes)
My choice today (3/11/23) is Brahms’ Symphony No 4. The whole work is too long to be accommodated according to the ‘rules’ of this list, so I’m going to focus on the last two movements of it – though obviously if you’re listening to the symphony it makes far more sense to hear it all, a decision I would very warmly recommend! Looking back at the archive of musical choices via this playlist I’m struck (‘shocked’ might be better) by the realisation that it’s 18 months(!) since we last had any Brahms on this list. Given that, as I’ve often said, Brahms is one of the composers closest to my heart, that seems a worrying state of affairs – and all the more reason to enjoy some today. In fact, we’ve had Brahms six times on this list (see Days 31, 51, 121, 125, 279 and 280), mostly chamber music, but with just the one look at Brahms in orchestral dress, the ‘Variations on a Theme of Haydn’. For most (sensible!) people, the pinnacle of Brahms the composer for orchestra is his symphonic output, and – not, I think, a controversial statement – the pinnacle of this is his last symphony, the Fourth. It’s a work I fell in love with as a teenager, and I think what appealed to me all those decades ago was the fact that no other work of the 19th century offers such a perfect balance of heart and head, of feeling and intellect. Brahms wrote it over the summers of 1884/5, at a period in his life when he was already contemplating winding down to a leisurely retirement. With hindsight (always an easy thing to access), the 4th Symphony does have a kind of ‘valedictory’ feel, and though I’m not sure we end up anywhere all that comforting at the conclusion of the journey, we are enriched, I think, by the process. Brahms was always self-deprecating about introducing his symphonies to the world, and of this one, he wrote to the conductor Hans von Bulow, ‘I have a couple of entr’actes which when strung together might make what is commonly called a symphony.’ It won’t surprise you to know that the symphony is nothing like as casually constructed as Brahms playfully suggests. Another aside to von Bulow compared the symphony to the influence of the climate in the Austrian Alps where Brahms composed in the summers: ‘I’m really afraid [the Fourth Symphony] tastes like the climate here. The cherries don’t ripen in these parts; you wouldn’t eat them!’ And one last, notionally off-putting remark: Brahms’ most loyal critic of the time, Eduard Hanslick, heard the work initially in a version for two pianos, and commented, ‘it’s like being beaten up by two tremendously intelligent people’. But don’t be daunted, folks – as I said earlier, heart and head. Focusing as I am on the third and fourth movements, you’ll have to imagine (or better still, find them on YouTube and listen!) we’ve had the first movement, built out of the endlessly inventive elaboration of its first four notes, and the second, a beautiful, tender Andante of glowing lyricism. So, what of the third movement? Well, one thing to say is that it really shocked Brahms’ early listeners, who were entirely unprepared for its zip and vigour … and the (for Brahms) unheard of use of a triangle in the percussion section. The heading ‘Allegro giocoso’ gives a clue to its rowdy, ebullient quality. It seems to me to be the closest Brahms got to writing a scherzo in the style of Beethoven. We go straight from that to the finale, a movement described in some places as a ‘chaconne’ and in others as a ‘passacaglia’. (In truth, there’s barely a difference.) In some ways this is Brahms looking back, at the forms of Baroque music (he studied a lot of Bach and Handel – and in fact earlier music than that, like the compositions of Palestrina). What we get here is a theme based on the opening eight chords of a chaconne written by Bach from his Cantata No 150, which has the illuminating title ‘Nach Dir, Herr, verlanget mich’ (‘I long to be near you, Lord’). Brahms was definitely not a conventional Christian (see the comments I wrote about the German Requiem – Day 280), but I think it’s not too fanciful to hear in the final movement his journey searching for something (comfort, maybe, or consolation), even if the ending suggests such a thing is elusive. But the journey is fantastic! The movement is constructed of 32 variations on those eight chords, constantly exploring and evolving. Hanslick again: his review of an early performance described this last movement as ‘an astonishing harmonic and contrapuntal art never conspicuous as such and never an exercise of mere musical erudition’. Spot on, Eduard! There are lots of performances of Brahms’ 4th Symphony on YouTube, but finding recordings of individual movements narrows down the field a bit. In the end I’ve chosen playing by a relatively new orchestra, one with the initially unpromising-seeming name, Les Dissonances. The orchestra was put together in 2004 by the violinist David Grimal, who leads the ensemble from the first violin desk. The musicians are drawn from many of Europe’s leading orchestras, and the group varies in size depending on the repertoire it’s playing. It seems to me that if nothing else, these performances are always alive, always thoughtful, searching the music for what it can tell us. You’ll find their video recordings here: Brahms: Symphony No 4 (3rd movement) and here: Brahms: Symphony No 4 (4th movement)
Day 457: Tragic Overture (Time: 13 minutes)
Those who’ve got several years’ experience by now of this playlist will know that Brahms is one of my ‘top six’ favourite composers, so I’d rarely want to pass up a chance to highlight his music. He’s appeared seven times on this list already, but working on the assumption that you can never have too much of a good thing, today (20/2/24) here comes an eighth. The work by Brahms on the Halle’s programme this month is his ‘Tragic Overture’, one of his tautest, pithiest creations. It’s a work of Brahms’ maturity, with a fairly straightforward back-story. By the later 1870s, Brahms was a renowned figure across Europe, and began to be the recipient of honorary degrees from various establishments. For instance, in 1876 he got a Doctor of Music degree from Cambridge University. In 1879, the University of Breslau (then in Prussia; now the University of Wrocław, Poland) did the same, offering him an honorary D.Phil. For the occasion, Brahms provided the institution with a piece of music. This was in many ways the most ‘un-Brahmsian’ of pieces, the ‘Academic Festival Overture’, Op 80, a light-hearted work (light-hearted? Brahms??) based on several popular student songs of the time. (Don’t be misled by the rather frivolous scoring of that work, though – it may have cymbal and triangle parts, but it’s not just a pot-pourri of jolly tunes; the ‘academic’ bit of the title allows Brahms to engage in some complex and elaborate counterpoint too.) Still, in 1880 Brahms, then on his familiar summer holiday at the fashionable resort of Bad Ischl, a spa town in Austria, began to conceive of a companion piece to the first overture. This became the ‘Tragic Overture’, Op 81. There’s a regularly-quoted remark by Brahms in relation to these two works. As he said to his first biographer, ‘One weeps; the other laughs.’ And, commenting further, he said (though take all such comments by Brahms very much tongue-in-cheek), ‘I simply could not refuse my melancholy nature the satisfaction of composing an overture for tragedy.’ It appears that Brahms had no particular tragedy in mind, and in fact he changed the title during the process of composition from ‘Tragedy Overture’ to the rather more abstract ‘Tragic Overture’. (He had a similar struggle with the title of the companion work. He wrote to a friend at the time, ‘I used just to dislike my music; now I dislike the titles too’!) In effect, the ‘Tragic Overture’ is like a movement from a symphony. The CD liner notes for the performance I’ve got are a little too fulsome, perhaps, but worth quoting: ‘a larger piece than its companion but made from much less material, close-packed, massy, full of event, stubbornly new and challenging, lofty in style, immensely powerful in impression.’ In fact, if it’s not too ‘pseuds’ corner’, I’d like to quote another comment that seems to me to come close to the point of this work. The Brahms scholar Walter Niemann wrote: ‘The fleeting touches of thrilling, individual emotion in this overture are not to be found in conflict and storm, but in the crushing loneliness of terrifying and unearthly silences in what have been called “dead places”.’ Now, all this might lead you to think that this overture is hard work, but, honestly, it’s not. It does have a stormy and turbulent quality, right from the two hammer-blow chords with which it opens, and even though there’s a brief ray of sunshine in the overture’s second theme on the violins, it is quickly overwhelmed by further upheaval. So, not a ‘light’ piece by any means – but one whose dark tones feel like an almost Beethovenian ‘wrestling with fate’. As for a performance, YouTube contains several that I’d be really happy to live with, but there’s an especially rugged and powerful one from the Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra, Amsterdam, conducted by Herbert Blomstedt. You’ll find it here: Brahms: Tragic Overture
Day 510: Symphony No 3 (Time: 37 minutes)
Today (4/10/24), I want to focus on one of the works being played by the Hallé Orchestra at the first concert of the season in Sheffield City Hall, which will take place later this month. On the programme is Brahms’ Symphony No 3. Although there’s been plenty of Brahms on this list to date – eight pieces, in fact – it’s well over six months since the last selection, so it’s about time we had some more. In terms of symphonic Brahms, I chose the 3rd and 4th movements of the Symphony No 4 back on Day 426, but haven’t explored any of the previous three symphonies. So today it’s the turn of his 3rd Symphony. The four symphonies have different characters. The first is rugged and Beethovenian, the second sunny and genial, and the fourth stark and granite-like. In comparison, the Symphony No 3 is the gentlest of Brahms’ symphonies, a work of mellow, autumnal moods by and large. This quality of understatement can sometimes lead to it being undervalued, and of the four it’s probably the one that gets played the least. You can sense its restraint in the orchestration: although the symphony uses trombones, they play only about 15% of the time. (There’s also a double bassoon … but only in the first movement.) It’s a work from 1883, which meant a gap of something like five years from its predecessor (the 2nd, by contrast, emerged only 12 months after the Symphony No 1). Brahms spent the summer months of that year composing on holiday in the spa town of Wiesbaden, and the premiere took place in Vienna in December 1883 – when, startlingly, the concert was disrupted by demonstrations by the pro-Wagner faction in Vienna. It’s a matter of record that Wagner articulated a strong animosity towards the music of Brahms; Brahms, in contrast, seems to have quite liked Wagner’s music, and promoted it – particularly the opera ‘Tannhauser’ – generously. But the Vienna of the later 19th century was musically very tribal; like some football rivalries of our own day, you had to be for one side or the other. Sitting on the fence did not seem to be an option. It’s hard to imagine that anything about this lovely, subtle music could have so riled some members of the audience. Other fellow composers were in no doubt about the work’s quality. Dvorak wrote to the publisher he and Brahms shared: ‘I say without exaggerating that this work surpasses his first two symphonies; if not, perhaps, in grandeur and powerful conception, then certainly in beauty.’ Elgar, then starting out on his own journey as a composer, wrote of this piece, ‘I look at the Third Symphony of Brahms, and I feel like a pygmy.’ One unusually personal quality of the piece (Brahms was otherwise surely the composer of the most purely ‘abstract’ music in the second half of the 19th century) is that it contains a ‘motto’ theme. This was a fashion of the times. Brahms was close friends with the famous composer-violinist Joseph Joachim, whose musical motto was ‘frei aber einsam’ – ‘free but lonely’, or, in terms of musical notes, F-A-E. Brahms, in contrast, identified himself as ‘frei aber froh’, ‘free but glad’, and the F-A-F pattern (or sometimes, given the music’s ambivalence in places, its minor key equivalent, F-Ab-F) echoes throughout this symphony. (Sometimes I wonder about Brahms’ determined insistence on his happiness at being ‘free’, especially given the intensity of some of his unrequited love affairs in his younger days. Still, by the 1880s, he was almost defiantly committed to his ‘bachelor’ lifestyle.) The symphony is in the traditional four movements. Although three of the four of them are marked either ‘Allegro’ or ‘Allegretto’, this is rarely fast music. Its pace is unhurried, and, in the finale, where you might expect Brahms to let his metaphorical hair down, the music is initially solemn – this is the point where we spend most time in F Minor rather than F Major – and when it does reach its final bars it comes to a glowing and serene halt, rather than anything more triumphant. Before that, the first movement not only plays with the tension of the major/minor ambiguity, but also teases listeners with its rhythmic patterns: sometimes splitting bars into two groups of three beats, and sometimes three groups of two beats, so that we never settle with any certainty into one pattern or the other. The second movement is a lovely and even rapturous Andante, mostly sunny, but with hints of cloudy skies, which will be more characteristic of the sweet yet melancholy third movement. If you know nothing of this symphony, it’s quite possible that you know this third movement in other guises from other contexts. It seems to have been pillaged regularly as a pop music melody (from Frank Sinatra’s ‘Take my Love’ and Serge Gainsbourg’s ‘Baby Alone in Babylone’ to Carlos Santana’s ‘Love of my Life’ and Stevie Wonder’s ‘Part-Time Lover’) – I suspect Brahms would have been spinning in his grave. The theme from the third movement has also been used in more films than I have space to list here, from the 1946 film noir ‘Undercurrent’ to the 2013 film ‘Kill Your Darlings’, about the younger days of Kerouac, Burroughs, Ginsberg et al. (I also love the bit in the ‘Fawlty Towers’ episode where Sybil Fawlty tells Basil to stop ‘listening to that racket’, to which he replies, ‘Racket?! That’s Brahms! Brahms’s Third Racket!’) In terms of performances on YouTube, there are a good many video recordings which stand up to repeated listening. I don’t have any special reason for selecting this recording in particular, but I like this reading from the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Andrés Orozco-Estrada, which is followed by lots of applause. You’ll find it here: Brahms: Symphony No 3
Day 528: Variations and Fugue on a Theme by Handel, Op 24 (Time: 27 minutes)
Brahms' ‘Variations and Fugue on a Theme by Handel’ is being performed tomorrow evening here in Sheffield by Tim Horton, so that’s the reason I’m exploring it today (7/2/25). We’ve had lots of Brahms on this list before, which is only right given how utterly, utterly wonderful his music is. (You’re allowed to disagree mildly with that assessment, but never in my company!) From previous choices, I’d particularly point you in the direction of what I wrote on Day 279 about his Variations on a Theme by Haydn, because during that discussion, I made much of the fact that Brahms is surely the greatest writer of variations in the history of music. (Possibly not the greatest single piece of music in variation form, or devotees of Bach or Beethoven might take issue; but the composer whose output contains so many sets of variations, all constructed with that perfect balance of heart and head that is Brahms’ special gift to musical posterity.) Brahms was, like so many great composers of the 19th century, initially famous as a performer rather than a composer, and he seems to have been an exceptional pianist. But he wrote for the piano all his life, and exceptional stuff it is too. Three of his first five ‘opuses’ are piano sonatas (after which he never published another one!) and at the other end of his career you’ll find the four sets of late piano pieces, Op 116-Op 119. I’d probably argue that those late works are the pinnacle of Brahms’ piano music, a distillation of all his musical and spiritual wisdom into tiny fragments of pianistic contemplation which speak with such understatement yet say so much. However, between the two ends of his creative life what you’ll find in the middle, in terms of his piano works, are a good many sets of variations, and out of those the Variations and Fugue on a Theme by Handel, Op 24 is generally regarded as the greatest. Brahms wrote it in 1861, or at the point where you might see him emerging from the early ‘saviour of German music’ phase (quite a burden for Schumann to saddle him with) and beginning to find a compelling and confident voice in everything he wrote. He dedicated the piece to Clara Schumann (‘To a beloved friend’ … though as is well known the relationship between the two was, well, complicated): apparently she performed it (not an easy task!) at a soiree which Brahms attended, but after it, she wrote, ‘Johannes, however, hurt me very much by his indifference. He declared that he could no longer bear to hear the variations, it was altogether too dreadful for him to listen to anything of his own and to have to sit by and do nothing. Although I can well understand this feeling, I cannot help finding it hard when one has devoted all one's powers to a work, and the composer himself has not a kind word for it.’ This says lots more about Brahms’ emotional incompetence than his view of the piece – later he wrote elsewhere, ‘I am fond of it and value it particularly in relation to my other works.’ The basis for the variations is a movement from Handel’s Harpsichord Suite No 1, a movement in which Handel himself subjects the theme to a set of variations. Brahms wrote insightfully about what attracted him to particular subjects for variation treatment: ‘In a theme for a [set of] variations, it is almost only the bass that has any meaning for me. But this is sacred to me, it is the firm foundation on which I then build my stories. What I do with a melody is only playing around ... If I vary only the melody, then I cannot easily be more than clever or graceful, or, indeed, [if] full of feeling, deepen a pretty thought. On the given bass, I invent something actually new, I discover new melodies in it, I create.’ Compare this with other 19th century composers’ approach to variation form, and you’ll see instantly how deeply and with what complexity Brahms worked out his ideas in this field. It’s also striking how attached Brahms was to ideas from the past. So, we don’t just have an early 18th century theme, but we also have variations that employ patterns and rhythms of that earlier age – a siciliana, a musette, a canon, a fugue. The 24 variations have been sub-divided in many different ways by musicologists, and to be honest I don’t think it matters whether we see them falling into three groups of eight, or 12 sets of alternating pairs, or whatever. There is, as you might expect, constant variation, particularly that idea Brahms discussed about finding ‘new themes’ in the original theme’s bass line. The crowning glory of the work is the final fugue, a huge and mesmerising achievement, where what we actually have are variations on the variations, alongside the final recollection of Handel’s original theme. So trust me – this is something very special indeed. As for a performance, YouTube has several that would suffice, but I particularly like this one by the winner of the 2006 Leeds International Piano Competition, Sunwook Kim. (He performed in the finals of that competition with the Halle and Sir Mark Elder, and later they made an excellent recording of both Brahms’ Piano Concertos.) You’ll find his performance here: Brahms: Variations and Fugue on a Theme by Handel, Op 24
Day 542: Violin Sonata No 3 (Time: 21 minutes)
Today (13/6/25) I’m featuring a work from a concert at this year’s imminent Bradfield Festival. I’ve devoted ten previous editions of this playlist to the music of Brahms, because, as I’ve noted many times, his music, with its perfect blend of head and heart, is in many ways the pinnacle of 19th century Romantic composition … and it’s also music that I love passionately. Those earlier choices have covered some chamber music (the Piano Trio No 3, the String Sextet No 1 and the Clarinet Sonata No 1) but so far nothing for violin and piano. Brahms wrote three violin sonatas. Actually, I should correct that: Brahms allowed three violin sonatas to be published in his name. As you may know, Brahms was fastidious to the point of being obsessive about exercising extreme quality control over his writing, and he appears to have destroyed almost as much music as the extant stuff that he left us with. There’s evidence in his correspondence of work on four violin sonatas that we now have no music for, before finally, in 1879, by then in his mid-40s, he published his first violin sonata. It might have been the appearance of his Violin Concerto, which was warmly received the year earlier, that finally convinced Brahms that writing for the violin was something that he might have mastered! Nearly a decade later, and in quick succession, he wrote two more such sonatas, and it’s the final one, the Violin Sonata No 3, Op 108, that is being played in Bradfield. That opus number is indication enough that this is mature Brahms: his planned final published work – a set of canons for female chorus – was labelled Op 111, so his Op 108 is clearly almost a ‘last work’. (As you might know, it was discovering the playing of the clarinettist Richard Mühlfeld that triggered Brahms’s late, great ‘Indian summer’, initially music for clarinet in various chamber combinations, but subsequently sets of mesmerizingly pure solo piano music, a handful of songs and a set of organ preludes – another dozen opus numbers in total.) Still, however you calculate it, the Violin Sonata No 3 is late Brahms – which means you get the (hopefully) familiar concise structure with no flab, and an intensity of argument that means that even though this is barely more than 20 minutes long, its compression makes it feel much more substantial. Its key – D Minor – is not all that common in Brahms, but he used it for his early, sweepingly romantic Piano Concerto No 1, a real ‘calling card’ to the world, and also for the tempestuous Tragic Overture (see Day 457). The sonata is in four movements – his other two sonatas had only three movements – and it’s not unreasonable to think there’s something almost ‘symphonic’ going on here, albeit in compressed form. Brahms began work on it in 1886, finishing it two years later, and it got its first performance, with Brahms at the piano, later in 1888. The first movement is the longest of the four, and it begins with a stormy-sounding violin theme over an agitated piano accompaniment. The second theme is a bit sweeter, a kind of arching melody, but it’s not a movement that relaxes all that much, until suddenly, right at the end, that urgent minor key theme turns up in the major, and it’s like the sun suddenly coming out! If the first movement was intense, the second is tender and lyrical. Those people (can there really be any?) who struggle to find Brahms tuneful should listen to this movement a few times, with its lovely, gentle ‘song without words’ melody, like a kind of slow waltz. Into a span of under five minutes it takes you from tenderness, through things more shadowy and turbulent, before finding its resolution again in a peaceful conclusion. The third movement is shorter still – barely three minutes in most performances – and this time the piano dominates. Brahms wasn’t big on writing full-blown scherzos in the manner of Beethoven (the one in his 4th Symphony stands out because of its rarity value), instead preferring something more like a gentle intermezzo, as here, which is propelled by the piano’s rhythmic insistence but never to the point where we feel we’re being shouted at! The finale, meanwhile, is typical too: Brahms making it at least as complex as the first movement, so that the ‘weight’ of the work falls here as much as at the beginning. It’s marked ‘Presto agitato’, and it feels a bit like a tarantella (and of course we all know how it feels to be bitten by a tarantula!), with the piano particularly relentless. Actually, there’s a kaleidoscopic array of changing moods here, sometimes rashly tempestuous, sometimes with a hymn-like calm, sometimes moody in the vein of Brahms’ immensely popular Hungarian Dances, but the tarantella material is never far from the forefront. The closing bars are tumultuous, very emphatically in D Minor, bringing the work to an explosively driven conclusion. YouTube has videos of some nice concert performances of this work, and there quite a few that I could happily live with. However, out of the options I’ve chosen this one, by the American violinist Joshua Bell, accompanied by his fellow American Jeremy Denk on piano. You’ll find it here: Brahms: Violin Sonata No 3
Day 589: Horn Trio in Eb, Op 40 (Time: 29 minutes)
In recent instalments, I’ve been exploring pieces of music being played at this year’s Sheffield Chamber Music Festival and today (8/5/26), I’m looking at a trio. The trio in question features in a concert on the penultimate evening of the festival, when members of Ensemble 360 will be performing a work by Brahms. Brahms wrote three piano trios (that is, works for three performers playing violin, cello and piano), a clarinet trio (clarinet, cello and piano, written near the end of his life as part of the ‘Indian summer’ of chamber works inspired by the playing of clarinettist Richard Muhlfeld) and then one other piece for a trio of performers, the Horn Trio, Op 40. It’s this last piece that turns up in Ensemble 360’s concert, and is my focus for today. If you’ve had more than a passing acquaintance with this list over the years, you’ll know how very special the music of Brahms is for me, and that it moves me in ways that aren’t really true of any other composer, except maybe Schubert. He’s not generally what you’d call an innovative composer in the sense of breaking new ground; it’s more often the case that he took existing forms and structures and worked his magic on them. However, the Horn Trio is a bit of a curiosity, in that many discussions of it give the impression that nobody had written one until Brahms came along. Without wishing to spoil a good story, I don’t think that’s quite true, in that pieces for horn, violin and piano do exist in the repertoire before this work, but they’re pretty obscure. The earliest I’ve been able to track down is by Jan Ladislav Dussek (not to be confused – see Day 453 – with Franz Xaver Dussek), who wrote a ‘Notturno Concertante’ for these forces as early as 1809. The first to write a work that takes the sort of approach we’d expect of a piece labelled ‘Horn Trio’ is by that wonderful innovator Carl Czerny (see Day 493), a composer who deserves a lot more limelight than is currently the case. Czerny’s Trio No 1 of 1827 is for the same forces that Brahms wrote for, and is a substantial three-movement work. All this hasn’t stopped Brahms’ Horn Trio being described as the first of its kind, presumably because it established itself almost immediately in the repertoire of 19th century horn players, and is clearly one of Brahms’ major chamber works. One curiosity of the piece is not so much its scoring as the fact that it was written for a ‘natural horn’ (in German, a ‘waldhorn’), an instrument without valves, so that if you wanted to play a note that wasn’t part of its natural harmonic scale – in practice, you had a choice of only 16 notes – you could only do it by stuffing your hand to a greater or lesser extent in the bell of the instrument. Brahms would have heard his musician father playing such an instrument regularly as a child. Valved horns (Ladybird Book of Musical Instruments summary: ones that could play a full range of notes equivalent to chromatic scales on a piano) began to appear in around 1815, though it was only about thirty years later that composers began routinely to write for them. Brahms’ Horn Trio was begun in 1865, so Brahms was being distinctly ‘retro’ in writing the work for the natural horn. Apparently, he preferred the sound of the natural horn, considering it more ‘authentic’ and (an important consideration) reminiscent of the musical sounds of his childhood, which, in terms of this work’s genesis, was particularly important. Nobody knows for sure what prompted the work, but he began to sketch it only three months or so after the death of his mother in February 1865. A lot of time is often spent trying to pry under the surface of Brahms’ rather curmudgeonly personality, particularly in terms of his relationship with women. There’s obviously the long-running saga of his connection with Clara Schumann, and the 1860s and 70s featured at least one abortive love affair that he’d hoped would lead to marriage. But there are grounds for saying that the woman he was closest to in his life was his mother, and her death (she was taken suddenly ill and died before Brahms could get from Vienna to Hamburg to see her) caused him great grief. It was on a kind of retreat in the Black Forest in the summer of 1865 that he finally began to come to terms with his distress, and to turn it in a musical direction. Its most powerful expression is in this trio, particularly the first and third of its four movements, which are poignant and nostalgic. The four movement form (slow/fast/slow/fast) occurs nowhere else in Brahms’ chamber output, and seems reminiscent of the ‘church sonata’ structure of 18th century chamber works by Corelli and the like, which again gives the piece a kind of ‘backward-looking’ feel. The first movement is an oddity in Brahms’ chamber compositions – his only first movement not in sonata form, with its rigorously worked-out formal structure. Instead it consists simply of two themes, alternated in an A-B-A-B-A way. The first theme is a close relation of one of Brahms’ favourite folk songs as a child, ‘In der Weiden steht ein Haus’ (‘In the meadow there stands a house’) – more nostalgia! The primary use of the horn, historically, was as a ‘hunting’ instrument, and in the faster movements Brahms writes strikingly in this vein. So, the second movement’s outer sections are dominated by a fanfare-like theme, enclosing a lovely, mellifluous folk-like middle section. The emotional heart of the piece is its ‘adagio mesto’ (‘sad adagio’) third movement – not, in some simplistic way, a ‘funeral march’, but nonetheless a deeply introspective, intensely felt movement, a musing on mortality that never tips into sentimentality or mawkishness. It was, contemporary references made clear, an elegy for his mother. The finale, another brisk, fanfare-led movement, clears the air and rounds off the work in vigorous high spirits. Its scoring was, as I’ve said, unusual – which might explain why Brahms also prepared a performing edition in which the cello replaces the horn (so that it’s scored like a conventional piano trio), and why later still he sanctioned the publication of a version in which the viola takes what had been the horn part. But in its horn/violin/piano form it strikes an (almost) unique note in 19th century music, and it is, I think, a masterpiece! (But then I would, wouldn’t I…?) There are many really quite impressive video recordings of the piece on YouTube. Almost everyone these days plays it on a ‘modern’ valved horn, but if you want to hear what the work sounds like on the natural horn, there’s a good performance, played by Javier Bonet on horn, with Mario Pérez on violin and Miriam Gómez-Morán on piano, which you’ll find here, but after listening to a few performances elsewhere on YouTube, I’d finally recommend this one, by one of the contemporary legends of the horn, Radovan Vlatkovic, alongside Jakub Haufa on violin and Ilya Rashkovskiy on piano. You’ll find their performance here: Brahms: Horn Trio in Eb, Op 40
Bretón, Tomás (1850-1923)
Day 570: String Quartet No 3 - 1. Allegro comodo (Time: 10 minutes), 2. Andante (6 minutes), 3. Allegro no mucho (7 minutes) and 4. Allegro deciso (5 minutes)
Today (26/12/25), for my final posting of the year, I want to mark (as last week) the 175th anniversary of a composer’s birth. This time out, the composer in question is Tomás Bretón. Who he? You may well ask. He’s not what you’d call a famous composer, though he was undoubtedly that in his time, at least within the somewhat parochial world of late 19th/early 20th century music in Spain. I’ve developed a mild curiosity about him since discovering one of his more flamboyant orchestral works, ‘Salamanca’, whilst disappearing down an online rabbit hole in search of other Spanish composers of the period. Is his music worth your consideration? I hope so… and at any rate, I’ll spend a little while here trying to make a case for it. So, Tomás Bretón (1850-1923) was born on December 29th, which means his 150th anniversary falls this coming Monday. From a brief trawl of the interweb, there’s not a lot of biographical detail out there beyond the basic outline. He was born in Salamanca, began to develop a reputation as a violinist from an early age, and by his mid-teens he had moved to Madrid to study performance and composition at the Conservatory there, funding himself by playing in theatre orchestras around the capital. He wrote much (I suspect essentially to pay his way) in the popular Spanish genre the ‘zarzuela’ – which regular visitors to Spanish restaurants might know as a kind of stew, often with lots of seafood, but which is also the name of a kind of musical genre that’s a bit closer to a musical or a folk opera than a regular opera. They were (and are) immensely popular in Spain, and Bretón wrote one of the most famous of them, ‘La Verbena de la Paloma’ (‘The fair of the Virgin of La Paloma’), which seems to have been an instant hit not just in Spain but all over the Spanish-speaking world. This was in 1894, and in many ways it made Bretón’s reputation (and financial security). However, he also had aspirations to write in more statusful genres, and devoted a lot of his creative life to operas, of which he wrote nine. He was also very active as a musical administrator – he became director of the Madrid Conservatory from 1901 onwards, and in that sense you can see his story as one of the inexorable rise of the provincial outsider arriving at the heart of the musical establishment. In later years his fame as a composer began to wane somewhat, and certainly by his death in the 1920s his ‘serious’ music was all but forgotten – and it’s really only in the past couple of decades that more of it has begun to appear on disc and online. The appeal of Spanish music has largely been a niche thing, with occasional exceptions when some figures emerged into the European mainstream, largely from the decades after Bretón’s generation: Albeniz was a decade younger than him, Granados 17 years younger, de Falla (the one truly breakout star) 26 years younger. Later still of course you’ve got people like Turina or Mompou or Rodrigo … but even so they tend to be written about as being on the margins of European ‘classical’ music, perhaps because Spain itself is on the margin of the continent. Anyway, if you dig around enough in Bretón’s back catalogue, you’ll find him (like so many others across Europe of his generation) trying to balance a respect for ‘tradition’ – which tended, regardless of an individual’s geographical origin, to mean ‘Germanic tradition’ – and the rather more flamboyant assertiveness of local music that gave pride of place to national forms, melodies and idioms. It would perhaps be fair to say that people like Turina put their emphasis on nationalism; others, like de Falla, retained their ‘Spanishness’ but looked to integrate themselves with more modern trends, especially those coming out of France. Bretón’s route was to steer a kind of middle course, and maybe it’s the fact of being ‘neither one thing nor the other’ that has led to his music falling out of favour. I wondered about what to choose to give a flavour of this rather neglected figure. He wrote three symphonies, but the echoes of Beethoven and Mendelssohn are louder than the sounds of anything individual in them, I think (though the 3rd is interesting and worthwhile). In the first decade of the 20th century he wrote a fair bit of chamber music: three string quartets, a piano quintet (which uses the same basic musical material as the Symphony No 3), and a sextet for piano and winds. Of these, I think the most interesting is the String Quartet No 3, a substantial work in four movements dating from 1909. I think this is more than just a curiosity, largely because in it you can hear the tension I’ve suggested exists in his work between mainstream European tradition and local colour. As far as I can tell it seems to have had only two performances in Bretón’s lifetime, a premiere in 1910 and another outing in 1913. He did adapt its third movement into a piece for piano trio, which he called his ‘Scherzo Andalou’, and which has the fantastic tempo marking ‘Allegro no mucho’! The quartet’s first movement has Mendelssohn’s thumbprints all over it, though glimpses of Spanish colour break through from time to time. The second movement Andante is the lyrical core of the work, with its long, winding, rather mournful melody. Then, after the previously mentioned scherzo, the finale, marked Allegro deciso, is both ‘academic’ in approach (a nice fugal section) but also quite original, with a distinctively Spanish feel. Sadly, YouTube offers no video performances of this piece, and it’s not even possible (as far as I know) to get the whole quartet via one online link, so I’m going to have to post this out as four separate links, one to each movement. Sorry. Anyway, here it is, Bretón’s String Quartet No 3 in E Minor, played by his namesakes, the Bretón String Quartet: Breton: String Quartet No 3 - 1. Allegro comodo, 2. Andante, 3. Allegro no mucho and 4. Allegro deciso
Brian, Havergal (1876–1972)
Day 346: Brian: 'Legend' for Violin and piano (Time: 7 minutes)
Today (25/11/22), my posting marks an anniversary – in this case the 50th anniversary of the death of one of the most eccentric British composers of the 20th century, which will occur this coming Monday, 28th November. So, let’s start with one of those general musical knowledge questions: who is the most prolific British symphonist? Of well-known composers, one might think of Vaughan-Williams (who wrote nine) or Peter Maxwell Davies (10)… but then when one gets off the beaten track, you’ll find Edmund Rubbra or Robert Simpson (both 11), George Lloyd (12), the somewhat less well-known Michael Garrett (13) or James Douglas (15) … and then there’s the 18th century symphonist and astronomer William Herschel (24, when he wasn’t busy discovering Uranus, as the tiresomely sniggering schoolboy joke has it), that modern British minimalist John White (25), the immensely prolific 18th century figure John Marsh (39), or (deep breath) the even more implausibly prolific 20th/21st century composer Derek Bourgeois (114!). Of course, globally that pales into insignificance beside the Finnish conductor and composer Leif Segerstam (350 and counting, I believe – he may have added a few more while I’ve been typing this). All of which trivia is really to set the scene for today’s composer, Havergal Brian (1876-1972), who composed 32 symphonies during his long life. However, to put that figure into context, his first symphony, ‘The Gothic’, on which he worked for many years, was completed in 1927, when he was already 50 years old. By the time he’d reached 60 years old, that symphony count had reached four; by the time he was 70, he’d written five; by 80 he’d written 11; and then in the last 16 years of his life he wrote another 21 symphonies! It is of course fair to question whether the works of someone who produces so much are likely to be any good, or whether the quantity/quality axis is tipped permanently in favour of the former. I don’t propose to answer that question in relation to Brian, largely because I only know a tiny proportion of his output, but what I’m prepared to put my neck on the line to say is that as a composer he’s ‘interesting’, and definitely not to be dismissed. He was born, unusually for a 19th century composer, into a working-class family with few musical connections. His name at birth was William Brian. The ‘Havergal’ seems to have been adopted by him at a young age as a tribute to the family of Victorian writers of hymns, of whom Frances Ridley (‘Take My Life and Let It Be’) Havergal is probably the most famous today. The work that, as it were, turned him on to music was Elgar’s now quite obscure oratorio ‘King Olaf’, which Brian heard in 1896. In 1907 he was ‘adopted’ musically by a local Potteries businessman, who gave him £500 a year – decent money in those days – to become a full-time composer. Brian doesn’t appear to have been the easiest person to get along with, and seems to have looked a fair few gift horses in the mouth over the years. Retiring in 1940, he then gave himself entirely to composition, with the prolific results I’ve already mentioned. In the 1950s he was championed by the composer (and BBC producer) Robert Simpson – see above – and one of the quirkiest details of Brian’s career is that in 1973 the then 91-year-old conductor Leopold Stokowski conducted the first performance of the then 87-year-old composer Brian’s Symphony No 28. However, that pales into insignificance beside the fact that Brian’s Symphony No 1, begun in 1919, was finally given its first (amateur) performance in 1961, and finally got its first Proms performance in 2011. It lasts a mere 105 minutes(!), and is scored for a very (very) large symphony orchestra, four extra brass ‘orchestras’, four solo singers, four large adult choirs and, just in case more were needed, a massed children’s choir. There are some clips of that Proms performance on YouTube, though not the whole symphony, if you want to know what almost 1000 performers sound like. All of which might make my choice of a piece of music by Brian seem a bit perverse, but rather than just give you a snippet of one of his large-scale works, I’d like to illustrate his music with what is in fact his only known surviving piece of chamber music. In 1919 (though it’s not clear that the work was composed then or whether it was revived from an earlier point in his life) Brian wrote a short single-movement work for violin and piano called ‘Legend’. He revised it a few times over the following years, though it didn’t get its first performance until 1975. At this summer’s Proms, the violinist Alina Ibragimova and her regular pianist partner Cédric Tiberghien performed the work, only the ninth performance ever of any music by Brian at the Proms. It’s a short work, and has a typically ‘late Romantic’ feel, though it’s characteristic (in technique rather than scale) of much of Brian’s music, with its abrupt shifts of mood and changes of tempo. In its short span it encompasses dramatic minor-key episodes and more lyrical major-key passages. The violin is clearly the lead instrument, though in the stormy middle section (some suggestion here that it was prompted by Brian’s response to the First World War) the piano is almost overwhelming. The work ends quietly – not perhaps in consolation but in exhausted relief. Unsurprisingly, performances of ‘Legend’ are few and far between. The choice I’ve made for today is an audio-only recording by the violinist Jonathan Stone, accompanied by pianist Sholto Kynoch, which you’ll find here: Brian: 'Legend' for Violin and Piano
Bristow, George Frederick (1825-98)
Day 568: Symphony No 2 ('Jullien') (Time: 44 minutes!)
If my previous posting was prompted by a suggestion from within our Playlist community, I’m pretty sure that nobody is going to request, nor is likely to mention, the name of George Frederick Bristow to me in relation to this list. You may decide, on the basis of hearing some of his music, that there are good reasons for this, but I want to spend today (12/12/25) examining the life and music of Bristow, not just because it’s obscure (and obscure things deserve their place in the spotlight now and then) but also because – within limits – it seems to me that he wrote quite interesting music. For those who’ve never heard of him before, I should say that George Frederick Bristow (1825-98 … so the 200th anniversary of his birth comes up next Friday) was an American composer, the son of a musician whose family had arrived in America from England in the early 1820s. There are, as it were, musicians and musicians. Mr Bristow senior was not, if you like, just ‘a jobbing musician’, but an influential figure in the developing music scene in New York in the first half of the 19th century. Thus Bristow grew up in a musically and artistically cultured society, taking music lessons not just from his father but from other members of the New York Philharmonic Society (the organisation that eventually morphed into the New York Phil) as he grew up. You could argue that fate had marked his card by the fact that he was named ‘George Frederick’ – his parents’ nod in the direction of Mr Handel, and all that he stood for. Bristow joined the string section of the New York orchestra as a teenager, and apart from a short period caused by an ideological spat (more in a minute) he remained with the orchestra, acting as music director for a time in the 1850s, until he retired. Bristow was a great promoter of American music – not just as a performer (he played piano and violin, conducted choirs and other vocal groups, and played in chamber music ensembles) but also a journalist and writer about music, and of course as a composer. The ‘spat’ referred to above came about because the American composer WH Fry fell out with a couple of influential critics because he felt they unfairly scorned one of his compositions, and Bristow joined the debate, arguing that American musicians and critics should do more to advocate for American composers. Bristow’s list of compositions is pretty extensive, even if not a lot of it has been recorded yet. There are five symphonies, two operas, a handful of oratorios, some almost completely overlooked chamber music, and popular songs. His earliest symphony dates from 1848, and as you might expect both from the date of composition and the relative youth of the composer, it’s a quite derivative work, with an awful lot of Mendelssohn and Beethoven in its DNA. The last of the five (‘the Niagara’) dates from almost half a century later, and it’s a grand affair for orchestra and chorus. Between the two, Bristow’s style evolved, though in an essentially ‘conservative’ idiom. It might seem odd to note this of a self-professed advocate of ‘American’ music, but Bristow’s language is largely that of Mendelssohn and Schumann, and he’s certainly on that side of the great divide in Germanic music, rather than lining up with Wagner and Liszt. I have one CD of Bristow’s music (I imagine this is one more than anyone else on this list), and I have to say that I’m quite fond of it. It pulls up no trees, perhaps, but it’s attractive and imaginative in a slightly cautious way. I’m going to break my own ’40 minute rule’ (again! – what is the world coming to?) here to select Bristow’s Symphony No 2, the ‘Jullien’, which was commissioned in 1853 from Monsieur Jullien (a French musician who set up an orchestra in New York to rival that of the Philharmonic Society), though it had to wait until 1856 for its first performance. It’s in the familiar four movements, with the scherzo placed second. The ‘Allegro appassionato’ first movement has an imposing and dramatic opening leading to a brooding main theme, and then a contrasting major key second melody which is more wistful. The movement proceeds to develop these ideas in ways that suggest Bristow had spent a lot of time studying Beethoven. The scherzo is Mendelssohnian (the aforesaid WH Fry called it the symphony’s ‘best hit’, and even the critic RS Willis – with whom Fry had fallen out, above – called it ‘cleverly worked and of pleasing effect.’ These critics, eh?) I actually quite like the Adagio third movement, which explores its three different themes and develops them with some imagination. The finale is perhaps more bluster than substance, though it does interesting (Schubertian?) things with its three trombones. It should surprise you not at all to discover that there are absolutely no video recordings of Bristow’s orchestral music, so we’re in wall-to-wall audio-only territory here. The recording of the symphony I’ve chosen is, in fact, the one that I own, by the Royal Northern Sinfonia conducted by Rebecca Miller. You’ll find it here, and you can listen while admiring the painting of a suitably pastoral American landscape that, alas, I’m unable to name: Bristow: Symphony No 2 ('Jullien')
Britten, Benjamin (1913-76)
Day 82: Four Sea Interludes (from ‘Peter Grimes’) (Time: 17 minutes)
This morning (12/6/20), in keeping with the overall mood of damp mistiness, I thought a bit of East Anglian scene painting might do the trick, so today we have the Four Sea Interludes from ‘Peter Grimes’, by Benjamin Britten. Britten (1913-76), born in Lowestoft and enduringly associated with Suffolk throughout his life, was the principal British composer of the middle decades of the 20th century. His style is very distinctive (and shaped in large measure by his close professional and personal association with the tenor Peter Pears, for whose voice he wrote so much), but equally it’s hard to imagine that his sound world, like that of, say, Shostakovich, could have existed had Mahler not gone before him. Britten has some claim to being the closest to a child prodigy that these islands have ever produced, and he established himself internationally during the 1930s. In his twenties he was, like many others, politically involved, being deeply affected by the Spanish Civil War and the rise of fascism, and during this period he was heavily influenced, both politically and in terms of his sexuality, by the poet WH Auden. It seems likely that it was the departure of Auden and the writer Christopher Isherwood for the USA, along with the problematic position for committed pacifists like Britten in Europe at the time, that led Britten and Peter Pears to leave for America in 1939. The stay in America lasted only three years, however, and it appears that, amongst other things, it was reading the poetry of the 18th century writer George Crabbe, notably his collection of poems set in Suffolk called ‘The Borough’, that awakened Britten's homesickness for his native landscape. He said later: ‘in a flash I realised two things: that I must write an opera, and where I belonged’. From Crabbe's poems, it was the narrative poem ‘Peter Grimes’ that most fired Britten's imagination, and it’s probably fair to say that his opera ‘Peter Grimes’, from 1945, is the work that cemented his world-wide fame. The opera takes Crabbe's central character, Peter Grimes, and makes what was a simple villain into someone psychologically complex, who is cruel because the society around him is cruel to him. Britten summarised it thus: ‘ a subject very close to my heart — the struggle of the individual against the masses. The more vicious the society, the more vicious the individual.’ The opera was an immense critical and popular success, and from it, Britten extracted a stand-alone concert suite, a sequence of ‘interludes’ which, in the opera, introduce the time and place of the subsequent action. Britten took four of these moments: ‘Dawn’, with its morning stillness and crying gulls, all bleak and watery; ‘Sunday Morning’, the prelude to Act 2, with church bells and lively interaction of the villagers; ‘Moonlight’, the introduction to the last act, with its sinister, brooding sense of menace; finally ‘Storm’, which, with its violence, sweeps the piece to a tempestuous ending. YouTube is a good source of performances of this work, and I’ve gone for the version played by the BBC Symphony Orchestra, conducted by a very young-looking Edward Gardiner, from the Proms, back in 2010. You’ll find it here: Britten – ‘Four Sea Interludes’ (from ‘Peter Grimes’)
Day 149: A Ceremony of Carols (Time: 23 minutes)
Today (29/12/20), another Christmas suggestion from Pete Dutton,
and one that I’m very glad to include because it’s been a favourite of mine
since it was on the O-level Music syllabus which I studied many decades ago.
The piece is Benjamin Britten's ‘A Ceremony of Carols’, written in 1942
and a product of the dark days of the second world war, not that you’d
know it from the musical world it inhabits. Britten has appeared on this
list once before – see Day 82, above, when I explored the Four Sea Interludes from
‘Peter Grimes’. I won’t repeat, therefore, much general biographical information,
beyond saying that early in 1939, Britten (and Peter Pears) left for America,
largely as a consequence of the darkening political climate in Europe.
However, three years later they set out on the return journey,
motivated particularly in Britten's case by the call of East Anglia and the
desire to write an opera (which was to be ‘Peter Grimes’) after the inspiration
of reading the poetry of George Crabbe. Part of Britten's reading matter
on the voyage home was an anthology, ‘The English Galaxy of Shorter Poems’,
many in Middle and Early Modern English (roughly 1150-1650). It seems extraordinary
to me, given the constant threat of death on the Atlantic crossing, that from
that volume Britten composed this series of short choral pieces that seem to
come from another world entirely. The piece was originally written for
three-part children's choir, accompanied by harp, though subsequently Britten
produced an arrangement for conventional four-part choir, which is how ‘A
Ceremony of Carols’ ends up in the repertoire of so many amateur choirs.
However, the requirements of the original intended performers mean that the
piece, whilst not simplistic, is very direct and without too many complex
technical challenges. ‘A Ceremony of Carols’ sets nine poems, bookended
by the Gregorian chant ‘Hodie Christus natus est’ (which we have met quite
often these past few days) which functions as processional and recessional
music (though the final movement is omitted in the performance I’ve chosen
below), and – in the middle of the work – an Interlude for solo harp. The
oldest texts date from the early 1400s – ‘Wolcum Yole’, introducing guests to
the Christmas feast, ‘There is no Rose’, a text in praise of Mary who gave
birth to Jesus, and ‘As dew in Aprille’, which is likewise a product of the
era's veneration for the Virgin Mary. The most recent texts are by the
Elizabethan poet (and Catholic martyr) Robert Southwell – ‘This little babe’,
an animated and increasingly complex tour de force which is often performed
independently, and ‘In freezing winter night’, an atmospheric evocation of the
disharmony surrounding Christ's birth leading to hope for the future because of
it. The harp's role in the whole work is incredibly inventive – far more
than mere accompaniment. As for a performance, I’ve gone for something rather
left-field here. The original scoring, for boys’ choir, means there are
many performances by Anglican choir schools and the like, and you could chase
one of these up for contrast if you wished. You can also hear what adult
voices sound like in polished performances by the likes of The Sixteen.
However, keeping with the intended idea of a performance by younger singers,
I’ve chosen this recording by La Maitrise de Radio France (the Choir School of
Radio France), a mostly female choir of young voices, conducted by Sofi
Jeannin, with Iris Torossian playing the harp. I’m really taken by the
quality of the singing: the precision of attack and overall tidiness of
ensemble are really impressive, given that it’s such a large choir.
You’ll find the performance here: Britten:
A Ceremony of Carols
Day 186: Suite on English Folk Tunes, ‘A Time There Was’) (Time: 15 minutes)
Today (7/5/21), the composer under the spotlight is Benjamin Britten, and the work I want to home in on was one of the last he composed before his death in 1976. Britten has appeared twice before on this list (see Days 82 and 149), so what I wrote on those occasions should help fill in any necessary biographical detail. What I think is worth exploring today is Britten's attitude to folk songs and their treatment by 20th century composers, because there’s an interesting contradiction here. On the one hand, during his early years, and perhaps influenced by the fact that his teacher Frank Bridge introduced him to ‘modernist’ musical trends in continental Europe in the first couple of decades of the 20th century, Britten seems to have had an enduringly dismissive attitude to what might be called the English Pastoral School of composers (notably Vaughan Williams, but also figures like Howells, Moeran, Finzi and Ireland): for Britten, this was the Cow Pat School of musical composition. However, this doesn’t seem to have been a dismissal of folk music as such, as the basis for a composition. He was particularly enthusiastic about the folk-based works of Percy Grainger (see Day 164) for example. And, heavily influenced by his urge to write for the voice of his partner Peter Pears, he produced eight volumes of Folksong Arrangements from the British Isles and France for voice and piano (and occasionally guitar and harp) – generally speaking rather bare settings which concentrate on the clear vocal line of the songs, backed by a somewhat sparse and occasionally harmonically disruptive accompaniment. Which brings us to today’s piece, the Suite on English Folk Tunes, ‘A Time There Was’, which dates from 1974. Britten had major heart surgery in 1973, suffering a stroke in the course of the operation. Unsurprisingly, he was both physically frail and emotionally depressed afterwards, and his return to composition was halting. However, in 1974, he was reminded of a short piece for wind band, based on the folk song ‘Hankin Booby’, which he had written in 1966 for the formal opening, the following year, of the Queen Elizabeth Hall in London, where Britten conducted the inaugural concert. In the summer of 1974, Britten went back to that brief isolated piece and decided to add others to it, producing a five-movement suite. Unlike the approach of Vaughan Williams in such compositions, Britten barely states the folk themes explicitly at any point in the work; instead the themes are partially quoted and then developed in Britten's idiosyncratic way. The movements are ‘Cakes and Ale’, ‘The Bitter Withy’, ‘Hankin Booby’, ‘Hunt the Squirrel’ and ‘Lord Melbourne’. The piece is ‘lovingly and reverently dedicated to the memory of Percy Grainger’, who had died in the early 60s, and who was the source for the folk song that dominates the final movement. Britten took the title of the suite, ‘A Time There Was’, from Thomas Hardy's poetry collection ‘Winter Words’, which Britten had set a couple of decades earlier. The music is quite bitter and gruff in the first four movements, but the final and by far the longest movement is poignant and almost serene. The way the music closes is a kind of peaceful death – without getting too metaphorical here, one can see in this work Britten's own farewell to life. If you’d like some pre-performance listening, there’s a very short introduction to the work from the conductor Rumon Gamba here. As for a performance, there’s a tolerably good 1980s video recording (love those hairstyles!) on YouTube by the Sydney Symphony Orchestra, conducted by John Hopkins. You’ll find it here: Britten: Suite on English Folk Tunes, 'A Time There Was'
Day 277: Sinfonia da Requiem, Op 20 (Time: 19 minutes)
Today (22/3/22), we have another (perhaps rather tenuously linked) piece of music for Lent. Benjamin Britten has appeared three times so far on this list (see Days 82, 149 and 186), and today’s fourth appearance is on the basis that his Sinfonia da Requiem qualifies as a ‘Lenten’ piece by virtue of its employment of not just the titles of parts of the Requiem Mass, but also the fundamentally lamenting (though finally perhaps consolatory) nature of the music. It is, one might say, notwithstanding its movement headings, a ‘secular’ requiem. The piece has a complicated back-story, which I’ll summarise. In 1939 Britten, a committed pacifist, had emigrated briefly to the USA (‘For the moment I’m stuck here,’ he wrote in 1940), in response to the war in Europe. At that point he was approached by the British Council to compose a work for the festivities associated with an anniversary of a ‘reigning dynasty’ of an unspecified foreign power. Enigmatic, you might say. It turned out that the foreign power in question was Japan, and the piece was to celebrate the 2600th anniversary of the foundation of the Mikado’s dynasty by Jimmu Tenno in 660BC. It seems that Britten may have misinterpreted the intention to commission something ‘in memory’ of Japan’s first Emperor as requiring something more funereal rather than celebratory, but in the event, having sent off the score of the work, he subsequently received a blunt rejection from the Japanese authorities, who claimed the piece was unsuitable on account of its Christian programme and fundamentally melancholy nature. One might think that as a pacifist, Britten would not want to be associated with the then overtly militaristic regime in Japan (though in 1940 Japan had not actually entered the Second World War on the side of the European fascist powers); in any case, after the attack on Pearl Harbor in December 1941, relations between Britain and Japan were severed, and the work’s initial Japanese connection ceased to matter … although curiously it wasn’t until 1987 that the original score, which had been sent to Japan and never returned, was rediscovered. There is, however, another level to this work: Britten’s inscription at the head of the piece is ‘In memory of my parents’, who had both died when he was in his early twenties, and whose loss he felt very deeply. He was only 26 when he wrote this, and the grief is audibly still raw. The Sinfonia da Requiem is in three movements. The first, ‘Lacrymosa’, is a kind of slow lamenting march, built on the obsessive repetition of tiny fragments of theme, and where the pervasive melancholy mood is enhanced by Britten’s use of an alto saxophone. This leads without a break into the most dramatic (indeed, vicious) of the movements, a ‘Dies Irae’. ‘A form of the Dance of Death’, is how Britten described it: its brass fanfares lead into a kind of chillingly mechanistic march, and, eventually, to an almost complete disintegration of the musical texture – some of the most daring music Britten had composed to date. Out of the ruins of that movement, we get to the finale, ‘Requiem Aeternam’, a hymn-like song of something which provides a kind of tranquility, but maybe borne of exhaustion rather than peace. You can hear the fingerprints (can one hear fingerprints?) of Mahler all over this music, but also, I think, a hint or two of Alban Berg, whose Violin Concerto Britten had heard the first performance of, and which had impressed him greatly. As for a performance, there’s a good one from the BBC Symphony Orchestra conducted by Thomas Adès, given at the 2013 BBC Proms. You’ll find it here: Britten: Sinfonia da Requiem, Op 20
Day 468: Three Divertimenti for String Quartet (Time: 11 minutes)
Later this week, the four string players of Ensemble 360 are playing some relatively early Benjamin Britten in a concert in Sheffield, and it’s his piece that is my choice for today (2/4/24). We’ve had four pieces of Britten on this list already (see Days 82, 149, 186 and 277), consisting of the lovely ‘A Ceremony of Carols’ and three substantial orchestral works, the Four Sea Interludes from ‘Peter Grimes’, the Sinfonia da Requiem and the late Suite on English Folk Tunes, ‘A Time There Was’. Today the focus shifts to Britten’s chamber music, a strand that was never his major preoccupation (that was opera) but one which marked the two extremes of his life. Much of this material tends to be either from really early or really late in his career. For instance, the 1960s and 70 saw the production of his three solo cello suites, as well as solo works for guitar and harp, and the last of his three numbered string quartets. At the earlier end of his career you’ll find several now largely neglected works for string quartet (an unnumbered quartet from 1928, his Rhapsody for quartet from 1929, the Quartettino from 1930, another unnumbered quartet from 1931, and an ‘Alla Marcia’ for quartet from 1933); alongside those there are two pieces for solo viola written while he was still in his teens, and his Phantasy Quartet, Op 2 (oboe replacing the second violin) from 1932. At this stage in his career, though he was evidently a child prodigy when it came to composition, he was still finding his authentic voice. As many will know, he had music lessons early in life from Frank Bridge, whom he met in 1927 when just 13 years old. Bridge’s sage advice at that point: ‘you should find yourself and be true to what you found.’ This ideal was tested over the next few years, first as an unhappy boarder at Gresham’s School in Norfolk (1928-30) and then at the Royal College of Music (1930-33) where he studied, seemingly unrewardingly, with John Ireland. Britten’s cautious retrospective view of Ireland’s contribution was that he ‘nursed me very gently through a very, very difficult musical adolescence.’ It’s hardly a ringing endorsement. But it’s at this point – 1932-3 – that Britten’s composing career began in earnest, with a flurry of works including the Sinfonietta, Op 1, the choral variations ‘A Boy was Born’ and a set of songs called ‘Friday Afternoons’. Also from this time is the work I’ve chosen for today, the Three Divertimenti for String Quartet (1933, revised 1936). These had an unhappy start in life. They began as a series of character portraits for a suite for string quartet that Britten originally planned to call ‘Alla Quartetto Serioso’, with the subtitle ‘Go play, boy, play’ (a quotation from Shakespeare’s ‘The Winter’s Tale’, a seemingly chirpy enough subtitle, though Leontes, the central character, says it to his young son just before he accuses his wife of adultery and chaos breaks out as a result). It was going to be a series of five portraits of Britten’s school friends. However, by 1933 Britten had completed only three of them, and these were given their first performance that year. It did not go well. Three years passed before Britten revised the work, retitling it ‘Three Divertimenti’, and taking the personal details out of the titles of the movements, which now became ‘March’, ‘Waltz’ and ‘Burlesque’. That second performance was also disastrous. Britten wrote in his diary that it was met with ‘sniggers and cold silence’, and the result was that Britten (particularly sensitive at that age to bad reviews) withdrew the work completely, and it only reappeared after his death in 1976. It seems likely that Britten’s sensitivity about the work was at least in part caused by the personal relationships he had with what had been the first and third character portraits as they were back in 1933 before Britten set about anonymising things. The opening March was originally a portrait of a friend from his time at Gresham’s, David Layton (who also appears, alongside a self-portrait, in Britten’s Two Portraits for String Orchestra from 1930). The final movement ‘Burlesque’ was originally called ‘Ragging’ (public school bullying), and was a portrait of Francis Barton, with whom Britten was very close during his time at boarding school. There are photos of the two of them arm-in-arm and clearly very comfortable in each other’s physicality. I don’t think one needs to be too much of a part-time psychoanalyst to see this formative relationship (when Britten was still exploring his sexual as well as social identity) as very important to Britten – hence the pain he felt when the music was so summarily dismissed when played in public. It should be said that in the decades since Britten’s death the little pieces (taken together they come to just over 10 minutes) have become considerably more popular, and particularly so as a kind of appetiser at the start of a concert. The first movement, ‘March’, is an early example of a form that Britten used a lot throughout his life, alternatingly brisk and sardonic. The second movement is ‘Waltz’, charming, relaxed and really quite tender. Finally there is the ‘Burlesque’ movement, an energetic ‘moto perpetuo’. YouTube has a lovely performance of this early Britten work given by the wonderful Danish String Quartet in America in January 2023. You’ll find it here: Britten: Three Divertimenti for String Quartet
Day 580: Variations on a Theme of Frank Bridge (Time: 27 minutes) and Courtly Dances (from 'Gloriana') (11 minutes)
Today (6/3/26), I want to highlight two works by probably the foremost British composer of the middle years of the 20th century. I suspect that for many, if we take the longer view, Vaughan Williams has now eclipsed Britten as the 20th century British composer, but there was a time – say from the 1930s to the 70s – when Britten was regarded as the principal creative figure from these islands, particularly on the international stage. Later this month, there are two opportunities to catch works by Britten in orchestral concerts at the City Hall, and as they’re both easily able to be fitted within our notional ‘40 minute rule’, I’m going to feature both of them in today’s discussion. We’ve had five pieces by Britten on this list already, so I’m not about to rehearse substantial biographical stuff about Britten here – if you want more context, check out those pieces from Days 82, 149, 186, 277 and 468. On the English Chamber Orchestra’s programme later in the month will be Britten’s Variations on a Theme of Frank Bridge. Although Britten’s name and reputation had been advancing steadily since his breakthrough works from the early 1930s – the Phantasy Oboe Quartet, the choral piece (still very popular with amateur choirs) ‘A Boy was Born’ and the early set of songs ‘Friday Afternoons’ – it was really the Frank Bridge Variations that put Britten on the international map. His first meeting with Bridge came in 1927 when Britten was a mere 11 years old, and Bridge took him on as a private composition pupil almost immediately. In that sense, Bridge functioned very clearly as Britten’s mentor, both personally and musically, and Britten’s sense of debt to the older composer remained for the rest of his life. For example, it was at Bridge’s prompting that Britten gained his first substantial job, as a composer for the BBC Film Unit, in 1935 when he had completed his studies at the RCM. These middle years of the 1930’s were very fertile for Britten, alongside some key events in his personal life (the death of his mother, and his first meeting with the man who would be his life’s companion, Peter Pears). The key work in making Britten’s name at this time was the set of Variations on a Theme of Frank Bridge. In May 1937 the conductor Boyd Neel, who had a renowned string orchestra under his baton, was invited to bring three works to that year’s Salzburg Festival – with a key stipulation being that one of the works should have been previously unperformed. Britten wrote the piece very fast, in around 10 days for the first draft, and it was ready for its first performance at the Salzburg Festival in August the same year. It’s a set of ten variations (the last a fugue leading to a finale) on a theme taken from one of Bridge’s ‘Three Idylls’ for String Quartet. What makes this piece so wonderful can be summarised in two ways. Firstly, Britten insisted that each of the variations illustrated an aspect of Bridge’s character: the Adagio represented Bridge's integrity; the March was his energy; the Romance his charm; the Aria Italiana his humour; the Bourrée his tradition; the Wiener Walzer his enthusiasm; the Moto Perpetuo his vitality; the Funeral March his sympathy; the Chant was his reverence; the Fugue was his skill (it contains a number of references to other works by Bridge); and their mutual affection appears in the Finale. But, alongside this, if you like, private set of allusions, Britten also revealed the richness and diversity of his imagination in exploring, in each of the variations, aspects of European classical music from the past and the (1930s) present. So, you’ll find imitations/parodies of Rossini, say, or Ravel or Stravinsky. What’s also interesting is how Britten’s irony, which he often wore as a kind of mask to hide deeper emotion, is present even in this early work. For example, the March (Variation 2) is exaggeratedly military, which is at odds with Bridge’s avowed pacifism. Similarly, the Funeral March (Variation 8) is dedicated to Bridge’s ‘vitality’, a sorrowing lament of death for a person brimming with life. The final Fugue is a musically academic tribute to the man who taught Britten so much, but the piece ends, pretty evidently, with an outpouring of love. There are plenty of decent performances of this work on YouTube, and from them I’ve chosen this one by the reduced forces of the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra directed by Duncan Riddell, given in 2021 under social distancing conventions. You’ll find the performance here: Britten: Variations on a Theme of Frank Bridge. Also in Sheffield this month, the first work on the Halle’s programme will be Britten’s Courtly Dances (from his opera ‘Gloriana’). I thought this was worth a brief look, simply because it’s an interesting glimpse into the way Britten’s career developed from the pre-Second World War days when he was first making waves. By the end of the war, and especially with his opera ‘Peter Grimes’ of 1945, Britten had established himself as the leading British composer. In the years that followed his reputation as an opera composer achieved greater heights, and he began to be commissioned as a kind of ‘establishment’ figure, writing music that had a distinctly public role. These two aspects came together in 1953 when he was commissioned to write an opera to celebrate the coronation of Queen Elizabeth II. The result was ‘Gloriana’, and it was, to put it bluntly, something of a disaster. Some of that is clearly because it was at odds with the national mood. It’s about Elizabeth I – an ageing Elizabeth I and the end of her relationship with her one-time favourite the Earl of Essex. Britten made a set of ‘complete recordings’ of his work for Decca, but it pointedly didn’t include ‘Gloriana’, and it wasn’t recorded at all until the 1980s. Though the opera disappeared, Britten rescued from it two orchestral pieces. There's a 25-minute Concert Suite, which gets a very occasional outing, but from within that suite there’s the roughly 10-minute ‘Courtly Dances’, a kind of pastiche of the Elizabethan musical idiom of the late 16th century. The critic Arnold Whittall noted that ‘Britten's imaginative use of allusions to Elizabethan dances and lute songs create not only local colour but also a sense of ironic distance from the 20th century.’ Irony again, you see. For me, it’s one of the defining characteristics of Britten’s music. Not that that makes his work insincere. It's just that ‘mask wearing’ – notably in relation to the emotionally repressed Britten’s complex relationship to the public expression of his homosexuality – was, if you like, baked into the man and his music. Anyway, if you want to listen to a recording of the Courtly Dances on YouTube, it's an audio-only experience, I'm afraid. This is a slightly stodgy performance of the dances, given by the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra again, but conducted here by André Previn: Britten: Courtly Dances (from 'Gloriana')
Bruch, Max (1838-1920)
Day 323: Eight Pieces for Clarinet, Viola and Piano, Op 82 Nos. 2, 6 & 7 (Time: 14 minutes)
Today (6/9/22), it’s time to welcome yet another new composer on this list, good old Max Bruch (1838-1920). That appellation might seem somewhat patronising, but I don’t mean to be; what I mean is, Bruch seems to me to be one of those composers who is generally regarded quite benignly, known for (at most) three works, but someone who was never really going to set the musical world alight. He was (and I definitely don’t want this to seem to be pejorative!) one of music’s conservatives (small ‘c’!). The fact that he lived to 1920 meant that, by that point, he was most definitely a musical anachronism, in that nothing he produced really showed any awareness of (or at least attraction to) what had been happening in the musical world since about 1880 – you’ll find no echoes of Debussy, or Stravinsky, or Bartók, or Schoenberg, or any of the other composers busy rearranging the musical landscape of the era. He was something of a child prodigy (though we’re not talking about being in the Mozart or Richard Strauss league here), and was backed in his musical education by his family, so there were no conflicts about his future career. After graduating, he held conducting and teaching posts across a range of German cities and (from 1880-83) in Liverpool as the conductor of the Liverpool Philharmonic Society, where his tenure appears to have been pretty successful. He taught composition from 1890-1910 at the Berlin Hochschule fÜr Musik, before retiring and spending his final decade quietly composing – there is no evidence in his late work of the horrors of the First World War going on around him at the time. I’ve mentioned previously how German music of the mid-to-late 19th century was essentially an extended arm-wrestling match between Wagner and his advocates on the one hand and Brahms and his followers on the other. Bruch very definitely falls into the latter camp. In fact, it is one of the recurring frustrations that Bruch mentions in letters that his compositional career was overshadowed by that of Brahms through the 1870s and 80s. (I don’t want to suggest anything amiss here: Brahms is the greater composer by several orders of magnitude.) However, what this means for Bruch’s work is that it tends to consist of pieces that attract the sorts of descriptions that feel, one might say, a little underwhelming. The liner notes to one of the CDs I have of his music comments on his ‘extraordinary taste and refinement’, and the fact that ‘he consistently produced works of professional finish and great beauty.’ It’s all, one might say, very nice. Of course, the work for which Bruch is still rightly renowned is his Violin Concerto No 1 (he wrote two others, which are as rare as hen’s teeth in the concert hall), which he wrote in 1866 and revised a couple of years later; it pre-dates Brahms’ Violin Concerto by over a decade, and it’s easy to see where Brahms got at least some of his ideas from. If you want to dig deeper, you’ll find three impressive symphonies from the 1860s-80s, three orchestral suites from the early years of the 20th century, some lovely short concertante works (notably the lyrical ‘Kol Nidrei’ for Cello and Orchestra, which was once very famous indeed), and an awful lot of choral music which is now largely gathering dust in archives but which was the basis of Bruch’s reputation during his lifetime. Then (you can pick up my musical preferences here as elsewhere on this playlist) there’s some very fine chamber music: four string quartets, two string quintets, a piano trio, a piano quintet, a string octet à la Mendelssohn … and then also today’s work, his Eight Pieces, Op 82, for Clarinet, Viola and Piano. He wrote these in 1910, with the apparently excellent clarinet playing of his son (also Max) in mind. The pieces are interesting, in that compositions for this combination of instruments are very rare (at least, until quite recently – there’s a bit of a vogue for them these days): Mozart’s ‘Kegelstatt’ Trio is a bit of a one-off, Schumann wrote a piece for these forces in the 1850s, and there’s Bruch and Carl Reinecke in the period around 1900, but that’s really it. Bruch never intended the work to be played in its entirety – the full set of eight pieces lasts 35-40 minutes in performance – but rather he assumed performers would pick a handful of pieces to suit the occasion. That being the case, what I’ve gone for today is a video recording of the superstar clarinettist Martin Fröst, playing alongside the equally renowned viola player Amihai Grosz and pianist Itamar Golan playing three of these little gems. So here you get No 2: Allegro con Moto; No 6: Nachtgesang (Andante con Moto); and finally No 7: Allegro Vivace, ma non Troppo. What I love about these pieces is the luscious sound-world they inhabit, a consequence of the specific instrumentation. It’s all very rich and glowing. You’ll find the recording here: Bruch: Eight Pieces for Clarinet, Viola and Piano, Op 82 - Nos. 2, 6 and 7
Bruckner, Anton (1824-96)
Day 64: Symphony No 7 (3rd movement) (Time: 11 minutes)
As the weeks have passed, I have been aware that the original 15-minute ‘rule’ (honoured perhaps more in the breach than the observance, as the Prime Minister might have said in a press conference) has stood in the way of exploring the work of some of those composers most renowned for large-scale symphonies, since it feels a bit brutal to serve up a single movement in isolation and thereby damage the ‘meaning’ that that movement has in relation to the whole work. Still, unless we go down that route (as today – 25/5/20), you may never get to hear any Bruckner or Mahler – and our lives would undoubtedly be poorer as a result. So, with apologies for the fact that in so doing we deprive Anton Bruckner (1824-96) of the impact of the whole ‘cathedral in sound’ (Compendium of Musical Cliches, Vol 1) that would be achieved if you heard the entire piece, here is the third movement of Bruckner's Symphony No 7. Bruckner's symphonies owe a lot to Wagner in terms of their harmonic language, but more maybe to Schubert in terms of their simultaneous expansiveness and relentlessness. His ‘scherzo’ movements (usually placed third) tend to be fierce and rhythmically-driven affairs, with something simpler and more ‘rustic’ for the central ‘trio’ section. I love the third movement of Symphony No 7 especially for that sonorous downward stamping of the lower brass towards the end of each repeat of the outer sections of the movement (just after 3'30", for example, in the version I’ve chosen). This performance is by Gunter Wand and the NDR Symphony Orchestra, thrilling even though sound and image are slightly out of sync, and you’ll find it here: Bruckner – Symphony No 7 (3rd movement)
Day 221: Mass No 2 in E Minor (Time: 15 minutes)
Anton Bruckner (1824-96) has featured once before on this list (see Day 64, when I posted the Scherzo from his Symphony No 7), and as I observed at the time, it’s difficult, with a playlist rationale like ours has, to do justice to a composer like Bruckner, whose works make their impact in large measure by their immense scale. Bruckner is known primarily as a symphonic composer, and after several decades of neglect after his death, it’s now the case that all his symphonies from the 4th Symphony onwards are staple items in most orchestras’ repertoires. (I’m passing over the fact that Bruckner's popularity in Nazi Germany – he appears to have been one of Hitler's favourite composers – kept his name alive earlier in the 20th century. He obviously couldn’t have known something like that would happen, and given both his intense Christian faith and his gentleness of personality, he would undoubtedly have been appalled to be associated with fascism.) Despite the fact that his character is often portrayed as both naïve and unworldly – a familiar quotation about him is the 19th century conductor Hans von Bulow's comment that he was ‘half genius, half simpleton’ – as a composer, he was capable of constructing music as rich and technically complex as any of his peers. If he had a besetting character weakness, it was that he was very insecure and lacking in confidence about his work, and thus prone to taking to heart any criticisms of it (from his friends as much as his musical opponents – and in Bruckner's Vienna, you were either a follower of Wagner, as Bruckner was, or of Brahms, and much vitriolic comment came Bruckner's way as a result). The consequence of all this is that Bruckner was constantly revising, redrafting and editing his work – many of the symphonies exist is three or four versions, for example. However, this week, I want to consider other areas of Bruckner's output, starting today (7/9/21) with his church music. There isn’t quite the same ‘multiple versions’ issue here as there is in relation to the symphonies, though the piece for today exists in at least two versions. Bruckner wrote a number of church pieces as a ‘young’ composer, though the term is relative, in that he didn’t really hit his stride as a composer until he was well into his forties. There are three mass settings plus a requiem mass from his early years, but in terms of performance these days, the three ‘mature’ masses of the 1860s are the ones that tend to see the light of day. Of these, the first and third are evidently ‘concert’ works, settings for soloists, choir and a full orchestra, but the Mass No 2 in E Minor is somewhat different. There are no solo singers, and the eight-part choir is accompanied by an ensemble of 15 wind instruments (oboes, clarinets, bassoons, horns, trumpets and trombones). It’s possible that this scoring was evidence that Bruckner primarily wrote the work for an ecclesiastical setting. The piece was written in 1866, and then reworked (as I’ve noted, a familiar tale) in 1882: it is the later version that is almost always performed today. There is, as the liner notes to my box set of the complete Bruckner masses observe, no fundamental difference between the style and texture of Bruckner's symphonies and the style and texture of his major choral works. Themes tend to be shaped and developed in the same sorts of way. Touchingly, when asked why it had taken him so long to reach this mature style, he replied, ‘I didn’t dare to before’. One other influence, in relation to the Mass No 2, is worth a mention: that of Palestrina, respect for whose compositional skills united all warring factions in Vienna's music scene. Bruckner quotes from Palestrina's ‘Missa Brevis’ in the ‘Sanctus’ section. For me, this short movement is particularly compelling. In it, a two-part canon is wrapped round in eight lines of counterpoint, and built into a formidable climax in a way typical of Bruckner's symphonic work. As for a performance, I’m quite taken by the concert recording of the work given in Cologne by the winds of the WDR Symphony Orchestra and the WDR Chorus, conducted by Stefan Parkman. You’ll find it here: Bruckner: Mass No 2 in E Minor
Day 222: Intermezzo for String Quintet (Time: 4 minutes)
A look at the list of Bruckner's compositions reveals some very obvious points of focus, and then some equally obvious blank spots. He is known mostly these days for his nine symphonies (well, eleven, if we count the ‘Symphony No 0’ and the ‘Symphony No 00’, both ‘practice’ works from his period of study in his thirties/forties). There is a handful of other orchestral works, but all products of this early, relative immaturity. He’s also extensively represented in the field of sacred choral music, as we saw last time: in addition to the numbered masses, there are mature settings of the Te Deum, Psalm 150 and a large number of short, unaccompanied sacred motets. What’s less well known is that he also wrote a considerable amount of secular choral music, mostly ceremonial or triumphal settings for public occasions. There are some rarely played piano pieces, but virtually all of these come from the ‘Study Book’ he kept when taking lessons in composition from one Otto Kitzler in the early 1860s. (To put this in context, Bruckner was nearly 40 at the time. It’s difficult to think of another major composer who was still, as it were, ‘going to school’ at that age – and so lacking in confidence in his own ability.) Which brings me to Bruckner's chamber music, which you could easily fit onto two CDs. In this period of study in the 1860s, he wrote a string quartet, which was not rediscovered until 1950(!), alongside a handful of short compositional exercises for the same forces. But then, at a time when he was reaching evident maturity as a symphonic composer (around the time he was writing and rewriting his 4th and 5th Symphonies), we find another composition that is unique in Bruckner's output, a String Quintet. Now, there are somewhat polarised views about this work, from those who see it as a substantial and original contribution to the authentic late Romantic chamber music repertoire, to those who see it as ‘a symphony for just five string players’. For what it’s worth, I think it’s only in the final movement (and maybe only in the last five minutes or so of that movement) that you might feel that Bruckner is trying to write a grand ‘orchestral-style’ apotheosis for forces that can’t cope with these demands. Curiously, the violinist Joseph Hellmesberger, for whom the work was written, took violently against the Scherzo second movement of the work, and refused to play it. It says something for Bruckner's almost paralysing lack of self-confidence that even in 1879, in his mid-fifties, he immediately set to work and wrote a shorter, gentler replacement for that movement. This is the Intermezzo for String Quintet, which is my music choice for today (10/9/21). It did not receive its first performance until 1904, and was not recorded until 1956. It uses the same Trio middle section as the Scherzo that it was written to replace, but the spiky, leaping theme of the original Scherzo is replaced by something closer to the genial Austrian ‘landler’, a slow dance in three/four time. The whole movement is very short, which is why I can programme it alongside the Mass No 2 this week and still get under to ’40 minutes maximum’ for the total playing time of the music I’ve chosen! Unsurprisingly, there aren’t many performances of the Intermezzo around, but there is a video recording on YouTube by the iPalpiti Soloists, given at their chamber music festival in Los Angeles in 2012. You’ll find the recording here: Bruckner: Intermezzo for String Quintet
Day 505: Symphony No 6 (1st movement) (Time: 16 minutes) and Locus Iste (4 minutes) and Psalm 150 (10 minutes)
September 2024 is a peak month for musical anniversaries, and although it’s not September yet, the first of these anniversaries will come round during the next seven days – next Wednesday, 4th September, when it will be 200 years to the day since the birth of Anton Bruckner (1824-96). We’ve had three appearances by Bruckner on this list to date, but today (30/8/24) I’m going to pick out three pieces (well, two whole ones and one extract) to mark this landmark anniversary of one of the 19th century’s greatest and most original composers. It appears, mystifyingly (to me), that there are still people who don’t like Bruckner, and I really hope these selections will erase any lingering doubt about his music if there are still sceptics out there. First, let me take you back in time – so, your phone/tablet/laptop screen goes all misty and fuzzy in that time-honoured way TV programmes have of showing flashbacks, and when things come back into focus it’s the autumn of 1974, and your correspondent is an innocent(ish!) 16-year-old, just starting Music A-level, an enthusiast for the subject, but someone with, at the time, very conservative (small ‘c’) tastes. I had never heard any music by Bruckner, because, illogically, I thought I wouldn’t like it. But part of doing A-level Music was going to as many concerts as I could in Manchester, to see the Halle at the old Free Trade Hall, and the BBC Northern Symphony Orchestra (as it then was) in studio recordings at the BBC’s Oxford Rd premises, and also going to concerts at the RNCM to hear the student orchestra going through its paces. In this last category I went to the RNCM one autumn evening in 1974, and Bruckner’s Symphony No 6 was on the programme for after the interval. I contemplated leaving at half time because, of course, I knew I wouldn’t like the second half. But I stayed … and the experience, as they say, blew me away. I had never heard anything like this – such power and yet also such spaciousness and serenity. It was, if you like, a Damascene conversion. Later, I came to see that Bruckner’s 6th has some notable differences from his other symphonies – its first movement is more direct, more rhythmically driven, and it grabs you from the outset. It’s still not possible to provide a link to a whole Bruckner symphony and stay under the ‘no more than 40 minutes per week’ limit, so what you’ve got here is just that first movement. (If you’re grabbed, seek out the rest on YouTube!) The performance I’ve chosen is by the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Paavo Järvi. If you can listen to the link on some halfway decent sound equipment, then whack up the volume and prepare to be thrilled. You’ll find it here: Bruckner: Symphony No 6 (1st movement). The cliché about Bruckner is that everything is on an epic scale. The symphonies certainly are, but Bruckner also wrote a considerable amount of music for the church (his Catholicism is often described as naïve, but it was undoubtedly sincere), and so the second piece I’d like to share today is tiny, simple and beautiful. This is the motet ‘Locus Iste’. This dates from 1869 (for comparison, the 6th Symphony is from 1881). Bruckner had been organist at the Old Cathedral in Linz, Austria, from 1865-88, and in the 1860s work began on a new cathedral there. The first section to be completed, a ‘votive chapel’, was finished in 1869, and for its opening Bruckner set the text based on Genesis Ch 28, the story of Jacob’s ladder, in which Jacob remarks, ‘Surely the Lord is in this place.’ The text reads as follows: ‘Locus iste a Deo factus est, inaestimabile sacramentum, irreprehensibilis est.’ (An approximate translation: ‘This place was made by God, a priceless sacrament; it is without reproach.’) It’s a piece that Escafeld Chorale, the choir that I sing with, has performed a couple of times since I joined them – from which you may infer that it’s not that difficult to sing! I thought I’d choose a performance by somewhat more accomplished performers, however, so here is the renowned choir Tenebrae, with their director Nigel Short. You’ll find their recording here: Bruckner: Locus Iste. And finally, something from the other end of the choral scale. The last of Bruckner’s sacred choral works dates from 1892, not long before his death. It’s a setting of Psalm 150, which, as most people on this list will know, is a vivid and celebratory text full of praise to God. It is, though, despite its sacred text, very definitely a piece for the concert hall – it demands a soprano soloist (though she only sings 11 bars of music), a mixed chorus and full symphony orchestra. After a string of ‘Hallelujahs’, it lists reasons, locations and instruments for articulating praise to God. After the soprano’s interjection, the ‘Hallelujahs’ return, followed by an elaborate fugue and a final, ringing ‘Hallelujah!’ The performance I’ve chosen is by the Spanish Radio and Television Orchestra, conducted by Miguel Ángel Gómez- Martínez, and the soprano soloist is Natalia Labourdette. You’ll find the recording here, preceded by about a minute’s worth of introductory chat … in Spanish: Psalm 150, for Soprano, Chorus and Orchestra
Bryars, (Richard) Gavin (b1943)
Day 45: ‘Jesus’ Blood Never Failed Me Yet’ (Time: 5 minutes)
Today's instalment (6/5/2020) is a suggestion from Malcolm for a bit of ‘found music’/minimalism that has evolved into several different variant forms over the decades since it was first performed in 1972, and subsequently appeared on LP in 1975. The composer is Gavin Bryars, and the piece is ‘Jesus' Blood Never Failed Me Yet’. The original concert/LP version lasted 25 minutes and there have been later versions lasting up to 75 minutes released on CD. Today's YouTube clip, however, is an extract of just under five minutes. The provenance of the piece is interesting. In the early 1970s, Bryars was working on a film about rough sleepers in the area around Waterloo Station in London, and one of the sound recordings (actually unused in the film itself) was of an anonymous tramp singing (pretty much in tune, but in a rhythmically uneven way) the words that formed the title of the piece. Bryars recalls the profound emotional impact that the repeated sound loop of the man's voice had on listeners, and from there evolved a kind of ‘backing track’ in which washes of sound increase in intensity and then die away again behind the singer. The version linked here also includes the voice of Tom Waits, who re-recorded the vocal in the 1990s. You’ll find the piece here: Gavin Bryars – ‘Jesus’ Blood Never Failed Me Yet’
Busoni, Ferruccio (1866-1924)
Day 500: Indian Fantasy for Piano and Orchestra (Time: 25 minutes) and Sonatina No 6 ('Kammer-Fantasie uber Carmen) (9 minutes)
My choice for this 500th posting today (23/7/24) is some music by the magnificently named Ferruccio Dante Michelangiolo Benvenuto Busoni, who died in Berlin on 27th July 1924 – which means that it will be the 100th anniversary of that event four days from now. When you look back at the development of music over the centuries (assuming you occasionally do such a thing), there are clearly composers whose place in the ‘story’ is secure and fixed – they exemplify perfectly the musical language of the day, or they push it on (interesting how we maintain the illusion that change is ‘progress’!) in a new direction which will become the dominant set of conventions for the next generation. But there are other composers who don’t ‘fit’ neatly into such a scheme. Their music is ‘of its time’ without necessarily being important, either at the time or since – but nonetheless they contribute something uniquely their own, rather than producing so many yards of generic ‘stuff’. Busoni, I would submit, is such a composer. He was born in Italy, and (there have been a lot on this list) was an astonishing prodigy as a pianist and composer. First public performance: aged 7. First concerto performance (Mozart’s Piano Concerto No 24): aged 9. He entered the Vienna Conservatory aged 11. (He remarked later, given that some of these ‘firsts’ were a product of ambitious parents, ‘I never had a childhood.’) He was composing, too, from an early age. I have a 3CD set of Busoni’s ‘early’ piano works (I know, I should get out more…), all written long before he reached 18: lovely pieces, bright and sparkly in an accessibly ‘romantic’ idiom … but not, you might say, very individual. (Another retrospective observation of Busoni’s was that he had far too much early work published at the time, and with hindsight regarded anything written before 1898, when he was a comparatively old man of 32, as music that ought to be dismissed.) For almost all his life he was regarded first and foremost as a performer, endlessly touring across Europe, Russia and the USA. He taught, too, having a roster of famous pianists who studied with him, but he also taught (and wrote extensively) about musical theory, history and philosophy. Probably his most famous publication in this field is ‘Sketch of a New Aesthetic of Music’ of 1907, an astonishingly visionary document that foresaw not just atonality and serialism, but the further breakdown of our tonal system into quarter-tones (as in Indian classical music) and even the idea of electronic music. Curiously, for such a theoretical trailblazer, his music was often exotically experimental – but also often much more concerned to be cautiously interested in bringing the music of the past with him into the present. The vast majority of his completed works are, unsurprisingly, for piano, but he also wrote chamber music, some orchestral pieces and his ‘magnum opus’, his unfinished opera ‘Doktor Faust’. I thought I’d mark the imminent Busoni centenary by considering two works. One is a virtual piano concerto. (He also wrote an actual piano concerto – an epic thing in five movements with a choral finale … but then if Beethoven could put a choir into a symphony why shouldn’t Busoni add one to a piano concerto?) Anyway, the not-quite-a-piano-concerto-by-name is his ‘Indian Fantasy’ for piano and orchestra. The musical inspiration here came from a text published by one of his piano pupils, Natalie Curtis, called ‘The Indians’ Book’, in 1907. For pretty much the first time this aimed to depict the culture of Native American peoples as a rich, complex thing (and absolutely not ‘primitive’) – and this cultural richness included the music of many of the Native American cultures. Busoni’s imagination was gripped, and in fairly short order he wrote this piece, which runs continuously but which is in three identifiable sections (‘Fantasia’ – ‘Canzone’ – ‘Finale’). The opening section with its insistent drumming rhythm is based largely on Hopi melodies. The central section is dominated by a song of the Passamaquoddy people which so impressed Busoni that he thought it should become the ‘national anthem’ of the Native American peoples. The finale is based on themes of Hopi and Cheyenne cultures, and it allows a lot of animated interplay between piano and orchestra. YouTube is quite well off for performances of this piece, and from the options, I’ve gone for this slightly elderly (2002) video of a live concert, where the National Symphony Orchestra of Italian Radio and Television is conducted by Daniele Callegari, and the pianist is the Italian Giovanni Bellucci. You’ll find the recording here: Busoni: Indian Fantasy for Piano and Orchestra. Which might be thought to be enough for one posting, but as this is now a once-a-week affair, there’s opportunity for a bit more, so here is one of Busoni’s best-known works for solo piano. Between 1910-21 Busoni wrote six pieces that he called ‘Sonatinas’, which fit the conventional bill in that they’re essentially short works, but if the familiar ‘sonatina’ is an easy or lightweight piece, then Busoni is definitely stretching the definition here. The last of the six sonatinas was composed in 1920 and he gave it the title ‘Kammer-Fantasie über Carmen’. The idea of the piano ‘fantasy’ on operatic themes was largely, I guess, the brainchild of Liszt, whose works in this vein are usually made up of a pot-pourri of themes from an opera treated to some pretty gymnastic fireworks at the piano. Busoni’s ‘Carmen’ Fantasy both does and doesn’t fulfil the expectation. It’s got virtuosity in abundance, but it doesn’t outstay its welcome or degenerate into ‘look at me’ showing off. At its core is a dazzling treatment of the famous ‘Habanera’ from Bizet’s opera. Busoni wrote the piece as a gift for a close friend, Leonhard Tauber, in whose home Busoni was staying in Paris, where he was giving a string of immensely successful piano recitals. YouTube is pretty well stocked when it comes to this work too, and from the many options here is the remarkable young French pianist Emmanuel Despax (though the principal camera angle – the view up the pianist’s right nostril – isn’t hugely helpful): Busoni: Sonatina No 6 ('Kammer-Fantasie uber Carmen')
Butterworth, George (1885-1916)
Day 481: Rhapsody - A Shropshire Lad (Time: 12 minutes)
George Butterworth (1885-1916) is (how often have these words come up?) another of those great ‘might have beens’ of classical music. His life, like that of so many of his contemporaries, was cut short in the slaughter on the Western Front during the First World War. This is perhaps inescapably the lens through which we now look back at Butterworth’s short life, and it colours what went before with the shadings of tragedy. George Sainton Kaye Butterworth (in full) was a Londoner, though his family moved to York just after his birth because his father was moved there as a manager of North Eastern Railway. He had the familiar upper-middle class educational route – private boarding school then Eton then Oxford, where his musical focus was enriched by friendships with Vaughan Williams (with whom he shared folksong-collecting excursions), Cecil Sharp and Adrian Boult. Butterworth was also an expert morris dancer (for a while he was a professional morris dancer; who knew such a thing existed?). After graduating, he worked as a music critic and teacher. In the years before 1914, he composed a handful of works which have become pretty well known: Two English Idylls (1910) for orchestra; a cycle of four poems by WE Henley which he called ‘Love Blows as the Wind Blows’ (1911-12); and a short orchestral rhapsody called ‘The Banks of Green Willow’ (1913-14). The last of these was the final time that Butterworth heard a piece of his own music being performed when it received its London premiere in March 1914. However, alongside these works (and a small handful of other song settings and brief pieces of chamber music) perhaps Butterworth’s lasting legacy is his setting of eleven poems (split across two collections) from AE Housman’s cycle of verse ‘A Shropshire Lad’. These poems (there were 63 of them in Housman’s 1896 publication) have had an extraordinary impact on composers in the years since, and particularly in the two decades that followed their appearance. It’s easy to parody their sentimental yearning, and their feeling of time passing as registered in the mind and experience of the adolescent male who seemed to be its target audience. Nevertheless, the poetry was absolutely and potently of its time. Pretty much every English song composer in the decades that followed responded to their mood, from Arthur Somervell (the first to set some of them) through Vaughan Williams (in his cycle ‘On Wenlock Edge’ and the later ‘Along the Field: Eight Housman Songs’), Ivor Gurney (‘Ludlow and Teme’), Moeran (‘Ludlow Town’), Ireland (‘The Land of Lost Content’) to Lennox Berkeley (‘Five Housman Songs’) and on and on. (I was astonished to discover that there are settings not just by familiar American song composers, like Barber and Rorem, but even Henryk Gorecki had a go at some of them!) As for Butterworth, there are two collections, firstly of six poems (‘Six Songs from “A Shropshire Lad”’) and then another five (‘Bredon Hill and Other Songs’). These occupied Butterworth from 1909-11. However, he also composed a sort of ‘postlude’, an orchestral epilogue to the song settings, that used some of the themes from the songs. He originally thought of calling this work ‘The Land of Lost Content’, and then changed his mind to ‘The Cherry Tree’, before eventually settling on the now-familiar title ‘Rhapsody: A Shropshire Lad’, and it’s this work that I want to focus on today (17/5/24). The main theme of the rhapsody is taken from Butterworth’s setting of the poem ‘Loveliest of Trees’. After a slow introduction in which muted strings sound an A Minor chord, melodies from this poem are combined to reach a passionate climax. The closing section quotes poignantly on the solo flute from another of Butterworth’s Housman settings, ‘With Rue My Heart Is Laden’, the final poem from the second collection. Now, context is obviously important in understanding all art forms, and the personal and historical context for Butterworth's Housman settings and the subsequent orchestral rhapsody mean it’s now almost impossible to hear these works ‘innocently’ any more. We know that Butterworth (along with friends, a characteristic of the time) joined up at the start of the First World War, rising from private to the rank of lieutenant in the Durham Light Infantry, fighting at the Battle of the Somme. He won the Military Cross for gallantry in the summer of 1916 but did not live to be presented with it. On 5th August 1916, fighting with German forces for control of a trench, he was shot through the head by a sniper and died instantly, being buried where he lay. (His body was never recovered for formal burial.) His commanding officer, discovering belatedly that Butterworth had been a promising English composer, wrote of him: ‘a brilliant musician in times of peace, and an equally brilliant soldier in times of stress.’ I doubt that now anyone can hear this powerfully nostalgic work without reflecting on ‘the lads that will die in their glory and never be old,’ lads that included Butterworth himself. Sadly there aren’t any video recordings of performances of this work on YouTube that I’d want to share with you all, so we’re in audio-only territory here. However, in a nod to the City Hall concert tomorrow, here is the performance that the Halle Orchestra issued on CD over 20 years ago, conducted by Mark Elder. You’ll find it here: Butterworth: Rhapsody - A Shropshire Lad
Byrd, William (c1540-1623)
Day 86: ‘Agnus Dei’ (from Mass for Four Voices) (Time: 4 minutes) and ‘Agnus Dei’ (from Mass for Five Voices) (4 minutes)
Today (16/6/20), I thought we should listen to some William Byrd. Byrd (1540ish-1623) was, along with his older contemporary Thomas Tallis (see Day 67), the leading figure in English 16th century vocal and instrumental music. He appears to have converted to Catholicism in the 1570s, not necessarily a move consistent with holding major musical office in Elizabethan England, or indeed with holding on to one's head, but Byrd appears to have had enough friends in high places to have survived. Along with major collections of motets (published as ‘Cantiones Sacrae’ in 1589 and 1591, and ‘Gradualia’ in 1605 and 1607), the pinnacle of Byrd's liturgical music is usually regarded as his settings of the Mass, of which he wrote three in the 1590s. I thought it might be interesting today to compare Byrd's treatment of the ‘Agnus Dei’ in the four- and five-part settings of the Mass. Although these pieces have obvious similarities (they set the same words!), the differences are fascinating – listen, for instance, to the way the words ‘dona nobis pacem’ are treated in the two versions. What I love about Renaissance choral music at its best is the way it is both emotionally expressive and restrained at the same time. These settings by Byrd seem to me to fulfil both of those criteria apparently effortlessly and very beautifully. The ‘Agnus Dei’ from Byrd's Mass for Four Voices is sung by members of The Sixteen, and you’ll find it here: William Byrd – ‘Agnus Dei’ from Mass for Four Voices. The setting of the same words from Byrd's Mass for Five Voices is sung by members of The Gesualdo Six, and you’ll find it here: ‘Agnus Dei’ from Mass for Five Voices
Day 393: Tristitia et Anxietas (Time: 10 minutes) and Ave Verum Corpus (5 minutes)
In this and the following posting, for what I hope will become obvious reasons, I’m featuring the same composer across both editions. So, on 4th July 1623, at the age of approximately 83 (he is assumed to have been born in 1540, but it’s not clear when precisely), William Byrd died in the Essex village of Stondon Massey, where he had been based for the final 30 years or so of his life. That means, and I’m sure you’re ahead of me here, that today (4/7/23) is the 400th anniversary of his death. Byrd has featured only once before on this list – see Day 86 for the ‘Agnus Dei’ sections of both his Four Voice and Five Voice Masses – so even if it hadn’t been the 400th anniversary, it would surely have been not before time for his reappearance. To sketch in a little background, he was probably born in London, and probably about 1540, and he possibly sang as a chorister at the Chapel Royal until (and maybe after) his voice broke. All the ‘hedging around’ here should make it clear that really not a great deal can be said definitively about him until he was appointed organist and master of choristers at Lincoln Cathedral in 1563, where he stayed for nine years, and where during that time he married. His big break came in 1572 when he was appointed Gentleman of the Chapel Royal, a position which was given for life – and it’s at this point where music, politics and religious challenges overlap. Byrd seems to have been Protestant by upbringing, but in the 1570s became more closely connected to Catholicism, a decidedly risky course to follow in the turbulent doctrinal battles that raged pretty much throughout Elizabeth I’s reign. In 1570 the then Pope had excommunicated Elizabeth and absolved all Catholics in England from affirming loyalty to her – and consequently all Catholics in England were viewed by the political establishment as potentially guilty of sedition. Byrd’s compositional skills here, and his judicious dedication of much music to his monarch, seem to have consistently sheltered him from persecution, and it’s not unreasonable to think that Elizabeth’s own fondness for music (she played various keyboard instruments, and liked much elaborately wrought composition) saved him from at least some of what might have come his way. One such move was the decision in 1575 to grant Byrd and his older contemporary Thomas Tallis a monopoly on the printing of music for 21 years, a kind of ‘establishment’ imprimatur that maintained his status, and ensured the publication of his first collection of ‘Cantiones Sacrae’ in 1575. Other major publications of Byrd’s work setting (religiously risky) Latin texts came in 1589 and 1591, and two volumes of ‘Gradualia’ (1605 and 1607), but throughout his life he was also writing and publishing music setting texts in English (1588, 1589 and 1611), and establishing a tradition of writing both for keyboards and for string ensembles that rivalled anything being produced in Europe at the time. His long ‘semi-retirement’ in Essex from the early 1590s onwards might not be regarded as ‘peaceful’ (he was endlessly cited for recusancy – failure to attend Anglican services – and repeatedly heavily fined as a result) but he survived to die, seemingly, a rich man. I thought I’d devote two postings to Byrd in order to focus one of them on a couple of pieces of church music, and then to shift the focus in the other one to his secular compositions. So today my first choice is his motet ‘Tristitia et Anxietas’, which was published in his collection ‘Cantiones Sacrae’ of 1589. The 1580s was a particularly dangerous decade to be a Catholic in England, and Byrd had many friends and acquaintances who were forced into exile or in some cases lost their lives at this time. Byrd set many texts at that point which focused on themes of persecution and suffering, setting Biblical and other texts describing the Jews’ persecution in Babylon or Egypt as a metaphor for the struggles of Catholics in England. The first part of ‘Tristitia…’ sets words from the Lamentations of Jeremiah, and Byrd’s writing here is both intense and emotional – the mesmeric, repetitive intoning of the opening word ‘Tristitia’, the steadily mounting anguish of ‘in dolore’ and so on. It is followed by a second section setting verses from Psalm 112 (‘But you, Lord, who does not forsake…’), which offers music which I’d hesitate to say is optimistic, but it does at least suggest a degree of consolation. It’s performed in this video recording by the Tallis Scholars, directed by their founder Peter Phillips, and you’ll find it here: Byrd: Tristitia et Anxietas. My other choice from Byrd’s religious music is considerably simpler – and it takes me back several decades to when I studied this piece for my O-level Music exam. It’s the short motet ‘Ave Verum Corpus’, a setting of a text used for the Feast of Corpus Christi, the celebration of which had been outlawed in England since 1548. Once again, the fact that this is a Latin text, from a time when that was regarded as evidence of the ‘old religion’, and no doubt intended for use at the clandestine celebrations of Catholic ritual in private houses, shows what a risk Byrd was taking. The fact that this Eucharistic hymn is now often a staple of Anglican services would, I think, have been completely unimaginable to Byrd. It was first published in Byrd’s ‘Gradualia’ of 1605 (which, along with its companion volume from 1607, might seem to show a tentative optimism on Byrd’s part that the reign of James I might offer Catholics a slightly easier ride), a collection of Latin motets. It’s probably Byrd’s most famous piece of liturgical music. I think that as a sixteen-year-old I found it less immediately exciting than some of the other works on the syllabus back then, but I quickly fell for its impassioned yet direct expression. It’s performed here by the ensemble Voces8: Byrd: Ave Verum Corpus
Day 394: Fantasia in A Minor (Time: 8 minutes), Pavan and Galliard (4 minutes) and If Women Could be Fair (4 minutes)
Last time out, I concentrated on what is doubtless the most explored and valued part of Byrd’s oeuvre, the unaccompanied choral music he wrote (in English and in Latin) for the ‘official’ use of the relatively new Church of England, but also for the rather more clandestine rituals of the Catholic church in the later 16th and early 17th centuries. However, a quick look at Byrd’s complete list of compositions reveals that this strand of his creative output was but one aspect of his career, so today (7/7/23), I’m going to look at three short pieces which, I hope, will give a taste of Byrd the ‘secular’ composer. So, let’s start with Byrd the composer for keyboards of one sort or another. He appears to have composed short pieces, or sets of pieces, pretty much throughout his compositional life, though the immense collection of such works that was published in 1591 as ‘My Ladye Nevells Booke’ is probably the best source if one is looking for a survey of such pieces. This publication contains 42 pieces of Byrd’s keyboard music: dances dedicated to various members of the nobility and other acquaintances, arrangements of popular Elizabethan ballads, and some early examples of ‘programme’ music (such as the nine sections that make up ‘the Battell’). However, there’s also the Fitzwilliam Virginal Book, a collection of keyboard pieces by various composers roughly dating 1560-1610, and this contains another 63 Byrd compositions. Then, inevitably, there are many more free-standing pieces that have been collected together since Byrd’s death. A project called ‘Musica Britannica’ (which dates back to the early 1950s) is an attempt to collect together various compositions of many composers, and the project includes two volumes dedicated to Byrd’s keyboard Fantasias; in amongst that collection you’ll find Byrd’s Fantasia in A Minor. The ‘Fantasia’ (various spellings exist) was a significant keyboard genre in England (and mainland Europe) for over 200 years, from roughly 1550-1750, and as the name implies, the element of ‘fantasy’ is paramount, so that there are lots of changes of mood and tempo in such works. Byrd’s A Minor Fantasia is an excellent example of this strand in his output. Such music might have been played at the time on virginals, or harpsichord, or chamber organ – but (ahistorically, though hopefully not too perversely) I’ve chosen a performance on a modern piano, which highlights the changeability of mood in action here. You’ll find the work performed on this video by the Jordan-born but currently German-based keyboard player Karim Said, the link to which is here: Byrd: Fantasia in A Minor. Byrd was also a significant composer for instrumental ensembles, such as consorts of viols. These seem to have been particularly a feature of the first half of Byrd’s time as a composer, the years 1570-1590. Actually, it’s possible that he wrote considerably more than the relatively small catalogue of such works that we have left to us, but what’s here shows Byrd’s invention in this area too. There are ‘Fantasias’ for these forces, too, but also other forms, some now fallen into obscurity (such as a ‘Browning’, a set of variations in a kind of round), and others which we might recognise as Elizabethan dance forms, such as the pavan(e) or galliard. This seems quite ‘innocent’ music, I think, simple and graceful, but always carefully crafted. As an example, the wonderful viol consort Phantasm plays Byrd’s Pavan and Galliard for Six Viols, which you’ll find here: Byrd: Pavan and Galliard a6. Finally, in this quick skim of Byrd’s secular music, I’ve chosen a piece for voices and viols. As I mentioned last time out, Byrd published sets of vocal music in English on several occasions during his life. The first of these emerged in 1588, and was called ‘Psalmes, Sonnets, and Songs of Sadness and Pietie’. It consists of ten psalm settings in English, two ‘funeral songs’ which set music by the poet Sir Philip Sidney, seven ‘songs of sadness and piety’ by various poets, and sixteen ‘sonnets and pastorals’, again with words by various contributors. This final sub-set touched on a very fashionable strand in Elizabethan poetic and musical creativity, the evocation of the ‘idyllic’ existence of nymphs and shepherds in some pastoral arcadia, whose existence is often contrasted with the more decadent nature of life at court. Such pieces are often rather gender-stereotyped. One such work is ‘If women could be fair’, which sets words by Edward de Vere, Earl of Oxford. In essence, the lyrics describe the inconstancy and unreliability of women … but therefore also the folly of men in devoting such energy to their pursuit. Hmm… Anyway, Byrd’s setting is performed here by the collective forces of the viol consort Fretwork and the vocal sextet The King’s Singers. You’ll find the link here: Byrd: If women could be fair
| C–G |
C · D · E · F · G |
|
Cannabich, Christian (1731-98)
Day 407: Symphony No 50 (Time: 10 minutes)
Today 29/8/23) we’re back in the 18th century, with yet another of those composers we hear hardly anything about because of the shadows cast by the imposing figures of Haydn and Mozart. So, let’s hear it for Christian Cannabich (1731-98), the 225th anniversary of whose death was marked (actually almost certainly passing unnoticed) back on 20th January this year. Johann Christian Innocenz Bonaventura Cannabich, if we’re being particularly formal, was born in Mannheim, in what is now western Germany, the son of a musician who worked in the local court orchestra. This was no ordinary court orchestra, mind you. The orchestra at the court of the Elector Palatine Carl Philipp was, by common consent, one of the most famous in Europe during the middle years of the 18th century, renowned for both the virtuosity and musicality of its wind players and also the discipline and flair of its strings. (The so-called ‘Mannheim Rocket’ was the dramatic rising string figure which frequently opened symphonies by composers associated with the Mannheim school, a gesture much imitated in this period.) Cannabich spent his whole life associated with this orchestra, as it moved around various locations under the rule of Carl Philipp and his successors. He was registered as a string player in the ensemble from the age of 12, and after a period being sent to Italy to further his musical education he returned to Mannheim as joint leader of the orchestra in the late 1750s, and by 1774 he had become director of music for the whole of the Elector’s establishments, a position he held for the rest of his life. The reputation of the Mannheim orchestra reached its peak in the 1770s. The English travel writer and diarist Charles Burney wrote of the orchestra that it was ‘an army of generals’, and Cannabich’s role at the head of this quite substantial body of musicians (apparently an orchestra of 95 players in its prime, similar to a decent-sized symphony orchestra of today) was particularly noted by Mozart on his visits to Mannheim, and Mozart, it has to be said, was not often so complimentary about fellow musicians. But he described Cannabich as ‘the best director that I have ever seen [who] has the love and awe of those under him’. In fact, Cannabich seems to have been an all-round good sort, welcoming to visiting performers and a committed defender of the status (and salaries) of his orchestral musicians. As a composer Cannabich was noted particularly as a provider of music for the court’s ballets (he seems to have written around 40 of these), but the musical form in which he excelled – at least in terms of his posthumous reputation – was the symphony. He appears to have written 76 of them (there is a little dispute about the exact number), and the vast majority come from the 1760s and 70s. Many of the pieces he wrote were published in batches of three or six symphonies at a time, and the symphony I’ve chosen today to illustrate Cannabich’s qualities as a composer, the Symphony No 50 in D Minor, was first published simultaneously in Mannheim and Paris as one of a set of six symphonies, Op 10, dedicated to ‘M le Comte de Sickingen’, about whom, sadly, I can tell you absolutely nothing. What I can say, however, is that Cannabich’s symphonies (almost all in three movements, in a fast-slow-fast design) are, by and large, beautifully composed, with a lot of interesting and often quite subtle orchestral detail, with lively and energetic outer movements and lovely central slow movements, typically featuring strings alone. The Symphony No 50 has a kind of sombre power in its opening movement that must surely have influenced Mozart’s minor key music. The central Andante con Brio is serene and poised, before the work ends with a sparkling Presto finale. Unsurprisingly, video recordings of Cannabich symphonies are thin on the ground, so we’re in audio-only territory today. The Symphony No 50 is performed on this recording by the players of the Budapest-based Nicolaus Esterhazy Sinfonia, conducted by Uwe Grodd, and you’ll find their performance here: Cannabich: Symphony No 50
Canteloube, Joseph (1879-1957)
Day 319: Songs of the Auvergne (extracts) (Time: 16 minutes)
My selection for today (23/8/22) is for music by the French composer Joseph Canteloube (1879-1957). There are composers out there whose works appear on concert programmes with extreme regularity – if you’ve been listening to this season’s Proms broadcasts, you’ll have heard a lot of Mozart and Beethoven and Brahms and Sibelius and so on. Then again, there are composers who are, in the public mind, ‘one hit wonders’. We don’t hear much Dukas these days except ‘The Sorcerer’s Apprentice’. We don’t hear much Pachelbel except his ear-worm of a ‘Canon in D’. We don’t hear much Orff apart from ‘Carmina Burana’. (There are people who think this last is probably a good thing.) And we definitely hear pretty much nothing else by Canteloube apart from extracts from his settings of ‘Songs of the Auvergne’. He was born in Annonay in the Auvergne region in south-eastern France. His initial link to the musical establishment in France was via correspondence with Vincent d’Indy (see Day 174), finally moving to Paris in 1907 to study with d’Indy at the Schola Cantorum. He wrote a number of pieces in the two decades that followed that have in effect disappeared, notably a prize-winning opera ‘Le Mas’, which in 1925 won him 100,000 francs, but which appears to have soon died a death in performance. More relevantly for today’s posting, it was also in 1925 that with a number of like-minded friends he formed the grouping La Bourrée. Their aim was to publicise the folklore and culture as well as the geographical attractions of the region of the Auvergne. There are other things to say about Canteloube, some of them that we’d see less kindly these days (he joined the Vichy government during the Second World War, writing and broadcasting about French folklore), but the main preoccupation of the final 30 years of his life was the production of five volumes of songs collected from the Auvergne region. The melodies are all traditional tunes of the region, and the words are in the regional language of Occitan. Canteloube wrote vividly about his love for the area: ‘I lived at that time deep in the country in a region where the country folk would still willingly sing. I began to roam through farms and villages to listen to the songs of the country folk, making both old men and old women sing to me, as well as the shepherds and shepherdesses in the fields, the farm-labourers and the harvesters at their work.’ In many ways, this makes him an ethnomusicologist in the vein of Vaughan Williams or Bartók. What makes Canteloube distinctive is that his versions are not pared-back to be original, but rather arrangements that are often lushly scored – as a pupil of d’Indy, he inherited a rather Wagnerian approach to orchestration, though there’s also, I think, a little bit of Ravel in there at times. However, his intention, he argued, was not to ‘dress up’ the folk songs in formal attire, but to communicate something of the ‘atmosphere’ of the locations that gave rise to this music in the first place: ‘Just because the country folk sing without accompaniment, that is not sufficient reason to imitate them. When the farmer sings at his work, or during the harvest, there is an accompaniment which surrounds his song which would not be felt by those whose interest is purely academic. Only poets and artists will feel it, and even then, alas! not all of them. It is nature herself, the earth which makes this, and the countryman and his song cannot be separated from this... If you separate this atmosphere, you rob the song of a large part of its poetry... Only the immaterial art of Music can evoke this essential atmosphere with its timbres, its rhythms and its impalpable, moving harmonies.’ Listening to these songs, it’s clear that Canteloube was a deeply conservative (small ‘c’!) composer. He rejected entirely the modernist French world of Poulenc and ‘Les Six’, or the experimentation with different styles of Stravinsky. The echoes of Ravel at times in the orchestration are about as close as Canteloube got to contemporary music. He wrote, over the period 1923-54, five volumes of these songs. They are rarely performed in their entirety (too much sweet stuff in one go might make you sick!), but selections, including the inescapable ‘Baïlèro’, feature often in concert programmes. There are many recordings on YouTube, and from them I’ve chosen this selection of five songs performed by the French soprano Véronique Gens, with the French National Orchestra conducted by Dalia Stasevska. The songs are: ‘Baïlero’, in which a shepherdess beckons a shepherd to cross a river to make love to her; then ‘L'aïo de rotso’, a lively song recommending a glass of wine rather than the spring water of the title, to encourage (ahem) romantic ardour; thirdly, there is ‘N'ai pas leu de mio’, a song of the lonely male shepherd playing on his pipe; the fourth song in this selection is ‘La Delaissado’, literally ‘the abandoned girl’, about a sad shepherdess who has been forsaken; and finally we have ‘Lou Coucut’, which is, as you might guess, about a cuckoo. You’ll find this selection here: Canteloube: Songs of the Auvergne (extracts)
Carwithen, Doreen Mary (1922-2003)
Day 343: Sonatina for Piano (Time: 11 minutes) and Bishop Rock Overture (9 minutes)
We are definitely in the territory of sadly neglected composers today (15/11/22), with a composer I’ve selected in honour of the fact that exactly 100 years ago this very day, Doreen Carwithen was born. So, this is a brief musical tribute to an often overlooked figure in British music – and also it helps to redress the overwhelming bias towards male composers on this list (indeed, in classical music in general… at least until very recently). Doreen Mary Carwithen was born in Buckinghamshire, started music lessons with her mother, and entered the Royal Academy of Music in 1941. Whilst there, initially to study piano and cello, she won all available composition prizes, having switched to composition classes, and became a Sub-Professor of Composition from 1946-8. She made a mark initially with an overture, ‘ODTAA’ (which stood for ‘One Damned Thing After Another’) in 1947, when it was performed by the LPO under Adrian Boult. She produced a cluster of other scores in the five years or so that followed, all of them seemingly successful and gleaning positive reviews. At this point, it’s worth observing that beginning to study composition brought her into contact with the composer William Alwyn, who taught her. He was 35 and married; she was 19 and single. There’s a familiar pattern to what comes next: they appear to have begun almost immediately a secret affair, thus initiating a relationship that lasted until Alwyn’s death in 1985, but conducted clandestinely for decades. Her early ‘Serenade for Voice and Piano’ has a private dedication to Alwyn, and the note ‘My true love hath my heart and I have his.’ When they were both working on film scores in the 1950s they appear to have avoided contact with each other when they were in the same studios, for fear of causing a scandal, though in 1961 they moved to rural Suffolk (it was at that point that she started referring to herself as ‘Mary Alwyn’ rather than ‘Doreen Carwithen’) and eventually, Alwyn having recently divorced his first wife, they married in 1975. Whatever the moral and ethical dilemmas generated by their intimacy, what is clear is that Carwithen’s musical career suffered as a consequence of her relationship with Alwyn – though to balance out the blame, one might also say her career suffered as a consequence of the ingrained sexism of the British music scene in the mid-20th century. By the late 1940s, with a tiny handful of exceptions, she had stopped composing concert music, and begun instead to write film scores. It appears that she can lay claim to the title of being the first full-time female composer of film music in the world! She wrote many scores for films produced by the Rank Organisation, though actually getting her name on the credits proved more challenging. For instance, she wrote the music for the film ‘Elizabeth is Queen’, but her only credit is as ‘assistant to Adrian Boult’, who conducted the soundtrack. However, by a decade or so later, commissions were drying up, and there’s a period of silence from then on – Carwithen focusing on sustaining a domestic environment conducive to Alwyn’s creative needs, and (after his death) keeping alive the flame of his music as the guardian of his reputation and archives. Seemingly it was only in the last years of her life that she turned again to composition, though she suffered a paralysing stroke in the late 1990s and died in 2003. I think there’s time, given my choices for this week, to consider two short pieces of hers (almost everything she wrote was short) that might illustrate the talent that – voluntarily or not – flourished all too briefly. First, a piece from 1945, the work of a young woman in her early 20s. It’s her Sonatina for Piano. The piece has three movements, the outer ones sparky and occasionally rather jazz-inflected, the middle movement being more contemplative and still. The pianist Clare Hammond, whose performance you can find linked here, describes the Sonatina as ‘characterised by an appealing melodic style, sprightly rhythms and engaging vivacity’. You’ll find a video of her performance here: Carwithen: Sonatina for Piano. To mark the centenary of Carwithen’s birth, the BBC Proms this summer featured three of her compositions, and out of the three the one that I found most convincing was the orchestral score ‘Bishop Rock’, which dates from 1952, and is therefore one of her last orchestral compositions. Inspired by the lighthouse on one of the westernmost points of the Isles of Scilly, it’s a rugged seascape in musical form – one might see it as a distant descendant of Mendelssohn’s ‘Hebrides’ Overture, or maybe of Arnold Bax’s symphonic poem ‘Tintagel’ (one day soon on this list, I hope…). Carwithen herself wrote the liner notes for a CD of her music that includes this piece, and she reflected that ‘this lonely tower is the last sight the seafarer has of land, and, to the traveller from the New World, is a symbol of welcome after the bleak waters of the Atlantic’. The work, she said, is ‘an impression of the thoughts stimulated by the lighthouse and depicts Bishop Rock in both storm and calm’. It begins in stormy turbulence, before a central section of relative peace, in which a singing string line rises to a climax before settling into calm again. From this point the storm rises once more. As for a performance, we’re in audio-only territory here, I’m afraid. There are several options on YouTube, and from them I’ve chosen this one by the LSO conducted by Richard Hickox. You’ll find it here: Carwithen: Bishop Rock Overture
Castillon, Alexis de (1838-73)
Day 359: Piano Quartet in G Minor, Op 7 (3rd movement) (Time: 10 minutes)
Today (3/3/23), I want to mark the 150th anniversary (this coming Sunday, March 5th) of the death of a French composer who is all but forgotten these days, but one whose premature death deprived us, I think, of the opportunity to hear some significant compositions, if his early work is anything to go by. I realise that the history of music abounds with tales of lives cut short, so I don’t want to make uniquely dramatic claims about Alexis de Castillon (1838-73) – Schubert was considerably younger when he died, Pergolesi younger still, Arriaga barely out of short trousers – but I think you can hear in Castillon’s work something which is distinctive, even though there are also evident echoes of composers who influenced him. Of his life, I have not been able to find out a great deal. He was born into an aristocratic family in southern France (full name: Marie-Alexis de Castillon de Saint-Victor), so his story is not one of overcoming financial or familial struggle. He was expected to pursue a military career, but as far as I can tell there was no great conflict when he announced his decision to give this up in favour of musical study. Although he had a number of teachers, his most notable influence was Franck, with whom he studied for a period from 1869. The liner notes of the CD I have which features his G Minor Piano Quartet describe him as ‘a gifted amateur composer’, and if that seems ever so slightly like condescension, the fact remains that he never had the chance to turn his musical talents to professional outcomes. Readers of previous playlist notes about 19th century French composers will be aware of the cataclysmic influence of the Franco-Prussian war of 1870 and its aftermath on national cultural life. For Castillon, the cataclysm was personal. Despite never being in the best of health when younger, Castillon volunteered to fight, but fell ill and was demobilised within a year. His health worsened, and in 1873 he died from the complications resulting from developing a fever. At his death he left several sets of piano miniatures and some chamber music, along with a considerable amount of unfinished material for a variety of forces. The piece I’ve chosen for us to listen to is part of his Piano Quartet in G Minor, Op 7. The work had its provincial premiere in late 1869 and was dedicated to the Russian piano virtuoso Anton Rubinstein. Though it made relatively little impact then, its performance in Paris two years later was greeted with immense enthusiasm, and established Castillon as a significant new face (d’Indy described him as one of the best chamber music composers of his time), though his death cut short any attempt to build on that success. The music of Schumann hangs over Castillon’s Piano Quartet, but not, I think, in a slavishly derivative way, and you might also hear the influence of Mendelssohn too. The whole work lasts almost 30 minutes, so there isn’t time to consider all of it. Out of its four movements, therefore, I’ve picked the third movement (‘Larghetto, quasi Marcia Religiosa’) for us to sample. It feels a bit like a Mendelssohnian ‘song without words’ initially, though it blossoms from there into something much more impassioned. This movement was a great success in Paris and was encored more than once. (It’s worth saying that it may feel as though the movement ends somewhat oddly. That’s because it leads directly into the Finale, and so the closing moments prepare us for that vigorous and animated movement that is to follow.) Unsurprisingly, there aren’t that many recordings of Castillon’s music around, and so today we’re in audio-only territory. The third movement of Castillon’s Piano Quartet Op 7 is played on this performance by the Quatuor Elyséen, whose recording you’ll find here: Castillon: Piano Quartet in G Minor, Op 7 (3rd movement)
Caurroy, Eustache du (1549-1609)
Day 451: Requiem (Time: 28 minutes)
The posting for today (30/1/24) concerns a somewhat obscure composer. Nevertheless I hope that if you read these comments and listen to the music that’s linked to them you’ll find something both mesmerising and deeply consoling as a result. So, let’s hear it for Eustache du Caurroy, who will be 475 years old (if you see what I mean) this coming Sunday. Not many people have heard of Caurroy, and I suspect even fewer will have listened to much of his music. If you think about Renaissance composers from the late 15th through to the 17th centuries, there are some predictable household names whose music is much recorded. Lots of them are Italian – Palestrina, Gabrieli, Ferrabosco, Monteverdi, d’India, Allegri; others are Spanish/Portuguese – Lobo, Cardoso, Penalosa, Morales, Guerrero, Victoria; some are English – Power, Dunstable/Dunstaple, Frye, Fayrfax, Ludford, Taverner, Tallis, Tye, Sheppard, Mundy, White, Byrd. There’s a substantial batch of names associated with the Franco-Flemish school (in the area that’s now the Netherlands, Belgium and north-eastern France) – Ockeghem, Regis, Isaac, Josquin, Obrecht, de la Rue, Willaert, Gombert, Clemens non Papa, de Rore. However, in general it’s harder to generate the same sort of list for French composers. If I stare hard at my CD collection, I can come up with Dufay, Compere, Mouton … and the composer I’ve chosen for today, Caurroy. Eustache du Caurroy (1549-1609) was, in his day, a renowned figure in the development of French music, and for centuries after his death his name was associated with one particular composition, which I’m going to home in on. As with so many of these Renaissance composers, not a great deal is known about Caurroy’s life. He was born and brought up in an area about 50 miles north of Paris, seems to have been a member of the musicians at the royal court from the age of about 20, and won a number of musical competitions at court over the next 15 years or so. His rise seems to have continued at a steady pace, until by the age of 50 he became the official composer at the chapel royal. He continued to accumulate honours, and considerable personal wealth, in his final decade, before he died at the age of 60. He was a writer of both secular and sacred vocal music, and also there is a substantial number of instrumental pieces which have survived. Almost all of his music was published posthumously. Caurroy is principally associated with the reign of Henry IV of France. (‘Henry the Great’ to the French, the born Catholic but raised Protestant King of Navarre who subsequently ruled France, first as the only French Protestant king until – pragmatically? ‘Paris is worth a mass’ – he converted to Catholicism, and was instrumental in bringing to a close – almost – the 16th/17th century religious wars in that country. I say ‘almost’ because he was assassinated in 1610 by a Catholic zealot.) At the funeral of Henry IV, mourners heard a performance of Caurroy’s Requiem Mass (Caurroy himself had been dead for a year by this stage), and for the next two centuries afterwards this work was performed at the funerals of French monarchs or other leading royal figures. Caurroy actually began work on the Requiem in the early 1590s, and it seems to have had a first performance in 1606. It seems very unlikely that Caurroy could have imagined that the work would have developed such a lasting posthumous reputation. Nevertheless, it’s a solemn and quite magisterial piece, and it’s easy to see why it should fit so well on major funereal state occasions. It’s a well-crafted work in seven movements: Requiem, Kyrie, Si Ambulem, Domine Jesu, Sanctus, Agnus Dei and Lux Aeterna. The impact of the work can be understood from this early 18th century comment: ‘those who care for trifles will not find here what they are seeking. This music … is most sad, but it is also of the utmost excellence and no others are ever sung at the funerals and services of Kings and Princes at Saint-Denis.’ (Sadly, I can’t attach a name to that comment…) It’s solemn but not gloomy music. In fact, for me it’s the music’s harmonic richness which makes me return to it. As for a performance, it may not surprise you to know that YouTube does not have any video recordings of the complete work, so we’re in audio-only territory here. The performance I’ve chosen is by the Choir of New College, Oxford, conducted by Edward Higginbottom. You’ll find it here, accompanied by an image of a not entirely apt painting by Frans Hals: Caurroy: Requiem
Chabrier, Emmanuel (1841-94)
Day 310: Suite Pastorale (etc.) (Time: 21 minutes)
Emmanuel Chabrier (1841-94) – actually Alexis-Emmanuel Chabrier, if we’re being precise – is one of those composers who, I think, it’s hard to listen to without a smile coming to the lips and a broad feeling of contentment spreading through one’s whole being. His music, even at its most serious – and he could be serious, now and then – is suffused with a sense of well-being and ‘joie de vivre’. Poulenc, writing about Chabrier, called him ‘the father of us all’. Clearly the metaphor is a distortion, in that French music over the lifetimes of Chabrier and Poulenc (who was born five years after Chabrier’s death) was a varied and multi-stranded thing, but it hits the spot, I think, in that like Poulenc, Chabrier was able to fuse together ‘serious’ and ‘popular’ music, and this easy and flexible mix of styles is, I would argue, Chabrier’s great gift as a composer. These days Chabrier is known largely for one piece, his orchestral miniature ‘España’, which, so the claim goes, is loved as a colourful and authentic depiction of Spain by everyone in the world except the Spanish. However, I want to sidestep this familiar piece and explore today (22/7/22) something a little more off the beaten track. For most of his life, Chabrier was an ‘amateur’ composer: his father was a lawyer, and wanted young Emmanuel to follow in the family line, and as a result Chabrier passed his law exams and entered the French Civil Service, where he worked full-time until 1880. Only then – and revealingly for those who only see Chabrier as a ‘light’ composer, this was immediately after going to Bayreuth to see a performance of Wagner’s ‘Tristan and Isolde’ – did Chabrier devote the rest of his life to composition, a life cut short in his early 50s by the dementia and physical paralysis that almost certainly came as a result of contracting syphilis. Chabrier seems to have been an immensely sociable person, not given to faction fighting. He was genuinely good friends with d’Indy, Saint-Saens, Massenet and Faure, not to mention writers like Verlaine, Zola and Mallarme, and painters like Manet, Renoir and Degas. He seems to have been particularly (one might say literally) striking in his piano technique. There’s a lovely quotation from Aline Renoir, wife of the painter, about this: ‘one day Chabrier came to call, and he played ‘España’ for me. It sounded as if a hurricane had been let loose. He pounded and pounded the keyboard. It was summertime and the window was open. I happened to look into the street. It was full of people and they were listening, fascinated. When he reached the last crashing chords I swore that I would never play the piano again. Besides, Chabrier had broken several strings and put it out of action.’ Whatever his idiosyncrasies as a pianist, Chabrier wrote a considerable amount of attractive piano music, including, in 1880 whilst on holiday in Normandy, his ten ‘Pièces Pittoresques’. A comment at the work’s premiere, attributed both to Vincent d’Indy and Cesar Franck, claimed the audience had ‘just heard something exceptional – this music links our own time to that of Couperin and Rameau’. It’s true that these little pieces have a kind of crystalline beauty and clarity that is characteristic of 18th century French harpsichord writing. Eight years after the composition of these ten pieces, Chabrier (or, in some accounts, his friend the conductor Felix Mottl, working under Chabrier’s instruction) orchestrated the sixth, seventh, fourth and tenth of them to make up the ‘Suite Pastorale’. In this new garb, the opening ‘Idylle’ (‘exquisite in every way’, according to d’Indy) is followed by the tender ‘Danse Villageoise’. Of the ‘Idylle’, Poulenc, on hearing the work for the first time, wrote with splendid hyperbole: ‘A universe of harmony opened itself up suddenly in front of me, and my music has never forgotten this first kiss of love.’ Then comes ‘Sous-bois’, with its sense that the shifting harmonies evoke the rustling of leaves, under which the meandering bass line keeps things more or less stable – apparently a particular favourite of Ravel. Finally we reach the ‘Scherzo-Valse’, a spirited and good-natured conclusion. Which only leaves the question of finding a suitable performance. There are a number of decent audio-only recordings on YouTube, but I know people on this list have a general preference for video links if possible. The only way I can achieve this is by providing a link to a whole series of Chabrier pieces given in a concert by the Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Sir John Eliot Gardiner. So, you get, in this order, Chabrier’s very Wagnerian overture to his opera ‘Gwendoline’, the ‘Suite Pastorale’, and then his ‘Fête Polonaise’, the overture to his opera ‘Le Roi Malgré Lui’, and finally (inevitably) ‘España’. There’s clearly nothing to stop you listening to the whole 47 minutes’ worth, though it goes way beyond this list’s ’40 minute rule’ for the total listening time for any Tuesday + Friday recordings. However, to listen just to the 21 minutes of the ‘Suite Pastorale’, start at 9 mins 45 secs. You’ll find the recording here: Chabrier: Suite Pastorale(etc.)
Day 403: Souvenirs de Munich (Time: 10 minutes)
Today (8/8/23), and subsequently on Day 405, I’m responding to a suggestion from Jenny Holt for a theme for the week, to hear music in which one composer responds to the work of a previous composer – in, for example, a set of variations on a previous work, or an arrangement/rescoring/paraphrase of it. We’ve had a few such pieces over the years on this list (Rachmaninov’s ‘Paganini Rhapsody’ and Vaughan Williams’ ‘Tallis Fantasia’ spring to mind) but this week we have two works that explicitly have their starting point in another composer’s work and take it in what one might see as an unexpected direction. Both these choices are great fun, and in each case written by a composer with his tongue more or less firmly in his cheek. So, Emmanuel Chabrier has made just one appearance on this list to date (see Day 310 when I programmed his ‘Suite Pastorale’, though in a YouTube link that would have given you lots more Chabrier too if you’d watched the whole video). In the notes I wrote for that posting I made the comment that Chabrier had been an essentially amateur composer (having a day job with the French Civil Service) until 1880, when he made a trip to a performance of Wagner’s opera ‘Tristan und Isolde’, the impact of which was, for Chabrier, literally life-changing. Catching the ‘Wagner bug’ was not unusual in the latter half of the 19th century, and it’s striking how powerful its impact was on French composers in particular, though the outcomes weren’t necessarily predictable. Wagner’s music-dramas were in almost all ways the antithesis of French grand opera, and most French composers of the time went through a Wagner phase – some coming out the other side quite quickly (Saint-Saens, say), others taking Wagnerian motif-led cyclic structures on board and transmuting them (Franck, for example) and some seeing Wagner’s music as something to be resisted, or at the very least parodied (Satie might be the best illustration). There’s an excellent quotation from Debussy that summarises this attraction/repulsion, saying of Wagner’s music that it was ‘a beautiful sunset mistaken for a dawn’. Where, then, does Chabrier fit into this? Well, in 1880, having blagged his way into taking time off work (allegedly to go to Bordeaux on a private matter, when really he was in Munich with Vincent d’Indy, Henri Duparc and others, weeping with joy at hearing the Prelude to ‘Tristan…’ - see Day 88!), Chabrier was well and truly smitten. Although in so many ways Chabrier’s music feels like the epitome of French elegance and charm (as it is, of course!), you really can hear Wagner in the background of the music he was composing at the time – listen to his opera ‘Gwendoline’, or at least to its Overture, for instance. But, there are layers to Chabrier’s Wagner-enthusiasm, and what he caught at that performance of ‘Tristan und Isolde’ was by no means just a nasty case of hero-worship. One of the most notable features of Chabrier’s writing is its infectious joie-de-vivre, the sense that it can always make you smile, even when its subject matter is serious. So, on his return from his baptism into all things Wagnerian, Chabrier considered how he might pay homage to this towering figure in German operatic music. A transcription of some of the opera, perhaps? As a young man he had copied out the full score of Wagner’s opera ‘Tannhäuser’, just to see how it ‘worked’. A set of variations on some Wagnerian themes, maybe? Well, sort of. What Chabrier came up with is his ‘Souvenirs de Munich’, a work for four hands at one piano which he composed in the mid-1880s. It’s a quadrille (a kind of square dance) based on themes from ‘Tristan…’. It is in five short sections. The first, ‘Pantalon’ (literally, one’s trousers, and usually referring to a ‘commedia dell’arte’ character who appears with his trousers round his ankles) takes themes from the Sailors’ Chorus in Act I of ‘Tristan…’. Then we have ‘Eté’ (‘Summer’) which uses the love theme from Act II of ‘Tristan…’, the opera’s erotic highlight – what has been called the most dramatic ‘coitus interruptus’ in the whole of opera! Third is a ‘Poule’ (‘Hen’), which uses the rustic music of the shepherds in Act III of ‘Tristan…’ but mixed in with the ‘death theme’ from Act II. The fourth movement is a ‘Pastourelle’, which uses the theme associated with Kurwenal, Tristan’s closest friend. Finally, the sequence is rounded off with a ‘Galop’, which incongruously blends Kurwenal’s theme with the ‘death theme’ from Act II. So, is this just a parody, a mocking send-up of Wagnerian solemnity in the guise of a kind of music-hall skit? Certainly Francis Poulenc, a composer of a subsequent generation who himself mixed humour and something much more profound, thought it was ‘irresistibly funny’, Wagner mocked up in ‘false beards and fake moustaches’. Well, maybe. Certainly it started a brief fashion for this sort of thing: only a few years later Fauré and his contemporary André Messager, composer of ballets and comic operas, wrote the similar ‘Souvenirs de Bayreuth’. The Fauré/Messager work does sound pretty straightforwardly like it’s laughing at Wagner’s expense. But Chabrier’s piece? Yes, it’s got a twinkle in its eye (everything that Chabrier wrote did) but I’d probably want to argue that what we have here is, if I can split hairs, almost as much a pastiche as it is a parody. Anyway, see what you think. I can’t find a professional performance on video on YouTube (lots of amateur ones that, alas, don’t do the music any favours) so here is an audio-only recording by the young-ish French pianist Alexandre Tharaud and the Serbian Aleksandar Madžar. You’ll find their performance here: Chabrier: Souvenirs de Munich
Chausson, Ernest (1855-99)
Day 463: Poeme, for Violin and Orchestra (Time: 17 minutes)
Today (12/3/24), I want to highlight one of the works being played by the China
Shenzhen Symphony Orchestra, who are currently on a UK national tour,
when they turn up at Sheffield City Hall two days from now, which includes
something of a rarity in the concert hall, a work for violin and orchestra by Chausson,
so it’s that piece that I want to focus on here.
I’m more than a little shocked to have got 463 postings into this compendium of
treasures and to find that this is the first time we’ve had music by Ernest
Chausson (1855-99), even if I’ve mentioned him in passing when discussing music
by Franck, d’Indy and Saint-Saens. He’s definitely far more than just a
footnote in 19th century French musical history, even if his
relatively early death means that there’s not a lot of Chausson out there to
choose from. In fact, Chausson’s death is one of the best-known things
about him, so let’s get that out of the way first. Composers have
regularly died in statistically unusual ways (hit by a falling bookcase –
Alkan; stabbed through the foot with his own conducting staff – Lully) but one
of the most startling deaths is Chausson’s: killed falling off a bicycle.
Inevitably, there’s more to it than that. He was cycling downhill and ran
into a wall, and was apparently killed on impact. I bet he wasn’t wearing
a helmet. Anyway, though it’s what he’s ‘famous’ for, I’d much rather
focus on his life and music. Chausson came from a wealthy family (his
father was a builder who made his wealth helping Baron Haussmann redevelop
Paris in the mid-19th century) and was, initially, something of a
dilettante, trying his hand at writing and painting before settling on
music. Paternal pressure meant he studied and qualified to practise Law,
but it held no interest for him. It was only in his mid-20s that he began
to take music seriously, taking lessons from Massenet (another omission from
this playlist; one day, folks…). The ‘road to Damascus’ moment for
Chausson (as for so many later 19th century musicians) was going to
Bayreuth to see a Wagner opera. However, though you can hear evidence of
Wagner’s music in some of the stuff Chausson composed in the mid-1880s, he
gradually became less enamoured of things Wagnerian, and more and more
convinced of the need for him and his contemporaries to develop an authentic
French ‘voice’ in their work. I’ve written before about the impact of the
Société Nationale de Musique in the 30 years between the Franco-Prussian war of 1870
and the end of the 19th century, and Chausson gradually became more
and more involved with it, as Secretary of the organisation from 1886 until
(I think…) his death, and his Parisian home became one of the major salons at
which musicians premiered a considerable amount of French chamber music and
songs during Chausson’s lifetime. It’s something of a cliché to see
Chausson’s output in three phases: there’s the early stuff, which feels very
French in a rather light and colourful Massenet-type way; there’s the
middle-period stuff under the heavy influence of Wagner; and, in the final
dozen years of his life, the ‘mature’ Chausson’s independent voice – even if
the latter does bear quite a large imprint of the influence of Cesar Franck,
with whom Chausson was on very friendly terms. His published works add up
only to 44 opus numbers. There’s an opera (‘King Arthur’) on which he
spent a lot of time, rather fruitlessly. There are many sets of songs for
voice and piano (or voice and orchestra) and a small handful of really lovely
chamber pieces: an early Piano Trio, the wonderful ‘Concert’ for Piano, Violin
and String Quartet, a dramatic Piano Quartet and an unfinished String Quartet
that he was working on when he died. The works of his that probably get
the most airtime (and, in truth, that doesn’t amount to much) are his only
Symphony in Bb (which it’s hard to imagine existing in the form it does without
Franck’s Symphony in D Minor having existed first), the languid song cycle for
voice and orchestra, ‘Poème de l'amour et de la mer’, and this, the ‘Poème’,
Op 25, for violin and orchestra. It dates from 1896, so it’s mature
Chausson, and it’s a short, extremely rhapsodic work in a single movement.
There’s a lovely story attached to its premiere and publication.
Chausson was often beset by feelings of depression and lack of confidence.
He did not anticipate any interest in the Poème at all.
But Albeniz, to whom Chausson had shown much encouragement early in the Spaniard’s career,
arranged for the music publisher Breitkopf to print the work.
They initially didn’t want to, saying the piece was ‘vague and bizarre’
and would have ‘few adherents’. So Albeniz himself put up the money
for publication, plus 300 marks, which he arranged for the publishers to send
to Chausson, pretending that these were royalties. It seems, from all
accounts, to have done wonders for Chausson’s self-confidence … at least for a
time. As for the work itself, it’s structurally almost impossible
to analyse – real ‘stream of consciousness’ stuff – but regardless of that it
contrives not to feel ‘shapeless’, but rather to evolve, in a dreamy sort of
way, from a darkly mysterious introduction, through a range of challenging
violin themes to a main climax, before ending in a state of some tranquillity.
YouTube has quite a few recordings of this work, but I’m particularly fond of this one,
recorded as far as I can tell during lockdown (there’s no audience) by the Swedish
Radio Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Johannes Gustavsson.
The soloist is the wonderful Janine Jansen. You’ll find their performance here:
Chausson: Poeme, for Violin and Orchestra (17 minutes)
Day 485: Poeme de l'amour et de la mer, Op 19 (Time: 26 minutes)
Today (31/5/24), as was the case last time out, I’m considering a work by a composer who died in June 1899. On 3rd June that year, Johann Strauss II breathed his last; exactly a week later, and in circumstances I’ve already explored on this playlist, the same happened to Ernest Chausson. It’s not much more than a couple of months since that first appearance of Chausson on this list, but if you can’t make the cut on the 125th anniversary of your death, when can you? (An entirely rhetorical question – feel free not to answer it.) I covered most of what I’d want to say about Chausson’s biography in that earlier posting, so today I want simply to focus on the single work I’ve picked to commemorate this most lusciously dreamy of late 19th century French composers. (There’s a bit of a transferred epithet there – it is of course the music that is lusciously dreamy; I believe Monsieur Chausson was essentially mild-mannered and thoughtful, if a little prone to self-doubt and depression.) Anyway, part of that luscious dreaminess is undoubtedly due to the influence of Wagner, whose music had Chausson under its spell as his musical language matured, though like other French composers of the age Chausson came to see the need to cure himself of that affliction if he were to really find his own voice. As I mentioned in that previous posting, Chausson’s early death (and his tendency to spend a long time worrying over his pieces) meant that he got as far only as Op 44 in the list of his completed works. My previous Chausson choice was the Poème for Violin and Orchestra, a lusciously dreamy mini-concerto, if you like. Without wishing to seem unduly repetitive, my choice for today is also a ‘Poème’ … and it’s also undoubtedly lusciously dreamy. It’s Chausson’s beautiful work for solo mezzo-soprano and orchestra, the ‘Poème de l'amour et de la mer,’ his Op 19. Some things – well, actually, most things – sound better in French. But I can’t help feeling that a title like that is based at least in part on the lovely phonological echoes in the words rather than being strictly about love and the sea … though it is about love and the sea too, amongst other things. It’s a work in three movements. The middle one is a short purely orchestral interlude, a kind of palate-cleanser between the outer ‘courses’ which are lengthy settings of two poems by Chausson’s friend and compatriot, Maurice Bouchor. The poems in question are ‘La fleur des eaux’ (‘The Flower of the Waters’) and ‘La mort de l’amour’ (‘The Death of Love’) – so at least we know that the general direction of the cycle’s emotional journey is towards a pretty bleak (though still exquisitely beautiful) conclusion. Though, as I’ve just said, Chausson regularly took a long time over his compositions, the ‘Poème de l'amour et de la mer’ took even longer than most. In fact, he started it in 1882 (when he was still deep in his ‘Wagner’ phase) but didn’t finish it until 1890, and then he tinkered with it a bit more until 1892, before its first performance the following year. If you want to reduce it to its most banal, the piece tells the story of a holiday infatuation at the seaside … and, as we all know, such things often begin in implausible optimism, and end in tears. The young man in question falls for a girl on holiday, but when he returns the following year he finds she’s lost interest in him. That all feels a little adolescent and shallow, but it’s what Chausson does with the sensual patterning of images that lifts this into another realm entirely. As Roger Nichols writes in the liner notes to the CD copy I have of this, the work’s quality emerges from the way Chausson takes us through ‘ecstasy, doubt, hope, nostalgia and finally heartbreak’. Images recur – of lilacs, of sunlight and the sea. Try this opening stanza of the first poem: ‘An exquisite scent of lilac fills the air/ from blooms that deck the walls from top to bottom,/ and perfume women’s hair./ Bathed in bright sunlight, the sea will be aflame,/ and on the fine sand, in a kiss,/ break dazzling waves.’ And so it goes on…. So, in the first song the narrator’s ‘heart awoke that summer morning for a beautiful girl,’ but just as the sea ‘surges upon the shore, mocking and indifferent,’ so the narrator is lost, and ‘the mocking wind jeers at the anguish of my heart.’ The short orchestral interlude that comes next (marked ‘Lent et triste’ – slow and sad) picks up some of the rhapsodic music of the first section but it seems to show, in its rather pallid way, where we are going: as quickly as love blossoms, it dies again. The second poem isn’t just a complete downer. There are memories of the past that illuminate the narrator’s agitated state, but the final verse has its own inevitability: ‘How sweet and happy was the spring/ that came last year to bathe us in its sunshine glow!/ The flower of our love is now so withered,/ alas, that your kiss cannot revive it!/ And you, what are you doing? No flowers blooming,/ no merry sunshine or cool shade;/ the time of lilac, and the time or roses,/ with our love, is forever dead!’ Still, please be reassured: it’s proper sad stuff, and no mistake, but the music Chausson composed is exquisite. YouTube has some splendid audio recordings of this work, but this video of a concert performance is not bad either, I think. The orchestra is the West German Radio Symphony Orchestra, Cologne, under the baton of Marie Jacquot. The soloist, with perhaps an excess of vibrato, is the mezzo Michèle Losier. You’ll find the performance here: Chausson: Poeme de l'amour et de la mer, Op 19
Chávez, Carlos (1899-1978)
Day 487: Symphony No. 2 ('Sinfonia India') (Time: 13 minutes)
Today (7/6/24), I’m still deeply immersed in the events of June 1899 and its string of 125th anniversaries of various composers’ births or deaths; and today we move from the north-west corner of the USA to the southern end of North America, and to Mexico City to be precise, which was the birthplace of today’s composer on 13th June, 1899 – which means his actual 125th anniversary is a week from now. The person in question is Carlos Chávez, who is generally regarded as Mexico’s leading 20th century composer. Chávez – the rather extensively named Carlos Antonio de Padua Chávez y Ramírez, in full, which must have occasioned the odd challenge when filling in official forms – was the seventh child of a ‘criollo’ family, having a Mexican father (who died when Chávez was three) and an indigenous Indian mother. (I find this ethnic labelling a bit tricky from a ‘politically correct’ perspective; I have a CD of Chávez’s music the liner notes of which refer to him as a ‘Mestizo’, and I wonder about what it is or isn’t appropriate to say these days. The key point here, I think, is that through his mother’s line, Chávez found a direct link with the Mexican nationalist culture of the age that was making overt connections back to Aztec roots.) Chávez had formal lessons as a young man in harmony and piano playing, but as regards composition and orchestration he was entirely self-taught. As you may know, the ‘Mexican Revolution’, which saw the country assert its independence from Spanish control, was a protracted affair – effectively a series of sporadic rebellions over the period 1910-20 – so this period of turbulence was significant during Chávez’s formative years. He took an active part in the cultural aspects of this rebellion, forming a cultural journal with friends in 1916 and later writing for the Mexico City newspaper ‘El Universal’ between 1924 and his death in 1978. As a composer Chávez burst onto the scene in 1921 when a concert made up entirely of his own compositions made a significant impact, and led to a series of future commissions, notably the ballet ‘El Fuego Nuevo’, which made much of Mexico’s ancient Aztec history. The composer Manuel Ponce (see Day 374; Ponce may perhaps rival Chávez for the title of Mexico’s leading composer) said of Chávez at this stage: ‘He finds himself under the double influence of romanticism … and of modernism, which attracts him with its glamour of novelty and exoticism.’ The ‘modernist’ tendency was encouraged by Chávez’s visits to Europe and the USA during the early 1920s, but for most of his composing career his music reflected his belief that composition should find its roots in the musical language of the indigenous culture. (In this respect the tension in his work is quite similar to that of, say, Ginastera – see Day 294 – in Argentina.) That’s not to say that he wasn’t committed to exploring new ideas in musical sound worlds. His 1930s book ‘Toward a New Music’ expresses a real interest in electronic music, making him one of the first composers of note to write about it. As a composer, Chávez wrote pieces in most of the major genres: six symphonies, six piano sonatas, three string quartets, several concertos for solo instruments and orchestra, for example. But there are also many vocal and choral scores that draw on Mexican folklore and poetry, as well as works for the stage that are based on indigenous themes. In 1959, in one of a series of Norton Lectures at Harvard University, he said this of his compositional approach: ‘The idea of repetition and variation can be replaced by the notion of constant rebirth, of true derivation: a stream that never comes back to its source; a stream in eternal development, like a spiral.’ This seems to me to be a key idea in Chávez’s work, and this concept of rhythmic and melodic patterning, a subtle but constant transformation of the ‘building blocks’ of his work, recurs in so much of his music. To mark his imminent anniversary I thought I’d choose what is arguably Chávez’s most popular work, his Symphony No 2, which has the sub-title ‘Sinfonia India’. This dates from the mid-1930s, and is a one-movement work (though with three identifiable sections with a conventional fast-slow-fast pattern) lasting just under 15 minutes. What makes it significant in Chávez’s work is its explicit use of melodies from native American tribes living in northern Mexico. It’s scored for a fairly conventional orchestra, but with the addition of an array of percussion instruments: you don’t normally find such things in a conventional symphony orchestra (and Chávez allowed them to be replaced by ‘equivalent’ items, though he insisted on originals where possible) but what he really wanted were the following - a ‘jicara de agua’ (half of a gourd inverted and partly submerged in a basin of water, struck with sticks), a ‘güiro’(an open-ended hollow gourd with notches along one side), a ‘cascabeles’ (a pellet rattle), a tenabari (a string of butterfly cocoons), a pair of teponaxtles (elaborately ornamented drums with a slit along one side), a ‘tlapanhuéhuetl’ (a kind of tubular drum on legs, a bit like a conga), and a set of ‘grijutian’ (a string of deer hooves)! The work has been extensively recorded, to the point where it is in effect Chávez’s calling card. As for a performance, YouTube has many, both audio and video recordings. Out of the options, and even though he takes the music at breakneck speed a lot of the time, I’ve gone for the energy of Venezuelan conductor Gustavo Dudamel, conducting the forces of the Berlin Philharmonic. You’ll find the recording here: Chavez: Symphony No 2 ('Sinfonia India')
Chisholm, Duncan (b1968)
Day 61: ‘Leaving Stoer’ (Time: 4 minutes)
Today (22/5/20), we have another ‘not really classical’ (but nevertheless wholly attractive) music request, this time from Claire. It’s for a track from the Scottish fiddler Duncan Chisholm's 1997 album ‘Redpoint’. I discover from Wikipedia that Chisholm (b.1968) played fiddle with Skye band Runrig (when, presumably, he was really quite young), and more recently with folk band Wolfstone, and with Scots Gaelic singer Julie Fowlis. The track Claire suggests we listen to is called ‘Leaving Stoer’, and you’ll find it here: Duncan Chisholm – ‘Leaving Stoer’
Chopin, Frederic (1810-49)
Day 8: Ballade No 1, Op 23 (Time: 10 minutes) and Nocturne in C# Minor, Op Posth (4 minutes)
Today (30/3/20), it’s my pick, and I’ve selected two items for you (still keeping within the 15 minutes max. for both of them together, so that’s ok!). I wanted to select some Chopin, but then felt overwhelmed at the thought of picking only one piece from a composer who, more than any other I think, can take a percussion instrument (the piano) and make it sing. I think there’s a good argument for seeing Chopin as the composer for piano who took it from its classical roots (there’s much more Mozart than Beethoven in Chopin's work for me) and pointed the way not just to late Romantic pianism (Rachmaninov, say) but also the lyrical nationalism of someone like Szymanowski. Anyway, enough of the waffle. The two pieces I’ve chosen are the Ballade No 1, Op 23, played here by Krystian Zimerman: Chopin – Ballade No 1 and the Nocturne in C# Minor, Op Posth, played by Vladimir Ashkenazy, which is here: Nocturne in C# Min, Op Posth
Day 241: Preludes, Op 28: No 4 in E Minor (Time: 2 minutes), No 6 in B Minor (2 minutes), No 7 in A (1 minute), No 8 in F# Minor (2 minutes), No 9 in E (2 minutes), No 15 in Db (15 minutes) and No 24 in D Minor (3 minutes)
At the end of this month, Ensemble 360’s resident pianist, Tim Horton, is giving a recital in the Crucible Studio, consisting of the complete 24 Preludes Op 28 by Chopin, and Book 2 of Debussy's Preludes. That seems to me like a suitable cue for this week’s postings, exploring at least two of the many approaches to the concept of ‘the prelude’ in music, starting today (16/11/21) with a selection of preludes by Chopin. Frédéric (at birth, Fryderyk) Chopin has appeared just the once on this list before now (see Day 8, above, for his Ballade No 1 and Nocturne in C#min Op Posth), which might seem to indicate undue neglect of one of music’s great innovators at the piano. He is a composer dear to the hearts of many listeners – particularly, if I can say this without appearing in any way condescending, to listeners who don’t necessarily like ‘classical music’. I suspect this is largely because his music speaks very directly to our emotions; there are stylistic and conceptual richnesses in his work for the ‘expert’, but alongside this there is the very essence of ‘the Romantic composer’ in his pieces – passion, drama, dreamy yearning, heroic calls to action, the vitality of the dance, and so on, all embodied in the short and often tortured life of a composer whose love life was turbulent (especially in his association with the novelist ‘George Sand’) and whose physical life was dogged by the tuberculosis which killed him before he was 40. In some ways Chopin is the antithesis of that other great Romantic pianist-composer of the era, Liszt: where Liszt was (for some of his career at least) ‘the great showman’, Chopin hated performing in public concerts – he seems to have given only about 30 of them in the whole of his life – and preferred private music-making with a familiar group of friends in a small salon. They were both swayed by public events (compare Liszt’s reaction to the European revolutions of 1848 with Chopin’s to the Warsaw Uprising of 1830) but Chopin was never a public figure in the same way. Everything Chopin wrote included the piano – apart from two piano concertos and a handful of other pieces for piano and orchestra, a cello sonata, an early piano trio and 20 or so songs for voice and piano, almost all of it is for piano alone: Chopin conjuring miniature worlds at the keyboard. These worlds were given titles that, largely due to him, shaped the piano repertoire in the succeeding century: he did not invent the forms, but it is Chopin who brought into the spotlight the ballade, the impromptu, dance forms such as the polonaise, waltz and mazurka as concert pieces, the nocturne, the étude, the scherzo … and the focus for today’s choices, the prelude. Now, as with ‘the nocturne’ a couple of weeks ago, the concept of the ‘prelude’ had been around for a long time, and the logical question to ask about such a term is surely ‘the prelude to what?’ Well, in the 18th century, preludes came before fugues (the most obvious example being Bach’s two books of 24 Preludes and Fugues); elsewhere the term signified the opening movement at the start of a bigger work – the prelude to a keyboard or orchestral suite, or to an opera or oratorio. (This usage of the term has endured. Verdi, to take just one example, called the orchestral movement at the start of his operas ‘overture’ on some occasions and ‘prelude’ on others.) But it is Chopin who took the term and gave it its new meaning: a short independent piece for piano, conveying a single idea or emotion. However, in publishing as his Op 28 a set of 24 preludes in all the major and minor keys, Chopin seems to be at least nodding in the direction of Bach, whose Preludes and Fugues do the same, even if the ordering of the keys of the pieces differs. On the other hand, there’s no evidence that I’ve seen that suggests Chopin intended the pieces as ‘a set’, to be played through in their entirety, even though pianists often do these days. Evidence from his own playing indicates that he’d typically perform half a dozen of them, say, as evocative miniatures. So that’s what you’re going to get today, in that I’ve picked out seven of the pieces as illustrations of the diversity that exists within this collection. So, here are links to seven different pianists in video recordings (in concert or in the recording studio) of some of the Preludes, Op 28: Khatia Buniatishvili playing the Prelude No 4 in E Minor as an encore here: Chopin: Prelude Op 28 No 4 in E Minor; Alessandra Ammara playing the Prelude No 6 in B Minor (a piece played at Chopin’s funeral) here: Chopin: Prelude Op 28 No 6 in B Minor; Marjan Kiepura playing the very short Prelude No 7 in A (after a short introduction) here: Chopin Prelude Op 28 No 7 in A; Lara Melda playing the Prelude No 8 in F# Minor here: Chopin: Prelude Op 28 No 8 in F# Minor; Eric Lu playing the Prelude No 9 in E here: Chopin: Prelude Op 28 No 9 in E; Lang Lang playing the Prelude No 15 in Db, the ‘Raindrop’, really absurdly slowly here: Chopin: Prelude Op 28 No 15 in Db; and finally Rafal Blechacz playing the turbulent final Prelude No 24 in D Minor here: Chopin: Prelude Op 28 No 24 in D Minor
Day 348: Two Nocturnes, Op 27 (Time: 10 minutes) and Three Mazurkas, Op 59 (11 minutes)
Chopin has featured only a couple of times during the existence of this list – back on Day 8 when I chose his Ballade No 1 and the Prelude in C# Minor Op Posth, and Day 241 when I chose a selection of his 24 Preludes Op 28 – so it’s about time today (2/12/22) that we had some more. Tim Horton, whose solo recital this month includes some Chopin, has been at pains to say that Chopin is not just one of the greatest composers of music for the piano, but in fact one of the greatest composers, full stop. It’s just the fact that all of Chopin’s music features the piano that makes the world think of him as being pigeon-holed more narrowly. Chopin did write some large-scale music for the piano, notably the three piano sonatas and the two piano concertos, and there’s the cello sonata with piano and an early piano trio. However, for the most part, his output appears to define him as a miniaturist: of the other solo piano pieces only the Allegro de Concert Op 46, the F Minor Fantasy Op 49 and a couple of the Polonaises run to over 10 minutes in normal performances. So, we’re left with, as it were, ‘worlds in miniature’ – but what worlds! Horton’s recital includes both nocturnes and mazurkas, so I thought it was worth considering both genres. As we know (see Day 237!) Chopin didn’t ‘invent’ the Nocturne – John Field did. However, there’s no doubt that Chopin discovered in this dreamy, ‘late night’ music rich new landscapes. Chopin produced 18 numbered Nocturnes, along with the posthumous one I’ve featured before and two unnumbered nocturnes from early in his career. What the nocturnes have in common is (I generalise crudely) slow tempi, languorous but ‘song-like’ melodies in the right hand, and a kind of ‘rippling’ accompaniment in the left. However, compared to Field’s pieces, the structures are more complex, and the sense of drama is greater, because of Chopin’s mastery of the creation and release of tension. The pieces featured in Tim Horton’s recital are the Two Nocturnes, Op 27. They were composed in 1836, and they mark a development in what Chopin was doing with the form: they’re longer than the previous published nocturnes, and considerably more expressive. The first, in C# Minor, is dreamy at the start; but, even here, it feels troubled and uneasy emotionally, and the middle section is especially restless. There’s a burst of light at the end of the work, but this is a long way from something soft-focus and innocuous. The Nocturne Op 27 No 2 in Db Major is less troubled, with an opening melody of aching beauty. It becomes more agitated later, but leaves the listener with a sense of gentle melancholy. The other works in Tim Horton’s recital are mazurkas. The ‘dance forms’ that Chopin developed into ‘art music’ are often a little showy (the ‘ballroom’ worlds of the waltzes and polonaises) but for me the heart of Chopin’s music lies in his mazurkas; these are the infinitely varied jewels of his Polish heritage polished into something sparkling but still intimate. The mazurka is a folk dance in origin, in three-four time (so like a waltz, but whereas in the waltz the stress is on the first beat of the bar, in the mazurka the emphasis falls sometimes on the second and sometimes on the third beat, so there’s always a sort of lilting, ‘limping’ quality to them). Their migration from rural dance hall to salon started before Chopin’s time, but he seems to have become close to obsessed with the form after the failed 1830 Polish uprising, and he continued to compose them until his death in 1849, producing in the end 49 numbered mazurkas, and another 10 from various points in his career. How close these concert pieces are to the ‘original’ folk form is up for debate: Bartók, for instance, writing a century or so later, claimed that these weren’t ‘authentic Polish folk music’ because Chopin had little meaningful exposure to such material. Whatever the case, the mazurkas still are, I’d argue, where you’ll find the ‘real’ Chopin, the works that are closest to the core of his being. Horton’s recital contains the Three Mazurkas Op 59. Composed in 1845, they don’t make great technical demands on the pianist (for the most part the melody stays within a relatively limited keyboard range), but there are, if you like, infinite grades of tenderness and yearning contained within these constraints. The second piece of the set was given by Chopin to Mendelssohn, as a gift for Mendelssohn’s wife. He had written to Chopin with the request, ‘Would you out of friendship write a few bars of music, sign your name at the bottom to show you wrote them for my wife, and send them to me? … Her favourite works are those you have written.’ (That might have been a bit crushing to Mendelssohn’s ego!) The last of the three pieces is a faster mazurka, a kind of whirling dance, though still hesitant at its core. As for performances, what you have here is a pair of recordings by the Russian pianist Yulianna Avdeeva. First she plays the Two Nocturnes, Op 27, which you’ll find here: Chopin: Two Nocturnes, Op 27. Then, she plays the Three Mazurkas Op 59, which are here: Chopin: Three Mazurkas, Op 59
Day 425: Berceuse, Op 57 (Time: 5 minutes) and Ballade No 4, Op 52 (11 minutes)
Chopin has featured on three occasions so far in this playlist’s existence, though given that on each occasion I’ve provided links to more than one piece of music, there is by now quite a range of compositions in the ‘back catalogue’ available via this site: the Ballade No 1, the Nocturne in C# minor, Op Posth, and the Two Nocturnes Op 27, the Preludes Op 28 Nos 4,6,7,8,9,15 and 24, and the Three Mazurkas Op 59. In the course of discussing these works in previous postings, I’ve written a fair bit about Chopin’s life and the context of his compositions, so today (31/10/23), I’m just going to focus on the two works in question. The first of these, and the only example of a work with this title in Chopin’s oeuvre, is his Berceuse, Op 57. The literal meaning of the French word ‘berceuse’ is ‘cradle song’, and it’s a work whose gentle, lulling beauty has made it immensely popular since Chopin wrote it sometime in late 1843/early 1844. This makes it a ‘late’ work, because even though Chopin was just 33 at the time, he only had five more years to live and was already dogged by ill health, with the consequence that his flow of creative inspiration was already slowing. Not that this lovely, tender piece shows any signs of angst or despair. In some ways it’s a disarmingly simple work, in that apart from a brief moment near the end the left hand plays the same two chords over and over again (the tonic and the dominant seventh, if you want to be technical, but ignore that if it means nothing to you!) – though it’s worth saying that when this left hand pattern does change the effect is wonderful – and this ‘rocking’ motion underpins the series of variations on a theme that the right hand plays over the top of it. It appears that the theme Chopin uses is a variant of a Polish cradle song with the catchy title, ‘The moon has now risen, the dogs are asleep’ (it sounds better in Polish) that Chopin knew from his own childhood. One of the things I love about this little piece is its constant flow – most ‘theme and variations’ compositions tend to make it clear where one variation ends, often with a literal pause, before the next one begins. Here, however, there are no breaks, but just this constantly repeated four bar loop. The variations get more fluid as the piece progresses, building up in complexity and speed until the ninth variation, and then gently winding down again afterwards. However, dynamically the piece remains hushed (it is designed to lull a baby to sleep, after all!) and we end in something pretty close to perfect tranquillity. Some rather florid things have been written about this work over the past 180 years. The Polish composer and musicologist Zdzisław Jachimecki wrote, ‘At first the melody of the Berceuse shows itself in its entirety. It is joined by the middle voice, which with its syncopations banters with the theme bars 7–10. Subsequently, the theme sounds solely in grace notes bars 15–18. Finally, it is pulverised into some luminous dust, transformed into a volatile state of almost immaterial little passages, trills and fioriture bars 44–46. Then (in the ending) it returns in its original form bars 63–66.’ (I particularly like ‘pulverised into some luminous dust’!) One thing worth saying about this piece in performance is that pianists often take some liberties with tempo. There are quite a few recordings on YouTube which proceed somewhat briskly (the recording by Arturo Benedetti Michelangeli will appeal if you like to hurry your infant to sleep), but other pianists have a distinct tendency to wallow. There’s a bit of that in the recording I’ve chosen, by Bertrand Chamayou, but my sense is that once you get used to the pace it’s hypnotically serene, even if the slight ‘out of sync-ness’ of the two hands is a bit irritating. The video here suffers from a nasty attack of ‘artsiness’, but you can always listen to it with your eyes closed! It’s here: Chopin: Berceuse, Op 57. Alongside that, the other Chopin work I’m featuring is the Ballade No 4 in F minor, Op 52. This is the last of Chopin’s Ballades, and was written about 18 months before the Berceuse. ‘Ballade’ itself is a term more obviously associated with poetry (hence ‘ballad’ in English), though by implication something to be sung rather than simply read. Chopin appears to have been the first to use the term to describe a solo piano piece (previous uses are in relation to songs). Apparently there is a literary inspiration, a poem by the Polish writer Adam Mickiewicz called ‘The Three Budrys’, in which a father sends his three sons out to seek treasure, but they return with three Polish brides. Hmm… Anyway, if there’s any evidence of the action of the poem in Chopin’s composition, it’s not something I’ve ever been able to hear. Musicologists get very excited about the 4th Ballade for its rich and complex structure, but I’m guessing that most people on this list don’t want a heavy dose of technical analysis with their videos, so I’d simply observe that it has a density and richness of detail that makes it feel like it lasts much longer than its actual 11 or 12 minutes. The great British pianist John Ogdon wrote illuminatingly, ‘It is unbelievable that it lasts only twelve minutes, for it contains the experience of a lifetime.’ There are quite a few good performances of the work on YouTube, but I particularly like this one by the Georgian pianist Khatia Buniatishvili, which you’ll find here: Chopin: Ballade No 4 in F minor, Op 52
Day 429: Scherzo No 2 in Bb Minor, Op 31 (Time: 11 minutes)
There’s been some Chopin on this list recently (see Day 425) but working on the assumption that ‘everybody likes Chopin’ (I certainly do!), you’re getting some more today (14/11/23). As I’m sure I’ve mentioned at some point over the three and a half years of this list, ‘scherzo’ is an Italian word, meaning ‘jest’ or ‘joke’. Its first usage as a title for a musical composition dates from the Renaissance (Monteverdi wrote two sets of them, for instance, where the sense is of a kind of light-hearted madrigal), but the term came to prominence at the transition between ‘classical’ and ‘romantic’ eras, when typically it was used to refer to a movement in a larger work – such as a symphony – in place of ‘minuet’ (see Beethoven, most obviously). Where the minuet was a regular and usually graceful three-in-a-bar dance form, a scherzo was more rumbustious and rhythmically ‘spiky’. In this sense, composers throughout the 19th century continued to write ‘scherzo’ movements in symphonies, string quartets and so on. However, the idea of the ‘Scherzo’ as a free-standing composition came to the fore in the work of Chopin. His four pieces with this title date from the decade up to 1843. They are (I generalise) ‘darker’ works than the ‘joke’ meaning might suggest – they have (apart maybe from the last of them) a sinister, violent energy. The first of them, Op 20, caused Schumann to write, ‘How is “gravity” to clothe itself when “jest” goes about in such dark veils?’ What caused Chopin to write these pieces isn’t clear, but they’re certainly part of the stylistic departure in his work after the failed 1830 Polish revolution, when he began to write works that were both more intensely ‘Polish’ and more darkly impassioned. They are all marked ‘presto’ or ‘presto con fuoco’ (with fire), with abrupt, spiky openings and sudden dramatic loud/soft contrasts. Given that Tim Horton is playing all four of these pieces in his concert later this month, I suppose I could choose any of them to illustrate Chopin’s genius, but (though it’s a tough choice) my favourite is probably the second of these works, so that’s what you’re about to get a link to. The Scherzo No 2 in Bb Minor, Op 31, was completed in 1837. To go back to Schumann again (his writings provide a running commentary on so many compositions in the second quarter of the 19th century), he wrote of this piece that it is ‘so overflowing with tenderness, boldness, love and contempt’. (How striking that last word is – probably best explained in that Schumann compared the work to Byron’s poetry, where ‘contempt’ features often enough.) Chopin is supposed to have said that the quiet ‘under the breath’ opening phrase is a question, to which the explosive second phrase is some kind of answer. Despite these contrasts in dynamics, it seems to me to be a piece that is unrelenting from start to finish. Even when the more lyrical central section appears, there is still tension, not least because of the dazzling passage-work involved. If your general sense of Chopin is that he’s a composer of delicate miniatures (all those nocturnes and mazurkas and waltzes) then the four Scherzos are something of a challenge to that view – and in this Scherzo No 2 that is especially the case. As for a performance, YouTube is quite well stocked with recordings, and from them I’ve gone for this reading from the pianist (and in more recent times also conductor) Krystian Zimerman, who was born in Poland, though he’s been a Swiss citizen for the past four decades. He first came to fame by winning the International Chopin Piano Competition in 1975, and since then the composer has often featured in his recitals and concert performances. The video here dates from 1987, so you’ll have to excuse its very ‘80s’ presentation (and Mr Zimerman’s hair!), but all that is worth it for the performance. You’ll find it here, though be aware that there’s no music for the first 30 seconds: Chopin: Scherzo No 2 in Bb Minor, Op 31
Day 469: Andante Spianato et Grande Polonaise Brillante, Op 22 (Time: 14 minutes) and Barcarolle in F#, Op 60 (9 minutes)
Tim Horton (of Ensemble 360) gives his final all-Chopin programme later this week, and so today (5/4/24), I’m taking two works from this concert to explore. We’ve had a fair bit of Chopin on this list – see Days 8, 241, 348, 425 and 429 – in part to reflect Horton’s series of recitals here in Sheffield. In those postings, you’ll get a lot of biographical and historical detail, so today all I want to do is to concentrate on exploring the pieces themselves. Horton’s recital ends (well, there’ll almost certainly be some encores…) with what is probably one of the oddest works in Chopin’s oeuvre, the Andante Spianato et Grande Polonaise Brillante, Op 22. It exists in two forms – one for solo piano, the other for piano with orchestral accompaniment (and it really is just an ‘accompanying’ role) – but that’s not its primary strangeness. Odder still is that it’s actually two different pieces, composed at different times, and then attached to each other by a kind of fanfare-like ‘joining passage’. The pieces are in different keys – the Andante in G, the Polonaise in Eb – and have utterly contrasting characteristics. It might be reasonable in that context to ask whether this yoking together of apparent opposites actually ‘works’ in performance. There are some strongly assertive views out there suggesting that it doesn’t, and that this is definite ‘chalk and cheese’ category stuff. In fact, those who do make a case for the work as a whole often cite this sense of disparate worlds coming into contact as evidence for its success, that something new and worthwhile emerges from the collision of opposites. The ‘polonaise’ bit came first, and dates from 1831, which makes it early Chopin, started in Warsaw in 1830 and completed in Vienna the following year. Other than this piece, Chopin wrote at least 16 other polonaises, and the defiantly nationalistic qualities of the form evidently mattered to him, especially during the years of exile from Poland after 1830. The distinctive rhythm – in which the 2nd quaver of a bar in three-four time is replaced by two semi-quavers (‘dum-diddy-dum-dum-dum-dum’, he said, technically…) – recurs throughout. Three years after composing this, Chopin wrote an ‘Andante Spianato’ in G, for piano solo. It’s not entirely clear at what point in the compositional process Chopin had the idea of then joining the two sections together. Certainly, ‘spianato’ (literally ‘smooth’) is a curious marking, and doesn’t occur anywhere else in anything Chopin wrote. If one played the ‘Andante’ entirely smoothly, the result might seem a bit dull, so presumably the value of hitching it to the polonaise is that the contrast between calm and rhythmic energy is made more extreme. There is a case for arguing that what Chopin was doing in the opening section was imitating the ‘bel canto’ style of operatic arias that were fashionable at the time; there is a clear ‘singing’ quality to this section. However you choose to hear this opening – a bit like a nocturne, a bit like a lullaby – there’s no mistaking the dramatic shift that leads into the polonaise section, or the ‘showing off’ element suggested by the way Chopin appends the description ‘brillante’ to his title. As for a performance of this piece, there’s quite a bit to choose from on YouTube, and out of the options I’ve gone for a video recording of the playing of Eric Lu, the American pianist who won the Leeds Piano Competition in 2018 (amongst many other competition successes), and was a BBC New Generation Artist from 2019-21. This video dates back to 2015, when (as a 17-year-old) he was performing at the International Chopin Competition in Warsaw. (He came fourth.) You’ll find the recording here: Chopin: Andante Spianato et Grande Polonaise Brillante, Op 22. The other piece from Tim Horton’s recital that I thought I’d feature is one of Chopin’s most popular works, his Barcarolle in F#, Op 60. This is (and, as noted previously about Chopin, all this is relative) ‘late’ Chopin, dating from 1846, three years before he died. This is the only ‘gondola song’ in Chopin’s output, though works with this descriptive title were not uncommon in 19th century music. The ‘barcarolle’ does indeed have its (watery) roots in Venice (‘barcarolle’ from ‘barca’ = ‘boat’), in the songs of Venetian boatmen, usually in a rocking 6/8 rhythm. There are loads of examples in 19th century opera, but Mendelssohn in particular popularised them in his piano music, where there are three different ‘Venetian Gondola Songs’ in the various sets of his ‘Songs without Words’ for solo piano. Subsequently, in the 19th and 20th centuries, you’ll find them turning up in the piano works of Tchaikovsky, Saint-Saens, Balakirev, Glazunov, and there’s a collection of 13 of them by Fauré. In fact, Chopin used to set his pupils to play Mendelssohn’s barcarolles, which may have given him the idea to write one of his own. At any rate, he never visited Venice, so we can discount direct personal experience. It’s well documented that pianists find this a difficult work to play, tricky writing for the right hand and a lot of stretching for the left. Its mood is ambiguous. There’s a sense of sweeping romance, but at the same time there’s something wistful, almost melancholy, about it. I like the comment of the musicologist Hugo Leichtentritt, who described it as ‘a work of bewildering beauty’. YouTube has several fine performances of this piece, but when I featured some Krystian Zimerman in an earlier Chopin posting, it drew some appreciative comments, so here he is again in this piece (and again looking ‘very 1980s’, but we should forgive him that): Chopin: Barcarolle in F#, Op 60
Day 511: Piano Concerto No 2 (Time: 33 minutes)
The 175th anniversary of Chopin’s death falls next Thursday, October 17th 2024, and that seems to me a good enough excuse to return to a composer whose appearances on this list seem to generate a warm response. There has been a considerable amount of Chopin on the Playlist before now, largely because of Ensemble 360’s Tim Horton, whose cycle of ‘Chopin plus…’ piano recitals have run here in Sheffield from 2022-24. What all the previous choices have in common is that they feature music for piano – no surprise, in that everything Chopin wrote featured the piano; but the previous choices are all for solo piano, so I thought it might make an interesting change today (11/10/24) to explore something for piano and orchestra. Chopin wrote a mere six works that involve an orchestra, and they all come from the relatively early years of his musical career. There were, seemingly, long-running but never fulfilled plans for a third piano concerto that Chopin was still discussing into the 1840s, but they amounted to almost nothing; the only hint that remains is a solo piano work, the ‘Allegro de Concert’, Op 46, which sounds very like the first movement of a concerto that hasn’t yet been orchestrated. So what we have left are pieces dating from when Chopin was 17-21 years old – not exactly juvenilia, but not the ‘authentic’ Chopin of the final 15 years of his life. (He died, don’t forget, at the relatively young age of 39.) These six works begin with the Variations on ‘Là ci darem la mano’, Op 2, (the theme being from Mozart’s ‘Don Giovanni’) which Chopin wrote when he was 17. A year later saw the appearance of two more obviously ‘nationalistic’ works, the Fantasy on Polish Airs, Op 13, and the Rondo a la Krakowiak, Op 14. Then, in the two years after that, Chopin wrote two piano concertos, and finally, a year later still, the Grande Polonaise Brillante (to which Chopin subsequently added an introductory ‘Andante Spianato’ for solo piano; the composite work featured on this list, in its version without orchestra, on Day 469). Out of those options, the work I’d like to focus on today (simply because it’s the one I like best!) is the Piano Concerto No 2 in F Minor, Op 21. To add a little to the confusion, although this work is numbered as the second concerto, it was actually composed first – it dates from 1829-30, whereas ‘No 1’ dates from later in 1830. The reason for the eventual numbering is that the concerto we now know as ‘No 2’ was only published in 1836, some years after the other one. Writing piano concertos was for Chopin a way of getting himself known – as has been frequently stated, the two concertos were ‘calling cards’, if you like, ways that Chopin could make a splash with the concert-going public. When he wrote the 2nd Concerto Chopin was still in Warsaw, and in fact he was only just out of school. And, like many impetuous and romantic teenagers, he appears to have been smitten with adolescent passion. The concerto seems to have been motivated by a young singer, Konstancja Gładkowska, who was the same age as Chopin, and whom he met when they were both studying at the Warsaw School of Music. (There’s an alternative narrative that says that the object of Chopin’s affection was actually a young man, Tytus Woyciechowski, the dedicatee of those Mozartian variations that were Chopin’s first foray into writing for orchestra, and with whom Chopin engaged in some rather adolescent homoerotic correspondence. But it’s generally the heterosexual narrative that has stuck.) Those looking for the musical clues to swooning passion tend to arrive at the central slow movement of the concerto. Chopin himself wrote of this infatuation: ‘I have – perhaps to my own misfortune – already found my ideal, whom I worship faithfully and sincerely. Six months have elapsed, and I haven’t yet exchanged a syllable with her of whom I dream every night – she who was in my mind when I composed the Larghetto of my Concerto.’ And it’s plausible to hear that movement’s richly spun opening melodic line as the articulation of a romantic spirit that was new to the musical world, and indeed the more turbulent central section, like a kind of operatic recitative, as the expression of Chopin’s yearning and frustration. It’s also worth saying that although this concerto, like everything else he wrote that involved an orchestra, has generally been the subject of condescending remarks about how Chopin ‘couldn’t orchestrate’, this middle bit of the middle movement treats the orchestra in a fresh and original way. Before the middle movement, the concerto begins with a reasonably conventional ‘Allegro maestoso’, in which, after the introduction, the orchestra largely recedes into the background, leaving the piano centre stage to explore a dramatic and urgent-sounding first theme and an altogether more lyrical, tender second theme. The final movement is strongly influenced by the dance, especially the section based on the Polish national dance the mazurka. (Chopin’s mazurkas for solo piano, of which there are at least 58, are, I’ve claimed before, the music which allows us to see into Chopin’s inner self most clearly.) There’s another couple of little orchestral flourishes in this movement: a passage in which the violins and violas play ‘col legno’ – hitting the strings with the wood of the bow, an effect much in vogue at the time (see also Berlioz’s ‘Symphonie Fantastique’); and a romantic horn call that interrupts the flow before the piano leads the work to its conclusion. The concerto had its private and then public first performances in March 1830. Chopin was unimpressed by the audience’s lack of enthusiasm. However, it didn’t take long for other composers to value it. Liszt, to take one example, said it was ‘of a perfection almost ideal, its expression now radiant with light, now full of tender pathos.’ As for a performance, YouTube is pretty well stocked with video recordings that are commendably fresh and lively. From the many options, I’ve gone for this version by the never knowingly overdressed Yuja Wang, accompanied by the San Francisco Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Michael Tilson Thomas. You’ll find it here: Chopin: Piano Concerto No 2
Day 556: Piano Trio (Time: 31 minutes)
Today (19/9/25), I want to consider another work from the new 2025/26 season under the banner of Music in the Round. The programme includes a real rarity from Chopin, which is my choice for today. Chopin has featured on seven occasions already on this list, and every selection has featured the piano – for the very obvious reason that literally everything that Chopin wrote featured the piano. All bar one of the choices have been for solo piano, although most recently, on Day 511, I explored the Piano Concerto No 2. Chopin wrote very little chamber music. In fact, you could pretty much fit it all on one CD. There’s a sweet if rather innocuous early set of variations for flute and piano on a theme by Rossini, and two pieces for cello and piano: the rather slight Introduction and Polonaise, Op 3, and the much more substantial Cello Sonata that he wrote a couple of years before he died. And then there’s the work that the Leonore Trio are playing in this concert, the Piano Trio in G Minor, Op 8. This is curious for lots of reasons. It’s Chopin’s only work for these forces. It’s also the only time he wrote an independent solo violin line in any work. Listening to the piece, it’s obvious that Chopin wasn’t actually all that interested in the violin, and the part he wrote for it is, to say the least, very basic. As you might expect, the work’s heavy lifting is done by the piano, but the cello does at least get some meaningful moments, and it’s evident that Chopin had much more sympathy for its sound than for that of the violin. It’s an early work, written before Chopin ended up exiled in Paris after the Polish Uprising of 1830. It appears to have been begun in 1827 (so Chopin would have been 17 or so), finished by the spring of 1829, and published (some dispute here) probably in 1833. Why Chopin wrote it, apart from wanting to explore one of the major genres of the day, is a bit of a mystery, but one clue is that he met a Polish nobleman, Prince Antoni Radziwiłł, in 1827, and the prince invited Chopin to stay for some time on his estate in Poznań (a location beloved of Manchester City fans, but that’s another story…), where Chopin seems briefly to have given musical tutoring to the prince’s two teenage daughters, one of whom played the piano and the other the violin. The prince himself was a cellist (Chopin wrote the Op 3 Introduction and Polonaise for him). It seems likely then that, even though the trio wasn’t actually completed until 1829, the Radziwiłł family would have played at least some of it during Chopin’s stay. (The rudimentary violin part may also be explained by the limitations of the young lady learning that instrument, since for the most part the violin barely moves out of first position in the whole of the first movement.) However, it also seems to have been a piece Chopin completed as ‘homework’, as part of his studies with Josef Elsner in Warsaw, which seems a bit prosaic, but then even homework can be exciting if you’re a budding piano genius. By Chopin’s standards, it’s quite a big work, in four movements, of which the first is the most substantial. This first movement, marked ‘Allegro con fuoco’, is indeed fiery and assertive, and full of dramatic gestures; in fact, I’d even suggest that there’s something Beethovenian about it, especially when the rugged and powerful opening gesture is set against a quiet, restrained ‘response’. The movement as a whole is structured conventionally (Chopin doing his ‘homework’?) but I think there’s something original too about the oddly ‘dream-like’ coda. The second movement is a lively ‘Scherzo con moto’. Most discussion of this work that I’ve read suggests that this is the weakest movement of the four, though there are hints of Polish dance rhythms in the middle Trio section. The slow movement finds Chopin on much more secure ground, where the emphasis is on the dreamy and poetic, showing hints of the composer Chopin would become. Finally the ‘Allegretto’ last movement reveals Chopin’s nationalist character, imbued with the spirit of, if not direct quotation from, a ‘krakowiak’, a Polish dance form. So, just ‘homework’, or something more substantial? Early commentators were largely enthusiastic (Schumann, always tending to gush a little when he liked something, wrote ‘Is it not as noble as one could possibly imagine? Dreamier than any poet has ever sung?’) but it soon faded from the repertoire. The great American pianist Emanuel Ax is obviously a fan, wondering why ‘so graceful and winning a piece is not more of a staple in the concert hall’. It doesn’t strike me as a work to get into any hypothetical Chopin ‘top ten’, but surely it doesn’t deserve its general neglect. See what you think, on the basis of this YouTube video. The performers are the Canadian ensemble Trio Fibonacci. You’ll find their performance here: Chopin: Piano Trio
Cima, Giovanni (c1570-c1630)
Day 520: Sonata a Tre, for Violin, Cornett and Continuo (Time: 4 minutes), Recorder Sonatas Nos 1&2 (8 minutes) and Ricercare for Organ (5 minutes)
The composer for today (13/12/24) was chosen by Malcolm Lambert, once Priest-in-Charge at St Tim’s, and member of this group since its inception in March 2020. Malcolm takes us a long way off the beaten track, requesting some music by the Italian early Baroque composer Giovanni Paolo Cima (c1570-1630 – but see below). As far as music history is concerned, Cima has one specific claim to fame – the composition of the first ever trio sonata (or at least, the composition of the first published trio sonata). In fact, information about Cima is pretty thin on the ground, and specific material facts about Cima’s life can be summarised pretty briefly. He seems to have been born in Milan around 1570, though I’ve not been able to find any evidence to confirm that date precisely. His date of death is equally uncertain, but all sources I’ve found claim that he died of ‘the plague’. The most common date is 1630, though other websites suggest anything from as early as 1610 through to 1622. We know that from 1595 he was director of music and organist at the chapel of Santa Maria presso San Celso in Milan, but there don’t seem to be any other references to further appointments, or support from wealthy patrons. He published both ecclesiastical choral music – notably his ‘Libro primo delli motetti a quattro voci’ in 1599 – and two mixed collections of choral and instrumental music, his ‘Partito de ricercari ed canzoni alla francese’ of 1606 and his ‘Concerti ecclesiastici’ of 1610. The last of these is a substantial collection of 52 pieces, of which five are ‘sonatas’ for various combinations of instruments, including the previously mentioned trio sonata. And in terms of sleuthing, that’s as far as I’ve been able to go as regards filling out details of his life and work. Certainly compared to his more illustrious contemporaries in Italy – Monteverdi and Frescobaldi – much of the story of his life seems a pretty blank canvas. So, what about this trio sonata? Well, as this is (I think) the first trio sonata we’ve had on this list, perhaps it makes sense first to explain what one is. Essentially, this is a composition for two ‘melody’ instruments (two violins, say, or a violin and flute, or – in Cima’s case – violin and cornett), underscored by a third ‘part’ playing a bass line. However, just to confuse things, this ‘basso continuo’ (later just shortened to ‘continuo’) was often given to two players, a low string instrument (the equivalent, say, of a modern cello) and another player on something that would produce chords (a harpsichord or similar). So, slightly weirdly, the norm was for a trio sonata to actually need four performers. Through the 17th and the first half of the 18th century this was probably the most common instrumental genre when it came to domestic music making, and people went on writing them really up to the beginning of the classical era. CPE Bach wrote plenty of them, for instance. At the earlier end of the historical spectrum, Cima’s sonata was published in his 1610 collection referred to above. It’s a short work, played here by Ensemble Sonnerie (audio-only, I’m afraid), accompanied by the musical score, which may or may not help you…: Cima: Sonata a Tre, for Violin, Cornett and Continuo. However, here’s a bit more where that came from. There’s a nice video recording of a couple of pieces by Cima that are usually known as Sonatas for Recorder and Basso Continuo, though also occasionally labelled as ‘Church Sonatas’ (‘Sonate da Chiesa’). On this video, there’s an initial discussion of the pieces so the music starts just over a minute into this recording. The first sonata is played by Jean-Marc Andrieu on recorder, accompanied by Yasuko Uyama-Bouvard on keyboard. For the second sonata they are joined by Laurent de Chenadec on bassoon: Cima: Recorder Sonatas Nos 1&2. And finally, because we don’t get much music just for organ on this list, here’s one of Cima’s pieces for organ solo, his ‘Ricercare per organo’, dating from the 1606 collection mentioned above. A ‘ricercar(e)’? Well, it’s hard to say, beyond that it’s an instrumental work, often vaguely improvisatory, and sometimes acting as an introduction to something else. Wikipedia helpfully says: ‘Whether a composer called an instrumental piece a toccata, a canzona, a fantasia, or a ricercar was clearly not a matter of strict taxonomy but a rather arbitrary decision’. Which is not a lot of assistance… Anyway, here is Cima’s ‘Ricercare per Organo’, played by Jacqueline Farrell: Cima: Ricercare for Organ
Clarke, Rebecca (1886-1979)
Day 209: Viola Sonata (Time: 22 minutes)
Next month, Ruth Gibson and Tim Horton (viola player and pianist from Ensemble 360) will be giving an hour-long concert in Sheffield of two works: Schubert's ‘Arpeggione’ Sonata and the piece I want to home in on today (27/7/21), the Viola Sonata by Rebecca Clarke. Clarke (1886-1979) is often claimed to be an ‘English’ composer, and it’s true that she was born here – but to an American father and German mother, and she retained dual British/US citizenship, and lived the last 40 years of her life in the USA. Considering key facts from her life story, it’s hard to avoid the sense that in her case, as in so many others, it’s the fact that she was female that makes her less well-known than she would otherwise have been. She studied briefly at the Royal Academy of Music but (sexism alert!) was withdrawn from the institution by her father when her tutor proposed to her. Clearly evidence of ‘one law for him, another for her’, her father than proceeded to disown her when a few years later she objected to his extensive extra-marital affairs. This left Clarke to make a living from music, which she did for some time, being an excellent performer on the viola. She emigrated to the USA in 1916 in search of better prospects. Her compositional career spanned only a few years, and her output consists of a handful of songs for voice and piano, some pieces for mixed choir, and a slightly larger collection of chamber pieces. There are early student works for violin and piano, but then, from 1917-23, a short series of works that keep her name alive. Tellingly, two of these were entered for music competitions under a male pseudonym, and in that guise the Viola Sonata won second prize in the 1919 chamber music competition sponsored by the Elizabeth Sprague Coolidge Foundation (an institution that acted as midwife to a large number of now mainstream works from the years after the First World War). The Viola Sonata is in the traditional three movements, though the second movement is a scherzo and the finale is marked ‘Adagio’. There are strong thematic links between the first and third movements, which gives the work a sense of unity. It seems to me to have a distinct English/French quality to its musical language. In one sense, you can hear the same sort of modal language based on folk-song influences that Clarke might have inherited from Vaughan Williams, and it feels as though it might have been written by Bridge or Ireland. However, there’s also a real whiff of French impressionism about it too, the language of Debussy or Ravel, particularly the latter's Piano Trio. People who’ve been reading these emails for months will be used to me writing variations on ‘sadly neglected’ or ‘deserves to be better known’ about composers and their work. In this case (as in all the others), it’s true, and it’s great to have the chance to hear professional performances of it here in Sheffield next month. As for a recording on YouTube, there’s a splendid live performance given by the violist Richard O’Neill, accompanied on piano by Jeremy Denk. You’ll find it here: Clarke: Viola Sonata
Coleridge-Taylor, Samuel (1875-1912)
Day 134: Ballade for Orchestra, Op 33 (Time: 14 minutes)
Welcome to the second of David's selections of music by black musicians to mark the occasion of Black History Month (celebrated every October in the UK). After ‘the black Mozart’ on Tuesday, today (6/11/20) we have someone who might, flippantly, have been labelled ‘the black Lakeland poet’. This is Samuel Coleridge-Taylor (1875-1912), not to be confused with the writer Samuel Taylor Coleridge, though he was named after Wordsworth's fellow poet and, ahem, addict. Samuel Coleridge-Taylor was of mixed race heritage (I do hope that’s an appropriate way to say it, not wishing to be inadvertently tactless), having a Sierra Leonean father and a British mother, and he acquired the hyphen in his surname during his teenage years, after a printing error (honestly!) had joined his middle name to what was previously his single surname. He made his musical reputation early in life, notably via the cantata ‘Hiawatha's Wedding Feast’, which he wrote while still in his mid-20s. Several tours of America followed, where he became known as ‘the African Mahler’, and was welcomed at the White House by then president Theodore Roosevelt. His visits to America prompted his developing fascination with the music and oral and literary culture of African-American people, and he subsequently wrote a number of pieces based on his Sierra Leonean ancestry. As well as the cantata ‘Hiawatha’, Coleridge-Taylor wrote extensively in most mainstream musical forms, notably chamber music, works for solo piano, and a number of orchestral pieces, particularly a violin concerto, which is only just beginning to be recognised and recorded. He died of pneumonia at the young age of 37, and in that sense although he has an extensive catalogue of works to his name, he is one of the great ‘might have beens’ of British music. From his output, David has suggested that we listen to his Ballade for Orchestra, Op 33. This dates from 1898, and there is an endearing story behind its genesis. Apparently the Three Choirs Festival approached Elgar with a commission for a work for performance that year in Gloucester, but he declined, and apparently said, ‘I am sorry I am too busy to do so. I wish, wish, wish you would ask Coleridge-Taylor to do it. He still wants recognition, and he is far and away the cleverest fellow going amongst the young men.’ The work is in a single movement, and does not, as far as I am aware, have any specific programme. It is played in this recording by the Chineke! Orchestra, conducted by Wayne Marshall, in a performance from the BBC Proms in 2015. Chineke!, in case you haven’t heard of them before, are the UK's first professional orchestra made up entirely of BAME musicians. You’ll find the recording here:Coleridge-Taylor: Ballade for Orchestra, Op 33
Day 552: Clarinet Quintet (Time: 28 minutes)
Today (22/8/25), I’m considering a composer who was 150 years old (in a manner of speaking) last Friday, 15th August. We’ve had one appearance by Samuel Coleridge-Taylor on this list before – see Day 134 for his Ballade for Orchestra – but a big anniversary is occasion enough for another exploration of this fascinating composer. Coleridge-Taylor (1875-1912) was only in his early 20s when he wrote that orchestral ‘Ballade’, but he had already established a significant reputation as a composer by then, a reputation that was briefly to turn stratospheric a couple of years later with the appearance of his cantata ‘Hiawatha’s Wedding Feast’ when he was still only 25. There seems no doubt that had Coleridge-Taylor not died of pneumonia at the relatively young age of 37 he would now be regarded as one of the major British composers of the first half of the 20th century. Indeed, his great success in America on his visits there in the early 1900s perhaps suggests a global renown. However, although he was a prolific composer during his lifetime, what we have is only a taster for what might have been – an observation that’s particularly true when it comes to Coleridge-Taylor’s output of chamber music. The great majority of his chamber compositions date from before 1900. After that date there’s a Romance for violin and piano from 1904, a set of variations for cello and piano from 1905, the Five Negro Melodies for Piano Trio from 1906, a Ballade for Violin and Piano from 1909, and (most tantalisingly of all) a String Quartet from the last few years of his life that is sadly lost. However, at the earlier end of his composing life, chamber music seems to have been at the forefront of his creativity. Coleridge-Taylor (at that point, one should say, simply ‘Taylor’, the hyphen appearing in his name only from his late teens onwards) studied at the Royal College of Music from the age of 15, initially as a violin student but quickly changing to the composition classes of Stanford, who held him in very high regard. Indeed, Stanford’s contribution to Coleridge-Taylor’s end of Easter term report at the RCM for 1895 is very sweet: ‘Regularity and Punctuality: Invariable. Industry: Indefatigable. Progress: Indisputable!’ The early works which generated his initial reputation were largely for chamber forces – in a sense this isn’t surprising, given that such pieces are easier and cheaper to put before the public. His official Opus 1 is a Piano Quintet, a substantial work which shows the influence of Schubert and Dvorak. His Opus 2 was a Nonet (for wind quartet, four strings and piano), another work of almost 30 minutes duration. However, his biggest chamber work, dating from 1895 (so Coleridge-Taylor was still only just turning 20), and my focus for today, is his Clarinet Quintet in F# Minor, Op 10. The back-story to this is quite droll. If you’re familiar with the clarinet quintet repertoire, you’ll know that there are essentially two towering masterworks for this combination of instruments – the clarinet quintets of Mozart and Brahms – and anyone writing such a work subsequently has daunting predecessors to compete with. Brahms’ work dates from 1891, and was regarded by Stanford (an avowed Brahmsian) as the definitive work for these forces. Indeed, as Stanford said to his composition class at the time, it would be impossible to write a clarinet quintet without being influenced by Brahms. Coleridge-Taylor’s Op 10 is his response to that challenge. Endearingly, when Coleridge-Taylor showed Stanford the finished manuscript, Stanford said, ‘You’ve done it, my boy!’ How? Well, listening to Coleridge-Taylor’s Clarinet Quintet (as I hope you will!) the inescapable shadow is not that of Brahms, but of his contemporary, Dvorak. However, to my ears at least it sounds like Dvorak filtered through the melodic and harmonic patterns of English folk song and of Negro spiritual. Given that Dvorak was just heading home from his stay in America when Coleridge-Taylor wrote this piece, it’s perhaps not surprising that it’s the recent, ‘New World’ voice of Dvorak that was most potent for the young English composer – an English composer who, by the way, was becoming increasingly conscious of his Black heritage, courtesy of his Sierra Leonean father. The quintet is in four movements, and is in many ways conventionally structured, though the scoring, in which we have two violas rather than the usual two violins, is less common. The first movement (‘Allegro energico’) is indeed energetic, from the cello’s forceful opening gesture onwards, and it’s not just a showpiece for the clarinet, which is often to be found filling in the texture or doubling the violin line. The slow movement, headed ‘Largo affettuoso’, is a lovely, genial thing, evidently shaped by the idioms of folk song, but with interesting phrasing – the key thematic elements are five bars and four bars long, so nothing feels too ‘four-square’ and predictable. I especially love the closing passages of this movement, the theme played high up on the cello, before the clarinet takes it up, with a hushed violin descant over the top. The third movement scherzo does that familiar thing of playing with the rhythmic contrasts of twos and threes (sometimes sounded as three groups of two beats, at others as two groups of three beats). But there are also quirky dynamic contrasts to disrupt any sense of predictability. The middle section trio is gentler, much more obviously revealing Dvorak’s fingerprints. The finale is driven by the rhythmic ‘Scotch snap’ (a short note on the beat followed by a longer one). Just before the end there’s a gentle reminiscence of the slow movement, before an excitable coda in which the spirit of Dvorak is once again to the fore. After its first performance in 1895 the Clarinet Quintet, like most of Coleridge-Taylor’s work except for the ‘Hiawatha’ music, disappeared for decades, and it’s only in the past 30 years or so that his work has been recorded and performed with any frequency. Certainly this piece, even for a 20-year-old, is surely the work not of a student but of a mature composer. As for a performance, YouTube has one or two video performances alongside audio recordings, so out of the video options I’ve gone for this one, given at the Mistral Music Festival in Boston (USA!) in 2021 – hence the masks… The performers are Sarita Kwok on violin, Stephanie Fong and Julianne Lee on violas, and Sasha Scolnik-Brower on cello (he’s now moved on to conducting, and is currently Simon Rattle’s understudy with the Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra). The solo clarinet is played by Todd Palmer. You’ll find their performance here: Coleridge-Taylor: Clarinet Quintet
Copland, Aaron (1900-90)
Day 36: ‘Quiet City’ (Time: 11 minutes)
Well, here we are. Into week six of the lockdown, and today (27/4/20) an accidentally appropriate choice from Malcolm, an atmospheric piece by Aaron Copland called ‘Quiet City’. As he has written to me: ‘A first appearance for Copland. Wonderful interweaving of the two soloists (Cor Anglais and Trumpet) and the strings. The title comes from the play for which the music was written. So the title isn't intended to be descriptive of the piece, but nonetheless makes this an appropriate choice as we enter week 6 of lockdown.’ You’ll find the recording, featuring Wynton Marsalis on trumpet (a second appearance on this list for him, having illuminated Handel's ‘Eternal Source of Light Divine’ a couple of weeks back) here: Copland – ‘Quiet City’
Day 193: El Salón México (Time: 11 minutes)
Copland has featured once before on this list (see Day 36) when we listened to his short, atmospheric orchestral piece ‘Quiet City’. Copland (1900-90) is often considered the first of the truly ‘modern’ American composers – at least at the time of his breakthrough works in the 1920s (retrospectively, of course, we can see that this overlooks Charles Ives, but in truth he has become more famous after his death than was ever the case during his lifetime). Copland was the son of Russian Jewish emigres, and was a quiet, bookish child with a strong left-leaning political streak. Like pretty much everyone in the musical universe in the first half of the 20th century, Copland had the obligatory sojourn in Paris at the metaphorical feet of Nadia Boulanger (one wonders how she found the time and energy) and he studied with her for three years. In fact, those Paris years were powerfully influential for Copland, who mixed not just with musicians but also the vast cohort of American writers and intellectuals who made their home in Paris between the wars. On his return to America, Copland's early mature works were modernist in tendency, ‘gritty’ works like the ‘Piano Variations’ or the Symphony for Organ and Orchestra. However, by the end of the 1920s Copland seems, in the same way that other composers across the world were doing, like Hindemith in Germany, to want his music to be ‘socially useful’. The influential figure in Copland's life here is the Mexican composer Carlos Chavez. He invited Copland to Mexico for the first time in the autumn of 1932, and the first fruits of that experience can be found in the composition we’re looking at today (1/6/21), the orchestral piece ‘El Salón México’, begun in 1932, though not completed for another four years. There’s a lovely quotation from Copland's ‘Autobiography’ about this work: ‘Perhaps my piece might never have been written if it hadn't been for the existence of the ‘Salón México’. I remember reading about it for the first time in a tourist guide book: "Harlem-type nightclub for the peepul(!), grand Cuban orchestra. Three halls: one for people dressed in your way, one for people dressed in overalls but shod, and one for the barefoot." When I got there, I also found a sign on the wall which said: "Please don't throw lighted cigarette butts on the floor so the ladies don't burn their feet." … In some inexplicable way, while milling about in those crowded halls, one really felt a live contact with the Mexican people — the atomic sense one sometimes gets in far-off places, of suddenly knowing the essence of a people — their humanity, their separate shyness, their dignity and unique charm.’ To this, I’d just add a quotation from Alex Ross's masterly ‘The Rest is Noise’: ‘Crucial to Copland's transformation [in the 1930s] were his adventures south of the border in Mexico. He first went there in 1932, at the invitation of the Mexican composer Carlos Chávez, and appreciated the adulation that Chávez and others offered him. “At last I have found a country where I am as famous as Gershwin!!” he wrote to the Koussevitzkys. … Galvanized by the Mexican scene, Copland began sketching the tone poem El Salón México, which, six years later, gave him his long-sought popular breakthrough. El Salón is richly stocked with Mexican melody and dance rhythm. At the same time, it retains the rhetorical punch of the composer's early modernist scores. As Michael Tilson Thomas has pointed out, the jaunty, upward-leaping figures at the beginning of El Salón look back to passages in the Piano Variations. Similarly, oratorical quarter-note utterances for the trombones and horns in the closing pages recall the craggy fanfares that set in motion the late-twenties Symphonic Ode.’ There are a lot of recordings of ‘El Salón México’ on YouTube, and many of them have considerably better sound quality than the one I’ve chosen. But I thought that, as a historical artefact, it might be interesting to see and hear the piece as conducted by Copland himself, with the New York Philharmonic, in 1960, at his 60th birthday celebrations. The performance is introduced by Leonard Bernstein at his most verbose, but once Copland takes to the podium you can sense the energy he transmits to the orchestra. You’ll find it here: Copland: El Salón México
Day 194: Fanfare for the Common Man (Time: 3 minutes) and Symphony No 3 (4th movement) (13 minutes)
Last time, we saw Copland achieve his first major popular success, the atmospheric and colourful orchestral piece ‘El Salón México’. Today (4/6/21), to pick up the narrative from that point, we can see that this marked the start of a rich period of composition for Copland, when his musical imagination and his socio-political desire to make his music communicate to as broad an audience as possible combined to produce a string of what are now seen as popular classics of American music. There were ballets exploring key moments from American history and culture: ‘Billy the Kid’ (1938), ‘Rodeo’ (1942) and ‘Appalachian Spring’ (1944). There was music mining the words of hallowed figures from American politics, like the ‘Lincoln Portrait’ (1942), setting a spoken reading of a number of Abraham Lincoln's speeches, including the Gettysburg Address, to a stirring orchestral accompaniment. He drew on the influence of jazz in the Clarinet Concerto (1948), which he wrote for bandleader Benny Goodman. Copland also became a significant film composer during this decade, notably scoring ‘The Heiress’ and ‘The Red Pony’ in 1949. Which brings us – almost – to the second of Andrew Weaver's suggestions for music by Copland, his Symphony No 3. However, as a kind of ‘amuse bouche’ to that epic work, I thought we ought first to consider a very short piece, written in 1942 to a commission by the Cincinnati Symphony Orchestra, and taking its cue from a speech given by the American Vice-President Henry A Wallace, in which he declared that the 20th century was ‘the century of the common man’. In fact, Copland's ‘Fanfare for the Common Man’ was one of 18 different fanfares that Eugene Goossens, the conductor of the Cincinnati orchestra, commissioned, intending that they should act as stirring introductions to the season's orchestral concerts – but Copland's work is the only one to have found a regular place in the concert hall. Since its first performance in 1943, it has been employed (one might think ‘exploited’ a better word) in a vast range of political, media and popular contexts. I can’t be the only one whose consciousness was scarred as a young adult by the Emerson, Lake & Palmer version. However, taken on its own terms, it’s a direct and powerful piece. You’ll find a strong performance of it here from the Orchestra of St Luke's, conducted by Gilbert Levine: Copland: Fanfare for the Common Man. Interestingly, having written that fanfare, Copland found it demanded more of his attention, and during the period 1944-6, as he was working on plans for his third symphony, the fanfare came to assume a pivotal role in the symphony's development. In fact, Copland's Symphony No 3 is an epic work (typically running to over 40 minutes), and it really deserves a full listen – but within the time constraints of this playlist, I’m going to focus only on the final movement. There are fragments from the Fanfare for the Common Man earlier in the symphony, notably in the first movement, but it is in the finale that the fanfare is given extensive development, initially pianissimo, but subsequently involving the whole orchestra in loud celebration. Some time ago, when I was considering Roy Harris's Symphony No 3 (see Day 179), I suggested that that work, alongside Copland's Third, were the two pieces that probably deserved the title ‘Great American Symphony’ (in the way that writers have been aiming to produce the Great American Novel). Listening to the final movement of this work, I hope you can hear what I mean. As for a performance, I’ve chosen the audio recording by the London Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Copland himself. You’ll find it here: Copland: Symphony No 3 (4th movement)
Day 271: Appalachian Spring (Time: 26 minutes)
Copland has featured on three occasions on this list (see Days 36, 193 and 194), during which I’ve explored pieces of his orchestral music – ‘Quiet City’, ‘El Salón México’, the ‘Fanfare for the Common Man’ and its use in the last movement of the Symphony No 3 – and today (1/3/22), we have another of these popular pieces with which Copland cemented his reputation as one of America’s leading composers in the 1930s and 40s. And it’s particularly fitting on the first day of spring that today’s piece is probably the most popular of all Copland’s scores from that era, the music he wrote for the ballet ‘Appalachian Spring’… although (and I say this before anyone emails me back to point it out) the ‘spring’ in the title is literally a reference to a water source, rather than to the season. (The title was suggested to Copland by the choreographer for whom he wrote the music, Martha Graham, taken from a line from a poem by the American modernist poet Hart Crane, called ‘The Dance’: ‘O Appalachian Spring! I gained the ledge;/ Steep, inaccessible smile that eastward bends/ And northward reaches in that violet wedge/ Of Adirondacks!’) However, given that the plot of the ballet involves essentially a welcoming of spring as an illustration of seasonal renewal, I feel reasonably justified in choosing this as our piece for today. Copland was commissioned to write the work in 1942, with the suggestion that the ballet should have ‘an American theme’. As he wrote the music over the following couple of years, Copland had no particular thoughts of either a title or the evocation of a sense of place. A matter of months before the premiere he still called it simply ‘Ballet for Martha’. However, retrospectively the music and the ballet’s narrative seem startlingly well attuned to each other. A quotation from a review of the work in the Los Angeles Times has become pretty ubiquitous as a summary of the plot, so I’ll quote it here too: ‘A young farm couple ruminate on their lives before getting married and setting up house in the wilderness. An itinerant preacher delivers a sermon. An older pioneer woman oversees the events with sympathy and wisdom. The newlyweds muse on their future as night falls. In the course of the dance, Graham reveals the inner lives of the four principal characters – Wife, Husbandman, Pioneer Woman and Preacher. She shows that the couple will face a future that will not be all sweetness and light, but she also draws out the private and shared emotional resources they will be able to bring to the challenges. Such is the power of Graham's images, however, that this very particular story broadens out to become a parable about Americans conquering a new land.’ (With hindsight, there’s some sense of unease here, for me anyway: ‘conquering a new land’ is all very well, but as we know it was someone else’s land first, and ‘conquering’ wasn’t just about taming the landscape. However…) The ‘folksy’ sentiments expressed in the ballet and its music culminate in the famous section in which Copland pens variations on the Shaker hymn ‘Simple Gifts’, no doubt one of the main reasons for the work’s enduring popularity. In musical terms, the piece exists in several versions. The original ballet score was for a chamber orchestra of 13 instruments. Later, Copland re-scored it for full orchestra, and there is also an orchestral suite, that edits out just under ten minutes of the music but retains the fundamental arch of the dramatic and musical narrative. It’s a lovely piece – pastoral, innocent, joyful and ultimately serene. YouTube has a number of good recordings in its archive, and from them I’ve taken this video of a concert performance by the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra conducted by Alondra de la Parra. You’ll find it here: Copland: Appalachian Spring
Day 562: Clarinet Concerto (Time: 16 minutes)
Today (31/10/25), we have another upcoming birthday posting, because two weeks from now, on Nov 14th, it will be 125 years to the day since Aaron Copland was born, so it seems only fitting that this occasion should be observed in some way. We’ve had four appearances by Copland on this list before now, and by and large I’ve focused on the more popular (maybe even populist?) pieces of music he composed – Appalachian Spring, the Fanfare for the Common Man, parts of his Symphony No 3, El Salón México and Quiet City. I had wondered about finding something a little more astringent this time round, but in the end, working on the assumption that what makes Copland’s popular works popular is their all-round accessibility and tunefulness, I’ve found another piece where the previous ones came from. However, as we’ve not yet had Copland the writer of concertos on this list, I thought that might be worth exploring – so what we have today is Copland’s Clarinet Concerto (sometimes referred to as his Concerto for Clarinet and String Orchestra … or even, when it’s standing on ceremony, as his Concerto for Clarinet, Strings, Harp and Piano). It’s conventional to regard Copland’s creative years as broken into three phases – up to 1935, when his music was finding its feet, experimenting and absorbing influences from the likes of Stravinsky and the group known as ‘Les Six’ in France; 1935-1950, when he was writing music pretty much directly aimed at the hearts and minds of American audiences, music of emotional directness and tuneful immediacy; and finally the post-1950 stuff, which is more challenging, less overtly melodic, more aware of the influence of Schoenberg and the music of serialism. Everything on this list up to now comes from that folk- and jazz-influenced middle period, and today’s choice, completed in 1948 and first performed a couple of years later, does too. The work was prompted by a request from the ‘King of Swing’, clarinettist Benny Goodman, for a concerto for him to play. Goodman, one should say, had always been interested in the classical repertoire as well as playing jazz with his own band. For instance, he recorded Mozart’s Clarinet Concerto in the 1930s, and in the same decade he commissioned ‘Contrasts’ for Clarinet, Violin and Piano from Bartók. For Copland, as for all American composers in the 20th century, jazz had been simply a part of the environment as he grew up. However, as Copland himself observed, it was only when he went away from America – studying with Nadia Boulanger in Paris in the 1920s and travelling through Europe at the time – that he realised how integrally a part of American identity it was: ‘The impression of jazz one receives in a foreign country is totally unlike the impression of such music heard in one's own country ... when I heard jazz played in Vienna, it was like hearing it for the first time,’ he wrote on listening to a jazz ensemble in Austria. However, there’s obviously a difference between writing jazz-inflected music and writing specifically for one of the icons of jazz to play, and initially Copland was unsure about how to fulfil Goodman’s request. Clearly Goodman wanted music that would enable him to show off his skills, and the many ‘voices’ of the clarinet, but integrating that into the (reduced) orchestral palate that Copland eventually settled on took a little while to bring into focus. Goodman’s perspective was that he ‘made no demands on what Copland should write. He had completely free rein, except that I should have a two-year exclusivity on playing the work. I paid two thousand dollars and that's real money.’ (How very American!) The structure that Copland eventually settled on was essentially a two-movement form (slow first movement, faster second movement) linked by a cadenza for the soloist in which Goodman could show off his technique. Curiously, though, it took Goodman a long time to perform the piece in public for the first time, and his two-year ‘exclusive’ performing right was almost up before Goodman played the work in a radio broadcast in November 1950. The first movement, labelled with impeccable logic ‘Beginning’, is predominantly slow and lyrical, a kind of cross between an expressive song and a slow dance. It was this movement, in many ways echoing the ‘innocent’, wide-open-spaces feel of music like the ballet ‘Appalachian Spring’, that led the choreographer Jerome Robbins to employ the music of the concerto as his ballet ‘The Pied Piper’ a year after its first broadcast. This first movement is marked ‘slowly and expressively’, and there’s little that's flashy here to show off the clarinettist’s technique, other than for long-breathed solo lines arching over and intertwining with the basic string sound. However, between the first movement and the second (again, quite logically, labelled ‘Conclusion’) there is a cadenza for the soloist, and here, gradually and seemingly inevitably, the clarinet shifts from elaborating rhapsodically on the song-like material of the first movement and begins to introduce the funkier rhythms of the finale. The cadenza is fully written-out (that is, it’s not a space for the soloist to improvise) but Copland consciously evokes the kind of ‘hot jazz’ improvisatory quality for which Goodman was famous. The finale is both jazzy and very ‘Latin’ in feel; Copland wrote most of the work while in Rio de Janeiro, and it’s not unreasonable to hear in this movement the sounds he was hearing around him at the time. One final thought: the original score still exists, in which amendments made by or at Goodman’s request can be found. The coda which closes the work was revised and a hand-written note added (though it’s not clear if Copland himself wrote it): ‘1st version —later revised— of Coda of Clarinet Concerto (too difficult for Benny Goodman)’ – though more recent performances, as for example the one below, restore the original ending. YouTube has some good, but I think one exceptional performance of this work. It’s by a clarinettist that some would say (I’d include myself!) is the greatest performer on the instrument in the world today. This is Martin Fröst, and in this excellent performance he’s also directing the Norwegian Chamber Orchestra. You’ll find their reading here: Copland: Clarinet Concerto
Corelli, Arcangelo (1653-1713)
Day 151: Concerto Grosso Op 6 No 8 ('Christmas Concerto') (Time: 16 minutes)
Welcome to this, the eleventh and final offering for Advent and Christmas. So, today (5/1/21), I thought I’d share with you one of the most popular of Italian Baroque concertos (after Vivaldi's ‘Four Seasons’), the Concerto Grosso Op 6 No 8 in G Minor by Corelli, a work better known as his ‘Christmas Concerto’. Arcangelo Corelli (1653-1713) is probably the most famous and influential of the generation of composers that came before the ‘high Baroque’ superstars, Bach, Handel and Vivaldi (with honourable mentions for Telemann and Domenico Scarlatti). In the late 17th/early 18th centuries, some considerable developments took place in the ordering and systematising of musical theory and practice, most notably the ‘formalising’ of the concept of tonality, and the tonal relationships that different keys have with each other. Corelli's compositions explore these ideas in a way that had not been attempted before. (Don’t worry – that’s as far as the music theory is going to go.) There is anecdotal evidence that Corelli visited the French court as a young man, but otherwise his career developed purely in Italy, primarily as a violinist, and subsequently as a teacher of the next generation of Italian composers, notably Locatelli and Geminiani. His compositions are almost exclusively in the field of instrumental music, either small-scale ‘trio sonatas’ (conventionally for two violins with a continuo accompaniment) or larger scale ‘concerti grossi’, a form in which much is made of the musical contrast between a small group of soloists (the ‘concertino’) and a larger orchestra (the ‘ripieno’). Corelli's set of 12 Concerti Grossi Op 6 almost certainly date from the 1680s, but they weren’t published until after Corelli's death – although their influence was significant even at that stage, and Handel's own set of Concerti Grossi Op 6, dating from the late 1730s, are modelled very closely on Corelli's works. Corelli's Concerto Grosso Op 6 No 8 has the inscription ‘Fatto per la notte di Natale’ (‘made for the night of Christmas’), and is scored, like the rest of the set, for two solo violins and a cello (the ‘concertino’ group) and a larger body of strings with harpsichord accompaniment. It has five movements, the last of which is almost certainly what gave the concerto its nickname, because it’s a ‘pastorale’ movement that summons up the ‘Christmas’ music of Italian folk culture and its characteristic ‘bagpipe’ drones. There are some very fine performances of this piece on YouTube, and out of them I’ve picked the recording by the Freiburg Baroque Orchestra. You’ll find it here: Corelli: Concerto Grosso Op 6 No 8 ('Christmas Concerto')
Day 213: Concerto Grosso, Op 6 No 2 (Time: 10 minutes)
This week, I want to explore two works which are linked across 300 years, starting today (10/8/21) with some music by Corelli. Archangelo Corelli (1653-1713) has appeared on this list once before (see Day 151) when I concluded a survey of pieces for Advent and Christmas 2020 by looking at his Concerto Grosso Op 6 No 8, the so-called ‘Christmas Concerto’. There are some biographical details and discussion of the concerto grosso as a form in that posting, so I won’t repeat that stuff here. Today, I’ve chosen another work from that Op 6 set, the Concerto Grosso Op 6 No 2 in F. As I mentioned when writing about Corelli previously, the set of 12 Concerti Grossi, Op 6, was probably written in the 1680s, but it wasn’t until towards the end of Corelli's life, when he had retired from public performance, that he prepared the pieces for publication in the volume that became designated his Op 6. One interesting feature about his collection that I didn’t mention last time, and which might be worth a little diversion today, is that these dozen concertos actually fall into two groups: the first eight are labelled ‘concerti da chiesa’ (‘church concertos’), whilst numbers 9-12 are called ‘concerti da camera’ (literally ‘room concertos’, but more typically ‘chamber concertos’). The distinction – and it runs in parallel with the similar contrast between ‘sonata da chiesa’/’church sonata’ and ‘sonata da camera’/’chamber sonata’ in compositions for smaller-scale forces – is rooted in the historical context for which such compositions were written. Oversimplifying hugely, in the late 17th century composers developed a range of compositions for use in church services, where they were substituted for the ‘Proper’ during Mass (that is, the bit of the liturgy that varied specifically according to the day or liturgical season, rather than being part of the ‘ordinary’, the bit which is pretty much constant from day to day). These instrumental compositions – the ‘church sonatas’ and ‘church concertos’ – evolved a four or five movement form, essentially alternating slow/fast in tempo. They came to be distinguished from compositions written for similar forces but in secular contexts – the ‘chamber sonatas’ and ‘chamber concertos’ – which usually also consisted of four or five movements, but in these cases a prelude followed by a series of dance movements. By the time Corelli was writing, in the last couple of decades of the 17th century, these distinctions were already starting to blur, but they are still evident in the way he organised his works for publication: his Op 1 and Op 3 sets are labelled ‘Sonata da Chiesa’, and his Op 2 and Op 4 sets are labelled ‘Sonata da Camera’. The Op 6 Concerti Grossi are written for larger forces (there’s a string ensemble as well as the soloists) but nevertheless Op 6 Nos 1-8 are in movements organised in a slow-fast-slow-fast pattern, whilst Op 6 Nos 9-12 are in movements organised with a prelude followed by a sequence with dance titles – allemanda, corrente, gavotta, minuetto, sarabanda, giga, and so on. (If you remember the discussion of Bach's solo instrumental works for violin or cello in previous postings, this idea of a prelude and sequence of dance movements will be familiar: the ‘sonata da camera’ is where all that started!) To get back to Corelli's Op 6 No 2, this opens with a movement that alternates Vivace and Largo sections. The second movement is an Allegro in a fugal style, with lots of imitative entries. Next comes a ‘Grave’ movement, in which sombre descending lines of melody dominate, before the final movement, a perky Allegro in two distinct sections, concludes the work. As for a performance, there’s a lively one by the San Francisco-based period instrument ensemble Voices of Music (even if rather bizarrely it breaks the piece up into ten ‘movements’: to map that against the four I’ve described above, you should interpret them as movements 1-6; 7; 8-9; 10 on the video). You’ll find the performance here: Corelli: Concerto Grosso Op 6 No 2
Crotch, William (1775-1847)
Day 545: Symphony in F (Time: 24 minutes)
Sometimes an innocent reader of these notes might think that there are moments when I lower the tone of the discussion from the elegance and sophistication that the exploration of centuries of musical riches might demand. And while I would, of course, reject such a foolish notion, the posting for today (4/7/25) provides a little more ammunition for those nay-sayers. Why? Well, I mean … William Crotch?? My excuse, of course, is that Mr Crotch was born 250 years ago tomorrow, so this is one of those familiar ‘anniversary’ postings. And, of course, this has nothing to do with the fact that said Mr Crotch has a comedy surname. We are, I’m sure, not so immature as to find such a matter funny, so I’m in no doubt that absolutely nobody on this list will want to click on the link here to the moment when a question on William Crotch appeared on the venerable TV quiz show ‘The Chase’. Well done for not looking…! So, surname aside, why spend time in the company of this most obscure of English composers? Well, as I’ve had occasion to remark on this list before now, what we hear of the music of the past is constrained by the ‘famous names’ that dominate each era. So the ‘classical’ period is defined for us by the music of Haydn and Mozart, and we assume that as early Beethoven and Schubert turn into later Beethoven and Schubert, we find ourselves being ushered gently (perhaps less gently in Beethoven’s case) out of things ‘classical’ and into things ‘romantic’. But meanwhile, literally hundreds of composers across Europe and North America were doing their stuff, and surely it’s good for us to know what they (or at least some of them) were up to at the time. And in England, that ‘land without music’, in the decades after the death of Handel (who was, let’s face it, actually German for most of his life), there were still English, or at least British composers, going about their musical business. Not all of them are now forgotten, of course: William Boyce, Jeremiah Clarke, Thomas Linley (actually, both Thomas Linleys), Samuel Wesley, Thomas Arne, Johann Baptist Cramer, William Herschel (when he wasn’t, ahem, discovering Uranus), James Oswald, and so on all turn up from time to time on the radio or on disc. And to this number we should add William Crotch (1775-1847). In some ways he had the worst possible start in life – not by being born into poverty and destitution, but by being, not to put too fine a point on it, a spoilt brat. At the age of two(!) he was performing for visitors at the family home in Norwich, including for the historian and musician Charles Burney. At three years old he was playing the organ in London for King George III and others. Contemporary accounts suggest he was a bit like a performing animal in a circus: The London Magazine in 1779 wrote that ‘He appears to be fondest of solemn tunes and church musick, particularly the 104th Psalm. As soon as he has finished a regular tune, or part of a tune, or played some little fancy notes of his own, he stops, and has some of the pranks of a wanton boy; some of the company then generally give him a cake, an apple, or an orange, to induce him to play again.’ Later, Crotch himself confessed: ‘I look back on this part of my life with pain and humiliation … I was becoming a spoilt child and in danger of becoming what too many of my musical brethren have become under similar circumstances and unfortunately remained through life.’ In fact, Crotch went on to become a substantial establishment figure – most obviously as the first Principal of the Royal Academy of Music during its first decade, from 1822-32. (Accounts by some of his pupils, like Sheffield’s William Sterndale Bennett, suggest that he was an impressively dull teacher.) Other claims to fame? Well, he might (or, as they say, might not) have been the composer of the ‘Westminster Chimes’ that we hear from Big Ben hour after hour. He is at least in the frame for being one of the suspects. He wrote music for pretty much the whole of his life, from his first oratorio as a fourteen-year-old, through to a great many choral motets and anthems and other vocal and organ works for the Anglican Church in adult life. He was, once the ‘performing seal’ phase of his childhood was over, known for the most part as an organist before his years as a musical administrator took over. In later life painting came to rival composition. He is (I don’t feel qualified to be sure) by repute an impressive water-colourist – the equal, certainly, of Mendelssohn as a ‘composer who also painted’. I wondered what to choose to mark the 250th birthday of this not entirely remarkable English composer. YouTube offers little in the way of video performances, except for small children playing easy piano pieces and the occasional choir singing an anthem. And even in audio-only territory, there’s still not a lot out there. In terms of orchestral music, his most substantial work is a Symphony in F, which appears to date from 1814. This isn’t, you may not be surprised to know, music to reveal Crotch to be ‘the English Mozart’, but it’s music with its roots in the classical era, with more than just a kind of nodding respect given towards the language of Haydn. It’s in the familiar four movements, with the slow movement placed second. The first movement opens with a slow introduction which feels a bit like he must have been aware of Schubert, but once the main ‘Vivace’ gets going it does feel very like Haydn, energetic if (unlike Haydn!) a bit dull in terms of its development. The minor key ‘Andante’ second movement has an attractively folksy feel. The third movement is a minuet, with a middle section that almost feels like a waltz – there’s certainly no sense that Crotch is aware of the more robust scherzo-style movements of Beethoven. The closing ‘Vivace’ seems to me to be pretty good, with some nice bits of counterpoint. So, would I make a claim for the rehabilitation of Mr Crotch? Possibly not … but he’s a composer characteristic of his age, conservative for his day, but worth his 15 minutes (or so) of fame. See what you think: you’ll find his Symphony in F played by the Milton Keynes Chamber Orchestra (apparently also known as the Milton Keynes City Orchestra), an ensemble of professional musicians who began working in Milton Keynes in 1975 but who, if the internet is telling me the truth, became defunct in 2019. They’re conducted by Hilary Davon Wetton, and you’ll find the recording here, accompanied by some early 19th century art: Crotch: Symphony in F
Crusell, Bernhard (1775-1838)
Day 558: Clarinet Concerto No 2 in F Minor (Time: 24 minutes)
In just under a fortnight (on 15th October, to be precise), it will be the 250th anniversary of the birth of (probably) the most significant Finnish composer before Sibelius. I realise that unless you have an interest in Finnish classical music, this might not seem much of a claim, but Bernhard Henrik Crusell (1775-1838) is a name much better known to those who play (or have a penchant for listening to music for) the clarinet. In any case, he’s the subject of my posting for today (3/10/25), and if he’s new to you, I hope you’ll be charmed by his lyrical music. Crusell was born into a Swedish-speaking Finnish family in 1775. In fact, Finland was ruled by Sweden for most of several centuries before that, and when the Swedes weren’t in charge the Russians were. In practice, it was relatively normal for many Finns to be Swedish speakers. (For instance, we tend to view Sibelius as the archetypal ‘nationalist’ Finnish composer, but he was actually a Swedish speaker by upbringing.) Crusell’s origins were pretty humble, his father being a bookbinder in the then small, isolated location of Uusikaupunki – also known by its Swedish name, Nystad – in south-west Finland. Although there was no musical influence in the family, Crusell seems to have been mesmerised by listening to musicians perform from being a small child. Eventually a family relative noted his enthusiasm, and as a child he began to play a friend’s clarinet, basically learning by ear. His big break came at the age of 13, when he was taken under the wing of one Major Wallenstjerna, who was based at the sea fortress of Sveaborg, just off the coast near Helsinki. Crusell became a member of the military band there, and from then on his career blossomed. Through the 1790s and early 1800s he travelled Europe, taking lessons from the leading clarinettists of the day, notably Tausch in Berlin and Lefèvre in Paris. From then on he lived almost entirely in Sweden, though he continued to refer to himself as Finnish. Apart from an opera, ‘The Little Slave Girl’, and a handful of songs, almost everything Crusell wrote was either for the clarinet as a solo instrument or for wind ensembles that featured the clarinet. There are three concertos, three clarinet quartets, three duets for a pair of clarinets, and a Sinfonia Concertante for clarinet, horn, bassoon and orchestra, and (though recordings of it are hard to come by) a set of variations on a Swedish drinking song for clarinet and orchestra! However (fascinating fact coming up) of all the clarinet concertos written in the late 1700s/early 1800s, only Crusell’s were written by someone who was a virtuoso performer on the instrument. Actually, this was the first peak time for clarinet concertos – along with Crusell’s there’s Mozart’s of course, but also compositions by Spohr and Weber – and this music exploited the fact that technological developments in the clarinet’s construction had moved on considerably since the clarinet made the transition from simple folk instrument (the chalumeau) to fully-fledged member of the orchestra as the 18th century drew to a close. Crusell’s three concertos are essentially classical in style (you’ll hear echoes of Mozart in these works), though they also offer glimpses of the impending Romantic era, with their lyrical, song-like lines. Crusell also seems to have listened to quite a bit of early/mid-period Beethoven. Of the three concertos, I thought I’d choose the second one, the Clarinet Concerto in F Minor, Op 5. This is sometimes known as Crusell’s ‘Grand Concerto’, and it seems to have been the most popular during his lifetime. It was dedicated to Tsar Alexander I of Russia, after Crusell was welcomed by the imperial family on a tour of Russia at the very end of the 18th century. There seems considerable debate about its date of composition, and I’ve read claims from as early as 1803 to as late as 1815; it’s only called ‘No 2’ because of the order of publication. It’s scored for a typical ‘classical’ orchestra (strings and winds, plus two trumpets and timpani), and it’s predominantly lyrical in mood after its dramatic orchestral introduction. My favourite movement is the slow central one, an ‘Andante Pastorale’, where the clarinet is accompanied by strings alone, and the whole movement has a gentle emotional warmth, though there are hints of something darker in the minor key middle section. The last movement is a cheery rondo, full of chances for the clarinet to show off, particularly in the coda that ends the concerto with a real flourish. YouTube has just the one video recording of this work, but it’s an attractive one, I think. The orchestra is the Finnish Radio Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Hannu Lintu. The soloist, the young Korean performer Han Kim, is principal clarinet with the Los Angeles Philharmonic and the Orchestra of Paris Opera – a definite rising star. You’ll find the performance here: Crusell: Clarinet Concerto No 2 in F Minor
Cui, Cesar (1835-1918)
Day 183: Song of the Most Holy Theotokos (Magnificat) (Time: 12 minutes)
This week, marking the fact that it’s Holy Week in the Eastern Orthodox Christian calendar, I thought I’d go for some Russian Orthodox church music today, and some music composed to commemorate Easter itself on Friday. So today (27/4/21), you have the answer to the pub quiz question (admittedly, a rather up-market pub quiz) that you won’t have been able to remember. When invited to name the members of the group of Russian Nationalist composers in the second half of the 19th century who went under the collective title ‘the Kuchka’ (‘the Mighty Handful’, and elsewhere ‘the Five’), César Cui (1835-1918) will have been the one you struggled to bring to mind. (The others, as of course I’m sure you know, are Balakirev, Borodin, Mussorgsky and Rimsky-Korsakov.) Cui is little more than a musical footnote these days. I’ve never heard a note of his music in concert, and it would surprise me if any of his compositions turned up on the radio from one year to the next. When he gets a mention at all, it’s as the composer of songs and rather ineffectual chamber music for the St Petersburg salons. Cui was, in the authentic sense of the word, an amateur composer. He had an entirely different professional life, in which he rose to the rank of General in the Imperial Russian Army. In fact, he was an engineer, particularly in the field of military fortifications, gaining the academic status of Professor as well as being a military General. He wrote several textbooks on the subject. As if that career wasn’t enough, he was also a music critic, writing nearly 1000 articles for journals in Russia and across the rest of Europe, but particularly in St Petersburg where he was an influential advocate for the music of Balakirev and his circle. (Almost inevitably, given the rivalry between Tchaikovsky and the nationalist group, Cui had little sympathy for Tchaikovsky's music. Tchaikovsky, one should point out, was splendidly abusive about almost all of the members of ‘the Kuchka’ in return.) As a composer, Cui's major interest was in opera, of which he wrote fifteen, as well as having a hand in the completion of Mussorgsky's unfinished ‘Sorochinsky Fair’. There are a great many art songs and piano pieces too, along with a substantial collection of chamber music, including three very attractive string quartets. However, the piece I want to home in on today was written for the church. It’s ‘The Song of the Most Holy Theotokos’, for solo soprano and mixed choir. It is, in effect, the Russian Orthodox equivalent of the ‘Magnificat’. There’s nothing specifically ‘Russian sounding’ about Cui's piece, except for the characteristic employment of low writing for the bass part, and one might think it a piece for the concert hall at least as much as for the church, but I think it’s very beautiful in places, and the first time I heard it I really didn’t expect the hushed ecstasy with which it ends. As you might imagine, it’s not a piece blessed with lots of recordings, but out of the selection on YouTube, I’ve gone for an audio version by the St Petersburg Chamber Choir, directed by Nikolai Korniev, and the mezzo soloist is the renowned Russian singer Olga Borodina. You’ll find it here: Cui: Song of the Most Holy Theotokos (Magnificat)
Curry, Jessica (b1973)
Day 312: Dear Esther (Time: 1 minute), 2. 'I have begun my ascent' (4 minutes), 9. 'Always (Hebridean mix)' (9 minutes), 16. 'The Very Air' (1 minute) and 17. 'Ascension' (all from 'Dear Esther') (4 minutes)
Today (29/7/22), the focus is on Jessica Curry (b1973) a British composer,
and someone who seems to have accidentally found her way into
the world of composing for video games. She was co-founder of the video
game developer The Chinese Room, mostly, it seems, because her husband, Dan
Pinchbeck, was developing an experimental video game in the early years of this
century, and asked Curry to write the score for it. This became the game
‘Dear Esther’, which was first available in a free-to-play format in 2008,
before being commercially released in 2012. In that iteration, the score
for ‘Dear Esther’ was nominated for a BAFTA; the sequel to that game,
‘Everybody’s Gone to the Rapture’, which came out in 2015, actually won Curry a
BAFTA for its soundtrack. ‘Dear Esther’ is an odd thing amongst video
games, in that it has no tasks to complete, challenges to overcome or journeys
to undertake. Indeed, one criticism of it is that it isn’t actually a ‘game’
in any meaningful sense at all, but might equally have found its way out into
the world as a film or a graphic novel. Instead, the player simply
explores the game’s setting, an uninhabited Hebridean island, and at various
locations listens to an anonymous man reading fragments of letters written to
his deceased wife, Esther. Much is made of atmospheric locations –
derelict buildings, a shipwreck, a cave system with markings on its walls – but
what it all means, if anything, is left to the player to intuit. (When I
wrote the previous posting, I claimed my only experience of video games was
playing ‘Super Mario Kart’ with my daughters. I realise, in preparing
this posting, that that isn’t quite true. Sometime probably about 30
years ago I was introduced to the game ‘Myst’ by one of my then brothers-in-law,
and I realise now that in some ways that must have been a forerunner of ‘Dear Esther’,
involving as it did the exploration of a mysterious island and deducing things
from the fragments of information discovered at various locations.
Nothing new under the sun, I guess…)
One of the interesting things about ‘Dear Esther’ is that according to an early reviewer
it ‘taps into an emotion that few games dare to approach: unhappiness’,
and that Curry’s music creates ‘an impressively ethereal atmosphere’.
It is the absence of puzzles, the lack of familiar game-playing requirements,
that allows the focus to fall on loneliness and isolation.
Curry has talked about her experience, not all of it positive, of writing music for video games,
which you can watch here;
she is also a former presenter of the BBC Radio 3 programme ‘Sound of Gaming’, in which she
has explored her own and others’ compositions for this still relatively young medium.
The score for ‘Dear Esther’ consists of 17 free-standing movements, most of them slow moving
and repetitive.
Stylistically, her writing has minimalist tendencies, resting on repeated keyboard figurations,
but overlaid by other patterns, predominantly brooding and melancholic in mood.
Given the setting of the video game, there is perhaps unsurprisingly a recourse to underlying drones and melodic figurations
characteristic of Scottish folk music. The result is, I think, undeniably atmospheric.
To give some sense of its impact, here are the first two movements from the piece,
its ninth and most extended movement, and the final two movements;
all of them are taken from the original soundtrack for the game. You’ll find them here: Curry:
01. 'Dear Esther',
02. 'I have begun my ascent',
09. 'Always (Hebridean mix)',
16. 'The Very Air' and
17. 'Ascension' (from 'Dear Esther')
Czerny, Carl (1791-1857)
Day 493: String Quartet in D Minor (1st movement) (Time: 9 minutes)
After Carl Reinecke in my previous posting, today (28/6/24) it’s the turn of Carl Czerny. If you have no back-story when it comes to playing the piano, it may well be that you’ve never heard of Mr Czerny. But there’s lots more to him than the writer of endless, somewhat dull exercises in piano technique, which is what he’s generally known for today. This very evening, the Consone Quartet (period-instrument playing, multi-award-winning BBC New Generation Artists) are performing at the Bradfield Festival, in a programme of string quartets by Haydn, Mozart and Czerny – one of a handful of his quartets that has lain unpublished for over 150 years in a dusty archive in Vienna. (I’m taking some liberties with the facts here. I can’t be sure about the dust.) They were only ‘rediscovered’ less than 20 years ago, and have gradually started to be recorded and – as tonight – played in public. So, is the music of Carl Czerny (1791-1857) worth exploring? As you might expect, my answer would be a resounding ‘yes’. Well, a qualified, resounding ‘yes’. I should explain. Czerny’s main reputation – in his day and afterwards – is as a teacher, of pianists and of piano technique. In that regard, he was immensely prolific. His published works get as far as Op 861, and as many of these are ‘multi-piece’ sets, it comes to lots more than 1000 actual pieces of music. There are, in addition (as, for example, the string quartets) quite possibly hundreds more works that are only now being excavated and made available. Czerny was, like so many of the people to make it onto this list, a child prodigy. From a musical but not an affluent family, Czerny began to play the piano aged 3, started composing at 7, made his public performance debut aged 9 playing a Mozart piano concerto. As you do. A year later he was introduced to Beethoven, who, by way of a challenge, asked Czerny to play his ‘Pathétique’ Sonata. Obviously Czerny passed the audition because Beethoven accepted him as a pupil, and Czerny remained close to Beethoven throughout the remaining 25 years of Beethoven’s life. He premiered Beethoven’s 1st Piano Concerto, and could play any of Beethoven’s piano sonatas from memory as a teenager. But what mattered to Czerny was to be able to earn a living, so from the age of 15 he began giving piano lessons to the great and the good of Viennese society. So, although he remained a performing pianist in public, his primary identity was as a teacher. Most famous pupil? Probably Liszt, but pretty much any roll call of mid-19th century piano virtuosi can be traced back to Czerny. To facilitate his position as piano teacher to the world, he published an array of compositions and volumes of exercises (titles like his Op 802: ‘Exercises Pratiques des Doigts’, or his Op 820: ’90 Daily Studies’). Would you like to study a composition called ‘The School of Velocity’ or ‘The Art of Finger Dexterity’? Well, Czerny’s your man. The problem with all this, as you might expect, was that it boxed Czerny in as essentially a rather dull pedagogue, strong on technique but short on inspiration. (Schumann on Czerny’s ‘Caprice on Themes from Meyerbeer’s “Les Huguenots”’, Op 424: ‘It would be difficult to find a failure of imagination greater than that of Czerny.’ Ouch…) Interestingly, Czerny himself catalogued his compositions in four separate categories: Studies and Exercises; Easy Pieces for Students; Brilliant Pieces for Concerts; Serious Music. And the sad thing, for Czerny’s reputation over the nearly 170 years since his death, is that that last category was kept deliberately under wraps by Czerny himself, in case it should interfere with his reputation as a teacher. In other words, there are lots (and this actually does mean lots) of works that were written, as the liner notes for the CDs I have of Czerny’s string quartets put it, ‘for the shelf’ – not to be published, or performed in public, but just there, buried in an archive somewhere (in Vienna), waiting to see the light of day. It is thought that there may be about 40 such quartets (nobody knows, and they’re still being unearthed), but the Sheridan Ensemble (a variably-sized collection of principal players from many European orchestras) has begun that work, with the recording of four of his quartets. One of these, the String Quartet in D Minor, has been performed a number of times (though not tonight, when they’re playing his A Minor quartet) by the Consone Quartet. There isn’t time (40-minute rule, etc.) to select all of it, but I’ve chosen the first movement, marked ‘Allegro Moderato’. And here’s another experiment for you (well, not for you, because you already know the answer, but try it on someone who knows, as it were, a bit about classical music): play this movement without telling them what it is, and ask them to guess the composer. I’d put 50p, were I that sort of chap, on the fact that almost all of them will say Beethoven. One or two might say Mendelssohn. I’d absolutely guarantee that nobody will say Czerny. It’s neatly put together: the first theme, on viola and cello, leads to a second theme in the major key which is in fact a variation on the first. There’s a satisfyingly agitated middle section before we end with a neatly telescoped summary of the opening themes. I think that if you want to explore string quartets from the period 1825-60 (that is, after Beethoven and Schubert, but before Brahms) then the obvious places to look are at the quartets of Mendelssohn and Schumann. But on the next tier down, as it were, alongside Ries (another Beethoven pupil) or Onslow, there surely should be a place for Czerny. As you might expect, there’s not a lot of Czerny out there in terms of performances on YouTube, but the Consone Quartet made a video recording of the first movement of the D Minor quartet last year. You’ll find it here: Czerny: String Quartet in D Minor (1st movement)
Danzi, Franz (1763-1826)
Day 584: Wind Quintet in Bb, Op 56 No 1 (Time: 13 minutes) and Quintet for Piano and Winds, Op 41 (25 mins)
Today (3/4/26), there’s another new name to add to the by now pretty extensive list of composers you can explore on this list. The reason for my choice is that on 13th April it will be 200 years exactly since the death of Franz Danzi, a composer of some note in his day, but whose reputation has only really recovered in the CD era over the past 40 years or so. Franz Ignaz Danzi (1763-1826) – and so with a birth date exactly midway between those of Mozart and Beethoven – was born in Schwetzingen, near Mannheim, which pretty clearly makes him a German composer. However, his father, an Italian, was in Mannheim when Franz was born because he was principal cellist in the famous Mannheim orchestra at the time. It’s not pushing things to say that Danzi’s music has a foot in both ‘national’ styles. If you’re not familiar with 18th century orchestral history, by the way, it’s worth saying that the Mannheim orchestra in the latter half of the 18th century, when Johann Stamitz was its leader, had a reputation as the top rank orchestra in German lands, famous notably for its brilliantly drilled string and woodwind sections, and in particular for two musical ‘effects’, the so-called ‘Mannheim rocket’, when the strings would perform fast rising scales (see the opening of Mozart’s Symphony No 31, for instance) and the orchestra’s steadily growing crescendo at moments of climax, of the sort that Rossini made famous in subsequent decades. Franz himself was primarily a cellist, and he joined the orchestra as a teenager in 1778, taking over from his father as principal in 1784. He later worked in Munich, Stuttgart and finally Karlsruhe. Danzi was famous in his day as a writer of music for woodwind ensembles, though his back catalogue contains the typical range of symphonies, string quartets and concerti as well. However, it’s the wind band that I’m going to explore today. Although wind ensembles had had a place at the various European courts for many decades, their development from the mid-1700s onwards is as striking, in its way, as that of the string quartet or the symphony under Haydn and his many Austro-German contemporaries. If there’s one name associated with early 19th century wind music it’s Anton Reicha (the Germanic spelling – you’ll find lots of variants, like Antonin or Antoine Rejcha). Reicha’s wind quintets raised the wind ensemble from being purveyors of light, ‘entertainment’ music to something closer to chamber music that placed higher demands on performers and audiences, the equivalent in many ways of the string quartet. (I’ll get round to Reicha one day, I hope…) Reicha was based in Paris, and Danzi first discovered Reicha’s wind quintets via the contemporary music press, and on exploring the written scores of some of them he set out to model his work on their rich sonorities, a mixture of an ensemble approach where all instruments sound together and the more individualistic, quasi-soloistic approach where particular instruments have a concerto-like role. Danzi wrote three sets of three wind quintets, scored (as you might expect) for flute, oboe, clarinet, bassoon and horn. They all seem to have been written in the first half of the 1820s – so, very much at the end of his life – though there’s little concrete evidence to suggest why he wrote them at that point in particular. Of the nine, I’ve chosen the Wind Quintet in Bb, Op 56 No 1, as a typical example of his musical ‘voice’. The Op 56 set was published in 1821 and dedicated to Reicha. It’s sparky and good-humoured writing, very ‘Classical’ in style (a big debt to Mozart, I think), but what I like most is the way Danzi captures the individual characters of the five instruments in a genuinely idiomatic way. There are four movements. The first is neatly organised and amiable, but the second shows something more pensive, in the minor key, where the lead is often the oboe or the bassoon, giving the music a less ‘bright’ character. The minuet third movement is typically ‘dancing’, and I especially like the playful dialogue of the instruments in the trio section in the middle of the movement. The finale is a good-humoured rondo with an identifiable ‘bounce’ to it. YouTube has a nice performance of the work in its catalogue, given by the Monet Wind Quintet, a group who met first as members of the German National Youth Orchestra, and who have performed as a quintet for over a decade. You’ll find their performance here: Danzi: Wind Quintet in Bb, Op 56 No 1. Danzi also wrote three quintets for wind and piano, which largely date from around a decade earlier than the wind quintets. Even with our ’40 minute rule’, there’s opportunity for another work by Danzi today, so I’ve chosen the first of these pieces, the Quintet for Piano and Winds in D Minor, Op 41, which dates from 1810. (Danzi published a version for strings and piano – his Op 40 – at the same time, which suggests a composer with an eye for as many audiences as possible!) Compared to the wind quintets, the piano here replaces the flute, which gives the whole ensemble a slightly darker sonority. It’s also clear that it’s the piano that has the most obviously ‘soloistic’ role, though there’s still the sort of ‘dialogue of equals’ at times between the piano and the various wind instruments that you’ll find in Mozart’s Quintet for Piano and Winds (see Day 538!). I make no claims for the Danzi in comparison to the infinitely superior Mozart piece, but it’s a good illustration of music of this era from the pen of a capable workman, as opposed to a genius! Danzi’s Op 41 is in three movements, though the first has a solemn slow introduction before we arrive at its genial Allegro main section. The Andante slow movement is the sort of thing that attracts an adjective like ‘charming’, while the finale burbles happily. There’s a nice video performance of it on YouTube, given by the Spanish chamber music group the Azahar Ensemble, with Rosalia Gómez Lasheras as the elegant and poised pianist. You’ll find their performance here: Danzi: Quintet for Piano and Winds, Op 41
Debussy, Claude (1862-1918)
Day 72: Prélude A l’Après-Midi d’Un Faune (Time: 11 minutes)
Today (2/6/20) is the last really sunny and hot day for a bit, according to the forecast, so I’ve gone for something languid and indulgent (though that’s just fortuitous – I was going to choose this anyway). I often ask myself (well, I don’t really – I’m just clearing my throat) what the point was at which we could say ‘modern music has arrived’. (I don’t mean in the sense of rock and roll, or hip hop – I mean the point which marks the shift from Romanticism to something more ‘twentieth century’.) There’s an argument for saying it’s in the first decade of the 20th century when Schoenberg and his associates dispensed with tonality altogether, and had to devise another system to keep the chaos at bay. There’s an argument for saying it’s 1913 when Stravinsky produced ‘The Rite of Spring’. Going further back, it could be argued that its seeds are there in the Prelude to ‘Tristan and Isolde’ by Wagner, back in the 1850s, with its sliding chromatic harmonies. But I’d like to stake a claim for today’s composition as being ‘the one’, if such a thing can be said to exist. Claude Debussy (1862-1918) was perhaps a quieter revolutionary than any of those mentioned above, but what he did with music in the late 19th century changed the landscape for good. The piece I’ve chosen is the ‘Prélude à l’Après-midi d’un Faune’. What is astonishing about this 1894 masterpiece is what it does with melody and harmony. Debussy makes particular use of what would become one of his fingerprints, the whole tone scale (try going up a scale on the piano C-D-E-F#-G#-A#-C), which has the unnerving quality of ‘floating’ harmonically, if you play any combination of those notes together, without any real sense of where ‘Doh’ might be. He also makes a lot of use of the tritone, a melodic leap (C-F#) that had been known for a long time (in the middle ages it was the ‘diabolus in musica’, because in diatonic harmony, when these notes are sounded together, they disrupt the expected harmonic pattern of fourths and fifths), as a signal of disturbance. [If all this music theory stuff turns you off, please feel free to ignore it!] Anyway, the ‘Prelude…’ is sensual, exotic, even erotic. Rather than me trying to explain it, here is Debussy himself: “The music of this prelude is a very free illustration of Mallarmé's beautiful poem. By no means does it claim to be a synthesis of it. Rather there is a succession of scenes through which pass the desires and dreams of the faun in the heat of the afternoon. Then, tired of pursuing the timorous flight of nymphs and naiads, he succumbs to intoxicating sleep, in which he can finally realize his dreams of possession in universal Nature.” There are lots of performances of this on YouTube, but the one I’ve chosen, by the LSO under the very dapper Francois-Xavier Roth, seems to me to be very beautiful. You’ll find it here: Debussy – ‘Prélude à l’Après-midi d’un Faune’
Day 113: Children’s Corner (Suite) (Time: 17 minutes)
Today (25/8/20), it’s the turn of Claude Debussy, and his ‘Children's Corner’ piano suite, half a dozen miniatures that catch wonderfully Debussy’s gift for scene or mood painting. Debussy has been on this list before (Day 72 – ‘Prélude à l'Après-Midi d'un Faune’) when I was mostly concerned with trying to make the case for Debussy as the instigator of what we might call ‘modern’ or ‘20th century’ music. Debussy is traditionally credited with being the first ‘Impressionist’ composer (impressionism being all the rage at the end of the 19th century, in art in particular), though Debussy himself rejected the label. Debussy had a rather turbulent personal life, and there are very clear grounds for deploring his treatment of women, given his serial affairs and abandonments. In fact, it’s often stated almost as a fact that the only person Debussy really loved was himself. However, that reckons without his devotion to his only child, Claude-Emma (‘Chou-Chou’), the daughter he had with Emma Bardac, the wife of a Parisian banker (who was herself not averse to a history of marital infidelity, having previously been mistress for a while of Faure). Debussy wrote the ‘Children's Corner’ pieces in 1908, dedicating them to his three-year old ‘ma chère petite Chouchou’. (A sad footnote: Debussy died of cancer in 1918 at the age of only 55, and Claude-Emma survived him by only another year, dying of diphtheria in 1919.) The six pieces that make up the suite begin with a gentle mockery of 19th century piano studies which are the (usually dull) building blocks of children's piano technique, which Debussy called ‘Dr Gradus ad Parnassum’. This is followed by five character pieces: ‘Jimbo's Lullaby’, about a captive elephant; the rather oriental-sounding ‘Serenade of the Doll’; the flickering snowflakes of ‘The Snow is Dancing’; ‘The Little Shepherd’, with its imitation flute calls; and finally the immensely popular ‘Golliwogg's Cakewalk’. In our rather more ‘woke’ era, this feels a little uncomfortable, but in the early 20th century, ‘golliwoggs’ - black dolls made up to look like blackface minstrels - were very popular. Whatever we feel about its provenance and nomenclature, the movement is infectiously playful, a ragtime number; and in it Debussy makes satirical use of the melody from Wagner's Prelude to ‘Tristan and Isolde’ (see Day 88!), following it with piano figurations that allude to banjo playing. As for performers, there’s no shortage of choices on YouTube, but I’ve gone for a very old 1960s film of Arturo Benedetti Michelangeli. He was one of the 20th century's great pianists, even if he was given to living a reclusive lifestyle and cancelling performances at short notice. He committed relatively little music to disc, given his standing, but this 1962 film gives a little sense of his talent, playful and fastidious at the same time. You’ll find it here: Debussy: Children's Corner (Suite)
Day 242: Preludes for Piano, Book 2 (Nos 7-12) (Time: 20 minutes)
Debussy has been on this list twice before (Day 72 for ‘Prélude à l'Après-midi d'un Faune’; Day 113 for the piano suite ‘Children's Corner’), but a posting discussing some of his Préludes for piano will open up a little new ground in understanding the range of his work. As we saw last time out, Chopin's Preludes were, if you like, miniature ‘mood paintings’, free-standing compositions (albeit composed within a strictly patterned framework of changing key signatures) that evoked a range of different emotions in their listeners. The ‘prelude’, in this sense, was a form taken up by other Romantic composers after Chopin — there are sets by Alkan, Cui, Scriabin and Rachmaninov, for example. However, with Debussy's two sets of Préludes, there is a notable change in both what the pieces set out to do, and how they proceeded to do it. Debussy published his 12 Préludes, Book 1 in 1910. The fact that they were published with the title ‘Premier Livre’ suggests that he already had a second set in mind at the time, thus completing 24 in total, after the fashion of Chopin and, before him, of Bach. The Deuxième Livre seems to have been written over about 18 months up to the early part of 1913, and the collection was published later that year. What makes Debussy's compositions in this genre distinctive is the extent to which they contain extra-textual associations. The pieces have ‘titles’, which allude to works of art or literature or evoke landscapes or weather conditions. Very few of them have titles which are purely musical. The other curious feature of these pieces is that the titles come, in the printed editions, at the end of each piece, the intention being to allow the listener to respond to the music ‘innocently’ first, and then be told what the composition was depicting. (This is obviously a trick that can only be played once – after that, you know what each prelude is called and the element of surprise is gone – but Debussy’s principal way of distinguishing the pieces is purely by their numerical title, with the ‘epigram’ being regarded simply as a footnote.) In relation to all this, a comment Debussy made to the composer Dukas is interesting: ‘It is unnecessary for music to make people think… It would be enough if it made them listen.’ The general view is that Book 2 of the Préludes is a little more challenging to listen to than Book 1, the pieces a little more opaque and allusive. This is ‘pure music’, each prelude with its individual sound world, as much as music that tells a story. Out of the 12 pieces in the Préludes, Book 2, I've chosen today (19/11/21) to present a link to the second half of the set, pieces 7-12. The seventh piece, ‘La Terrasse des Audiences du Clair de lune’ (which translates a little awkwardly as ‘The Terrace of the Moonlight Audiences’) – and I am indebted to playlist member Pete Dutton for this – was inspired by a phrase in an article Debussy read about a visit the historian Rene Puaux made to the abandoned city of Amber, near Jaipur (and is nothing to do with the coronation of George V as Emperor of India, the usual explanation). It seems to me to be ‘about’ the mysteries of the East. Then comes ‘Ondine’, about a mermaid unhappy in love. (If you want some extra listening, try comparing this piece with the middle movement of Ravel's piano suite ‘Gaspard de la Nuit’, also titled ‘Ondine’. Ravel's mermaid is much more troubled.) The ninth piece is ‘Hommage à S Pickwick Esq. PPMPC’, Debussy's tribute to Dickens and his character. The massively clunking opening quotation from ‘God Save the Queen’ sets the scene. After that, we have ‘Canope’, a depiction in sound of a burial urn of the sort used in Ancient Egyptian funeral ceremonies. Debussy's love for harmonic resonances in the style of Indonesian gamelan music is clear here. The penultimate piece, ‘Les Tierces Alternées’ (‘Alternating Thirds’) is the only prelude lacking an extra-musical title: it's a study in movement in rapid thirds. Finally, the set ends with ‘Feux d’Artifice’ (‘Fireworks’), a virtuoso piece of flashing cascades of sound; embedded near the end (in a nod to typical French July 14th celebrations) is a quotation from ‘La Marseilleise’. The pieces are played on this video recording (accompanied by appropriate images and pages from Debussy's challengingly illegible manuscript editions) by the American pianist Matthew Bengtson. You’ll find it here: Debussy: Preludes Book 2, Nos 7-12
Day 378: Sonata for Flute, Viola and Harp (Time: 17 minutes)
Debussy’s Sonata for Flute, Viola and Harp features in a Sheffield Chamber Music Festival 2023 concert later this month, which is my reason for selecting it for my posting today (9/5/23). Claude Debussy’s music has featured three times to date on this list (see Days 72, 113 and 242), but so far, although we’ve had compositions for solo piano and also a piece of orchestral music, there’s been nothing one might categorise as ‘chamber music’. To be fair, this is in large measure because Debussy didn’t write very much for such small-scale combinations of instrumental forces. There’s a very early Piano Trio, which dates from when Debussy was about eighteen, and which doesn’t sound all that much like the Debussy we’re familiar with today; there’s his String Quartet, written roughly when he was thirty and still a regular fixture in the repertoire; there’s the short Première Rhapsodie for Clarinet and Piano from around 1910; an even shorter solo flute piece, ‘Syrinx’ (which feels like a kind of off-cut from his ‘Prélude à l'après-midi d'un faune’); and then finally, in the last years of his life, there are three pieces for different chamber ensembles, and the Sonata for Flute, Viola and Harp is one of these. The origin of these late pieces is worth a bit of consideration. By 1914 Debussy knew that he was dying, having already been diagnosed with the colorectal cancer that would kill him four years later. 1914 also saw the start of the First World War, a time when to many French musicians the very idea of French culture was under threat. The attractions of hindsight in relation to Debussy’s compositions of the second decade of the 20th century are pretty obvious, but it’s not too much of a stretch to see a sense of the valedictory and the nostalgic in these works. It was in 1914 that Debussy’s publisher, Jacques Durand, encouraged him to consider writing chamber works, which led to the announcement of the imminent appearance of ‘Six sonates pour divers instruments, composées par Claude Debussy, musicien français’ (notice that patriotic final description). In some ways, Debussy was looking back to 18th century French musical culture, to the age of Rameau and Couperin, for inspiration. It appears to have been Debussy’s intention that the six sonatas would all be differently scored, and that the final, sixth sonata would include all the instruments that had featured in the previous five. In the event, Debussy’s failing health meant that he completed only three of the works: the Cello Sonata of 1915; the Sonata for Flute, Viola and Harp of the same year; and the Violin Sonata of 1916. (The hypothetical final three sonatas were for quirky combinations: the fourth for oboe, horn and harpsichord; the fifth for trumpet, clarinet, bassoon and piano; and the final one for an ensemble of the twelve instruments previously featured, plus a double bass to underscore the texture. One can only imagine what such a sound world might have been like!) The combination of flute, viola and harp is, it would appear, one that had not appeared before the early 20th century. Though Debussy was not the first to write for these forces (that was Théodore Dubois's ‘Terzettino’ of 1905) he was the second, and his Sonata of 1915 breaks almost entirely new ground in the way it treats the novel musical combinations of sound that the ensemble permitted. The titles of the three movements (Pastorale, Interlude, Finale) suggest something quite formal, harking back indeed to 18th century models, but listening to the music seems to me to be essentially an emotional experience. The liner note for the CD I have of this music describes it with vivid clarity as ‘a kind of desolate sensuousness’, which I think is lovely. There’s a lot of tosh written about Debussy as a composer (‘Debussy was the poet of mists and fountains, clouds and rain, of dusk and glints of sunlight through the leaves. He was moonstruck and seastruck, a lost soul under a vast sky illuminated by distant stars. His music begins where poets run out of words, where painters run out of paint.’ And so on…) Debussy himself seems to have been much more pragmatic. He wrote to Stravinsky that ‘I have been writing nothing but pure music in our old form, which graciously does not impose [Wagnerian] ring-cycle efforts upon the auditory faculty.’ It’s this sense of ‘purity’ that seems to me to come across most strongly in this luminous, uneasily-shifting piece. After hearing the finished piece, Debussy, by this point becoming a frail shadow of his former self, commented: ‘The sound of it is not bad, though it is not for me to speak to you of the music. I could do so, however, without embarrassment for it is the music of a Debussy whom I no longer know. It is frightfully mournful and I don't know whether one should laugh or cry - perhaps both?’ There is a handful of video performances of the work on YouTube, and out of them I’ve chosen this recording by the La Mer Trio, a group of three young(ish) award-winning female performers - Renate Sokolovska on flute, Maja Wegrzynowska on viola and Hannah Stone on harp. (Trivia fans may want to know that Ms Stone is also Mrs Bryn Terfel and, as if that wasn’t enough claim to fame, Harpist to the Prince of Wales!) I have been unable to discover if these performers still exist as an ensemble – the most recent reference to them that I can find is as far back as 2015 – but this recording shows you what they sounded like in 2014. You’ll find it here: Debussy: Sonata for Flute, Viola and Harp
Day 418: Première Rhapsodie for Clarinet and Piano) (Time: 8 minutes)
Debussy (1862-1918) has featured four times already on this list (see Days 72, 113, 242 and 378), and I’ve written a fair amount about the biographical and historical context for the works chosen on those days, so I won’t repeat any of that here. The work I’m homing in on today (6/9/23) – the Première Rapsodie for Clarinet and Piano – dates from 1909/10, and thus falls between the piano suite ‘Children’s Corner’ and the 2nd Book of Preludes, in terms of the works I’ve featured on this list to date. The Première Rapsodie is a work from what is generally regarded as Debussy’s ‘late’ period (usually defined as the years from 1906 until his death), and it has a very specific genesis. It was composed as a competition piece for the final examinations at the Paris Conservatoire for aspiring clarinettists. Now, the byways (usually) of musical history are littered with pieces composed for this sort of activity, and broadly speaking they tend not to be particularly memorable, or to have much of a life outside their narrow reasons for existence in the first place – they’re full of things that are hard to achieve for performers, and the focus tends to be on ingenuity rather than musicality. However, now and then one of these compositions escapes the confines of ‘exam pieces’ and becomes a fully-fledged independent work with a life in the concert hall. Debussy’s Clarinet Rapsodie is one such item. In 1909, Gabriel Fauré, at that time the Director of the Paris Conservatoire, appointed Debussy to the rather grandly titled position of member of the Conseil Supérieur of the Conservatoire (effectively its board of directors), which meant that Debussy had to provide music for the final practical examination for – in his case – clarinettists, and to listen to the candidates performing the work. It has to be said that Debussy seems not to have been thrilled at the thought of listening to 11 performers playing this same piece and (depending on what you read about it) he seems to have been broadly unimpressed by the whole experience, though he was apparently very taken by the playing of the winner of the competition, one Vandercruyssen, who, according to Debussy, ‘played by heart, and like a great musician’. Debussy actually wrote two pieces in his role as examiner – the other was a short sight-reading piece called, rather literally, ‘Petit Pièce’, which rarely turns up in public these days unless performed as a kind of aperitif before a performance of the Rapsodie. However, Debussy was so taken by the success of the Rapsodie that he orchestrated the work the following year, and these days the clarinet and orchestra version is probably performed more often than the clarinet and piano original. In either version, there are good grounds for seeing it as the first major work (even accepting that it lasts under ten minutes) for clarinet in the 20th century. Pierre Boulez observed, in a nice phrase, that it ‘hovers between reverie and scherzo’, and it exploits both the dreamy, singing quality of the clarinet and its more virtuosic tendencies. As the title ‘Rapsodie’ suggests, it’s a structurally fluid piece, of contrasting moods: there are long lyrical lines in a slow, flowing tempo, designed to challenge performers’ phrasing and breath control, but then there are other, ‘dancing’ sections which are playfully acrobatic and full of unexpected twists and turns, making great demands on technique. In particular, there are several complicated rhythmic traps for players to fall into. All of this might make it sound a bit contrived and unduly artificial, but the reason for its continued popularity is that above all it’s a wonderfully thrilling piece that transcends its ‘competitive’ origins to become one of the high points of the clarinet repertoire. Debussy was, no doubt, right when he wrote to a friend, ‘Surely this piece is one of the most immediately pleasing I have ever written.’ (One odd thing: it’s called the Première Rapsodie, which might suggest that somewhere out there is a ‘Second’ one, but if Debussy at any point planned this, it never materialised.) As for a performance, although there are more choices when it comes to the clarinet and orchestra version, you can select from quite a few performances of the work for clarinet and piano. I’ve gone for one by one of today's manifestly ‘superstar’ clarinettists, Martin Fröst, along with pianist Peter Friis Johansson, playing in what looks suspiciously like a college music room. You’ll find the recording here: Debussy: Première Rapsodie for Clarinet and Piano
Day 462: La Mer (Time: 25 minutes)
Today (8/3/24), we have one of the greatest orchestral masterpieces of the early 20th century. I’ve been sitting (metaphorically, obvs) on this suggestion for at least 18 months, but at long last, it’s time to hear Debussy at his most idiomatically sensuous and vivid. We’ve had Debussy on this playlist five times to date (see Days 72, 113, 242, 378 and 418) but so far only one purely orchestral work, the early (and startlingly revolutionary) ‘Prélude à l'après-midi d'un faune’, which dates from 1894. It wasn’t Debussy’s first orchestral work by any means, but it was the first that didn’t start life as a piano work before being orchestrated (usually by somebody else). After that, roughly five years elapsed before Debussy and the orchestra got together again, in the dazzling triptych ‘Nocturnes’, a set of three ‘picture paintings’ that seem like a response in sound to the works of the impressionist painters of the age. (One day, I hope, one day...) However, around five years later again, we arrive at today’s choice, the ‘Three Symphonic Sketches’ that otherwise are generally known as ‘La Mer’. (Debussy was evidently fascinated by pieces in groups of three. There is one more orchestral work after ‘La Mer’ which also groups three ‘illustrative’ pieces together, the orchestral ‘Images’ … although, even more quirkily, this piece contains a group of three within a group of three, in that the middle ‘movement’ ‘Ibéria’, actually consists of three movements itself.) Anyway, back to ‘La Mer’. This was written at a somewhat tempestuous time in Debussy’s life, when the fallout from his affair with Emma Bardac (some years previously the mistress of Fauré) caused a scandal. In the middle of 1904, having sent his wife back to her parents’ home, Debussy and Emma Bardac eloped together, initially and secretly to Jersey, and then to a village on the Normandy coast, from where Debussy announced that his marriage was over, and when his affair became public knowledge there were, as they say, ructions: Debussy’s wife attempted suicide, Bardac’s family disowned her, and in the aftermath Debussy lost a considerable number of friends, who sided with his soon-to-be ex-wife. The reason for all this domestic detail is that this is the reason why the genteel location of Eastbourne has such an immortalised place in musical history, because Debussy and Emma chose to escape the poisonous environment of Parisian life in 1905, spending the summer at the Grand Hotel, Eastbourne, where Debussy (when presumably not enamoured of his clearly fascinating mistress) was working on the orchestral proofs of ‘La Mer’. The work got its premiere in October of 1905, and it has to be said that it wasn’t an unqualified success. A leading music critic, Pierre Lalo (son of the composer: see Day 410), wrote: ‘I do not hear, I do not see, I do not smell the sea.’ There are other even more snarky comments. Try this one: ‘The audience seemed rather disappointed: they expected the ocean, something big, something colossal, but they were served instead with some agitated water in a saucer,’ wrote the critic Louis Schneider. Or this: ‘a lot of impressionistic daubs of colour smeared higgledy-piggledy on a tonal palette, with never a thought of form or purpose except to create new combinations of sounds. … One thing only was certain, and that was that the composer's ocean was a frog-pond and that some of its denizens had got into the throat of every one of the brass instruments,’ said the American critic Henry Krehbiel after the first American performance. The work’s three movements have pictorial titles: ‘From dawn to midday on the sea’; ‘Play of the waves’; ‘Dialogue of the wind and the waves’. (And one last iconoclastic quotation: the wonderfully droll Erik Satie wrote of his apparent approval of the work, noting in relation to the first movement, ‘I particularly liked the bit at about a quarter to eleven’!) If the earlier ‘Nocturnes’ had its inspiration in French impressionist art, the general view of ‘La Mer’ is that it’s greatest artistic debt is to Turner, and his seascapes. On the other hand, Debussy wanted a print of the Japanese painter Hokusai’s ‘The Hollow of the Wave off Kanagawa’ to be reproduced at the head of the score. It’s entirely possible to listen to this music and, as it were, let its waves of sound wash over you. However, it’s worth noting Debussy’s sub-title: ‘Three Symphonic Sketches’. I think ‘sketches’ is meant with at least a little irony. This is a meticulously orderly three movement symphony (an Allegro, Scherzo and Finale, if you like), with the characteristically late-19th century ‘cyclic’ form in which the finale incorporates two themes from the first movement. YouTube has a great number of very impressive video recordings of this work. It’s clearly a party-piece for many orchestras and conductors. However, from the options available, I’m going to go for my favourite Debussy conductor, Bernard Haitink, conducting his beloved Amsterdam Concertgebouw Orchestra. Recorded not long before his death in 2021, it’s clear that Haitink is physically frail at this point, but once he has the orchestra in the palm of his hand, he’s surely one of the best in this repertoire. No wonder the good burghers of Amsterdam give him a standing ovation at the end. You’ll find the performance here: Debussy: La Mer
Delius, Frederick (1862-1934)
Day 91: ‘La Calinda’ (from ‘Koanga’) (Time: 5 minutes)
Today (21/6/20), an offering from Malcolm for a short piece by the English composer Frederick Delius, Bradford's most famous musical son (even though he didn’t live there for long!). Delius (1862-1934) might be regarded as an ‘English’ composer, but his family background was German/Dutch (his father became a naturalised British subject in 1850), and he was named Fritz, which he used himself until he was 40. The family lived in Bradford due to its connections with the wool trade. Initially, Delius was intended to have a career in the family firm, but it quickly became clear that he had no interest in it – so his father sent him to manage an orange plantation in Florida (as you do). From America, Delius moved on to Leipzig, then to Paris, and finally to a village about 40 miles outside Paris, Grez-sur-Loing, where Delius lived for the rest of his life. His musical career flourished most strongly between 1900-20, after which he suffered from the impact of syphilis over the final 15 years of his life, becoming paralysed and blind, though still composing, with the painstaking help of his amanuensis Eric Fenby. The piece Malcolm has chosen for us to listen to is ‘La Calinda’, a short orchestral interlude from his early opera ‘Koanga’. Delius’ music was initially influenced by Wagner (hard to find composers who weren’t during that era), but there are subsequent layers of Grieg, Debussy and English folk song. The opera's roots are in Delius's American period, and its setting is a Mississippi slave plantation. (It’s not a terribly ‘woke’ piece, but then one wouldn’t expect that in the 1890s.) ‘La Calinda’ is an interlude from the second act of the opera, in context sung by slaves as part of the action’s wedding preparations. It’s performed in this recording by the Academy of St Martin in the Fields, conducted by Neville Marriner. You’ll find it here: Delius – ‘La Calinda’ (from ‘Koanga’)
Day 285: On Hearing the First Cuckoo in Spring (Time: 6 minutes)
I want this week to return to the theme of music for spring, which raised its head briefly in early March. My choices for the week are both English, one very famous, the other much less so. The famous piece is the choice for today (19/4/22). Frederick Delius (1862-1934) has appeared just once before on this list (see Day 91), when at Malcolm’s suggestion we heard his early orchestral piece ‘La Calinda’. In writing about that composition, I drew attention to the fact that talking about Delius as an ‘English’ composer is at best an ambiguous thing, given his German/Dutch heritage and the fact that he called himself Fritz until at least the age of 40, not to mention the fact that he only actually lived in England until his early twenties, spending the vast majority of his adult life in the French village of Grez-sur-Loing, near Paris. His most popular works emerged in the fifteen years 1905-20, including the orchestral tone poems ‘Brigg Fair’, ‘In a Summer Garden’, the ‘North Country Sketches’, the Scandinavian-influenced orchestral piece ‘Eventyr’ and the pair of pieces from which today’s choice is taken, the ‘Two Pieces for Small Orchestra’. One of the things that, despite his life story, makes Delius feel like an English composer is that so much of his work draws either explicitly on English folk song, or implicitly on the sort of music we might associate strongly with a very rural sense of Englishness. The Two Pieces for Small Orchestra had their first performances in October 1913, so there is about their sound world not just a sense of English local colour but also that characteristic nostalgia so typical of much English music of the era, that sense of a ‘lost world’ – something that became almost literal after the mechanised horrors of the First World War. The ‘Two Pieces’ are a pair of orchestral miniatures, scored for strings with a small band of woodwind (a flute and oboe, along with pairs of clarinets, horns and bassoons). The second piece – though actually written first – is ‘Summer Night on the River’, dating from 1911 (a piece I may come back to if/when we have a ‘summer’-themed phase). Its more famous partner was written a year later. It is the evocative tone poem ‘On Hearing the First Cuckoo in Spring’. The work in effect consists of two themes: the first is simply the call of the cuckoo, a falling major or minor third (an E to a C, for example, or Eb to C in the case of the minor key version), which we hear near the start on oboe and then in the strings. The second theme flags up Delius’s debt to and love for the music of Grieg. It is a tune taken from Grieg’s ’19 Norwegian Folk Tunes’, Op 66, for piano, where the melody is No 14 in the set, a tune called ‘In Ola Valley, in Ola Lake’. You wouldn’t know the music’s origin was in a piano piece, though; the scoring, particularly the way Delius wields the almost luminously glowing string lines (divided into up to nine parts at times, giving a rich, densely woven texture), and the forward-moving impulse (Delius marks the score ‘with easy flowing movement’) give the work a dreamy quality that is in no sense static. The cuckoo motif emerges most strikingly where the clarinet is given its characteristic two note ‘song’ (both major and minor versions!) ten times in the space of five bars. For all of Delius’s international cosmopolitanism, it feels as though we are rooted in a timelessly pastoral vision of the English countryside. As for a performance, we’re in audio-only territory here, in this recording by the Academy of St Martin-in-the-Fields, conducted by Sir Neville Marriner. There are also pictures of the Derbyshire countryside, not entirely fitting with the music, but there. You’ll find the link here: Delius: On Hearing the First Cuckoo in Spring
Diamond, David (1915-2005)
Day 180: Symphony No 4 (Time: 17 minutes)
If the previous posting on this list featured a (to us, here in the UK) relatively obscure American composer, in that probably the only piece of Roy Harris ever to be performed over here is likely to be his 3rd Symphony, then I’m willing to venture the opinion that the composer for today (16/4/21) will be even less on anyone’s radar. David Diamond (1915-2005) comes from the same school of composers as Howard Hanson and Roy Harris, whom we’ve met before, and others like Walter Piston or William Schuman, whom we haven’t (yet), in that he wrote music in all the major traditional forms (eleven symphonies, eight concertos, ten string quartets and an extensive range of other chamber and piano music) that was tonal and conservative (small ‘c’). This was music that found a wide audience and ready performers in the early-to-middle years of the 20th century, but which fell out of favour in the 1960s-70s when atonal and serialist compositional practices held sway. His Symphony No 4 was written in 1945, and was premiered three years later by the ubiquitous Leonard Bernstein. Robert Layton in his ‘A Companion to the Symphony’ describes the work as ‘an excellent example of [Diamond's] considerable refined sensibility and impeccable craftsmanship.’ The blurb underneath the YouTube recording of the symphony that I’m featuring has a rather more expansive and useful quotation from the composer himself, on the subject of its overtly romantic style: ‘I recognize, of course, that romanticism is currently the Cinderella, without possessing the social status of its older sister, the Neoclassicism; however, I accept it fervently, believing that, as I do, this romanticism will find in this country (the USA) a fertile soil for a new, young and vigorous youth.’ The piece is in three movements, moving from gentle beginnings in the first movement, through the contemplation of the second, before the third movement sweeps all before it with considerable rhythmic drive. There are relatively few performances of Diamond's Fourth Symphony out there, but the one I’ve chosen, an audio recording by the Seattle Symphony Orchestra conducted by Gerard Schwarz, is faithful to the composer’s intentions, I think. You’ll find it here: Diamond: Symphony No 4.
Dittersdorf, Carl (1739-99)
Day 513: Sinfonia in G Minor - 1. Allegro (Time: 9 minutes), 2. Andante (8 minutes), 3. Minuetto (5 minutes), 4. Presto con Garbo (8 minutes)
The subject for today (25/10/24) came into the world as the plain and simple Carl Ditters. However, before his demise – which occurred 225 years ago yesterday, and which is the reason I’m commemorating him and his works here – Ditters had found himself ennobled, and became henceforth known as Carl Ditters von Dittersdorf… or Dittersdorf for short. He is not, perhaps, a household name. You’re unlikely to meet any of his works in the concert hall, and even on the radio, such pieces are few and far between. But in his day (1739-99) he was, if not a front rank composer, then certainly one who mixed with front rank composers, and was himself highly esteemed. An anecdote from the 1780s: on occasion Haydn and Mozart met each other in Vienna, and one of their favourite pastimes was to make chamber music together. Haydn was a violinist, Mozart a viola player. But they greatly enjoyed playing string quartets, and regularly recruited two other performers who pulled in the crowds to complete the line-up – Johann Baptist Vanhal on cello (and we’ll get to Vanhal one day – he’s definitely worth it), and on first violin Dittersdorf himself. They were, if you like, The Traveling Wilburys of late 18th century Vienna. Which is, it has to be said, virtually nowhere (in geographical terms) but a long way (in musical ones) from where Dittersdorf’s story started. He was actually born in Vienna, where his father’s military pension was sufficient to allow young Ditters a decent level of education and regular music lessons. The child was clearly able: by the age of 12 he was a prominent violinist with a court orchestra in Thuringia, in central Germany. And now, if you’ll permit a diversion, here’s a general knowledge quiz. How many of the following people/places do you think are real, and how many are inventions: Prince Joseph Friedrich von Saxe-Hildburghausen; Adam Patachcich, Bishop of Nagyvarad; Philipp Gotthard von Schaffgotsch, Prince-Bishop of Breslau; Baron Ignaz von Stillfried of Neuhof, Bohemia? Well, the answer, as you might imagine, is that all of them were real, and these were the patrons of Ditters in his long, varied years of service at the courts of minor aristocracy and church figures of central Europe in the latter half of the 18th century. The ‘von Dittersdorf’, by the way, came Ditters’ way in 1773, when, in addition to working at the court in Breslau (by some distance his most enduring appointment) he was not just employed as a musician – in which role he was named a ‘Knight of the Golden Spur’ (a title also bestowed on both Haydn and Mozart) – but also, and here one might think this story is stretching the bounds of plausibility, a Forest Supervisor and District Administrator for the territory of Freiwaldau. Rather sweetly, our composer’s Wikipedia entry characterises him as ‘a composer, violinist and silvologist’! Anyway, in order to fulfil this non-musical role, he had to be made a member of the nobility (because only members of the nobility ever occupied the position), and so in 1773 the Austrian Empress Maria Theresia bestowed a title on Ditters – hence the label ‘von Dittersdorf’, where the ‘von’ is the marker of status. He retired from his musical and administrative roles in 1795, and lived out his final four years in a ‘spare’ castle (and let’s face it, who doesn’t have a spare castle or two knocking around?) of Baron von Stillfried, during which time he wrote (I am told – haven’t actually read it) an engaging autobiography and made some inroads into putting his life’s musical work in order. It has to be said, there was a great deal of stuff that needed ordering. In his day, Dittersdorf had an extensive reputation as a composer of Italian operas and German ‘singspiels’ (his big hit was the opera ‘Doktor und Apotheker’), but also as a prolific writer of chamber and orchestral music. There are many concertos, notably ones for the double bass, but even more symphonies. The regularly-quoted conservative estimate is that he wrote about 120 of these, and quite possibly up to another 100 that might be by him. Now, it’s easy, in contexts like these, to think, well, virtually unknown composer producing hundreds of symphonies as though off a production line – they mustn’t be very good… And that, I would contend, would be to do Dittersdorf a disservice. Some of the symphonies are, in the way of these things in the later 18th century, ‘programmatic’ works. There is a famous (well, relatively so) series of six symphonies based on tales from Ovid’s ‘Metamorphoses’ – titles like ‘The Transformation of Actaeon into a Stag’ and ‘The Transformation of the Lycian Peasants into Frogs’. Still others were exercises in musical ventriloquism – works like ‘Sinfonia of the Taste of Five Nations’, with movements in the German, Italian, English and French/Turkish styles, before they all come together in a Viennese finale. However, as an example of this prolific composer’s work, I thought I’d choose a symphony which is definitely not a ‘novelty item’, but rather a substantial and cogent piece in the late 18th century ‘classical’ style. This is his Sinfonia in G Minor, which appears to date from the late 1760s. The work shows Dittersdorf tuning in to the mood of the age, for this is the period of the fashionable ‘sturm und drang’ works of Haydn and CPE Bach, among others. Emotionally, it has a lot in common with Haydn’s Symphony No 39, also in G Minor. The opening Allegro is typically turbulent, but it has one formally curious feature, in that in its central section we don’t have a ‘development’ of this movement’s themes, but of other, seemingly unrelated ones. However, in the Finale these themes recur, and are subject to a development that links first and last movements together – the sort of thematic unity that would have been regarded as very novel. Between these outer movements, there’s an Andante and a Minuetto and Trio. Really it’s only in the Trio section of the third movement that there’s much in the way of sunlight in this symphony. That is, until the very end of the finale, when we are suddenly in G Major, and what seems like yet another new theme, before a kind of apotheosis based on the way the Finale opened. This is, in other words, interesting stuff, and not remotely formulaic. Unsurprisingly, YouTube doesn’t offer much in terms of Dittersdorf’s symphonies if you want a video recording, so today we’re in audio-only territory, and also (frustratingly) I can only give you four separate links to the work’s four movements, rather than a single link to the whole thing. Still, here the symphony is, performed by the Failoni Orchestra, Budapest, conducted by Uwe Grodd: Dittersdorf: Sinfonia in G Minor - 1. Allegro, 2. Andante, 3. Minuetto and 4. Presto con Garbo
Dohnányi, Ernst von (1877-1960)
Day 345: Sextet in C, Op 37 (Time: 29 minutes)
The man who signed most of his compositions Ernst von Dohnányi (1877-1960) was actually born Ernő Dohnányi, in what we now know as Bratislava in modern-day Slovakia. This, you might think, would not make him ‘Hungarian’, but he was the child of Hungarian parents and he lived all his adult life in Budapest until the upheavals of the Second World War… of which more later. I suspect one of the reasons Dohnányi gets less attention than he might deserve is that his musical style, whilst identifiably Hungarian in some ways, does not have its roots in Hungarian folk music in the way that’s true of Bartók and Kodaly. Instead, in many ways the earliest influence on his career was probably Brahms – more in the way his music was composed structurally rather than in the actual melodies he used. Dohnányi’s initial talent was as a pianist, but he was already composing by the time he started to study at the National Hungarian Music Academy in Budapest when he was 17. He graduated by the time he was 19 and began a career as an international concert pianist. He joined the staff of the Berlin Musikhochschule in 1905, but war intervened (not for the last time) and in 1915 he went back to Budapest. He was chief conductor of the Budapest Philharmonic from 1918-44, and on two occasions (in 1919 and again in 1934) he became director of the Budapest Academy. Which brings us to another reason why, maybe, we don’t hear as much about Dohnányi as we might, in that in the turbulent political world of inter-war central Europe Dohnányi appears to have been (metaphorically) shot at from the political left (for alleged Nazi sympathies – which recent research has demonstrated conclusively to be complete nonsense) and from the political right (for his dissidence against the prevailing fascist ideologies of the time). From 1945 performances of his music in Hungary were banned (until the 1970s!), and in the later 1940s he left Europe, initially for Argentina, and then from 1949 for the USA, where he was professor of composition and piano at Florida State University until his death in 1960. By that point, compared to, say, the music of the European avant-garde, his music was hopelessly old-fashioned (his final composition, his American Rhapsody of 1953, is a pot-pourri of American folk and popular tunes, including things like ‘Turkey in the Straw’ and ‘On Top of Old Smokey’), but although in the end his output isn’t huge (all that teaching, administration and, let’s face it, political turmoil got in the way – not to mention a rather vivid private life that saw him married three times) it’s rich in fascinating compositions. There are two large-scale symphonies (from 1901 and 1945, the latter revised 10 years later, so from either end of his creative career), two piano concertos, two violin concertos, an orchestral suite, the popular ‘Ruralia Hungarica’ (which exists in a variety of different formats), and the once extremely popular but now almost entirely neglected ‘Variations on a Nursery Song’ for piano and orchestra (‘Twinkle, twinkle, little star’!). There’s a great deal of piano music, mostly collections of shorter character pieces. Then there’s chamber music – three numbered string quartets, a piano quartet, two piano quintets, a violin sonata, a cello sonata, an exceptional Serenade for String Trio (which I’d strongly urge you to chase up) … and the piece I’ve chosen for today (22/11/22), his Sextet for piano, string trio, horn and clarinet. It dates from 1935, and is a substantial work in four movements. The first movement has a familiar classical sonata form structure (don’t worry if that means nothing to you!), but its marking, ‘Allegro Appassionato’, gives some indication of its emotional turbulence. In some ways the composer I hear most often in it is Mahler. The second movement is a kind of slow march, in which a tranquil mood gives way to something much more sinister, until tranquillity is restored near the end. Then we have a slightly sentimental scherzo (or at least a kind of hybrid form of scherzo and set of variations). This leads directly to the finale, which has a curious mixture of moods and textures, a helter-skelter movement which seems to show Dohnányi as a fan of those early Hollywood silent movies from the likes of Buster Keaton or the Keystone Cops. You might feel like you hear some jazz inflections here (jazz was all the rage for a while in central Europe between the wars) and ragtime, and further on a rather sentimental waltz. In all, it’s a rich and varied piece which hardly ever sees the light of day – but one which is great fun to listen to, and a taste at least of the writing of a much-neglected composer. YouTube is not well endowed with video performances of Dohnányi’s Sextet, but there is a handful, and from the options I’ve gone for a performance given in South Korea last year by a mixed ensemble of soloists: Elina Vähälä on violin, Sangjin Kim on viola, Eun-Sun Hong on cello, Radovan Vlatkovic on horn, Sérgio Pires on clarinet, and Ilya Rashkovskiy tackling the demanding piano part. You’ll find it here: Dohnányi: Sextet in C, Op 37
Donizetti, Gaetano (1797–1848)
Day 347: Sinfonia in G Minor for Winds (Time: 6 minutes) and Oboe Sonata in F (8 minutes)
225 years ago to this very day (29/11/22), Domenico Gaetano Maria Donizetti (1797-1848) was born in Bergamo, Italy. His reputation these days is founded very firmly on the production of music for up to 75 operas. (That figure is, as you can infer, a bit hazy – there is a handful of pieces that Donizetti may have contributed to, or which were completed by others, and some which are known about but which have been lost.) However you stack it up, that’s an awful lot of operatic music, given that he wrote them all in a period of about 25 years. His peak year seems to have been 1840, when no fewer than five new operas saw the light of day. He was almost exactly the contemporary of Rossini and Bellini, and between the three of them they dominated Italian opera during the first half of the 19th century, in the process making it fashionable across much of the rest of Europe (with the possible exception of Germany, which never really went in for this sort of ‘bel canto’ stuff in such a big way). There are a lot of famous Donizetti operas – you may be at least passingly familiar with ‘L’Elisir d’Amore’, ‘Lucrezia Borgia’, ‘Lucia di Lammermoor’ and ‘La Fille du Regiment’ – and a great many more not so famous ones (favourite title: ‘Emilia di Liverpool’). He was a pupil of the now almost entirely forgotten German composer Simon Mayr, subsequently finding training at the Bologna Academy of Music. Most of his big breaks as a composer came in Naples – 50 of his operas received their premieres there – but as his international reputation spread, he became a feted figure in Vienna and, notably, Paris, during his 30s and 40s. He died, back in Bergamo, at the age of 50, after some years of being institutionalised with mental derangement as a consequence of syphilis. Now, regular readers of these postings, if such folk exist, will know that opera is not really my bag, and so it may not come as a surprise to discover that I want to illustrate the music of Donizetti not with a show-stopping aria from one of his operas, but with some instrumental music from Donizetti’s youth. (The obvious thing to say here to readers who want operatic highlights is that you have to suggest them! I respond very readily to people’s ideas…) Anyway, as mentioned, Donizetti studied in Bologna in his late teens, and for reasons which are now rather obscure, he appears to have written an extensive amount of chamber music and concerti for various instruments with chamber orchestra support during those years. I should say at this point that I make no claims at all for the depth or substance of these works. They are lightweight, enjoyable, ‘late Classical’ pieces, exploiting the ‘singing’ qualities of the instruments Donizetti brings to the fore. (They strike me in many ways as similar to the String Sonatas that were a product of Rossini’s youth. You can see the direction of travel, even if we haven’t got to anywhere substantial yet.) So, here are two such pieces from the active stream of creativity that Donizetti was beginning to discover in himself. First there’s a work for wind ensemble, a ‘Sinfonie a Soli Instrumenti di Fiato’ in G Minor. This dates from 1817, so Donizetti was 19 years old at the time. It carries the rather grand dedication (translated into English!) ‘Dedicated to Signor Nebbie Deleidi by his obedient servant Gaetano Donizetti, Bologna, 19th April 1817’. It’s a short, single-movement work, and it has a kind of bubbling charm. The YouTube recording I’ve gone for is by the Spanish wind ensemble Grupo Harmonie, and you’ll find it here: Donizetti: Sinfonia in G Minor for Winds. Alongside that, here is a sonata for oboe and piano. This is another of the products of Donizetti’s early years. It appears to exist nowadays more commonly as an oboe concerto, but its original manuscript bears the title ‘Suonata per oboe e Pianoforte’ and it’s dedicated to ‘his friend Severino degli Antonj’ (about whom, alas, I can tell you nothing). It’s a chirpy little piece in F Major, and in two movements, though the initial Andante has a livelier episode within it. The second movement Allegro – and indeed the whole piece – allows the oboe to sing. The performance I’ve chosen is by the oboist Jens Georg Bachmann (YouTube tells me he’s also the Chief Conductor of the Cyprus Symphony Orchestra) accompanied on the piano by Simeon Spasov. You’ll find it here: Donizetti: Oboe Sonata in F
Dowland, John (1563-1626)
Day 163: Lachrimae Antiquae; Earl of Essex's Galliard; Mrs Nichols’ Almand (Time: 8 minutes) and Flow, My Tears (5 minutes)
Today (16/2/21), it’s the turn of John Dowland (1563-1626). In fact, the actual date of Dowland’s death is not clear, but what we do know is that he was buried on 20/2/1626, so this coming Saturday will be the 395th anniversary of that event. Many events in Dowland’s life are somewhat mysterious, and he seems to have had a number of simultaneous careers, which took him at times into some rather murky waters. He was probably born in London (even that isn’t clear), and early in his life spent time in France in the pay of two successive English ambassadors to the French court. He seems to have converted to Catholicism at this time, and there is tentative evidence that when he returned to England and married he may have struggled to get musical employment at Elizabeth's Protestant court because of it. One thing we do know is that from 1598-1606 Dowland worked at the court of King Christian IV of Denmark, where he seems to have been treated as some kind of musical royalty, and paid huge sums. However, alongside his musical activities, there is also evidence that Dowland spent time as a spy in the pay of the Elizabethan/Jacobean courtier Sir Robert Cecil, whilst in France and Denmark, and also that at some stage he travelled to Italy, where he seems to have got caught up in a Catholic plot of some sort against the English throne, before he got cold feet and confessed all to Cecil and Elizabeth I, and (unusually in such circumstances) lived to tell the tale. If there is one thing Dowland (the first syllable is pronounced as in ‘dough’) is famous for, it is for being miserable: his ‘catchphrase’, as it were, was ‘Semper Dowland, semper dolens’ (‘Always Dowland, always doleful’) – though here again it’s not clear if this was his actual temperament or whether he was simply cultivating an ‘artistic’ melancholic image. In terms of selecting a variety of short pieces to illustrate his musical personality (nothing that he wrote lasts more than six or seven minutes) I thought I’d share with you some music for viol consort, as this is not an instrumental combination that’s appeared on our playlist before. In 1604 Dowland published his ‘Lachrimae, or Seaven Teares’, a collection of instrumental dances that begins with seven ‘Lachrimae’ pavans, variations on a previously existing ‘Lachrimae pavan’ that Dowland had written, and which formed the basis for one of his most famous songs, ‘Flow, My Tears’, which came out four years earlier. (I told you he was miserable!) In this YouTube video the Concordia Viol Consort play three pieces from the ‘Lachrimae’ collection: the ‘Lachrimae Antiquae’ (which opens the collection) and two shorter dances, ‘The Right Honourable Earl of Essex, His Galliard’ and ‘Mrs Nichols’ Almain’ (or ‘allemande’). You’ll find their performance here: Dowland: Lachrimae Antiquae; Earl of Essex's Galliard; Mrs Nichols' Almand. And for a glimpse of Dowland the writer of songs, here is a performance of ‘Flow, my Tears’, sung by the countertenor Philippe Jaroussky, accompanied on guitar by Thibaut Garcia: Dowland: Flow, my Tears
Day 578: Eight Pieces for Solo Lute (Time: 18 minutes)
In this posting, I’m focusing on the music of John Dowland (1563-1626) for the very good reason that today, 20th February, it is exactly 400 years since his death. (Well, since the recorded date of his burial, to be precise, but that’s the best we can do in terms of his demise.) Anyway, 400 years seems like a significant anniversary, so consequently I’m going to explore a handful of his works here, all for solo lute. Dowland has been the subject of this playlist once before (see Day 163 for three of his pieces for viol consort, and also one of his most famous songs, ‘Flow My Tears’), and on that occasion I summarised most of the significant details that we have (there’s a very great deal that simply remains unknown) about Dowland’s life and creative output – so go back to that to refresh your memories! Today’s YouTube link is to an extract from a TV programme from 1987, when the lutenist/guitarist Julian Bream performed a number of Dowland’s works alongside readings from Shakespeare by Peggy Ashcroft. There’s no denying the rather dated impression the programme generates, but that shouldn’t blind us to the impressive playing on show here, and (of course) to the way the extracts from the programme showcase the talents of Dowland himself. The first piece Julian Bream plays in this recital is titled ‘Mignarde’. (Elsewhere it’s sometimes referred to as ‘Mignarda’.) This is a galliard, a very popular dance form in 16th/17th century Europe. Typically it’s a lively dance, involving lots of high kicking and leaps, but Dowland’s instrumental galliards range from very extrovert dances to compositions at the other end of the spectrum like this one, which is very much more introverted and sweet-sounding. It would appear that the manuscript for this particular piece comes from a collection of 17 works by Dowland held by Cambridge University Library. After this, Bream plays another galliard, this one titled ‘The King of Denmark’s Galliarde’ (or, to give it its full title, ‘The Most High and Mighty Christianus the Fourth, King of Denmark, His Galliard’). As I wrote back on Day 163, Dowland spent around eight years at the end of the 16th/beginning of the 17th centuries working for King Christian IV – though it’s possible that he was also functioning as a spy in the service of Elizabeth I and later James I at the same time. This piece exists in variant forms – as a solo instrumental, as Bream plays it here, but also as a five-part piece for viol consort. The piece was first published in 1610, by Robert Dowland (John Dowland’s son), in a collection called ‘A Varietie of Lute Lessons’. The third item in Bream’s programme is ‘Loth to Departe’, which, like the ‘Mignarde’ discussed earlier, appears in the Cambridge University Library collection. As might be inferred from the title, this may have originally been a song rather than an instrumental piece, and Dowland later produced a substantial (by his standards) set of variations on the melody, though in this recording Bream simply plays the lute song unadorned. The fourth item in Bream’s recital is the famous Lachrimae Pavan. As I mentioned in the previous posting on Dowland, in 1604 he published the instrumental collection ‘Lachrymae, or Seaven Teares’, which included a set of variations on the original ‘Lachrymae’ piece that he had written earlier, and which can be found in a different manuscript collection in the Cambridge University Library. Dowland’s most famous song, ‘Flow my Teares’, finds its source in this original ‘Lachrymae’ composition. The fifth item Bream plays is the rather curiously titled ‘Tarletone’s Riserrectione’. This appeared in a collection of pieces for lute called the Wickhambrook Lute Manuscript, music by various composers and, seemingly, of only middling difficulty, as though it might have been a compilation of pieces for amateur players. Richard Tarleton was an actor, musician, poet and favourite performer of Queen Elizabeth I. His sudden death prompted a flurry of musical tributes by various composers of the time, and this is Dowland’s contribution to the preservation of his memory. Next comes ‘A Fancy by Mr Dowland BM’. This is another piece archived in an anthology, this time the Cosens Lute Book. Dowland wrote at least seven pieces which he called ‘A Fancy’, and several others with the related title ‘A Fantasia’. As the ‘fanciful’ name suggests, there’s something improvisatory and expressive in these pieces, and this particular one is no exception. The penultimate piece that Bream plays on this recording is the famous ‘Semper Dowland Semper Dolens’ (‘Always Dowland, always doleful’). As I wrote back on Day 163, it’s not clear whether Dowland was actually temperamentally morose, or whether this was just a kind of artistic pose, the adoption of the sort of ‘tortured genius’ persona we may more familiarly associate with the Romantic era. Whatever the case, this piece, collected in yet another contemporary anthology, the Euing Lute Book, expresses a dark melancholy, whether in its guise as a song or, as here, an instrumental. Finally, Julian Bream plays ‘Orlando Sleepeth’, which may, it is said, be the shortest instrumental piece Dowland ever wrote. In fact, there’s some debate as to whether this is an original composition, or whether Dowland was arranging a pre-existing tune. It’s not even clear why the piece has the title that it does, though the favourite explanation that I’ve read suggests that it was prompted by a moment in a play, ‘Orlando Furioso’ by the now barely-known Elizabethan playwright Robert Greene, in which our hero is charmed asleep, at which point, according to the stage directions, ‘satyres enter with music and plaie about him, which done they staie, he awaketh and speakes.’ Here then are these eight pieces for solo lute by Dowland, played by Julian Bream: Dowland: Eight Pieces for Solo Lute
Dring, Madeleine (1923-77)
Day 409: Festival Scherzo for Piano and Strings (Time: 5 minutes)
Today (5/9/23), I want to choose a short but attractive piece by a composer born 100 years ago this Thursday, two days from now. Madeleine Dring (1923-77) – or, rather splendidly, Madeleine Winefride Isabelle Dring, in full – was an English composer, though also, it should be said, an individual with a love for the theatre, so she might equally be listed as a singer and an actor, and (I’ve discovered in writing these notes) a cartoonist too! She was born and lived in London throughout her life, and was married from 1947 until her death to Roger Lord, who was Principal Oboe of the LSO for over three decades. One consequence of that is that Dring wrote a considerable amount of chamber music for the oboe, in essence for her husband to play. She studied at the Royal College of Music, including lessons in composition from Howells and (occasionally) Vaughan Williams, though her musical language shows virtually no trace of this sort of pastoral Englishness. Alongside her musical training she studied mime, drama and singing, and a great deal of her output consists of (often very witty) songs, either free-standing or intended for stage productions. Much of this music she wrote for herself, since she performed cabaret numbers and took part in West End revue performances. Although she had her favourites as a composer (notably Rachmaninov) her music is extremely hard to classify stylistically. I think, from the relatively little I’ve heard, that her closest musical connection is with Poulenc, though her tastes were very eclectic, encompassing jazz, ‘American songbook’ composers such as Gershwin and Cole Porter, and also the popular fashions of the day, such as the taste for calypsos and other Caribbean idioms in the 1950s and 60s. She wrote an opera, two ballets, music for at least half-a-dozen revues, and incidental music for more than a dozen television productions, both one-off plays and more extended television series. She had a parallel career as a television and stage actress, and images of her (easily found on the web) are very striking. For all the evidence of her contributions to the arts in the mid-20th century, she seems to have been quite elusive in terms of her character and temperament. When asked about this, she once quipped, ‘Couldn’t you say I come from the Moon, and wish to remain a mystery?’ I wondered what to choose by way of illustration of her diverse talents as a composer and musical creator, but since her cabaret songs are quite easily available on the web if anyone cares to look, I’ve gone instead for one of her instrumental compositions, the Festival Scherzo for piano and strings. The piece was Dring’s response to the celebrations for the Festival of Britain in 1951. This five minute snippet of playfulness is characterised by the piano’s opening theme which consists of an upward arpeggio followed by a returning downward scale ending on a ‘wrong note’. There’s a marked ‘popular music’ element to the work, such as the Cockney swagger of the second theme, which perhaps reflects similar sorts of pieces by Poulenc or Ibert. The opening section – more than half the piece – ends with the piano crunching out dissonant chords in an exuberant mood before the reflective middle section, followed by a brief cadenza, and the return of the opening theme. Recordings of this piece are extremely rare, but there is a video of a performance by the Spanish pianist Antonio Oyarzabal, playing alongside the HERo Ensemble, a group of musicians put together for a women’s conference in Florida earlier this year. You’ll find the piece here: Dring: Festival Scherzo for Piano and Strings
Dufay, Guillaume (1397-1474)
Day 314: Nuper Rosarum Flores (Time: 6 minutes) and Conditor Alme Siderum (4 minutes)
Today (5/8/22), I want to look at two short pieces by someone whose birthday fell on this very day, 625 years ago. Allegedly. So, here is another new name on the playlist – that of Guillaume Dufay (1397-1474). These days, he tends to be referred to as ‘Dufay’, though you’ll also find ‘Du Fay’ and occasionally ‘Du Fayt’. And, while we’re dealing with ambiguities, I’m suggesting this is his 625th birthday, but there are doubts about whether he was born in 1397, and often you’ll find ‘c1400’ cited instead. Who knows? Anyway, from that uncertain (and probably illegitimate) start in life, his precocious musical gifts meant that he went a long way, very quickly, from the (now Belgian) area of Brabant, to the cathedral at Cambrai in what is now northern France, and then in the 1520s on a number of trips to Italian courts; and by the late 1520s, he had a position in the Papal Choir, the foremost musical establishment in Europe at that time. There followed several decades of to-ing and fro-ing between Italian locations and Cambrai, largely because this period in 15th century history involved fisticuffs over the papacy, with simultaneously competing popes in various European locations. What seems indisputable is that by the time of his final years in Cambrai, he was regarded as the leading composer of the day and, as I noted last time, a key link in the chain of composers of the Franco-Flemish school. Dufay’s output is substantial, and includes a considerable number of secular vocal pieces as well as many masses and motets. Of his mass settings, I’d suggest that his Missa L’Homme Arme and his Missa Se La Face Ay Pale are probably most characteristic of his best work. However, for today I thought a couple of short works might give a taster of his sound world. The first is his motet ‘Nuper Rosarum Flores’ (which roughly translates as ‘recently roses came’), a ‘middle period’ work in terms of Dufay’s oeuvre, dating from 1436, and written for the consecration of Florence Cathedral. The text celebrates the Santa Maria del Fiore (St Mary of the Flower), the name of the cathedral itself. There is some debate about the relationship between the structure of Dufay’s piece and the architectural proportions of the cathedral, which I’m going to ignore completely because it seems to generate more heat than light in the arguments of its competing commentators. What is clear is that the motet is significant because of the way it illustrates the shift between the way musical fashions had worked previously (so-called ‘isorhythmic’ writing, where the same rhythmic pattern will turn up throughout a composition somewhere in at least one of the vocal lines) and the more recognisably ‘contrapuntal’ style (multiple lines which are melodically independent of each other yet harmonically interdependent) that’s more familiar to us now in Renaissance choral music of the two centuries that followed. The performance I’ve gone for is by the American ensemble Quire Cleveland, directed by its founder Ross Duffin, and you’ll find it here: Dufay: Nuper Rosarum Flores. The other piece by Dufay that I wanted to share is his Advent hymn ‘Conditor Alme Siderum’ (‘O bountiful creator of the stars’). This is what’s known in the trade as an ‘alternatim’ setting (education as well as entertainment here, folks!) – that is, where a verse in plainchant is ‘answered’ by a verse set polyphonically, in which the top voice sings an elaborated version of the plainchant melody. The text itself appears to date from as far back as the 7th century, and it celebrates Christ’s coming into the world at Christmas while also looking forward to his second coming in judgment. As for a performance, I’ve gone for a recording by the acclaimed Boston-based (that’s Massachusetts, not Lincolnshire) ensemble Blue Heron, directed by the choir’s founder Scott Metcalfe. You’ll find their version here: Dufay: Conditor Alme Siderum
Duparc, Henri (1848-1933)
Day 389: 'L'Invitation au Voyage' – male voice (Time: 5 minutes) and female voice (5 minutes)
If you have no interest in art songs, then it’s entirely possible for you to have overlooked Henri Duparc – or Eugène Marie Henri Fouques Duparc, in full – all of your life, or at least until today (20/6/23). Duparc (1848-1933) was, as you can see from the dates, immensely long-lived, and yet very little of his music survives now. However, unlike those whose work disappeared in wars or revolutions, or library fires, Duparc’s output was constrained by the man himself. He was born in Paris, and had an upbringing that seemed to suggest a secure start both as a composer (he studied composition with Franck) and as a member of the French musical elite: he was one of the founder members of the Société Nationale de Musique in 1871 in the aftermath of the disaster of the 1870 Franco-Prussian War. (Other founder members, many of whom you’ve heard on this list, included Saint-Saens, Dubois, Faure, Massenet, Franck and Taffanel.) And yet, at his death in 1933 he left only a handful of works to his name, among them one or two chamber works and – the reason his flame still burns, as it were – 17 songs. The reason there are so few is that in 1885, at the age of 37, Duparc stopped composing completely, and the remaining 48 years of his life consist of a musical silence that outstrips even that of Sibelius. The reason was medical/constitutional. Duparc was diagnosed with what was then described as ‘neurasthenia’, literally a ‘weakness of the nerves’, and characterised variously in different sufferers, but typically a collapse of the body’s nervous system. In the later 19th century it seems to have been a fashionable diagnosis, in relation to women sufferers in particular, showing itself as weakness, dizziness, fainting and lethargy. In Duparc’s case there seems to have been some sort of mental collapse, but physical symptoms were present too, including the almost complete loss of sight. The anguish this caused can be readily imagined, but though Duparc sought cures from medical sources, it seems that he looked also to his religious faith – there are records of more than one visit to Lourdes to try to find release from this mysterious condition that killed all desire to create. However, the outcome was an almost complete withdrawal from public life, turning inward to his family, his faith, and creativity expressed in producing the occasional painting. He also destroyed a number of musical compositions, including an incomplete opera ‘Roussalka’. (There’s a terribly sad letter from the early 1920s in which he writes about this: ‘Having lived for 25 years in a splendid dream, the whole idea of [musical] representation has become – I repeat to you – repugnant. The other reason for this destruction, which I do not regret, was the complete moral transformation that God imposed on me 20 years ago and which, in a single minute, obliterated all of my past life. Since then, [my opera], not having any connection with my new life, should no longer exist.’) The 17 songs that survive by Duparc turn up regularly in recitals of French art song, and one of them, ‘L’invitation au voyage’, features in the Armonico Consort Soloists’ programme at this year’s Bradfield Festival. It’s a setting of two of the three verses (verse two is omitted) of a poem by the French lyric symbolist poet Baudelaire. It was composed in 1870 and first heard two years later. It’s an extraordinary, sensual, in some ways erotic piece. Baudelaire’s poem first appeared in his scandal-generating collection ‘Fleurs du Mal’ in 1857, and it attempts (among other things) to capture the fleeting, changing nature of beauty in a modern urban world, and although it’s absurdly difficult to translate – because so much of the effect is caught up in the sounds and rhythms of French, and because the images in the poem are often linked together by association rather than any kind of literal narrative – it reveals a lover’s attempt to seduce the object of his desire. The voyage she is invited to go on promises pleasures of many sorts, including sex, but is as much about the wish-fulfilment of dreams as it is about any literal place. What’s more (‘D’aller là-bas vivre ensemble, Aimer à loisir, Aimer et mourir, Au pays qui te ressemble’ – which I’d not very competently translate as ‘To go there, live together, Love at leisure, Loving and dying, in the country that looks like you’), this is a love bound up in transience, and loss, even though, as the end of each verse suggests, ‘There all is order and beauty, Luxury, calm and voluptuousness’. Heady stuff, folks… Duparc’s setting evokes a wonderful sense of yearning, as though what we’re hearing might be a dream, or a memory, or a wish. In the space of only a few minutes we are taken on a voyage that is both physical and spiritual, and one that considers the whole arc of a relationship’s trajectory before setting out on it. One of the really interesting things about this song in performance is the difference created by having it sung by a male (as was Duparc’s intention) or a female voice. If it’s the latter, there’s a curious shift in perspective. In some ways it stops being a song about ‘the male gaze’ (to use a much-employed term about representational art, whether painting, sculpture or film) and more about a kind of disembodied, barely articulate yearning. Anyway, enough of this pseuds’ corner stuff. What you’ve got here are two performances of the song. First, here is the leading contemporary tenor Jonas Kaufman, accompanied by the pianist Helmut Deutsch, in this audio-only recording: Duparc: 'L'Invitation au Voyage' (male voice). And, by way of comparison and contrast, here is a rather aged video performance of the song (try not to be distracted by the very 1980s fashions and décor) by Kiri Te Kanawa, accompanied by Roger Vignoles: Duparc: 'L'Invitation au Voyage' (female voice)
Day 18: ‘Pie Jesu’ (from ‘Requiem’) (Time: 5 minutes)
Welcome to our offering for today (9/4/20), which is a suggestion from regular contributor Martin. His request is for an excerpt from the Requiem by Maurice Duruflé. Often unfairly criticised as a re-hashed version of the more famous treatment by Fauré, the Duruflé ‘Requiem’ needs time and reflection to reveal its strengths, but the ‘Pie Jesu’ movement is tender and intense, and fairly immediately accessible. However, Martin adds a second reason for choosing the particular version we have here. He explains, ‘Anna Harvey is the youngest daughter of great friends of ours and we have known and loved her all her life. She is now singing in Dusseldorf Opera house - but not currently of course as she is back in Sheffield for lockdown. It is pretty cool to hear a little girl you knew so well singing like this!’ You’ll find her performance, with the South Netherlands Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Kenneth Montgomery, here: Maurice Durufle – ‘Pie Jesu’ (from ‘Requiem’)
Dussek, Franz Xaver (1731-99)
Day 453: FX: Symphony in C (Time: 13 minutes)
Today (6/2/24), we go back in time, to a musician who died 225 years ago next Monday. He’s not well known (but then, when has that stopped me/us?), and to make things more complex, there are some ambiguities about his name, but all will become clear… So, there are (at least) two composers with the surname Dussek who flourished in the late 18th/early 19th centuries. The (slightly) more famous one is Jan Ladislav Dussek (1760-1812) a Czech composer. That is the Germanic version (and, by and large, the version you get on English language websites) of his name. In the original Czech, he was Jan Václav Dusík. To help make things murkier, his surname is also sometimes ‘Duschek’ and even ‘Düssek’. Anyway, having accumulated all that information, feel free to forget it, at least until this Mr Dussek (etc.) features on this list. Meanwhile, go back a generation or so, and you get to the chap who is the subject of today’s posting. This is František Xaver Dušek (in the original Czech spelling) … or Franz Xaver Dussek (or very occasionally ‘Duschek’) as he was in German/English. His dates (1731-99) make him an almost exact contemporary of Haydn. Like lots of others who’ve featured on this list over the years, he was Bohemian by origin – if you had to compile a list of prominent 18th century musicians by place of birth mapped against size of population, I suspect Bohemia would comfortably win that particular competition, in the same way that Finnish musicians might do today. Dussek (which is what I’m going to call him from now on, to keep things simple) was mostly a composer of instrumental music, though also a fine keyboard player and teacher. Benefiting like so many before him from the aristocratic network of employers in the Austro-Hungarian empire, he made significant contacts in Prague, and from there also in Vienna, though Dussek seems to have remained in Prague for most of his life. His contacts book was presumably helped by the fact that his wife, Josepha, was a famous soprano, for whom Mozart wrote concert arias. (There are extensive rumours – at least, the evidence is tenuous – that Mozart stayed with the Dusseks in the late 1780s when he was in Prague for the local production of ‘The Marriage of Figaro’ … and also that Mrs Dussek locked Mozart in the summer house at their summer residence and wouldn’t let him out until he’d written another aria for her. What japes they got up to back in the day…) One thing that Mozart seems to have been impressed by is that Dussek was essentially a freelance composer in Prague in the later 18th century, and that idea that such a figure could make a living without being effectively ‘owned’ by some aristocrat was very attractive to Mozart, although by the time Mozart tried it in Vienna the economic climate was much less in his favour. Like lots of other composers of his day, Dussek seems to have written most of his 40 or so symphonies during the 1760s and 70s, the point in the 18th century when the appetite for new symphonic music (and the means to pay for its performance) was at its height. In many of his symphonies, Dussek seems to have been quite innovative, and in terms of the transition between baroque and classical eras, Dussek is very definitely on the ‘classical’ side of that divide. He seems to have been not just a skilful composer, but also an efficient and effective user of the orchestra, capable of writing attractive, well-crafted music. Without getting too technical, the development (the ‘middle section’) of his first movements show an interest not just in taking a theme through a range of related key changes, but actually extending and developing that theme in ways that would sit convincingly in the symphonic output of Haydn. He also wrote interestingly for wind instruments, adding colour and contrast to the basic string texture. Out of the many choices open to me, I’ve selected Dussek’s Symphony in C (there are two ‘symphonies in C’ in his catalogue, but I can’t tell you which this is…). It’s a four-movement work, which appears to have been composed in 1767. The opening brief Adagio Maestoso leads straight into a Allegro Spirituoso main section, a brisk, lively movement with lots of light and shade. The second movement, Andante, makes use of solo string players to contrast with some singing woodwind lines. After a short Minuet and Trio, the final movement, Allegro Assai, rounds off the work with some lovely bright horn fanfares. It will not surprise you, I’m sure, to know that there’s very little Dussek on YouTube in video form, so we’re in inevitable audio-only territory here. However, there’s a sprightly performance of Dussek’s C Major Symphony given by the Czech Chamber Philharmonic, conducted by Vojtěch Spurný. You’ll find it here: Dussek, FX: Symphony in C
Dvorak, Antonin (1841-1904)
Day 37: ‘Songs My Mother Taught Me’, Op 55 No 4 (and some nightingales!) (Time: 3 minutes)
Today (28/4/20), a suggestion from Martin. This is a very old archive selection (from 1927), so there’s an awful lot of bacon fat frying in the background (and even in the foreground) of this recording. It’s of the cellist Beatrice Harrison playing a solo version of Dvorak's ‘Songs my Mother Taught Me’ (from his cycle ‘Gypsy Songs’, Op 55 No 4). If you don't know this recording already, what makes it notable is that Ms Harrison and her cello are not given the starring roles, as you’ll hear… You’ll find the performance here: Dvorak – ‘Songs My Mother Taught Me’, Op 55 No 4 (and some nightingales!)
Day 126: Piano Trio No 1, Op 21 (1st movement) (Time: 11 minutes)
Dvorak's Piano Trio No 1, Op 21, is a considerably more obscure piece of music than the Brahms trio that I featured on Tuesday. In fact, I suspect that today (9/10/20), the performance by Ensemble 360 will be the first ever in Sheffield. Dvorak wrote four published piano trios, and of these, only the last (the ‘Dumky’ Trio, Op 90) has a secure place in the repertoire. The Piano Trio No 1 was actually the third that Dvorak completed, but in his younger days as a composer, he was an enthusiastic destroyer of works that he considered sub-standard, and there are records of two piano trios from the early 1870s that are now lost. In the first half of the 1870s, Dvorak was still a struggling provincial composer, subsisting on teaching and organ playing, and barely known outside Prague. Apart from Czech folk music, the earliest influence on his work was Wagner, but by the mid-1870s, he was starting to escape the Wagnerian shadow and to find what would become his own authentic voice. In 1874 and again in 1876 and 1878, he won the Austrian State Prize for composition, which allowed him not just to give up the day jobs, but to buy a piano, and to devote himself to composition. The Piano Trio No 1 dates from 1875, and was published on exactly the same day as his well-loved Serenade for Strings, Op 22. It’s a substantial work in four movements, so time constraints don’t permit me to send you a link to the whole work. The final two movements in particular are lively, and imbued with Dvorak's characteristic folk-inflected melodies, but I thought it might be good to focus on the rather more serious and thoughtful first movement, in which Dvorak is making the case to be regarded as a composer able to write with academic rigour. In this performance, the movement is played by Trio Fontenay, and you’ll find it here: Dvorak: Piano Trio No 1, Op 21 (1st movement)
Day 132: Piano Quintet in A, Op 81 (2nd, 3rd and 4th movements) (Time: 29 minutes)
Today (30/10/20), it’s the turn of Antonin Dvorak, and his irrepressibly infectious (in a good way!) Piano Quintet in A, Op 81. (Technically, this is his Piano Quintet No 2 in A, Op 81. There is another piano quintet, also in A, which is Dvorak's Op 5, a very early work which is virtually never performed nowadays.) A piano quintet, in case explanation is necessary, is a piece for piano and string quartet. The 'famous' A Major quintet dates from 1887, when Dvorak was at the height of his fame in Europe – Dvorak mania had swept Britain in the 1880s, and he was now being commissioned by a wide array of European and North American musical organisations. In fact, the quintet began life as Dvorak's attempt to revise his earlier piano quintet, but eventually he gave up and started again from scratch. Having selected just the first movement of the previous piece of Dvorak chamber music on this list (see Day 126), this time round I thought I’d offer you the whole quintet, with the exception of the first movement – that way I can get as close as possible to listing the whole piece and still stay within the 40 minute limit for the week overall. So, the movement you’re not getting is sunny and lyrical in Dvorak's typical manner, but the movement that follows is particularly interesting for the way Dvorak exploits folk music forms. It’s a ‘dumka’, a dance form, originally Ukrainian but widespread all over Eastern Europe. In it, a slow melancholy theme is contrasted with a series of livelier, faster episodes. Here, Dvorak's structure is ABACABA, where A is the slow passage, and B and C are contrasting quicker sections. The third movement is also folk-influenced, being a ‘furiant’. As the name suggests (etymologically linked to words in English like ‘fury’ and ‘furious’) it is lively, with heavy cross-rhythms – typically you’ll hear patterns that go 123123121212, where the stress is on the ‘1’. The finale is a polka, another lively, high-spirited dancing affair, in which Dvorak gives full rein to his good-natured sense of fun and celebration. Just before the end, the music slows for a chorale-type passage, and we get the main theme of the music slowed down (in augmentation, if we’re being technical) before the whole ensemble sets off in a rush for the finish. As I hope you’ll gather from these descriptions, this is an overwhelmingly joyful piece, one of the masterpieces of the piano quintet repertoire, and Dvorak at his most ‘feel-good’. There are a large number of competing versions on YouTube, but in order to select one that has been uploaded in separate movements I’ve gone for this performance by the Israeli Chamber Project, which you’ll find, via three separate links, here: Dvorak: Piano Quintet in A, Op 81 - 2. Dumka, 3. Furiant and 4. Finale: Allegro
Day 140: Nocturne in B for String Orchestra, Op 40 (Time: 7 minutes)
Today (27/11/20), I’d like to focus on a short free-standing piece by Dvorak, to ensure that the week's output stays under the 40 minute mark! The piece in question has a rather complicated history. Dvorak was evidently very fond of it, because he used it in at least three different incarnations. It began life as the slow movement of an early string quartet. As you might recall from my notes from (Day 126), when I introduced his Piano Trio No 1 (and don’t worry if you don’t recall it – there won’t be a test!), Dvorak was a very enthusiastic destroyer of early works that he felt didn’t really hit the spot. Amongst a number of chamber pieces that he thought he’d disowned was a String Quartet in E Minor, now known as his String Quartet No 4. He believed that this, along with Quartets Nos 2&3, had been disposed of, but in fact copies of the separate performance parts for the four instruments survived – which is how the quartet has continued to see the light of day. It seems to have been written in the late 1860s (and it’s thus what we might see as an ‘apprentice’ piece, part of Dvorak's developing sense of his own mode of working as a composer). The middle movement of the quartet is marked ‘Andante Religioso’, an indication that gives some sense of the music's mood and sentiment. However, before Dvorak got round to, as he thought, disposing of the quartet, he had already revealed a fondness for this particular movement by reworking it not for string quartet, but for string quintet (by adding a double bass), and he used it as a slow movement in his String Quintet in G, ‘Op 18’. I use inverted commas there because in that form, written in 1875, it had a public performance as a piece in, unusually, five movements, including two slow movements, one of which was this reincarnation of the slow movement of the early string quartet. Dvorak then had second thoughts, deciding that the String Quintet in G, Op 18 was too long, and he ditched the ‘Andante Religioso’ movement, revised the rest a little, and eventually the piece was published as the String Quintet in G, Op 77, in 1888. However, that left the discarded movement, which still seems to have nagged away at Dvorak as a piece too lovely simply to ignore. So, finally (almost!), he reworked the music again, this time as a Nocturne (or Notturno – both names are used these days) in B for String Orchestra, Op 40; and this version eventually reached the public domain in 1883. That’s almost the end of the story … though Dvorak then made subsequent versions of this piece for violin and piano, and then again for piano four hands. Having explored its complicated genesis, there’s very little I want to say about the piece itself, except that it’s a very beautiful and serene composition. The pervading mood is one of calm, though the middle section of the work is a little more animated. It very rarely gets an outing on the concert platform these days, and even radio broadcasts are thin on the ground, which seems to me to be a real shame, given its mood of tender contemplation. It’s performed in the YouTube clip I’ve selected by a conductorless string ensemble from Boston, USA who call themselves A Far Cry, and it comes from a concert they gave in 2011. You’ll find it here: Dvorak: Nocturne in B, Op 40, for String Orchestra
Day 171: Stabat Mater (10th movement: ‘Quando Corpus’) (Time: 8 minutes)
Today (16/3/21), the composer under the metaphorical spotlight is Dvorak. He has featured several times on this list before (see Days 37, 126, 132 and 140), so there’s some quite extensive biographical information in the Archive already, which I won’t duplicate here. In addition, if you want to know more about the Stabat Mater text, you can read that in the entry on (Day 167: Lassus). Of all the settings of the Stabat Mater made by 19th century composers, the one by Dvorak is by some distance the most popular and substantial (I guess an argument could be made for the Rossini version in terms of popularity, but not, I think, in terms of substance). In fact, it usually runs to about 85 minutes in performance, so what you’re going to get today is a taster only. As we’ve seen in previous postings about Dvorak, the 1870s was the decade in which he began to achieve a degree of fame outside his Czech homeland, notably as a result of his Serenade for Strings in 1875, and the first set of Slavonic Dances in 1878. These years also saw the gradual evolution into its finished form of the Stabat Mater, years which coincided with a run of terrible tragedies in Dvorak’s family life. There has long been an assumption that these events were what triggered the production of the Stabat Mater, but current thinking is that Dvorak had already planned and sketched sections of the work before domestic troubles hit. What is clear, however, is that in the aftermath of these events, Dvorak returned to and reworked the composition into the brooding and heart-felt piece it is today. Dvorak appears to have had a deep and abiding Catholic faith: there is a caricature image of him as an essentially 'simple' man, with simple tastes (pigeons, steam trains) and a simple faith to go with it. I am certain that this is a distortion, and it’s hard to think that he could have lived through the later 1870s and emerged from it without scars and grief, which appear to be channelled into this piece of music. On 21st August 1875 the Dvoraks’ youngest child, Josefa, died at only two days old. At that stage, Dvorak had planned a setting of the Stabat Mater, but put it aside for a year, returning to it in 1876 as an unorchestrated draft. Then, in the summer of 1877, Dvorak’s two remaining children died in quick succession: his daughter Růžena, after ingesting phosphorus solution (a normal household product of the age) and his son Otakar of smallpox. Dvorak immediately returned to the Stabat Mater, completing it within two months, and it had its first performance in 1880. (The Dvoraks would eventually have three more children, so this isn’t a tale of unremitting woe.) The Stabat Mater was the composition which made Dvorak famous all across Europe and the USA: he made several tours of England in the 1880s on the basis of its fame. This setting of the Stabat Mater is probably the opposite of something like Rossini’s operatic and theatrical version: Dvorák takes the listener on a profound journey through loss and grief to a kind of healing by the end of the score. From this epic creation, I’m going to focus only on the final movement, a setting of the last verse of the Stabat Mater, ‘Quando corpus morietur’. After a dark, minor-key passage for a quartet of soloists and chorus on the words ‘Quando corpus morietur’ (‘When my body dies’), the powerful, anguished music from the first movement of the Stabat Mater returns, but this time climaxes with a turn to the major key at the words ‘ut ánimæ donétur paradísi glória’ (‘grant that to my soul be given the glory of paradise’). A lyrical theme from the first movement then reappears (Dvorak is busy unifying the piece here), leading to a radiant fugue on the word ‘Amen’. The splendour of the fugue fades to the work’s serene conclusion, leaving listeners full of hope and peace. As for a performance, I’ve gone for an audio recording by the Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra and Chorus, conducted by Rafael Kubelik. You’ll find it here: Dvořák: Stabat Mater (10th movement: 'Quando Corpus')
Day 229: Symphony No 9, 'From the New World' (2nd movement) (Time: 12 minutes)
Today (5/10/21), I thought that we should listen to at least part of one of the best-loved of all 19th century symphonies, in honour of the fact that the Hallé Orchestra are programming it here in Sheffield later this month. Dvorák has featured on this playlist several times (see Days 37, 126, 132, 140 and 171), but not, so far, as a symphonist. The ‘New World’ Symphony is the last of his nine pieces in this genre: not, in my opinion, his greatest (that, surely, is the 7th) nor even his happiest (that’ll be the 8th), but without any question his most popular. It’s not hard to see why: it has strong and driving themes, It’s colourfully and attractively orchestrated, and (without patronising its listeners) it has a clarity and simplicity of structure that communicates with great directness. Dvorák wrote it in America in the spring of 1893. He was in America as the Director of the National Conservatory of Music in New York, at the invitation of his musical patron, Mrs Jeanette Thurber, who made him an offer he couldn’t refuse: a salary of $15000 a year (to put that into context, his equivalent post in Prague paid him $600 a year) for, in effect, 18 hours of work each week with four months' holiday per year. Things didn’t go completely swimmingly – America faced a serious financial meltdown for several years from 1893, so his salary was reduced to $8000, and was often paid late; and on top of that, Dvorák was homesick (at least until he discovered the Czech community in Spillville, Iowa, where he spent his summers). In the end, he remained in America for only three years. Nevertheless, in that time, he made a great impact on the burgeoning musical scene (most significantly in promoting African American and Native American music as the basis of a ‘national’ musical style), and in return, it’s clear that America made a great impact on him – and on his music. How much of an impact is an ongoing debate, particularly in relation to this symphony. Some claim to be able to hear the influence of ‘Indian melodies’; others argue that the piece is full of longing for home, and that at its heart is the Czech landscape and culture, not the American one. I don’t think it matters either way, but I like the New York Herald’s review of the first performance at Carnegie Hall, which stated: ‘It may be Indian in spirit, but it is Bohemian in atmosphere. Dr Dvorák can no more divest himself of his nationality than the leopard can change his spots.’ In an interview published on the day of the work’s premiere, Dvorák claimed the slow movement was ‘a study or sketch’ for a cantata or opera he was intending to write based on Longfellow’s poem ‘The Song of Hiawatha’, a piece he never got round to. This has led to lots more fairly fruitless speculation – is this a depiction of Minnehaha’s funeral, for instance – but again it seems irrelevant in the end. The movement is very well known, and not just because of that Hovis advert of the 1970s (and its many parodies!), but mostly because of the lovely cor anglais theme at its heart. The movement is bookended by solemn brass chords before the main theme unfolds over a wash of strings. There are further episodes – a rather plaintive woodwind theme over a kind of ‘walking bass’ part, and a perky little oboe tune that is cut short by the symphony’s brooding ‘motto theme’ that features in all four of its movements – before, very poignantly, the cor anglais tune returns but breaks off incompletely. It might be obvious from my many selections for this playlist that I love Dvorák’s music, and I really don’t have much time for the view that it might be tuneful but that it’s musically inconsequential. No matter how many times I hear this movement – and it’s been a lot! – it remains hauntingly beautiful in its emotional control. As for a performance, YouTube has a nice clip of a composite ensemble, made up of players from all the leading American orchestras, and called with typical American restraint the All-Star Orchestra. It’s conducted by Gerard Schwarz. You’ll find their performance of the ‘Largo’ slow movement here: Dvořák: Symphony No 9, 'From the New World' (2nd movement)
Elgar, Edward (1857-1934)
Day 34: Introduction and Allegro for Strings (Time: 16 minutes)
Today (25/4/20), for no reason other than the fact that I was just sitting in the garden listening to it on my iPod, I thought I’d send out one of the classics of the string orchestra repertoire, Edward Elgar’s Introduction and Allegro for Strings. The general stereotypical view of Elgar (Land-of-Hope-and-Glory, flag-waving, Edwardian patriotism) is a long way from the truth. He was solitary and introverted, deeply provincial (roots in rural Worcestershire) rather than metropolitan, questioning rather than assertive, Catholic rather than Anglican establishment. Lots of these qualities are evident in the Introduction and Allegro, with its turbulent flourishes, its ruggedly questing fugal writing, and at the heart of it, a soaring yet mournful Welsh folk tune that the Elgars heard on holiday. There are lots of famous recordings of this, but I’ve gone for one from close to (my) home, by the combined forces of the strings of the Halle and the RNCM Orchestra, with a string quartet of students, under Sir Mark Elder. You’ll find it here: Elgar – Introduction and Allegro for Strings
Day 79: Cello Concerto (1st movement) (Time: 8 minutes)
Today (9/6/20), we have a suggestion from Alex, who spent some time this past weekend watching a documentary about the renowned British cellist Jacqueline du Pré, and as a result, thinks it would do us good to listen to some of her performance of the Cello Concerto by Elgar. There are some obvious reasons why these recordings have remained in the spotlight – she was evidently an astonishing talent, there’s the additional melodramatic quality of her being young, beautiful and struck down in her prime, plus the rather less worthy tabloid-style curiosity about the dynamics of the relationship between du Pré, Daniel Barenboim and members of the wider family. Whatever the reasons, though, these are performances to cherish. The Cello Concerto was Elgar’s last major work, composed in 1919 in the aftermath of the First World War by a composer who was very definitely no longer in tune with the musical times. In so many ways, it feels nostalgic, lamenting, a voice from the past. Although it was received fairly coolly at its first performance, it has become a mainstay of the concerto repertoire in the past 50 or 60 years, and du Pré’s famous recording with the LSO and Sir John Barbirolli from 1965 is part of the reason for that. You’ll find it here: Elgar – Cello Concerto (1st movement)
Day 278: Cockaigne Overture (In London Town), Op 40 (Time: 15 minutes)
Elgar has made only two appearances on this list (see Days 34 and 79), and like those choices – the Introduction and Allegro for Strings and the Cello Concerto – there’s something inescapably nostalgic and poignant about the music of the Cockaigne Overture (‘In London Town’), Op 40, my choice for today (25/3/22). Elgar was already heading into middle-age in 1900 (he was 43!), and he was just beginning to find his feet as an established composer, after a long apprenticeship which with its false starts must have often felt like it was making a step back for every step forwards. Through the 1890s, he produced a series of works that gradually consolidated his reputation: the Serenade for Strings (1892), the choral songs ‘From the Bavarian Highlands’ (1896), the song cycle ‘Sea Pictures’ (1899), and then – his great breakthrough – the ‘Enigma’ Variations (1900), followed by the epic choral work ‘The Dream of Gerontius’ (admittedly initially a failure with the public, but not for long) of the same year. Suddenly, after what must have seemed like decades of slogging away in provincial obscurity, Elgar was the great figure of British music. It was at this point that Elgar wrote his overture ‘Cockaigne’. The work was dedicated ‘to my many friends, the members of British orchestras’. Cockaigne (sometimes ‘Cockayne’) was a mythical land in scurrilous medieval literature and art, a land of plenty but also of licence: in the Middle English poem ‘The Land of Cockaigne’, abbots are beaten by their monks, nuns flash their buttocks to the world and the sky rains cheese. Hmmm... Someone’s been on the mead too much, maybe. Anyway, in Elgar’s hands, it becomes a portrait of Edwardian London, raucous and occasionally hedonistic, but also gentle and sentimental. According to Elgar himself, the idea came ‘one dark day in the Guildhall: looking at the memorials of the city’s great past and knowing well the history of its unending charity, I seemed to hear far away in the dim roof a theme, an echo of some noble melody.’ Later, to his friend the conductor Hans Richter, he wrote that the music of the overture was ‘honest, healthy, humorous and strong but not vulgar.’ The work is fairly episodic in nature. There are glimpses of cockneys selling their wares, lovers meeting in the park, a Salvation Army band, and so on. If you know much Wagner, it will be clear that Elgar’s ‘Cockaigne’ has a lot in common with Wagner’s Prelude to Act I of ‘Die Meistersinger’. Not that that’s a bad thing… As for a performance, we’re in audio only territory I’m afraid, but what I’ve chosen is a famous old recording of the work by the London Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Sir John Barbirolli. You’ll find it here: Elgar: Cockaigne Overture (In London Town), Op 40
Day 539: Piano Quintet in A Minor Op 84 (Time: 35 minutes)
The final concert of this year’s Sheffield Chamber Music Festival has exactly the same programme as the first concert Ensemble 360 gave in Sheffield on their formation back in 2005. The final work in these events and my choice for today (23/5/25) is Elgar’s Piano Quintet. Elgar’s career trajectory is an interesting one. Born in 1857 and living until 1934, it’s reasonable to argue that there was only just over a decade – the period from around 1899 to 1911 – when he was regarded as indubitably Britain’s greatest composer and a serious figure on the international music stage. Before the seemingly sudden success of the Enigma Variations in 1899 there had been 20 years or more of provincial ‘apprenticeship’. Then, post-‘Enigma’, there was a flurry of pieces that absolutely reflected the spirit of the age – the oratorio ‘The Dream of Gerontius’, the Introduction and Allegro for Strings (see Day 34), the Symphony No 1 and the Violin Concerto. Is it just a coincidence that the death of Edward VII also marked the beginning of the end of this ‘purple patch’ in the music of this most ‘Edwardian’-seeming of composers? Whatever the truth of that, his Symphony No 2 of 1911 met with a rather baffled response, and Elgar never had another popular success in the remaining 20-odd years of his life. Then, of course, the 1914-18 war intervened. Elgar, surely the most ‘European’ of English composers (he has more in common with Richard Strauss than he does with, say, near contemporaries like Vaughan Williams) was deeply depressed by the Great War. He came close to stopping composing altogether, apart from a smattering of ‘patriotic’ pieces that haven’t aged well, and by 1917 he was writing to his close confidant Alice Stuart Wortley, ‘Everything good and nice and clean and fresh and sweet is far away – never to return.’ At this point Elgar’s wife Alice decided that a change of scene from wartime London was called for, and the Elgars rented a cottage in Sussex called ‘Brinkwells’, and gradually Elgar’s creative juices began to flow again. It’s not that the music, when it came, returned to the Edwardian mode of his pre-war success. What he wrote was largely mournful, almost broken, and when it was heard in public initial impressions were that these were pieces composed by someone of a bygone age, with nothing in common with the ‘modern’ post-war world. Elgar had composed chamber music much earlier in his life, but after decades devoted to orchestral and choral music it was to small-scale forces that Elgar returned in 1918/1919. He wrote three substantial compositions which overlapped in the writing, and it’s reasonable to see all three as expressions of a single creative utterance. First came the Violin Sonata and then the String Quartet, both of 1918, and then finally the Piano Quintet of 1919. The last of these occupied space on Elgar’s composing desk alongside his last great orchestral work, the Cello Concerto (see Day 79). What all these pieces share, apart from their minor key (three in E Minor and the other, the Piano Quintet, in A Minor), is a sense of something ‘valedictory’. I sometimes wonder if hindsight has much to answer for when we look at composers’ work, but I think in Elgar’s case the valedictory mood is absolutely the note these works strike. There’s a bit of superstitious nonsense about the roots of the quintet’s opening. Near Brinkwells was a grove of withered trees that were allegedly the remnants of a group of ‘impious’ Spanish monks struck by lightning for their dodgy practices. (For the record, there is no evidence of any religious establishment, Spanish or otherwise, anywhere near Brinkwells.) Alice Elgar wrote of the ‘reminiscence of sinister trees’ that the work’s opening was prompted by, and Elgar himself wrote to his friend, the critic Ernest Newman about the first movement, ‘I want you to hear it. It is strange music I think, and I like it – but it’s ghostly stuff.’ Whatever the inspiration, that opening – an almost plainsong-like melody on the piano, interrupted by these ghostly interjections from the strings – sets the tone for the rest of the piece. George Bernard Shaw was hugely impressed after the first private performance of the work in March 1919: ‘The Quintet quite knocked me over … the finest thing of its kind.’ The first movement, after that curious introduction, is occupied with a faster Allegro that is both martial and brooding – though the nagging introductory notes keep returning. The middle movement is a tender Adagio, led by a tranquil viola solo, setting a mood of quiet longing, before the movement builds to a soaring climax (‘something of the “Nimrod” to it’, said a contemporary reviewer). The final movement again begins slowly, Elgar making the ‘cyclic’ nature of the piece overt by quoting again from the introduction to the first movement. When the finale eventually gets under way, it might seem that we’re in the world of noble, patriotic Elgar at first, but the movement’s shadows are never far away, and things get both rhythmically disruptive and emotionally complex. However, in the end, something rather sunnier wins out, with a shift from A Minor to A Major which, as it were, banishes the ghosts. YouTube is fairly well stocked when it comes to performances of Elgar’s Piano Quintet, and from the options I’ve selected this concert performance given at La Jolla Music Festival in California in 2017. The performers are Cho-Liang Lim and Michelle Kim of violins, Paul Neubauer on viola, Clive Greensmith on cello and Haochen Zhang on piano. You’ll find their performance here: Elgar: Piano Quintet
Eller, Heino (1887-1970)
Day 328: 'Videvik' ('Twilight') (Time: 6 minutes) and 'Koit' ('Dawn') (7 minutes)
This is the first in a short series of postings I’m writing about the music of Estonia – a part of Europe which has, for over a century, punched well above its weight. And, although we’ve had music from Estonia before, it’s all been by Arvo Pärt (see Days 33, 83 and 249), so I thought it might be good to hear from some of his predecessors and contemporaries. Estonia is a remarkable country when it comes to music. In fact, I’d be inclined to say that only Finland, perhaps, eclipses it when it comes to the number of extraordinary musical figures (composers and performers) per head of population that the nation has produced. Before the later 19th century Estonia had a somewhat chequered history, persistently dominated by Russia to the east. However, the Estonian ‘national awakening’ of the latter half of the 19th century placed great emphasis on the Estonian language, its folk history and culture, and, importantly for my discussion, its music. Its first National Song Festival was held in 1869, and over the next 120 years, through the many decades of suffering that the nation underwent at the hands of the Soviet Union and Nazi Germany, its singing culture continued to thrive, as a symbol of national identity and resistance. Its modern-day independence was first declared in 1918, and it survived attempts at invasion by the Soviet Union through its first 20 years as a democratic state. However, the Second World War brought invasion from Stalin’s forces, then from the Nazis and, from 1944, from the Soviet Union again, leading to a significant influx in the Russian-speaking population and the forced removal of Estonian nationalist figures after the Second World War. However, in the 1980s, along with the populations of Latvia and Lithuania, it benefited from the slow easing of repression under Gorbachov, and the social/political phenomenon we now know as the ‘Singing Revolution’ helped the nation to independence in 1991. I love the idea that you can defeat tyranny by singing! The Estonian Song Festival, a once every five years event, was held in Tallinn in 1988, and at that event daytime performances were followed by spontaneous massed singing demonstrations throughout the evenings. Patriotic songs fuelled this passion, and culminated in the ‘Baltic Way’ (or ‘Chain of Freedom’), a human chain of two million people linking Estonia’s capital, Tallinn, with Vilnius in Lithuania, nearly 450 miles to the south, in August 1989. It would be naïve to say that song alone was the foundation of Estonia’s independence, but it’s a profound symbol of Estonian culture and identity, and has remained so to this day. And today (23/9/22) I want to consider the first of three composers whose music articulated a sense of Estonian identity through the 20th century, the man who is generally regarded as the founder of contemporary Estonian music, Heino Eller (1887-1970). He wasn’t the first Estonian composer to produce work that was heard across Europe (that’s probably Rudolf Tobias), but as a teacher he was responsible for educating many of the significant figures of the middle years of the 20th century, including the two composers I’ll feature next. Although during his working life Estonia was essentially under Soviet control, the pieces he wrote particularly towards the end of the First World War begin to articulate a distinct sense of what Estonian music might be in its own right. Today I want to feature two short orchestral works. The first is ‘Videvik’ (‘Twilight’) from 1917. This is in many ways a fairly conventional late-Romantic orchestral piece, lyrical and exploring ‘feeling’ in a way which is quite reminiscent of Sibelius or Stenhammar. The New Grove Dictionary says about Eller: ‘the northern colouring of Eller’s music places it close to Grieg, while his refined nervous tension and impetuousness aligns him with Scriabin’. In this audio-only recording of ‘Twilight’, the Royal Scottish National Orchestra is conducted by that indefatigable Estonian Neeme Järvi. You’ll find it here, accompanied by some dreamy impressionist images: Eller: 'Videvik' ('Twilight'). A companion piece, ‘Koit’ (‘Dawn’) was actually started before ‘Twilight’, but it took until 1920 for Eller to be satisfied that the work had reached its final form. It has a little more of a sense of its Estonian identity than its predecessor, generated by its folk-like melodic and harmonic colouring. It’s performed in this video recording by the Estonian State Symphony Orchestra, conducted once more by Neeme Järvi, which you’ll find here: Eller: 'Koit' ('Dawn').
Eller was responsible for the musical education, at the Tartu Higher School for Music from 1920-40 and then at the Tallinn Conservatory from 1940-70, of at least a dozen composers whose contribution to Estonian music has made it a force in the world, including Arvo Pärt. Next time, I want to look at the life and work of one of the first of these figures, Eduard Tubin.
Enescu, George (1881-1955)
Day 478: Violin Sonata No 2, Op 6 (Time: 22 minutes)
Later this month, as part of the Sheffield Chamber Music Festival, the exceptional young violinist Irene Duval will be performing (with members of Ensemble 360) music by Fauré and George Enescu. We’ve got a fair bit of Fauré on this list by now, whereas Enescu has never featured, so for that reason, I’ve chosen his life and one of his works to explore today (7/5/24). George Enescu (1881-1955) – or, if you’re French, or reading any blurb from French recording companies, Georges Enesco – is one of those composers who was so prolifically talented as a performer that his compositions have tended to be rather overshadowed as a result. The history of Western classical music is full of child prodigies (Mozart is probably the most famous, but one could also include Richard Strauss, Mendelssohn, Saint-Saens, Korngold… and no doubt many others) but George Enescu definitely deserves his place in that category. He was Romanian by birth, born into a prosperous family on the Romanian/Ukrainian border. He showed remarkable early talent for music, both as a performer (on the violin) and as a composer. At the age of 7, he entered the Vienna Conservatoire. (The standard earliest entry was at age 14; Enescu was only the second person, after Fritz Kreisler, to get in at such an absurdly young age.) By the time he was 14, he had moved on to the Paris Conservatoire, where he continued his studies with Fauré and Massenet. He spent most of the time up to the outbreak of the First World War in Paris, and after that, he lived variously in Romania, France again, the USA, Romania again, and finally in France once more, where he died in some poverty after suffering from a crippling curvature of the spine that put paid to his performing career, finally dying from the after-effects of a stroke in 1955. These days, a considerable amount of Enescu’s music has been recorded and performed, and as his reputation as a violin virtuoso becomes more distant, it’s good that his compositions are getting more time in the limelight. He produced work in most of the major genres of Western classical music. I’m confident that even those who might deny any knowledge of his work, or who might claim never to have heard of him, will know his Romanian Rhapsody No 1, an early work from 1901, as soon as you hear it. He wrote one opera, ‘Oedipe’, which he considered to be his masterpiece. There are five symphonies (two left unfinished at his death) and other lively orchestral works, notably his three Orchestral Suites. There’s some solo piano music (suites and sonatas), but considerably more chamber music, almost all featuring the violin, unsurprisingly. In particular, and this brings me to today’s featured work, there are three violin sonatas (well, actually four if you count the single-movement so-called ‘Torso’ Sonata). The first sonata dates from Enescu’s early teens, and is heavily influenced by Brahms; the third, his most famous (and stunningly difficult to play), is a mature work from 1926. (If you ever get the chance to hear that in concert, jump at it; I saw Ben Nabarro and Tim Horton of Ensemble 360 play it a few years ago, and it was frankly astonishing.) However, the work Irene Duval and Tim Horton will be playing this month is the Violin Sonata No 2, Op 6, which dates from 1899, when Enescu was already an experienced composer of 17 years of age. As you’ll see from the dates above, he was by this time based in Paris, and he wrote approvingly of the influence of French musical style and culture on his hitherto mingled Germanic and Eastern European musical language. In his view, the 2nd Violin Sonata was the first work in which he felt he’d found his ‘real’ voice: ‘I felt myself evolving rapidly, I was becoming myself . . . Until then, I was fumbling. From that moment I felt able to walk on my own legs, even if not yet to run very fast ...’ The idea for the work’s initial main theme had been with him since ‘the age of 14, when I was walking by myself in Prince Maurouzi’s garden [in Romania, and] a theme came into my head… I carried it inside me for three years; then, at 17, I wrote my Second Violin Sonata in the space of a fortnight.’ It’s a work in three movements, and it’s dominated by the long, winding theme that opens the first movement. Elements of this theme feed into the music of all three movements, in ways that might not be immediately obvious, but which give the piece as a whole a strong sense of unity. Without getting too nerdy, you can hear in this piece two of the most important characteristics of Enescu as a composer. One is his interest in ‘organic’ structures, in which, you might say, everything is related to everything else, and which generates a strong ‘cyclical’ quality as the work reaches its final movement, the sense that we’re not just encountering themes we’ve heard before but that Enescu is piling them on top of one another in ways that show their hidden links. The other compositional quality I’d flag up is his interest in music which is harmonically ambiguous, so that we’re never entirely sure, if you like, which way is up, or where it’s safe to put down our feet. (Metaphors, folks, but you know what I mean, I hope.) The music sounds both exotically foreign, but also (to me anyway) very French… but behind it all is the inescapable influence of Romanian folk music. YouTube is reasonably well-stocked with performances of this work, and out of the options available, I’ve gone for this one by violinist (and also an international-standard concert pianist … though she doesn’t play both parts here!) Julia Fischer, accompanied at the piano by Yulianna Avdeeva. You’ll find their performance here: Enescu: Violin Sonata No 2, Op 6
Evans, Bill (1929-80)
Day 97 – Peace Piece (Time: 7 minutes)
Today (27/6/20), in a break with tradition, Malcolm would like to suggest we listen to some jazz. If justification were needed, he points out that this piece featured on Radio 3 recently – though, let’s face it, the diversity of types of music on Radio 3 far exceeds that on any other broadcast station. Anyway, the composer is Bill Evans, and the piece is called ‘Peace Piece’. Bill Evans (1929-80) was a pianist and composer with a training in classical music. He played on Miles Davis’ legendary album ‘Kind of Blue’, and subsequently played in a range of smaller ensembles, often trios. This is jazz as chamber music, I think. Evans’ career is, like that of many jazz musicians, a complex and fluid one, stalked by addiction to heroin and cocaine. But in a range of collaborations, and via some very experimental developments in piano writing (particularly in terms of harmonies) he was a pioneer in his field. His pianism has echoes of Chopin, but even more of Debussy, Ravel and Satie, and that ‘floating’ harmonic impressionism they developed. It is said that ‘Peace Piece’ began life as an improvisation when Evans was still a music student, but it resurfaced in the later 1950s and appeared on the album ‘Everybody Digs Bill Evans’ in early 1959. Evans describes the piece as starting as an improvisation on the chord patterns of Leonard Bernstein’s ‘Some Other Time’ (which, trivia fans, appeared as a bonus track on the ‘Everybody Digs Bill Evans’ album), over which Evans elaborated different melodic patterns. The result is this serene and beautiful moment of contemplation. You’ll find it here: Bill Evans – Peace Piece
Falla, Manuel de (1876-1946)
Day 154: The Three-Cornered Hat (Suite No 2) (Time: 13 minutes)
Today (15/1/21), in this, the second instalment in ‘Spanish Sunshine Week’, a suggestion from me. For a while, I’ve wanted to include some music by Manuel de Falla, and there’s just time within the ’40 minute rule’ to fit this in alongside the Rodrigo we heard last time out. Manuel de Falla (1876-1946) was from the generation just a little after Albeniz (see Day 27) and Granados (one day soon!), so most of his output falls squarely in the 20th century. He was born in Cadiz, and moved to Madrid as a young man, but probably the most important influence on his musical development came from the years he spent in Paris from 1907-14, during which time he met not just the leading French composers of the day (Debussy, Ravel, Dukas) but also the major cultural figures associated with the Ballets Russes, busy scandalising the French capital (Stravinsky, Massine, Picasso and – influentially – the impresario Diaghilev). He returned to Madrid at the start of the First World War, and spent the rest of his time in Spain until the triumph of Spanish Fascism drove him into exile in Argentina, where he died. He seems to have been an essentially private person (he neither married nor had children, and there’s no evidence of any long-term relationships) and was quite a fastidious composer: his whole output that has survived would comfortably fit on half a dozen CDs. However, even if there isn’t a lot of it, Falla’s music is vivid and colourfully orchestrated, and very heavily influenced by the folk music of Andalusia, particularly Andalusian flamenco. He wrote a small amount of orchestral music for the concert hall, an equally sparing quantity of chamber music, and rather more songs and piano pieces, but his preferred medium was music for the stage – a number of ‘zarzuelas’ (a kind of Spanish version of a stage musical, I guess) and, in his maturity, a number of ballets. ‘El Sombero de Tres Picos’ (‘The Three-Cornered Hat’) dates from the last years of the First World War, and was first performed in 1919 at the instigation of Diaghilev. It’s a comic story, in two acts, about a magistrate (wearer of the titular hat) who is infatuated with a miller's wife, tries to seduce her and gets his just deserts by being tossed in a blanket (don’t ask…). The full ballet lasts not much more than half an hour, but two concert suites also exist, and today I thought it would be enjoyable to watch a performance of the second suite. The music is in effect almost all of Act 2 of the ballet, starting with the lilting seguidilla of ‘Dance of the Neighbours’, followed by the more lively farruca of ‘The Miller’s Dance’, and finally the barnstorming jota of the ‘Final Dance’. There’s a vigorous performance of the Suite No 2 from Falla's ‘The Three-Cornered Hat’ on YouTube, played by the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra, conducted with some panache by Andres Orozco-Estrada, which you’ll find here: Falla: The Three-Cornered Hat (Suite No 2)
Day 240: Nights in the Gardens of Spain (Time: 25 minutes)
Manuel de Falla (1876-1946) has made one appearance so far on this list; see Day 154, above, when we encountered the 2nd Suite from his ballet ‘The Three-Cornered Hat’. I wrote extensively about his life in that posting, so do refer back to it for more biographical information. The two reasons for including his music today (12/11/21) are, firstly, that, two days from now, it will be the 75th anniversary of his death on 14/11/1946, in Argentina, where he had been in exile since the establishment of Fascist government in Spain after the Spanish Civil War. The second reason is that my current focus on a ‘nocturnal’ theme means this is an ideal time to explore the most important work Falla wrote for piano and orchestra (it could be argued that it’s the most important work for piano and orchestra by any Spanish composer ever), the not-quite-a-piano-concerto ‘Nights in the Gardens of Spain’. (When pushed, he described the piece as ‘Symphonic Impressions’, insisting that the piano was not a solo instrument, but rather embedded in the texture of the orchestra, even though in most performances, like the one below, the pianist appears on stage as though this were indeed a piano concerto.) Interestingly, the piece began life as a plan for a collection of nocturnes for solo piano in the years before the First World War. However, Falla’s compatriot, the pianist Ricardo Viñes, suggested it would make a greater impact as a larger-scale work with orchestral accompaniment, which is how it made its first public appearance in 1916. It’s a three movement work, with each movement given the title of a garden that makes (directly or indirectly) reference to places in Falla’s own home region, Andalusia. The first movement is called ‘En el Generalife’ (In the Generalife), the gardens around the Alhambra Palace in Granada, and it is notable for the fact that its theme gives the impression of being plucked on a guitar, and the strings sustain the illusion of being ‘strummed’. The second movement is less specific: we are listening to a ‘Danza Lejana’ (A Distant Dance) in another nocturnal landscape. This is the most animated of the three movements, reminiscent in places of flamenco. Finally, we have ‘En los Jardines de la Sierra de Córdoba’ (In the Gardens of the Sierra de Córdoba) – the area around Cordoba in Andalusia. Here again, the influence of flamenco is apparent – in the central section, the piano soloist acts like the vocalist in a ‘cante jondo’, which the notes to my CD copy of this music identify as "a vocal Flamenco style in which a florid melody in the high treble sings over a throbbing bass". The piece ends quietly, as though dying away into the silence of the night. The melodies and rhythms of the piece overall are reminiscent of Andalusian folk music, which was never far from Falla’s heart as an inspiration. YouTube offers several decent video recordings of this work, and from them, I’ve chosen this one by the Chicago Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Placido Domingo, with Daniel Barenboim as soloist. You’ll find it here: Falla: Nights in the Gardens of Spain
Fano, Guido Alberto (1875-1961)
Day 536: Piano Quintet (Time: 38 minutes)
I’m a long way off the beaten track today (2/5/25), but I think it’s a risk worth taking (you can decide on hearing the music later) in relation to Guido Alberto Fano (1875-1961), who is my choice because the 150th anniversary of his birth is coming up later this month. So, apart from acknowledging that Fano is a rarely-heard composer, and that in truth there’s very little of his music out there in terms of recordings, what is worth saying about him and his work? Well, I’d start with a quick review of the state of Italian music during the 19th century. The familiar cliché is that music in Italy in those years meant, effectively, Italian opera – think of that pretty much direct line between Rossini, Bellini, Donizetti and Verdi, and then leading on to Puccini and the various purveyors of Italian operatic ‘verismo’ as we move into the 20th century – and, like all clichés, this one is essentially true. If you’ve rarely, if ever, heard an Italian symphony or string quartet or similar from the 19th century, apart from the odd student work by composers who went on to write opera, you may be tempted to think it’s because there are none. It’s only in recent years that I’ve come across the music – well worth exploring, and trust me, we will one day – of Giovanni Sgambati, who it would be reasonable to describe as the ‘father’ of non-operatic Italian music from the 1870s onwards. Well, in the generation after Sgambati, there’s a whole swathe of Italian musicians who, while not forswearing operatic composition entirely, did at least make space for orchestral, symphonic and chamber music too. This is the so-called ‘Generazione dell'Ottanta’ (the Generation of the Eighties, the 1880s). This list has featured one such figure already (see Day 152 for Ottorino Respighi), but we could also add – and I’d like to think that before too long this list might illustrate – the music of Casella, Ghedini, Malipiero, Martucci, Pizzetti … and Guido Alberto Fano. The last of these was born on 18th May 1875 in Padua. He was, by training, a pianist, and indeed his initial career plan was to make his living as a concert performer. However, he also studied composition with Martucci in Bologna, graduating from the latter’s composition class with flying colours in 1897. His career from then on consisted of concert performances, composing, and the increasingly burdensome role of musical director at a handful of Italian music conservatories – in Naples in 1912, Parma in 1916 and in Milan from 1922. One other thing worth noting about Fano is that he was Jewish, and therefore (this is such a familiar story for Jewish composers and performers in the first half of the 20th century) in 1938 he lost his job as a result of the anti-Jewish race laws promoted under Mussolini’s Fascist rule in Italy. In fact, Fano and his family had a hard time during the 2nd World War, taking refuge in religious institutions in Fossombrone and Assisi. In 1945, at the end of the war, he returned to his post in Milan, but he retired in 1947, living quietly until his death in 1961. There aren’t that many recordings of Fano’s music, and in part that’s because he didn’t actually write all that much. His compositional career began in the 1890s with music that’s essentially conventionally late Romantic (there are salon-type pieces for piano or chamber forces, and the occasional larger scale work, like his Cello Sonata of 1897), and there’s a fertile period in the decade or so before the outbreak of the First World War, when his music became much more modern (if not modernist). This was largely stuff written under the influence of Richard Strauss (Fano found the language of Strauss’s operas ‘Salome’ and ‘Elektra’ both compelling and a little scary!). Then the creative force pretty much dies away. There are actually three operas by Fano (it’s not like he was allergic to writing for the human voice), alongside a somewhat OTT symphonic poem (‘The Temptation of Jesus’) and a short concerto-style work, the Andante and Allegro con Fuoco for Piano and Orchestra – written in the 1890s and then reworked in the mid-1930s. But the most enduring stuff is actually for solo piano (there’s a large-scale Piano Sonata from the late 1890s, though not actually published until 1920) or chamber music. In this last category, apart from the previously-mentioned Cello Sonata, the stand-out works are his Piano Quintet of 1917, and a String Quartet from as late as 1942. I think the work I’d choose to illustrate Fano’s mature compositional voice is the Piano Quintet, a substantial four movement work. I’d suggest that probably the biggest musical influence on the work is Brahms, though perhaps it’s lacking the kind of rigorous musical logic that (for me, anyway!) makes Brahms’ music so wonderful. Or at least, it starts off being Brahmsian, before heading off in other directions. One other thing worth saying about Fano’s Piano Quintet is that the piano plays a very prominent part (almost like a concerto soloist), perhaps unsurprisingly given Fano’s back-story as a concert pianist. And one last thing: when did you last hear a Piano Quintet (usual line up: piano and string quartet) with a trumpet? Well, there’s one in the last movement, where it articulates the chorale-like apotheosis with which the work concludes. Far out, man… You will be entirely unsurprised to know that recordings of Fano’s Piano Quintet are about as common as hen’s teeth. Inevitably therefore we’re in audio-only territory here, with a recording by that most aristocratically elegant pianist Aldo Ciccolini, with the Torino String Quartet. (I’m afraid I can’t track down the trumpet player…) You’ll find the recording here: Fano: Piano Quintet
Farrenc, Louise (1804-75)
Day 322: Sextet for Piano and Winds, Op 40 - 1. Allegro (Time: 12 minutes), 2. Andante Sostenuto (7 minutes) and 3. Allegro Vivace (7 minutes)
Later this month, Ensemble 360’s winds alongside pianist Tim Horton are playing a concert of music by Beethoven, Farrenc and Danzi, and from that programme I want to select the music for today (2/9/22), and yet another new name on this playlist. Louise Farrenc (1804-75) is in many ways typical of female composers of the 19th century, from the uphill struggle to study on an equal footing with men, to being undervalued (and underpaid!) as a music teacher, to failing to have her music taken with the seriousness that would have been afforded to her male contemporaries. It has to be said that the cards were consistently stacked against women in the world of music composition and performance (with the possible exception of renowned female singers, the need for whom is obvious in the world of opera, and those figures whose longevity and association with male composers helped to maintain their status, such as Clara Schumann). In some ways, Farrenc’s family background did at least help her to get a start in life: she was the daughter and sister of sculptors, and family life in the artistic ‘commune’ near the Sorbonne in Paris, where she grew up, meant that music was not ruled out as a socially unacceptable career for a young woman. She studied at the Paris Conservatoire (composition and piano), though there is some doubt as to whether she actually attended classes, which were all-male affairs at the time, or whether she simply had lessons privately. At the age of only 17, she married Aristide Farrenc, a flautist, who later stepped back from concert performance and started up the Farrenc music publishing business, a source of financial security over the following decades. In her 20s, Farrenc had a public life as a concert pianist, and a private one as mother to Victorine – naturally, it was expected that public life would be put on hold to prioritise motherhood – before, in the 1830s and 40s, beginning to compose more seriously. Unsurprisingly, as a concert pianist her early compositions are for piano, and they’re attractive enough in a ‘salon’ style, but subsequent works include three symphonies and a couple of concert overtures, although very little of her orchestral music was heard in her lifetime. It’s probably fair to say that Farrenc failed to become a household name as a composer in France at the time because she had no interest at all in writing opera, which was the foremost musical form in France throughout the 19th century. For thirty years from 1842, she was Professor of Piano at the Paris Conservatoire. It’s perhaps inevitable that in that role she was paid less than her male contemporaries, at least until the successful performance of her Nonet for Wind and Strings in 1849. I’d want to make a strong case for saying Farrenc’s chamber music is the strongest strand of her output. As well as the Nonet, you’ll find two piano quintets, two piano trios (plus two other works for piano, cello and a wind instrument replacing the violin), two violin sonatas, a cello sonata … and today’s work, the Sextet for Piano and Wind Quintet. This dates from 1852, and as far as I know, it’s the very first work ever written for this combination of forces. (On the rare occasions that it gets programmed, it usually features alongside the Poulenc work for the same set of players, since there really isn’t a lot of this repertoire to go round.) It’s in the dark and rugged key of C Minor, and although you can hear the influence of fashionable early Romantic composers of the day (like Hummel or Mendelssohn), there’s plenty of evidence of the music taking us to harmonically unusual places for a work of this date. It’s a sort of ‘concertante’ piece, in that the piano is in some ways a ‘soloist’, though Farrenc employs combinations of the wind instruments in interesting and varied ways. Although she never wrote an opera, listening to the ‘vocal’ wind writing, in the slow movement especially, you can get a sense of what one of her operas might have sounded like. There are no video performances of this work uploaded as a single link on YouTube, so for this piece you’ll get links to each of the three movements. It’s played by the Australian chamber forces of the Omega Ensemble, and you’ll find it here: Farrenc: Sextet for Piano and Winds, Op 40 - 1. Allegro, 2. Andante Sostenuto and 3. Allegro Vivace
Note: These videos have now been removed by their owner. Alternatives to follow soon.
Fauré, Gabriel (1845-1924)
Day 101: Masques et Bergamasques (Suite) (Time: 16 minutes)
Today (14/7/20) is Bastille Day, and it seems inevitable, therefore, that we should have some French music. But I've gone not for something tub-thumping and jingoistic, but rather for something subtle and elusive, picking up on French music's characteristic elegance and charm. I’ve chosen music by Gabriel Faure (add your own acute accent) (1845-1924), who hasn’t yet featured on this list. Faure is in some ways difficult to place in the history of French music. His birthdate suggests a link with Saint-Saëns or Massenet, but he lived well into the 20th century, outlasting the likes of Debussy in the process. So he’s neither an obvious late Romantic, nor an obvious ‘Impressionist’. Add to that the fact that he seems to have a clearly demarcated ‘early’ and ‘late’ style, and also that his later years were troubled by deafness, generating music of increasing ‘inwardness’ and contemplation, and it becomes harder to point to any one ‘fingerprint’ and say that that’s evidence of Faure at work. However, the general consensus is that his most popular and accessible work came early in his career, whilst the more critically-valued stuff comes later on, particularly in terms of its harmonic complexity. He wrote some very popular and beautiful pieces – the ‘Requiem’ of course, but also his ‘Pavane’, or that favourite with amateur choirs the ‘Cantique de Jean Racine’, or songs like ‘Apres Un Reve’ (again, sorry about the accents). But I've decided to go a little off the beaten track by selecting the suite of music he wrote for ‘Masques et Bergamasques’, a late work dating from 1919. This has a slightly complex history. It began life as music for an ‘entertainment’ for the Prince of Monaco, originally featuring choral and solo vocal numbers, but the more familiar orchestral suite played these days consists of four movements. In fact, though it dates from 1919, the first three of its movements were salvaged from an attempt at a symphony that Faure abandoned back in the 1860s, and only the final movement is entirely new and original. It was Faure's last music for orchestra. The performance I've chosen is by the Lausanne Chamber Orchestra, conducted by Bertrand de Billy, and you’ll find it here: Fauré – Masques et Bergamasques (Suite)
Day 176: Requiem (Time: 35 minutes)
Today (2/4/21), as it’s Good Friday, and in keeping with the solemnity of the occasion, I’ve chosen (after quite a few selections which have highlighted music that isn’t necessarily always of front-rank quality, even if it deserves an airing) a composition which is indubitably one of the masterpieces of its genre. What’s more, given that Malcolm’s choice from a few days ago only used up four of our hypothetical forty minutes’ music each week, we can contemplate today’s work in full. This piece is a suggestion from Jenny, which I’ve had since the start of Advent 2020 (Jenny is very keen on Requiems for Advent!), and which I’m very happy to be able to act upon today. The composer in question, Gabriel Fauré (1845-1924), has appeared on this list only once before (see above, Day 101), when we encountered the early/late work, the ‘Masques et Bergamasques’ Suite – late in that it was his last orchestral composition, early in that three of its four movements existed in some form 50 years before they finally saw the light of day. Fauré is a complex and elusive composer to characterise. He is almost an exact contemporary of d’Indy (see Day 174), but where d’Indy's language remained largely static in expression right through to his death in the 1930s, Fauré by contrast developed a harmonic language in particular that moved on considerably from late 19th century Romanticism. Fauré experienced relatively little fame and success in the first forty years of his life, but his fortunes changed during the 1880s. Until then his output consisted essentially of sets of songs and piano pieces, with the occasional chamber work. However, in 1887 he began work on what would become his most popular and enduring piece, the Requiem. His parents died in 1885 and 1887, but there is little evidence that Fauré was prompted to begin writing as a result of this. Instead, he wrote that ‘it wasn’t written for anything – for pleasure, if I may call it that.’ The work evolved slowly, and can be seen to exist in at least two different forms. The first version was performed, actually for a funeral service, in 1888, and consisted of five movements, the Introit and Kyrie, Sanctus, Pie Jesu, Agnus Dei and finally In Paradisum. Church rules meant no female voices, and a boy treble in the Pie Jesu. The instrumental forces amounted merely to a small chamber ensemble. By 1893 a new, fuller version emerged, essentially for the concert hall, for a larger mixed choir, male and female soloists, and full orchestra. One ‘new’ movement, the Libera Me, was actually salvaged from a piece for baritone and choir composed in the 1870s; the Offertoire movement was completely new. Fauré’s faith (or lack of it) is often a subject for discussion, but he wrote very illuminatingly about this work in ways that I find extremely moving: ‘Everything I managed to entertain by way of religious illusion I put into my Requiem, which moreover is dominated from beginning to end by a very human feeling of faith in eternal rest.’ Elsewhere he noted that ‘It has been said that my Requiem does not express the fear of death and someone has called it a lullaby of death. But it is thus that I see death: as a happy deliverance, an aspiration towards happiness above, rather than as a painful experience.’ Comments like these explain why Fauré does not set the Dies Irae sequence (apart from its final Pie Jesu section). It has been said that, however different they are in musical language, Fauré’s Requiem has many things in common with that of Brahms, and not simply in terms of patterns of movements and sections employing the two soloists; perhaps most of all what they share is that they are ‘human’ requiems. In terms of performances on YouTube, I haven’t been able to locate a video performance of sufficient quality of the earlier chamber-sized ‘ecclesiastical’ version, so what you’ve got instead is the familiar ‘concert’ setting. I have to confess a preference for a female soloist with virtually no vibrato in the Pie Jesu section, but in the end I can just about cope with the rather wobbly soprano Sylvia Schwartz alongside the excellent Roderick Williams as the baritone, in this performance given by the Danish Radio Symphony Orchestra and Choir, conducted by Ivor Bolton. You’ll find it here: Fauré: Requiem
Day 238: Nocturne No 4 in Eb, Op 36 (Time: 7 minutes), Nocturne No 6 in Db, Op 63 (9 minutes) and Nocturne No 10 in E Minor, Op 99 (5 minutes)
After my previous posting, which addressed the ‘father’ of the nocturne, John Field, today (5/11/21) we move to the late 19th/early 20th century, and the set of nocturnes written by Gabriel Fauré. Alan Harrison, one of the list's ‘invisible’ correspondents, has suggested we listen to a selection of these, which, in the context of Field's pieces, show how flexible the concept of ‘the nocturne’ could be. Fauré has appeared twice before on this list (see Day 101 for his ‘Masques et Bergamasques’ Suite, and Day 176 for his Requiem), so I won’t recap basic biographical information here, as you can chase it up, if you wish, via those postings. However, in the paragraphs on Fauré that I wrote previously, I didn’t address at all the fact of Fauré’s piano music, which formed a consistent compositional thread throughout his career. There is quite a lot of it – enough to fill four CDs – though he wrote no large-scale works for piano, beyond an early Ballade for piano solo (which also exists in a later version for piano and orchestra) from the late 1870s that comes in at just under 15 minutes, and an inventive Theme and Variations from a couple of decades later, which is of about the same length. Instead, what Fauré seems to have preferred is to write shorter-form pieces: he produced 13 Nocturnes, spanning the years 1875-1921; there are also 13 Barcarolles (1880-1921), six Impromptus (1881-1904), the famous ‘Dolly’ Suite for piano four-hands, and a range of pieces with more ‘salon’-style titles (songs without words, valses-caprices and so on). The titles of his major collections of piano music might suggest a debt to Chopin, but for me that debt disappears after the 1880s, when Fauré’s piano music starts to lose its more immediate sense of accessibility and directness, and becomes instead something almost elusive and impossible to pin down. I guess it’s true that Fauré’s Nocturnes, like Chopin’s, are primarily slow and contemplative pieces (though often with more turbulent middle sections), but while it’s possible to imagine a late-night Proms performance of Chopin’s Nocturnes packing out the Royal Albert Hall, Fauré’s equivalent works make for a more challenging listen – though a deeply rewarding one if you give them time to make their often understated impact. There are lots of contradictions to be encountered in these works. For example, they’re rarely ‘showy’ in that 19th century Romantic pianist’s ‘look at me’ sort of way, yet they’re often extremely difficult to play (Liszt and Saint-Saens used to complain that what Fauré wrote was ‘too difficult’). There’s a nice quotation from Fauré himself on the challenge of writing for the piano: ‘In piano music there's no room for padding – one has to pay cash and make it consistently interesting. It's perhaps the most difficult genre of all.’ Fauré’s favourite composer-pianist seems to have been Schumann, and I think you can hear that particularly in the sudden shifts of mood and direction in some of these Nocturnes, and in the way the codas of these pieces summarise the ‘journey’ they take us on. Time constraints don’t allow us much more than a sampling exercise here, but I thought it would be good to show at least three phases of Fauré’s development within this genre, so the links here are to Nocturnes Nos 4, 6 and 10. Fauré’s Nocturne No 4 in Eb, Op 36, dates from the mid-1880s. The generally lyrical style of the piece is challenged by something more sombre in its central section, with its bell-like tolling. It’s played on this video recording by the young French pianist Paolo Rigutto, which you’ll find here: Fauré: Nocturne No 4 in Eb, Op 36. Almost exactly a decade later Fauré wrote his Nocturne No 6 in Db, Op 63. For most critics, this is the finest of Fauré’s Nocturnes. In the liner notes to my box set of Fauré’s piano music, the writer Bryce Morrison says it is ‘among the most rich and eloquent of all Fauré's piano works.’ Aaron Copland wrote that, for him, this was the work in which Fauré was at last free of the shadow of Chopin falling across his work. He summed up the work's journey thus: ‘The breath and dignity of the opening melody, the restless C# Minor section which follows (with the peculiar syncopated harmonies so often and so well used by Fauré), the graceful fluidity of the third idea: all these elements are brought to a stormy climax in the short development section; then, after a pause, comes the return of the consoling first page.’ In this video recording, it’s played by Michel Dalberto: Fauré: Nocturne No 6 in Db, Op 63. Scroll forward another decade or so and we reach Nocturne No 10 in E Minor, Op 99. By this point, many things are rather darker in Fauré’s life, particularly in terms of his increasing deafness. His piano writing is generally more withdrawn: not what you’d call calm, but definitely more restrained. That said, this particular Nocturne is dark and troubled, at least until its closing pages. To quote Morrison again, the middle section ‘inhabits a world of nightmare’, so if this is ‘nocturnal’ music it’s not a place of sweet dreams. It’s played on this recording (audio only this time) by the renowned French pianist Eric Le Sage: Fauré: Nocturne No 10 in E Minor, Op 99.
Day 474: Piano Quartet No 1, Op 15 (Time: 31 minutes)
We’ve had three opportunities to explore Fauré’s work on this list to date - see Days 101, 176 and 238 – which has provided us with compositions for orchestra (the ‘Masques and Bergamasques’ Suite), choir (the indestructible Requiem) and solo piano (a selection of his Nocturnes). The Guest Curator of next month’s Sheffield Chamber Music Festival is renowned cellist Steven Isserlis, and the music of Fauré is one of his obsessions. As a result we have a piece of Fauré’s chamber music to open proceedings in the first concert of the festival, his effervescent and popular Piano Quartet No 1 in C Minor, Op 15, which is my focus for today (23/4/24). My previous postings about Fauré have highlighted the element of contrast in his output between ‘early’ Fauré (a relative term for someone whose compositional career spanned over 60 years) up until he was in his late 40s, and ‘later’ Fauré, the final three decades. Obviously there is continuity too, but it’s striking that almost all Fauré’s most regularly performed compositions come from the former period – the Élégie for cello and piano, the early songs such as ‘Après un Rêve’, the ‘Cantique de Jean Racine’ and the Requiem, and the orchestral ‘Pavane’. The music of his later years is, as is often remarked upon, more ‘inward’, less overtly accessible. There are reasons, naturally, both public (a lot of his time after 1905 was taken up with his job as Head of the Paris Conservatoire) and private (his eventual almost total deafness). However, the Piano Quartet No 1 is very definitely ‘early’ Fauré, and it has an immediacy and freshness that has ensured that it is by some distance his most popular work for chamber forces. It was written initially in the final years of the 1870s, and – though you’d not guess it from the generally sunny mood of the piece, possibly the sunniest C Minor work there is! – its genesis coincided with one of the more turbulent periods in the composer’s life. He’d been courting (to use a rather old-fashioned word) Marianne Viardot, daughter of the famous singer (and composer!) Pauline Viardot for five years before they became engaged in 1877. Within six months, for reasons that aren’t clear, she broke off the engagement, and it was out of this troubled moment that Fauré began his piano quartet. As I’ve just said, it’s generally bright and optimistic – only the melancholy slow movement (which Fauré himself claimed was a lament for the sudden breakdown of that relationship) allows the storm clouds to gather with any permanence. In fact, with hindsight Fauré seems to have regarded the break with the Viardots as beneficial for him as a composer, free to write what he wanted (which was generally songs, short piano works and so on) rather than the more public works on a grand scale that his potential in-laws expected from him. Fauré himself said, ‘Perhaps the break was not a bad thing for me. The Viardot family might have deflected me from my proper path.’ The piano quartet was given a first performance in 1880, but by the time it was published in 1883 Fauré replaced the finale with an entirely new movement; the original did not survive Fauré’s bonfire of manuscript material in his last years. The first movement (‘Allegro molto moderato’) begins decisively, with a singing melody on the strings set against forceful piano chords, and from this music, along with a lyrical second theme for the viola, Fauré builds the whole movement. It’s tautly structured in the manner of a ‘classical’ sonata form (don’t worry if that means little) but the impression on the ear is that it’s unfolding with a kind of spontaneous flexibility rather than fitting into any kind of mould. The second movement is a scherzo, and it’s a curiously lively (one might even say ‘frothy’) creation, fairly unusual in Fauré’s output as a whole. There is a contrasting middle section with a lovely melody for muted strings over the piano’s arpeggios. Then we get to the slow movement, and really for the first time we’re confronted by something darker and more melancholy. There are two initial themes, the first solemn and brooding and the second more expansive and contemplative, and these vie with a yearning and nostalgic middle section for the emotional direction of the work, with the darker mood eventually prevailing. The replacement finale is energetic in the extreme, and manages to be both turbulent and playful at the same time. The work ends with a fizzing coda, with pretty much all the storm clouds lifted in a mood of almost innocent triumph. It’s a lovely, sparkling work, and a perfect choice to open this year’s festival. There are some pretty impressive performances of Fauré’s Piano Quartet No 1 on YouTube, and from them I’ve gone for this video performance recorded in the atmospheric (but clearly deserted) surroundings of the Romanesque church of the Pieve de Corsignano in Pienza, by what seems to be a scratch ensemble put together for the recording, Nelson Goerner on piano, with violinist Daishin Kashimoto, viola player Lawrence Power and cellist Antonio Lysy. You’ll find their performance here: Fauré: Piano Quartet No 1, Op 15
Day 514: Cantique de Jean Racine (Time: 1? minutes) and String Quartet (25 minutes)
Today (1/11/24), I’m homing in on a couple of pieces of music by Gabriel Fauré, for the simple reason that this coming Monday, 4th November, it will be 100 years exactly since the composer’s death in Paris at the age of 79. We’ve had several selections of music by Gabriel Urbain Fauré (1845-1924) before now – see Days 101, 176, 238 and 474. As part of the discussion of those choices – the ‘Masques et Bergamasques’ Suite, the evergreen Requiem, a selection of Nocturnes for piano, and the Piano Quartet No 1 – I’ve covered most of the biographical details of Fauré’s life, so I won’t repeat myself here. Instead, to mark this major centenary, I thought I’d explore music from both ends of Fauré’s career, and feature one of his earliest works alongside his very last composition. The early item is his lovely short choral work ‘Cantique de Jean Racine’, a piece with which I’m very familiar as the choir that I sing with has performed it more frequently than anything else (with the exception of a substantial number of Christmas carols!) since I joined them in 2007 – and at Escafeld Chorale’s spring concert in March 2025, you’ll hear it again! You may infer from these comments that the ‘Cantique’ is relatively straightforward to sing – which is true – but it’s also remarkably beautiful. It’s a work dating from 1865, and it was written for a composition competition at the music school at which the young Fauré was then studying, the École Niedermeyer, which was founded in 1853 and which accepted Fauré the following year as one of its first pupils. It was a school specialising in training singers and composers in church music (weekly choir singing was part of the deal for all students), and so not surprisingly Fauré set a devotional text. This is a paraphrase of a hymn from the breviary by the great 17th century French dramatist Racine, ‘Verbe égal au Très-Haut’ (‘Word, one with the Highest’). The original scoring is for the familiar four-part SATB choir, with piano or organ accompaniment, though when it got its first public performance in 1866 this had been re-scored for strings. (There have been other versions since, notably John Rutter’s arrangement where strings and harp accompany the choir.) Considering that he was only 19 when he wrote it, the work sounds incredibly like mature Fauré, with his characteristic mood of serenity and mellifluousness. It could almost be an offcut from his much later setting of the Requiem. Before the voices enter, the introduction has some typical Fauré fingerprints: a slow-moving and very singable melody – often marked ‘legato’ or ‘sempre legato’ – a carefully treading bass accompaniment, and (offering a hint of movement in the relative stillness) a triplet figure in the middle parts. There are three verses, and what’s strikingly confident, for someone so young, is how fluidly the vocal lines respond to the text and influence our response to it. It’s also, without getting too nerdy, a quietly subversive work in some ways. A common response to Fauré’s work is to feel as though it’s both still and moving at the same time, and it would be easy for a work so serene to plod a little, but it doesn’t because Fauré spices up the harmonies with some subtly subversive unconventional harmonic choices. As for a performance, YouTube offers everything from church choirs to massed forces of young singers to rather operatic renditions replete with warbly vibrato. The scoring is not quite as Fauré wrote it, but I’ve gone for this performance by the vocal group Voces8, with the English Chamber Orchestra conducted by Barnaby Smith playing the accompaniment in a restrained orchestration by Taylor Scott Davis. It’s a Covid lockdown performance, which explains the staging. You’ll find it here: Faure: Cantique de Jean Racine. Nearly 60 years later, Fauré composed his very last work, his one and only string quartet. In the early 1920s, Fauré’s health was precarious. He had lung problems (largely caused by heavy smoking) but probably the most distressing thing for him was his crippling deafness. Seemingly he was entirely unable to listen to music any more because it caused agonising physical pain. He was offered the opportunity to have the quartet played through privately just before he died, but turned it down because it would have sounded so distorted to him; the first performance only came some time after Fauré’s death. Fauré had written chamber music pretty much all his life – there are two each of piano quartets, piano quintets, violin sonatas and cello sonatas, alongside a single piano trio and a number of shorter works for solo instrument and piano – but until the very end of his life, Fauré suggested, he did not dare to contemplate writing a string quartet. The weight of the example of Beethoven was too daunting for him. It’s also the only chamber work Fauré wrote that does not feature the piano, his own instrument. There had been encouragement for Fauré to write a quartet for many decades. Back in 1903 Ravel dedicated his String Quartet to Fauré, and urged him to write one himself. There’s a quotation that appears pretty much everywhere in relation to this piece. Fauré spent his summers in Annecy in south-east France, and from there he wrote to his wife in Paris in September 1923: ‘I have undertaken a quartet for strings, without piano. This is a genre which Beethoven in particular made famous and causes all those who are not Beethoven to be terrified of it! . . . So you can well imagine I am frightened too. I have spoken of this to no one. I shall say nothing about it as long as I am nowhere near my objective: the end!’ That end was itself something that Fauré was initially uncertain about. The finished piece is in three movements, but even up to the last minute, Fauré contemplated a fourth movement, before deciding that (in another letter to his wife) ‘The quartet is completed, unless I decide to have a little extra movement which might have a place between the first and the second. But since it is in no way a necessity, I shall not tire myself by searching for it, at least not at the moment.’ Without wishing to sway your response to this music, I’d have to say that for some people, the quartet feels very static and not particularly straightforward to listen to. So maybe you’ll need to listen to it more than once for it to reveal its subtle and profound depths. I think the middle movement, a radiant Andante, is particularly beautiful, and, for me anyway, both nostalgic yet also lively and questing at the same time. The whole thing offers, as one might expect from Fauré, a quiet yet profound farewell to life. YouTube has some fine performances of this work, and out of the choices, I’ve gone for this one by the wonderful Ebène Quartet, which you’ll find here: Fauré: String Quartet
Day 543: Piano Trio (Time: 22 minutes)
It’s the Fauré trio which is my focus for today (20/6/25), another work to be featured in this month’s Bradfield Festival. I’ve devoted five previous editions of this playlist to Fauré, which might be regarded as quite a lot, relative to the appearances of some other composers, but the only explanations I’d offer are that there’s been a fair bit of Fauré performed at local concerts, and also his music has that wonderfully elusive quality that repays lots of repeated listening. His most recent appearance (Day 514) featured his String Quartet, Op 121, his final work. Today, we have the Piano Trio, Op 120, his only work for this combination of forces. In other words, we’re in much the same sound world as for the quartet, and in many ways the circumstances of the composition are identical – lung problems and excruciating deafness meant he was physically very frail. By now in his late 70s, he had retired from his role heading the Paris Conservatoire, and although this allowed theoretical extra time for composition, the fact that he could not listen to any music without feeling extreme physical pain meant that work progressed slowly, largely making the journey from his head to the manuscript, as it were, without the ‘interference’ of actually playing the stuff. Nonetheless, those last years were productive, especially in the area of chamber music. In the years between the end of the First World War and his death in 1924, we get the Cello Sonata No 2 (1918), a relatively obscure piece for solo harp, ‘Une châtelaine en sa tour’ (1918), the Piano Quintet No 2 (1919-21) and the previously featured String Quartet (1924), as well as the Piano Trio in D Minor, from 1923. He actually began work on it in 1920, but health problems and compositional frustration meant it did not emerge in its finished form for another three years. In fact, originally his plan was not for the traditional piano trio line-up (violin, cello, piano), but for a clarinet to replace the violin – but he abandoned this fairly soon in the writing process. Work was therefore slow – ‘The trouble is that I cannot work for long at a time. My worst tribulation is a perpetual fatigue,’ he wrote to his wife in Paris from his summer retreat in Annecy. Still, the first performance went well, apparently, this review comment being typical in its observations about the trio’s ‘elegant clarity, the equilibrium of thought and the serenity,’ which made it of a piece with the rest of Fauré’s late masterworks. As in almost all his late chamber music, the trio is in three movements, which have a loosely fast-slow-fast pattern, though one of the things that becomes obvious listening to late Fauré is its fluidity of thought and expression, so that it’s difficult to ‘explain’ how his works are put together with reference to any kind of formal pattern. The sleeve notes to my CD of the work try hard to be analytical but then just give up: ‘It is inadvisable to attempt to fit the (last) movement into any fixed formal pattern, and the same applies to the formal organisation of the other movements.’ (Some of you, I suspect, may be grateful for that, as it stops me trying to get all ‘musical analysis’ on you!) Of course, one consequence of that is that much of what you might read about the work (and late Fauré in general) tends to become all metaphorical quite quickly: consider this, from the musicologist Kai Christiansen, for example – ‘Like a flowing river in which one can never step twice, ideas recur but always in fresh treatments.’ For me (and at risk of making myself redundant) the best option seems to be to abandon the recourse to words and just listen to the music, in all its rippling, swaying, gradually evolving glory. YouTube is quite well stocked with performances of this work, so if you’re not keen on my choice it’s easy enough to locate others that might be more to your taste. But my favourite, after a cursory listen to the possibilities, is this one by the ATOS Trio, which you’ll find here: Faure: Piano Trio
Ferroud, Pierre-Octave (1900-36)
Day 522: Trois Pieces pour Flute Seule (Time: 10 minutes) and Fables, for piano (14 minutes)
Today (27/12/24), I want to home in on the impending 125th anniversary of the birth of the French composer Pierre-Octave Ferroud, who was born on 6th January, 1900. I find him a fascinating figure – based on the tiny amount of his music I’ve heard and what little I’ve read about him. And if this is your first introduction to his music, I hope this may interest you too. So, Pierre-Octave Calixte Ferroud, in full (1900-36) was born in eastern France, near Lyon, and what little biographical detail I’ve been able to track down about him suggests that his musical education began in Strasbourg, where he was stationed on military service, before continuing in Paris in the early 1920s. He appears to have been a writer of music reviews and essays as well as being a composer. In terms of (relatively) famous names associated with him, he seems to have been a ‘disciple’ of Florent Schmitt (not to be confused with Franz Schmidt, the subject of Day 521), and indeed Ferroud wrote a biography of Schmitt, though the subject lived on for three decades after the writer’s death. In fact, without wishing to seem too grisly, Ferroud’s death is one of the more famous things about him, since he was, not to mince matters, decapitated in a road accident in 1936 at the age of just 36, an event which had a particularly marked impact on, amongst others, Francis Poulenc (see Days 25, 122, 145, 172, 258, 282, 443 and 477!). But to make Ferroud the subject of today’s email simply because of his gruesome death would be a bit gratuitously tasteless. Fortunately, his music is really interesting, as I hope you’ll agree. Ferroud’s surviving musical compositions began to emerge around 1920, and from the decade and a half of his creative life there remain about 30 works, many for solo piano, alongside others for chamber forces, an opera, a number of ballets and a sadly neglected Symphony in A. Behind Ferroud’s music are some recognisable influences – Debussy, Ravel and Stravinsky are all present in the background of his pieces. There’s also a little evidence of the more subversive characters of the French early 20th century – Satie, Poulenc, Milhaud, Auric and so on – and it’s clear that Ferroud, still relatively young at his death, was absorbing and responding to the fertile atmosphere of inter-war Paris throughout his creative life. I wondered about choosing the Symphony as an illustration of ‘typical’ Ferroud, but have decided instead on two works from the chamber repertoire, one for solo flute, the other for solo piano. In 1932 Ferroud founded the music company Triton to, as he wrote, ‘stimulate the creation and the performance of works of chamber music.’ One of his earliest published compositions, just over a decade before founding Triton, was his collection of Three Pieces for Solo Flute. If you know your flute-flavoured Debussy (not just the ‘Prélude à l'après-midi d'un faune’, but also the solo flute piece ‘Syrinx’) you might feel like you’re in familiar territory here. Ferroud’s ‘Trois Pièces pour Flûte Seule’ begins with a piece called ‘Bergère Captive’ (‘Captive Shepherd’), a slightly melancholic pastoral-feeling piece. The second movement is ‘Jade’, and it’s one of those pieces that pick up on the early 20th century European interest in Orientalism. The typical ‘eastern’ pentatonic scale (try just playing the black notes on a piano) is evident here. Finally there’s another oriental-flavoured piece, with the title ‘Toan-Yan: La Fête du Double Cinq’. ‘Toan-Yan’ (or ‘Double Five’) depicts the Chinese festival that takes place on the fifth day of the fifth month. This piece has a vaguely improvisatory feel, including at one point an imitation of the sound of a Chinese flute. YouTube has some nice performances of this work, and from the options I’ve chosen this version by (the presumably related) Josephine Olech-Ferroud: Ferroud: Trois Pieces pour Flute Seule. Alongside that, here’s an example of one of Ferroud’s many works for solo piano. This is ‘Fables’, a set of six short piano pieces which dates from 1931, so we’re a decade or so on from the solo flute pieces. About this work, I can tell you almost nothing. There was a recording of Ferroud’s complete piano music by the pianist Marie-Catherine Girod in the 1990s, but it’s disappeared from the catalogue now and the interweb has virtually nothing to say. But these are, I think, hugely enjoyable pieces, and it’s a great shame that they’re barely known let alone heard these days. The pieces have no titles, so what they ‘mean’ can be left to your imagination. Girod’s recording is here: Ferroud: Fables, for piano
Fibich, Zdeněk (1850-1900)
Day 559: Untitled (Time: 2 minutes), At Twilight, Op 39 (17 minutes) and Poème for Violin and Orchestra, Op 39a (arr. Kubelik) (4 minutes)
Today (10/10/25), I want to mark another significant anniversary, because in five days from now, on October 15th, it will be 125 years to the day since the death of Zdeněk Fibich. It’s quite possible that there will be some on this list who have never heard of him, or heard any of his music – so we should remedy that situation right now! Fibich – actually Zdeněk Antonín Václav Fibich if you want all his names – is a composer who, one might say, has not travelled well. That is, he’s from the same generation, broadly, as Dvorak, who is pretty much a household name across the classical music world. Fibich was born in 1850 (so there’ll be another major anniversary, this time the 175th of his birth, later this year); Dvorak was born in 1841 so they were not that far apart in age. However, though Dvorak’s infectious folk-inflected music has gained widespread acclaim, Fibich’s less ‘folky’, more Germanic sound (he had a Wagner phase that lasted quite a long time) is more serious, more thoughtful, and consequently less directly appealing. He is very definitely seen as a ‘major’ composer in the Czech Republic, but not so much across the rest of the musical world. One problem is that he’s not, really, a nationalist composer – as Smetana and Dvorak both were – and that’s partly because his upbringing was more cosmopolitan: his mother was a German speaker from Vienna, and in fact his early education was in German, before he had what we’d see as his secondary school years in Prague, and after that he spent some time in musical study in Leipzig. He then went, with his young wife, to Vilnius in what is now Lithuania, taking up a post as a choirmaster, but during his two years there both his wife and their two very young children died, an experience that unsurprisingly affected him profoundly. He returned to Prague at the age of about 24, already with several compositions behind him, but struggled for recognition because of his markedly Wagner-influenced compositional voice. On a personal note, he very quickly remarried – to the sister of his deceased wife – but this turned out to be a spectacularly misjudged move, and Fibich’s rather tangled web of intimate relationships over the following decades was only resolved when in the last five years of his life he left her for a former student and piano pupil, Anežka Schulzová. These last few years were probably Fibich’s happiest, and they yielded a substantial range of compositions, largely inspired by this rather intense and impassioned relationship. Though Fibich died before the age of 50, he was a pretty prolific composer. There are, these days, quite a lot of recordings of his music, so it’s relatively easy to explore. There are three numbered symphonies (try No.2, if you’re interested) and a good number of symphonic poems and suites of what you might call pieces of ‘mood painting’ in music. There are seven opera, and (a Fibich speciality) nine ‘melodramas’, pieces for narrator and orchestra, plus a huge quantity of incidental music for the theatre. He wrote chamber music (two string quartets, two piano trios, and pieces for solo instrument with piano) and piano music – and it’s starting with this last instrument that I’ll give you a taste of his sound world. I thought it would be interesting to trace Fibich’s use, and re-use, of a particular musical idea, across three separate pieces of music. One of the most extraordinary undertakings of his last decade was a set (actually, as published, several sets) of piano music, with the overall title ‘Moods, Impressions and Reminiscences’ (some translations have ‘Souvenirs’ as the final noun). It’s not too melodramatic to claim that this huge collection of 376 short piano pieces is a kind of ‘erotic diary’: it explores his relationship with Schulzová, it anatomises her (almost literally – there are pieces about different parts of her body!) and explores her character and temperament, and it analyses his emotional reaction to these changing moods too. It’s not the sort of thing to listen to end-to-end, but they are lovely character pieces, with real intensity of emotion at times, but more gently reflective at others. It’s often very hard to decipher the structure of the set – there are four publications: Op 41 (the first 171 pieces), Op 44 (Nos.172-204), Op 47 (Nos.205-352) and Op 57 (Nos.353-376). But more challenging still, the separate opus numbers are then subdivided into ‘Books’ – so, Op 41 is in four Books, and sometimes this means pieces are referred to by their number in the overall collection, and at other times, by their number within the specific book within the overall collection. The reason for this long-winded explanation is that I want to start with a short work that is either Op 41 No 139, or Op 41 Book 4 No 14. Anyway, the piece was originally unnamed, though it retrospectively acquired the title ‘Poem’, and it’s played here by the Swedish-American pianist Lars Roos: Fibich: [Untitled] (from 'Moods, Impressions and Reminiscences' Op 41 No 139). It’s a gentle, largely dreamy bit of late Romanticism, with a faint Czech quality. However, it clearly lodged firmly in Fibich’s creative consciousness, because shortly after completing the piano work he used its principal melodic idea in a longer orchestral piece called ‘At Twilight’. This aimed to convey the emotions and setting of late evening walks that he took in Prague with Anežka, accompanied, as you’ll hear, by the songs of nightingales. In this work, Fibich slowly builds towards the melody of the original piano piece before developing it through a series of increasingly lush variations. It’s a strikingly Wagnerian work, but – for me at least – a hugely evocative one. You’ll find it here (audio only, I’m afraid) played by the Czech National Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Marek Štilec: Fibich: At Twilight, Op 39. Fibich died, as I noted, in 1900, but in the following year the Czech violinist Jan Kubelik arranged a version of part of ‘At Twilight’ as a piece for violin and orchestra (though it now exists in dozens of versions, and has become Fibich’s most famous work … even if it’s not actually technically by Fibich!), which he called ‘Poème’, and it acquired the opus number 39a, as a kind of addendum to ‘At Twilight’. It’s played in this recording by the violinist Pavel Sporci, with the Prague Symphony Orchestra conducted by Tomas Bruner. You’ll find it here: Fibich arr. Kubelik: Poeme for Violin and Orchestra, Op 39a
Day 569: Symphony No 2 (Time: 33 minutes)
Today (19/12/25), I’m turning my attention to Zdeněk Fibich once again. I realise it’s only a couple of months since he last featured on this list, but – given that a lot of my decision-making about what to include here is driven by anniversaries of one sort or another – another Fibich anniversary has come along quite soon after the previous one. Back on Day 559, I marked the 125th anniversary of Fibich’s death on 15th October 1900. Well, two days from now, on December 21st, it will be 175 years to the day since Fibich’s birth … from which you can deduce that he died a couple of months short of his 50th birthday. Last time he featured, I traced the use he made of one of the 376 short piano pieces he collected together under the title ‘Moods, Impressions and Reminiscences’, from an untitled single piece in the first published collection of these little gems, through its role in his symphonic poem ‘At Twilight’, until finally it began a posthumous life of its own under the title ‘Poème’, in an arrangement by the Czech musician Jan Kubelik. So, if that posting took a trawl through a number of linked pieces of Fibich’s output, this time I’m going to settle for a closer look at one particular work, Fibich’s Symphony No 2 in Eb, Op 38. Last time I wrote about Fibich, I tried to make two particular points about him as a composer: one, that he sat on some kind of metaphorical boundary between being on the one hand a Czech composer in the ‘nationalist’ sense (like Smetana and Dvorak) and on the other being rooted in the Germanic tradition of Schumann and Brahms; and two, that almost all of his output in the final decade of his life was shaped by the all-consuming nature of the passion he developed for the young woman he fell in love with, Anežka Schulzová, his relationship with whom being the subject of the intimate record contained in his ‘Moods, Impressions and Reminiscences’. Fibich seems to have had a somewhat obsessive disposition, and consequently his music in the last few years of his life keeps coming back to this piano collection, and excerpts from it feed into very many other works, including his final two symphonies. He began work on the earlier of these, the 2nd Symphony, in 1893. Almost all its themes, across all four movements, come from the ‘Moods…’ piano pieces. But alongside this focus, you can hear pretty clearly the influence of Dvorak on this work. At the time, Dvorak had written eight of his nine symphonies, and was feted across Europe for his 7th and 8th in particular, so it’s not surprising that a similar Czech ‘voice’ is present in Fibich’s work too. However, there is also, in Fibich’s symphony, a focus on formal structure (much more so than in Dvorak’s relatively more ‘freewheeling’ approach to form), and this is where evidence for Fibich’s ‘Germanic’ roots (his mother was German, and much of his early general and musical education was in German-speaking lands) can be heard: there’s a lot of Schumann and (I think) a bit of Brahms to be heard in this 2nd symphony too. The first movement starts with a motto theme – predictably drawn from the Schulzová-inspired piano pieces – and this dominates the whole work in various guises. Certainly it’s the key idea of the almost obsessively monothematic opening movement. Instead of the expected contrasts of two or more themes which one normally finds in an opening Allegro, Fibich focuses instead on the manipulation and transformation of this initial idea, leavened only by glimpses of a more song-like clarinet melody. The slow movement, placed second, is the most soulful of the four, and although Fibich keeps a tighter rein on emotion than many late 19th-century symphonists, this is probably the place where his feelings for Schulzová most obviously come to the fore. The primary theme of the movement, you’ll not be surprised to know, comes from the ‘Moods…’ collection, and specifically the piece in which Fibich depicts the day on which he first declared his love to Schulzová. I don’t think it’s too far-fetched to hear the slightly more turbulent woodwind idea that disturbs the initial calm as a kind of musical equivalent of the occasionally less serene aspects of Fibich and Schulzová’s relationship, but by the end of the movement, after an affecting solo violin leads the return of the movement’s first idea, there is no doubt that an underlying contentment wins the day. The third movement Scherzo is, I think, identifiably Czech in character, though it avoids the overt ‘folksiness’ of Dvorak’s scherzos. The ‘motto’ rhythm that unites the whole symphony is much in evidence, though the gentler ‘trio’ section in the middle of the movement has more of the feel of an Austrian ‘landler’ dance. I’ve seen some comments suggesting you can hear hints of Mahler here. The finale seems to divide critics. You’ll find some who lament that it goes on for too long given the relatively limited quality of the material, but others see this as evidence of Fibich’s mastery of orchestration and musical manipulation. I suppose I’d end up saying that Fibich the symphonist (not just here but in the 1st and 3rd symphonies too) does not always work with the most strikingly memorable ideas, but I think he’s a creator of impressive structures in which little is wasted or superfluous … and underneath that rigorous (obsessive?) cohesiveness there is an individual voice. It’s a pity that none of Fibich’s symphonies appears on YouTube in a video recording, so we’re in audio-only territory once again. There are a number of recordings to choose from, and all the ones I’ve listened to seem to me to be perfectly serviceable. I’ve got to know Fibich’s symphonies via CD recordings I own by the Detroit Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Neeme Järvi, so that’s what you’ve got here, accompanied by a mid-19th century Bohemian landscape painting: Fibich: Symphony No 2
Field, John (1782-1837)
Day 237: Nocturne No 2 in C Minor (Time: 3 minutes),
Nocturne No 7 in C (6 minutes),
Nocturne No 10 in E Minor (4 minutes) and
Nocturne No 18 in E (5 minutes)
The word ‘nocturne’ is remarkably flexible, when it comes to pinning down its meaning. In a broad artistic sense, it is ‘a work of art dealing with evening or night’. Given its etymology (from the Latin ‘nocturnus’), this idea of ‘a night scene’ helps explain its use in the titles of paintings (think of Whistler’s work, say). However, in music, variations on ‘nocturne’ turn up regularly in titles of compositions throughout the 18th century, but largely to indicate when the composition would be played, rather than to suggest what the composition is aiming to depict. So, Haydn and Mozart wrote ‘Notturnos’, which, like ‘Serenades’, were designed for evening listening at the musical soirees of the great and the good. But these are not ‘nocturnes’ in the now more widely established sense of the musical term. In this latter sense, nocturnes are pieces primarily for the piano, compositions which tend to be brief, ‘romantic’ (another can of worms), dreamy, pensive. It’s true that in the past couple of centuries there have been ‘nocturnes’ for other performing forces (most famously, probably, Debussy’s ‘Nocturnes’ for orchestra and female chorus), but for most music lovers the word is indelibly associated with a series of short piano works by Chopin. (See Day 8 in the archive below, for example, for Chopin’s Nocturne in C# Minor, Op Posth.) However, Chopin was not the ‘inventor’ of this musical form, even if he is, in most people’s view, the composer who raised the form to the status of great art. To find the origins of the nocturne as a piano composition we have to go back a generation to our subject for today (2/11/21), the Irish composer John Field (1782-1837). Field is a fascinating composer. These days, if he is remembered at all, it is for a handful of rather showy early 19th century piano concertos - and as the originator of the piano nocturne. In his day, he was a rather larger than life figure: his story would make a mildly sensational film or TV miniseries. As a teenager he went to London, studied with Clementi, made a reputation as a very capable concert pianist, and joined Clementi’s business as a performer on Clementi’s pianos, a kind of walking illustration of their capabilities, if you like. At the age of 20 his musical travels with Clementi took him to St Petersburg, where he stayed on after Clementi returned to London, and became a renowned performer in concerts, not to mention a hit with the ladies in aristocratic salons. The liner notes to one of my CDs of his music say, with disarming frankness, ‘he enjoyed the convivial society of friends, drank far too much and was careless with his money.’ Marriage and parenthood did not appear to induce in him any desire to settle down. He seems to have had a particular penchant for French women, with at least one of whom he fathered another child. He enjoyed, if that is the word, spectacular ill health, but medical help did not produce any great change in his behaviour, until eventually he was ‘rescued’ from several months’ stay in a hospital in Naples by a Russian princess (told you this would make a rather technicolour novel) and brought back to Moscow, where he died of pneumonia in his mid-50s. His compositions, like Chopin’s, all feature the piano. Apart from seven piano concertos, there are other ‘Divertissements’ for piano and orchestra, a handful of chamber music compositions with piano, several rather shallow sets of variations for piano on popular themes of the day (melodies with titles like ‘Fal lal la’, ‘Slave, bear the sparkling goblet’ and ‘Since then I’m doomed’!), and his collection of, in the end, 18 nocturnes for solo piano, written, as far as we can tell, between 1812-36. The nocturnes tend to have slowish tempi, rather limpid, dreamy right-hand melodies and a left-hand accompaniment that breaks the harmonising chords up into arpeggios, to give a kind of ‘rippling’ background figure under the ‘singing’ melody line. In fact, several of Field’s Nocturnes were published (by him) under other titles during his lifetime, so we should perhaps not take the ‘rules’ of the form too seriously, as you’ll see from my examples here, but I thought it might be nice to hear four of these pieces, to give a flavour of where the nocturne came from before Chopin got his hands on it. Nocturne No 2 in C Minor is a song-like ‘romance’, played here (audio only) by Elizabeth Joy Roe: Field: Nocturne No 2 in C Minor. The seventh piece in the set is interesting largely because for much of the time the roles of left and right hand are reversed, so that the left hand carries the melody and the right hand the accompaniment. The piece is given the direction ‘träumerisch’ (‘dreamy’), which gives a good sense of what to expect. It’s played here (audio again, I’m afraid) by local Sheffield pianist Benjamin Frith, alongside (for no good reason that I can see) pictures of paintings by Constable: Field: Nocturne No 7 in C. The Nocturne No 10 in E Minor, probably my favourite of the set, has a gentle melancholy, almost a delicacy, in its expressive, singing tone. It’s performed here (video this time) by Eduardo Viñuela: Field: Nocturne No 10 in E Minor. Finally, to demonstrate that what Field called a nocturne didn’t have to be slow and dreamy, here is the last of the set performed (video again) with a no-nonsense briskness by John O’Conor: Field: Nocturne No 18 in E
Finzi, Gerald (1901-56)
Day 206: Eclogue for Piano and Strings (Time: 11 minutes)
Gerald Finzi (1901-56) is one of a collection of English composers of the first half of the 20th century who might be loosely grouped in terms of their essentially ‘pastoral’ musical idiom. (This is a sweeping generalisation, and simplifies the complexity of the true picture, but it’ll do as a label!) In the wake of Vaughan Williams, these figures include Howells, Ireland, Moeran, Bax (to an extent), Bridge (ditto), Delius (a little to one side) ... and Finzi. He was born in London on 14th July, 1901 (so his 120th anniversary was actually two days ago) into a non-observant Jewish family. He seems to have been a shy, introverted figure, and evidently far happier in the quieter surroundings of the English countryside than in the city. He had a brief spell teaching at the Royal Academy of Music in the 1930s (a job wangled for him by Vaughan Williams) but it didn’t suit him, and he and his wife lived out the rest of their lives in Wiltshire (where he composed, and also grew and catalogued obscure varieties of English apple!) and later in Hampshire. Culturally, probably the greatest love of his life was the poetry of Thomas Hardy, and he composed several cycles of songs on this basis. He is known in Anglican circles for the anthems ‘Lo, the Full Final Sacrifice’ and ‘God is Gone Up’, but he also wrote other large-scale choral works (notably ‘In Terra Pax’, which still gets occasional performances at Christmas). In the field of orchestral music, I suspect the only piece you’re likely to have come across is his Clarinet Concerto (which I would have chosen for this posting had it been rather shorter). However, he also wrote an impassioned Cello Concerto (composed in the 1950s after he had been given only a few years to live following his diagnosis with the then incurable Hodgkin’s Disease), and also – earlier in his life – he attempted a piano concerto, a remaining fragment of which is, in fact, the piece I’ve chosen for today (16/7/21). He had begun a piano concerto in 1927, and he made some progress with it over the next two or three years, without ever being fully satisfied with the outcome. He continued to revise it, on and off, throughout the rest of his life, but it was never performed. After his death, his wife and son prepared a performing edition of what had been the slow movement for publication and gave it the title ‘Eclogue’. It is scored for piano and strings, and is a piece of gentle, pastoral tranquillity. (Another of the movements from this abandoned work became his Grand Fantasia – to which he added a Toccata – for piano and full orchestra.) There aren’t many performances of the Eclogue on YouTube, but there’s a pleasing one by the London Mozart Players, conducted from the piano by Howard Shelley. (Try to ignore the rather distracting camerawork at the beginning and end!) You’ll find it here: Finzi: Eclogue for Piano and Strings
Day 491: Lo, the full, final Sacrifice (Time: 15 minutes)
We’ve had just one selection so far from the music of Gerald Finzi (1901-56) – see Day 206 for his Eclogue for Piano and Strings. We’ve had just one selection so far from the music of Gerald Finzi (1901-56) – see Day 206 for his Eclogue for Piano and Strings. I wrote on that occasion about Finzi’s essentially ‘pastoral’ musical idiom, and his intense love for the poetry of Thomas Hardy, whose verse prompted a range of song cycles from Finzi. But another strand of his output was music for the Anglican church, one example of which we have today (21/6/24). On one level, this is curious, because Finzi’s background (born into a non-observant Jewish family) might not initially make him seem like the obvious choice to be commissioned in such repertoire. But composing is, in the end, a job of work, and Finzi’s love for English choral music made him a popular choice for those looking to develop new anthems for the established church. One such figure was Walter Hussey, then Vicar of St Matthew’s in Northampton. He commissioned Britten to write the splendid ‘Rejoice in the Lamb’ in 1943, and continued to request pieces from leading British composers over the following years, and in 1946 it was Finzi’s turn. (Hussey went on lining up composers for such tasks further on in his church career; later as Dean of Chichester Cathedral he commissioned Leonard Bernstein to produce the ‘Chichester Psalms’ – see Day 58.) Finzi’s starting point for this piece was a pair of poems by the 17th century ‘Metaphysical’ poet Richard Crashaw – actually not original poems but translations of Latin verse by Thomas Aquinas, which Finzi combined together in what popular culture would now describe as a ‘mash up’. Back when I were a lad studying English Literature at university (many, many decades ago), Crashaw had a mixed reputation as a poet, being seen as somewhat over-wrought and given to producing poetry of rather gushing emotionality. Finzi himself found some of this verse quite challenging (at the time he complained of ‘the involutions and obscurities’ of Crashaw’s texts), but the composition that resulted, while rather episodic structurally, is impassioned and intense in its celebration of the sacrifice of Christ that lies at the heart of the Eucharist. For an Anglican piece, this sets very Catholic poetry (Crashaw converted to Catholicism, a risky manoeuvre in the mid-17th century, and lived out the rest of his life in exile in Rome). The piece starts with a lengthy, subdued organ introduction, which sets the mood of sober contemplation. The choir’s entry is characteristic of the work as a whole, intoning ‘Lo, the full, final, Sacrifice/ On which all figures fix’d their eyes./ The ransomed Isaac, and his lamb;/ The Manna, and the Paschal Lamb.’ The setting goes on the celebrate the person of Jesus as ‘Our Food, and faithful Shepherd too,’ and there is a lengthy consideration of the significance of the communion ritual for the recipient (‘Live ever, Bread of loves, and be/ My life, my soul, my surer self to me’). After several episodes of rather more vigorous animation, notably a thrilling ‘echoing’ passage at ‘Rise, Royal Sion!’ and then a more emphatically declarative section at ‘Lo! The Bread of Life…’, we reach the tender and beseechingly vulnerable appeal that forms the work’s moment of stillness just before the end. Finzi thins out the choral texture here at ‘Wash my worlds of sin from me’, as Crashaw’s verse begs to see not ‘in a glass darkly’, as it were, but instead ‘for thy veil give me thy Face’. We end as we began, a solemn incantation of ‘Lo, the full, final, Sacrifice’, before the work ends with a lovely rich setting of ‘Amen’, in which Finzi splits the four-part choir even further, into eight separate lines, in a final statement of awe and reverence. It’s a work that’s not easy to digest on a single hearing, so it’s the sort of thing you might want to come back to, but it repays your attention, I think. It’s a piece I know pretty well, the choir that I sing in, Escafeld Chorale, having performed it twice in the past decade. Sadly (or maybe thankfully), I can’t provide you with a recording of Escafeld performing it. Instead, here is a joint performance by English and American choirs, the Choir of New College, Oxford, and the St Thomas Choir of Men and Boys, New York, given at St Thomas’ Church, Fifth Avenue, New York. The choirs are directed by Robert Quinney, and the organist is Nicholas Haigh. You’ll find the performance here: Finzi: Lo, the full, final Sacrifice
Fitkin, Graham (b1963)
Day 372: Hard Fairy (Time: 12 minutes) and Skirting (9 minutes)
Tomorrow will be the 60th birthday of the British composer Graham Fitkin. He first made his mark in the musical world in the mid-1980s, and has kept up a steady supply of compositions, many of them for piano, ever since. He’s Cornish by origin, and in fact has spent pretty much his entire life there, apart from time in Nottingham, The Hague and London as a student in the 1980s. He is usually referred to as a ‘minimalist’ (or sometimes as a ‘post-minimalist’) composer. That is, if we take ‘minimalism’ in its American incarnation as the basic model (see the music of Steve Reich, Days 32 and 227; John Adams, Day 267; Philip Glass, Day 261), we’re looking at music with regular repeated patterns, an essentially constant pulse, where the music develops by slow incremental changes in the process of repetition. Obviously there’s more to it than that, but it’s clear that minimalist tendencies have shaped a considerable amount of music created over the past half-century or so. The music of Anna Meredith (see Day 370) exhibits at least some of these characteristics. Like Meredith, Graham Fitkin composes for orchestra (he has had work commissioned by pretty much all the major British orchestras and has been composer-in-residence with both the RLPO and the London Chamber Orchestra), but also for many diverse types of small ensemble, and a lot of ‘site-specific’ music, created for particular players in particular places. For example, he’s engaged in cross-discipline collaborations with Tate St Ives, and with the Minack Theatre in Cornwall. He writes a great deal for ballet and modern dance companies, unsurprisingly given the consistent rhythmic patterns in his work. His website summarises his work thus: ‘I compose for live performance, for recordings, dance, media and installations. I work with acoustic instruments, electronic instruments and audio recordings.’ Interestingly, one of the performers he has worked with consistently over the years is the pianist Kathryn Stott, who is the guiding spirit and curator of the Sheffield Chamber Music Festival coming up here next month, and on 15th May, Ensemble 360 are playing a major work by Fitkin, ‘Recur’, for Harp and String Quartet, in which the soloist will be Fitkin’s wife, the harpist Ruth Wall. His compositions tend to have short, punchy, monosyllabic titles (a few at random: ‘Loud’, ‘Cud’, ‘Reel’, ‘Pawn’, ‘L’) or titles that seem deliberately ‘dry’ (‘Piano Piece 93’). A lot of his work is, as I’ve mentioned, for piano, his own instrument, and he’s particularly drawn to writing for multiple performers at the piano – in the early 1990s he wrote a number of pieces for six pianos(!) and there’s also a work for four pianos called ‘Totti’, named after Francesco Totti, the great Italian footballer! To give a flavour today (18/4/23) of this really quite prolific composer I thought I’d choose two works. One of his most-performed works is called ‘Hard Fairy’, written for saxophone and two pianos. It was composed in 1994, though (characteristic of Fitkin’s music) it previously existed in a different form as music for a dance film broadcast on BBC2. To quote from the composer again, ‘it is non-programmatic, works by juxtaposition of blocks of material and, I like to think, is propelled by rhythmic momentum until the final coda, when everything sits back and the whole business can be viewed from a different angle.’ It’s played on this rather quirky video by virtuoso saxophonist Sarah Field, accompanied (at both pianos!) by pianist Dawn Hardwick. You’ll find it here: Fitkin: Hard Fairy. For something a little more restrained (at least in terms of compositional forces), I thought you might like to encounter a piece called ‘Skirting’ for solo guitar, which Fitkin wrote in 2001. Again, I reckon the best insight into the work is probably to quote the composer himself: ‘Skirting’ is a work for solo guitar. I’m not a guitarist. And despite it being one of the most popular instruments around, it is very idiosyncratic. There are things it cannot do. Unfortunately, I seemed to be drawn to putting as many of those particular things into this piece as possible.’ He was also particularly taken by the performance of the work I’ve chosen here, by the young Singaporean guitarist, Kevin Loh, remarking, ‘I think he's done a fabulous job on a rhythmically and technically difficult piece, and he carries such poise all the way through from the bare opening to the more testing and contrapuntal music later on.’ You can find the video recording here: Fitkin: Skirting
Foss, Lukas (1922-2009)
Day 316: Night Music for John Lennon (Prelude, Fugue and Chorale) (Time: 14 minutes), Prelude in D (4 minutes) and For Lenny (Variation on 'New York, New York') (3 minutes)
Today (12/8/22), I am celebrating the impending 100th anniversary of the birth of the composer (and pianist, conductor, music educator and all-round musical polymath) Lukas Foss. Not a famous name in the history of recent American music, but an interesting composer nevertheless. Foss (1922-2009) was born on August 15th, which means the 100th anniversary is three days away, as I write this. He was born Lukas Fuchs, in Berlin, to parents who fled the rise of Nazism in 1933, moving to Paris, and from there in 1937 to the USA, joining the rising tide of members of the displaced Jewish intelligentsia in the years before the Second World War. The Fuchs family changed its name to Foss soon after arriving in America, no doubt to help with the process of integration into contemporary society. Foss himself was a child prodigy as a pianist, and entered the Curtis Institute, in Philadelphia, at the age of only 15 – at that point it would appear that he had already been composing music for about a decade! At Curtis, one of his fellow students was Leonard Bernstein, and the two became enduring friends and mutual supporters. Foss’s subsequent career is based largely around two points of focus – teaching and conducting. As a teacher, he became Professor of Music at UCLA in 1953, succeeding no less a figure than Arnold Schoenberg. Later academic posts were at the State University of New York at Buffalo and at Boston University. As a conductor, he had periods as principal conductor of the Buffalo Philharmonic, the Brooklyn Philharmonic and the Milwaukee Symphony Orchestras. I first encountered the music of Lukas Foss as an A-level Music student back in the mid-1970s, when I went to a Halle concert in Manchester at which, amongst other works, was programmed Foss’s ‘Baroque Variations’. At that point in my (relatively sheltered) musical life, I had never heard anything like it, and to see this music performed was startling – well, startling enough for me to remember it after several decades, as one of very few out of the dozens of concerts I must have gone to at Manchester’s Free Trade Hall before I moved to Sheffield to study. What made it an indelible experience was the final movement, with its subversive and anarchic, and yet always clearly controlled, deconstruction of fragments of Bach’s music. You can find the score of the piece if you search for the work on YouTube; the first two movements are relatively conventional, but the final one is something else entirely. However, I thought that rather than startle you with that work, I’d pick out some shorter works by Foss that show the extent to which his writing, for all its modernism, is rooted in sound worlds that are familiar – particularly the Baroque, and the world of jazz. Having heard Bernstein’s ‘Prelude, Fugue and Riffs’ last time out, I thought I’d start today with a work Foss wrote after the murder of John Lennon in 1980. This is his ‘Night Music for John Lennon (Prelude, Fugue and Chorale)’ for Brass Quintet and Orchestra. (There’s also a nice link in that both these pieces clearly have their roots in 18th century musical forms.) The Prelude is a still and contemplative movement, and this in turn is followed by the slightly spikier Fugue, before the work ends with a return to the stillness of its opening in the final Chorale. It’s played on this recording (audio-only, I’m afraid) by five members of the brass section of the Brooklyn Philharmonic Symphony Orchestra, and they and the rest of the orchestra are conducted by Foss himself. You’ll find the performance (alongside an image of John Lennon by the inimitable Andy Warhol) here: Foss: Night Music for John Lennon (Prelude, Fugue and Chorale). I mentioned early on in this posting that Foss was a child prodigy on the piano. In fact, he didn’t write a great deal of solo piano music, and much of what he did write comes from relatively early in his career. I thought I’d offer you all two short pieces showing firstly Foss’s underlying reverence for the music of Bach. His ‘Prelude in D’ was written in 1947, and in its deliberately tonal way, it feels quite subversive, given that this wasn’t the way the prevailing musical winds were blowing. It’s a light and delicate piece, which you’ll find in this recording by the pianist Scott Dann, here: Foss: Prelude in D. Finally, and much nearer the end of Foss’s life, in 1988 he wrote ‘For Lenny’, a tribute to his friend Leonard Bernstein on the latter’s 70th birthday. It exists in two versions, one for piano and orchestra, but the other (which I’ve chosen here) for piano solo. It plays tenderly (one might even say lovingly) with ‘New York, New York’, the opening number in Bernstein’s musical ‘On the Town’. You’ll find it in a performance again by Scott Dann here: Foss: For Lenny (Variation on 'New York, New York')
Françaix, Jean (1912-97)
Day 226: 'L'Horloge de Flore' for Oboe and Orchestra (Time: 16 minutes)
After the specific floral tribute of Puccini’s ‘Chrysanthemums’ last time out, today (24/9/21) we have a whole selection of flowers, gathered into a timepiece. Jean Françaix (1912-97) is a fascinating composer. Born into a family of musicians (his father was a piano teacher and director of the music conservatory in Le Mans, his mother a choral conductor, and together they founded and directed the local ‘Société des Concerts’ in the city), Françaix showed an early ability both as a pianist and composer. His parents’ musical endeavours formed an ideal context for him to try out his skills as a writer of music both for voices and instruments. It may not surprise you to know that he studied with Nadia Boulanger (who didn’t?) from the age of 20, and he was internationally famous by the end of the 1930s. It would be fair to say that his musical language remained relatively unchanged throughout his life, so all the vast changes of fashion during the 20th century tended to pass him by. His music is essentially tonal, though occasionally with ‘spicy’ harmonies, and the essential building blocks of his style are repetition and variation. You don’t have to hear too much of Françaix’s music to realise that his sound world is incredibly French – in today’s work there are echoes of Debussy but also (as elsewhere in his output) of Poulenc. He was an immensely prolific composer, writing over 250 works, in most of the conventional genres, though a great deal is made up of works for solo piano, often suites of short movements, a consequence of his great skill as a concert pianist. He also loved writing concertos – there are more than 20 of them, from the Concertino for Piano and Orchestra of 1932 to the Double Concerto for Flute and Clarinet of 1991. He seems to have been particularly fascinated by the sonorities of wind instruments, and that is evident in today’s work, his composition ‘L’Horloge de Flore’ (‘The Flower Clock’), a suite that is in effect an oboe concerto, which dates from 1959. This isn’t simply a musical representation of the conventional arrangement of flowers into a clock-face pattern, the sort of floral arrangement one gets in many municipal gardens. Rather, this work is based on an idea of Carl Linnaeus, the 18th century Swedish naturalist who is the founding father of the botanical system of classification still in use today. Linnaeus devised a ‘flower clock’ corresponding to the day-through-to-night opening times of a variety of different flowers. In this work, Françaix creates a sequence of six pieces that take us through the day from 3am (the ‘Galant du Jour’) to 5am (the ‘Cupidone Bleue’) to 10am (the ‘Cierge à Grande Fleures’) to midday (the ‘Nycthanthe du Malabar’) to 5pm (the ‘Belle de Nuit’) to 7pm (the ‘Geranium Triste’) and finally to 9pm (the ‘Silène Noctiflore’). (Apologies for the fact that all the flower names are in French!) The music seems more suggestive of the times of day than of the actual flowers themselves, I think. Although the oboe takes the soloist’s role here, there are some lovely moments where flute and clarinet, in particular, have prominent parts in the conversation. All in all it’s a genial and attractive piece by (one of my familiar refrains) an unjustly neglected composer. As for a performance, almost all the recordings on YouTube are audio only, but I realise that most of my readers prefer to watch the music being performed if possible, so I’ve gone for this recording by the famous oboist Albrecht Mayer, alongside the Bamberg Symphony Orchestra conducted by a relatively young Gustavo Dudamel. The sound quality and indeed the camera work are variable at best, but I think the spirit of the work comes through. You’ll find it here: Françaix: ‘L'Horloge de Flore’ for Oboe and Orchestra
Franck, César (1822–1890)
Day 349: Prelude, Fugue et Variation, Op 18 (Time: 10 minutes)
Today (6/12/22), let’s hear it for César Franck (1822-90), who was born 200 years ago on this coming Saturday, 10th December. He is a fascinating composer – a demonstrably ‘Romantic’ one, and a household name in the world of organists. But though he is often namechecked in lists of composers of the latter half of the 19th century, his reputation (apart from organ works) rests on a really small selection of his compositions from the final years of his life. In that respect, he reminds me a lot of Janacek, who also wrote a great deal throughout his life but what we hear now are the pieces of his last 20 years. (In other respects, like his sound world, he is nothing at all like Janacek!) He was born, rather grandiosely, César-Auguste Jean-Guillaume Hubert Franck (I’ll come back to familial visions of grandeur) in what we now know as Belgium, which came into existence only in 1830 – those apocryphal ’10 Famous Belgians’ lists usually include him! – but which at the time was the United Kingdom of the Netherlands, one of those inventions of the post-Napoleonic settlement of 1815. Actually, to muddy the waters still further, Franck is often regarded as ‘French’ in the same way that, say, Offenbach might be. Franck became a French citizen in 1872, so that, according to the rules, he could become a professor at the Paris Conservatoire. Still, to go back to his earlier years, he seems to have had a terrifyingly ambitious father, who appears to have wanted to use his sons (César-Auguste and the similarly double-barrelled Nicolas-Joseph) as the means by which he could engage in some serious social climbing. So the Franck brothers were touted around the salons and concert halls of Belgium and France as child and adolescent prodigies on piano and violin. Not a great deal came of this (blame for which is usually laid at the parental door) but by 15 Franck had enrolled at the Paris Conservatoire, where he seems not to have been an outstanding student. He withdrew from the conservatoire before completing his studies, and the assumption is that this is because his father had made enemies of almost all Parisian music reviewers and concert promoters. (The toxic relationship with his father became worse in the 1840s when Franck moved out of the family home and into the household of his then girlfriend – subsequently wife – disowning his father entirely.) It looked like a quiet life in provincial Belgium beckoned, but by the mid-1840s he was back in Paris, attempting early compositions that largely failed with critics and public. By his mid-20s Franck seems to have abandoned a compositional career in favour of teaching and playing the organ. And it is as an organist in Paris that he then became famous, first at Notre-Dame-de-Lorette for a decade, and then, from 1858 until his death, at the Basilica de Sainte-Clotilde. Not wishing to get too bogged down in detail, what turned Franck into a megastar was his skill on the newly-built Cavaillé-Coll organs, one of which was installed at Sainte-Clotilde. This reputation led to Franck being invited to join the staff of the Paris Conservatoire in 1872 – which was when he discovered that in fact he wasn’t a French citizen after all, because although his father had obtained citizenship for himself in 1837 at the start of all his social climbing, the sons reverted to being Belgian on reaching the age of 21, having been accorded French citizenship as dependents of their father only while they were minors). And it is really only after 1872 that Franck the composer comes to the fore. Before that the only works that still appear at all in performance are the short ‘Panis Angelicus’ (1861; it exists in a choral setting, an arrangement for voice and orchestra, or as a purely orchestral piece) and the work I’ve chosen for today, the Prélude, Fugue et Variation in B minor, Op 18, which occupied Franck from 1859-62. [I’ll continue Franck’s life story on Friday, covering the years of his maturity as a composer.] The Prélude, Fugue et Variation in B minor is not a great piece of music, I think, but I find it to be a haunting and beautiful one, notably for its lovely opening melody. Today it is known effectively as a piece for solo organ, and that’s how one tends to hear it. A version exists for solo piano, and another one for two pianos. However, it’s my understanding that the original version of the work was for piano and harmonium … and this opens up another, possibly rather arcane but at the time very popular musical niche, the world of the French harmonium. The harmonium seems to have been a very significant instrument in French music. One might regard it as ‘the synthesizer of the 19th century’, if you like, and it was all the rage, especially in chamber music, in mid-late 19th century France. Composers like Saint-Saens, Berlioz, Liszt, Reger and Franck wrote copiously for the instrument – who knew? A particularly favoured combination was to pair the harmonium with the piano. The sound of the two instruments together is lovely! Franck wrote for the harmonium throughout his career, from his ’44 Pieces for Harmonium’ (1858) to a whole slew of pieces for harmonium that he was working on at his death. The Prélude, Fugue et Variation in B minor starts with, as I’ve said, a hauntingly lovely melody. The middle section is one of Franck’s typical (perhaps rather stodgy) fugues, before the work closes with a short set of variations linked closely to the original theme. Not surprisingly, video performances of this work in its original guise are few and far between, but I’ve tracked down one from Dutch TV in the late 1990s, introduced by an anonymous chap and then played by Joris Verdin on harmonium and Arthur Schoonderwoord on piano. You’ll find it here: Franck: Prelude, Fugue et Variation, Op 18
Day 350: Symphonic Variations for Piano and Orchestra (Time: 16 minutes)
I left off Day 349’s narrative in 1872, when Franck was appointed to the staff of the Paris Conservatoire, thus giving him employment and financial security for the rest of his life. However, to backtrack slightly, Franck’s other big break came a year earlier in 1871, even if it might not have felt like such a thing at the time. The brief but (for the French) crushing Franco-Prussian war of 1870 led to some desperate times, especially in Paris, but one major musical development was the establishment in 1871 of the ‘Société nationale de musique’, dedicated exclusively to the performance of contemporary French music (motto: ‘Ars Gallica’), particularly orchestral and chamber music. The names behind this organisation included Saint-Saens, Castillon, Fauré, Massenet, Duparc and César Franck. Though the organisation came over the decades to represent a more conservative approach to music, in its first 30 years or so it was responsible for the premieres of many now very popular scores – Dukas’s ‘Sorcerer’s Apprentice’ and Debussy’s ‘Prélude à l'après-midi d'un faune’, to name but two. Franck’s work thus found a reliable route into the public gaze … not that audiences or critics found much of his music pleasing at the time. However, with his involvement in this organisation and his teaching duties at the Conservatoire, Franck entered the mainstream of French musical life. At the Conservatoire (and through private pupils, whom he continued to teach) he developed a band of ‘disciples’, composers of the next generation who were devoted to ‘Père Franck’, as he came to be regarded. Vincent d’Indy (see Day 174), Chausson and Duparc subsequently became established composers, as (in the relatively limited ways allowed at the time) did his only female pupil, Augusta Holmès (surname pronounced in a French way: ignore the ‘H’ and give the name two syllables!) – someone we’ll encounter again in the not too distant future… What’s lovely about this connection between Franck and his pupils is their devotion to each other, but also Franck’s evident humility as a teacher and a composer. There’s endearing evidence that in compositional terms, the relationships were two-way. D’Indy comments that ‘when Franck was hesitating over the choice of this or that … he always liked to consult his pupils, to share with them his doubts and to ask their opinions.’ On the other hand, the way Franck’s musical style developed over the final two decades of his life led to some serious hostility. His wife accused his pupils of leading Franck astray, into music increasingly sensual and indulgent. She was particularly horrified by a late orchestral work, ‘Psyché’, music of potent eroticism. There was a splendid falling-out with Saint-Saens over Franck’s rather turbulent Piano Quintet of 1879; Saint-Saens was the pianist in the first performance, but once it was over he stalked offstage, and refused to come back out to accept the applause. However, these later years produced almost all the pieces by Franck that we now get to hear (more often in recordings than in the concert hall, sadly): a string of orchestral symphonic poems (such as ‘Le Chasseur Maudit’ and ‘Les Djinns’), the stately and imposing ‘Prelude, Chorale and Fugue for Piano’, the huge (and hugely dramatic) String Quartet from his final year, the wonderful Symphony in D Minor (in which one can clearly hear that Franck composes like an organist, creating huge blocks of sound that crash and grind against each other like tectonic plates), his ever-popular Violin Sonata (‘the Frank Sinatra’ as it’s known in the trade), and the work I want to encourage us to listen to today (9/12/22), the Symphonic Variations for Piano and Orchestra. These were premiered by the Société nationale de musique in 1886, and (along with the Violin Sonata) this was – eventually, after a slow-burn of a first performance – one of the great triumphs of Franck’s career. It’s typical of Franck, though, that this ‘almost concerto’ doesn’t do what the conventional 19th century concerto set out to do: to generate fireworks from the opposition of soloist and orchestra, acting as a showpiece for flamboyant display. Instead, Franck transmutes the soloist/orchestra relationship into one of eloquent dialogue and mutual encouragement. The result is a piece that deserves the ‘symphonic’ aspect of its title. The work is, broadly, in three sections – an introduction, setting out the two contrasting themes that constitute the main material; a set of variations on these principal themes; and a sparkling and effervescent finale. This was the work that first made me fall in love with Franck’s music, and I hope you can hear what drew me to it. Video performances on YouTube are a bit hit and miss, I think. There’s a pretty good performance by the Russian pianist Nikolay Khozyainov but it sounds like the microphone was under someone’s overcoat at the time; there’s an aged one with the legendary György Cziffra but it wallows dreadfully. I’m not entirely convinced by my eventual choice either, but from the options I think it’s the performance by Jorge Viladoms and the Sinfonietta de Lausanne (conducted by someone whose name isn’t mentioned on YouTube) that works the best. You’ll find it here: Franck: Symphonic Variations for Piano and Orchestra
Fuchs, Robert (1847-1927)
Day 268: Piano Trio No 1 in C, Op 22 (1st movement) (Time: 11 minutes)
I suspect that for most of you the posting for today (18/2/22) will be an encounter with a new name, so let me introduce to you Robert Fuchs (1847-1927). He was born 175 years ago last Tuesday; he died, aged 80, on 19th February 1927, so we can also mark the 95th anniversary of his death tomorrow. It would be fair to say that Fuchs and his music disappeared from view well before that date in 1927, and his works have only started to gain a foothold in the catalogues of music labels in the past couple of decades. There are a handful of laudatory quotations about Fuchs that seem to do the rounds of all the liner notes of CDs of his music that I own. To take one example, here is Brahms (let’s face it, a notorious curmudgeon when it came to praising the compositional skills of others) who remarked of Fuchs that he was ‘a splendid musician; everything is so fine, so skilful, so charmingly invented that one cannot fail to be pleased.’ An observation in a review of an early performance of Mahler’s Symphony No 2 draws attention to the similarity of its second movement to the music of Fuchs, which does at least suggest that Fuchs’s music was still being listened to in the final decade of the 19th century. Fuchs was born in Frauental, Austria, studied at the Vienna Conservatoire, and was a skilled performer on the flute, violin, organ and piano. However, if there is a ‘missing link’ in Fuchs’s psychological make-up, it is that he seems to have been entirely lacking in the skills of self-promotion, a diffidence which meant that relatively few concerts of his music were given during his lifetime. In fact, his reputation in the second half of his life was made largely as a teacher, when, on the staff of the Vienna Conservatoire, he taught not just Mahler (perhaps that’s where the Fuchs-isms came from!), but also Hugo Wolf, Sibelius, Franz Schmidt, Schreker and Zemlinsky, amongst others. In terms of his music, he became well-known in his mid-twenties for an early composition, his Serenade No 1 for orchestra. In fact, as he followed this up with four other serenades, one of his nicknames in his lifetime was ‘Serenade Fuchs’. However, there are plenty of other works out there which show how well-constructed and musically satisfying Fuchs’s writing could be – three symphonies, three piano sonatas, and (my favourites) an extensive amount of chamber music, including six violin sonatas, two cello sonatas, four string quartets, two piano quartets and, leading to my chosen music for today, two piano trios. What I’ve selected as a snapshot of Fuchs the composer is the first movement of his substantial Piano Trio No 1 in C, Op 22. Perhaps that commendatory quotation from Brahms that I noted above is at least partly a consequence of the fact that, if there is a ‘father figure’ looming over Fuchs’s compositions, it is Brahms himself. This 1st Piano Trio was dedicated to Brahms when it appeared in 1879, and there are certainly echoes of Brahms in the trio’s use of counterpoint, the genial feel for melody, the ‘conversational’ interaction of the instruments and a large-scale grasp of form and structure. There is a ‘heroic’ quality to the main theme of the first movement, but also a sense of the darker, more brooding atmosphere that lies behind it, which emerges in the middle section of the movement. I have a penchant (you may have noticed it on this list!) for slightly obscure composers of Germanic descent that populated the foothills of music, if you like, from, say, 1840 to 1930. Fuchs, I would argue, deserves his moment in the spotlight, and perhaps this first movement of the 1st Piano Trio will show you why. Video performances of Fuchs’s music on YouTube tend to be amateur recordings only, so for today this is just an audio link, I’m afraid, but here is the splendid Gould Piano Trio (Sheffield’s own Ben Frith on piano) playing the work: Fuchs: Piano Trio No 1 in C, Op 22 (1st movement)
Gabrieli, Giovanni (c1554-1612)
Day 464: Sonata Pian e Forte (Sacrae Symphoniae, No 33) (Time: 5 minutes), Canzon II à 4 (Canzoni per Sonare, No 2) (3 minutes), Sonata No 18 à 14 (Canzoni e Sonate, No 18) (7 minutes) and Sonata for Three Violins (Canzoni e Sonate, No 21) (5 minutes)
Gabrieli (c1554-1612) has not featured on this playlist before, which has to be a good reason for featuring him today (15/3/24). There were in fact (at least) two musical Gabrielis based in Venice in the 16th and early 17th centuries. The earlier one was Andrea Gabrieli (1532-86), a composer who in 1566 became organist at St Mark’s, Venice, a role he retained for the rest of his life. But in his later years he became famous also as a teacher, and one of his star pupils was his nephew, Giovanni Gabrieli (from here on referred to just as ‘Gabrieli’ to keep things simple). There are good grounds for saying that Gabrieli would not have become the composer he turned into were it not for his uncle’s example – not just in terms of his musical education, but more importantly in showing the younger man the creative sonic possibilities available in the interior space of St Mark’s. If you’ve been there (or – if not – if you’ve read about it) you’ll be aware that it has a remarkable acoustic, and particularly offers rich potential for antiphonal and ‘echo’ effects. These qualities were exploited by Andrea Gabrieli in some of the very vivid ceremonial music he wrote in the couple of decades before his death, qualities taken to even greater heights by the younger Gabrieli. In fact, for a time, it was believed that these two were father and son, though that seems definitely not to be the case, even if Gabrieli wrote of himself being ‘little less than a son’ to his uncle, and it is thought that his uncle brought him up as well as teaching him about composition. As was common at the time, Gabrieli travelled to Germany to study in his younger days, particularly to Munich where he studied with Lassus, and there’s a lot of Lassus’s influence on Gabrieli’s style. Returning to Venice, Gabrieli became principal organist at St Mark’s in 1585, and on the death of his uncle the following year he became principal composer there too. Later he also became organist at the socially prestigious Scuola Grande di San Rocco, and undoubtedly benefited from the exposure his music got in front of the rich and famous. There’s a fantastic quotation from the English travel writer Thomas Coryat, who wrote, on hearing works by Gabrieli played at San Rocco, ‘The third feast was upon Saint Roches {sic] day being Saturday and the sixth day of August, where I heard the best musicke that ever I did in all my life both in the morning and in the afternoone, so good that I would willingly goe an hundred miles a foote at any time to hear the like... This feast consisted principally of musicke, which was both vocall and instrumentall, so good, so delectable, so rare, so admirable, so superexcellent, that it did even ravish and stupifie all those strangers that never heard the like...’ Gabrieli is an interesting composer because you can hear in his work the beginnings of the transition between Renaissance music (which might simplistically be seen as made up of the woven counterpoint of several instrumental/vocal lines) and early Baroque (in which groups of instruments play together in a more ‘chordal’ fashion, so that often there’s a harmonic basis over which ‘soloists’ have a ‘melody’). [If all of that means nothing to you, feel free to ignore it!] Gabrieli was one of the first composers to pay attention in his scores to written dynamics, making much of the acoustics, at St Mark’s in particular, that allowed for effects of contrasting ‘loud’ and ‘soft’ playing. He often wrote music for two spatially separate groups of players, and sometimes a third group placed centrally between the antiphonal extremes. Gabrieli (unlike his uncle) was keen to publish his music, and it appeared in five volumes, from the 77 pieces in the ‘Concerti’ of 1587 (mostly by Andrea but also six pieces by Giovanni), the ‘Sacrae Symphoniae’ of 1597 (63 pieces, a mixture of vocal, choral and instrumental works, all by Gabrieli), the ‘Canzoni per Sonare’ of 1608 (a mixed bag by several composers, but containing six works by Gabrieli), and two posthumous collections, all of Gabrieli’s work, that appeared in 1615, the ‘Canzoni e Sonate’ (21 instrumental pieces) and the ‘Sacrae Symphoniae II’, 32 sacred motets and anthems. To show something of Giovanni Gabrieli’s music, I’ve chosen several short pieces, all video recordings. (Apart from a few substantial choral works, almost everything he wrote is no more than five minutes long.) First, from the 1597 ‘Sacrae Symphoniae’ collection, here is his ‘Sonata Pian e Forte’ (No 33 in that volume). It’s played here on modern instruments in an arrangement by Fabio Codeluppi, by members of the brass section of the Orchestra del Teatro La Fenice, in Venice. You can see how the arrangement of the players sets up something of the antiphonal effect Gabrieli was after. You’ll find it here: Gabrieli: Sonata Pian e Forte (Sacrae Symphoniae, No 33). Next, here is a work from the 1608 ‘Canzoni per Sonare’ volume. It’s the Canzon No 2 a 4 (the ‘a 4’ means it’s for four instrumental lines). It’s played on this recording by I Cavalieri del Cornetto, a group playing on reproductions of original instruments, which I thought would make an interesting contrast with the previous video. You’ll find the recording here: Gabrieli: Canzon II a 4 (Canzoni per Sonare, No 2). Then, from the posthumous ‘Canzoni e Sonate’ volume from 1615, here are two pieces. First, another (but much more large-scale) brass piece, the Sonate No 18 a 14, played by the ensemble Schola Cornettorum Basiliensis, in which the stage layout mirrors to an extent Gabrieli’s ‘antiphonal’ ideas. You’ll find that here: Gabrieli: Sonata No 18 a 14 (Canzoni e Sonate, No 18). And finally, to show Gabrieli not writing just for brass, here is the 21st sonata from the same volume, this one scored for three violins. It’s played on this recording by members of the Academy of Ancient Music: Gabrieli: Sonata for Three Violins (Canzoni e Sonate, No 21)
Gassmann, Florian Leopold (1729-1774)
Day 447: Symphony in C Minor (1st movement) (Time: 7 minutes), (2nd movement) (8 minutes), (3rd movement) (3 minutes) and (4th movement) (6 minutes)
It’s time today (16/1/24) to mark the 250th anniversary of the death of a once-renowned but now almost totally ignored composer from the early Classical period. And, before anybody else gets there first (and with apologies to both Eugene O’Neill and Flanders and Swann) it’s time today to say ‘The Gassmann Cometh!’ (Sorry…) There’s very little music by Florian Leopold Gassmann (1729-1774) doing the rounds these days, largely because (as for other composers from that age who have now fallen by the wayside) the fame of Haydn and Mozart has left them permanently in the shade. If you trawl through his music that has found a niche in the recording catalogues, much of it is choral or operatic. He was born, and in this he’s another representative of a group who were disproportionately influential in 18th century European music, in Bohemia. Again like others of his era, as a child he was destined to follow the family line and become an ironsmith and general merchant. However, he left home as a thirteen-year-old and went to what is now Karlovy Vary (then Carlsbad), where he seems to have made a decent living playing the harp and singing at various regional fairs. These endeavours financed a subsequent trip to Italy, initially to Bologna and then to Venice – during which time he studied music with a range of teachers and began to try his hand at composing. His opera ‘Merope’ was first performed at the Venice Carnival in 1757 (and he composed an opera annually for Venice over the next six years), which is what put his name on the musical map. During the 1760s and early 1770s he seems to have alternated between Vienna and Venice, and in the former location he gradually came to be seen as a significant figure in his own right, eventually being appointed Hofkapellmeister to the courts of Joseph II and his mother the Empress Maria Theresia. He was also the teacher of Mozart’s great rival Antonio Salieri. He died in 1774, only in his mid-40s, as a result of complications after a serious fall from a moving carriage. It’s a mark of the regard in which he was held that when his wife gave birth to a second daughter three months after Gassmann’s death, Maria Theresia became her godmother. Later, and again in respect for Gassmann’s influence on his career, Salieri taught Gassmann’s two daughters to become fine opera singers, the younger one going on to sing the role of Queen of the Night in Mozart’s ‘The Magic Flute’ in Vienna after Mozart’s death. Gassmann’s surviving oeuvre is pretty substantial: more than 20 operas (though only ‘Cantone in Utica’ keeps a toe-hold on operatic stages these days), a great deal of sacred choral music (notably a still occasionally-performed ‘Requiem’), and a good number of string quartets and other chamber music. There are also – and this takes me to my choice for your listening pleasure today – at least 30 symphonies, along with some others whose attribution is still a matter of speculation. The general assumption is that most of these symphonies were composed in the final 15 years of Gassmann’s life, about half of them in three movements and the others (usually seen as being later compositions) in four movements. These pieces were highly regarded during the 1770s, and Mozart is known to have spoken very highly both of Gassmann and his symphonic works. One might be hard pressed to listen to a piece of Gassmann’s music and know within a few bars who the composer was, but this is music which is not just representative of its age but very musically accomplished. There are a cluster of similar composers from these years who (in my view!) we ought to listen to a lot more these days – maybe this playlist will get round to Dittersdorf, Michael Haydn, Ordonez, Vanhal and Hofmann before too much longer – but for now let Gassmann be an illustrative example of their collective prowess. Each of them wrote particularly satisfying symphonies in minor keys, full of that ‘Sturm und Drang’ of mid/late 18th century fashion, and the work I’ve homed in on for today is one such piece. It’s Gassmann’s Symphony in C Minor, which is an interesting example of his style, quite markedly contrapuntal in places but with what would be the rather more streamlined clarity of the classical period in others. Gassmann’s C Minor symphony is in four movements. The opening Allegro begins with a thoughtful melody, underpinned by a sturdy but fleet-footed bass line. The second movement, marked ‘Poco Andante’, is graceful, with some tender flourishes in the wind parts. The third movement is a brief, perky (if sombre – we’re still in a minor key here) minuet with its dark-toned ‘walking bass’, before the symphony concludes with another lively minor key ‘Allegro Molto’. Recordings of Gassmann’s symphonies are rare, and in fact I think there’s only one of this C Minor symphony, by the Czech Chamber Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by Petr Chromčák. Sadly I can’t offer it to you as a single link, but instead there are links to the four separate movements, which you’ll find here: Gassmann: Symphony in C Minor (1st movement), Gassmann: Symphony in C Minor (2nd movement), Gassmann: Symphony in C Minor (3rd movement) and Gassmann: Symphony in C Minor (4th movement)
Gershwin, George (1898-1937)
Day 68: Three Preludes for Piano (Time: 7 minutes)
Today (29/5/20), I thought I’d go for something sunny and bright, to fit the weather. George Gershwin (1898-1937) is probably best known, still, these days as a Tin Pan Alley and Broadway composer, and it’s true that the majority of his output is rooted in musical theatre, notably the supposedly ‘first Black American opera’, ‘Porgy and Bess’ (not bad going for a white Jewish New Yorker!). However, there is another strand to Gershwin’s oeuvre, a product of his desire to study with Nadia Boulanger (she turned him down, as did Ravel), and compositions such as ‘Rhapsody in Blue’ and notably the Piano Concerto in F are evidence of his yearning to make his mark in the world of ‘serious’ music as well as in popular culture. For today, I’ve chosen a recording of his Three Preludes for Piano, composed in the mid-1920s. His initial aspiration was to match Chopin and Debussy and produce a larger cycle of pieces, but he eventually settled for just the three that we have today. The outer movements are syncopated and vivid, either side of a slower middle prelude which Gershwin himself called ‘a sort of blues lullaby’. There are a number of versions on YouTube for a variety of instruments, but if you want the original piano version, it’s hard to find performances that avoid excessive rubato and tempo changes, or where the video images aren’t way out of sync with the sound. I’ve settled for a recording by the South American pianist Enrique Graf, which you’ll find here: Gershwin – Three Preludes for Piano
Day 199: Piano Concerto in F (Time: 33 minutes)
Gershwin has appeared only once before on this list - see Day 68 for his Three Preludes for Piano. George Gershwin (or Jacob Bruskin Gershowitz, as he was known at birth) was initially a 'popular culture' composer, writing songs as part of the thriving Tin Pan Alley music scene in New York (including under such quirky pseudonyms as Bert Winn and Fred Murtha). His first major hit was ‘Swanee’, as taken up by Al Jolson, which he wrote at the age of 20. Soon he was writing musicals, but the appeal of writing 'serious music' for a 'classical' audience clearly drew him increasingly powerfully as the 1920s unfolded. His first work in this vein was ‘Rhapsody in Blue’, written in 1924 for Paul Whiteman and his concert band, with Gershwin himself as soloist. That work was orchestrated by the established arranger Ferde Grofé, but Gershwin gradually became more confident in his powers as both composer and orchestrator, as can be heard in pieces as diverse and colourful as his tone poem ‘An American in Paris’ and the music I’ve chosen for today (22/6/21), his Piano Concerto in F. Evidence of Gershwin’s yearning for acceptance as part of the mainstream classical music establishment can be seen in his desire to take lessons in Paris from Nadia Boulanger, and from Ravel – who apparently, on discovering how much Gershwin earned from his song-writing, turned him down, saying words to the effect of ‘you should give me lessons’. (It should be said that Gershwin’s biographical tale comes with a range of apocryphal additions: different versions of that exchange exist in which Gershwin was seeking lessons from Igor Stravinsky and, rather startlingly, Arnold Schoenberg!) But the link to Ravel is interesting, in that Gershwin was strongly attracted to French musical styles of the early 20th century, and in the Piano Concerto it’s not hard to hear, alongside jazz and blues, the music of Debussy and Ravel. The Piano Concerto in F was written in 1925, in the traditional three-movement form. The comments of Gershwin himself give a nice flavour of his intentions: ‘The first movement employs the Charleston rhythm. It is quick and pulsating, representing the young enthusiastic spirit of American life. It begins with a rhythmic motif given out by the kettle drums…. The principal theme is announced by the bassoon. Later, a second theme is introduced by the piano. The second movement has a poetic, nocturnal atmosphere which has come to be referred to as the American blues, but in a purer form than that in which they are usually treated. The final movement reverts to the style of the first. It is an orgy of rhythms, starting violently and keeping to the same pace throughout.’ I’m particularly fond of the smoky, bluesy slow movement, with its yearning solo trumpet melody. As for a performance, there’s a lively one on YouTube by Yuja Wang, with what I think is the LSO (I can’t see a credit anywhere on the video) conducted by Michael Tilson Thomas. You’ll find it here: Gershwin: Piano Concerto in F
Day 200: Walking the Dog (Time: 3 minutes)
Malcolm’s choice of music for today (25/6/21) has, as you will see, a personal connection. But first, some composer biography. Gershwin died of a brain tumour in 1937 at the young age of 38. Clearly all premature deaths are terribly sad, and the roll-call of composers dying young was already long enough at that point, but there is something tantalisingly poignant about Gershwin’s death, depriving us, as it does, of knowing how his musical talents might have evolved as the 20th century unfolded. Much of the year before his death was spent working on the score for the film ‘Shall We Dance’, a Ginger Rogers/Fred Astaire vehicle that allowed Gershwin to write not just an extensive film score, but an essentially ‘symphonic’ piece that aimed ambitiously to introduce the worlds of jazz and ballet to each other. Each scene of the film is accompanied by music written in a different style of dance music: there’s a ‘galop’ for a French ballet class, a rumba in which Gershwin explores Cuban musical traits, the waltz ‘Graceful and Elegant’ to accompany a classic ballet pas de deux, and the film’s big production sequence, the 10 minute ‘Hoctor's ballet’, amongst other compositions. The film’s plot has no great substance to it, but Gershwin’s score is richly imaginative. One of its more droll numbers is Promenade (‘Walking the Dog’), in which Astaire’s character borrows an enormous hound to attempt to get closer to Rogers’ character as she walks her lapdog on the deck of an ocean liner. In his email to me, Malcolm says, ‘I have walked our dog Toby around the Bole Hills and the streets of Crookes twice a day for three years; this seems like an appropriate, and light hearted, way to say goodbye’ on his retirement from St Tim’s, Sheffield. And in fact, you get a ‘two for the price of one’ offer today. The original scene from ‘Shall We Dance’ is here (since removed by the video owner). If you want a video performance of the music in full orchestral setting, YouTube offers a slightly sedate rendition by the Halle Orchestra, conducted by Stephen Bell. You’ll find it here: Gershwin: Walking the Dog
Day 415: Rhapsody in Blue (Time: 18 minutes)
Today (26/9/23) marks the 125th anniversary, this very day, of the birth of George Gershwin, to commemorate which I’m absolutely not going to sidestep the obvious, as you’ll see… Gershwin has featured on this list three times (Day 68: Three Preludes for Piano; Day 199: Piano Concerto; Day 200: ‘Walking the Dog’, from the film ‘Shall We Dance’). In the course of those postings I’ve covered much of Gershwin’s biographical story, so today I want to home in just on what is certainly Gershwin’s most popular work, at least in the concert hall. Gershwin left school at the age of 15 and spent some of the rest of his teenage years as a ‘song plugger’ in Tin Pan Alley, playing/popularising songs published by Remick and Co., with whom he had a $15 a week contract. But playing other people’s music wasn’t his goal, and before he was 20 he had written his first major hit, the song ‘Swanee’, as famously sung by Al Jolson. But the lure of the concert hall, and the desire to be seen as a ‘serious’ composer, clearly nagged away at him, and the first piece to satisfy at least some of that desire was the work I want to feature, ‘Rhapsody in Blue’. Around its premiere a variety of myths has grown up, but there are at least some undisputed facts. It was first performed in February 1924, by Paul Whiteman’s jazz band, with Gershwin himself on piano. The concert itself was proudly marketed as ‘An Experiment in Modern Music’ (which might make you think it was going to feature pieces by Schoenberg or Edgard Varese!). Rather scarily the concert was advertised and promoted a month before it took place on the basis that Gershwin was allegedly already ‘at work on a jazz concerto’ – which was news to Gershwin, at least. Many composers embroider their recollections of the gestation of some of their works, so it may be that some scepticism is needed, but Gershwin wrote of taking a train journey from New York to Boston: ‘It was on the train, with its steely rhythms, its rattle-ty bang, that is so often so stimulating to a composer.... I frequently hear music in the very heart of the noise. And there I suddenly heard—and even saw on paper—the complete construction of the rhapsody, from beginning to end. No new themes came to me, but I worked on the thematic material already in my mind and tried to conceive the composition as a whole. I heard it as a sort of musical kaleidoscope of America, of our vast melting pot, of our unduplicated national pep, of our metropolitan madness. By the time I reached Boston I had a definite plot of the piece, as distinguished from its actual substance.’ Well, maybe. At any event he produced a score, passed it to Whiteman’s usual orchestrator, Ferde Grofé (famous, if at all, these days for his ‘Grand Canyon Suite’), and the work was performed as the penultimate piece on the programme – followed, bizarrely, by Elgar’s Pomp and Circumstance March No 1! The piano’s role was at least partly improvised, but jazz bands are used to that sort of thing. To say that the piece was a massive success is probably an understatement. It had performances in the UK and across Europe (one British performance being broadcast live on the fledgling BBC), and within three years Gershwin and Whiteman’s recording had sold more than a million copies. Professional music critics, it’s worth saying, were condescending at best (‘the lifelessness of its melody, so derivative, so stale, so inexpressive’) and even the usually irrepressibly enthusiastic Leonard Bernstein wrote, ‘”Rhapsody in Blue” is not a real composition in the sense that whatever happens in it must seem inevitable, or even pretty inevitable. You can cut out parts of it without affecting the whole in any way except to make it shorter. You can remove any of these stuck-together sections and the piece still goes on as bravely as before. You can even interchange these sections with one another and no harm done.’ Which is no doubt true – but nevertheless its striking clarinet opening, its rhythmic vitality and some ‘earworm’ tunes mean that it has never lacked performers or enthusiastic listeners. Apropos Bernstein’s comment, there’s not a lot worth saying about the way the piece ‘works’ – it’s just one thing, and then another thing, and then another, and then, oh, here’s the first thing again… But it’s terrific fun, and it reveals the ‘spirit of the age’ (the 1920s jazz age) with great panache. Later, of course, Gershwin went on to more complex things in the world of ‘concert music’, notably the fizzing Piano Concerto and the tone poem ‘An American in Paris’, but this is where that journey started. ‘Rhapsody in Blue’ exists in a variety of versions (Grofé made at least three orchestrations) and has been variously hacked about and manipulated by dozens of pianists in the past century (the ‘disco’ version made by the pianist Richard Clayderman in the late 1970s is probably the most hideous). However, something close to the ‘original jazz band’ version (an approximation given, as I said earlier, that Gershwin improvised chunks of the piano part) is, for me, the best way to hear this music. As for a recording, I’ve chosen one by the self-effacingly named All-Star Orchestra (an American ensemble of musicians from a variety of leading American orchestras) conducted by Gerard Schwarz. The soloist – and I feel a little awkward about this, for the lady in question has accumulated a staggering number of online followers at least partly on the basis of wearing skimpily short skirts and revealing an expanse of thigh and cleavage – is Lola Astanova. But let’s not seem too superior. It’s a very impressive performance, I think. You’ll find it here: Gershwin: Rhapsody in Blue
Day 448: An American in Paris (arr. for reed quintet by R Hekkema) (Time: 18 minutes)
Later this month, the exceptional musicians that make up the Calefax Reed Quintet will be in Sheffield for a concert in the Upper Chapel. Calefax are a Dutch ensemble, who have been around with various changes of personnel for getting on for 40 years, and whose performances are vivid, lively affairs. Unlike the conventional wind quintet (usually flute, oboe, clarinet, bassoon and horn), Calefax feature an oboe, a clarinet, a bass clarinet, a bassoon and a saxophone. Historically there’s no music at all for this combination of instruments, and although they have commissioned and performed original pieces in their time, most of their performances (and almost everything they’re playing in Sheffield) will consist of arrangements for these forces of music originally for keyboard, or string quartet or orchestra… including music by the composer I’m featuring today (19/1/24), George Gershwin. We’ve had four works by Gershwin on this list to date (see Days 68, 199, 200 and 415) so my comments on those occasions cover the central biographical details of Gershwin’s life. I’ll restrict myself today, therefore, to a discussion of the work in Calefax’s concert, Gershwin’s ‘An American in Paris’. This piece was written in 1928, so in terms of the output of Gershwin the ‘classical’ composer, it postdates ‘Rhapsody in Blue’, the Piano Concerto in F and the Three Preludes for Piano, but we’re still some distance away from his opera ‘Porgy and Bess’. Gershwin spent some time in Paris initially in 1926, the trip being planned so that he could study with Ravel, whose music he revered. Ravel turned him down (‘Why be a second-rate Ravel when you can be a first-rate Gershwin?’), though at Gershwin’s request Ravel did make the trip to America in 1928. One consequence of their meeting at that time was that Gershwin returned to Paris (partly because this time he thought he might be able to study with Nadia Boulanger – though she too turned him down, saying ‘What could I give you that you haven’t already got?’), and determined to write a piece of music that might express something of his response to that city, with which he had obviously fallen in love. This was the period, we shouldn’t forget, when there was a significant American expatriate community in Paris, the likes of literary figures such as Pound, Hemingway and Scott Fitzgerald, and composers as diverse as Antheil, Copland and Thomson. The piece that emerged, ‘An American in Paris’, is broadly structured in an A-B-A design, where the central section is a more ‘bluesy’ and introspective composition (including the inevitable but nevertheless lovely trumpet solo) than the outer, more lively and extrovert music. Gershwin wrote at some length about the ideas that the piece was supposed to express, which in simple overview amounted to this: ‘My purpose here is to portray the impressions of an American visitor in Paris as he strolls about the city, listens to the various street noises, and absorbs the French atmosphere’. Amongst those ‘street noises’, there’s a notable part (in the original score) for four Parisian taxi horns, which Gershwin took back to America and used in the first performance. As was often the case when Gershwin composed music intended for a ‘classical’ rather than a more ‘popular’ context, there were some disparaging comments after early performances. Gershwin’s response feels a little defensive, but understandable: ‘It's not a Beethoven Symphony, you know... It's a humorous piece, nothing solemn about it. It's not intended to draw tears. If it pleases symphony audiences as a light, jolly piece, a series of impressions musically expressed, it succeeds.’ This seems to me to be underselling its imagination and originality. Years after its original composition, and long after Gershwin’s early death, the MGM film ‘An American in Paris’, starring Gene Kelly and Leslie Carron, won the ‘Best Picture’ Oscar in 1951; the film ends with an extended dance sequence based on a version of Gershwin’s score. As I’ve said, the work was originally written for a large symphony orchestra (not just with added car horns, but also an extensive percussion section, including a ‘whip’, xylophone and tubular bells, and also three saxophones and celesta), but over the years arrangements have been made for various combinations of instruments. If you want to compare/contrast, there’s an idiomatic reading of the score by the New York Phil under Leonard Bernstein which you can find here. The version that Calefax Reeds are playing next week is by their saxophonist Raaf Hekkema, and YouTube has a nice recording by the Akropolis Reed Quintet of that very arrangement. You’ll find it here: Gershwin: An American in Paris (arr. for reed quintet by R Hekkema)
Ginastera, Alberto (1916-83)
Day 294: Estancia (Suite) (Time: 13 minutes) and Malambo (from 'Estancia') (4 minutes)
After the previous posting about the Brazilian composer Villa-Lobos, today (20/5/22) we head south and a little bit west for music from Argentina, and another new composer on this playlist. This is Alberto Ginastera (1916-83). First a confession: I have been mispronouncing his surname as though it were a Spanish word (Argentines being Spanish speakers) for several decades, but I’ve discovered in reading about him that, as someone of mixed Catalan and Italian origin, his preferred pronunciation of his last name uses the same sound as at the start of the word ‘gin’ (as in the drink). Fascinating… Anyway, Ginastera is, for most people, the pre-eminent Argentinian composer, at least until the rise to fame and popularity of Astor Piazzolla (see Days 99 and 169). Ginastera was born in Buenos Aires, and after studying music at the conservatory there he taught for some time before devoting himself to composition. He lived until his fifties in Argentina, though with frequent visits to study and work in the USA; in 1970, he moved to Switzerland, where he lived until his death at the age of 67. His music divides, by his own explanation, into three distinct periods, discounting his very early works from the beginning of the 1930s, which he largely destroyed. So, from 1934-48 he wrote music in a style that he described as ‘Objective Nationalism’, in which there is explicit and often very colourful use of Argentine folk music, alongside the influences of composers he admired, such as Bartók, Falla and Stravinsky. Then, from 1948-58 we reach the ‘Subjective Nationalism’ phase, in which these folk elements tend to be less overt, so that the music is more abstract and less clearly rooted in a sense of place. Finally, from 1958-83 his compositions exhibit, in his terms, ‘Neo-Expressionism’. In this last phase, his work is more avant-garde, occasionally employing serial techniques, even if not necessarily in the sort of strict form that might have been employed by Schoenberg, say, or Webern. Those wanting a less astringent musical experience on this list will probably be pleased to know that I’ve chosen a work from his early ‘Objective Nationalism’ phase – the suite from the ballet ‘Estancia’. Ginastera’s music, in this phase of his output in particular, is characterised by extreme rhythmic energy contrasted with passages of an almost mystical calm, the whole thing very colourfully orchestrated. ‘Estancia’ (a large ranch in Argentina, as you may already know) was commissioned by an American ballet company in 1941, but unfortunately the company went bust the following year, and so the ballet’s first performance did not take place until 1952. However, in 1943 Ginastera put together a four-movement suite from the ballet, and its first performance was an immense success, consolidating his reputation both in Argentina and abroad. The original ballet request was for a work based on Argentine country life, and the story has a kind of folksy charm of the sort you might have encountered in Copland’s ballets from the 1940s. Here a young man from the city has to prove himself capable of the hard work of a ranch hand in order to win the love of a country girl. The movement titles give a clear sense of what to expect. The first is ‘Los trabadores agricolas’ (‘The land workers’); then comes ‘Danza del trigo’ (‘Dance of the wheat’ – this is Ginastera depicting an air of peace amid the beauty of nature); third is ‘Los peones de hacienda’ (‘the cattle men’); finally we encounter the ‘Danza final: Malambo’. The ‘malambo’ is a dance of overt masculinity – one might almost say machismo – performed only by the men, who dance energetically on the spot until the ‘winner’ is the last man standing. As for a performance, there may well be some of you who vividly remember the appearance of the Simon Bolivar Youth Orchestra of Venezuela under an endearingly fresh-faced Gustavo Dudamel at the BBC Proms in 2007. (This is from the days when the Venezuelan music system, El Sistema, was one of the wonders of the world, and before Venezuela became an economic basket case.) You’ll find their performance of the Suite from ‘Estancia’ here: Ginastera: Estancia (Suite). If you do remember that Prom, you may recall that there were a string of encores given to increasingly frenzied applause, culminating in a repeat performance (with some orchestral boogieing for good measure) of the final movement of Ginastera’s suite. You’ll find that encore here: Ginastera: Malambo (from 'Estancia')
Glass, Philip (b1937)
Day 261: String Quartet No 2 ('Company') (Time: 9 minutes)
Today (25/1/22), I want to look forward to the 85th birthday of Philip Glass (b1937), which will arrive next Monday, January 31st. This is the first time his music has featured on this list, though we have had ‘minimalists’ before now, notably his sometime friend, sometime rival Steve Reich (see Days 32 and 227). Reich and Glass are often mentioned in the same breath when discussing modern American music, usually also with a third figure, John Adams – not to be confused with John Luther Adams, an entirely different composer – and those waiting for John Adams to appear on this list won't have to wait very long. What all three shared, at the start of their careers, was a label, inherited largely from the artistic and sculptural scene in New York and elsewhere in the USA, ‘minimalism’. Glass appears to prefer to be identified as a composer of ‘music with repetitive structures’, as he wrote in 2008. In many ways, rather like the career of Steve Reich, we can see Glass’s evolution from a kind of ‘pure’ minimalism in his works from the 1960s and 70s, into something more multi-layered as his career as an opera composer and a symphonist have evolved. Initially a flautist and then keyboard player, Glass studied at the Juillard School in New York before, in the mid-60s, winning a Fulbright Scholarship to permit him a two-year stay in Paris and (join the throng!) study with Nadia Boulanger. This period, notably because it involved some intensive investigation of the music of Bach and Mozart, is the point at which Glass turned away from ‘modernism’ in music, the sound world of Stockhausen and Boulez, and towards something more condensed and ‘pure’. Another notable influence at this time was Indian classical music: he worked with Ravi Shankar on a couple of film scores, discovering in the process the complex ‘additive’ nature of rhythmic patterns in Indian music. Back in New York, Glass met up with, and for a couple of years worked alongside, Steve Reich, until they went their separate ways (with variable degrees of acrimony, depending on what sources you read). Over the next decade Glass wrote a great deal of music for film and theatre, as well as more ‘abstract’ pieces for the concert hall, before branching out from the mid-70s into opera. He has now written over a dozen operas (notably ‘Einstein on the Beach’, ‘Satyagraha’ and ‘Akhnaten’), along with another dozen or so ‘chamber operas’, not to mention works for the concert hall: at the latest count 14 symphonies, 12 concertos, eight string quartets. A prolific composer, then. Not wishing to ignore the odd dissenting voice, there are many (I cautiously add my name here) who regard his music as rather variable in terms of quality, featuring a ‘samey’ banality of musical ingredients. (Consider Michael White’s review of Glass’s Violin Concerto No 2 in ‘The Daily Telegraph’: ‘as rewarding as chewing gum that’s lost its flavour … strung-out sequences of arpeggiated banality … and vacuously formulaic.’) I wondered about what music to choose to highlight Glass’s impending birthday. I’m very fond of his 1st and 4th Symphonies – but I think that’s largely because they’re based on two David Bowie albums, ‘Low’ and ‘Heroes’, that I love. In the end, though, I’ve gone for a piece of chamber music that started life as incidental music for the theatre. Samuel Beckett’s novella ‘Company’ was published in 1979, and it was adapted for the stage for a performance in New York in 1983. Glass wrote ‘Company’, four short pieces for string quartet, to be played in intervals between the stage action. The subsequent life of this music as his String Quartet No 2 has given it a future independent of Beckett’s narrative. The piece lasts about nine minutes, and exists now in both string quartet and larger string orchestra format. You’ll find both on YouTube, but I’ve selected a performance for quartet, in which you can hear much more clearly the patterned interaction of musical lines of the four instruments. It’s played in this video recording by the young Latvian ensemble the ReDo String Quartet, which you’ll find here: Glass: String Quartet No 2 ('Company')
Glazunov, Alexander (1865-1936)
Day 223: Autumn (from 'The Seasons') (Time: 12 minutes)
Today (14/9/21), I thought it might be nice to consider some music associated with autumn, given that we are (meteorologically speaking) already a fortnight into the new season. Also, for no reason other than that it’s fun, I thought it might be a good thing to listen to some Russian ballet music once in a while, given that it has rarely appeared on this list. In fact, looking back, the only Russian ballet music we’ve had has been by Stravinsky (the closing numbers of ‘The Firebird’, ‘The Rite of Spring’ and the Circus Polka). Anyway, with today’s choice, we go back in time a little from Stravinsky (of whose music our composer had a distinctly low opinion), to the career of Alexander Glazunov. Glazunov (1865-1936) was an interesting composer – one of many who found the arrival of 20th century modernism in music not to his taste, and who consequently came to be seen as something of a musical anachronism long before his death in the mid-1930s. At the other end of his career, however, Glazunov was something of a prodigy, the ‘next big thing’ in Russian music as the 19th century drew to a close. You may remember from some previous postings that I’ve alluded to something of a cultural/musical divide in Russian music in the second half of the 19th century, the stand-off between the ‘western facing’ Tchaikovsky, Arensky and Taneyev, and the ultra-nationalist school of Balakirev, Borodin, Mussorgsky, Rimsky-Korsakov, Cui and Liadov. Well, Glazunov started off very much in the latter camp, when as a teenage prodigy he was taken under the wing of Rimsky, who taught Glazunov in the 1880s, having been impressed with the 15-year-old’s Symphony No 1. However, as the 1880s led into the 1890s, Glazunov’s music started to develop an increasingly ‘cosmopolitan’ sheen, blending the opposing nationalist and western-facing approaches. The years 1890-1905 were probably the period that saw the height of Glazunov’s creativity – from this time you’ll find his 4th-8th Symphonies, his two orchestral Concert Waltzes, his Violin Concerto, his 4th and 5th String Quartets, his two Piano Sonatas, and the work for today, his ballet in one act, ‘The Seasons’. If there is a sense of unfulfilled promise to Glazunov’s work after the age of about 40, there are several reasons: he became director of the St Petersburg Conservatory in 1905, staying there through the Russian Revolution in 1917 and only resigning officially in 1930, and there is no doubt that he found the responsibilities of the job exhausting; on a personal level, there’s the issue of his seemingly worsening alcoholism, which evidently dulled his creativity; and, as noted, he felt increasingly out of step, musically, with the age, and though he valued Shostakovich as his pupil, he had no sympathy with the music of Shostakovich, Prokofiev or any other European composers who dragged composition into the 20th century – he had little good to say about Stravinsky, Debussy, or Schoenberg and his followers, for instance. However, back in 1900, when ‘The Seasons’ was premiered, none of that seemed an issue. What we have here is a work unashamedly in the vein of Tchaikovsky’s ballets: melodic, colourfully orchestrated, full of meltingly swooning adagios and vivid character dances. The ballet has no plot, as such; rather it’s a series of ‘mood pictures’, representations of the characteristics of each of the four seasons. ‘Autumn’ is the final movement, and it begins with a vivid bacchanal. Subsequently there are moments that revisit music from the previous three movements and then what the CD notes to my copy of this work rather bizarrely refer to as ‘a shower of dead leaves’, before the inevitable final apotheosis. It’s not music which is going to make any great demands on a listener, but of its kind it’s a distinctly superior example! YouTube does not appear to have a video recording of a professional performance of just the ‘Autumn’ movement, so today we’re in audio only territory. I’ve chosen the performance by the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by Vladimir Ashkenazy, which you’ll find here, accompanied by a slide show of seasonal images: Glazunov: 'Autumn' (from 'The Seasons')
Glière, Reinhold (1875-1956)
Day 524: Russian Sailor's Dance (from 'The Red Poppy') (Time: 4 minutes) and Horn Concerto (27 minutes)
For my posting today (10/1/25), I’m in anniversary mode, marking the 150th birthday tomorrow of the Russian/Soviet composer Reinhold Glière. It used to be the case that at least some of Glière’s music found its way onto the radio (and even, occasionally, into concert halls) but for the most part, he’s become a forgotten composer these days – so maybe this anniversary posting, Glière’s first appearance on this list, will kindle a little curiosity about a figure who made notable contributions to music in Russia both before and after the 1917 revolution. We should perhaps start with his not remotely Russian-sounding name. This actually isn’t a surprise when one realises that his father was German and his mother Polish. They emigrated to what was then Russia, where Reinhold was born in Kyiv (to give it its modern Ukrainian spelling) in 1875. At his birth he was Reinhold Ernest Glier. The name change was the composer’s own: it appears that sometime around the turn of the century Glier started styling himself Glière, tapping into the fashion in Russia for all things French (or at least vaguely Frenchified). In the years before the 1917 Revolution, he studied in Kyiv and then at the Moscow Conservatory, where he was taught by, amongst others, Taneyev (one day, folks, one day…) and Arensky (see Day 165). After graduating, he taught for a while, amongst other things giving lessons to the 11-year-old Prokofiev. Early compositions had a mixed reception. Stylistically, early Glière is music in the Russian nationalist tradition – a successor to people like Rimsky-Korsakov and Glazunov – and there was a market for this kind of thing, but his early Symphony No 1 flopped at its first performance, and it seems to have hit Glière’s confidence. However, from 1905-8 he was in Berlin studying conducting and orchestration, and by the time he returned to Russia with his epic Symphony No 3 (‘Ilya Muromets’), which lasts all of 80 minutes or so, his music was received with great acclaim. If you know much about Russian/Soviet composers in the first half of the 20th century you’ll know that they did not have an easy time after the 1917 Revolution, but Glière seems to have led something of a charmed life, at least compared to the likes of Shostakovich, Prokofiev and Khachaturian. In part this was because his musical idiom was essentially conservative, and therefore he wrote little that might have raised the wrath of Soviet censors on the grounds of writing ‘formalist’ or ‘bourgeois’ music. He was appointed Professor of Composition at the Moscow Conservatory in 1920, and other positions of responsibility followed: Director of Music at the Moscow Dept. of People’s Education, and later Chair of both the Moscow Union of Composers and the Soviet Union of Composers. He was awarded a number of state honours, such as the membership of the Order of the Red Banner and People’s Artist of the USSR. All of this might suggest he was something of a party ‘yes man’ (his name was conspicuously absent from the wholesale denunciations of musicians in 1936 and 1948), but he seems not to have raised the hackles of those (clearly musically more able) figures such as Shostakovich and Prokofiev. In fact, Shostakovich called him ‘not a bad fellow’, reserving his criticism for the fact that the finale of Glière’s ballet ‘The Red Poppy’ was adopted by Leningrad (Shostakovich’s home city) as its anthem. As Shostakovich said, hearing the ‘Hymn to the Great City’ blaring forth when people arrived at Leningrad central station made ‘the travellers duck their heads and walk faster’! Glière died, still seemingly unruffled by further upheavals subsequent to Stalin’s death, in 1956, and was buried with full state honours. I wondered what to choose to mark Glière’s anniversary, and in the end I’ve decided to go for his most famous single short piece, and a really rather lovely (if utterly conventional) concerto. If anything by Glière turns up in concert, it’s usually the ‘Russian Sailor’s Dance’ from ‘The Red Poppy’, which touring Russian orchestras (before the current conflict in Ukraine) often played as an encore piece. It’s maybe best seen as a work in the line of Glinka’s musical fantasy ‘Kamarinskaya’ (again, one day…), which set the template for how Russian composers treated variations on folk song melodies. Glière’s piece uses the traditional melody ‘Yablotchko’ (‘Little Apple’) and subjects it to a series of twelve variations, getting ever more elaborate along the way. It’s performed with some enthusiasm here by the Symphony Orchestra of the Conservatory for Music and Ballet, Ljubljana, conducted by Slaven Kulenović: Gliere: Russian Sailor's Dance (from 'The Red Poppy'). The concerto in question (Glière wrote one each for horn, harp, cello, violin and, unusually, coloratura soprano) is his final completed orchestral piece, the Horn Concerto in Bb, Op 91. Glière had met the Soviet horn virtuoso Valery Polekh, principal horn at the Bolshoi Theatre, in 1950 while rehearsing for another of his ballets, ‘The Bronze Horseman’; Polekh asked Glière to write a concerto for him, and Glière duly obliged. Virtually no horn concertos by Russian composers existed before Glière’s work, so it is really the first major work for horn and orchestra in Russian/Soviet history. Musically, like everything by Glière, it’s stylistically cautious, and could almost certainly have been written 60 years or more before it emerged, but it’s a vivid, full-blooded concerto with challenging technical demands on the soloist’s skill, particularly because it’s longer than other horn concertos in the repertoire. The pool of horn concertos isn’t all that deep, but Glière’s is one of the best. In structure, it employs the familiar three-movement fast-slow-fast pattern. The lyrical slow movement is wistful and delicate, and the finale shows the research Glière had done in his earlier days into Russian folk music in the 1920s and 30s. The work isn’t remotely ground-breaking, but I think it’s one of Glière’s finest non-theatrical works, and a fitting tribute to an overlooked composer. You’ll find a video recording of the concerto here, played by the Mariinsky Orchestra, conducted by Zhang Guoyong, and the soloist is the young Chinese performer Yun Zeng (as of the 2024/25 concert season the Principal Horn at the Berlin Phil!): Glière: Horn Concerto
Glinka, Mikhail (1804-57)
Day 216: Spanish Overture No 2 (‘Summer Night in Madrid’) (Time: 10 minutes)
Today (20/8/21), I’ve chosen a tourist’s picture postcard, as our final example of summer music for the season. It’s a piece which makes no meaningful demands of the listener other than to sit back and enjoy a bit of local colour. The composer is Mikhail Glinka (1804-57), who is generally (if not entirely accurately) credited as being ‘the Father of Russian Music’. In practice, Russian church music has a longer history, but ‘Russian classical music’ in the sense of looking to western Europe for its inspiration, but nonetheless trying to forge a distinctively Russian identity, might be said to start with Glinka. He was born into a wealthy aristocratic family, had a rather sheltered upbringing, and acquired an early job in the Department of Public Highways – essentially a sinecure which allowed him as much time as he wanted to compose, initially in rather superficial styles suited to the salons of St Petersburg. After his pampered upbringing, he seems to have enjoyed ill health in a fairly extensive way, which involved a large number of dubious medical treatments but also regular visits to warmer climes – trips to Italy, France and Spain featured during his 30s and 40s. Gradually, there grew in him the urge to create music of a distinctively Russian sort, drawing on folksong and the dance music of the peasantry. He is remembered today mostly for a handful of short orchestral pieces – the Overture to his opera ‘Ruslan and Ludmilla’ and the tone poem ‘Kamarinskaya’ in particular. (According to Tchaikovsky, ‘the Russian symphonic school is all in ‘Kamarinskaya’, just as the whole oak is contained in the acorn.’) Glinka appears not to have enjoyed his stay in Spain in the mid-1840s all that much, but from it came a couple of distinctively Spanish-influenced pieces, the not particularly imaginatively titled Spanish Overture No 1 and Spanish Overture No 2. Fortunately, each piece has a sub-title, and the second overture, written when Glinka was safely back in Russia in 1848, and then revised three years later, is called ‘Summer Night in Madrid’. It’s essentially a pot-pourri of Spanish tunes, a couple of seguidillas, a jota and a punto Moreno (at least, that’s what the notes to my CD copy tell me!). Spain and its music and culture seems to have exerted a marked influence on Russian composers in the 19th century, perhaps because of its diametric contrast with the Russian climate. A few decades later, Rimsky-Korsakov made a similar collage of local themes and instruments (listen out for the castanets!) in his Capriccio Espagnol. But it was Glinka who blazed the trail with his Spanish pieces. Glinka’s biographer, the musicologist David Brown, suggests that the abrupt introduction of each new tune in this Spanish Overture No 2 coincides with Glinka’s arrival at another new night spot, encountering the music being played there. It makes the piece something of a Madrid pub crawl! For a performance, I’ve chosen a video recording of a concert given in Sofia, Bulgaria, by the Classic FM Radio Orchestra of Sofia, conducted by Luciano Di Martino. You’ll find it here: Glinka: Spanish Overture No 2 ('Summer Night in Madrid')
Godard, Benjamin (1849-95)
Day 503: Berceuse (from 'Jocelyn') (Time: 6 minutes) and Symphony No 2 in Bb, Op 57 (26 minutes)
Today (16/8/24) the focus of my posting is the French violinist and composer (when – rarely – he gets mentioned in anything I’ve read, the words tend to be in that order) Benjamin Godard. Not, it has to be said, a household name, though there are the beginnings of a Godard revival: the recording label ‘cpo’ (one of my favourites, just because they put on the market loads of 19th/20th century composers who are otherwise ignored) has been issuing discs of Godard’s music for a little while now. Anyway, Benjamin Louis Paul Godard (1849-95) was born exactly 175 years ago this coming Sunday. He was Parisian by birth, and considered something of a virtuoso violinist from a young age. His family background was Jewish, though I’ve not read anything that suggests that that counted against him, which, given that later 19th century France was not necessarily that tolerant of Jews, seems to suggest that as a performer and composer, his musicianship shone through. He died relatively young (aged 45) of tuberculosis, having been dogged by ill health for a number of years, and in the last decade of his life in particular, he seems to have become less a performer, more a composer. If you’ve not heard of him before, it’s because at his death, his music pretty much disappeared from view – with one notable exception – and, as I’ve noted above, it’s only in the past couple of decades that works are starting to appear on disc (if not in concert halls) again. The exception, to get it out of the way first, is a short piece which was once a fashionable encore for singers, cellists or violinists. Godard’s great hope as a composer was to be known for his operas, of which he wrote seven. The only one that stuck around for any length of time was ‘Jocelyn’, and from that work, the ‘famous bit’ (the term is relative) is the tenor aria ‘Oh! ne t'éveille pas encore’ (literally ‘Oh! Do not awaken yet’, though often better known in English as ‘Angels guard thee’). Even after the opera had sunk out of sight, tenors in recital would often programme the piece as an encore. Godard himself arranged it for either cello and piano or violin and piano, and in those guises it had a life in the world of chamber music too. It’s an initially dreamy and subsequently impassioned little work, opening with a somewhat mysterious chordal passage which feels like it’s not firmly rooted in any particular key. The soloist then has a recitative-style passage of a typically declamatory sort, before the berceuse’s simple, lyrical melody unfolds with some charm (and, it has to be said, a little sentimentality). From the options on YouTube I’ve gone for the cello and piano version, performed in this video recording by the cellist Octavio Hidalgo, accompanied on piano by Lilia Valdespino. You’ll find their recording here: Godard: Berceuse (from 'Jocelyn'). However, that’s only the ‘hors d’oeuvre’ before today’s main dish. Alongside opera, Godard’s other great passion – and this was very unusual in 19th century French music – was the symphony. However, for Godard the term ‘symphony’ was rather flexibly applied. Wikipedia says with some precision that Godard wrote five of them, though other sources suggest that actually there are as many as 11 works with ‘symphony’ in the title. Often these pieces had descriptive titles (‘Symphonie Gothique’, ‘Symphonie Populaire’, and so on), and often they were for vocal soloists and choir as well as orchestra. Others – like the ‘Symphonie Ballet’ – are more like suites than symphonies, and essentially colourful and decorative rather than anything more profound. In fact, there is only one of these eleven pieces that resembles what we could regard as a conventional, orchestral, four-movement symphony. This is the Symphony No 2 in Bb, Op 57. It was composed in 1879 and premiered the following year. It is an essentially serious piece, though we might see it as looking backward at earlier 19th century models rather than being forward-looking and innovative. Standing behind it are the figures of Mendelssohn and Schumann, and it would be fair to say that the symphony is broadly Germanic in technique rather than French. That’s especially true of the first and last movements (the most substantial). The first theme of the first movement has something of Dvorak’s ‘folksy’ feeling to it, though after that we have a conventionally worked-out structure. The second movement is a set of variations on a theme, and I think one of the most interesting things here is how Godard uses the orchestra, including (unusually) four bassoons! The third movement scherzo faces partly towards Mendelssohn, partly towards another of Godard’s inspirations, Tchaikovsky, especially the Tchaikovsky of the ballets. The finale is the biggest of the four movements, which keeps tending towards the minor key, giving the work a broadly serious quality. Is the symphony any good? Well, I don’t think it’s going to pull up any trees, as it were, but it’s an interesting example of what was going on in French orchestral music away from what we now regard as the mainstream in the final couple of decades of the 19th century. In any event, it’s worth the occasional outing, and Godard’s 175th anniversary seems a reasonable excuse. You won’t find video recordings of it anywhere, so we’re in audio-only territory here, in this decent performance by the Munich Radio Orchestra, conducted by David Reiland: Godard: Symphony No 2 in Bb, Op 57
Gombert, Nicolas (c1495-c1560)
Day 272: In te, Domine, speravi (Time: 10 minutes)
I thought today (4/3/22) I’d turn the focus to things Lenten, and introduce a Renaissance composer whom many of you may not be familiar with, Nicolas Gombert (c1495-c1560). The details of Gombert’s life (apart from one somewhat shocking event) are obscure. Even his birth/death dates are uncertain. He was probably born in what is now north-eastern France, somewhere near Lille. The first meaningful reference to his existence comes in the 1520s, when he was known to be a singer in the service of the Emperor Charles V. Hermann Finck, a music theorist writing in the mid-16th century, claimed that Gombert was a pupil of Josquin (see Day 218), though I haven’t read anything that might suggest that to be conclusively true. There are references to him working in the Imperial Chapel in the later 1520s and 30s, describing him as ‘magister puerorum’ (master of the boys [for the royal chapel]) and later (in French!) as ‘maître des enfants’ in the same establishment. He may well have become a priest in the 1530s, but as far as one can tell, he was never actually musical director of the Imperial chapel. The one significant event that we do know about him is that around 1539, the Emperor sentenced him to an indefinite period in the galleys on the high seas, for the offence of sexually abusing a choirboy in his charge. After this there is only one known detail from the rest of his life: a letter he wrote in or around 1547 to the Emperor’s ‘Gran Capitano’, accompanied by some of his musical compositions, appealing for pardon for his crime. After his release from the galleys (the music he sent was presumably persuasive!) he disappears entirely from public view, and the date of his death has been speculated as being any time from 1555-61. There are other musical figures from this era whose misdeeds colour their compositions – perhaps the most notable being Gesualdo, who will no doubt appear on this list before long – but a number of penitential texts were set by Gombert in ways that seem to address his own human frailty. One such is his setting of the first few verses of Psalm 31 (Psalm 30 in the Vulgate numbering). Finck’s comments on Gombert and his music are frequently quoted (they are pretty much all we have from the period), and one observation in particular is a useful way into his music and how it works: he praised Gombert in particular because ‘he has shown all musicians the way, for he shuns rests, and his compositions use full harmonies in general, and imitative textures in particular.’ Gombert was one of that generation of composers between Josquin (c1450-1521) and Orlando Lassus (c1532-94) whose work illuminated the years around the middle of the 16th century. (Others include Clemens non Papa, Willaert and Morales.) What makes Gombert’s music interesting is, essentially, the density of its texture (‘for he shuns rests’) and a kind of unstoppable and constant flow of imitative entries. Once the music gets started, it unfolds with an energetic momentum of its own. The text of the part of the psalm that Gombert sets, in the King James version, reads: ‘In thee, O Lord, do I put my trust; let me never be ashamed: deliver me in thy righteousness./ Bow down thine ear to me; deliver me speedily: be thou my strong rock, for an house of defence to save me./ For thou art my rock and my fortress; therefore for thy name's sake lead me, and guide me./ Pull me out of the net that they have laid privily for me: for thou art my strength./ Into thine hand I commit my spirit: thou hast redeemed me, O Lord God of truth.’ These verses are used in the Office of Compline, but composers of all Christian traditions have set them as part of the penitential contemplation associated with Lent. As for a performance, YouTube only offers audio recordings, so I thought I’d post a link to one which allows those who can to follow the score. (Even if you can’t read music, you’ll be able to recognise the way in which, once all six voices are up and running, the singers have few breaks in the texture.) This performance is by the vocal group Magnificat, directed by Philip Cave, and you’ll find it here: Gombert: In te, Domine, speravi
Gorecki, Henryk (1933-2010)
Day 13: Symphony No 3, ‘Symphony of Sorrowful Songs’ (2nd movement) (Time: 9 minutes)
OK – bit of a risk today (4/4/20), in that in these rather straitened times you might not want to listen to music of sorrow and desolation. But … it’s 43 years to the day today since the first performance of Gorecki's Symphony No 3. I know this became a world-wide hit, and you probably have a copy in your music collection, but even very popular things deserve an outing on this list. Gorecki, like his contemporary Arvo Part, is often lumped in with other Eastern European composers as a ‘Holy Minimalist’ – that is, like the American minimalists (Reich, Glass, Adams, etc.) only using devotional texts and overtly Christian themes. As we enter into Holy Week 2020, this is music that asks us to look tragedy straight in the eye. The second movement of the symphony sets the words of a prayer inscribed by an 18-year-old girl on the walls of a Gestapo prison in 1944. One final thought: Gorecki, like so many Poles, lost family members in concentration camps – his grandfather in Dachau, his aunt in Auschwitz. But he said this: ‘You know how it is between Poles and Germans. But Bach was a German too – and Schubert, and Strauss. Everyone has his place on this little earth.’ You’ll find the music here, in a performance by Sinfonietta Cracovia conducted by John Axelrod, with Isabel Bayrakdarian as the soprano soloist: Henryk Gorecki – Symphony No 3, ‘Symphony of Sorrowful Songs’, (2nd movement)
Gough, Orlando (b.1953)
Day 575: Birds on Fire [1] (Time: 6 minutes) and Birds on Fire [2] (8 mins) and Birds on Fire [3] (11 mins)
Next month, the viol consort Fretwork will be in Sheffield, and in their programme will be a movement from the work and the composer I’ve chosen for today (30/1/26), Orlando Gough. In 2008, Fretwork released a CD called ‘Birds on Fire’. It consisted, for the most part, of Fantasias and Pavans for viols by composers at the courts of Elizabeth I and James I, composers such as Thomas and Joseph Lupo, and Augustine and Hieronymus Bassano, whose Jewish identity was not established until the 1980s. (Jewish figures were officially banished from England from the late 13th century through to the 1660s, so the identity of these composers was, as it were, a coded secret.) But what gave the CD its title was a work by the modern British composer Orlando Gough, written specifically for Fretwork to play, called ‘Birds on Fire’. Gough is an interesting composer. Born in 1953, he has composed music for a great variety of ensembles and contexts. He was a member of the band (or, as he describes it, a ‘chaotic collective’) The Lost Jockey in the 1970s, and in the 80s of another somewhat anarchic group of musicians, Man Jumping. Probably his name and music are most often associated with the worlds of ballet and contemporary dance, though there are also operas, such as ‘The Mathematics of a Kiss’ and ‘The Finnish Prisoner’. A lot of his work is site-specific – that is, it’s written for particular performers in particular spaces, such as two pieces written to be performed on (both in the sense of that being their location, but also in the sense of using parts of the ship as ‘instruments’) HMS Belfast, a museum ship moored on the Thames in London. His most recent site-specific piece is ‘Herd’, a 2023 work in West Yorkshire that was ‘scored’ for a thousand performers, composers, sound artists, volunteers, and 23 sheep. He’s clearly a man of diverse interests and specialisms. He published ‘The Complete A-Level Mathematics’ in the later 1980s (he’s a maths graduate), and has also published recipes as a result of his interest in cooking, a book about Brighton, and, most recently, a book about bell-ringing. Now, all this might make him seem like just another English eccentric – albeit of a very extreme kind – but ‘Birds on Fire’ is a very striking piece indeed. He has written at some length about it in the liner notes to the Fretwork CD of the same name, from which I see no reason not to quote. ‘In Aaron Appelfeld's wonderful novel “Badenheim 1939”, a group of middle-class Jews gather in an Austrian holiday resort for their summer holidays. As they enjoy the gentle pleasures of the resort, organised by the local impresario Dr. Pappenheim, and settle into their old friendships and enmities, the town gradually, almost unnoticeably, becomes a ghetto. They persuade themselves that the sinister changes are improvements and continue their holiday amusements as the town closes in. Summer turns to autumn; life becomes very hard. The food runs out and they are reduced to eating indigestible delicacies from the hotel stores. And at this desperate stage, they begin to take pride in their Jewishness. The band plays Jewish tunes secretly at night. A pair of twins give a reading – “their words were like birds on fire”. The book ends as a train arrives to take them away. “Because the carriages are so dirty,” says Dr. Pappenheim, “it must mean we haven't far to go.”’ Gough adds to this the mental image he had when composing the music: ‘My mental picture of ‘Birds on Fire’ is of a group of musicians daring to play Jewish tunes at night in a small hotel room. The piece is based on two klezmer tunes: Kandel's Hora and Odessa Bulgarish.’ In fact, the origins of the work, both musically and in terms of inspiration, came much earlier. In the early 1980s he began collaborating with the dance company Second Stride, and for them he wrote the music for a theatre piece, ‘Badenheim’, in 1994. It was some of this music, developed and adapted to the unique sound world of a five-part viol consort, that eventually emerged as the three-movement piece ‘Birds on Fire’. The three different sections are marked only by numerical titles, and Gough has offered no commentary on the piece other than to describe its origins in the manner I’ve quoted. It’s fair to say that responses to Fretwork’s CD were mixed. For every review that was enthralled by the way Gough’s piece fitted into the aural picture of the compositions by the Lupos and the Bassanos, there was another that ‘tut-tutted’ at the intrusion of 20th music into the rarefied sound world of Renaissance viols. For what it’s worth, I bought a copy of the CD on its release precisely because of its historical material, and knowing nothing of Orlando Gough or his music, but I have to say that I play this CD a lot these days, and find Gough’s ‘Birds on Fire’ a rich blend of modern minimalism, a hint of jazz and generous amount of klezmer music. As you might expect, there are no video performances of this work on YouTube, so we are yet again in audio-only territory, but you’ll find the three movements of Orlando Gough’s ‘Birds on Fire’, performed by Fretwork, here: Gough: Birds on Fire [1], Birds on Fire [2] and Birds on Fire [3]
Gounod, Charles-Francois (1818-93)
Day 564: Petite Symphonie for Winds (Time: 20 minutes)
I should start today (14/11/25) by saying that it often shocks me, looking back on (before today) 563 previous postings on this list, to realise that there is a vast number of not even slightly obscure composers who have yet to be featured. If my guiding principles – at least since this forum stopped being a daily thing once I’d reached Day 100 back in June 2020 – have been to feature music by ‘anniversary’ composers or music about to appear at a concert here in Sheffield (and, when occasion permits, music requested by others on this mailing list), it follows that some composers may never in fact get a look in. But as good luck would have it, a much expanded wind section of Ensemble 360 are giving a concert of wind music this month that features the really quite neglected Charles Gounod. But not neglected any more, at least as far as this list is concerned. There was a time when Gounod was a much bigger musical name than he is today. In fact, after the death of Berlioz in 1869, there was a period when he was regarded as the leading French composer of the day, but the moment was brief – affected by turbulent political/military events – and before his death he was definitely ‘yesterday’s man’. Nowadays in all probability, if you encounter music by Gounod in the concert hall, or on stage or in church, the chances are you’ll be listening to one of five things: the opera ‘Faust’, which is by far his most enduring work; the opera ‘Romeo et Juliette’, which still sees the light of day from time to time; the ‘Ave Maria’, his setting of a descant line above Bach’s Prelude in C Major from Book 1 of ‘The Well-Tempered Klavier’; the rather inconsequential but once extremely popular ‘Funeral March of a Marionette’; or today’s featured work, the Petite Symphonie for Winds. There’s loads of other stuff, mostly gathering dust (or whatever the digital equivalent might be) but the prevailing view is that it’s largely rather sentimental, in a later 19th century sort of way, or shallow, or both. Which feels a bit crushing, but there – fashions change. Charles-Francois Gounod (1818-93) was born in Paris into a cultured household (his mother taught piano, while his father was an artist and teacher), and even after his father’s death when young Charles was only five, his focus remained on music and the arts, leading to a period studying at the Paris Conservatoire. He won the Prix de Rome – the most prestigious compositional prize of the day – which opened the doors to three years study not just in Rome but including travels across Europe to visit other leading composers. There are two things of note that emerged from this: he met both Fanny and Felix Mendelssohn, and from the latter he discovered the music of Bach, which Mendelssohn was busy reviving; and his stay in Rome inspired in him a pretty intense Catholic faith, to the point where he seriously considered a religious vocation, but it also inspired a love in him of previous eras’ church music, notably the works of Palestrina. But back in Paris there was another itch which, as it were, his commitment to church music was unable to scratch – the desire to write for the opera house. I’ve mentioned in previous posts on 19th century French composers that the culture of the time pushed them to write for the theatre rather than the concert hall, and though in his thirties he wrote two symphonies (attractive if lightweight pieces) it was really the stage and the church that occupied most of his time. He wrote 13 operas (mostly failures, alas, but it didn’t stop him trying, and ‘Faust’ was an immense success) but also nine oratorios (very very occasionally you might come across a performance of ‘Mors et Vita’), 20 settings of the Mass and dozens of other sacred motets. A bit of politics: as you may be aware, the Franco-Prussian war of 1870 was pretty cataclysmic for French national pride, but out of its humiliating defeat came a desire to reassert French cultural identity – and in musical terms this ‘renaissance’ included the founding of the Societe Nationale de Musique (see Day 174 for the posting on Vincent d’Indy) in 1871, and the Societe de Musique de Chambre pour les Instruments de Vent in 1879, founded by the exceptionally skilled flautist Charles Taffanel. This new generation of French musicians (not just d’Indy, but Saint-Saens, Bizet, Chabrier, Massenet, Faure and others) tended to regard Gounod as a bit of a dinosaur, but his friendship with Taffanel meant that Gounod found the opportunity to write something for this new era in French wind music. (In addition, it’s worth saying that this was, in terms of instrument technology, a vital time for wind instruments, under the instrument designer Theodore Boehm, which brought the wind ensemble to the fore after almost a century in the shadows.) And this brings me to Gounod’s Petite Symphonie, a wind nonet – the familiar octet of a pair each of oboes, clarinets, bassoons and horns, plus a single flute, on which Taffanel could show off his technique – that was written in 1885. In some ways it embodies those classic French stylistic virtues: elegance, clarity, balance and gentle wit. It’s a short piece in four movements, and formally it harks back to the wind serenades of Mozart, with a bit of Haydnesque wit thrown in. The first movement’s slow introduction leads to a lively if orderly (it’s in sonata form) Allegretto. The slow movement was definitely designed as a showcase for Taffanel, in a gentle and serene Andante Cantabile, whose vocal quality might be expected from a composer who wrote literally hundreds of songs. Then there’s a jolly ‘hunting horn’ scherzo and finally a bubbly finale full of playful exuberance. It’s not a masterpiece, but it’s a very lovely example of the sort of transparent flair and inventiveness of French music shorn of any influence of Germanic ‘heaviness’. I have to say that I love it. As for a performance, there are quite a few decent video recordings on YouTube, but out of them I’ve gone for this very French one by the wind section of the Radio France Philharmonic Orchestra. You’ll find it here (and note that nothing particularly happens for almost two minutes): Gounod: Petite Symphonie for Winds
Gouvy, Théodore (1819-98)
Day 417: Symphony No 4 (Time: 25 minutes)
Today (3/10/23), I have a composer that I’ve only discovered myself within the last six months – and a very exciting discovery it’s been. Given that one of the strategies I’m pursuing on this list is to mark major anniversaries, I feel a bit sad that I didn’t draw your attention to M. Gouvy back in April, but the truth is that at that point he was just a name to me, and I’d not really started to get to know his music. Now that I have become familiar with it, I’m keen to share it with you all. So, Théodore Gouvy died 125 years ago on April 21st this year. Gouvy (1819-98) was a composer whose work did not find the audience it deserved, for a variety of reasons, during his lifetime, and a composer who, since his death, has been almost completely neglected until perhaps the past 15 years or so, when it is at last being performed, published and recorded, and we can hear what we’ve been missing. One of the big reasons for Gouvy falling between the cracks of musical history is that he was neither fully French nor fully German, and there was a sense during his lifetime that he was a ‘foreigner’ in both countries. He was born in what is now Germany. However, when his mother gave birth to the first two children in the family they were French, living as they were at the time in the French village of Goffontaine. (Even more confusingly, the village had earlier been Belgian – that bit of territory on the French/German/Belgian border has a tangled history.) However, between the births of his elder brothers and Gouvy’s own appearance in the world in 1819, the post-Napoleonic map of Europe was laid out at the Congress of Vienna in 1815, and one of the outcomes of that re-drawing of the lines was that the village of Goffontaine became under Prussian control. This meant that Gouvy, unlike his older brothers, was not a French citizen, and therefore was unable to study at the Paris Conservatoire. (He was eventually ‘naturalised’ as a French citizen 32 years later.) Gouvy was fortunate, I suppose, in being bilingual (actually, he was also fluent in English and Italian) but his mixed French/German identity was to plague his musical experiences. He wrote feelingly to his mother in the 1850s, by which point he’d resided in the French capital for nearly 20 years, ‘Paris is my purgatory!’ – and, as I’ve written before in these emails (most recently in relation to Edouard Lalo – see Day 410), the principal source of his frustration was that Parisian audiences (and musicians for that matter) had very little interest in the forms of music that mattered to Gouvy: symphonic and chamber music. The French wanted opera and ballet music, and pulling together an orchestra from scratch to perform a contemporary symphony was a mammoth effort, and there was no guarantee that the players would commit to rehearsing, or turning up to the performance. By 1856 Gouvy had already written three symphonies. Probably the only people in France who had gone before him in symphonic terms in recent times were Louise Farrenc and George Onslow (one day, people, one day…). Consequently Gouvy’s first three symphonies were first performed in Leipzig, where the Gewandhaus Orchestra was probably Europe’s leading symphonic ensemble. In fact, Gouvy’s music was performed more than any other ‘foreign’ composer in Germany in the second half of the 19th century – all of which makes his effective disappearance from the (musical) history books all the sadder. Still, he entrusted the first performance of his Symphony No 4 in D Minor to a scratch Parisian orchestra. The outcome wasn’t great, though it was performed in Leipzig, Berlin and elsewhere in Germany that same year. To finish Gouvy’s story, he wrote six numbered symphonies and three other symphonic works in all (now recorded on the wonderful CPO label, and well worth your time), but most of his final couple of decades was taken up with chamber music – 11 string quartets, seven string quintets, 5 piano trios, and so on. And he died, I guess, at an unfortunate time, for someone neither fully French nor fully German, because the forces of musical nationalism caused him to be overlooked in the period up to the First World War, and then, in the musically ‘revolutionary’ postwar context, almost completely forgotten. The Symphony No 4 sounds as one might expect a symphony to sound from the 1850s – a musical world shaped by Schumann and Mendelssohn, with the inescapable shadow of Beethoven lying behind it. But it’s fine stuff, I think – proper symphonic ‘argument’ rather than just a procession of pretty themes. Indeed, for me anyway, things like the occasionally unusual scoring of the finale, where low strings combine with trombones, put me in mind of Brahms. The symphony is in four movements, with the scherzo second and the slow movement third. As for a performance, it will not surprise you to know that we’re in audio-only territory here, but I hope it won’t detract too much from your enjoyment of this music. The performers are the German Radio Philharmonic Orchestra of Saarbrucken Kaiserslautern, conducted by Jacques Mercier. You’ll find their recording (accompanied, rather bafflingly, by a painting that seems entirely unconnected to the music, as far as I know) here: Gouvy: Symphony No 4
Graf, Christian Ernst (1723-1804)
Day 392: String Quartet Op 17 No 1 in G Minor (Time: 11 minutes) and Symphony in D, Op 14 No 1 - 1. Allegro (3 minutes), 2. Andante (3 minutes) and 3. Presto (2 minutes)
This time out, I have chosen to nod in the direction of a composer whose birthday falls today (30/6/23) – and it’s not just any old birthday, but the 300th birthday of none other than the really not very famous at all Christian Ernst Graf. So, why bother with a really very obscure 18th century composer whom almost nobody will have heard a note of? Well, partly because (for me at least) this is one of the reasons this playlist exists, to shine a light into the darker recesses of musical history – but also because Graf is interesting (or ‘interesting’, for the sceptics amongst you) as one of those transitional figures in the history of music, in this case as the Baroque era had given way to what would come to be known as the Classical period. What we have from Graf is music of the very early decades of the new age of the ‘Classical’. (To put this into a little context, he was nine years older than Haydn.) So who was he, Christian Ernst Graf (1723-1804)? Well, he was born in Germany, in the small Thuringian town of Rudolstadt, but for most of his adult life, he was based in the Netherlands – hence the occasional references one finds to him as Christian Graaf, or Christiaan Graf, in the Dutch fashion. He was, as you can see from his dates, relatively long-lived for the era, and quite a lot of more obviously famous names made his acquaintance during the decades of his compositional life, notably CPE Bach (by some distance the most famous of the Bach dynasty during this period) and Mozart – both of whom seem to have had only good things to say about him. In the interests of balance, I should point out that he fled to Middelburg (then second only to Amsterdam in terms of city status in the Netherlands) from his native Rudolstadt, ‘in debt, having taken orchestral instruments and too much leave’. Another account from the time described him as ‘restless, if not adventurous’ – which feels very much like the comment of a writer searching for euphemisms! However, maybe this was just a question of taking a little time to grow up, because Dutch contemporaries noted that ‘Graaf was accomplished in arts and sciences, an educated man who was comfortable in his personal relations, and even talkative and lively in his circle of friends. He had a special skill in teaching, most notably young people to whom he liked to impart a taste for the arts and sciences.’ He subsequently moved to The Hague, where in the late 1750s he became court composer to William V and his wife Anne of Hanover – and in 1768 became master of the court music there. These days, not a great deal of Graf’s music has survived, though there are references to considerably more. Some of those compositions are perhaps best categorised as ‘curiosities’ (for which the Dutch seemed particularly fond), such as his Op 27, which was for two players on one violin! More conventionally, he also wrote a considerable amount of vocal and choral music (the most substantial example of which is his oratorio of 1802, ‘Der Tod Jesu’), but nowadays what little reputation he has rests on music either for string quartet or for orchestra. He seems to have been an impressive violinist – there are records of his performances at major public events such as the weddings of nobility in a number of German states as well as in the Netherlands. In terms of finding music by Graf to illustrate this posting, there is, unsurprisingly, not a great deal to choose from, but I thought I’d select one of his string quartets and one of his symphonies (none of his works lasts much more than about 10 minutes). So first, here is his String Quartet in G Minor, Op 17 No 1. It’s in the conventional three movements of the time, with a fast-slow-fast pattern (the appearance of an additional movement, usually a Minuet, placed third in order, is one of the more obvious markers of mature ‘classical’ as opposed to ‘baroque’ fashion). The opening Allegro shows quite a lot of similarity with Haydn’s early minor key quartets or symphonies, notably in the way the lower parts maintain a relentless urgency over which the first violin engages in more ‘song-like’ melodies. In the slow Largo that follows the cello part is supported by a harpsichord, which suggests perhaps Graf is looking back at the Baroque ‘continuo’ accompaniment, but the music feels temperamentally much closer to classical models, with the emphasis on ‘feeling’, the fashionable ‘sentimentalism’ of the time. The last movement is rhythmically quirky, and the first violin plays streams of brisk notes in a display of some virtuosity. All in all, it’s clearly not a masterpiece, but for its time (1777 or so) it’s an interesting illustration of what the early decades of the classical period sounded like. You’ll find it here (audio only, I’m afraid) played by the period instruments of the Via Nova Quartett (all, erm, five of them): Graf: String Quartet Op 17 No 1 in G Minor. And, for a taste of something on a slightly larger canvas, I’ve picked one of Graf’s symphonies, which also have the three movement format of the quartet above. This is Graf’s Symphony in D, Op 14 No 1. One thing that is noteworthy here is the ‘ceremonial’ quality of the piece, with its trumpets and drums, which are given plenty of opportunity to shine in the opening Allegro. The central Andante is a gentle, restrained affair, before the symphony ends with a return to the ‘public’ music of trumpets and drums in a brisk Presto. Once more, it will pull up no trees, but I feel it’s good to give houseroom to this sort of music now and then – if nothing else, it will enable us to appreciate the originality and ingenuity of Haydn and Mozart when we return to them after these diversions into the byways of music in the 1760s and 70s. There’s a good video performance of this symphony given by the New Dutch Academy (a chamber orchestra based in The Hague), conducted by Simon Murphy. Unfortunately it’s only available as three separate links, but here they are: Graf: Symphony in D, Op 14 No 1 - 1. Allegro, 2. Andante and 3. Presto
Grainger, Percy (1882-1961)
Day 164: In a Nutshell (Suite) (Time: 20 minutes)
Today (19/2/21), I want to write a little about - and introduce a work by - Percy Grainger, who died on 20/2/1961, sixty years ago tomorrow. But first, a little ethical throat clearing. I suspect that in an ideal world, one might like people whose fame in one sphere generates admiration and subsequent popularity to live relatively spotless lives and to espouse relatively palatable opinions in other spheres too. However, common sense suggests that is unlikely to be the case. In our current age, ‘no platforming’ and ‘cancel culture’ are ways in which people with unsavoury views might be prevented from spreading those views, but it’s extremely hard (except in a totalitarian state) to wield that power retrospectively. What’s more, in the creative arts in general, I suspect it’s always been the case that composers, artists, writers and so on have been cut a little more slack than we ordinary mortals because ‘greatness’ in some way permits such figures to behave in ways that are otherwise reprehensible. Do we choose not to like Picasso’s art because we know he treated women dreadfully? Probably not. Do we reject Wagner’s music because of his anti-Semitism? With rather more reservations, again probably not. (After all, it’s hard to find many composers in the 19th century who weren’t in some ways anti-Semitic: witness Schumann’s comments about Mendelssohn, and they were supposed to be friends at the shared forefront of musical progress.) Where is all this going? Well, in the case of Percy Grainger, we have a composer of vividly multi-faceted creativity and musical imagination, who also happened to hold opinions about politics and race that most people would now find repulsive – crudely racist and eugenicist views that make him, in most people’s eyes, a straightforward bigot – and whose private predilections (he seems to have been heavily into S&M all his life, and almost certainly had an incestuous relationship with his very dominant mother, not that the latter is necessarily his fault, of course) might, to say the least, make the vast majority feel uncomfortable. And yet his musical output is a vast teeming canvas of works of quirky eccentricity, wild experimentation, and the defiant rejection of the idea that there is any valid division between ‘high’ and ‘low’ culture. Percy Grainger (1882-1961) is Australia’s most famous composer, though he moved to America in 1914 and took out US citizenship four years later. It might help to consider his music in various ‘strands’. There’s the follower in the footsteps of Grieg, whose music he loved; there’s the folklorist and collector, who was a prominent figure in the English folksong revival of the early 20th century; there’s the explorer of all things Nordic, inspired by Icelandic sagas; there’s the musical iconoclast, inventor of new instruments, particularly electronic ones, and composer of pieces in which chance plays a prominent role; there’s the almost ‘music hall’ performer and populariser, creator of small-scale gems like ‘Mock Morris’, ‘Handel in the Strand’ and ‘Country Gardens’. Any one of these things might have filled the career of another composer; with Grainger, we get them all, and often all at once. The piece I want to suggest we listen to today is his suite ‘In a Nutshell’, which he ‘dished up’ (a very characteristic Graingerism, meaning to collect together from previously existing pieces) in 1916. He had a very fluid idea of how pieces should sound, and often published them in multiple scorings. So, ‘In a Nutshell’ exists in a version for solo piano, another for piano four-hands, and another for orchestra, including a range of optional instruments of various degrees of eccentricity. ‘In a Nutshell’ is in four movements. The first is called ‘Arrival Platform Humlet’. As Grainger explained, it is ‘the sort of thing one hums to oneself as an accompaniment to one's tramping feet as one paces up and down the arrival platform, waiting for the arrival of a belated train bringing one's sweetheart from foreign parts’ (there’s something quirkily AA Milne-like about the idea of humming ‘a humlet’); it is pretty much a continuous melody, only lightly harmonised. The second movement is ‘Gay but Wistful (Tune in a Popular London Style)’. It is clearly strongly influenced by music hall traditions, though there’s a touch of the Duke Ellington about the jazz-like harmonies. The third movement, ‘Pastoral’, is the most extended and experimental. Interestingly, for a composer who wrote at great length about almost all his music, he was conspicuously silent about this movement. It starts innocently enough, but develops layer upon layer of harmony and orchestration. In some ways it feels like the sort of thing Charles Ives might have composed. Finally, there is ‘The Gum-Suckers’ March’. Grainger was born in Melbourne, Victoria, and apparently Victorians were known as ‘gum suckers’ because in hot summer weather they sucked eucalyptus leaves to keep cool! The music is raucous and free-wheeling, though even here the harmonies are occasionally subversive. As for a performance, YouTube is well stocked with arrangements for military band, but there’s an excellent audio performance of Grainger’s orchestral score by the BBC Phil, conducted by Richard Hickox, which you can find here: Grainger: In a Nutshell (Suite)
Grieg, Edvard (1843-1907)
Day 192: From Holberg’s Time (Suite in Olden Style) (Time: 19 minutes)
Last time, I addressed one of Grieg’s more obscure larger-scale works, the Violin Sonata No 2. This time out (28/5/21), I’ve gone for something much more mainstream and popular – and more characteristic of Grieg’s skills as a writer of shorter pieces – although in a performance that will, I hope, prove quite startling to you. I mentioned last time that Grieg wrote a fair amount of ‘occasional’ music, compositions to mark the opening of concert halls, or to celebrate coronations, or to commemorate anniversaries or whatever. Ludwig Holberg was a playwright and all-round humanist polymath, who was born in Bergen, Norway (also Grieg’s home city) in 1684. He’s a kind of cross between Moliere and David Hume, I think. The 200th anniversary of his birth was marked with some fanfare in Norway (and Denmark – at the time he was born, Denmark and Norway were part of a unified kingdom). As part of those anniversary celebrations, Grieg wrote a suite for piano, consisting of five short movements in 18th century dance styles. This is interesting, I think, in that we tend to see the early decades of the 20th century as the period when ‘neo-classicism’ (and the ‘neo-baroque’) were particularly fashionable: previously on this list we’ve explored Prokofiev’s ‘Classical’ Symphony (see Day 103) and Stravinsky’s ‘Octet’ (see Day 135), typical examples of neo-classicism in action. However, throughout the 19th century too, this tendency to write ‘in the olden style’ was entirely normal. Tchaikovsky, to take just one example, called his Orchestral Suite No 4 ‘Mozartiana’, basing the movements on pieces by his idol Mozart. Grieg’s ‘Holberg Suite’ – or, as it’s more correctly titled, ‘From Holberg’s Time (Suite in Olden Style)’ – was not based on previously existing compositions, but Grieg set out to sympathetically pastiche 18th century musical forms and conventions. The movements of the work are titled ‘Praeludium’, ‘Sarabande’, ‘Gavotte’, ‘Air’ and ‘Rigaudon’: the last four of these might easily be the titles of movements in a baroque suite. In 1885 Grieg arranged the work for string orchestra, which is the version that is better known today. The music is lively, fresh and warm-hearted: even for a composer whose music is usually upbeat, the Holberg Suite is one of Grieg’s happiest works. There are a number of entirely capable performances on YouTube, but I’ve gone for one which is more vigorous than most. It may not be the most sensitive playing you’ve ever heard, but it’s a whole lot of fun. It’s a performance by the Camerata Nordica String Ensemble, directed from the violin by Terje Tonnesen, and you’ll find it here: Grieg: From Holberg's Time (Suite in Olden Style)
Day 191: Violin Sonata No 2, Op 13 (Time: 20 minutes)
Over the months, this list has featured music from Finland (Sibelius – see Day 77), Sweden (Roman and Stenhammar – see Days 159/160, Denmark (Nielsen – see Day 98) and even Iceland (Rautavaara – see Day 80), but until today (25/5/21), nobody from Norway. I think if you asked your average punter, in a ‘Pointless’ sort of way, to name Norwegian composers, the inevitable most popular answer would be Edvard Grieg. (To be fair, there’s not a lot of competition. I think you need to be either Norwegian or a bit of a classical music nerd to be familiar with the inimitably named Ole Bull, or Johan Halvorsen, or Christian Sinding, or Johan Svendsen, or – a good one for the folkies amongst you – Geirr Tveitt.) Maybe their days on this list will come, but for this week I want to focus on Mr Grieg himself, whose reputation, I think, is possibly lower than it ought to be, just because we hear so little of his musical output. (Maybe too ‘Song of Norway’, for those of a certain age, stamped him as irredeemably ‘middle-brow’ in the same sort of way that ‘Kismet’ did for Borodin.) Grieg (1843-1907) was undoubtedly the main figure to forge a clear sense of national identity for Norwegian music in the Romantic era. The problem, perhaps, is that his close association with the folk music of his home country means that he tends to be seen as a mere transcriber of native tunes – or someone composing in the style of those native tunes – and consequently not engaged in the ‘serious’ business of musical development in the mainstream 19th century sense. Another thing that often counts against him is that he wrote very few large scale compositions: the inescapable Piano Concerto, obviously, but beyond that there’s a very early symphony, a string quartet, a piano sonata, a cello sonata, three violin sonatas … and then just lots and lots of collections of shorter pieces, whether for solo piano (like the ten books of Lyric Pieces) or suites for orchestra built out of incidental music (‘Peer Gynt’, of course) or ‘occasional’ music in the rather literal sense of music written for a special occasion. The result is that he is seen as a miniaturist, and not much more. If I were making a case for Grieg, I’d suggest that he’s very interested in rhythm, and in developing musical structures using the repetition and variation of short melodic fragments, almost like ‘cells’, which are then fused together (on a good day) into larger formal structures. I think a really good example of this technique in action can be found in his Violin Sonata No 2 in G, Op 13. It’s a long way off the beaten track when it comes to Grieg’s work – I’ve never heard it in concert, and it rarely appears on the radio – but I really think it deserves to be heard more often. He wrote it on his honeymoon in 1867, and it is infused with a kind of vital optimism. The first movement starts with a minor-key improvisational feel, but once we reach the main Allegro Vivace the folk dance known as the ‘springdans’ becomes the basis for what follows. All three movements of the sonata are in triple time (Grieg’s fascination with rhythm again), even though the tempo of each movement is very different – a calm Allegretto Tranquillo second movement and a final, vigorous Allegro Animato. Not surprisingly, the sonata is not terribly well represented on YouTube, but there is an impressive video performance by the virtuoso Vadim Repin, accompanied by pianist Vladimir Mogilevsky, which you’ll find here: Grieg: Violin Sonata No 2, Op 13
Day 501: Lyric Piece Op 12 No 1: Arietta (Time: 2 minutes) and Lyric Piece Op 38 No 8 (Kanon) (5 minutes), Lyric Piece Op 43 No 6 (To the Spring) (3 minutes), Lyric Piece Op 54 No 3 (March of the Trolls) (4 minutes), Lyric Piece Op 65 No 6 (Wedding-Day at Troldhaugen) (6 minutes) and Lyric Piece Op 71 No 7 (Remembrances) (2 minutes)
Next month (September 2024), Kathryn Stott is playing one of Grieg’s many Lyric Pieces
at her concert in Sheffield, and I thought I’d use that as a stepping off point
today (2/8/24) to feature a selection of Lyric Pieces in a variety of performances
by different pianists, and to mark the start of your new Weekly Cultural Fix.
So, we’ve had music by Grieg only a couple of times on this list
(see Days 191 and 192 for his Violin Sonata No 2 and the Holberg Suite),
which seems a bit like it’s not giving him his due.
The notes I wrote back then underscored the extent to which Grieg’s reputation
these days is built on a tiny handful of works, and highlighted the fact that
almost all of Grieg’s substantial output is written for the piano
(either solo or accompanying a singer or other soloist).
There is a kind of recurring thread that runs through Grieg’s writing from
relatively early on in his life through to almost his final composition, and
this is the production of sets of short piano pieces to which he gave the
over-arching title ‘Lyric Pieces’. He actually published these in ten
separate ‘books’ (each containing between six and eight individual compositions),
so there are actually 66 different pieces in total, written from 1866-1901.
Although there are many ‘pianist-composers’ in the history of music, I can’t
off the top of my head think of any other composer who kept coming back again and
again to such a specific musical idiom – maybe Mendelssohn’s ‘Songs without Words’
from earlier in the 19th century is the closest fit.
It’s like he found in these works a vehicle to be both descriptive (lots of the
pieces have ‘scene-setting’ titles) and reflective at the same time.
Anyway, here are six of those pieces, taking in the full sweep of Grieg’s work in this area.
The first book of Lyric Pieces, Op 12, was written in 1866 (Grieg was 23 at the time) and
published the following year. These are the shortest and, largely, the simplest
of all the sets of Lyric Pieces, and they have historically had a function as music
for budding pianists to practise on. The very first piece is called ‘Arietta’,
a gentle singing melody of a piece. It’s performed in this concert recording
by the then teenage Canadian pianist Jan Lisiecki: Grieg: Lyric Piece Op 12 No 1 (Arietta).
Sixteen years elapsed between the Op 12 set of Lyric Pieces and Grieg’s next volume of them,
his Op 38, which was published in 1883. Between these first and second volumes, Grieg wrote
a lot of music which made him famous: the Piano Concerto, of course,
but also the 2nd Violin Sonata, the incidental music for ‘Sigurd Jorsalfar’
and the incidental music for ‘Peer Gynt’.
But this second set of Lyric Pieces is not just more mature, but also more extensive
in its musical language. One of the major influences on Grieg as he developed was
the music of Schumann, also largely a miniaturist, so I thought from this second set,
I’d go for the final piece, ‘Kanon’, which (to me at least) feels quite Schumannesque.
It’s played here on this video recording by the Latvian pianist and composer
Vestards Šimkus: Grieg:
Lyric Piece Op 38 No 8 (Kanon). Three years later, Grieg wrote his third
set of Lyric Pieces, Op 43. By this point, these short pieces have become
more developed still, with much attention to the cohesion of the set as a whole
and the connected moods and emotions running from one piece to the next.
The last work in the set is one of Grieg’s most popular, his ‘To the Spring’,
written in a state of homesickness while Grieg was away from his native
Norway. It’s played here as an encore by the Russian pianist Denis
Kozhukhin: Grieg:
Lyric Piece Op 43 No 6 (To the Spring).
In 1888, Grieg’s Op 47 set of pieces emerged, and in 1891 the fifth set, Op 54, followed it.
Grieg actually took four of the Op 54 set and orchestrated them as his Lyric Suite
(also Op 54), but maintaining the focus on piano playing today I thought I’d
choose another of Grieg’s immensely popular works, and one that mines that
characteristic folk-dance inspired quality that Grieg employed a lot. So
here is ‘March of the Trolls’ (otherwise known as ‘March of the Dwarfs’) from
the overtly nationalistic Op 54 set, played in concert by the Russian pianist
Mikhail Pletnev: Grieg:
Lyric Piece Op 54 No 3 (March of the Trolls). As you can see from the
dates of these publications, in the 1880s and 90s Grieg was on something of a
roll when it came to his sets of Lyric Pieces, and the sets kept coming – Book
6 in 1893 and Book 7 in 1895. With the publication of Book 8 in 1896, we
reach the work that Kathryn Stott is playing in Sheffield next month, Grieg’s
‘Wedding Day at Troldhaugen’, which surely has to be Grieg’s most popular
composition for solo piano. He wrote it for his 25th wedding
anniversary, which took place at his and his wife’s then home, Troldhaugen.
It’s played on this video (another encore after a concerto performance, from
the look of it) by the Russian pianist Nikolai Lugansky: Grieg: Lyric Piece Op 65 No
6 (Wedding-Day at Troldhaugen). There’s some evidence that by this
stage Grieg was coming to see the ongoing production of these pieces as
something of a tiresome burden, though evidently the public at large seem not
to have tired of them. There’s a rather bitter remark to a friend that he
felt unable to write much that was worthwhile except ‘the so-called “Lyric
Pieces”, which are surrounding me like lice and fleas in the country.’
Or this, from the same period: ‘I cannot be blamed if my music is played in
third-rate hotels and by school-girls… I guess this popularity is all
right, but it is dearly bought. My reputation as a composer is suffering
because of it.’ So sad… There were to be two more volumes of Lyric
Pieces, in 1898 and 1901, and I thought I’d end with the last piece from the
tenth and last book. Grieg called it ‘Remembrances’, and it includes a
quotation from ‘Arietta’, the first piece in the first book.
Whatever Grieg thought of these pieces at various points in his life,
it’s a lovely way to bring the cycle full circle, and back to where it started.
It’s played here by the Lithuanian pianist Vadim Chaimovich: Grieg:
Lyric Piece Op 71 No 7 (Remembrances)
Day 574: Piano Concerto (Time: 29 minutes)
This evening, the Hallé are playing a Scandinavian programme here in Sheffield, and from it, I’ve chosen music for today (23/1/26) by Grieg, the filling in the familiar overture-concerto-symphony sandwich, and one of the most regularly performed of any 19th century piano concertos, the Piano Concerto in A Minor. It’s a piece that’s so well known that it’s hard to imagine that there’s anyone on this list who isn’t familiar (and maybe over-familiar) with it. Those of a certain age will remember when André Previn was chief conductor of the LSO, and featured on the Morecambe and Wise 1971 Christmas Show, when Eric Morecambe repeatedly failed to perform the opening bars of the piano’s first entry to this concerto (saying afterwards that he was ‘playing all the right notes … just not necessarily in the right order’), but even if you’re too young for that, there will have been other opportunities for the Grieg concerto’s melodies to have embedded themselves in your consciousness – in the musical humour of sketches by Bill Bailey, for example. Grieg’s reputation, these days, essentially rests on a small handful of works – the Piano Concerto, of course, but also shorter suites of pieces, like the ‘Peer Gynt’ incidental music and the Holberg Suite (see Day 192). After that, most of his music that features in concerts or is broadcast tends to be from his many collections of piano miniatures (see Day 501 for a selection of his ‘Lyric Pieces’). It’s not that Grieg was unable to conceive of music in large-scale forms, but more that those works come primarily from his early years as a composer, and in his maturity he tended to focus on shorter works, often for piano, that he, as a gifted concert pianist, could play. But there was a time when he did, in fact, aspire to the construction of substantial compositions. As early as 1863, when he was just 20 years old, he began work on a Symphony in C Minor. It was finished the following year and performed several times in Scandinavia, either whole or in part, over the next few years. But he suppressed it in 1867 (‘Must never be performed’, he wrote on the front of the manuscript), and although there’s no definitive explanation for this, the most common thinking is that he felt the work bore too obvious a debt to the Germanic composers whose music he’d studied during his years in Leipzig (especially Mendelssohn and Schumann), and in his early twenties it was becoming more important to Grieg to pay attention to the voice of musical nationalism in his creative consciousness. This, surely, is why the Piano Concerto has survived (indeed, thrived) where the Symphony disappeared. It’s also worth saying that in 1868, when Grieg composed the concerto, he was both deeply happy, having married his first cousin, the singer Nina Hagerup, the year before, and also financially secure. And yet, if we see Grieg’s concerto as successful because it was indebted to the idioms of Norwegian folk music, where the Symphony wasn’t because its roots were in Germanic symphonic traditions, we miss at least one of the major sources of his Piano Concerto, namely the concerto by Robert Schumann. The similarities between the two, in terms of their first movements in particular, are so evident that it’s almost as though Grieg were tracing over a template prepared beforehand. It’s no surprise that the two works are often coupled in recordings released on disc. And yet, they are, in atmosphere, really very different, and those descriptive observations – sometimes loaded with slightly pejorative overtones – about Grieg’s work, focusing on its freshness and vitality of melodic idea, are surely why this concerto is still played over and over again, even 150 years and more later. If we’re brought up on Mozart, Beethoven and Brahms, say, for our model of the piano concerto, we may think that what matters in these large-scale works is not so much the ideas themselves as what happens to them, how they’re developed. But you can’t ask those questions, as it were, of the Grieg concerto. Its themes barely develop at all, but are simply restated literally when they recur. What matters instead are the tunes, the clarity and character of their orchestration, and the way the contrasts between them give the piece its musical dynamism. After the famous opening flourish, the first movement follows all the ‘rules’ of sonata form, but I imagine that what we remember from it are the engaging march-like initial theme and the sighing, yearning cello melody that stands in contrast to it. The slow movement has a simple A-B-A structure, introspective at the beginning and end, but with a more passionate middle section. It’s the finale, though, that allows Grieg the greatest freedom to exploit the folk-music of his homeland. None of this is direct quotation, but rather in the vein of the Norwegian folk dance the ‘halling’, an energetic manoeuvre regularly performed by young men at weddings, apparently. There’s a tender interlude featuring a lovely solo flute melody, and the work closes with a broad sweeping restatement of this theme for full orchestra. Grieg never wrote another concerto – there are sketches in the 1880s for a second one, but they came to nothing – and maybe, in the context of his whole career, the Piano Concerto is best regarded as a happy accident, a moment of youthful genius. And I don’t think I speak only for myself in saying that if, faced with the prospect of yet another performance of this concerto, we might sigh a little, it only takes the opening bars to remind us why we love it, and will go on doing so. There are several more than acceptable video recordings of Grieg’s Piano Concerto on YouTube, and out of the options I’ve gone for this one, by the Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra conducted by Riccardo Chailly. But the main reason for choosing it is as a tribute to the German pianist Lars Vogt, who died of cancer in 2022 in his early 50s. He gave quite a few memorable performances of concertos and solo piano works here in Sheffield. You’ll find the recording here: Grieg: Piano Concerto
Guðmundsson, Hugi (b1977)
Day 253: Dýr fæðingin Drottins vors (Time: 4 minutes)
If I went a little off the beaten track with the music of Juan Garcia de Zespedes last time out, I’m fairly confident that we’re even more lost in the footnotes and margins of classical music with the choice for today (28/12/21). This is the music of the contemporary Icelandic composer Hugi Guðmundsson (b1977). If you were looking for CDs of his work, as far as I can tell, there are only two full-length discs out there. The first, which dates from 2007, is ‘Apocrypha’, a rather astringent selection of tracks for mezzo-soprano, baroque chamber ensemble and electronics; the second, ‘Djúpsins Ró’ (‘Calm of the Deep’), from 2013, is completely different. It consists of eight short choral works which Guðmundsson had composed in the decade or so before its release, interspersed with three movements from a suite for strings based on music by Handel, and four intermezzi for solo viola de gamba specially composed for the disc and played by his wife Hanna Lofsdottir. That might make the whole album seem like a bit of a hodge-podge of diverse bits and pieces, but (and I’m a bit biased here) it has been my wife’s favourite disc since I bought it for her several years ago, and it’s music which repays repeated listening in its richness of contemplation. As a young man, Guðmundsson studied classical guitar from an early age, but also performed in a number of death metal bands as an adolescent, not that the sound world of the latter finds its way into today’s selection! He graduated with a degree in composition in 2001, followed by postgraduate study in Denmark and the Netherlands. His choral music has become part of the standard repertoire of Icelandic choirs in recent years, and is now beginning to find new performers and audiences across the world. He is also a composer of opera (his first, ‘Hamlet in Absentia’, won several awards) and film scores. The piece I’ve chosen for today is a setting of the hymn ‘Dýr fæðingin Drottins vors’ (‘The Blessed Birth of Our Lord’) by the 17th century Icelandic poet and pastor Ólafur Jónsson. It’s a work of a particular serenity, I think, in which scrunching dissonances resolve into a stillness in which you get the same sense of space and distance opening up that’s a feature of so much contemporary Nordic choral music. In some ways Guðmundsson’s writing reminds me of Ola Gjeilo’s work, though it’s nowhere near as ‘ambient’ and twee in its sound world. I hope this music gives you as much pleasure to listen to as it does me. For a performance, I thought that, rather than simply take the track from the CD (which is easy to find if you want to explore further), I’d go for a live performance by the Icelandic choir, the Cantoque Ensemble. You’ll find it here: Guðmundsson: Dýr fæðingin Drottins vors
Guebrou, Emahoy Tsegué-Maryam (1923-2023)
Day 375: The Homeless Wanderer (Time: 7 minutes) and Mother's Love (4 minutes)
Today (28/4/23) we are, perhaps, more ‘off the beaten track’ than we have ever been in musical terms, but this posting explores just a tiny bit of the fascinating music of a composer who died very recently, on 26th March, and whose life was, to say the least, unusual. I am indebted to Peter Wigglesworth of this very playlist for alerting me to her story, though I had come across some of her music before. (Actually, the truth is that I’d come across her music on a few occasions on Radio 3, but always the same piece(!) – see below.) Emahoy Tsegué-Maryam Guèbrou (1923-2023) was born in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia’s capital, into a life of relative privilege. It would appear that she and her sister were the first Ethiopian girls to be sent to Europe to be educated, and it was at boarding school in Switzerland that she first learned to play the violin, and then the piano. At the age of nine she returned to Ethiopia, where as a precocious young girl she sang for the Emperor, Haile Selassie, and seems, despite her tender age, to have had some kind of administrative employment in the civil service. During the war between Ethiopia and Italy (1935-7), she and her parents were taken as prisoners of war and housed on islands off Italy, but after the war the family returned home, where she continued her musical studies and began to develop the contacts for what might have turned into a career as a concert performer. She studied initially in Cairo, but struggled with the heat there and returned again to Addis Ababa. But at the age of 21 she had some kind of physical/spiritual crisis. She appears to have been refused permission to travel to London to study at the Royal Academy of Music, the consequence of which was that she gave up her music and became a nun, living barefoot for a decade in a monastery on Mount Guishen in northern Ethiopia. (‘I took off my shoes and went barefoot for ten years. No shoes, no music, just prayer.’) And that, perhaps, might have been that, but in the mid-1950s the monastery closed down, and she returned home to live with her mother. Through the 1960s and 70s she composed extensively, mostly songs and piano pieces, and made recordings, the first one appearing in 1967. One gets the impression that at this stage of her life, in her 40s and 50s, she had come gradually to terms with the conflict of being both a nun and a musician with a public role. This period in Ethiopia saw a resurgence of interest not just in the local folk music of the area but also a kind of ‘Ethiopian jazz’, based on a localised version of the pentatonic scale (play just the black notes on a piano), which also in some ways shaped her musical language. Another dislocation in her life occurred in the 1980s, when the installation of a Marxist regime in Ethiopia, and the chaos of a brutal civil war, led to her moving to Jerusalem, where she lived out the final decades of her life in an Ethiopian Orthodox convent there. A collection of her recordings of piano pieces emerged in 2006, thanks in large measure to her friendship with the Israeli musician Maya Dunietz, and gradually the musical world seems to have woken up to the unique sound world of her compositions. In 2017, the BBC broadcast a programme with the musician and Radio 3 presenter Kate Molleson, called ‘The Honky Tonk Nun’, which is, six years later, still available online; you can find it here. Dunietz has talked about the difficulty of editing and publishing her work for wider consumption, as often manuscripts are fragmented, incomplete, and sometimes just notes indicating aspects of improvisation for Guèbrou herself to play. It may be some time yet before we have a complete edition of her work. As for what to suggest we listen to, to get a sense of her music, you might want to start with this trailer for a documentary about her life, ‘Labyrinth of Belonging’, which you can find here. In terms of her actual compositions, I suspect the most popular of them is the piano piece ‘The Homeless Wanderer’, which was used in the 2021 Netflix film ‘Passing’. When her 2006 collection appeared on CD, this was the composition that grabbed people’s attention. You’ll find it here, played (audio only) by the composer: Guebrou: The Homeless Wanderer. As her music has become more widely available, it is beginning to be recorded by other artists. A CD called ‘Soulscapes’ performed by Maria Thompson Corley, features another piece by Guèbrou, ‘Mother’s Love’, and on YouTube you’ll find a video recording of Corley playing that piece here: Guebrou: Mother's Love
Guerrero, Francisco (1528-99)
Day 351: Alma Redemptoris mater (Time: 4 minutes) and A Un Nino Llorando (3 minutes) and Rorate Caeli (2 minutes)
Francisco Guerrero – ‘who he?’ you might ask. Well, if you ask Wikipedia, it will tell you that there are several Francisco Guerreros – including a couple of footballers, and, rather alarmingly, a serial killer. However, our Francisco Guerrero (1528-99) was a Spanish Renaissance composer. He existed within the same time frame as other Spanish composers such as Cabezon, Alonso Lobo, Morales (who taught him), Ortiz and, most famously, Victoria (see Day 246). Guerrero was about 20 years older than Victoria, but you can hear in his sound world the same sort of influences. From what I’ve discovered about him, perhaps the most striking thing about Guerrero is the inappropriateness of his name: it means ‘warrior’, and Guerrero was one of the gentlest men you could ever have met. He was also the most ‘Spanish’ of composers – born in Seville, he was for a time music director at the cathedral in Jaén in Andalusia as a young man, and also spent a year in Italy in his early 50s, where he met Victoria – but apart from that he spent the whole of his career in Seville at the cathedral there. He also (and although it wasn’t an unheard of event, it was certainly not common) made the trip from Spain to Jerusalem when he was a relatively old man of about 60 – a trip he recalled vividly in his ‘El viaje de Hierusalem’ (‘The Journey to Jerusalem’), with its rather scary ‘adventures’: he was attacked twice by pirates on his way back to Spain, robbed of his possessions and held to ransom. When he got back to Spain, penniless and alone, he was thrown into a debtors’ prison, and only rescued by his previous employer at Seville Cathedral. At least his book about his travels was, seemingly, a best-seller, which helped to recoup some of his losses. As a musician he seems to have had a beautiful tenor voice, and to have been skilled on the organ, vihuela (a Spanish instrument that’s a kind of cross between a guitar and a lute), harp and cornett (a wind instrument about the size of an oboe but with a brass instrument-type mouthpiece – apparently very difficult to play). If you were contrasting Guerrero as a composer with Victoria, there’s no doubt that the latter wrote more tightly organised and polished music, capable I’d argue of reaching greater profundity and a kind of dark beauty. However, Guerrero composed music that’s melodically vivid, and also music that was able to depict a wide range of emotions and sensations: ecstasy, happiness, melancholy, yearning, submissiveness, solemnity and vivacity. The liner notes for a CD of his music that I own argue that ‘if one had asked any Spanish musician of the 1580s to name the leading composer of the day, the answer would have been Guerrero.’ His published music dates from 1555-97, and includes more than 100 Motets, two books of Masses, Psalms, music for the Office of the Dead, two Passions, and a collection of religious ‘villancicos’ in Castilian Spanish, not to mention a substantial amount of secular music. In terms of music by Guerrero that would give some sense of his sound world, I’ve chosen for today (13/12/22) three pieces, all of which have historically featured during church services in Advent. The first is his motet ‘Alma Redemptoris Mater’, a Marian hymn (‘Loving Mother of our Redeemer’), the text of which seems to date back to at least the 11th century. The text often featured in Advent services, and it has been set by hundreds of composers, notably by Dufay, Josquin, Lassus, Palestrina, Victoria, Byrd, Charpentier, and of course Guerrero. It’s a short setting for four voices (SATB), and contains some nice ‘word painting’, notably the falling lines at ‘succurre cadenti’ (‘give aid to a falling people’). What I love about this piece is that although it’s relatively easy to sing it feels rich and impassioned. It’s performed on this audio-only recording by the French-based group Ensemble Jacques Moderne, directed (I think!) by Joël Suhubiette. You’ll find it here: Guerrero: Alma Redemptoris Mater. Then, to give you a sample of Guerrero the ‘Spanish’ composer, here is ‘A un niño llorando’, a narrative about the visit of the Magi to the Christ child. It’s got the lively Iberian rhythmic flair that is typical of the music of the region. It’s performed here by the USC Thornton Chamber Singers, directed by Micah Bland: Guerrero: A Un Nino Llorando. The final piece by Guerrero for today is Guerrero’s motet ‘Rorate Caeli’ (‘Drop Down, Ye Heavens’), another text frequently performed during Advent, with its text taken from Isaiah, Ch 45. It’s performed on this (again audio-only, I’m afraid) recording by the Swiss vocal group Ensemble Corund, conducted by their American director Stephen Smith. You’ll find it here: Guerrero: Rorate Caeli
| H–L
|
H · I · J · K · L |
|
Haas, Pavel (1899-1944)
Day 488: String Quartet No 2 (1st movement) (Time: 10 minutes) and Study for Strings (9 minutes)
Today (11/6/24), I want to take one last dip into the events of the month of June 1899. Today’s posting, like the four immediately before it, highlights the birth or death of a significant composer during that month – and this time I want to focus on the fact that 10 days from now, on 21st June, it will be 125 years precisely since the birth of the Czech composer Pavel Haas. For many of you, perhaps, if you associate the name Pavel Haas with anything, it will be the string quartet that bears his name – you may have heard them playing live on Radio 3 only last night (well, three-quarters of them, anyway) in music by Brahms. But that quartet took its name from Pavel Haas the composer (1899-1944), probably the most significant of the pupils of Janáček, and a composer who was well on the way to developing a strong and identifiable voice of his own until his life was cut short by the Nazis when he was murdered in the gas chambers in Auschwitz. Haas was born in Brno, in the Moravian region of what we are now encouraged to call Czechia. He was from a Jewish family with no particular background in music, but he appears to have had a strong natural talent, eventually entering the Prague Conservatory in his late teens, culminating in two years’ tuition from Janáček in the early 1920s. Through the next decade and a half he produced music in a range of genres, though he seems to have been immensely self-critical, refusing to publish many works and destroying others: in terms of ‘official’ works, he got as far only as Op 18. Still, there’s an array of chamber music, songs (both for soloists and choir), piano music, incidental music for both theatre and film, and an opera, ‘The Charlatan’, that appeared in 1938. He married in 1935 and by 1938 the couple had a child – but it was clear by then which way the wind was blowing for Jews in central Europe. In a desperate attempt to keep his wife and child safe he divorced them, helping them to avoid the increasingly anti-Semitic tendencies of Czech authorities. He tried, and failed, to organise for his family to escape to the USA, with the help of his (ex-)wife’s family. But in 1941 he was deported to the Terezin (Theresienstadt) concentration camp, a kind of ‘waystation’ for Jews on their way to their deaths elsewhere, but meanwhile existing in a kind of mockery of real life, a community allegedly governed by a Jewish Council of Elders rather than directly by the SS. Unsurprisingly, reports suggest that Haas was deeply depressed at the time, but other Jewish/Czech musicians at the camp encouraged him to continue to compose, even in such desperate circumstances. As you may know, in a strategy to fool a Red Cross inspection of the camp, Terezin was remodelled as a kind of ‘commune’ for Jewish inhabitants, and there was even a film (‘The Führer Gives the Jews a City’) that purported to show the idealised lives the captives were living; in one shot, Haas can be seen bowing to the audience after a performance by the camp orchestra of his ‘Study for Strings’, which Haas had composed while at the camp in 1943. The brutal reality was that immediately after the film was made public, the 18,000 inhabitants of the camp, including Haas, were shipped off to Auschwitz where most were murdered. Particularly poignantly, on arrival Haas was standing next to the renowned Czech conductor Karel Ančerl (who survived Auschwitz, and was later chief conductor of the Czech Philharmonic from 1950-68, and, after the Russian invasion of Czechoslovakia that year, chief conductor of the Toronto Symphony Orchestra from 1968-73). Apparently as the Nazis were deciding who to send instantly to the gas chambers on arrival, Ančerl was due to be chosen, but then Haas next to him had a coughing fit, and so he was selected instead. To mark the birth of this distinctive composer there’s an opportunity to select two works. First, here is the opening movement of the String Quartet No 2, which dates from 1925, and is one of the first major works Haas produced after his period of study with Janáček. It has the subtitle ‘From the Monkey Mountains’, an area of Moravia. In this work you can hear a lot of the influence of Janáček, but also of Moravian folk music and Haas’s emerging interest in jazz; originally Haas scored the final movement, ‘Wild Night’, for a percussionist alongside the quartet, though he cut out the part after early performances, a decision reversed in many recent recordings. I’ve chosen to consider the opening movement, ‘Landscape’. It’s a slowly evolving piece, soulful and lamenting, though the shifting textures allow for greater animation as the movement progresses. I find it (and indeed the whole quartet) powerful, almost monolithic, in its ‘solidity’ and intensity. It’s played on this audio-only recording by the Pavel Haas Quartet, and you’ll find it here: Haas: String Quartet No 2 (1st movement). Alongside it, I thought it would be poignant to hear a recording of the piece that featured on the Nazi propaganda film, Haas’s ‘Study for Strings’. This is his penultimate work, a short and often intense composition whose outer sections are full of cross-rhythms and busy agitation, while the central section is a slower, more melancholy adagio. I suspect that if you didn’t know the circumstances of its composition it would not necessarily seem so remarkable, but knowing the context makes it particularly haunting. Here again we’re in audio-only territory, in a recording made by the Prague Chamber Philharmonic conducted by the late Jiří Bělohlávek: Haas: Study for Strings
Hadley, Patrick (1899-1973)
Day 459: Kinder Scout (Time: 7 minutes)
Today (27/2/24), there’s an opportunity to mark the 125th anniversary of the birth of a scarcely-known composer, and to honour the occasion with a work that evokes a local landscape feature. So, Patrick Hadley (or Patrick Arthur Sheldon Hadley, in full) was born on 5th March 1899, or 125 years ago next Tuesday. I’d have to confess that I know very little about him or his music, so the interweb is doing most of the heavy lifting today. Hadley (1899-1973) is mostly known these days, if indeed he is known at all, as the composer of anthems for liturgical use, and perhaps too for shorter works for voice (accompanied by piano, small ensemble or occasionally full orchestra) that evoke the moods and sentiments associated with the English landscape. Referred to throughout his lifetime as Paddy, he was probably known for most of his life as a figure in the field of music education rather than composition, which he seems to have found difficult and time-consuming. Born into an upper-middle class family, his education was interrupted by the First World War, in which he was wounded just before the war’s end, losing his right leg below the knee. (His older brother was wounded at the same time, and died shortly afterwards.) His war wound seems to have knocked his confidence, but over the following decades he progressed via a B.Mus from Cambridge in 1922, followed by an MA in 1925, and in the same year he joined the staff of the Royal College of Music. In 1938 he became a Lecturer in Music at Cambridge, was elected Chair of Music there in 1946 and stayed in that post until retirement in 1962. He died just over a decade later, having suffered from cancer for several years. His music, if you ever get the chance to hear any more of it than today’s snippet, is very English and distinctly pastoral – you can hear the influence of the major figures in 20th century English music in his work, notably Vaughan Williams, Delius and Howells. There’s almost no trace of the sorts of influences from the avant-garde that were revolutionising music across Europe at the time. He drew quite passionately from the moods and atmospheres of the English landscape, particularly Norfolk, where he lived for much of his life, but also Derbyshire, where his mother’s family was from. His ‘master work’, by general consent, is the four-movement composition ‘The Trees So High’, for baritone soloist, chorus and orchestra, drawing on the Somerset folk song of the same name. However, the music I’ve picked for us to listen to today – and in fact the only reason why I’m taking this detour into the compositions of a figure who otherwise might pass us all by – is a much earlier work by Hadley, the tone poem ‘Kinder Scout’. Hadley holidayed regularly in the Peak District, and had a real affinity with the landscape of the Derbyshire hills. He wrote later that ‘they were the first real hills I ever saw, except for the South Downs in Sussex once as a child.’ The piece dates from 1923, when the composer was just 24, so it’s a product of Hadley’s student days. It was first performed by the Buxton Spa Orchestra that same year. As far as I can tell it’s the first piece for orchestra that he ever wrote. In my view this makes it really quite impressive. You can hear the fingerprints (can you hear fingerprints??) of the English composers I’ve mentioned already in this short piece, but it has a quiet, ruminative voice of its own too, I think, and one that develops as the music unfolds into something that reminds me a little of Richard Strauss in its use of orchestral horns, and of Sibelius in its evocation of the moods associated with landscape. It was recorded for the first time in 2019 by the BBC Philharmonic, conducted by Rumon Gamba, and as far as I know it’s the only version of the piece that you can get hold of. The work garnered some very affirmative reviews. Consequently that’s the recording I’ve chosen for us to listen to today. You’ll find it here: Hadley: Kinder Scout
Hahn, Reynaldo (1874-1947)
Day 22: ‘A Chloris’ (two versions) (Time: 3 minutes each)
Renaldo Hahn is a French composer of South American origin – he moved to Paris as a child – and his fame today rests on a selection of songs (he was himself an accomplished singer), though there is now a small handful of recordings of chamber works and orchestral pieces too, as a result of growing interest in recent years. Hahn’s personal life was a complex one – he appears to have been a closet homosexual who was occasionally given to making unpleasantly homophobic remarks. He formed a close friendship and working relationship with the writer Marcel Proust. Hahn wrote many songs about love, of which the selection for today (13/4/20) is probably the most performed. It was written in 1913, and appeared in a collection (20 Melodies, Book 2) in the early 1920s. Its exquisite tenderness seems to me to be meltingly beautiful. In fact, you get a special ‘buy one, get one free’ offer today, because I thought it would be interesting to compare/contrast a famous recording, employing the conventional mezzo-soprano voice, with a counter-tenor version of the song. So, here is the classic recording with Susan Graham, accompanied by Roger Vignoles: Reynaldo Hahn – ‘A Chloris’ and, on the other hand, here is Philippe Jaroussky, accompanied by David Kadouch: ‘A Chloris’
Day 502: Piano Quintet in F-sharp minor (Time: 30 minutes)
Today (9/8/24), it’s the 150th anniversary of the birth of a composer: Reynaldo Hahn was born on 9th August 1874, which means he’s 150 years old (if you see what I mean) this very day. In the relatively early days of this playlist, back on Day 22, I chose a song by Hahn – actually, the most famous (and beautiful) song by Hahn, ‘A Chloris’ – but nothing else by him has appeared on this list since. He’s a lovely composer, but perhaps one whose works, except in the field of vocal music, have tended to fall off the radar of most orchestras, chamber ensembles or pianists. Like many other composers who straddled the 19th/20th centuries, he did not ‘move with the times’, and so his work has a 19th century ‘Belle Époque’ feel, even the stuff he was writing after the 2nd world war. Hahn - Reynaldo Hahn de Echenagucia if we’re filling in official forms – was the son of Carlos (actually ‘Karl’ at birth) Hahn, who came from a family of Jewish migrants who settled in Venezuela in the mid-19th century, and Elena de Echenagucia, a Catholic woman of Spanish descent. Reynaldo was actually the baby of the family – the last of twelve children. The family moved from Venezuela to France when Reynaldo was seven, and settled in Paris. Hahn’s musical and linguistic skills were evident from early on, and he had access to the familiar roll-call of famous names at the Paris Conservatoire as teachers: Dubois, Gounod, Massenet, Saint-Saëns. He was popular in the salons of the time, and evidently very attractive to both men and women. His two closest relationships were with the writer Marcel Proust, with whom he had a short passionate affair followed by several decades of close friendship, and the actress Sarah Bernhardt, about whom he wrote a biographical tribute after her death in the 1920s. One of the ways in which Hahn’s music has been put down over the years has been to regard him as ‘a mere salon composer’, writing music which is sensitive and charming but relatively insubstantial. This is, in my opinion, nonsense, and confuses beauty with superficiality. In his mature years, Hahn had great success as an opera conductor, particularly in the works of Mozart, his musical idol. Though I’m making no claims for equality here, I think there’s a ‘Mozartian’ quality to Hahn’s music, a fluency and grace that gives the illusion of effortlessness. Hahn’s great claim to fame, historically, is as a song-writer – he wrote over 100 songs, starting as a teenager and still going in 1947, the year of his death. He was also an opera and operetta composer, with 16 full-length scores to his name, including ‘Mozart’, which was wildly successful in the 1920s, and in which quotations from Mozart’s work were stitched together with music by Hahn ‘in the style of Mozart’, so successfully that critics were often unable to locate the joins. I wondered what to choose to shed a little more light on this still neglected composer, and toyed with the idea of exploring the quirkily-scored pastiche of 18th century dances, ‘Le Bal de Beatrice d’Este’ (easy to find on YouTube, but no videos of top class performances), but instead I’ve gone for some of Hahn’s chamber music, which really is a neglected strand of his output. There’s a generous amount of short, ‘poetic’ stuff that might have got an airing at fashionable pre-First World War salons, but later in life he wrote some more extensive pieces. There are two string quartets he wrote during the Second World War, a Piano Quartet from just after it, but a couple of decades earlier there’s also a Piano Quintet in F# Minor, which he started composing towards the end of the First World War (in which Hahn volunteered to join the army, and as a result of which he was given the Croix de Guerre and appointed to the Legion of Honour), completed in 1921, and which had its first performance the following year. It’s a lively and often sparkling work, even if it’s not (its minor key notwithstanding) turbulent or tragic. You can hear traces of other composers in it (Fauré most obviously, though there’s a geniality and almost an ‘innocence’ to the writing that often puts me in mind of Dvorák), and the work has that very French ‘cyclic’ quality, in which music from the first and second movements makes a reappearance in the third movement finale, a technique borrowed most obviously from the (Belgian, not French) Cesar Franck. The first movement starts ‘Molto agitato e con fuoco’, which generates the requisite amount of fiery passion, though the ‘dolce, amoroso’ second theme offsets this beautifully. The second movement (‘Andante, non troppo lento’) is a more ‘inward’ thing, grave, dignified, with what’s surely a conscious echo of Fauré’s ‘Élégie’, though here too the mood shifts, with a middle section that feels rustic and wistful. The last movement is both scherzo and finale in one, and themes from the two previous movements make an appearance here, though transformed from their original guises. There’s a bit of playful teasing – what feels like the recapitulation, where the movement’s opening idea is reintroduced, turns out to be in the ‘wrong’ key, so that we have to re-recapitulate on the right track – but mostly what you get in this finale is the sort of fuss-free charm for which Hahn’s songs are famous. Overall, it’s a work that isn’t going to revolutionise anything, but, as the liner notes to my CD copy of this music point out, ‘How such captivating music as Hahn’s chamber works for piano and strings has remained generally unknown is a mystery.’ As for a performance, there’s a video on YouTube of a bright and lively performance of the first two movements only by the French ensemble Quatuor Tchalik with pianist Dania Tchalik, but as (I assume) people would prefer to hear the whole thing performed by the same musicians throughout, I’ve gone instead for this slightly more muffled-sounding performance from South Korea, in which the performers are Arah Shin and Svetlin Roussev on violins, Ralph Szigeti on viola, Doo-Min Kim on cello and Jinsang Lee on piano. You’ll find their recording here: Hahn: Piano Quintet
Hamerik, Asger (1843-1923)
Day 396: Symphony No 6 (Time: 29 minutes)
July 13th marked the 100th anniversary of the death of Asger Hamerik, an event, I think, marked by a notable absence of comment on any of our classical music stations or in any music publications, and so today (14/7/23), I want to change that - it seems to me to be a great pity, because there’s a lot to enjoy in this man’s writing. Hamerik (1843-1923) was actually born Asger Hammerich (in the German fashion) near Copenhagen, to a prosperous middle-class family. His father was Professor of Theology at the city’s university. He had the good fortune to be related to both of Denmark’s then leading composers, Niels Gade and JPE Hartmann, and he had private lessons in composition from both of them. However, he seems to have been a rather restless soul, and spent much of his teens and twenties travelling and studying with leading musical figures in Germany and France. In Germany he was a pupil of Hans von Bulow, but their contact was disrupted by the war between Germany and Denmark over the territory of Schleswig-Holstein in 1864, which led to Hammerich’s departure from Germany and also his decision to change his name to its more conventionally Nordic spelling, Hamerik. His travels then took him to France, where for four years he studied and worked with Berlioz. However, the latter’s death in 1869 set Hamerik off on his travels again, initially to Italy, but then, significantly, to the USA, where he was headhunted as Director of the newly-established Peabody Institute in Baltimore. Having an orchestra, a choir and a concert hall with which to do pretty much what he wanted was clearly to Hamerik’s taste, and after his wanderings he spent the years 1871-98 in that role. It was here that most of his significant compositions were produced. His early American works harked back to his Nordic roots – five suites based on Scandinavian folk tunes. However, although he’d written a symphony as a teenager (a piece subsequently lost) in his thirties he now began a series of seven symphonies which are, in large measure, the pieces by which Hamerik is known today – that is, if he is known at all. These works are, if one is being rigorous in one’s evaluation, fairly uneven in quality, and given to the sort of sprawl that is characteristic of mid/late 19th century music. The pieces all have French sub-titles, in the manner of Berwald (see Day 208 for his ‘Sinfonie Singuliere’). Thus, his symphonies are, in order, subtitled ‘Poétique’, ‘Tragique’, ‘Lyrique’, ‘Majestueuse’, ‘Sérieuse’, ‘Spirituelle’, before (on his eventual return to Denmark in 1900) he produced his final version of his last symphony, the ‘Korsymfoni’ for soprano, choir and orchestra. The return to Denmark seems in effect to have signalled his retirement – he wrote virtually nothing in the final 20 years of his life. There are only 41 works given opus numbers in his catalogue, and the symphonies form the major thread throughout his composing life. I think it would be fair to say that their titles bear relatively little resemblance to the music within each work, and to listen to (I have, maybe so that you don’t need to!) they’re pleasant enough without being startling. However, I think his Symphony No 6 (the ‘Spirituelle’) is a very significant cut above the rest, and really deserves a wider audience. He wrote it in 1897, just before his tenure in Baltimore came to an end, and it’s scored for strings only (some of the earlier symphonies have much denser orchestration) for the very pragmatic reason that when he was composing it the brass and woodwind sections of his orchestra were on strike! It seems to me that this constraint worked in Hamerik’s favour, in that he was forced to focus his ideas into a much tauter mould. The reviewer in the Gramophone magazine, considering a recorded set of all seven symphonies, wrote ‘The Sixth for strings alone, however, is an unqualified masterpiece, exalted and dignified in tone, a delight to play and listen to.’ It’s a sentiment I couldn’t agree with more. In some ways it has the feel of a string serenade – its recurring opening motif may put you in mind of Tchaikovsky’s Serenade for Strings – but the handling of its musical ideas is more ‘symphonic’, evolving with some rigour. The symphony has four movements, opening with a fanfare-like descending scale before the first movement proper gets under way. The second movement juxtaposes a dramatic initial theme with a second idea of real lyricism. The third movement is a theme and variations, before we reach a festive finale. This is extrovert music, I think, and worth its place on many more concert programmes than is currently the case. As for a performance, there’s one video recording alongside the various audio-only ones, and it’s by the Ostrobothnian Chamber Orchestra, conducted by that well-known figure in British music circles, Sakari Oramo. I realise that in posting the symphony in its entirety, I’m breaking my self-imposed ’40 minute rule’ for the Tuesday + Friday postings, but I think this is a piece that deserves to be heard whole. You’ll find it here: Hamerik: Symphony No 6
Handel, George Frideric (1685-1759)
Day 5: ‘Gentle Morpheus’ (from ‘Alceste’) (Time: 8 minutes)
Today (27/3/20), a first appearance on this list for the adopted British composer George Frideric Handel. Along with Bach, Handel is, for most critics, the standout composer of the Baroque period. In fact the contrast with Bach is very striking – in many ways Handel seems the more ‘modern’ of the two. His writing for the voice, in particular, can often sound direct and intense in ways that cut through the formulaic conventions of Baroque technique. His music for the masque ‘Alceste’ dates from his maturity, though ironically it was never performed in his lifetime. Martin suggests that we listen to the pure soprano voice of the inestimable Emma Kirkby, singing the haunting ‘Gentle Morpheus’ from this work, accompanied by the Academy of Ancient Music, conducted by Christopher Hogwood. You will find it here: Handel – ‘Gentle Morpheus’ (from ‘Alceste’)
Day 23: ‘Eternal Source of Light Divine’ (from ‘Birthday Ode for Queen Anne’) (Time: 3 minutes)
Today (14/4/20), a suggestion for some more Handel, this time an offering from Malcolm, and it features the formidable double act of soprano Kathleen Battle and trumpeter Wynton Marsalis, with the Orchestra of St Luke’s, conducted by John Nelson, in Handel’s ‘Eternal Source of Light Divine’, from the Birthday Ode for Queen Anne. This is a relatively early work, dating from 1713, and written not just for the Queen’s birthday, but also (Handel was, we must assume, something of a politician) to celebrate the Treaty of Utrecht, which ended the War of the Spanish Succession. Handel’s diplomacy obviously worked – as a result Queen Anne gave him a ‘pension’ of £200 a year for life! The opening section is for female voice, accompanied by a solo trumpet. As Malcolm very simply puts it: ‘More light!’ You’ll find it here: Handel – ‘Eternal Source of Light Divine’ (from ‘Birthday Ode for Queen Anne’)
Day 298: Zadok the Priest (Coronation Anthem No 1) (Time: 6 minutes)
Today (3/6/22), in keeping with the celebratory mood of the moment during the Queen’s Platinum Jubilee weekend, we have some music with royal connections, and an old favourite of, I suspect, just about everybody. I’m quite surprised that Handel’s music has featured only twice before on this list (see Days 5 and 23), though less surprised to find that those selections, like today’s, showcase music for the human voice – though Handel’s orchestral, chamber and instrumental music is vivid and engaging stuff, it’s his ability to communicate via singing that is, I think, his special gift. The process by which the German Georg Friederich Händel metamorphosed into the British George Frideric Handel was a slow and gradual one, but his association with a range of public events in this country in the early 18th century evidently played a part in his ‘adoption’ as a ‘British’ composer. At the end of 1710 he came to London (and had a great success with an early opera, ‘Rinaldo’) and by 1712 he had decided to settle over here. Over the years that followed, he was fortuitously placed not just to become commercially successful as a result of the almost insatiable thirst of London audiences for opera in the Italian style. He also created the ceremonial musical events that followed on from the fact that in 1715 the man who had briefly been his employer as Elector of Hanover became King George I, particularly after performances of the ‘Water Music’ in 1717 had set the seal on Handel’s reconciliation with the king. He had several wealthy patrons, but none more so than George and his son George II. There is of course far more to his almost 50 years spent in this country than just public pieces written in honour of British monarchs, but they show just how embedded Handel’s music became in the ceremonial life of both Stuart and Hanoverian monarchies. Handel became a naturalised British subject in 1727, one of George I’s last acts before his death. Handel’s first public musical statement after that event was to write four anthems for the coronation of George II and his wife Queen Caroline later that year. Handel was, evidently, immensely capable when it came to writing music for great occasions, and for the coronation of George II he seems to have had at his disposal an orchestra of over 150 players and a choir of around 100. These Coronation Anthems are extrovert works, full of large gestures and dramatic contrasts, designed to fill Westminster Abbey and have a suitably compelling impact on their listeners. The words of the anthem ‘Zadok the Priest’, taken from 1 Kings 1:38-40, concerning the coronation of King Solomon at the death of his father David, have been used at every English coronation since the time of King Edgar (‘the Peaceful’), who ruled from 959-975, though his coronation occurred only in 973. The music Handel wrote has been used at every coronation since 1727, and it is easy to hear why. This is one of the most popular, thrilling and dramatic short pieces of choral music in the repertoire, from the extended introduction to the triumphal ‘Allelujah!’ with which it ends. The 22 bars of the instrumental introduction generate an extraordinary sense of anticipation, fulfilled in the choir’s powerful utterance, ‘Zadok the priest and Nathan the prophet anointed Solomon King’, delivered in a homophonic declamation by the whole choir. The middle section ‘And all the people rejoiced and said:’ offers a more dance-like texture, still essentially homophonic and syllabic (that is, one note per syllable), ending on the anticipatory dominant chord (‘said’) that will usher us headlong into the final section. This last part is one of dramatic contrasts. The subjunctive ‘God save the King! Long live the King! God save the King!’ is delivered homophonically again, all four voices solidly as one; the subsequent ‘May the King live for ever!’ is repeated four times, consolidated each time by the fact that extra voices are added, from the first utterance just by altos, to the second for altos and tenors, to the third in which basses are added too, until the final version brings in sopranos as well. Contrasting with this, the reiterated ‘Amen! Amen! Allelujah! Amen!’ gives each part in turn extended semiquaver runs on ‘Amen!’ before the tempo slows for the final, emphatic ‘Allelujah!’. There are, of course, many different ways of performing this piece, from the sort of ‘cast of thousands’ massed Albert Hall-style approach to something more agile and wiry, using much smaller forces and period instruments. You can find many examples of both approaches on YouTube if you don’t find the version I’ve chosen to your taste. However, the video recording I’ve settled on is bright and lively, largely I think because of its cast of young voices. It’s a performance by members of the Riga Cathedral Choir School and the Sinfonietta Riga chamber orchestra, conducted by Mārtiņš Klišāns. You’ll find it here: Handel: Zadok the Priest (Coronation Anthem No 1)
Hanson, Howard (1896-1981)
Day 166: Symphony No 2, ‘The Romantic’ (Time: 30 minutes)
Today’s instalment comes courtesy of suggestions from Calgary, Canada, from where Andrew Weaver, whose superpower is invisibility (at least as far as this list is concerned) has written to me with a list of pieces that we might feature, taking a north American view of the development of 20th century music. One of those compositions fits perfectly with our recent commemorative theme. 40 years ago today (26/2/21), the great American symphonist Howard Hanson died at the age of 84. Hanson (1896-1981) has been described as a New Romantic composer. I should make it clear here that we’re not talking ‘New Romantic’ in the sense of Culture Club, Duran Duran or even Adam and the Ants. This is ‘New Romanticism’ of the early-to-mid 20th century, a direct reaction against the modernist fashions in music that dominated the period during and after the first world war. Hanson was born in Nebraska to Swedish immigrant parents, and there’s something of both the wide open spaces of the American Midwest and an empathetic link with Scandinavian symphonists like Sibelius in Hanson’s music. Although he spent some time studying in Europe after winning the American Academy’s ‘Prix de Rome’ in the early 1920s, Hanson really found his voice in the succeeding decades whilst based in Rochester, in upstate New York, where he became director of the new Eastman School of Music at Rochester University for 40 years. He has an exceptional reputation as a musical educator, from presenting weekly radio programmes on Western music to weeks of free festivals of music held annually in Rochester and broadcast nationally. Andrew has sent me some useful quotations from Robert Layton’s ‘A Companion to the Symphony’: ‘The first American composer to write entirely in [the 20th] century and to create a substantial body of symphonies was Howard Hanson … whose music was championed by Serge Koussevitzky with the Boston Symphony Orchestra. An unabashed romantic, Hanson was for many years thoroughly out of fashion with the American musical establishment, but [the later 20th century has] seen a gradual reawakening of interest in his work, of which the early scores especially pay homage to his Swedish ancestry... In all, Hanson produced seven symphonies; the ’Nordic’ first in 1924, the final choral ’Sea Symphony’ shortly before his death. Of these, the ‘Romantic’ Symphony (No. 2) is quite possibly the most performed of all American symphonies, for though it rarely appears on the programmes of American major orchestras, it has long been a great favourite with lesser ensembles, such as amateur and youth orchestras, of which there are many.’ To that, I’d like to add an illuminating quotation from Hanson himself, who wrote of his 2nd Symphony: ‘It was a genuine expression of romanticism and a protest against the growing Schoenbergism of the time – the cold music – and I wanted to write something that was warm and young, vigorous and youthful.’ Hanson’s Symphony No 2 is in three movements, and was commissioned by the Boston Symphony Orchestra for its 50th anniversary season in 1930. To quote again from Robert Layton’s book: ‘The first movement’s slow introduction is based on a reiterated rising three-note figure that builds to a climax and subsides, after which a horn fanfare leads into the movement’s principal descending theme, heard first from the brass. After an extended transition, a tenderly nostalgic and yearning second theme appears in the strings, which is ultimately to dominate the entire symphony. This theme is truly ‘Romantic’ in character, even a bit sentimental, and if one is to accept the work one must surrender to it for, once heard, it tends to remain in one’s consciousness, particularly as the composer brings it back in the remaining two movements, each time with greater emphasis. A gentle woodwind theme dominates the second movement, and two horn themes of American Indian character animate the Finale, the second over vigorous ostinato string pizzicati.’ To which I’d merely add that if you are at all familiar with the late 70s sci-fi horror film ‘Alien’, you will know this symphony much better than you might otherwise think. Andrew’s preferred YouTube performance is by the St Louis Symphony Orchestra conducted by Leonard Slatkin, even though we both recognise that there’s a slight break in the recording about 7 minutes into the piece, and the transition from the first to the second movement is similarly disrupted. You’ll find the performance here: Hanson: Symphony No 2 ('The Romantic')
Day 235: Elegy to the Memory of my Friend, Serge Koussevitzky (Time: 13 minutes)
In two days from now, it will be 125 years exactly since the birth of another great American symphonist, Howard Hanson. Hanson (1896-1981) has featured once before on this list, on Day 166 (see above), when we encountered what is probably his most famous and popular work, his Symphony No 2. I wrote at some length then about Hanson's life and attitudes to music, so please refer back to that posting for more information. Today (26/10/21) I want to consider one of Hanson's shorter orchestral works, his ‘Elegy to the Memory of my Friend, Serge Koussevitzky’, which he wrote in 1955, and which received its first performance the following year. Koussevitzky (1874-1951) was one of the foremost conductors and commissioners of new work of the 20th century. He was Principal Conductor of the Boston Symphony Orchestra from 1924-49, during which time he was known as a great champion of contemporary music. Amongst other works, he premiered Ravel's orchestration of Mussorgsky's ‘Pictures at an Exhibition’, Prokofiev's 2nd and 4th Symphonies, Bartók's Concerto for Orchestra, Copland's ‘Appalachian Spring’ Suite and Barber's ‘Knoxville: Summer of 1915’. For the Boston Symphony Orchestra's 50th anniversary season in 1931 he commissioned works such as Copland's ‘Ode’, Hindemith's Concert Music for Brass and Strings and Stravinsky's Symphony of Psalms. Not a bad record, I think! Koussevitzky had a particularly close relationship with Howard Hanson. His Symphony No 2 was composed at Koussevitzky's request, and the conductor also subsequently gave the first performances of Hanson’s 3rd and 4th Symphonies and his Piano Concerto, amongst other works. After Koussevitzky's death, Hanson was commissioned by the Boston Symphony Orchestra and the Koussevitzky Foundation to write a commemorative work to honour the conductor, to coincide with the orchestra's 75th anniversary. It’s a broad paced and expansive piece of music, solemn without being maudlin. It’s shaped in a single arc of music, ranging from quiet introspection to something more full-blooded and noble. For a recording (audio only, I’m afraid) I’ve selected this fine performance by the Seattle Symphony Orchestra under the conductor Gerard Schwarz. You’ll find it here: Hanson: Elegy to the Memory of my Friend, Serge Koussevitzky.
Harris, Roy (1898-1979)
Day 179: Symphony No 3 (Time: 19 minutes)
You may recall Andrew Weaver’s choice of Howard Hanson’s Symphony No 2 earlier this year; the two symphonies on the menu this week confirm Andrew’s interest in what one might call ‘20th century romanticism’ in American music – compositions which are essentially tonal, melodic, and full of the wide-open spaces of the American landscape. Today (13/4/21), the composer in question is Roy Harris (1898-1979). Andrew has written, reminding me of the comments made about Harris by Alex Ross (in his excellent book about 20th century music, ‘The Rest is Noise’), which I’m happy to quote in full at this point: “[Harris’s] background might have been dreamed up by Great American Composer central casting: he was born in the oil-boom town of Chandler, Oklahoma, in a log cabin, no less, on Lincoln’s birthday. Time further noted that the log cabin had been ‘hewed by hand’ and that the young composer had driven a truck. The implication was that Harris was no classical sissy or bourgeois darling. The work that won Harris nationwide attention was his Third Symphony of 1939—an all-American hymn and dance for orchestra in which strings declaim orations in broad, open-ended lines, brass chant and whoop like cowboys in the galleries, and timpani stamp out strong beats in the middle of the bar. Such a big-shouldered sound met everyone’s expectations of what a true-blue American symphony should be. When Toscanini deigned to conduct the piece in 1940, the owner of the Pittsburgh Pirates wrote to the composer: ‘If I had pitchers who would pitch as strongly as you do in your Symphony, my worries would be over’.” To portray Harris as in some way true to the roots of folksy Americana is a fair comment, I guess, though (like almost everyone else in American 20th century music) he also went to Paris to study with Nadia Boulanger, so there’s a bit of ‘old world’ sophistication to go with the distinctively American vitality we get here. Harris himself made an interesting remark: ‘Let’s face it, my Third Symphony happened to come along when it was needed.’ Of this comment, my CD liner note says: ‘It came along in 1939, assured, instantly and forcefully intelligible, exuberant with physical energy and aflame with ethical aspiration, at a point when America was ready for an unmistakeably American symphony.’ American novelists of the past 120 years have been in various ways obsessed with writing ‘The Great American Novel’. Whilst composers haven’t necessarily had the same yearning to capture the varied moods of a continent in a single piece of music, I reckon that if you did want to pin down ‘The Great American Symphony’, there are probably two Third Symphonies at the front of the queue: Copland’s (one day very soon, folks) and this one from Roy Harris. For me, the greatness of this music lies in the way it conveys an immense breadth of feeling in an essentially pared-down and focused way: the 19 minutes of this one-movement work seem to contain a whole world. As is the case with many other iconic American works, Harris’s Symphony No 3 is strongly associated with Leonard Bernstein, and it’s his live recording of the work with the New York Philharmonic that I’ve chosen for us to listen to. You’ll find it here: Harris: Symphony No 3
Harris, William Henry (1883-1973)
Day 4: ‘Bring Us, O Lord God’ (Time: 4 minutes)
A choice from Malcolm today (26/3/20), a radiant performance by the immaculate vocal group VOCES8 of Sir William Henry Harris’s setting of ‘Bring Us, O Lord God’, poetry by the early 17th century Metaphysical poet John Donne, whose verse has that astonishing blend of virtuosity and yet deep sincerity. Harris was known in his time primarily as a choral trainer and conductor, though nowadays it’s his compositions for Anglican liturgy, along with compositions for organ, that maintain his place in music history. You can find other more traditional performances of the piece on YouTube, but you’ll find Malcolm’s choice here: William Henry Harris – ‘Bring Us, O Lord God’
Haydn, Joseph (1732-1809)
Day 15: Symphony No 26 (‘Lamentation’) (Time: 18 minutes)
There will be a number of occasions during the construction of this playlist when I hope I will be indulged sufficiently to home in regularly on the work of my favourite composers. Of those, Haydn is probably the one who most consistently brings me joy and happiness. Others are more ‘perfect’ (Bach) or more ‘heroic’ (Beethoven) or more in touch with matters of life and death (Schubert) or more able to marry heart and head (Brahms), but from Haydn’s music there is a continuous flow of contentment which is balm to the soul. And, moving away from Pseuds’ Corner(!), today (6/4/20), given that we’re now in Holy Week 2020, it seems apt to suggest Haydn’s Symphony No 26, known as the ‘Lamentation’. It’s relatively early Haydn, as the numbering would suggest, and it was written for Easter Week in the late 1760s. It gets its title because the second theme in the first movement (taken up again in the following slow movement) quotes a plainsong chant associated with Jesus’ Passion. The symphony is close to my heart not just because of its religious significance, but because Haydn was the composer who got me hooked on ‘classical music’ as an 11- or 12-year-old, and collecting the complete symphonies on LP was one of the rather nerdy joys of my adolescence. (Sad, eh?) The recording I’ve chosen, by the Basel Chamber Orchestra under Giovanni Antonini, is a specially vivid one, I think, and you’ll find it here: Haydn – Symphony No 26 (‘Lamentation’)
Day 46: String Quartet in D, Op 76 No 5 (2nd movement) (Time: 7 minutes)
Time for some more Haydn today (7/5/20), for no reason other than his music is joyful and restorative, and even here, in the extract I’ve picked, where there’s a kind of solemnly dignified melancholy, I can’t help feeling that you come away from listening to this in a wholly better state than before. The piece is the slow movement (marked ‘Largo: Cantabile e Mesto’ – roughly ‘slow and stately: song-like and solemn’) of the String Quartet Op 76 No 5. The six quartets that make up the Op 76 set are (subjective value judgment coming up) his greatest collective set of chamber works. The slow movements of all of them reach places that give the lie to the idea of Haydn as a composer of essentially polite and genteel music for the upper classes of central Europe (and later, of London). I could have picked the slow movement from any one of the six and been happy to say ‘Listen to this – Haydn being good for your soul!’. I’ve gone for the second movement of the Op 76 No 5 quartet simply because of its expression of tenderness and comfort. There are lots of performances on YouTube, including a complete one by the Lindsays (for those with memories of them playing this repertoire over several decades here in Sheffield), but the best free-standing recording of this single movement that I’ve found is from the period-instrument quartet Quatuor Mosaiques, and you’ll find it here: Haydn – String Quartet Op 76 No 5 (2nd movement)
Day 78: String Quartet in Eb, Op 33 No 2 (4th movement) (Time: 4 minutes) and Symphony No 45 in F# Minor (4th movement) (7 minutes)
I thought today (8/6/20) it would be a good thing to encounter some more Haydn. If you’ve been following these emails rather than just deleting them (J), you’ll know that Haydn is one of my obsessions. But one aspect of his work that’s regularly referred to – his ‘wit’ – seems to me to need a bit more unpicking, given that 21st century ideas of what ‘wit’ is have shifted somewhat from the late 18th century. (Apologies if you’re aware of all this – just skip the next bit!) To the 18th century mind ‘wit’ wasn’t just ‘humour’ (though Haydn can do ‘laugh out loud funny’ too) but ‘cleverness’, the adroit manipulation of skills to achieve an intellectually as well as emotionally satisfying effect. Haydn’s work is full of the whole range of witty effects, from the imitation of animals (bears and hens in Symphonies 82/83) to mockery of pompous stereotypes (philosophers and schoolmasters in Symphonies 22/55) to comic ‘mistakes’ with tuning (the ‘false start’ in the last movement of Symphony 60) to the more ‘serious’ applications of wit, such as the third movement of Symphony 47 in which the music is played first ‘forwards’ and then ‘backwards’ in a palindromic way. And all that is just from the symphonies – there’s similar invention in the quartets, piano trios, piano sonatas, and so on. Pretty much anything that Beethoven did by way of innovation in the symphony (apart from singing!), Haydn got there first. So, today, I have two items for you (adding up to nowhere near 15 minutes!), to show ‘laugh out loud’ funny, and then to show ‘wit’ in the service of a serious point. ‘Laugh out loud’ wit – Here are (is?) the Endellion String Quartet playing the last movement of Haydn’s String Quartet in Eb, Op 33 No 2. If you don’t already know the ending, I’m confident that you won’t know when it’s over. You’ll find it here: Haydn – String Quartet Op 33 No 2 (4th movement) ‘Serious’ wit – Haydn wrote his Symphony No 45 in 1772, when working for Prince Nikolaus Esterhazy. The Esterhazys had a very grand summer palace at Eszterhaza in the (then) very isolated plains of rural Hungary, and it was the convention that Prince Nicolaus’ whole court (including all his musicians) would spend the summer there. In this year, the stay went on and on, and everyone concerned was missing their families back in Eisenstadt in Austria. Haydn used this symphony to drop a not very subtle but equally not directly offensive hint to the prince that people had had enough. So, the Symphony No 45 is pretty conventional (though in the very unusual key of F# Minor) until the last movement, which starts in an expected way, but is then derailed in ways you can see in the video clip I’ve chosen. You’ll find the performance by the ensemble Concerto Classic, Vienna, directed by Leopold Hager, here: Haydn – Symphony No 45 (4th movement)
Day 127: String Quartet in G, Op 77 No 1 (Time: 24 minutes)
Today (13/10/20), it’s the turn of Haydn’s String Quartet in G, Op 77 No 1. Haydn has featured several times on the playlist before (see Days 15, 46 and 78), so there’s already extensive evidence of my mild obsession with his music, and my contention that his compositions are amongst the most life-affirming and restorative in the whole canon of classical music… so I won’t labour the point yet again! Haydn is familiarly known as ‘the Father of the String Quartet’ – which is only a slight distortion of the truth. That is, other composers of the later 18th century were writing string quartets, some of them before Haydn started, but Haydn’s output, from the early 1760s to the final incomplete quartet he wrote in 1803, raised what had been a rather inconsequential, serenade-type form into the pinnacle of classical elegance and formal complexity. The two quartets which are listed as Haydn’s Op 77 date from 1799, and are known as the ‘Lobkowitz’ Quartets, after Joseph von Lobkowitz, the 7th Prince of the House of Lobkowitz, who is probably most renowned today as one of the main patrons of Beethoven for much of his life in Vienna. (Beethoven dedicated his 3rd, 5th and 6th Symphonies to Lobkowitz, not to mention the six String Quartets, Op 18, which Lobkowitz had commissioned. It’s interesting, in a ‘changing of the guard’ sort of way, that Lobkowitz requested a set of six quartets from both Haydn and Beethoven at the same time. With hindsight, it feels like there’s a very definite handing on of the torch at this point.) Haydn only managed to complete two of the six quartets that Lobkowitz commissioned, due to his increasing ill health, though also because his focus was more on choral music at that time, writing his oratorio ‘The Seasons’. The quartet Op 77 No 1 opens with a march-like movement, making great use of ‘dialogues’ between first and second violins, and also between the first violin and the cello – the cello’s part in this quartet is very independent, and not just there to hold down the bass line. For me, it is the second movement that is the high point of the quartet – a movement that is a mix of sonata form (a topic for another day!), variation and passacaglia, in which the initial musical motif is present almost throughout. The third movement is labelled ‘Minuet’, but it’s more like the sort of ‘scherzo’ movement that would be typical of Beethoven, contrasted with a Trio section that’s like a kind of manic peasant dance. The final movement also has a pretty rustic feel, and it’s alive throughout with Haydn’s characteristic rhythmic wit. It’s a tribute to Haydn’s creative imagination even at this late stage in his career that everything in the movement grows from the first four bars of music. The recording I’ve chosen is by the award-winning Parker Quartet (not, in case you were wondering, named after me…), and you’ll find it here: Haydn: String Quartet in G, Op 77 No 1
Day 158: String Quartet in D, Op 64 No 5 (‘The Lark’) (Time: 18 minutes)
In the second of this week’s instalments during ‘Lark Week’, today (29/1/21), it’s time (when is it ever not?) to return to Haydn. Quite a number of Haydn's string quartets have acquired nicknames, although as far as I know, Haydn himself is not responsible for any of them. These vary from the fanciful (‘The Frog’, Op 50 No 6, because allegedly the finale has repeated patterns that sound like the croaking of frogs) to the more literal (‘The Emperor’, Op 76 No 3, because its slow movement is a set of variations on the ‘Kaiser’-hymn that became the German national anthem). Haydn's String Quartet in D, Op 64 No 5, is known as ‘The Lark’ because of the soaring first violin line in the opening movement. It’s not as obviously ‘larky’ as the birdsong on the Vaughan Williams we heard last time out, but you can at least hear what Haydn's initial audiences were getting at. This is music of Haydn’s maturity. During Haydn’s long years in the service of the Esterhazy household, where he worked from 1761-90, generating a veritable production line of symphonies, piano sonatas, piano trios, operas, divertimenti and dozens of chamber pieces for his employer, Prince Nikolaus's favourite instrument, the rather weird baryton (you’ll hear it here sometime soon!), there are relatively few string quartets until close to the end of his employment there. There’s a set of six, Op 20, published in 1772, and another set of six, Op 33, from 1781, but only in the late 1780s did Haydn focus on the genre in a major way. Partly this is a consequence of his increasing fame throughout Europe, when his music began to be published and played to such an extent that he was by 1790 the most famous composer across the whole continent, and his string quartets were in great demand. The six quartets Op 64 were written in 1790 and published the following year. There is some evidence that their first performances came when Haydn was persuaded (for a large fee) to visit London. This suggests that these are amongst the first quartets Haydn wrote for public performance – that is, in a concert hall before a paying public, as opposed to on some aristocratic estate for family members and guests. Haydn's ‘Lark’ quartet is a largely serene affair. The soaring main theme of the first movement has an innocent song-like quality, though that doesn’t stop Haydn engaging in some much more complex key changes as the movement unfolds. The slow second movement is, I think, one of Haydn’s loveliest. In form it’s very simple – two sections in A Major enclosing a more urgent middle section in A Minor – but what makes it so beautiful for me is the way the first violin ‘sings’ throughout in an almost unbroken stream. The third movement is a typically rough-and-ready sounding Minuet, and to conclude there’s one of Haydn’s dashing and dynamic ‘perpetual motion’ finales. As for a performance, there are a number on YouTube that would get the thumbs-up from me, but I’ve gone for one by the Jerusalem Quartet, given on their USA concert tour in 2017. You’ll find it here: Haydn: String Quartet in D, Op 64 No 5 ('The Lark')
Day 219: Piano Trio in C, Hob XV:21 (Time: 14 minutes)
Next month here in Sheffield, the award-winning Leonore Piano Trio (three performers from Ensemble 360 who’ve formed an independent sub-group within the Ensemble) are starting a new series of concerts linking a Romantic-era piano trio with a trio by Haydn. From this programme, I want to consider my piece for today (31/8/21), Haydn’s Piano Trio in C, Hob XV:21, otherwise known sometimes as the Piano Trio No 35. The nomenclature might be initially a bit off-putting. Anthony van Hoboken was a Dutch musicologist, whose life work was the cataloguing of all of Haydn’s compositions. He sorted the works according to genre, and so category 15 details all (well, almost all) the trios for piano with accompaniment by violin (or flute) and cello. That accounts for the ‘Hob XV’ bit of the work’s title. Then, in Hoboken’s listing, the C Major trio was No 21. What makes this more challenging is that yet another Haydn authority, an American called HC Robbins Landon, has also catalogued the works. His numbering for the piano trios is strictly chronological (which makes some sense), and so in Robbins Landon’s numbering, the C Major trio is No 35. Now, I suspect not many of you wanted to know all that, but it might help you to make sense of how Haydn’s piano trios are referred to if you’re ever stuck on a rainy Sunday afternoon with nothing else to do. Haydn, as well as being known as the clichéd ‘Father of the Symphony’ and ‘Father of the String Quartet’ is also, for what it’s worth, ‘Father of the Piano Trio’. His 44 extant piano trios form the biggest collection by a mainstream composer as the genre developed its familiar conventions in the late 18th century. In practice, the piano trio was a much gentler, less ‘heavyweight’ affair than the string quartet. Where quartets exploited a dense four-part texture and complexities of formal construction, piano trios were generally less intellectual, more concerned with making an agreeable noise, and more easily and loosely constructed. They were often written with an eye for the amateur market: a none-too-taxing piano part, and often simply supportive roles for violin and cello. (It took Mozart’s late piano trios and especially the trios of Beethoven to give the instruments more equal status, and Beethoven and Schubert’s trios to give the genre it first epic masterworks.) The Piano Trio in C, Hob XV:21, dates from Haydn’s second visit to London, in 1794-5, so this is mature stuff. It’s a particularly happy work, even taking into consideration that Haydn is surely the composer of happy, life-affirming music par excellence. It’s unusual in being the only Haydn piano trio with a slow introduction, which leads directly into a distinctly un-showy first movement. The middle movement is a flowing, song-like ‘Molto Andante’. Finally, there is a typical Haydn-esque finale, scurrying to a lively conclusion. The dominance of the piano in the texture throughout might be understood if we realise that the piece was published as a ‘Sonate pour le Piano Forte avec Accompagnement de Violon & Violoncelle’! There is a handful of video recordings of this work on YouTube, and from these options I’ve selected a performance by the Boston Trio (from Boston – Massachusetts, not Lincolnshire – funnily enough). Unfortunately, it’s only available via three separate links, but I think this is preferable to a couple of recordings I can provide a single link to, but which are either a bit wooden or so fast as to make it almost impossible to hear the details. So, you’ll find the Boston Trio’s performances here: Haydn: Piano Trio in C, Hob XV:21 - 1. Adagio Pastorale - Vivace Assai, 2. Molto Andante and 3. Finale: Presto
Day 275: Piano Trio in G, Hob XV: 25 ('Gypsy Rondo') (Time: 15 minutes)
Haydn has been a regular on this list (see Days 15, 46, 78, 127, 158 and 219), for which I make no apology. Not only is he one of the greatest composers ever, but he’s really the one whom I should credit with switching on my brain when it came to classical music, so I’ve loved his work since I was about 11 or 12. Back on Day 219, I featured another of Haydn’s piano trios, the not terribly well-known Trio in C, Hob XV:21 (otherwise known as the Piano Trio No 35, depending on whose cataloguing system you want to refer to). In that posting, I noted how the piano trio as a genre in Haydn’s output was essentially a ‘lighter’ musical form, and one dominated by the piano, in which the violin and especially the cello have essentially supportive roles. My choice for today (15/3/22) is without doubt the most popular and most frequently performed of the 44 trios Haydn wrote for this combination of forces. It’s the so-called ‘Gypsy Rondo’ Trio, the Piano Trio in G, Hob XV:25 (and otherwise known as the Piano Trio No 39). The reason for the nickname is immediately obvious as you listen through to the end of the work, for the final movement is a ‘Rondo all’Ongarese’ (Rondo in the Hungarian Style). This sort of ‘folksy’ approach to what one might call ‘art’ music isn’t just a 19th century feature, part of the growth of nationalism in music that was a product of European cultural change in the 1800s. Even well before that, composers were using localised folk music styles in their work – you’ll find examples in, say, Telemann’s music, in the Baroque period, and in the Classical era, a time we might associate much more with a kind of cultural elitism (I hope that’s not too pejorative a term: I simply mean music that was discovering a sense of its own structural complexity, largely via the symphony and the string quartet), there is still plenty of evidence of music at least imitating more rustic styles. Haydn, who spent a very long period of time in the service of the Esterhazy family, consequently found himself enduring long summers on the family estate in the depths of rural Hungary (as we know it today), and so ‘Hungarian Gypsy’ music was familiar to him as part of the natural local musical idioms he would have heard around him much of the time. In fact, the ‘Gypsy Rondo’ Trio was written after Haydn’s release from his duties as court composer to the Esterhazys, when he was allowed to take up other commissions and to travel widely throughout Europe. He made two immensely lucrative visits to London, and towards the end of the second of these, in 1794-5, he wrote this trio. The first movement is an Andante, a gentle but imaginative piece which explores one of Haydn’s favourite structures, the major/minor variation form, in which he explores and varies his theme in contrasting modes. One of the striking features of this movement is the extent to which the violin develops a life independent of the piano – the direction of travel for piano trios in general. The same is true of the second movement, a ‘Poco Adagio’, which has a lovely song-like middle section that feels like it’s not far from the world of the Romantic piano trio of the following century. Then finally, we have this zestful ‘Hungarian’ rondo, in which the sophisticated music of the salon and the concert hall is blended with the music of the villages and the sprawling Hungarian plain. The ‘Hungarian’ quality isn’t just confined to the melodies of the piece; Haydn gets his instruments to imitate ‘folk’ ways of playing too, notably moments where you appear to be hearing strumming. All in all, it’s a trio whose popularity is well deserved – an immense amount of fun. The trio is reasonably well served on YouTube, and from the options I’ve chosen this performance by the multi-national Emerald Piano Trio (given in a rather overly-resonant acoustic, in a church in Texas), which you’ll find here: Haydn: Piano Trio in G, Hob XV: 25 ('Gypsy Rondo')
Day 284: 'Seven Last Words of Our Saviour on the Cross' (Time: 5 minutes), 4. My God, my God, why have you forsaken me? (7 minutes), 5. I thirst (7 minutes), 6. It is finished (6 minutes) and 7. Father, into your hands I commend my spirit (8 minutes)
Welcome to the Good Friday posting for this ongoing series. Throughout Lent, as you’ll be aware, I’ve made selections of pieces of music that have some sort of reflective or devotional feel to them – some explicitly in the Christian tradition, others more generally contemplative. Having heard music by Gombert, White, Britten, Brahms, Mozart, Poulenc and Salieri, I thought I’d bring this series to a close today (15/4/22) with a work that has an overt connection to this specific day in the Christian calendar, and which has been suggested by a regular contributor to this list, (the invisible) Pete Dutton. The composer in question is Joseph Haydn (a frequent choice on this playlist – see Days 15, 46, 78, 127, 158, 219 and 275), and the work is his composition ‘The Seven Last Words of our Saviour on the Cross’. This is a very unusual piece, with a very specific genesis. Haydn was commissioned by a remarkable priest, Don José Sáenz de Santa María, a canon at Cadiz Cathedral, to write a series of pieces of music for an event to be performed in the Oratorio de la Santa Cueva, a church built underground in a large cave in Cadiz, on Good Friday, 1786. Later, Haydn summarised the experience: ‘The walls, windows, and pillars of the church were hung with black cloth, and only one large lamp hanging from the centre of the roof broke the solemn darkness. At midday, the doors were closed and the ceremony began. After a short service the bishop ascended the pulpit, pronounced the first of the seven words (or sentences) and delivered a discourse thereon. This having ended, he left the pulpit and fell to his knees before the altar. The interval was filled by music. The bishop then in like manner pronounced the second word, then the third, and so on, the orchestra following on the conclusion of each discourse.’ What Haydn was invited to produce, then, was a series of seven slow, contemplative Adagios (preceded by an Introduction – also slow – and followed by a short fast concluding movement) to follow the speaking of each of the seven last utterances of Christ on the Cross, each with its own short homily. The piece exists in several different forms. The first performance in 1786 was for an orchestra of Haydn’s usual size – strings, with flutes, oboes, bassoons, horns, trumpets and timpani – but within a year Haydn’s publishers in Vienna had asked him to make other, more saleable versions, so he made one for string quartet (the most common performing version these days) and also one for keyboard. A decade or so later, on his way back to Vienna from his lucrative second trip to London, he happened to arrive in the town of Passau (near Linz, in Austria), where he heard a kind of ‘bootleg’ version of the work made by the local choirmaster, one Joseph Frieberth, which added choral parts (fairly sub-standard late 18th century verse) to Haydn’s score. Haydn being Haydn, he was polite and respectful, but on returning to Vienna he collaborated with his friend Baron van Swieten (who was later to produce the texts for his two great oratorios ‘The Creation’ and ‘The Seasons’) to write his own vocal score to van Swieten’s heavily edited and rewritten version of the lines Frieberth had come up with. The seven last words are, as most of you will know, as follows: 1: ‘Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do’; 2: ‘Today, you will be with me in paradise’; 3: ‘Woman, behold your son; son, behold your mother’; 4: ‘My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?’; 5: ‘I thirst’; 6: ‘It is finished’; 7: ‘Father, into your hands I commend my spirit’. The whole composition lasts, in most performances, just under an hour, so it’s not something I can select complete for this playlist. It presents challenges to the listener – apart from the couple of minutes at the end (which depict the ‘earthquake’ that took place at the point of Jesus’s death) all the music is slow – but the result, in my experience, is profoundly moving, whether one hears it in a ‘secular’ concert performance, or as part of a Good Friday service, or as a kind of hybrid of the two. (The Lindsays used to perform this regularly in Sheffield in the company of Dr John Taylor, former Bishop of Winchester, who wrote a series of homilies about each of the ‘words’, that he would read before each movement.) I wondered about providing links to a range of movements in each of the different formats in which the work exists, but decided in the end that this wouldn’t give a clear sense of the cumulative impact of the piece. Instead, what you have here is a video recording of a performance which is a kind of hybrid of the string quartet and choral versions, given by the American vocal group Seraphic Fire (part of whose performance of Mozart’s Requiem I suggested recently), accompanied by the Spektral Quartet (quartet-in-residence at Chicago University). So that you get some feel for what the purely instrumental string quartet version sounds like, here is the link to the Introduction: Haydn: Introduction (from 'Seven Last Words of Our Saviour on the Cross'). Then, I’m afraid, I can’t provide a single link to the rest of the work, because it’s been uploaded in individual movements, so what you have here are ‘words’ 4-7 (the last of these having the ‘terremoto’ earthquake finale appended to it). You’ll find the performances here: 4. My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?; 5. I thirst; 6. It is finished; 7. Father, into your hands I commend my spirit
Day 326: Symphony No 44 in E Minor ('Mourning') (Time: 28 minutes)
As we’re in the later stages of official mourning for the Queen before next Monday’s funeral, I want today (16/9/22) to choose one last piece of appropriate music for the times, and to go back to one of the greatest composers of all time, and one of his greatest masterpieces. Those who’ve followed at least some of these postings will know that my admiration for the music of Joseph Haydn is unbounded (for me, he’s one of the half-dozen greatest composers ever), and has been since I ‘discovered’ his music at the age of about 11. There’s been a great deal of Haydn on this list (Days 15, 46, 78, 127, 158, 219, 275 and 284), but working on the principle that you can never have too much of a good thing, here’s some more. One of the pleasures of my rather nerdy teenage years was collecting the complete set of Haydn symphonies (on 48 LPs!), and the first box that I bought contained Symphonies 36-48, which means I’ve got to know these works really pretty well! They are almost all innovative and original, a product of Haydn’s employment with the Esterhazy family which allowed him the opportunity to develop his skills as a symphonist in relative isolation, whilst also being aware of the prevailing trends elsewhere in Europe. Perhaps the key ‘fashionable’ concept that Haydn exploited in these works was the ‘Sturm und Drang’ literary/artistic movement that was, if you like, a kind of ‘Romanticism before the Romantics’ phase (though there’s no indication that Haydn himself used the term). In music this ‘storm and stress’ manifested itself in writing that was emotionally turbulent, full of contrasts of volume and texture, and often in minor keys. Haydn’s Symphony No 44 (the ‘Trauersinfonie’, or ‘Mourning Symphony’) in E Minor is one of the gems of this phase in his symphonic career. It was written in around 1771/2, and for Haydn’s familiar orchestral forces of the time, strings plus two horns, two oboes and a bassoon to underscore the bass line. The nickname is said to be Haydn’s own, and allegedly (so you can choose how much you want to believe this) it’s because he expressed a desire to have the beautiful slow movement of the work played at his own funeral. (I haven’t read anything that suggests that it was actually performed then.) What I think makes this symphony so impressive is its sustained emotional intensity, achieved in part by the fact that he shifts the ‘weight’ of the symphony, after the powerful first movement, by putting the minuet second and slow movement third, before ratcheting up the drama again in the intense finale. The first movement (marked, unusually for Haydn ‘Allegro con brio’ – something more typical of Beethoven) is tense and driven, particularly when Haydn pushes the momentum along with all those semiquavers. The ‘Menuetto’ that comes next is one of those ‘show-off’ pieces where Haydn plays with structure – here the music is in strict canon, with the top and bottom lines playing the same music but with the latter always one bar behind. We’re still in the minor key, which makes this brooding rather than simply a lightweight dance movement. The ‘Trio’ middle section of the movement, though, moves from E Minor to E Major and this is striking, I think, because although the major key brings a kind of ‘release’ there’s an extreme lyricism and tenderness here which means we’re still emotionally involved. The slow movement is a lovely Adagio, with muted strings and very restrained use of the oboes and horns (which reach some scarily high notes here – and on ‘natural’ rather than valved horns, as we have it in the recording I’ve chosen, this feels quite exposed). The finale, rather than being some kind of playful release, takes us back into the world of the first movement: more urgent unison passages, lots of driven semiquavers. As the Haydn musicologist HC Robbins Landon says, with this symphony and the one that followed it (see Day 78!), along with the set of six String Quartets Op 20, Haydn revolutionised the history of music, which was never the same again. YouTube has a few nice performances of this work, but I’ve gone for one by the ‘modern instrument’ forces of the Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra (though with ‘old-style’ horns) conducted by the clearly very impressed John Eliot Gardiner. The performance employs all the repeats, and so comes in a good six or seven minutes longer than many other recordings, but it’s worth every minute! You’ll find it here: Haydn: Symphony No 44 in E Minor ('Mourning')
Day 509: Piano Trio No 44 in E, Hob. XV:28 (Time: 17 minutes)
Today (27/9/24), I want to pick a piece from the programme being performed next month in Sheffield by the Leonore Piano Trio (three-tenths of Ensemble 360, but with a top drawer reputation in their own right). To begin the concert, they’ll play one of Haydn’s 45 piano trios, in this case No 44 (Hob. XV:28) in the relatively unusual key of E Major. There’s been a lot of Haydn on this list over the years, on the purely selfish basis that he was my first love as a composer, and I’d still rank him in my favourite half-dozen indispensable musical geniuses. Among the ten works I’ve featured before there are two piano trios, Hob. XV:21 and Hob.XV:25 (the famous ‘Gypsy Rondo’ trio), so if you’ve listened to those works you might feel like you know your way around what Haydn’s ‘voice’ sounds like in this particular medium. If so, prepare to be startled, because the music I’ve chosen today is quite extraordinary, particularly its slow movement. My discussion of the two piano trios I’ve featured before (see Days 219 and 275) explores the complicated background to the numbering of these works, and also the historical background to their composition in an era when the form was dominated by the piano, with (generally) only supporting roles for violin and cello. Haydn’s piano trios are broadly divisible into ‘early’ works (the first 15 of the ones that survive) which almost all date from the 1760s when Haydn was still getting established as a composer, and ‘late’ works (the other 30), which date from 1784-97, by which time Haydn was a major figure in European music and, by the time of his two visits to London in the 1790s, a true musical superstar. The piano trio I’m exploring today is probably one of the very last of those works, because the final three trios emerged as a set in 1797, dedicated to the hugely talented amateur keyboard player Theresa Jansen (after her marriage Theresa Bartolozzi, which has led to these pieces being known as the ‘Bartolozzi Trios’). I say ‘probably’ one of his last works in the genre because although the other two in the set seem to have been written for Bartolozzi, the middle trio of the three appears to have been written earlier, probably in 1794/5. By this stage in his career, Haydn was producing rabbits out of hats with every new work, and this E Major trio is no exception. The opening movement starts with the string instruments playing pizzicato, all three instruments playing the same theme in unison, making an effect a little like a harp or maybe a mandolin. When the theme is repeated Haydn fills out the keyboard line and from there the movement gets more and more harmonically complex and adventurous. By the middle (development) section we even find the music wandering into Ab Major (key signature has four flats, unlike the ‘home’ key of E Major, which has four sharps – a long way apart from each other) before finding its way home again. But for me it’s the second movement which makes this a piece of astonishing originality. If you’ve ever listened to music by the Modern Jazz Quartet (purveyors of ‘cool’ jazz, but heavily influenced by their members’ awareness of classical music and its traditions) from the 1950s and 60s, then you might feel quite at home with Haydn’s slow movement, in which the MJQ approach is blended with what feels like a Baroque trio sonata movement. It’s a bare, sparse sound world, with a meandering ‘walking bass’ line picked out in the piano’s left hand, over which the right hand, supported by the violin and piano, unfolds a melody which is constantly varied. It feels a bit like a passacaglia, the Baroque form that had a fixed, repeated bass line, but unlike the passacaglia Haydn’s bass line evolves and modulates to accommodate the sinuous melody that runs above it. The whole movement has a kind of solemn processional feel, with its steady tread. It’s a bit like listening to Bach crossed, as I’ve suggested, with the MJQ. I know nothing like it from the classical period – quite extraordinary. After that, the finale seems almost conventional. Almost – but even here Haydn is keen to keep pulling the rug out from under our feet. Melodies have irregular phrase lengths, so that nothing appears too ‘four square’ and orderly, and again the harmonic shifts would have been really disturbing to a late 18th century audience – for a work largely in E Major to have a passage here in Eb Minor (four sharps giving way to five flats, and a change from major to minor mode!) would have seemed really wild, even if our ears have had over two centuries of further musical experimentation since, which might mean it doesn’t quite have the same impact on us. Just before the end, there’s even a sequence using ‘diminished sevenths’ (if it means nothing, fret not – but imagine the sort of harmonies created by the soundtrack to a silent film in which the heroine is tied to the tracks in the path of an oncoming train), before there’s a sudden, celebratory rush for the certainty of home. You’ll perhaps pick up that I’m somewhat in awe of this piece of music. Not many of Haydn’s piano trios break out of their ‘niche’ and become mainstream – possibly only the ‘Gypsy Rondo’ one, in fact – but this one deserves far more time in the spotlight. As for a performance, YouTube is reasonably well stocked, though some of the live video recordings have rather limited sound quality. In the end, I’ve gone for a performance by Trio Conventi, who, as far as I can tell, are an American-based group from the New England Conservatory in Boston. Their members are Yun Janice Lu on piano, with Yiliang Jiang (violin) and Jeffrey Ho (cello). You’ll find their performance here: Haydn: Piano Trio No 44 in E, Hob. XV:28
Day 541: The Creation (Part One; arr. L Golofeev) (Time: 37 minutes)
Today (6/6/25), I want to explore at least some of the music from the single work that closes the 2024/25 concert season at the City Hall here in Sheffield in two days from now, when the Halle Orchestra and Sheffield Philharmonic Chorus and three vocal soloists will be performing Haydn’s great oratorio ‘The Creation’. I’ve devoted ten previous editions of this list to music by ‘Papa’ Haydn, for the entirely logical reason that he is one of the very greatest composers, like, ever. And also the one that made me fall in love, as a slightly nerdy 11-year-old (nerdy, moi? surely not…), with this kind of music. I’ve made my views about Haydn known over and over again in those previous postings, but one thing that they don’t really demonstrate is the breadth of Haydn’s output. There’s an obvious reason for this, in that most of the previous links were prompted by chamber music performances given here in Sheffield over the past few years, so your back-catalogue of his works is skewed heavily towards string quartets and piano trios. Meanwhile, you’ve only had two symphonies (out of the current estimate of 106, depending on what you count, at our disposal) and no piano sonatas at all … and nothing from Haydn’s output of choral music (all those wonderful late mass settings, which we might get to one day). However, this weekend’s concert performance of ‘The Creation’ redresses that balance at least a little. By the time he was in his late fifties, Haydn was coming to the end of his years as court composer to the Esterházy family, and the relative freedom (and financial independence) to do what he wanted led to his two visits to London (1791/2 and 1794/5), which made him not just richer than he could ever have imagined, given London’s thriving public concerts and their entrepreneurial promotion, but absolutely the most famous composer in the (known) world. Following the second of these visits he returned to Vienna, where he lived out the remaining decade or so of his life – not always happily, given his developing ill health in the first decade of the 19th century and the continent-wide wars with Napoleon’s forces, which were laying siege to Vienna as Haydn lay dying. In those later years, Haydn’s creative energy shifted from symphonic and chamber music to choral pieces, including six settings of the Mass. However, the two large scale projects of that time were a pair of oratorios: ‘The Creation’ (1798) and ‘The Seasons’ (1801). The back story to ‘The Creation’ is fairly well established, though the relative importance of the events that triggered it is disputed. Two things seem clear: while in London he came across Handel’s large-scale oratorios (not just ‘The Messiah’ but ‘Israel in Egypt’, in which Handel explored musical ‘effects’ that illuminated the text being sung, an idea Haydn built on); back in Vienna, he collaborated with the Dutch/Austrian nobleman, diplomat and musical supporter Baron Gottfried van Swieten – a great patron of the arts, sponsoring not just Haydn but Beethoven too, amongst many others – over a text, based essentially on the opening of the Book of Genesis. This libretto, originally in English, had been passed to Haydn while in London; its authorship is unclear, but it seems it had been around for several decades when it came into Haydn’s possession. Van Swieten and Haydn translated it into German, but also produced an amended version of the original in English – so when the work was performed in public, versions in both languages existed. The work is in three sections: Part One begins with the depiction of formless chaos which then leads to the Genesis narrative which takes us as far as the end of the fourth day in the creation story; Part Two takes the action through to the creation of Man, and ends on a note of idealised celebration; Part Three depicts Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden before the fall. The work was first performed in Vienna in 1799, and premieres across Europe followed swiftly. There’s a touching story of one of Haydn’s last appearances in public, in 1808, at a performance of the work. He was carried into the auditorium, at which point the audience burst into spontaneous applause, but Haydn (don’t you just love him?) pointed heavenward and said words to the effect of ‘Not from me: everything comes from up there.’ The whole work lasts around 90-100 minutes (depends how slowly it’s conducted – of which more in a moment). I wondered about choosing snippets from it, but in the end I’ve decided to provide a link to the whole of Part One, for a couple of reasons: first, that it allows the depiction of ‘Chaos’ that forms the work’s orchestral introduction, and Part One ends with the chorus ‘The Heavens are Telling the Glory of God’, which is a favourite for both professional and amateur choirs, and a chorus I’ve sung with my choir before now. But secondly, getting an extended chunk of the work will help to show how it’s constructed – recitative passages that narrate verses from Genesis Chapter 1, interspersed with arias for the soloists (who, at this stage in the oratorio, are the ‘voices’ of three angelic figures, Gabriel, Uriel and Raphael; later, in Part Three, two of them will take on the roles of Adam and Eve) and commentary on the action from the Chorus. A couple of other thoughts: you might want to contrast Haydn’s depiction of chaos with that of Jean-Féry Rebel in his ballet ‘Les Élémens’ (see Day 306), in that Rebel’s ‘chaos’ from the 1730s really feels chaotic, whereas by the end of the 18th century (‘the Age of Reason’, let’s not forget), Haydn depicts chaos in sonata form! (Even if you don’t know exactly what that is, it’s worth realising that it’s a way of organising the structure of music … which is, erm, not very chaotic.) Actually, Haydn is being chaotic, within his terms of reference: he largely omits the cadences that would signal that phrases have come to an orderly close that these chords would signal. Another moment that is noteworthy is the ‘sunrise’ that Haydn depicts at the end of Day Four of the Genesis narrative: a scale of D Major, the notes variously harmonised as they are sounded. And this then leads into the wonderful fugue that is the final chorus of Part One. As for a performance, this is where things get a bit tricky. YouTube has several complete versions of Part One, though not many on video. There’s a turgidly slow one by the Philharmonia Orchestra under Gilbert Levine. Apologies if it’s to your taste, but for me it almost feels like it’s encouraging you to nod off. So, what you have here is something a bit more stripped-down and experimental. Haydn’s original was clearly intended to be a large-scale affair (full strings; two each of flutes, oboes, clarinets, trumpets and horns; three each of bassoons and trombones; and timps). However, my link is to a pared-back arrangement of the work for just eight string players, a chamber chorus of eight voices, plus the three vocal soloists. In a sense it’s obviously not a ‘kitchen sink’ version of ‘The Creation’, but it’s lively on its feet and full of energy. The performers are the Texas-based and conductorless Apollo Chamber Ensemble with extra guest string players, and the Cantare Houston Choir. The soloists are Lynelle Rowley, Eduardo Tercero and Brendan Emig. This arrangement of Haydn’s ‘The Creation’ is by Lorento Golofeev. You’ll find the performance here: Haydn: The Creation (Part One; arr. L Golofeev)
Herbert, Victor (1859-1924)
Day 483: Cello Concerto No 2, Op 30 (Time: 20 minutes)
Today (24/5/24), we have another commemoration of a death, since on 26th May, 1924 – which the mathematical among you will realise was 100 years ago this coming Sunday – the ‘Irish’/American cellist and composer Victor Herbert died in Connecticut at the age of 65. He is known these days – if he is known at all – as a composer of operattas and then of musicals, but be reassured: I’m not about to choose a piece for the playlist from ‘Babes in Toyland’ (which sounds alarmingly like a soft porn movie from the euphemistically-titled ‘adult film’ industry) or any of Herbert’s other hits in the world of light music. Nevertheless, I don’t think we should disown him as merely an occasionally ‘serious’ composer, and his life story is a revealing narrative of the ways in which what we now call classical music blurred into other art forms. Herbert (1859-1924) was actually born on Guernsey. His mother, then in her mid-20s, had a brief liaison with someone called August Herbert, of whom I can tell you nothing else. At the time, she was married to a Mr Muspratt, who divorced her on learning that the child – Victor – wasn’t his. His mother told Victor that he was born in Ireland, and this is what he put on official papers when emigrating to the USA in 1886. Before then, Herbert and his mother turned up in Germany, where he was baptised, then in England, where he lived for a while with his maternal grandfather, then in Germany again, where his mother remarried. He lived in Stuttgart for the rest of his childhood and adolescence – one consequence of which was that when he turned up in the USA he was an ‘Irishman’ who spoke English with a strikingly German accent! After a traditional musical education he found employment as a cellist (he played for a year in Eduard Strauss’s orchestra in Vienna) and built a considerable reputation as a soloist. The move to the USA came at the invitation to join the Metropolitan Opera in New York as principal cellist, and he and his new wife settled there once their initial contracts expired, becoming US citizens. In the years either side of the turn of the century, Herbert’s career – as solo cellist (in the first American performance of Brahms’ Double Concerto, for example), conductor (he was Principal Conductor of the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra for six years), concert promoter and composer – flourished quite dramatically. From the outset he had a keen interest in promoting a blending of ‘serious’ classical music with ‘light classical’ fare. He ran his own orchestra, the Victor Herbert Orchestra, from 1904 until his death, giving concerts that programmed light orchestral music with more serious fare. It sounds like the sort of thing one might have heard – and, thanks to Radio 3 now, one can still hear – on ‘Friday Night is Music Night’! In terms of his career as a composer, the ‘serious’ stuff comes relatively early in his output, and certainly once he’d developed a facility for writing operetta it was the latter than essentially took over. His first such work emerged in 1894, and three others followed in quick succession, before a hiatus caused by his commitments with the Pittsburgh Orchestra (1898-1904), but after that there was no stopping him. He wrote several international hits, of which ‘Babes in Toyland’ (1903), ‘Mademoiselle Modiste’ (1905) and ‘The Red Mill’ (1906) were probably the most successful. As the 20th century unfolded, operetta (his style was essentially a mix of Viennese operetta in the style of Lehar, mixed with Gilbert and Sullivan) gave way to musicals. Herbert seems to have seen these as being little more than ways of sustaining a decent lifestyle, and certainly they meant much less to him than the two ‘grand operas’ that he wrote – ‘Natoma’ in 1911 (hobbled, seemingly, by an unwieldy libretto) and ‘Madeleine’ in 1914 – but it was the lighter stuff (he actually wrote 43 operettas and musicals) that sealed his reputation. Having decided to leave aside this kind of material and focus on Herbert’s compositions in more traditionally serious classical contexts, I wondered what to choose to illustrate his talents in this area. As a cellist, much of his work features the cello as soloist, in both chamber music and concertos. True, there are other works (there’s a rather Lisztian symphonic poem called ‘Hero and Leander’ from 1901), but the cello is what made him a musician in the first place so that’s what I’ll choose. He wrote two cello concertos. The first is an early piece, from 1882, when Herbert was in his early 20s, and it’s a rather sprawling and unmemorable work, in truth. However, the Cello Concerto No 2 is another matter altogether, and it has a distinct place in the musical history of America. It was written in 1894, and had its first performance in New York with Herbert himself as soloist. Which might in itself not seem very significant, except for the fact that in the audience at that first performance was Dr Antonin Dvorak, who was in America in his role as Director of the National Conservatory of Music in the city. In fact, Dvorak and Herbert were colleagues. Dvorak seems to have been extremely impressed by Herbert’s concerto, coming up to him at the post-performance party to say ‘Famos! Famos! Gang famos!’ (which I’m assured by the internet can be translated as ‘Tremendous! Tremendous! Very tremendous!’). And this is the prompt Dvorak needed to compose his own cello concerto, which, alongside the Elgar, is probably the most famous cello concerto there is. (Herbert also led the cello section at the first performance of Dvorak’s ‘New World’ Symphony, by the way.) What of Herbert’s concerto itself? Well, it’s in the familiar three movements (essentially fast-slow-fast) and it’s a rather ‘conservative’ piece. It harks back to the mid-19th century in style, and seems to have as its model the concertos of Saint-Saens. It is, if you like, a stylistic amalgam of Irish, Germanic and American idioms – the sort of mixture that featured in Herbert’s operetta writing later. In typical late-19th century fashion it evolves from the strong initial theme at the outset. There’s a lovely ‘Andante Tranquillo’ slow movement, and then a virtuoso finale based on the same theme that opened the concerto. I don’t think it’s going to suddenly be rediscovered as a lost masterpiece, but it seems pretty clear that as a work it convinced Dvorak that it was possible to write for a solo cello in the midst of a full symphony orchestra without the soloist being drowned out, and on its own terms it seems to me to be deserving of being dusted down and celebrated every now and then – and the centenary of the composer’s death is as good a time as any. As you might expect, performances of the work aren’t ten a penny, but there’s a video recording from a concert given by the Canadian cellist Amanda Forsyth, with the Israel Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Pinchas Zukerman (who just happens to be her husband!). You’ll find their performance (in a video clip that lasts far more than 20 minutes, but there’s much to-ing and fro-ing after the performance, not to mention a violin-and-cello encore) here: Herbert: Cello Concerto No 2, Op 30
von Herzogenberg, Heinrich (1843-1900)
Day 557: Piano Quintet in C, Op 17 (Time: 29 minutes)
Today (26/9/25), I want to shine a light on one of the more obscure 19th century Austrian composers, the 125th anniversary of whose death will arrive on 9th October. It will almost certainly not be marked by a week’s worth of programmes on Radio 3, and in fact, I’d be surprised if he even gets a mention on the day itself. But stay with me, because although he’s often regarded as a second-rate composer (when he’s regarded at all, that is), he’s a really, really good second-rate composer. He is Heinrich von Herzogenberg, or rather, and it’s worth quoting in full because it’s so quirky, Heinrich Picot de Peccaduc, Freiherr von Herzogenberg. The reason for the rather ceremonial moniker is that his family history made him a member of the French aristocracy whose grandfather left France after the 1789 Revolution, entered the service of the Habsburgs and became a high-ranking officer in the Austrian army. Herzogenberg the composer (1843-1900) was reasonably prolific, producing works in most of the major genres of 19th century music except for opera, but in terms of references to him these days, they tend to turn up in the context of his musical relationship with Brahms. First, a quotation from a rather snarky piece of music journalism from 1908, written by Busoni (see Day 500!). In it, Busoni imagines existence in a kind of musical limbo reserved for those who did neither good nor evil musically, and who were thus destined to spend eternity in a kind of empty void. The place is populated by Mendelssohn, Spohr, Kalliwoda, Niels Gade, Lachner and others. Briefly, Schumann pops down from heaven. Mendelssohn asks if Brahms is ‘up there’. Of course, says Schumann, although ‘he sits somewhat lonesomely in the German department – he would have liked to move closer to Beethoven – but nevertheless he has comfortable furnishings, quite simple: a couple of soft pillows, a few horns on the walls, broken triadic chords, and a wonderful collection of syncopations. The Herzogenbergs, husband and wife, have been assigned to him as servants.’ Then Schumann heads off back to heaven to play a set of his studies for Brahms, noting ‘The dear Herzogenbergs are already so happy in anticipation.’ It’s a bit crushing, but it reflects the wider view, a decade or so after Herzogenberg’s death. In fact, if you read almost anything on Herzogenberg, the noun attached to him almost like a ball and chain is ‘epigone’ (as in ‘he’s an epigone of Brahms’, a kind of dutiful if essentially talentless imitator). Interestingly, there is an immense amount of correspondence between Herzogenberg (and also his wife) and Brahms, and it’s fascinating, and amusing in a rather sad way. Brahms was of course a notorious curmudgeon, but Herzogenberg really desperately wanted Brahms’ approval and endorsement for his compositions, and Brahms was brilliantly determined never to give it. The closest he came, just before he died, was to say, with impressive vagueness, ‘Herzogenberg is able to do more than any of the others.’ More what? We don’t know… One of the reasons Brahms may have had for not playing ball is that in 1866 Herzogenberg married Elisabeth von Stockhausen, a piano pupil of Brahms, for whom, it is often surmised, Brahms had the hots (not that Brahms ever seems to have been able to translate initial amorous enthusiasm into anything more substantial) – and so Brahms took against Herzogenberg for ‘stealing’ this attractive young woman from his grasp. Whatever the case, both Herzogenbergs maintained this rather one-sided friendship with Brahms for the best part of three decades. Anyway, what of Herzogenberg’s music? Well, actually he started out on the other side of the great 19th century German musical divide, as a follower of Wagner and the ‘New German School’, but quite soon he discovered Bach … and by the early 1870s he was a convinced ‘traditionalist’, and saw Brahms (as most traditionalists did at the time) as the incarnation of the great Germanic tradition (Bach to Beethoven to Brahms) for his era. And so not surprisingly, the music Herzogenberg produced has a hint (and sometimes lots more than a hint) of the Brahmsian about it. Over recent years (rather sad nerdy admission coming up) I’ve accumulated quite a lot of Herzogenberg’s music on CD (the German label ‘cpo’ has recorded huge amounts of it) and so I’ve given a bit of thought to what to choose from this composer’s output to try to convince you that he’s more than just a mere shadow of Brahms. In his last years Herzogenberg wrote a huge amount of sacred music (interestingly, for the German Lutheran tradition, even though Herzogenberg himself was a Catholic), but in his prime, alongside orchestral and piano music, there’s a rich collection of chamber music, and it’s from this strand of his work that I’ve selected a piece from 1876, the Piano Quintet in C, Op 17. This was effectively the first work Herzogenberg produced after a period of three years writing nothing, and it marked the turning point in his journey from devotee of Wagner to devotee of Brahms. This quintet is in four quite substantial movements, beginning with a powerful ‘Allegro Moderato’ introduced by the piano, but (after the strings enter) growing into a dramatic march-like passage. For those with an ear to musical form, this is actually a sonata-form movement, but it’s embedded in a soundscape that feels much more rhapsodic and free-flowing. Herzogenberg was very attached to counterpoint (noddy definition: where separate themes are played simultaneously) and you get quite a bit of that here, as well as a fugal passage to show that Herzogenberg could do the technical stuff too. The second movement, marked ‘Adagio’, is altogether more tender and gentle; an early reviewer called it ‘moving and simple, like a children’s song.’ Even here, though, there’s complexity too – more counterpoint, particularly setting the Adagio’s theme against the main motif from the first movement. Then comes an energetic Scherzo, playing (in a quite Brahmsian way) with syncopation, where the stress falls on the off beats. The ‘Presto’ finale has an initial jaunty dance-like air, and its rhythmically-accented theme dominates, though there are reminiscences of both the opening and slow movements along the way, before the work ends with great energy and drive. There’s lots more Herzogenberg out there (a couple of lovely string trios, five string quartets, a couple of piano quartets, three violin sonatas, three cello sonatas, and some really attractive chamber music for winds) but maybe this will give you a taste for a composer who really ought to be seen as more than just a pale imitator of Brahms. Not surprisingly, YouTube has very little Herzogenberg on video, apart from amateur performances, so this is an audio-only link. The performers here are the Minguet Quartet and the pianist Oliver Triendl. You’ll find their recording here: Herzogenberg: Piano Quintet in C, Op 17
Hindemith, Paul (1895-1963)
Day 116: Symphonic Metamorphosis of Themes by Carl Maria von Weber (Time: 22 minutes)
After Day 115’s instalment, in which Berlioz merely ‘colours in’ Weber’s original version of ‘Invitation to the Dance’, I thought it would be good to contrast that today (4/9/20) with the much more wholesale reworking of Weber’s music that Hindemith gives it in his rather grandly titled ‘Symphonic Metamorphosis of Themes by Carl Maria von Weber’. Hindemith (1895-1963) is a fascinating composer. Like many others, there is a ‘before’ and an ‘after’ in terms of Hindemith’s compositional style. His early work is in a strongly late-Romantic idiom, and even rather expressionist in the manner of early Schoenberg. But from the 1920s onwards, his style becomes more contrapuntal, like a kind of ‘mechanised’ version of Baroque music. He wrote a large number of pieces in this vein for various chamber orchestra combinations, especially a series called ‘Kammermusik’, which are well worth a listen. He had an uneasy ‘on/off’ relationship with the Nazis in the 1930s, but eventually left for the USA, via Turkey, and later in his life became a US citizen. Although Hindemith is best known as a composer, he was also a formidable viola player, and a music theorist and teacher who had a clear sense that music should be ‘useful’ and ‘functional’. For me, he wrote two orchestral masterpieces, the Symphony ‘Mathis der Maler’ (which I’ll aim to programme sometime soon) and the ‘Symphonic Metamorphosis’ that is the subject of today’s listening pleasure. Hindemith wrote the work in 1943, using mostly short solo piano pieces by Weber as the basis for three of the four movements. However, he also took a march from music that Weber composed for a staging of Schiller’s translation of a play by Carlo Gozzi, ‘Turandot’, for another movement. To hear Weber’s original, try this version by the LSO and Hans-Hubert Schonzeler: Weber: March (from 'Turandot') However, what Hindemith does with Weber’s themes in all four movements of the ‘Symphonic Metamorphosis’ is quite radical. He keeps the melodies largely intact, but expands them in harmony and rhythm. The first movement has a Hungarian flavour; the second, the ‘Turandot’ march, is more oriental, subjecting the theme to increasingly lively variations; the third movement is lyrical and contemplative; finally there is a march, stirring and exhilarating. As an example of creating something new out of the old, the whole piece seems to me to be remarkably successful. There are a number of good recordings of it on YouTube, but this one, by the SWR Symphony Orchestra, Stuttgart, conducted by Dima Slobodeniouk, gets to the heart of the music’s vivid colours. You’ll find it here: Hindemith: Symphonic Metamorphosis of Themes by Carl Maria von Weber
Hisaishi, Joe (b.1950)
Day 567: Merry-go-round of Life (from 'Howl's Moving Castle') (Time: 3 minutes), Viola Saga (movement 1) (12 minutes) and Viola Saga (movement 2) (10 minutes)
Today (5/12/25), prompted in part by a suggestion from Playlist member Peter Wigglesworth, I have another ‘anniversary’ posting, because tomorrow, Dec 6th, will mark the 75th birthday of the Japanese composer Joe Hisaishi. Now, it’s possible that unless you’re a consumer of particular sorts of media Mr Hisaishi’s name might not mean a lot to you. But – trust me – his is a big name, and by that I mean a really really big name, in the world of film soundtracks, and also, in more recent years, in the world of what we have become used to calling ‘classical music’. So, I have a couple of pieces for you that might illustrate Hisaishi’s ‘voice’ as a composer. The first thing worth saying about him is that he’s not, in fact, called Joe Hisaishi. His real name is Mamoru Fujisawa. The story behind ‘Joe Hisaishi’ as a ‘nom de plume’ is simple: the name is an approximation of the way the name ‘Quincy Jones’ translates in Kanji characters (‘Quincy’=’Hisaishi’, because – and bear with me here, because I’m just getting this information from the interweb – ‘Hisaishi’ can also be pronounced ‘Kuishi’ ... which is almost like 'Quincy' – and the ‘Joe’ is derived from ‘Jones’), and Hisaishi adopted the name as a consequence of being powerfully influenced by Quincy Jones’ techniques as composer and arranger in the late 1970s. If you have any acquaintance with Japanese cinema, the likelihood is that you’ll have watched a film with the soundtrack scored by Hisaishi. In particular, he is very closely associated with Studio Ghibli films, and specifically the work of director Hayao Miyazaki: think of films like ‘My Neighbour Totoro’, ‘Princess Mononoke’, ‘Spirited Away’, ‘Howl’s Moving Castle’ or ‘The Boy and the Heron’. (If all this means nothing to you, I’d gently suggest you educate yourself. The films are lovely.) Hisaishi scored all these and more. In fact, by now he’s responsible for the music to well over 100 films. Concerts in which Hisaishi performs attract massive crowds (we’re talking tens of thousands in large arenas) and while he might not be in the Taylor Swift league, he’s a serious star. (One might observe that Bob Dylan is not the only person to have a best-selling ‘Live at Bukodan’ album!) Now, there may be some reading this (though one might hope not – this list aspires to being culturally democratic) who might think he’s ‘only’ a film composer, so why take him seriously – but he’s also a composer of concert music, and someone who conducts major league orchestras around the world. His compositional style is essentially minimalist. Major influences are people like Philip Glass, Steve Reich, Terry Riley (with whom he’s collaborated) and Arvo Pärt. Much of his concert music that gets performed is made up of suites of pieces from his film scores, but he’s also the composer of (to date) three symphonies, as well as concertos and chamber music. I thought I’d illustrate his music for those on this list who haven’t otherwise come across it with two pieces. First, here is what is probably Hisaishi’s most famous single composition, ‘Merry-go-round of Life’ from the score to ‘Howl’s Moving Castle’. If you want to listen to (and watch) the original soundtrack version of this gently nostalgic waltz, you can find it here, but I’d also recommend this arrangement that Hisaishi made for piano and orchestra, which he performs in this studio video with the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra: Hisaishi: Merry-go-round of Life (from 'Howl's Moving Castle'). However, as highbrow culture-vultures, I know you’ll also want to explore some of Hisaishi’s concert music, quite a lot of which he’s now recorded with some front-rank orchestras, like the Vienna Phil. Now, at this point I should offer a personal comment. I have listened to all three of his symphonies (don’t say I don’t take my duties seriously), and, in my humble and politely-expressed opinion, they’re really quite exceptionally dull. A lot of it sounds like Philip Glass on an off day – endless repetitive melodic cells and predictable rhythmic and harmonic patterns. Obviously you can find this stuff for yourself, and then you won’t have to take my word for it. However, in passing, I’ve come across some pieces which seem to me to have much more substance, and which I think are genuinely interesting. One of his more recent works is a viola concerto with the title ‘Viola Saga’. It was premiered in July 2023, having evolved into its current version over a period of years. It’s a two movement work, with a back-story associated with Nordic prose legends – essentially epic adventure tales. However, the title is non-specific enough for the listener to construct her/his own narrative that the music is, as it were, soundtracking. Hisaishi produced his own programme note for the concerto’s premiere, in which he wrote, ‘The composition consists of two movements: 1. A lively divertimento driven by brisk rhythms, and 2. A somewhat emotional piece characterised by dispersed harmonies.’ (I *think* I know what that means...) The work opens with the solo viola playing what seem initially to be fairly straightforward arpeggios, but from this the first movement builds into a soundscape of layered complexity: the rhythms are never quite as simple as they initially appear. In the end, you might feel that this music is still quite ‘filmic’, but it's definitely, I think, a composition to be taken seriously. Sadly, when it comes to performances of this work, we’re in audio-only territory. There are excerpts from the performance – by the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Hisaishi himself, with the soloist, the famous viola player Antoine Tamestit – out on video in a promotional sort of way, but if you want the whole work, it comes as two separate links, here: Hisaishi: Viola Saga (movement 1) and (movement 2)
Hol, Richard (1825-1904)
Day 547: Symphony No 1 in C Minor (Time: 24 minutes)
Welcome, today (18/7/25), to yet another posting about yet another composer you’ve never heard of. It has occasionally been observed by those who discuss matters musical with me that I ought perhaps to get out more, rather than just trawling through the back catalogues of unbelievably obscure composers. Such people may have a point. But still, if you can’t celebrate a chap’s 200th birthday, what is the world coming to? So today, let’s hear it for Richard Hol (occasionally, it seems, Rijk Holle), who was born 200 years ago next Wednesday. Although if you were motivated to explore more of Mr Hol’s music, you’d be rapidly disappointed because to the best of my knowledge, there are only two recordings of his music out there (and one of those is a ‘download only’). Still, I’m hoping this rather shallow dive into the world of mid-19th century symphonic music will not be a complete waste of your time … if only (as I’ve said before about the Classical era) so that we see (hear!) the world beyond Mendelssohn, Schumann, Brahms and Bruckner, which is pretty much the standard repertoire when it comes to mid/late western European19th century fare, aside from occasional French works. I can tell you relatively little, in truth, about Richard Hol (1825-1904). He was Dutch, which (if you’re trying – and probably failing – to name famous Dutch composers from the 19th century) puts him well outside the mainstream of European music in this period. He is one of those ‘small c’ conservative composers who litter the byways and cul-de-sacs (culs-de-sac?) of the era. To my ear, there’s plenty here to link him to Reinecke or Rheinberger or Bargiel or Dietrich or Draeseke – I could go on! – in that his is music that’s mildly interesting, attractively scored, well organised … but perhaps not memorable enough for you to be able to hum any of it 10 minutes after hearing it. Still, a moment or two in the spotlight never did anybody any harm. Anyway, Hol (the son of an Amsterdam milkman, I discover) graduated from the Royal Conservatory in Amsterdam in 1844, after which he had an extensive career – almost all of it in the Netherlands – as not just a composer, but a conductor, organist, pianist and teacher. Wikipedia (and where else for someone as obscure as this?) tells me that he spent time as a choral conductor in Amsterdam before moving to Utrecht in his late 30s, where he remained for the rest of his life. He seems to have been a major figure in the city’s musical landscape, conducting concert series and, for 20 years, being principal organist at Utrecht Cathedral. He was director of the main music school in Utrecht and, in later years, a writer and editor, particularly about organ playing and composition. So far, so worthy … and if you want something quirky you might want to note that Hol composed the ‘national anthem’ played in the Transvaal – at least until the British arrived in 1887. If he is known at all these days it’s as a composer of choral music – until Chandos issued two discs of his symphonies, at which point the world became reacquainted with Hol the symphonist too. Still out there waiting to be recorded are two operas, several song cycles and a substantial amount of liturgical music. Still, working with what’s available, what can we say of Hol the symphonic composer? Well, there are four symphonies, the first from 1863-6, the last from 1889. The first thing worth saying is that you won’t hear the influence of Brahms or Bruckner here – the touchstones of Hol’s sound world are Schumann and Mendelssohn. One might also say (I’ve listened to all four, so you can take my word for it) that there’s little sense of ‘progression’ or development in Hol’s musical language as you go from the first symphony to the last, so if he was not quite ‘cutting edge’ in the mid-1860s, he was heading towards being an anachronism by the late 1880s. An interesting side note: as conductor of the city’s orchestra he introduced his audiences to music by Berlioz, Wagner and Liszt, as well as both Brahms and Tchaikovsky, so he clearly had an ear for the new … but it just didn’t find its way into his own music. Out of his four symphonies, I’ve gone for the Symphony No 1 for us to listen to. It seems to me to be the freshest of the four, and there’s still a kind of youthful vigour here. The Symphony No 1 is in the traditional four movements, and there’s nothing structurally original about it. The first movement has a slow introduction that sounds as though Hol had spent some time getting to know the music of Schubert, before Schumann takes over as the guiding influence of the main faster section of the movement. The melody of the slow movement is a lovely, lyrical thing – there’s still more than a hint of Schumann, but Hol clearly has the technique to develop his ideas with some originality. (Sometimes I think there are hints of Offenbach, of all people, to be heard here too.) The third movement has the feel of a ‘hunting’-style scherzo, before Schumann and Schubert (hints of the Great C Major here) provide Hol with models for his finale. I’ve read a review which says that Hol’s symphony ‘is fresh, unpretentious, well-crafted and falls easily on the ear’, which seems to me to be about right, if maybe just ever so slightly damning with faint praise. You’ll be entirely unsurprised to note that there are no video recordings of Hol’s Symphony No 1 on YouTube, so we’re in audio-only territory here. The recordings of all four Hol symphonies are by the indefatigable Matthias Bamert (whose discography is full of overlooked, under-appreciated composers) conducting the Residentie Orchestra of The Hague, and these are the forces on this recording: Hol: Symphony No 1 in C Minor
Holmès, Augusta (1847-1903)
Day 352: Symphony - 'Roland Furieux' (Time: 26 minutes)
Today (16/12/22), I want to highlight an anniversary – of a composer of whom, apart from the fact that I mentioned her only as recently as Day 350, you may well never have heard and by whom (unless you listened to Radio 3 back in 2020, when she was featured in the ‘Composer of the Week’ series) you may never have heard any music either. So we have another composer new to this list – Augusta Holmès (1847-1903). The reason for celebrating her life and work today is that it marks, exactly, the 175th anniversary of her birth. As I mentioned on Day 350, in my second posting on the music of César Franck, Holmès was one of Franck’s pupils – a fact that caused not simply musical waves at the time. She was of Irish descent, but born in France and therefore identifying as French throughout her life – she became a French citizen in 1871, a consequence, as far as I can tell, of the patriotic fervour that followed the humiliating Franco-Prussian war of 1870. The addition of the ‘grave’ accent to her name, and the decision to pronounce it in an overtly ‘French’ way (two syllables, silent ‘H’) comes from around that time. She was, one might say, quite a character. She was regarded as exceptionally beautiful (‘a flame-haired goddess’ was one of the familiar labels that attached itself to her), and it appears that she did not fight shy of employing those charms to her advantage. She seems to have known pretty much everyone there was to know in musical circles in Paris (and beyond – she was on friendly first-name terms with both Wagner and Liszt) and her nonconformist views made her a figure on the French cultural scene. As an only child she inherited her father’s estate, thus making her not only financially independent but able to take advantage of the fact that she wasn’t encumbered with the sort of social and familial constraints that generally limited the lives of women in that era. She never married, but was the mistress of the poet Catulle Mendès, with whom she had five children – though she never appears to have acknowledged that fact in public! By some distance the most interesting thing about her creative life was the extent to which she fought against (and largely defeated) the prevailing sexism of musical and cultural life in the later 19th century. In her twenties she embarked on a compositional career in a substantial way, initially in conventionally ‘feminine’ genres (song and instrumental salon music), but there was a clear determination to conquer larger forms, notably large-scale orchestral music and opera. She studied briefly with Saint-Saëns, an experience that seems to have disturbed him greatly (like most other men she came into contact with he seems to have fallen in love with her, but at the same time to have been somewhat intimidated by her forthrightness; ‘Like children, women have no idea of obstacles, and their willpower breaks all barriers. Mademoiselle Holmès is a woman, an extremist,’ he once wrote). She began to write pieces under a male pseudonym, ‘Hermann Zenta’, but her big break came in 1876 when she was accepted as a pupil of Franck, who seems to have taken her compositional aspirations entirely seriously. Franck had a genuinely saintly reputation, but there seems little doubt that his intensely turbulent Piano Quintet of 1879 was driven by the ardour he felt for Holmès. To quote Saint-Saëns again, Franck was allegedly unable to ignore ‘her bold beautiful features, abundant golden hair, and handsome breasts of which she was justifiably proud’! (I suspect the problem here lies with Saint-Saëns: on another occasion he described her as ‘this beautiful pythoness [who] was not satisfied with cultivating art and preaching art; she caused it to flourish all about her. As Venus fecundated the world when she knotted her tresses, so Augusta Holmès shook over us her reddish locks, and when she was prodigal with the lightning of her eyes and the brilliance of her voice, we ran to our pens, our brushes; and works were born.’) From the 1870s to 90s Holmès wrote a number of substantial works – a string of symphonic poems and programmatic symphonies, and four operas. Her view on music and gender issues is perhaps best illustrated by her remark that ‘I must show the males what I’m made of!’ Perhaps the most striking illustration of that is the fact that she was commissioned in 1889 to write a major piece for the Exhibition Universelle, the event that brought the Eiffel Tower into existence. The work Holmès produced, her Ode Triomphale, called for 900 choir members and instrumental forces numbering at least 300. Clearly not a woman daunted by questions of scale! If you want any more contextual discussion of her work, there’s an interesting talk by the music researcher Anastasia Belina-Johnson on YouTube, which you can find here. As for what to choose to illustrate her music, given that the vast majority of it lies unperformed (and indeed unpublished), I thought one of the substantial orchestral pieces might show the mould-breaking determination that drove her to compose in genres that were not considered the domain of female artists at the time. This is the symphony ‘Roland Furieux’, her ‘Symphony after Ariosto for large orchestra’. It dates from 1876, so it's just about from the time that she began studying with Franck. It's a piece in three movements, which have programmatic titles: 1. Roland riding through the world in search of Angélique; 2. Angélique with her beloved, Médor, in the woods; 3. Roland, full of rage fuelled by his unrequited love. As you can tell from these details, it's a melodramatic narrative, and to a large extent the music revels in that melodrama, but I'd certainly want to argue that there’s evidence of a distinct personal voice here, and one we ought to hear considerably more of. YouTube has quite a number of audio-only performances of Holmès’ music, and the link I've selected is to what appears to have been the first performance of the symphony in modern times, given by the BBC Welsh Symphony Orchestra conducted by Valentina Peleggi. You’ll find it here: Holmès: Symphony - 'Roland Furieux'
Holst, Gustav (1874-1934)
Day 14: ‘Venus’ (from ‘The Planets’) (Two-piano arrangement) (Time: 7 minutes)
It would be utterly unfair to characterise Holst as a ‘one-hit wonder’ – there are now many recordings of his music in the catalogue, and pieces like ‘Egdon Heath’ and the ‘St Paul’s Suite’ turn up occasionally in concert programmes – but nevertheless performances and recordings of his orchestral suite ‘The Planets’ vastly outnumber those of all his other works put together. However, today (5/4/20) Malcolm suggests we listen to some familiar music in an unfamiliar guise. He writes: ‘Like most people, I've known ‘The Planets’ all my life. But it was only a couple of years ago that I discovered Holst first scored it for four hands/two pianos (except Neptune, originally scored for one player on organ.) The orchestral version came later. I really like the piano version, and it has changed how I listen to the orchestral version.’ Certainly it’s true that this version ‘clarifies’ the texture and harmonies of the original, and like many piano versions of orchestral repertoire (especially from the late 19th/early 20th centuries) there is something quite revelatory about the result. You’ll find the piano duo partnership of Richard Nettle and David Markham here: Holst – ‘Venus’ (from ‘The Planets’), two piano arrangement
Day 436: Choral Hymns from the Rig Veda (Group 3) (Time: 14 minutes)
Today (8/12/23), I have a suggestion from the invisible Pete Dutton (a regular promoter of occasionally recondite repertoire) who, a long time ago, proposed that this list should contain some more music by Holst – a composer whose catalogue of pieces is overshadowed by his single most popular work, to the extent that hardly anything else by him is widely known. Gustav Holst (1874-1934 … so almost inescapably an ‘anniversary’ composer for next year) has appeared just the once on this list to date. Unsurprisingly, back on Day 14, what we got was a movement from ‘The Planets’, though, a little more surprisingly, what Malcolm suggested back then was an arrangement of ‘Venus’ for two pianos. Well, you’ll get nothing more from ‘The Planets’ today, but rather one of Holst’s rather dreamily exotic-sounding choral pieces. Holst was part of that extraordinary generation of British composers that flourished in the early 20th century, a contemporary of lifelong friend Vaughan Williams. After graduating from the Royal College of Music in 1898, he worked in a hand-to-mouth sort of way as a professional musician, working as an organist in London churches, and as a trombone player in theatre orchestras, until he began teaching in schools as a more reliable source of income in the early 20th century. Effectively a collection of part-time posts, he was director of music at James Allen’s Girls’ School in Dulwich (1905-21), Morley College, an adult education centre in London (1907-24) and, probably most famously, at St Paul’s Girls’ School, Hammersmith (from 1905 until his death in 1934). This economic stability allowed him to devote much of the rest of his time to composition. Holst had a kind of ‘magpie’ mind, and seems to have been fascinated by a wide range of different cultures and societies from across the world. One recognisable strand here is what might be called his ‘Indian phase’, and a good many works from the first two decades of the 20th century in particular have their roots in Indian religious and cultural ideas. Musically these concepts prompted the opera ‘Sita’ (eventually, after several years, emerging in 1906), as well as several shorter pieces, like the violin and piano work ‘Maya’, from 1901. Then there is a chamber opera, ‘Savitri’ (1908). In the same year, Holst composed a setting for voice and piano of nine ‘Hymns from the Rig Veda’, a sacred Hindu text that briefly exerted a great influence on him. He translated the texts of these nine songs himself. The Rig Veda is a collection of Vedic Sanskrit hymns, texts which date back to 1000-2000BC, which makes the ‘Vedas’ the oldest body of religious texts in the world. The ‘Rig Veda’ texts are for the most part simple hymns and ritual chants and invocations to fire, water and other elemental forces. That these texts and others like them should have found their way into British culture is not surprising, given the British presence in India over the previous century and a half, and the ‘melting pot’ of different religious and spiritual ideas blending in much of Western Europe in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Musically and creatively, there’s an argument for saying that Holst’s early infatuation with Wagner (he was by no means unique as a young composer in that respect) gave way to his more mature style because he discovered a range of other fascinations which then blended together: English folksong, of course, but also the music of Ravel, and then his interest in Eastern religious ideas. And don’t forget that Holst had at least an amateur interest in astrology for pretty much all his life, even if the characterisations of the musical movements of ‘The Planets’ only use astrological concepts as their stepping-off points. How much, as it were, did Holst ‘believe in’ all this? It’s not clear, but one of his rare metaphysical observations, in relation to the ‘Rig Veda’ pieces, is this: ‘I believe most thoroughly in comradeship in all shapes as being the ideal of this world. And, as regards the future, I am Hindu enough to believe that comradeship becomes transmuted into Unity, only this is a matter that lies beyond words’ – which is suitably enigmatic… Holst followed his nine settings for solo voice with fourteen further settings for chorus (again, all translated by Holst himself), but collected into four ‘groups’: First Group for mixed chorus and orchestra; Second Group for female chorus and orchestra; Third Group for female chorus and harp; and Fourth Group for male chorus with string orchestra and optional brass. There isn’t time to explore all of these, and Mr Dutton’s suggestion is to consider the Third Group. This is made up of four pieces: ‘Hymn to the Dawn’, ‘Hymn to the Waters’, ‘Hymn to Vena’ and ‘Hymn of the Travellers’. YouTube has a number of recordings of the Third Group of Choral Hymns from the Rig Veda, and from the options I’ve gone for a live performance taken from a concert given as part of the BBC Proms in 2013. The performers are female members of the BBC Singers, accompanied on the harp by Lucy Wakeford. The music is directed by Nicholas Kok. You’ll find the recording here: Holst: Choral Hymns from the Rig Veda (Group 3)
Day 508: Egdon Heath (Time: 13 minutes) and Hammersmith (14 minutes)
Having celebrated Schoenberg’s 150th birthday on Day 507, today (20/9/24), we have yet another one – Gustavus Theodore von Holst, as he rapidly ceased to be known (he lost the ‘us’ from his first name very early on, and ‘von’ disappeared by deed poll in 1918, to avoid Germanic associations), was born 150 years ago tomorrow, 21st Sept, 1874. So, happy birthday, Gustav! We’ve had just two appearances by Holst on this list before: ‘Venus’ (from ‘The Planets’, in a version for two pianos) and Group 3 of the Choral Hymns from the Rig Veda. In my posting on the choral pieces, I briefly summarised Holst’s biography and musical development up to the point of the ‘Choral Hymns’ being written, just before the First World War. In a nutshell, one might say that in the first four decades of his life Holst was a physically frail and often paralysingly shy individual, living a largely hand-to-mouth existence as a freelance trombone player and part-time music teacher, picking up and putting down again a range of ‘influences’ on his work but still awaiting the breakthrough that would change his life. Well, having tried and (inevitably, given his health issues) failed to enlist or take an active role in wartime service, Holst spent the war years composing and continuing to teach, and one of the works he created during these years was ‘The Planets’, which from the time of its first private performance in 1918 and its first public one a year later became pretty much an instant hit with critics and the public alike. And now this is curious – almost overnight Holst went from being a struggling, often penniless composer to being feted as a musical celebrity, and this latter state he absolutely loathed. It’s not implausible to see the remaining 15 or so years of his life as being evidence of Holst trying his best to avoid public and institutional acclaim by any means he could fashion, as though success were a thing to be run away from. He turned down honours and awards, gave hardly any interviews and even refused to sign autographs. So, to celebrate his 150th birthday, I thought that I’d pick out two works that Holst wrote in his final decade, works that were met with bafflement or worse, but works that seem to me to be absolutely ‘authentic’ Holst in their inspiration and musical language. In 1927 he was commissioned by the New York Symphony Orchestra (not the New York Phil, as is often claimed) to write a symphony for them. He didn’t – but what he presented them with instead was a fairly short orchestral work of largely dour and sombre music, his tone poem ‘Egdon Heath’. Those whose literary antennae do not immediately start to vibrate at that title may not have read much Thomas Hardy. As someone who studied Hardy’s novel ‘The Return of the Native’ for A-level Lit, I fell for Hardy’s unique blend of melodrama, pessimism and mixed stylistic qualities (often passages of dazzling brilliance and clunking incompetence on the very same page) immediately, so maybe I’m biased, but it seems to me that Holst nails the ‘character’ (and it is ‘a character’, as much as any of the human participants) of the vast tract of Dorset landscape that Hardy called Egdon Heath in this composition. Apparently, Holst and Hardy (then really very old) went walking in Dorset as Holst was writing the piece, and Hardy accepted its dedication to him in 1927. (Hardy died the following year.) Holst prefaced the score with words from Hardy’s description of the landscape from ‘The Return of the Native’: ‘A place perfectly accordant with man's nature – neither ghastly, hateful, nor ugly; neither common-place, unmeaning, nor tame; but, like man, slighted and enduring; and withal singularly colossal and mysterious in its swarthy monotony!’ Early performances did not generate much enthusiasm, but it seems as though Holst himself didn’t care – he thought it his best work to date. It’s scored for a relatively restrained orchestral palate, but with more strings than usual, which Holst employs interestingly by often having these forces partly muted and partly not, which creates a curiously ‘hazy’ texture (‘colossal and mysterious’, maybe?). The work opens seemingly shapelessly, a meandering string melody that appears to go nowhere in particular. Changes of texture follow – a brass lament that feels at least a little ‘Planets’-like, and an odd dancing passage that ends abruptly before we end up pretty much as we began, in the brooding stillness of the landscape. Although one critic after an early performance wrote ‘Whereas the First Choral Symphony was stillborn, ‘Egdon Heath’ can scarcely be said to have been born at all’, its restless austerity, matching the imagined physical world of Hardy’s novels, seems to me to be perfectly achieved. YouTube doesn’t have any video recordings of the work, I’m afraid, so we’re in audio-only territory here, and out of the options I’ve gone for this performance by the Royal Scottish National Orchestra, conducted by David Lloyd-Jones: Holst: Egdon Heath. Alongside that, there’s another late work that I think sums up the characteristic sounds of Holst the mature composer. This is his ‘Hammersmith’, which Holst described as a ‘Prelude and Scherzo’. He started work on this in the summer of 1930, and its inspiration is the London borough where Holst had lived for 40 years. It was a place that he clearly loved, and his work depicts the inevitable ebb and flow of the Thames alongside the restless but largely good-humoured crowds who lived there in such cramped circumstances at the time. It was commissioned by the BBC for its military band – a full-orchestra version came the following year, but I think the wind-band instrumentation is more ‘authentic’. The printed score contains the following note written by his daughter Imogen: ‘Those who knew nothing of [Holst’s] forty-year-old affection for the Hammersmith district of London were puzzled at the title. The work is not programme music. Its mood is the outcome of long years of familiarity with the changing crowds and the changing river: those Saturday night crowds, who were always good-natured even when they were being pushed off the pavement into the middle of the traffic, and the stall-holders in that narrow lane behind the Broadway, with their unexpected assortment of goods lit up by brilliant flares, and the large woman at the fruit shop who always called him "dearie" when he bought oranges for his Sunday picnics. As for the river, when he had known it since he was a student, when he paced up and down outside William Morris' house, discussing Ibsen with earnest young socialists, during all the years since then, his favourite London walk had been along the river-path to Chiswick. In ‘Hammersmith’, the river is the background to the crowd: it is a river that goes on its way unnoticed and unconcerned.’ I don’t want to write anything else about this work, except to say that this portrait of teeming urban life alongside nature seems to me to be reminiscent of the sound world of Charles Ives in places – those snatches of popular melody in a kind of collage, sounding often in two keys at once. The piece disappeared almost immediately from the orchestral repertoire, but in its military band version it’s had a long and vivid life. This is a bit of a left-field choice, but here it is played by the University of Michigan Symphony Band, conducted by Michael Haithcock: Holst: Hammersmith
Horovitz, Joseph (b1926)
Day 7: Euphonium Concerto (2nd movement) (Time: 7 minutes)
Music today (29/3/20) to make you stop and listen is a choice from Malcolm. It’s the slow movement from the Euphonium Concerto by Joseph Horowitz. Horowitz’s Jewish family came to Britain from Vienna before the second world war. Horovitz is a conductor and academic as well as a composer. His music is accessible (he has written a great deal for television) without being ‘easy’. As Malcolm wrote to me: ‘this movement from the Horowitz concerto is one of the most "euphonious" things I know. 30 years ago I bought a euphonium and had lessons just because I wanted to be able to play this.’ Which strikes me as taking an enthusiasm for something to rather exceptional lengths, but there’s a lesson in there somewhere, I think..! You’ll find the piece here, played by David Childs and the BBC National Orchestra of Wales, conducted by Bramwell Tovey: Joseph Horovitz – Euphonium Concerto (2nd movement)
Hovhaness, Alan (1911-2000)
Day 65: ‘And God Created Great Whales’ (Time: 13 minutes)
Today (26/5/20), I thought it might be interesting to encounter another of those great American eccentrics (it’s striking how often those words turn up in collocation in relation to music), Alan Hovhaness (1911-2000). He was immensely prolific (67 symphonies and counting – there are apparently several more still in manuscript form, waiting to see the light of day), and his writing reflects the way throughout his life he maintained a kind of wide-eyed wonder at the world. Armenian by background, he absorbed all sorts of global musical and spiritual influences, producing music which is vivid, direct, often deeply mystical. One of my favourite of his works is the orchestral piece ‘And God Created Great Whales’, Op 229 No 1. It uses recordings of the singing of humpback and bowhead whales blended into the orchestral texture of the piece. The performance of the work by the Seattle Symphony Orchestra and Gerard Schwartz (and some whales, obvs!) is here: Alan Hovhaness – ‘And God Created Great Whales’
Day 73: ‘The Prayer of St Gregory’ (Time: 6 minutes)
Just over a week ago, I introduced this list to the music of Alan Hovhaness, via the sonorous soundscape of the piece ‘And God Created Great Whales’. Hovhaness’ music was evidently new to many of you, judging by the email correspondence that followed, and it caused Martin in particular to take time to do some more exploration of Hovhaness’ sound world and to come up with the suggestion for today (3/6/20). It’s for the relatively early work, ‘The Prayer of St Gregory’, which dates back to 1946. The liner notes for the CD I have of this work suggest that it was initially an interlude from a now extremely obscure opera called ‘Etchmiadzin’. In its original form, ‘The Prayer of St Gregory’ was for trumpet and strings, but since it began to take on a life of its own independent of the opera, there have been numerous arrangements of it for different forces. The performance that Martin has selected is for cornet and harmonium, in a Dutch recording by Jacq Sanders and Theo Hes. You’ll find it here: Hovhaness – ‘The Prayer of St Gregory’
Howells, Herbert (1892-1983)
Day 250: Here is the Little Door (Time: 4 minutes), A Spotless Rose (3 minutes) and Sing Lullaby (4 minutes)
Today (17/12/21) we welcome a new face into our gallery of composers. Herbert Howells (1892-1983) is probably best known these days for his extensive output of Anglican church music, but that tradition is only one of probably four main influences on his musical career: along with the church music of Tudor England, we should add the works of Vaughan Williams, English folk song, and the landscape of Howells’s native Gloucestershire. Like Parry, Vaughan Williams, Holst and Gurney (and, if we stretch geographical definitions, Elgar) Howells was another West Country composer who responded powerfully to landscape and the sense of place. But to that we should add the idea of ‘belonging’ to a sense of time too. In a telling remark, Howells said, ‘All through my life I‘ve had this strange feeling that I belonged somehow to the Tudor period, not only musically but in every way.’ A key moment of revelation in this sense came when, as a 17-year-old in Gloucester Cathedral in 1910, he heard the first performance of Vaughan Williams’ ‘Fantasia on a Theme of Thomas Tallis’ (see Day 59). As he wrote later, ‘It was after that that I felt I really knew myself, both as a man and artist. It all seemed so incredibly new at the time, but I soon came to realise how very, very old it actually was, how I’d been living that music since long before I could even begin to remember.’ After study at the Royal College of Music, he was only in his early 20s when he was diagnosed with a potentially fatal auto-immune disease and given only six months to live; he survived (don’t try this at home) by being given the then untried treatment of radium injections in the neck twice a week for the next two years! His whole professional life was spent at the RCM, where he was on the staff, amazingly, from 1920-79. His private life was touched by tragedy, when his then 9-year-old son Michael contracted polio and died within three days. A sense of grief at that event runs through so much of Howells’ later music, even compositions not explicitly referencing it. Over the decades that followed, although he wrote ‘secular’ music (there’s an excellent Cello Concerto, some lovely chamber music including the Rhapsodic Quintet for clarinet and string quartet, and some quirky keyboard music including sets of short pieces that are gentle pastiches of Elizabethan/Jacobean forms, notably ‘Lambert’s Clavichord’ and ‘Howells’ Clavichord’), he is essentially known as a composer of ‘religious’ music, even if he did not have what one might call conventional Christian beliefs. In the decades from the mid-1940s onwards, he wrote more than thirty service settings for Matins and Evensong, as well as larger-scale choral works such as his Requiem and Stabat Mater. The pieces I’ve chosen for today date from 1918-20, his three carol-anthems ‘Here is the Little Door’ (1918), ‘A Spotless Rose’ (1919) and ‘Sing Lullaby’ (1920). The first of these sets words by Frances Chesterton (wife of G.K.). As Howells recalled much later, ‘The text was found for me by GK Chesterton (to whom it is dedicated) among a sheaf of typescript poems by Mrs Chesterton.’ Its hushed tone depicts the moment of entering the stable where the Christ Child lay, by turns awed and poignant. It’s performed here by the Gesualdo Six, directed by Owain Park: Howells: Here is the Little Door. We have encountered the original German text of ‘A Spotless Rose’ recently – it’s a relatively free translation of ‘Es ist ein Ros’ entsprungen’ (see Day 248). Howells recalled, in a mixture of the sublime and the mundane, the genesis of the work: ‘This I set down and wrote after idly watching some shunting from the window of a cottage... which overlooked in Midland Station [in Gloucester]. In an upstairs room, I looked out on iron railings and the main Bristol to Gloucester railway line, with shunting trucks bumping and banging. I wrote it and dedicated it to my mother – it always moves me when I hear it, just as if it were written by someone else.’ It’s performed in this recording by the vocal ensemble Ars Nova, Copenhagen, conducted by Paul Hillier: Howells: A Spotless Rose. Finally, we have ‘Sing Lullaby’, a setting of words by the so-called ‘Laureate of Gloucestershire’, FW Harvey, almost certainly written while he was a prisoner-of-war in Germany. It’s performed on this video by the young British group Siglo de Oro, directed by Patrick Allies. You’ll find it here: Howells: Sing Lullaby
Day 356: Elegy for Viola, String Quartet and String Orchestra, Op 15 (Time: 13 minutes)
Howells (1892-1983) died on 23rd February 1983, at the age of 90, so it will be the 40th anniversary of that occasion two days from now, which is my excuse for including some music by him today (21/2/23). Howells has featured only once before on this list (see Day 250) when I chose his three Carol Anthems (‘Here is the Little Door’, ‘A Spotless Rose’ and ‘Sing Lullaby’) as part of a selection of music for Advent and Christmas. In that previous posting I explored quite a lot of biographical details so I won’t repeat them here. However, the quotation I highlighted then in relation to Howells hearing the first performance of Vaughan Williams’ ‘Fantasia on a Theme of Thomas Tallis’ in 1910, when Howells was only 17, is particularly pertinent to today’s musical choice, Howells’ Elegy for Solo Viola, String Quartet and String Orchestra, Op 15. The key issues, I think, are not just the influence of Tudor church music, but also the influence of a particularly ‘English’ way of writing for strings. In a lovely quotation from a BBC talk Howells gave in 1943, he remarked on the ‘immemorial cantabile of violins, violas and cellos … Strings were born to sing – rightly, passionately, simply, or liltingly’. Further on in the talk he imagines the sense of continuity of string writing across several centuries, how Byrd would recognise his own language in Vaughan Williams, or Purcell in Elgar. And he concludes: ‘Sonority it is – sonority without noise – which is the great abiding power of the string medium. In a world of sounding brass and tinkling cymbal, and of noise magnified to the nth degree, this it is – sonority without noise – that marks the supreme contribution made by string music to the fund of our musical enchantment.’ He namechecks English composers from Byrd, Tallis and the Elizabethans, through Locke, Purcell and Boyce, to the composers of his recent past and present: Parry, Elgar, Holst, Warlock, Vaughan Williams and Bliss. To that list we should surely add Howells himself. It seems a great shame to me that we hear so little of Howells’ orchestral music these days, overshadowed as it is by liturgical and organ pieces. In 1917, he wrote a Suite for Strings, a work in three movements, but at some point, and for reasons that remain obscure, he set it aside. However, one of the movements eventually turned up in his Concerto for Strings of 1938, and another, very substantially reworked, became today’s piece, the Elegy, Op 15. Its model, both in style and scoring, is Vaughan Williams’ ‘Tallis Fantasia’, so if you like that work it should whet your appetite for this piece. Howells wrote his own programme note for the piece (in the rather stiffly third-person voice conventional at the time) when it received its first performance, and he drew attention to the inspiration for the work: ‘It is inscribed to the memory of Francis Purcell Warren, a fellow student of the composer at the RCM in the years of the First World War. He was a Viola Scholar, and composer, and also one of the circle of young musicians [Goossens, Benjamin, Bliss and Howells], all fellow students at one time. Purcell Warren was killed in the 1914-18 War, and this ‘Elegy’ was composed soon after his death. It is not in the least ‘heroic’; it was entirely dominated (in my mind) by the personality of my friend.’ It is, it should be said, a terribly sad piece, but after its first performance it became very popular indeed, and it led to a substantial body of broadly elegiac works in Howells’ output. To go back to Howells’ observations about ‘sonority’ that I quoted earlier, I think one of the great things about this piece is the way it plays with different sonorities, the contrasts of solo viola set against a string quartet, and also against the full body of the string orchestra. It’s effectively a long slow movement, and if it has that same ‘very old and yet at the same time very new’ quality that you find in Vaughan Williams’ string works, it’s largely I think because Howells makes a lot of use of the Phrygian mode (play a scale of E – E on a piano using the white notes only): more minor than major, but not a minor key in the conventional 18th/19th century sense. There aren’t many video performances of the work on YouTube, but even though the one I’ve chosen is from a student concert I think it’s pretty impressive. The soloist is Ana Teresa Alves, with the Marmen Quartet and the Royal College of Music Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Michael Bracewell. (Incidentally, the Marmen Quartet were the first recipients of Music in the Round’s ‘Bridge’ Scheme, initiated by the late Peter Cropper of the Lindsay String Quartet, which planned to give young emerging quartets mentoring and performance experience. Several years on, you can hear the Marmen Quartet here in Sheffield next month! They’re very good.) You’ll find the performance here: Howells: Elegy for Viola, String Quartet and String Orchestra, Op 15
Day 525: Phantasy String Quartet (String Quartet 'No 2') (Time: 13 minutes)
The starting point for today (17/1/25) is a concert to be given here in Sheffield next month by Ensemble 360 of music associated with the concept of ‘fantasy’ (or sometimes, slightly archaically, ‘phantasy’), including three works in the first half called ‘Phantasy Quartet’ – one of them by Howells. We’ve had two selections so far on this list from the music of Howells (1892-1983): Day 250 for three short carol-anthems (‘Here is the little door’, ‘A spotless rose’ and ‘Sing lullaby’), and Day 356 for the Elegy for Viola, String Quartet and String Orchestra. In my discussion of those works, and of the life of the man behind them, I’ve made much of Howells' ‘Englishness’. That sense of belonging to a culture and landscape is one of the things that ties Howells very firmly into that group of composers born at the tail end of the 19th century whose musical idiom is essentially pastoral – the major figure here is Vaughan Williams, but to him you could add Finzi, Holst, Ivor Gurney and Howells himself. After his upbringing in rural Gloucestershire, and the seminal impact of hearing the first performance of Vaughan Williams’ ‘Fantasia on a Theme by Thomas Tallis’ (see Day 59), Howells moved to London in 1912 to study at the Royal College of Music, taught by those luminaries of a previous generation, Stanford and Parry. Howells seems to have thrived at the RCM. Parry noted in his diary that Howells, on his arrival at the college, seemed ‘a queer looking scrubby little creature’ (not big on compliments, then), but within months, Howells himself considered the RCM to be ‘a cosy family’, in which he felt at home and in which his creativity could flourish. Howells’ time as a student was interrupted by two things: the discovery in 1915 that he had Graves’ disease, and his consequent inability to enlist to fight in the First World War, a conflict whose shadow loomed over the society and culture of the time. It meant that Howells didn’t actually stop being a student until 1920 – and at that point he shifted seamlessly from the role of student to teacher, becoming a member of staff at the RCM for the next fifty years, only retiring in 1970! But it’s his student days that I want to focus on today, because they saw the emergence of a remarkably substantial body of work of (for a student) exceptional maturity. There’s a glimpse of Howells the Anglican choral composer to come in a setting of the Magnificat and Nunc Dimittis, and around a dozen other anthems for use in and out of church; there are some orchestral pieces, notably the ‘Elegy’ I featured on Day 356; and there are some keyboard pieces, such as the ‘Phantasy’ of 1917. But most impressively of all, there are some very eloquent pieces of chamber music, which don’t sound at all like the work of a beginner just finding his way as a composer. There’s a Piano Quartet from 1916 and a Rhapsodic Quintet (for clarinet and string quartet) from 1919. But these years also saw Howells wrestling with the challenge of writing string quartets. He wrote three in all, though in each case they don’t overtly advertise themselves as ‘string quartets’. There’s ‘Lady Audrey’s Suite’ of 1915, which is in effect his String Quartet ‘No 1’. The following year he started work on a quartet he called ‘In Gloucestershire’, a large-scale work for string quartet that occupied him from 1916-20, and which was revised later in the 1930s. These days this is usually labelled as his String Quartet ‘No 3’. Between the two, and dating from 1917, is his Phantasy String Quartet, a piece which is in effect his String Quartet ‘No 2’. This quartet has an interesting context, which takes us back to 1905 and the musical interests of an English industrialist called Walter Willson Cobbett. He set up an occasional competition in that year for a piece he described as a ‘phantasy’, with the following specification: ‘The [instrumental] parts must be of equal importance, and the duration of the piece should not exceed twelve minutes. Though the Phantasy is to be performed without a break, it may consist of different sections varying in tempi and rhythm.’ Later, in 1911, he continued: ‘I reflected that in literature there are the lyric and epic poem, the short story and the long novel; in the orchestra, besides the symphony, the overture and the symphonic poem; but that in chamber music there is only one form that counts [the string quartet] and I concluded that a new type suited to the needs of the chamber music composer was needed.’ The existence of the prize shaped much chamber composition in the first two decades of the 20th century. Winners included Bridge, Ireland and WH Reed, and outside the competition works were commissioned from composers such as Bridge (‘Phantasy for Piano Quartet’) and Vaughan Williams (‘Phantasy for String Quintet’), amongst others. Howells entered the 1917 competition, where his ‘Phantasy String Quartet’ won second prize, and 10 guineas! He was beaten to the first prize by the Folk Song Phantasy (‘Dance to your Daddy’) by Harry Waldo Warner (no, me neither). Howells’ work is rich with folk-song sentiment, from its opening violin recitative onwards. The piece, in one continuous movement, lasts only about 13 minutes, but goes through a series of character and tempo changes in the process before it ends with the same dreamy pastoral mood with which it began. Its modal harmonies and the use of the pentatonic scale (try using only the black notes on the piano) make it very similar to Vaughan Williams’s work from this period, and it shows Howells’ confidence in handling the forces of the string quartet. As for a recording, as you might expect this isn’t a work which offers a lot of choice on YouTube. However, there’s a nice video performance given under the auspices of the ‘Young Virtuosi’ Festival, an occasional series, in this case from an event from France in 2013. The musicians on this video aren’t credited, and I haven’t been able to track down any names, but you’ll find the performance here: Howells: Phantasy String Quartet (String Quartet 'No 2')
Hurlstone, William Yeates (1876-1906 )
Day 571: Fantaisie-Variations on a Swedish Air (Time: 37 minutes)
Today (2/1/26), I’m consdering the life and music of William Hurlstone, who was born on 7th January 1876, and whose 150th anniversary thus falls next Wednesday. Hurlstone is only really a name familiar to devotees of late 19th/early 20th century British music, and maybe only to slightly nerdy enthusiasts (no comments at the back there, please) within that select grouping. This seems to me to be a great shame, which is why I’d like to introduce Mr Hurlstone to those who may know nothing of him or of his music. I’d like to suggest that there are two possible reasons why Hurlstone is barely known these days: one is that there’s a lot of competition for prominence among those who came up through the teaching classes of Stanford or Parry in the Victorian/Edwardian era, and if you’ve got Holst, Ireland, Howells, Moeran, Butterworth, Bridge, Coleridge-Taylor and the rest jostling for prominence then other composers who maybe wrote far less might not get their 15 minutes of fame; and the other reason for missing out on Hurlstone and his music is that he lived to be only 30 years old, being plagued almost from birth by the bronchial asthma which killed him in 1906. But while he lived, Hurlstone was very highly thought of, and evidently had the potential to achieve exceptional things, a little of which is evident in the works he left behind that were written during his twenties. He was born in the exotic location of Fulham (fortunately neither he nor any of his forebears came from the village of Glasshouses in North Yorkshire – sorry: I’ll leave a moment or two for that to sink in, and then just quietly move on…) into a family prominent in both arts and sciences during the 19th century but who, by Hurlstone’s generation, were falling on more challenging times. He won a scholarship to study piano and composition at the Royal College of Music as an 18-year-old, where Stanford, his composition teacher, saw him as the most brilliantly gifted of all that generation of pupils that he taught. Incidentally, Elgar too noted Hurlstone’s talent, particularly his skills in variation form – and coming from the writer of the ‘Enigma’ Variations that seems like high praise. After graduating he scraped together a living as a piano teacher, choirmaster and accompanist, to help the family cope with increasing penury, and it seems like a generous benefactor and family friend, one Capt. Alexander Beaumont, funded much of the music Hurlstone was able to produce, given the intrusions of his ill health, before his early death. Almost all of Hurlstone’s music is either orchestral or for chamber forces – this makes him something of an oddity in his era, when most tyro composers were writing songs or works for solo piano. Although he wrote steadily from his early teens, Hurlstone’s extant music mostly comes from the decade after 1895. It hardly ever features on concert programmes, and even on CD there’s not an awful lot out there. If you can find recordings of them, I’d warmly recommend much of his chamber music. There’s a Piano Quartet and a Piano Trio, along with a Violin Sonata, a Cello Sonata and a Bassoon Sonata (you’ll find videos of the last of these on YouTube – it’s evidently popular nowadays with bassoonists). Most of these works were published posthumously as a tribute to Hurlstone’s unfulfilled talent. However, I thought I’d devote this posting to one of Hurlstone’s handful of orchestral works. There’s a Piano Concerto that he performed a couple of years before his death, and a great many works in variation form: Variations on an Original Theme, Variations on a Hungarian Air, and the work I want to encourage you to listen to here, his Fantaisie-Variations on a Swedish Air. This seems to have started life as a piece for piano duet, but by the summer of 1903 it was finished in its orchestral guise, and it got its first performance, conducted by Stanford, in May of the following year. There was another performance in 1906 just before Hurlstone’s death, but it wasn’t published until 1910. The work is indeed based on a Swedish melody, ‘De Rosor, och der Blader de göra mig så glader’ – which I’m sure you don’t need me to translate (though I will…) as ‘The roses, the leaves, they make me so happy’. (The Swedes in Fotherington-Thomas mode there...) Despite its rather dilettante-sounding title, the ‘Fantaisie-Variations’ is generally considered to be Hurlstone’s masterpiece among his orchestral works, and it’s certainly a long way from the approach to writing sets of variations that finds a nice tune and then decorates it with increasing ornamentation through the variations that follow. What you get from Hurlstone is, instead, something that feels much more ‘symphonic’ in scope. Partly, as Hurlstone himself noted, this is because the variations are ‘for the most part continuous, with a view to avoiding that tendency to patchiness which this form of composition is apt to create.’ The melody itself is a gentle, rather pastoral thing, and in and of itself it surely wouldn’t sustain a substantial 20-minute work. What’s fascinating about Hurlstone’s approach is that so much of what follows the statement of the theme is actually an exploration of counterpoint (that is, counter melodies that could run alongside the folk theme) – and in many of these variations the original theme is left almost as just an idea, a couple of chord changes, or a bit of interesting harmony. By the time we get to Variations 12-15 the effect is, I would suggest, seriously impressive. It will surprise you not at all to know that YouTube has no video recordings of this (or indeed of any other orchestral works by Hurlstone), so it’s audio-only territory yet again, which is a shame. Still, one of the landmark early recordings of Hurlstone’s orchestral music was a disc made by the London Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Nicholas Braithwaite, and it’s their version that you’ll find here: Hurlstone: Fantaisie-Variations on a Swedish Air
Ibert, Jacques (1890-1962)
Day 182: Divertissement (Time: 17 minutes)
Welcome to the second of this week’s two postings on ‘serenades and diversions’. And as trailed last time out, this posting explores a French take on the theme. Today (23/4/21) then, we have music by Jacques Ibert (1890-1962), brother of the more famous Ted (to get the old joke out of the way as soon as possible), and his irrepressible ‘Divertissement’. As I explained previously, the French term ‘divertissement’ is roughly equivalent to the Italian ‘divertimento’ – with the caveat that ‘divertissement’ came to have a separate, distinctive meaning in the world of opera and ballet, where a ‘divertissement’ – an ‘entertainment’, usually with little to do with the main action – might be inserted into the plot, such as the ballet section that turns up in Gounod’s opera ‘Faust’. This digression is of relatively little help in explaining Ibert’s ‘Divertissement’, however, which came about in an entirely different fashion. Ibert is an interesting and often overlooked composer (I’ve lost track of the number of times I’ve written something like that over the months of writing these notes), who had little to do with most of the fashionable groups of composers taking a stand for this or that approach to composition in the first half of the 20th century. He’s almost exactly the contemporary of Poulenc, but where Poulenc formed part of the coterie of composers known as ‘Les Six’, Ibert tended to keep himself to himself, picking up and putting down styles in a chameleon-like way. The word most often used to describe his work is ‘eclectic’: ‘All systems are valid’, he wrote on one occasion. Probably his most famous work other than the ‘Divertissement’ is his set of symphonic portraits ‘Escales’ (‘Ports of Call’), but you’d never guess that they were by the same composer; whereas ‘Escales’ is a lush, exotic late-Romantic score, the ‘Divertissement’ is sharp, ironic, cartoonish. He wrote extensively for the stage, particularly (though never really successfully) the opera, and in later life wrote a good many film scores. ‘Divertissement’ started life as the incidental music for a stage play, the farce ‘The Italian Straw Hat’, by the 19th century French dramatists Labiche and Marc-Michel, subsequently turned into at least six film versions over the years. Like many French farces, its plot is absurd, involving the urgent search for a new straw hat for our heroine for her wedding, the previous one having been eaten by a horse whilst said heroine was canoodling in the shrubbery on the morning of her wedding day with her secret lover. (That’s the French for you…) Ibert took six short numbers from the stage score and worked them into a suite for small orchestra. We start, logically, with an Introduction, a frenetic and chaotic overview of the action. Then there is a Cortege, a kind-of-solemn procession which keeps slipping out of order, mangling Mendelssohn’s ‘Wedding March’ in the process. There follows a Nocturne, a satirical Waltz and a Parade of deliberate banality. Finally, as one might expect, there’s a Finale: it starts with crashing dissonant chords on the piano, before a crazy slapstick scurrying whirls the music to an end. It’s just about possible to hear that the horse has the last laugh. As for a performance, I’ve picked out the video recording on YouTube by the socially-distanced WDR Symphony Orchestra, Cologne, conducted by Cristian Măcelaru, for us to listen to. You’ll find it here: Ibert: Divertissement
Day 452: Cinq Pieces en Trio (Time: 9 minutes)
Monsieur Ibert has made just one appearance on this list to date – see Day 182 which featured his fizzing, irrepressible ‘Divertissement’ – so another one is in order. Descriptions of the life and musical talents of Jacques François Antoine Marie Ibert, to give him his full collection of names, tend to home in on two things: his choice not to belong to any kind of ‘school’ or musical grouping, and his lifelong identity as a Parisian artist. Though he did spend time elsewhere (on military service in the navy in the First World War, three years in Rome after that as winner of the 1919 Prix de Rome, from 1937-55 in Italy as the director of the Academie de France in Rome, apart from a hiatus during the Second World War), he seems to have been attached both emotionally and in terms of family ties to the French capital. As for Ibert’s ‘eclecticism’ and his willingness seemingly to pick and choose from the musical styles he heard around him, all I’d say is that although it can be hard to hear a piece of his music and say definitively that it’s clearly Ibert’s ‘voice’, there are some features that run pretty consistently through his compositions. There’s a nice quotation from his biographer, Alexandra Laederich: ‘His music can be festive and gay … lyrical and inspired, or descriptive and evocative … often tinged with gentle humour … all the elements of his musical language bar that of harmony relate closely to the Classical tradition.’ And as for harmony, although he has his ‘spiky’ moments, these tend to be localised and for (often humorous) effect, so there’s nothing in Ibert’s music that would, as it were, frighten the horses. It would probably be fair to describe him as a frustrated opera composer – he wrote seven, none of them particularly successful – and instead his most enduring pieces tend to be shorter items, often whimsical. He wrote a good many film scores and some incidental music for the theatre, in both fields showing a knack for the quick and vivid sketching in of setting and mood. He also wrote a very great deal of chamber music, much of it for wind players – and it’s this that brings me to the piece for today (2/2/24). Probably the most popular of Ibert’s wind works is his ‘Trois Pieces Breves’ for wind quintet, but it’s another, slightly later work that Ensemble 360 are playing in concert here in Sheffield next week. This is Ibert’s ‘Cinq Pièces en Trio’, which dates from 1935. The ‘Five Pieces’ are very short: the whole work comes in at about nine minutes, and the individual movements range from about 30 seconds to three minutes in length. Still, within this tiny framework, Ibert weaves music that both suits the individual characters of the three players and generates plenty of his typical French flair and wit. The five short movements alternate fast and slow sections: first, an Allegro Vivo which is a vigorous march-like piece; then an Andantino, which is barely long enough to function as much more than an upbeat to the following Allegro Assai, which makes playful use of the call of the cuckoo; the fourth movement is a short Andante, again barely more than an upbeat to the final Allegro Quasi Marziale. This last movement isn’t really all that ‘martial’, but brings the work to a perky close. There are some nice performances of this genial and easy-going music on YouTube, and from the options available I’ve gone for this recording by three members of what seems to be a loose collection of American performers that go under the umbrella name of Camarada. In this case, we have Sarah Skuster on oboe, Sheryl Renk on clarinet and Ryan Simmons on bassoon. You’ll find their performance here: Ibert: Cinq Pieces en Trio
d’Indy, Vincent (1851-1931)
Day 174: Cello Sonata (Time: 19 minutes)
Today’s featured composer was born 170 years ago tomorrow. I suspect he will be a musical figure known only to a few of you – and I think, if I were that way inclined (I’m not), I’d wager a small amount on the claim that none of you will ever before have heard the piece I’m suggesting we listen to. So let’s hear it today (26/3/21) for Vincent d’Indy (1851-1931), a French composer whose musical roots were, as you can see, in the mid-19th century, but who survived long enough to be regarded as a complete musical anachronism by the time he died in 1931. I find him a fascinating composer, and very definitely an underrated one. Some of his contemporaries have fared rather better in terms of reputation (Saint-Saëns, Franck and Fauré, for example) but d’Indy played a significant role in late 19th/early 20th century French musical life. He was born into an aristocratic French family (he is Paul Marie Theodore Vincent d’Indy, in full) and he seems to have therefore had sufficient financial independence after his grandmother’s death in 1872 to be able to devote himself to musical study and composition. He became a student of Cesar Franck at the Paris Conservatoire (and, as I type that, I realise with some sadness that Franck himself has not yet featured on this list – we’ll have to remedy that pronto), and became a ‘disciple’ of Franck in the decades that followed. Like Franck, d’Indy fell heavily under the spell of Wagner, though he also felt committed to developing a distinctively French approach to music, being a founder member of the Société Nationale de Musique, a movement founded after the catastrophic outcome of the Franco-Prussian War of 1870, and which aimed to avoid copying the dominant Germanic approaches to composition. (d’Indy became President of the society for a time after Franck's death in 1890.) However, d’Indy felt little sympathy with the more modernist trends in music in the early 20th century, seeing himself as having little in common with rising stars such as Debussy and Ravel, and even less with the more iconoclastic figures of the next generation like Poulenc and the other members of ‘Les Six’. I reckon the only work by d’Indy which has anything like an ongoing life in the concert hall these days is his Symphony on a French Mountaineer’s Song (which, despite the title, is in effect a piano concerto), though there are a great many other pieces that deserve attention: if you like big sweeping symphonies in the vein of Franck or Chausson, you should try his Symphony No 2 in Bb; fans of late 19th century chamber music should look out for his String Quartets Nos 1&2, and there’s a Piano Sonata in E from the first decade of the 20th century which is as stirringly compelling as the sonata by Dukas. However, the work I want to home in on today is d’Indy's Cello Sonata, Op 84, which dates from 1925. By that time, the musical world had very definitely passed him by, and I have the strong sense (as with Saint-Saëns' late chamber music) that this is a sonata d’Indy wrote simply to please himself. It is in four movements, and it has all those characteristics that have come to be seen as reflecting a distinctively French musical sensibility: charm, elegance, fluidity, and a kind of nostalgia for older musical forms. The first movement, Entrée, is thoughtful, but it’s followed by three more whose titles (Gavotte en Rondeau, Air and Gigue respectively) highlight this backward-looking tendency. However, this is no simple pastiche. The formal elegance is the vehicle for lyrical dancing in the second movement, a mood of gentle melancholy in the third, and a robust playfulness in the finale. As I’ve written a number of times about a number of musical choices on this list recently, nobody is going to mistake this for music of earth-shattering greatness, but it has a beauty and grace all of its own. Not surprisingly, there aren’t that many performances of this work to choose from on YouTube, but I’m very happy with the audio recording by the cellist Nicolas Altstaedt (a BBC New Generation Artist about a decade ago), accompanied by the pianist Jose Gallardo. You’ll find it here: d'Indy: Cello Sonata
Day 582: Symphony on a French Mountain Air (Time: 27 minutes)
Exactly one week from today (20/3/26), it will be 150 years since the birth of Vincent d’Indy so this posting should shine some light on (in my opinion) this still far too easily overlooked late 19th/early 20th century composer. And for his impending birthday I’d like to introduce you, if you don’t know it already, to d’Indy’s most famous work. Paul Marie Théodore Vincent d'Indy, in full, has appeared once before on this list – see Day 174 for his nostalgic, elegant Cello Sonata of 1925. As I wrote back then, d’Indy doesn’t get much of a look in these days, though the music label Chandos has a fine series of recordings devoted to his orchestral music, and you can even find quite a bit of his chamber music if you look hard enough. It would be fair to say that although he was massively important to the development of French musical studies in the period 1870-1910 in particular – as Secretary and then President of the Société Nationale de Musique that was founded immediately after the terribly humiliating Franco-Prussian War of 1870-71, as co-founder of the Schola Cantorum de Paris, set up to promote greater intellectual musical rigour than was allegedly on offer at the Paris Conservatoire, and as the teacher of an authentic ‘who’s who’ of later generations of composers (Magnard, Roussel, Honegger, Milhaud, Canteloube, Satie – though he claimed to have learned nothing from the experience – and, implausibly, Cole Porter) – it’s still a rare thing to encounter a work by d’Indy in the concert hall, or even on the radio. It’s hard to escape the thought that d’Indy’s time in the spotlight never quite came to pass. He was (like his mentor César Franck) in love with Wagner’s music at a time when all things Germanic were shunned in France after the 1870 war. He managed the Schola Cantorum in an essentially backward-looking way, focusing on technique and the lessons of the past at a time when Debussy and Ravel were pushing the boundaries of harmonic invention in the direction of the future. He could make nothing of the subversive wit of Poulenc and his contemporaries in the years after the First World War so that by his death in 1931 he was so far from the musical spotlight that he had effectively disappeared from musical life years before. Add to this the fact that after the death of his first wife in 1905 he seems to have become something of an outspoken hard-line, very right wing and often overtly anti-Semitic Catholic traditionalist, losing the moderating influence that she apparently had on him, and you can see why he was often at odds with his age. And yet… Well, for me the ‘and yet…’ is that his music is superbly crafted, often very impressively orchestrated, wearing its influences (Beethoven, Wagner, Gregorian chant, regional folk music) lightly enough to be able to allow him to forge his own voice out of them. And the piece I’ve chosen for today is, I hope, proof of that. It’s the Symphonie sur un Chant Montagnard Français – the Symphony on a French Mountain Air, in English – though it’s also sometimes known as the Symphonie Cévenole, because it’s principal theme was one that d’Indy heard while staying in the area around Périer in the Cévennes mountains. It’s a work that’s hard to categorise, in that although d’Indy called it a ‘symphony’, it’s not a symphony in the conventional 19th century sense. And although it has a prominent part for piano, it’s not really a piano concerto (or at least, only as much as, say, Falla’s ‘Nights in the Gardens of Spain – see Day 240!). It might be described as a set of variations, in that the principal theme is explored in all three movements, though it’s not a ‘theme and variations’ in the conventional sense either! All this means it doesn’t fit neatly into any kind of box, which might explain at least some of its neglect over the past 50 years or so. d’Indy wrote it in 1886 – which makes it contemporary with pieces like Saint-Saens’ Symphony No 3 or Franck’s Symphony in D Minor – and, sticking my neck out, I’d describe it as a kind of little sibling of those two huge masterpieces. Part of d’Indy’s assertive patriotism can be found in his dedication to regional folk music, and the tune that dominates this work has both a precise regional identity and yet (like Franck’s work) it is treated ‘cyclically’. That is, it undergoes varieties of transformation so that the work as a whole has a (symphonic?) unity. There are other reasons to love it, beyond the fact that it’s great fun to listen to. For one, listen out to the way d’Indy employs the dialogue between piano and harp – it’s very original and forward-looking. I wondered about offering some kind of analytical breakdown of the structure of each of its movements, but (though the work’s organisation, both within and between movements, is complex) I think the thing I’d most want you to do in relation to this piece is just to enjoy it! And happy birthday, M. d’Indy! One of the challenges with this work on YouTube is that the only video recording is of an orchestra made up of music students en route to their first professional placements, a body called The Orchestra Now, based at Bard College in the USA. If a video recording is what you want, you’ll find it here. However, for me it’s a performance that has some ragged edges, and for something more cohesive and elegant, we’re in audio-only territory. There’s a classic old(er) recording – that is, it’s from the 1970s, which it’s sobering to note is now quite some time ago – featuring the Orchestre de Paris, conducted by Serge Baudo, and the solo pianist is the aristocratic Aldo Ciccolini. You’ll find their version here: d'Indy: Symphony on a French Mountain Air
Ives, Charles (1874-1954)
Day 89: Symphony No 2 (5th movement) (Time: 10 minutes)
Today (19/6/20), it’s time for yet another of those ‘great American eccentrics’, who seem to populate the terrain of classical music in great numbers. Today’s oddball is Charles Ives (1874-1954), a composer who resolutely ploughed his own furrow in the early years of the 20th century, and just kept right on going. For much of his life, his music was completely ignored, even though the things he was experimenting with (like polyrhythmic compositions, or polytonal compositions, or working in quarter-tones, or using random/chance choices in performance) became fairly normal for the avant-garde in the 1950s/60s. He was a great champion of making music out of everything that surrounded him in everyday life, and he incorporated popular folk songs, or hymn tunes, or military marches, into the fabric of his compositions, often all at the same time. That might make his music sound challenging to listen to, and some of it is. However, I’ve selected the final movement of Ives’ Symphony No 2, which is a great tumbling mish-mash of snatches of Brahms, Beethoven, Bach and Dvorak mixed up with glimpses of ‘Camptown Races’ and ‘Columbia, the Gem of the Ocean’ amongst many, many others. The symphony was composed at the very beginning of the 20th century, but was not performed until Leonard Bernstein, a great champion of Ives’ music, premiered it in 1951. And what of that final chord? It’s been described, in American parlance, as a ‘Bronx cheer’ – what we in the UK might call ‘blowing a raspberry’. It seems to me that, in a very good humoured way, it’s saying ‘Up yours!’ to the great traditions of 19th century symphonic music. There are few video recordings of the movement on YouTube, so here is Bernstein’s audio recording of it, performed with the New York Phil: Charles Ives – Symphony No 2 (5th movement)
Day 299: Variations on 'America' (Time: 9 minutes) and 2. Variations on 'America' (orch. Schuman) (7 minutes)
Most of us will have found it hard to avoid flag-waving royalist enthusiasts over the last few days, even if we’d wanted to. The National Anthem was just about everywhere. Interestingly, I discovered, digging around a bit, that ‘God Save the Queen’ is still several countries’ anthem, including New Zealand, Norfolk Island, Tokelau, as well as the various Crown Dependencies (Isle of Man, Jersey, Guernsey, etc.) and Overseas Territories (Falkland Islands, Gibraltar, etc.). What’s more, the tune for ‘God Save the Queen’ (though with different words) is also the national anthem of Liechtenstein, not to mention the royal anthem (a slightly different thing) of Norway. And, as those of a historical bent will know, the national anthem of the USA is now ‘The Star-Spangled Banner’, but only since 1931. Before that, using the lyrics ‘My Country, ‘Tis of Thee’, the tune we know as ‘God Save the Queen’ was also, under the name ‘America’, one of the national anthems of the USA. So, why the history lesson? Well, because when last time out I promised that today (7/6/22) I’d blow a very very gentle raspberry in the direction of all this royalist ceremonial stuff we’ve been experiencing recently, the vehicle for this raspberry-blowing is a composition by the then very young Charles Ives. Ives has appeared only once on this list thus far (see Day 89), when we entered the chaotic and cartoon-like world of the last movement of Ives’s Symphony No 2. As I noted back then, Ives was, if you like, the great lost genius of American music, a composer whose work was ignored for almost all his creative life, but who went on ploughing a lonely furrow through the first half of the 20th century, doing extraordinary things with music that avant-garde composers would ‘discover’ for themselves later in the middle years of the 20th century, only to find that Ives had got there before them when his music did make its way to a wider public, thanks very largely to the efforts of Leonard Bernstein. Ives grew up in Connecticut in the last decades of the 19th century, in a world of church choirs, marching bands and amateur orchestras. If you know much of his music, you’ll know one of his signature techniques is setting off the rhythms and harmonies of several different tunes at the same time, playing at different speeds and in different keys. Ives’ ears were attuned to this order/disorder sitting in the town square in Danbury, Connecticut, listening to his father’s marching band practising, whilst, at the same time, other marching bands practised different pieces on other sides of the central space. Ives himself started playing and then composing music quite early on. He became organist at the local Methodist church at the age of 14, and it was his job not just to accompany congregational singing, but to provide organ solos at the beginning and end of the service. At the age of 17 he composed his ‘Variations on “America”’, allegedly for the 4th of July celebrations at the church, and Ives himself has commented that he played the piece more than once at services afterwards, though as he said, his father ‘didn't let me do it much, as it made the boys laugh’ in church. It’s a short piece, consisting of an Introduction and Theme (‘America’, or ‘God Save the Queen’ as we know it), followed by five variations – and two ‘Interludes’, which are like very truncated variations – and a concluding Coda. Actually, when I noted earlier that the piece is a kind of aural raspberry, I don’t think Ives necessarily intended it that way. It’s subversive, yes, and anarchic in places – in the Interludes we get extensive use of ‘bitonality’ where music is being played in two different keys at the same time, a memory for Ives, almost certainly, of those days listening to multiple marching bands back in Danbury. The other variations exploit different effects (there’s one that has the feel of a fairground organ, for instance, and another that has an underlying Latin American dance rhythm), using the sorts of mixed high/low culture effects that Ives was to take so much further in his more mature music. Ives’ piece started life as an organ solo, so I thought it would be sensible to share with you a version in that form. If nothing else, this video underlines just how complicated it is to be an organist (at least, playing this sort of music!), brought out vividly by the split screens of this recording. You’ll find it here, performed by the organist Joseph Ripka: Ives: Variations on 'America'. However, as there’s enough time this week for a little more, you may like to consider this version too, as orchestrated by the American composer William Schuman in 1962. His version points up the playful qualities of the work, in a way which brings out the humour. You’ll find it here, in an impressive audio-only recording by the Philadelphia Orchestra conducted by Eugene Ormandy (and alongside a score for you to follow if that’s your sort of thing): Ives: Variations on 'America' (orch. Schuman)
Day 439: The Unanswered Question (Time: 6 minutes)
Today (19/12/23) I have another suggestion from the invisible Pete Dutton, for what is one of the most fascinating and enigmatic pieces of music in the orchestral repertoire. Charles Ives (1874-1954… and so another composer with a big anniversary coming up next year) has featured twice on this list already, on Day 89 when I included the final, uproarious movement of his Symphony No 2, and on Day 299 when I featured both versions (organ and orchestral) of his Variations on ‘America’. For today, Pete has suggested we listen to a work roughly contemporary with the 2nd Symphony, though with Ives it’s very difficult to be sure about dates of composition because he seemed to regard almost everything he wrote as a ‘work in progress’, and would often return to pieces many years later and rework them, or cannibalise them for use in another composition entirely. This whole process was in large measure a consequence of the fact that hardly any of Ives’ music was performed just after he wrote it, and in many cases first performances had to wait several decades. Ives was an extraordinary composer. The liner notes to one of the CDs of his work that I have puts this well, I think: ‘No creative artist’s life was ever as badly timed as that of Charles Ives. He was obliged to earn his living as an insurance agent in order to be able to compose at weekends music so far ahead of its time that nobody wanted to listen to it. The passing of time has brought him his revenge, for his brilliant intuitions have been incorporated one by one into the musical language of [the 20th] century.’ That sense of initial bafflement and more recent realisation was clearly evident in today’s work, ‘The Unanswered Question’. This was initially composed in 1908, when it formed part of a two-work set to which Ives gave the title ‘Two Contemplations’. The first of those two pieces was ‘The Unanswered Question’, to which Ives gave the subtitle ‘A Contemplation of a Serious Matter’. (The second work in the group, ‘Central Park in the Dark’, subtitled ‘A Contemplation of Nothing Serious’, was actually composed first, but then revised after he’d completed his first version of ‘The Unanswered Question’ – the latter a piece that Ives came back to more than 25 years later to tinker with some more.) One of the remarkable things about Ives’ work is how long he had to wait to hear pieces being performed. ‘The Unanswered Question’ in its revised form had its first performance in 1946, and the original version had to wait until 1984! For a work so relatively short, it has generated an immense amount of discussion, both musical and philosophical. So, what was this ‘unanswered question’? Well, and I simplify some very complicated things here, it’s a bit like this. The music has three distinct sets of material. First, there is a sort of string chorale, a slow, serene, ‘gauzy’ sort of sound, which, said Ives, represents ‘the silence of the Druids, who know, see and hear nothing’. (It seems to have been Ives’ original intention that these string players should be ‘offstage’, or at least far enough away from the other performers so as not to ‘influence’ them.) Then, in the foreground as it were, we have a solo trumpet that, seven times over, plays a figure that asks ‘the perennial question of existence’. In response to this, a group of woodwinds, sometimes (as in the performance below) four flutes, sometimes flutes with oboe and clarinet (the ‘fighting answerers’), tries vainly six times to provide an answer, each time getting more agitated and dissonant. Recognising the futility of their efforts, after six times they give up, and so the trumpet’s seventh utterance of the question remains unanswered; as Ives puts it, ‘the question is heard a last time as it comes up against the impenetrable wall of the Druids’ silence’. So we end with the strings, again as Ives puts it, ‘humming softly in the distance, like the eternal music of the spheres’. All of which feels pretty existentially deep! Further discussion (and trust me, there is a lot of it out there) often feels a bit ‘pseuds’ corner-ish’ in its pretentiousness. A way into the work might be to consider the poem ‘The Sphinx’ by the American transcendentalist writer Ralph Waldo Emerson, which appears to be where Ives got his title from; in the poem Emerson says of the sphinx: ‘thou art the unanswered question’. As for a performance of the work, YouTube has a good performance of it, I think, by the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Andrés Orozco-Estrada. You’ll notice that the strings (somewhat larger forces than Ives intended) are onstage, but the solo trumpet is offstage, and invisible to us. You’ll find the piece here: Ives: The Unanswered Question
Day 512: Three Places in New England (Time: 20 minutes)
The posting for today (18/10/24) marks a big birthday, this time of Charles Ives, who was born on 20th October 1874, making him 150 years old, in a manner of speaking, two days from now. It’s an occasionally challenging listening experience that I’ve lined up for us all, but worth it, I think. Ives has appeared three times to date on this list. When I first featured him, I presented him as a ‘great American eccentric’ – one of many that the USA has produced in the past couple of centuries. Without rehearsing the content of those earlier discussions again, the standout features of Ives’ (remarkably consistent) style are, in no particular order: a ‘magpie’ approach to collecting and quoting other pieces of music in his own work, which is often a densely-packed collage of this material; a resolute defiance of traditional harmonic and rhythmic conventions, and in particular a fascination with writing music in multiple keys or multiple rhythms at the same time; a love for and celebration of all aspects of late 19th/early 20th century American life, blending both ‘high’ and ‘low’ culture; an interest in philosophical issues and a desire to express them in his music (as in ‘The Unanswered Question’ – see Day 439); and a complete refusal to take decades of neglect, in which the musical establishment largely ignored him, as a reason for not pursuing the sound world generated by his unique musical sensibility. One thing that I didn’t explore much in my commentaries on previous Ives postings was the question of when he wrote, and why he wrote in the forms and for the forces that he did employ. Almost all his compositions emerged in the period 1890-1918. At that time he was not a professional musician, but instead, on his graduation from Yale in 1898, he became an insurance agent, initially for a firm called Charles H Raymond and Co., and then, from 1907 until he retired in the 1930s, for his own insurance business (Ives & Co., later Ives & Myrick). There can’t be many composers out there whose magnum opus, at least in terms of public recognition by the time they reach the age of 45, is a tome called ‘Life Insurance with Relation to Inheritance Tax’! Of course, throughout those years he was, as a sideline, writing music, hardly any of which was played at the time, unless Ives himself happened to finance its performance, and much of which existed as ‘works in progress’ with which he tinkered over and over again, drafting and redrafting, in his evenings and at weekends. This is one of the reasons why so many of Ives’ works can be hard to date, because they mutated over the decades. One other issue worth commenting on is the fact that (in some ways like Sibelius at roughly the same time) there came a point when he simply stopped composing, even though he had a good 25 years to live. Apparently he came downstairs from his study one day in 1927 and said to his wife, ‘Nothing sounds right.’ After that, although he spent his years going back over previous pieces, nothing new emerged. The piece I’ve chosen to celebrate Ives’ big birthday demonstrates just this kind of reworking. This is his ‘Three Places in New England’, also sometimes known as his ‘Orchestral Set No 1’. (There is also an ‘Orchestral Set No 2’, dating approximately – and with the reservations about dates that might be obvious by now – from 1915-19, but it gets nothing like the performance time of its predecessor.) ‘Three Places in New England’ is, as the title suggests, in three movements, each marking a location in the New England landscape, which is where Ives had his roots. Ives found the three-movement form attractive, using it repeatedly, and in particular being fond of a slow-fast-slow pattern for those movements. The first movement is called (with due consideration made of its now somewhat politically incorrect title) ‘The “St. Gaudens” in Boston Common (Col. Robert Gould Shaw and his Colored Regiment)’. The ‘St. Gaudens’ in question is a bas-relief by the sculptor Augustus Saint-Gaudens, that depicts the first Black regiment to fight in the American Civil War. In particular it commemorates a heroic and largely doomed assault by the regiment on the Confederate stronghold of Fort Warner in South Carolina. Ives seems to have begun this movement in the years before the First World War, though it wasn’t ‘completed’ until the early 1920s, and was then substantially rewritten in 1929 for its first performance (more on this later). For the most part it’s a slow, brooding march, underscored by a traditional military band’s drumbeat, along with old Civil War songs, 19th century parlour ballads and Negro spirituals. The middle movement is one of Ives’ characteristic polytonal, polyrhythmic up-tempo pieces; he wrote a good deal in this vein, all of which seem traceable back to his childhood experience of watching his bandmaster father rehearsing a marching band … alongside other marching bands all playing, chaotically at once, in the town square of his childhood in Danbury, Connecticut. The piece is called ‘Putnam’s Camp, Redding, Connecticut’, where there is a landmark to commemorate Gen. Israel Putnam, a leader in the Revolutionary War of the 1770s, especially the Battle of Bunker Hill. This movement has, as I say, very deep roots for Ives, and he wrote this quasi-autobiographical anecdote at the head of the score: ‘Once upon a '4 July,' some time ago, so the story goes, a child went here on a picnic, held under the auspices of the First Church and the village cornet band. Wandering away from the rest of the children past the camp ground into the woods, he hopes to catch a glimpse of some of the old soldiers. As he rests on the hillside of laurels and hickories the tunes of the band and the songs of the children grow fainter and fainter; – when – "mirabile dictu" – over the trees on the crest of the hill he sees a tall woman standing. She reminds him of a picture he has of the Goddess Liberty – but the face is sorrowful – she is pleading with the soldiers not to forget their "cause" and the great sacrifices they have made for it. But they march out of camp with fife and drum to a popular tune of the day. Suddenly, a new national note is heard. Putnam is coming over the hills from the center, – the soldiers turn back and cheer. – The little boy awakes, he hears the children's songs and runs down past the monument to "listen to the band" and join in the games and dances.’ The final movement also has a deeply personal prompt. It’s called ‘The Housatonic at Stockbridge’. Either just before or after his marriage in 1908 (recollections vary, as they say) Ives and his wife(-to-be) went walking by the side of the Housatonic River in this idyllic rural setting in Massachusetts. Ives wrote later, ‘We walked in the meadows along the river, and heard the distant singing from the church across the river. The mist had not entirely left the river bed, and the colors, the running water, the banks and elm trees were something that one would always remember.’ A mere two days later Ives started sketching musical ideas for a depiction of this experience, though characteristically it would be another five years before it reached an even vaguely finished form, which depicts the mist and fog rolling over the expanse of the river and the echoes of singing from the church across the way dissolving into the distance. And so to a performance. Well, the first performance of the work wasn’t until 1930, and this was of a much-reduced version for a chamber orchestra (the original, now lost, seems to have been for a full symphony orchestra), because Ives was encouraged by the enthusiast for his music, the conductor Nicolas Slonimsky, to rework the piece for his forces, the Boston Chamber Orchestra. Since then attempts have been made to reconstruct a working version of the larger piece, even though Ives didn’t so much rescore it as rewrite a lot of it. Anyway, it’s that 1931 performing chamber version that I’ve gone for here, in a video recording of a performance by the Paris-based Ensemble Intercontemporain, conducted by Matthias Pintscher. You’ll find it here: Ives: Three Places in New England
Janáček, Leos (1854-1928)
Day 9: ‘Love Letter’ (from ‘Moravian Folk Poetry in Songs’) (Time: 2 minutes)
Leos Janacek is, by most estimates, the greatest Czech composer since Dvorak. Although he wrote a large quantity of music throughout his life, he is often regarded as the ideal example of a ‘late flowerer’, in that most of his greatest works date from the last 20 years of his life. He wrote extensively for orchestra, chamber groups and solo piano, but the bulk of his mature output was written for the opera house. The biggest influence on his life was probably Moravian folk music (and folk culture more generally), and you can hear the impact that this music has on pretty much all his work. Today (31/3/20) we have another request from Martin. It takes us explicitly to Moravia, the area in the east of the Czech Republic, where the composer Janacek collected and arranged folk music throughout much of his life. The 53 folk song arrangements that he gathered together during the final decade of the 19th century and published as ‘Moravian Folk Poetry in Songs’ include this little gem, entitled ‘Love Letter’. It’s sung here by (and I’m sorry that I don’t have the skill/patience to put all the relevant diacritics on the letters) the soprano Iva Bittova, accompanied by the Skampa Quartet. You’ll find it here: Leos Janacek – ‘Love Letter’ (from ‘Moravian Folk Poetry in Songs’)
Day 119: Pohadka, for Cello and Piano (Time: 11 minutes)
Janacek featured early on in the history of this playlist (see Day 9), an exquisite miniature folk song setting for soprano and string quartet. This week, I want to shift the focus to later in Janacek’s life than the 1890s, when that arrangement was made, and consider two works that form part of Janacek’s ‘late flowering’ as a composer. In some ways it seems scarcely credible that Janacek was a mere 13 years younger than Dvorak, so that during the 19th century they were regarded almost as contemporaries. The reason this seems so strange is that although Janacek wrote a lot of music during the 1880s-90s that bears all the hallmarks of 19th century Czech nationalism and the easy-going charm of Dvorak’s Czech pastoral style (see his Idyll for Strings, say, or the Moravian Dances), almost all the music by Janacek that we hear these days comes from the period from 1905-28, when we encounter the mature Janacek who is most definitely a ‘modern’ composer. There are many reasons for this maturing style, but I’d argue that we could look to the familial (the death of his daughter in 1903), the political (Janacek’s witnessing of the violent suppression of a demonstration in support of a Czech university in Brno, his home city, which led to Janacek’s bitter and furious Piano Sonata - 1.X.1905) and the personal (Janacek’s sense of growing frustration at his relative lack of success as he entered his sixth decade, leading him to destroy a number of early works and resolve to strike out in new directions). So, today (15/9/20), to the first of my choices to illustrate this late stage of Janacek’s career, the chamber music piece for cello and piano, ‘Pohadka’, which dates from 1910. I am told by my Czech-speaking ex-brother-in-law that the simple translation of ‘pohadka’ is ‘a tale’, but usually the work’s title is translated into English as ‘Fairy Tale’. The piece underwent several changes during Janacek’s lifetime, settling on the three-movement form we know today only in the 1920s. It is based loosely on a Russian poem by the early 19th century poet Zhukovsky, called ‘The Tale of Tsar Berendyey’, but the piece doesn’t tell the story of the poem as such, but rather illustrates three scenes or moods drawn from the verse. The movements have no titles beyond tempo indications, but the last is a little more animated. In this performance, the cellist is the French virtuoso Ophelie Gaillard (you may recall that she was in the news a couple of years ago when she was held up at knife point and her really very valuable cello stolen), accompanied by Anais Crestin on piano. You’ll find it here: Janacek: 'Pohadka' for Cello and Piano
Day 120: Sinfonietta (Time: 26 minutes)
If Day 119’s Janacek piece was a small-scale chamber work, today (18/9/20) we are at the opposite extreme of Janacek’s handling of musical forces, in the sweeping sonorous landscape of his Sinfonietta. This dates from the spring of 1926, and is therefore a very late work indeed, but I suspect that if you didn’t know it was the creation of a man in his 72nd year, there is nothing in the music that would give you a clue. In the previous five years, he’d produced three of his greatest operas (‘Katya Kabanova’, ‘The Cunning Little Vixen’ and ‘The Makropulos Affair’), the wind sextet ‘Youth’ and the Concertino for Piano and Ensemble, so he clearly wasn’t winding down towards a mellow old age. He still had the Glagolitic Mass, his final opera ‘From the House of the Dead’ and his second string quartet to produce in the following two years. This feisty old age is at least in part explicable by his obsession (essentially unreciprocated) with Kamila Stosslova, a married woman 38 years younger than him, and with whom he carried on a passionate correspondence of, seemingly, more than 700 letters between their first meeting in 1917 and his death. (She appears to have had a surprisingly tolerant husband, though the impact of this obsession on Janacek’s wife was considerably more distressing.) The Sinfonietta’s origins lie in a military parade with accompanying brass bands that Janacek witnessed, prompting him initially to write a series of fanfares of his own. He developed these into the Sinfonietta, claiming that it described ‘contemporary free man, his spiritual beauty and joy, his strength, courage and determination to fight for victory.’ He subsequently dropped much of the militaristic rhetoric, but the sense of joy in the newly-liberated Czech homeland remains in all five movements. (As an aside, those of a certain age may recognise the theme tune for an old itV daytime drama series ‘Crown Court’ here too, at the start of the fourth movement! Those with slightly more highbrow tastes will know this music from Murakami’s 2010 novel ‘1Q84’.) For me, this piece offers some of the most thrilling sounds in the whole 20th century orchestral repertoire. There are several excellent performances on YouTube, including one by Simon Rattle and the LSO which I’d have chosen if it didn’t have an intrusive ‘Bill and Ted’ advert embedded in it! Instead, from the 2011 BBC Proms season, I’ve selected a performance by the Halle Orchestra and Mark Elder, which you’ll find here: Janacek: Sinfonietta
Day 300: Mládí (Youth) for Wind Sexte (Time: 19 minutes)
One of the things I’ve consistently wanted for this list is that it should be the product of communal and shared interests rather than just being my personal musical obsessions, so I’m pleased to be able to use the 300th posting to pick up on a suggestion from Alan Harrison of St Tim’s sister church, The Vine. Back at the beginning of October 2021, I selected Nielsen’s Wind Quintet for this playlist, prompting Alan to tell me about a concert he’d been to in Sheffield in which the Nielsen was paired with a work by Janáček, which made a significant impression on him. It’s that work which is the focus of today’s discussion. We’ve had three pieces by Janáček (1854-1928) on this list before today (10/6/22) – see Days 9, 119 and 120 – in which the principal focus has been on works from the composer’s last years, the ‘Indian summer’ of his creative life. Today’s choice is no exception. In 1924, Janáček turned 70, which is a significant milestone in any person’s life. Endearingly, as a kind of 70th birthday present to himself, he wrote a work that looked back consciously at his younger, formative days in Moravia. The result was a wind sextet – the scoring is for flute, oboe, clarinet, bass clarinet, bassoon and horn – which he called ‘Mladi’, which translates as ‘Youth’. Back in his adolescent days, Janáček was a chorister in Brno and a pupil of the choirmaster Pavel Křížkovský, and though Křížkovský seems to have considered Janáček to be a rather headstrong and difficult pupil, Janáček himself, particularly from the vantage point of a nostalgic old age, seems to have remembered his teacher with great fondness. In ‘Mladi’ Janáček revisited several of the Moravian folk songs and melodies of his youth, which had formed many of the musical memories of his time singing in this local choir as an adolescent. In fact, the composition is one of Janáček’s most melodic and lyrical. Moravian folk music, and folklore in general, powerfully shaped Janáček’s own conception of how music ‘worked’ – the region’s folk musicians composed in modes that were harmonically distinctive, underpinning melodies that were rhythmically irregular and which often contained (by conventional standards) odd leaps from one note to the next. Janáček researched these ethno-musical qualities very meticulously, noting down as precisely as possible the speech-rhythms of the area, which he called ‘speech tunes’. Much like Vaughan Williams and Cecil Sharp in Britain, Janáček acquired an Edison phonograph, and began to use it in field recordings. He was also, for a time, President of the Working Committee for Czech National Folksong in Moravia and Silesia, and it is clear that his involvement in this field was more than just a way of finding his own sources of musical inspiration. ‘Mladi’ is one of a cluster of works that Janáček produced in and around his 70th year, an immensely fertile period in a life which had always been full of musical creativity. Major works from this time include the opera ‘The Cunning Little Vixen’ (1921-23), the String Quartet No 1 (1923), the opera ‘The Makropulos Affair’ (1923-5), a symphonic poem ‘The Danube’ (1923-6), the Concertino for Piano and Chamber Ensemble (1925), the Capriccio for Piano (left hand) and Chamber Ensemble (1926), the epic orchestral Sinfonietta (1926), the Violin Concerto (‘The Pilgrimage of a Little Soul’) (1926), the Glagolitic Mass (1926), the opera ‘From the House of the Dead’ (1927-8) and the String Quartet No 2 (1928). Don’t let anybody tell you that in your seventies you ought to slow down! On a much smaller scale, in 1924 he wrote a short march for piccolo and piano (Janáček being Janáček, there is a version not just for piccolo and piano, but also flute, bells and tambourine!) called ‘March of the Blue Boys’. Janáček, and the other choirboys at St Augustine’s Abbey in Brno, dressed in blue uniforms as they marched through the streets. This march makes its appearance in the third movement of ‘Mladi’. Before that, there is a jaunty Allegro opening movement, the main theme of which is apparently a treatment of the spoken utterance ‘Youth, golden youth’. The second movement is a set of variations, sober and almost dirge-like. Then comes the ‘Blue Boys’ march, before the buoyant and life-affirming finale. Just before the end, the music slows for another wistful revisiting of the ‘Youth, golden youth’ refrain, before the piece scurries to a helter-skelter close. There are quite a few serviceable performances of ‘Mladi’ on YouTube, and from them I’ve chosen this video recording by members of Manchester Camerata – regular attenders of Ensemble 360 concerts will recognise horn player Naomi Atherton (playing with the Camerata is her ‘other’ job), and bassoon player Ben Hudson was also a former member of Ensemble 360 in its early days. You’ll find the performance here: Janáček: Mládí (Youth) for Wind Sextet
Day 365: String Quartet No 2 (‘Intimate Letters’) (Time: 24 minutes)
Before kicking off the musical discussion for today (24/3/23), I wanted to point out that yesterday, March 23rd, marked the third birthday of this list, being started, as it was, on ‘lockdown day’ 2020, at the start of the Covid pandemic. A lot has happened since then – but (at least, I hope this is true) one of the constants has been that this playlist has continued to shine an informative and hopefully occasionally entertaining light on a vast range of classical music over the course of its, so far, 365 postings. Which is nice… Anyway, to business. This evening the remarkable Marmen String Quartet are playing quartets by Mozart, Janáček and Beethoven here in Sheffield, and to mark this, I want to focus on the middle work in their programme, Janáček’s String Quartet No 2 (‘Intimate Letters’). Janáček has been the subject of four postings on this list so far (see Days 9, 119, 120 and 300), all except the first drawing on music from the final, dazzlingly creative years of the composer’s life. Today’s work is no exception: in fact, the String Quartet No 2 was Janáček’s final work. He began composition of it towards the end of January 1928, and had completed a first draft by February 19th. By April it was finished, but sadly Janáček died in August 1928, and the work was not given its first performance until a month after his death, and was not published until the late 1930s. I’ve written in previous postings on the subject of Janáček that the inspiration for the extraordinary flowering of creativity he enjoyed in his final years was the passionate love affair he had with Kamila Stösslová, a woman 38 years his junior. Well, passionate in the sense that she was the recipient of well over 700 letters which he wrote to her over the final 11 years of his life. This quartet’s title was going to be ‘Love Letters’ when he first conceived the idea for it. He wrote to Kamila on 29th January, 1928, ‘Today it’s Sunday and I am especially sad. I’ve begun to work on a quartet; I’ll give it the name Love Letters.’ In general terms, he wrote to another acquaintance, it isn’t obvious what inspires composers, commenting, ‘Is it possible to reveal the human being from which the crystals of my motifs grew? Has any writer ever told the public? With painters it is no secret. But a composer?’ However, to Kamila herself Janáček was much more forthright: ‘You stand behind every note, you, living, forceful, loving. The fragrance of your body, the glow of your kisses – no, really of mine. Those notes of mine kiss all of you. They call for you passionately.’ (He clearly had it bad!) In fact, Janáček’s first conception was that the viola’s role in the composition should be taken by the viola d’amore (literally ‘viola of love’), a close relation of the viola, a six or seven string instrument that had its heyday in the Baroque period. However, in performance terms this turned out not to be a remotely practical idea, and so Janáček reverted to the conventional viola as the third ‘voice’ in the quartet, but it is clear that the instrument has a distinctive role within the piece, and is intended to personify Kamila herself. His letters to Kamila show how programmatic this composition was. The first movement he described as ‘the impression of when I saw you for the first time!’ and the third evokes a moment ‘when the earth trembled’. The fourth movement was ‘filled with a great longing – as if it were fulfilled.’ The quartet is in the conventional four movements, but their impassioned and turbulent emotions don’t fit neatly into the usual division of fast outer movements enclosing a slow movement and a more dance-like scherzo. Instead, all four movements express this great surging of emotion that drove the work’s creation. The Czech novelist Milan Kundera wrote of Janáček that he was a composer skilled at ‘capturing unknown, never expressed emotions, and capturing them in all their immediacy’. This is brilliantly, powerfully true of this piece. (A poignant footnote: Janáček died in 1928, his long-suffering wife Zdenka in 1937. Kamila had died two years before that, in 1935. When the quartet was published with its eventual title ‘Intimate Letters’ in 1938, all three of them were dead. Given the searing emotional force of the piece and its inspiration, that’s probably just as well.) As for a performance, YouTube has several entirely decent video performances, though they do vary quite a lot in terms of sound quality. The one I’ve settled on comes from the ChamberFest Cleveland, a music festival, in 2016. The musicians playing the work are not players in an established quartet but rather an ad hoc assembly of performers put together at this festival. It seems to me that, in that context, this is an exceptional performance of the work. You’ll find it here: Janáček: String Quartet No 2 ('Intimate Letters')
Day 470: On an Overgrown Path (Book 1) (Time: 27 minutes)
Some considerable time ago, list member Pete Dutton wrote, suggesting that we listen to some of Janáček’s piano music, and particularly the collection of short pieces Janáček (eventually) had published as a ten-movement volume called ‘On an Overgrown Path’. There’s been a fair bit of Janáček on this list over the years (see Days 9, 119, 120, 300 and 365 – all easily accessible above), and most of what we’ve encountered has been from that astonishing final dozen years or so of his life, when most of the pieces that now regularly appear in concert halls and opera houses were written. Today (9/4/24), though, we have a work that takes us back to a much less celebrated period in Janáček’s life, the first decade of the 20th century, when (for much of the time at least) Janáček felt seriously unfulfilled and profoundly unhappy. One of the things it’s easy to overlook with Janáček is just how little success he had during most of his composing career. Although there are a lot of early works out there (mostly rarely performed), he was almost 50 years old before he produced a composition that made anything like a splash in his native country (in Prague, he was regarded as ‘provincial’, being from Brno), and nearly 60 before he began to be taken seriously across Europe more widely. Around 1900, he was writing church music (for an institution whose ideology he didn’t believe at all), wrestling with unsuccessful operatic plans, and still deeply immersed in studying folk music, particularly of the local Moravian culture. The first evidences for what would become ‘On an Overgrown Path’ can be traced to 1900, when he wrote a cycle of five works for harmonium actually called ‘On an Overgrown Path’, based on Moravian folk songs, intended as evocations of childhood memories. These are numbers 1,2,4,7 and 10 of the collection as it was eventually constituted. This first version was published in 1901. However, in Janáček’s personal life, troubles multiplied. In 1902, his daughter Olga went to St Petersburg, where she was studying Russian. Only months later she fell ill, the Janáčeks brought her back to Brno, and in February 1903, she died of typhoid fever. This loss had a more overt expression in other works of the time, like his opera ‘Jenufa’, but over the years 1903-8, the tiny set of harmonium pieces evolved, becoming more preoccupied with sorrow and death, so that even the more playful pieces gained a poignant resonance in the process. By 1908, the collection had grown to eight pieces, now all arranged for piano rather than harmonium, and by 1911 when the set was eventually published as ‘On an Overgrown Path – Book I’ (a shorter set of five untitled pieces that made up ‘Book II’ came out the same year) there were ten pieces in all. The title comes from a Moravian folk song in which, hardly cheerily, a bride laments, in a metaphor of loss, ‘the path to my mother’s house is grown over with weedy clover.’ The original five pieces are: 1. ‘Our Evenings’, a wistful little piece containing scraps of folk melody; 2. ‘A Blown-away Leaf’, which Janáček claimed was ‘a love song’; 4. ‘The Madonna of Frydek’, which Janáček said was about ‘recollections of religious processions’; 7. ‘Good Night!’, apparently ‘a tender leave-taking of one’s lover’; and 10. ‘The Barn-owl Has Not Flown Away’, alluding to a Czech folk legend that a barn owl will hover about a house in which someone is about to die. The new pieces that were added to these five, however, serve to place them in a much more solemn, indeed grief-stricken context. (‘There is more distress than there are words to tell it,’ Janáček said.) These new pieces are: 3. ‘Come With Us!’, suggesting, said Janáček, ‘a letter put away and forgotten’; 5. ‘They Chattered Like Swallows’, reflecting the touching innocence of ‘young girls talking on an outing’; 6. ‘Words Fail!’, revealing, said Janáček, ‘the bitterness of disappointment’; 8. ‘Unutterable Anguish’, overtly relating to the experience of nursing his dying daughter – ‘maybe you will sense tears, the premonition of certain death; during the hot summer nights that angelic person [Olga] lay in such deathly anguish’; and 9. ‘In Tears’, which Janáček described as portraying ‘crying with a smile’. I can’t say this is a happy collection of pieces, but what I hope comes across is the nature of grief and loss transmuted into some of the gentlest, if occasionally most desolate piano works in the repertoire. YouTube has plenty of audio-only recordings of famous pianists playing this stuff, but almost all of them via separate links to individual movements. Noting the general preference for video performances if possible, I’ve gone instead for part of a recital given by the London-born Japanese pianist Misuzu Tanaka, which you’ll find here: Janacek: On an Overgrown Path (Book 1)
Day 504: In the Mists (Time: 16 minutes)
Today (23/8/24) I’m focusing on a piano work by Janáček because it’s one of the items on the programme for Ensemble 360’s opening concert of the Autumn 2024 season here in Sheffield. The programme consists of two works by Pavel Haas - if you want any more background on Pavel Haas see the entry for Day 488. Alongside the pieces by Haas are two works by Janáček, his wind sextet ‘Mladi’ (see Day 300, when it was featured on this list) and my choice for today, the piano suite ‘In the Mists’. If you were to look up a complete survey of Janáček’s piano music, you’d find what seems to be a pretty extensive list of compositions. However, there’s very little for piano of what we might call ‘mature’ Janáček. In his early years as a composer (that is, up to about 1900, by which time he was in his mid-40s … but Janáček was definitely a late developer!), he wrote lots of sets of arrangements of Czech/Moravian folk songs for piano, but his first really mature work was the suite ‘On an Overgrown Path’ (see Day 470), fragments of which emerged in 1901, but which achieved its final form around 1911. After that, there’s the terse and angry Piano Sonata from 1905. Finally (in terms of substantial works) there’s ‘In the Mists’, which dates from 1912. (Between 1912 and Janáček’s death in 1928 there are more short incidental compositions and 13 unpublished pieces that found their way into a manuscript album belonging to his muse, Kamila Stösslová, but no major works.) To understand (and hopefully to come to love) ‘In the Mists’, it helps to know what life was like for Janáček in the years just before the First World War. The answer, by and large, was ‘not great’. Things were difficult domestically (I wrote in relation to ‘On an Overgrown Path’ about the impact of the death of his daughter and his sense of alienation from his wife), and also professionally (though his opera ‘Jenufa’ was a big success in Brno in 1904, it was rejected in Prague until 1916, and virtually nothing by Janáček had any success outside Czech lands), so although there was a flurry of what we now see as front-rank compositions before 1914 (alongside those I’ve mentioned there was also the cello-and-piano suite ‘Pohádka’ which I featured back on Day 119), it would be fair to say they became famous only retrospectively. These were years of depression and frustration for Janáček, and it’s this sense of pervasive gloom and insecurity that seeps into the four rather haunting movements that make up ‘In the Mists’. Still, let’s not get too down about things – Janáček wrote on the basis of new discovery too, in this instance hearing a performance of Debussy’s ‘Reflets dans l’eau’ in 1908, leading to Janáček’s further exploration of Debussy’s ‘impressionistic’ pianistic language. However, although you can hear the language of Debussy in the background of these pieces, a stronger influence is, as so often in Janáček, the melodic shapes and harmonic patterns of Moravian folk music. Commentaries on ‘In the Mists’ make much of the ‘misty’ keys in which this music is composed. I’m not sure whether this is attributing too much to key signatures, but the movements of the work are in Db and Gb, both keys with lots of flats, and it does give a distinctive sonority to the music. There’s a lovely quotation from the contemporary composer Thomas Adès about this: ‘The greatness of “In the Mists” lies in its very claustrophobia, and austerity of means affecting every aspect of the music. The solo piano becomes a narrow space with four solid walls.’ The first movement, marked ‘Andante’, sets a short five-note theme against a background harmony that stays largely imprecise. The middle of the movement brightens a little, before the restatement of the nostalgic and melancholy idiom of the opening. Then we have a second movement marked ‘Adagio’, again revolving obsessively around repetitions and variations of a short melodic fragment. The ‘Andantino’ third movement takes a similar route, in this case a graceful opening idea contrasting with something more rash in the central section, before we return to where we started. Finally we have a ‘Presto’ last movement, which is the most obviously ‘folky’ of the four, with its imitations of a gypsy violin and the almost metallic clang of the cimbalom. Overall this is indeed rather ‘foggy’ music, but it’s not (at least, I’m convinced it’s not) depressing stuff. Janáček’s life up to this point was punctuated with unhappiness, but paradoxically the experience of listening to this music is surely life-enhancing – it’s also music of tenderness and nostalgia, but absolutely not sentimental. YouTube has a reasonable selection of video recordings of this work, and from them I’ve chosen this performance by the French pianist David Kadouch, which you’ll find here: Janacek: In the Mists
Day 560: Lachian Dances (Time: 20 minutes)
Today (17/10/25), I want to explore a work by Janáček which is being played
tomorrow evening here in Sheffield by the visiting Brno Philharmonic Orchestra.
Even if Brno was not actually Janáček’s birthplace (he was born in Hukvaldy,
which is in the Moravian-Silesian region in the far east of what is now the Czech Republic)
it was at least his main home for most of his adult life, so it’s quite fitting that the
orchestra should open its concert with a performance of Janáček’s ‘Lachian Dances’.
We’ve had music by Janáček on this list seven times before now, so there’s
a fair range of his works that I’ve already explored, but most of the choices
have come from the kind of ‘Indian Summer’ of his creative life,
the final decade or so before his death in 1928.
The ‘Lachian Dances’, on the other hand, come from very much the other end of his
composing career. Well, to be truthful, the work both does and doesn’t,
since Janáček’s treatments of these folk melodies can be dated in several
variant forms back to the late 1880s, but it was 1925 before he
brought them together in the version we know today.
In Czech musical culture, the impact of Dvořák’s ‘Slavonic Dances’ was massive:
not just a Europe-wide hit that made Dvořák’s name known across the continent,
but a signal to Czech composers that this was a way to celebrate the music of their homeland.
However, though Dvořák used the dance forms of his native culture,
most of the melodies were Dvořák’s own, and it took the next
generation for composers to engage in authentic ethno-musicological
exploration, making field recordings of actual folk song and dance melodies and
transcribing them in authentic forms. Janáček was one of the first Czechs
to engage in this exploration (in this sense his approach is very similar to
that of, say, Vaughan Williams in England) and from the late 1880s onwards he
spent considerable time collecting folk music in the Moravian-Silesian region
where he was born – and elsewhere too, including large parts of what is now
Romania. The seeds of the ‘Lachian Dances’ (originally ‘Wallachian
Dances’ after the region called Wallachia – which then changed its name, so
Janáček followed suit) can be traced back to 1889, when his ‘Two
Wallachian Double Dances’ appeared for the first time. A couple of years
later Janáček produced a volume of collected material, ‘Folk Dances in
Moravia’, containing melodies for a dozen such dances. Through the early
1890s Janáček used and re-used the material in these collections in a
variety of compositions (including his Suite for Orchestra, Op.3, and his
second opera, ‘The Beginning of a Romance’). But then thirty years or so
elapsed before, in 1924-25, Janáček was prompted to look back at some of that
old material in relation to a proposed ballet on folk themes that might include
these original melodies. As a result, Janáček revised and
reorganised some of those earlier pieces into the six movement form that the
‘Lachian Dances’ takes today in its definitive version. The work had its
first performance in Brno in 1925. The liner notes for the CD version of
this music that I’ve got (coincidentally performed by the Brno Phil) wax quite
poetical here: ‘For Janáček, the ‘Lachian Dances’ meant the fragrance of
his birthplace and memories of his youth – given that the end of the 1920s were
a period of avant garde compositions – and the ‘Lachian Dances’ seem truly
idyllic in comparison, like the beauty of late youth.’ There are, as I
said, six movements. The first is ‘Starodávný’, usually translated as
‘Old-Time Dance I’, actually based on two regional melodies, a tragic song
called ‘Matthew has been killed’, and a more upbeat ‘ribbon dance’. The
second movement, ‘Požehnaný’, or ‘The Blessed One’ is a wedding dance.
Then comes ‘Dymák’ (‘Bellows Dance’), music imitating a blacksmith at work,
with changes of tempo like a Ukrainian ‘dumka’. The fourth movement is
again a ‘Starodávný’ (‘Old-Time Dance II’), which is probably the point in this
composition where Janáček’s music most resembles that of
Dvořák. The penultimate movement, ‘Čeladenský’ (‘Čeladná
Dance’) actually contains several melodies, woven together and leading to an
increasingly wild conclusion. Finally, there is ‘Pilky’ (or ‘The Saws’),
a woodcutter’s dance, based on a Moravian folk song called ‘The saws have
stopped cutting’ (can’t help feeling it probably sounds better in
Czech…). YouTube isn’t all that well off when it comes to this music, but
there is something of a novelty item for you here. It’s a concert at
which the Janacek Philharmonic Orchestra, Ostrava, conducted by Paul Mauffray
are accompanied by the Hlubina Dance Ensemble. The sound quality isn’t great,
but it’s a good recording for bringing out the music’s deep-rooted folk elements.
You’ll find it here:
Janacek: Lachian Dances
Jenkins, Karl (b1944)
Day 26: ‘Benedictus’ (from Mass: ‘The Armed Man’) (Time: 6 minutes)
Karl Jenkins (or, to give him his full and rather splendid name, Sir Karl William Pamp Jenkins) has an interesting musical history. In the first half of his career he was far better known in the world of ‘prog rock’ than concert music. He was a member and major creative force of the band Soft Machine, part of the ‘Canterbury scene’ in the 1970s and early 80s. Subsequently he began to have a more prominent profile in what one might regard as the ‘new age’ niche within classical music, releasing a number of CDs titled ‘Adiemus’. His ‘mass for peace’ ‘The Armed Man’ was premiered in 2000, since when it has become by some distance his most performed piece. Today (17/4/20) Martin has particular reasons for wanting us to hear the ‘Benedictus’ movement from the work. As Martin notes: “I had heard bits of 'The Armed Man' before but this version of the Benedictus by Laura Wright drilled into me during our trip to Belgium with the Youlgreave Sculpture in 2018. It was playing at the museum in TOCH house in Poperinge, and later played by Youlgreave brass band in the Cathedral at the presentation. And the Benedictus is a significant part every day in Morning prayers with Malcolm.” (In case you are unaware of Martin’s particularly understated modesty here, it should be noted that ‘the Youlgreave Sculpture’ in question was carved by Mr Hill himself.) You’ll find the performance here: Karl Jenkins – ‘Benedictus’ (from Mass: ‘The Armed Man’)
Jongen, Joseph (1873-1953)
Day 437: Concert a Cinq, Op 71 (Time: 26 minutes)
Joseph Jongen (1873-1953) is a composer whose fame, these days, rests on one strand of his output only – organ music. His oeuvre, however, encompasses much more than just that, so what I want to do today (12/12/23) is argue the case for making some, albeit small, space for Jongen’s music in our lives. He was born on 14th December, 1873, which means (you may be ahead of me here once more) that in two days from now we’ll get to the 150th anniversary of his birth. He was born in Belgium – in that country he is generally regarded as second only to Cesar Franck as the nation’s greatest composer. He was, like so many before him, something of a child prodigy. He entered the Liège Conservatoire at seven years old, began composing in his early teens and by his early twenties had won all the available prizes, both for performance (on the piano and organ) and composition that the Belgian establishment had to offer. After studying abroad through his twenties, he settled in Belgium for the rest of his life, apart from during the 1914-18 war when he relocated his family to England for the duration. For two decades he was part of the musical furniture in Belgium, eventually rising to be director of the Royal Conservatory in Brussels until he retired in 1939, before devoting his remaining years to composition. His wasn’t, in truth, an exciting life, but it was an immensely productive one. As I said earlier, these days organists know Jongen’s music pretty well, both the solo stuff and the works for organ and other forces – of these his most famous piece is his Symphonie Concertante for Organ and Orchestra. However, there are lots more pieces out there waiting to be listened to. There’s a symphony, and a good many other orchestral works; then there are concertos for piano, for clarinet, for violin, for cello, for harp, for viola, and for trumpet. There’s a great deal of chamber music: string quartets, violin sonatas, piano trios, and so on, as well as chamber works for unusual combinations of forces, about which see below. There are songs for voice and piano, and many solo piano works. And behind that lot, there are many, many works for organ. As for what to choose from these options, I’ve decided in the end to illustrate Jongen’s very French-sounding compositional skill in the chamber music field by selecting his ‘Concert a Cinq’, Op 71, a three movement work dating from 1923. In truth, in this area of the repertoire, Jongen’s ‘voice’ does sound very French, and the influences of Debussy and particularly Ravel are pretty evident throughout this piece. It’s scored for violin, viola, cello, flute and harp, so there are echoes here of Debussy’s Sonata for Flute, Viola and Harp (see Day 378) and also of Ravel’s Introduction and Allegro for Flute, Clarinet, Harp and String Quartet (see Day 35), but I’d like to hope you can hear something of Jongen’s own musical language here too: richly scored, often dreamy (even in the two outer movements, marked ‘Décidé’ and ‘Très décidé’ respectively). The first movement is sunny and essentially cheerful, while the finale has echoes of Spain (always a draw for French composers). Between them is a serene slow movement, headed ‘Calme’, a deeply tender piece. It seems clear to me that Jongen had no interest in ‘modernism’ in music, but was devoted to the evocation of beauty; the sounds are often lush, even when agitated. As for a performance, there’s an attractive video recording on YouTube from five players drawn from the ranks of the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra: Akemi Mercer-Niewöhner on violin, Dirk Niewöhner on viola, Ulrich Horn not on horn but on cello, Sebastian Wittiber on flute, and (introducing the performance) Anne-Sophie Bertrand on harp. It’s one of those recordings many musicians produced during the first Covid lockdown, which accounts for the socially distanced layout. You’ll find the work here: Jongen: Concert a Cinq, Op 71
Joplin, Scott (c1868-1917)
Day 471: The Entertainer (Time: 5 minutes) and Solace (7 minutes)
Today (12/4/24), I’m responding to a suggestion from Peter Wigglesworth for some music by Scott Joplin, which will mark the first time on this list for the composer. A bit of (possibly redundant) philosophising first. You will know, if you’ve been reading these postings for any length of time, that providing a tidy definition for the troublesome term ‘classical music’ is well-nigh impossible. There is, I guess, a kind of ‘canon’ (in the same kind of way there is for, say, ‘English literature’ – and, in the same kind of way, one might sum it up as ‘dead white males’), but the term’s boundaries are very porous, and bleed ambiguously into all sorts of other genres, notably folk music, but also more recently 20th/21st century strands of ‘popular music’. Indeed, one of the major developments in this area during my lifetime has been the gradual erosion of the once seemingly rigid distinction between ‘high’ and ‘lowbrow’ musical expression. (There are some who probably lament that loss. I am not one of them!) Anyway, you may (reasonably) be thinking, what’s the point of all this musing? Well, it’s because with the music of Scott Joplin (c1868-1917) we have one of those classic examples of a musician working within a particular musical idiom who, looked at from one angle, is most definitely generating compositions that embody norms of popular culture, but who, looked at from a different angle, is taking those musical conventions and bringing them into the world of this mysterious entity called ‘classical music’. ‘Ragtime’ (or ‘rag-time’ or even sometimes ‘rag time’) very definitely has its origins in African-American culture of the later 19th century. Its musical characteristics are easily summed up: ‘four in a bar’ pieces for (almost always) piano, with heavy syncopation, so that left hand chords land on the ‘off’ beats and the right hand melody is even more heavily syncopated, so that the notes are only occasionally ‘on the beat’. (If none of that means anything to you, don’t worry: it will become obvious listening to the examples below.) Originally the music developed from the practice of ‘ragging’ (messing with the rhythm of) marches. You can trace its fashionable peak to the two decades either side of 1900, and by 1920 it was metamorphosing into other types of music, most obviously jazz in the music of the somewhat indelicately named Jelly Roll Morton or the ‘stride piano’ of Fats Waller. Scott Joplin was not the first to have ‘ragtime’ music published (that was the comedian/minstrel Ernest Hogan in 1895), but he was clearly the most popular, hence his rapidly established epithet, ‘The King of Ragtime’. There’s some dispute about his birthdate (usually 1868 but maybe a year or two earlier) and birthplace too (usually cited as the splendidly named Texarkana on the Texas/Arkansas border, but maybe actually Linden in Texas). He might have been destined for a ‘career’ (a euphemism) as a railway labourer, but rapidly turned into an itinerant musician, playing whenever and wherever he could in the southern states of the USA, including various urban red-light districts. He did, however, have serious lessons as a pianist in his teens from a German-born tutor called Julius Weiss, and this was his introduction to ‘classical music’, and particularly opera. His big break seems to have been at the World’s Fair, a massive event in Chicago in 1893, and over the following decade ragtime became a kind of national craze. One of the things that distinguished most early practitioners of ragtime is that theirs was a music popularised in print, rather than being passed on by copying other performers and playing by ear. Joplin’s first bestseller, from 1897, was ‘The Maple Leaf Rag’ (apparently the first instrumental sheet music hit in America), and over the next two decades, he produced at least 40 further rags (there may be many more, but not everything he wrote has survived) along with songs and, perhaps startlingly, ballet (he wrote one called ‘Rag Time Dance’) and opera. By the early 1900s Joplin was already exhibiting signs of the syphilis that would eventually kill him, and his personal life was scarred with other sadnesses: his daughter died in 1903, and he separated from his first wife; even more sadly he remarried in 1904 but his second wife died 10 weeks after their wedding, apparently (not sure I can believe this) of a cold. He did marry again in 1909, and his last years seem to have been a race to publish his music – and particularly his opera ‘Treemonisha’ – before he died. This excursion into opera is fascinating, and suggests an attempt to attach status to a popular musical art form (in this case ragtime) by introducing it into the world of ‘highbrow’ opera, a couple of decades before the appearance of ‘Porgy and Bess’. As for what to choose to mark this singular musician’s compositions, I’ve gone for two pieces. One is what is now his best-known rag, ‘The Entertainer’. Those of a certain age will find this indelibly linked to the Paul Newman/Robert Redford film ‘The Sting’. ‘The Entertainer’ dates from 1902 and is described on its title page as ‘A Rag Time Two Step’ (a fashionable dance of the era). Structurally, it behaves a bit like a classical rondo, in that it’s organised in sections which repeat (Intro – AA – BB – A – CC – Intro repeat – DD), and it modulates in a similar way (the ‘CC’ section takes us from C Major to F Major) and also varies the ‘scoring’, in that repeats are often indicated to be played an octave higher. The other piece I’ve chosen is one of my favourite Joplin works, the ‘Habanera/Mexican Serenade’ that he called ‘Solace’. This dates from 1909, and it shows how ragtime blends with other dance music forms of Caribbean origin, like the tango and the habanera. As for performances, it probably won’t surprise you to know that YouTube is well stocked with video recordings of amateur players, often teenagers, playing this stuff in their own living rooms – with, it has to be said, mixed results. There aren’t any ‘professional’ video recordings I’ve found that I’d want to share here, so we’re in audio-only territory. One of the big ‘revival’ triggers for this sort of music was the publication in the 1970s of recordings by the American composer, musician and musicologist (and Bach specialist! – a lovely contrast with his ragtime stuff) Joshua Rifkin of pieces of Joplin’s music. This is how I first got to know and love this stuff. So here, played by Rifkin, are the two pieces mentioned: Joplin: The Entertainer and Joplin: Solace
Josquin des Prez (c1450-1521)
Day 218: Miserere Mei, Deus (Time: 16 minutes)
Five hundred years ago today (27/8/21), the composer Josquin (c1450-1521) – usually referred to simply by his first name, though he is also recorded as Josquin des Prez, and seemingly his birth name was Josquin Lebloitte – died in the area of Condé-sur-l’Escaut, where he was born, in what is now northern France, close to the border with Belgium. Details of his early life are, as is often the case with musicians of the time, sketchy. He may have been born in 1450, but other sources put his birthdate as much as five years later. He is known to have worked in Milan in the early 1480s, in Rome in the papal choir in the 1490s, and notably in the employ of the Duke of Ferrara in the early 1500s, though by 1504 he seems to have retired to home ground, where he lived out the final 17 years of his life. During and in the century after his lifetime, he was lionised as the greatest composer in Europe, and though his reputation was eclipsed later by those of Palestrina, Lassus and other ‘high renaissance’ composers, he is now recognised as a foundational figure in the Western musical canon. Peter Phillips, director of the Tallis Scholars, writes: ‘If one were looking for a superstar among Renaissance composers ... Josquin is unquestionably the front runner. He was a star in his lifetime, travelling more widely, being paid better and having more desirable employment than anyone else; and he has become a star again more recently. It is true that in the centuries in between, it has been Palestrina and Tallis who have been performed more consistently, where Josquin was forgotten, but this was on account of their simple music, which choirs of any ability could sing. Josquin didn’t write any simple music. All his music is complex, intellectually and vocally. As with Beethoven, it is now recognised that facing up to Josquin’s message can bring unparalleled rewards.’ Though he is perhaps best known these days for his settings of the mass, I want to focus today on his famous motet, ‘Miserere Mei, Deus’, which dates from 1503 and was written at the request of the Duke of Ferrara, the aged supporter of the revolutionary/reformist Dominican friar Girolamo Savonarola, who was executed in Florence in that year. Savonarola railed against many things in relation to the corruption of church power and influence, but in terms of music he advocated, like Lutheran Protestants of the age, transparency and directness in musical communication, in which the words could be clearly discerned. In his ‘Miserere’, Josquin sets words from Psalm 51 (‘Have mercy upon me, O God’). It’s a five part setting, though all five parts rarely sound at the same time, and at the core of the work is the ‘motto’ theme given to the tenor which occurs at the outset and returns like a refrain 19 times at the end of each verse in a clearly rhetorical manner. And although the music is austere and restrained, there are nevertheless patterns here to satisfy the mind as well as the ear: the repetitions of the ‘miserere’ motto take us down in steps from an E to the E which is an octave below; then the steps are retraced, back up to the initial upper E; finally we step down again to the A on which the music ends. Not all Josquin’s music is as spare and lacking in ornamentation as this composition, but it’s a piece whose beauty, I feel, lies in precisely this restraint. There are not many video recordings of this work on YouTube, but the one I’ve chosen, by the Dutch vocal group Ensemble Hermes, directed by Jeroen Spitteler, does some justice to the work, I hope. You’ll find it here: Josquin: Miserere Mei, Deus
Keita, Seckou (b1978)
Day 438: L'Epopee Mande Arab (Time: 9 minutes)
Today (15/12/23), I am indebted to playlist member Peter Wigglesworth for the suggestion that
we should explore the music of a Senegalese composer and performer whose creative history is one
of varied collaboration with many other musicians, including (as you’ll see via my link below)
those in the ‘classical’ field. Given that this list describes itself as
‘the St Tim’s (etc.) Classical Playlist’, I should perhaps say that we are, as it were,
pushing the envelope here, in accommodating Mr Keita on this list, though we’ve had
folk musicians before now, not to mention those from a jazz or ‘light music’ background,
so I don’t anticipate this being a very controversial move.
Seckou Keita (b1978) comes from Senegal, though he has been settled in the UK for
more than twenty years, living near Nottingham.
His heritage is significant: on his father’s side he is descended from the Keitas
who were royalty in Mali; his mother’s family are, in Senegalese culture,
‘griot’ in origin, or hereditary musicians (a privileged group with distinctive social status).
Although he is also a percussionist (he was a member of the ‘world music’ ensemble Baka Beyond
– see what they did there? – from the late 1990s), Keita’s primary instrument is the kora.
Without getting too technical, this is a traditional West African instrument,
the body of which is made from half a gourd covered with (usually)
cow skin, attached to a long neck made of hardwood. The traditional
version has 21 strings, and is categorised, according to one definition I read,
as ‘a double-bridge-harp-lute’. Seckou Keita has done a considerable
amount over the past two decades and more to both extend the playing technique
of the kora (including developing and amalgamating the several different
tunings of the instrument that exist in the various areas of West Africa –
Senegal, Mali, Guinea-Bissau and so on – where the kora is popular) and also to
revolutionise its physical capabilities, notably by developing a double-necked
instrument, which is what he played when I saw him live in Sheffield four years
ago. On that occasion he was collaborating with Welsh harpist Catrin
Finch, and his appearance at the Sheffield Chamber Music Festival in 2019 was
to perform material from their album ‘Soar’. He and Ms Finch have now
made three albums together, but this connection is only one of many, and
although Keita produces solo material, his preferred experience is to create
music collaboratively. (If you’d like to hear a piece from ‘Soar’, here’s
a link to the opening track on that album, ‘Clarach’, played by Finch and
Keita: Keita/Finch:
'Clarach'). He has appeared at many different sorts of festival
and performance venue, including at the BBC Proms, Glastonbury, WOMAD and the
London Jazz Festival. The piece I’ve chosen to illustrate Keita’s
compositional and performance skills is a track called ‘L'Épopée Mande Arab’,
which is from an album that emerged in 2022 in which Keita performs with the
BBC Concert Orchestra and a variety of other soloists, notably the cellist Abel
Selaocoe (a frequent performer on Radio 3) and Italian
composer/arranger/bassist Davide Mantovani. The disc in question is
called ‘African Rhapsodies’, subtitled ‘A work for kora and symphonic
orchestra’. The title of the track I’ve chosen isn’t easy to translate –
it’s literally ‘the epic Mande Arab’ – but is best understood as a celebration
of the musical and literary traditions of the various West African native
groups who speak varieties of Mande languages. One review of the album
that I read describes ‘L'Épopée Mande Arab’ as ‘a journey from Senegal
eastwards to the Middle East’. It has a sweeping filmic quality without, I
think, being simply ‘crossover’ stuff. In terms of a recording, here is a
link to a film of the recording session for the album, so the performers here
are Selaocoe on cello (and rather startling vocals), Mantovani on double bass,
percussionist Suntou Susso, the BBC Concert Orchestra and Seckou Keita himself
on kora. You’ll find the work here: Keita: L'Epopee Mande Arab
Kiel, Friedrich (1821-85)
Day 230: Piano Trio No 7 in G Minor, Op 65 No 2 (Time: 22 minutes)
Today (8/10/21), I want to celebrate an almost completely unknown figure in the history of classical music, but one whose 200th birthday falls this very day. So, let’s hear it for the one and only Friedrich Kiel. Kiel (1821-85) was a German composer and teacher. Perhaps the saddest thing posterity has done (apart from – until recently – forgetting about most of his compositions) has been to label him ‘an academician’, thereby cementing his reputation as a composer of music of a kind of ‘dry-as-dust’ sterility. If he appears in musical history much these days, it is as a kind of footnote, as the teacher of subsequent composers, like Stanford or Paderewski. I think this is very sad, even if it’s not unusual in terms of the shape of musical history as we understand it. If we think of German Romantic composers of the 19th century, certainly in relation to orchestral or chamber music, there is by now a fairly familiar list: Weber, Mendelssohn, Schumann, Brahms, Bruckner, with maybe a space in the footnotes for the likes of Spohr or Hummel or Raff, and now that we’ve ‘discovered’ that women too can write music, we might add Fanny Mendelssohn or Clara Schumann. It must be obvious that dozens and dozens of composers have fallen through the cracks in the story of German music of that era. It seems to me to be naïve to think that the only reason we don’t add other names to that list is because their music wasn’t ‘good enough’. And this, I think, is why we ought to try to rehabilitate composers like Kiel. To be fair, it’s only in the past couple of years that I’ve started to listen to his music – I found a recording of his Piano Concerto, which I liked, and then a disc of his Piano Quartets, and from then on, I’ve been digging around on YouTube and other online sources to find more. Not a lot of his work has been recorded, but what has is very interesting. Not 'great', I’ll grant you, but with a distinctive, if reserved, musical voice. He was something of a child prodigy, but though he developed a reputation as a pianist, his breakthrough as a composer only really came in his 50s, with the oratorio ‘Christus’. However, he wrote a considerable amount of music for the piano and also an extensive number of chamber works. From reading about his life and character, I suspect his besetting 'weakness', if you want to think of it in those terms, was that he was immensely self-effacing: apparently his only public performance as a pianist in Berlin, his home for pretty much half his life, led to an ovation from the audience, and he was so overcome that he refused to go back on stage and take a bow. During his life, he was offered many appointments in prestigious places, such as being choirmaster in Leipzig, following in the footsteps of Bach and Mendelssohn, but he refused them all. The famous 19th century conductor Hans von Bulow observed that his works ‘reveal such a maturity of spirit, such a rare store of knowledge and skill, that not to know him can only be excused in the amateur’! Kiel’s major influences were Mendelssohn and Schumann, though his work is more 'inward' than Mendelssohn’s, with less of a sense of showy virtuosity. There are hints of Brahms too. The (sadly unnamed) writer of sleeve notes to one recording of his chamber music I’ve come across describes his work as ‘perfectly crafted, sometimes virtuoso but never effusive, and always marked by a noble pathos’. All of this left me wondering about which work of Kiel’s to choose to illustrate these understated but nevertheless impressive characteristics. In the end, I’ve gone for the last of his seven numbered piano trios, the Piano Trio in G Minor, Op 65 No 2. It’s a work of his maturity, dating from the mid-1870s, and it’s in three movements. It opens quite darkly, and the overall mood of this first movement, despite the lyrical second theme given to the cello, is one of tension. The Adagio slow movement is poignant, sad without being melancholic or grieving. The final Rondo has moments when you think it might break out into the sort of 'Gypsy-like' dancing quality you get in some of Brahms’s last movements, but even here the prevailing mood is of restraint and reflection, at least until the final pages. I don’t expect to encounter any of Kiel’s work in concerts in the foreseeable future, or even to hear much of it on the radio, but maybe this posting might do something, however minutely, to make his work a little better known. As for a performance, as you might expect, there’s not a lot to choose from, but the work does turn up on YouTube in an audio recording by the Genberg Trio. You’ll find it here: Kiel: Piano Trio No 7 in G Minor, Op 65 No 2
Klami, Uuno (1900-61)
Day 554: Merikuvia (Sea Pictures) (Time: 24 minutes)
First today (5/9/25), a bit of a quiz. Name me a Finnish composer. Even though I can’t ‘see’ your answers, I’m entirely confident that almost all of you would have said ‘Sibelius’. He is so comprehensively connected to Finnish landscape, history and culture that he almost completely obscures other figures from the same neck of the woods. So, if quiz question 2 was ‘Name another Finnish composer’, it would be interesting to see what turned up. Some of you, perhaps, would have named Rautavaara, but otherwise? Well, this seems to me to be an area worth exploring, because one of the consequences of Sibelius’ fame (not that I’m knocking it – he’s a wonderful composer) is that the rich tradition of Finnish classical music in the 20th century is unfairly obscured. Another issue here is Sibelius’ longevity. He was born in 1865, but died as recently as 1957. Consequently he outlived some of the composers born 20 or 30 years after him, so to see them as ‘the generation after Sibelius’ feels a curious formulation if the ‘father figure’ of Finnish music was still around (albeit musically silent for the final nearly 30 years of his life), overshadowing those who followed him. But considering Finnish composers born between Sibelius’ birth in 1865 and Rautavaara’s in 1928, there are two at least who stand out: Leevi Madetoja (b1887) and my subject for today, Uuno Klami (1900-61). So, what of Uuno Klami? He was born in 1900 in the Virolahti region of Finland, its extreme south-east where it borders Russia. There appears to be no significant musical influence on him in terms of his family background, but from an early age he expressed a determination to be a composer. In academic terms, this led to study initially in Helsinki with Melartin, but probably the formative musical step came in 1924-25 when he studied in Paris, coming very strongly under the influence of Ravel, but also of Stravinsky (particularly the ‘Russian ballets’-era Stravinsky) and the sadly neglected Florent Schmitt. Returning to Finland, he spent most of the rest of his life effectively earning an income from composition, with some music journalism on the side. Much of his output consists of short, colourful pieces that he composed for the newly-established Finnish Radio Orchestra. Like Sibelius, his cultural experiences were steeped in Finnish national traditions, particularly the epic narrative of the Kalevala. But, as the Ravel and Stravinsky links just mentioned might suggest, he wasn’t really a ‘nationalist’ composer, but rather one who absorbed a wide range of cultural influences, including jazz. However, his love of the Finnish landscape never left him, and in fact not just the land but also the sea – he was an obsessive yachtsman and spent large amounts of holiday time sailing around the islands of the Gulf of Finland. The influence of his stay in Paris led to his first major work, a piano concerto called ‘A Night in Montmartre’, but the titles of other significant orchestral pieces reveal the influence of Finnish landscape and literature, such as the Karelian Rhapsody, the Kalevala Suite (perhaps the most obvious point to encounter his blend of Ravel and ‘Rite of Spring’-era Stravinsky), the oratorio ‘Psalmus’, and the orchestral song cycle ‘The Song of Lake Kuujarvi’. Later there were pieces of more ‘abstract’ music – two numbered symphonies, another piano concerto and a violin concerto. (My favourite Klami title: ‘The Cyclist-Rondo for Orchestra’, which, sadly, I’ve never heard!) To give a taste of this composer (and, as you’ll hear, his influences!) I thought I’d provide a link to a popular suite of short pieces that he wrote in the early 1930s called (with no payment of royalties to Elgar!) ‘Sea Pictures’ – or, in Finnish, ‘Merikuvia’. This evolved over the years 1930-32, initially as a number of short free-standing orchestral works that he composed for the Finnish Radio Orchestra, which premiered them as they emerged. The sea, as I mentioned earlier, was a constant in Klami’s life, though maybe only the sixth and final piece in this suite is consciously rooted in his sailing experience. The six pieces have vaguely programmatic titles, about which (sorry to disappoint) I can tell you relatively little. The opening movement is ‘A Foggy Morning’, and unsurprisingly it’s a dreamy, misty affair. Then comes ‘Captain Scrapuchinat’ – and if anyone can tell me anything at all about him or what he’s famous for, I’ll edit this and give you a named credit! What you will hear in that movement is the significant influence of Ravel on the young composer. The third movement is ‘The Deserted Three-Master’, another largely sombre and atmospheric movement, based on a poem by Valery. Fourthly, we have a Nocturne, subtitled ‘The Song of the Watch’. I particularly love this movement, with its simple but beautifully judged shaping and orchestration. The fifth movement is a ‘Scene de Ballet’ and the last has the apparently cryptic title ‘3Bf’, a reference of Force 3, ‘Gentle Breeze’, on the Beaufort Scale. You’d be forgiven for thinking you were eavesdropping on an out-take from Ravel’s ‘Bolero’ here – the influence is obvious. But, noted Klami, ‘This [movement] does not aim to depict the desolation of the sea, nor its movements or colours. It is simply a description of the satisfaction and freedom from care which one experiences when the sails are filled with a force 3 wind and the August sun is shining in the zenith.’ I have to say that although I’ve not listened to lots of Klami’s music, everything I’ve come across is beautifully orchestrated, never outstays its welcome and feels ‘alive’ in the vividness of its imagination. Unsurprisingly, there are no video recordings of this work, so we’re in audio-only territory this week. From the possibilities, I’ve chosen this recording, by the Iceland Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Petri Sakari. You’ll find it here: Klami: Merikuvia (Sea Pictures)
Kodaly, Zoltan (1882-1967)
Day 93: ‘Hary Janos’ Suite (extracts) (Time: 15 minutes*)
Today (23/6/20), we have another suggestion from Malcolm, though it’s one that will require you to exhibit enormous self-control if you’re to maintain adherence to the 15 minute rule. The composer is Zoltán Kodály (1882-1967), and the piece is the Suite from Kodály’s opera ‘Háry János’. If Kodály gets a mention these days, it tends to be in reference to Bartók, given that in the early years of the 20th century they shared a love of and a practical commitment to researching and preserving the folk music of Hungary and the neighbouring provinces of what was still at that time the Austro-Hungarian Empire – pretty much exactly contemporary with what Ralph Vaughan Williams and Cecil Sharp were doing here in the UK. As the 20th century unfolded, the two composers diverged to an extent – Bartók is the more overtly modernist and experimental, Kodaly slightly the more conservative in his musical language. In some circles today, Kodaly is more renowned as the inventor of the ‘Kodaly Method’, an approach to music education based (I simplify) on such ideas as the syllabic 'sounding out' of rhythmic patterns and linking rhythm to movement (clapping, walking, etc.), with the whole method being underpinned by a very clear child-centred and child-development focused approach. (Wikipedia tells me that in 2016 the Kodaly Method was declared a UNESCO Intangible Cultural Heritage.) As a composer, Kodaly mixed the colours and harmonies of early 20th century late-Romanticism with the brighter, more direct expression rooted in Hungarian folk music. In the concert hall these days, one occasionally encounters the folk-based ‘Dances of Galanta’ or the ‘Dances of Marosszek’, and in choir and orchestra concerts there are sometimes performances of his ‘Psalmus Hungaricus’. On a smaller scale (in terms of forces) I have a deep love of his Sonata for Solo Cello. However, his most popular work today is undoubtedly the Suite he put together from the opera ‘Háry János’. The opera is the story of Háry, a soldier in the Austrian army, who tells tall tales of defeating Napoleon single-handedly, and similar feats. The Suite has six movements, and (this is where it gets tricky) Malcolm suggests we listen to the last three of these: ‘Battle and Defeat of Napoleon’, ‘Intermezzo’ and ‘Entrance of the Emperor and his Court’. Adding colour to conventional orchestral forces is a cimbalom, that mainstay of Hungarian folk music, a kind of dulcimer. YouTube offers only one version of a recording of these three movements only in a performance for not very well tuned military band, so rather than subject you to that, Malcolm suggests selecting a recording of the whole suite, and starting half-way through. (You could always start at the beginning, and pretend the 15 minute rule doesn’t exist!). The performance is by the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Juraj Valcuha. To hear movements 4-6 only, start listening at approx. 12'35"*. You’ll find the link here: Kodaly – ‘Hary Janos’ Suite (extracts)
Day 215: Summer Evening (Time: 17 minutes)
This is another week surveying music with a summer-related theme, and as the season is almost at its end, so the pieces of music for the week take us to summer at the close of the day, as you’ll see. Zoltán Kodály (1882-1967) has appeared once before on this list (see Day 93, above), when we heard excerpts from his colourful and witty ‘Háry János’ Suite, one of the most familiar of his compositions these days. I wrote extensively about his life and musical interests in that entry, so do refer back to it for some context for what we’re going to hear today (17/8/21). This is a suggestion from Pete Dutton, who proposes that we listen to Kodály’s Idyll for small orchestra, ‘Summer Evening’. This is a very early work – in fact, in its original form, it was Kodály’s first significant orchestral composition after an overture he’d written for his school orchestra when he was sixteen. The first version of the piece dates from 1906, a time when he and his great Hungarian contemporary Bartók were engaged in the collection of Hungarian folk music, and the year he completed his research thesis, ‘Strophic Construction in Hungarian Folksong’. At that time, ‘Summer Evening’ had a couple of performances, and then Kodály put it aside. Considerably later, towards the end of the 1920s (so, after the composition of many of his major works, like ‘Háry János’ or his great choral work ‘Psalmus Hungaricus’), Kodály was encouraged to revise it. He has written with considerable humility about this process, which I’d like to quote in some detail: "If one surveys occasionally one’s own creation from a critical point of view, one recognizes clearer than any stranger all faults and imperfections of the work. This and that would succeed better today, if one only could do it once again! But the former self appears as a stranger in this work, and it seldom occurs that we have the courage to demolish the statue, in order to rebuild it. I wrote this work first in 1906. After two performances, it was put aside. If I should succeed today to remove the ancient failures, I shall have to give thanks for it to a great master [Arturo Toscanini, conductor at the time of the New York Philharmonic], whose example and request have roused again in me this feeling of responsibility and this constant dissatisfaction, which make me want to begin it all again." The piece has no particular programmatic content. To quote Kodály again: "The title means only that the work was conceived on summer evenings amid newly cut corn fields and by the murmuring Adriatic waves. It may remain as reminiscence." ‘Summer Evening’ is a single movement work which in its revised version is for a small orchestra – no brass other than horns that are embedded in the woodwind texture, and no percussion. There is a cor anglais that has the initial soft and expressive theme that sets the dreamy tone for the work, followed by a shorter, more vigorous theme on oboe and flute. The movement generates greater animation in its central development section, before the earlier themes are reprised, leading to a conclusion in a mood of atmospheric and unruffled calm. As for a performance, there don’t appear to be any videos of professional performances on YouTube, so today’s link is to an audio recording only. It’s played by the Philharmonia Hungarica (an orchestra made up of exiled musicians following the suppression of the 1956 rebellion in Hungary) conducted by Antal Doráti. You’ll find it here: Kodály: Summer Evening
Korngold, Erich (1897-1957)
Day 276: Violin Concerto, Op 35 (Time: 25 minutes)
Today’s composer, featuring for the first time on this list, is Korngold, and the work in question is his Violin Concerto. So, let’s get the cheap jibe out of the way first: for years the ‘humorous’ remark that got made about Korngold’s work was to describe his music as ‘more corn than gold’. There was a time when that pretty much reflected mainstream opinion. Erich Wolfgang Korngold (1897-1957) – with that middle name he was pretty much on a hiding to nothing – was effectively ignored by the ‘serious’ musical establishment by the time of his death, and it’s only really in the past 40 years that substantial attempts have been made to rehabilitate him as a significant figure in the music of the first half of the 20th century. He was (and this is a title frequently wrestled over) a child prodigy, possibly the most talented such figure since Mozart (with apologies to Mendelssohn, Richard Strauss and so on). He was born into a musical family in what is now Brno, in the Czech Republic, but which in those days was simply part of the vast, sclerotic Austro-Hungarian Empire. His father was the famous Viennese music critic Julius Korngold. Korngold Snr. knew Mahler, so when young Erich, at the age of six, wrote a cantata called ‘Gold’, Mahler was summoned to the Korngolds’ Viennese establishment where he listened in astonishment as Erich played the piece through for him at the piano. ‘A genius!’ said Mahler – and Erich’s career trajectory was sealed. There is a substantial number of works in Korngold’s oeuvre that in the careers of other composers would be labelled ‘juvenilia’, but which are remarkable for their maturity and stylistic complexity, and pleasingly a lot of these are now regularly recorded and broadcast. Among them, if you get interested in Korngold, I’d strongly recommend his ballet ‘The Snowman’ (written when he was 11), his remarkable ‘Sinfonietta’ (he was a mature 14!), a rich, Straussian String Sextet (an aged 16-yr-old), the incidental music he wrote to a performance of ‘A Midsummer Night's Dream’ (20 by then), and his most substantial ‘statement’ work of his young life to date, his opera ‘Die tote Stadt’ (when he was 22). These works, by the way, were not given simply private performances by rich and doting relatives – they featured on the programmes of the major orchestras and opera houses of central Europe. By 1930 Korngold had pretty much got the musical world at his feet… and then, of course, as we know, history intervened. The rise of Nazism led to Korngold leaving Europe for America in 1934, initially at the invitation of the film and theatre director Max Reinhardt. This is, if you like, the start of Korngold’s second career, as a Hollywood film composer. If you know nothing about Korngold’s concert music, you will almost certainly nevertheless know some of his most sweeping film scores, from ‘Captain Blood’ (1935) or ‘The Adventures of Robin Hood’ (1938) or ‘The Private Lives of Elizabeth and Essex’ (1939) or ‘The Sea Hawk’ (1940). There are many more. Being a film composer was lucrative, but what it did to Korngold’s reputation as a ‘serious’ composer was pretty devastating. He vowed not to write any more concert music until Hitler had been defeated, but when in the second half of the 1940s he ‘retired’ from scoring films and went back to the concert hall, the musical world had changed so much that he often struggled to get a hearing for new works, notably a Cello Concerto of 1947 and a Symphony in F#, which took him five years to write from 1947-52. These late works, in my opinion, are remarkable, complex post-Mahlerian things. However, one work from this late phase which has made a real impact in both recordings and performances is his Violin Concerto, which dates from 1945, and which is my choice for today (18/3/22). It takes music from his film scores (‘Another Dawn’ and ‘Juarez’ in the first movement, ‘Anthony Adverse’ in the second, and the sweeping theme from ‘The Prince and the Pauper’ in the finale); but this is a virtuoso work – first performed by Heifetz – of rich craftsmanship. It’s a wonderful piece, I think, and maybe it might provide you, if you don’t have Korngold filed away as a composer of note, with a way into the compositions of this really impressive composer. YouTube serves Korngold well, generally, and that is certainly true of the Violin Concerto. The performance I’ve chosen is by the exceptionally talented Leonidas Kavakos, supported by the NDR Elbphilharmonie, conducted by Alan Gilbert. You’ll find it here: Korngold: Violin Concerto, Op 35
Day 295: Symphonic Serenade for Strings, Op 39 (Time: 34 minutes)
This coming Sunday, 29th May (which is incidentally, but in this context irrelevantly, my wedding anniversary!) it will be 125 years to the day since the birth of Erich Wolfgang Korngold. Korngold (1897-1957) has appeared on this list just the once before (see Day 276), when we all enjoyed (I hope!) his lyrical Violin Concerto. My ‘programme note’ for that day gave a brief survey of Korngold’s life, so I won’t go back to that narrative in any detail, except to say that the work for today (24/5/22) comes from his time in America, where he had gone in 1934 to start a career as a film composer, which was lucrative but critically damaging (in terms of his reputation as a ‘serious’ musician). He began work on his last original film score in 1946 (‘Deception’, starring Claude Rains and Bette Davis), out of which grew the music for his first major concert piece for some years, the Cello Concerto in C, Op 37. The next year, Korngold turned 50, announced his retirement from film work and conceived the intention of returning to Vienna. However, at that point, his life took an unexpected turn, for in early September 1947, he suffered a serious heart attack and was hospitalised for some time. Reduced to a state of passive stillness, as he later recounted it, he took to composing music in his head to distract himself from the tedium of hospital existence. The result of this enforced isolation was the work that I’ve chosen for today, his Symphonic Serenade for Strings in Bb, Op 39. Now, the ‘serenade for strings’ label might lead you to think this is a lightweight work, or at least one that isn’t very complex. Musical history has given us several lovely such pieces – the serenades for strings by Dvořák, Tchaikovsky, Elgar and Suk, for instance, are popular in the concert hall and (for the most part) overflow with melodic charm. On the other hand, one wouldn’t seek them out for complexity of argument or sophistication of musical structure. They’re just full of nice tunes! However, the key word in the title of Korngold’s piece, I think, is ‘symphonic’. It may seem something of an oxymoron to couple this term with ‘serenade’, but what Korngold is getting at, surely, is that this is a work of substance, where the treatment of the melodies aspires to the depth and profundity of the symphony. The scoring is often complex, with each of the string sections subdivided on many occasions. It’s in the familiar four movements of a symphonic work – an opening Allegro, a virtuosic scherzo, an imposing ‘Lento Religioso’ slow movement and a fiery finale. He dedicated the work to ‘Luzi, my beloved wife, my best friend,’ and it had its first performance in 1950, given by the Vienna Phil under Furtwängler. Sadly, after a tiny number of subsequent performances, the work disappeared almost entirely. It didn’t get its first UK performance until 1985. It is, in my humble opinion, a masterpiece, from the way the innocent-seeming first theme is transformed in the opening movement, through the sparkling scherzo, then the impressively Mahlerian slow movement (especially the astonishing way in which it closes), and finally the ‘perpetuum mobile’ of the last movement, interrupted by the soaring, passionate second theme. As 19th and early 20th century symphonies often did, the last movement contains echoes of earlier movements, before we reach an emphatic conclusion. If this is a new piece for most of you (as I suspect), I hope it gives you the sort of excitement of discovery it gave me when I first came across it. As for a performance, YouTube has several excellent audio-only recordings, and one of the merits of these (see, for instance, John Wilson’s recording of the first movement with the Sinfonia of London, which you can hear here) is that the greater ‘weight’ of the strings of a full symphony orchestra is suitably imposing, but I wanted to find a video recording if possible. The best I can do is this performance by the Irish Chamber Orchestra, conducted by the multi-talented Jörg Widmann. You lose quite a lot, I think, in terms of depth and richness of sound, with only a small string orchestra, but on the other hand the multi-layered scoring comes across well. You’ll find the performance here: Korngold: Symphonic Serenade for Strings, Op 39
Day 587: Piano Quintet, Op 15 (Time: 33 minutes)
Today (24/4/26), the first of four postings that I’m going to devote to pieces being played at next month’s Sheffield Chamber Music Festival, on the first weekend of which Ensemble 360 will play a chamber composition by Korngold, his Piano Quintet, Op 15. We’ve had two pieces by Korngold (1897-1957) on this list already (see Day 276 for his popular Violin Concerto and Day 295 for his terrific Symphonic Serenade for Strings), but so far nothing for chamber music forces, and chamber music was a medium to which Korngold returned regularly during his composing career. As you may know, Korngold’s musical life is the classic ‘game of two halves’. In the first, he was a Viennese musical prodigy of extraordinary talent – producing the ballet ‘The Snowman’ at age 11, his brilliant and substantial Sinfonietta at 14, having two one-act operas conducted by no less a figure than Bruno Walter before he was 16, before his Europe-sweeping opera ‘Die tote Stadt’ (‘The Dead City’) emerged by the age of 22. In the 1920s he had more operas performed in opera houses across Europe than anyone except Richard Strauss. Korngold, however, was Jewish, and with the rise of Fascism across Europe he moved to America, where his second career, as a Hollywood film composer, began in the mid-1930s with ‘Captain Blood’, and led to 22 film scores, two of which won Oscars. For most of the rest of the 20th century the fact that he was perceived as having ‘sold out’ to Hollywood meant that his concert music and operas were ignored, and it’s only in the past 30 years or so that Korngold has been rehabilitated as one of the great composers of the first half of the 20th century, and you can now get almost all his major scores in front-rank recorded performances. The Piano Quintet is a product of peak ‘first career’ Korngold. He wrote it in 1921, and it was premiered two years later. One feature of the rhythm, if you like, of Korngold’s compositional career is that he tended to write chamber scores immediately after large-scale operatic pieces. Thus, ‘Die tote Stadt’, after its simultaneous premieres in Hamburg and Cologne in 1920, went on to be performed at opera houses across the continent over the next few years, and in its wake, as a way of ‘taking stock’, as it were, he began work on two substantial chamber pieces, a first string quartet, and his Piano Quintet in E, Op 15. The latter is a substantial work in three movement, full of lush, late Romantic harmonies and some really challenging writing for all five players. There are links connecting this work to the recently-composed ‘Die tote Stadt’, and also to a song cycle of a few years earlier, ‘Abschiedlieder’, his ‘songs of farewell’. In the song cycle, and thus in the piano quintet that followed, there are coded references to the growing love affair between Korngold and Luise von Sonnenthal, his beloved ‘Luzi’, whom he eventually married in 1924, after a long courtship and against the wishes of his parents. The key song from the cycle, the title of which might be translated as ‘Moon, thus you rise once more’, which Luzi suggested contained references to the sound of her voice, forms the basis for the emotional core of the piano quintet, where it is made the foundation for a set of nine free variations on the song material that make up the slow movement. However, before that, there’s a swirling, impassioned opening movement (Korngold gives the movements quite elaborate titles, and this first one he labels ‘Moderate speed, with blossoming expression’), one that feels very operatic and full of very Richard Strauss-like harmonic richness. It’s a movement that teems with ideas, from the expansive, upward-leaping opening motif, followed by a gentle, almost simple (but distinctly Mahlerian) second theme. However, it’s the extensive slow movement that really steals the show for me. As I’ve noted, it’s a set of variations, but the experience of listening to this might not make it easy to hear when one variation ends and the next starts, because the thematic ideas undergo almost constant growth and elaboration in one long, unbroken arch. As a declaration of love for the woman who was to become his wife, it’s a movement of great tenderness, moving from dream-like raptness to deep introspection, before concluding mysteriously but luminously (if you’ll allow the mixed metaphor) on an unresolved chord. The last movement starts with apparent seriousness, with a dramatic violin cadenza, but then it opens out into something more light-hearted, bubbling over with unpredictable energy. There are moments towards the close of the work that feel almost orchestral in texture, such is the density and complexity of the instrumental writing. Before the end the opening theme of the first movement is restated, but then there’s a thrilling (and trilling) dash to the finish line. For a work which doesn’t get that many outings in the concert hall, there turn out to be really quite a lot of video recordings of this piece on YouTube. Out of the options, I’ve gone for this one, by an ad hoc collection of exceptional performers, brought together for a chamber festival in Amsterdam in early 2021. So, here are Daniel Rowland on first violin, Tijmen Huisingh on second violin, Joël Waterman on viola, Maja Bogdanovic on cello and Natacha Kudritskaya on piano. The performance is preceded by a slightly meandering introduction by Daniel Rowland, so the music starts after about two and a half minutes, but I thought a link to the whole video was worthwhile, if only because Rowland makes the (to me) somewhat outrageous claim that this is the greatest of all piano quintets. What, greater than the Schumann or Brahms piano quintets, or the Dvorak, or Franck, or (from the 20th century) the piano quintets by Shostakovich or Weinberg? Not for me, anyway… But still, it’s a very fine piece of music, and you’ll find it here: Korngold: Piano Quintet, Op 15
Koželuch, Leopold (1747-1818)
Day 303: Symphony in G Minor (Time: 18 minutes)
I have a strong suspicion that the music for today (28/6/22) – and indeed today’s composer – will be new to almost all of you. So, let’s hear it for Leopold Koželuch (1747-1818), whose 275th birthday you probably didn’t celebrate two days ago. (Actually, some sources give his birthdate as 20th June, but at this distance it’s hardly worth quibbling over.) I suspect I’ll surprise nobody by saying that, as a composer, Koželuch is very little known. However, for a while I’ve felt that what this playlist was lacking (amongst many other things) was much in the way of music from the second half of the 18th century that wasn’t by Haydn or Mozart, and I’d argue that their dominance means there are genuinely dozens of very impressive composers whose work we hardly ever hear. Just skimming through my CD collection, I’m aware that we encounter almost nothing by Abel, or Arriaga, or CPE Bach, or JC Bach, or Barta, or Beck, or any of the several members of the Benda family (though you won’t have to wait long there), or Boccherini, or Boyce, or Brixi. (The observant will note that I’ve only considered the first two letters of the alphabet. This playlist clearly has a long way to go…) Anyway, to Mr Koželuch. He was a Czech composer (given the geopolitics of the time, he would have been known as a Bohemian composer), born an almost literal stone’s throw from the location of Dvorak’s birth 100 years or so later. He was born Jan Antonín Koželuh, but then again, so was his older composing cousin – it’s odd how often families seem to give closely related children the same name (compare Leclair back on Day 291) – so as he reached adulthood, he named himself Leopold to avoid confusion with his cousin. The surname spelling uncertainty is due to the fact, as was the case with many Bohemian composers of the later 18th century, that for most of them the natural career progression was from their native town or village to Prague as the regional capital, and thence to Vienna, where their names generally acquired a Germanic spelling convention. Hence, Koželuh to Koželuch. In his day, Koželuch was really quite famous. One notable not quite career moment was the offer made to him to succeed Mozart as court organist at the Salzburg base of Prince-Archbishop Colorado. He appears to have reasoned along the lines that if the Archbishop could treat someone of Mozart’s genius that badly, what might he do to poor Koželuch? There is a nice quotation by that indefatigable European traveller of the age, Dr Charles Burney, who in the 4th volume of his ‘General History of Music’ in 1789 wrote of Koželuch: ‘an admirable young composer. His productions … are in general excellent, abounding with solidity, good taste, correct harmony [what a wonderful insight into the workings of the 18th century mind!]; and the imitations of Haydn are less frequent than in any other master of that school.’ That mention of Haydn points us in the direction of Koželuch’s qualities, and reminds us again of what a great shadow Haydn casts over the age. Koželuch wrote a considerable amount of music, amongst which there are at least 11 symphonies known to be by him, as well as surviving concertos, chamber music and around 50 piano sonatas. The work of his that I thought I’d focus on to make a case for listening to his music is his Symphony in G Minor, which dates from 1787. G Minor was chosen as a turbulent emotional key by other composers of the time (Mozart’s Symphony No 40 is the most obvious example), and Koželuch’s example is nothing if not dramatic. It’s in three movements – there is no Minuet – with impassioned outer movements. The first movement might remind some of Mozart. The lyrical slow movement is eloquent (exploring ‘feeling’ in a very 18th century sort of way), while the concluding Presto movement is tense, agitated, with that wiry forward propulsion characteristic of Haydn. I’m aware that I’m defining this music almost all the time in terms of the compositions of Haydn and Mozart, but Koželuch has his own voice. His work repays more listening, I think. It won’t surprise you to know that video performances of Koželuch’s symphonies are notable by their absence, so for today we’re in audio-only territory. The music label Chandos has done impressive service to this sort of repertoire in its ‘Contemporaries of Mozart’ series, and it’s from those recordings that I’ve taken this performance by the London Mozart Players, conducted by Matthias Bamert. You’ll find it here: Koželuch: Symphony in G Minor
Lalo, Édouard (1823-92)
Day 410: Symphonie Espagnole, for Violin and Orchestra) (Time: 34 minutes)
Today (8/9/23), I’m delving back to January of this year when I failed to mark the 200th anniversary of the birth of Édouard Lalo on 27th January 2023. So, predictably enough, and better late than never, here’s a brief tribute to a composer who should be a lot better known, illustrated by what is by some distance his most popular work. Lalo (1823-92) – or in fact Édouard-Victoire-Antoine Lalo if we’re in formal company – was in some ways as French as the next French composer of the 19th century, but in others he very definitely swam against the tide. The son of a soldier who fought with Napoleon, and from a family with a long line in military careers, Édouard Lalo was expected to follow a similar line of work in his turn, but a stubborn attachment to music (and an impressive talent as a violinist) were persuasive enough to ensure that his family allowed him a musical career instead. After study at the Paris Conservatoire his experiences in his 20s and 30s were not particularly remarkable. He played violin in chamber groups and orchestras, and taught violin privately in Paris, but there was no big breakthrough or in fact any real public recognition of note at that time. Some of this seems to have been (and here we swim against the tide) because what really interested Lalo was chamber music, and especially the chamber music of Haydn, Mozart and Beethoven; in this he was at odds with French musical culture in general (Germanic music being unfashionable in mid-century France) and in writing chamber music he chose what was probably the least popular of types of musical discourse in France – where opera and ballet ruled, and the more complex forms of the symphony or string quartet were considered dry and ‘academic’. In the mid-1850s he formed part of a string quartet dedicated to the popularising of quartets with the public, but although deemed ‘influential’ by the critics, there was no mass acclaim. His own compositions at the time were either destroyed (two apprentice symphonies among them) or have lain in obscurity until relatively recently – Sheffield’s Leonore Trio produced a disc of his three Piano Trios a few years ago. Even as he turned 40 there was still nothing notable for him to celebrate, but then two things happened: in 1865 he married a contralto, Julie Besnier, and she persuaded him to write more for the voice, and to take an interest in opera; and in 1870, after the disaster of the Franco-Prussian war of that year, the reaction to France’s humiliating defeat led directly to the founding of the Société Nationale de Musique to celebrate all things French, including a willingness to promote both orchestral and chamber music, which played to Lalo’s strengths as a composer. As far as stage works go, even though Lalo wrote two operas (with a third unfinished at his death) he was never particularly popular, largely because his music was considered too ‘Wagnerian’ – his opera ‘Le Roi d’Ys’ is almost exactly contemporary with Bizet’s ‘Carmen’, and two more contrasting operas it is difficult to imagine. However, and you must be wondering about when, if at all, there’ll be light at the end of the tunnel, in the 1870s he also wrote a lot of orchestral music (‘a lot’ is relative here: Lalo’s total published work comes to only about 45 pieces), and made a name for himself as a writer of concertos. In 1873 he wrote a Violin Concerto for the Spanish virtuoso Pablo de Sarasate, and its success meant that the next year Lalo wrote another work for Sarasate, the rather oddly titled ‘Symphonie Espagnole’ – odd because it’s only a little bit Spanish, and it’s definitely not a symphony! It is in fact a violin concerto in all but name. (This fashion for ‘national’ styles and labels clearly appealed to Lalo. Before the 1870s were over he’d written two further violin and orchestra pieces, a ‘Fantaisie Norvegienne’ and a ‘Concerto Russe’.) The ‘Spanishness’ of the Symphonie Espagnole emerges in some of the more obvious rhythms of Spanish national music that feature in this work, and notably in the second movement ‘seguidilla’. It’s an unusual concerto too in being in five movements rather than the normal three. In some ways it’s more like a suite than anything more tautly structured, though Lalo described the ‘suite’ as ‘a tainted and discredited title’, suitable only for music of the greatest superficiality. The first movement ‘Habanera’ is the most substantial and serious of the five, from its stern opening, which acts as a kind of glue to hold the whole movement together. Then comes the ‘Seguidilla’, in the middle section of which we get a kind of ‘recitative’ passage for the solo violin. The third movement ‘Intermezzo’ is lighter in character, and at times in the past when soloists and promoters felt a five-movement work would be too unwieldy, this movement was often cut. The fourth movement ‘Pavane’ has a vein of gentle melancholy, without ever seeming quite tragic. The final movement ‘Rondo’ is dance-like and lighthearted, with some glittering bits of orchestration and plenty of opportunity for the violinist to show off. One curious thing about this work is its influence on another violin concerto of the 1870s, the one by Tchaikovsky. Apparently as Tchaikovsky was recovering from the utter folly of his marriage by taking refuge at the estate of his patroness Nadezhda von Meck in Switzerland, he was visited by his lover the violinist Iosif Kotek, who brought with him the manuscript of Lalo’s ‘Symphonie Espagnole’ in a violin and piano reduction, which apparently the two of them greatly enjoyed playing together, and it gave Tchaikovsky the impetus he needed to begin work on his own massively popular concerto in turn. Tchaikovsky actually wrote of Lalo’s work, ‘It has a lot of freshness, lightness of piquant rhythms, of beautiful and excellently harmonized melodies. . . He [Lalo], in the same way as Léo Delibes and Bizet, does not strive after profundity, but he carefully avoids routine, seeks out new forms, and thinks more about musical beauty than about observing established traditions, as do the Germans.’ Which tells us a lot about Tchaikovsky, of course, but also about Lalo’s hugely enjoyable score. As for a performance, YouTube has quite a range of video and audio recordings, and from these options I’ve gone for a concert performance by the young(ish) German-American violinist Augustin Hadelich, playing alongside the Orchestre National de France, conducted by Cristian Macelaru. You’ll find the recording here: Lalo: Symphonie Espagnole, for Violin and Orchestra
Lassus, Orlando de (c1532-94)
Day 167: Stabat Mater (Time: 17 minutes)
First, today (2/3/21), a sentence or two about the text of the Stabat Mater itself. Its origins appear to be quite obscure, but there is evidence that it existed from the mid-13th century onwards. It’s a Marian hymn, and in all likelihood it evolved during that era in Western culture (broadly 1200-1450) when the idealisation of women was a theme for both secular writing (in the poetry of courtly love) and religious texts (in the cult of devotion to Mary). As part of the liturgy, it dropped out of use as a result of the changes brought about by the Council of Trent in the mid-16th century, but it retained its place in the commemoration of the ‘seven sorrows’ of the Virgin Mary on her feast day. In extremely vivid and pathos-laden terms, the poem describes the grief of Mary at the foot of the Cross, and the narrator’s desire to share in that grief. Its emotive quality is one reason why it has appealed as a vehicle for choral composition over several centuries. The setting I suggest we listen to today is by Orlando de Lassus – also, and not exhaustively, referred to in records as Roland de Lassus, Orlando di Lasso, Orlandus Lassus, Orlande de Lattre and Roland de Lattre! Along with Palestrina and Victoria, he is generally regarded as one of the three greatest writers of Catholic Renaissance polyphony. Though details are uncertain, Lassus (c1532-94) was born in what we now know as Belgium; in this area of Europe the so-called ‘Franco-Flemish’ school of musical composition flourished for over two centuries, from Dufay and Binchois in the first half of the 15th century to Lassus and Rogier in the late 16th/early 17th centuries. As a young man, Lassus appears to have spent time in the courts of various members of the Italian nobility, but he lived out the final 40 years of his life in Munich, in the service of the Duke of Bavaria. He was an incredibly prolific composer, in both secular and sacred terms, and in a variety of languages, leaving a vast quantity of music in Latin, French, Italian and German. At least 60 masses have survived complete, often ‘parody masses’ (see Day 148!), and often based on really rather bawdy popular songs. (The sacred/secular division appears to have been far less meaningful in such times.) Lassus’ setting of the Stabat Mater was published in 1585, and is composed for two four-part choirs that sing alternate pairs of stanzas until they come together in some really satisfying eight-part polyphony contrasted with more chordal blocks of harmony at the end of the piece. As for a performance, I think this one by an expanded Hilliard Ensemble has a lovely balance of intensity and restraint. (It’s accompanied by images of a mixture of art works of occasional eccentricity, but which are always thought-provoking.) You’ll find it here: Lassus: Stabat Mater
Lauridsen, Morten (b.1943)
Day 147: O Magnum Mysterium (Time: 6 minutes)
Earlier in this series (see Day 145),
we encountered Poulenc’s setting of the medieval text ‘O magnum mysterium’
(O great mystery), and today we have another setting of the same text, this time
by the contemporary American composer, Morten Lauridsen.
Lauridsen (b. 1943) studied music at the University of Southern California, and he was
professor of composition at the same institution from 1967 until February of this year,
when he retired. Although his working career was based in southern California,
his roots are in the Pacific north-west, and most of his compositional time is spent
on a remote island off the coast of Washington state.
As might be anticipated in that sort of context, his works tend to
be contemplative and peacefully tranquil. His music is typically
conservative (small ‘c’), almost always tonal and rarely dissonant – a
combination which might not make him a ‘cutting edge’ composer, but he’s
definitely an extensively performed one. In 1994 he became Composer in
Residence for the Los Angeles Master Chorale, and in that same year he wrote
the motet ‘O magnum mysterium’ for them. It has since become not just his
most popular work, but it has made him the most performed modern American
choral composer. The piece, for unaccompanied double choir (that is, two
four-part choirs), sets the following words (in translation): ‘O great
mystery,/ and wonderful sacrament,/ that animals should see the newborn Lord,/
lying in a manger!/ Blessed is the virgin whose womb/ was worthy to bear/ the
Lord, Jesus Christ./ Alleluia!’ It is, as you can see, a combination of
the message in Isaiah about the oxen and donkey next to the manger and the
narrative in Luke’s gospel about Elizabeth’s greeting to the pregnant
Mary. There is an interesting clip of Lauridsen talking about both the
inspiration and challenges of setting this text in a short YouTube video that
you can watch here. Particularly interesting in that video is
Lauridsen’s discussion of why on the word ‘virgo’ (virgin) he chose the only
moment of dissonance in the piece. As for performances, there are many on
YouTube, but I thought I’d go for one of the USA’s most impressive student
choirs, the University of Utah Singers, conducted by its music director, Brady
Allred. You’ll find it here:
Lauridsen: O Magnum Mysterium
Day 358: Lux Aeterna (Time: 31 minutes)
Today (28/2/23), I’d like to introduce you (and for some of you this might be the first time) to a substantial work by Morten Lauridsen, who was 80 years old yesterday. The piece I’ve chosen also fits quite comfortably into the category of music for spiritual contemplation, and as such is appropriate, I think, for this period of Lent. We’ve had one encounter with Morten Lauridsen already on this list – see Day 147 for his most performed work, ‘O Magnum Mysterium’. I wrote back then about some aspects of his life, so I won’t repeat that stuff here: you can scroll up this A-Z archive and read it for yourselves! However, today I want to consider one of Lauridsen’s few large-scale works, his ‘Lux Aeterna’ for (in the version I’ve selected) choir and orchestra. There are several reasons why I think this is music worth our consideration, but the main one, I’d argue, is that Lauridsen’s work repays thoughtful and considered repeated listening, after which the layers of spiritual depth in his pieces become more apparent. ‘Lux Aeterna’ dates from 1997, and its composition was influenced by a significant and moving event in his life, the death of his mother, who had been his musical inspiration (though he had already begun work on the composition before this). ‘Lux Aeterna’ is, in effect if not overtly in name, a requiem. Interestingly, rather than the ‘blood and thunder’ approach to the requiem mass (perhaps Verdi’s is the best example), Lauridsen’s work is closer in spirit, if not in musical language, to the requiems of Brahms (see Day 280) or Fauré (see Day 176). One might see this, like Brahms’s work, as a ‘requiem for the living’. Like Fauré’s ‘Requiem’, the emphasis is on consolation and comfort in grief. An apt quotation from the American conductor Nick Strimple sums up Lauridsen’s musical language well, I think, when he observed that Lauridsen is ‘the only American composer in history who can be called a mystic, [whose] probing, serene work contains an elusive and indefinable ingredient which leaves the impression that all the questions have been answered.’ (There are things I’d take issue with there, such as the claim that Lauridsen is ‘the only American composer’ who might be called ‘a mystic’: what about Alan Hovhaness, for instance? But still, the comment gives a good indication of the source of Lauridsen’s inspiration.) ‘Lux Aeterna’ is in five movements – Introit: Lux Aeterna; In Te, Domine, Speravi; O Nata Lux; Veni, Sancte Spiritus; Agnus Dei. What all the texts share are references to light. To quote the critic Carol Talbeck, ‘The five movements of ‘Lux Aeterna’ are based on various references to light from sacred Latin texts: perpetual light, light risen in the darkness, Redeemer-born light from light, light of the Holy Spirit, light of hearts, most blessed light, eternal light — all supporting an earthbound spirit seeking not only mercy, understanding, and consolation but also renewal.’ You can hear regularly in Lauridsen’s work his enduring devotion to the music of medieval and Renaissance composers. His musical language is often modal, and rich in counterpoint, such as in the four part canon at ‘et lux perpetua’ in the opening movement. The second movement, ‘In te, Domine, speravi’, is perhaps the most inward-looking: the musical textures are often pared down to pairs of parts – sopranos and altos, or tenors and basses. The central movement, ‘O Nata Lux’, is for unaccompanied choir. Without getting too pretentious, I’d echo many writers who’ve observed of this movement that it is like painting light in sound. The penultimate movement offers something more jubilant than the contemplative journey we’ve experienced so far (it’s marked ‘Exuberantly’ in the score). Finally, we reach the ‘Agnus Dei’, the closing movement of conventional mass settings, though in Lauridsen’s case here appended to it is a reprise of the ‘Lux Aeterna’ music of the opening movement. The work closes softly, with the gentle benediction of an ‘Amen’. As for a performance, almost all the recordings on YouTube are of American performers, but I thought I’d go a bit off the conventional path by returning to recordings made in Estonia (which I featured notably in my selections of music by Estonian composers, see Days 328-30). So, this is a performance by the Tallinn Music School Symphony Orchestra and Choir, alongside the Estonian Philharmonic Chamber Choir, all conducted by Mikk Murdvee. These are young performers, but convincing ones, I think. You’ll find the performance here: Lauridsen: Lux Aeterna
Le Beau, Luise Adolpha (1850-1927)
Day 535: Elegie for Violin and Piano Op 44; Prelude Op 12 No 2; Romance for Violin and Piano Op 35; Cello Sonata Op 17; Prelude Op 12 No 7 (Time: 33 minutes)
Today (25/4/25), a composer with whom I imagine not many are familiar - unless you listened to ‘Composer of the Week’ on Radio 3 in December last year, when you might have heard 5 hours of music by her. My reason for featuring Luise Adolpha Le Beau now? Well, she (1850-1927) was born exactly 175 years ago today. And, while we’re on, the comments that follow will refer to her as ‘a composer’ and not ‘a woman composer’, as though her sex requires a special sub-category – though as you’ll see from the discussion below, she spent most of her life fighting wearisome sexist attitudes towards those who might have the temerity to be both female and writers of music. Hmm… Anyway, Luise Caroline Marie Henriette Adolpha Le Beau, in full, was born in the town of Rastatt in Germany, the daughter of a moderately well-off military family, and she was fortunate that both parents seem to have invested much time and effort in her general education. Showing an evident musical talent from an early age (she could sing back melodies before she could talk, write music before she could write in German, and so on), her developmental years seem to have been relatively untroubled, though she encountered collisions with the familiar ‘glass ceiling’ (‘what? – a woman and a composer’) over and over again. She studied with a whole swathe of musical figures whose compositions are rarely heard these days, but can be found in at least some people’s music collections (well, mine anyway): Kalliwoda, Rheinberger, Lachner and, for a time, Clara Schumann. The last of these, sadly, was a short-lived relationship, ‘because of Clara Schumann's teaching methods and personal differences’, as Le Beau wrote in her autobiography – she seems to have been a committed follower of Liszt, and in the great ‘Liszt and Wagner vs. Brahms’ conflict, Clara Schumann came down definitely on the other side of that divide. Le Beau's ‘career’, if one can call it that, seems to have consisted of periods spent in several major musical centres in Germany (Munich, Berlin, Baden-Baden), where she taught piano and wrestled with patriarchy to get her compositions accepted and valued. It’s interesting (where ‘interesting’ means ‘quite depressing’) that so many female composers of the later 19th and early 20th centuries in effect made their way in life as performers (most though not all on piano) rather than composers. Even people who supported Le Beau did so in terms that almost excused her: she studied with Rheinberger after he heard her Violin Sonata, Op 10, and found it ‘manly, and not sounding as if composed by a woman’. Even as late as 1882, when her ‘Four Pieces for Cello and Piano’ won first prize in an international competition, Le Beau wrote with rather despairing amusement of ‘the surprise the judges showed upon discovering that the prize work was written by a woman. It appeared rather comical that ‘Herr’ had been printed everywhere on the enclosed certificates; it was now crossed out and replaced with ‘Fräulein’.’ After ten years in Munich, she fell out with Rheinberger, who seems to have been jealous of her compositional successes, and moved to Berlin, but attempts to gain a foothold in the musical establishment were seemingly thwarted simply because she was a woman. She applied to opera houses throughout Germany but was never permitted the title ‘Imperial Music Director’ that such roles would require because, you won’t be surprised to hear, such a title was never granted to women, which meant, as she wrote in her memoirs, ‘I could not formally hold any academic position as a teacher or composer within the Prussian school system, which included music conservatories.’ One might have thought that a life lived on such terms might have made her bitter and resentful, but her memoirs reveal her resignation and, in the end, stubborn independence: ‘It is difficult to come to terms with such circumstances when one has dedicated one’s entire life to a profession, but one must be satisfied with the consciousness of having helped to build the temple of art according to one’s best knowledge and with honest intentions. I also feel satisfied that I, even with the disregard of all my musical interests, am completely free in thought and deed. I have attained this highest and most worthy goal of humankind, and all of the successes of the world could not replace that for me.’ Le Beau composed throughout her life. There are several substantial items – a symphony, a piano concerto, two operas – but short pieces for solo piano or for chamber forces, songs and choral works make up the bulk of her catalogue. Her compositions are starting to appear on disc, and I’d strongly recommend digging out her string quartet, string quintet, piano quartet and the sonatas for violin and piano, or cello and piano. Her voice is neither revolutionary nor ground-breaking, but it’s lively and distinctive. So, in exploring what I might choose to highlight her work, I’ve ended up selecting a compilation of her small-scale compositions from a ‘virtual concert’ given online in late 2022 and now accessible on YouTube. The major work on the programme here is Le Beau’s Cello Sonata, Op 17, but in order we have the Elegie in G Minor for Violin and Piano (4 minutes), the Prelude for Piano Op 12 No 2 (2 minutes), the Romance for Violin and Piano, Op 35 (6 minutes), the Cello Sonata, Op 17 (18 minutes) and the Prelude for Piano Op 12 No 7 (2 minutes). The ‘concert’ is introduced by the American pianist Byron Schenkman, with Rachell Ellen Wong on violin and Nathan Chan on cello. You’ll find the whole set of performances here: Le Beau: Elegie for Violin and Piano Op 44; Prelude Op 12 No 2; Romance for Violin and Piano Op 35; Cello Sonata Op 17; Prelude Op 12 No 7
Leclair, Jean-Marie (1697-1764)
Day 291: Violin Sonata Op 2 No 8 in D (Time: 11 minutes)
It has come as quite a shock to me to realise that in almost 300 postings to this list,
there have been precisely no choices related to French baroque music.
Given how significant French music and musicians were in the period 1660-1760,
this strikes me as a very serious omission.
No Lully, no Charpentier, no Marais, no Couperin, no Rameau (my personal favourite
out of this lot), and nothing either from our composer for today (10/5/22).
So, let’s take at least a little step to redress the balance.
On 10th May 1697, the composer Jean-Marie Leclair (1697-1764) was
born in Lyon, the son of a lacemaker. (Interestingly, he also had a
brother called Jean-Marie Leclair. His parents obviously liked the
name…) He was brought up to study the same trade, but also (and
fortuitously for us) he studied dancing and the violin (not necessarily
simultaneously). But these latter two skills would have prepared him to
follow the French dancing-master tradition. However, in his late teens, he
went to Italy to study violin technique, and it seems his musical
experiences there tipped the balance in favour of a musical career.
At this point it’s worth having a brief digression about ‘national’ musical
styles. In the early 18th century, there were, broadly, three
distinct schools of thought about what made for good taste in music and
compositional technique. On the one hand, there was the Germanic approach
– exemplified most obviously in the music of Bach, though others who’ve
featured on this list like Telemann would stand in just as well. Without
trying to over-intellectualise it (this is definitely The Ladybird Book of
Classical Music stuff), Germanic traditions were musically complex, with lots
of focus on counterpoint, complex structure, music if you like of the head as
much as the heart. Vocal/choral music was focused on the church, and
hardly at all on opera. Contrast this with the Italian style.
Contrast, for instance, Bach with Vivaldi. There’s much less interest in
complexity of form, much more interest in dramatic and theatrical contrasts of
mood and emotion. Opera was a big thing in the 18th century
Italian music. The superstars of the age were opera singers or violin
virtuosi. Then there’s the French tradition. Opera matters here
too, sitting alongside instrumental music, both solo and for small chamber
groups. Perhaps the defining thing for French culture is the concept of
elegance. It’s hard to discuss French musical life during this era
without acknowledging the dominance of the royal court at Versailles, which set
the boundaries of musical taste and manners. Ornamentation (the
management of the ‘twiddly bits’ in musical phrasing), for instance, mattered a
lot. Occasionally composers broke out of these broadly national silos and
there was some kind of cross-pollination (‘les goûts réunis’, to use the
title of a collection of Couperin’s instrumental music). So, where does
Leclair come into this? He returned to France from Italy in the
mid-1720s, his head full of the music of Italian masters like Corelli and
Locatelli. The result was a series of compositions that aimed at a
synthesis of Italian lyricism and French elegance. Leclair’s output
consists almost exclusively of music for the violin: a dozen or so violin
concertos, three dozen violin sonatas (with a handful of works for two violin
soloists). One final thing before choosing a representative piece –
Leclair is also famous in the musical world because he’s one of those composers
with a notorious death. In 1764, living in a reputedly dodgy area of
Paris, he was stabbed to death at his home, and his murderer was never
found. It was the gardener wot done it, they said … but then maybe it was
his nephew, who was after the money … or maybe his second ex-wife (not quite as
many wives as violin concertos, but still…), whose printing business was in
dire straits and who also could have done with the money. Who
knows? There’s undoubtedly a rather melodramatic bit of period fiction in
this, if anyone’s interested.
Anyway, to the music: in a nice link to the viol consort music you heard last week,
I thought, I’d select Leclair’s Violin Sonata in D, Op 2 No 8, but played here by
Jordi Savall on baroque violin, backed by his instrumental consort Le Concert des Nations
(viols, baroque flute and harpsichord). You’ll find it here:
Leclair: Violin Sonata Op 2 No 8 in D
Leifs, Jón (1899-1968)
Day 475: Hekla, Op 52 (Time: 9 minutes)
Today (26/4/24), I want to add a new name to our ever-expanding survey of all things classical. Jón Leifs (originally Jón Þorleifsson) was born on 1st May 1899, which means that next Wednesday marks the 125th anniversary of his birth. He’s a composer worth being aware of, I think, even if I doubt he’ll ever command much in the way of popular appeal, mostly because of the immense demands made on players (logistically as much as technically) if his works are to be performed live. Still, given that anniversaries of various kinds are useful prompts for this list, this is your chance (for most, I imagine, your first chance) to encounter some of his music. So, Leifs (1899-1968) might lay some claim to being the first ‘proper’ composer to come from Iceland, where there is now a thriving classical music scene, not to mention professional orchestral musicians, not something that was available to Leifs – pronounced, as far as I know, ‘layfs’ – at the start of his career. Consequently he studied in Germany, at the Leipzig Conservatory, from 1916-21, and he remained based in Germany through to 1944 when he (and his first wife, who was Jewish) fled to Sweden. In this first half of his life, as it were, he was primarily known as a conductor (the only internationally-touring Icelandic conductor at the time, not that there was a lot of competition) rather than as a composer, though in fact he composed fairly steadily during the period 1920-44: these are mostly songs and choral pieces, though there are also some orchestral works (the ‘Iceland Overture’ gets the occasional outing) and one ‘statement’ work, the exceptionally violent Organ Concerto, Op 7. If I were trying to characterise his music in this period, it would be to say that it’s modernist, experimental, with embedded wisps of folk music amid the disruptions of tonality. The mid-1940s marks the transition from a ‘before’ to ‘after’ in Leifs’ life as much as his work. Some reasons are personal: in 1946 he and his wife divorced, and she and their children remained in Sweden while Leifs moved back to Iceland. Some are musical/cultural: he became heavily involved in supporting musicians’ rights and music education in Iceland at this time. One other key event in Leifs’ life came in 1947 when his younger daughter drowned in Sweden, and his grief generated a range of works that are at least performable with some regularity, given their small scale. The most important – and readily available via YouTube – are the Requiem, Op 33b, for mixed choir and the String Quartet ‘Vita et Mors’, Op 36. In the years after his return to Iceland, his works become much more obsessed with Icelandic (or more broadly Norse) myth, and with musical depictions of the landscape of Iceland. Leifs died in 1968, but one of the major products of his final years was a set of four orchestral works, tone poems that celebrated specific landmarks or landscape features in Iceland. These are ‘Geysir’ (1961), ‘Hekla’ (also 1961), ‘Dettifoss’ (1964) and ‘Hafis’ (1965). These depict, in that order, the ‘original’ Geysir (which gives us the word ‘geyser’ to describe all other such hot springs), the eruption of the volcano Hekla, the Icelandic waterfall Dettifoss (which the interweb tells me is ‘the second most powerful = speed of water flow x distance of drop’ waterfall in Europe), and finally a depiction of broken ice floes around the Icelandic coast. What all four pieces share is an extraordinary attempt to generate in the listener a sense of the almost visceral power of the landscape. They make demands on performers that might make you think that Leifs was writing simply to depict what was in his imagination without really expecting the works to be performed, but in fact there have been both performances and recordings of all of them. To illustrate the disruptive imagination of this unusual composer I thought I’d select a performance of the tone poem ‘Hekla’, Op 52. When Leifs along with other Icelandic figures featured on Radio 3’s ‘Composer of the Week’ series back in 2014, the presenter Donald Macleod described this work as ‘the loudest music ever written … probably’. The volcano Hekla erupted in a very big way in 1947, and Leifs was present to witness it. The experience stayed with him. The scoring of the work is, shall we say, implausible: full symphony orchestra, with a part for an ad lib chorus, but also 19 percussionists, who, in addition to the full armoury of the modern orchestral percussion section, ‘play’ (if that’s the word) items such as huge metal ships’ chains, sirens, guns (or at least things generating gunshots), anvils, and small and large rocks ideally sourced from the volcano itself! The effect, I was about to write, is like nothing else in music, but it strikes me that there is some very loose comparison with the works of Charles Ives at his most raucously unbuttoned: a hushed, rather formless introduction, followed by rising climaxes generating a kind of cacophony (but always an ‘orderly’ cacophony, in the sense that it’s not just ‘noise’!) before we reach a kind of exhausted stillness after all force is spent. To quote from the liner notes of the CD booklet I’ve been reading, ‘The work begins with quiet harmonies, but soon percussion instruments enter as the tension starts to build. As the diminished-seventh chords and rising glissandi grow increasingly loud, the outrageous percussion section becomes ever more extravagant in its graphic depiction of the spouts, spurts and explosions of a volcano in full force. The eruption finally subsides with a blast before everything falls quiet, and the queen of lcelandic volcanoes again lies dormant.’ The work actually got its first performance in Finland in 1964. It did not go down well – it baffled the audience and outraged critics. It only got its Icelandic premiere (and second ever performance) in 1989, though it has now been recorded twice (once on a disc titled ‘Earquake: the LOUDEST Classical Music of All Time’, so I guess you know what you’re in for). I suppose, in choosing this, I’m setting out to depict Leifs’ music as ‘challenging’ – which it is! – but also in its way remarkable. It will not surprise you to know that YouTube has no video recordings of authentic live performances. Well, there is one by the MusicaNova Orchestra of Arizona, USA, but it uses pre-recorded and synthesised sound effects rather than actual Leifs-style percussion played by real people, so I’m passing over that. Instead, what you have here is an audio-only recording by the Helsinki Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Leif Segerstam. There are still photographs of the volcano in full flow to accompany the recording, though I’m not sure you need visual aids when the sounds of the piece are so graphic. Enjoy! Leifs: Hekla, Op 52
Ligeti, Gyorgy (1923-2006)
Day 57: Bagatelle No 3 for Wind Quintet (Time: 3 minutes) and ‘Kyrie’ (from ‘Requiem’) (8 minutes)
The recommendation for today (18/5/20) is from Jenny, who would like us to
listen to the ‘Kyrie’ from the Requiem by Gyorgy Ligeti (1923-2006).
His early adult life in post-war Communist Hungary meant that his initial compositions
tended to be quite folk-music based, though he was already displeasing the authorities
before he fled to the west in 1956 after the suppressed Hungarian Revolution of that year.
Depending on how much of a film buff you are, you might actually be more familiar with Ligeti’s
work than you think, if you’re watched many films by Stanley Kubrick.
I hadn’t realised that I knew the ‘Kyrie’ until Jenny sent me the link – you may
have some visual memories here of the encounters with the monolith in ‘2001’.
In fact, I thought it might be interesting to compare/contrast some early and
later Ligeti, so I’m suggesting, as a kind of ‘amuse bouche’, that you listen
to one of Ligeti’s ‘Six Bagatelles for Wind Quintet’ (originally written
pre-1956, but suppressed in Hungary by the authorities for being ‘too
dangerous’!).
So, here is Bagatelle No 3 from the ‘Six Bagatelles’, played by the Barry Tuckwell
Wind Quintet:
Gyorgy Ligeti – Bagatelle No 3 for Wind Quintet...
and then here is the ‘Kyrie’ from Ligeti’s Requiem.
To quote from Jenny’s email to me,
‘I only really came across him when listening to the ‘Fugue’ episode of Radio 3’s
Listening Service a few months ago. They were talking about how his Kyrie in
‘Requiem’ is actually a fugue but it’s so multi-layered, it comes out more like
a wall of sound (and needs a 3ft score). I thought it was a really interesting
idea, and it creates a very interesting sound!’
It’s performed by the Choir and Orchestra of Radio France, conducted by Esa-Pekka Salonen,
and you’ll find it here:
Ligeti – ‘Kyrie’ (from ‘Requiem’)
Day 382: String Quartet No 1 (Time: 21 minutes)
György Ligeti was born on 28th May, 1923, which means that this coming Sunday will mark his 100th birthday. Now, I realise that for some on this list, Ligeti may be a composer whose work is, to put it mildly, challenging. In some ways, I’d count myself in that group – I struggle to warm to compositions that were produced by card-carrying devotees of the particularly rigorous modernism of the post-Second World War era (Boulez, Stockhausen, Maderna and, of course, Ligeti). So it may not surprise you to note that the work I’ve chosen to mark his 100th anniversary is not one that’s likely to cause you to splutter into your cornflakes. In fact, we’ve had some Ligeti on this list before now – see Day 57, when, at Jenny’s prompting, we encountered the ‘Kyrie’ from Ligeti’s Requiem, and (by way of a sweetener from me) one of his Bagatelles for Wind Quintet. Ligeti, as I mentioned in that previous posting, was a ‘Hungarian’ composer, though his place of birth, back in 1923, was then in Romania. His family was Jewish, and he and they suffered under Nazi persecution during the Second World War. Ligeti was sent to a forced labour camp by the Nazi-supporting Hungarian authorities, and his father died in Auschwitz. One might say that having been persecuted by one totalitarian regime, he then suffered under another, due to the Soviet influence over post-war Hungary. Consequently, a lot of Ligeti’s early music is either ‘conformist’ in outlook (lots of folk music-based pieces and ‘user-friendly’ choral work) or it was written and, as it were, put away in a ‘bottom drawer’ for some hopeful future occasion. After the 1956 Hungarian uprising was suppressed by Soviet authorities, Ligeti and his ex-wife fled on foot to the West. Ligeti left almost everything behind, taking only what he regarded as his most important scores. Only in 1970 did he set foot in Hungary again, by which time he was an Austrian citizen. Of his post-1956 compositions, as well as the influence of the rather ‘hard line’ modernist school he encountered in Cologne, you can also hear his interest in mathematics (many of his scores are minutely mathematically plotted), and also his fascination with rhythm, whether the drumming patterns in African music or the multiple layering of polyrhythms. I toyed with the idea of choosing some later Ligeti as this posting’s ‘birthday’ tribute – and one day I’ll find an excuse to select some of his 18 Études for piano, published between 1985-2001, because they’re wonderful – but in the end I want to share with everyone a work that I encountered for the first time only a few weeks ago. I was at a classical concert at the Leadmill here in Sheffield, mostly focused on the electronica-influenced contemporary composer Anna Meredith, but the performers (actually the Ligeti Quartet, who have made their study of his work foundational to their careers) made one exception: they opened the second half of the programme with Ligeti’s String Quartet No 1, which dates from 1953-4, and which is therefore part of what he came to see as his ‘prehistoric’ output before his escape to the West. One prompt for the work may have been the death of Stalin in 1953, and therefore the fleeting hope of a more enlightened approach by the Communist authorities to contemporary music. The quartet has a subtitle, ‘Métamorphoses nocturnes’, and this offers both an insight into how it is structured, with its focus on continuous change and metamorphosis, but also into one of its inspirations – the ‘night music’ of his Hungarian predecessor, Bartók. Bartók’s quartets were banned from being performed in Hungary in the 1950s, so Ligeti only knew them from scores that he looked at. Bartók’s 3rd and 4th Quartets were particularly inspirational when Ligeti came to write his own debut piece for this combination of forces, and you can hear the strong influence of Bartók on this first quartet. (Ligeti’s near-contemporary, the fellow modernist composer György Kurtág, described it as ‘Bartók’s 7th Quartet’ – Bartók himself having written six such pieces – and somehow I don’t think Kurtág meant it as a compliment!) I’m going to quote Ligeti himself on this work, it being better to get these ideas from the horse’s mouth: ‘The first word of the sub-title ‘Metamorphoses nocturnes’ refers to the form. It is a kind of variation form, only there is no specific ‘theme’ that is then varied. It is, rather, that one and the same musical concept appears in constantly new forms - that is why ‘metamorphoses’ is more appropriate than ‘variations’. The quartet can be considered as having just one movement or also as a sequence of many short movements that melt into one another without pause or which abruptly cut one another off. The basic concept, which is always present in the intervals but which is in a state of constant transformation, consists of two major seconds that succeed each other transposed by a semitone. In this First String Quartet there are certainly some characteristics of my later music, but the writing is totally different, ‘old-fashioned’; there are still distinct melodic, rhythmic and harmonic patterns and bar structure. It is not tonal music, but it is not radically atonal, either. The piece still belongs firmly to the Bartók tradition (remember my situation as a composer in Hungary at the beginning of the fifties), yet despite the Bartók-like tone (especially in the rhythm) and despite some touches of Stravinsky and Alban Berg, I trust that the First String Quartet is still personal work.’ The work is in 17 sections, running without a break. As for a performance for today (22/5/23), there’s a good one on YouTube by the Callisto Quartet (a young prize-winning quartet from America and Canada), which you’ll find here: Ligeti: String Quartet No 1
Liszt, Franz (1811-86)
Day 90: La Lugubre Gondola 2 (Time: 10 minutes)
Today (20/6/20), I thought we might consider the pianist who, one might say, became the first ‘rock star’ of the instrument – Franz Liszt. I’m basing this on the assumption that even the great pianists of the ‘classical’ era, like Beethoven, weren’t public phenomena in the way that Liszt was (and in any case Beethoven’s deafness curtailed his public appearances), and that the only predecessor of the romantic era whose reputation is solely linked to the piano, Frederic Chopin, was not seemingly drawn to playing in large auditoria in front of adoring crowds of swooning ladies in quite the way that Liszt was. Liszt (1811-86) was an extraordinary figure in 19th century music – ‘larger than life’ in the same sort of way that one might claim to be true of Paganini, say, or Berlioz. But although the Liszt who drew the crowds by playing the piano in a way that made him, at that time, the greatest virtuoso who ever lived was certainly one of the ‘characters’ he played, there are others: the academic and theorist, the devout seeker after the divine, the ‘inventor’ of musical genres, like the symphonic poem, that altered music in ways that make him arguably the most important influence on shaping the future of music between the death of Beethoven and the start of the 20th century. There is certainly far more to Liszt than the technicolour garishness of Ken Russell's ‘Lisztomania!’ might make one believe. Liszt was an extraordinarily prolific composer. (Leslie Howard's recordings of the complete piano music of Liszt run to 99 CDs … and he continues to release additional albums as new discoveries are unearthed.) His writing for the piano, as one might expect, reveals a player of scarcely credible technique, so there’s a lot of ‘show-offy’ stuff from the early years of Liszt's career. However, I want to focus on the later Liszt, the Liszt whose writing looks ahead to the 20th century, to Schoenberg, to Debussy and to Bartók. Amongst other things, Liszt was Wagner’s father-in-law (Liszt’s daughter Cosima ran off from her marriage to the conductor Hans von Bulow to settle down with Wagner). His piece ‘La Lugubre Gondola’ was written in 1882, though, as was Liszt's habit, subsequently reworked several times in the years that followed - and in fact there’s what seems to be a wholly ‘re-composed’, new version that existed in manuscript when Liszt died, and which is now known, oddly, as ‘La Lugubre Gondola 1’ … whereas the ‘original’ one is now often catalogued as ‘La Lugubre Gondola 2’! It was seemingly originally composed after a visit to Wagner in Venice in the autumn of 1882. When in February 1883 Wagner died, his funeral procession started with the journey of his corpse from his home in Venice to the main railway station by funeral gondola, before it subsequently made its journey back to Bayreuth in Bavaria, where Wagner was buried. It seems that at some point in the couple of years that followed, Liszt came to see his piano composition as a kind of memorial to Wagner. If you still have a memory of the Prelude to Wagner's ‘Tristan and Isolde’ in your head from a couple of days back, you may have a feel for what Liszt is doing here with these winding melodies and strings of unresolved harmonies. As a contemplation of death, it’s pretty powerful, I think. There are quite a few recordings of this on YouTube, but I’ve chosen one by the virtuoso pianist Arkadi Volodos (audio only – though you can contemplate the rather inscrutable image of the very old Liszt whilst you listen). You’ll find it here: Liszt – ‘La Lugubre Gondola 2’
Day 332: Legend No 1 ('St Francis of Assisi Preaching to the Birds') (Time: 9 minutes)
Franz Liszt has appeared, rather disappointingly for such a major 19th century figure, just the once on this list before now (see Day 90), when we encountered his homage to the recently deceased Wagner in his ‘La Lugubre Gondola 2’. I wrote back then about the ways one might see Liszt as something of a misunderstood figure if all we have is the stereotype of Liszt the showman, a kind of Jimi Hendrix of the piano. (He may well have played the keyboard behind his back, or with his teeth, for all I know.) The liner notes of one of my Liszt CDs say this: ‘He was the archetypal artist of the Romantic era: brilliant virtuoso composer-pianist, campaigning conductor, indefatigable transcriber, legendary teacher; worldly ‘grand seigneur’ and devout minor canon of the Catholic church; Hungarian nationalist and folklorist; revolutionary formal and technical innovator; and eventually a visionary prophet of 20th century music.’ It’s a lot to live up to, and I’m convinced the general musical public still hasn’t really got its collective head around that multitude of personae. Llŷr Williams’s recital in Sheffield this month contains two pieces by Liszt. There’s the ‘diabolical’ side of his work, represented by his dazzling Mephisto Waltz No 1. But Williams is also playing one of the two ‘Franciscan Legends’ that Liszt wrote in 1863, which celebrated two different saints. One of these pieces depicts ‘St Francis of Paola Walking on the Waters’, a vivid, visionary piece. The other one, and my focus for today (7/10/22), is the one Williams is due to perform, ‘St Francis of Assisi Preaching to the Birds’. For a long time it was assumed that both of these pieces started life as piano works, which Liszt then orchestrated; it’s my understanding that recent scholarship is of the view that the orchestral versions are the originals, and the piano transcriptions follow on from them. Whatever the case, ‘St Francis of Assisi Preaching to the Birds’ is one of the most attractive of Liszt’s attempts to picture non-musical scenes at the keyboard, even if his prefatory note to the piece suggests some extreme self-deprecation: ‘My lack of ingenuity, and perhaps also the narrow limits of musical expression possible in a work of small dimensions, written for an instrument so lacking in variety of accent and tone colour as the piano, have obliged me to restrain myself and greatly to diminish the wonderful profusion of the text of the Sermon to the little birds. I implore the glorious poor servant of Christ to pardon me for thus impoverishing him.’ The inspiration comes from these lines about St Francis, from a 14th century text: ‘He lifted up his eyes and saw the trees which stood by the wayside filled with a countless multitude of birds; at which he marvelled, and said to his companions: “Wait a little for me in the road, and I will go and preach to my little brothers the birds.” And he went into the field, and began to preach to the birds that were on the ground; and forthwith those which were in the trees came around him, and not one moved during the whole sermon; nor would they fly away until the Saint had given them his blessing.’ (Elsewhere St Francis preached to the fishes, and is said to have converted a wolf – clearly he was good with animals.) The opening pages of the piece are almost literally full of the tweeting and chirruping of birdsong. Then, St Francis begins to preach, his words initially echoed by traces of birdsong, before the avian voices are stilled in a kind of awe, depicted by rising chordal passages. According to the legend, St. Francis preaches to the birds that they have much to be thankful to God for and that they should sing their praises to Him every day. The work ends in a kind of transcendence, a gentle, spiritual piece of musical storytelling. This combination of piety and birdsong might make you think of Messiaen, but clearly Liszt got there first! There are quite a few impressive performances of the piece on YouTube, but the one I’ve gone for is by the Australian pianist Leslie Howard, and not simply to honour his lifelong devotion to the music of Liszt. (For those who don’t know, Howard’s life’s work has been to record every bit of Liszt’s piano music: there’s an initial survey on 99(!) CDs, but since then there have been several further CDs with new discoveries on them. If any current pianist can claim to have worked on Liszt’s music sufficiently to inhabit it, surely it’s Howard.) You’ll find his performance here: Liszt: Legend No 1 ('St Francis of Assisi Preaching to the Birds')
Day 424: Mazeppa (Time: 16 minutes)
We’ve had two examples of Liszt’s music on this playlist to date (Day 90 for La Lugubre Gondola No 2; Day 332 for the Legend No 1, ‘St Francis Preaching to the Birds’), both works for solo piano, the repertoire that accounts for the vast majority of the material Liszt (1811-86) generated in his extensive composing life. In fact, ‘Mazeppa’, the orchestral work which is my choice for today (27/10/23), has its origins in a work for piano of the same name, one of a series of ‘Etudes’ that Liszt wrote in 1825 (so, this makes him a mere 14 years old at the time!) to perform in public to show off his phenomenal technique at the piano. Gradually these early studies eventually emerged (Liszt was fond of rewriting material extensively throughout his life) in the form in which they now usually see the light of day – as the ‘Transcendental Studies’ of the early 1850s, by which point Liszt had officially retired from the public platform and devoted his life to composition. In this state, ‘Mazeppa’ is the fourth of these studies. However, one of Liszt’s many great contributions to the development of music (along with things like ‘inventing’ musical impressionism, or composing atonal music, for example, things that very significantly shaped the music of the early 20th century) was to ‘invent’ (I realise I keep putting inverted commas round this; what I want to suggest is that Liszt’s ideas in these areas evolved over time, but fundamentally he is the originator of these developments) the ‘symphonic poem’ as a form/genre. It would take more space than I have to justify this in detail, but although broadly ‘programmatic’ music had existed before (as in Mendelssohn’s ‘The Hebrides’ Overture, say) Liszt was the first to create single movement orchestral works whose intention was to depict or evoke something extra-musical, whether drawn from poetry, drama, painting, historical event or the character of a historical personage. And alongside this ‘illustrative’ quality, Liszt developed an interest in musical structure – the idea of thematic transformation, where a melody or ‘motif’ metamorphoses through the course of a work in a kind of continuous development, which is what would give the work it coherence and structure. As with the ‘programme music’ idea, Liszt didn’t generate this concept out of nothing: I’d make a good case for saying Schubert, in his ‘Wanderer Fantasy’ (a piece very important to Liszt, who orchestrated it) actually created the first work to be organised by transforming a basic theme, but Liszt, in his ‘symphonic poems’ worked through the ideas and generated a series of examples. Liszt wrote 13 symphonic poems in all – one very near the end of his life, but the other 12 in the decade 1848-58. Liszt initially farmed out the task of taking his Transcendental Study ‘Mazeppa’ and orchestrating it to one of his pupils at the time, Joachim Raff (see Day 296), but at some stage in the early 1850s Liszt himself decided to recast it in the form it now takes today. In terms of narrative, this is the story of Ivan Mazeppa, a 17th century Polish nobleman who, at the royal court, had an affair with another nobleman’s wife. On the discovery of this, the wronged husband had Mazeppa tied naked to the back of a wild horse which was driven off into the desert, where he was discovered half-dead by a band of Cossacks. Eventually, as is the way of these sorts of narratives, Mazeppa became the Cossacks’ leader in their struggle against the Russian Tsar. (The story had already inspired poetry by Byron and Hugo, which may have played some part in Liszt’s decisions to transform his original piano piece.) The music starts with orchestral effects suggesting the unhappy horse being whipped into flight (this is the sort of music that you can hear pre-echoes of Tchaikovsky or Sibelius in), before we get the main theme representing Mazeppa himself. This goes through a series of transformations before the first part of the music concludes with the shuddering exhaustion of the poor horse. The latter half of the piece focuses on Mazeppa’s rescue by the Cossacks, leading to a heroic, triumphal march theme (actually lifted by Liszt from music he wrote during the 1848 European revolutions, a ‘Workers’ Chorus’ for male voices and piano). This music is combined in the end with the original ‘Mazeppa’ theme to form a grand (if you’re a little less sympathetic to the Lisztian ideal, maybe a grandiloquent) conclusion. It’s worth saying that, given the ‘culture wars’ of the mid-19th century, responses to this work differed enormously. The traditionalists of the time (those who would be, I guess, the pro-Brahms faction in the later 19th century in Germanic music) took the ‘full of sound and fury, signifying nothing’ line. However, the pro-Wagnerian faction hailed this – and the other symphonic poems Liszt produced in these middle years of the 19th century – as evidence that Liszt could achieve in these works three key things that were undeniably new in music: to relate music to the outside world; to integrate multi-movement forms into a cohesive whole; and to raise (programmatic) orchestral music to a status at least as important as opera. I don’t think it’s too grand a claim to say that without Liszt in this field, we would not have arrived in the way we did at the genre’s subsequent practitioners – Tchaikovsky, Franck, Saint-Saens, Borodin, Balakirev, Rimsky-Korsakov, Smetana, Dvorak or Richard Strauss in the 19th century, or Bax, Delius, Hanson, Karlowicz, Nielsen, Respighi, Sibelius or Suk in the 20th. As for a performance, I’ve gone for the modern descendant of the orchestra Liszt would have had at his disposal in Weimar when this piece was premiered in 1854, so here is the Orchestra of the Staatskapelle, Weimar, conducted by the man who has been chief conductor of the Bournemouth Symphony Orchestra for the past 15 years, Kirill Karabits. You’ll find the performance here: Liszt: Mazeppa
Day 449: Hungarian Rhapsody No 9, 'Carnival in Pest' (version for piano trio) (Time: 13 minutes)
We’ve had music by Liszt on three occasions on this playlist to date (see Days 90, 332 and 424), and you can find both biographical information and extensive notes on the pieces of music selected on those days via those notes. So far, we’ve had ‘middle period’ orchestral Liszt from the 1850s, some devotional Liszt for solo piano from the 1860s, and some funereal late Liszt from the 1880s. The work for today (23/1/24) – the one with which Trio Gaspard will conclude their Sheffield recital this month – dates from the 1840s, a point in Liszt’s career when he was still a travelling virtuoso and keyboard showman, though that version of his identity would soon be coming to an end. During the years 1848-60, Liszt was based in Weimar, in which time he conducted concerts at the royal court, gave piano lessons to some of the figures who would become renowned keyboard players in the second half of the 19th century, wrote polemical articles about issues in ‘modern music’ (notably pieces celebrating the music of Wagner and Berlioz), and otherwise composed a very great deal. At the beginning of those years he produced a series of pieces that celebrated his ‘nationalist’ identity as a Hungarian composer. Or at least, that’s sort of the case. Some years earlier, in 1840, Liszt returned from extensive touring back to the then twin cities of Buda and Pest, where he was greeted as a national hero. He visited the village where his grandfather conducted the church choir, and also a nearby Gypsy encampment, where he was treated to a kind of improvised musical entertainment. Writing about it later, he described women dancing while jingling their tambourines (that’s not a euphemism, by the way), children turning somersaults, men strutting around with newly-acquired horses then seizing their violins and engaging in a kind of frenzied song and dance. Liszt was duly gripped – and felt that here was the ‘authentic’ Hungarian music, a true Magyar voice with no Germanic influence. Now, later research by Bartók and Kodaly showed that the actual authentic Hungarian music wasn’t, in fact, the stuff of Gypsy encampments, but rather that the Gypsy music Liszt heard was an offshoot derived from something much older. For Liszt, though, the experience prompted a series of 15 ‘Hungarian Rhapsodies’ (to which another four were added much later in his life), and Liszt began to see these not just as pots-pourri of strung-together melodies, but ‘in reality … parts of one great whole – parts disseminated, scattered, broken up, but lending themselves to the composition of one harmonious ensemble’. Thus, these Hungarian Rhapsodies were neither individual and unrelated pieces, nor a continuous concert work, but part of a kind of ‘collective act’ of composition. The work in Trio Gaspard’s recital is the Hungarian Rhapsody No 9, which has the subtitle ‘Carnival in Pest’. It was dedicated to the virtuoso violinist of the time, HW Ernst, and accordingly the composition is even more startlingly jaw-dropping than the other rhapsodies in the set, especially in its dazzling final section. All the rhapsodies were originally written for piano, and written explicitly for Liszt himself to play to the no doubt astonished and adoring crowds. All of them, including No 9, employ contrasting slow and fast sections (the ‘lassu’ and ‘friss’ alternations of the Gypsy music Liszt was emulating), ‘sound effects’ like the imitation of the Gypsy cimbalom, and the melodic and harmonic influences of the musical scales of Gypsy culture. Six of the rhapsodies, including ‘Carnival in Pest’, were orchestrated, initially by Liszt’s pupil Franz Doppler, and subsequently by Liszt himself, and two of these, including No 9, were also arranged by Liszt himself for violin, cello and piano. These piano trio versions come from as early as 1848, though characteristically Liszt went on tinkering with them into the early 1880s, just before his death. The 1848 version – now in the possession of the Juilliard School in New York – is covered in extensive handwritten revisions showing that process in action. This piano trio version only appeared in print posthumously in 1892. It’s a piece that uses five basic themes, three of them folk tunes he would have heard in his Gypsy encounters. It’s largely celebratory in mood, culminating in a dizzying coda. As for a performance, YouTube fortunately has a video recording of the piano trio version, given by the young Czech ensemble Trio Bohémo, founded only in 2019 but already winners of an array of prestigious awards. You’ll find their performance here: Liszt: Hungarian Rhapsody No 9, 'Carnival in Pest' (version for piano trio)
Day 531: Piano Concerto No 1 in E-flat Major, S.124 (Time: 19 minutes)
We’ve had music by Liszt four times on this playlist so far, including works for solo piano – as you’d expect, given Liszt’s reputation as a performer-pianist – and for orchestra, but so far nothing until today (28/2/25) for piano and orchestra. In fact, for such an immensely prolific composer (we’re talking somewhere well north of 700 compositions), there’s relatively little for piano and orchestra, and what there is sometimes exists in multiple versions, revised over the years. The earliest stuff plays heavily on Liszt’s ‘diabolic’ reputation as a concert performer (plenty of lazy journalism from the time about how only someone making a pact with the devil could play with such virtuosity, sparks flying from the keyboard, not to mention innocent maidens falling swooning into his clutches, etc.) – and these early pieces include his ‘Malédiction’ of 1833, and the Grande Fantaisie Symphonique on Themes from Berlioz’s melodrama ‘Lélio’ (possibly the dullest work Liszt ever composed) of 1834. Later in life, when Liszt had settled down from touring, there are other things, notably the splendidly dramatic ‘Totentanz’ (which exists in two versions) and some sets of variations for piano and orchestra (one on a theme by Beethoven, another an arrangement of one of Liszt’s Hungarian Fantasies). You might get the sense from all this revising and redrafting that Liszt’s output is a tangled thing, and it is. To this collection we should add two (some would say three!) piano concertos. To deal with ‘No 3’ first, this was left incomplete at Liszt’s death, and only re-assembled in the 1980s from sources that, bizarrely, had been given away by Liszt’s housekeeper after his death to any visiting friend or acquaintance who wanted a ‘memento’ of the composer. The two ‘official’ concertos each had a very long gestation, evolving as Liszt performed them across Europe: No 1 was begun properly seemingly in 1835, when Liszt was in his early 20s (though there are sketches from his teenage years) but not settled on definitively until over 20 years later; No 2 had a similarly slow evolution into its finished form, from 1849-61. The early start date for the Piano Concerto No 1 reflects the fact that it was the product of the ‘Lisztomania’ years, and you can readily see why the concerto form should have appealed to Liszt. The piano dominates proceedings, and the theatrical ‘debate’ between piano and orchestra offered lots of opportunity for pyrotechnics. But it would be unfair, I think, just to dismiss this work as full of showmanship and hot air. There’s another side to Liszt (well, there were many sides to Liszt!): this is Liszt the innovator, the inventor of new models of musical structure, the pusher of boundaries. One of his most significant contributions to musical development in the mid-late 19th century is the promotion of ‘cyclic’ musical form, taking larger scale pieces in different directions from the ‘classical’ models of Haydn, Mozart and Beethoven. Contrasting any of Beethoven’s piano concertos with Liszt’s Piano Concerto No 1 is very revealing: in a piece lasting barely 20 minutes it weaves a notional four movements into one, with lots of cross-threads providing unity across the piece. Another interesting aspect of the work is the way Liszt gives various orchestral instruments an almost ‘soloistic’ role alongside the orchestra (flute, clarinet, viola, and even the triangle – which caused a scandal at the time!). The first movement starts with a dominant sounding theme, to which the piano responds in dramatic octave passages. Both these will recur in the finale. The song-like slow movement (the theme of which will turn into a vigorous march in the finale) feels a bit like a Chopin nocturne, before it heads off into different directions. The triangle leads off the scherzo (those allergic to Liszt at the time called this work the Triangle Concerto!), jokey at first but then turning darker, before fragments of the first movement recur to lead us into the finale, in which themes from all three previous movements are transformed, leading to a breakneck conclusion. I suspect there will always be people who take against Liszt, and who find the ‘showman’ persona a bit facile. But (at least, this is my view) almost every development in 19th and early 20th century music can be traced back to facets of Liszt’s original musical mind. Perhaps, to meet the nay-sayers half way, we could say that Liszt’s ideas are more compelling than many of his finished works, but what you almost always get with Liszt is startling originality. Compare this work with any other piano concerto written before 1860 and you’ll see what I mean. YouTube has many recordings of this concerto, and in particular there are a lot by what you might call ‘virtuoso’ pianists (Martha Argerich, Yuja Wang, Boris Berezovsky, Daniil Trifonov, and so on). From the many options, this is Ms Wang (startlingly attired as always), performing with the NDR Elbphilharmonie, conducted by Alan Gilbert. You’ll find the performance here: Liszt: Piano Concerto No 1
Lloyd Webber, Andrew (b1948)
Day 10: ‘All I Ask of You’ (from ‘Phantom of the Opera’) (Time: 3 minutes)
Andrew Lloyd Webber is one of the most influential of contemporary composers for the musical theatre. From the early days of ‘Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat’ (in an initial version from 1968) through to ‘School of Rock’ (in 2015), there have been Lloyd Webber shows running somewhere in the world (sometimes several somewhere) all the time. Occasionally, he has made forays into what one might call ‘concert music’, notably his ‘Variations’ from 1978, a set of variations for cello and orchestra on the famous Caprice by Paganini which has seemingly compelled composers to write pieces based on it for the best part of 200 years. However, it is the theatre which has remained the focus of his work. Today (1/4/20), we have a request from Hannah, who would like us to listen to the Phantom London Orchestra and the ubiquitous Andrew Lloyd-Webber, performing ‘All I Ask of You’ from ‘Phantom of the Opera’, performing in lockdown in the relatively early days of the Covid-19 pandemic. Working on the principle that music is music is music, and not getting hung up on the whole high culture/low culture debate. Enjoy..! You’ll find it here: Andrew Lloyd Webber – ‘All I Ask of You’ (from ‘Phantom of the Opera’)
Lutoslawski, Witold (1913-94)
Day 107: Variations on a Theme by Paganini (Time: 6 minutes)
Today (4/8/20), I thought I’d end this brief series of instalments based on the Paganini Caprice No 24 with one of my favourite sets of variations on the theme, the work of Witold Lutoslawski (1913-94). His early career was interrupted by the Second World War, and having escaped from German capture early in 1940 he survived through the next few years playing music in cafes in Warsaw, notably forming a piano duo with fellow composer Andrzej Panufnik. Apparently they arranged something like 200 pieces for piano duet in the years that followed, but when Lutoslawski escaped from Warsaw with his mother in 1944 just before the Warsaw Uprising, sadly the only score that he salvaged from those compositions was the Paganini Variations. The piece is thus an early work, and reveals relatively little of the composer Lutoslawski would go on to become, who would write music based on aleatoric techniques as well as his own version of a kind of twelve-tone serialism. Like many composers and performers from behind the Iron Curtain, Lutoslawski had his fair share of conflict with political authority, but unlike those who fled or were sent into exile he remained in Poland, giving strong support to the Solidarity movement in the 1980s. I have a vivid memory of the concert Lutoslawski gave with the Halle at the City Hall in Sheffield in the mid-1980s conducting a programme consisting of just his own works – a real sense of history in the making! There are a lot of performances of Lutoslawski’s Variations on a Theme by Paganini on YouTube. If you’ve watched the Rachmaninov from last time out (see Day 106), you’ll be aware that Stephen Hough played Lutoslawski's own arrangement of his Paganini Variations for piano and orchestra (an expansion on the original two-piano version dating from the early 1970s) at the same Prom that featured the Rachmaninov – and it’s easy enough to track down that recording if you’re interested – but it doesn’t quite have the explosive vitality of the original version, especially when played by two virtuosi like Martha Argerich and Evgeny Kissin, which you’ll find here: Lutoslawski – Variations on a Theme by Paganini
Day 414: Dance Preludes (Time: 10 minutes)
We’ve had music by Lutosławski on this list once before (see Day 107), and I summarised some biographical details there, so I won’t repeat them. After the Second World War, Lutosławski returned to Warsaw, where he had lived until forced to flee ahead of the Nazi destruction of the city after the failed Warsaw Uprising in 1944. His works in the immediate post-war period fell essentially into two groups: the ‘functional’ music he wrote to earn a living and to provide for his family (things like his ‘Polish Carols’ and the piano suite of ‘Folk Melodies’), and then the more ‘serious’ music in which he began to stretch his wings as a composer (notably, at this time, his Symphony No 1). Like the arts in the rest of eastern Europe, cultural life in Poland was severely repressed after 1947 in the cause of ‘socialist realism’, and Lutosławski’s symphony was branded ‘formalist’ and banned. Lutosławski resigned from the Union of Polish Composers, and in the years that followed he made a living simply by composing more of the ‘functional’ pieces for which he perceived a social need. Unlike many other creative figures residing in Soviet Bloc countries in the mid- and later 20th century, Lutosławski didn’t emigrate to the West, but continued to produce work that gained a growing international reputation whilst remaining just about acceptable to the Communist authorities. In the first ten years after the Second World War one of the key influences on his work was Polish folk music, though often transformed so radically that what you hear has a kind of echo of folk music rather than being undiluted direct quotation. The high point in his oeuvre in this vein is almost certainly his Concerto for Orchestra of 1954 (which I’ll try to find an excuse to feature in the not too distant future). The year after this he wrote what he later described as his ‘farewell to folk music’, his Dance Preludes, which is the work that I’m featuring today (22/9/23). Initially written for clarinet and piano, there are subsequent arrangements for other forces – notably a version for nonet (wind quintet plus four string instruments) dating from 1959 – but it’s the original version that features in Ensemble 360’s upcoming concert later this month, and so that’s what you have here. The five movements are based on folk tunes from northern Poland, though perhaps it would be more accurate to say that they’re based on Polish dance rhythms rather than actual melodies. What all five sections have in common is their heavily syncopated and irregular rhythms, often changing metre from bar to bar, and indeed at times featuring the clarinet playing in a different metre from the piano. The first movement is a kind of jerky dance in 2/4, alternating with 3/4. The second is slower and more flowing, with an underpinning ‘three in a bar’ rhythm. The third movement is a kind of scherzo in which alternating three- and four-beat bars give the music a wild, abandoned character, and fast, high-register passages for the soloist suggest the rather acid tang of the Eb clarinet favoured by many Polish folk musicians. The fourth movement is again slower, and this is probably the simplest of the five sections, with a direct and relatively ‘innocent’ melody. Finally there’s the most complex of the movements, in which the clarinet departs most evidently from the rhythmic underpinning of the piano. It ends with music of great exhilaration, with ‘bagpipe’-type drones and (says the liner note to the CD I have of this music) a ‘jolly atmosphere, rising to a wild climax, perhaps [suggesting] a village wedding’. It’s a work of immense rhythmic and melodic vitality, and a great deal of fun. You’ll find quite a few recordings of the ‘nonet’ version of the Dance Preludes on YouTube, but rather fewer examples of the original clarinet and piano version. However, there is one by the Portuguese pairing of Vitor Fernandes and Bruno Ferreira, which you’ll find here: Lutoslawski: Dance Preludes
| M–Q |
M · N · O · P · Q |
|
Mackenzie, Alexander (1847-1935)
Day 318: 'Pibroch' Suite for Violin and Orchestra (Time: 24 minutes)
Today (19/8/22) brings me to the second instalment of the week that’s been focusing on a couple of figures who were among those who led the shift in British music in the 19th century, so that from the relative dearth of top-flight composers in the years up to, say, 1860, there was a relative flood of significant composers from these islands by the start of the 20th century. Probably the most substantial influence on this development was the professionalization of musical study in Britain in the later 19th century, from the establishment of the Royal Academy of Music (actually as far back as 1822), to the Guildhall School of Music (1880) and the Royal College of Music (1882). In terms of teaching, I suggested last time that essentially three figures led the way in musical study: Stanford, Parry… and today’s composer in focus, Sir Alexander Mackenzie. It is in fact the 175th anniversary of Mackenzie’s birth this coming Monday (22nd August), so it seems apt to explore his contribution to British music today. There are an awful lot of Alexander Mackenzies out there: so, this is not Sir Alexander Mackenzie the explorer of North America, nor the Alexander Mackenzie who became Prime Minister of Canada, nor yet any of the many Alexander Mackenzies who in the 19th and 20th centuries made their mark in fields as diverse as law, history, colonial administration, architecture, cricket, painting or politics. One wonders sometimes about these families with old Scottish clan names, like Mackenzie or Macdonald or Campbell or Douglas or whatever: it’s as though there’s a limited repertoire of first names to pick from, so the same names crop up time and again. Anyway, our Alexander Mackenzie (1847-1935) – actually Alexander Campbell Mackenzie – fits into the ‘musical educational’ role in that he ran the Royal Academy of Music from 1888-1924. However, he’s interesting, I think, as a composer at least as much as an administrator. He came from a family of generations of musicians, particularly violinists. He studied in Germany from 1857-61, gaining insights into the then very ‘modern’ music of Wagner and Liszt, and then studied at the Royal Academy of Music from 1862. He was a full-time musician (teaching, conducting and so on) through the next couple of decades, before arriving at the top job at the Royal Academy of Music. Fortunately, relations between the Royal Academy of Music and the more recent Royal College of Music were amicable, particularly because of the friendship between Mackenzie at the RAM and Parry at the RCM. As a musician, Mackenzie appears initially to have been interested in contemporary music, giving British premieres of works by Liszt, Tchaikovsky, Gounod and Dvorak. However, by the turn of the 20th century, he was becoming a markedly more conservative figure, and he took rather violently against the music of Debussy and Ravel in particular. We hear relatively little of Mackenzie’s music these days, even though there’s quite a lot of shorter orchestral works to go with the half dozen operas that were the basis of his reputation in his lifetime but which have now disappeared completely. As a proud Scot, he was very interested in Scottish folk music, making several compilations of traditional tunes, and weaving them into larger-scale compositions. It’s one of these, his ‘Pibroch’ Suite for Violin and Orchestra, Op 42, which dates from 1889, that I want to suggest we listen to today. He wrote it for the Spanish virtuoso violinist Pablo de Sarasate, completing it in time for the Leeds Festival of 1889. If you’re looking for a musical context for the piece, I’d suggest that its nearest companion is probably Bruch’s ‘Scottish Fantasy’ (dating from 1880, and also written for Sarasate), the two works having a great deal in common. In fact, Mackenzie wrote quite a few works with a Scottish focus, such as the orchestral ‘Rhapsodie Ecossaise’ of 1879, the ‘Scotch Rhapsody No 2’ (‘Burns’) of 1880, and the Scottish Concerto for Piano and Orchestra of 1897, as well as many shorter pieces. Mackenzie wrote endearingly of completing the ‘Pibroch’ Suite while on holiday in Braemar (‘I have been here since 1st August, enjoying the damp, cold weather’ – some things don’t change! – ‘and scoring a new violin piece for Sarasate’), and also of his pessimism about the work’s success (‘It is to come out at the Leeds Fest., but I don’t anticipate any success there, as it is a Scottish effusion and likely at first at least to be mis-understanded [sic] of the people’). Pibroch music is, one might say, the ‘classical’ music of the Scottish bagpipe repertoire, as distinct from dance music such as reels and strathspays. The Gaelic word from which it is derived literally means ‘(the act of) piping’ and pibrochs tend structurally to be based on a kind of ‘theme and variations’ approach. Mackenzie’s piece is in three movements – Rhapsody, Caprice (where the ‘theme and variations’ pattern is most in evidence) and Dance – and throughout, it has a broadly improvisational quality. Underpinning the work are a couple of traditional Scottish tunes, ‘Three Guid Fellows’ in the second movement and ‘Leslies Lilt’ in the finale. Unsurprisingly, recordings of Mackenzie’s ‘Pibroch’ Suite are not all that common, so the link today is to an audio-only performance. It’s by the American violinist Rachel Barton Pine, accompanied by the Scottish Chamber Orchestra conducted by Alexander Platt. You’ll find it here: Mackenzie: 'Pibroch' Suite for Violin and Orchestra
MacMillan, James (b1959)
Day 16: ‘Sing Unto the Lord’ (Time: 6 minutes)
Today (7/4/20), we have a suggestion from Malcolm, for something modern and devotional. Sir James MacMillan achieved international acclaim after the performance of his piece ‘The Confession of Isabel Gowdie’ at the BBC Proms in 1990, and since then his music has been performed with considerable regularity, and to both critical and popular approval. His music is both highly political and also infused with a deep sense of spirituality. Often his writing has its roots in Scottish folk tradition. Alongside works written for the stage and concert hall he has continued to write vocal and choral music for amateur performers, notably for church choirs. Today's piece is a setting of verses from Psalm 96, and, as Malcolm notes, this is "a song of praise to God who IS coming. At the time of Jesus, this was sung every evening and was a prayer of hope for the coming of the Messiah. For Christians it both looks back to what Jesus has done for us, and forward to his coming again in glory. So it is appropriate for Holy Week. The notes to the printed score say: “This short anthem on texts from Psalm 96 is an ideal introduction to MacMillan’s choral music with its inflections of Scottish folk music, Gaelic Psalmody and plainsong”." You’ll find this performance by The Sixteen, conducted by Harry Christophers, here: James MacMillan – ‘Sing Unto the Lord’
Day 142: O Radiant Dawn (Time: 5 minutes)
James MacMillan has featured on this list just the once before (see Day 16),
when his verse anthem ‘A New Song’ (‘Sing Unto the Lord’) was featured.
No less a figure than Harry Christophers, the founder and conductor of the vocal group
The Sixteen, claims that MacMillan is one of the three greatest composers of sacred music
ever (the other two being the Spanish Renaissance composer Victoria, and Francis Poulenc)
– a view open perhaps to the occasional dissenting voice
(where might Tallis or Byrd or Palestrina or Lassus fit into this assessment, not to mention Bach?)
but the comment at least suggests MacMillan’s stature in this field.
The choice for today (4/12/20) is the Advent antiphon, ‘O Radiant Dawn’.
MacMillan is a much performed contemporary composer, with an output featuring symphonies,
concertos, operas and chamber works, but at the heart of his oeuvre is choral
music, most of it designed for practical liturgical use. MacMillan's
socially-committed Catholicism means that a lot of his work has a political
edge, but equally many compositions have simply been written for the choir at
his own church, St Columba's, in Glasgow, to perform as part of routine weekly
services. The Strathclyde University Choir also makes regular visits to
St Columba’s, and over the past fifteen years MacMillan has composed a number
of shorter choral pieces for them to sing, written piecemeal, but pulled
together under the overarching title ‘Strathclyde Motets’. ‘O Radiant
Dawn’ was the seventh of these to be written, in 2007.
It is an ‘O’ Antiphon, that is, one of a series of seven antiphons that starts with the vocative
‘O’ and which describes an attribute of Jesus, as depicted in the scriptures.
These are traditionally sung in the week leading up to Christmas Day
(and ‘O Radiant Dawn’ is actually the antiphon for Dec 21st),
but I hope it’s ok to select this one for today. The text begins: ‘O
Radiant Dawn, Splendour of eternal Light, Sun of Justice: come, shine on those
who dwell in darkness and the shadow of death.’ The analogy is familiar,
comparing the coming of Christ to the brilliant rising sun, dispensing healing
warmth and dispersing shadows. The setting is simple and beautiful,
hymn-like in its directness. The coda, with its six ‘Amens’, rounds off
the piece in great tranquillity. ‘O Radiant Dawn’ is written for
four-part choir, but I’ve chosen a recording for solo voices, which highlights
clearly the harmonic richness and delicacy of the setting. The ensemble
performing the piece on this recording is called Apollo5, and you’ll find their
version here: MacMillan:
O Radiant Dawn.
Mahler, Gustav (1860-1911)
Day 76: Symphony No 5 (5th movement) (Time: 15 minutes)
A while back, I wondered about the problems a list like this might throw up in terms of not being able to fairly represent the music of the more expansive practitioners of 19th century Romanticism, like Bruckner. It’s the same story today (6/6/20): what to do about Mahler (1860-1911)? I could go for some of his song settings, but how do you give a sense of what his symphonic music is like in (allegedly!) under 15 minutes? Looking at my collection of Mahler symphonies, it’s clear that most of the really compelling movements come in at well over 15 minutes. And then think about the famous quotation from Mahler’s conversation with Sibelius about symphonic music: “A symphony must be like the world. It must embrace everything.”> Embracing everything in 15 minutes is asking a lot! So, in the end, this is just a snapshot. I’ve gone for the final movement of the Symphony No 5, for no really obvious reason except that it always feels to me like the end of a phase in Mahler’s symphonic journey (even though it’s conventional to see it as the start of the middle period of his work: this convention breaks the symphonies into three groups, Nos 1-4, 5-7 and 8-‘10’). My only reason for seeing Symphony No 5 as the end of a group (Nos 1-5) is that this is really the last time Mahler works through a narrative from darkness to light in the context of a single work, from the epic funeral march of the first movement of Symphony No 5 to the gleeful, tumbling celebration of life that is this last movement. (From here onwards, death seems to be the endpoint of the works to come.) There are quite a lot of decent Mahler performances on YouTube (even if, from my perspective, there seems to be something of an over-representation of Leonard Bernstein’s Mahler – never knowingly undersold!). So I’ve gone for a performance by the somewhat optimistically titled World Orchestra for Peace, founded in 1995 by Georg Solti, and conducted in this performance from the 2010 BBC Proms by the permanently dishevelled-looking Valery Gergiev. You’ll find it here: Mahler – Symphony No 5 (5th movement)
Day 189: Piano Quartet Movement in A Minor (Time: 9 minutes)
Today (18/5/21) marks the precise 110th anniversary of Mahler’s death in Vienna on 18/5/1911. He was 50 years old at the time, which, if we compare his longevity with that of Richard Strauss (see Days 187/188), means we have missed out on a potential three decades of Mahler’s musical development. Nevertheless, although Mahler’s compositional output is relatively small – he was far better known as a conductor than as a composer during his lifetime – what he produced casts an immensely influential shadow over much 20th century music, not just in the Vienna of the dying years of the Austro-Hungarian Empire, but elsewhere. It’s hard to imagine Shostakovich or Britten, say, could have written as they did had not Mahler’s example showed the way. Mahler has featured on this playlist once before (see Day 76), when I highlighted the final movement of his Symphony No 5. That is a complex, multi-layered work – but then Mahler, perhaps more than any other notable inhabitant of the neurotic, troubled world of pre-First World War Vienna, was a complex, multi-layered individual. Mahler’s background – poor, Bohemian and Jewish – gave him an evident ‘outsider’ status at the outset. Nevertheless, he was able to study at the Vienna Conservatory, and absorbed the influences of Wagner and Bruckner as a young man. His conducting career began early (he was a professional conductor in various minor opera houses in central Europe from the age of 20) and by 1885, he had worked his way up to become Music Director of the State Opera in Prague. His development as a composer did not really take off until about the same time – his Symphony No 1, his first major work, occupied him for four years in the mid-1880s, and was first performed in 1889. All that exists today (there seem to have been other works written and then destroyed) from before the First Symphony is a cantata for soloists, chorus and orchestra, 'Das Klagende Lied', three short sets of songs with piano, 'Lieder und Gesange', the immensely influential four-song orchestral cycle, 'songs of a Wayfarer' – immensely influential in that extracts from them crop up in his first four symphonies – and the work which I’d like to focus on today, his earliest surviving composition. This is the single movement of a Piano Quartet in A Minor, which dates from 1876, which means it was written when Mahler was about 15 or 16. It’s his only piece of chamber music. It’s a nice example of, if you like, ‘the road not taken’. Who knows what might have emerged from Mahler’s imagination had he worked in the realm of chamber music rather than on the vast orchestral and choral canvases that occupied him instead. What we have today is a fragment of a bigger work (there are 24 bars of a second movement, but nothing else to show how the work might have looked). It’s written for the conventional combination of piano with violin, viola and cello, and in most performances lasts around ten minutes. It doesn’t tell us an awful lot about the Mahler that was to come, but it’s a fascinating fragment in its own right. There are a number of performances on YouTube, out of which I’ve selected this relatively brisk one by the Schubert Ensemble, which you’ll find here: Mahler: Piano Quartet Movement in A Minor.
Day 190: Das Lied von der Erde (6th movement: ‘Der Abschied’ (Time: 30 minutes)
Having considered Mahler’s earliest surviving piece of music last time out, today (21/5/21), I want to shift our attention to the final years of Mahler’s life. In that previous mailing, I looked at Mahler’s life up to the later 1880s, when he had his first major success with his Symphony No 1. The years 1890-1910 were immensely turbulent ones for Mahler, and any minimal summary is likely to distort the complexity of that experience. Put simply, those years saw remarkable personal success as a conductor – in Budapest, Hamburg and, from 1897, in Vienna, where he led the Vienna Court Opera for a decade. From 1907, he was enticed to America as principal conductor of New York Metropolitan Opera. However, with the prestige came a whole complex of troubles, personal and professional. There were volatile arguments with local politicians, opera management and performers. Mahler’s workload was insanely busy. He does not seem to have been an easy man to work with, but evidently his Jewish roots continued to lead to conflict with anti-Semitic elements, especially in Vienna. (Mahler had converted to Catholicism as a pre-condition of being appointed to the Vienna Court Opera, but it was seen as a largely cosmetic manoeuvre.) Then one might consider his volatile personal life. In 1902, he married Alma Schindler, author, composer and Viennese socialite (previously the mistress of the composer Zemlinsky). She was 22 at the time; Mahler was 41. It would appear that many were surprised at the marriage and assumed it would not last. Mahler was moody and controlling, Alma flirtatious and headstrong. Two children were born in quick succession, but the relationship started to unravel in 1907 when both daughters contracted scarlet fever and diphtheria, and Maria (the elder one) died. At the same time, Mahler collapsed with overwork (the final bust-up with the Vienna Opera), and was diagnosed with a heart condition the impact of which overshadowed him for the remaining years of his life. What might have been the triumph of the first performance of his Symphony No 8 (the ‘Symphony of a Thousand’ – not quite but almost the literal number of performers at its first outing) was overshadowed by Mahler's discovery that Alma was having an affair with the architect Walter Gropius. (After Mahler's death, she married Gropius. Their daughter, Manon, was the young woman whose early death inspired Alban Berg to write his stunning Violin Concerto. How it all connects…) This brings us to the last years of Mahler's life, 1908-11, and the three final works with which he bade farewell to the world: the Symphony No 9, with its haunted last movement that seems to foreshadow the murderous cataclysms of 20th century conflict; the unfinished Symphony No 10, work on which troubled Mahler right up to his death, and which is similarly tortured; and the symphonic song-cycle 'Das Lied von der Erde' ('The Song of the Earth'). This was written in 1908/9, and is based on a translation of ancient Chinese poetry. Although it was called a ‘symphony’ at its first performance, it consists of six songs for a pair of alternating soloists (ideally a tenor and alto) with orchestral accompaniment. The songs vary in mood. The tenor’s songs (1st, 3rd and 5th) are lively and occasionally a little raucous: 'The Drinking Song of Earth's Sorrow', 'Of Youth' and 'The Drunkard in Spring'. The alto’s contributions are more mellow: 'The Solitary One in Autumn', 'Of Beauty', and the piece I want to celebrate today, the sixth and final song, 'The Farewell'. This is an extraordinary setting, of epic proportions – it is pretty much as long as the other five songs put together. It is, as the title suggests, a song of leave-taking, signalling that though the earth might go on renewing itself, man the individual must inevitably die. The first performance was given six months after Mahler’s death. It is, without doubt, Mahler's own farewell to life. YouTube lists a number of fine performances of the song, from which I’ve selected the performance by the Amsterdam Concertgebouw Orchestra conducted by that legendary Mahlerian, Bernard Haitink. The alto soloist is Anna Larsson. Have your hankie at the ready. You’ll find it here: Mahler: Das Lied von der Erde (6th movement: 'Der Abschied').
Malling, Otto (1848-1915)
Day 384: Piano Quartet in C Minor, Op 80 (1st movement1) (Time: 8 minutes)
Otto Malling (1848-1915) was born on 1st June, which means that two days from now we will mark his 175th anniversary. He was born in Copenhagen, and had a conventional upbringing for an aspiring composer. In his youth, Denmark’s musical scene was dominated by two figures, Niels Gade and JPE Hartmann. Malling took lessons from both of them, but (as is often the way with headstrong young men) in his early days he rejected what he saw as their essential conservatism, and in his mid-20s he was a leading figure in moves to establish an ‘alternative’ music society in Denmark to promote not just his own music but that of (then) progressive composers like Saint-Saens, Gounod, Delibes and Massenet. (He remained sympathetic to the French musical tradition of the mid-late 19th century all of his life.) However, by the 1890s, Malling had become the successor to those establishment figures, following on from Hartmann as professor at the Copenhagen Academy of Music, and succeeding Gade as Director of the Royal Danish Academy. If you’re aware of the trajectory of Saint-Saens’ career from various postings on this list about that composer – ‘enfant terrible’ to founder of ‘new music’ organisations to, eventually, an anachronism before his death – you can see a distinct comparison between his musical journey and Malling’s. In fact, one of Malling’s passing nicknames was ‘the Danish Saint-Saens’. Malling’s compositional career definitely moved in phases. As a young man he was famous for vocal and choral music. In his 40s he wrote mostly orchestral pieces (a Piano Concerto that was immensely popular, but also a substantial Symphony in D Minor amongst other things), but the musical conditions in Copenhagen didn’t really favour orchestral music, so in the 1890s Malling turned to chamber pieces – an initial Piano Trio was followed by a Piano Quintet, a String Quartet, a String Octet, a Violin Sonata and finally, in 1903, his last chamber work, a Piano Quartet. The last 15 or so years of his life were focused on writing organ and church music. In fact, probably one of the reasons why Malling’s music and his reputation disappeared at his death is that church reform in the first couple of decades of the 20th century was much focused, in musical terms, on getting rid of the sort of late-Romantic material which was characteristic of Malling. At his death he was described in the Danish press as ‘one of the top people of our musical life – a name that had the rank of a high officer within Danish music.’ But, somewhat crushingly, the article went on, ‘However, he never indulged in any form of daring venture or experiment.’ I don’t have any urge to promote the idea of Malling as a kind of lost genius, but (as might be clear from some of the postings on this list) I have a great fondness for the music of the great many ‘forgotten’ composers of the period 1850-1930, and Malling’s Piano Quartet in C Minor, Op 80 is a good example of this sort of stuff. The liner notes to my CD of this work describe it as ‘charming’ (not always a compliment!), but also dramatic. This is a work that is clear and concise in expression, and you can tell that Malling was both an expert pianist and a knowledgeable writer for other instruments. (He wrote the first Danish textbook on orchestration.) I’ve chosen to focus this posting on just the first movement of this work. You can hear from the outset a kind of ‘Nordic’ quality in the memorable opening to the work (the influence of Grieg is never too far away), and there’s something decoratively Mendelssohnian here too, but alongside that I think there’s evidence of that sympathy for French harmonic colouring that Malling retained throughout his composing career. There’s a contrasting, rather hymn-like second theme, and then the music is developed in ways that are enjoyable and rarely merely conventional. Unsurprisingly, not a lot of Malling’s music (apart from organ and choral stuff) has found its way onto YouTube, so today (30/5/23) this is yet another audio-only link, I’m afraid. The first movement of Malling’s Piano Quartet in C Minor is played on this recording by the Copenhagen Piano Quartet, and you’ll find it here: Malling: Piano Quartet in C Minor, Op 80 (1st movement)
Manfredini, Francesco Onofrio (1684-1762)
Day 353: Concerto Grosso Op 3 No 12 ('Christmas Concerto') (Time: 8½ minutes)
Today (20/12/22), I’m back on the Advent- and Christmas-themed trail, and a work by another very obscure composer, but one who offers a gentle Baroque view of Christmas music. This is Francesco Onofrio Manfredini (1684-1762). Although he was a full-time musician, with a lifelong career in the service of a number of secular and sacred authorities, we know almost none of Manfredini’s musical compositions today. He was born in Pistoia in Italy, studied in Bologna (where he had lessons from Torelli, one of the many many Italian composers whose output consists essentially of music for small instrumental groups, the ‘concerto grosso’, the ‘church sonata’ and the ‘chamber sonata’). Manfredini’s most long-lasting appointment was as Maestro di Cappella at the Cathedral in his home town, in which role he served from 1727 to his death 35 years later. Before that, his most prominent post was as leader of the court orchestra in Monaco. The most important reason for our relative ignorance of Manfredini’s compositions today is that it appears that after his death most of his work was destroyed in the years that followed. (This does not make him in any way unusual. There’s far more music ‘out there’ than we are generally exposed to these days, and far more music again that has been lost through damage or neglect. So it goes…) Anyway, what remains to us today of his output essentially boils down to three sets of a dozen compositions each: the Twelve Concertini per Camera Op 1, the Twelve Sinfonie de Chiesa Op 2, and the Twelve Concerti Grossi Op 3. So, you might reasonably ask, what reason do we have for focusing our attention on an obscure Italian Baroque composer today? Well, largely because what he offers us is the entirely typical fare one might expect to encounter in early 18th century Italy. He’s not in any way that I can see a unique or special composer – he’s just one of many dozens of people plying his musical trade at that time and in that place. If all that seems like damning the poor guy with faint praise, the specific reason for landing on his work today is that he (like many others of that age, notably Corelli, whose Concerto Grosso Op 6 No 8 we heard back on Day 151) wrote what he and his contemporaries called a ‘Christmas Concerto’. What made Christmas concertos ‘Christmassy’ was usually, as here, the fact that one of the movements of the work is in the form of a sicilienne, which was associated at the time with ‘pastoral’ compositions, and specifically with compositions depicting the shepherds in the nativity narrative. Manfredini’s Christmas Concerto, his Concerto Grosso Op 3 No 12, is in C, and in three movements: an opening Pastorale in the form of a Sicilienne, a slow Largo middle movement, and a sprightly final Allegro which focuses on the prominent solo violin parts, and again highlights the ‘pastoral’ feel of the piece by including a kind of mock-bagpipe drone in the bass. Interestingly, for a composer so little known, there are a good many performances of Manfredini’s Christmas Concerto on YouTube, and out of them I’ve gone for this one by the Combattimento Consort of Amsterdam. You’ll find their performance here: Manfredini: Concerto Grosso Op 3 No 12 ('Christmas Concerto')
Marais, Marin (1656-1728)
Day 305: Sonnerie de Sainte-Genevieve du Mont de Paris (Time: 9 minutes)
I want to use a suggestion today (5/7/22) from the enthusiastic if invisible Pete Dutton, a regular suggester of repertoire, for some music by Marin Marais. Marais (1656-1728) is associated above all with the viol, and the vast majority of his output is for that family of instruments, usually in small chamber ensembles. He did also write a handful of (largely unsuccessful) operas, but he was undoubtedly the leading viol player of his time. I think it’s fair to say that if the viol family had not effectively become obsolete by 50 years or so after his death (the viol consort being in essence superseded by the string quartet), he would be seen as a figure comparable in fame and status to Francois Couperin, say, or Rameau. He was a pupil of another major figure in the history of viol playing, Jean de Sainte-Colombe, who was a leading exponent on the viola de gamba (the bass member of the viol consort, an instrument roughly comparable to the cello). He taught Marais for six months at some point in the last decade of the 17th century, saying that after that time he had nothing left to teach Marais, and that the latter would undoubtedly surpass him. Marais’ renown reached its height when he became the key figure on the instrument at the court of Louis XIV in the early decades of the 18th century. He had been appointed ‘Ordinaire de la Chambre du Roi’ at the age of only 23, which required him to serve at the French court for six months per year, leaving him free and financially secure to spend the rest of his time composing or pursuing other lucrative positions. A nice quotation from the writer Hubert le Blanc, writing in 1740 about Marais’ command of the instrument, reads: ‘The empire of the viol was founded and powerfully established by Le Père Marais’. Viol music, particularly> that of the French Baroque period, is fragile and delicate stuff. It is about elegance of phrasing, and an attention to ornamentation that feels both fastidious and tender at the same time. Marais was aware of the need not only to publish his compositions but to convey as precisely as possible the stylistic features he demanded in performance. In the introduction to Book 1 of his ‘Pièces de Viole’ he wrote: ‘having recognised [...] that players were not performing [my pieces] the way I had composed them, I have finally decided to issue them in the form in which I play them, with all the ornaments that should be added to them.’ (Unsurprisingly, Marais’ work has been of vital usefulness to modern viol ensembles, in revealing how the instrument was played in its heyday.) He published five books of viol pieces, often grouped into suites that, in ways we’ve seen before on this list, employed stylised versions of dance forms. However, Marais also wrote what one might describe as ‘character pieces’, depictions of extra-musical events or locations or activities. Perhaps the most curious is his piece ‘The Bladder-Stone Operation’(!) for viola de gamba and harpsichord, which contains annotated descriptions like ‘The patient is bound with silken cords’ and, more gruesomely, ‘He screameth’! The work Pete has suggested we listen to, as a taster for Marais sound world, is probably his most famous composition, ‘Sonnerie de Sainte-Geneviève du Mont de Paris’ (‘The Bells of St Genevieve’). It is a real ‘ear worm’ of a piece, with its recurring bass line and hypnotic melody. It was composed for viol, violin and harpsichord, though it has been interpreted via many other combinations of instruments. As its title suggests, it depicts the ringing of bells. That brings us to the performance I’ve chosen, which uses Marais’ original instrumental grouping. It’s played on this performance by some of the stars of the baroque instrumental world, who go under the umbrella name Ensemble Fantasticus. On this recording we have Rie Kimura on baroque violin, Robert Smith (not, I hasten to add, Robert Smith of The Cure!) on viola de gamba, and Guillermo Brachetta on harpsichord. You’ll find it here: Marais: Sonnerie de Sainte-Genevieve du Mont de Paris
Martinů, Bohuslav (1890-1959)
Day 75: La Revue de Cuisine (Suite) (Time: 20 minutes)
After the angst and emotion of yesterday’s Schubert, I thought a little light relief might be in order. So, today (5/6/20), we are in 1920s Paris, experiencing that distinctive phenomenon, the European take on jazz. Bohuslav Martinů (1890-1959) moved from his native Czech homeland to Paris in 1923 – he would subsequently move to the USA, and sadly was one of many 20th century composers who never found their way back to their homeland due to the totalitarian politics of the era. In Paris, he discovered jazz, was inspired by the ‘neo-classical’ style of Stravinsky and was attracted by the surrealist movement across the arts. This last influence is most apparent in his 1927 ballet ‘La Revue de Cuisine’, in which the dancers play a range of kitchen and domestic items (pot, lid, dishcloth, broom and so on). There is a suite of movements from the ballet that gets performed more often than the whole score, and it’s the suite I’ve chosen for today, played by six members of the Orchestre Philharmonique de Radio France. The suite is in four movements – Prologue, Tango, Charleston and Finale. (It looks worryingly as though I’ve exceeded the 15 minute rule by a lot in this clip, but it takes over a minute for the players to come on stage, bow and tune up, and there’s almost a couple of minutes of applause and credits at the end. It still overshoots the mark, but not by as much! You’ll find the link here: Bohuslav Martinů – ‘La Revue de Cuisine’ (Suite)
Day 232: Nonet (Time: 16 minutes)
Bohuslav Martinů (1890-1959) has appeared just the once before on this list, on Day 75, above, when I chose the suite of music from his ballet ‘La Revue de Cuisine’, a jazzy and surrealist-inflected playful take on life in Paris in the 1920s. As the 20th century took a turn for the totalitarian in the 1930s, Martinů felt increasingly under threat, and as German troops closed in on Paris in 1940, he and his wife escaped via Spain and Portugal, eventually arriving in the USA in 1941. I wrote last time out about how Zemlinsky struggled as an émigré composer in 1940s America, and much the same could initially be said for Martinů. However, with the help of several other Czech musical exiles he gradually found his feet, picking up commissions and being engaged as a teacher at a music college in Massachusetts. Subsequent appointments took him to Princeton University, as well as major music colleges in New York and Illinois. At the end of the war he was unsure whether or not to return to Czechoslovakia, but the establishment of a hard-line pro-Soviet government there in 1948 put an end to any plans, and he never set foot in his homeland again. He spent his last years in Europe, however, first in France and then in Switzerland. Throughout the 1940s and 50s he continued to compose prolifically (all six of his symphonies, for instance, date from this period), and this creativity was only briefly interrupted when he sustained a fractured skull in a fall in 1946. However, during his sixties his health started to deteriorate, and he was diagnosed with stomach cancer. He was already very ill with this condition and aware that he was dying when in early 1959 he began work on one of his finest chamber works, the featured piece for today (15/10/21), the Nonet (sometimes known as the Nonet No 2, because there’s a fragment of an earlier Nonet, with a piano where the more mature work uses a double bass, from the 1920s). This late work is scored for the fairly conventional nonet line-up, a wind quintet (flute, oboe, clarinet, bassoon, horn) plus four string players (violin, viola, cello and double bass). This combination of forces had been in use since Spohr employed it back in 1813 in his Grand Nonetto, and it became the standard line-up for this type of composition throughout the 19th century. Martinů's work is in three movements, and in character it is typical of many of the chamber works of his final decade, having a ‘neo-classical’ feel (particularly an affection for the music of Haydn) and also a touching sense of nostalgia for his lost homeland: all three movements are rich with associations of the sort of music played by country musicians in Bohemia and Moravia. Like so much of Martinů's music, the piece has clear textures and lots of counterpoint (the simultaneous sounding of more than one line of music) in a work which, in its outer movements, is serene and confident – for a composer only five months away from his death, it’s immensely life-affirming. Only the slow central Andante casts a shadow over the proceedings, in a movement of subdued dynamics and pervading melancholy. As for a performance, there are some video recordings on YouTube, but for me none of them rises above the fairly stodgy, so instead I’ve gone for an audio-only recording, given by Ensemble Wien-Berlin, soloists from both the Berlin and Vienna Philharmonic Orchestras. You’ll find it (accompanied by the musical score: I’d hope that even if you don’t read music you might be able to pick up the patterns as the different instruments play their individual lines) here: Martinů: Nonet
Day 289: Three Madrigals for Violin and Viola (Time: 17 minutes)
Today (3/5/22), we have a work by (as you might have discovered over the playlist’s existence) one of my favourite 20th century composers, Bohuslav Martinů. Martinů (1890-1959) has appeared a couple of times on this list (see Days 75 and 232). I wrote in particular on the latter of those days about Martinů’s travels to escape from totalitarian Europe at the outbreak of the Second World War, and his extended stay in the USA in the 1940 and early 1950s. During those years he produced not just most of his symphonies, and some of his most emotionally direct music, such as the searing ‘Memorial to Lidice’, remembering the massacre of the inhabitants of that Czech village by the Nazis in 1942. But also, there are many works for various mixed chamber ensembles from that time too. Martinů wrote for conventional chamber forces (string quartets, piano trios, cello sonatas and the like) but also for far more unusual combinations of instruments: works for two recorders, for two cellos, for violin and cello, for flute, cello and piano, and so on. And he gave many of these works quirky titles. In particular, he seems to have been fascinated by the Renaissance madrigal as a genre (largely because of its seemingly effortless counterpoint, which had so enchanted Martinů when he first heard The English Singers in this 16th and 17th century repertoire in 1923), and he composed at least four works with ‘madrigal’ in the title.. First, still in Paris in 1938, he wrote his ‘Four Madrigals’ for oboe, clarinet and bassoon. Then, in 1942, homesick in America but determined to woo his new audiences, he wrote his Madrigal Sonata for flute, violin and piano. The following year, he wrote his Five Madrigal Stanzas for violin and piano, for a very famous violinist (and perhaps rather more famous physicist!), Albert Einstein, who played them with the pianist who introduced Einstein to Martinů, Robert Casadesus. Finally, in 1947 he wrote the Three Madrigals for violin and viola. It was hearing a performance of Mozart’s Duo in Bb for these forces that inspired Martinů to compose his Three Madrigals. Martinů wrote to his friend Miloš Šafránek on 16 May 1947: ‘I have written Three Madrigals for violin and viola … for Josef Fuchs and Lillian (his sister) who is a great and unique viola player. I heard them at a concert and was amazed by their artistic quality, so I wrote the Duo for them, and it seems to be good. They are both excited and will put it in their Carnegie recital.’ This was given on 22 December 1947 and in the next day’s New York Times, the venerated critic Virgil Thomson (see Day 112!) gave a warm welcome to the new work: ‘a delight for musical fantasy, for ingenious figuration [and] for Renaissance-style evocation.’ The work is in three movements, two fast ones enclosing a slow pastoral-like Andante. It’s a work which is worthy to stand alongside the Mozart Duos. But it’s also, surely, a memory of, and memorial to, his roots: Bohemian-Moravian folk themes and dances, the pentatonic scale, the instrumentation of his beloved violin and viola, creating intimate sketches of his homeland momentarily at peace, in the brief gap between the end of the Second World War and the Soviet rule imposed on Czechoslovakia in 1948, and recollected from his distant convalescence in the USA; Martinů had fractured his skull in a fall the previous year, but you’d hardly know it, in these pieces which are bursting with life. The work features on a number of YouTube recordings, but I’m very taken by this concert performance by the violinist Hyeyoon Park and viola player Timothy Ridout, which you’ll find here: Martinů: Three Madrigals for Violin and Viola
Mason, Daniel (1873-1953)
Day 430: String Quartet Op 19, 'Quartet on Negro Themes' (1st movement) (Time: 8 minutes) and (2nd movement) (13 minutes) and (3rd movement) (7 minutes)
The composer for today (17/11/23) is Daniel Mason, to which, I expect, the almost unanimous response from people on this list will be, ‘Who?’. Well, Daniel Gregory Mason (1873-1953) was born on 20th November 1873, which (as the mathematical among you will realise) means that this coming Monday will mark the 150th anniversary of his birth. There have been quite a few ‘150ths’ this year, but quite possibly Mason’s is the one least likely to be remarked upon. Now, I suspect there will be many whose reaction to that will be to observe that most ‘unknown’ composers are unknown because in the end their work just isn’t very memorable. I can’t pretend to be a Mason expert – I own (and you’re about to get a link to) one recording of his music, and I’ve heard four or five other pieces on YouTube – so it may well be that a lot of his output just isn’t very startling, but the work I’m about to put before you seemed to me to be at the very least fascinating, so that’s my excuse for devoting this posting to him. He was born in Massachusetts into a long line of musical forebears. His father, Henry, founded a piano manufacturing company, but considerably more influentially in musical terms his grandfather, Lowell Mason, was a prolific writer of hymns and carols (he is responsible for the most common treatment of ‘Joy to the World’, and for the tune to which the words of ‘Nearer, My God, to Thee’ are normally sung). After a stable New England upbringing he studied music under the now not very well known but then key figure, John Knowles Paine, and subsequently with another member of the so-called ‘New England school’, Arthur Chadwick. (We’ll get to these folks at some point on this list, don’t worry.) The whole of Mason’s career, pretty much, was in music education – he worked in the Music Department at Columbia University from 1905 until his retirement in 1942, heading the department for most of the final 15 years of his time there. He was also, though, a prolific writer on music and musicians; allegedly in the middle years of the 20th century he was the most widely read author of books on music and composers in America. Some of the views expressed in his writing don’t stand up too well these days, not just the fact that he effectively refused to countenance music more ‘modern’ than that of Brahms. (Even though he studied for a while with d’Indy he found ‘impressionism’ in music abhorrent.) More troublingly, he had what seem now like quite overtly racist, and especially anti-Semitic views, being publicly critical of the likes of Gershwin, Copland and Bloch … who all just happened to be Jewish. I realise I’m even less likely to succeed in making a case for Mason in the light of these attitudes, but one positive thing to be said in his favour is that he was very keen to integrate music by Black Americans into a wider expression of ‘American music’, and it’s this that leads nicely to the piece I want to explore today. Mason didn’t write a great deal of music in total (three symphonies, quite a few songs, and some chamber music) but one piece that seems to have survived the otherwise general neglect of his output is his String Quartet, Op 19 (‘Quartet on Negro Themes’). He wrote a first version of this in 1918-19, but became dissatisfied with it for what he came to regard as its ‘Debussian harmonies’ (he had little time for French music in general, being wholeheartedly of the view that only ‘Germanic music’ could be regarded as having lasting value) so he rewrote it for subsequent publication in 1930. Negro Spirituals, alongside Mason’s own original themes, occur in all three movements of the work. The opening spirited ‘Allegro’ is based on the perhaps disconcertingly vivacious tune (given the words) ‘You May Bury Me in the East’, which sits alongside a gentler, more lyrical theme of Mason’s own. The slow second movement is based on the well-known spiritual ‘Deep River’, which Mason subjects to some interesting harmonisation. The movement has a livelier middle section, before ‘Deep River’ returns and is developed further to a climax, leading to the movement’s long, rather nostalgic coda. The final movement (‘Allegro moderato, drammatico’ and then a whole range of other tempo markings leading to a final ‘Presto’) actually features three different spirituals: ‘Shine, Shine, I’ll Meet You in the Morning’, ‘Oh, Holy Land’ and ‘Oh, What Do You Say, Seekers?’, before the quartet closes with a final reminiscence of ‘Deep River’ and subsequent sprightly close. This isn’t, I think, great music (I’m aware of making that observation on more than a few occasions in the course of writing these playlist notes), but it’s distinctive and neglected music, and I think it deserves its moments in the spotlight. It will not surprise you to know that recordings of this music are not common. Speculatively, earlier this year, I bought a 2CD set called ‘The Early String Quartet in the USA’ (I know, I should get out more) and it’s a fascinating collection. It’s from this set of recordings by the Kohon Quartet that Mason’s ‘Quartet on Negro Themes’ is taken. You’ll find it here, in audio only, and unhelpfully not as a complete single recording but rather in three separate movements: Mason: String Quartet Op 19, 'Quartet on Negro Themes' (1st movement), Mason: String Quartet Op 19 (2nd movement) and Mason: String Quartet Op 19 (3rd movement)
Mawdyke, Thomas (attrib.) (16th century)
Day 146: The Coventry Carol (Time: 4 minutes)
Today, a carol. Historically, a carol was, as it were, for life, not just for Christmas. That is, a carol was simply a song, usually accompanied by a dance, for any kind of festive occasion. During the centuries after the Norman conquest in 1066 carols became increasingly associated with religious events, notably mystery plays, performed by guilds of artisans/craftsmen, and often re-telling biblical narratives. Nowadays ‘carol’ is pretty much synonymous with ‘Christmas carol’, particularly since the 19th century revival of Christmas carols during the Victorian era, a period when many of the features of Christmas tradition, as we now regard them, were either invented or formalised.
I promised that today I’d feature my favourite Christmas carol of all time.
Obviously, what one wants from a carol may vary, but for me the feeling of listening to
something ancient, something evoking the sense of awe in a candlelit cathedral or similar, is essential.
(This is not to dismiss the many 20th and 21st century carols that
have found their way into the repertoire of many choirs – it’s just that, well,
I want things to feel very, very old.) With that in mind, for me it’s a
near run thing, because I really love ‘O come, O come, Emmanuel’ (but fret not
– I’ve got a strategy for squeezing that into our playlist early in 2021), but
the perfect carol has to be the Coventry Carol. This carol gets its name
because it was written down as part of a nativity play performed by the Guild
of Shearmen and Tailors as part of the cycle of Coventry Mystery Plays.
Nobody knows for sure where the text for the carol came from, though there are
references to it dating back to the late 14th century.
The music, however, seems to be either an original composition or a
copying out of a traditionally sung melody by one Thomas Mawdyke in the late 16th
century. The text is, for a carol, terribly sad – it’s the lament of the
mothers of the young male children massacred on the orders of Herod in his
attempt to murder the Christ child, as recorded in Matthew’s Gospel. The
music, too, has an underlying melancholy, I guess largely because it’s set in a
minor key. I also like its rhythmic irregularity, the insertion of bars
in 2/4 in a song mostly in 3/4. However, for me its most powerful moment
is the clash of F/F# that comes just before the end of each verse (the second
‘by’ in the ‘by by, lul-ly, lul-lay’ that closes each verse). Such
dissonances were not unusual in Renaissance music, but this moment seems to me
to be particularly poignant and anguished in the light of the subject matter of
the carol – a moment made even more touching by the bitter-sweet final chord of
each verse (a ‘Picardy third’, for those who want the jargon – a major chord at
the end of a minor key piece), which has a kind of ‘smiling through tears’
effect. There are inevitably dozens of performances of this on YouTube
(and I’ve just been listening to one of the most recent ones, posted by St
Tim’s musicians on the St Tim’s Facebook page), but for me the purest, most
touching version is that by The Sixteen, conducted by Harry Christophers.
You’ll find it here (and you can follow the score as you do so): Mawdyke(?):
The Coventry Carol
Maxwell Davies, Peter (1934-2016)
Day 54: ‘Farewell to Stromness’ (Time: 6 minutes)
The composer for today (15/5/20) is Sir Peter Maxwell Davies (1934-2016), known to everyone in the music world simply as ‘Max’. Back in the 1960s, he was fearsomely modernist in musical outlook (try out the ‘Eight Songs for a Mad King’ if you’re feeling brave enough!). However, over the decades, both as composer and conductor – in a long association with the BBC Phil – he mellowed somewhat, composing in conventional forms (ten each in terms of symphonies, concertos and string quartets). There are many reasons (beyond, of course, the tendency in most humans to become more conservative – small ‘c’! – as they age), but a very significant one is his decision to move to Orkney (initially to Hoy, and later to Sanday) in the early 1970s. As well as being a champion of gay rights, he was a strong environmentalist, and it’s this latter trait that is the genesis for today’s composition. In 1980, in response to ‘yellowcake’ uranium being potentially mined on the largest island on Orkney to fuel a nuclear power plant, Max created the ‘Yellowcake Revue’ (cabaret songs, recitations and two piano interludes), which was first performed in 1980 in Stromness. From this collection of pieces, we get to today’s choice, the solo piano piece, ‘Farewell to Stromness’. It’s essentially a simple lament, which contrives to be simultaneously melancholy and yet consoling. It’s played on this recording by Max himself, which you’ll find here: Peter Maxwell Davies – ‘Farewell to Stromness’
McKay, George Frederick (1899-1970)
Day 486: Evocation Symphony (Symphony for Seattle) (Time: 25 minutes)
I’m currently still focusing on events during the month of June 1899, but instead of last week’s marking of deaths (Johann Strauss II and Chausson) this week, I want to focus on two significant births that occurred during that month. It’s entirely possible – in fact, it’s entirely probable – that none of you will have heard of the composer for today (4/6/24) George Frederick McKay (occasionally ‘Mackay’ … though I’m pretty sure that’s a mistake), let alone heard any of his music. That would have been true of me too, until about six months ago, when I happened across a suite of orchestral music by him, felt the stirrings of curiosity, did a bit of digging and found a CD of his music on the Naxos label (where you’ll find vast amounts of such stuff) and discovered a composer of some charm and interest. McKay was born on 11th June, 1899, which means that we reach his 125th birthday this time next week. He’s from the Pacific northwest of the USA, born into a farming community in Washington state. He’s yet another of those composers (there are so, so many) whose parents disapproved of a music vocation, insisted on their offspring doing something ‘proper’ (a business degree, in McKay’s case) before the inevitable rebellion followed. McKay eventually studied music at university in Seattle before subsequently graduating from the famous Eastman School of Music in Rochester, New York. He taught at several locations across the USA before spending over forty years at the University of Washington, Seattle, where he taught for the rest of his life, and composed works that have received plenty of exposure in America but not much elsewhere. He died in 1970. His compositions fall into three phases: the formative period (1920-37) when he was influenced by European as much as American culture; a more overtly ‘American’ phase (1937-49), in which you can hear the influence of Copland and Roy Harris on his output; and finally a period labelled by the critic Henry Clarke as ‘synthesis and evocation’ (1950-70). He was a very prolific composer, his works ranging from chamber music (violin and cello sonatas, string quartets, and so on), large-scale choral pieces, lots of songs, and a great deal of music for children, or for broader educational purposes in general. Apparently (I have the liner notes of the CD of his music to thank for this) ‘evocation’ was a key word in McKay’s world view – it’s also the title of an organ piece McKay wrote in the mid-1940s – signifying something place-specific but also spiritual. This is significant in relation to the work I’ve chosen to mark this composer’s anniversary, ‘Evocation Symphony (Symphony for Seattle)’. The commission came in 1951, to mark the 100th anniversary of the founding of the city of Seattle. Though the resulting work is inescapably American, you can hear the influence of Czech composers important to McKay, Janacek and Martinu. The work is in three movements, though their titles (Andante – Allegro con moto; Andante teneramente e pastorale; Allegro vigoroso e ritmico) don’t imply anything ‘picturesque’ about the piece. In that sense it’s ‘pure music’ rather than the sort of folk-influenced stuff that he was producing in his earlier years. If I were comparing McKay to another American composer, I’d probably go for Howard Hanson (see Days 166 and 235), in the sense that what we have here is tonal, post-Romantic stuff, with that rather rugged, expansive feel that such music exploits. (See also – and one day this playlist might illustrate work by – Walter Piston or William Schuman.) For me the stand-out movement is the middle one, a really quite beautiful and tender piece. Unsurprisingly, there are no videos on YouTube of the whole of this piece (there’s a shaky, obviously filmed on someone’s phone, version of the last movement) so this is going to be another audio-only experience. Still, this recording, by the National Symphony Orchestra of Ukraine (who toured the UK, including a visit to Sheffield, last autumn) and John McLaughlin Williams, is acceptable, I think, even if the strings occasionally sound a bit weedy. You’ll find it here: McKay: Evocation Symphony (Symphony for Seattle)
Mealor, Paul (b1975)
Day 175: Ubi Caritas (Time: 4 minutes)
Today (30/3/21), we have a short piece suggested by Malcolm some time ago. It was actually part of a set of suggestions linked to music for Valentine’s Day, but its focus on love and compassion from a divine perspective fits well with the fact we are currently in Holy Week. The composer in question is Paul Mealor (b1975), a musician whose output is largely though not exclusively focused on choral music. I suspect he became famous in effect for one piece – the one Malcolm has chosen for us to listen to – but like many other composers at the popular end of the contemporary music spectrum, his recordings have spent some time at the top of the classical music charts. (Not only did his first album, ‘A Tender Light’, spend six weeks there in 2011, but he also achieved a Christmas No 1 in the pop charts in the same year for his tie-in with the BBC series ‘The Choir: Military Wives’. He was voted ‘the nation’s favourite living composer’ in the Classic FM ‘Hall of Fame’ in 2012, higher than which one might think it impossible to aspire to.) He was born in North Wales, and for most of the past 20 years, he has been Professor of Composition at Aberdeen University. The music Malcolm has suggested is a short composition, commissioned by Prince William, that Mealor wrote for the wedding of those current darlings of the British tabloid press, the Cambridges, back in 2011. At that point, the music was performed as a motet during the wedding ceremony. Interestingly, it had had a previous incarnation as one of Four Madrigals, which dated from the previous year, in which version it was a setting of Tennyson’s erotically charged poem ‘Now Sleeps the Crimson Petal’. However, by the time of the wedding in Westminster Abbey, the music had been re-presented as a vehicle for the ancient Christian hymn ‘Ubi Caritas at Amor’, a text attributed to one Paulinus of Aquileia in the late 8th century. These days it is associated most often with the foot-washing ceremonies of Maundy Thursday (which, by no design on my part, also makes it apt for our focus this week). Its opening line (‘Ubi caritas et amor, Deus ibi est’) translates roughly as ‘Where charity and love are, there God is’. Mealor’s music seems to come from the same harmonic landscape as that of Eric Whitacre or Morton Lauridsen (see Day 147), though there’s a nice echo near the end of the motet of the Gregorian chant that Maurice Duruflé used in his setting of these words, which gives this very fine piece a sense of being part of an established musical tradition. The performance Malcolm has asked for is by the wonderful Tenebrae, conducted by Nigel Short. You’ll find it here: Mealor: Ubi Caritas
Mendelssohn, Fanny (1805-47)
Day 292: Piano Trio in D Minor, Op 11 - 1. Allegro Molto Vivace (Time: 12 minutes), 2. Andante Espressivo and 3. Lied: Allegretto (8 minutes) and 4. Finale: Allegretto Moderato (6 minutes)
Today (13/5/22), a piece of music by Mendelssohn … but not that Mendelssohn. Instead, I’d like to introduce a new name onto the playlist. Tomorrow will mark the 175th anniversary of the death of Fanny Mendelssohn (1805-47), who stands as a perfect exemplar of the position of women in the musical world of the first half of the 19th century. These days it is conventional to name her ‘Fanny Mendelssohn’, though at birth she was Fanny Cäcilie Mendelssohn Bartholdy, and after her marriage she became Fanny Hensel, though also sometimes Fanny Mendelssohn Hensel. When I wrote about her younger brother Felix (see Days 84 and 203), I drew attention to the exceptionally privileged upbringing enjoyed by both him and his sister in the family household in Berlin. I also highlighted the general sense that Felix Mendelssohn was regarded as a kind of ‘infant prodigy’ of the musical world, though interestingly the piano teacher of both Mendelssohn children saw Fanny as the greater talent as a young teen, both in terms of piano technique (at 14, she could play all Bach’s Preludes and Fugues from memory) and also compositional skill. However, without wishing to labour the sexist culture of the era (perhaps made worse rather than better by the stifling social conventions of the well-to-do milieu in which the Mendelssohns moved), Fanny’s father had no truck with his daughter’s burgeoning musical abilities. At around the age when she was astonishing people with her playing of Bach, her father wrote to her: ‘Music will perhaps become [Felix's] profession, while for you it can and must be only an ornament.’ Even her beloved younger brother was cautious, writing: ‘I should say that she has neither inclination nor vocation for authorship. She is too much all that a woman ought to be for this. She regulates her house, and neither thinks of the public nor of the musical world, nor even of music at all, until her first duties are fulfilled. Publishing [her music] would only disturb her in these, and I cannot say that I approve of it.’ (Feel free to grind your teeth in fury at the condescension of it all!) Fortunately her husband did at least encourage her to play in public, and, more cautiously, to continue to compose. It’s worth saying that Felix Mendelssohn did finally soften his attitudes a little. When a collection of her songs was published as her Op 1, Felix offered her ‘my professional blessing on becoming a member of the craft ... may you have much happiness in giving pleasure to others; may you taste only the sweets and none of the bitterness of authorship; may the public pelt you with roses, and never with sand.’ (Revealingly, she wrote in her journal: ‘I know that he is not quite satisfied in his heart of hearts, but I am glad he has said a kind word to me about it.’) This was in 1846. Sadly, a year later she died, suddenly, from a stroke. It’s hard to say with any confidence what might have been, but there is about her life and its experiences a sense of unfulfilled promise. During the last year of her life she was working on a Piano Trio in D Minor, her Op 11, a substantial work in four movements, which was published posthumously in 1850. Its opening movement is particularly impressive, I think. The piano part clearly shows the influence of her brother’s music for keyboard, though there’s also evidence of Schubert there in the background, in my opinion. The second movement ‘Andante Espressivo’ starts conventionally enough, but it develops in ways which suggest a more personal ‘voice’. The final two movements are, without wishing to seem unduly critical, rather less memorable, but taken as a whole the work surely ought to see the light of day in performance rather more than it does. At her death, Fanny Mendelssohn left well over 400 compositions, mostly songs and solo piano pieces, but there is a handful of large-scale works to explore if this piece piques your interest, and as the broadcasting and recording industries have begun to wake up to the fact that women too composed quite a lot of music in the 19th century (see the ‘discovery’ of Louise Farrenc, Emilie Mayer, Alice Mary Smith, Louise Viardot, Augusta Holmes, Amanda Rontgen-Maier, and so on), there will no doubt be more of Fanny Mendelssohn’s work to be explored in the years to come. There are limited choices when it comes to performances of Fanny Mendelssohn’s Piano Trio on YouTube, but from them I’ve chosen this one by the American-based all-female Aletheia Piano Trio. Unfortunately it only exists on YouTube in separate clips, which you’ll find here: Fanny Mendelssohn: Piano Trio in D Minor, Op 11 - 1. Allegro Molto Vivace, 2. Andante Espressivo and 3. Lied: Allegretto and 4. Finale: Allegretto Moderato
Day 458: String Quartet in Eb (Time: 20 minutes)
I’ve featured Fanny Mendelssohn just the once so far on this list (see Day 292 for her Piano Trio in D Minor, Op 11), at which point I mused about her identity as an exemplar figure for the position of female composers in a pre-20th century world, a marginal position exemplified even by her name: Fanny Mendelssohn Bartholdy at birth, Fanny Hensel after her marriage, but also sometimes Fanny Mendelssohn Hensel, and, just to complete the set, Fanny Hensel Mendelssohn … but often just Fanny Mendelssohn. Fanny (1805-47) was a prolific composer from the outset, and in the late 1820s she began work on a piano sonata. For whatever reason (domestic duties, perhaps…; in 1829 she married Wilhelm Hensel, and the following year gave birth to their only surviving child) she broke off from writing it, but some of the material found its way into her only string quartet, my choice for today (23/2/24), finally finished in 1834. This makes it a relatively mature work in her output as a whole, though a good dozen years before her Piano Trio Op 11. It is, you might be rather startled to note, one of the very first string quartets written by a woman to have survived. Whether this is because before this point women simply didn’t write quartets, or (a little more likely) because they didn’t publish their work, which has thus fallen into obscurity, the fact remains that Fanny Mendelssohn’s String Quartet in Eb is a startling and unusual work, regardless of the sex of its composer. Declaring herself ‘not an eccentric or overly sentimental person’, she wondered how she might have produced such volatile music, explaining it best by noting the impact of ‘the exceedingly moving and emotional style’ of Beethoven’s quartets, which she encountered as a young adult. Even so, there was something daunting to her (as, similarly, for Clara Schumann) about writing in large-scale forms – the vast majority of Fanny Mendelssohn’s output consists of songs or short piano pieces – claiming she ‘lacked the ability to sustain ideas properly and give them the needed consistency.’ That may or may not be true, but there’s no denying that her string quartet is structurally unusual and unconventional in development. The work has four movements, starting with a sombre slow section marked ‘Adagio ma non troppo’ which stays resolutely in the key of C Minor. In fact, this mood of quiet anguish should confirm that this is ‘serious’ music by a serious composer. Nominally in the key of Eb, the music only finds its way to the major key close to the end of the movement. The abandoned piano sonata of 1829 provided the material for the first two movements. The second movement is an ‘Allegretto’ that feels a little like Felix Mendelssohn’s ‘gossamer’ scherzos, though hints of C Minor keep the mood rather darker than usually found in her brother’s similar pieces. The third movement ‘Romanze’ is again in the minor (G Minor this time), and in most performances this is the longest of the movements, during which she takes the music into some very obscure keys. There’s a sense here of a composer not doing things ‘by the book’, but instead following a kind of emotional narrative. Her brother found this movement particularly perplexing, in the way it avoided taking the ‘correct’ procedures dictated by conventional forms. I suspect this is where her interest in Beethoven’s late music led her. Only in the final movement, perhaps, do we get something more conventional. It’s a whirling and energetic finale, with a contrasting, more lyrical idea to offset the vigour of the main theme. The work had only one performance during her lifetime, at the Hensel family’s musical salon. It’s a sad thought that her brother Felix disapproved strongly of the work, saying it had an undisciplined approach to form, and maybe as a consequence she never attempted such a piece again. In terms of performances on YouTube, there are quite a few decent video recordings out there. From them I’ve selected this one by what appears to be a scratch quartet assembled for the occasion at the Summerfest series in August 2023 put on by the La Jolla Music Society in California. The standout name here is Agustin Hadelich on first violin, but the other performers seem pretty impressive to me too: Andrew Wan on 2nd violin, Matthew Lipman on viola and Julie Albers on cello. You’ll find their performance here: Fanny Mendelssohn: String Quartet in Eb
Mendelssohn, Felix (1809-47)
Day 84: Octet for Strings (1st movement) (Time: 14 minutes)
Today (14/6/20), filling a notable gap, in that it’s about time we had some Mendelssohn, I thought a performance of some of his Octet for Strings would be a bright and sparkly way to celebrate music’s ongoing vitality. Felix Mendelssohn (or Jakob Ludwig Felix Mendelssohn Bartholdy, as he was known in the family!) (1809-47) really was an infant prodigy. By the time he came to write his Octet, as a 16-year-old, he had already written (a handful of examples from a very very long list) at least five operas, a dozen string symphonies, his full orchestral Symphony No 1, three piano quartets, a couple of violin sonatas and a large collection of solo piano music. His facility in some ways might seem to count against him: there is a sense in which Mendelssohn’s music seems too bland, too ‘nice’, lacking the grit in the oyster that would generate something properly great. Schumann called him ‘the Mozart of the nineteenth century’, and Mendelssohn certainly appreciated (and mastered) the techniques of previous musical eras – not just Mozart, but Beethoven and especially Bach. For some critics, Mendelssohn never matured beyond his early youthful brilliance. But whilst a lot of his work doesn’t set out to provoke a response in the listener or to disturb any sense of equilibrium, there are a handful of pieces that shine with a jewel-like attraction: the Overture to ‘A Midsummer Night’s Dream’, the ‘Italian’ Symphony, the Violin Concerto. And in fact, there are some works, written at points of deep emotional distress, like the String Quartet in F Minor, Op 80 (written after the death of his beloved sister Fanny) that break through the veneer of charm and elegance, and reach a genuine intensity of feeling. Still, in 1825, when Mendelssohn was 16, all that was still in the future. In that year, he wrote his String Octet as a birthday present for his violin teacher – what a gift! It feels like it’s composed of joy and light. Mendelssohn himself said later, ‘I had a most wonderful time in the writing of it,’ and you can definitely hear that in the music. I thought, even though it’s the Scherzo that usually gets played by way of illustration, it would be more satisfying to listen to the first movement of the piece, where technique and enjoyment are most pleasingly matched. YouTube offers a variety of audio recordings, but one of the pleasures of Mendelssohn is watching players navigate all those semi-quavers, so I’ve gone for a video recording from Australia, by a group called the Omega Ensemble. You’ll find it here: Mendelssohn – Octet for Strings (1st movement)
Day 203: A Midsummer Night’s Dream (Overture) (Time: 12 minutes)
This week, in honour of the season, is Summer Music Week. Sidestepping Vivaldi, probably the second most popular summer-related piece in the classical music world is the score Mendelssohn composed to Shakespeare's comedy ‘A Midsummer Night's Dream’, so I thought some of that might be a suitable place to start on this short survey of music for the season. Mendelssohn has appeared just the once before now on this list (see Day 84), when we explored the first movement of his Octet for Strings. Writing about that piece, I highlighted Mendelssohn’s prodigious talents as a teenage composer, and it’s likely that the choice for today (6/7/21) simply serves to reinforce the ‘Boy Wonder’ view of this particular musician. Mendelssohn had an exceptionally privileged youth, acquiring the best education and excelling in many areas – had he not been a composer, he might have been a painter or a writer – surrounded by many of the great and good of the European intelligentsia who passed through the household of his parents. Thus it’s not a surprise to find that Mendelssohn had a good working knowledge of many of the plays of Shakespeare as an adolescent. The first one to strike a creative spark from him was the multi-layered comedy ‘A Midsummer Night's Dream’. As a (relatively) older man in his 30s, Mendelssohn wrote an extensive amount of incidental music for the play, including the Wedding March which has marked the nuptials of many couples since its first performance in 1842. However, as a mere seventeen-year-old he wrote a concert overture based on the play, an extraordinarily mature and imaginative evocation of the various ‘worlds’ of the drama, from its romantic lovers, to its ‘rude mechanicals’, to (most characteristically in terms of Mendelssohn's ‘voice’ as a composer) its fairy kingdom. Grove (of ‘Grove’s Dictionary’ fame) called the work ‘the greatest marvel of early maturity that the world has ever seen in music’. The overture's opening wind chords (which will expose the dodgy tuning and balance of many an orchestra) give way to the gossamer string writing of the fairy kingdom, before we encounter the sound world of the lovers and subsequently (and with a broad humour) the ‘hee-haw’ of Bottom, in his transformed role as an ass. The fairy music dominates the central section of the piece, before the various themes are repeated, leading to the fairies having the final word, as in the play, and the overture ends with the nocturnal stillness of the wind chords with which it began. All in all, it’s a remarkable piece of work for the 1820s, and a remarkable piece of work for someone who was just 17 at the time. There’s a sensitive and well-balanced performance of this work on YouTube from the Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra, conducted by Riccardo Chailly (though it takes him a while, after the start of the video, to arrive on the podium). You’ll find it here: Mendelssohn: A Midsummer Night's Dream (Overture)
Day 331: Piano Trio No. 1, Op 49 (Time: 29 minutes)
Felix Mendelssohn has turned up just twice so far on this list (see Days 84 and 203), featuring a movement from his youthful Octet and the equally youthful Overture to ‘A Midsummer Night’s Dream’. Rather than keep plugging away at this idea of Mendelssohn the ‘boy genius’, today (4/10/22), we have a product of Mendelssohn’s maturity – his Piano Trio No 1 in D Minor, Op 49. In March 1837, at the ripe old age of 28, Mendelssohn married Cécile Charlotte Sophie Jeanrenaud (she was 20 at the time – it’s how they tended to do things in those days), and on his honeymoon, he began to contemplate writing chamber music after what had been (for him) quite a long gap. In his gifted adolescence, he produced three early piano quartets, a couple of violin sonatas, a viola sonata and a very early (unnumbered) string quartet, as well as the marvellous String Octet. Then, in his late teens/early twenties, he wrote two ‘mature’(!) string quartets. Then other projects took precedence, until at the time of his marriage and after a ten year gap (who knows if this is causal or just a coincidence), there emerged a sudden flurry of chamber pieces. Between 1837 and 1840, we get the three string quartets Op 44, a violin sonata, a cello sonata… and today’s work, his Piano Trio No 1. The piano trio as a genre reached its early maturity with Beethoven and Schubert, and there is a sense, I think, of Mendelssohn aspiring to stand alongside these musical greats by producing a work of substance and complexity. Mendelssohn’s trio elicited almost instant approval after its first performance in 1840. It was this work that prompted Schumann (never one to hold back on his enthusiasms) to describe Mendelssohn as ‘the Mozart of the 19th century’, but for me what’s most interesting about that remark is that it continued thus: ‘the brightest musician, who most clearly understands the contradictions of the age and is the first to reconcile them.’ It’s this sense of reconciling contradictions that seems to me to be the key to understanding Mendelssohn and what he’s trying to do. His musical background was steeped in the baroque and classical eras (he had an intense devotion to the music of Bach, Mozart and Beethoven), but he also knew how powerful the pull of musical romanticism was, the turbulence and passion to be found in, say, the works of Chopin and Schumann and early Liszt, or even in its lesser lights, like Spohr, Hummel and the fellow composer who persuaded Mendelssohn to revise this first piano trio after its initial performance, to make it more ‘of its age’, one Ferdinand Hiller. Back to Schumann again: he described the Piano Trio No 1 as ‘the master-trio of our time; even as Beethoven's B-flat and D Major trios and Schubert's E-flat at their time, this will delight the future generation.’ You can hear from the start of the work this emotional intensity in Mendelssohn’s writing, in which both cello and violin have their moments in the spotlight, but underpinned by virtuosic, rippling piano writing. The slow movement is one of those characteristic Mendelssohnian ‘songs without words’. Here again there’s opportunity for all three instruments to engage in deeply lyrical writing, notably towards the end of the movement, where the violin soars over the cello’s accompaniment. There is a tendency sometimes, I think, to regard this sort of movement as merely ‘pretty’. I’d argue that we do the early Romantic period in music a disservice here: the passion may not have the ‘heart on sleeve’ melodrama of later 19th century excess, but it speaks eloquently of the emotions of its time. The third movement is again ‘typical Mendelssohn’, in this case the Mendelssohn of the gossamer scherzo writing characteristic of ‘A Midsummer Night’s Dream’. The piano writing shows what Mendelssohn’s gifts as a pianist must have been, brilliantly dealing with staccato rhythms and lightning-fast passagework. Finally, the last movement seems to me to be the place where Mendelssohn most obviously shows his admiration for Schubert. It’s warm-hearted ‘singing’ stuff, even if there are passages that strike a more conventionally ‘romantic’ pose. We end, after all that minor key turbulence, in a radiant D Major. There are quite a few performances, audio and video, on YouTube, that offer plenty to choose from, but in the end (and really because of the larger-than-life personality of the pianist) I’ve gone for this recording by Martha Argerich on piano, and the string players Arata Yumi and Dan Sloutskovski. You’ll find it here: Mendelssohn: Piano Trio No 1, Op 49
Day 339: String Quartet No 6 in F Minor (Time: 27 minutes)
Today (1/11/22), I want to mark the anniversary of the death of Felix Mendelssohn at the tragically young age of 38 on 4th November 1847, 175 years ago this week. We’ve had a fair bit of Mendelssohn on this list over the time it’s been running (see above, Days 84, 203 and 331), but I’d like to believe that today’s choice of music takes us in a direction we might not expect. If there’s a stereotypical view of Mendelssohn, it’s that he is the composer of music of filigree delicacy (all those ‘fairy-like’ scherzos), or gentle lyricism (the many ‘Songs without Words’), or the writer of pieces of youthful brilliance (his Octet for Strings or the ‘Midsummer Night’s Dream’ Overture), or that one popular product of his latter years, the inexhaustibly serene Violin Concerto. Well, for his detractors (and there are quite a few) what it all adds up to is a collection of music which is skilful, but essentially just too well-mannered, too ‘nice’ to really reach the heights with any consistency; his is music of great facility, but that carries within it the sense that it is, in some ways, often ‘facile’, a kind of note-spinning. So, I hope that today’s choice will be, if nothing else, an antidote to that picture of gentility. It’s his String Quartet No 6 in F Minor, Op 80. Its genesis could hardly be more personal and intimate. You may know from previous postings that, though Mendelssohn married and had five children (and, allegedly, had an intense – though maybe not adulterous – relationship with the famous Swedish soprano Jenny Lind), the one woman who was the constant figure in his life, his soulmate from a very early age, was his sister Fanny, who was three years his senior and clearly his equal during their prodigiously gifted youth. In May 1847, when she was just 41, she died suddenly of a stroke. The impact on Felix, when he heard the news, was devastating. Apparently he collapsed with shock into a state of unconsciousness, and in the six months or so left to him he never really recovered. His letters and writings from these months communicate something of the intensity of emotion that her death prompted. The day after getting the news, he wrote to another sister, Rebecka, ‘since yesterday and today, and for many, many days to come, I’ll be unable to write anything beyond – God help us, God help us!’ Elsewhere, he wrote that he ‘could not think of work, or even music, without feeling the most intense emptiness and barrenness in the mind and heart.’ In the summer of 1847 he spent some time in Interlaken in Switzerland, and there he was at least able to compose some pieces, and among them is this string quartet, the first he had written in nine years, and by most people’s estimation by some distance his greatest work for this medium. It was destined to be the last piece he completed – in September 1847 he suffered another collapse and wrote nothing more until his death in early November. Although Mendelssohn heard it played privately a month before his death, it did not appear in public until, on precisely the first anniversary of his death, it was performed with the renowned violinist Joseph Joachim on first violin. The quartet has sometimes been called his ‘Requiem for Fanny’. It is, to quote Sara Bitlloch of the Elias String Quartet (whom many will remember from their brief time with Ensemble 360 here in Sheffield from 2005-9), ‘a cry of despair, of rage, of pain in its rawest form’ – words that one would surely never normally associate with the music of Mendelssohn. This sense of tragedy and sustained anguish is apparent from the outset – restless tremolos from the lower strings leading to a violent cry from the first violin. This relentlessness drives the first movement; although the second theme is a touch more lyrical, the music keeps being pulled back into feverish activity. The string writing is challenging for all four parts, but particularly for the first violin as it cries high and inconsolable over the voices of the other three parts. If the first movement is wild and heart-broken, the second is even more startling. In the place where we might expect a gossamer-light scherzo we get an obsessive and relentless battle with fate, broken only by a middle section which feels like macabre funeral march – it offers no relief. Only the third movement might seem to lighten the mood. This could almost be a ‘song without words’. The melody is in fact very vocal, but there’s little let up in the emotional burden. We’ve reached some kind of calm, perhaps, but calmness infused with pain. And the finale pulls us back into scurrying, obsessive rhythms and sudden outbursts of something quite like fury. As I said at the start, if you have a familiar view of ‘that nice Mr Mendelssohn’, this will come as something of a shock. YouTube is quite well stocked with versions of this work, some rather older and more staid than others, but all of them rewarding. Out of the options available, I’ve gone for a performance given at the ChamberFest in Cleveland, Ohio, in 2019, by four musicians who appear to have come together for this event, rather than being an established string quartet. They are Alexi Kenney and Nathan Meltzer on violins, Hsin-Yun Huang on viola and Nicholas Canellakis on cello. It’s a recording that captures a lot of the turbulence that, I’ve been aiming to suggest, makes us see Mendelssohn in a rather different light than usual. You’ll find the performance here: Mendelssohn: String Quartet No 6 in F Minor
Day 530: String Quartet No 2 in A Minor, Op 13 (Time: 33 minutes)
Next month, the period-instrument ensemble the Consone Quartet are performing a day of music by Felix Mendelssohn, including his String Quartet in A Minor, Op 13 – and it’s that work that I’m focusing on today (21/2/25). Mendelssohn’s compositions have featured four times already on this list, and among those choices I’ve already explored the last of Mendelssohn’s quartets, the anguished F Minor quartet, Op 80. However, today’s choice turns the clock back almost to the start of his career as a composer in this form. Almost, because Mendelssohn seems to have had an extraordinary facility when it came to writing for strings from a very early age indeed. For instance, between the ages of 12 and 14, he wrote thirteen striking String Symphonies, with their echoes of both JS Bach and his son CPE Bach, as well as Mozart and Haydn. In his fourteenth year, he also tried his hand at a string quartet – a work not published in Mendelssohn’s lifetime and now usually labelled String Quartet ‘No 0’. In the four years that followed, Mendelssohn’s mid-teens, the quantity of work he created is phenomenal, and these aren’t ‘juvenile’ works, but (in many cases) masterpieces that have stood the test of time: most obviously the Octet for Strings (see Day 84 for the first movement), but also his Symphony No 1 and the ‘Midsummer Night’s Dream’ Overture (see Day 203). In 1827, by then a terribly grown-up 17-year-old, Mendelssohn returned to the string quartet. Confusingly, the work he then wrote, the String Quartet in A Minor, Op 13, has now acquired the label ‘No 2’ – because there is also a String Quartet No 1, though this work dates from two years later, 1829; it just happens to have been published before ‘No 2’, hence the numbering. The fact that the A Minor quartet was written when it was makes it pretty astonishing, I think. 1827 was the year of Beethoven’s death. As far as I’ve been able to discover, Mendelssohn’s work was begun before Beethoven died, but completed after this event – and there are distinct Beethovenian echoes in this Mendelssohn work. He seems to have known and loved Beethoven’s late string quartets (not a universally shared opinion in the second half of the 1820s), and his own string writing indicates that he drew substantially on Beethoven’s example. One thing very obvious about the A Minor quartet is how innovative it is. Mendelssohn clearly had original ideas about structure and organisation, breaking the conventional mould for the quartet medium in ways that would become more mainstream as the 19th century progressed. Probably the most important development in this Mendelssohn quartet is its use of ‘cyclic’ form – a mainstay for Romantic composers in the decades to follow: see the works of Liszt, for example – and in this quartet the striking slow introduction to the first movement recurs more than once, but particularly at the very end of the piece, bringing it ‘full circle’ and ending it in an unusually downbeat and reflective way. (A bit more nerdy detail: this slow introduction makes extensive use of a three-chord motif that Mendelssohn took from one of his early love songs, ‘Frage’ (‘Question’). In the song, the chords accompany the words ‘Is it true?’, and you don’t need to be too much of a Beethoven enthusiast to recognise it as a version of Beethoven’s ‘Muss es sein?’ (‘Must it be?’) that features in his final string quartet, composed only a few months before. Coincidence? I don’t think so.) After the slow introduction, the first movement proper is an anxious, hectic affair, but it’s followed by a romantic slow movement that once more echoes the work’s slow introduction – or at least it is initially romantic, though it turns into a fugue that’s rather more austerely thoughtful. Then, instead of a Mendelssohnian scherzo (for which he was already famous even in his late teens) there’s a more graceful intermezzo, harking back to the classical minuet – though even here the song-like melody on the first violin echoes the work’s very first bars. If you know the finale of Beethoven’s String Quartet Op 132 (and if you don’t, don’t worry!), you might recognise aspects of it in Mendelssohn’s final movement to his quartet: initially quite tragic, with an anxious ‘recitative’ on the first violin, which comes back after an intervening fugue (Mendelssohn clearly wanting to gain full marks for intellectual rigour). But just when it seems like the piece is set for a hard-won triumphant resolution, Mendelssohn pulls the rug out from under us – another ‘soloistic’ passage from the first violin, then an echo of the fugue theme from the second movement, and then a return of the whole of the first movement introduction, which is then developed through to the work’s ending. For me, this is a work that deserves to be much better known, and it’s one that marks Mendelssohn the writer of string quartets as the heir not just of Haydn and Mozart, but particularly of Beethoven. As for a performance, YouTube has quite a few that would do the trick, but out of the options, I’ve gone for this one by the renowned Emerson String Quartet, which you’ll find here: Mendelssohn: String Quartet No 2 in A Minor, Op 13
Meredith, Anna (b1978)
Day 1: ‘Hands Free’ (Time: 13 minutes)
Anna Meredith (b1978) is one of those fascinating composers who exists at the interface between ‘classical music’ in its conventional sense and more modern ‘electronica’-based styles. She has written extensively for more traditional instrumental forces (she was composer-in-residence for the BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra for a time), but in addition she has developed another career as a solo performer and with a four-piece band. Her debut album ‘Varmints’, of 2016, is strikingly original. The piece I’ve selected for today (23/3/20) is called ‘Hands Free’, given in a performance by the National Youth Orchestra of Great Britain at the BBC Proms in 2012. It’s a piece for orchestral musicians to play, but not using their instruments. Instead it employs voices, body percussion and beat boxing, in visually choreographed ways, to create a rich tapestry of rhythmic sound patterns. Although a ‘score’ for the piece exists, it will not surprise you to know that it looks nothing like a conventional piece of music, and it is usual for it to be performed from memory as a result of being ‘choreographed’ in rehearsal. You’ll find it here: Meredith – Hands Free
Day 370: Tuggemo (Time: 6 minutes)and ‘Octet’ (6 minutes)
For today (11/4/23), I want to highlight the music of the composer whose work is the sole focus of the concert to be given in two days from now under the auspices of Music in the Round here in Sheffield – in the hallowed precincts of the Leadmill, to be precise. (A little known fact: I played at the very first concert ever to be given at the Leadmill, way back when it was still being fitted out, so before the official opening. Don’t get too starry eyed, though. The band I played in then was about third from bottom out of a line-up of a dozen or so, so it didn’t turn out to be our first step en route to stardom. Obviously.) Anyway, I suspect today’s choice might prove to be a tiny bit divisive, if only because the composer in question straddles the worlds of ‘classical music’, pop/electronica/dance music, film soundtracks (you may have heard her work while watching ‘The Favourite’, the 2018 film with Olivia Coleman and Rachel Weisz) and music for installations. She is Anna Meredith, and today’s choice takes us back to the beginning of time. Not, that is, to whatever your version of what happened ‘in the beginning’ might be, but the beginning of time as regards this playlist, because Day 1, on 23/3/20, consisted of a piece called ‘Hands Free’ by this very composer – and so here we are again. (Actually, accuracy compels me to point out that the original ‘Day 1’ music was another piece by Anna Meredith, but as it was taken down from YouTube almost instantly, I replaced it with ‘Hands Free’.) There’s quite a lot of interesting stuff about Anna Meredith on the interweb, but if you’re entirely new to her work there’s an illuminating 10-minute Q&A video on YouTube with Radio 3’s Kate Molleson, which you’ll find here. There can’t be many people whose work has been played on Radios 1, 2, 3, 4 and 6 Music! She seems to me to be an essentially intuitive composer, one who sees the process of creation as being both practical and physical. If your memories go back to the First Night of the BBC Proms in 2018, you might recall her piece ‘Five Telegrams’ being premiered there. If you go back even further to 2008, her piece ‘froms’ was heard at the Last Night of the Proms. I first came across her work even before that, hearing a recording of ‘Axeman’ from 2004, a piece for solo bassoon, which is electronically distorted to sound like an electric guitar! Thursday’s concert is the launch event for a CD/download of an album of music by Anna Meredith for string quartet called ‘Nuc’ – both actual string quartets and pieces of her music arranged by the Ligeti Quartet for that medium. That being the case, I thought a piece of her music for string quartet might go down well. Interestingly (and this might give you some idea of the sort of world we’re in with today’s selection) the track ‘Tuggemo’ is billed as ‘the first single’ from the album – not the sort of line I regularly type when composing these playlist notes. The piece was written in 2017 for string quartet and electronics, and it’s characteristic of a sort of relentless rhythmic drive that you’ll find in a lot of Meredith’s music. Meredith’s own programme note for the piece reads as follows: ‘tuggemo is a (sadly obsolete) old English word for a swarm of birds or flies. This piece is all about swoops of direction and energy.’ You might also like to know that the piece is about to be performed by the Los Angeles Chamber Orchestra this month, where it’s described as ‘concluding the program with an epic electronica groove-scape between the string quartet and composed electronics.’ On the grounds that most people on this list prefer video to audio recordings, I’ve chosen a performance by the Solem Quartet, which you’ll find here: Meredith: Tuggemo. The other work I thought you all might find interesting (or at least, some of you might!) is her Octet, which dates from 2010. This uses precisely the same scoring as Stravinsky’s Octet (see Day 135), and is in many ways a ‘response’ to it (it was commissioned to stand alongside the Stravinsky piece in concert), but where Stravinsky’s work fits the ‘neo-classical’ parameters of that phase in his output, Meredith’s work is maybe better understood as ‘post-minimalist’. It takes some points from Stravinsky’s composition (notably its opening and closing gestures) and uses them as stepping-off points for her own creation. You’ll find a performance of it given by the ensemble Sinfonia Viva, directed by André de Ridder, here: Meredith: Octet
Messiaen, Olivier (1908-92)
Day 47: ‘Louange à l’Eternité de Jésus’ (from ‘Quatuor pour la Fin du Temps’) (Time: 11 minutes)
Today (8/5/20), I thought it might be time for a bit of ‘stretch and challenge’ again,
my present of Conlon Nancarrow having gone down so, erm, well last week.
So, today we have a movement from one of the twentieth century’s
most powerful masterpieces in the chamber music repertoire, the
‘Quatuor pour la Fin du Temps’ (Quartet for the End of Time) by Olivier Messiaen.
Messiaen’s sound world is, in general, a fairly challenging one
(though absolutely one worth getting to know … and love!).
Messiaen (1908-92) was a composer, organist and also an obsessive ornithologist.
(Twitchers should check out his thirteen movement set of piano pieces,
‘Catalogue d’Oiseaux’, for evidence of how obsessively detailed Messiaen was in
his attempts to notate birdsong.) There are many other influences on his music –
the influence of Balinese music for the gamelan, and a very mathematical version of
the patterning not just of notes/melodies, but of harmonies, textures, etc.
Above all, though, the key to Messiaen’s music is his absolute and intense Christian faith.
The ‘Quatuor pour la Fin du Temps’ had one of the most legendary of premieres,
in the prison camp Stalag VIII-A in what is now south-west Poland.
Messiaen, a medical orderly in the French Army at the start of the war,
had been captured in 1940.
In the camp, he met three other musicians, and with the help of a sympathetic guard,
he was able to source a clarinet, a violin and a cello to go with a battered old upright piano.
The premiere of ‘Quartet for the End of Time’ took place, apparently, in pouring rain, outdoors, in January 1941.
It must have bemused the audience of prisoners and guards.
Its 50-minute span includes movements for all four instruments together,
a movement for solo clarinet, and two movements for a solo string instrument accompanied by piano.
These two movements, ‘Louange à l’éternité de Jésus’ (Praise to the Eternity of Jesus)
for cello and piano, and ‘Louange à l’immortalité de Jésus’ (Praise to the Immortality of Jesus)
for violin and piano are, for me, two of the most amazing pieces of composition that I know,
in which there is a real sense that time has stopped.
(I don’t mean that in the sense of ‘drifting off’ while the music plays
– my wife has perfected that skill at concerts regardless of the repertoire!
No, what I mean is that when listening to this, one feels the sense of being outside of time.)
The movement I’ve chosen is the cello and piano duet, about which Messiaen wrote:
‘Jesus is considered here as the Word. A broad phrase, "infinitely slow",
on the cello, magnifies with love and reverence the eternity of the Word,
powerful and gentle, "whose time never runs out".
The melody stretches majestically into a kind of gentle, regal
distance. "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and
the Word was God." (John 1:1)’ You’ll find it in a performance by
the cellist Richard vonFoerster and pianist Heidi Leithwood here: Olivier Messiaen – ‘Louange
à l’éternité de Jesus’ (from ‘Quatuor pour la Fin du Temps’)
(I realise that’s a rather longer introduction to a piece of music than even I
usually end up writing. Sorry… but I really hope you do enjoy this
extraordinary music, and that it might make you want to explore – be brave!
– the rest of the ‘Quartet for the End of Time’. And, so that you get at
least one other aspect of Messiaen’s sound world, before this list winds to an
end, I’m definitely going to pencil in a movement from his splendid and utterly
bonkers ‘Turangalila’ Symphony! Still, that’s for another day…)
Day 100: Turangalila Symphony (5th movement) (Time: 7 minutes) and (10th movement) (8 minutes)
My 100th and final choice (for this version of the list) harks back to Day 47, when I wrote a programme note about Olivier Messiaen’s ‘Quartet for the End of Time’, which ended: “I realise that’s a rather longer introduction to a piece of music than even I usually end up writing. Sorry… but I really hope you do enjoy this extraordinary music, and that it might make you want to explore the rest of the ‘Quartet for the End of Time’. And, so that you get at least one other aspect of Messiaen’s sound world, before this list winds to an end, I’m definitely going to pencil in a movement from his splendid and utterly bonkers ‘Turangalila’ Symphony! Still, that’s for another day…” And here we are – ‘another day’ (30/6/20) has arrived! Messiaen (1908-92), you may recall, was a remarkable 20th century composer, whose work is built on some very unshakeable foundations: birdsong, mathematical patterns and a deep, immovable Christian faith. Messaien wrote the ‘Turangalila Symphony’ in the late 1940s, and its first performance was conducted by the ubiquitous Leonard Bernstein. It’s an extraordinary ten-movement work lasting well over an hour, scored for a huge orchestra, a phenomenally difficult piano part and a starring role for one of Messiaen’s favourite instruments, the ondes martenot (a very early electronic keyboard, but with a mechanism that also allowed the player to make swooping, sliding notes, like a theremin). Much like ‘Tristan and Isolde’, which has featured now and then on this list, the Turangalila Symphony is preoccupied with love and death, but when asked what it ‘meant’, Messiaen’s reply was simple: ‘It’s a love song.’ I’ve chosen movements 5 and 10 for us to listen to. The fifth movement is called ‘Joie du sang des étoiles’ (‘Joy of the Blood of the Stars’), and Messiaen conceived it as a kind of cosmic dance in which two lovers are united. The final movement is called ‘Final’ (unsurprisingly!), but Messiaen directs it to be played ‘avec une grande joie’. As Messiaen said, of the final emphatic F# chord, ‘glory and joy are without end’. As for performances, I’ve found two different recordings of the National Youth Orchestra of Great Britain, from the BBC Proms in 2001 and 2012. (I was going to take them both from the 2012 performance, but in that version the 5th movement feels a bit flat-footed and slow.) So, here is Turangalila Symphony Movement 5 played by the NYOGB (class of 2001) conducted by Andrew Davis, and with the piano part played by Pierre-Laurent Aimard: Messiaen – Turangalila Symphony (5th movement) and here is Turangalila Symphony Movement 10 played by the NYOGB (class of 2012) conducted by Vasily Petrenko, and with the piano part played by Joanne MacGregor: Turangalila Symphony (10th movement) In both performances, the ondes martenot is played (there aren’t that many world-class ondes players to choose from!) by Cynthia Millar.
Milhaud, Darius (1892-1974)
Day 197: La Création du Monde (Time: 17 minutes)
Darius Milhaud (1892-1974) is probably most famous today as a member of ‘Les Six’, the iconoclastic group of (at the time) relatively young composers of the 1920s/30s who were keen to overturn what they saw as the rather stuffy conventions of the French musical tastes of the era, and to usher in the brash fashions of ‘modernity’. (Poulenc and Honegger are the other two members of the group whose music has survived the test of time; we hear rather less these days of Auric, Durey and Tailleferre.) Milhaud was an immensely prolific composer, a fact which has sometimes seemed to count against him. Rather like, say, Villa-Lobos, Milhaud is seen to lack the appropriate ‘quality control’ to distinguish better compositions from the more routine in his output. (I suspect this is the fate of prolific composers of all eras – you get the same criticism levelled at Telemann and Vivaldi, for instance.) I have a vivid memory of seeing a documentary about Milhaud many years ago, following him about in the last years of his life. By then confined to a wheelchair, he was being pushed through a busy French market, surrounded by shoppers haggling over fruit and veg – and all the while, in his lap, was a music manuscript, on which he continued, undistracted, to compose. In his early years, there were two complementary influences on Milhaud’s musical development. In his mid-twenties he served as secretary to the poet and critic Paul Claudel, who was at the time the French ambassador to Brazil, and consequently Brazilian music had a formative impact on Milhaud – you’ll find it in ballets like ‘Le Boeuf sur le Toit’, for instance. The other main force acting on his musical imagination was his revelatory discovery of jazz, which he heard for the first time in London in 1920, attending the Hammersmith Palais to hear Billy Arnold’s Jazz Orchestra from New York. Two years later he visited Harlem and heard New Orleans jazz for the first time. His reaction was visceral: ‘The music I heard was absolutely different from anything I had ever heard before and was a revelation to me… A Negress whose grating voice seemed to come from the depths of centuries sang … authentic music which had its roots in the darkest corners of the Negro soul, the vestigial traces of Africa.’ Consequently, Milhaud returned to France determined to use jazz for a chamber work, and the piece which is the subject of the posting for today (15/6/21), ‘La Création du Monde’, was the result. This ballet was a treatment of a creation myth, and the staging, choreography and Milhaud’s music exploit the then fashionable Eurocentric view of African ‘primitivism’ in art. It was one of the first serious attempts to blend jazz and the more conventional world of ‘art music’, and is, I would suggest, Milhaud’s masterpiece. It’s worth saying that alongside jazz and blues, you can hear (especially at the outset) Milhaud’s respect for Bach, and also the music of Milhaud’s native Provence. As for a performance, today you have a multi-media extravaganza, in that you get to see a danced performance of the work, accompanied by soloists from the Orchestre des Pays de Savoie, conducted by Nicolas Chalvin. The dancers are Jan Spotak and Maria Chiara Mezzadri. Note that you’ll be almost two minutes into the video before the performance starts – there are lots of ‘atmospheric’ shots of the environs of Evian, where the music festival was held, at the start, but be patient (or scroll forward!). You’ll find the performance here: Milhaud - La Création du Monde
Day 198: Concerto for Marimba, Vibraphone and Orchestra (Time: 21 minutes)
In an email to me about the piece for today (18/6/21), Malcolm recalls watching the recent BBC Young Musician finals (won, as many of you may remember, by the extraordinary young Chinese percussionist Fang Zhang), and how that sent him back on the trail of other percussion concertos, including ‘Darius Milhaud's Concerto for Marimba and Vibraphone, which we heard Evelyn Glennie perform many years ago’. The Concerto for Marimba, Vibraphone and Orchestra, Op 278 dates from the late 1940s, a period in Milhaud’s life when he found a greater stability than had been the case during the war, when his Jewish identity obliged Milhaud and his family to emigrate to the USA. After the war, he split his time between teaching in the USA, in California, and teaching at the Paris Conservatoire. When he wrote the Concerto for Marimba and Vibraphone he had already written a previous percussion concerto (in the late 1920s), but this later piece continues to reveal the influence of jazz on Milhaud’s creative imagination that we heard so vividly in ‘La Creation du Monde’ in the previous posting. After all, both solo instruments are much more likely to be found in a jazz ensemble than in the conventional orchestra, especially when given a prominent role. Milhaud’s concerto reveals a great interest in tone colours and timbres, particularly in the contrast between the sound of the marimba (essentially a form of xylophone, with its origins in South America, in which resonators - originally gourds but subsequently aluminium and now, I believe, PVC - hang below the wooden bars that are struck with mallets, thus amplifying the sound) and the vibraphone (in which, in simple terms, the metal bars which are struck with mallets are situated over resonating tubes, but the sound is influenced by rotating metal discs between each bar and its associated tube, thus allowing for vibrato effects … hence the name). Milhaud’s concerto was repurposed in 1952 as the Suite Concertante for Piano and Orchestra, Op 278b, but in its original form it’s a light and breezy work in three movements. The two outer movements are animated and lively, with a playfully jazzy feel, while the central slow movement has a dreamy, nocturnal quality. As one might expect, there are not many versions of this work to choose from on YouTube, especially if one wants a video performance. Consequently I’ve chosen this recording by the Symphonieorchester der Robert-Schumann-Hochschule, Dusseldorf (the student orchestra of the university in that city), conducted by Bernhard Moncado. The percussion soloist is Roland Härdtner. Unfortunately, the recording is only accessible, as far as I know, in three separate instalments, which you’ll find here: Milhaud: Concerto for Marimba, Vibraphone and Orchestra - 1. Animé, 2. Lent and 3. Vif
Day 489: Le Boeuf sur le Toit (Time: 18 minutes)
Today (14/6/24), I want to mark the imminent 50th anniversary of the death of the immensely prolific French composer, Darius Milhaud. The anniversary itself falls on June 22nd, a week tomorrow. We’ve had just two appearances by Milhaud (1892-1974) on this list so far: see Day 197 for what is probably his masterpiece, the ballet ‘La Création du Monde’, and Day 198 for his Concerto for Marimba, Vibraphone and Orchestra, courtesy of a suggestion from St Tim’s former priest-in-charge, Malcolm Lambert. In my postings about those works I referred to one of the formative experiences of the young Milhaud’s life, the time spent in Brazil from 1917-19, when he was secretary to the then French ambassador to the country. Milhaud later wrote a vividly entertaining autobiography, ‘Notes without Music’, in which he described strikingly the sights, sounds and smells of Rio de Janeiro. He returned to Paris in 1919, and almost immediately set about writing music that evoked the flavour of his South American experiences. There’s a set of popular dance tunes, ‘Saudades do Brasil’, and a ballet score, ‘L’Homme et son Désir’. However, nowadays far more famous than either of these is a short orchestral piece that he wrote under the title, ‘Le Bœuf sur le toit’ (which translates as ‘The ox on the roof’). In his autobiography, Milhaud tells the reader, ‘I assembled a few popular melodies, tangos, maxixes, sambas, even a Portuguese fado, and transcribed them with a rondo-like theme recurring between each two. I called this fantasia “Le Boeuf sur le Toit”, the title of a Brazilian popular song. I thought the character of the piece might make it suitable to accompany a Charlie Chaplin film.’ Two things are worth noting here: one is the fact that many of the melodies of this work are ‘borrowings’ (though the recurring linking theme is Milhaud’s own) – allegedly over 20 pieces of music are quoted in passing; a second curiosity is that Milhaud didn’t write the score for anything specific, no particular Charlie Chaplin film, suggesting that what he was after was a creation of a mood, an atmosphere. However, the irrepressible Jean Cocteau took an interest in the music, and produced a pantomime-style ballet with a bizarre narrative as a visual correlative of the music. As the musicologist James Harding noted, the action of the ballet is ‘pleasantly devoid of all meaning’. The setting is a bar in America during the prohibition era. There are stylised characters – a boxer, a Negro dwarf, a jockey, a lady of fashion, a billiard player, a red-headed woman dressed as a man, a bookmaker, a gentleman in evening dress, a bartender and, later, a policeman – all wearing cardboard heads at least twice life size. The barman offers everyone cocktails and then an array of weird things happens: the boxer struggles to light his cigar so the barman cuts the end off it with a pistol shot, in the process killing the billiard player. Meanwhile the jockey objects to the way the boxer is chatting up the red-haired woman and knocks him over, and then dances a tango. A policeman enters and the setting is immediately transformed into a milk bar, and as the policeman goes round smelling everyone’s breath, the barman operates a ceiling fan which descends and decapitates the policeman. The red-headed woman dances with the severed head (a deliberate parody of Salome and the head of John the Baptist), before eventually all the customers drift away. The policeman is reunited with his head, and is presented by the barman with a massive bill for all the drinks everyone has consumed. (I have the sense that in the creation of this work one or more people must have been doing drugs somewhere along the line…) The first performance, you may not be surprised to note, went down badly, largely because music critics objected to ‘popular’ music being interwoven into a supposedly ‘serious’ musical context. More fool them. As Milhaud said, this ‘merry, unpretentious divertissement’ is full of sexy rhythms, fun tunes and witty instrumental effects – and the sort of subversive musicality (at the start the strings are playing in C major, the flute in Eb major and the clarinet in F# major – deliberate and disorientating anarchy) that is entirely characteristic of Milhaud. As for a performance, YouTube is really quite well stocked with decent ones. Out of the choices available, I’ve gone for this brisk and lively performance at the hands of L’Orchestre de Paris, conducted by Alondra de la Parra. You’ll find it here: Milhaud: Le Boeuf sur le Toit
Moeran, Ernest (1894-1950)
Day 566: Symphony in G Minor (Time: 46 minutes)
Today (28/11/25), yet another new name appears on this list. As you’ll know, if you’ve spent a reasonable amount of time with the composers and works I’ve featured over the years, British music of the early-to-mid 20th century – that is, the generations after Elgar, Stanford and Parry – has been a fertile source of material. There has been music by Holst, Vaughan Williams, Britten, Walton, Delius, Coleridge-Taylor, Finzi, Clarke, Tippett, Arnold, Howells, Bax, Carwithen, Brian, Bell, Hadley, Butterworth and Bliss. In fact, although I’m entirely prepared to believe there are people I’ve overlooked (like Alywn, Rubbra or Lloyd, for instance), the only two stand-out names that are missing from that list seem to me to be John Ireland – and here I want to acknowledge that I’ve had a polite request for music by Ireland from once-of-this-parish Malcolm Lambert (one day, Malcolm, one day) – and EJ Moeran (1894-1950). Conveniently, given that this coming Monday marks the 75th anniversary of Moeran’s death, there is an opportunity to right that latter wrong right now. Ernest John Smeed Moeran, to give him his full set of names (though apparently he was universally known as ‘Jack’) was not a very prolific composer. Well, perhaps it would be fairer to say that he had prolific periods of creativity in his life, but also substantial fallow stretches, when (depending on whose views you might read) various of life’s complexities got in the way. Before the First World War he was part of that remarkable group of composers (Vaughan Williams, Holst, Howells, Butterworth, Ireland) who seemed to signal a new renaissance in English (perhaps more properly ‘British’) music – composers influenced by the melodies and harmonies of the folk songs of these islands as much as by more mainstream developments in continental Europe. Moeran went to the Royal College of Music in 1913, as one of Stanford’s many composition pupils, but in 1914, at the age of 19, he enlisted to fight. In 1917, during ongoing fighting around Arras, he was wounded in the head – and this incident in many ways coloured the whole of the rest of Moeran’s life. Some reports suggest that he needed emergency life-saving surgery, that he had a metal plate inserted in his skull, and that shrapnel was embedded too close to his brain for it to be removed – and that a consequence of this was that it gave the impression that he was drunk, even when he wasn’t. (Other accounts suggest the injury was less severe, pointing out that he gave a piano recital in London later in 1917, implying that the outcome couldn’t have been too problematical.) Whatever the truth of this, it points us towards another ambiguity in Moeran’s story: the extent to which he was a functioning (and sometimes non-functioning) alcoholic. In fact, the years from 1918-25 seem to have been exceptionally productive, and there’s a string of works from those years, mostly enriched by Moeran’s time spent collecting English (and especially East Anglian) folk songs. There are orchestral works (the symphonic poem ‘In the Mountain Country’ and two orchestral Rhapsodies) the song cycle ‘Ludlow Town’ (the influence of Houseman’s poetry was strong for Moeran as for all the rest of that generation), and some lovely chamber music and pastorally-influenced piano works. However, things went pear-shaped from 1926 onwards, when he began to share a house with Peter Warlock (pen name of the composer Philip Heseltine), whose industrial levels of consumption of alcohol and other attributes of wild living led to Moeran having a complete creative collapse, and he wrote almost nothing until the early 1930s when he returned to the parental home or stayed with friends. But for the final two decades of his life much of his time was spent in south-west Ireland (his father was Irish), and as was the case for Bax the pull of the ‘Celtic twilight’ (the poetry of Yeats, the landscape and the folk music of Ireland) was strong. The years 1930-50 were thus intermittently productive, but also intermittently desolate, when the lure of his alcoholism became too inescapable. He married somewhat abruptly in 1945, to the cellist Kathleen Piers Coetmore, but the demands of her career and Moeran’s ongoing drinking meant the relationship was only brief. He died in 1950, initially it was thought from drowning (and thus possibly suicidally) but a post mortem revealed he’d had a cerebral haemorrhage. I wondered what to choose to illustrate the music of this somewhat conservative but (I think) always distinctive composer. There are major late works – both a Violin Concerto and a Cello Concerto, along with a lovely Sinfonietta from the 1940s, and both a String Quartet in Eb and a Cello Sonata, but in the end (and recognising it’ll break this playlist’s official ’40-minute rule’) I’ve gone for his undisputed masterpiece, his sole completed Symphony in G Minor. (He had been working for years at his death on another symphony, which now exists as a reconstructed work and has been recorded.) The G Minor Symphony was actually commissioned as far back as 1926 by Hamilton Harty (then chief conductor of the Halle), but – blame Warlock, or the war wound, or the alcohol – Moeran struggled with it until the mid-1930s. It was finally completed in 1937, first performed in 1938, and it’s one of those strikingly tempestuous symphonies by British composers in that decade, like Vaughan Williams’ 4th or Walton’s 1st. The influence of Sibelius on it is very striking, but despite all the Sibelian echoes it’s also imbued with a deep sense of both English and Irish landscape, and Moeran’s own uniquely dark sensibility. The first movement, after its assertive opening, has often been compared to the restless power of the sea, or to the relentless drive of an uphill locomotive (not both at the same time, of course). The slow movement is full of East Anglian folk sensibility, even if it does not quote any actual folk songs – it was, he wrote, ‘conceived around the sand dunes and marshes of East Norfolk’ – but Sibelius’s thumbprint is evident here too, in the woodwind writing in particular. There’s even more Sibelius in the third movement Vivace (especially evident if you know Sibelius’s 3rd or 4th Symphonies), but, as Moeran wrote, here ‘the sunlight is let in, and there is a spring-like contrast to the wintry proceedings of the slow movement.’ However, there is no happy ending here: the final movement is brooding and tragic. There’s exploitation of folk-like rhythms – something a little like a jig – but the middle of the movement is full of strife and the ending, when it comes, feels dark. More Sibelius: if you know his late symphonic poem ‘Tapiola’, you’ll know the sound world Moeran is evoking. Now, this symphony typically comes in at around the 45-minute mark, but although this isn’t the first time I’ve broken my 40-minute rule, I think it’s worth it on this occasion for you to hear the whole thing. However, another issue is that as far as I can tell, there is only one video recording on YouTube from a professional orchestra. I think there are better performances than this out there, but if you want to see this being performed (at least, if you want to see bits of it – the very limited camerawork often doesn’t actually show you the key performers at any given time) you’ll end up with this link to a concert performance by the RTE Symphony Orchestra of Ireland, conducted (in a very sparsely attended hall) by Timothy Henty, after a long delay at the start of the clip. You’ll find it here: Moeran: Symphony in G Minor
Monteverdi, Claudio (1567-1643)
Day 497: Zefiro Torna (Time: 7 minutes)
In an email to me, playlist member Julian Fisher enthuses about the music of Monteverdi, and particularly the composition you’ll get a link to at the end of this message. I find it mildly shocking that I’ve got close to 500 entries on this list without yet featuring any Monteverdi, so Julian’s suggestion for today (12/7/24) will help remedy that state of affairs forthwith. Claudio Monteverdi (1567-1643) is, these days, regarded as one of the major figures in European musical history, and in particular as the outstanding composer at a time when so-called ‘Renaissance’ music (think about people we’ve had on this list already, like Byrd, Lassus, or Palestrina) was giving way to so-called ‘Baroque’ music (examples on this list include Bach, Telemann or Vivaldi). However, from time to time, I’ve featured composers who are, if you like, liminal in these terms – neither Renaissance nor Baroque, or perhaps both Renaissance and Baroque – such as Gabrieli or Schutz. And to that final list, I can now add Monteverdi. Some of his early works – the first two books of Madrigals, for instance – feel like Elizabethan or Italian Renaissance madrigals. But his later work, especially the material written in the last 25 years or so of his life, seems to point the way to a different sound world, one in which one tends to listen not so much to the rich tapestry of complex interweaving lines but rather more to the expressive contrast and interplay of fewer lines but underpinned by something more stable and regular. (If all that feels a bit waffly, the musical example at the end of all this should help to show what I mean.) Anyway, Monteverdi was born and had his earliest employment in the Lombardy region of northern Italy. But it’s his time in Venice (the last 30 years of his life) that made his name. As for many other composers of this period, what we know of his music today is only a small fraction of what he wrote – there is a lot that gets performed, but references to other work that has subsequently been lost far outweigh what we hear. He was appointed ‘maestro’ of St Mark’s, Venice in 1613, though before then, he’d already composed many works that we now hear often – the Vespers of 1610, for example. It’s also the case that we tend nowadays to associate Monteverdi with the pioneering development of opera as a musical art form – a genre that itself reveals the shift from ‘Renaissance’ to ‘Baroque’ sensibilities, with its interest in individual characters shaped by plot developments. He wasn’t the first opera composer (that seems to have been one Jacopo Peri, who wrote ‘Dafne’ – subsequently lost – in 1598, and ‘Euridice’, the earliest surviving opera, in 1600), but he’s certainly the composer of the first opera to now hold a regular place in the repertoire – his ‘L’Orfeo’, from 1607. In fact, historical records suggest that Monteverdi may have written about 18 operas in his lifetime, though only three (the other two are ‘The Return of Ulysses’ and ‘The Coronation of Poppea’) survive. These last two works date from the final few years of Monteverdi’s life, which shows that, like the later example of Verdi, he remained vividly creative in this field to a ripe old age. One of the interesting things about Monteverdi is the fact that he’s one of those composers who fell out of fashion only a few years after his death, and ‘disappeared’ from the story of musical history for at least 200 years. Only in the later 1800s was he ‘discovered’ again, and really only in the past 60 years or so has his work become appreciated for its ground-breaking place in the story arc of Western music once more. The piece that Julian is keen that we should listen to first appeared in 1632 in a publication called ‘Scherzi Musicali’, a collection of seven songs for one or two voices with instrumental accompaniment. The seventh and last of them is called ‘Zefiro torna e di soavi accenti’ (which is the opening line of the text, and which roughly translates as ‘Zephyr returns, and with sweet accents…’). The work reappeared after Monteverdi’s death as the final composition in his posthumously-published Ninth Book of Madrigals (1651), and the fact that it had this notable last place in the final footnote to his compositions suggests the extent to which it was both popular and valued at the time. A ‘zephyr’, for those who might not know, was a mild, kindly west wind, named after Zephyrus, Greek god of the west wind. Its appearance – or perhaps one might say its reappearance – tended to signal the arrival of spring, with all the flourishing of natural and human ‘reawakening’ associated with it. The text is a sonnet by the Italian Ottavio Rinuccini (who wrote the librettos for the operas by Peri I mentioned earlier, and also for at least one of Monteverdi’s lost operas, ‘Arianna’). As you might expect, it’s about the arrival of spring … but also the arrival of love and desire, and equally predictably of love and desire thwarted and unrequited. ‘Twas ever thus! What makes this work so much of an ‘earworm’ is the fact that it’s a chaconne – a form in which a repeated cyclic bass line and chord pattern underpin the whole, over which the singers intertwine and play off each other like, if it’s not too incongruous an analogy, riffing jazz musicians. YouTube has many examples of performances. Julian enthuses about getting to know the work from an old 1960s LP recording with Raymond Leppard on harpsichord. Fashions change, of course, and the ‘period instrument’ revival of the past half century has done lots to bring out conventions of performance practices of the 1600s. But both Julian and I have a love for the ‘early music’ group L’Arpeggiata, directed by the Austrian musicologist and performer Christina Pluhar. I put ‘early music’ in inverted commas there because in the past 25 years this ensemble has evolved from performing, if you like, in a narrowly ‘authentic’ style into something more free-wheeling, with more than a little influence of folk and jazz traditions. In this video performance from a live concert, L’Arpeggiata perform Monteverdi with two vocal soloists who’ve regularly appeared with them over the years, French counter-tenor Philippe Jaroussky and the Catalan soprano Nuria Real. You’ll find it here: Monteverdi: Zefiro Torna
Morricone, Ennio (1928-2020)
Day 111: Cinema Paradiso (original soundtrack extract) (Time: 10 minutes)
This week is Film Music Week, courtesy of choices made by Claire and by me. And this is film music in the sense of ‘originally composed for film’ – so no Wagner via ‘Apocalypse Now’, and even no Mozart via ‘Amadeus’. What we want to do this week is to show a tiny bit of the range of music that has made its way from original soundtracks and into the concert hall. Claire’s choice first: she has suggested that today (18/8/20) we listen to some of the music Ennio Morricone composed for the moving film ‘Cinema Paradiso’. Morricone (1928-2020), who died just over a month ago, was an extraordinarily prolific composer. Wikipedia tells me that he scored over 400 films and television series, not to mention writing ‘serious’ classical pieces for the concert hall, from early works in the 1950s through to a long period in the 1960s and 70s as a core member of the avant-garde ‘Gruppo di Improvvisazione Nuova Consonanza’ (a kind of amalgam of free jazz and experimental classical music). For me personally, Morricone’s strongest association as a film composer is with the ‘spaghetti western’ tradition, notably ‘The Good, the Bad and the Ugly’, but he worked with many film directors and scored the music for films as diverse as ‘The Mission’, ‘The Exorcist II’ and ‘The Hateful Eight’. And did you know that he scored the official theme tune for the 1978 World Cup? (Me neither.) And that he co-wrote music with the Pet Shop Boys, k.d. lang and Sting (not all at once, of course!). Claire has a particular liking for the film ‘Cinema Paradiso’, which appeared in 1988, directed by Giuseppe Tornatore. A story of the power of both memory and cinema, the film has rapidly acquired classic status, particularly but not only for the ‘kissing sequence’ with which the film closes, the projectionist Alfredo’s last gift to his protégé Salvatore. In this sequence from the original soundtrack to the film, Morricone himself conducts, though I haven’t been able to identify the musicians involved. You’ll find it here: Morricone: Cinema Paradiso (original soundtrack extract)
Mouton, Jean (c1459-1522)
Day 144: Nesciens Mater (Time: 5 minutes)
Today (11/12/20), I want to introduce a composer who may be new to many of you,
and to be fair it’s only in the past year that I’ve got to know some of his works for myself. He’s the late 15th/early 16th century French composer Jean Mouton.
Mouton (c1459-1522) was born near Boulogne in the north of France,
but very little is known about his early life.
What is clear is that by the early 1500s he had in effect assumed
the role of principal composer to the French court, and in the first two
decades of the 16th century, he produced a significant number of
works for state occasions. There is some evidence that he might have been
in charge of the musical celebrations that accompanied the ‘Field of Cloth of
Gold’ festivities, what we’d now call an international summit meeting between
Henry VIII of England and Francis I of France. If I were to compare
Mouton to anyone, in terms of his musical style, it would probably be Josquin –
they both tended to use the sorts of imitative and patterned techniques that
we’ll see in today’s piece. However, I think there’s a real sense in
which we can see something much more ‘modern’ going on in Mouton’s music, in
that rather than hearing musical lines moving almost independently of each
other in a basically linear way, as it the case in 15th century
music, there’s a greater sense in Mouton of listening to changing harmonies and
chord progressions. Quite a lot of Mouton’s music has survived, probably
because of the fact that he held official positions at court, and out of this
array of riches, the piece I’ve chosen to focus on today is his motet (Ladybird
Book of Musical Terms definition: an all-purpose label for pretty much any kind
of short vocal/choral composition) ‘Nesciens Mater’. The text seems to
have its obscure origin in the 13th century. This was the era
in which the medieval concept of courtly love was at its most inventive, and
which found secular expression in texts about knights going on quests in the
devoted service of inaccessible idealised women, and sacred expression in the
fashionable adoration of the Virgin Mary. A rough paraphrase of the text
of ‘Nesciens Mater’ reads: ‘Not knowing a man, the Virgin Mary has brought
forth without pain the Saviour of the centuries, Him, the King of the
angels. The only Virgin gave milk, her breasts full by heavenly
act’. Whatever one makes of this idealisation, it is undoubtedly the case
that composers of the time found Marian texts fruitful sources for some quite
inspired music. It seems to me that there are two basic approaches to
listening to compositions like Mouton’s ‘Nesciens Mater’. One is what one
might call the ‘warm bath’ approach – this is music to relax into, to let it to
seep into you, turning the brain off and allowing it access to your inner
being. On the other hand, often it’s interesting to know about
compositional practice, to see and hear the composer’s technique.
‘Nesciens Mater’ doesn’t just sound beautiful; it’s complex and patterned in a
really interesting way. For those who can read music, try looking at the
score as you listen to this recording by Ensemble Jacques Moderne, directed by
Joel Suhubiette, which you’ll find here: Mouton: Nesciens Mater.
You’ll see that the piece is for eight vocal parts, split into two groups of
four, and that the second group of four sing exactly what the first group have
sung, but two bars behind them and a fifth higher (so Tenor 2 starts his part
on C, and two bars later ‘Mean 1’ (Soprano 1) sings the same thing starting on
G … and so on). Even if you can’t read music, you will probably be able
to see how the top four lines of music copy the bottom four lines of music two
bars after them. So, this is ‘clever’ music, for the brain and the
intellect – but never at the expense of beauty. It seems to me to be one
of the absolute gems of Renaissance composition. In terms of what to listen
to, I don’t want to recommend the Ensemble Jacques Moderne version (above)
because it is incredibly fast-paced, which seems to me to lose some of the
serenity of the piece. On the other hand, the Monteverdi Choir and John
Eliot Gardiner take more than twice as long, a performance that for me is so
slow that you can barely hear the patterns at all. So, my ideal recording
is this one from the Tallis Scholars, directed by Peter Phillips, which you’ll
find here: Mouton:
Nesciens Mater. I hope it brings you joy and peace.
Mozart, Wolfgang Amadeus (1756-91)
Day 28: Piano Concerto No 20 (2nd movement) (Time: 11 minutes)
Mozart is a composer about whom it’s difficult to say anything without slipping into clichés and stereotypes. He is probably the most naturally and innately gifted creator of music there has ever been. His life is much mythologised, from the punishing ‘childhood prodigy’ phase through to his mysterious death. For most critics, he stands on a par with Bach as the creator of something close to musical ‘perfection’. His greatest contributions to musical history were probably made in the realms of opera and the solo concerto, and today (19/4/20) we have a movement from a piano concerto that, like so much of his work, ‘sings’ from the piano. In the second movement of the Piano Concerto No 20 you will find all Mozart’s hallmarks – clarity, balance and transparency – but also the passion and occasional violence that mark out his greatest work. This concerto was composed in 1785, and first performed with Mozart himself as soloist. The key of the concerto, D Minor, is a portentous one for Mozart (it’s the key of his ‘Requiem’, for instance), but the second movement is in the more tranquil key of Bb – tranquil, that is, until we arrive at the turbulent middle section in G Minor, with its stormy intensity. This is Malcolm’s choice, and he has gone for a historic performance, recorded in 1959, of Sviatoslav Richter, accompanied by the Warsaw National Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by Stanislaw Wislocki. You’ll find it here: Mozart – Piano Concerto No 20 (2nd movement)
Day 50: ‘Sull’aria … che soave zeffiretto’ (from ‘The Marriage of Figaro’) (Time: 3 minutes)
Today (11/5/20), a suggestion from Martin, in a ‘two for the price of one’ sort of way. It’s for the aria ‘Sull’aria … che soave zeffiretto’, from Mozart’s opera ‘The Marriage of Figaro’. Martin’s request is for the performance by Cecilia Bartoli and Renee Fleming, which you’ll find here (rather disconcertingly, given that they’re singing in Italian, the subtitles are in Spanish!): Mozart – ‘Sull’aria…’ (from ‘The Marriage of Figaro’) It is, as Martin says, ‘balm for the soul’. And then, as a bonus, here is the scene from the 1994 film ‘The Shawshank Redemption’ which features that aria being broadcast on the prison public address system. There are layers of irony here, helpfully summarised on Wikipedia: ‘In the 1994 film, The Shawshank Redemption, prisoner Andy Dufresne defies Warden Sam Norton by playing an excerpt of this song over the prison's public address system. Norton sentences Dufresne to solitary confinement as a result. Ellis Boyd "Red" Redding remarks in his voice-over narration: "I have no idea to this day what those two Italian ladies were singing about. [...] I'd like to think they were singing about something so beautiful it can't be expressed in words, and it makes your heart ache because of it." This is ironic as the opera characters are singing about a duplicitous love letter to expose infidelity, and Dufresne's wife's affair is the event which indirectly leads to his imprisonment.’ A further irony for us of course is, as Martin notes, ‘how apposite it is to lockdown!’. You’ll find the scene in question here: The Shawshank Redemption (Mozart)
Day 66: Clarinet Quintet (1st movement) (Time: 10 minutes)
Today (27/5/20), I thought we’d go for an indisputable gem of the chamber music repertoire, the Clarinet Quintet by Mozart. There’s not a lot I’d want to say about this, other than it seems to me to be close to perfection – grace, elegance, serenity, a kind of (seeming) effortless fluidity of action and interaction between the players. The first great work for the clarinet in a chamber music context, I reckon. Anyway, I realise I’d get told off if I suggested that you listen to the whole work, so (hard task!) I’ve limited myself to the first movement only. (If this floats your boat, it’s easy enough to find the rest!) The performance I’ve chosen is by the Endymion Ensemble and the clarinettist Mark van der Wiel, and you’ll find it here: Mozart – Clarinet Quintet (1st movement)
Day 141: Requiem (Dies Irae; Tuba Mirum; Rex Tremendae; Recordare, Confutatis and Lacrimosa) (Time: 19 minutes)
There is no doubt a sermon to be written (in fact, there’s probably a PhD thesis
to be written) on the church’s changing attitudes to marking the season of Advent,
as they have evolved over the centuries.
Today (1/12/20), the emphasis is essentially on the generation of warm, fuzzy feelings
of anticipation, with the keynote themes being love, joy, peace and hope.
The second coming of Christ, with all its associated significance, is alluded
to, but fundamentally the first coming in Bethlehem is the order of the
day. Go back a couple of hundred years, and things are much more, shall
we say, eschatological. And it is in the light of seeing the Advent
season as being about Heaven, Hell, Purgatory and Judgment that we arrive at
Jenny’s suggestion for today, which is to hear a section from Mozart’s Requiem.
A Requiem, as no doubt we all know, is a special form of the Mass,
in this case for the soul or souls of one or more people who have died –
and more broadly, musical settings of the Requiem Mass are compositions
which address more generalised feelings of mourning and loss.
Although composers over the years have opted to choose which additional sections of
text might be interpolated alongside the conventional liturgical material of the Mass,
one of the most common choices (though not, notably, for Faure in his setting
– except for his use of the ‘Pie Jesu’ stanza) is to set the Dies Irae
‘Sequence’, a probably 13th century text (though almost certainly
with its roots going back beyond that) concerning the day of judgment.
Mozart sets this text between the Kyrie and Offertorium sections. What is also
well-known about the Mozart Requiem, is that he left it unfinished (in fact, in
many sections, barely started) at his death, and it was Mozart’s widow,
Constanze, who asked Mozart’s pupil Sussmayr, to produce a performing version.
Without getting into too much detail, the ‘Sequence’ sequence (Dies Irae, Tuba
Mirum, Rex Tremendae, Recordare, Confutatis and Lacrimosa) was complete in a
skeletal outline, except for the ‘Lacrimosa’ section, which broke off after
only eight bars, so the final two and a half minutes or so of this movement are
Sussmayr’s own work.
This section of Mozart’s Requiem takes us through some turbulent emotional experiences,
from the opening Dies Irae (‘Day of Wrath...’) through the pleading tenderness of the
Recordare (‘Remember, blessed Jesus … do not forsake me’) to the tearful conclusion of the
‘Lacrimosa’. There are relatively few links on YouTube to postings of the
‘Sequence’ in its entirety, and in fact the version I’ve chosen posts the
‘Lacrimosa’ separately from the rest. The performance comes from a
concert to commemorate the 200th anniversary of Mozart’s death; the
performers are the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra and Vienna State Opera Chorus,
with soloists Arleen Auger, Cecilia Bartoli, Vinson Cole and Rene Pape,
conducted by Sir Georg Solti. You’ll find it here: Mozart: Requiem (Dies Irae;
Tuba Mirum; Rex Tremendae; Recordare and Confutatis) and here: Mozart: Requiem (Lacrimosa).
Day 155: Concerto for Flute and Harp (Time: 29 minutes)
Today (19/1/21), a suggestion from Paul, for what is definitely one of Mozart’s strangest creations. Mozart has appeared on this list four times already (see Days 28, 50, 66 and 141), but in each case, the composition was for a mainstream combination of instruments. Today, though, we have a definite ‘one-off’, the Concerto for Flute and Harp, K 299. Discussion of ‘early’ as opposed to ‘mature’ Mozart is rather a fraught thing in a context when the child Mozart had been hawked around European cultural centres from a ridiculously young age by his father. These tours began at the age of six, and by the time he was eight, Mozart had composed his first symphony, eleven by the time of his first piano concerto, and fourteen when he produced his first string quartet. Compositions poured out of him by the dozen, which is why the Flute and Harp Concerto has the catalogue number K299 and yet Mozart was still only 22 at the time. The location is actually quite important in relation to this piece: Mozart resigned from his fraught employment in Salzburg in 1777 and set off on another tour, which included six months in Paris in mid-1778. Culturally, Paris was fashionable and elegant, and these qualities imbued the music of the French capital just as much as its dress sense. Parisian music was, if you like, ‘showy’ and ‘decorative’. Complexity of musical argument was less important than charm and elegance. No instrument embodied these qualities more than the harp, seemingly designed ideally for young ladies to show off their musical talents. The harp was not yet a member of the orchestra; it is also the case that it was not seen, with a very small number of exceptions, as a solo instrument in a concerto. Certainly nobody had ever considered writing a concerto for harp and flute at the same time, and to the best of my knowledge nobody has ever done so again. It was commissioned by the father and daughter duo the de Bonnieres, who seem to have been competent but not brilliant performers. What I find most fascinating about this piece is that Mozart was able to write something attractive using instruments he actively disliked. He wrote nothing else featuring the harp and his comments about it are dismissive. In fact, the music written for the harp here seems to be a simple transcription of a previously composed keyboard part. There is no attempt to play to the harp’s unique features, such as the decorative glissandi which, a century later, would add colour to the ballet music of Tchaikovsky or Delibes. As for the flute, only a couple of months after writing this concerto Mozart wrote to his father, ‘You know that I become quite powerless whenever I am obliged to write for an instrument which I cannot bear.’ Yet although this is clearly not the most profound music Mozart would write, it is very pretty indeed. It has the usual three movement ‘fast-slow-fast’ structure, and the two soloists take turns to lead and accompany. As for a performance, I’ve selected one that, whilst not the best, has a local connection. It’s by the Israel Philharmonic Orchestra under the occasionally soupy direction of Zubin Mehta. The harpist is Julia Rovinsky, but my reason for choosing this recording is that the flautist is Guy Eshed, who was one of the founder members of Ensemble 360 before being whisked off by Daniel Barenboim to play in both the West-Eastern Divan Orchestra and the Berlin Staatskapelle. You’ll find the performance here: Mozart: Concerto for Flute and Harp in C, K 299.
Day 156: Adagio for Glass Harmonica, K 356 (Time: 5 minutes) and Adagio and Rondo for Glass Harmonica and Instrumental Quartet, K 617 (4 minutes)
After the odd combination of flute and harp in the concerto that was the focus of Tuesday’s Mozart posting, today (22/1/21) the oddity is in the musical instrument itself. It is more than possible that at some stage in the past you have amused yourself (and possibly others, if they were tolerant enough) by licking your finger and running it around the rim of a wine glass, producing an eerie resonance that could be raised or lowered in pitch by changing the amount of liquid in the glass. This is the principle behind the glass harmonica, also sometimes known as the glass harp, bowl organ or hydrocrystalophone(!). At this point, enter Benjamin Franklin, who, before he became one of the Founding Fathers of the United States, had several other careers, often simultaneously. He seems to have been scientifically curious, and ceaselessly inventive in terms of putting that scientific curiosity to practical use. One of his inventions is the ‘mechanical’ glass harmonica, in which several glass bowls (the equivalent of the wine glasses) are mounted on a central spindle, and the whole mechanism is then propelled by a foot-operated treadle. It is a curious instrument that acquired a certain popularity – maybe even notoriety – in the 18th century. There was a school of thought that said it drove its performers distracted with melancholy because of its other-worldly sounds. In modern times its haunting tones have led to its use by many artists – prog rock fans may know it from Pink Floyd’s ‘Shine on you Crazy Diamond’ from their ‘Wish You Were Here’ album, whilst Bjork, always a sonic experimenter, used it on her ‘Homogenic’ album. Mozart employed the instrument in two different compositions. First, there is a free-standing Adagio in C, K 356 (also catalogued as K 617a), for a solo glass harmonica. I thought it would be interesting to see and hear this in a performance which uses a modern copy of Franklin’s design. On this YouTube recording it is played by Dennis James, and you can find it here: Mozart: Adagio for Glass Harmonica, K 356. In addition, Mozart wrote an Adagio and Rondo, K 617, for Glass Harmonica, Flute, Oboe, Viola and Cello. In some performances this runs to more than ten minutes, but there is on YouTube a heavily truncated version played by the Glass Duo (on an ‘instrument’ which is closer to the traditional wine glass version) accompanied by Agnieszka Respondek on flute, Jaroslaw Wyrzykowski on oboe, Michal Markowski on viola and Blazej Golinski on cello (and sorry for all the missing diacritics there). You’ll find it here: Mozart: Adagio and Rondo for Glass Harmonica and Instrumental Quartet, K 617.
Day 181: Wind Serenade in C Minor, K 388 (Time: 23 minutes)
Today (20/4/21), I thought I’d consider one work from an 18th century tradition – the composition of pieces variously titled ‘serenade’ or ‘divertimento’ or ‘cassation’ or ‘partita’ or ‘notturno’. What all of these have in common is that 18th century composers used these labels to describe music for ‘entertainment’, often whilst those for whom the works were written were busy doing other things, like eating or meeting visiting dignitaries or holding lavish aristocratic parties. In a sense, the specific titles don’t mean a great deal: a sort of convention developed in which divertimenti were daytime pieces, whilst serenades were played in the evening and notturni at night, but there was a lot of overlap between these different labels. What these works had in common was that they were usually in several movements, some of which were relics of the dance-form pieces we’re seen in Baroque suites in previous postings. If one were being uncharitable, one might describe them as a kind of musical ‘wallpaper’, but, unsurprisingly, better composers found ways to make the music compelling to listen to, rather than merely decorative. They might be written for a conventional-sized orchestra (Mozart’s ‘Haffner’ Serenade, for example) or a string orchestra (Mozart’s ‘Eine Kleine Nachtmusik’ Serenade, say) but a very substantial sub-set of these compositions was written for an ensemble that was extremely popular in particular in the period 1760-1820. This is ‘harmoniemusik’, composed for a wind ensemble (of usually up to eight players), and, in the later 18th century, German and Austrian nobility would often have their own house band or ‘harmonien’. The Austrian Emperor, Joseph II, had a particularly fine wind band at his disposal, drawn from the players at the Imperial Opera, and it was for this crack ensemble that Mozart wrote his Serenade in C Minor, K 388. The scoring was for pairs of oboes, clarinets, bassoons and horns. (Although logically horns are brass instruments, they were seen as part of the ‘wind band’ or the wind section of an orchestra.) Mozart wrote three great wind serenades in his maturity: the so-called ‘Gran Partita’ Serenade for 13 wind instruments, K 361; an Eb Serenade K 375, originally omitting oboes from the conventional scoring; and this four-movement C Minor Serenade, K 388. The critic Roger Hellyer described this last of these pieces as ‘a curiously sombre and powerful work which often conveys a mood of dramatic intensity totally alien to the informal background music normally associated with the serenade type.’ It appears to have been written in around 1782, though later Mozart clearly valued it enough to re-score it for strings (as the String Quintet, K 406), in which guise it sounds equally powerful. C Minor was for Mozart (as for Beethoven) a ‘dramatic’ key, and the piece plays a lot with contrasts of loud unison statements set against gentler, more lyrical passages. The first movement is brooding, almost neurotic, in its intensity, a mood alleviated by the gracious and lyrical second movement. The finale is a ‘theme and variations’ movement which takes us through various moods before ending in a triumphant and relaxed C Major. However, my favourite movement, and one I’d like to home in on, is the third movement Minuet. One might expect this to be the most lightweight part of the piece, minuets being usually simple and graceful dance movements in three-time. The outer ‘Minuet’ sections are in canon: oboes followed by bassoons in strict imitation, one bar behind them. So far, so predictable, if satisfying. However, in the middle ‘Trio’ section of the movement Mozart pulls another trick: this part is ‘in canone al roverscio’ - now the second oboe takes the initial melody, and then two bars later the first oboe plays that theme upside down; two bars later still the first bassoon has the oboe’s theme, and two bars after that the second bassoon has the upside down version. And so it continues. You don’t have to know how artfully it’s put together to find it utterly joyful and compelling – but once you do, it multiplies the pleasure! There are a number of good performances of this piece on YouTube, and from these options, I’ve chosen a video recording by an Australian group, the Omega Ensemble. You’ll find it here: Mozart: Wind Serenade in C Minor, K 388
Day 257: Fantasia in C Minor, K 475 (Time: 12 minutes)
The programme that the young British pianist Mishka Rushdie Momen is playing in Sheffield later this month ranges across five centuries of music, but out of the pieces she’s playing I wanted to focus today (11/1/22) on just one, Mozart’s Fantasia in C Minor, K475. There have been two examples of a fantasia (or fantasy, or phantasy, or fantaisie … and so on) on the playlist thus far (see Day 49 for Schubert’s Fantasie in F Minor for piano four hands, and Day 59 for Vaughan Williams’ ‘Fantasia on a Theme by Thomas Tallis’) so I thought a few words about the ‘fantasy’ as a form might not go amiss first. The clue is in the name, to a large extent: this is a form that puts greater emphasis on the creative play of the imagination than on tautness or complexity of structure. It is also very strongly linked, historically, with the practice of improvisation, in which composers give free rein to their spontaneous creative skills in performance. The label ‘fantasy’ attached to a piece of music goes back certainly as far as the 1500s, specifically linked at the time to pieces for solo instrumental performance, whether on the lute or early keyboard instruments. In British music alone, you’ll find ‘fantasies’ by Byrd, Gibbons, Lawes, Locke and Purcell, for instance, before the year 1700. In the Baroque period, Bach wrote many such pieces, often as prefaces to fugues. By the time we get to Mozart and the Classical period, such pieces remain a significant strand of a composer’s output: Beethoven’s ‘Moonlight’ Sonata is, you may know, a ‘sonata quasi una fantasia’, to account for its unusual structure and ‘expressive’ quality; Schubert’s emotionally wide-ranging ‘Wanderer Fantasy’ (also on Ms Rushdie Momen’s programme), like the four-hand ‘Fantasie’ we’ve encountered before, seems to be dragging the music out of the Classical and into the Romantic era. Mozart wrote four fantasias for solo piano (one of them, Bach-like, with an attached fugue), all dating from the early-to-mid 1780s, when Mozart was at the height of his fame as a composer-pianist, giving concerts of his own music to, largely, adoring audiences. The C Minor Fantasia, K475, was written in 1785 (the manuscript copy is dated 20th May), and it is very strongly linked with a piano sonata, also in C Minor, which he wrote some seven months earlier – the two works share some stylistic resemblances over and above the fact that they were both composed by Mozart at around the same period of time and in the same key, notably their extremes of emotional range and dynamic contrasts. Interestingly, though the Fantasia is typical, one might say, in exploring a wide range of harmonies and modulations of key, what anchors the piece is the atmosphere of tension and unrest of the opening Adagio section, which returns at the end in a conclusion which does little to dispel the sombre mood. Performances of a piece as volatile as this are, unsurprisingly, often strikingly different from each other, so choosing just one from the options on YouTube inevitably involves making some kind of value judgment about how one might like the work to sound. If you want to dig around for yourself, you’ll find recordings from the sober and statesmanlike to others that are flighty and spontaneous, and that’s before you decide whether you’d like to hear a modern concert grand or a fortepiano of Mozart’s day. In the end I’ve chosen a performance by the Hungarian pianist Zoltán Kocsis, which you’ll find here: Mozart: Fantasia in C Minor, K 475
Day 281: Requiem (Introitus: Requiem Aeternam; Kyrie) (Time: 7 minutes)
For the next two weeks, I’m focusing exclusively on compositions for Lent, beginning today (5/4/22) with music by Mozart. Back on Day 141, Jenny suggested we listen to the ‘Sequenz’ sequence of Mozart’s Requiem – the sections featuring the Dies Irae, Tuba Mirum, Rex Tremendae, Recordare, Confutatis and Lacrimosa – as part of music for Advent, harking back to the era when Advent focused more explicitly on things eschatological. However, it is more common these days for settings of the Requiem Mass to be performed or featured on concert programmes during Lent, on the basis that this is music to put us into the right devotional frame of mind for Easter when it arrives. Fellow (but invisible) list member Pete Dutton suggests that we focus on the ‘Kyrie’ section of Mozart’s work. The words, after all, are straightforward and to the point: ‘Kyrie eleison, Christe eleison, Kyrie eleison’ (‘Lord have mercy, Christ have mercy, Lord have mercy’). However, as the ‘Kyrie’ in most performances lasts under three minutes, I thought that I’d preface it with the opening section of Mozart’s Requiem, the introductory ‘Requiem Aeternam’. A rough translation of this opening movement reads: ‘Eternal rest give unto them, O Lord and let perpetual light shine upon them. A hymn, O God, becomes you in Zion, and a vow shall be paid to you in Jerusalem. Hear my prayer: All flesh shall come before you. Eternal rest give unto them, O Lord. And let perpetual light shine upon them.’ As I suggested back on Day 141, a certain amount of romantic legend has accumulated around the origins of Mozart’s Requiem (‘romantic’ unless you happened to be Antonio Salieri, of whom more next week!), starting with the apparently anonymous commission for a requiem from a stranger in July 1791. Then there’s the question of the authenticity of the individual movements of the work, which his widow Constanze left deliberately unresolved after Mozart’s death in that year. However, it appears certain that Mozart was responsible in full for the Introitus: Requiem Aeternam and the Kyrie which follows it. We are firmly in the work’s key of D Minor for these opening movements. After a brooding instrumental introduction, the chorus, starting with the basses, intones the opening words. The mood is sombre, dark. The soprano soloist shifts the sentiment at ‘Te decet’ and the whole chorus explores this briefly, before the movement ends with a return to the darker ‘Requiem aeternam’. This movement leads directly into the ‘Kyrie’, which is a double fugue (that is to say, one with two themes treated fugally simultaneously), one stately and strong (‘Kyrie eleison’), the other an elaborate semiquaver run (‘Christe eleison’) that feels extremely Handelian. It’s a thrilling section to sing, if a bit of a challenge for the sopranos in the chorus. (If you want to link this part of the Requiem to what follows, Mozart takes us from the end of the ‘Kyrie’ directly into the ‘Dies Irae’ which you’ll find links to under Day 141.) As for a performance, I did wonder about using the same 200th anniversary (of Mozart’s death) performance that I used back on Day 141 (the Vienna Phil and Vienna State Opera Chorus under Georg Solti, which is readily available on YouTube) but I thought it might be an interesting contrast to set that old-style performance with its cast of hundreds against a more fleet-footed and incisive modern interpretation. So, instead, I’ve chosen a performance by the American vocal ensemble Seraphic Fire, directed by Patrick Dupré Quigley, accompanied by the period instrument group The Sebastians. You’ll find it here: Mozart: Requiem (Introitus: Requiem Aeternam; Kyrie)
Day 538: Quintet for Piano and Winds in E flat Major, K. 452 (Time: 25 minutes)
Today (16/6/25), I want to consider a piece given by Ensemble 360 at next week’s Sheffield Chamber Music Festival 2025. Mozart has made nine appearances on this list over the years, and there have been pieces of chamber music before now – a movement from the Clarinet Quintet, the Wind Serenade K388 and two weird pieces Mozart wrote for the glass harmonica. But the work I’d urge us all to listen to today – the Quintet for Piano and Winds, K452 – is both a masterpiece and (as far as I can tell) the very first work written for this combination of instruments. Quintets involving a piano are, by and large, written for piano and strings, and usually the four string players constitute what would be the forces of a string quartet: two violins, viola and cello. Sometimes composers play around with this pattern a little. So, Schubert’s famous ‘Trout’ Quintet (see Day 381) replaces the second violin with a double bass. However, what this ‘piano + strings’ combination always creates is an essentially homogenous sound, given that the four string players are basically playing different sizes of the same sort of instrument, and the ‘effects’ available are common to all the strings – like the ability to play long flowing lines without, say, having to stop to breathe! But if you think about four wind players, as opposed to string players, the challenges are two-fold: first, the issue of breathing just mentioned, which means a composer has to solve this by writing shorter phrases with spaces to breathe; and secondly there is the fact that unlike the homogenous sound of the strings, the four wind instruments are strikingly different in timbre to each other, and getting these to ‘blend’ with each other, let alone with a piano as well, is not easy. But … enter Mozart. In 1784 Mozart’s musical life changed in some interesting ways. First, at the age of 28 and having written by then over 400 works, he eventually got round to starting to catalogue them. In itself that might seem a bit dull and administrative, but in the process Mozart assessed and began to change his priorities. One change (or perhaps development) was that he began to take a greater interest in writing for wind instruments. Thirdly, he was at that point in his life mostly putting on concerts (very successfully) featuring a starring role for himself on piano. The most obvious vehicle was the piano concerto – he wrote a scarcely plausible six of them in 1784, three more the next year, and three more still the year after that. But there’s a real development evident in the scoring of his Piano Concerto No 17, K453, one of the ones from 1784, compared to those that came before it, where the interaction between piano and the various wind instruments becomes a marked feature of the sound world Mozart is trying to create. It’s reasonable to assume that this step was a result of Mozart experimenting with the piano/wind interaction in the Quintet for Piano and Winds which he wrote immediately before it, and which was, as I’ve mentioned, the first such work of its kind ever. Mozart, unlike some composers (Tchaikovsky, say) often had a high opinion of the works he’d just written, but in relation to this quintet he wrote to his father: ‘I consider it the best thing I have written in my life. I wish you could have heard it, and how beautifully it was performed.’ Perhaps what gave him the most satisfaction is the way he solved the sorts of technical problems I’ve mentioned to do with managing the blending and contrasting of sounds within the group. Without getting into too much detail, he does this either by alternating passages for the piano with those for the wind players as a group in their own right (a sort of mini-‘wind band’), or by setting off the wind players in sub-groups, so that they take it in turn to play in ‘dialogue’ with the piano or with each other, or in pairs or threes while the other players are at rest, because, let’s face it, wind players are going to get tired much faster than pianists, and need a break. (This will all make more sense when watching a performance.) The work is in the familiar three movements. The first movement has a slow introduction - itself a nice illustration of Mozart sketching in the relationships between instruments, first with piano set against the strings, and then gradually unwinding that starkness of contrast until all the different sonorities are melded together. In the main body of the movement, each instrument has its turn in the spotlight, with the piano partnering rather than in competition with the winds. The slow movement Larghetto also treats the wind players soloistically, taking it in turns to play with the piano; there’s one lovely moment where they pass a tender melody to and fro among each other, underpinned by harmonies in the piano. The final movement is one of those joyful Mozartian rondos, an ABACA structure, where the ‘A’ section returns, separated by two contrasting episodes. The moment just before the final return of the ‘A’ material is especially vivid: a seemingly improvisatory but actually fully written-out ‘cadenza’ for all five players. Then, almost like an operatic flourish, the piece ends in playful high spirits. The work was given its first performance in Vienna on April 1st, 1784, in a mammoth concert of Mozart works. One other thing: Beethoven was known to be particularly impressed by Mozart’s Quintet for Piano and Winds – so much so that one of his early works, the Quintet for Piano and Winds, Op 16, is an overt homage to Mozart’s original. YouTube has several recordings of this piece that I could quite happily live with, but out of the options I’ve gone for this video performance by some star names: Alexei Ogrintchouk on oboe, Nicolas Baldeyrou on clarinet, Laurent Lefèvre on bassoon, Stefan Dohr on horn, and Nikolay Lugansky on piano. You’ll find their recording here: Mozart: Quintet for Piano and Winds, K452
Day 555: Violin Sonata in E Minor, K304 (Time: 16 minutes)
Today (12/9/25), I want to explore one of the works being performed
at the first concert of the 2025/26 season under the auspices of
Music in the Round here in Sheffield, when members of Ensemble 360 play music
by Mozart – three of his violin sonatas – and Schumann. From that
programme I’ve chosen one of Mozart’s most impassioned pieces of music for
these forces, the Violin Sonata in E Minor, K304. There have been ten
appearances of music by Mozart on this list, but so far nothing from his compositions
for violin and piano. Although Mozart wrote somewhere around 32 violin
sonatas (the exact figure is debatable, owing to doubts about the authenticity
of some, and the fact that there are also incomplete sonatas that Mozart
evidently didn’t get around to finishing), but the first 16 of these date from
when Mozart was 10 years old or younger, so – with due respect given to his
‘child prodigy’ status – I’d suggest that these very early ones are not of any
great musical interest. Consequently, and certainly as far as concert
performances are concerned, the focus in this area is on Mozart’s 16 ‘mature’
violin sonatas. I put ‘mature’ in inverted commas because of those 16,
seven emerged in the year Mozart turned 22 years old. These seven sonatas
– actually a set of six, plus an additional ‘one off’ sonata written for a
pupil of his – of 1778 were written with their audience very much in
mind. Mozart, accompanied by his mother, had travelled to Paris, where
audiences appreciated the fashionable style of chamber pieces in which the
violin was beginning to lose its ‘accompanying’ status and to vie with the
keyboard instrument as the focus of musical attention, or as an increasingly
equal partner in a ‘dialogue’ between the instruments. He had discovered
this ‘new’ approach in the now lost sonatas of an almost forgotten composer
called Joseph Schuster, prompting him to write to his father, ‘I enclose … six
duets for keyboard and violin by Schuster, which I have often played
here. They aren’t bad… I’ll write six myself in the same style,
which is very popular.’ These are the six sonatas numbered K301-306 in
Köchel’s catalogue. All Mozart’s violin sonatas are in major keys except
for one – the E Minor, K 304. This is probably the most obvious way in
which it distinguishes itself from the others, but there’s a bit of
biographical detail that adds an extra layer of significance to that.
Mozart and his mother arrived in Paris in March 1778, and in early July of that
year his mother died. Now, we should be careful with any ‘biography
influences music’ argument here, because at the time Mozart wrote this sonata,
which one might think articulates emotions of grief and loss, he was also
writing the succeeding sonata (a bright, joyous affair in D Major), not to mention
his Symphony No 31 (the ‘Paris’), which is a fizzing, extrovert thing, full of
fashionable turns and techniques. But, all that said, it’s hard to escape
the sense that the E Minor sonata taps into a deeper level of emotional
intensity than anything else Mozart was writing at the time other than the
near-contemporary Piano Sonata in A Minor, K310, and that the death of his
beloved mother was almost certainly the cause. Like all except one of the
set of six violin sonatas Mozart had published in Paris, the sonata K304 is in
only two movements. The texture of the music is often spare and the lines
of music exposed (a sort of ‘less is more’ approach to expression), but the
emotional impact is immediate. The first movement starts with a sombre
theme played in unison by both instruments, and although the movement’s second
theme is a little more jaunty and playful it’s the first theme that dominates
almost throughout. I’m particularly taken with the start of the
recapitulation (the bit where the opening ideas return after the meanderings of
the middle ‘development’ section) just because of the way this theme – bare
unison first time around – is now harmonised, highlighting the emotional
intensity of the moment. It’s almost like a foreshadowing of the sound
world of Beethoven! The other movement is labelled ‘Tempo di Menuetto’,
but it’s only partly characteristic of the kind of genteel dance-like form that
such a label would imply. The movement is in rondo form (noddy
definition: an episodic structure in which one section keeps returning, and is
interspersed by others in, for example, an A-B-A-C-A structure, where the ‘A’
sections form the pillars of the overall structure), and it’s one of the
intervening sections that gives the movement its most beautiful moments.
There’s a hopefully easily recognisable bit where the music shifts to E Major,
and marked ‘Dolce’ (‘sweetly’) by Mozart, that is particularly tender –
Einstein, often given to outpourings of adoration about Mozart’s music, called
this ‘a brief glimpse of bliss’. Sounds about right! There are
several performances of Mozart’s Violin Sonata in E Minor, K304 on YouTube, and
I’d be happy with many of them, but out of the options I’ve gone for this one
by the brother and sister duo of Gil and Orli Shaham. It’s a slightly
‘old-fashioned’ performance, in the sense that doesn’t engage with much ‘period
instrument’ practice, but its emotional engagement suits the character of this music.
You’ll find it here:
Day 572: String Quintet in G Minor, K516 (Time: 37 minutes)
Later this month, Ensemble 360 will play three different quintets by Mozart: the Horn Quintet K407 (scored for horn, one violin, two violas and one cello); the glorious Clarinet Quintet K581 (clarinet, two violins, one viola and one cello); and finally one of the short series of string quintets that Mozart wrote towards the end of his life, the String Quintet in G Minor, K516 (two violins, two violas and one cello). I make a point of mentioning the scoring not just because it promises to be a fascinating evening of contrasting musical textures, but particularly because the scoring of the string quintet – my choice of music for today (9/1/26) – is, in Mozart’s hands, very striking. If you’ve spent any amount of time exploring the music I’ve posted on this forum, you’ll know that ‘the string quartet’ was, as it were, an established sub-set of chamber music since this combination of instruments gradually superseded the viol consort in the late 17th century. Haydn (‘father of the string quartet’, as the cliché has it) above all others made this ensemble the vehicle for music of wit, complexity and profundity during the second half of the 18th century. Mozart wrote 23 string quartets, though only the last ten of these are, as it were, ‘mature’ works. It’s hard sometimes to know how seriously to take Mozart’s comments about the process of composition, but, if we take him at his word, the six quartets he wrote that he dedicated to Haydn were ‘the fruit of long and laborious toil’. However, if (and it’s a big ‘if’) Mozart found writing for the string quartet more than usually challenging, there’s no doubt that the addition of a second viola, to make a string quintet, was hugely liberating. He wrote six of them. The first is a very early work, and the second is a transcription for string quintet of the Serenade for Wind Octet, K388 (see Day 181!). However, the other four are late works, and they are, to quote Charles Rosen, the American pianist and musicologist, ‘by general consent, Mozart's greatest achievement in chamber music.’ The G Minor Quintet, K516 was originally one of a pair, being written concurrently with the quintet in C Major, K515. Mozart was very fond of writing like this, particularly two works in contrasting major and minor keys. There’s the Piano Concertos, Nos 20 in D Minor K466 and 21 in C K467. Or take the pair of Piano Concertos in A Major K488 and C Minor K491. In relation to the two string quintets though (C Major and G Minor) perhaps a more striking connection is with Mozart’s final two symphonies – No 40 in G Minor and No 41 in C Major (exactly the same keys as these two string quintets!). Just a coincidence? Maybe … though my view is that this particular combination of light and shade triggered something powerfully expressive in Mozart’s musical imagination. What did Mozart get out of adding a second viola to the familiar string quartet line-up? Well, for instance, Mozart could explore different combinations of instruments – groups of two against three, or solo cello harmonised by both violas in a deeper, more sonorous mix of voices. In particular, the viola lines (and don’t forget the viola was Mozart’s own favourite instrument to play) give a special richness to the string sound compared to listening to a string quartet. A biographical thought: I’ve expressed caution before (see Day 555 for the Violin Sonata in E Minor, K304, allegedly the product of Mozart’s grief over the death of his mother) about linking what Mozart wrote to what was going on in his life, but he wrote the G Minor String Quintet during the final illness of his father, Leopold (he finished it in May 1787, and Leopold died 12 days later), and it could be argued that this piece, written by an estranged son who knew his father was dying, is the most grief-laden work in Mozart’s oeuvre. A month earlier Mozart had written in a letter, ‘death, when we come to consider it closely, is the true goal of our existence, I have formed during the last few years such close relations with this best and truest friend of mankind that his image is not only no longer terrifying to me, but is indeed very soothing and consoling!’ Some critics see the work as full of resignation and despair … though that is to overlook the fourth and final movement. Before that, though, things stay pretty dark almost all the time. The opening Allegro is a melancholy, often subdued thing, with two initial themes that feel broken and plaintive, underpinned by the same sort of ‘chugging’ chords you find in the famous opening movement of the Symphony No 40. The ‘sliding’ effect of chromatic melody lines (just listen to the second bar of the movement!) feels pretty heart-breaking. The second movement is allegedly a Minuet, but this is no ornate or formal dance, but sombre, and punctuated by sharp, angry outbursts. The slow movement, marked Adagio, drew a striking (and revealing!) comment from Tchaikovsky when he heard a performance of it: ‘No one else has ever known how to interpret so beautifully and exquisitely in music the feeling of resignation and inconsolable sorrow....I had to hide in the farthest corner of the concert-room so that others would not see how much this music affected me.’ (All a bit Fotherington-Thomas, if you recognise the cultural allusion, but you can hear what he means in the music.) Then there’s the finale, which, it has to be said, divides opinion. It starts in yet more gloom, but after the slow introduction the sun comes out and the tension relaxes. Some see irony and hollowness under the apparently jolly surface. Who knows? There are several more than decent performances to choose from on YouTube, and from them, I’ve gone for one by regular visitors to Sheffield under the auspices of Music in the Round, the Dutch ensemble the Van Kuijk Quartet, with the addition here of Adrien La Marca on second viola. You’ll find their performance here: Mozart: String Quintet in G Minor, K516
Musgrave, Thea (b 27th May 1928)
Day 380: Song of the Enchanter (Time: 5 minutes)
Sheffield City Hall is about to host a performance from rare visitors, the Estonian National Symphony Orchestra, with a programme including Sibelius’s Symphony No 5, and an ‘upbeat’ to it, if you like, from my composer for today (16/5/23). Thea Musgrave (b1928) is a Scottish composer, though as she’s lived and worked in America for over 50 years it makes at least as much sense to see her as an American composer these days. She was born in Edinburgh and went to university there, before following almost every 20th century composer you can think of in studying in Paris with Nadia Boulanger. Further study in America with Aaron Copland, and academic posts in California and New York, not to mention marriage to the American conductor Peter Mark, are the reasons why over half her life has been spent in the United States. Her big breakthrough as a composer was probably her Concerto for Orchestra of 1967, though it would be fair to say that by and large her output has been driven by programmatic ‘narrative’ works rather than ones in more abstract forms. She is, for instance, the composer of ten operas, as well as ballets – and even apparently ‘abstract’ works, like her Oboe Concerto, are illustrative in that they base their development on extra-musical ideas, in this case the depiction of Helios, the sun god. In fact, she is an immensely prolific composer, and though inevitably she has slowed down in her tenth decade, new pieces are still emerging (a piccolo concerto from 2021 being the most recent). There are a couple of comments of hers that are worthy of quotation, I think. Asked in a BBC interview if she felt like ‘a woman composer’ she said: ‘Yes I am a woman, and I am a composer. But rarely at the same time.’ And, rather less quirkily, she was asked as an established composer about advice for beginners at the job, and said: ‘Don't do it, unless you have to. And if you do, enjoy every minute of it!’ The piece that the Estonian National Symphony Orchestra is playing in Sheffield is her short orchestral work ‘Song of the Enchanter’, and it’s particularly apt (and obviously deliberate!) that it precedes Sibelius’s 5th Symphony, because it was written in 1990 to a commission from the Helsinki Philharmonic to mark the 125th anniversary of Sibelius’s birth. I’m going to lift the description of the work’s context and content from Musgrave’s own website, since it conveys what I want to say clearly: ‘This short work, written in the winter and spring of 1990, was commissioned by the Helsinki Philharmonic Orchestra to honour the 125th anniversary of Sibelius's birth. It is based on an episode from the Kalevala, the great Finnish epic, where Väinämäinen, the hero-God, has fashioned a magical five-stringed instrument from the bones of a giant pike. Orpheus-like, he plays upon it and enchants the people. All listen and all weep, their hearts melted. Even Väinämäinen weeps and his tears 'bigger than cranberries' fall into the clear waters of the deep blue sea. A sea bird dives down to retrieve his tears – they have ripened into pearls.’ In other words, we are embedded here in the extra-musical context that drove so much of Sibelius’s own work, and in lots of ways you can hear the ‘voice’ of Sibelius in this music. The ‘story’ of ‘Song of the Enchanter’ may suggest that the enchanter in question is Väinämäinen, but for Musgrave (and so many other composers) the ‘enchanter’ himself is Sibelius, and this music is a homage to his ‘song’. The sound world is very akin to Sibelius in some ways, from the swirling strings that open the work to the ‘bardic’ quality of the harp writing – though I very much doubt Sibelius would have gone in for the ‘aleatoric’ middle section of the work, where the wind and brass are given pitches and basic rhythmic patterns, but are free to choose how often and it what order to play them. (One nostalgic piece of information: this piece was given its first performance in 1991 by the Helsinki Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by none other than James Loughran, who – many will remember – was the Principal Conductor of the Halle Orchestra from 1971-83, and Conductor Laureate for the eight years after that.) As for a recording, YouTube offers no video performances, I’m afraid, so we’re in audio-only territory for today. This recording is by the orchestra that commissioned the work, the Helsinki Philharmonic, conducted by Sergiu Comissiona. You’ll find it here: Musgrave: Song of the Enchanter
Mussorgsky, Modest (1839-81)
Day 239: Night on Bald Mountain (Original Version) (Time: 13 minutes)
Modest Mussorgsky (1839-81) is new to this list. We’ve had other members of ‘The Kuchka’ (‘The Five’ or ‘The Mighty Handful’) – César Cui on Day 183, Rimsky-Korsakov on Day 184 (and it won’t be long before we encounter Balakirev and Borodin) – but Mussorgsky’s is an interesting case, in that nowadays almost all the works we hear with his name attached to them are in fact orchestrations or ‘edited versions’ put together by other composers. The simple explanation for this state of affairs is that Mussorgsky seems relatively rarely to have actually completed many works in a settled form. And the reason for that seems, by common consent, to be Mussorgsky's difficulty with alcohol addiction. Mussorgsky (spellings vary pretty widely in Russian, but this is the settled western version) was born into a land-owning family, and he initially took the relatively conventional route through education and early employment for young men of such a social background: officer cadet school followed by entry into the Imperial Guard. However, as a teenager he met Borodin and, through him, other influential Russian nationalist composers and musicians. Consequently, before he was 20, he had resigned his commission and regarded himself as a full-time composer. The death of his mother when he was in his mid-twenties seems to have led to his first major bout of alcoholism, but then this compulsion to drink seems to have been what caused the swift decline in his creativity from about his mid-thirties onwards, and he died at the age of just 42. Contemporary opinions of Mussorgsky and his work tended to be largely unfavourable. Tchaikovsky - never one to mince his words about potential musical rivals – did at least recognise the raw talent struggling to get out: he wrote to his patroness, Nadezhda von Meck: ‘Mussorgsky you very rightly call a hopeless case. In talent, he is perhaps superior to all the other [members of ‘The Five’] but his nature is narrow-minded, devoid of any urge towards self-perfection, blindly believing in the ridiculous theories of his circle and in his own genius. In addition, he has a certain base side to his nature which likes coarseness, uncouthness, roughness. He flaunts his illiteracy, takes pride in his ignorance, mucks along anyhow, blindly believing in the infallibility of his genius. Yet he has flashes of talent which are, moreover, not devoid of originality.’ A look at the list of Mussorgsky compositions reveals a huge number of unfinished works: of his major pieces, he completed the opera ‘Boris Godunov’, the piano cycle ‘Pictures at an Exhibition’, a handful of pieces for chorus, and (by far the largest set of works) a significant number of songs for voice and piano. His first attempt at the piece now known as ‘Night on Bald Mountain’ (elsewhere ‘St John's Eve on Bald Mountain’ or ‘A Night on the Bare Mountain’ and other variants on these titles) came in 1867, but Balakirev (semi-official leader of ‘The Kuchka’) rejected it outright, and it was never heard in Mussorgsky's lifetime. In fact, even before that the idea for such a piece seems to have been part of Mussorgsky’s planning for his projected operas ‘St John's Eve’ and ‘The Witch’, neither of which got very far. Subsequent versions of the piece surfaced in a failed composite opera called ‘Mlada’, and then his final incomplete opera ‘Sorochinsky Fair’. The version that is best known and most often played these days is a performing version put together by Rimsky-Korsakov five years after Mussorgsky’s death. If you know this version and compare it with what Mussorgsky originally wrote, it’s clear that in many ways Rimsky's version is not so much a ‘performing edition’, but rather a ‘re-composition’ based on Mussorgsky's original. For example, the slow ending with the tolling of the bell to indicate daybreak at the end of the piece is not present in Mussorgsky's original. Elsewhere, Rimsky rather ‘sanitises’ the irregularity and rawness in the original score to make it seem acceptably polished. (It’s possible, of course, that you might know the work mostly from the version used in the Disney cartoon ‘Fantasia’ – yet another ‘reworking’ of the piece by the conductor Leopold Stokowski.) It would appear that Mussorgsky's original manuscript was rediscovered in the 1920s, and performances of this ‘authentic’ version began to be heard from the 1930s onwards. It is this version – quite startling, I think, if you only know the piece in Rimsky's edition – that I’ve chosen for today (9/11/21). There are quite a number of decent video performances of the work on YouTube. From them, I’ve selected this recording by the Estonian Festival Orchestra, conducted by Paavo Järvi. You’ll find it here: Mussorgsky: Night on Bald Mountain (original version)
Myaskovsky, Nikolai (1881-1950)
Day 550: Cello Sonata No 2 (Time: 21 minutes)
Last time out, I trailed the fact that the following two editions were going to be commemorations of the anniversaries of the deaths of two Soviet composers. Those with an ear to the ground (when listening to Radio 3 anyway) will know that tomorrow marks the 50th anniversary of the death of Shostakovich. However, before that there’s another anniversary to observe. Today (8/8/25) marks the 75th anniversary of the death of Nikolai Myaskovsky (sometimes ‘Miaskovsky’ and, to the French and the Poles, I believe, ‘Miaskowski’). Although 75 years ago, he would have been regarded as a significant composer, his works keep a low profile these days, but although I certainly wouldn’t speak of him in the same breath as either Shostakovich or Prokofiev, he is a significant composer with a distinctive, somewhat melancholy voice. If you don’t know any Myaskovsky, I hope you’ll enjoy a skim over his history and a listen to one of his most attractive works. Nikolai Yakovlevich Myaskovsky (1881-1950) is usually described as a Soviet composer, but as you can see from his birthdate he was already in his later thirties when the October Revolution reshaped Russian culture in the years after 1917. So maybe ‘a Russo-Soviet composer’ would be a more suitable label. However, to confuse things just a tiny bit further, he was born in what is today Poland – in fact about 50km north of Warsaw – but since in the late 19th century Poland as we know it today did not exist, having been swallowed up by Russia, Austria-Hungary and Germany, he would have been recognised as a Russian citizen, since that chunk of Polish territory was then part of the Russian Empire. Following family tradition, his initial career plan was to be a soldier/engineer, but music exerted a stronger pull. (The balance was tipped, apparently, by his attendance at a performance of Tchaikovsky’s Pathetique Symphony.) He studied at the St Petersburg Conservatory, under Lyadov (one day, I hope…) and Rimsky-Korsakov (see Days 184 and 337). His bond with his classmate Prokofiev lasted until his death in 1950 – they composed joint pieces sometimes, and were always responsive to what each other was doing musically. Before the revolution, Myaskovsky served in the Russian army during the First World War, where he was seriously wounded on the Austrian Front, and the experience seems to have scarred him psychologically for the rest of his life, making an already shy and introverted man even more averse to public exposure. Curiously, the Russian Revolution and its aftermath seem not to have caused him undue problems. He continued to work at the Moscow Conservatory, and he was a leading member of the Soviet Association for Contemporary Music. The sort of censure that caused Prokofiev (for a time), and Rachmaninov and Stravinsky (permanently) to flee Russia, and which evidently traumatised Shostakovich, seems to have escaped Myaskovsky until almost the end of his life. Why? Well, partly because in his introverted way he kept a low profile, but also he simply continued to plough his own furrow, as it were, regardless of the fashions of the age. He is a composer, for the most part, of symphonies (27 of them) and string quartets (13 of them), with a side helping of nine piano sonatas and a smattering of chamber music (of which more in a minute). In other words, he was a traditionalist. He wrote no operas, so there’s nothing in his repertoire like Shostakovich’s ‘Lady Macbeth of Mtsensk’ to trouble the censors or to make ‘Pravda’ angry. His music, apart from a slightly experimental 1930s phase, is essentially tonal. He also seems, in his understated way, to have been regarded as a thoroughly decent man, who made no enemies. Clearly at some points in the first half of the 20th century he was seen as a ‘great’ composer. I’ve come across, more than once, reference to a survey by the American broadcaster CBS, who in 1935 asked which then living composers would be seen as being among the world’s greatest 100 years later. As you might expect, Stravinsky, Richard Strauss, Prokofiev, Rachmaninov, Sibelius and Ravel made the top ten, as did Gershwin (it was an American poll, after all). So did Myaskovsky. His one brush with authority came in 1948 when he was caught up in the purge of Soviet composers (alongside Shostakovich, Prokofiev, Khachaturian and so on), accused of writing ‘formalist’, ‘bourgeois’ music. Interestingly, he refused categorically to make a grovelling speech of recantation, but just ignored the threat. This may have been due to the fact that at that stage he already knew he was dying of the cancer that would take his life in 1950, but it’s a striking illustration of the fact that he was, right up to the end, ‘his own man’. For an example of Myaskovsky the composer, I thought I’d sidestep the symphonies (largely rather dour, slow-moving affairs) and go for the piece of chamber music that Myaskovsky wrote, seemingly in direct response to the critical attacks by the Communist Party in 1948. This is his Cello Sonata No 2, dedicated to (and regularly played by) Mstislav Rostropovich. It’s a good illustration, I think, of Myaskovsky’s late style, clean lined and in some ways simple, but (for me, anyway) very moving. After his death the work won the Stalin Prize (a kind of posthumous rehabilitation by the authorities, I suppose); in fact he won the Stalin Prize six times, more than anyone else. The work is in three movements, in the traditional fast-slow-fast pattern. The first movement echoes the simple modality of Russian folk song, the middle movement is largely song-like, though with an assertive middle section, and the finale is a dance-like moto perpetuo. YouTube is actually quite well-stocked when it comes to performances of this work, and out of the options I’ve gone for this one by the renowned Russian cellist Natalia Gutman, accompanied here by pianist Viacheslav Poprugin: Myaskovsky: Cello Sonata No 2
Myers, Stanley (1930-93)
Day 38: ‘Cavatina’ (Theme from ‘The Deer Hunter’) Time: 4 minutes)
Today (29/4/20), a suggestion from Claire, for music that exists at that intersection between light classical and the more poignant end of the film music spectrum. As with the appearance of a tune from a musical by Andrew Lloyd-Webber some weeks ago, I’d take the line here that music is music is music, and not get too hung up on any tiresome high culture/low culture debate. So, the composer here is Stanley Myers, and it’s a piece he initially scored for a film called ‘The Walking Stick’ in 1970, a British crime drama that has left no permanent impression on cinematic history. However, subsequently popularised by the guitarist John Williams, the theme was spotted by the producers of the 1979 film ‘The Deer Hunter’, and the rest, as they say, is history. There are lots of recordings of ‘Cavatina’ on YouTube of John Williams performing in concert or on TV, but I’ve not been able to find one where the image and sound are synchronised enough not to drive you crazy. So, here is John Williams’ LP recording with Stanley Myers and his Orchestra: Stanley Myers – ‘Cavatina’
Nancarrow, Conlon (1912-97)
Day 39: Study for Player Piano 3A (Time: 3 minutes) and Study for Player Piano 3B (6 minutes)
Having had five and a half weeks to soften you up (apologies
to the relatively new arrivals, whose softening-up process hasn’t been quite so
extensive!), I thought I’d try hitting you today (30/4/20) with one of 20th
century music’s great eccentrics, the composer Conlon Nancarrow (1912-97), who
was born in America, but lived most of his life in isolation in Mexico.
His music is an attempt, before the age of computers, to compose beyond what
human hands were able to play. His chosen instrument was the
player-piano, a ‘self-playing’ piano that functions on the basis of punched rolls
of paper (usually), which are fed into a mechanism that drives the keys and
‘plays’ the music. Nancarrow was really only ‘discovered’ in the 1980s,
but since then has been hailed as a trail-blazer in his (admittedly rather
recondite) field. Almost all Nancarrow’s ‘Studies for Player Piano’ are
available on YouTube, so there’s lots more to explore if this takes your
fancy. But I thought possibly the way into his rather quirky musical
world would be via the first two movements of his ‘Boogie-Woogie Suite’, which
are also known as the Studies 3A and 3B. I’ve provided links here to both
of them – the slightly more manic Study 3A here: Conlon Nancarrow – Study for
Player Piano 3A and the more laid-back Study 3B here, in an ‘animated’
performance: Study for
Player Piano 3B
I promise not to distribute anything this weird again – but please don’t be
scared by this stuff! Its roots are definitely in American popular music,
even if it takes you somewhere that you might think required some kind of
hallucinogenic substance for its inspiration!
Nicolai, Otto (1810-49)
Day 479: The Merry Wives of Windsor (Overture) (Time: 9 minutes)
The entry for today (10/5/24) is a ‘commemorative’ posting, highlighting the fact that tomorrow, Sat 11th May, marks the 175th anniversary of the death of a composer who is, these days, very definitely a ‘one hit wonder’. And, not wishing to tease out the suspense, it is in fact that piece of music that I want to feature. Otto Nicolai (1810-49) was born in what was then Königsberg, in Prussia (and is now Kaliningrad in the Russian enclave on the southern coast of the Baltic). As has been remarked many times on this list, musical history is full of ‘what ifs’, particularly in the case of composers who died young. Mozart and Schubert, Pergolesi and Donizetti, Chopin … and Nicolai? If that last name doesn’t seem naturally to fit with the others it’s because while they have all become established as part of the canon of Western music, Nicolai has, at best, only a minimal place in that company. The pairing of Chopin and Nicolai was deliberate, not because their music has much in common (it doesn’t) but because their dates of birth and death are almost identical, which might help to place his work in its historical context. He was born into a musical family, but his parents divorced when he was a child and he ran away from home as a teenager, settling in Stargard (then also Prussian, though now in north-west Poland). By the time he was 17 he was in Berlin, studying with the then-famous teacher Zelter. His early career in German-speaking territories did not last long (despite the successful premiere of an early symphony) and during most of the 1830s he was based in Italy, where he developed a facility in writing Italian opera. There are a couple of ‘sliding doors’ moments here involving him and the young Giuseppe Verdi. La Scala in Milan offered the libretto of ‘Il Proscritto’ to Verdi, who turned it down, and it became an early operatic hit for Nicolai, who picked up the text as second choice. Later, the roles were reversed, Nicolai turning down the chance to write the music for a libretto that went, as a consequence, to Verdi, for whom as a consequence ‘Nabucco’ became his first great success. One of the odd things about Nicolai is that although he was thoroughly German, five of his six surviving operas were written in Italian. By 1841 he was based in Vienna, where he had a stipend as court composer to the Austro-Hungarian Emperor. This point in his life marks another reason we should value Nicolai’s contributions to music, because he was one of the founder members of the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra. He and a group of friends met ‘at a local hostelry’ (as they say) where they discussed setting up a professional orchestra in Vienna and, seemingly reluctantly, Nicolai accepted the post of conductor with the new band. Nicolai’s short life – he died just before his 39th birthday – was evidently ‘on the up’ in its last years. On the very day he died of a stroke in 1849 he had been accepted as a member of the Royal Prussian Academy of Arts in Berlin and had just taken over running the Berlin State Opera. As for today’s piece, though almost all Nicolai’s operas were in Italian, the one that wasn’t has become his calling card, in musical terms, over the past 170 years. This is ‘The Merry Wives of Windsor’, written in German in the last year of his life and given its first performance in Berlin just before his death. Opinions may vary, but I’ve generally been of the view that ‘The Merry Wives of Windsor’ is one of Shakespeare’s worst plays – a bit of a potboiler dreamt up because of the all-round popularity of the character of Falstaff in Shakespeare’s two ‘Henry IV’ history plays. The libretto Nicolai used for his opera mangles that narrative even further (certainly it’s not a patch on the libretto Boito generated for Verdi when the latter produced his own opera ‘Falstaff’ several decades later). Nicolai’s composition makes very occasional appearances in the opera house, but the overture to the opera is, if not a fixture, then certainly a regular feature in the sorts of concerts that are devoted to shorter selections from the ‘lighter’ end of the bill of classical fare. I don’t, in saying all this, want to denigrate the piece: it’s lovely, attractive, melodic stuff. The overture begins with a depiction of moonrise over Windsor Great Park, after which the main faster section of the overture feels very reminiscent of Mendelssohn’s ‘A Midsummer Night’s Dream’ Overture (see Day 203!), perhaps unsurprisingly in that it’s depicting Falstaff being tormented in the dark by children and townsfolk whom he takes for sprites and fairies. Nicolai uses the opera’s melodies that depict Mistress Page (one of the ‘merry wives’) and Falstaff himself – slightly galumphing but with a certain dignity too – before he weaves several of the themes together in a lively coda. As for a performance, YouTube has quite a few. From them I’ve chosen this video recording from a concert given by the Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra, conducted by Kurt Masur. You’ll find it here: Nicolai: The Merry Wives of Windsor (Overture)
Nielsen, Carl (1865-1931)
Day 98: Symphony No 4 (4th movement) (Time: 12 minutes*)
Today (28/6/20), I wanted to share with you the music of Carl Nielsen (1865-1931), the greatest Danish composer and one of the foremost symphonic composers of the early 20th century. Nielsen was an almost exact contemporary of Sibelius, and their musical development offers some similarities, evolving from early works revealing echoes of late 19th century romanticism into highly original and personal interpretations of what the symphony should ‘mean’ in the often violent and mechanised world of the early 20th century. For me, the high points of Nielsen’s symphonic career are the two symphonies he composed during and after the first world war, Symphony No 4 (1914-16) and Symphony No 5 (1921-22). In both works you can hear Nielsen wrestling with the opposing forces of order and chaos. In an ideal world (i.e. one without a 15 minute rule!) I’d like to show how each of these works, in their different ways, strives to depict what Nielsen called ‘the life force, the unquenchable will to live’ in overcoming all obstacles. So, given the time constraints, I’ll just go for the final movement of Nielsen’s Symphony No 4. Nielsen gave this symphony the name ‘The Inextinguishable’. The first movement of the piece is full of a kind of elemental violence, and though the two middle movements offer a little relief from the conflict, the finale takes it up with blazing effect. The most striking feature of the movement is the ‘battle’ between the two timpanists, who engage in a duel from either side of the stage. It seems to me to be one of the most exhilarating movements in the whole of the orchestral repertoire. I’ve tried to find a video recording of just this movement, but I can’t find one with both decent sound and a decent picture. So here is a recording of the whole symphony (so you could always unilaterally ignore the 15 minute rule and watch it all!) by the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra conducted by Paavo Jarvi. The four movements play without a break, but the transition between the third and fourth movements happens at about 25'50" on this recording. You’ll find it here: Nielsen – Symphony No 4 (4th movement)
Day 228: Wind Quintet (Time: 23 minutes)
Carl Nielsen died 90 years ago this coming weekend. He has appeared once before on this list – see Day 98, when the focus was on the final movement of his Symphony No 4. I wrote at the time about the ways in which Nielsen’s output evolved from early works across which the shadow of 19th century Romanticism fell very obviously to a more individual voice in his work from the start of the 20th century, a voice in which order battled with chaos in large-scale compositions like his symphonies. Today (1/10/21), though, I want to shift the focus to a piece on a smaller scale, his Wind Quintet. It would be my contention that this is the greatest work written for these forces in the history of music. Admittedly, the competition for this accolade isn’t very intense. There are great works written for larger wind forces (like Mozart’s three mature wind serenades), and there are great works written for the combination of wind quartet/quintet with piano (from Mozart and Beethoven through to Poulenc). However, the wind quintet as such (flute, oboe, clarinet, bassoon and horn) seems to have generally invited gentler, more genial works rather than anything more substantial. The line-up interested composers from the early 19th century onwards: there are attractive pieces by Reicha and Danzi in the first few decades of that century, and in the past 100 years there have been fine works by the likes of Barber (his ‘Summer Music’ – see Day 204), Carter, Hindemith, Ligeti (his Bagatelles – see Day 57), Milhaud and Villa-Lobos. However, I don’t think any of these compete with the achievement of Nielsen’s Wind Quintet, and I’ll try to explain why. Nielsen wrote the work in 1922, and it’s quite striking that its idiosyncratic charm sits directly alongside the cataclysmic strife of the Symphony No 5 in his output. But although it’s undoubtedly entertaining, this music has considerable depth. The piece was written for the very specific characters of the players in the Copenhagen Wind Quintet, musicians Nielsen got to know extremely well. Nielsen himself wrote of the piece, in the third person: ‘[In] the quintet for winds … the composer … has attempted to render the characters of the various instruments. At one moment they are all talking at once, at another they are quite alone. The work consists of three movements: a) Allegro, b) Minuet and c) Prelude – Theme with Variations. The theme for these variations is the melody for one of his spiritual songs [the chorale tune Nielsen wrote to the hymn ‘My Jesus, make my heart to love thee’], which has here been made the basis of a set of variations, now merry and quirky, now elegiac and serious, ending with the theme in all its simplicity and very quietly expressed.’ In the first movement, Nielsen shows great ingenuity in generating a surprising variety of blends of sonority from the different combinations of instruments. The second movement is a minuet, but quite some distance removed from the minuets of Mozart and Haydn. However, it’s the Finale that impresses me the most: there’s a wild, rather stormy Praeludium before we get into the Theme and Variations that form the rest of the work. Nielsen himself seems to have had no conventional religious belief, but (perhaps Vaughan Williams is a good comparison) he wrote a great many hymns and settings of religious words that are still in use in Denmark today, and the hymn tune he chose to work with in this movement would have been very well known to his audience. The variations capture the moods and characters not just of the five different instruments, but of the five different players of the original Copenhagen ensemble who gave the premiere. It’s by turns gentle, witty, irreverent and touching, before it ends in a simple restatement of the theme. As for a performance, YouTube has several that are really impressive, but, out of the options, I’ve chosen this one by the players of the Berlin Philharmonic Wind Quintet. You’ll find it here: Nielsen: Wind Quintet
Novak, Vítězslav (1870-1949)
Day 498: Slovak Suite, Op 32 (Time: 24 minutes)
My choice for today (16/7/24) highlights the 75th anniversary of the death of a major Czech composer of the first half of this century… though someone who doesn’t get anything like the exposure of some of his contemporaries. The history of Czech music is very rich, as I’ve often had occasion to remark, from all those ‘Bohemian’ musicians of the 18th century who made their names in Prague and then in Vienna through to the still vital traditions of the 20th and 21st centuries. There is, I suppose, a ‘first team’ of composers who put modern Czech music on the map from the mid-19th to the mid-20th centuries, and these composers have often featured on this list: Smetana (1824-84), Dvorak (1841-1904), Janacek (1854-1928) and Martinu (1890-1959). But alongside them, there’s a kind of ‘reserve team’, who’ve turned up far less on these pages but whose music is rich with not just local colour but also diverse and interesting ways of ‘accommodating’ those regional strains into the other musical fashions of the age. In this ‘2nd XI’ I’d put people like Fibich (1850-1900), Foerster (1859-1951), Novak (1870-1949), Suk (1874-1935) and Ostracil (1879-1935). I appreciate that not all of those on my second list are what you might call household names, in the canon of classical music, but they’re figures worth focusing on in their own right – starting today with Vítězslav Novák. Novák was born in southern Bohemia, the son of a local doctor, who died when Novák was eleven. Without wanting to overstate things, it appears that this event turned young Vítězslav into a serious and occasionally anxious adolescent, old beyond his years. The family having moved to Prague after his father’s death, young Novák was supposed to study Law at Charles University in Prague, but (a familiar tale) instead spent most of his time studying music at the Prague Conservatory, eventually, in 1891-2, making it into the composition masterclass of Dvorak. However (there’s always a ‘however’!), Novák was prone not just to self-criticism but also periods of depression, and for a while in his mid-twenties it appeared that he might give up music altogether. It was a trip to the isolated region of Moravian Vallachia, in 1896, that was to provide him with a way forward. The area was isolated and impoverished, cut off from the main currents of Czech life – and one consequence of this was that the region’s folk traditions, its music and dances and oral storytelling culture, were maintained in a particularly pure fashion. Novák wasn’t unique in drawing on this vein of indigenous culture – Janacek was another who made field recordings, transcribed songs and dances and fed them into his musical language. For Novák it provided a way forward that wasn’t influenced by Austro-German traditions like the music of Brahms, or even the Czech version of these idioms as they might appear in the music of Dvorak. There were other influences too – for some time around the turn of the 20th century Novák was attracted to the fashion for ‘impressionism’ in music (notably the early works of Debussy), and a little later he fell under the influence of Richard Strauss, which generated from Novák some large-scale orchestral and choral works – but it’s the Moravian/Slovakian stuff that fuelled Novák’s creativity. To conclude the biographical narrative, Novák spent 30 years (1909-38) as Professor at the Prague Conservatory, and then the decade from retirement until his death on 18th July 1949 (75 years ago this coming Thursday) writing both music and his autobiography. These were, as you might understand, years of turbulence in central Europe, but Novák’s main outlet in times of stress seems to have been walking in the mountains on the Bohemian/Moravian border. And that last point brings me neatly to the musical illustration I’ve chosen to demonstrate at least some aspects of Novák’s musical language. His most fertile period compositionally came at the start of the 20th century and up to the outbreak of the First World War. In those years there were big works, lushly scored in a late-Romantic idiom, but instead I want to focus on a suite of short pieces, originally written for piano in early 1903, but orchestrated later that year. This is the rather misleadingly titled ‘Slovak Suite’ – because (particularly now that Slovakia is a separate country distinct from Czechia) the music is not from Slovakia as we know it today, but from the area of eastern Moravia that borders on Slovakia. In old age, Novák wrote in his memoirs, ‘About Myself and Others’, the following observation about life as he spent it in the quiet Moravian village of Javornik: ‘I was sitting outdoors on the logs, watching a picturesque stream of people leaving the church. Suddenly I heard a chorus, that I later inserted into the first movement of the ‘Slovak Suite’. The last movement evokes memories of a beautiful nocturnal mood. Upon returning home through meadows wet with dew, from a distance I heard a tune of longing, sung by a young lover. The fourth movement (‘Village Dancing’) also has its roots near Javornik.’ The suite has five movements, bookended by two longer ones that raise the music from simple, rather naïve depiction of folk practices into something richer, more mystical; between these come three shorter movements, more artless in approach. The first movement is ‘At Church’, which seems to mingle traditions both Catholic (mystical strings, celestial harps) and Protestant (hymn tunes, organ solos). The middle three movements (‘Children’s Scene’, ‘The Lovers’, ‘The Ball’) are rich with secular folkloric ideas, before the final movement (‘The Night’) brings us back to Novák’s great inspiration in all his works, the rich affinity of the relationship between man and nature. There aren’t any video recordings of this work on YouTube, but I’ve come across an interesting Czech TV programme which features a performance of the Slovak Suite, played by the State Philharmonic Orchestra, Brno, conducted by František Jílek. The programme was made in 1966, and consequently it’s richly evocative, in a Soviet-era idiom, of a way of life that, almost 60 years on, feels as though it’s lost forever. You’ll find it here: Novak: Slovak Suite, Op 32
Ockeghem, Johannes (c1410-97)
Day 313: Salve Regina (Time: 9 minutes) and 2. Intemerata Dei Mater (8 minutes)
My choice for today (2/8/22) is the relatively little-known musician Johannes Ockeghem (c1410-97). As a composer, he was a key link in the chain of the ‘Franco-Flemish’ school that flourished for a couple of centuries from Dufay and Binchois in the early 15th century to Lassus and Rogier in the early 17th century. Ockeghem’s dates, as you can see, place him early in that period, but most of his work dates from half a century on from the Dufay I’ll feature next time, 50 years or so in which musical fashions changed quite distinctly. He seems to have been taught by Binchois, and in his turn to have taught Josquin (see Day 218). I’ve been fond of Ockeghem’s music (and the owner of a 5-CD box of his masses!) for many years, and what I like most about his work is the way it sounds fresh and ever so slightly unpredictable, as though one can’t be sure where it will turn next. As the liner notes to that box of CDs puts it, ‘If Ockeghem had set out to write music that would persistently elude modern analysis, he could not have been more successful’. Ockeghem was born in the city of Saint-Ghislain, in what is now Belgium. Virtually nothing is known about him before 1443-4, when he turns up as mentioned in a minor singing role in the cathedral in Antwerp. There followed several positions in establishments in Tours and Paris, including at the French court, but the last 15 years or so of his life are again a bit of a mystery. A reasonable amount of Ockeghem’s music has survived, though as with many of the composers of this period much of the music previously attributed to Ockeghem is now thought to be by other hands. Nevertheless, it seems we can be fairly sure about a dozen or so Masses, a Requiem, and a handful of motets and a couple of dozen chansons, the secular vocal music of the day and a kind of relic of the songs of the troubadours. If I were to stick my neck out, I’d suggest that in the music of Ockeghem, more than any other composer of the 15th century, we can hear the work of someone inspired by a very direct sense of spirituality, at times reflective, at others almost ecstatic. What you don’t get, by and large, are the formulae of Renaissance choral music. There is imitation, where one part copies another, but it’s rare in Ockeghem; occasionally his works employ a ‘cantus firmus’ (a pre-existing melody that forms the basis of a composition) but again it’s much less common than in the work of his peers. Sometimes one is even pushed to identify things like clear cadences or sectional divisions. Instead, his work generates a kind of forward momentum in ways that seemingly happen at random. In order to demonstrate something of the work of this quirky creative mind, I’ve gone for a couple of shorter devotional settings. One uses the ‘Salve Regina’ text, a Marian hymn from, probably, late in the 12th century. It covers familiar territory for Marian texts of this period – an idealisation of Mary as Mother of God, and an appeal to her to intercede on our behalf. Ockeghem’s setting is for a conventional four-part unaccompanied SATB choir. This might sometimes feel like music to lose yourself in, but in particular I’d suggest listening out for the ravishingly beautiful way Ockeghem sets the words ‘O pia! O dulcis!’ towards the end of this work. There a quite a few decent performances on YouTube, but you can’t beat the ever-reliable Ars Nova Copenhagen, directed by Paul Hillier, which you’ll find here: Ockeghem: Salve Regina. Alongside that you might want to consider Ockeghem’s setting of the text ‘Intemerata Dei Mater’. This is a five-part (SATTB) sacred motet based on a relatively obscure Marian text. There is some thought that Ockeghem might have composed this for his own posthumous commemoration. I don’t feel I can do better than to quote again from the liner notes from my CDs of Ockeghem’s sacred music: ‘With its kaleidoscopic treatment of vocal combinations, its often bold and pungent treatment of dissonance, its dark scoring and unerring formal sophistication, ‘Intemerata’ is a magnificent instance of Ockeghem’s art.’ The recording I’ve chosen is by the Minneapolis-based vocal group The Mirandola Ensemble, directed by Scott Sandersfeld, which you’ll find here: Ockeghem: Intemerata Dei Mater
Orbón, Julián (1925-91)
Day 549: Tres Versiones Sinfonicas (Time: 22 minutes)
I’m on the anniversary trail throughout this month, there being no live music in Sheffield until late September, and today (1/8/25) I suspect I’m introducing a new name to almost all of you. This is Julián Orbón, the 100th anniversary of whose birth falls next Thursday, August 7th. Orbón was a new name to me, too, until about six months ago, but although there’s not actually a lot of his music (and even less of it has been performed or recorded) I’m convinced that he is an interesting composer, whose music is well worth our time and attention. At least, that’s what I’ll hope to show… Julián Orbón (1925-91) – actually, to be precise, Julián Orbón de Soto – is usually referred to as a Cuban composer, though he was born in Spain. His father was a composer and teacher, and it was his father’s career that took the family to Cuba when Orbón was thirteen, because Orbón Snr. moved to work at the conservatory in Havana, escaping from the Spanish Civil War. During the 1930s and 40s, there emerged a thriving ‘school’ of Cuban musicians, and Orbón, as an adopted Cuban, formed a significant part of that group. In the later 1930s his father founded the Orbón Conservatory in Havana, and after his father’s death in 1944 Orbón took over the running of the institution, even though he was not yet quite 20 years old. However, shortly after that he won a scholarship to study with Copland at Berkshire Music Centre in Massachusetts, and this was to prove a decisive step in the development of Orbón the composer, because though there are other evident influences that shaped Orbón’s early compositions, such as the music of Manuel de Falla (see Days 154 and 240), it’s the sound world of Aaron Copland (see Days 36, 194 and 271) – particularly the Copland of the ballet music of the late 1930s and early 1940s, ‘Billy the Kid’, ‘Rodeo’ and ‘Appalachian Spring’ – that became the young Orbón’s template, as it were, for his own works. After his study with Copland, Orbón returned to Havana, but he left Cuba for good in 1953 at the outbreak of the Cuban Revolution, becoming a reluctant emigrant for the second time in his life. After a short period living in Mexico, he moved to the USA, where he was permanently based from 1964, settling into a life largely devoted to teaching, leaving relatively little time for composition. That’s a brief sketch of his life. As for his music, there really isn’t much of it to explore at all – around a couple of dozen works in total – and to the best of my knowledge only a handful have made it onto disc. Stylistically, as I’ve said, we have a kind of Spanish/Cuban fusion, overlaid with the ‘wide open spaces’ of Copland’s Americana, but beyond that quite a few other, quirky influences can be discovered. Orbón was very interested in Medieval and Renaissance music, so echoes of Gregorian Chant, or the music of early madrigalists, appear in his compositions also. In later life he developed friendships with Villa-Lobos (Days 293 and 450) and Chavez (Day 487), and consequently you’ll find traces of their music in his works too. All this might make it seem that Orbón wasn’t the most original of composers, but even if you want to regard his as ‘fusion’ music, it’s fusion of a fresh and invigorating sort. His earliest surviving orchestral work is a Symphony in C, dating from 1945, but I can find no trace of this on disc or in performance. However, in the mid-50s a couple of other works appeared, which have fared rather better, and it’s the first of these, the ‘Tres Versiones Sinfónicas’ (literally, ‘Three Symphonic Versions’), that I want to focus on today, to try to persuade you that the music of Orbón is worth your listening time. The work won the Juan Landaeta prize at the Festival de Música Latinoamericana in Caracas, and it was this event that led to Orbón’s meeting with Villa-Lobos. As you might imagine, the Tres Versiones Sinfónicas is a work in three movements, whose titles – ‘Pavana’, ‘Organum’ and ‘Xilofono’ – suggest at least a little of their intentions. The first movement is based on a pavane for the vihuela (a Spanish instrument that’s a kind of cross between a guitar and a lute) by the Renaissance composer Luis de Milán. This starts in a sombre, graceful fashion, before metamorphosing into a more vigorous (and Copland-style) celebration. The second movement takes us back even further for its starting point, in a melismatic (that is, where a syllable is stretched over several sung notes – think of the vocal style of Morrissey from The Smiths, if that helps!) vocal work by the 12th century composer Pérotin. It’s a largely solemn, contemplative movement, and to my ears at least it seems to point to a more distinct and private voice, rather than the ‘outdoor’ music of the first and third movements. The finale is a virile, Afro-Caribbean dance based on a traditional tune which features, as you might expect, a starring turn for the xylophone player. This description of the work might suggest why ‘Versions’ appears in the title: these aren’t narrow arrangements of previously existing music, or even variations on themes, but rather re-composed, re-imagined ‘versions’ of the originals. And I think the word ‘Symphonic’ in the title is key here, not just in the way it signals Orbón’s virtuoso exploitation of the symphony orchestra, but the way it reveals his creative, cohesive exploration of his starting material. The Tres Versiones Sinfónicas is one of the few works by Orbón that YouTube features in a video recording of a concert performance. The video isn’t the best in terms of visual quality, but the orchestra – the Simon Bolivar Symphony Orchestra of Venezuela – is on lively form, conducted by Andrés Ascanio. You’ll find it here: Orbon: Tres Versiones Sinfonicas
Paganini, Niccolo (1782-1840)
Day 105: Caprice No 24 for Solo Violin (Time: 5 minutes)
Today (28/7/20), we reach Day 105 of the grand old St Tim’s Classical Music Playlist, and it’s time to plug yet another gap in the list of composers to have graced our shared company. Niccolo Paganini (1782-1840) occupies a curious position in musical history. His birthdate, you’ll note, puts him somewhere between Beethoven and Schubert, and so one might anticipate compositions sitting firmly in the style of the late ‘classical’ period. But in practice, he has far more in common with the virtuoso showmen (predictably, they were all men, it appears) of the subsequent era of Romantic performers. Paganini is to the violin what Liszt is to the piano. His career as a travelling virtuoso began in his early 20s, and he appears never to have been shy about displaying the technical skills he’d developed. He also appears to have enjoyed the lifestyle that went with the reputation, and his late career decline seems to have been a consequence of a life of, shall we say, over-indulgence in the whole ‘sex’n’drugs’n’rock’n’roll’ milieu. There is a presumably spurious association with the occult in his posthumous reputation (only someone in cahoots with the devil could play the violin thus, etc.) but his professional relationships, notably with Rossini and especially Berlioz, have more to do, I’m sure, with the sort of music he composed. He is remembered these days for a handful of violin concertos that exist as vehicles to show off the soloist’s skills, but also for his 24 Caprices for Solo Violin, Op 1. These exist as a sort of compendium of finely wrought and highly diverse miniatures, and (for me, anyway) they stay safely on the right side of being illustrations of merely superficial display, even though they are all monstrously difficult to play. Of the 24 Caprices, the most famous is undoubtedly the last one, the basis for sets of variations from many gifted composers (and Andrew Lloyd Webber) over the years. It’s both stunningly challenging and yet also an earworm of exceptional persistence. There are a number of fine recordings of it on YouTube, but I’ve gone for the one by Maxim Vengerov, even though the camera operator spends far too long getting the ‘view up the soloist’s nostrils’ angle for my liking. You’ll find it here: Paganini – Caprice No 24 for Solo Violin
Palestrina, Giovanni Pierluigi da (c1525-94)
Day 148: Missa - Hodie Christus natus est (Time: 3+24 minutes)
I hope the pieces selected for today’s 8th instalment in this Advent/Christmas series reflect in some measure the sense of joy associated with the occasion. Today, then – Christmas Day 2020 – music by one of the greats of Renaissance choral music, Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina (c1525-94). Palestrina is curious in that he is known now not by his surname but by his place of birth, Palestrina, a city to the east of Rome. (It’s a bit like finding William Walton of Oldham thereafter referred to as ‘Oldham’.) His birthdate isn’t certain, but what is clear is that from a relatively young age, he held prominent positions in churches in both Palestrina and Rome, notably a spell of more than two decades as musical director at the Julian Chapel at St Peter’s Basilica in Rome. As a composer, he was prolific, leaving at his death over 100 masses and over 300 motets, amongst a great deal else. Stylistically, Palestrina’s work is usually seen, along with the music of Victoria and Lassus, as marking the high point of 16th century sacred composition. Unlike, say, pieces by composers of the previous generations (such as Mouton – see Day 144 – or Josquin) Palestrina’s work sounds rather more ‘smooth’ and fluid. There are dissonances, but they tend not to be prominent in his compositions, so the overall effect is quite homogenous. He was incredibly popular during his lifetime, and continued to exert a strong influence over subsequent composers long after his death. There is a view, treated quite cautiously these days, that sees Palestrina as ‘the saviour of [Catholic] church music’, in that after the Council of Trent (minimal definition: a meeting of top brass of the Catholic church (1545-63) after the Protestant Reformation, to which it was in effect the Catholic church’s response) there was a perceived need for greater clarity and simplicity in church music, making it easier for participants in church services to hear and understand the texts being sung. For today, I’ve chosen two linked pieces of music by Palestrina. Firstly, his motet ‘Hodie Christus Natus Est’. A minimal translation of the text might be: Today Christ is born, Today the Saviour has appeared, Today on Earth the angels sing, and archangels rejoice, Today the just exalt, saying Glory to God in the highest, Alleluia. Palestrina writes for eight-part choir, but what makes the piece so engaging is that interspersed with the traditional text are cries of ‘Noe, noe!’ (‘Noel, Noel’), so that there is a lovely contrast between the slow-moving solemnity of the celebration of Christ’s birth set against the joyful cries of ‘Noe’, with which the piece comes to an end. Alongside this motet, I’ve chosen the mass setting ‘Hodie Christus Natus Est’. This is what is known in technical terms as a ‘parody mass’, which might need a little explanation, because this isn’t the modern meaning of ‘parody’, which nowadays means a generally mocking imitation of something else, usually for satirical purposes. A parody mass, rather, was a mass setting that employed a previously existing piece of music, which might be sacred (an extract from a motet, say) or secular (like a popular song). These mass settings were very popular in the 16th century, though settings using secular melodies as inspiration fell foul of the Council of Trent and so tended to die out in the later 16th century. Palestrina’s mass ‘Hodie Christus Natus Est’ is a parody mass because it uses the motet I’ve just discussed as its starting and finishing point. Sometimes Palestrina only uses the motet’s material loosely, but the opening Kyrie, for instance, starts with the same music that opens the motet, and the Kyrie movement makes a lot of use of the ‘Noe, noe!’ figure. All the movements of the mass except the Agnus Dei end, as the motet does, with the rather lively, boisterous triple-time section that celebrates Noel.
There are quite a few performances of both these works on YouTube, but I reckon you can’t beat The Sixteen, conducted by Harry Christophers, in this sort of repertoire. So you’ll find them performing the motet here: Palestrina: Motet - Hodie Christus natus est (3 minutes), and the mass setting here: Palestrina: Missa - Hodie Christus natus est (24 minutes).
Day 527: Missa Papae Marcelli (Time: 37 minutes)
Today (31/1/25), I want to celebrate a major work by a composer whose 500th
birthday might (we should be cautious here) be due to be celebrated this coming Monday,
3rd Feb.
The composer in question is Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina. Most references
to his dates of birth and death hedge a bit when it comes to the details.
He may have been born on 3rd February 1525 – and if that’s the case he is
indeed 500 years old (if you see what I mean) next week. On the other hand,
it’s quite possible that he was born at some stage in the 12 months that followed,
that is, at any point up to 2nd Feb 1526. However, the earlier date
is the one most commonly referenced, so that’s why he’s on your playlist today.
His date of death is more precise: 2nd Feb 1594
(so, probably, the day before his 69th birthday).
In the end, these details don’t matter all that much (though I’m sure they
mattered to Palestrina at the time!!), and these days, when Palestrina’s
reputation as one of the leading composers of the Renaissance era is entirely
secure, it’s the music that we tend to focus on. Palestrina has only
appeared once before on this list – see Day 148 for his Motet and subsequent
Mass ‘Hodie Christus Natus Est’ – so his 500th ‘birthday’ is a
reasonable excuse to explore at least a little more of his vast output.
In fact, I’m going to focus on just one work, a mass setting that has become,
probably, Palestrina’s most famous (out of the over 100 such settings by him
that have survived), his ‘Missa Papae Marcelli’. It’s not necessarily
obvious why this particular setting should outshine all the others (to the
point where there are more than two dozen recordings of it available at the
present time), except that it has found itself caught up in a degree of
myth-making that doesn’t necessarily accord with what we know (or scholars of
the period tell us) about its context. So, very briefly indeed, the mass
was composed in honour of (or, perhaps – ambiguity again – composed retrospectively
in commemoration of the memory of) Pope Marcellus II. He was head of the
Catholic church for all of three weeks in 1555. Quite possibly a figure
who occupied his position for a mere 22 days wouldn’t be remembered at all now
were it not for this music that bears his name. He became Pope during the
meetings of the Council of Trent (1545-63), which (Ladybird Book of Church
History definition coming up) was the extended discussion by Catholic ‘top
brass’ over how to respond to the Europe-wide rise of Protestant
churches. This years-long conflab debated many things, but one – the
place of music in the Catholic church, and the style it should adopt – featured
towards the end of the meetings of the council. Over-simplifying again,
two things were at the centre of the discussion: the need to persuade composers
not to create ‘parody masses’ (that is, where the key musical themes of the
mass might be based on secular songs – particularly popular ditties about
drinking and sex, which existed then, as now!) and also to persuade composers
to write music in which the text would be audible and intelligible to
listeners. And – for the ‘Missa Papae Marcelli’ – this is where the truth
gets harder to separate from fiction. If you know anything of Pfitzner’s
opera ‘Palestrina’ (and don’t feel bad if you don’t!), you’ll know that it
turns on a performance of this Palestrina mass setting in the papal chapel,
which astonished and impressed the powers that be by both its beauty and its
immediate intelligibility. This is because Palestrina’s style in this
mass is, by the standards of the age, simple and declamatory, and consequently
it was deemed that polyphonic writing could in fact be intelligible to its
listeners if the composer paid sufficient attention to the setting of the words
and didn’t indulge in florid ornamentation that might obscure them. It’s
worth saying again that there is no evidence in historical records that the
Council of Trent had any intention of banning polyphony entirely, nor that this
Palestrina mass was the thing that might have caused that not to happen.
So, what we’re left with is, I’m afraid, a bit of a non-story (‘Famous
Palestrina Mass Turns Out to have been Not That Important After All’ as the
shouty newspaper headline might have had it) – but we are still left with the
music … which is, not to put too fine a point on it, quite beautiful. It
has the conventional movements of its age – Kyrie, Gloria, Credo, Sanctus and
Benedictus, and Agnus Dei – and it’s mostly set for six voice parts (one soprano
line, one alto line, two split tenor lines and two split bass lines) apart from
the Agnus Dei, which expands to a seven-part texture, and which gives the
impression of being ‘brighter’ by splitting every part except the tenor line,
so that there are more interweaving soprano and alto lines. I’ve come to
the conclusion that not many of you would welcome a complex musical analysis of
this piece, so I’m going to skip all that. Suffice it to say that the
opening ‘Kyrie’ makes extensive use of imitative patterns in the various vocal
lines, and the same is true to an extent when we get to the final movement, the
pair of settings of the ‘Agnus Dei’. But between these, most of the rest
of the music is much simpler in style, so that the words are pretty much clearly
audible throughout, and each new line of text is highlighted by being given to
a new combination of voices. It’s also worth saying that this setting
(like so much of Palestrina’s music) is very sparing in its use of dissonance,
so there are only rare moments when the lines ‘clash’ with each other.
It’s this that makes Palestrina (unlike, say, famous contemporaries like
Victoria) sound so ‘sweet’ rather than dark and brooding.
For a performance, it’s hard to find a video recording of the complete mass that
doesn’t grate on repeated hearing, so we’re in audio-only territory today.
From the options, I’ve gone for this performance by the Tallis Scholars,
directed by Peter Phillips, which you’ll find here (though you do get some nice
Renaissance paintings to look at while you listen):
Palestrina: Missa Papae Marcelli
Parry, Hubert (1848-1918)
Day 317: Symphonic Variations (Time: 14 minutes)
This week, our location is ‘the land without music’. Although that quotation has been attributed to a number of people, I think it’s the case that it was coined by a German music critic, one Oscar Schmitz, in 1904. And the nation the jibe was aimed at? Great Britain. In some ways, one might argue that the claim was nonsense – after all, all the various nations that make up Great Britain had and have thriving indigenous musical traditions (‘folk music’, if you like) – but if, as was intended, the comment is seen to reflect the glaring absence of major British composers on the European scene, then yes, one could argue that Britain was indeed ‘a land without music’. After the death of Purcell in 1695, one has to wait a long time for a native British composer to make a significant impression on the historical map of classical music. (Handel was of course German, though he ‘became’ British, by royal decree, in 1727.) However, this week I want to consider two composers who played a significant part in establishing the conditions in which British composers could flourish. One of them has a 175th ‘birthday’ at the end of this week; the other, the focus for today (16/8/22), is the composer of, amongst other things, that great hymn tune and substitute national anthem, ‘Jerusalem’. Hubert Parry (1848-1918) – or Sir Charles Hubert Hastings Parry, and in fact 1st Baronet Parry of Highnam Court (Gloucestershire) from 1902 onwards – is one of a handful of composers, teachers and administrators who, in the latter half of the 19th century, began the work that led to the regeneration of ‘classical music’ by composers born and trained here, as opposed to just being shipped in from abroad. His name tends these days to be coupled with that of Charles Villiers Stanford (see Day 302), and there is a sense in which these two were rivals as much as colleagues. Born into a financially secure family (his father’s inherited wealth permitted the purchase of the 17th century pile, Highnam Court, in the 1830s), Parry had, in some ways, a privileged upbringing, though seemingly also a rather solitary one. He seems to have been naturally musical. Whilst still a pupil at Eton, he successfully sat the B Mus exam at Oxford, the then youngest person ever to have done so. There was family pressure to study Law, not Music, Parry being intended for a career in commerce, and indeed after Oxford he worked at Lloyds of London through most of the 1870s, seemingly hating it but trying not to disappoint his domineering father. Nevertheless he continued to study music and to compose. Gradually music took over. He became assistant editor of Grove’s Dictionary of Music in 1875, and Professor of Composition at the newly-formed Royal College of Music in 1883. He succeeded George Grove as Director of the RCM in 1895 and remained as its head until he died. He is, therefore, in many ways the ‘father’ (or at least, with Stanford and Sir Alexander Mackenzie – more of the latter on Friday – one of the fathers) of the great generation of composers that followed. Parry’s pupils included Vaughan Williams, Ireland, Bridge and Holst. All this might make him renowned as a teacher and administrator rather than as a composer, and it’s true that during his lifetime, his compositions were regarded as being secondary to his educational role. Some critics – notably George Bernard Shaw – were splendidly rude about Parry’s (and Stanford’s) compositional skills. Like Stanford, Parry was a devout admirer of German music, and that of Brahms in particular. Some of the following generation of British composers (Delius and Bax, for instance) held this against him, caricaturing his music as second-rate and his attitudes to music as trapped in the past. These days, when more of Parry’s music is being recorded and performed, there’s a better sense of his qualities as a composer: ‘traditional’, perhaps, but with his own distinctive voice. He is probably best known for choral music – not just ‘Jerusalem’ and the anthem ‘I was Glad’, but mainstays of amateur choirs like ‘Blest Pair of Sirens’ and the ‘Songs of Farewell’. There are also five symphonies which are well worth seeking out, along with some excellent chamber music (piano trios and string quartets). The piece I thought I’d explore today as a taster of Parry the orchestral composer is his ‘Symphonic Variations’. An obvious inspiration for the work is Brahms’ ‘Haydn Variations’ (see Day 279), but also Dvorak’s ‘Symphonic Variations’ – Dvorak’s music was immensely popular in Victorian England. Parry’s work dates from 1897, and was first performed that year conducted by Parry himself. ‘The band played up like bricks and it went capitally,’ he said afterwards, in that characteristically British establishment sort of way! It’s a set of 27 variations on an original theme, and the ‘symphonic’ aspect of the title highlights the way Parry creates a structure for the piece that gives it characteristics of symphonic form (with associated changes of key, tempo and organisation) rather than being just simply episodic. The 27 variations are organised into four ‘movements’ following the pattern of a symphony: the theme and variations 1 through 11 (E major and E minor) form the first ‘movement’; variations 13 to 18 (C major) constitute a ‘scherzo’; variations 19 to 23 (A minor) form the ‘slow movement’; and variations 24 through 27 (back in the main key of E major) make up a ‘finale’ in which the main theme returns to form an eloquent conclusion. As for a performance, I’ve chosen one by a not terribly well-known orchestra, the Argovia Philharmonic (the orchestra of the Aargau region of Switzerland), directed by the British conductor Douglas Bostock. You’ll find their performance here: Parry: Symphonic Variations
Day 357: Blest Pair of Sirens (Time: 10 minutes) and I was Glad (5 minutes)
Today (24/2/23), I’m marking the arrival in this world of Hubert Parry (Sir Charles Hubert Hastings Parry), who was born on 27th Feb 1848, thus making this coming Monday his 175th anniversary. He’s appeared just the once on this playlist to date – see Day 317, for his Symphonic Variations – so I thought that this time rather than go for something off the beaten track I’d select pieces that are, alongside Parry’s setting of ‘Jerusalem’, probably his most popular compositions. Although he wrote a considerable amount of orchestral and chamber music, Parry’s enduring reputation is as a choral composer. In particular, Parry’s works in this vein have attached themselves firmly to state occasions, particularly ceremonial events such as royal weddings. If you have even a passing acquaintance with the Last Night of the Proms, you’ll know that Parry’s setting of the words to Blake’s poem ‘Jerusalem’ is a regular fixture on that evening, and though I’m not at all sure what Blake, that radical republican, would have made of all the patriotic tub-thumping and Union Jack-waving that goes on, there’s no denying that Parry’s tune taps into something quite profound in the national psyche, which is why the work has in many ways become a kind of unofficial national anthem. However, I thought that today, I’d sidestep recordings of ‘Jerusalem’ and head instead for two examples of Parry the writer of choral anthems, pieces that are not just widely performed on big occasions but also in the repertoire of many an amateur choir up and down the country. (I’ve sung both of them with Escafeld Chorale here in Sheffield within the past ten years.) First, consider a setting of Milton from 1887, ‘Blest Pair of Sirens’. ‘At a Solemn Musick’, the poem Parry uses, isn’t one of Milton’s major works, though it has all the characteristics of his verse style, notably the rather high-flown rhetorical language and incredible complexity of grammar. (It’s worth noting that in a poem of 28 lines, the first sentence is 24 lines long!) The poem, which Parry sets in its entirety, celebrates the experience of listening to great poetry set to music, an experience likened in the poem to listening to the music of heaven itself. The basic image of the poem depicts two Sirens of Greek myth (‘harmonious Sisters, Voice and Vers(e)’) drawing us to a state of rapture with their utterance. Parry’s setting, for eight-part choir, was written in 1887, at which point he wasn’t yet an established composer, though he had recently become Professor of Composition at the RCM. The work was a great success, and has remained a regular feature in concerts, both professional and amateur, ever since. The review of the first performance in The Times was enthusiastic: ‘The choral writing is in eight parts and abounds in contrapuntal devices. At the same time the spirit and the accent of the words are carefully attended to, as befits a work in which "sphere-born harmonious sisters, voice and verse" are invoked to "wed their divine sounds, and mix'd power employ". An excellent rendering contributed to the brilliant success of the ode.’ As I observed earlier, these works of Parry’s have often been performed on royal occasions, and ‘Blest Pair of Sirens’ turned up at the wedding of Prince William and the then Catherine Middleton in 2011, for example. As for a performance, I’ve gone for music-making on an epic scale here, as on this video the late, great choral conductor Sir David Willcocks directs the massed voices of the combined National Youth Choirs of Great Britain (along with former students), with David Hill at the organ. You’ll find the performance here: Parry: Blest Pair of Sirens. Alongside that piece, I thought it would be pleasing to have another of Parry’s popular anthems, ‘I was Glad’. This is a setting of words from Psalm 122, which found liturgical use in the Church of England after its inclusion in the 1662 Book of Common Prayer. There are other notable settings of these words, which in some form have been sung at the coronation of every British monarch since Charles I in 1625 (Purcell and Boyce spring to mind, among Parry’s predecessors), but these days it is Parry’s version that tends to be performed to the exclusion of all others. In fact, Parry selects only verses 1-3, and 6-7: ‘I was glad when they said unto me: We will go into the house of the Lord. Our feet shall stand in thy gates, O Jerusalem. Jerusalem is built as a city, that is at unity in itself. [Vivat Rex…/Regina…! Vivat! Vivat! Vivat!] O pray for the peace of Jerusalem; they shall prosper that love thee. Peace be within thy walls, and plenteousness within thy palaces.’ (The ‘Vivat!’ interpolation is a convention dating back to the coronation of James II in 1685: ‘Vivat Rex…’ or ‘Long live King…’ to indicate the acclamation of the new sovereign, and these lines have been included at coronations since. The concert performance I’ve chosen here naturally omits them.) The work begins and ends with music of great ceremony, enclosing a gentler middle section, ‘O pray for the peace of Jerusalem’. Back to royal events again, this piece by Parry was also performed at the wedding of the now Wessexes (obviously they, or possibly their advisors, were evidently great fans of Parry’s music), and also, back in the heady days of the early 1980s, at the wedding of the then Prince Charles and Lady Diana Spencer. After the cast of thousands in my recording of ‘Blest Pair of Sirens’, I’ve gone for something a little more restrained here, albeit restraint with an American accent, in a performance by the A Cappella Choir of the University of North Texas, directed by Allen Hightower, and a sadly anonymous organist. You’ll find this version here: Parry: I was Glad
Pärt, Arvo (b1935)
Day 33: ‘Spiegel im Spiegel’ (Time: 9 minutes)
Today (24/4/20), a suggestion from Malcolm, and one that I wholeheartedly endorse, because I love this music, and I’ve owned the very recording in question since it came out over 20 years ago. The composer here is Arvo Part, and the music is the mesmeric and serene ‘Spiegel im Spiegel’ (literally ‘mirror(s) in the mirror’). Part started life as a composer employing serialist techniques, and his earlier work is rather indigestible, but denunciation by Soviet officialdom (Latvia at that point being under the control of Soviet communism) led to a crisis both musically and spiritually. In 1972, he converted from Lutheranism to Orthodox Christianity, and he re-emerged from a period of silence as a composer in 1976 with a wholly new (and resonantly old!) compositional technique, of which ‘Spiegel im Spiegel’ is a perfect example. He called it ‘tintinnabulation’, where fragments of sound and melody echo and recur like the ringing of bells. The recording Malcolm has chosen is by the recently (and surely too early) retired Tasmin Little, accompanied by Martin Roscoe. You’ll find it here: Arvo Part – ‘Spiegel im Spiegel’
Day 83: ‘Cantus in Memoriam Benjamin Britten’ (Time: 7 minutes)
Today (13/6/20), we have a suggestion from Malcolm for another composition by the Estonian Arvo Pärt. He has featured on this list before (see Day 33, above) so I won’t repeat all the biographical stuff, except to say that Pärt was particularly affected by the news of Britten’s death in 1976, and the result was today’s selection, the ‘Cantus in Memoriam Benjamin Britten’. The piece is scored for string orchestra and a single bell,which sounds the note A. In effect, the piece is a canon (in which a melodic line is then repeated by other ‘voices’ in turn), but a very specific form of canon (a ‘prolation canon’ for those who like the nerdy details), in which those repetitions of the initial phrase happen at different speeds compared to the original. There are in effect two things going on in this piece – some of the strings are playing a descending A Minor scale at different paces and starting at different times, whilst others are playing notes from an A Minor chord (A-C-E), again at different paces and starting at different times. Against this ‘wash’ of string patterns, the tubular bell intones its funereal lament. The result is hypnotic and hauntingly beautiful. The piece is, as its title suggests, a meditation on death. The piece starts in silence (there are three bars of silence marked in the score before the first note is sounded) and ends with the dying away into silence of the final striking of the bell. If you like the idea of being dazzled by musical science, you could consider that although the whole piece has been in A Minor (the A Minor scale and the A Minor chord as its constituent parts), the last tolling of the A on the bell generates ‘overtones’ that resonate alongside the pure note A … and the fourth ‘overtone’ is not the note C but actually C#, which means that there’s a very subtle sense that we end not in A Minor (A-C-E), but in A Major (A-C#-E). There is a hint, though no more than a hint, of resurrection! The performance Malcolm suggests we listen to is taken from the same 2010 BBC Proms concert that turned up yesterday, in which the BBC Symphony Orchestra is conducted by Edward Gardiner. You’ll find it here: Arvo Pärt – ‘Cantus in Memoriam Benjamin Britten’
Day 249: Sieben Magnificat-Antiphonen (Time: 13 minutes)
If you have an idle hour or two and you browse through the postings on this playlist, some patterns begin to emerge. One such recurs today (14/12/21): the music of Arvo Pärt (b1935) has been requested three times, including today’s suggestion, and all of them have come from Malcolm. I’m not complaining, of course – of all contemporary composers, I think Pärt lays some claim to being the most profoundly contemplative, and I suspect that’s true regardless of whether one shares his faith-based world view or not. There’s a lovely quotation from Steve Reich, who says of Pärt and his music, ‘He's completely out of step with the ‘zeitgeist’ and yet he's enormously popular, which is so inspiring. His music fulfils a deep human need which has nothing to do with fashion.’ I’ve written about the background to Pärt's adoption of his mature compositional style before (see Days 33 and 83), so I won’t repeat much of the context, but it’s worth noting that initially Pärt’s mature fame rested on a range of instrumental works (Spiegel im Spiegel, Tabula Rasa, Cantus in Memoriam Benjamin Britten, and so on), but he has produced many substantial works for choirs over the past four decades, and these are beginning to establish themselves in the repertoire of ensembles across the world. If you like today’s suggestion, you might want to go on to explore pieces like his Berliner Messe, or his St John Passion, or – on a smaller scale – his Magnificat. The work Malcolm has suggested for today is a kind of adjunct to that last piece. It is his ‘Seven Magnificat Antiphons’. These treatments of the ‘O’ Antiphons date from 1988, and were revised again in 1991; they were written for the RIAS Chamber Choir, Berlin, where Pärt had been living since his exile from Soviet-controlled Estonia in 1982. The settings are in German for this reason. We’ve encountered one of the ‘O’ Antiphons on this list before – James MacMillan’s ‘O Radiant Dawn’ back on Day 142 – but this composition by Pärt sets all seven of these short texts. The ‘O’ Antiphons date from as far back as the mid-500s A.D. and form a series of names for or attributes of Christ (‘O Root of Jesse’, ‘O Key of David’, ‘O Dayspring’, etc.). In Catholic traditions, it has been conventional to sing or recite them as part of the liturgy at Vespers on the seven days 17th-23rd December. Pärt’s settings are – within the broad characteristics of his music as a whole – quite diverse and contrasting. I wrote back on Day 247 about the ‘patterned’ nature of Bach’s structure in his Magnificat in D. One might say the same about Pärt here. The work is scored for the standard SATB choir, except for the second antiphon (‘O Adonai’), for tenor and bass only, and the third (‘O Spross aus Isais Wurzel’), for soprano and alto only. Tonally speaking, the piece is rooted in A Major, the key in which the first antiphon (‘O Weisheit’), the fourth and middle antiphon (‘O Schlüssel Davids’), and the last (‘O Immanuel’) are heard. The second and third antiphons are in F# Minor and C# Minor respectively, a third below and above A; the fifth (‘O Morgenstern’) and sixth (‘O König aller Völker’) are in E Major/Minor and D Minor respectively, thus a fifth above and below the central key. None of this needs matter in terms of your listening pleasure, but it’s a mark of how the music is conceptually as well as ‘emotionally’ constructed. As for a performance, I’ve chosen this video by the Warsaw Philharmonic Choir, directed by Bartosz Michalowski. I find watching it incredibly poignant – the choir and conductor go through the normal rituals of concert life, bowing to the audience before and after the performance, even though we are in the desolate world of December 2020, when all such musical experiences were ‘virtual’ only. You’ll find it here: Pärt: Sieben Magnificat-Antiphonen
Pejacevic, Dora (1885-1923)
Day 413: Symphony in F# Minor (1st movement) (Time: 15 minutes) and Piano Sonata in Ab, Op57 (12 minutes)
The reason for highlighting the work of Dora Pejačević
back in March this year, had I done so, would have been because March 5th
marked the centenary of her death.
Pejačević (1885-1923) is a composer associated with a number of
‘firsts’ – the first Croatian composer of any note, the first Croatian composer
of a symphony, and so on – and that’s before we recognise that, even in the
early 20th century, being a composer and a woman was to exist on an
unequal playing field. It helped, of course, that Pejačević was
from an aristocratic family, and there is undoubtedly a sense in which that
privilege afforded her opportunities that might not otherwise have come her way
– though the impact of the First World War on her world view did a great deal
to shape her thinking in ways that disowned the rewards associated with that
privilege. In a world of formalities she was actually Countess Maria
Theodora Paulina Pejačević. The ‘Croatian’ label is both
helpful and misleading. In the late 19th century the lands of
eastern Europe, including the Balkans, were mostly part of the vast, rather
sclerotic Austro-Hungarian empire, and Croatia as an independent country as we
know it today didn’t exist. She was born in Budapest (which might make
her seem ‘Hungarian’) to Count Theodor Pejačević – who would
subsequently become ‘Ban’ (‘Governor’) of Croatia, Slavonia and Dalmatia in the
years before 1914 – and a Hungarian Countess, Lilla Vay de Vaya, who was a
gifted pianist and singer, and whose encouragement meant that young Dora was
able to immerse herself in music as she was growing up. In her youth she
lived in a castle (like you do) in Našice, a town in what is now eastern
Croatia. She seems to have had a remarkably independent spirit, and was
immensely well-read. In a letter written just before her death she
commented on the literally hundreds and hundreds of books she had read, on
history, philosophy, science, music, politics and so on, and she was evidently
more than a mere dilettante when it came to translating her beliefs into lived
action. In another letter she wrote, ‘I don't understand how one can live
without work... However, it's true that I don't align with members of my social
class; in everything, I seek substance and value, and neither norms nor traditions
nor lineage can blind me with sand in my eyes.’ It was the First World
War that transformed her most, however. She worked as a paramedic, and
her experiences gave her a much darker view of the human psyche, and life in
general. To complete her brief life story, in late 1921 she married an
Austrian military officer, and in March 1923 she died of sepsis following the
birth of their first child, at the age of only 37. As a composer she was
largely self-taught, and her early works are largely songs and solo piano
pieces. Initially they show the influence of Mendelssohn, Schumann and
Grieg, but in the years leading up to 1914 you can hear more obviously late
Romantic complexities emerging. The major orchestral and chamber works
mostly date from during and after the First World War. There’s not a lot
of orchestral music: a Piano Concerto of 1913 (another Croatian ‘first’), a
Phantaisie Concertante for piano and orchestra of 1919, a concert Overture from
the same year, and a Symphony in F# Minor, written initially in 1916-17 but
revised in 1920. The ’40 minute rule’ doesn’t allow me to choose it all,
though I’ve gone for a video recording of the whole piece, so there’s nothing
to stop you sneakily watching the rest of it, even though I’m concentrating only
on the first movement. It opens dramatically, almost forbiddingly, and
the whole movement ebbs and flows with tension and release, richly
orchestrated. There are formal, structural patterns observed in the
movement’s development, but there’s almost continuous transformation which
makes the movement both exciting and dramatic, culminating in a coda that
brings Mahler to mind for me. The recording I’ve chosen is a video of a
concert given by the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Jader Bignamini.
If you’re sticking strictly to the first movement, it ends at about 14'40"
(though do feel free to carry on!).
You’ll find it here:
Pejacevic: Symphony in F# Minor (1st movement).
Alongside that work, though, I thought I’d offer you a taste of
Pejačević’s mature piano music.
In the years after the First World War, there are still sets of short, often
whimsical, piano works, but also examples of larger, more complex structures.
One such is her final work for piano, her Piano Sonata No 2 in Ab, which dates from 1921.
She had written a rather more conventional three-movement sonata back in 1914,
but the later work, in a single movement, is an altogether more turbulent affair.
It seems to me to show the influence of Liszt in its ‘fantasia’-like form,
though like late Brahms there’s continuous transformation of themes, subtly altering
and developing them as the movement progresses.
It may last under 12 minutes, but it’s a work of great
density and richness. In my opinion, it’s a real gem.
You’ll find it played here (audio only, I’m afraid) by Nataša Veljković:
Pejacevic: Piano Sonata in Ab, Op 57
Pergolesi, Giovanni (1710-36)
Day 17: ‘Stabat Mater Dolorosa’ (from ‘Stabat Mater’) (Time: 4 minutes)
Pergolesi (1710-36) is one of the great ‘might have beens’ of 18th century Italian music. Had he not been cut down in his mid-20s by tuberculosis, who knows what might have been achieved? As it is, we are left with a handful of works, largely in the realms of opera and sacred music, on which to base any claim to greatness, and of these there is no doubt that his ‘Stabat Mater’ is his most popular. He composed it during his final illness, in a monastery in Pozzuoli, on the outskirts of Naples, and, it is said, completed it only days before he died. So, as this is Holy Week the choice for today (8/4/20) is another dip into the popular end of the Baroque repertoire. I’ve chosen the first movement (‘Stabat Mater Dolorosa’) from Pergolesi’s ‘Stabat Mater’. The performance I’ve chosen, from the Academy of Ancient Music under Richard Egarr, and with a countertenor, Tim Mead singing one of the solo lines (alongside soprano Keri Fuge), is a bit brisker and less ‘swoony’ than older performances were wont to be, but I hope you find its clashing and resolving harmonies as moving as I do. You’ll find the recording here: Giovanni Pergolesi – ‘Stabat Mater Dolorosa’ (from ‘Stabat Mater’)
Pfitzner, Hans (1869-1949)
Day 482: Cello Concerto in G, Op 42 (Time: 15 minutes)
Today (21/5/24), it’s the turn of a composer whose reputation has taken something of a bashing over the decades since his death, though maybe now we’re far enough away from the bad stuff to have a bit more of a perspective on his music. Tomorrow will mark the 75th anniversary of the death of Hans Pfitzner, so he’s the focus of this posting. Hans Erich Pfitzner (1869-1949) was not an easy person to warm to. In fact, even during his lifetime – and before we get into any murky waters in terms of his relationship with the Nazis in the 1930s and 40s – he was rarely discussed by other musicians or music administrators without some kind of disparaging remark about his character being voiced along the way. Some people, let’s face it, are just hard to find sympathetic. Pfitzner seems to have been such a guy. What I’d hope my musical choice for today might show is that bad-tempered and narcissistic or not, he wrote music that’s eminently listenable to and in some cases really very impressive. If he’s famous at all today, it’s for his 1917 opera ‘Palestrina’, but there’s much more to him than that. He was actually born in Moscow, where his father was working as an orchestral musician, but he and his German parents moved back (to Frankfurt) before Pfitzner was two years old, and he always saw himself as 100% German. After a conventional musical upbringing he had a range of lower-ranking jobs, mostly in opera houses, before his first significant appointment, as director of the opera house and music conservatory in Strasbourg, just before he turned 40. At the time (1909), the province of Alsace was under German control, but the Treaty of Versailles of 1919 that officially divided the spoils of the First World War handed Alsace to the French, and Pfitzner lost everything – job, home, professional standing – leaving him bankrupt and with virtually no options at the age of 50. Whatever happened after that could, without special pleading, be seen as a consequence of this trauma. Within the next decade his wife died and his son contracted meningitis, consequently needing permanent medical care. Pfitzner became not just bitter and sarcastic in his dealings with others, not just angry that his feelings of entitlement (to a position of status and the income to match it) were crushed, but in need of people to blame. It is around this time that he first came into contact with Hitler (apparently in 1923 Hitler visited him in hospital where he’d undergone a gall bladder operation) and the evolving Nazi machine. However, seemingly even the Nazis didn’t rate him (there was always some doubt – though in truth there’s nothing to the rumour – about whether Pfitzner had Jewish ancestry) and Pfitzner found himself rebuffed over and over again for positions of power and musical influence under the Nazis, even though he displayed a naïve enthusiasm to engage with their propaganda. (Naivety seems the key here: otherwise, why tell his Nazi masters that he wouldn’t write new music for Shakespeare’s ‘A Midsummer Night’s Dream’ because who could ever write better music than Mendelssohn did?) Effectively by the mid-1930s, Pfitzner was in a state of semi-official retirement. By 1945, he was homeless again (his home destroyed by Allied bombardment) and mentally ill. He spent the final four years of his life in an old people’s home in Salzburg, where he died. So, not a very laudable life – but what of the music? Pfitzner was definitely a conservative, musically. He rejected totally ‘modernism’ in music, and his language is, by and large, a kind of late Romantic vocabulary, essentially tonal, and looking back to Bach as the foundation stone of Western music. Since the 1950s, and after the ban on his music being performed was lifted, there has been a kind of halting rehabilitation of his work, not just the operas but a substantial amount of his orchestral and chamber music. I have a few CDs of his pieces, and one of my favourite ones is of his cello concertos. He wrote three of these – a very early one (1888) in A Minor, a very late one (1943) also in A Minor – and between these there’s a lovely short, single-movement Cello Concerto in G, Op 42, which is what I want to feature to try to persuade you that the music of Pfitzner is worth a listen. Everything that happens in this piece is derived from the initial theme which the cello voices right at the start (to the accompaniment of a timpani roll). If you’re looking for echoes of other composers in this work, it has perhaps inevitable reminiscences of Richard Strauss (Pfitzner was bitter about a lot of things, and one of them was the status accorded to Strauss that Pfitzner felt was due to him too), and there’s something a little bit like Samuel Barber about the falling melody line of that main theme. What I like a lot about this concerto is its lightness and ‘transparency’. The orchestra never drowns out the cello, but at the same time the soloist is not there just to engage in virtuoso flights of fancy, but is rather a kind of ‘first among equals’ in the relationship with the orchestra. Although it’s a one movement piece, there are shifts of tempo (slowish – faster – slower again) and also of mood, though the primary mood, I think, is a kind of somewhat tender melancholy. Though I’d never dream of putting this alongside Brahms in terms of the quality of the composition, there’s something of Brahms’s continuous thematic development about the way the writing evolves, until, to quote the music critic Nigel Simeone, the music evolves ‘with a highly expressive return of the main theme, leading to a lovely coda—a restrained, harp-drenched transfiguration of the opening theme, with the soloist bringing the music to a quietly rapturous close.’ Anyway, see what you think. Not surprisingly, there are no video recordings of the work on YouTube, so this is just audio once again I’m afraid. What I’ve chosen is the recording by cellist David Geringas with the Bamberg Symphony Orchestra conducted by Werner Andreas Albert. You’ll find it here: Pfitzner: Cello Concerto in G, Op 42
Piazzolla, Astor (1921-92)
Day 99: ‘Milonga del Angel’ (Time: 7 minutes) and ‘Primavera Portena’ (from ‘Four Seasons in Buenos Aires’ (8 minutes)
Today (29/6/20), I wanted to share the music of the Argentine composer Astor Piazzolla (1921-92) who has been a real favourite of mine since Gidon Kremer and his ensemble Kremerata Baltica came to the Crucible Studio back in the late 1990s and played a whole evening of Piazzolla’s music. Piazzolla is associated with a movement known as 'nuevo tango’ (‘new tango’), which took root in the 1960s and 70s, and involved opening up the traditional tango to influences of jazz and classical music. Like so many, he spent time studying with the legendary Nadia Boulanger in Paris, but in effect her advice boiled down to taking the route of a career in tango rather than ‘classical music’. From the 1950s onwards, he led a range of different ensembles, though perhaps the ‘New Tango Quintet’ from the late 1970s to the end of the 1980s was the ensemble in which he honed his style to perfection. He wrote a considerable amount of film and theatre music, and his discography stretches to dozens of albums and collections of pieces. He always kept a foothold in the world of ‘classical music’ – he wrote ‘Le Grand Tango’ in 1982 for the legendary cellist Mstislav Rostropovich, and the ‘Five Tango Sensations’ to perform with the Kronos Quartet in 1989. Really satisfying recordings of his music (apart from ones on which he appeared himself, playing bandoneon – the Argentinian accordion) are sometimes harder to find. There is a tendency to ‘smooth over’ the gritty qualities of dissonance in his music, so some recordings have a rather ‘Palm Court Orchestra, Scarborough’ feel about them (if that reference makes any sense) – they can have a kind of ‘Radio 2’ ‘easy listening’ quality. Equally, although the famous cellist Yo Yo Ma has done a lot to popularise his work, particularly via the CD ‘Soul of the Tango’, even here there’s a rather ‘cleaner’ sound than in Piazzolla’s own work. But the essence of ‘nuevo tango’ is the ‘bite’ it brings to the traditional forms, so I think this is what we should be listening to. I suggest a couple of recordings from YouTube. The first is a recording of a live performance of the melancholy tango ‘Milonga del Angel’, given by Piazzolla and his New Tango Quintet in 1984. You’ll find it here: Astor Piazzolla – ‘Milonga del Angel’ The second is a recording of Gidon Kremer and Kremerata Baltica playing ‘Primavera Portena’, one of the ‘Four Seasons of Buenos Aires’ that Piazzolla composed, and which is frequently recorded these days alongside Vivaldi’s ‘Four Seasons’. You’ll find that recording here: ‘Primavera Portena’ (from ‘Four Seasons of Buenos Aires’)
Day 169: Bandoneon Concerto: 1. Allegro Marcato (Time: 7 minutes), 2. Moderato (7 minutes) and 3. Presto (6 minutes)
Today (9/3/21), we celebrate a very big birthday indeed. In two days’ time, on March 11th, it will be 100 years to the day since the birth of Astor Piazzolla (1921-92). For me, he is the greatest Argentine composer there has ever been (well, maybe it’s a toss-up between him and Alberto Ginastera, who was Piazzolla’s teacher for a time, but in any case, Piazzolla is very very special). He has featured once before on this list (see Day 99) so you can find some of the more basic background information to his life and music there. One thing I did mention on that occasion which invites a little more exploration is the fact that Piazzolla himself played the bandoneon. This is a sub-species of accordion, and functions similarly by squeezing air via bellows activated by pushing and pulling with both hands and directing it through reeds by pressing buttons on either side of the instrument. It was invented by a Mr Band (well, Herr Band, given that he was German … and I leave a little space for you to make your own ‘humorous’ quip) in the mid-19th century, and it was taken over to Argentina by German and italian migrants in the latter part of the 1800s. The peak time for the production of the instrument seems to have been the 1920s and 30s. (Wikipedia tells me that in 1930 alone 25000 bandoneons were made in Germany specifically to be shipped out to Argentina.) If you’d like to explore the quirks of this instrument, there’s an introductory video on YouTube here (12 minutes) which is quite interesting, especially on the utterly bizarre fingering. Although Piazzolla primarily played bandoneon in jazz and tango ensembles (notably his New Tango Quintet) he was consistently interested in introducing the instrument into the ‘classical music’ field too, and probably the best piece to illustrate this is his Concerto for Bandoneon, Strings and Percussion, that he wrote in 1979. The decision to omit woodwind and brass instruments was taken to allow the soloist to ‘sing’ more clearly over the string ensemble. In some ways it observes the familiar concerto model (it’s in three movements, with an essentially fast-slow-fast set of tempo markings), but it’s also a clear demonstration of all aspects of Piazzolla’s mature style as a composer of ‘nuevo tango’. The first movement has a lot in common with the music of his teacher Ginastera. It’s quite percussive, and rhythmically ‘spiky’ in ways that prompt echoes of the music of, say, Stravinsky or Bartók. The second movement, a ‘milonga’ (which the sleeve note to my CD of this music describes as ‘an excited habanera’!), is much closer to the sort of intimate music of Piazzolla’s more reflective chamber pieces. Finally there is an energetic and rousing Presto movement to bring the concerto to a vibrant conclusion. As for a recording, there is (though sadly not all in one piece) a video recording of Piazzolla himself as soloist, in a concert performance with the WDR Symphony Orchestra of Cologne, conducted by Pinchas Steinberg. You’ll find it here: Piazzolla: Bandoneon Concerto - 1. Allegro Marcato, 2. Moderato and 3. Presto
Piston, Walter (1984-1976)
Day 236: Symphony No 2 (Time: 26 minutes)
Our contributor to this list from Canada, Andrew Weaver, clearly has a penchant for American composers of the mid-20th century. So far on this list, his choices have included symphonies by Hanson, Harris, Diamond and Copland. Today (29/10/21), we can add to that the Symphony No 2 by Walter Piston (1894-1976). Piston was largely self-taught up to the age of 20 – his original plan had been to be an engineer, and music was a sideline – and he learned the violin and piano as a child, and then the saxophone and other wind and brass instruments as a teenager. He played in dance bands in his 20s, but his name is enduringly associated with study (from 1920-24) and then teaching (from 1926-60) at Harvard. Predictably, the two-year interregnum saw him head to Europe to study, like so many others, with Nadia Boulanger. During his long period as a professor at Harvard, he gained a distinguished reputation as a music theorist. However, it would be unfair to characterise his music as dry or unduly ‘academic’. His most popular work today is probably his ballet score to ‘The Incredible Flutist’, an energetic and exuberant piece. It’s actually quite difficult to point to any one work and say that it’s ‘typical’ of Piston's oeuvre, because at different times in his life, different emphases came to the fore – some of his early work (such as the Symphony No 1) is influenced by Schoenberg's serialist techniques, and the compositions of his final decade return to this ‘twelve-tone’ strategy. However, at other times his music reflects the lively American ‘national’ school of the 1920s and 30s; and then again, he was strongly influenced by conventional European musical models – particularly his interest in form and structure, which often relied on ‘classical’ symphonic traditions. His Symphony No 2 dates from 1943, and it might not be too fanciful to see its slightly more ‘popular’ qualities as a reflection of the demand to support a nation at war. After its first performance in 1944, its conductor, Hans Kindler, wrote to Piston saying that the piece was ‘one of the half dozen great works written during the last ten years.’ There is no doubt that this is the work that made Piston's reputation as a creative artist. The symphony is in three movements. The first movement makes much of the contrasts between the irregular rhythm of its initial melody and a contrasting dance-like second theme. The final movement is fast, energetic and assertive, right from its initial fanfares, and even the more lyrical section dominated by the cor anglais and clarinet can’t hold back its momentum. However, it’s the central slow movement that gets to the work's heart and it is, I think, the reason for the symphony's enduring reputation at a time when hardly any of Piston's work still gets regular performances. Whilst this work is not ‘romantic’ in the sense of, say, Howard Hanson's symphonies, this middle movement of the 2nd Symphony certainly occupies very similar territory. When Piston died in 1976, Leonard Bernstein and the New York Phil played this movement as a tribute to the composer. As for a performance, we’re in audio-only territory again today, in a recording by the Seattle Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Gerard Schwarz. You’ll find it here: Piston: Symphony No 2
Ponce, Manuel (1882-1948)
Day 374: 24 Preludes for Guitar (Time: 22 minutes)
I want to spend the posting today (25/4/23) marking the 75th anniversary, yesterday, of the death of a Mexican composer whose reputation has survived really rather well in the intervening decades, in the world of guitar music at least. So, Manuel Ponce (pronounce his surname with two syllables – ‘Pon-Say’) was born in central Mexico in 1882 and died in Mexico City on 24th April 1948. His life story mirrors that of many South and Central American composers in the 19th and 20th centuries, in that he went to Europe to study, before returning to his homeland and developing a musical style based on the folk music and culture of his native land. In Ponce’s case, the European stay was quite extensive – he lived and studied in Paris from 1925-33, working for much of that time as a student of Dukas – and, as you can see from the dates involved, he was already a mature composer by that stage. Even before his time in Paris there were several landmark compositions to his name – notably his most famous work, the song ‘Estrellita’ (1912), which has subsequently been arranged for pretty much every conceivable combination of vocal and instrumental forces, but before he was 40 we can also find a piano concerto, a piano trio, a cello sonata, and his first substantial orchestral work, ‘Estampas Nocturnas’. But he really hit his stride as a composer from the Parisian years onwards. He did continue to compose pieces in the conventional forms of Western classical music – there’s a string quartet, three more mature concertos with orchestra (notably the very good Violin Concerto) – but I guess the main reason people have heard of Ponce today, if indeed they have heard of him at all, is as a composer of music for the guitar. The catalyst for this was Ponce’s meeting with the great guitarist Andrés Segovia. Ponce had reviewed a concert Segovia gave on the occasion of the latter’s first visit to Mexico City in 1923; the review was very complimentary, and one consequence was that Segovia asked Ponce to write some compositions for guitar specifically for him. Ponce discovered a real affinity for the instrument, and over the following 25 years or so guitar music became the backbone of Ponce’s oeuvre. There’s a guitar concerto, ‘Concierto del Sur’ (dedicated to Segovia); probably the most substantial work for solo guitar is his ‘Introduction, Variations and Fugue on “La Folia”’, the famous medieval melody that has been the basis for so many composers’ works over the years. I toyed with the idea of choosing this work for us to listen to (there are a number of decent video recordings on YouTube if you want to seek it out), but in the end I’ve gone for a work – or perhaps a collection of works – that pays tribute to Ponce’s skills as a miniaturist. The composition in question is Ponce’s 24 Preludes for Guitar. Ponce spent several years on this collection in the second half of the 1920s. His intention was, after the fashion of Chopin at the piano, to write preludes in all 24 major and minor keys, and they were to form the basis for a primer exploring a wide range of guitar techniques. Segovia intended not only to play these short pieces (the longest is less than two minutes in most performances, and most of them are under a minute in length) but to get them published too. (It’s worth saying at this stage that the publication of Ponce’s music has been a very haphazard affair, and even now there is no definitive catalogue of all his works.) Half of the pieces were published as the ‘Twelve Preludes’ (two sets of six preludes each) in 1930, but the state of the global financial economy in the late 1920s and early 30s deterred the publisher from completing the job, and in fact it wasn’t until 1980 that another guitarist, Miguel Alcazar, gained access to all of Ponce’s manuscript archives, and discovered all the remaining preludes, and published the collection in full for the first time. It’s Alcazar who is responsible for the ordering of the pieces, which mimic the Preludes of Chopin by moving around the circle of fifths. (That is C Major and A Minor, and then G Major and E Minor, and so on through all the keys.) Actually, it’s a tiny bit more complicated than that, in that Alcazar tracked down 23 preludes, but was unable to find a Prelude in G Major. His solution, rather than publish the set as ’23 Preludes’, was to use Ponce’s folk song ‘Cuando la Aurora’, which was in the appropriate key, in place of the missing prelude. The final, D Minor prelude, is the only one, as far as I know, that has an alternative title: ‘Chant Populaire Espagnol’. As for a performance, there’s an attractive video recording by the guitarist Anna Pietrzak, which you can find here: Ponce: 24 Preludes for Guitar
Poulenc, Francis (1899-1963)
Day 25: ‘Laudamus Te’ (from ‘Gloria’) (Time: 3 minutes)
One of my favourite composers from the 20th century is Francis Poulenc (1899-1963). I love the way he can be both ‘witty’ and sensitive at the same time, and certainly the stuff he wrote after his religious experience in the mid-1930s belies his former reputation as a frivolous or lightweight composer. The piece I’ve chosen for today (16/4/20) is his ‘Gloria’, which, written in 1959, dates from towards the end of his life. The whole piece is joyous and celebratory, but I wanted to share with you the second movement, ‘Laudamus Te’, which was allegedly inspired by Poulenc seeing a group of monks playing football. You’ll find it here, in a performance by the Boston Symphony Orchestra and Tanglewood Festival Chorus, conducted by Seiji Ozawa: Francis Poulenc – ‘Laudamus Te’ (from ‘Gloria’)
Day 122: Clarinet Sonata (Time: 14 minutes)
After a bit of autumnal Romanticism courtesy of Brahms last time out, I want to shift the focus today (25/9/20) very definitely into the 20th century, though, like the Brahms, Poulenc’s Clarinet Sonata is also a late work. Francis Poulenc (1899-1963) has featured on this list before (see Day 25), with a snippet from his ebulliently good-humoured ‘Gloria’. For many years during his lifetime and for a while after it, Poulenc was regarded as an essentially frivolous composer, with the focus on the satirical early works he produced as part of the informal group of composers known as ‘Les Six’. However, as I wrote about him in discussing the ‘Gloria’, Poulenc’s work has its own ‘before’ and ‘after’ – in this case, caused by the sudden accidental death of his friend and fellow composer Jean-Octave Ferroud in 1936, and Poulenc’s subsequent visit to the ancient devotional site of Rocamadour in France, which led to works during the rest of his career in which an altogether more serious tone overshadows (though never quite obliterates) the playful ironist of old. Religious themes dominate many of his late works, from the ‘Stabat Mater’ of 1951 (which I’m definitely going to find an excuse to put on this list sometime soon) through to the tragic opera ‘The Dialogue of the Carmelites’ of 1956 and the ‘Gloria’ of 1959. But you can hear seriousness (and, behind it, still the twinkling of playfulness) in ‘secular’ works of Poulenc’s old age too, notably in the series of three sonatas for piano and wind instruments that he composed between 1956-62 – one each for flute, oboe and clarinet. The Clarinet Sonata dates from 1962, and was commissioned by jazz clarinettist and bandleader Benny Goodman, who gave the premiere the following year with Leonard Bernstein (he gets everywhere!) on piano, a mere three months after Poulenc’s sudden death from a heart attack. The sonata is in the conventional three movements, with an apparently conventional fast-slow-fast structure, though as the first movement is marked ‘Allegro Tristamente’ any liveliness at this stage is shot through with tears. The soloists on this performance are Nicolas Baldeyrou on clarinet, accompanied by the pianist Catherine Cournot. You’ll find it here: Poulenc: Clarinet Sonata
Day 145: Quatre Motets Pour le Temps de Noel (Time: 11 minutes)
Francis Poulenc has already appeared twice before on this playlist (see Days 25 and 122), and so I won’t repeat previous remarks about his life story, except to say that we are today (15/12/20) in the presence of Poulenc the ‘spiritual’ composer, rather than exploring the more, shall we say, carnal side of his output. (The composer Ned Rorem puts this quite neatly, describing Poulenc as ‘deeply devout and uncontrollably sensual’; the music critic Claude Rostand described him as ‘half monk, half rascal’… though, in the original French, ‘voyou’ is perhaps closer to ‘thug’ than ‘rascal’.) One recurring lament amongst those who love Poulenc’s music (and I very definitely include myself in that group) is that the ‘frivolous’ side of his compositional personality has led to his music not always being taken as seriously as it might. On that score, I’d refer you back to the comment of the conductor Harry Christophers (see Day 142) that Poulenc is one of the three greatest composers of sacred music. However controversial that remark might be, at least it highlights that Poulenc’s sacred music is very special. The pieces Pete has chosen for today are the ‘Quatre Motets Pour Le Temps De Noel’ (Four Motets for Christmas Time), which Poulenc composed in the early 1950s. These are settings of ancient Latin texts for ‘a cappella’ choir (that it, voices with no accompaniment). Back in 1939, Poulenc had written his ‘Quatre Motets Pour un Temps de Penitance’, and this later group of four Christmas pieces is a kind of counterpart to the solemnity of the earlier group. The Christmas Motets are not uniformly upbeat, but they are essentially serene. The first motet, ‘O Magnum Mysterium’ (O great mystery), is a regular on seasonal programmes of many professional and amateur choirs, even though it presents its challenges in singing very quietly, and for the sopranos in hitting their first note with total conviction. The text describes the mystery of Christ’s adoration in the manger in the visit by simple farm animals. (This is not the last time we’ll encounter this text over the next few days.) The second motet is ‘Quem Vidistis Pastores Dicte’ (Tell us, shepherds, whom you have seen), and it narrates, as might be expected, the joyful encounter of the shepherds with the Christ child, a text regularly sung at Christmas Matins services. Next comes ‘Videntes Stellam’ (Seeing a star), an anonymous text telling of the visit of the Magi. Finally we have ‘Hodie Christus Natus Est’ (Today Christ is born) – another text you might expect to encounter more than once over the next few days. Poulenc treats the words with a lively and celebratory enjoyment. There are a few video recordings of the work on YouTube, but these are often rather approximate performances of pieces that require crystal clear and precise singing. So I’ve gone instead for an audio recording (though accompanied by some lovely Christmassy images), by the Netherlands Chamber Choir, directed by the legendary choral conductor Eric Ericson. You’ll find it here: Poulenc: Quatre Motets Pour le Temps de Noel
Day 172: Stabat Mater (Time: 32 minutes)
Today (19/3/21), in this series of settings of the Stabat Mater, the composer is Francis Poulenc (1899-1963). Poulenc has featured a number of times on this list already (see Days 25, 122 and 145), and regular readers will know that he is in my view one of the greatest of 20th century composers. In the earliest of these Poulenc postings I featured a movement from his effervescent Gloria, a composition that foregrounds the sense of joy that Poulenc found in his Christian faith. Today, with his Stabat Mater, we are in some ways in very different territory, this being a contemplation of loss and death – and yet throughout this work there is, I would maintain, a profound sense of consolation too. I’ve discussed in previous postings on Poulenc the shift to a new form of seriousness that emerged in his writing from the mid-1930s, as a consequence of his rediscovery of his faith, and from that time onwards he produced a stream of devotional works that have entered the repertoire of most choirs and orchestras. Some of these pieces were prompted by the deaths of those close to him, and the Stabat Mater is no exception. In 1949 the fashion and theatre designer Pierre Berard died suddenly of a heart attack. Initially, it appears that Poulenc thought of writing a Requiem in memory of him, but a visit to the ancient shrine of the Black Virgin of Rocamadour, and a consideration of the text of the Stabat Mater, led him to change his mind in favour of setting the medieval text we’ve heard regularly over the past weeks, and Poulenc completed the piece in under two months. Poulenc’s Stabat Mater was first performed in 1950, and was received very enthusiastically from the outset. It’s a setting for soprano soloist (in the 6th, 10th and 12th movements), chorus and orchestra – in fact, it’s Poulenc’s first devotional composition to feature both chorus and orchestra. For the most part the writing, though dark, is solemn and dignified – though that doesn’t stop occasional flashes of Poulenc’s trademark more lively and piquant style coming through, as in the ‘Eja Mater’ 7th movement. The choir is at the core of this piece, and one of the main reasons I love it is that it’s one of the best pieces (certainly the most difficult to sing!) that I’ve performed in my time with Escafeld Chorale. For me the absolute highlights are the ‘Fac ut Portem’ 10th movement, a slow and grave-sounding sarabande, with some really moving choral writing, and the last movement, ‘Quando Corpus Morietur’ (an interesting comparison/contrast with the Dvorak setting we heard last time), where the choir and soloist engage in an ardent plea to be admitted to Paradise, but the music eventually subsides into what seems like an acceptance through faith, conveyed through gentle, beautiful music, before a brief and definite ‘Amen’. Working on the assumption that most folks on this list would prefer a video recording to just an audio one, I’ve looked at what YouTube has to offer, and some performances in ecclesiastical settings seem to suffer from a very muddy acoustic. In the end, I’ve gone a little off piste, and selected a performance by the soprano Nadeja Kucher, with the Orchestra and Chorus of the Opera and Ballet Theatre, Perm, conducted by Valeriy Platonov. You’ll find it here: Poulenc: Stabat Mater
Day 258: Concerto for Organ, Strings and Timpani (Time: 24 minutes)
We’ve had quite a bit of Poulenc on this list over the months since it started (see Day 25, 122, 145 and 172), and I’ve managed to select most of the choral works by Poulenc that I really love during that time. However, having not chosen any orchestral Poulenc thus far, the fact that his Organ Concerto (actually, to be precise, Concerto for Organ, Strings and Timpani) is on an imminent concert programme at the City Hall seems to me to be the perfect excuse for featuring my absolute favourite organ concerto – not that there’s a lot of competition, in truth – today (14/1/22). Poulenc is, as you won’t have escaped realising over the time of these postings, one of my all-time favourite composers. In my discussion of previous selections of his work, I’ve made much of the before/after narrative in his output, pivoting on the rediscovery of his Christian faith in the mid-1930s. It makes sense to see evidence of this in his settings of ‘religious’ texts (hence my choices of the ‘Gloria’ and the ‘Stabat Mater’, for example). But I think you can hear this newer, more profound Poulenc even in works that are much more obviously ‘abstract music’, as is the case with this Organ Concerto. The work was commissioned back in 1934, but it was finished in 1938, so not only can we hear this as a product of his shifting world-view, but it also makes sense to recognise its historical context on the eve of the Second World War. (Poulenc was actually called up to fight in the war, but only for about seven weeks(!), being demobilised when France surrendered to the Germans in June 1940.) Poulenc wrote four concertos for keyboard instruments during his lifetime. Two of them (the ‘Concert Champêtre’ for Harpsichord and Orchestra, and the Concerto for Two Pianos and Orchestra) are from the earlier period in Poulenc’s life, and though they have some meltingly beautiful moments, they are primarily entertaining works. The Organ Concerto of 1938 is, however, another kettle of fish altogether. There’s an interesting observation Poulenc made, saying it was ‘on the outskirts’ of his devotional music, and though it has a breezy ‘fairground’ quality in places, in other sections it feels to me much more influenced by Bach’s organ music. He wrote to his fellow composer Jean Francaix (see Day 226!), ‘The concerto...is not the amusing Poulenc of the Concerto for Two Pianos, but more like a Poulenc en route for the cloister.’ Extraordinarily, it was the first work Poulenc had written for the organ in his life, and his study of Bach’s work before embarking on the concerto perhaps accounts for its Baroque sound world in places. The work is in a single movement, though it divides pretty clearly into seven distinct sections, bookended by loud, sonorous organ chords that should leave us in no doubt of the work’s solemnity. In the middle sections though, as I’ve suggested, there are moments of greater playfulness, but also too of extreme tenderness. For me, this is a real masterpiece. I hope you enjoy it as much as I do. There are quite a few performances on YouTube, but one of the challenges of this work if it’s performed in an ecclesiastical setting is that the string sound often gets lost in the duration of the echo in churches, so the whole thing becomes a bit ‘muddy’. For that reason I’ve gone for a concert performance, played in this instance by the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Andrés Orozco-Estrada. The organist is the young Latvian keyboard player Iveta Apkalna. You’ll find the recording here: Poulenc: Concerto for Organ, Strings and Timpani
Day 282: Quatre Motets pour un Temps de Pénitence (Time: 16 minutes)
Welcome to another posting exploring music for Lent. Today (8/4/22) - and this would be pretty much true of any other day! - I’m keen to go back to one of my favourite composers of the last century, Francis Poulenc. Poulenc has appeared five times on this list already (see Days 25, 122, 145, 172 and 258), which perhaps gives some indication of the esteem in which I hold his music. Most of those selections have been from his choral music, and the same is true for the work I’ve chosen today. There is (for me, anyway) something intensely powerful and emotionally direct, without being in any way sentimental, about Poulenc’s compositions for voices. My comments on the selection (actually Pete Dutton’s selection back then) of Poulenc’s ‘Quatre Motets pour le Temps de Noel’ (‘Four Motets for Christmas Time’) on Day 145 drew attention to the fact that, written in the early 1950s, these were a sort of companion piece to a much darker selection of motets that Poulenc wrote just before the Second World War – though I don’t think there’s any overt sense in which these earlier pieces were a response to the worsening political climate in Europe at the time. The composition in question is the ‘Quatre Motets pour un Temps de Pénitence’ (‘Four Penitential Motets’). Other playlist notes I’ve written about Poulenc highlight the dramatic shift in his outlook, with its renewed focus on his faith, from the mid-1930s onwards. The first fruits of that shift came in 1936 with the ‘Litanies of the Black Virgin of Rocamadour’, and it’s remarkable how completely Poulenc’s development of his distinctive ‘voice’ in writing for unaccompanied chorus was present even then. The following year he wrote his Mass in G, and then, between July 1938 and January 1939, these Penitential Motets that I’m featuring today. Sung in Latin, the first of these pieces sets verses from Psalms 54 and 30. The other three motets use familiar Tenebrae Responsories for Holy Week. The first motet, ‘Timor et Tremor’, might be translated as follows: ‘Fear and trembling have come over me, and darkness has fallen on me. Have mercy on me, Lord, have mercy, for my soul trusts in you. God, hear my prayer, for you are my refuge and my strong advocate. Lord, I have called upon you; do not destroy me.’ You can hear the typical Poulenc fingerprints here: ‘block-like’ phrasing, with shifts in texture from one phrase to the next. There’s also a consistently unsettled time signature, so that the motet feels edgy and dark in mood. The second motet is ‘Vinea mea electa’ (‘My chosen vineyard, I planted you; why have you changed into bitterness so as to crucify me and release Barabbas? I hedged [protected] you, and removed stones from around you, and built a watch tower’). It begins tenderly, which highlights the sudden burst of anguish at ‘ut me crucifigeres’ all the more clearly. The third motet is ‘Tenebrae Factae Sunt’ (‘It became dark when they crucified Jesus of Judea. And about the ninth hour Jesus cried with a loud voice, My God, why have you forsaken me? And bowing his head he gave out his spirit. Exclaiming in a loud voice, Jesus said, Father, into your hands I commend my spirit’). It is a powerful setting of the events of the Crucifixion, full of abrupt mood shifts, and a great sense of desolation at the soprano line articulating ‘exclamavit Jesus’. Finally we have ‘Tristis est anima mea’ (‘My soul is sorrowing to death. Stay here, and watch with me. Soon you will see a crowd which will surround me. You will take flight, and I will go to be sacrificed for you. Behold, the hour is near and the son of man will be given into the hands of sinners’), an exploration of the profoundly sorrowful words Jesus speaks to his disciples in the Garden of Gethsemane. Poulenc’s setting of Jesus’s prediction of the disciples’ flight is vivid, and and his depiction of Jesus’s first statement that he is going to be sacrificed for them is tumultuous. But Poulenc gives the second presentation of this statement a richer, eight-part treatment, with the luminous soprano transforming Jesus’s words into something almost radiant. All in all, this is powerful stuff, plumbing profound emotional depths. For a recording, there are a number of impressive audio-only ones, but very few videos of live performances. However, this one, by the West German Radio Choir, directed by Peter Dijkstra, is pretty good, I think. You’ll find it here: Poulenc: Quatre Motets pour un Temps de Pénitence
Day 443: Sonata for Horn, Trumpet and Trombone (Time: 9 minutes)
Our first posting of the year celebrates another ‘big birthday’ of 2024, in this case the 125th anniversary this coming Sunday of the birth of Francis Poulenc, who was born in Paris on 7th January 1899. There’s been quite a lot of Poulenc during the history of this list – on six other occasions to be precise: Days 25, 122, 145, 172, 258 and 282 – and consequently, there’s also quite a lot of biographical and musical detail about him that’s accessible via those entries. Of the six pieces featured hitherto, five of them postdate his rediscovery of his Catholic faith in 1936 when he was in his mid-30s, and the other (the Organ Concerto) was begun before that critical watershed in his life, but finished after it, so it could be said that all the Poulenc we’ve encountered so far has been shot through with the richness and complexity of his mature output in the final 25 years or so of his life. However, today (2/1/24), I want to go back to somewhere close to the very beginning of Poulenc’s life as a composer, and sample one of the works that made him such a subversive and iconoclastic figure in the years after the First World War. Interestingly, Poulenc was very definitely not one of the ‘child prodigy’ brigade, though by all accounts, he was an impressive pianist from an early age. His first work wasn’t published until he was almost twenty. Responding to a request from his London publisher for some autobiographical detail, he wrote the following in 1919: ‘I studied … composition almost solely through books because I was fearful of being influenced by a teacher… My four favourite composers, my only masters, are Bach, Mozart, Satie and Stravinsky. I don’t like Beethoven at all… I loathe Wagner… In general, I am very eclectic, but while acknowledging that influence is a necessary thing I hate those artists who dwell in the wake of the masters. Now, a crucial point, I am not a Cubist musician, even less a Futurist and, of course, not an Impressionist. I am a musician without a label.’ For three years from January 1918, Poulenc was a conscript in the French army, a situation which seems to have allowed him quite a lot of opportunity to compose alongside his largely administrative duties, and it’s during this period that Poulenc, with five others (Honegger, Milhaud, Durey, Tailleferre and Auric) became known as a member of ‘Les Six’, an informal grouping of young composers making bright, somewhat ironically-inclined and very definitely not lush Romantic music. Occasionally, they collaborated (the ballet ‘Les Mariés de la Tour Eiffel’ of 1921 contains music by all of them to accompany an absurdist narrative about a wedding party on the Eiffel Tower), but in large measure each went his (or her) own way, linked only by the playful subversiveness of their work. In 1921, Ernest Newman wrote in ‘The Guardian’: ‘I keep my eye on Francis Poulenc, a young man who has only just arrived at his twenties. He ought to develop into a farceur of the first order.’ This association of Poulenc and his music with the idea of the farce is evident in the piece I’ve chosen for today to celebrate his anniversary, the Sonata for Horn, Trumpet and Trombone. He wrote a cluster of chamber works in the years 1919-22, for some unusual combinations of instruments. There’s a Sonata for Clarinet and Bassoon, for instance, and a Sonata for Two Clarinets, as well as this piece for three brass instruments. One of the great attractions to Poulenc as a young man was the music of the fairground: raucous, playful, mockingly anti-intellectual. The Sonata for Horn, Trumpet and Trombone is in three movements, in the familiar fast-slow-fast pattern. The cheerful opening Allegro starts with a brisk trumpet tune, and though in the middle of the movement there is a more lyrical passage for horn and trumpet, it’s the youthful vigour of the start that wins through in the end. The slow movement is more tender (‘The Andante makes you cry!!!!!!’ wrote the surrealist writer and artist Jean Cocteau – the exclamation marks are all his), an almost-lullaby of a piece. Finally there’s a bright and breezy rondo Finale, taking what seem like they ought to be conventional melodies but spicing them with ‘wrong notes’ and bizarre harmonies. After the first performance Poulenc wrote, ‘Very bizarre reception for the ‘Sonata’, some whistles, some ironic ‘Encores’, but overall amazement. The end … provoked a huge roar of laughter.’ It should be said that this reaction pleased Poulenc immensely! As for a performance, there’s a nice (if ‘socially distanced’) video recording by three members of the West German Radio Symphony Orchestra of Cologne, Přemysl Vojta on horn, Martin Griebl on trumpet and Jeffrey Kant on trombone. You’ll find the recording here: Poulenc: Sonata for Horn, Trumpet and Trombone
Day 477: Sextet for Piano and Winds (Time: 18 minutes)
The work I’m featuring today (3/5/24), Poulenc’s Sextet for Piano and Winds is another work to be featured in this year’s Sheffield Chamber Music Festival later this month. Regular readers of these emails will know that Francis Poulenc (1899-1963) is one of my favourite 20th century composers, and I’ve tried to squeeze as many examples of his tender, bittersweet wit into this list as I can get away with. There are seven such pieces available via the Menu below (see Days 25, 122, 145, 172, 258, 282 and 443), and to them I now add one of Poulenc’s most bracing chamber works. The notes accompanying the previous examples of his writing make much of the ‘division’ in Poulenc’s life between the earlier years of ‘devil may care’ iconoclasm in post-First World War Paris – when the music critic Claude Rostand wrote of him, ‘He always placed a great value on being regarded as light, charming, frivolous, and flip. He loved risqué jokes and a Rabelaisian way of life. … it was a point of honour for him never to appear serious’ – and the more contemplative creations that came after his rediscovery of his Christian faith in the mid-1930s. Today’s work sits fascinatingly across either side of that turning point, in that its first version appeared in 1931, but Poulenc revised the piece very substantially and the reworked version emerged in 1939. The piano features in almost everything Poulenc wrote apart from his unaccompanied choral writing or purely orchestral work. But when it comes to chamber music, the piano is joined almost always by wind instruments. (There’s a Violin Sonata of 1943 and a Cello Sonata from 1948, but otherwise nothing else of note that doesn’t feature winds.) The 1930s was dominated by works for solo piano or songs, but the Sextet is his major chamber work of the decade. In it, the piano provides the perfect foil for the rather acid tones of the wind quintet, in a piece that has a ‘neo-classical’ feel that is (for me, anyway) a perfect blend of depth and frivolity. In fact, even in his early works, you don’t have to look very hard to find hidden depths that speak of Poulenc’s emotional complexity. Rostand again: ‘Behind this spontaneity, this easy and ironic cutting up, was hidden much inner turmoil….’ When the revised 1939 version was completed, Poulenc wrote to the Comtesse de Polignac that he had ‘thoroughly revised my entire Sextet (now very good)’. It was given its first performance in this new version in the early days of the German occupation of Paris in December 1940, and its mixture of defiant Gallic charm and troubled spirits must have suited the times very well. It’s in three movements, with the familiar fast-slow-fast pattern, though both the first and second movements have contrasting and differently-paced middle sections. The opening movement starts out with a kind of muscular seriousness, but part-way through the bassoon slows the tempo, introducing a melancholy melody that recurs as the piece unfolds, before the sprightly vigour of the opening returns to round off the movement. The middle movement, marked ‘Divertissement’, reverses this pattern: slow outer sections enclosing something more perky. This movement allows Poulenc to pay homage, as so often in his work, to the spirit of Mozart, the composer whom he loved more than any other. The middle section is rather more comic, but the ending, wistful and tender, shows Poulenc’s more intimate side. The finale is a whirlwind. Marked ‘Prestissimo’, it’s wild and occasionally brash, mixing jazzy syncopation with longer, more flowing melodies. But then, when it looks like the circus or the music hall will win out, the bassoon returns with the yearning theme from the first movement, and the piece ends abruptly with a dissonant chord, these last few bars having an almost Stravinsky-like grittiness. YouTube has a number of decent performances of Poulenc’s Sextet, and out of the choices, the one I’ve gone for is by the London Conchord Ensemble, in a live performance given at the BBC Proms in 2013. You’ll find it here: Poulenc: Sextet for Piano and Winds
Praetorius, Michael (c1571-1621)
Day 248: Es ist ein Ros' entsprungen (Time: 3 minutes) and Weihnachtsmusik (arr. Schoenberg) (5 minutes)
Today (10/12/21), we start in the early 17th century and end up just over 300 years later. What links the two pieces I’ve chosen for today is a hymn, the text of which appears to date back to the 1400s. Though its origin is lost in time (we don’t have any evidence for who wrote it), the text appears to have continued to be acceptable in both Catholic and Protestant traditions during the schisms of the following centuries. The piece is best known these days as a Christmas carol, its opening line being ‘Es ist ein Ros entsprungen’ (literally ‘it is a rose sprung up’, but translated probably most commonly as ‘Lo, how a rose e’er blooming’). By the end of the 16th century it had acquired a tune that was known across a large area of Europe. In 1609, the composer Michael Praetorius (c1571-1621) produced a version which harmonised that tune, and this is the version that has since become popularised and generally used. Praetorius sounds like it ought to be a fairly unusual surname, but in fact there are vast numbers of Praetoriuses (Praetorii??), particularly in the 16th and 17th centuries in the German-speaking territories of the era. It was especially fashionable amongst composers (as well as Michael, you might find compositions by Bartholomaeus, Christoph, Hieronymous, Jacob, another Jacob, and Johannes Praetorius). The reason for this is that people whose surname was ‘Schulze’ (or variant spellings of it) or ‘Richter’ took to calling themselves ‘Praetorius’, which (‘praetor’=magistrate) had pretty much the same meaning in Roman times. All this is best filed under ‘Renaissance weirdness’, I guess. So, Michael Praetorius (at birth, Michael Schulze) was a composer whose origins are obscure, but who came to prominence as the organist, and later music director, at the court of the Duke of Brunswick-Luneburg. He is famous, if indeed he is famous, today for two reasons: one is that he wrote a compendium of several hundred instrumental dances which was published under the title ‘Terpsichore’ – certainly my first encounter with him as a young person getting interested in classical music was hearing some of the several suites of dances from that collection, particularly as popularised by performers like the early music pioneer David Munrow or the now somewhat reputationally tarnished Philip Pickett. His other claim to fame is the setting of this wonderful Christmas carol, a staple feature of many carol concerts (it’s the opening number in the concerts given by the choir I sing with, Escafeld Chorale, over the next few days). It’s a lovely piece, I think – simple enough to be immediately accessible, but with just enough irregularity to remain interesting on repeated hearing. There are many recordings of it on YouTube, and from them I’ve chosen this one, given by the vocal group The Gesualdo Six. You’ll find it here: Praetorius: Es ist ein Ros' entsprungen. Fast forward 300 years or so, and the same tune turns up again, from the pen of that arch-modernist, Arnold Schoenberg (1874-1951). This might seem something of a departure from a composer who had been busy writing atonal music from around the start of the second decade of the 20th century, and who was to formalise the serialist techniques for which is he famous (replace this with another adjective if this sort of stuff isn’t your cup of tea) from the early 1920s. However, at Christmas 1921 Schoenberg and his family were following a long-standing domestic tradition of communal Christmas music-making, and to that end Schoenberg made an arrangement (actually, ‘arrangement’ seems to underplay the originality of what he was doing) of Praetorius’s carol. The forces at his disposal might remind you of his arrangement of Johann Strauss’s ‘Roses from the South’ (see Day 150!): two violins, cello, harmonium and piano. The result is a kind of mash-up of Praetorius’s melody (and sometimes his harmony) and the even more familiar ‘Stille Nacht’ (‘Silent Night’), the result of which Schoenberg called ‘Weihnachtsmusik’ (‘Christmas Music’). I find it particularly touching, and knowing that it’s by Schoenberg makes it really very endearing. You’ll find it here, performed by the Taverner Players, directed by Andrew Parrott, and accompanied on this video by attractive (if not terribly relevant) scenes from the Peak District: Praetorius, arr. Schoenberg: Weihnachtsmusik
Price, Florence (1887-1953)
Day 138: Piano Sonata in E Minor (Time: 27 minutes)
Welcome to the last of the suggestions to mark Black History Month (belatedly), a piece of music by the American composer Florence Price. Florence Price (1887-1953) is by most people’s calculations the first female African-American symphonic composer. Her career is unusual in that she had to confront not just racism (she enrolled at the New England Conservatory in Massachusetts as ‘Mexican’ to evade some of the bias against black Americans) but also sexism, in that apart from a handful of examples (Amy Beach is probably the most established), there were very few female composers of note in America in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries to act as role models. At one point in her life, she wrote offering some music for performance to Serge Koussevitzky, the legendary conductor of the Boston Symphony Orchestra, noting that ‘I have two handicaps: I am a woman, and I have some Negro blood in my veins.’ (The Boston orchestra did not take up her offer.) She grew up and, after her first marriage, settled in Little Rock, Arkansas, but after race riots and lynchings in 1927, the family moved to Chicago, where she was based for the rest of her life. The cornerstone of her reputation today is the collection of four symphonies (though the second of these has, as things stand, been lost) which she wrote between 1931 and 1945. Recordings of the remaining three symphonies have appeared with increasing regularity in recent years. Musically her writing is essentially conservative. Her training, as was the case at the time, was based largely on models of European musical Romanticism, but her work consistently feels and sounds ‘American’, particularly in its reliance on African-American spirituals, in terms of harmonies and rhythmic patterns as well as melody. She was a committed Christian, and wrote a great deal of music, both choral and for solo voice, which is heavily blues-inflected. In 1932, she entered two works for the Wanamaker Foundation Awards. Her Symphony in E Minor took first prize (and was later premiered by the Chicago Symphony Orchestra, the first symphony by a black female composer to be played by a major American orchestra), and the piece I want to focus on today (20/11/20), her Piano Sonata, also in E Minor, took first prize in the instrumental category. This Piano Sonata is in three movements, and I think the slow second movement in particular is a very touching piece of writing. The opening movement begins with a slow introduction, followed by a faster main section that reveals her characteristic blending of the language of nineteenth-century German piano technique with an idiom closer to African-American folk songs and plantation dances. The following Andante is more closely associated with Negro spirituals, and the finale is probably the most virtuosic section, a whirling mixture of black American folk music within a template based on classical conventions. I wouldn’t want to claim that the Piano Sonata is a great piece, but it seems to me to be a really interesting insight into the evolution of music written by black American composers in the first half of the twentieth century. There are a handful of recordings of this piece on YouTube, though frustratingly the sound quality on much of the video material isn’t good, so I’ve settled for an audio recording by the pianist Cole Burger. You’ll find it (uploaded movement by movement) here: Price: Piano Sonata in E Minor - 1. Andante - Allegro, 2. Andante and 3. Scherzo: Allegro.
Prokofiev, Sergei (1891-1953)
Day 103: Symphony No 1 (Time: 14 minutes)
Today (21/7/20), I thought it would be good to plug another of the many gaps left by our first 100 days on the list, and listen to some music by Sergei Prokofiev (1891-1953). Along with Shostakovich, Prokofiev was the leading figure in Russian/Soviet music in the first half of the 20th century. He was unusual in terms of composers’ journeys in that, having left Russia in 1917 after the Communist Revolution, he eventually returned there in 1936 and lived out the rest of his life in the Soviet Union. That didn’t stop him becoming as much a figure of persecution as all other significant cultural performers during Stalin’s rule – he was denounced in 1948 for ‘anti-democratic formalism’ in the ‘Zhdanov decree’ (which also persecuted Shostakovich and Khachaturian amongst others). However, many of the leading performers of the period – the cellist Mstislav Rostropovich and the pianist Sviatoslav Richer particularly – continued to perform his music. Perhaps the saddest irony of Prokofiev’s time in the Soviet Union is that he died on exactly the same day as Stalin (Wikipedia tells me that in ‘Pravda’ his death notice was placed on p116, the first 115 pages of the paper being given over to eulogies about Stalin!). Although he produced many very popular works after returning to the Soviet Union (the enduringly popular ‘Peter and the Wolf’, the cantata ‘Alexander Nevsky’, and the three great wartime piano sonatas, for example), at the other end of his career Prokofiev was an undoubted ‘enfant terrible’. He was a first-rate pianist, and many of his early compositions feature spiky, percussive piano writing. However, he also had a strong, rather ironic humorous streak. It’s this that I want to focus on today, by considering what has always been one of his most popular works, his Symphony No 1, usually known as the ‘Classical’. He wrote it in 1917 (you could hardly guess that the world was in turmoil around him!) as a deliberate attempt to imitate the style of Haydn, ‘modernised’ for the 20th century – so in that sense it’s an early forerunner of the ‘neo-classical’ style that was to become very fashionable over the following two decades. It’s a sprightly, joyous work, resolutely in major keys pretty well throughout, and the outer movements in particular fizz with joie de vivre. There are a lot of recordings on YouTube, but I’ve gone for one by a relatively new orchestra, the Baltic Sea Philharmonic (founded in 2008, and drawing on musicians from all countries bordering the Baltic), and conducted by the uber-cool Kristjan Jarvi, the youngest of the Jarvi conducting dynasty. You’ll find it here: Prokofiev: Symphony No 1
Day 342: Violin Concerto No 1 (Time: 22 minutes)
Although this playlist is 342 editions old (and counting), we’ve only encountered Prokofiev once before (see Day 103 for his irrepressible Symphony No 1, the ‘Classical’), so we’re long overdue another meeting with this rather enigmatic figure from the first half of the 20th century. As I mentioned in that previous Prokofiev posting, his early reputation was as something of a rebel, and the music he wrote before he left Russia for life abroad in 1917 (initially in America, then – mostly – in France, though he eventually returned to the Soviet Union in the mid-1930s) was often ‘spiky’ and modernist. His ‘Sarcasms for Piano’ of 1912 are characteristic of his musical persona both in title and in musical language, being polytonal (in more than one key at once) a lot of the time. However, as the ‘Classical’ Symphony (of 1917) shows, there was more to Prokofiev than thumbing his nose at musical tradition. There’s humour, rich melody and a genuine tenderness at times. The work Maxim Vengerov is playing in Sheffield this month, and which I’ve selected for today (11/11/22) is the Violin Concerto No 1, which was pretty much exactly contemporary with the ‘Classical’ Symphony; both of them were scheduled for performance in late 1917, though those plans were derailed by the two Russian revolutions of that year, and the Violin Concerto didn’t get a public outing until 1923. It’s in the conventional three movements, though the usual fast-slow-fast model is inverted here: we start with an ‘Andantino’ which is dreamy and leisurely; the second movement is a scherzo, marked ‘Vivacissimo’; the finale starts slowly, ‘Moderato’, before picking up speed, although the concerto ends by slowing and dying away to silence. In other words, like so much of Prokofiev’s music, this adapts the conventions of the genre he’s working within to the subversive tendencies of his musical imagination. However, at its premiere in Paris it was given something of a mixed reception. Partly that can be explained by the fact that Parisian audiences were keen on, if you like, ‘the shock of the new’, and undeniably there is something, if not Romantic in the traditional 19th century sense, then lyrical and tender in this concerto that perplexed its first hearers. The composer Georges Auric (one of ‘Les Six’, the iconoclasts that numbered Poulenc, Milhaud and Honegger among their members) described the concerto as ‘Mendelssohnian’ – and I don’t think that was intended as a compliment! This is, nevertheless, a ‘concerto’, and as such it’s a virtuosic piece, making great demands of the soloist. But the fireworks juggle for supremacy with an inherent lyricism and what might seem an apparent simplicity in the way the music is scored. One of the work’s great champions, the violinist Joseph Szigeti, wrote of the concerto that it was ‘a mixture of fairy-tale naïveté and daring savagery in lay-out and texture’. In his ‘Short Autobiography’ of 1941, Prokofiev aimed to describe the various ‘strands’ of his musical identity – the classical, the modern, the motoric, and the lyrical (he later added a fifth, the ‘scherzo-ish’) – and it is in relation to the fourth of these characteristics that Prokofiev mentions his Violin Concerto No 1, although, as he noted, ‘this [quality] was not noticed until much later. For a long time I was given no credit for any lyrical gift whatever, and for want of encouragement it developed slowly. But as time went on I gave more attention to this aspect of my work.’ That ‘lyrical’ quality is present at the very beginning of this concerto, in the line that the soloist spins over the blurred and dream-like orchestral accompaniment. I love too the way that first movement ends, a wisp of sound on the solo flute, like smoke vanishing. The second movement is short but savage: the music critic Michael Steinberg writes of how ‘the music, full of contrast, is by turns amusing, naughty, for a while even malevolent, athletic, and always violinistically ingenious and brilliant.’ The last movement starts with the ticking of a clock, and the violin weaves its way round and through the orchestra, often not so much an up-front soloist as a commentator on the orchestral action. The flute has (almost) the last word in this movement too, as the work closes in a peaceful and dreamy state. YouTube has several impressive recordings of this concerto. From those many options, I’ve gone for a video of a performance given by the soloist Leonidas Kavakos, accompanied by the Orchestra of the Mariinsky Theatre, conducted by Valery Gergiev. You’ll find it here: Prokofiev: Violin Concerto No 1
Day 465: Cello Sonata in C, Op 119 (Time: 23 minutes)
Today (19/3/24) I want to look forward to a very Russian concert being given here in Sheffield tomorrow evening by members of Ensemble 360, which includes a substantial work for cello and piano, Prokofiev’s Cello Sonata, Op 119 – and it’s this work that I wanted to explore here. We’ve had Prokofiev twice before on this list (see Day 103 for the sprightly Symphony No 1 and Day 342 for the dreamy Violin Concerto No 1), both of these works being the product of the relatively early days in Prokofiev’s career, being written in or around 1917. Today’s work comes from much closer to the end of Prokofiev’s life – he died in 1953 – and it’s a good example of ‘mature’ Prokofiev. Prokofiev wrote a number of works for cello, from the early Ballade for Cello and Piano, which dates from 1912, through the substantial (but still rarely performed) Cello Concerto (of 1938, though it was revised later), until we get to the last five or six years of Prokofiev’s life, when a number of works came in something of a rush. Alongside the Cello Sonata, Op 119 (from 1949, though revised after its first performance a year later), there’s also a Symphony-Concerto for Cello and Orchestra, Op 125 (1950-52), and then two works that were left incomplete at Prokofiev’s death, a Sonata for Solo Cello and a Cello Concertino. Evidently one of the reasons for this sudden flurry of works for cello was Prokofiev’s friendship with and admiration for the playing of Mstislav Rostropovich; the latter was just beginning what was to be a quite phenomenal career in the later 1940s. Prokofiev was clearly musically smitten: ‘I am fascinated with your crazy instrument,’ he wrote to Rostropovich as he was beginning work on the Cello Sonata. Prokofiev was clearly fortunate to have a performer of the calibre of Rostropovich to write for – and equally fortunate, I guess, that the piano part was written for Sviatoslav Richter! – and he certainly made the most of the opportunity! There were, this being the Soviet Union after the 2nd World War, hoops to be jumped through. In 1948 Prokofiev found himself denounced (alongside Shostakovich, Khachaturian and many others) for ‘anti-democratic formalism’ in the so-called ‘Zhdanov decree’, and there was an evident need to tread carefully as a result. This is Richter’s account of the process: ‘We [Rostropovich and I] gave the first performance of Prokofiev's Cello Sonata. Before playing it in concert, we had to perform it at the Composer's Union, where these gentlemen decided the fate of all new works. During this period more than any other, they needed to work out whether Prokofiev had produced a new masterpiece or, conversely, a piece that was 'hostile to the spirit of the people.' Three months later, we had to play it again at a plenary session of all the composers who sat on the Radio Committee, and it wasn't until the following year that we were able to perform it in public, in the Small Hall of the Moscow Conservatory on March 1, 1950.’ The sonata is in three movements. It opens with an Andante, with the cello playing low in its register. Prokofiev (conscious, perhaps, of the views of officialdom) labelled this early section, ‘Man: Proud-sounding’. This first movement develops in somewhat conventional ways, though climaxing in a frenzied passage in which both instruments imitate the fateful ringing of bells, before the music subsides into something shimmering and detached. The second movement is a short scherzo, and has the sort of qualities that attracted Prokofiev to Haydn’s music all those decades ago in his ‘Classical’ Symphony. It’s playful and comic (or is it the fake smile of someone being playful because it’s prudent to do so?), with a more tender and heartfelt middle section. The last movement is broad and expressive, with much use of long lyrical melodies, one of which – with its slightly oriental feeling – always makes me think of Khachaturian. We’re firmly in C Major at the end, with rhetorical flourishes from both instruments. YouTube has some attractive performances of this work, and from them the one I’ve chosen is by the cellist Sol Gabetta, supported very impressively (the piano part is no walkover!) by pianist Polina Leschenko. You’ll find their performance here: Prokofiev: Cello Sonata in C, Op 119
Puccini, Giacomo (1858-1924)
Day 225: 'I Crisantemi' (string quartet version) (Time: 6 minutes) and 'I Crisantemi' (string orchestra version) (7 minutes)
To mark Chelsea Flower Show, this week I have two works associated with flowers, starting today (21/9/21) with a short work by Puccini. Giacomo Puccini (1858-1924) – or, if you prefer, Giacomo Antonio Domenico Michele Secondo Maria Puccini – is by common consent the greatest Italian opera composer after Verdi, and, with Verdi and Mozart, one of the most popularly performed writers of opera of all time. He emerged as a composer as Verdi’s long dominance of Italian opera was coming to an end, and the label most regularly associated with him is that he was a composer of ‘verismo’ opera – that is, work that is broadly ‘realistic’ (a word conveniently open to infinitely flexible definitions), focusing on the passions, struggle and occasional violence of characters from the lower end of the social spectrum. Of his most regularly performed works, only ‘Tosca’ perhaps fits that definition with some accuracy. What is certain is that for the 30 years up to his death, Puccini dominated the Italian stage with a string of popular and (mostly) critically successful operas. Like many immensely popular composers (one can compare him to Tchaikovsky, say, in this respect) Puccini’s work is sometimes regarded with something of a sneer of critical superiority by those who might see him as too ‘middlebrow’, excessive popularity being something of a two-edged sword. Puccini had a somewhat tempestuous personal life (plenty of amorous liaisons and at least one near-death experience in a serious car accident), giving it a melodramatic edge familiar from his operas. However, he doesn’t seem to have engaged particularly with the social and political upheavals of his time – there’s no evident response to the turbulence of the First World War and its aftermath, for example – although the work I want to focus on today is, at least, the consequence of a significant political event. Although Puccini is primarily an opera composer, he also wrote a small quantity of orchestral works (all of them from his twenties, as he was finding his feet as a composer), a couple of dozen songs for voice and piano, four or five youthful piano pieces, and a similar quantity of chamber music. There’s an early string quartet that he wrote in his mid-twenties (along with a couple of other ‘workshop’ exercises) – but then some ten years later, in 1890, we get to today’s composition, the short quartet movement ‘I Crisantemi’ (‘Chrysanthemums’). In January 1890, Prince Amadeo di Savoia, Duca d’Aosta and King of Spain, died unexpectedly. Almost immediately, Puccini wrote (allegedly in one night) this short, melancholy quartet movement in his memory. He called it ‘I Crisantemi’ because in Italy chrysanthemums are associated with death and funerals (and elsewhere too? – I’m not sure, though I have a vivid memory of my 16-year-old self studying, for my O-level English Literature, a DH Lawrence short story, ‘Odour of Chrysanthemums’, which focuses on death and mourning, and its Nottinghamshire mining town milieu is a long way from Italy). Puccini’s piece is in a simple A-B-A form. Shortly after its premiere for string quartet, Puccini arranged it for string orchestra. And almost immediately it acquired another use, in the dramatic climax of his opera ‘Manon Lescaut’ (which dates from 1893). As for a performance, there’s enough time available to us this week to hear the work in both versions that Puccini made for strings. So you’ll find a rather restrained performance of the work from the Enso String Quartet here: Puccini: 'I Crisantemi' (string quartet version). And then, in the rather more indulgent and full-throated version for string orchestra, members of the Netherlands Radio Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by Karina Canellakis, perform the work here: Puccini: 'I Crisantemi' (string orchestra version)
Day 518: Capriccio Sinfonico (Time: 13 minutes) and 'Che gelida manina' (from 'La Bohème') (5 minutes)
Today (29/11/24), it’s an anniversary edition – probably the last big anniversary of 2024. The composer concerned is Giacomo Antonio Domenico Michele Secondo Maria Puccini, who died on 29th November, 1924, which means it’s exactly 100 years since his death this very day. We’ve had just one appearance on this playlist by Puccini to date – see Day 225, when I featured both versions of his short commemorative piece ‘I Crisantemi’, the original for string quartet and Puccini’s own later version for string orchestra. I’ve had occasion to observe on a number of occasions, when writing about music, that there are ‘blind spots’ in my musical knowledge and appreciation, one of the most humbling of which is my relative ignorance of – and, alas, lack of interest in – operatic repertoire. All of which makes me pretty under-qualified to write about opera composers and their work. But we can’t celebrate Puccini’s life without at least dipping a toe into his operatic oeuvre, so that’s what I’ll do. However, I thought I’d precede that moment with a quick look at one of Puccini’s very small number of purely orchestral works. Apart from the preludes and interludes in his operas, you would only need the fingers (no need even for the thumb) of one hand on which to count them. There’s a very early ‘Preludio Sinfonico’ dating from 1876 when Puccini was still in his teens; another, different ‘Preludio Sinfonico’ from 1882 when Puccini was a music student; a short ‘Largo Adagietto’ movement from the same time; and finally Puccini’s graduation work as a student, his Capriccio Sinfonico, which dates from 1883. This is an interesting work, and more, I think, than just a bit of juvenilia. Conventional graduation pieces at that time might be rather formal things (sets of fugues, for example) or small-scale compositions like songs for voice and piano. Puccini was having none of that. He wrote about his student days from a musical perspective later in his career: ‘I composed at home, in the street, in class, at the Osteria Aida or at the Excelsior of good old Signor Gigi, where one ate without the silly pretence of being able to pay for it; I wrote on odd sheets, bits of paper, and the margins of newspapers.’ Composition, in other words, was a compulsion. He showed the work to one of his teachers at the Milan Conservatory, Ponchielli (he of the ‘Dance of the Hours’ fame), who claimed not to be able to make head or tail of it, but nevertheless it was performed by the student orchestra in the summer of 1883, when Puccini’s time as a student came to an end. Ponchielli, converted to the work’s strengths, wrote to Puccini’s mother: ‘Those who deserve honours sooner or later receive them. In time, your son will achieve his just reward.’ Press reviews were equally glowing – one that almost, but not quite, hits the nail of the future on the head is this: ‘Puccini has won the favour of the general public. He unquestionably possesses the rare essentials of a symphonic composer. I am certain he would be equally successful in the vocal field and in dramatic expression, but his orchestral composition contains so much unity of style, personality, character, and brilliant technique as is rarely found among the most mature composers.’ Right about being ‘successful … in dramatic expression’, but wrong, at least in terms of Puccini’s mature interests, when it comes to the symphonic Puccini. Still, the Capriccio Sinfonico is definitely worth a listen, from its dark sonorous opening for winds and brass, via the lyrical and melodic reflective sections to the brisk, vigorous central episode, before it ends as it began. YouTube has a fine, if audio-only recording of the work, given by the Berlin Radio Symphony Orchestra and conducted by Riccardo Chailly, which you can find here: Puccini: Capriccio Sinfonico. Interestingly, the work disappeared pretty much without trace as a free-standing orchestral item after 1884, but Puccini went back to it at least twice: for a theme from his second opera, ‘Edgar’, and, more famously, for a more substantial episode from his fourth opera, ‘La Boheme’, which dates from 1896. It was his third opera, ‘Manon Lescaut’, that marked Puccini’s major breakthrough as an opera composer, but ‘La Boheme’ and its two successors (‘Tosca’ and ‘Madame Butterfly’) demonstrated convincingly that he was the natural heir to Verdi. ‘La Boheme’, based on an 1851 novel by the French writer Henri Murger, is a melodramatic tale of love in the midst of artistic impoverishment among the bohemian youth of Paris. Actually, when Puccini was writing this, his was not the only ‘La Boheme’ on the stocks. The composer Leoncavallo (the opera ‘Pagliacci’ is his most famous work) was also writing a version – but history has quite obliterated that telling of the story in favour of Puccini’s treatment. I thought I’d go for one of the opera’s most famous moments, in which the poet, Rodolfo, our romantic lead, sings to the frail, consumptive, seamstress heroine Mimi, whose tiny hand is, as is well known, ‘frozen’. (This particular line is a recurring motif in the Parker household, although the subject matter is often not just one tiny hand but both, not to mention both feet and a nose, Mrs P’s circulation not being the best.) Anyway, I thought we should finish marking Puccini’s centenary by sampling this most famous of tender moments. There are a number of versions on YouTube taken from videos of stagings of the opera, but either the image quality is poor or the performance is terribly hammy. So here is the tenor Jonas Kaufmann in a recording session, performing with what I think might be the City of Prague Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by Marco Armiliato. (The performers seem to be uncredited on this video, so if my guess is wrong and anyone has a better idea, do let me know!). You’ll find the performance here: Puccini: 'Che gelida manina' (from 'La Boheme')
Purcell, Henry (1659-95)
Day 53: ‘Dido’s Lament’ and ‘With Drooping Wings’ (from ‘Dido and Aeneas’) (Time: 12 minutes)
Today (14/5/20), a joint suggestion for some music by Henry Purcell (1659-95),
in that Malcolm emailed me a couple of days ago, suggesting that we hear Emma Kirkby
singing Dido’s lament, ‘Remember Me’, from Purcell’s ‘Dido and Aeneas’,
specifically in recognition of those who are mourning at this time.
For those who’d like this version in particular, here it is:
Purcell: 'Dido's
Lament' (Emma Kirkby)
However, at the same time as Malcolm’s email arrived, I was in the process
of lining up the closing minutes of Purcell’s opera anyway (in effect,
Dido’s Lament plus the closing chorus), so I’ve sought out a version
that takes us through the last ten minutes or so of the piece, in the company
of Maria Ewing as Dido, with the orchestra and chorus of Collegium Musicum 90,
conducted by Richard Hickox. ‘Dido and Aeneas’ is Purcell’s only
‘authentic’ (that is, sung throughout) opera. The final few minutes
of the opera are renowned for their poignant emotional intensity, the
chromatic tread of the repeated bass line of the lament, punctuated by Dido’s
desolate plea: ‘Remember me, but ah! – forget my fate’. The actual means
of death remains ambiguous here (unlike Virgil’s poem ‘The Aeneid’, on which
the opera is based, in which she falls, with bitter irony, on the sword Aeneas
had given her as a gift), but musically at least there is the implication that
the cause of death is a broken heart. The final chorus and dance of the
Cupids cements this bond between love and death. Purcell’s music raises the
occasionally prosaic libretto of Nahum Tate to remarkable heights here, finding
extraordinary beauty in the desolation with which the opera ends. You’ll
find the recording here:
Henry Purcell – ‘Dido’s Lament’ and ‘With Drooping Wings’ (from 'Dido and Aeneas')
Day 290: Fantasia No 6 in F (Time: 4 minutes) and Chaconny in G minor for String Quartet (7 minutes)
Later this month, the four string players who are part of Ensemble 360 are playing a programme which includes three pieces by Henry Purcell – so I thought I’d focus particularly on two of those pieces today (6/5/22). Purcell has appeared just the once on this list before (see above, Day 53), when the music in question was the closing sequence from his opera ‘Dido and Aeneas’. There are many who consider Purcell to be Britain’s finest composer (a tricky thing to judge, given that there’s competition from Tallis and Byrd among his predecessors and Elgar and Vaughan Williams among 20th century figures). Sitting on the fence somewhat, I’d confidently say he was Britain’s finest composer between the lives of Byrd and Elgar – I’m not sure I’d want to go further than that! He died at the relatively young age of 36, but into those years he packed an immense amount of musical composition. In some ways, he was born at an opportune time: the restoration of the monarchy in 1660 prompted a revival in musical activity (frowned upon as frivolous in Cromwell’s time), both privately, in terms of small ensembles in the service of the aristocracy, and publically, in terms of the renewed growth of interest in staged performances, including operas. In addition, church music again demanded creativity from the country’s finest composers. In terms of his public career, Purcell became organist at Westminster Abbey at the age of 20, and an enormous amount of his church music (over 60 verse anthems, 50 hymns, and a dozen settings of the Anglican morning, evening and communion services, in addition to the Funeral Music for the Death of Queen Mary) was the result. However, at the same time, he was a prolific composer for the London stage: there is incidental music for over 40 plays, and at least 7 surviving operas. Beyond that, there are literally hundreds of free-standing songs, odes and catches (a kind of round). However, amongst all this music essentially for the voice, Purcell wrote a quantity of instrumental music, which is fascinating, mostly for the sense that it was both ‘modern’ (for its time) and simultaneously backward-looking, in that it used forms and titles that had essentially fallen out of fashion by early in the 17th century, before the rupture in musical life that occurred with the Civil War and Commonwealth period. Most striking amongst these works is the set, ‘Fantasies and In Nomines’, which Purcell published in 1680. His motive in writing them is not at all clear. There is some suggestion that they were a kind of academic exercise, and that he may never have heard them performed during his lifetime. The likeliest explanation is that Purcell regarded them as a conscious exploration of a bygone idiom, but infused them with the theatricality of his more dramatic music, so that rather than being works of the late Renaissance (like similar pieces by Lawes, say, or Gibbons, a half-century earlier) they are more clearly works of the early Baroque period. He wrote them for musical forces that, again, were essentially out of date: the viol consort (see Day 163 for music by Dowland that is for these forces). The viol consort was a ‘family’ of string instruments of various pitches, the predecessors of the modern violin, viola, cello and double bass. By the 1680s when Purcell was writing these works, viol consorts were distinctly old-fashioned, and the new craze was for the combination of instruments we now have in the string quartet. Nine of the 13 ‘Fantasies’ (the spelling varies) Purcell wrote are for four ‘voices’ (that is, four different instruments), so you can see how this fits the musical forces of the future as well as the past. Ensemble 360 are playing Fantasies Nos 6&7, and the Chacony in G Minor (the last of these seemingly originating in Purcell’s theatre music, but famous particularly in a 20th century arrangement by Benjamin Britten). So that you have a sense of what the music sounds like when played on a consort of viols, here is the Fantazia No 6 in F, played by the American early music ensemble Wildcat Viols: Purcell: Fantazia No 6 in F. Then, in contrast, here is the Chacony in G Minor, in Britten’s arrangement, played by the Escher String Quartet: Purcell: Chacony in G Minor for String Quartet (arr. Britten)
Day 325: Music for the Funeral of Queen Mary (extracts) (Time: 11 minutes)
Considering some more appropriately solemn music for this period between Queen Elizabeth II’s death and her funeral next Monday, it occurs to me that in fact there has been some extraordinary music written for royal occasions past, in which composers have sought to express something of the desolation, as well as the inevitable drama, of such state events. Today (13/9/22) I’ve chosen some music by Henry Purcell (1659-95), who has appeared on this list twice before (see Days 53 and 290). As I wrote on that latter occasion, Purcell was renowned in his time not simply as a prolific composer for the church, but also as an inherently theatrical composer for the London stage. In his ‘Music for the Funeral of Queen Mary’ I don’t think it’s disrespectful to recognise both these tendencies in the finished piece. Purcell had previously written music for Mary II (the spouse of William III of Orange) who co-reigned with her husband from 1689 to her death five years later. His Birthday Ode (‘Come Ye Sons of Art’) was written for the Queen’s birthday in April 1694. Sadly, by 28th December of that year, she was dead at the age of only 32, a consequence of an attack of smallpox. Queen Mary’s death was a devastating blow not just to her husband, who had come to rely on her advice and guidance, but also an event that deeply affected the whole country. Having not wanted to marry William back in 1677 (let’s face it, she was only fifteen), the relationship between William and Mary seems to have become touchingly deep by the time of her death, and her popularity with the general public meant that there was strong demand for a funeral that would do justice to such devotion. However, the winter of 1694/5 was exceptionally cold (the Thames froze over), and it appears that this slowed the arrangements for her funeral, which were delayed until early March 1695. (Her embalmed body apparently lay in state in Whitehall for over two months.) When the occasion arrived, it was a theatrical event for which no expense was spared. Sir Christopher Wren ensured that the route to Westminster was lined with black railings, and it appears that 300 sombre older women led the funeral entourage dressed in black capes, with young boys carrying their trains. In this context, the potent and bitter-sweet music of Purcell suited the occasion ideally. Purcell had written funeral music before (three of the so-called ‘Sentences’ from the Anglican Burial Service), and it is thought that for the funeral of Queen Mary he used two of these (‘Man that is born of a woman’ and ‘In the midst of life we are in death’) along with a newly-composed version of the lines ‘Thou knowest, Lord, the secrets of our hearts’, a March and a Canzona – two sombre but undeniably dramatic instrumental pieces. It is a sad irony that by November of that same year the very same music would be performed in Westminster Abbey for Purcell’s own funeral. The ‘Music for the Funeral of Queen Mary’ is not a precisely fixed score. The fact that Purcell employed some previously-existing material, and the fact that the occasion allowed for some movements to be repeated, mean that a performance of this work can last anywhere from 15-30 minutes. For today’s posting, I’ve gone for a selection of pieces that make up part of this ‘Funeral Music’ – that is, the wonderfully dramatic March, the choral settings of ‘Man that is Born of Woman’ and ‘In the Midst of Life’, and the brass Canzona. [Don’t be puzzled by the suggestion, near the start of the following video, that there will also be ‘Thou Knowest, Lord’ and a repeat of the March – these come in a subsequent video.] The performance is by the Choir of Clare College, Cambridge and the instrumental group Baroque Brass of London. The conductor is Timothy Brown. The video quality is mixed and shows it age, and it has to be said that a couple of the soloists do look really quite scary – but I think it communicates that sense of theatre for which Purcell was renowned very impressively. (And, in case the music of the March sounds particularly familiar to some of you of a certain age, you may recall its use in Stanley Kubrick’s somewhat grotesque film version of ‘A Clockwork Orange’, where it was put to rather different ends!) You’ll find the performance here: Purcell: Music for the Funeral of Queen Mary (extracts)
Quantz, Johann Joachim (1697-1773)
Day 395: Flute Concerto No 161 in G (Time: 17 minutes)
Tomorrow marks the 250th anniversary of the death of Johann Joachim Quantz (1697-1773). In his day, he was one of the most renowned flute players (and flute makers) in Europe. Quantz has had a couple of peripheral mentions on this list already (see Days 117/8) in the context of flute music written by, or attributed to, JS and CPE Bach. I mentioned back then that this music, especially that written by Carl Philipp Emmanuel Bach, was heavily influenced by and quite possibly written for Quantz, who was for much of his professional life in the employ of Frederick II of Prussia, in whose court Quantz worked in the decades until his death. He was born in a village in Saxony and destined, seemingly, for life as a blacksmith until the untimely death of his father (the village blacksmith intent on passing on his trade to his son), when Quantz was ten years old, which gave the young Quantz a degree of freedom to pursue what really interested him in life, which seems to have been music. Study with various relatives and local musicians followed, including counterpoint with Zelenka (see Day 391), before finding employment as an oboist in the court orchestra of August II of Saxony (that’s August ‘the Strong’ for those who like to distinguish between their various Augusts). Seeing how the land lay in the world of oboe playing, Quantz switched to the seemingly more employable flute, completed his ‘education’ with a Grand Tour of Europe in the mid-1720s, and came to the attention of the Queen of Prussia, who thought him entirely suitable (it’s odd how the world worked back then) as the flute player who might cure the ‘melancholy’ of her eldest son (the one who would become Frederick ‘the Great’ later on). When Frederick eventually became King of Prussia in 1740 (actually, not wishing to be inundated with emails from pedants, I should say that he became ‘King in Prussia’ in 1740, but ‘King of Prussia’ from 1772), Quantz entered his employment as his flute teacher, as well as being an official flute maker to the king – who seems to have owned at least a dozen flutes made by Quantz – and court composer. Curiously, Quantz was never actually a member of Frederick’s court orchestra, though he did play music with them over the succeeding decades. It would seem that from the early 1740s onwards, Quantz was pretty much set up for life, and in musical terms he was offered effectively the freedom to devote himself to the theory and practice of flute playing from then on. He was the author of the imaginatively titled ‘On Playing the Flute’ in 1752, which is one of our primary sources for understanding how flute playing evolved during the 18th century. But from music history’s point of view, he was also the composer of, implausibly, at least 281 known flute concertos and at least 184 known flute sonatas. Hardly any of this music was actually published during Quantz’s lifetime, and some of it is only now beginning to see the light of day – ‘new’ works by him are still being discovered, such as the six flute quartets that turned up in Berlin in 2001. I’d have to say, hand on heart, that I’d have trouble telling a lot of his hundreds of concertos apart from each other – obviously the minor key ones sound different to the major key ones, and ones for two flute soloists sound different to ones for a single soloist, but this is, to a large extent, music ‘composed by the yard’, as it were, and appearing on a production line to suit the needs of court performance. To that extent, I’d make no great claims for the quality of a lot of this stuff. It’s pleasing, perhaps, but not hugely memorable. Why then go to this trouble to bring it to your attention? Well, as ever, because it seems to be a pity for composers to be forgotten, when we can use their music to fill in the gaps between the works that are part of the mainstream repertoire. And also because it’s characteristic of the sort of style that was in high fashion in the middle decades of the 18th century, before ‘classical’ music swept away the last vestiges of baroque music in (roughly) the final three decades of the 18th century. So today (11/7/23), and picked pretty much at random (largely because I can provide a link to a video performance of a work played in its entirety, rather than each movement being linked separately), here is Quantz’s Flute Concerto No 161 in G. It’s in the familiar three movements, ordered fast-slow-fast, and it’s played on this video recording by the recently-formed Orfeus Barock, a period instrument chamber ensemble from Stockholm. The soloist on baroque flute is Benedick Csalog. You’ll find the recording here: Quantz: Flute Concerto No 161 in G
|
R–V
|
R · S · T · U · V |
|
Rabl, Walter (1873-1940)
Day 433: Clarinet Quartet, Op 1 (Time: 24 minutes)
Today (28/11/23) it’s (sort of) happy birthday time again. To be precise, two days from now, on Nov 30th, it will be 150 years exactly since the birth of Walter Rabl. Not many people know that … but I hope that if/when you get round to reading this and listening to the music, you might find it an enriching experience. A great many composers were born in 1873, and if Rachmaninov’s anniversary overshadowed all the others (see below), it doesn’t mean we can’t give them a moment or two in the spotlight. In truth, Walter Rabl (1873-1940) is now almost completely unknown, and the fact that he stopped composing entirely at the age of 30 means that there’s not a lot of his music out there to get to know. If you look for him on YouTube, you’ll find that over 90% of the links take you to Rabl’s Op. 1 … and it’s not surprising therefore that that’s the music you’ll get from me today. In 1896, when Rabl was in his early twenties, he entered a music competition, organised by the Vienna Tonkünstlerverein, the ‘Music Society’ of which, at the time, Brahms was president – and therefore also the main judge of the compositions of the 18 people who entered. Rabl’s life before this moment is not well documented. We know he was born in Vienna, but was educated in Switzerland and then studied Music Theory in Salzburg, before returning to study music with the teacher Karl Navratil in Vienna. Whether he wrote anything at all before his Op. 1 is also not clear – certainly nothing has survived. The Vienna Tonkünstlerverein was essentially a conservative musical organisation, formed just over a decade earlier as a kind of musical riposte to the ‘Wagner faction’ (the so-called New German School) in Vienna. These turf wars, if you like, between Wagnerites and Brahmsians played out over several years in the late 19th/early 20th centuries, in often vitriolic ways (due to the behaviour of the composers’ followers, it has to be said). Anyway, this competition that Brahms judged invited, unsurprisingly, music of a not very revolutionary character, but rather pieces that built on and developed very Brahmsian ways of making music. The only piece from the competition that has any kind of foothold in the repertoire today was the Clarinet Trio, Op 3 by Zemlinsky (see Day 231), which won third prize. The piece that came second has now disappeared entirely, but the first-prize winner was … Rabl’s Clarinet Quartet, Op 1. As far as I know, it’s the first piece ever composed for clarinet, violin, cello and piano – a line-up made very famous indeed nearly 50 years later by Olivier Messiaen (see Day 47 for a movement from his Quatuor pour le Fin de Temps). Brahms was very taken by Rabl’s piece, which was submitted, according to the rules, anonymously, though clearly some clues leaked out. He wrote to his publisher, ‘the best [entry] is said to be by Rabl, a pupil of Navratil. I know little about the young man and his music … Now of course I’ll keep my eyes on him, and his piece.’ A fortnight later, Brahms wrote again: ‘I have more and more encouraging things to report of our prize-winner Walter Rabl. A whole pile of his music lies before me.’ On the basis of this, one might imagine that Rabl had a glittering career ahead of him, but by 1903 he had stopped composing altogether. Why? Well, it’s not clear, in that there are indications that his early works (several sets of songs, some ‘Fantasy Pieces’ for piano trio, a violin sonata, and even a symphony) were reasonably well received, but then he wrote an opera, ‘Liane’ in 1903, which again seemed successful, but the reviews very explicitly highlighted its Wagnerian qualities, and it seems as though this was enough to deter Rabl (ever the Brahms devotee) from proceeding further. There’s a telling quotation from Rabl’s son about this: ‘Following its premiere, his final work was described by critics as clearly echoing Wagner in style, a description he himself felt was justified. In (perhaps overly harsh) self-criticism, he drew the conclusion that he lacked the creative powers to compose and that it would therefore be the right thing to cease efforts in this area. Perhaps he also felt he had betrayed the Brahmsian tradition and joined the then endless legions of Wagner’s epigones.’ It should be said that maybe another explanation is that Rabl’s conducting career in the opera house was beginning to take off, and in fact that’s the profession he followed for the rest of his life in various German opera houses. The Clarinet Quartet is in four movements. It’s quite a compact work, with very little ‘late Romantic’ sprawl about it – very Brahmsian, in fact. But if it sounds like late Brahms that’s not a bad thing (definitely not, in my view!), and for a young composer’s first meaningful work it’s very impressively structured and sensitively composed for all four instruments. After a terse first movement the second is a kind of funeral march and the third a lilting ‘Andantino’ before a finale that actually looks back beyond Brahms, I think, to Mendelssohn and Schumann. So, is there a distinctive ‘Rabl voice’? Probably not … but he’s an excellent ventriloquist. As for a performance, YouTube has dozens of them, though many are amateur performances of variable quality. Out of the available video recordings, I’ve gone for this one by the not very self-effacingly named Fantastico Quartet (an ensemble about which I can tell you absolutely nothing at all beyond the names of the performers – this recording dates from April 2021, but I can find no further references to them on the interweb). You’ll find it here: Rabl: Clarinet Quartet, Op 1
Rachmaninov, Sergei (1873-1943)
Day 56: Symphonic Dances (3rd movement) (Time: 14 minutes*)
I thought today (17/5/20) I’d go with a late work by Rachmaninov (1873-1943). Like Stravinsky yesterday, Rachmaninov never returned to Russia after the 1917 Revolution, and this had a marked impact on his composition in two ways. One was that it brought it almost to a standstill – if you look at a catalogue of his works, between 1918 and 1943 he completed just six pieces of music – largely because he spent so much time touring as a pianist as a way of making ends meet. However, the second way in which exile changed Rachmaninov’s music is that it imbued what was already an essentially melancholy, nostalgic style with a deeper and deeper sense of loss. (He was also seen by musical history as a kind of relic in the years after the first world war, working in an idiom that the rest of the musical world had mostly left behind.) However, I’d want to argue that these latter years of his life provide us with at least two front-rank masterpieces, the ‘Rhapsody on a Theme of Paganini’ and today’s work, the ‘Symphonic Dances’. In earlier Rachmaninov, the tendency to wallow in an emotion is often fairly unrestrained; however, there’s a cooler, more restrained edge to the works of his final years. And the Symphonic Dances, like so much of his music, is haunted by two musical fingerprints (if you can be haunted by a fingerprint – I hope you know what I mean!). One is the sound of the music of the Russian Orthodox Church, and the other is the medieval theme, the ‘Dies Irae’, whose sombre tread turns up in many many composers’ work, but is everywhere in Rachmaninov. If the 15-minute rule were ignored, I’d love to recommend the whole of the Symphonic Dances, but trying at least occasionally to be good, I’m going to opt for the final movement. In this last movement, there is a spiritual conflict if you like between the ‘Dies Irae’ theme, representative of death, and a quotation from Rachmaninov’s much earlier ‘Vespers’ (or ‘All Night Vigil’), from a movement which sets words about Christ’s resurrection. The ‘Resurrection’ theme has the final word – Rachmaninov writing ‘Hallelujah!’ over the score at this point. I’ve looked around for performances of this, and have been particularly taken by the Netherlands Radio Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Edward Gardiner. However, it’s a full performance of the work… so to listen to the 3rd movement only, you will need to scroll forward to approx. 23mins, 15secs* into the video or click here. (You could of course start from the beginning and enjoy the whole thing, but I wouldn’t want to be thought to be advocating such over-indulgence!) You’ll find the recording here: Rachmaninov – Symphonic Dances (3rd movement)
Day 62: ‘All-Night Vigil’ (movements 5, 6 and 9) (Time in total: 13 minutes)
Today (23/5/20), a suggestion from Martin that emerged out
of the Stravinsky ‘Symphony of Psalms’ that I chose last Saturday. Martin
is keen that we listen to some more music with its roots in this tradition, so
he’s suggested a movement from Rachmaninov's ‘All-Night Vigil’, specifically
the sixth movement, ‘Bogoroditse Devo’ (the ‘Hail Mary’).
Rachmaninov wrote the ‘All-Night Vigil’ in 1915. (It is also popularly called the ‘Vespers’,
although – and I’m sure there are people on this list who can put me right on
theologically-appropriate terminology – my understanding is that only movements 1-6 of this
15-movement piece are technically settings of the ‘Vespers’)
It was one of his favourite compositions, and he had the ‘Nunc Dimittis’ movement from it
sung at his funeral.
In fact, because the movement Martin has chosen is so short, I’ve actually attached three movements
from the ‘All-Night Vigil’, as follows:
Movement 5: ‘Nine otpushchayeshi’ (the ‘Nunc dimittis’) – Rachmaninov:
All-Night Vigil (5th movement)
Movement 6: ‘Bogoroditse Devo’ (the ‘Hail Mary’) – All-Night Vigil (6th movement)
Movement 9: ‘Blagosloven yesi, Gospodi’ (‘Blessed Art Thou, O Lord’) – All-Night Vigil (9th movement)
I chose this movement because this is what Rachmaninov quoted in the final movement
of his ‘Symphonic Dances’, which you may recall I suggested we listen to last Sunday.
The performers on all three extracts (including the fantastic basses, who get down to
a bottom Bb – that’s the one which is off the bottom of the bass clef!)
are the Estonian Philharmonic Chamber Choir, conducted by Paul Hillier.
Day 106: Rhapsody on a Theme by Paganini (Time: 24 minutes)
You will recall that when last we met (Day 105: Paganini), we encountered the Caprice No 24 for Solo Violin, which along with the medieval dance tune ‘La Folia’ is one of the most reworked, varied and generally manipulated tunes in the whole classical repertoire. After Paganini published his 24 Caprices in 1820, composers queued up to arrange No 24 (Schumann in 1832, Liszt in 1833, for example, both for piano) and subsequently to write sets of variations upon it. Brahms wrote two books of variations on it in the 1860s (which ought to cure anyone who has ever been so foolish as to consider Brahms a stodgy Germanic composer), and in the 20th century, probably the two most famous composers to have taken up the theme’s challenges are Rachmaninov and Lutoslawski. Today (31/7/20), I wanted to share with you the joys contained in the former composer’s piece. The Rhapsody on a Theme by Paganini appeared in 1934, one of only six works that Rachmaninov composed after his self-imposed exile from Russia in 1917. Although it consists of 24 variations on Paganini’s theme, and is performed in one continuous flow, it has the rough overall shape of a piano concerto in the traditional three fast-slow-fast movements. When Rachmaninov appeared previously on this list (Day 56), I featured a movement from the Symphonic Dances, and like that piece, the Paganini Rhapsody also features the solemn tread of the medieval ‘Dies Irae’ theme: I don’t think there was a time when Rachmaninov wasn’t haunted by the sense of the omnipresence of death. The ‘Dies Irae’ theme appears in Variation 7, and from then on it is consistently interwoven with the Paganini Caprice. The most famous section is probably Variation 18, where Rachmaninov turns Paganini’s theme upside down and transposes it into the major key, to produce the sweeping tender melody that seems as though it’s come from a different world from the original. There are a number of good video recordings of the work on YouTube, from which I’ve gone for a performance by Stephen Hough, supported by the BBC Symphony Orchestra and conducted by Sakari Oramo, from the 2013 BBC Proms. Warning! The video makes it look as though the piece is 30 minutes long, but fret not – the Rachmaninov starts after 4 minutes (before that there’s some interesting chat between Mr Hough and Radio 3’s Katie Derham, not only about the Rachmaninov, but also about Lutoslawski as well… which might give you some idea of where I’m intending to go next!) and there’s a good couple of minutes’ applause at the end. You’ll find it here: Rachmaninov: Rhapsody on a Theme of Paganini
Day 260: Symphony No 2 in E Minor, Op 27 (3rd movement) (Time: 14 minutes)
Sergei Rachmaninov has featured three times on this list (see Days 56, 62 and 106), but not, so far, in terms of the lush sound world of pre-first world war Rachmaninov; so today (21/1/22), you have the opportunity for a good,cluxuriating wallow in Rachmaninov as he sounded before, if you like, he was forced to earn his living as a touring concert pianist, which effectively put a stop to the flow of compositions of his early adulthood: as I mentioned in an earlier posting, he only composed six pieces of music between 1917, when he left Russia for good, and his death in 1943. That’s not to say that everything was plain sailing compositionally for the pre-war Rachmaninov. As you may know, he wrote his Symphony No 1 in 1895, a thrilling and still rarely-played work that juggles the sound world of Russian liturgical music (and especially the theme that haunts almost everything he wrote, the medieval ‘Dies Irae’ melody) and a kind of Russianised ‘gypsy’ passion. The premiere of the symphony was a disaster – the familiar line is that Glazunov, who conducted the first performance in 1897, was drunk, and in any case the orchestra had been seriously under-rehearsed. Rachmaninov withdrew the work immediately – it was never played again in his lifetime, and only resurfaced from rediscovered orchestral parts in the 1940s after his death, allowing it to be reconstructed and returned to his oeuvre – and he suffered a kind of nervous breakdown, and consequent creative paralysis. Hypnotherapy with the Russian neurologist Nikolai Dahl seems to have ‘unlocked’ Rachmaninov’s creative flow – the indestructibly sweeping Piano Concerto No 2 was the result – and in the first decade of the 20th century Rachmaninov not only began composition again, but discovered a talent as an opera conductor that soon put him in great demand, as well as continuing to be renowned as one of the greatest pianists of his (or any) age. Rachmaninov seems to have had very little interest in politics or its impact on society, and he seems to have seen the failed Russian revolution of 1905 as evidence of the need to escape from the turmoil of Russian society. At any rate, after some meandering around western Europe, he and his young family settled for a time in Germany, where he spent a period of time from 1906 onwards composing the 2nd Symphony. (Along with several sets of piano pieces, other big works of the period 1905-15 include the 3rd Piano Concerto, the Liturgy of St John Chrysostom, the choral symphony ‘The Bells’ and finally the All-Night Vigil.) The Symphony No 2 is a huge work. Even when I started going to concerts as a young man in the 1970s it was still not uncommon to perform it with heavy cuts to the score, especially to the first movement, reducing what should be a 60 minute work to 45 minutes or so. But the sweep and grandeur of the piece as a whole is what makes it so compelling. Like many late Romantic works, it has recurring ‘motto’ themes, giving the work a kind of ‘cyclic’ cohesion. Unsurprisingly, one of those themes is the ‘Dies Irae’ melody. It echoes through the symphony’s most emotional moments in the third movement Adagio, which is what I’ve selected for us to indulge in. Before the ‘motto’ theme arrives, however, there are two melodies of impeccable Rachmaninov tenderness: the opening theme on the strings which will return at the movement’s climax, and a long, winding melody (like so much prime Rachmaninov, its phrases circle around two or three notes in a manner reminiscent of Russian Orthodox chant) on the clarinet. The themes unfold towards an impassioned climax before the movement subsides into a tranquillity that is both moving and consoling. If you like Russian Romantic music, this is about as good as it gets, I think. Performances (especially video recordings) of just the slow movement are thin on the ground on YouTube, but I’ve chosen this one by the authentically dark-sounding Russian Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by Kazuki Yamada. It’s not the most polished performance you’ll hear, but it has its roots in the Russian performing tradition, still audible even more than a century after Rachmaninov composed the work. You’ll find it here: Rachmaninov: Symphony No 2 in E Minor, Op 27 (3rd movement)
Day 360: Preludes Op 32 Nos 5 and 12; Piano Sonata No 2, Op 36 (Time: 25 minutes)
Imminently, the renowned Scottish pianist Steven Osborne (one of the first batch of BBC New Generation Artists from 1999-2001; it’s astonishing how many from that first group have gone on to have exceptional careers) is due to give a recital here in Sheffield, of music mostly by Schubert and Rachmaninov, so I thought it would be good to draw attention to some pieces by Rachmaninov that might feature on the programme. (I say ‘might’ because the information before the concert suggests we’ll hear the Piano Sonata No 2, plus ‘a selection’ of Rachmaninov Preludes and Etudes-Tableaux.) What I’ve chosen to discuss today, as a result, is the sonata and a couple of the preludes, that you may or may not hear in his concert. As far as the Preludes go, I’ve explored the issue of ‘what is a prelude?’ before (see Days 68 for Gershwin, 210 for Bach, 211 for Scriabin, 241 for Chopin, and 242 for Debussy, in relation to preludes for piano solo) so I won’t rehearse all that again. Rachmaninov wrote two substantial sets of preludes (10 Preludes, Op 23 and 13 Preludes, Op 32) and then a handful of free-standing individual pieces with that title – the famous C# Minor Prelude, Op 3 No 2, and a couple of others, in F Major and D Minor, that came later. The recording I’ve chosen for us of the 2nd Piano Sonata also includes, by way of a prelude (sorry…!), two of the Op 32 set – No 5 in G and No 12 in G# Minor. Op 32 No 5 and Op 32 No 12 are startling in that (along with No 11 from this set) they were all written on the same day, 23rd August 1910! At this point in his career Rachmaninov was in many ways at his creative peak. The whole set of the Op 32 Preludes came to him very quickly, and they have an ‘organic’ unity in that many of them develop from a particular motif or ‘cell’ which is then developed in various ways. The G Major Prelude, No 5, was in fact the first to be written, and its most striking quality, I think, is the way the lyrical upper melody ‘floats’ over the murmuring accompaniment in the left hand, but somewhat uneasily, in that the left hand is playing in units of five beats set against three in the right hand. No 12 in G# Minor starts with a bright, almost jangling figure high in the piano’s range, but this is increasingly challenged by the darker, brooding melody which becomes more urgent as the piece unfolds. The Piano Sonata No 2 in Bb Minor, Op 36, exists in two versions – one from 1913, and then a second, revised version, dating from 1931. The differences between them are largely a matter of thinning out the texture and shortening the whole. ‘So many voices are moving simultaneously, and it is too long,’ Rachmaninov said of the original version when the revised one was published. However, there is evidence that towards the end of his life Rachmaninov stepped back from the revision, and actually preferred the first version. At its first performance, that original version was overshadowed by the very recent performance of Rachmaninov’s choral symphony ‘The Bells’. It is perhaps the lack of an obvious ‘big tune’ that has prevented the Piano Sonata No 2 from becoming a popular hit with the public. It opens explosively, and the early moments are full of a kind of florid power, until gradually a nagging recurring theme emerges. The second movement feels like it comes from somewhere miles away. The liner notes from the CD I have of this music observe rather fancifully of this second movement: ‘It is a quiet summer’s day in southern Russia, with the butterflies gently fluttering against the rich colours of the motionless roses and lilacs in full bloom, the grass warmed with haze, the earth full yet not damp underfoot.’ (Make of that what you will!) There are renewed glimpses of two of the main ideas from the first movement before the final movement bursts in with relentless energy. We finish in the major key, triumphant and brilliant. As for a performance, there is a video recording on YouTube of the virtuoso Canadian pianist Marc-André Hamelin playing the 2nd Piano Sonata, preceded by the two Preludes from Op 32 that I’ve discussed, all taken from a recital Hamelin gave in Moscow in 2013. There are actually a great many recordings of the sonata on YouTube, played by a variety of famous and rather less well-known pianists, but out of the ones I’ve sampled in putting together this posting, Hamelin is I think very impressive – playing of neither buttoned-down restraint nor swooning excess. You’ll find his performance here: Rachmaninov: Preludes Op 32 Nos 5 and 12; Piano Sonata No 2, Op 36
Day 366: Isle of the Dead (Time: 20 minutes)
This week, for reasons that should become obvious, I think, the focus will be on Rachmaninov. He was born on April 1st, 1873, which makes this coming Saturday his 150th birthday. But also, in a rather more commemorative than celebratory way, the 80th anniversary of his death – 28th March, 1943 – falls today (28/3/23). So, as we have a double reason for marking this composer’s contribution to the richness of our musical life, you’re going to get two helpings of Rachmaninov as a result. I hope nobody minds… We’ve had five appearances by Rachmaninov on this list already – see Days 56, 62, 106, 260 and 360 – so I suppose there’s a bit of a danger of him being over-represented, but although his reputation amongst music critics has varied over the years of his life, and even more so since his death, he has remained immensely popular with the music-listening public, and I see no reason to sneer at popularity just because it exists. I’ve written extensively about the different compositional periods of his life over the course of previous (accessible via the ‘Archive’) postings, so all I want to say about the context for today’s work is that it comes from that rich compositional period in Rachmaninov’s life, the years from 1900 to the start of the First World War. Rachmaninov’s breakdown and subsequent compositional block after the disastrous first performance of his Symphony No 1 in 1897 was only cured, as you may know, by the intervention of hypnotist Nikolai Dahl, whose regime’s first fruits – the Piano Concerto No 2 and the Cello Sonata – seem to have given the always self-doubting composer the affirmation he needed. Though he continued to have bouts of anxiety about his art in the years that followed, music flowed relatively steadily from him up to 1914. I’ve chosen for today a not very well-known orchestral piece which dates from 1907/8. Rachmaninov actually didn’t write all that much for orchestra alone, the piano being the dominant instrument in his output. There were attempts at writing for orchestra when he was a teenager and then a music student, but otherwise we’re looking at three symphonies and the ‘Symphonic Dances’, and four ‘tone poems’: ‘Prince Rostislav’ (1891), ‘The Rock’ (1893), the Caprice Bohemien (also 1893), and then his one mature work in this vein, ‘Isle of the Dead’, which is what I want to share with you today. He began work on this in 1907, completing it early the following year. At the time, Rachmaninov and his wife and young family were living in Dresden, where he had recently completed his Symphony No 2. Contemplating a source of inspiration for a further orchestral piece, he encountered a black-and-white reproduction of a work by the Swiss painter Arnold Böcklin. Interestingly, Rachmaninov later saw the actual colour painting, and was prompted to remark, ‘I was not much moved by the colour of the painting. If I had seen the original first, I might not have composed my ‘Isle of the Dead’. I like the picture best in black and white.’ Böcklin (1827-1901) was a ‘symbolist’ painter. His canvases have something in common with the Pre-Raphaelite school in England, though they are perhaps a little more brooding and troubled in character. His painting ‘Toteninsel’ (‘Isle of the Dead’) – actually paintings, in that he produced five of them in the first half of the 1880s – seem to have had an impact on a lot of late 19th/early 20th century composers (not terribly famous figures like Hallen, Schulz-Beuthen, Weigl and Woyrsch, but also Max Reger, as recently spotted in these parts) but undoubtedly its most famous musical depiction is Rachmaninov’s orchestral work. You can see a black-and-white photograph of one of the painting’s several versions here. The music Rachmaninov wrote seems to me to be both hauntingly appropriate for the image – its stillness, its brooding sense of threat, its deeply sombre note – and (as is inevitable with Rachmaninov) to allow the composer yet another opportunity to exploit what was fast becoming his ‘motto’ theme, the medieval ‘Dies Irae’ melody. (You’ll find it in pretty much all the Rachmaninov that’s appeared on this list to date, but notably in the ‘Symphonic Dances’ and the Paganini Rhapsody.) Pieces rooted in a 5/8 (or 5/4) rhythm are not that common in music – probably the most famous are the second movement of Tchaikovsky’s Symphony No 6 or ‘Mars’ from Holst’s ‘The Planets’ – but Rachmaninov makes striking use of it at the beginning and end of this tone poem, conveying something of the rhythmic motion of the oarsman who is conveying the mysterious figure in white and the coffin towards the shore. This gently lapping pattern is broken by a horn solo (subsequently also oboe and then trumpet), a melody that has the seeds of the ‘Dies Irae’ within it. The central episode of the piece offers more animation and drama, developing the horn theme into a striking chorale for all the brass, leading to a huge climax. Out of that, the strings offer only a desolate echoing of the ‘Dies Irae’ before the music winds back down to where it started – the rocking 5/8 ‘rowing’ motif – and gradually to an enigmatic silence. YouTube offers quite a number of performances of this work. I’ve gone, as so often in this sort of music, for something as ‘authentic’ as possible, from a Russian orchestra and conductor. So, Rachmaninov’s ‘Isle of the Dead’ is played in this performance by the Russian National Orchestra, conducted by Mikhail Pletnev. You’ll find it here: Rachmaninov: Isle of the Dead
Day 367: Izhe kheruvimy ('Cherubic Hymn'), Op 31 No 8 (Time: 5 minutes) and Otche nash (‘Lord's Prayer’), Op 31 No 14 (6 minutes)
Welcome to the second instalment in Rachmaninov Week; the 150th anniversary of his birth falls tomorrow, a fact that’s pretty inescapable if you’re a Radio 3 listener, given all the trails for commemorative programmes. As for the choice for today (31/3/23), I realise we’ve had some of Rachmaninov’s unaccompanied choral music before (see Day 62 for movements 5, 6 and 9 from his All-Night Vigil) but, particularly in the run-up to Easter, I thought a little more liturgical choral music would not go amiss. So, what you’ve got today are two movements from Rachmaninov’s setting of the Liturgy of St John Chrysostom, Op 31. Rachmaninov wrote two large-scale religious works for unaccompanied voices – the Liturgy (1910) and the All-Night Vigil (1915) – and it is striking that the earlier of these pieces is markedly less popular than the later one. One reason for its lack of popularity might lie in the fact that the Liturgy is much more explicitly constructed to provide the music for pretty much a complete Russian Orthodox Church service; it was composed, in other words, for the church rather than the concert hall, and given its length, it does not easily lend itself to ‘secular’ performance. St John Chrysostom (literally ‘St John Golden-Mouthed’) was Archbishop of Constantinople in the early 5th century. He was one of the most celebrated authors in early church history, and his spiritual homilies achieved wide renown. The ‘Liturgy’ to which his name has become attached is, as I understand it, the normal Eucharistic liturgy today for both Eastern Orthodox and Eastern Catholic churches. Rachmaninov was by no means the first to compose music for the rite (Tchaikovsky wrote a version in 1878), but like his fellow composer, Rachmaninov fell foul of the immensely conservative church authorities when it came to liturgical usage. Rachmaninov wrote the work quite quickly (for him) over the spring and summer of 1910, writing to his friend Morozov, ‘I have been thinking about the ‘Liturgy’ for a long time, and for a long time, I strove to write it. I started to work on it somehow by chance and then suddenly became fascinated with it. And then I finished it very quickly. Not for a long time have I written anything with such pleasure.’ He liaised carefully with the religious foundation the Moscow Synodal School during its composition. Although it contains no movements based on traditional Orthodox plainchant (unlike the All-Night Vigil), but is rather an entirely ‘free-composed’ piece, Rachmaninov was keen to keep his creative urges compatible with church musical conventions at the time. Alas, the church authorities were entirely unimpressed, and forbade its use in services. An anecdotal comment by a teacher at the Synodal School noted that the piece is ‘absolutely wonderful, even too beautiful, but with such music it would be difficult to pray; it is not church music.’ A somewhat more gushing remark by a member of the audience at its first performance is this: ‘Rachmaninov came out on stage wearing a black frock-coat instead of the customary tail-coat. His tall, thin figure on the podium, and the sharp features of his face were particularly striking and beautiful; he embodied the mood of the whole concert and immediately transfixed the audience. Their solemn silence, intense concentration and inspired faces attested to the fact that Rachmaninov’s music had found its way to their hearts.’ The work is, by most calculations (it’s not an exact science), in twenty movements, so what I’ve opted to do today is to choose what are probably the two most popular sections of the piece. What you have here are the ‘Cherubic Hymn’ (No 8 in the normal counting method) and the Lord’s Prayer (No 14). The former – an approximate translation of its words is ‘Let us who mystically represent the Cherubim, and who sing the thrice-holy hymn to the life-creating Trinity, now lay aside all cares of this life, (Amen.) that we may receive the King of All, who comes invisibly upborne by the angelic host. Alleluia, alleluia, alleluia’ – comes at the point in the church service where in the early church, those who were not receiving communion would leave. The Cherubic hymn marks the beginning of the Liturgy of the Faithful, where the gifts of bread and wine are brought in. In Rachmaninov’s setting it starts as a slow contemplative hymn, but the speed doubles halfway through, and it ends with another Rachmaninov speciality – pianissimo Alleluias! The ‘Otche nash’ (or ‘Lord’s Prayer’) is a setting for double choir which in some ways looks forward to the more complex settings in the later All-Night Vigil. One choir has the words of the prayer, while the other repeats ‘Otche nash’ (Our Father). At the end, both choirs join to sing ‘Our Father’ before and during the final line ‘But deliver us from the Evil One’. Video performances of these movements on YouTube aren’t all that common, but there’s an enjoyable performance of the ‘Cherubic Hymn’, by the National Lutheran Choir (of America), directed by David Cherwien, which you’ll find here: Rachmaninov: Izhe kheruvimy ('Cherubic Hymn'), Op 31 No 8. As for the Lord’s Prayer, we’re in audio-only territory I’m afraid, but there’s a decent performance, I think, by the Choir of King’s College, Cambridge, conducted by Stephen Cleobury, which you can find here (prefaced by a plainchant version of the prayer): Rachmaninov: Otche nash ('Lord's Prayer'), Op 31 No 14
Day 519: Piano Concerto No 2 (Time: 35 minutes)
That evergreen warhorse, Rachmaninov’s Piano Concerto No 2 gets a concert performance in Sheffield tomorrow evening, and so this is my selection for today (6/12/24). Rachmaninov has appeared on seven occasions thus far on this playlist, which makes him one of the more popular choices. In terms of works for piano and orchestra, you can find the thrilling Rhapsody on a Theme by Paganini, one of Rachmaninov’s late works from his period of exile from Russia, on Day 106. You will probably know that apart from this piece, Rachmaninov wrote four concertos for these forces. The Piano Concerto No 1 was Rachmaninov’s Opus 1, the piece with which he formally announced himself to the musical world as a teenager in 1891. The Piano Concerto No 4 (the least played of the set) dates from 1926, when, after years of relentless touring as a pianist and conductor in his wanderings after the Russian Revolution, he eventually set aside time to complete a work he’d started back in Russia in 1917. The other two concertos, Nos 2 & 3, are the product of Rachmaninov’s most fertile period as a composer, the years from the beginning of the 20th century up to the 1917 revolution. However, the Piano Concerto No 2 has a well-known back story that shows how hard-won this period of creativity was. Back in 1897 Rachmaninov’s Symphony No 1 received its premiere in St Petersburg. The event was, by all accounts, a disaster. Opinions as to why vary, but seem to include extreme under-rehearsal of the orchestra and the inebriation of the conductor Alexander Glazunov (see Day 223 for a rather happier encounter with Glazunov). Rachmaninov, an impressionable young man of still only 24, fled from the hall in tears, and there followed a period of total creative collapse that lasted for the next three years. By the beginning of 1900 he had still composed almost nothing since the symphony’s first performance, and he was getting desperate. At that point he hit upon a course of treatment with a neurologist called Dr Nikolai Dahl, who specialised in hypnosis, and for three months in early 1900 he met Dahl daily at his home for treatment. This seems to have involved Rachmaninov falling into a trance-like state, while Dahl repeated an unvarying formula: ‘You will begin to write your concerto ... You will work with great facility ... The concerto will be of an excellent quality.’ However one chooses to make sense of this experience, the fact is that by the late summer of 1900 he had completed the second and third movements, and the opening movement too was finished by April 1901, and the concerto was performed, to a great reception, in November of that year. It was dedicated, by the way, to Dr Dahl, so there is no escaping the value that Rachmaninov himself placed on Dahl’s ‘cure’ for his writer’s block. It’s a work that has never lost its popularity, and even when critics got sniffy about Rachmaninov in the mid-to-late 20th century (all those swooning big tunes – must be of dubious quality) his concerto retained its place in the repertoire, and in people’s hearts. These days, when the musical landscape is less austere than was the case during what one might call an era of aggressive modernism, Rachmaninov’s music is welcomed much more openly. You don’t have to be a Classic FM devotee (on which station Rach 2 regularly ends up in the top two or three in their annual ‘Hall of Fame’) to know just how popular the work is, even if critics continued to sneer at it (‘of uneven worth … might have been written by any German, technically well-trained, who was acquainted with the music of Tchaikovsky’ wrote a reviewer of the first American performance in 1909; ‘plenty of cheap glitter’ said the Liverpool Post, even as late as 1927). The attraction of the work as material for film and TV soundtracks is one reason for it remaining consistently at the forefront of the public gaze. Its use in David Lean’s ‘Brief Encounter’ in 1945 is only the most famous of several occasions when the musical material did the heavy lifting for moments of passion and tenderness. As for a performance, YouTube is, unsurprisingly, well-stocked with options, and out of them I’ve gone for this recording by the pianist Nikolai Lugansky, accompanied by the French National Orchestra conducted by Emmanuel Krivine. You’ll find the performance here: Rachmaninov: Piano Concerto No 2 (followed by lots of applause and an encore, Rachmaninov’s own arrangement for piano of Tchaikovsky’s ‘Cradle Song’, Op 16 No 1).
And finally, a shameless plug: As many of you know I write short stories as well as writing about music, and I produced a short story, ‘Green Shoots,’ which is a creative re-telling of Rachmaninov’s experiences at the hands of Dr Dahl. This story found its way into my first published collection of short stories, ‘Girl with Fan’, which saw the light of day in late 2023. You can get a copy from Amazon or order it from any good bookshop (and presumably bad bookshop too … if a ‘bad bookshop’ isn’t too much of an oxymoron) for a mere £7.99! Worth every penny, I’d say!
Raff, Joachim (1822-82)
Day 296: 'Abends' ('Evening') - Rhapsody for Orchestra (Time: 7 minutes)
One of the things that attracts me about writing these playlist notes is the thought that occasionally their lucky(?) recipients might encounter composers they haven’t heard of, let alone heard any of these composers’ pieces. Today (27/5/22) will perhaps be one such occasion. If introductions are necessary, then, let me introduce you to Joachim Raff (1822-82), whose 200th birthday is this very day! Had any of us been around in, say, 1880, and asked a passing musician pretty much anywhere in Europe who the leading German composers of the day were, we might have got some familiar answers: Wagner, Brahms possibly Bruch, Offenbach no doubt (later a French citizen, but actually born in Germany). In addition, maybe there’d have been an honorary mention from a passing enthusiast for Volkmann or Herzogenberg – both of whom I’ve spent a lot of time discovering recently, and who might make this playlist one day soon. But a name very near the top of anyone’s list would be Joseph Joachim Raff, a composer who in 1880 had only two years left to live, but who by that stage in his life had become immensely popular and very highly regarded. The vagaries of taste and accidents of history have largely deleted Raff from the front rank of 19th century composers; and, indeed, apart from a tiny piece for violin and piano (his ‘Cavatina’ of 1862, one of his Six Morceaux Op 85) which still features on concert programmes, often as a slightly sentimental encore, his music disappeared until roughly the 1980s, when recording companies started to explore the byways of musical history, and Raff’s music started to become known once again. You’re still not likely to hear any of his major works in concert, however. Actually, having claimed him as a German composer, honesty compels me to acknowledge that he was born in Switzerland, though of German parentage, but he left Switzerland for Germany in his 20s and remained there for the rest of his life. In his musical development, he began as a follower of Liszt, though he was essentially self-taught. By the 1860s, he had distanced himself somewhat from the Wagner/Liszt strand of composition, though he avoided that rather binary way of thinking about Austro-German music that suggested that if you were anti-Wagner you must by definition be pro-Brahms. His greatest successes were probably in the 1870s, when his Symphony No 3 (‘In the Forest’) and Symphony No 5 (‘Lenore’) were performed not only across Europe but in the USA also. Raff was nothing if not prolific, and one of the things that has counted against him over the past 150 years or so is that there’s a lot of padding in his output, particularly quantities of rather ephemeral piano music that he published essentially to pay the bills. There is, if one is being brutally honest, an essential tameness about much of Raff’s work – writing in the vein of Mendelssohn or Schumann twenty years after their deaths wasn’t going to frighten the horses. Yet there’s a lot to like in his eleven symphonies, his five violin sonatas, his eight string quartets, four piano trios, and so on. I’ve wondered about what to choose to illustrate the qualities of this composer’s attractive music, but (trying to abide by this playlist’s ’40 minute rule’, when I’ve already used up 34 minutes on Tuesday’s Korngold!) in the end I’ve decided against a chunk of a symphony or a major chamber work, and chosen instead an orchestral fragment, Raff’s orchestral rhapsody ‘Abends’ (‘Evening’), Op 163b. It dates from 1874. It’s a rather lush and yet at the same time decorous bit of romantic nature painting. If nothing else, it might leave you with a warm glow of contentment. There are, as far as I know, no video recordings of this work on YouTube, so once again this is an audio-only link. There’s a leisurely performance by the Bamberg Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Hans Stadlmair, which you’ll find here: Raff: 'Abends' ('Evening') - Rhapsody for Orchestra
Ramirez, Ariel (1921-2010)
Day 220: Misa Criolla (Time: 20 minutes)
Tomorrow marks the 100th anniversary of the birth of the Argentinean composer Ariel Ramirez (1921-2010). The music of many composers can be seen to give expression to the folk culture of the countries of their birth. One can trace ‘nationalism’ in music back to the mid-19th century, and most European countries have at least one ‘national’ composer (Grieg in Norway, Smetana and Dvorak in the Czech homelands, Albeniz in Spain and so on), and as we move into the 20th century, for some composers, this sense of rootedness in the rhythms and melodies of their lands became a defining feature (Bartók and Kodaly in Hungary, say, or Vaughan Williams here in Britain). Similar tendencies can be seen in the music of both North and South America in the 20th century – and in Southern/Central America in particular, this has led to the composition of colourful, rhythmically exciting, dance-influenced pieces. The composer Ariel Ramirez was initially interested in the more urban music of Argentina (he might have followed Piazzolla into the world of the tango), but as a young adult, he became fascinated by the rhythms, dances and folk song of the various regions of Argentina, and subsequently of other national cultures in South America. He was ‘classically trained’ at the National Conservatory in Buenos Aires, and he subsequently studied in Europe – although he seems to have been one of the very few South American composers of note not to study with Nadia Boulanger. But from the mid-1950s onwards he saw his role essentially as a collector and disseminator of the folk songs of his nation. Whilst it would be wrong to see him as a ‘one work’ composer, in that many of his song arrangements are immensely popular in South America, it might be fair to say that in more global terms it is the work I want to focus on today (3/9/21), his ‘Misa Criolla’, which sees the light of day most often. This work owes a considerable amount to the deliberations of the Second Vatican Council (1962-65), which made significant changes to the way the Catholic Church functioned. One major area of change was in the language used in the Mass, with the provision that the liturgy could now be expressed in the vernacular, rather than in Latin. The opportunity to write a Mass setting in his native Spanish appealed strongly to Ramirez, and he coupled this with his obsessive interest in folk music to produce the ‘Misa Criolla’, which he wrote in 1963-4, and which received its first public performance in 1967, though it had been recorded on LP a couple of years earlier. One performance of the work led to an oft-quoted review in the Washington Post, describing it as ‘a stunning achievement, [combining] Spanish text with indigenous rhythms and instruments’, and summarising the effect as being like ‘a reverent carnival’. According to Ramirez himself, the genesis of the piece was an encounter he had with a group of women in Germany soon after the end of the Second World War, who had risked their own lives in feeding Nazi prisoners in their locality. He said he wanted ‘to compose something deep and religious that would revere life and involve people beyond their creeds, race, colour or origin.’ The ‘Misa Criolla’ is in five sections – Kyrie, Gloria, Credo, Sanctus and Agnus Dei – and each section features the folk style of a particular South American region. The Kyrie uses a ‘vidala-baguala’, a hushed and solemn music of the remote north of Argentina; the Gloria is an exuberant ‘carnavalito’, with a slower central section; the Credo employs a ‘chacarera trunca’, a kind of rural equivalent of a tango; the Sanctus is set to a ‘carnaval cochabambino’, a gently ceremonial dance style from Bolivia; finally the Agnus Dei is in an ‘estilo pampaneo’, closing the mass in music of the Argentinean pampas, with its wide open spaces and sense of solitude. Performances of the ‘Misa Criolla’ on YouTube vary very widely indeed, from more polished concert performances showcasing international opera soloists to versions which have their feet firmly in local soil, featuring folk musicians decked out in native garb. I’ve gone for what might be seen as a middle way between these extremes, in this recording from Buenos Aires, featuring two vocal soloists, an array of folk percussionists and four local choirs, under the direction of Hernán Sánchez Arteaga. If you have a copy of the score (I do because the choir I sing with performed it in 2012 – I suspect many of the people on this list from Escafeld Chorale will remember that experience, if only for the challenge of getting a mostly white and aged choir to ‘feel’ the rhythms of the dance), you’ll note that the performance takes some liberties with the printed instructions, but the spirit of the work, I think, comes across strongly. You’ll find it here: Ramirez: Misa Criolla
Rautavaara, Einojuhani (1928-2016)
Day 80: ‘Cantus Arcticus’ (Concerto for Birds and Orchestra) (Time: 16 minutes)
Today (10/6/20), I thought it would be interesting to introduce what might be a new name to some of you: Einojuhani Rautavaara. Rautavaara (1928-2016) was a Finnish composer. For many, he’s the most important Finnish composer since Sibelius. His output includes several symphonies (I’d particularly recommend Symphony No 7 (‘Angel of Light’) if you’re looking for somewhere to start), operas and concertos. His music evolved over the many decades of his composing life. Like lots of others, he had an avant-garde and somewhat indigestible phase in the 1960s, but after that, came a 'rediscovery' of the musical language of Romanticism, and his work over the final 30-40 years of his life might best be described as 'post-modern', employing a conscious range of different styles and techniques in a synthesised way. He’s often seen as a 'mystical' composer – lots of his works have religious themes. The idea of angels and annunciations turns up all over the place in his work. Anyway, one of his most famous and popular works (and interestingly composed at almost the same time as Hovhaness' ‘And God Created Great Whales’, which I featured a couple of weeks ago, with its taped whale songs) is the ‘Cantus Arcticus’ – also known as the Concerto for Birds and Orchestra. This was written in 1972. It’s in three movements, and incorporates taped recordings of birds made in the Arctic Circle and other areas in the marshlands of northern Finland. The music is essentially slow-moving, often proceeding via slow changes to an overall 'wash' of orchestral sound, though growing a little more agitated in the final movement, ‘Swans Migrating’. I find it very beautiful, and I hope (enough of) you do too! The version I’ve chosen is by the Orchestre Philharmonique de Radio France, conducted by Mikko Franck. Don’t be put off by the fact that the recording claims to be 17 minutes long – some of that is clapping at the beginning and end, and the music itself only marginally overshoots the 15 minute rule! You’ll find it here: Einojuhani Rautavaara – ‘Cantus Arcticus’ (Concerto for Birds and Orchestra)
Ravel, Maurice (1875-1937)
Day 35: Introduction and Allegro for Flute, Clarinet, Harp and String Quartet (Time: 12 minutes)
Today (26/4/20), I thought that, since one good ‘Introduction and Allegro’ deserves another, I’d follow up yesterday’s Elgar [Introduction and Allegro for Strings] with a piece by Maurice Ravel, the Introduction and Allegro for Flute, Clarinet, Harp and String Quartet. This piece was a product of competitive commissioning from rival harp makers. In 1904, the harp manufacturer Pleyel commissioned Debussy to write a piece (the ‘Danse Sacrée et Danse Profane’) to show off their new model. Consequently their rivals, Erard, sought out Ravel to write a piece for their latest bit of kit too. This piece is the result. I’ve chosen it mostly for that typical quality of Ravel’s writing – sensual and languid, but at the same time with an almost fastidious precision, like looking at a very fine bit of some meticulously crafted clockwork mechanism. The performance by members of the Orchestra of the New York Metropolitan Opera is here: Ravel – Introduction and Allegro for Flute, Clarinet, Harp and String Quartet
Day 114: ‘Mother Goose’ (Suite) (Time: 14 minutes*)
It may seem a bit of a predictable move, but having had some Debussy last time out, I thought it was logical to go on today (28/8/20) to select some music by Ravel next. In some ways, the two are musically inseparable – the leading French composers of the first three decades of the 20th century, both tagged ‘Impressionists’ (though both rejected the label), and both in many ways following the same paths in terms of musical language. However, for me the crucial difference is that where Debussy’s music is volatile and as ‘organic’ as the beating of a human heart, Ravel’s is like a beautifully jewelled mechanism in its precision and colour. This might make it appear that Ravel’s music has less ‘feeling’ to it, but I’d want to argue that he gets at ‘feelings’ by a different route, by paring away at excess until all that is left is a kind of pure intensity of sound and pattern. They were friends as well as musical rivals, at least initially, though Debussy’s decision to leave his then wife and elope with Emma Bardac (see Day 113) led Ravel, like many others, to side with Lilly Debussy in the acrimonious fall-out, after which relations between the two composers were rather cooler. Ravel’s characteristic method of composition was to produce pieces first for the piano, after which (if it were to happen) he would orchestrate them. That process is true of the ‘Pavane pour une Infante Defunte’ (see below), of ‘Le Tombeau de Couperin’, of ‘La Valse’, and of my choice for today, the music for his suite ‘Ma Mère l’Oye’ (‘Mother Goose’). Ravel always had a lively interest in children (which sounds like a rather creepy thing to write, but which appears, as far as I know, entirely innocent). Cipa and Ida Godebski, a Polish couple who were close friends of Ravel, and who kept a fashionable Parisian salon for musicians and artists, had two young children, Mimie and Jean, to whom ‘Mother Goose’ is dedicated. What is extraordinary about this music is that it is designed for children to play, and as a result, Ravel pares down and simplifies his style, without in any way making the music seem facile. In fact, its premiere was given by Genevieve Durony and Jeanne Leleu, then only six and seven years old respectively. (Many decades ago my first wife and I used to play this music together, though never at the speed of competent pianists – as I said, it’s very simple!) The five movements that make up the suite are called ‘Pavane of Sleeping Beauty’, ‘Little Tom Thumb’, ‘Little Ugly Girl, Princess of the Pagodas’ (an exercise in chinoiserie), ‘Conversation of Beauty and the Beast’ and ‘The Fairy Garden’. Later, Ravel orchestrated the pieces, and subsequently expanded them into a ballet by adding a couple of new movements at the start and linking passages between the five original pieces. However, I want to focus on the original piano four-hands version today, played here by Natsuko Inoue and itamar Golan. The YouTube video of their performance is prefaced by their playing of Ravel’s limpid and serene ‘Pavane pour une Infante Defunte’ (Pavane for a Dead Infanta). If you want to listen only to ‘Mother Goose’* it begins at around 6'35" on this recording. (You could of course listen to both pieces and still fall safely within 40 mins listening time for the whole week’s music!) You’ll find the performance here: Ravel: 'Mother Goose' (Suite)
Day 212: Piano Concerto for the Left Hand (Time: 19 minutes)
The story of the work chosen for today (6/8/21), the second of the instalments for ‘Sinister Week’, begins in the Wittgenstein family in the 1880s in Vienna. The probably now more famous member of the family, the philosopher Ludwig Wittgenstein, arrived in 1889. Two years earlier, his brother Paul had been born. When the First World War started, Paul Wittgenstein was well on the way to a professional career as a pianist, but he was called up for military service, and during action against the Russians, he was shot in his right elbow, and that arm was subsequently amputated. Clearly a stubborn character, he determined to continue to play as a left-handed pianist, initially arranging previously existing two-handed works for left hand only, and commissioning a large number of pieces from his former teacher Josef Labor. But it is in the 1920s and 30s that Wittgenstein’s enthusiasm for commissioning really took off, and a considerable number of major composers of the era wrote works for him, notably pieces for piano and orchestra. Several of these remain in the repertoire of many pianists. Examples include Britten’s ‘Diversions’ for Piano Left Hand and Orchestra, Korngold’s Piano Concerto for the Left Hand in C#, Prokofiev’s Piano Concerto No 4, Franz Schmidt’s Piano Concerto No 2 and Richard Strauss’s ‘Panathenäenzug’ for Piano Left Hand and Orchestra. However, the work which has had the most productive life in the concert hall is undoubtedly Ravel’s Piano Concerto for the Left Hand. Wittgenstein appears in some ways to have been quite a difficult pianist to write for. Sometimes he simply put the new commission in a drawer and ignored it (the fate of Hindemith’s Klaviermusik mit Orchester). Because he often demanded sole rights to play some commissioned pieces, he often claimed he wouldn’t play certain works until he ‘understood’ them better – for this reason, he never played the Prokofiev 4th Concerto, but then neither did anyone else until 25 years after it was composed. There were similar run-ins with Ravel, who began work on his Left Hand Concerto in 1929, leading to its first performance (by Wittgenstein) in 1932. Ravel was angered by Wittgenstein’s ‘improvements’ to his score. "Performers must not be slaves," argued Wittgenstein. "Performers are slaves," countered Ravel. During the final ten years of his life (he died in 1937), Ravel’s health deteriorated markedly, but one would not think this from the vitality shown in this Left Hand Concerto (and the two-handed Piano Concerto in G, which Ravel wrote at the same time). The concerto is usually regarded as being in one movement, though Ravel at times suggested it was in two linked movements. It’s a quite dark and brooding but jazzy piece. Ravel, like so many other composers in the 1920s and 30s, was fascinated by jazz. It’s a piece of pounding rhythms which, wrote Ravel, ‘contend with one another until they are brusquely interrupted by a brutal conclusion.’ However, there are also passages of intense lyricism, with an almost elegiac feel. (There are also moments, if it’s not too irreverent to say so, which feel like the forerunner to Henry Mancini’s theme music for ‘The Pink Panther’!) Malcolm has specifically asked that we watch the performance of the work given by the renowned French pianist Jean-Efflam Bavouzet, in a recording from the BBC Proms in which the Philharmonia Orchestra is conducted by Esa-Pekka Salonen. You’ll find it here: Ravel: Piano Concerto for the Left Hand
Day 269: Le Tombeau de Couperin (Time: 21 minutes)
We’ve had three pieces of Ravel on this list to date (see Days 35, 114 and 212 ), and in the paragraphs I’ve written on those days, I’ve made much of the jewelled precision of Ravel’s writing, whether for piano, chamber ensemble or orchestra. What attracts me to Ravel’s music most strongly is that on the surface it (like its composer) is outwardly the epitome of a kind of Gallic elegance and reserve, but (particularly when outer circumstances or inner emotional turbulence interrupted this sense of equilibrium) there is always a very fine line separating the innocent and paradisal (the ‘Mother Goose’ music we heard on Day 114) from the nightmarishly violent (such as parts of the Left-Hand Piano Concerto we heard on Day 212, or the dreamy cataclysm of ‘La Valse’). The piece I’ve chosen for today (22/2/22) is the orchestral suite ‘Le Tombeau de Couperin’. Its background might help explain why I think it’s a perfect example of this ‘light and shade’ I’m suggesting is evident in Ravel’s music. It was written – and this was entirely normal practice for Ravel – initially for piano, as a suite in six movements, before Ravel subsequently orchestrated four of the movements as a concert suite. Although Ravel lived until 1937, this was the last of his compositions for solo piano. His health deteriorated dramatically in the last 10-15 years of his life, making composition increasingly difficult. Those health problems were present even during the creation of this piece, which occupied Ravel from 1914-17 in relation to the piano original, before the orchestrated version emerged in 1919-20. The First World War made a huge impact on Ravel. In 1914 he tried to join the French Air Force, but was turned down because of his age and an underlying heart problem. In 1915 he finally succeeded in enlisting with an artillery regiment as a lorry driver. But in the next two years major health issues plagued him: insomnia and depression, frostbite and an operation for amoebic dysentery that left him with permanent bowel problems. At the same time, he was aware of the deteriorating health of his mother, with whom he was very close. She died in January 1917. Compounding all this, he found out about the deaths of several friends and acquaintances in the fighting. It is little wonder that his thoughts at this time turned to the broader idea of death, and the memorialising of the dead. And this is where the idea of a ‘tombeau’ comes in. The word has no tidy equivalent in English, but means something like ‘a piece written as a memorial’ (thus, perhaps, like a comment written on a tombstone). There was a tradition of writing such pieces in French music as far back as the 17th century, and Ravel’s inspiration specifically seems to have come from the keyboard writing of François Couperin – and, extending more generally, from the musical forms and idioms of the Baroque keyboard suite such as Couperin and his 18th century contemporaries had written. (We are in very similar territory here, in some ways, to the Baroque suite as illustrated in, say, the Bach Cello Suites we’ve heard on this list before now.) One might say that, in celebrating this Baroque dance idiom, Ravel was paying homage to a civilisation that he saw as disappearing for ever. The four movement orchestral version of ‘Le Tombeau’ consists of a Prélude (in memory of 1st Lt. Jacques Charleau), a Forlane (in memory of 1st Lt. Gabriel Deluc), a Menuet (in memory of the soldier Jean Dreyfus, in whose home Ravel recuperated when he was demobilised from the military) and a final Rigaudon (commemorating two childhood friends, the brothers Pierre and Pascal Gaudin, killed by the same shell in 1914). So much death … and yet listening to this beautiful music, the overwhelming feeling is of that characteristic poise and elegance for which Ravel is renowned. When he was criticised, after early performances of the work, for the gentle, reflective quality of the work and the absence of anything more sombre, Ravel said, pertinently, ‘The dead are sad enough, in their eternal silence.’ YouTube offers several carefully judged performances of this rich and tender music, from which I’ve chosen this concert recording by the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Jaime Martín, which you’ll find here: Ravel: Le Tombeau de Couperin
Day 336: Sonatine (Time: 13 minutes)
Ravel has appeared four times previously on our playlist (see Days 35, 114, 212 and 269) but although so much of Ravel’s oeuvre consists of solo piano music, we haven’t had any of that yet… until today (21/10/22). The piece that Tim Horton is playing as part of Ensemble 360’s upcoming concert is the ‘Sonatine’. It features so many of Ravel’s characteristic traits as a composer – classical restraint, a kind of refined grace, typically Gallic understatement, but also flashes of occasional, equilibrium-disturbing passion. Ravel wrote it from 1903-5. Actually, he wrote the first movement initially as a stand-alone piece, which was an entry for a competition run by the magazine ‘Weekly Critical Review’; the winner of the best opening movement of a piano sonatina of no more than 75 bars would collect 100 francs. The first movement of Ravel’s score is, I believe, 84 bars long, which might seem like self-sabotage. Interestingly, Ravel was always obsessed with riddles and ciphers, and because the competition required entries to be submitted under pseudonyms, his entry was seemingly composed by M Verla. (See what he did there?) Allegedly, his was the only entry – though there is some debate about this. But because his entry broke the rules, the competition was cancelled. (There is something of a ‘thing’ about Ravel and competitions. He tried unsuccessfully to win the prestigious ‘Prix de Rome’ five times, though that is surely down to the tame conservatism of the judges.) However, before we feel too sorry for him, the completed score of the ‘Sonatine’ was published in November 1905, and as a consequence he was put in touch with the Durand publishing house, who offered him a contract with exclusive publishing rights for a fixed annual salary of 12,000 francs (a lot of money!). It probably tells you quite a lot about Ravel that he refused such a sum – asking instead for only 6,000 francs ‘so as not to risk feeling compelled to turn out a greater amount of music’. There’s something both endearingly unworldly and remarkably self-contained about Ravel, I think. Like the much later ‘Tombeau de Couperin’ (see Day 269), the Sonatine is a kind of homage to 18th century French musical elegance. Just in case you might be tempted to think that what we have is a kind of late Baroque pastiche, it’s also a work in which musical details are woven carefully together in more obviously ‘cyclic’ 19th century fashion, with a particular debt to the patterns of musical transformation that were made fashionable by Liszt. So here the opening theme of the first movement is transformed in the two subsequent movements. The first movement’s tempo marking, ‘Modéré’, suggests some restraint, and the second, ‘Mouvement de menuet’, maintains this sense of emotional coolness. However the finale, marked ‘Animé’, is exhilarating, a sort of toccata in the 18th century style. (If you have a bit of leisure time, try comparing this third movement with the ‘Toccata’ from the original piano version of ‘Le Tombeau de Couperin’, and you can hear how Ravel continued to be absorbed by this sort of musical idea throughout his life.) There are quite a few halfway-decent performances of the Sonatine on YouTube, and from the available choices, I’ve gone for this performance by the renowned French pianist Pascal Rogé. You’ll find it here: Ravel: Sonatine
Day 387: Piano Trio (Time: 28 minutes)
Today 13/6/23), I’m focusing on more music being played at this year’s Bradfield Festival, and specifically a piece from a concert to be given by the Linos Piano Trio by Maurice Ravel. We’ve had five pieces by Ravel on this playlist so far (see Days 35, 114, 212, 269 and 336), but as he’s one of my favourite composers, I make no apology for including another one. I’ve written previously about most of the significant incidents in his life, and the story of his only Piano Trio overlaps a little with that of ‘Le Tombeau de Couperin’, as discussed on Day 269, so I won’t repeat those details here... Except to say that there are issues featuring in the background to Ravel's life, which rapidly became matters very much in the foreground, that gave both shape and impetus to his Piano Trio. Ravel was, by and large, both a slow and fastidious worker – his completed output adds up to only about 60 performable works, and these usually arrived after a long gestation and frequent excisions and rewrites. In some ways, the Piano Trio conforms to this pattern, in that it seems to have been present as an idea for a work for several years before Ravel started to put flesh on the metaphorical bones. There’s a well-known quotation (well, well-known in Ravel circles!) from a letter he wrote to one of his rare pupils, Maurice Delage, early in 1914 (at which point the work had been stewing in Ravel’s mind for at least six years), ‘I've written my trio. Now all I need are the themes.’ Aside from whether we should just see this as a bit of compositional humour, I think it flags up one of those things that makes Ravel's writing distinctive – that shape and form matter almost as much as melodic inspiration, even though the latter was, claimed Ravel, always paramount – and I think you can hear in this piece, as in so much of Ravel's work, an almost crystalline precision and clarity of structure. (Unkind observers fall back on that rather cheap quip that Ravel's music is like a fine Swiss watch, all jewel-like precision, but short on flesh and blood. We know, of course, how wrong they are!) What gave Ravel the impetus to work much faster than normal in the middle months of 1914 was the impending war that eventually engulfed Europe from August onwards. Ravel, all patriotic fervour, had been keen to enlist, but was turned down on grounds of a somewhat enfeebled constitution – his eventual commitment to the war effort came as a carer for wounded soldiers and as an ambulance driver, at least until amoebic dysentery put paid to his active engagement – and part of this surge of enthusiasm was to complete the Piano Trio quickly so that it was finished before, as he’d planned it, he went off to war. He wrote, again to Delage, ‘I want to finish my Trio before joining up. If you only knew how I suffer. . . . I just keep working so as not to hear anything [about the war]. Yes I am working with the persistence and concentration of a madman. But suddenly the hypocrisy of this conduct overwhelms me and I begin to sob over my note paper.’ There's nothing particularly valedictory about it, but he realised, as he put it in that letter, that it might have been his ‘oeuvre posthume’. He wrote most of it in what was, for him, the emotional heartland of the Basque region, in Saint-Jean-de-Luz, close to his birthplace in the Basque town of Ciboure. In fact, the first movement has a strongly Basque flavour (he was also working at the time on a Basque-themed piano concerto, though nothing came of that in the end), particularly an influential Basque dance form called the ‘zortziko’, the distinguishing feature of which is a recurring rhythmic pattern of 3+2+3 beats. You can hear this pretty much from the outset in this first movement, though Ravel gets a lot out of setting this against patterns in the piano part in particular which are more squarely 4/4 in emphasis. (Please feel free to ignore all that if musical analysis isn’t your cup of cocoa!) Ravel called the second movement ‘Pantoum’, which is a Malaysian verse form a bit like a villanelle, except that in this case the second and fourth lines of a four-line stanza become the first and third lines of the succeeding stanza. It seems that Ravel came across this in the poetry of Verlaine and Baudelaire, and this – particularly the ways in which the lines of the opening ‘scherzo’ section of the movement are then transformed into the music of the succeeding ‘trio’ section – is Ravel's attempt to give this pattern musical substance. The third movement is again formally tidy – it’s a passacaglia, a form in which a repeated bass line underpins the musical development. Here, in a kind of passionate emotional ‘arch’ that rises and falls, the underlying theme is played and repeated a further ten times as the music grows and retreats. The last movement is one of Ravel’s typical fizzing finales, all choppy interlocking rhythms (in this case bars of 5/4 set against bars of 7/4, again typical of Basque folk music) and sparkling folk-influenced melodic fragments. I suspect you’d never know, listening to it, that war was about to break out. It seems to me one of the most life-affirming pieces in all of Ravel's output. Ravel's Piano Trio is pretty well served on YouTube, and out of the various options, I’ve gone for this video performance by the ATOS Trio (regular prizewinners in international contests and BBC New Generation Artists from 2009-11), which you’ll find here: Ravel: Piano Trio
Day 585: Bolero (Time: 14 minutes)
Today (10/4/26), I have a very mainstream choice, one of the most popular compositions in the whole of the repertoire. The reason is because imminently at Sheffield City Hall there’s a rare visit from a Spanish orchestra, the Spanish Galicia Symphony Orchestra, playing a programme of works celebrating the light and colour of their homeland, including this piece by Ravel. This music has some claim to being Ravel’s most famous composition. In fact, when the rather corny romantic comedy ‘10’ appeared in cinemas in 1979, starring Bo Derek and (somewhat bizarrely) Dudley Moore, a film in which Ravel’s music was used for its, shall we say, orgasmic effect, the result was that for a little while Ravel became the best-selling classical composer in the world. That popularity increased further in 1984 when the ice skaters Torvill and Dean used ‘Bolero’ in their gold medal-winning performance at that year’s Winter Olympics. It is in many ways an odd work, and Ravel tended to describe it in, for want of better, ‘anti-musical’ terms. It began life as a commission from the dancer (and actress and general cultural icon of the early decades of the 20th century) Ida Rubinstein for Ravel to orchestrate some of the music from Albeniz’s piano suite ‘Iberia’ for a ballet. Discovering that the Spanish composer Enrique Arbós had already made a start on this, Ravel decided to orchestrate a work of his own instead, and later still to write something original from scratch. There are conflicting visions of the scene that the music might have portrayed. In Rubinstein’s version, premiered with sensational success in November 1928, this note appeared in the programme: ‘Inside a tavern in Spain, people dance beneath the brass lamp hung from the ceiling. In response to the cheers to join in, the female dancer has leapt onto the long table and her steps become more and more animated.’ This is not remotely what Ravel had had in mind. In his view, the music is deliberately, overtly mechanistic, and he had imagined the setting as an open-air space in front of a factory, so that the insistent rhythm and repetitive patterns of the piece exemplify the relentless drive of machinery in operation. As is well known, it’s a work with lots of repetition and virtually no musical development. Composers are, often, perverse creatures, and perhaps it was the work’s exceptional popularity that caused Ravel to be so dismissive of it. Interviewed by The Daily Telegraph in 1931 he said, ‘It constitutes an experiment in a very special and limited direction, and should not be suspected of aiming at achieving anything different from, or anything more than, it actually does achieve. Before its first performance, I issued a warning to the effect that what I had written was a piece lasting seventeen minutes and consisting wholly of "orchestral tissue without music"—of one very long, gradual crescendo. There are no contrasts, and practically no invention except the plan and the manner of execution.’ It has to be said that not everybody liked what they heard. The composer and writer Constant Lambert, in his 1930s book ‘Music Ho!’, wrote: ‘There is a definite limit to the length of time a composer can go on writing in one dance rhythm (this limit is obviously reached by Ravel towards the end of “La Valse” and towards the beginning of “Boléro”).’ Lambert, though, is in a minority, and ‘Bolero’ is a work that seems able to satisfy almost all listeners at whatever level of engagement they choose to take it on. The work is one of many in Ravel’s oeuvre that reveal his Spanish, or at least Basque, roots (his mother was from the Basque region), though famously he didn’t visit Spain until after most of his ‘Iberian’ works had been written, so what we have here is the Spain of his imagination (and the songs his mother sang to him as a child from her time living and working in Madrid). One of the things that interests me most about Ravel is the usually cool precision of his orchestration, and the orderly – sometimes quite fastidious – nature of his compositions. In that sense his music reveals not just his Basque maternal roots but the ‘Swiss watch-maker’ precision (a cliché, I know, but all clichés have a grain of truth in them) he inherited from his Swiss father. And so, though we can see ‘Bolero’ as the journey from foreplay to climax (and I think it’s really difficult not to feel that this music is consciously sexual – and I’m sure that’s not just me!), on another level it’s about how you build a musical edifice out of the most basic materials by concentrating on, if you like, its design features. The work lasts, in most performances, around 14-15 minutes (though really slow ones can take up to 17, and at the other end of the scale Ravel fell out with the conductor Arturo Toscanini because the conductor took it too fast, making a recording that takes just over 13). It starts with a snare drum, pianissimo, playing a two-bar rhythm, which its player then repeats unchangingly 169 times – well, unchanging apart from getting progressively louder. Over it, there are two melodies, identical in length, which are repeated in turn. The first has a narrower range from high to low, the second a much wider one, and the latter has a far more ‘bluesy’ feel because some of the notes of its scale are flattened. (It doesn’t matter, I think, if the musical jargon means little to you – you can feel the effect in performance.) Then the melodies are repeated 18 times, in pairs – melody A, melody A repeated, melody B, melody B repeated, and so on – as the orchestration fills out: flute, then clarinet, then other wind instruments, until by repetition no.7 we meet the trumpet, then saxophone, then, by repetition no.11, we get trombones added to the mix, and so on and so on. By repetition no.17 the full orchestra is playing fortissimo, and you might think, well, how can it be ended? This is Ravel’s masterstroke, because having been in C Major throughout, there’s a sudden shift at repetition no.18 into E Major, just for eight bars, before it drops back into C Major and comes crashing, via some crunching dissonances, to a close. (And again, if the ‘C to E’ shift and back again means nothing, just feel the experience as a listener!) As one programme note I once read about this work remarked, ‘never in the field of musical composition have so many enjoyed so much made from so little.’ YouTube, perhaps unsurprisingly, has very many video and lots more audio recordings of this work, so you can find a performance that suits you easily enough. I’ve gone for this one, recorded at the BBC Proms in 2014, performed by the West-Eastern Divan Orchestra, conducted by Daniel Barenboim. I pick this partly because Barenboim’s orchestra is one of the great achievements of musical/political diplomacy, but also because the flute player who takes the initial melody is Guy Eshed, who those with a long-ish memory will remember as one of the founder members of Ensemble 360 back in 2005, before the chance of working with Mr Barenboim lured him away to something more in the global spotlight. You’ll find the performance here: Ravel: Bolero
Rebel, Jean-Féry (1666-1747)
Day 306: Les Elémens (Suite) (Time: 24 minutes)
Last time out, I promised you something rebellious for today (8/7/22), and I’m being as good as my word. Almost certainly, this will be another posting about a composer most of you have never heard of, and music you may well never have heard either. Educational, n’est-ce pas? But hopefully lots of fun too. Jean-Féry Rebel (1666-1747) is one of a vast number of composers of the French Baroque era whose name these days is lost to mainstream audiences, obscured by the fame and box office attractions of Couperin, Lully and Rameau. In his day, he was initially something of an ‘enfant terrible’, and after that, for many decades, a respected member of the French musical establishment. If these days he is known essentially for just one work (see below), it’s really our loss. Rebel was a child prodigy on the violin, and something of a star pupil of Lully. In terms of being part of Louis XIV’s musical world at the court of Versailles, he became first violin at the Paris Opéra in his mid-thirties, then becoming one of the prestigious Vingt-Quatre Violons du Roi before he was 40, and Maître de Musique of that ensemble within a couple of years, before becoming (the pinnacle of status) Chamber Composer to the king at around the age of 60. His most important role in the evolution of French music of the early 18th century (apart from the fact that he conducted the premieres of a large number of major works by other French composers of the day) was his development of a distinctive musical form, the ‘opera-ballet’, in which dance becomes an equal partner of song, a form that evolved in a very French way as the 18th century progressed. He described some of the pieces he wrote as ‘symphonies de danse’, or ‘dance symphonies’. He was given, often, to writing music that to his audiences seemed fantastical, or full of elaborate musical jokes. In fact, it was the failure of Rebel’s only full opera, ‘Ulysse’, in 1703, that set him on the way to writing these curiously dance-dominated productions. And it is the last of these works, ‘Les Élémens’ (‘The Elements’) that I want to focus on today, largely for the one extraordinary feature it reveals. Its storyline is a creation narrative, starting with chaos and ending, via some characteristically 18th century dance movements (chaconnes, tambourins, siciliennes, and so on), with a ‘caprice’ that depicts the fulfilment of unfallen creation before mankind appeared on the scene. This sort of story was not new. In fact, an opera-ballet, ‘Les Élémens’ by a really obscure French composer, André Cardinal Destouches, was conducted at its first performance in 1721 by Rebel himself, and it seems likely that the idea for a work of his own on the same theme was prompted by that experience. What makes Rebel’s own composition ‘Les Élémens’ particularly striking is the way he depicts the ‘chaos’ at the start of the process of creation. He uses what 20th century avant-garde composers would come to describe as ‘tone clusters’ – that is, the simultaneous sounding of notes of a scale that lie so close to each other that the result is distinctively discordant. Rebel was not the first to get up to these sort of tricks. As far as I know, the first recorded instance of this sort of musical subversiveness came from Heinrich Biber’s ‘Battalia à 10’ in the 1670s, an instrumental programmatic depiction of a battle scene (I’ll definitely feature this work one day!), and after Rebel’s work of 1737 there were other instances of this sort of deliberate cacophony – in the Overture to Rameau’s opera ‘Zaïs’ in 1748, and in the Overture to Haydn’s ‘The Creation’ at the end of the 18th century. For today, though, let’s focus on Rebel’s ‘Les Élémens’. In his Preface to the score, Rebel described it as a ‘confusion de l’harmonie’. This ear-splitting opening (which must have seemed like madness to Rebel’s first audiences) illustrates, he claimed, ‘the confusion that has broken out among the elements before they occupy that place that is assigned to them according to the order of nature, determined by unalterable laws’ (how very 18th century!). After that chaotic opening movement, the dances that follow are clearly not illustrations of the natural world in its wild state (something that would have to wait for 19th century Romanticism) but the stylised order of the French Baroque, of the sort that gives the architecture and patterned gardens of the era their rather more artful formality. YouTube offers a couple of quite impressive recordings of Rebel’s composition, notably the one I’ve chosen by the Stuttgart Chamber Orchestra, conducted by Thomas Zehetmair. You’ll find it here: Rebel: Les Elemens (Suite)
Reger, Max (1873-1916)
Day 364: Suite in G Minor for Solo Viola, Op 131d No 1 (Time: 13 minutes)
Max Reger (Johann Baptist Joseph Maximilian Reger, I’ll have you know) was born on 19th March, 1873. In other words, it was his 150th birthday two days before the posting for today (21/3/23). In fact, if you have an idle moment to trawl through YouTube, you’ll quickly become aware that there has been a flurry of postings over the past few days from musicians (usually organists or pianists) marking this event by uploading video performances of some of Reger’s shorter pieces. When I was studying A-level Music many, many decades ago, my music teacher asked, by way of a joke, if it were possible to find two interesting things to say about Max Reger – the assumption being that everyone could point to one interesting thing (that Reger’s surname was a palindrome), but finding two things to say would be beyond us. Well, I’m pleased to say that, even if he’s by no means a ‘mainstream’ composer – except among organists and choral conductors – Reger has been substantially rehabilitated over the past three or four decades. (I suspect that this is largely down to the market for recorded music, given that once music labels have put out recordings of the core classical repertoire, it leaves the field clear to trawl through more obscure output too. Hats off, in passing, to ‘Naxos’ and ‘cpo’ labels in this respect!) Reger (1873-1916) packed an awful lot of composition into his relatively short life. Yet another of those composers whose parents’ other plans turned out to be thwarted (in Reger’s case to be a teacher), Reger’s ‘conversion’ to the idea of musical composition as a career came as a consequence of seeing a couple of Wagner operas in Bayreuth as an impressionable teenager. However, though he had a very brief ‘Wagnerian’ phase, Reger’s inspirations as a composer came from Wagner’s ‘antithesis’ in late 19th century Austro-German music, Johannes Brahms, and from Brahms back, via Beethoven, to his abiding touchstone, JS Bach. Bach, said Reger, is ‘the beginning and the end of all music: he is the basis and at the root of all true progress!’ One curiosity about Reger is that he studied music with someone better known as a musicologist than as a practising composer, Hugo Riemann, and many critics of Reger’s music attribute its ‘dryness’ or ‘stuffiness’ to precisely this relationship. But this, I think, is to miss the point. Reger, like Brahms before him, aimed to exploit the musical forms and techniques of the past (fugues, passacaglias and so on) in order to write music that, while in forms that acknowledged the models of previous centuries, nonetheless aimed to push the boundaries of melody and harmony … but from an essentially conservative standpoint. A helpful concept here might be ‘historicist modernism’ – that is, an approach to music that shares something with ‘neo-classical’ early 20th century compositions (think of Prokofiev’s ‘Classical’ Symphony or Stravinsky’s ‘Pulcinella’) but which works most forcefully in abstract forms – the string quartet and core chamber music forms, or the theme and variations form in relation to orchestral compositions. (Curiously, Reger never wrote a symphony – though he did compose a short ‘Sinfonietta’ – but he was never attracted to writing for the opera house or the stage.) What you get from Reger, then, is a desire to write identifiably ‘contemporary’ music, but in a language which has a deep-rooted engagement with the styles and structures of the past … and in Reger’s case, the past as specifically rooted in the music of Bach. His adoration (not too strong a word, I think) of Bach’s music took the form of arranging vast amounts of it (34 arrangements of Bach for two- or four-hands at the piano, 35 arrangements of Bach’s keyboard works for organ, 14 arrangements of Bach’s orchestral works for keyboard or chamber ensemble … and so on) but also in modelling his own work on some of Bach’s originals. Reger’s total output is huge, notably for organ, but amongst the many works for instrumental forces you’ll also find pieces that take the ideas of Bach’s works for single instruments (the cello suites, say, or the sonatas and partitas for solo violin) and revisit these solo pieces from the perspective of 20th century melody and harmony. And that brings me to the work I’ve chosen to mark Reger’s 150th birthday: his Suite for Solo Viola in G Minor, Op 131d No 1. Reger was very fond of grouping sets of pieces under a particular ‘opus number’. So, Op 131 consists of six preludes and fugues for solo violin (Op 131a), three canons and fugues in the old style for two violins (Op 131b), three suites for solo cello (Op 131c) … and three suites for solo viola (Op 131d). All these works come from the final year of Reger’s life – he suffered ill-health throughout his adult life, but died at the age of 43 of a heart attack in 1916 – and this whole collection (or collection of collections) grouped under Op 131 is steeped in the vocabulary of Bach’s world, both in terms of how it’s named and how the music is structured. The echoes of Bach are maybe more obvious in the works grouped elsewhere under Op 131; in the Suites Op 131d Reger wrote for an instrument that Bach never wrote extensively for – the solo viola. The Suite in G Minor, Op 131d No 1, is in four movements, arranged in a quasi-Baroque fashion – slow-fast-slow-fast – where the second and fourth movements are lighter in style, a dance-like scherzo and a perpetuum mobile-style finale, contrasted to the more weighty first movement, with its rhetorical flourishes, and the gentle andantino third movement. I don’t think I’d want to claim that this is any kind of ‘lost masterpiece’, or that Reger should feature on concert programmes as frequently as contemporaries like Richard Strauss or Mahler. But by overlooking his work, we’re losing sight of at least one key strand in early 20th century music. I hope this brief birthday tribute alerts some of you to the existence of this fine composer. As for a performance, there are a lot of videos on YouTube that look like they’re recordings of graduation recitals or from the earlier rounds of viola competitions. I’ve gone instead for a somewhat over-resonant domestic recording from the early days of Covid lockdown performances. In this case it’s given by the prize-winning French viola player Antoine Tamestit (a BBC New Generation Artist in the first decade of this century), and you’ll find it here: Reger: Suite in G Minor for Solo Viola, Op 131d No 1
Reich, Steve (b1936)
Day 32: ‘Electric Counterpoint’ (Time: 15 minutes)
Today (23/4/20), I’ve gone for a modern classic from the American ‘minimalist’ tradition, Steve Reich’s ‘Electric Counterpoint’. I know this sort of music is often regarded rather sniffily by classical music aficionados, as though it's not ‘proper music’. I have some sympathy with that view when it comes to the rather anodyne end of this particular spectrum (I get very tired of Philip Glass’s music very quickly!), but for me at least, Steve Reich (b1936) offers something richer and more satisfying. Pieces like ‘Electric Counterpoint’ are playing the same games with patterns in music (inversions, repetitions, changes to phrase length and rhythm) as you’d find, say, in Bach. The soloist (in this case the guitarist Mats Bergstrom) plays ‘live’ against 10 other pre-recorded tracks he’s already made. If you’ve not encountered this sort of music before, it might take some getting used to, but its interlocking patterns are mesmeric. I hope you enjoy it! You’ll find it here: Steve Reich – ‘Electric Counterpoint’
Day 227: Clapping Music (Time: 4 minutes) and Music for Pieces of Wood (12 minutes)
Steve Reich (b.1936) will celebrate his 85th birthday at the end of this week. He has appeared on this list once before (see Day 32) when I recommended that we listen to the hypnotic ‘Electric Counterpoint’ for electric guitar and pre-recorded tape. That’s a work from the later 1980s, at a point in Reich’s career when he was not only well established as a composer but also moving slightly away from the pared-down patterns of his earlier works. Early in the 1960s, as a music student, Reich turned away from the classical ‘establishment’ view of what music should be like (at that time, focusing on serialist techniques which can be traced back to Schoenberg) and instead looked to focus on the bare bones of music that interested him: the importance of repetition, of rhythmic pulse, and of a concept of variation based on the idea of ‘phasing’. In essence this last concept is quite simple – at its most basic, take two almost identical looping patterns (one, say, which is 12 beats long, and the other which is otherwise identical but only 11 beats long, missing the final beat) and set them running. After starting in sync with each other, the shorter pattern will gradually move one beat ‘forward’ in relation to the longer pattern until, with transparent mathematical certainty, they will eventually coincide again. (Without getting too nerdy, if the 12 beat pattern is played 11 times it equals 132 beats; if the 11 beat pattern is played 12 times it also equals 132 beats. Thus the first 11 beats are totally in sync, and at beat 133 they return to that state.) There’s a well-known quotation in which Reich explains his intention: ‘I am interested in perceptible processes. I want to be able to hear the process happening throughout the sounding music,’ he wrote in his ‘manifesto’ essay, ‘Music as a Gradual Process’. The consequence is that Reich shelves entirely the idea of ‘development’ as it’s been understood in classical music since the Renaissance, and replaces it with this ‘transparent’ mechanised form. Of course, no ideas exist in a vacuum, so although Reich is often called the most influential composer of the second half of the 20th century, his work couldn’t have existed without, say, the ideas of Terry Riley (especially his famous work ‘In C’), but also it almost certainly couldn’t have existed without the developments in technology (initially analogue but subsequently digital) that made this playing with patterns possible in such precise ways. Anyway, I thought that today (28/9/21) I’d go for a couple of Reich’s works from early in his career, that are in some ways music reduced to the level of pure ‘idea’. (I have friends who dispute that the result of all this is ‘real music’ at all; they’re wrong, of course, but it’s nice that they’re still friends!) So, first up is one of Reich’s breakthrough works, ‘Clapping Music’, from 1972. Reich wanted to create a piece of music ‘that would need no instrument beyond the human body’. The basis of the piece is a clapping rhythm based on patterns of African drumming that Reich studied (as a student he learned to play the drums because he wanted to play jazz), and it’s probably the most pure example of phasing in Reich’s entire output, illustrating both clarity of concept and the systematic nature of process to generate structure. It’s usually performed by just two people, as here by David Felberg and James T Shields, who produce the basic rhythm identically eight times through, and then start to phase out of sync, and, eventually, back together: Reich: Clapping Music. The year after he wrote that piece, Reich composed ‘Music for Pieces of Wood’, for five performers. The core idea of phasing underpins this work too, but the five wood blocks are tuned differently so there’s a sense of playing with sonority here as well as rhythm. The highest-tuned wood block starts, and sets up a basic metronomic pulse, around which the other four performers weave these canonic patterns of increasing complexity. What I love about this piece, apart from its hypnotic fascination, is the way the interplay of the different rhythms seems to shift the music in and out of different gears. The piece comes to its close through a gradual process of rhythmic diminution, where whole beats are removed from bar lengths, until we reach an abrupt stop. The performance I’ve chosen by the LSO Percussion Ensemble is very satisfying, I think. You’ll find it here: Reich: Clapping Music and Music for Pieces of Wood
Reinecke, Carl (1824-1910)
Day 492: Harp Concerto (Time: 25 minutes)
Today (25/6/24), we have belated birthday greetings for the once widely renowned but now almost entirely neglected 19th century composer, Carl Reinecke. And not just any old birthday greeting. Two days ago, it was 200 years exactly since Reinecke’s birth. It didn’t, as far as I know, cause a big splash on Radio 3, which seems a pity, because he’s a composer well worth getting to know. Carl Reinecke (1824-1910) shares his birth year with Smetana and Bruckner, and in that company, it’s perhaps easy to see why Reinecke might be overlooked. But he was a leading figure in the Austro-German musical tradition for the best part of 60 years, and in, say, the mid-1850s he’d have been accorded the same sort of status as Mendelssohn or Schumann, and ahead of the young Brahms. If there’s an inevitable ‘But…’ waiting in the wings, it centres on the fact that it’s difficult to discern much in the way of progression or development in Reinecke’s musical language over the decades, and consequently pieces he wrote in the 1850s and others he wrote in the first decade of the 20th century sound pretty much alike. Does that matter? Well, if you have the expectation that creative artists should evolve as the world around them changes, then I guess that, yes, it matters enough for us to understand why Reinecke was regarded as an irrelevance long before his death at the age of 85. However, (musical) history is full of composers who found a voice and stuck with it. Reinecke’s voice – probably equal parts Schumann and Mendelssohn, with a tiny sprinkling of Liszt just to keep things interesting – ought to be heard, I think. Carl Heinrich Carsten Reinecke was born in what is now an area of Hamburg, and therefore you might think a German composer, except for the fact that in the 1820s it was ruled by Denmark (hence the ‘Carsten’ bit in his name). He was a gifted pianist, and his career ticked off the usual staging points as his reputation and status grew. As a young man he moved to Leipzig, where he studied with Mendelssohn, Schumann and Liszt, and then spent some years as composer-in-residence at the Danish court in Copenhagen. By the early 1850s his career as a teacher in German musical establishments was taking off, in Cologne, Breslau (now, of course, in Poland) and Leipzig. He was principal conductor of the renowned Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra from 1860-95, so he was clearly no marginal figure (he conducted the first performance of the final version of Brahms’ ‘A German Requiem’, for instance). And a list of other composers he taught feels like a who’s who of late 19th/early 20th century figures: Bruch, Grieg, Sullivan, Stanford, Janacek, Delius, Svendsen, Albeniz and many, many others. (Of course, the fact that Reinecke taught them doesn’t mean that his influence can be felt on their music; a good few of those names actively loathed the experience and found Reinecke’s methods and musical tastes stultifying.) He was, alongside the conducting and academic teaching, an immensely prolific composer (works stretch as far as Op 288), and produced pieces in all the major genres of the day: three symphonies, four piano concertos, several other concertos for various instruments, plus string quartets, piano trios, cello sonatas, piano sonatas, not to mention some now completely invisible operas. These days, if Reinecke appears on concert programmes at all, it’s for a Flute Sonata nicknamed ‘Undine’, but really there’s nothing much else. Another obscure footnote: he’s the earliest born composer to be recorded on a piano roll, making recordings of some of his piano music in 1904. To mark the bicentenary of his birth, I thought I’d go for what has been described as the greatest concerto ever written for the instrument in question. If I say that we’re talking here about a harp concerto, you might object that there’s not exactly a lot of competition, but given that, really, the only concerto featuring the harp that regularly sees the light of day is the Mozart one for flute and harp (in which the harp part could definitely be played on the piano, so it’s not what you’d call idiomatic), with maybe also an occasional outing for Ginastera’s sparky Harp Concerto, then Reinecke’s Harp Concerto in E Minor, Op 182, deserves its place in such company. It was written in 1884 and first performed at a Leipzig Gewandhaus concert that same year. It has the familiar three movements – Reinecke’s work rarely breaks with any conventions – with a fast/slow/fast pattern. The opening movement, marked ‘Allegro moderato’, has a recurring rhythmic pattern that is stated at the outset by the orchestra and developed by the harp. The writing for harp is not that ‘flashy’ glissando-laden stuff such as, say, Tchaikovsky writes for the instrument in his ballets. Instead, this is cogent, argued, almost ‘symphonic’ in approach. I think it’s the second movement, a tender and lyrical Adagio, that is the work’s high point, with its hymn-like theme that has, to my ears, a hint of Beethoven about it. Finally there’s a Scherzo-Finale. There’s a nod in the direction of Liszt in Reinecke’s use of the triangle here (see also Liszt’s Piano Concerto No 1), but you can hear clearly enough t hat the conservative Reinecke’s idols are Mendelssohn and Schumann in this movement most of all. For such a relatively obscure piece, there are quite a lot of video recordings of this work on YouTube. Out of them I’ve gone for a performance by the Flanders Symphony Orchestra (who were in Sheffield only three days ago) conducted by Jan Latham-Koenig. The soloist is Anneleen Lenaerts. You’ll find the performance here: Reinecke: Harp Concerto
Reinhardt, Django (1910-53)
Day 60: ‘Nuages’ (Time: 5 minutes*)
As you will know (because I trailed this stuff beforehand) Music in the Round’s 2020 Sheffield Chamber Music Festival had a ‘virtual festival weekend’ on 15th/16th May, and highlights are currently still on YouTube. (I’m not sure they’re going to stay there permanently, so this may be a time-limited suggestion.) One of the performers due to appear in Sheffield was the award-winning guitarist Craig Ogden. Instead, he recorded a short session of four pieces, and it is this broadcast that Malcolm wants to draw our attention to – and specifically to the first piece in this set, an arrangement of Django Reinhardt’s ‘Nuages’. Reinhardt (1910-53) is probably most famous today for his performances with the Quintette du Hot Club de France in the 1930s and 40s alongside the violinist Stephane Grappelli, which featured his guitar-led ‘gypsy jazz’. ‘Nuages’, dating from 1940, is one of his most famous tunes, which he recorded many times in different arrangements. The performance here by Craig Ogden is an arrangement by Roland Dyens. The link I’m attaching here is to the whole of Craig Odgen’s online recital, which lasts just under 25 minutes. As well as the Reinhardt piece, therefore, you get performances of music by Villa-Lobos, Berkeley and Albeniz – in other words, more conventional ‘classical music’ fare. If you’re listening out for the Reinhardt performance specifically, you’ll find it starting approx. 2’25” in*, and finishing at approx. 6’30”. Here’s the link: Django Reinhardt – ‘Nuages’
Reizenstein, Franz (1911-68)
Day 405: Variations on 'The Lambeth Walk' (Time: 13 minutes)
Today (22/8/23), the second instalment of the planned pair of postings based on composers writing variations on other composers’ work as a follow on from the Chabrier ‘Souvenirs de Munich’ (Day 403). And, once more, we’re in the realm of the relatively obscure, at least when it comes to my choice of composer, though I hope you’ll all find the music itself a smile-inducing joy from beginning to end. I suspect many will not be aware of the existence of Franz Reizenstein (1911-68). He is one of those composers who has fallen out of fashion, partly by writing ‘the wrong sort of music’ at the wrong time, and partly, as I’ll argue, by being unfairly tarnished with the reputation of not being a ‘serious’ composer. He was born and grew up in Nuremberg, Germany, which for a Jewish family in the 1930s was not an ideal place. His family was both professionally and culturally well-connected, and Reizenstein showed an early talent as both pianist and composer, studying composition with Hindemith in the early 1930s. However, the rise of the Nazis led Reizenstein to emigrate, and he arrived in London in 1934, continuing his studies with Vaughan Williams and Constant Lambert. Before the outbreak of the Second World War he worked primarily as a pianist, though he continued to compose. In 1939, as a German living in England, Reizenstein was interned, one of a veritable galaxy of cultural and intellectual heavyweights who ended up in the camp in Douglas, on the Isle of Man. On his release he worked as a train conductor during the war, before resuming his musical career. In later life he taught at the Royal Manchester College of Music (now the RNCM). Musically, his twin influences (unsurprising given his composition teachers) were Hindemith and Vaughan Williams, and you can hear evidence of their musical fingerprints in a great deal of his work. His output is substantial and varied: several concertos (including two for the piano), a couple of operas, a great amount of very high quality chamber music (his Piano Quintet of 1949 is particularly good), a lot of solo piano music (including two piano sonatas), and some work for the film studio (probably most famously the scores for ‘The Mummy’ in 1959 and ‘The Curse of the Mummy’s Tomb’ in 1964). Perhaps it’s the fact that his music was essentially tonal when musical fashions after the Second World War were for the more astringent sonorities of Boulez, Stockhausen and the like (particularly at the BBC) that meant that he got very little exposure for the work he produced in the 1950s and 60s. But – and this strikes me as a very sad comment on the underlying elitism of some classical music circles – the other reason for his work being ignored is that he mixed this ‘serious’ output with compositions written for the Hoffnung Festivals of the later 1950s. (You come across the same sort of condescension when people dismiss the music of Malcolm Arnold, say, because of the things he wrote for the Hoffnung concerts.) In particular, Reizenstein was famous for writing the splendid ‘Concerto Poplare’, in which orchestra and solo pianist are at odds: the orchestra think they’re playing Tchaikovsky’s 1st Piano Concerto, while the soloist thinks he’s playing the Grieg Piano Concerto. I suspect the joke wears thin on multiple hearings, but the piece is great fun. However, that’s not what I’ve chosen for today. Instead you have another Hoffnung-influenced work, the ‘Variations on The Lambeth Walk’ for solo piano. For the benefit of younger persons among my audience, a word or two about the theme. ‘The Lambeth Walk’ is a number from the 1937 Noel Gay musical ‘Me and My Girl’. You can educate yourselves with a five-minute burst of the 1939 film version here. It’s the sort of thing that makes the Macarena look complicated! Reizenstein follows the theme with seven variations on it, in the style of, respectively, Chopin, Verdi, Beethoven, Mozart, Schubert, Wagner and Liszt. For me, the thing that makes this music such a joy is not just that Reizenstein beautifully ventriloquizes the melodic and harmonic language of his chosen composers, but that he weaves seemingly effortlessly well-known works by those composers into the fabric of the ‘Lambeth Walk’ melody itself. Thus, the Chopin variation uses his Nocturne Op 9 No 2, the Verdi variation uses ‘La Donna e Mobile’ from ‘Rigoletto’, the Wagner variation uses the Prelude to ‘Die Meistersinger’ and the Prelude to ‘Tristan und Isolde’, and so on … culminating in the ‘bring-the-house-down’ Lisztian variation in which ‘The Lambeth Walk’ vies with Liszt’s Hungarian Rhapsody No 2 for supremacy. Actually, my favourite variation is the Schubert one, in which Reizenstein perfectly captures the characteristic abrupt changes of key that are such a feature of Schubert’s work. So, 13 minutes of unalloyed fun. Sadly, I can’t find a video recording of anyone playing this work, so we’re in audio-only territory for today. The pianist Philip Martin has recorded all of Reizenstein’s piano works, and he is the soloist in this performance, which you’ll find here: Reizenstein: Variations on 'The Lambeth Walk'
Respighi, Ottorino (1879-1936)
Day 152: Botticelli Triptych (Time: 20 minutes)
When I was selecting the Advent/Christmas pieces, I felt I could squeeze in one Christmas carol, but two might be pushing it, so you got Coventry Carol (see Day 146), but not my second favourite carol, ‘O Come, O Come, Emmanuel’. Fortuitously, it makes an appearance today (8/1/21), in the second movement of Respighi’s ‘Botticelli Triptych’, a piece I’ve chosen, slightly belatedly, to mark Epiphany, an occasion associated amongst other things with the visit of the Magi to Jesus. And one of the Botticelli paintings that inspired this music depicts precisely that scene, albeit in an image that would have been unrecognisable in first century Palestine. Ottorino Respighi (1879-1936) is a fascinating if slightly neglected composer. That neglect might still have something to do with his rather unhappy association with Italian Fascism at the very end of his career, although I don’t think his music ‘sounds’ Fascist in the way one might think the music of Carl Orff, for example, does. I have always felt that he was born perhaps 30 years or so too early, because if he’d been around when film soundtracks were coming into their own I’m sure he’d have written a lot of them. His music is always vivid, ‘scenic’ stuff. I guess his reputation today is based largely on the ‘Roman’ symphonic poems he wrote between 1916 and 1928, ‘Fountains of Rome’, ‘Pines of Rome’ and ‘Roman Festivals’ – the last of these the most overblown ‘throw everything at it, including the kitchen sink, and then some’ piece of music I’ve ever heard. But his career took him to some interesting places musically. The earliest influence on his career was probably Rimsky-Korsakov, from whom he took lessons in orchestration, and in many ways, you could see him as the final step in the line of great orchestrators of the Romantic era, ranging from Berlioz via Rimsky to Respighi himself. There’s a strand of music in his output that’s heavily influenced by Wagner and Richard Strauss (big orchestras, lots of noise), but then there’s another thread you can follow that’s inspired by Monteverdi and composers of the Renaissance and early Baroque, and which led him to make many transcriptions of pieces by these composers, most obviously in his three suites of Ancient Airs and Dances or his suite ‘The Birds’. The three-movement suite ‘Botticelli Triptych’ dates from the same time as ‘The Birds’, 1927. It shows Respighi’s interest in colourful orchestration, but on a much smaller scale than the big orchestral pieces. Respighi’s inspiration was three paintings by Botticelli, ‘La Primavera’ (‘Spring’), ‘L'Adorazione dei Magi’ (‘the Adoration of the Magi’) and ‘La Nascita de Venere’ (‘The Birth of Venus’). If you want to look at the paintings whilst you listen, you’ll find them here: Botticelli Primavera, Botticelli Adoration of the Magi and Botticelli Birth of Venus. The ‘Spring’ music is full of trilling birds and skipping dances. For the ‘Magi’, there’s a note of greater solemnity, including, as trailed above, the ancient melody ‘O Come, O Come, Emmanuel’. Finally, ‘Venus’ is depicted with a simple, lilting theme that grows louder as her ‘shell’ nears land, set against the sound of undulating waves, before she reaches the shore. As for a recording, I thought this one by the WDR Symphony Orchestra, Cologne, conducted by Cristian Macelaru, might be interesting, not just because it’s a clear and vivid performance, but also because it shows what concert performances in 2020 were like, with screens separating orchestral musicians and a very socially-distanced audience. You’ll find it here: Respighi: Botticelli Triptych
Rigel, Henri-Joseph (1741-99)
Day 476: Symphony in C Minor, Op 12 No 4 (Time: 16 minutes)
For me, one of the great joys of the seemingly inexhaustible curiosity of recording companies (not so much broadcasters, who tend to be more conservative, presumably because they’re chasing audience numbers) is that every now and then I encounter a composer of whom I’ve never heard. So it is with M. Rigel (actually Herr Rigel at birth, but almost all his creative life was spent in France). I suspect I have something of a ‘blind spot’ for non-Germanic 18th century symphonies. Obviously, the joyous music of Haydn (of which one can surely never have enough) overshadows so much else in this field, and the shorter career of Mozart exemplifies another ‘famous name’ whose works put so many other composers in the shade. This playlist is very gradually filling in some of the blanks in terms of Austro-German territories – we’ve had music by CPE Bach, Salieri, Kozeluch, Benda, Graf, Quantz, Cannabich, Gassmann and Dussek so far – but I realise that my survey of the French 18th century orchestral output is much sketchier, amounting only to some music by Le Chevalier de Saint-Georges. Anyway, today (30/4/24) I want to lay down a marker for Henri-Joseph Rigel, in the hope that it’ll spark the sort of curiosity in you that it has in me. Henri-Joseph Rigel (1741-99) died on 2nd May 1799, which means that it’s the 225th anniversary of his death on Thursday of this week – another good reason for shining a spotlight in his direction. He was born in south-west Germany, the son of a musician who sadly died when Henri-Joseph was about 12 years old. His mother’s widow’s pension enabled her son to have music lessons, in Stuttgart, Mannheim and finally, by the time he was in his mid-twenties, in Paris. He arrived there in 1767 and stayed for the remaining 32 years of his life. Although he had composed a number of works before settling in France, his most fruitful period creatively was probably from the early 1770s onwards. Initially, his main successes were in orchestral and concertante works, but by the 1780s, he had become much more interested in writing ‘dramatic’ works, either fashionable religious oratorios, on topics like the exodus from Egypt or the fall of Jericho, or operas for the stage – at least 15 of them in the last decade of his life. To round off the biographical bit, he seems to have weathered the turbulence of the French Revolution reasonably well, diverting his energies to writing politically appropriate pieces like the ‘Hymne à la Liberté’. One of the musical consequences of the revolution was the establishment of the Paris Conservatoire, in 1795, and Rigel was amongst the first group of teachers to be appointed there, a post he retained for the remaining four years of his life. What about the music, though? Things are made a little more complicated here by the fact that one of Rigel’s sons, Henri-Jean, was also a composer, and until relatively recently it wasn’t always clear which ‘H-J Rigel’ wrote which music. However, we can be pretty confident that ‘our’ Rigel was a composer of, amongst other things, at least 14 symphonies, the first of these being performed in Paris in 1774. Six of them emerged as a set, Op 12, in 1774, another one in 1780, one more in 1783, and another set of six, Op 21, in 1786. They conform to the French convention in symphonic writing, having three movements (fast-slow-fast) as opposed to the developing Austro-German convention of adding a minuet as (usually) the third of four movements. Many of Rigel’s symphonies are in a minor key, and they have, to use an 18th century stylistic convention, a ‘Sturm und Drang’ quality, with stormily tempestuous outer movements, that frame a more lyrical slow movement. Rigel seems not to have written for large orchestra – usually strings plus a couple of oboes and horns. The work I’ve chosen to try to whet your appetite for Rigel’s music is the Symphony in C Minor, Op 12 No 4. For me, the most interesting aspect of this work is its melodic and rhythmic inventiveness. The development section of the outer movements (the ‘middle bit’ where the themes are reworked and manipulated) is never less than interesting, and often really quite startling. It seems to me that Rigel’s work is a kind of ‘missing link’ between the somewhat more well-mannered symphonies of Gossec (one day, perhaps…) and the more turbulent ‘(French) revolutionary’ symphonies of Méhul (again, one day…), whose work leads us on towards Beethoven. Unsurprisingly, there aren’t many options when it comes to recordings of Rigel’s symphonies. When I discovered him last year, I bought a CD of five of his symphonies recorded by the ‘early music’ ensemble Concerto Köln. It’s their recording I’ve selected here: Rigel: Symphony in C Minor, Op 12 No 4
Rimsky-Korsakov, Nikolai (1844-1908)
Day 184: Russian Easter Festival Overture (Time: 15 minutes)
Today (30/4/21), and for the first time on this list, we have music by Nikolai Rimsky-Korsakov (1844-1908). As you will know from the previous posting (if not before), Rimsky-Korsakov was one of the members of ‘the Kuchka’, ‘the Mighty Handful’ of Russian nationalist composers who produced considerable amounts of music on overtly Russian themes, using Russian folk music and folk tales as models, and generally celebrated music that did not look to western and central Europe for its inspiration. Of all the composers rooted in this St Petersburg milieu, Rimsky was certainly the most ‘professional’ – after a short-lived naval career, he came under the influence of Balakirev (the initial ‘ringleader’ of this nationalist music school), and by 1871, he became Professor of Composition and Instrumentation at the St Petersburg Conservatory. He gradually developed (and has retained) an impressive reputation as an orchestrator, even though he himself was well aware that most of his compositions from before the 1880s were essentially the product of intuition rather than any systematic study of musical forms or theory. Over the years that followed, Rimsky gradually became distanced from the more ‘naïve’ elements of the ‘Kuchka’ approach to composition, and a little more sympathetic towards the western-looking Tchaikovsky. Nevertheless, Rimsky’s fascination with Russian folk culture remained the dominant influence on almost all his music, and especially his operas, which have extraordinary and fantastical plots characteristic of Russian folk tales. In the years before he died, he evidently inspired his most famous pupil (Stravinsky, whose early works up to and including ‘The Firebird’ – see Day 69 – show very marked evidence of Rimsky’s influence), though he seems to have been repulsed by the ‘modern’ music of the new century, expressing a strong dislike for compositions by Richard Strauss and Debussy. These days, I guess Rimsky’s place in musical history is preserved by two main works, the ubiquitous ‘Scheherazade’ and the highly colourful (if really rather noisy) ‘Capriccio Espagnol’, even though there is a great deal more to explore: sixteen operas, three symphonies and a number of other ‘programmatic’ orchestral works, and a copious quantity of songs. However, the work I want to feature today is his Russian Easter Festival Overture, Op 36 (also known as his ‘Overture on Liturgical Themes’ and his ‘Great Russian Easter Overture’). It dates from the late 1880s, and was dedicated to Mussorgsky and Borodin. The melodies in the work are drawn almost completely from the Russian Orthodox liturgy; Rimsky himself does not appear to have had a meaningful religious faith, but he was strongly attracted to the passionate and all-embracing aspects of the Russian Easter festival as a mass cultural event. There are a number of strong performances of the work on YouTube, and out of these, the one I’ve selected is a video recording of a concert given by the South Netherlands Philharmonic, conducted by Stefan Blunier. You’ll find it here: Rimsky-Korsakov: Russian Easter Festival Overture.
Day 337: Scheherazade (1st movement) (Time: 10 minutes) and Scheherazade (4th Movement) (12 minutes)
As we’ve had some fairly recondite choices in recent months (and there’ll be more in the weeks to come!), it might make at least some on this list happy today (25/10/22) to hear what is by any standards a popular classic. Rimsky-Korsakov has featured just the once on this list so far (on Day 184, when we encountered his ‘Russian Easter Festival Overture’), but I mentioned at the time that his modern reputation is essentially down to two works, the raucous ‘Capriccio Espagnol’ and his treatment of ideas from the ‘1001 Nights’ narrative, ‘Scheherazade’. Rimsky is an interesting figure in Russian music – an outsider and amateur turned establishment figure, and a committed exponent of Russian folk music and culture turned ‘Europhile’. He wrote ‘Scheherazade’ in the late 1880s. In fact, it was among his last purely orchestral works: apart from devoting his time to his role as Professor of Composition at the St Petersburg Conservatory, the final two decades of his life were largely focused on the composition of operas. It’s worth saying that Rimsky-Korsakov was by no means unique amongst Russian composers in his fascination with the ‘exotic’, particularly as it was manifest in the ‘orientalist’ art, architecture and literature of the regions to the south of Russia. (For comparison, try Borodin’s ‘In the Steppes of Central Asia’, say, or Balakirev’s ‘Islamey’.) It’s not hard to see why ‘Scheherazade’ should have quickly become a popular work – it’s full of broad, lyrical melodies; it is orchestrated vividly and colourfully, using the orchestra with great flexibility; its consistent focus on rhythm gives it a directness of appeal in ways that aren’t always as obvious in more ‘symphonic’ works where composers might be more interested in complexity of argument. Indeed, though Rimsky described the work as a ‘symphonic suite’, the emphasis is far more on the latter word, I think: themes are stated, repeated, re-orchestrated in differently coloured clothing, but rarely developed or subjected to processes of transformation and integration. I don’t mean any of that in a pejorative way. This music is immense fun; it’s just not terribly deep – but then, why should it need to try to be? The inspiration for the work, as is well known, derived from the famous collection of Eastern tales, ‘A Thousand and One Nights’. Rimsky prefaces the score with the startlingly gender-biased summary which contextualises the narrative: ‘The Sultan Shakhriar, convinced of the faithlessness of women, had sworn to put to death each of his wives after a single night. But the Sultana Scheherazade saved her own life by diverting him with stories which she told him over a period of a thousand and one nights. The Sultan, overcome with curiosity, put off from day to day the execution of his wife, and at last entirely gave up his blood-thirsty vow. Many wonders were related to Shakhriar by the Sultana Scheherazade. For her stories the Sultana borrowed the verses of poets and the words of folk-songs, and she fitted together tales and adventures.’ Initially, Rimsky gave descriptive titles to the four movements of the piece, but kept them deliberately vague: these are not descriptions of particular tales, but rather the broader evocation of a fairy-tale world. Nevertheless, some features recur across the four movements, notably the depiction of Scheherazade herself on the solo violin, weaving her hypnotic spell, and the stern opening trombone theme which represents the Sultan Shakhriar. I can’t select the whole of the piece for this posting (I broke the ’40-minute rule’ once for Vaughan-Williams; not again… or at least not for a while!), so I’ve gone for the first and last movements. The opening movement reveals not just the two principal characters of the main narrative, but also, as the title of the movement suggests, ‘The sea and Sinbad’s ship’. Rimsky’s career initially took him to sea, as an officer in the Imperial Russian Navy (the family had a long history of naval service), sailing on a two-and-a-half year voyage through the Mediterranean and across the Atlantic to Brazil in the early 1860s. The sea was a powerful force in his life and in his creative imagination, and this first movement is impregnated throughout by the swell of the sea. The middle two movements are more lightweight – a gypsy-like theme and variations, and dreamy love scene – before we reach the finale, which endeavours to depict the following, rather challenging images: ‘The Festival at Baghdad. The Sea. The Ship Breaks against a Cliff Surmounted by a Bronze Horseman’. Rimsky does a lot of pulling together of themes from across the work at this stage, before ending (the Sultan is tamed, and not before time) with Scheherazade’s solo violin theme rising to an ecstatic note of triumph. So, here is the first movement, played by the all-American composite forces of the not all that self-deprecatingly named All-Star Orchestra, conducted by Gerard Schwarz, which you’ll find here: Rimsky-Korsakov: Scheherazade (1st movement). And then, for a taste of something more authentically Russian, here is the final movement played by the Moscow City Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Dmitri Jurowski, and followed by a good deal of applause: Rimsky-Korsakov: Scheherazade (4th Movement)
Rodrigo, Joaquin (1901-99)
Day 153: Concierto d’Aranjuez (Time: 24 minutes)
This week, two postings to mark ‘Spanish Sunshine Week’. Before Christmas, Claire suggested that we listen to what is probably the most popular guitar concerto in the repertoire, Rodrigo’s ‘Concerto d’Orange Juice’ (for those old enough to remember ‘Brassed Off’) – or, as it’s more properly known, the Concierto d’Aranjuez. Joaquin Rodrigo (1901-99) – or, to give him his full name, Joaquin Rodrigo Vidre, 1st Marquess of the Gardens of Aranjuez, the title he was given in 1991 by King Juan Carlos I – is perhaps best known for two distinguishing features: for being blind from the age of three, and therefore writing his compositions initially in Braille, and also for not quite being able to play the guitar (he was actually a pianist), which is astonishing given the amount of music he composed for the instrument. He began to compose in a serious way in the early 1920s, and the Concierto d’Aranjuez, which we’ll hear today (12/1/21), was his breakthrough work, dating from 1939. Its extraordinary success led to Rodrigo being commissioned to write a string of other concertos, many for the guitar on behalf of Andres Segovia and the Romeros guitar siblings, for the harp at the prompting of Nicanor Zabaleta, and the flute at the request of James Galway. He also wrote over two dozen works for solo guitar, and a similar quantity of pieces for solo piano, although, out of all this music, probably only the guitar concerto known as the Fantasia para un Gentilhombre rivals the Concierto d’Aranjuez in popularity. For many listeners, today’s concerto is the musical embodiment of Spanish identity, but there are a couple of contextual matters that might suggest more complex issues going on under the surface. The first is that he wrote it in 1939, when overtly ‘Spanish’ music had to be seen to be celebrating the Francoist nationalism that dominated Spanish culture at the time. By giving the work the title that he did, and insisting that its inspiration was the gardens of the Royal Palace of Aranjuez, south of Madrid, built (not personally, of course) by Philip II back in the 16th century, Rodrigo was able to sidestep slavish celebration of Spanish Fascism by pointing to a more distant era in Spain’s history. The second issue is considerably more personal. The concerto’s most famous passage is the second movement, with its tenderly melancholy dialogue between guitar and a solo cor anglais. Not until many years after the event did Rodrigo’s wife, in her autobiography, reveal that the movement was Rodrigo’s emotional response to the miscarriage of their first child. There are several audio recordings of the work on YouTube, but working on the assumption that a video version is rather more satisfying, I’ve chosen an authentically Spanish one given by the Symphony Orchestra of Spanish Radio and Television, conducted by Enrique Garcia-Asensio, with Pablo Sainz Villegas as the guitar soloist. (The recording is also another reminder of the melancholy state of Covid-compliant performance practice in 2020.) You’ll find it here: Rodrigo: Concierto d'Aranjuez
Day 434: ‘Tres Piezas Españolas’ (Time: 12 minutes)
We’ve had just one day on this list devoted to Rodrigo’s music before now – Day 153, which featured the ever-popular ‘Concierto d’Aranjuez’. I wrote then of the two most striking personal details about Rodrigo (1901-99) that shaped his life and music: the fact that he was blind from the age of three, and the fact that he was by training a pianist and not a guitarist, so that, in fact, his technique on the guitar never developed beyond the fairly rudimentary. Given that he wrote six concertos featuring one or more guitars as soloists, not to mention more than 20 (sets of) pieces for solo guitar, it seems extraordinary that he wasn’t proficient on the instrument. And it raises the question: why write so much for the guitar at all? My gut feeling is that the guitar is (I’m stereotyping here) the most ‘Spanish’ of instruments. Yes, you’ll find guitar music written by composers of other nationalities, but its richest collection of works comes from composers from Spain or from South and Central America – Spanish influence in the Americas of course being a product of colonialist expansion from the late 15th century onwards. In other words, writing for the guitar goes with the territory. Add to this the fact that Rodrigo was a consciously ‘nationalist’ composer, who saw his role as making, as it were, ‘Spanish music’ (and not just ‘his own’ music), and there’s even more of a case for saying that writing for the guitar was inevitable. Guitar works emerged throughout Rodrigo’s compositional life, and often written for (and creatively advised by) famous guitarists of the 20th century – notably Segovia, Angelo Gilardino and Celedonio Romero (the founder of Los Romeros quartet of guitar-playing quartet with his three sons). The piece by Rodrigo that Craig Ogden is playing in Sheffield this week, and so my choice for today (1/12/23) is his ‘Tres Piezas Españolas’ (or, if a translation is needed, ‘Three Spanish Pieces’!). As the title suggests, a sense of Spanish identity underscores the work. Its three movements are titled ‘Fandango’, ‘Passacaglia’ and ‘Zapateado’ – the outer movements named after dances rooted in Spanish flamenco tradition. There’s also something rather consciously ‘old-fashioned’ about this music too. It emerged at the same time as Rodrigo’s second most famous guitar concerto, his ‘Fantasia para un Gentilhombre’, in 1954. That concerto’s character overtly harks back to Renaissance times in its melodies and rhythms. The ‘Three Spanish Pieces’ seem in many ways cut from the same cloth – and both works, maybe not surprisingly, were written for and dedicated to Andres Segovia. The opening ‘Fandango’ wears its flamenco characteristics proudly from the opening bars, with its 3/4 rhythm and the stirring ‘rolled’ chords typical of flamenco guitarists. There are occasional dissonances to remind us that this is actually a piece of 20th century classical music and not just a period piece in the folk style. Rodrigo himself wrote of this movement: ‘The “Fandango” is a dance that was once enjoyed by all Spanish social classes … My fandango for guitar is a little solemn, but maintains a popular touch, for example in the central section, which contains various echoes of the “seguidilla” which recounts the heroic feats of brave smugglers.’ The middle movement is a passacaglia (see my posting on Brahms’ Symphony No 4 – Day 426 – for more on passacaglias), in which Rodrigo weaves a set of variations over the recurring bass figure. Even though this movement uses a more ‘classical’ form than the outer movements, there are still evidently ‘folk-like’ elements here, notably the use of minor seconds (try playing any two adjacent notes on the piano at the same time). The final ‘Zapateado’ is again rooted in flamenco culture, a foot-stomping dance in 6/8 time. What makes it more than merely pastiche, though, is the way Rodrigo keeps shifting key as the movement unfolds. The whole work is, I think, an ideal example of the blending of folk and ‘classical’ styles. There are plenty of performances of this music on YouTube. Out of them, I’ve gone for a performance by the Polish classical guitarist Marcin Dylla. You’ll find his performance of Rodrigo’s ‘Tres Piezas Españolas’ here: Rodrigo: Tres Piezas Españolas
Roger-Ducasse, Jean (1873-1954)
Day 371: Crux Fidelis (Time: 4 minutes) and 2. Pastorale (12 minutes)
Next Tuesday, April 18th, Jean Roger-Ducasse (or, to give him his full and splendid name, Jean-Jules Aimable Roger-Ducasse) would have been 150 years old, if you see what I mean. Hence the fact that I’m drawing his name to your attention today (14/4/23). I have the feeling that there will be very few on this list who have even heard of M. Roger-Ducasse, let alone heard any music by him. We are very definitely on the byways rather than the highways of the musical landscape here. But, I console myself, one of the things this list might be useful for is broadening people’s horizons, and it seems to me to be a shame that a small number of composers get anniversary celebrations on the radio and others simply don’t get a mention at all. So, you can’t move for Rachmaninov at the moment (not that I’m complaining about that!), but poor old Roger-Ducasse remains in the shadows. Well, not any more! So, what might you want to know about Roger-Ducasse (1873-1954)? He was born in a small town in south-west France, studied at the Paris Conservatoire, and was apparently close friends with both Debussy and Fauré, in fact succeeding Fauré as Professor of Composition at the Conservatoire. Later still, Wikipedia tells me, he succeeded Dukas (whom I must get onto this list one day soon) as Professor of Orchestration too. He actually wrote a considerable amount of music, in a wide range of forms and for a wide range of forces, but one of the reasons he might still not be a household name even in his own household is that he destroyed a lot of his work if, with hindsight, it didn’t match up to his fastidious high standards, and consequently not as much music survives as might have been the case. (The most comprehensive list I’ve been able to find consists of 54 extant compositions, a good many of them for solo piano.) It would seem that the first of his compositions to appear in public was his Petit Suite for Orchestra, first heard in 1898. He seems to have been very drawn to opera, with not necessarily popular results, though a stage melodrama ‘Orphée’ and a comic opera ‘Cantegril’ still get occasional performances. As you might be able to deduce from these postings, I’m particularly drawn to chamber music, and Roger-Ducasse wrote a couple of interesting string quartets (the latter being his final work, from 1952) and an attractive piano quartet. One of the nicest comments I’ve come across in relation to Roger-Ducasse as a composer comes from an unnamed critic who observed that ‘all the best qualities of the French musician are combined in him – an abundantly rich imagination, clear and deep thought… and unerring taste.’ Another, somewhat less complimentary assessment (again I can’t put a name to the comment, sorry) is that his orchestral music ‘enjoyed considerable success, without setting a mark for originality.’ Ouch… To give at least a flavour of this composer’s music, though, I thought I’d go for one of his most popular choral works and an organ piece that still has a regular place in the repertoire of many organists. Roger-Ducasse’s setting of the ‘Crux Fidelis’ was published as the second of his Three Motets, from 1911, and it has become the most performed of them. The text is part of the longer 6th century Latin hymn ‘Pange lingua gloriosi proelium certaminis’ (roughly ‘Sing, tongue, the battle of glorious combat’) by St Venantius Fortunatus, who was Bishop of Poitiers. A rather stodgy translation of the ‘Crux Fidelis’ by the Victorian John Mason Neale (best known maybe for writing that Christmas standard ‘Good King Wenceslas’) reads: ‘Faithful cross, true sign of triumph,/ Be for all the noblest tree;/ None in foliage, none in blossom,/ None in fruit thine equal be;/ Symbol of the world's redemption,/ For the weight that hung on thee!’ I have hazy memories of singing this with Escafeld Chorale back in the spring of 2014. However, this performance is by the American vocal group The Choral Scholars, directed by Paul Thornock, in a recording made earlier this month in Savannah, Georgia. You’ll find it here: Roger-Ducasse: Crux Fidelis. Out of all Roger-Ducasse’s works, though, the one that has stayed in the public gaze the longest is his Pastorale for Organ, which dates from 1909. It’s his only piece for organ, and was dedicated to that inescapably influential figure in 20th century music teaching, Nadia Boulanger. This is, I think, a remarkable work, and one that shows the range of Roger-Ducasse’s invention. It begins innocently enough, with a gentle serene theme in ‘siciliano’ rhythm (a kind of lilting 6/8, with a generally ‘pastoral’ feel), vividly described by one critic as having ‘a sun-dappled delicacy’, but builds in ever-more complex ways to a resounding climax which is powerful and knotty (in a good way!), before returning to the peaceful mood of the opening. It’s played on this video recording by the renowned organist Wayne Marshall; you’ll find it here: Roger-Ducasse: Pastorale
Roman, Johan Helmich (1694-1758)
Day 159: Drottningholm Music (extracts) (Time: 15 minutes)
Johan Helmich Roman (1694-1758) is, as they say, probably not even a household name in his own descendants’ household. I suspect that these days he is remembered for just one piece, of which more below. But his reputational plight seems to me to be characteristic of the fate of so many fine Baroque composers, in that so much of our possible radio listening or concert-going experience constantly reinforces the assumption that thinking of Baroque orchestral music means thinking of Bach, Handel, Vivaldi and Telemann. I imagine that many of you might not even have heard of Roman, let alone heard any of his music. If so, here’s a bit of awareness-raising for you today (2/2/21). Roman was born in Stockholm, and apart from two periods of travel abroad, spent all of his life in Sweden. Those travels were important, though, in that, in his early 20s, he spent six years in London, where the most significant thing that happened was that he met and worked with Handel. (As well as having a paternal reputation in relation to Swedish music, Roman is also sometimes known as ‘the Swedish Handel’.) Later, in his early 40s, he spent three years on a kind of musical ‘grand tour’, picking up the latest trends in German, French and Italian music. His role in relation to Swedish music was absolutely foundational: as director of the Swedish Royal Orchestra, putting on the first ever public concerts in Sweden, and being elected to the Swedish Royal Academy of Sciences. His later life was not entirely happy – he married twice, but the deaths of his wives after four and six years of marriage respectively left him with five young children to bring up, and in the last two decades of his life he was troubled by severe deafness, leading him to retreat from his public roles. The only piece of his that has survived the test of time is his ‘Drottningholm Music’, a couple of dozen (probably – though I’ve seen comments suggesting it might be as many as 33) free-standing short pieces that Roman wrote for the wedding in 1744 of Crown Prince Adolf Frederick of Sweden to Princess Louisa Ulrika of Prussia, whose three-day wedding celebrations took place at the Palace of Drottningholm, the private residence of the Swedish royal family. This collection of pieces mixes the obviously ceremonial (probably for grand entrances and exits) and the more functional (a great many minuets, presumably to be danced to). I’m not making the case that this is great music – merely that it has a lively freshness that deserves many more outings than it gets. The whole collection of pieces in the ‘Drottningholm Music’ lasts somewhere north of 50 minutes, so it’s unsuitable for our context. However, there are some nice selections on YouTube of movements put together in informal ‘suites’, and the one that I’ve chosen consists of six pieces, performed by the Drottningholm Baroque Ensemble directed by Nils-Erik Sparf. You’ll find it here: Roman: Drottningholm Music (extracts)
Rorem, Ned (1923–2022)
Day 422: Symphony No 3 (Time: 23 minutes)
We haven’t had any music by Ned Rorem (1923-2022) on this list before today (20/10/23), though we’ve had a number of his contemporaries (Copland, Barber, Harris, Nancarrow, Bernstein, Hovhaness, Thomson, Walker, Price, Hanson, Diamond, Piston, Foss – whose music you can explore here, via the A-Z!). But Rorem deserves his place alongside these figures, as I’ll try to show, for those who maybe haven’t heard of him or his music. He was born into an upper-middle class family and seems to have had a secure and happy upbringing. He was seemingly quite happy about being overtly gay from a relatively early age. Interestingly he is often referred to as ‘composer and diarist’, and it’s true that he wrote (and published) a series of diaries and other bits of autobiographical writing that explore in some detail his (social and sexual) relationships with many of the leading cultural figures of his age – Copland, Bernstein, Virgil Thomson, Barber, Noel Coward, and many others; at one point he estimated that he might have been involved in as many as 3000 intimate liaisons. Until his long-term relationship with the organist Richard Holmes, which lasted for about 30 years until the latter’s death in 1999, Rorem seems to have had serious problems with alcohol consumption, though the stability of the bond with Holmes evidently cured that. Whether any of this affects in any way our view of Rorem the composer, as opposed to Rorem the man, is a matter of individual perspective, I suppose. As a composer, his main influence was the music of French impressionists, especially Debussy and Ravel, though he also found much to inspire him in the compositions of Poulenc, Honegger and other members of ‘Les Six’. Curiously, he was one of the very very few American 20th century composers who didn’t study with Nadia Boulanger – her decision, not his, in that she suggested his style and musical language was developed enough as it was without her teaching aiming to ‘improve’ it. He had a peripatetic teaching career at American universities and music colleges for much of the middle years of his life, but he seems for most of the time to have been simply an immensely prolific composer. His main focus was on songs – more than 500 of them, composed pretty much throughout his life, and culminating in his epic song cycle ‘Evidence of Things Not Seen’, in 1997. He won prizes as well as critical acclaim throughout his life, winning the Music Library Association’s ‘Song of the Year’ and the Gershwin Prize for an orchestral overture before he was 25 years old, and much bigger things followed: the Pulitzer Prize for Music in 1976 for his orchestral work ‘Air Music’, and, in the 21st century, a Lifetime Achievement Award from the American Society of Composers and becoming a Chevalier de l’Ordre des Arts et des Lettres, the latter cementing his significant contribution to the arts as a composer with profound connections to French music and culture. Rorem wrote amusingly of the impact of winning the Pulitzer Prize: ‘When I got the Pulitzer, everything changed overnight. Of course, I was shocked because I thought I would never get it because of my wicked ways. To this day I can't believe those stuffy Pulitzer people would settle on me. But it sort of gives you a certain authority. My name is now always preceded by “Pulitzer Prize-winning composer.” ... So if I die in a whorehouse, at least the obit will say, “Pulitzer Prize-Winning Composer Ned Rorem Dies in Whorehouse”.’ I wondered what to choose to illustrate the music of this self-declared ‘neoromantic’ composer, who retained his commitment to tonality all his life, even when it was profoundly unfashionable. There are compositions in all the conventional genres – song cycles, naturally, but also opera, concertos (four for the piano and several others), solo piano music … and three symphonies (and two other works with ‘symphony’ in their titles). I decided in the end to settle on one of the numbered symphonies, No 3, which was first performed in 1959 by the New York Phil under Leonard Bernstein. The three numbered symphonies were composed in an eight year period, and the last of them was complete by the time Rorem was 35. It’s in five movements. Rorem summarised its structure thus: ‘Of the five movements the second was written first, the first was second, the fourth was third, the third fourth, and the last was written last. 1 is a Passacaglia in C, a slow overture in the grand style. 2 was written originally for two pianos eight years before the rest, and incorporated as the second movement of the symphony. It is a brisk and jazzy dance. 3 is a short, passionate page about somnambulism, full of dynamic contrast, and coming from afar. 4 is a farewell to France. 5 is a long and fast Rondo, in itself a Concerto for Orchestra.’ Though clearly at moments the work has the sort of ‘outdoor’ vibrancy that’s characteristic of American orchestral scores, a great deal of it is influenced by the long melodic lines of Rorem the song composer. Apparently the third movement, marked Largo, was Rorem’s favourite. To quote the conductor José Serebrier, ‘It starts with a one-bar ‘theme’ in the strings, which recurs several times and also closes the movement. In between, there are various duets of oboes and trumpets and a big orchestral climax. This movement has the directness and charm of a Rorem song.’ After its (well received) first performance, the symphony has disappeared somewhat from the repertoire, but I’m convinced it’s worth digging out and hearing again. I hope you agree. As for a performance, it might not surprise you to know that we’re in audio-only territory again today. That original broadcast performance by Leonard Bernstein and the New York Philharmonic from 1959 is occasionally a bit rough and ready, but it’s very evocative and also a notable historical document, so that’s the version you’ll find here: Rorem: Symphony No 3
Rossini, Gioachino (1792-1868)
Day 48: Overture – ‘La Cenerentola’ (Time: 9 minutes)
After yesterday’s spiritual riches [Messiaen’s ‘Quartet for the End of Time’], I thought it might be nice today (9/5/20) just to have a bit of froth instead, to show that music can be good even if it’s not in any way profound. So, by way of a bit of light entertainment, here is the Overture to Rossini’s comic opera ‘La Cenerentola’ (‘Cinderella’). Rossini’s output in the opera house was prodigious – between the ages of 18 and 38 he wrote 39 operas. If one were being uncharitable, one might say that the music is pretty much the same in all of them, and in fact he often used the same overture on more than one occasion for more than one opera. He lived on for almost 40 years after his ‘retirement’ from the stage, producing almost nothing for much of that time – though there are lots of charming salon pieces called his ‘Sins of Old Age’ from the last decade or so of his life, along with the much more substantial (and great fun to sing) ‘Petite Messe Solonelle’. However, for today, a sunny overture to accompany the sunny weather! You’ll find the performance by the Orchestra of La Fenice Opera in Venice, conducted by Kazushi Ono, here: Rossini – ‘La Cenerentola’ (Overture)
Rzewski, Frederic (1938-2021)
Day 401: Winnsboro Cotton Mill Blues (Time: 9 minutes)
In a week that focuses on virtuoso piano playing, playlist regular Pete Dutton has suggested we listen to some music by the possibly little known Frederic Rzewski (1938-2021), which I’ll feature today (1/8/23). You might think, from his name, that Rzewski was Polish, but in fact he was born and grew up in the USA – though he was the son of parents with Polish/Jewish heritage. His musical development largely focused on the piano, and he has often been the soloist in major performances of his work – for instance, he performed the solo part in his Piano Concerto at its first performance at the BBC Proms in 2013. As a student at Harvard, he was much influenced by avant-garde composers – Cage, Stockhausen and Boulez, for example – and a lot of early work is decidedly experimental. For instance, whilst working in Rome in the 1960s he formed part of an electronics-based ensemble that focused on improvisation and chance-techniques using electronic instruments. However, the other thing worth saying about Rzewski’s approach – not just to music but to life – is that he was deeply influenced by social justice movements, and a lot of his work is motivated by articulating the struggles of the powerless, especially workers oppressed by exploitative methods of those with power. He makes what is indisputably political art – and in many ways his formative musical experiences make him ‘a child of the 60s’, an era of protest music. In that sense alongside the musical avant-garde his compositions are shaped by folk music. He spent considerable time in the 1960s and 70s with the American folk musician Pete Seeger, and interestingly one of the musical figures Seeger pointed Rzewski in the direction of was JS Bach (‘follow the example of Bach: he was one of the first composers who was concerned with audience participation’). Rzewski’s work has garnered considerable praise for its blending of musical and political motivations. One of my favourite comments about him is this remark from the musicologist Nicolas Slonimsky: ‘He is … a granitically overpowering piano technician, capable of depositing huge boulders of sonoristic material across the keyboard without actually wrecking the instrument’! (I think that’s intended as a compliment!) His most famous piece (mentioned on this list some time ago when I discussed large-scale works that use variation form, in the vein of Bach’s ‘Goldberg Variations’ or Beethoven’s ‘Diabelli Variations’) is a massive set of variations on the protest song written by the Chilean musician and activist Sergio Ortega, ‘¡El pueblo unido jamás será vencido!’ (or, for those with little Spanish, ‘The People United Will Never Be Defeated!’). However, as that 1976 work is pushing 70 minutes in length, it’s not really suitable for this playlist – though do search it out, because it’s an extraordinary demonstration of how to use ‘modernist’ keyboard and compositional techniques in an essentially accessible idiom. As an alternative to offering you an extract from ‘The People United…’, what Mr Dutton suggests is that we listen to one of the four pieces Rzewski composed under the collective title ‘Four North American Ballads’, a work dating from 1978-9. These four pieces draw on melodies popular with the American organised labour movements of the 20th century – protest songs concerning the living or employment conditions of North American workers. The fourth of these ‘North American Ballads’ is ‘Winnsboro Cotton Mill Blues’. The lyrics of the labour ballad Rzewski bases the piece on are a condemnation of the harsh conditions of the textile mills of North Carolina in the 1930s. What makes this a thrilling piece, I think, is its juxtaposition of the relentless, driving mechanical representation of the cotton mill machinery at work and the yearning blues/jazz idiom that contrasts with this mechanisation. And (back to Bach, again) Rzewski had this to say about the composition: ‘I took as a model the chorale preludes of Bach, who in his contrapuntal writing consistently derives motivic configurations from the basic tune. In each piece I built up contrapuntal textures in a similar way, using classical techniques like augmentation, diminution, transposition, and compression, always keeping the profile of the tune on some level.’ Thus, the piece begins with a representation of the mill machinery, building to a deafening climax. Then, as the sound fades, the blues emerge as an evocation of the rising social and political consciousness of the workers. Variations on the melody follow, before the piece reaches an explosive ending. For a work of this era, you’ll find a remarkable number of performances on YouTube. Out of the options there, I’ve chosen this concert recording by the Swiss-American pianist Gilles Vonsattel. If this music is new to you, it might at least reveal to you how useful the forearm is as a means of playing the piano! You’ll find the recording here: Rzewski: Winnsboro Cotton Mill Blues
Saint-Georges, Chevalier de (1745-1799)
Day 133: Symphonie Concertante in G, Op 13 No 2 (1st movement) (Time: 9 minutes) and Symphony in G, Op 11 No 1 (15 minutes)
Welcome to a week of choices from David, in a slightly delayed observance of Black History Month. As Mr Cope noted in his email to me, it’s very sad that there were (and are) composers of real talent and originality out there whose route to fame was/is blocked simply by the colour of their skin. This week’s choices do a tiny bit to redress the balance. Today (3/11/20), the composer under the spotlight is Joseph Bologne (1745-99), known as Chevalier de Saint-Georges from the point at which he graduated from military training in 1766. By any standards, he lived an extraordinary life. He was the son of George Bologne de Saint-Georges, a French plantation owner (and slave owner) in Guadeloupe, and Anne Nanon, the 16-year-old African slave of his wife. Despite this potentially problematical past, Joseph was taken to Paris by his father and educated as befitted a son of the nobility. The young Joseph seems to have been a man of many talents – there are records of his exceptional skill at fencing and swordsmanship, at dancing, and in musical performance and composition. Pre-Revolutionary law prevented Saint-Georges from inheriting his father’s title and lands after his death when Joseph was 30, but with the advent of the French Revolution in 1789, and its declaration of equal rights to all French citizens, Saint-Georges threw in his lot with the Revolutionary military forces. He fought with an army unit made up exclusively of black soldiers, a body that became known as the ‘Legion St-Georges’ because of his military prowess. As a musician, Saint-Georges excelled as a violinist, playing as a soloist not just in his own compositions but in those of other leading figures of the day in Paris. In pre-revolutionary times he led the foremost orchestra in Paris, giving the first performances of Haydn’s six ‘Paris’ symphonies. There is even evidence that he performed some of his own violin sonatas, accompanied on keyboard by Marie-Antoinette, wife of Louis XVI. As a composer, he wrote at least a dozen violin concertos, several collections of string quartets, two symphonies and at least three surviving operas. David has suggested a number of Saint-Georges’ compositions for us to consider. A fashionable Parisian musical form of the day was the ‘Symphonie Concertante’, usually for more than one soloist. Saint-Georges wrote several of these for two solo violins, and they were typically in two movements. David particularly asked for a performance by the Buskaid Soweto String Ensemble, with soloists Simiso Radebe and Kabelo Monnathebe, of the first movement of the Symphonie Concertante, Op 13 No 2 in G. You’ll find it here: Chevalier de Saint-Georges: Symphonie Concertante in G, Op 13 No 2 (1st movement). Alongside it, David suggested that we listen to one of Saint-Georges’ symphonies. The Symphony Op 11 No 1 in G has been recorded a number of times, but I’ve gone for a performance by the Canadian baroque ensemble Tafelmusik, conducted by Jeanne Lamon. Drawing attention to both Saint-Georges’ ethnicity and his musical renown, the CD from which this performance is taken is called ‘Le Mozart Noir’! You’ll find the performance here: Chevalier de Saint-Georges: Symphony in G, Op 11 No 1 - 1. Allegro, 2. Andante and 3. Allegro Assai
Saint-Saëns, Charles-Camille (1835-1921)
Day 104: Septet for Trumpet, Piano and Strings (Time: 18 minutes)
Today (24/7/20), it’s the turn of Charles-Camille Saint-Saëns (1835-1921). Saint-Saëns is a fascinating composer, but one who tends to be valued these days for a very small handful of works – the ubiquitous ‘Carnival of the Animals’, the engaging if somewhat overblown ‘Organ’ Symphony, the symphonic poem ‘Danse Macabre’, plus the occasional outing for the Piano Concerto No 2 or the shorter pieces for violin and orchestra. Unsurprisingly, given how long-lived he was, Saint-Saëns' output is extensive. He was a child prodigy (concert debut aged 10, admission to the Paris Conservatoire aged 13, and so on), and in his twenties and thirties, he was a keenly ‘modern’ composer, a fan of Wagner and Liszt. However, as his long career unfolded, there is a real sense that musical history evolved without him and eventually passed him by. The peak of his fame was probably the 1880s (the decade of the Symphony No 3), but he was still composing up to his death in 1921, writing in a style that wouldn’t have been out of place 60 years earlier. Although their musical language is very different, I have the sense that there is about Saint-Saëns the same kind of ‘absence of difficulty’ that one finds in Mendelssohn. Both composers showed an astonishing facility for composition, a fluency and elegance that is on the surface very attractive. But ‘facility’ carries its own shadow – that their music is in some sense ‘facile’. In the era of the ‘romantic composer’, whose works were supposedly expressions of deep personal emotion, or at least a reflection of the socio-political turbulence of the times, you can read almost nothing into Saint-Saëns’ music of the state of his personal life or his attitudes to the major issues of his day. I don’t seem to be making a very good job of ‘selling’ him to you here! I should say, then, that I think his music is lovely, immensely enjoyable, written with a sparkling clarity of expression and scoring. I have a strong sense that he was most at home (for all the Wagner-admiration of his youth, he had no desire to write like Wagner!) when looking backwards – he wrote a great deal (for solo piano, for chamber ensembles, for orchestra) that exists on the level of a gentle pastiche of past forms and modes of expression. So I’ve chosen just such a work for today. It’s the Septet for Piano, Trumpet and Strings, dating from the start of the 1880s. The scoring itself is very unusual; there’s a Septet by Hummel from 60 years earlier that uses a trumpet, but in that case alongside wind instruments. I’m fairly certain that the scoring of Saint-Saëns’ Septet is unique. (Feel free to prove me wrong!) It’s in four movements, and like the Fauré ‘Masques at Bergamasques’ Suite that I featured last week the titles of the movements echo the 18th century French style: Preambule; Menuet; Intermede; Gavotte et Final. The performance I’ve chosen is by soloists from the ranks of the Bilbao Symphony Orchestra, and you’ll find it here: Saint-Saëns: Septet
Day 224: Oboe Sonata (Time: 11 minutes)
It will be 100 years this coming December since the death of Saint-Saëns. I will mark that anniversary more explicitly when the time comes, but for today (17/9/21), I thought it would be interesting to consider his Oboe Sonata as an example of Saint-Saëns’ late output. Saint-Saëns has appeared once before on this list (see Day 104) when we considered his Septet for Trumpet, Piano and Strings, and I wrote extensively then about his life and compositional style. Born in 1835, by the time we arrive at the 20th century Saint-Saëns was most certainly some distance from the ‘cutting edge’ of musical composition – and, it has to be said, very happy for that to be the case. (He commented crushingly, and with heavy irony, on the ‘development of taste’ shown in Schoenberg’s atonal and subsequent serial compositions, declared that Stravinsky was ‘insane’ in writing ‘The Rite of Spring’, and reacted to the spiky neoclassicism of Poulenc and Milhaud by saying, ‘Fortunately, there are still lunatic asylums in France’!) Still, for all this rather dyspeptic touchiness, he was deeply involved in fundraising for French music and musicians following the start of the First World War, and he continued to compose even though well into his eighties. I don’t know if this is a trait unique to French composers, but there seems to be a tendency amongst many of them to write with great restraint towards the end of their lives, manifesting itself in sequences (often unfinished) of chamber music pieces that in some way distil the essence of their styles. You can see it in Debussy, for instance (the Cello Sonata, Violin Sonata and Sonata for Flute, Viola and Harp), in Poulenc (the Oboe Sonata, Flute Sonata and Clarinet Sonata) – and also in Saint-Saëns, who, in the final year of his life, 1921, wrote three sonatas, for oboe, clarinet and bassoon respectively. The Oboe Sonata is a short work of great clarity of melodic line and refinement of harmonic and emotional expression. It starts with a slow ‘Andantino’ movement, before the second movement ‘Romance’ (which is bookended by ‘ad libitum’ sections in the style of a kind of cadenza for the soloist). The final movement is a vivacious ‘Molto Allegro’, demanding great skill from the oboist. As with almost all of Saint-Saëns’ work, you can’t really tell anything of what he was thinking or feeling when he wrote the piece – which is, I realise, a bit of a black mark for some people, who want composers’ music to be the expression of some inner reaction to lived experience. To which I am tempted to say ‘So what?’ Rather, what you always get from Saint-Saëns is polished and crafted elegance, and a refinement of taste and wit. That seems good enough for me! YouTube has a handful of video recordings of this work, and from them I’ve gone for the performance by the renowned French oboist Maurice Bourgue, accompanied in this instance on the piano by Ichiro Nodaira. You’ll find the recording here: Saint-Saëns: Oboe Sonata
Day 243: Cello Sonata No 1 in C Minor, Op 32 (Time: 20 minutes)
Saint-Saëns (1835-1921) has been on this playlist twice so far, his Septet on Day 104 and his Oboe Sonata on Day 224. Neither of those works could be described as a staple feature of concert programmes, and I’ve pointed out on those previous postings how few works by Saint-Saëns actually get heard by audiences with any regularity. One other issue that turned up in my discussion back on Day 224 was the fact that one of the key features of Saint-Saëns’s music is its ‘elegance’, a well-crafted urbanity that – regarded pejoratively – means that sometimes his music seems ‘polished’ but not necessarily all that deep. My choice for today (23/11/21), however, seems to me to be the product of its times (both personal and more broadly historical) in a very impassioned way, that should leave us in no doubt that Saint-Saëns was capable of expressing complex depths of emotional intensity when the occasion arose. 1870 was a cataclysmic year for French culture, and indeed for France in general. The outbreak of the Franco-Prussian war led to a conflict that was brief (it was over in about six months) but humiliating for the French. Crushing military defeats led to the payment of billions of francs in war indemnities, plus the loss of Alsace and Lorraine. The establishment of the Paris Commune did not lead to stability, but it did influence the policies of the Third Republic which came to power in France in 1871. The point of this history lesson is to suggest that this prompted much heart-searching amongst French artists, musicians, writers and intellectuals about the nature of French identity and culture. The Societe Nationale de Musique was established in 1871, with Saint-Saëns as its Vice-President, and in some of the works he composed in the immediate aftermath of this crisis you can hear the impassioned striving for music that would meet the challenge of the times. However, for Saint-Saëns there were personal crises too – notably the fact that in 1872 his great-aunt Charlotte Masson, who had played a major part in his upbringing and musical training, died, and this had a profound impact on Saint-Saëns’ feelings. The Cello Sonata No 1 in C Minor, Op 32 was one result of this bereavement. It’s a work of turbulence and emotional intensity in three movements, making particular use of the ‘darker’ lower register of the cello, set against a backdrop of often virtuoso piano playing. You can hear from the start of the first movement the strength of feeling in the work. There is some respite in the slow movement, marked ‘Andante Tranquillo Sostenuto’, though even here the middle section generates stronger feeling. The final ‘Allegro Moderato’ movement in particular demands a great deal from the pianist and in some ways it feels like some of the struggle in the piece is actually in the fight of the cello to dominate proceedings. There are flashes of C Major, but we end in the brooding gloom of C Minor: there is no ‘sunlight’ at the end of this journey. There is a notable performance of this work on YouTube by the cellist Steven Isserlis, accompanied (though there’s far more to it than mere ‘accompaniment’) by the pianist Jeremy Denk. You’ll find it here: Saint-Saëns: Cello Sonata No 1 in C Minor, Op 32
Day 244: Symphony No 3 in C Minor, Op 78 (4th movement) (Time: 8 minutes)
The posting for today (26/11/21) is the second marking the (relatively) imminent centenary of the death of Saint-Saëns, actually on 16/12/1921 but addressed now so we have an uninterrupted run of Advent/Christmas music starting next week. Today, the music I’ve chosen is a popular classic and probably one of the more vivid examples of Saint-Saëns letting his hair down. In the first half of his life, Saint-Saëns was particularly attracted to the ‘avant-garde’ composers of the mid-19th century, notably Wagner and his father-in-law Liszt. Liszt’s influence on the development of Western music is occasionally undervalued, I think, perhaps because people are put off by the ‘showman’ figure he cultivated in his early years, but there are two ways in particular in which he influenced huge numbers of composers in the second half of the 19th century. First, in the evolution of the symphonic poem (or ‘tone poem’), an orchestral composition which ‘tells a story’, and which had an impact on composers as diverse as Smetana, Dvorak, Tchaikovsky, Richard Strauss – and Saint-Saëns (think of ‘Danse Macabre’, say). The second way in which we might see Liszt’s fingerprints on the work of later composers is in his exploitation of ‘cyclic’ formal structures in his longer compositions, that is, where a piece is ‘unified’ by recurring themes or motifs, often transformed in the process. You can hear this in the symphonies of Franck, say, and Chausson (both of whom wrote symphonies in precisely this vein in the years after today’s work) … and indeed of Saint-Saëns. Interestingly, it was as he was starting to fall out of love with Wagnerian music, in the later 1880s, that Saint-Saëns produced his most Lisztian symphony, the Symphony No 3 in C Minor, Op 78. Liszt, who had described Saint-Saëns as ‘the greatest organist in the world’, died two months after the symphony’s premiere in 1886, and Saint-Saëns dedicated the work to his memory. The most obvious debt to Liszt in the work is its use of thematic transformation, where key themes are employed across all four movements (though as the first two movements are linked together, and the finale follows the third movement after only a brief pause, the symphony is often described as being in two large sections), but these are developed and manipulated in a process of gradual evolution. The piece is vividly orchestrated, with a prominent part in two of its four movements for organ, but also with parts for piano (four hands) and colourful percussion. One of the ways in which this occasionally rather brash work is given depth is in the fact that its themes have their roots in older musical traditions – echoes of the medieval ‘Dies Irae’ theme, which haunts the music of so many composers, and also of other plainsong melodies. The piece was a triumph at its first performance and has featured prominently in the repertoire of orchestras since (as long as they have access to a sufficiently imposing organ sound to carry the final movement). There isn’t time for the whole symphony, sadly, but I thought a performance of the last movement might be sufficient to bring this brief commemoration of Saint-Saëns’ music to a vibrant and triumphant conclusion. (It’s always possible that you may be familiar with this work from the 1990s film classic ‘Babe’, assuming you had plausible reasons for going to see it – both my daughters were primary school age at the time, which is my excuse!) There are lots of videos on YouTube of the whole symphony, but few just of the last movement. From those, I’ve chosen this recording from the 2013 BBC Proms, given by the Orchestre de Paris, conducted by Paavo Järvi. You’ll find it here: Saint-Saëns: Symphony No 3 in C Minor, Op 78 (4th movement).
Salieri, Antonio (1750–1825)
Day 283: De Profundis Clamavi (Time: 3 minutes)
Today (12/4/22), my choice is of music by a composer new to this list, Antonio Salieri. Salieri (18th August 1750 – 7th May 1825) was an Italian classical composer, conductor, and teacher. He was born in Legnago, south of Verona, in the Republic of Venice, and spent his adult life and career as a subject of the Habsburg monarchy. Salieri was a pivotal figure in the development of late 18th-century opera.
Last month, the choir that I sing with, Escafeld Chorale, performed its long-delayed pre-Easter concert (originally scheduled for March 2020 but derailed for obvious reasons), in which we gave what might be the first Sheffield performance of Salieri’s Requiem, plus a shorter psalm setting by Salieri which is my selection for today. Salieri is famous – or perhaps infamous – these days for his alleged, but almost certainly fictional, involvement in the death of Mozart. Peter Shaffer’s rather hammy but undeniably theatrical 1979 play ‘Amadeus’, and its subsequent film, have established the popular view of Salieri as a jealous nonentity seeking revenge on the divinely-inspired Mozart, slipping him the dose of poison that brought Mozart’s brief life to its premature end. Needless to say, there is no evidence for this. In fact, Salieri was an immensely popular and not negligibly gifted composer, largely of opera (of which he wrote 37 in his lifetime), and a great favourite of the Austrian Emperor Joseph II in the 1780s. He held several prestigious positions at court in Vienna, notably as Kapellmeister of the imperial court chapel and choir school for the final 35 years of his life. One of the nice ironies of the popularity of Shaffer’s play is that it has refocused attention on Salieri as a composer, and there is now a substantial library of his music on disc. Nobody would claim he is the equal of Mozart (who is, except perhaps Bach?), and certainly in singing his Requiem none of us in Escafeld Chorale considered the work to hold a candle to Mozart’s great Requiem. It does, however, have its attractions, and it’s good to be reminded of an example of the very many works being written by very many composers in the later 18th and early 19th centuries in the Austro-Hungarian Empire that, thanks to the enduring popularity of Mozart (and Haydn and Beethoven and Schubert) we just never hear. Alongside the Requiem in our concert last month, Escafeld performed Salieri’s psalm setting ‘De Profundis Clamavi’ (‘Out of the depths have I cried to you, O Lord’). Salieri wrote two versions of the ‘De profundis’ text (Psalm 130: 1-8, to which the traditional ‘Glory be’ is appended), of which the F Minor setting I’ve chosen for today is the later, dating from 1815. The text has a familiar place in almost all Judaeo-Christian liturgies. In the Catholic tradition within which Salieri wrote, it was one of seven ‘penitential psalms’ recited on Fridays during Lent. A rough translation of the text reads as follows: ‘Out of the depths I have cried to you, O Lord. Lord, hear my voice. Let your ears be attentive to the voice of my supplication. If you, O Lord, will mark iniquities: Lord, who shall stand it? For with you there is merciful forgiveness: and by reason of your law, I have waited for you, O Lord. My soul has relied on his word: my soul has hoped in the Lord. From the morning watch even until night, let Israel hope in the Lord. Because with the Lord there is mercy: and with him plentiful redemption. And he shall redeem Israel from all his iniquities. Glory to the Father, and to the Son, and to the Holy Spirit, as it was in the beginning, is now, and ever shall be, world without end. Amen.’ Salieri’s composition is a very simple though remarkably beautiful thing. Over a walking bass part, female and male voices alternate in a chant-like melody, taking one verse of the psalm each in turn. From a pianissimo opening, the volume rises with each new entry, until all parts join together in a fortissimo ‘Amen’. There are a couple of video recordings of this music on YouTube but the performances leave a little to be desired, I think, so for today we’re in audio-only territory. You’ll find the performance by the West German Radio Choir, Cologne, directed by Helmuth Froschauer here: Salieri: De Profundis Clamavi
Satie, Erik (1866-1925)
Day 466: Gymnopedie No 1 (Time: 4 minutes), Gymnopedie No 2 (4 minutes) and Gymnopedie No 3 (4 minutes)
I want to spend today (26/3/24) in the company of one of Western music’s true eccentrics. Sometimes it’s hard to know how seriously to treat Satie – both the man and his music – because he cultivated a deliberate strangeness throughout his life, but he’s a composer I have a lot of time for, and today I can at least plug this particular gap in the playlist’s back catalogue, this being the first time we’ve had any Satie on this list. Erik Satie (1866-1925) – though actually Eric Alfred Leslie Satie at birth; the ‘Erik’ seems to have been a late-teenage affectation that stuck with him for the rest of his life – has a life story that is deliberately mundane on the outside. What was going on on the inside is less clear. He was born in Honfleur in Normandy. His birthplace is now the Satie Museum, and if you’re ever in the vicinity I’d really recommend a visit, because it’s not just a place that documents the events and locations important in his life, but also a place that aims to dramatise them, with its vivid and often bizarre installations. If you were keen on finding childhood trauma to explain later behaviour, there’s some scope here: the son of a French Catholic father and Scottish Anglican mother, the latter dying when Satie was only six; a child passed from father back to grandparents and (after their death) back to father again, who quickly remarried to a woman Satie didn’t like. He was no prodigy, and though he enrolled in the Paris Conservatoire as a teenager, he was summarily kicked out three years later (‘the laziest student in the conservatoire’) and began five years of military service, only to avoid its risks by deliberately contracting bronchitis (standing outside topless on a wet winter night). He made an early living by playing as a cabaret pianist in Montmartre. His personal life seems to have been a cultivated blank: he lived in a bare and basic room, initially in Montmartre and then in another, cheaper, Parisian suburb, and adopted a variety of guises: an early ‘priestly’ phase of robes and crosses; a slightly longer one in which he dressed only in dark velvet suits, of which he owned seven, all identical; and finally and most famously with his umbrella, wing collar and bowler hat, like an anonymous bank clerk. He seems to have had no close personal relationships, apart from a brief liaison with the painter Suzanne Valadon. Even long-term friends (who included Debussy) didn’t get invited back to his flat: a bare, rather squalid room with a huge selection of umbrellas but no furnishings apart from a desk, chair and hammock (the last heated in winter apparently by a selection of bottles filled with hot water that stood underneath it; Stravinsky said it looked like a strange kind of marimba). In his 40th year he went back to music college, studying at the Schola Cantorum in an attempt to become more accomplished in counterpoint and orchestration, but in truth it doesn’t seem to have made a vast difference to the sort of music he composed. He first came to the public’s attention in 1911 when Ravel included some of his early piano works in a recital, and Satie was retrospectively regarded as an influence on early Debussy (or perhaps the other way round). Later, in 1917, his big break came when the impresario Diaghilev arranged for the staging of a ballet, ‘Parade’, a ‘cubist’ work inspired by Cocteau, with music by Satie, featuring some typically iconoclastic touches, like parts in the score for typewriter, siren, ship’s whistle and starting pistol. Towards the end of his life, he was celebrated again as a precursor of the subversive modernity of Poulenc, Milhaud and other members of ‘Les Six’, but in fact Satie fell out with pretty much everyone who had championed his work at some point. His lifelong commitment to heavy drinking may have contributed here, and he died of cirrhosis of the liver, and in poverty (he was never very good with money, spending or giving it away as fast as he earned it) at the age of 59. He had another, posthumous, moment in the spotlight in the 1960s when his music was seen as the precursor of American minimalism, and in more recent times as a kind of proto-ambient music, as acknowledged by the likes of Brian Eno. His compositions are mostly for solo piano. There are some orchestral works, like ‘Parade’, and pieces for voice and piano, like the cabaret song ‘Je Te Veux’ or the ‘symphonic drama’ that he called ‘Socrate’. Satie was fond of giving his pieces silly titles. For instance, there are ‘Three Pieces in the form of a Pear’, a set of seven (of course) piano miniatures, or the ‘True Flabby Preludes (for a Dog)’. Some of this seems to have been catching the fashionable wave of surrealism; some of it presumably helped with the cultivation of deliberate eccentricity. But I want to go back to somewhere close to the very beginning for today’s choice, a set of three pieces which are also, probably, Satie’s most popular works. These are the three ‘Gymnopédies’. The first and third of these were written in 1888, when Satie was just into his twenties. The second came quite a bit later, in 1895, and the three were finally published as a set in 1898. The title is Greek, and appears to refer to an ancient Greek festivity in which young men danced naked. The three pieces are all marked ‘Lent’ (slow) but with an accompanying adjective that announces a very slight shift in mood: thus, ‘Lent et douloureux’, ‘Lent et triste’ and ‘Lent et grave’. There are evident thematic links across the three pieces; in many ways it’s like looking at a sculpture from three different angles. Debussy helped popularise the works by orchestrating the first and third of them. Much later the composer Alexis Roland-Manuel orchestrated the second one. But it’s the piano originals I’m sticking with today. As for a performance, unfortunately YouTube doesn’t have a single link to a video recording of all three pieces, so instead this is coming your way as three separate links. The performances, though, seem to be from the same occasion, and are by the German pianist Olga Scheps. Some pianists play this music as though it’s clockwork machinery, which flattens the life out of it. Others pull the tempo and rhythm about so that no bar seems to last the same duration as the one before or after it, which just seems perverse. Ms Scheps seems to me to come close to getting the right compromise. You’ll find her recordings here: Satie: Gymnopedie No 1; Gymnopedie No 2; Gymnopedie No 3.
I’d like to dedicate today’s music to the memory of my sister Pat, who (as those who’ve been in touch with me will know) died last Friday. This isn’t ‘funereal’ music, I think, but it has a stillness and tranquillity that suit the family mood at the moment.
Day 544: Parade (Time: 15 minutes)
Today (27/6/25) I’m taking my cue from the fact that next Tuesday, 1st July, it will be 100 years to the day since the death of Erik Satie, one of the most unusual and innovative composers there has ever been. Satie has appeared just the once on this list before now (see Day 466, when I featured what are probably Satie’s most popular pieces, the Three Gymnopedies), so his centenary is a good excuse to dig a little deeper and explore some more of his extraordinary music. Back on Day 466, I wrote quite extensively about Satie’s personal history, so I won’t reiterate all that again here. In terms of today’s discussion, I want to pick up Satie’s life story in about 1911, when he was in his mid-40s. At that point, he had had little in the way of meaningful musical success. He was an established ‘bohemian’ figure on the Parisian scene, he played piano in a succession of fashionable (and less fashionable) cafes and bars, he had gone through his ‘priestly’ phase and the rather longer-lived ‘velvet gentleman’ phase, and had adopted the image of the anonymous city clerk, with his bowler hat and umbrella. In more overtly musical areas, he had enrolled (two decades after his failed period at the Paris Conservatoire) at the Schola Cantorum in Paris, where he studied from 1905-12. It’s at this point that his music began to attract a degree of public attention. Early in 1911, Ravel included some music by Satie in a piano recital he gave, and seemingly almost overnight, Satie became a focus of interest for composers a couple of decades younger than himself. The Spanish pianist Ricardo Viñes also performed some of Satie’s work, and music publishers began to request more. The First World War unsurprisingly disrupted much of France’s cultural life, but nevertheless, during those years, some attempt to maintain a pre-war creativity (when Paris had been the epicentre of European culture) continued. At this point in Satie’s story, enter Diaghilev’s ‘Ballets Russes’ and the creative force that was the poet, playwright, designer and all-round ‘influencer’ (as we’d say these days) Jean Cocteau. Cocteau had heard Ravel and Viñes performing Satie, specifically Satie’s ‘Trois morceaux en forme de poire’ (‘Three pieces in the form of a pear’), and wanted to get Diaghilev’s ballet company to perform a ballet to music by Satie … even though Satie had at this stage never written any music for dance. The work that emerged, ‘Parade’, was largely Cocteau’s baby, as it were. He devised its scenario and much of its narrative content, inasmuch as something he evisaged could be said to have a ‘story’. Cocteau described it as ‘A Realist Ballet in One Scene’, and the poet Guillaume Apollinaire provided the programme notes for the first performances, notably describing the action as ‘une sorte de surréalisme’, thus introducing a term that would influence so much art and culture in the decades that followed. The plot of ‘Parade’ is in one sense very simple: outside a fairground, three sets of circus performers put on samples of their acts to try to attract audiences to come inside, to see ‘the real thing’. There’s a Chinese conjurer who does tricks with an egg and tries out a little fire-eating display. There’s a ‘Little American Girl’, who’s a kind of figure out of silent films of the Chaplin/Buster Keaton era, of the sort who boxes, swims, leaps onto moving trains, and so on. She’s very ‘modern’ – and for her Satie composes a kind of ragtime number. Then there are acrobats, whose gymnastics reveal them to be more like sad clowns. Of course, the audience within the action assume that what they’ve just seen is in fact the show itself, and not a ‘parade’ of items they might then see in the show, and push off home, leaving the artistes frustrated. The ballet, given Diaghilev’s status, attracted a range of star names. Picasso designed the sets and many of the costumes (these consisted of large amounts of cardboard that massively restricted the dancers’ movements!); the choreography was by the dancer (and Diaghilev’s latest lover) Massine; meanwhile, Cocteau acted as a kind of overseer, and he seems to have irritated Satie by some of his ideas (like introducing pistol shots and typewriter sounds to the score). The first performance was exactly what Cocteau wanted – a ‘succès de scandale’, not perhaps on the scale of that for Stravinsky’s ‘The Rite of Spring’, but satisfying nonetheless. An amusing footnote: Satie ended up with an eight-day prison sentence, though postponed indefinitely. The reason is that the music critic Jean Poueigh wrote a scathing review, to which Satie responded by sending Poueigh a series of postcards (one said, when translated: ‘Sir and my dear friend – you are an arse, an arse without music! Signed, Erik Satie’); Poueigh sued him. In fact, Cocteau ended up worse off, because he was arrested and beaten up by police for repeatedly yelling ‘Arse!’ in court! Anyway, that’s ‘Parade’ for you, which seems to me to be an entirely suitable vehicle to commemorate the centenary of Satie’s death. Finding a recording on YouTube, however, is more of a challenge. There are plenty of audio-only ones, and some slightly mangled versions rearranged for two pianos, and sadly nothing that involves a performance of the ballet itself with its bizarre staging and choreography. So what I’ve settled for in the end is a video of a concert performance, this one given by the Royal Northern College of Music Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Benjamin Huth. It’s a bit rough and ready in places, but definitely enthusiastic. You’ll find it here: Satie: Parade
Schmidt, Franz (1874-1939)
Day 521: Intermezzo (from 'Notre Dame') (Time: 6 minutes) and Chaconne in D Minor (27 minutes)
Today (20/12/24), we have a new name to add to the roll call of the previous postings: there have been very many ‘150ths’ this year (there must have been something in the water in 1874), but I’d be surprised if Franz Schmidt gets much time in the limelight in the few days of the year that are left to him. Nonetheless, Schmidt (1874-1939) was born on 22nd December 1874, and so it will be his 150th birthday this Sunday. One of the reasons Schmidt tends not to spend much time in the musical foreground is that he was an essentially ‘conservative’ (small ‘c’) composer, and his musical language was not really in fashion during his later years, and almost completely disappeared from concert halls and recording studios during the middle years of the 20th century. There's much more of it available these days, thanks to the ‘completist’ tendencies of some music labels. Another problem Schmidt has, in hindsight, is that if you search for him on t’interweb, he features often as third in the queue of Franz Schmidts, after a medieval executioner and an Austrian serial killer. Not his fault, of course. And finally, to get the problems out of the way, Schmidt is one of those composers whose reputation has been tainted by his brush with Nazism, even though he died before the horrors of the 2nd World War – but that last fact meant that he never got the chance to rebut the accusations or do anything to lift the apparent stain on his music. In the 1930s, the Nazis liked what his music apparently stood for (wholesome post-Brucknerian, slightly grandiose tonal stuff, and not remotely ‘degenerate’), and when they annexed Austria in 1938, they effectively commandeered the premiere of his huge oratorio ‘The Book of the Seven Seals’ that same year. He was commissioned to write a cantata called ‘The German Resurrection’, though he did not complete it, and it wasn’t the focus of his dying efforts in his last year at all. The musicologist Hans Keller, a friend of Schmidt before escaping the Nazis by moving to London, said, ‘Schmidt was never a Nazi. That the Nazis claimed him as one of them and feted him in this sense wasn’t his fault.’ Certainly, figures like Richard Strauss were far more compromised in this sense, and, seemingly, the worst one can think of Schmidt here is that he was rather unworldly and naïve. He was born in what the British knew at the time as Pressburg, but which the local inhabitants knew as Pozony and which the world now knows as Bratislava, the capital of Slovakia. His family roots were in Hungary, though he and his family moved to Vienna when he was a teenager. He studied at the Vienna Conservatory, including for a very brief time with the then frail Bruckner, and by all accounts, he was an exceptionally talented performer on both cello and piano. He took part as a cellist in the first performance of Schoenberg’s ‘Verklärte Nacht’ (see Day 205), for instance, and the famous pianist Leopold Godowsky, when asked who the greatest living pianist was, replied with mock-modesty, ‘the other one is Franz Schmidt’. Schmidt spent almost all his adult life teaching at the conservatory in Vienna, retiring due to ill-health in 1937 and dying just two years later. His domestic life was initially unhappy; his first wife was committed to an asylum in 1919, where she remained until murdered by the Nazis as part of their brutal treatment of the mentally ill in 1943. Schmidt’s only child died during childbirth in 1932. Some consolation was provided by his second marriage in 1923, but the last decade of his life was dogged by illness. As for his music, what I think I’d say most of all is that although it’s conservative for its era (its most obvious forebears are Brahms, Bruckner and Mahler) it’s hardly ever less than interesting and sometimes far more than that. Not a lot gets played these days, though it’s much easier now to get hold of his four symphonies or ‘The Book with Seven Seals’, which sets passages from the Book of Revelation. I wondered about what to choose to mark his anniversary; I really like his symphonies, though each of them is longer than our notional ‘40-minute rule’ will allow us to listen to in full, and I think they’re best listened to whole (treat it as homework, if you want!). So instead, I’ve gone for a bit of early-ish Schmidt, and a bigger piece from his last decade. Schmidt wrote two operas, the first of which was ‘Notre Dame’, based loosely on Victor Hugo’s 1831 novel ‘The Hunchback of Notre-Dame’. Schmidt was around 30 years old when he wrote it, and it was premiered in 1914. It kept its popularity for about a decade and then largely disappeared from view … apart from an orchestral ‘Intermezzo’, which still turns up in the occasional concert. It shows the influence on Schmidt as a young composer of another 19th century strand in music, the attractions of ‘Gypsy music’, such as had been popularised by Brahms (in his Hungarian Dances) and Liszt (in his Hungarian Rhapsodies, and elsewhere). There’s some particularly gutsy writing for the strings in this short piece. There are a few video performances on YouTube, and out of them I’ve chosen this one by the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Paavo Järvi. You’ll find it here: Schmidt: Intermezzo (from 'Notre Dame'). To go with that early work, here’s something much grander (possibly even grandiose) from Schmidt’s later years. This started life as a work for organ, the Chaconne in C# Minor, dating from 1925. If you have any knowledge of the music of Max Reger (and you could always see Day 364 if you’re curious!), then you may feel there’s something Reger-like about Schmidt’s Chaconne. A chaconne is one of those musical forms that became popular in the 16th and 17th centuries, and which was very big during the Baroque era. Very like a passacaglia, it consists of sets of variations over (usually) a fixed bass line. In the 20th century, the form regained its popularity, offering as it does a kind of solid base on which composers could then engage in creative flights of fancy. Schmidt’s Chaconne is a big work, lasting nearly half an hour. Five years or so after the organ version was performed, Schmidt scored it for full orchestra, shifting it up a semitone to D Minor. Whether one feels this work can sustain its length without dragging is, I guess, a matter of taste, but for me it’s inventive, colourfully scored and cumulatively quite rewarding. You won’t find any video recordings on YouTube, but there’s a satisfying audio-only one from the Malmö Symphony Orchestra conducted by Vassily Sinaisky, which you’ll find here: Schmidt: Chaconne in D Minor
Schoeck, Othmar (1886-1957)
Day 494: Sommernacht (Time: 14 minutes)
Today (2/7/24), here is a suggestion from the entirely invisible (as far as this list is concerned) Pete Dutton, for a piece of music – and a composer – who you are pretty much guaranteed to encounter very, very rarely indeed. So let’s redress that imbalance right now! Othmar Schoeck (1886-1957) was a Swiss composer, which in itself makes him something of a rarity. The chances are that if you’ve heard of him at all, it will be because you’re a fan of lieder or, at least, music for the voice. He wrote well over 300 songs, to which one might add five operas, seven other sets of pieces for chorus, and three other stage works for which he wrote songs and incidental music; meanwhile, the whole of the rest of his output – piano pieces, concerti, chamber music and orchestral works – comes to a mere 20 works. His was a life lived largely at the margins of mainstream musical activity. He was born in the resort town of Brunnen, on Lake Lucerne, and was the son of an artist, whose career he was at least initially inclined to follow. But he dropped out of art classes to study music in Zurich, which is effectively where he remained for the rest of his life. During the First World War, he established himself in the city by giving piano lessons, conducting occasional concerts and leading local choirs. The two big influences on his life were the composer Busoni (you won’t have long to wait for him to appear on this list) and the wealthy industrialist Werner Reinhardt, who give the young Schoeck an annual subsidy to allow him to concentrate on composition. Schoeck seems to have been prone to being swayed by the influences of other musicians, especially as a young man, and after Busoni’s impact on him, Schoeck for a while fell under the spell of Honegger and the music of ‘Les Six’ (as heard so often on this list – see entries for Poulenc and Milhaud), and (rather differently) he was also deeply affected by the music of Berg and serialism. Still, even though modernist qualities turned up occasionally in his music, even towards the end of his life he was still, fundamentally, writing in a ‘late Romantic’ style, essentially tonal and really quite lush. The piece by Schoeck that Mr Dutton suggests we listen to is one of only five pieces of orchestral music in Schoeck’s whole output, the tone poem for strings ‘Sommernacht’ (‘Summer Night’), which dates from 1945. Its genesis is quite endearing. At the time, Schoeck was recovering from a recent heart attack and he was not intending to write much at all. However, in 1945 his then 12-year-old daughter Gisela came home from school full of excitement about a poem she had been introduced to in her class, by the poet Gottfried Keller. This was ‘Sommernacht’. To give you a flavour, here is a (slightly twee) translation of part of it: ‘There is a custom fair and old/ In my own home in valleys green:/ When bright the summer starlight’s gold,/ When through the bushes fireflies sheen,/ Why, then a whisp’ring, waving gay/ Draws near the ripened field by night,/ And through the golden crops there sway/ The sickles, gleaming silver-bright.’ Receiving at about this time a request for a work for string orchestra from a music society in Berne, Schoeck set to and produced ‘Sommernacht’, one of the most beautiful, if perhaps naively optimistic, pieces of the era. Schoeck endeavours to depict Keller’s poetic imagery in musical terms. It’s an often stated comparison, but if you’re aware of the ‘Forest Murmurs’ interlude from Wagner’s opera ‘Siegfried’, then you’ll know the sort of thing to anticipate. In the liner notes to a CD of this music that I’ve come across the Schoeck biographer Chris Walton writes: ‘The poem tells of an ancient custom according to which the young men of a village help harvest the field of a widow or orphans who are unable to do the work themselves. Keller’s visual imagery—the shimmering fireflies, the silvery glittering of the scythes—was transformed by Schoeck into aural experiences. Thus we hear the chirping of crickets, the ‘happy cries’ of the peasants, the strains of the accordion, and the birdsong of the early morning... The arrival and departure of the country folk in the fields also provide Schoeck with the opportunity to tell his tale in a three-part form with a neat recapitulation. The musical language of Sommernacht is thoroughly tonal. On the whole, it seems to endeavour to evoke a pristine, untouched, ideal world, far-removed from the horrors that had only just come to an end across the Swiss border. There may be orphans and widows in this work, but here they have happy, grateful peasant friends to stand by them. No one is left to suffer alone; loss finds its compensation; and no one questions his place in the scheme of things.’ Schoeck’s ‘pastoral intermezzo’, as he called it, doesn’t turn up all that often in the concert hall, and not much more often in recordings. However, YouTube gives us some options, and from them I’ve chosen this video recording by the Swiss-based and palindromically-named Camerata Ataremac, a flexible group of up to 16 string players who perform without a conductor. You’ll find their performance of Schoeck’s work here: Schoeck: Sommernacht
Schoenberg, Arnold (1874-1951)
Day 205: Verklärte Nacht (Time: 31 minutes)
Today’s composer, Arnold Schoenberg (1874-1951) died exactly 70 years ago, on 13th July 1951. (He suffered from triskaidekaphobia, which may or may not have contributed to the moment of his death – certainly there is substantial evidence that his deeply embedded fear of all things to do with the number thirteen left him sick, anxious and depressed on the day that he died.) I claimed last week that this week’s anniversary composers hadn’t featured on this list before, which isn’t strictly true, in that back on Day 150, I featured Johann Strauss II’s waltz ‘Roses from the South’ in Schoenberg's chamber arrangement, with its lovely wheezy harmonium in the background. But today (13/7/21) will definitely mark the first of Schoenberg's original compositions on this list. Unless you are a fan of atonality and serialism (and some are, so I’m not assuming that this is toxic to everyone), Schoenberg is not likely to be a composer whose music you listen to a lot. However, whilst much of the work he produced in his maturity is not at all easy to come to terms with, I think we do the man and his art a disservice if we don’t try to understand where he was coming from musically. In any case, the piece I’ve chosen for today, his string sextet ‘Verklärte Nacht’ (‘Transfigured Night’), is a very early composition. It has little in common with the works of his maturity – though there are signs in it of his future direction of travel. Schoenberg was born into a working-class Jewish family in Vienna, and seems to have grown up as a largely self-taught musician, though he had some training with the composer Zemlinsky, who was to become his brother-in-law. He was in his early twenties when he encountered the recently written and rather emotionally intense poem ‘Transfigured Night’ by the German poet Richard Dehmel. The poem describes a man and woman walking through a forest on a moonlit night. She tells him that she is pregnant with another man’s child. He replies that in the bright moonlight ‘Splendour falls on everything around’, and that ‘there is a glow of an inner warmth/ from you in me, from me in you’ … and that ‘that warmth will transfigure the stranger’s child.’ Musically, the outcome was an unusual experiment, a kind of ‘chamber symphonic poem’. Schoenberg’s score falls into five sections, which correspond to the five stanzas of Dehmel’s poem. The music feels like a natural extension of the chromatic expressiveness of Wagner (try comparing it with the Prelude to ‘Tristan and Isolde’ – see Day 88). It’s identifiably in the key of D Minor (we are a long way here from the atonality of Schoenberg’s compositions from ten years later, and even further from the serialism of twenty years later), though lushly scored with complex and often ‘rule-breaking’ harmonies. Polite Viennese musical society was particularly scandalised by the use at one point of an inverted ninth chord (which wasn’t in the text-books and was therefore ‘impossible’) … though polite Viennese society might have also found time to be scandalised by the poem’s (and thus the music’s) failure to criticise, and therefore maybe even to glorify, the act of extra-marital sex. Schoenberg wrote the piece for string sextet: that is, a string quartet with additional parts for a second viola and second cello. In 1917, he produced a version for string orchestra which is often heard today – in those clothes the textures are richer, the harmonic shifts more swooning. However, I love the original, in which you can hear more clearly how the strands of the score interweave, and in which the final section, with its delicate string tracery, depicts the moonlit ‘transfiguration’ in textures which are shimmering and ethereal. On YouTube there is a lovely performance by the wonderful French ensemble, the Quatuor Ebène, with the addition of Arnaud Thorette on viola and Felix Drake on cello. You’ll find it here: Schoenberg: Verklärte Nacht
Day 507: Suite in G for String Orchestra ('In the Old Style') (Time: 32 minutes)
This information might strike fear into the occasional heart, but the subject for Day 507 is none other than Arnold Schoenberg, on account of the fact that he is, in a manner of speaking, 150 years old today (13/9/24)! So, happy birthday, Arnie! Now, there will be those who instinctively recoil at his name, and who regard his music (or ‘music’, as they might have it) as proof of one of the greatest wrong turnings in the history of composition. Some will hold that his work is unlistenable to on principle, that someone who ‘broke’ the structures of Western music and replaced them with chaos or worse ought not to be given house room. Obviously, I credit the more enlightened members of this online community with broader minds and more generous hearts than that. But still… Anyway, I should say at the outset that although I toyed with the idea of presenting you with something scarily indigestible for today’s offering, fear not! The music at the end of this email is benign to the point of being innocuous, but it shows another side to Mr Schoenberg than the fearsome one of stereotype. This list has presented you with just the one truly original composition by Schoenberg (1874-1951) so far (see Day 205 for the completely wonderful string sextet ‘Verklärte Nacht’), though we have heard Schoenberg the arranger on two other occasions: see Day 150 for his delightfully wheezy chamber version of Johann Strauss II’s waltz ‘Roses from the South’ and Day 248 for his arrangement – or more correctly his recomposition – of Michael Praetorius’s beautiful early 18th century carol ‘Es ist ein Ros entsprungen’. The existence of these latter two pieces – and lots else besides in Schoenberg’s output – should be enough to convince us that the man was no radical iconoclast, laying waste to several centuries of musical history, but rather someone who was very conscious of his position in the narrative line of classical music, with an immense respect for what had gone before him. ‘Verklärte Nacht’ is an early piece of Schoenberg, dating from 1899. To fill in a little of his storyline after that date, his compositions in the first 15 years or so of the 20th century became more and more experimental in terms of their treatment of tonality (the sense that music should be in ‘a key’, so that when listening to it we have a sense of where ‘home’ lies) – you could try his song cycle ‘Pierrot Lunaire’ from 1912 as probably the most striking work from this period. A period of writing entirely atonal works followed, but Schoenberg came to see (I’m writing the Ladybird Book of 20th Century Music here) that if anything could be followed by anything, then chaos follows … and so by the early 1920s he’d evolved the concept of serialism (the ‘twelve tone method’) to impose an order on his creations. (Simplistic explanation: there are twelve semitones in a scale in the musical system we have in the west – play all the notes going upwards in order from ‘middle C’ to the next C an octave higher on a piano, and those are your twelve semitones; Schoenberg’s idea was to give each of those notes equal ‘status’ by not using one of them again until he’d used them all for the previous time.) The 1920s were probably his most radical decade, and by 1930 in addition to this, shall we say, rather scary stuff, he was also once more starting to write ‘tonal’ music. Why? There’s no one single answer, but one reason is that alongside his identity as a composer, Schoenberg was also a teacher, and musical education prompted him to produce music that (in theory, anyway) could be played by those learning their craft as performers. Schoenberg fled Germany in 1933 after the rise of the Nazis made it obvious that he had no future there (his music was given that familiar Nazi label ‘degenerate’), making his home in the USA for the rest of his life. The image of him playing tennis with Gershwin on the courts of UCLA, or popping round to the house of his neighbour Shirley Temple, sit oddly alongside his reputation as an ‘enfant terrible’. Although he wasn’t always happy in America (there were well-advanced plans to emigrate to New Zealand before ill-health in the mid-1940s put paid to the idea), he became an American citizen in 1941 and continued to teach at various American institutions until his death ten years later. So, what to choose to mark his big 150th birthday celebrations? Well, when he first arrived in America, he formulated a plan to write something ‘unplayable’. This turned out to be his Violin Concerto, begun in 1934 and completed two years later. If you heard Patricia Kopatchinskaja introducing and playing the work at the BBC Proms earlier this week you’ll know that she said that it was in fact not possible to play some of it unless as a violinist you had six fingers on one hand, so cheating is necessary. But endearingly, in 1934 (and thus precisely contemporary with the Violin Concerto) he also wrote the Suite in G Major for String Orchestra (‘In the Old Style’) – the two could not be more different! The trigger for the suite was a request from a young music professor and amateur double bass player at New York University called Martin Bernstein, who urged Schoenberg to write something for college orchestra musicians to play. Later, Schoenberg explained it this way: ‘I became convinced that every composer – especially every modern composer, and I above all – should be interested in encouraging such efforts. For here, a new spiritual and intellectual basis can be created for art; here, young people can be given the opportunity of learning about new fields of expression and the means suitable for these.’ In fact, he overestimated the capabilities of amateurs, however gifted, but it’s the thought that counts! The work makes more sense if we factor in Schoenberg’s total and unchanging reverence for the music of JS Bach, so the idea of him writing something ‘neo-Baroque’, if you like, isn’t all that weird. Critics and audiences were nevertheless baffled, even though Schoenberg prefaced the score with the comment: ‘This piece indicates no renunciation of my previous creations.’ It’s a work in five movements, taking the same kind of form as Bach’s Orchestral Suites: an ‘Ouverture’ and then a series of dance movements – in this case an Adagio, a Menuet, a Gavotte and a concluding Gigue. By avoiding what Schoenberg himself jokingly called ‘Atonality Poison’, he hoped to introduce young and amateur players to modern 20th century techniques, both in terms of composition and performance practice, in a user-friendly way. It’s worth saying that the first performance, broadcast live on a local LA radio station, generated spectacularly unkind reviews, dismissing the work as the consequence of the ‘Hollywoodisation’ of Schoenberg’s methods as a result of his settling in Los Angeles, though kinder critics saw in it an attempt on Schoenberg’s part to provide a kind of multi-layered link to the past. The piece isn’t often performed these days, but YouTube has at least one capable video recording of the work, by the Houston-based Kinetic Ensemble, and these are the performers you’ll find here: Schoenberg: Suite in G for String Orchestra ('In the Old Style')
Schubert, Franz (1797-1828)
Day 29: String Quintet in C, D956 (2nd movement) (Time: 15 minutes)
Looking back at the previous 28 days’ choices, I’ve been startled to find how many of my favourite composers haven’t featured yet. For me, there are half a dozen composers who stand head and shoulders above the rest. And – well, ok, since you ask – they’re (in alphabetical order, so as not to show bias) Bach, Beethoven, Brahms, Haydn, Mozart and Schubert. Now, so far, Bach has featured three times (soon to be four, as I have a request from Martin in the queue), and Beethoven, Mozart and Haydn once each. So, the absence of Schubert and Brahms from this playlist is something I’m going to remedy in short order, starting right now! So, today (20/4/20) here is the ‘Adagio’ movement from Schubert’s String Quintet in C, D956. This quintet is one of the most profound and moving compositions I know. Schubert more than any other composer can give you consolation in the face of loss in ways which are deeply healing. The slow movement forms the emotional core of the piece. The version I’ve chosen is by a young American ensemble, the Dover String Quartet (augmented by extra cellist Matt Haimovitz). I’ve chosen this particularly because this quartet came to Sheffield to perform in the Crucible Studio in mid-January this year, which seems like half a lifetime ago now! The only drawback is that some entirely inappropriate wild applause has been dubbed onto the end of the performance, which is a shame. You’ll find the performance here: Schubert – String Quintet in C (2nd movement)
Day 49: Fantasie in F Minor, D940, for Piano Four Hands (Time: 19 minutes)
Today (10/5/20), I thought we should revisit Schubert’s perfect sound world, for the second time since this list started. I’ve written before about how Schubert connects with places deep inside us, especially those points where we need consolation in moments of grief or melancholy. I don’t think Schubert is going to make us happy – but I do think he’s wonderful at bringing comfort. Today’s composition is the Fantasie in F Minor, D 940, for piano four hands. In the late 18th and early 19th centuries, most composers wrote music for more than one pianist (either at two pianos or just one) essentially for light entertainment – marches and minuets and German dances and waltzes and so forth. However, in this piece Schubert takes these performing forces into areas of deep introspection, moments of turbulent passion, and finally, yearningly (listen to the last 60 seconds or so, and how reluctant it feels to let go) to resolution. (I’ve also overrun my self-imposed 15 minute rule yet again … but, you know what, I don’t care! Not for music as great as this.) There are lots of legendary performances of this piece, but I’ve gone for the pairing of the incomparable Maria Joao Pires and one of her proteges, the young pianist Julien Brocal. You’ll find their performance here: Schubert – Fantasie in F Minor, D 940, for piano four hands
Day 74: Piano Sonata in A, D959 (2nd movement) (Time: 8 minutes)
Time for some more Schubert – it’s over three weeks since we last had any, which is far too long to wait. I’ve wittered on before and at length about Schubert and the ways in which he communicates so intensely matters which are at the core of what it is to be human – joy and grief, love and death, compassion and despair. His late works (the two piano trios, the last three piano sonatas, the string quintet, the ‘Winterreise’ song cycle, the four-hand piano Fantasie in F Minor) seem to me to be remarkable for the way that they comprehend and communicate the coexistence of these extremes. It’s mostly in the slow movements where this ‘light and shade’ finds its essential expression, and so today (4/6/20) I thought it would be good to listen to the Andantino second movement of the Piano Sonata in A, D959. Structurally, it’s similar to many of Schubert’s slow movements (think back to the extract from the String Quintet on Day 29, for instance), in that apparently serene outer sections enclose a middle section where something more turbulent is expressed. What makes the slow movement of this A Major sonata remarkable, I think, is this: the outer sections aren’t really ‘stable’ at any point, always teetering on the brink of sliding into darker places. And then, in the middle, there’s an explosion of something completely unhinged, a kind of free fantasy of crashing chords and chromatic runs up and down the keyboard. What it all ‘means’ is obviously open to all sorts of interpretation. These last three piano sonatas together seem very aware of death – Schubert knew he was dying of the syphilis he’d contracted some years before, though there’s no evidence I’ve read that suggests that he knew he was just about to die when he wrote them, but they date from the last three or four months of his life. For me, there’s something of a kind of existential terror about the middle section of the movement I’ve chosen. The panic is calmed by the movement’s end, but it’s not erased. That might raise the question of why it matters to listen to music like this. Why not just listen to ‘happy music’ that doesn’t shine its torch into such dark places? Because, surely, this is what life is like (‘in the midst of life, we are in death’, and all that), and this is music that recognises and absorbs that into its texture. Laying my cards on the metaphorical table, I’m an essentially sanguine chap with an ‘all shall be well, and all shall be well, and all manner of things shall be well’ view of the universe (though how is a mystery), and I wouldn’t want to subscribe to a ‘life is suffering’ world view. But suffering is part of life, and to be a follower of Jesus (at however inadequate a distance) is to comprehend that. Golly! Not sure where that lot came from. Anyway, here’s the music. There are lots of great performances around, but my ultimate Schubert interpreter is Alfred Brendel. Here’s his performance: Schubert – Piano Sonata in A, D959 (2nd movement)
Day 85: Impromptu in Gb, D899 No 3 (Time: 7 minutes)
I should state at the outset that today’s (15/6/20) Schubert suggestion has nothing to do with me! Malcolm has suggested that we listen to Krystian Zimerman playing Schubert's Impromptu in Gb, D 899 No 3. Schubert wrote eight Impromptus in the course of his short life, published in two sets of four. The D 899 set was published the year before Schubert died (the other set appeared posthumously). The term ‘Impromptu’ is relatively obscure as a title for a piece of music. Its first recorded use was in 1815, apparently, and the first composer to publish a ‘set’ of impromptus was the Bohemian Jan Vaclav Vorisek (diacritics missing – sorry!) five years before Schubert. (Vorisek was a quite interesting composer, actually; if we’re all still engaged in this activity in a few weeks from now, I’ll aim to schedule some of his piano music one day.) The Gb Impromptu is characteristic of mature Schubert. There’s a long slow unfolding of a song-like theme, underpinned by a rippling accompaniment, in the outer sections of the piece. However, in a way that’s entirely typical of Schubert, there’s a regular harmonic ‘slippage’ into something darker (that ‘sunlight and shade’ quality that makes his music so poignant), particularly in the middle section of the piece, where the emotional intensity rises a few notches. Hopefully (and with apologies to those who find the use of ‘hopefully’ as an initial sentence adverbial to be distressing!), listening to this will make you want to explore the other three pieces in the set. Well worth your time! Meanwhile, here is Krystian Zimerman: Schubert – Impromptu in Gb, D 899 No 3
Day 262: Symphony No 8 in B Minor ('Unfinished') (Time: 27 minutes)
This coming Monday (Jan 31st) will be the 225th anniversary of the birth of Franz Schubert, which seems to me as good a pretext as any for selecting his music as the topic of the posting today (28/1/22). Schubert (1797-1828) has appeared four times on this list, but not for a while (see Days 29, 49, 74 and 85). In those postings I’ve repeatedly (sorry!) made the case for Schubert’s ‘consolatory’ qualities, especially in his later works. However, for today’s composition I want to go back in Schubert’s lifetime to a period about six years before his death. Six years might not seem like a long time, but in terms of Schubert’s prolific output before his cruelly early death at 31, it encompasses huge changes in both Schubert’s compositional style and his maturity. There had been great leaps forward in Schubert’s output before this time. For example, 1815, when Schubert was 18, was his ‘year of song’, when he produced over 140 songs including many of his first masterpieces in the genre; he also wrote nine major works for liturgical performance and what became known as his Symphony No 2. The years 1815-22 were relentlessly fruitful, including what we now number as Symphonies 3-6. However, there are good grounds for saying that in 1822 Schubert took his musical inspiration to even greater heights, and the work that signals this step-change in his oeuvre is the piece I’ve chosen for today, his Symphony No 8 in B Minor, D759, familiarly known as the ‘Unfinished’. First, a word about the label. Composers have failed to finish symphonies for well over 250 years, usually because something (often, though not always, death) gets in the way. In that sense, there are dozens of ‘unfinished symphonies’ out there. Famous ones include Bruckner’s 9th (three full movements and very extensive sketches for a finale), Mahler’s 10th (in a substantial enough sketched format to be completed for performance by Deryck Cooke, and, subsequently, others), and Elgar’s 3rd (now largely accepted into the canon in Anthony Payne’s performing edition). Going a little further off the beaten track, you’ll find unfinished symphonies by the likes of Borodin, Bizet, Tchaikovsky, Moeran and, tantalisingly, Sibelius. So why is Schubert’s 8th ‘the’ Unfinished? It’s not even as though it’s Schubert’s only unfinished symphony: there are several proto-symphonies in D Major from the years 1811-20, existing as a single movement fragment, or sometimes a couple of movements; there’s a Symphony ‘No 7’ in E Major which appears to exist as sketches for all four movements; finally there’s a Symphony ‘No 10’, again in D Major, which exists in three movements for piano score, and which has been completed for performance by the musicologist Brian Newbould (and which I’ve heard at the City Hall before now). And yet … for all of these other compositions, it’s the two movement torso of Schubert’s 8th Symphony to which the label has become permanently attached. Nobody knows precisely why he stopped at two movements (although there are sketches for a piano score of a third movement). One view is that November 1822, when he was orchestrating the first two movements, was precisely the date at which he received the diagnosis of syphilis which was to haunt his final years and ultimately (if not directly in terms of being his literal cause of death) kill him. He gave the manuscript of the first two movements to his friend Anselm Hüttenbrenner in acknowledgement of his election as an honorary member of the Styrian Musical Society. The manuscript remained in Hüttenbrenner’s possession until 1865, long after Schubert’s death, when it was made public, allowing the symphony to be given its first ever performance. The first movement (often played far too slowly, but that’s another story) is tragic in tone, and even the famous second theme doesn’t really offer consolation because it’s interrupted by anguished ‘tremolando’ passages. In contrast, the second movement is largely (though not entirely – this is Schubert, remember) serene. Perhaps this consolatory tone is one reason why, even at only two movements in length, the Unfinished seems somehow ‘finished’. As for a performance, as I noted above, there is a tendency to take the first movement so slowly that the piece often feels as though it is made up of two slow movements, even though the first movement is marked ‘Allegro Moderato’. However, the performance given by the Chamber Orchestra of Europe, conducted by that period instrument specialist Trevor Pinnock, seems convincingly forward-moving to me. You’ll find it here: Schubert: Symphony No 8 in B Minor ('Unfinished')
Day 381: Die Forelle (The Trout), D550 (Time: 2 minutes) and Piano Quintet in A, D667, 'The Trout' (4th movement) (8 minutes)
The current Sheffield Chamber Music Festival ends tomorrow night, and Kathy Stott and Ensemble 360 are playing, amongst other things, Schubert’s Piano Quintet in A, D667 … probably better known as ‘The Trout’. Last time Ms Stott played this work in Sheffield it was in 2005 as one of the farewell performances given by the Lindsay Quartet before their retirement, so it’s splendid to get to hear her play it again. And, as you might have surmised by now, it’s that work which is the subject of the posting today (19/5/23). Or at least, given that there isn’t time to fit in the whole work because of the ’40 minute rule’, I’m going to home in on the fourth movement of the work, which is what gives the whole composition its name. But first, a song. In 1817 Franz Schubert, then aged 20, was already the composer of several hundred songs. 1817 isn’t quite such a prolific year as 1815 had been (when he wrote enough songs to fill eight CDs in my Schubert Complete Song collection!), but it was still very fruitful – approximately 75 songs, including ‘Die Forelle’, or ‘The Trout’. Schubert actually wrote six versions of the song, which don’t in truth differ all that substantially, but do at least suggest it was a song he continued to tinker with to get it into a form that satisfied him. As you may surmise, it’s a song about a trout, and a fisherman who catches it. The text, by Schubert’s near namesake Christian Schubart, was originally a moral tale – its last stanza takes the ‘innocent trout’/’rapacious fisherman’ analogy and becomes a warning to young women to be on their guard against the wiles of young men. Schubert removes this verse, which makes the text less moralising, but also means it becomes a song for a female singer as much as for a male one. The song is headed by the direction ‘Etwas lebhaft’ (or ‘somewhat lively’); how brisk is actually something on which singers diverge. From the fairly scanty records, it would appear that the song was almost immediately popular. Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau comments that ‘the vividness of the imagery, with the alternate troubling and smoothing of the surface of the water along with the exuberance of the melody itself, account for the song's universal appeal.’ It’s performed particularly briskly on this video recording, taken from the Song Prize final of the 2017 Cardiff Singer of the World competition (in which she won the Audience Prize) by Louise Alder, accompanied by an unnamed pianist (I would usually expect Llyr Williams in this context, but it doesn’t look like him). You’ll find it here: Schubert: Die Forelle (The Trout), D550. One of the reasons for inclining to the opinion that the song was an almost immediate hit with the public is the fact that after penning it, Schubert was encouraged to make the song the centrepiece of a chamber music composition. Two years after writing it he was on a walking tour of Upper Austria with his friend the baritone Johann Vogl, an important interpreter of many of Schubert’s songs. The composition he began that summer was a piano quintet, but for a fairly unusual combination – instead of the familiar line-up of a string quartet alongside the piano, the piece uses only one violin, but in addition there is a part for double bass. It seems that the intended dedicatee of the piece was a friend of Vogl, one Sylvester Paumgartner, an amateur cellist, and it was Paumgartner who requested the same instrumental line-up as in the then popular Piano Quintet in Eb by Johann Nepomuk Hummel, which dated from 1802. The work Schubert began in 1819 was finished in Vienna at the end of that year, though like much of Schubert’s work it remained unpublished in his lifetime, appearing in print only in 1829, a year after Schubert’s death. The piece is in five movements, the fourth of which is a set of variations on the earlier song. The theme presented at the outset is then followed by five variations. Unlike, say, Beethoven, whose approach to variation form is to take the theme apart and subject it to all sorts of transformations, Schubert’s treatment here is essentially decorative, adorning the theme (played in each variation by a different instrument or group of instruments) with ornamentation, or changing its harmonies to alter the mood. The whole quintet is an undeniably happy work. Unlike Schubert’s later masterpieces, which lie in the shadow of his diagnosis of syphilis and which are forever flitting in and out of light and shade, ‘The Trout’ is sunny and optimistic – undoubtedly the most popular of Schubert’s works from that more ‘innocent’ time in his life. The fourth movement of ‘The Trout’ is played in this video recording by five members of the Norwegian Chamber Orchestra. You’ll find it here: Schubert: Piano Quintet in A, D667, 'The Trout' (4th movement)
Day 421: String Quartet in G Minor, D173 (1st & 2nd movements) (Time: 14 minutes)
We’ve had quite a bit of Schubert on this list by now – unsurprisingly, given that he’d rank in my top six composers and (as I’m aware I’ve said more than once) he’s my go-to composer if you’re faced with issues of grief or existential melancholy. The archive of pieces by him, six postings in all, has not, until today (17/10/23), featured a string quartet. In previous postings about Schubert, I’ve drawn a lot on the relatively late works (it’s weird to be describing the compositions of someone in his late 20s or early 30s as ‘late’, but as Schubert (1797-1828) lived to be only 31 one’s perspective on ‘lateness’ shifts somewhat), but today’s piece comes from much closer to the other end of Schubert’s creative life. It’s generally agreed that Schubert’s big breakthrough year as a composer was 1815 when he produced (on average!) over 60 bars of music per day! And we should bear in mind that it’s not like he was sitting around just waiting for inspiration to strike. During this year, he was working as a teaching assistant at his father’s school, responsible for the education of the youngest pupils. At least one source I’ve seen suggests that he was working ‘full-time’ in this capacity, though I’ve not been able to find out just what that might have meant. But whatever it was, it seems to have been unmitigated drudgery for the teenage Schubert. Nevertheless, he was also having composition lessons twice a week with Salieri, and playing in the orchestra of the Imperial and Royal Seminary in Vienna, where he started in the second violins but rose rapidly to become the orchestra’s leader. He was also engaged in domestic music-making, playing quartets in the family home at music parties thrown by his father. Add to that the beginnings of his love life, a teenage infatuation with a local soprano, Theresa Grob, and it’s a wonder Schubert had any time left to compose. Yet in 1815 he produced (deep breath…) one and a half symphonies, nine liturgical works for choir and orchestra, including a Mass in G, four short operas, nine works for solo piano, over 160 songs … and a string quartet. By any standards, this is extraordinary – but this isn’t just ‘note spinning’. There are some early masterpieces amongst that lot that have very definitely stood the test of time. As regards exposure to string quartets, the family gatherings I’ve mentioned enabled Schubert to get to know the works of Haydn and Mozart, and to be familiar with the early Beethoven quartets. The quartet in G minor, D173 is catalogued these days as ‘No 9’, though it’s tricky to be sure what this actually means. One of Schubert’s problems, if you like, in these years of teeming creativity, was that lots of pieces got started but were never finished. Before we get to the ninth quartet, his chronological catalogue shows the existence of twenty other works for quartet, though only eight of them might be regarded as properly ‘finished’. This G Minor quartet takes, as its inspiration and starting point, what was documented as Schubert’s favourite symphony at this time: Mozart’s Symphony No 40 in G Minor. Perhaps most strikingly, if you know the opening theme of the last movement of the Mozart symphony, you’ll hear a version of it at the start of this quartet. Other models evident if you do a bit of comparing and contrasting are Beethoven’s quartets Op 18 No 2 and Op 18 No 4. Its composition took Schubert eight days. (In fact, he noted proudly, he completed the opening movement ‘in four and a half hours’!) But even if there are aspects of this work that are a little derivative, there are plenty of things that are recognisably stamped with Schubert’s mature style, notably the unpredictable Schubert changes of key, which alter the mood of what we’re hearing quite dramatically. The whole piece (readily available in full on YouTube should you care to look) lasts rather longer than I can accommodate, given the constraints of the ’40 minute rule’ and the length of the piece I want to share with everyone next time, so my focus now is simply on the first two movements. The opening movement has considerable forward momentum and energy after that initial Mozartian flourish. The second movement is a brilliant illustration of the way Schubert fashions a melody, and then an extended exploration of it, from the most minimal of means – essentially three notes, repeated and extended, so that we either have two notes repeated followed by another one a third higher, or two notes repeated followed by another one an octave higher. It all feels very Mozartian, whilst being recognisably by Schubert at the same time. To quote the musicologist Brian Newbould, in this quartet we find ‘things here that represent the first stirrings of inclinations that were to come to fruition in later works.’ (In the event that you want to hear the whole quartet, there are two further movements, a minuet and a brisk but song-like finale.) In terms of YouTube recordings, if one wants the first two movements only in a video recording, there is, as far as I can see, only one option, a performance by an all-female Polish ensemble called the Monet String Quartet. This recording, performed around a rather intrusive central pole (as opposed to Pole), dates from 2018, but I can’t find any other references to these musicians since. (There appears to be another ‘Monet String Quartet’ now, which bears no resemblance to these four young ladies.) The recording is here: Schubert: String Quartet in G minor, D173 (1st and 2nd movements)
Day 563: String Quartet in D Minor, D810 (Time: 40 minutes)
Today (7/11/25) – and there is surely no debate about this – we have a nailed-on, cast-iron masterpiece, one of the truly great pieces of music of all time. I’m featuring it now because later this month the young Dutch ensemble, the Dudok Quartet, are giving a concert here in Sheffield of five works linked by the theme of death, the last of which is Schubert’s String Quartet in D Minor, D810 … otherwise known as ‘Death and the Maiden’. Mildly digressive autobiographical detail: as you may know from stuff I’ve written for this playlist, I’ve been hooked on what is commonly called ‘classical music’ since the age of about 11, when I came across some of Haydn’s symphonies. Though that’s now well over five decades ago, it wasn’t the case then that I immediately fell in love with all classical music. (That’s still the case, because try as I might I really struggle with opera, or at least all except a very few operas.) Back then, I thought the symphony orchestra was probably man’s greatest invention, and I also loved solo piano music, but for reasons lost in the mists of time, there must have been at least a decade when I’d convinced myself that I ‘didn’t really like’ chamber music. (Mad, I know.) What cured me? Generally, it was coming to Sheffield as a student and hearing the Lindsay Quartet regularly – but specifically it was hearing a performance of Schubert’s ‘Death and the Maiden’ Quartet. It really was one of those ‘road to Damascus’ moments, and after it, my (musical) life was never the same again. If you, dear reader/listener, have not yet encountered this work, then this posting should be a real treat in store. We’ve had seven appearances by Schubert on this list, including extracts from an early string quartet, as well as from two more famous pieces of Schubert chamber music, the ‘Trout’ Piano Quintet and the formidable String Quintet in C. That last piece is, for me, possibly Schubert’s greatest single piece of music … but then I listen once more to ‘Death and the Maiden’, and all I can say is that I’m glad both exist and that we don’t have to choose between them. The story of ‘Death and the Maiden’ began for Schubert in 1817 when he made a song setting of a short dramatic poem by the German writer Matthias Claudius, a conversation, of sorts, between the figure of Death and a dying young woman. She begs Death to leave her (‘I am still young! Go, dear,/ And do not touch me’) but Death’s response is simultaneously horrifying and comforting: ‘I am a friend, and come not to punish …/ Softly shall you sleep in my arms.’ By seven years later, when Schubert was the ripe old age of 24 (and had a mere four years left to live) he had become inescapably aware that his spreading syphilis had an incurable grip on him, and this ‘encounter’ with death took on a deeper, more personal quality. Schubert took the piano accompaniment from the song as the basis for a set of variations, and these form the second of the quartet’s four movements. But what makes the quartet special – and exempts it from the charge often laid at Schubert’s door as a composer, that he never really had a grip on bigger structures, so that his larger works tend to sprawl – is that it grabs the listener by the throat (or any other part of the anatomy you prefer as a metaphor) from the very first bar, and never lets go. There’s a lovely quotation from Einstein in the booklet notes of my CD of this work, in which he says: ‘What distinguishes genius from talent is condensation, which is related to brevity but not identical with it.’ This quartet embodies that condensation consistently, with its density of musical drama. For one thing, nobody had ever written a string quartet before in which all four movements were in a minor key, so that the aural ‘darkness’ shows rarely any chinks of light, apart from the middle section of the third movement. Another dramatic feature is the regular and sudden shift in dynamics from fortissimo to pianissimo, which makes the music’s contrasts even more thrilling. You can hear it, for instance, in the first seven or eight bars of the opening, where a gruff, hammered out initial statement is ‘answered’ by a rhythmically similar but opposite tender response. There are moments of light in that first movement, but for the most part this is a movement of fiery and concentrated drama. In some ways, the sound feels almost ‘orchestral’, even though there are only four string players, and this is because there’s so much double-stopping (where an individual string instrument plays two notes at the same time) and even triple- and quadruple-stopping, so there may only be four players but many more notes being sounded at the same time. The second movement (the one which takes its theme from the piano part of the original song) is a set of variations on that theme, and usually that’s a form that allows composers the chance to ‘decorate’ the chosen material in various interesting ways, although a consequence of this is often that the music relaxes somewhat. In this quartet there are five variations, and if the first two (focusing on the first violin and then the cello) might tempt us to relax a little, the third variation pitches us directly into the ‘Sturm und Drang’ world of German literary romanticism. Then (the only glimpse of a major key here) the fourth variation lets in shafts of sunlight, before the final one tightens the screw again. The third movement is a scherzo, again full of rhythmic power and turbulence. Once more the feeling is of being driven forward relentlessly. Only the ‘trio’ section in the middle of this movement takes its foot off the pedal, but we’ve scarcely started to relax before the scherzo’s dark mood returns. And then we get to the finale. Conventionally, especially after such drama, the last movement might bring light relief, a period of genial relaxation. But in this quartet although this movement is indeed a dance, it’s a dance of death, a tarantella (you probably know that this was in origin a wild dance allegedly to ward off the fatal bite of the tarantula). It’s a rondo in form (that is, built of contrasting sections with one section recurring: ABACA… etc.), so there are major key sections that seem fleetingly comforting before we’re plunged back into the minor key ‘A’ section with its almost vehement aggression. There’s no ‘happy ending’ either. The whirlwind coda hints at one before plunging back into tragic maelstrom of the minor key. Interestingly, at its first (private) performance, the violinist Schuppanzigh (who premiered many of Beethoven’s quartets) apparently said to Schubert, ‘let well alone: stick to your Lieder.’ But then, what did he know? There are quite a lot of really impressive performances of this work on YouTube, so if you don’t like the one I’ve chosen there are plenty of others. But I’ve gone for this concert performance by the Tetzlaff Quartet, which you’ll find here: Schubert: String Quartet in D Minor, D810 ('Death and the Maiden')
Schumann, Clara (1819-96)
Day 43: Piano Concerto (3rd movement) (Time: 11 minutes)
Today (4/5/20), a suggestion from Malcolm, and one that picks up on the issue of the under-representation of female composers that was raised a couple of days ago. So, today’s composer is Clara Schumann (1819-1896), whose reputation has historically been based on two things – she was a pianist whose skills dominated the concert halls of Europe for over six decades, from the late 1820s to her final public concert in 1891; and she was married to Robert Schumann, one of the leading figures in German Romantic music during his (relatively briefer) life, up to his death in 1856. Only in the past few years have Clara's own compositions started to emerge into the public gaze with any regularity. In fact, most of the music she wrote dates from her young adulthood, and she composed nothing other than transcriptions of others’ work (Robert Schumann, Brahms) in the last 40 years of her life. The Piano Concerto in its final form dates from 1835, and she was 15 when she first performed this version. There are now a number of (mostly female) concert pianists who champion this work, and Malcolm suggests listening to Isata Kanneh-Mason (sister of cello-playing Sheku Kanneh-Mason), who in this recording plays the third and final movement of the concerto with the RLPO conducted by Holly Mathieson. You’ll find it here: Clara Schumann – Piano Concerto (3rd movement)
Day 131: Three Romances for Violin and Piano, Op 22 (Time: 10 minutes)
Afternoon, St Tim’s Classical Playlisters, and welcome to another week luxuriating in some of the 19th century’s most charming and vibrant music. (I realise that even phrasing it like that might suggest that there’s not a great deal of grit in this week’s oyster … which is true … but I’m working on the principle that you don’t necessarily want to be challenged every week, and that sometimes sensitively coloured melodies are enough.) Anyway, it’s my intention to illustrate two of the three pieces – the other is a world premiere, about which I can tell you nothing in advance – in Ensemble 360’s pair of concerts on 5th November. So, today we’re in the company of Clara Schumann. Clara Schumann has appeared on this list before (see Day 43, when we focused on the final movement of her Piano Concerto). I noted then that although she dominated the 19th century performance scene as a concert pianist (there are getting on for 1500 concert performances that have been documented), her compositions all date from her early years, and she composed nothing for the last 40 years of her life. The Three Romances for Violin and Piano, Op 22, were composed in 1853, when she was 34, and they are amongst the last of her pieces to be composed before her self-imposed silence. Poignantly, she reflected on her family responsibilities, saying: ‘I once believed that I possessed creative talent, but I have given up this idea; a woman must not desire to compose – there has never yet been one able to do it.’ These Three Romances suggest that she might have been wrong about that. The first of the Romances is a slow, slightly Gypsy-themed piece, which quotes her husband Robert's Violin Sonata No 1, composed a couple of years earlier. The second piece alternates the poignant and the more animated. The final piece is by far the most substantial, with long, flowing lyrical melodies. If one were being uncharitable (which of course one isn’t!) one might characterise these pieces as a rather superior form of salon music. But I think their delicacy and tenderness show what might have been if only she’d carried on composing. There are plenty of performances of these pieces on YouTube, and from them, I’ve chosen this one by Elise Bertrand on violin, accompanied by Julien Hanck on piano. You’ll find it here: Clara Schumann: Three Romances for Violin and Piano, Op 22
Schumann, Robert (1810-56)
Day 44: Konzerstuck for Four Horns and Orchestra (Time: 20 minutes)
So, what’s in store today (5/5/20)? Well, I thought that it would only be fair,
having heard some of Clara Schumann's music yesterday,
to turn the focus onto her husband Robert.
And at this point I have to confess (yet again) to a degree of time-related naughtiness,
for which I hope I’ll be forgiven. There are so many ways into Schumann's
music (lots and lots of short, atmospheric piano works, some wonderful song cycles,
not to mention very characteristic larger orchestral and chamber works) but I’ve
gone for the Konzertstuck (‘Concert Piece’) for Four Horns and Orchestra, because…
Well, because a) it shows off that very Romantic (indeed, very German Romantic)
fascination with the horn as the instrument of drama, the outdoors, the forest, and freedom;
b) it’s one of those splendidly 'over the top' pieces that show Schumann doing something
wholly original – as far as I know, this is the first piece to pit four horn players as soloists against an orchestra;
c) it is a good illustration of Schumann’s style, with all those relentlessly pounding repetitive rhythms.
OK – the ‘rule breaking’ thing is that most recordings of
this piece come in at about 18 minutes, and there are some that are a bit
shorter on YouTube, but I’ve gone for a recording that’s a touch longer still
by the WDR Symphony Orchestra of Cologne, with Heinz Holliger conducting (in his younger days,
probably the most famous oboist in the world), and four soloists, made up from the orchestra’s horn section.
I hope you enjoy it enough to stay with it beyond the 15 minute mark! You’ll find it here:
Robert Schumann – Konzertstuck for Four Horns and Orchestra
Day 234: Symphony No 2 (3rd movement) (Time: 11 minutes)
Robert Schumann (1810-56) has appeared only once before on this list (see Day 44, for the bucolic Konzertstuck for Four Horns and Orchestra). That ebullient work dates from 1849, and was written during what was relatively a mentally stable period for Schumann. His whole life seems to have been a roller-coaster of instability, though explanations for this have varied: there was a period when syphilis was regarded as the cause of his mental and psychological decay, but nowadays the generally accepted reading is that he suffered from bipolar disorder, leading to these extremes of manic and depressive behaviour. It’s also possible that he was poisoned by mercury given as part of his medical treatment. Whatever the cause, Schumann clearly suffered extensively during his relatively short life, and after a failed suicide attempt in 1854 he was committed to an asylum, where he died two years later. Apart from music, the great passion of Schumann's life was his love for Clara Wieck, whom he eventually married in 1840, after a long and acrimonious battle with her father, who refused the match for many years. The period after 1840 was prolific, not just in terms of piano music (Schumann's principal medium for creative expression) but song cycles, chamber music and orchestral works. He wrote his Symphony No 1 in 1841, immediately following it with the work that became his Symphony No 4 (numbered thus because it was revised and published last of all his symphonies). However, in 1844/45 he suffered a mental and physical breakdown, and in that very fragile state began work on what would become his Symphony No 2, a movement from which is the focus for today (22/10/21). This has consistently been the least performed of his four symphonies, though I find it hard to see why. The traditional reputation of Schumann's symphonies has not been positive, but that is largely because they were given heavy-handed treatment by orchestras performing them as if through a thick layer of brown varnish, as though they were the heavily orchestrated works of the late Romantic era rather than like Mendelssohn. It’s only really with the advent of period-instrument performances that they have started to sound crisp, wiry, energetic works full of rhythmic attack. The Symphony No 2 was, said Schumann, ‘a souvenir of a dark period’. The first movement is full of striving for control, the second (a scherzo) feels manic and agitated, and it’s only with the fourth movement Finale (written quite a bit after the first three) that we reach a sort of triumph that feels almost Beethovenian. However before this, the third movement (marked ‘Adagio Espressivo’) offers some kind of solace, with a yearning tenderness that feels to me very like a statement of love (for Clara?). It’s the most beautiful movement in all of Schumann's orchestral works, I think. As for a recording, it would have been nice to go for a period instrument performance, but I can’t find one on YouTube of just this movement. Instead (and it’s not a bad replacement!) here is a live performance by the late Claudio Abbado and his hand-picked Orchestra Mozart in this movement. It’s a bit more lush than I’d like (sometimes it feels a little more like Elgar than Schumann!), but it lingers tenderly on every last moment of yearning. You’ll find it here: Schumann: Symphony No 2 (3rd movement)
Day 455: Kinderszenen, Op 15 (Time: 19 minutes)
We’ve had only two appearances by Schumann on this list to date (the Konzertstuck for Four Horns and Orchestra on Day 44, and the slow movement of his Symphony No 2 on Day 234) so it’s about time today (13/2/24) that we had a substantial example of the sort of output for which Schumann is rightly famed: a work for solo piano. What’s more, a work for solo piano which, like many such examples in his oeuvre, is actually a collection of short pieces with an over-arching, non-musical connecting theme. Schumann was by training a pianist and, until excessive practising gave him a permanent hand injury which put paid to his aim to be one of Europe’s leading pianists in the first half of the 19th century, the expectation was that he’d be a performer more than a composer – or at the very least a ‘composer-performer’ rather than ‘just’ a composer. As it turned out, the great advocate for his music in performance turned out to be his wife Clara, whose own work has also featured twice on this list. Robert and Clara’s is one of the great musical/cultural love stories of the 19th century, and in the 1830s, during what must have seemed an interminable stretch of time before their marriage in 1840, during which time Clara’s father had forbidden the marriage, Schumann wrote almost exclusively for the piano. Into the pieces he wrote then he poured not just his love for Clara but also revealed (to her and the wider world) the nature of the composer he would become. The uncharitable might see this composer as too ‘heart on sleeve’, too keen to be immersed in the world of the imagination, and to see this as more potent than, as it were, ‘real life’. I don’t take that view myself, though I know it’s out there. Rather, I’d see Schumann as the archetypal composer of the Romantic era, someone who invested his compositions with all the hallmarks of German romanticism: a life of sensations, an immersion in the world of dreams, a child-like (most definitely not ‘childish’) embrace of life, a love of landscape and particularly of the forest, a desire to see himself as one of a league of artists battling against the ‘philistines’. He’s a mercurial composer, I think, one who functioned best in small-scale forms (there are legitimate objections, I accept, to the often repetitive structures in his larger scale works, like his piano sonatas or symphonies), where the pieces conjure a mood or an emotion … and then move on. The idea of ‘the child’ as uniquely, potently innocent is one of Romanticism’s touchstones in all the arts. It replaced, if you like, the previous, 18th century view that the child was a small adult. Schumann once wrote in his diary: ‘In man, there resides a tender genius that gently opens up gateways to new worlds and creations for the eternal child, and that, unnoticed and as if by chance, leads the youth in his first love to the blossoming spring with his beloved, uniting and revealing to each other their dreams.’ This sense of ‘the eternal child’, and the importance of keeping alive the eternal child in each of us as adults, was vital to Schumann. When he wrote ‘Kinderszenen’ he commented to Clara, in relation to the title: ‘Perhaps it was an echo of what you once said to me, that “Sometimes I seemed like a child” … You will enjoy them—though you will have to forget you are a virtuoso.’. That last comment is certainly true of this set of thirteen little character pieces. They are, by and large, easy to play … though not necessarily easy to catch the spirit of. He later described them as ‘reminiscences for those who have grown up’ – but also as pieces written with the needs of young players in mind. Clara, by the way, loved them: ‘It’s true, isn’t it, that they belong only to the two of us? They are so simple, so heart-warming, so very much you’, she wrote to him. In fact, as so often with Schumann, the music came first, and the titles for the different pieces came later, acting like a kind of ‘signpost’ to the character of each of the snapshots. Schumann actually wrote 30 pieces in this vein at the time. Some of them appeared subsequently in other works: the ‘Bunte Blätter’, Op 99 (literally, in English, ‘colourful leaves’ – leaves in the sense of an ‘album leaf’, or short sketched comment or observation) and the ‘Albumblätter’, Op 124, which also contained his offcuts from his extensive collection of pieces in the ‘Album for the Young’, Op 68. I hope you can see from this how central the idea of the child, and nurturing the child in us, was to Schumann’s imagination. Of the thirteen pieces in ‘Kinderszenen’, by far the most well-known is the central movement, placed at the core of the cycle, ‘Träumerei’ (‘Dreaming’). It’s (almost) every pianist’s favourite encore piece. The titles of the rest of the pieces sketch out a world of childhood fantasy: ‘Blind Man’s Buff’, ‘Knight of the Hobby-horse’, ‘Child Falling Asleep’ and so on. The final movement, though, is ‘Der Dichter spricht’ (‘The Poet Speaks’), in which, if you want to see it this way, Schumann ‘breaks the fourth wall’ of this fantasy world and addresses us, his listeners, directly. It puts me in mind of Wordsworth (hope that’s not too pretentious) and his observation ‘the child is father to the man’. These pieces are tender and intimate, hardly ever raising their voice above ‘piano’ and almost artlessly naïve. As for a performance, it’s going to be a matter of taste, I imagine, so if you don’t fancy the version I’ve gone for it’s easy enough to find others on YouTube. Considering video performances only, you can watch the 84-year-old Vladimir Horowitz bringing all his experience to this innocence, which for me is preferable to Martha Argerich trying to keep her inner virtuoso under control. There’s an ‘artless’ video performance by the young American pianist Tiffany Poon. But in the end I’ve gone for a recording by the Russian pianist Nikolai Lugansky, which seems to me to be a restrained but not ‘buttoned down’ performance. You’ll find it here: Schumann: Kinderszenen, Op 15
Day 517: Fantasie in C, Op 17 (Time: 30 minutes)
My choice of posting for today (22/11/24) is Schumann’s Fantasie in C, Op 17. We’ve had three pieces by Schumann on this list already – see Day 44 for the Konzertstuck for Four Horns and Orchestra, Day 234 for the slow movement of his Symphony No 2, and Day 455 for his piano suite Kinderszenen. In my previous writing about Schumann I’ve explored the familiar issues that shaped his life’s work: his abiding love for his (eventual) wife Clara, his almost obsessive focus on piano music (and small-scale forms within that oeuvre), and his unstable mental health, the last of these leading, as is well known, to his long periods of depression (bipolarity seems the issue, but exacerbated apparently by the effects of syphilis), his traumatic suicide attempt, and his final two years spent in a mental institution before his death in 1856 at the age of 46. As I’ve just mentioned, most of Schumann’s piano publications consist of collections of short items under a usually ‘poetic’ title – famous sets include not just my previously chosen Kinderszenen (‘Scenes from Childhood’), Op 15, but others such as Carnaval, Op 9, the Davidsbundlertanze (‘Dances of the League of David’), Op 6 and Kreisleriana, Op 16. It’s true that he did write some bigger works in seemingly conventional genres – there are two piano sonatas, for instance. But the Fantasie in C, Op 17 is an unusual work, an ‘almost’ sonata, with a complicated but revealing back-story. The work seems to have been triggered in 1836 by Schumann’s separation at that time from Clara (who was, as a then 17-year-old, being kept strictly apart from Schumann by her apparent ogre of a father), which led Schumann to write a short piano piece for her called ‘Ruins’. A version of this piece eventually emerged as the first movement of the Fantasie. But as well as this ‘private’ inspiration, if you like, there was a public prompt for the work too. This was a scheme, organised by Liszt amongst others, to raise funds for a commemorative statue to Beethoven, to be erected in Bonn (Beethoven’s birthplace), originally to mark what would have been Beethoven’s 65th birthday in 1835, though the project overran. Schumann conceived the idea of a ‘Grand Sonata for Pianoforte’ as his contribution to the scheme, since profits from the sale of his piece were to be donated to the fundraising appeal. At this point, the three-movement work had the titles ‘Ruins’, ‘Trophies’ and ‘Palms’ – all very grandly public and ceremonial. Over time (and this is entirely consistent with the way Schumann worked) the titles of the movements changed (‘Ruins’, ‘Triumphal Arch’ and ‘Constellation’), before disappearing altogether. By the time the work was eventually published in 1839 it had the much less showy title ‘Fantasie’, and the individual movement titles are more concerned with addressing how the work should be played: the first movement is ‘Quite fantastic and passionately delivered; In the tone of a legend’; the second is ‘Moderate. Quite energetic’; and the third is ‘Taken slowly. Keep quiet throughout’. One curious thing about this structure is that, unlike traditional three-movement sonata-style pieces which are generally arranged in a fast-slow-fast pattern, Schumann’s Fantasie is structured fast-fast-slow. This focus on a slower, ‘inward’ final movement bears some similarity to Beethoven’s late piano works, which often end in stillness. But whether or not we see Schumann’s Fantasie as a ‘public-facing’ work, the ties that bound him to Clara remain part of the piece’s intention, and its details. The work is prefaced by a quotation from the poet and philosopher Schlegel, which (broadly translated) reads: ‘Resounding through all the notes/ In the earth's colourful dream/ There sounds a faint long-drawn note/ For the one who listens in secret.’ Now, this ‘one who listens in secret’ was, inevitably, Clara. Schumann quotes a phrase from a song by Beethoven, from his cycle ‘An die ferne Geliebte’ (‘To the distant beloved’), towards the end of the first movement of the Fantasie, making it more evident that Clara was this ‘distant beloved’ by writing her a letter in which he described the Fantasie as the most passionate thing he had written to that date, and that Clara’s spirit inhabited every bar. The first movement is intense and tempestuous, with many sharp changes of mood. The second is a march, and one of the most heroic things Schumann ever wrote. Its closing passages contain some rather challenging leaps for the pianist to encounter. But then the finale is utterly different in character: still, tranquil, occasionally (but always restrainedly) anguished before finally achieving a serenity and peace that are almost transcendent. Interestingly, Clara (herself a great pianist) never played it in public in Schumann’s lifetime, and Liszt, to whom it was dedicated, never played it in public at all; it really didn’t become a major part of the romantic repertoire until the very end of the 19th century.. For me, it’s one of the greatest works Schumann wrote for piano, and one of the greatest pieces of the Romantic era. There are quite a few decent video performances of this piece on YouTube, and from them I’ve gone for one that, at the very least, looks the part. This is the Russian virtuoso Daniil Trifonov in authentic ‘wild man’ guise, but underneath that ‘why doesn’t he just get a haircut?’ exterior, he is a really fine pianist, especially in the Romantic repertoire. The link to his performance of Schumann’s Fantasie in C, Op 17 is here: Schumann: Fantasie in C, Op 17
Day 583: String Quartet Op 41 No 3 (Time: 31 minutes)
Today (27/3/26), my composer is Robert Schumann, and the reason for my choice is that imminently the Fibonacci Quartet, who have been accumulating prizes all across Europe in the past three or four years, are playing here in Sheffield – a concert that includes this Schumann quartet. Although Schumann gets a reasonable amount of exposure in concerts and broadcasts, this tends to be mostly either piano music or orchestral works. His three string quartets hardly get a look in, which is a state I intend to remedy right now. So, Schumann has appeared four times on this list already, looking at two of his major piano works, plus a movement from one of his symphonies and the vigorously bucolic Konzertstuck for Four Horns and Orchestra. However, the absence of any chamber music is another reason for exploring some today. Schumann’s character, a topic harder to separate from his compositions than is the case with almost all other composers, was one of extremes. There’s evidence of what today we might call ‘bipolar’ characteristics (mood swings so extreme that Schumann had his own names – Florestan and Eusebius – for these two ‘sides’ of his character), and also of a temperamental obsessiveness that meant that he often got ‘hooked’ on a particular musical idea, which he then pursued relentlessly. You can see some of this obsession in things like the fact that 1840 was his ‘year of song’ – he wrote over 150 of them in that year – and 1841 was his ‘year of orchestral music’. 1842 became his ‘year of chamber music’, of which he’d written almost nothing up to that point. But in 1842 he wrote his only string quartets (there are three of them), his piano quartet, his piano quintet and a set of fantasy pieces for piano trio. In 1842 his emotional state was ambivalent. He was blissfully happy at being married, at long last, to Clara, but in the early part of the year he also struggled a little with being ‘second fiddle’ in the relationship, accompanying Clara, world-famous concert pianist, on her latest tour around Europe – plenty of ‘And what do you do, Mr Schumann?’ moments. Returning home alone while Clara finished the final legs of her tour, he began to have what he described as ‘quartet-ish thoughts’, and returned to a previous study of the quartets of Haydn, Mozart and especially Beethoven. Then, in the summer of 1842, in the space of about three weeks (obsessive focus or what?) he wrote all three of his string quartets. The one I’m going to focus on, the A Major, Op 41 No 3, seems to have been completed in less than a week! There’s plenty of evidence that Schumann in fact saw the three quartets as a cycle, giving them linked themes and key relationships, and indeed writing short ‘transitional’ segments of music to join the quartets together into one continuous performance. They very rarely get played in the same concert, however, and in fact it’s quite a novelty to find one of them in concert at all. His String Quartet No 3 is the sunniest of the three, and it has some quirky and unusual features. The first movement starts with a tender, falling two-note figure – plenty of evidence here that he saw this as a ‘Clara’ motif – and that downward interval comes to dominate not just this ‘Andante espressivo’ slow introduction, but much of the whole piece. Interestingly, for someone whose piano music is often wildly romantic and given to flights of fancy, this quartet (like the other two) is remarkably concise and almost ‘classically’ structured – the result of his prefatory study of the work of his great predecessors. The movement isn’t monothematic, but pretty much all the material comes back to this sighing figure with which the movement started, and with which it finishes. The second movement, a theme and variations, is especially curious, because it’s only really with the third of the four variations that we get to what you might see as a statement of the actual theme itself. The opening of the movement, where we might expect to hear the theme, is instead given to a kind of shadowy, half-remembered version of it, almost like a singer gasping for breath. Another oddity of the movement is that we hardly ever know where the ‘down beat’ is – much of the time what we think is the down beat is actually an up beat. After it there’s another variation, full of churning forward momentum, and then a very curious coda which, in one discussion I’ve read, is described as ‘wandering like a sleepwalker through various keys before settling to a standstill.’ The emotional core of the work is the ‘Adagio molto’ third movement. To quote again from the analysis I’ve come across, it’s part hymn, part declaration of love, but – Schumann being Schumann – there’s then a central section which feels much more nightmarish, with the initially consoling theme subjected to troubling transformation. One might see the movement’s conclusion as the reassertion of stability, but darker undercurrents remain. The last movement is a rondo – actually a ‘double rondo’, in that there are two ‘A’ sections which find themselves interspersed with contrasting ‘B’ and ‘C’ sections. Like the second movement, this finale leaves you guessing throughout as to where the first beat of the bar is, and like the first movement this last one begins with exactly the same chord, though transformed by its different context. The quartet ends more or less jubilantly – more or less because even in the whirling coda it’s still hard to know where the down beat comes to mark the start of each bar until we get right to the very end of the work. Looking back over the quartet as a whole, you could say that Florestan (the ‘sunny’ side of Schumann’s identity) wins the day … but only just. As I’ve suggested, Schumann’s quartets don’t get out much, but on YouTube there’s a lovely performance by the wonderful Quatuor Ebène, which you’ll find here: Schumann: String Quartet Op 41 No 3
Schutz, Heinrich (1585-1672)
Deutsches Magnificat, SWV 494 (Time: 8 minutes)
Today (4/11/22), we’re commemorating the 350th anniversary of the death of probably the most notable German composer before Bach, Heinrich Schutz. Schutz is a new name on this list. If I had to make a confession on this score, it would be that for me the music of composers who lived pretty much entirely during the 17th century is, with a few exceptions (Purcell, Biber, Louis Couperin, Corelli, Pachelbel, M de St Colombe) something of a closed book – there’s a gap in my musical experiences between Renaissance polyphony of the sort that fell out of fashion in the 1620s and 30s, and 18th century Baroque music of people like Bach, Vivaldi, Handel and Telemann. Schutz is one of the figures that bridges the gap, if you like, between Renaissance and Baroque music – between (and I realise this is very much a ‘Ladybird Book of the History of Music’ explanation) polyphonic music, in which several lines of music run simultaneously in harmonies which are essentially modal, and the more ‘chordal’ style of the Baroque, in which major/minor key harmony (which is read ‘vertically’) was foundational. [If that made no sense, feel free to ignore it!] Anyway, the point about Schutz is that at the start of his career, he was writing music that evidently took early 17th century Venetian composers like Gabrieli and Monteverdi as style models, but by the end his music, very definitely pointed the way towards JS Bach. It helped, of course, that Schutz lived for, by 17th century standards, a long time. Born in Köstritz in central Germany in 1585, his singing brought him to the attention of the local nobility, and after time as a choirboy in Kassel, he went to Venice in his twenties to study with Gabrieli. After that, almost all of the rest of his life was based in Dresden, though he left and returned several times (European wars had a lot to do with that!) during the decades from 1615 until his death at the age of 87 in 1672. Aside from his skills as a composer, Schutz is one of the famous names associated with the history of that ancient and renowned orchestra, the Staatskapelle Dresden. Schutz was by all accounts a prolific composer, but although we have about 500 or so compositions of his that survive today, apparently several times more than that have been lost, so that what remains is almost exclusively music for the church. (One particularly sad loss is ‘Die Dafne’, seemingly the first opera to be written in German.) I wondered how best to illustrate the contribution of this transitional figure in the history of German music, someone who, for instance, wrote three settings of the Passion that are generally considered the best of their kind before Bach, a setting of the ‘Christmas Story’, and another of the ‘Seven Last Words on the Cross’. In the end, I’ve settled for a short piece from Schutz’s final years. His last publication during his lifetime was his ‘Opus Ultimum’ of 1671, a collection which has acquired the rather Schubertian nickname ‘Schwanengesang’ (‘Swan Song’). The main pieces in this collection are settings of verses from Psalm 119, along with an earlier setting of Psalm 100, but appended to these, as the final piece in this final collection, is a setting of the Magnificat. It’s written for two four-part choirs, with an organ and instrumental accompaniment, and it’s in a single movement. Schutz set the words of the Magnificat six times (once in Latin, five times in German) but two of the German versions have been lost; the composition that ends his ‘Opus Ultimum’ is the last of the four remaining German settings. One of the interesting features of this composition is the way it alternates between two ‘beats’ to the bar and three. (Terminology nerds might want to know that this 3:2 ratio, where three beats of equal value occupy the time usually taken by two, is known as a hemiola. Fascinating…) It’s not in any way a ‘showy’ treatment of Mary’s hymn of praise, but rather a somewhat sober but quietly assured statement of faith, culminating in a restrained and simple ‘Amen’. It may be of no interest to you at all to know that this is the only bit of Schutz I’ve ever sung, being, as it is, challenging but not beyond the competence of an amateur choir. That experience is the other reason why I’ve selected this piece for today: to hear it sung by a professional ensemble! YouTube has several versions of this piece in its archives, but working on the principle that most folks on this list would prefer a video recording if possible, I’ve selected this one by the Spanish choir El León de Oro, directed in this recording by Marco Antonio García de Paz. You’ll find it here: Schutz: Deutsches Magnificat, SWV 494
Schytte, Ludwig (1848-1909)
Day 419: Piano Concerto in C# minor, Op 28 (1st movement) (Time: 12 minutes)
Today (10/10/23), I want to take the opportunity to have one last look back to earlier in this year, and to mark, belatedly, another anniversary of a composer’s birth that got squeezed out back in April by competition from other things. For many (maybe all) of you, the name Ludvig Schytte may be completely new. To get the obvious out of the way first, I didn’t choose to mark the 175th anniversary of this composer’s birth simply because those with a schoolboy sense of humour might be amused by his surname. In fact, it has two syllables, and (the interweb reliably informs me) is pronounced approximately ‘shete’, where the first ‘e’ is the same sound as in the middle of ‘bed’, and the second ‘e’ is the sound you make at the end of the word ‘the’ in its unstressed form. There – hope that’s cleared that up. Anyway, Ludvig Schytte (1848-1909) was a Danish composer, though as he spent the vast majority of his adult years in Berlin and Vienna he’s only tenuously regarded as ‘Danish’ by the Danes. He was born in Aarhus, Denmark, to poor if musical parents. His initial training was as a chemist. However, the pull of music was stronger than making a living as a pharmacist, and in his early adult years he worked as a music teacher in Copenhagen. He wrote about this rather sweetly in the early 20th century, for an American magazine (hence the reference to US dollars): ‘My parents were poor, and when I was about sixteen years old, and had passed my school examinations with great success, I entered the employ of an apothecary as a student. At this time my love for music grew so strongly, and since a local musical authority expressed in the warmest words his astonishment that I, without knowing the notes, and without any instruction, only “by ear,” could play correctly the whole Scherzo (opus 31) of Chopin, I concluded to say adieu to pills and salves, and went, with the sum of $250, which I had saved from my salary, to Copenhagen to study music.’ The decisive moves in his career were influenced by Liszt with whom Schytte studied in the mid-1880s in the final two years of Liszt’s life. If we realise that at this point Schytte was already in his mid-30s, it’s evident that he was no child prodigy. What he definitely was, though, was an impressive pianist, even if initially he was lacking in confidence as a composer. However, his studies with Liszt at least made possible a first performance of the work I’m going to feature today, Schytte’s only Piano Concerto. Schytte subsequently wrote about this period: ‘in 1883, I went to Weimar to Liszt, from whom I had a most gracious reception. Liszt arranged that my concerto, opus 28, should be played for the first time at a music festival in Karlsruhe, and showed himself an interested patron up to the time of his death.’ In 1886 Schytte moved to Vienna, where he taught at a couple of music schools, and in 1907 he moved to Berlin where he was appointed associate professor at Sterns Music Conservatory, only to die two years later. In the last couple of decades of his life he developed a considerable reputation as a performer, but if he is remembered at all these days (except for having a comedy name, for English speakers anyway) it is as a pedagogue: his ’45 Sonatinas and Execution Pieces’ seems to be a staple compendium of works for budding pianists in Scandinavia even today. Most of Schytte’s output consists of short piano pieces, clearly influenced by the works of Schumann, though there are also a couple of operas which get the (very) occasional revival. However, apart from a large-scale piano sonata, the only work to get noticed (I use the term loosely) these days is his Piano Concerto in C# Minor, Op 28. As I mentioned above, this is a product of his years of study with Liszt, and it’s evidently a concerto in the ‘grand romantic’ style, with lots of keyboard flourishes and really only a minor role for the orchestra. (There are traces of Chopin’s concertos in this respect.) The whole work is almost half an hour long, so I’m going to focus only on the first movement, a stormy and impassioned Allegro. The liner note for the CD I have of this concerto (I know, I have some very obscure CDs) says, truthfully, ‘It is not possible to speak of any highly personal style,’ but then qualifies this by adding (again truthfully, I think) ‘but the melodic inspiration encountered here is by no means poor and, as might be expected, the piano writing is extremely elegantly crafted.’ In all of that, there is, I realise, a certain amount of damning with faint praise, and in truth, this concerto isn’t likely to be anyone’s absolute favourite. But it’s a good example of a kind of solid Championship level of compositional skill (to use a football analogy), greeted warmly in its day, and worth at least the odd outing in ours. The performance I’ve chosen is by the musicians on the CD I own, Oleg Marshev on piano, accompanied by the Aalborg Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Matthias Aeschbacher. You will be unsurprised to note that this is an audio-only recording. You’ll find it here: Piano Concerto in C# Minor, Op 28 (1st movement)
Scriabin, Alexander (1872-1915)
Day 211: Prelude Op 9 No 1, for Left Hand (Time: 3 minutes) and Nocturne Op 9 No 2, for Left Hand (6 minutes)
Today (3/8/21), the composer – for the first time on this list – is Alexander Scriabin (1872-1915). Scriabin is a fascinating composer… and also a very fascinating (you could replace this with other adjectives of your choice) human being. Musically, he starts off sounding like Chopin and ends up somewhere between Schoenberg and Richard Strauss. He was born in Moscow to musical parents, and became an evident whizz-kid on the piano at an early age. He studied at the Moscow Conservatory, where (more on this later) he injured his right hand practising. In the early years of the 20th century, he travelled widely, before returning to Russia, where he lived out the last six years of his relatively short life. The most striking thing about his work is the extent to which his evolving belief system shaped his musical composition. He was heavily into theosophy, and a devotee of Mme Blavatsky. He seems to have been synaesthetic (that is, where one sense shapes responses in another): in Scriabin’s case, he ‘saw’ music in terms of colours, as well as hearing it in terms of sounds, and he evolved a grand and complex compositional framework based on this. To his devotees, he was ‘the one great pioneer of the new music of a re-born Western civilisation.’ To his detractors, he was ‘a sad pathological case, erotic and egotistic to the point of mania.’ The ‘Great Soviet Encyclopedia’ entry on Scriabin sums it up pretty well: ‘no composer has had more scorn heaped on him or greater love bestowed.’ The work Malcolm points us to today comes from early on in Scriabin’s career. As I’ve mentioned, he was for a time a student at the Moscow Conservatory, pretty much contemporary with Rachmaninov and other virtuoso pianists such as Josef Hofmann. The competitive urge being strong, Scriabin practised the piano (notably the phenomenally difficult piano piece ‘Islamey’ by Balakirev, and Liszt’s ‘Reminiscences de Don Juan’), to the point where his right hand became so damaged that for a time it was thought that the injury was permanent. During his convalescence, Scriabin wrote his only works for solo left hand, the Two Pieces for Left Hand, Op 9. Even here, he seems to have had a point to prove, the Nocturne Op 9 No 2 being an extreme challenge. It’s pretty clear that at this stage in his life – 1894 – Chopin was still a significant influence on his musical language, which is evident in the Prelude Op 9 No 1 in particular, though there are clear pointers to the mature Scriabin to come. The two works ‘belong together’ (in the sense that they are both written for the left hand alone) in ways that aren’t always true about the ‘bundling’ of works under other opus numbers, where we often get very diverse collections of pieces which are not intended to be played as a set. This is definitely music to be watched as well as listened to, in order to get the sense of how challenging it is to play the piano with one hand only. Unfortunately, on YouTube, I haven't been able to find a performance which includes both pieces, so what you have here are two separate links. First, a performance of the Prelude Op 9 No 1 played by Yuja Wang, which you’ll find here: Scriabin: Prelude Op 9 No 1 (for left hand alone). Then there’s a relatively ancient but still remarkable performance of the Nocturne Op 9 No 2, played by Alexis Weissenberg, which you’ll find here: Scriabin: Nocturne Op 9 No 2 (for left hand alone)
Day 256: The Poem of Ecstasy (Time: 21 minutes)
Today (7/1/22), a belated 150th birthday greeting. Alexander Scriabin was born in Moscow on 6th January, 1872 – working on the basis of the Gregorian calendar we use today; when he was born, Russia used the ‘Old Style’ Julian calendar, meaning his birth date would have been Dec 25th... but we’ll not let that spoil a good anniversary. He has featured once before on this playlist – see Day 211 when Malcolm chose his Prelude and Nocturne, Op 9, both for piano left hand – and on that occasion I commented on Scriabin’s development as a composer, particularly in terms of how his changing philosophical beliefs shaped his music. It is conventional to consider his music, in retrospect, as falling into three distinct phases. In the first of these, which takes us into the first couple of years of the 20th century, his compositions, once they’ve left the imprint of Chopin behind, sound characteristically ‘late Romantic’. You’d not have a lot of trouble, in these works, identifying that they employ the conventional harmonic language of the last decades of the 19th century, though increasingly chromatic (noddy definition: using notes not in the scale of the key in which any particular piece of music is composed). They draw on the language of Wagner on the one hand and Debussy on the other. Then there’s a ‘middle phase’ – typically seen as the middle years of the first decade of the 20th century – when Scriabin was pushing even further at the boundaries of harmony, and he was obsessed with evoking in his music the sound of light. (More on this in a minute.) You can hear a lot of similarities, especially in Scriabin’s orchestral music of this period, with the work of Richard Strauss, or the early Schoenberg, or Szymanowski. This period coincides with the years Scriabin spent outside Russia, during which his marriage broke down and he began a relationship with a former pupil and established a second family, and in which he spent many years touring Europe and the USA as a composer-pianist. He returned to Russia in 1909, and the final phase of his short life (he died aged 43 in 1915, after a spot on his upper lip turned septic and the infection became, tragically, terminal) was largely preoccupied with the extraordinary though unfinished composition ‘Mysterium’, the eventual performance of which (and at this point you may wish to wonder at the state of his mind) was apparently supposed to herald the end of the world. Hmmm… Anyway, for today, I want to consider one of the high points of the second, ‘light-filled’ phase, ‘The Poem of Ecstasy’. I’m wary of getting too bogged down in music theory that most of you might not want, but I think the key thing to keep hold of, with this work, is the way Scriabin withholds much of a sense of ‘resolution’ in the way his melodies and harmonies develop. OK – one tiny bit of musical stuff: if you were in the key of C and everything was tonal and stable, a chord of G major would inevitably suggest the almost-arrival of the end chord. That is, a G major chord means we know a C major chord will follow, and then we’ll be 'home'. Now, what Scriabin loved to do was to take (in terms of the example I’m using) the G major chord but pile so many additional notes from higher up the scale on top of it, thus generating, in his system of thought, greater and greater ‘light’, so that its ‘G major-ness’ still has that sense of yearning for home without ever quite getting there. (Feel free to ignore all of that if it did nothing for you.) Anyway, ‘The Poem of Ecstasy’ is a work for a massive orchestra, a swooning, yearning journey towards an ecstatic climax. It may not surprise you, knowing at least a little of Scriabin’s mind and how it works, to learn that he also wrote a massive poem of several hundred lines to accompany the work, and, in addition, this ‘programme note’: “‘The Poem of Ecstasy’ is the Joy of Liberated Action. The Cosmos, i.e. Spirit, is Eternal Creation without External Motivation, a Divine Play of Worlds. The Creative Spirit, i.e. the Universe at Play, is not conscious of the Absoluteness of its creativeness, having subordinated itself to a Finality and made creativity a means toward an end. The stronger the pulse beat of life and the more rapid the precipitation of rhythms, the more clearly the awareness comes to the Spirit that it is consubstantial with creativity itself. When the Spirit has attained the supreme culmination of its activity and has been torn away from the embraces of teleology and relativity, when it has exhausted completely its substance and its liberated active energy, the Time of Ecstasy shall arrive.” Make of that what you will. There are quite a few recordings of ‘The Poem of Ecstasy’ on YouTube, from which I’ve chosen this performance by the Philharmonia Orchestra conducted by Esa-Pekka Salonen from the 2010 BBC Proms. You’ll find it here: Scriabin: The Poem of Ecstasy
de Séverac, Déodat (1872-1921)
Day 309: Tantum Ergo (Time: 3 minutes) and 2. 'Les Muletiers devant le Christ de Llivia' and 'Le Retour des Muletiers' (from ‘Cerdaña') (13 minutes)
Today (19/7/22), I want to consider a little of the music of Déodat de Séverac (1872-1921), the 150th anniversary of whose birth falls tomorrow, on 20th July. At birth, to give him his full name, he was Marie-Joseph Alexandre Déodat de Séverac, from a family with a long history as part of the French nobility. The liner notes to a CD I have of his piano music tell me that de Séverac’s father was a famous (in his time) painter, but the maternal line is the real key to his aristocratic lineage, being descended from the Aragon family in Spain. Apparently, his great-grandfather was a naval minister for Louis XVI. Even more impressively (if you’re impressed by these things) the family line can be traced back to the 9th century. (By the way, I can’t be sure whether he should be referred to as ‘Séverac’ or ‘de Séverac’, since stuff I’ve read uses both forms, often in the same paragraph – I’m going for the latter, possibly rather arbitrarily.) After a traditional early education, he began to study Law in Toulouse, but quickly switched to the study of music at the Toulouse Conservatoire. Eventually, he ended up at the Schola Cantorum in Paris, the slightly more ‘liberal’ of the Parisian musical institutions, where he studied with Vincent d’Indy (see Day 174) and Alberic Magnard (one day…), but possibly more influentially in terms of de Séverac’s developing style, he spent six months in 1900 as assistant to the Spanish pianist and composer Isaac Albéniz (see Day 27). It is from this point that one can trace the two most substantial influences on de Séverac’s developing career: the urge to write if not exclusively then very largely for the piano; and the urge to write music rooted in the culture and landscape of his native south-western France. In fact, de Séverac spent relatively little time in Paris, even though it was at this time in many ways the focal point of the musical world. By 1905, he was settled back in the Haute-Garonne region, where he remained until his relatively early death at the age of 48. His music is not terribly well-known today, and rarely gets performed, apart from a short choral piece (see below) that remains in the repertoire of reasonably competent amateur choirs. But he also wrote songs in both Catalan and Occitan (the traditional language of the Languedoc region), and quite a large quantity of solo piano music that focuses on this intense sense of regionalism. In musical terms, you can hear quite a lot of Debussy and Ravel in de Séverac’s writing for piano, but probably the influence of Albéniz is stronger still. I thought I’d illustrate the work of this attractive yet understated composer by considering his setting of the short choral piece ‘Tantum Ergo’, and then a couple of movements from what seems to be regarded as his most significant work for piano, the suite ‘Cerdaña: Cinq Études Pittoresques’. First the ‘Tantum Ergo’ setting. This is an example of de Séverac at his most simple and traditional. It has a kind of pastoral charm in its three-minute span. The ‘Tantum Ergo’ text is taken from the opening lines of the Medieval Latin hymn ‘Pange Lingua’, generally thought to be by St Thomas Aquinas. Many composers have set it, from Palestrina to de Séverac and beyond, taking in six settings by Schubert and eight by Bruckner. You can hear de Séverac’s treatment of it, in a video recording by the semi-professional Bath-based choir Noctis, directed by Francis Faux, here: de Séverac: Tantum Ergo. The suite ‘Cerdaña’ occupied de Séverac for several years in the early 20th century before its first performance in 1911. The area known in French as the Cerdagne and in Spanish as Cerdaña straddles the French-Spanish border in the Pyrenees. The area was ceded to France in the mid-17th century, except for the capital of the region, Llivia, which is still a Spanish enclave in otherwise French territory. The suite has five movements, from which I’ve chosen the final two. The fourth movement is ‘Les Muletiers devant le Christ de Llivia’, in which the local muleteers bow in worship before the 12th century statue of Jesus in the chapel at Llivia. The music evokes the bells of the ancient fortified church tolling in a vivid depiction of the scene, as the worshippers offer their moving prayers and petitions. The final movement is ‘Le Retour des Muletiers’, in which the muleteers are heard travelling back over the mountain roads, in music which, to quote the CD notes I mentioned earlier, ‘is essentially of the region, Catalonia and the Spanish Pyrenees, reflected through the prism of Paris.’ Just so. These two movements are played in a video recording by the German-based Japanese pianist Nobue Ito, which you’ll find here: de Séverac: 'Les Muletiers devant le Christ de Llivia' and 'Le Retour des Muletiers' (from ‘Cerdaña')
Shostakovich, Dmitri (1906-75)
Day 95: Festive Overture (Time: 7 minutes)
Today (25/6/20), we have another suggestion from Malcolm, this time for a piece by the Soviet composer Dmitri Shostakovich. Shostakovich (1906-75) is rightly regarded as one of the leading symphonists of the 20th century, his cycle of 15 spanning pretty much the whole of his creative life. He is also renowned as a composer of string quartets, again accumulating a cycle of 15, though he only started composing quartets relatively late in his career. For me, Shostakovich is one of the greatest composers of the last century, and I’d argue that more than any other his work explores the terrible experience of living through a totalitarian age, when one relatively innocuous false move would lead to a knock on the door in the night and the swift disappearance of the person in question to the gulags, or worse. Shostakovich’s relationship with the party censors was a very complex one indeed, and he was formally denounced on two occasions (usually an artistic and often a literal death knell), and yet on other occasions his music was feted by those in power, and he was given the highest honours available to artists in the Soviet Union. This ‘chameleon-like’ quality is evident in almost all his music, allowing him to write pieces often deliberately shrouded in ambiguity. The most obvious example is probably his 5th Symphony, in the wake of Stalin’s thumbs down for Shostakovich’s opera ‘Lady Macbeth of the Mtsensk District’, which Shostakovich announced as ‘a Soviet artist’s creative reply to just criticism.’ The symphony is, on one level, simply and triumphantly affirmative, but only, really, if one has cloth ears when it comes to the anguish of the slow movement, and only if one hears triumph and not mechanised desolation in the finale. On the other hand, there were times when Shostakovich was happy to toe the party line and produce music to order that was unambiguously cheerful and popular. One such piece is the Festive Overture of 1947, written to celebrate the 30th anniversary of the October Revolution, though it wasn’t performed until seven years later. It is this piece that Malcolm suggests we listen to, in a recording by the New York Phil conducted by Shostakovich’s friend and colleague Mstislav Rostropovich. Interestingly, most performances of this work come in at somewhere between five and six minutes. Rostropovich manages to take almost seven! I’ve never heard it played this slowly before in my life. See what you think: the recording is here: Shostakovich – Festive Overture
Day 108: String Quartet No 8 (Time: 22 minutes)
Today (7/8/20), I wanted to share with you one of my favourite bits of chamber music,
the String Quartet No 8 by Shostakovich.
I’ve written before about Shostakovich (see Day 95!),
so I won’t repeat all the biographical stuff.
However, one thing that is always important in listening to Shostakovich’s work is
to consider the relationship between him and the Soviet authorities.
For significant periods of his life, his public position as a composer was really
very precarious, and there are instances of major works that he withheld or suppressed,
because to go public with them would have invited a knock on the door in the night,
and his disappearance into some gulag somewhere.
The most obvious example is the Symphony No 4 – withdrawn while it was in rehearsal
for its first performance in 1936 and not actually performed until 1961,
in the rather more ‘thawed’ environment of Khrushchev’s era in power.
In 1960, Shostakovich joined the Communist Party (it’s extraordinary to think that
he survived until then without doing so!), and it’s an action that has been interpreted
in lots of contrasting ways, from cowardice to heroism.
He seems to have engaged in some overtly ‘public’ music-making:
in 1961 he wrote the Symphony No 12 (‘The Year 1917’) and dedicated it to the memory of Lenin.
However, a more personal and ‘authentic’ response to this crisis of role and identity
was the production, in only three days, of his String Quartet No 8.
He was in Dresden, writing music for a film (he did a lot of that – a safe way of
placating Communist Party demands), but he observed the remains of the horrific
fire-bombing of the city by Allied forces in 1945 – much of it was still in
ruins – and this moved him intensely.
The Eighth Quartet is dedicated ‘To the victims of fascism and war’ – but
Shostakovich is characteristically double-edged here, in that the addition of ‘and war’ turns the work
from simple propaganda to something searingly humane and a protest against totalitarianism
in all its forms.
There are two things I want to say about the quartet itself.
The first is the relentless reiteration of Shostakovich’s personal motto theme.
(A bit of music notation stuff: he uses the notes D-Eb-C-B, or, in German notation, D-S-C-H…
which are the initial and first three letters of Shostakovich’s name in its Germanic spelling:
Dmitri SCHostakowisch).
That motto theme is everywhere in his music, but especially in those pieces
where he wants to say ‘Yes, I’m still here, you can’t silence me’.
It turns up really powerfully in the Symphony No 10 (written before Stalin’s death
but not performed until after it), the Violin Concerto No 1 … and here in the 8th
String Quartet, which opens with the theme passed between instruments in the
slow introductory section. It comes back several times later.
He also quotes from his Symphony No 1 and (really very poignantly) from the Piano Trio
No 2, a kind of Jewish ‘klezmer’ theme but turned into a kind of nightmarish scream.
(There’s a whole other programme note to be written about Shostakovich’s deployment of
Jewish themes in his music – a risky business in the Soviet Union at any time!)
The work is not an easy listen, but I absolutely think it’s worth the experience.
I’d say, even though Shostakovich was always careful to wear a mask of ambiguity, it’s his most
intensely personal work. There are some splendid performances on YouTube,
and out of them I’ve gone for one by the Emerson String Quartet, which you’ll
find here:
Shostakovich – String Quartet No 8
Day 202: Piano Concerto No 2 (Time: 21 minutes)
Last time out, I noted how Richard Strauss’s early Horn Concerto No 1
was shaped very substantially by the horn playing of his father Franz.
Today (2/7/21), I want to consider a reversal of roles, and to look at a
piano concerto written by a father for a son.
The work in question is Shostakovich’s Piano Concerto No 2.
Shostakovich has appeared twice before on this list (see Days 95 and 108),
and you can read about his travails with the Soviet authorities in the notes to those works.
The 1950s saw perhaps the most important event in Soviet life – the death of Stalin
in 1953 – because from it flowed not just a slight thawing in the arbitrary
persecution of individuals and groups that had been such a feature of Stalin’s
later years, but, for Shostakovich himself, it led to a tentative rehabilitation into
public life and a greater freedom to compose as he wished, rather than merely to order.
It was a time of some upheaval also in Shostakovich’s personal life. He had had
an open marriage with his first wife, from whom he became gradually estranged, until her
death in 1954. There were seemingly two substantial affairs with female students of his
in the 1940s and 50s, and in 1956 he married again, rather abruptly – and, as it turned out,
unhappily: the couple divorced in 1961. However, in all this shifting domestic
landscape, it appears that his relationship with his two children remained
strong and stable. And one example of this commitment is the writing of
his 2nd Piano Concerto. This dates from 1957, and was written
as a 19th birthday present for his son Maxim, who played it at his
graduation from the Moscow Conservatory. It’s a work that has not had a
particularly good press from music critics, who regard it as facile, certainly
when set against the tragic public statements of his symphonies, and tragic
private statements of his string quartets. But for all that, it’s a work
brimming with good humour and a sense of fun – and, in the slow movement, a
melting tenderness that is rare in his compositions. Shostakovich himself
was pretty dismissive of it. Within weeks of completing it he wrote that it
had ‘no redeeming artistic merits’ – although, as ever with Shostakovich, we
should not take anything he said or wrote at face value. The work is in
the traditional three movements, and is written for relatively small forces
(the orchestra has no brass section – assuming we count the horn section as
part of the ‘winds’). The first movement is brisk and sparkling,
dominated by a march-like initial theme, though some ‘seriousness’ is
introduced in a fugal central section. The slow central movement is the
emotional core of the piece. For me, it has echoes of the slow movement
of Beethoven’s ‘Emperor’ Concerto. Finally, there is a helter-skelter
finale, fully of fizzing scales, with much use being made of rhythmic
disruptiveness of passages in 7/8 time. It has always been one of
Shostakovich’s most popular works (it goes down well with Classic FM audiences)
but popularity does not necessarily mean superficiality. If your (surely
misguided!) view of Shostakovich is that he wrote music which is dour and grim,
and where the only humour is of a bitterly ironic kind, then this work should
be something of an antidote. As for a performance, there are some very
serviceable ones on YouTube, and out of them I’ve gone for this one by the
pianist Christian Badian, with the Orquesta Sinfónica Ciudad de Zaragoza
conducted by Laura Pérez Soria. You’ll find it here: Shostakovich:
Piano Concerto No 2.
(The video contains an encore too –
of Bortkiewicz’s Nocturne Op 24 No 1. It is, I think, the first piece of
his music that I’ve ever heard!)
Day 397: Symphony No 9 (Time: 26 minutes)
Today (18/7/23) is the first of two postings making this a kind of ‘20th century Soviet week’, tho’ as we’ll see, not necessarily music that pleased the Soviet authorities. Shostakovich has featured three times on this list to date (see Days 95, 108 and 202), but not, so far, anything symphonic. In part this is a consequence of the constraints of my self-imposed ’40 minute rule’ (where Tuesday's + Friday’s music choices should add up to no more than 40 minutes viewing/listening time). It has meant that the most often performed of Shostakovich’s symphonies (Nos 1, 5, 7, 8, 10 and 15) could not be played in their entirety. So, given a choice of just picking a movement or two from one of those symphonies or selecting from his shorter symphonic works, I’ve gone for (that is, Pete Dutton has suggested) Symphony No 9 – a very curious piece indeed, and one that summarises neatly the complexity of Shostakovich’s relationship with his Soviet lords and masters, about which I’ve written at length in relation to his other works on this list. What makes his Symphony No 9 so satisfyingly problematic is a result of the timing of its appearance. Having been effectively written out of Soviet history (with his opera ‘Lady Macbeth of the Mtsensk District’) and then tentatively – or ironically, maybe – rehabilitated (with his Symphony No 5) in the 1930s, Shostakovich engaged with the war effort in the fight against Nazism seemingly entirely wholeheartedly. That included living defiantly through much of the siege of Leningrad between late 1941 and early 1943, before he and his family were evacuated to the artists’ enclave in Samara. It also included writing music that seemed proudly, heroically patriotic, most obviously the Symphony No 7 (the ‘Leningrad’). Even the subsequent Symphony No 8, though darker and more troubled than its predecessor, was regarded as suitable for the great patriotic war effort. However, by the beginning of 1945, when the tide of the war had irrevocably turned and the Red Army was making major strides westwards towards Berlin, the expectation was that Shostakovich would crown this period with a triumphant, flag-waving ninth symphony. Bear in mind that ninth symphonies since the time of Beethoven came with the added burden of having to ‘follow that’, as it were. Shostakovich actually generated some troubling pre-publicity here, saying as early as the end of 1943 that he wanted to cap his wartime symphony trilogy with a ‘heroic’ Ninth. In January 1945 he told his composition students that he’d begun work on it, and even played a chunk of the first movement through to some of them. One response, that this was music ‘majestic in scale, in pathos, in its breathtaking motion’, suggests the direction of travel. And then, abruptly, Shostakovich turned his back on it – and in a little over a month in the middle of 1945 he wrote the symphony we now know as his Ninth. At its first performance (broadcast live on radio, to breathless official anticipation), responses were mixed. ‘Splendid in its joie de vivre, gaiety, brilliance and pungency,’ went one reaction. But within a year it was the subject of official disapproval: was he trivialising the heroic Soviet victory? Quickly, most of those who initially praised the work were obliged to retract their approval, after a dismissive assessment from the authorities: ‘a temporary rejection of great, serious problems for the sake of playful, filigree-trimmed trifles. But is it the right time for a great artist to go on vacation, to take a break from contemporary problems?’ Actually, even in the west this line emerged. A review of a New York performance argued that ‘the Russian composer should not have expressed his feelings about the defeat of Nazism in such a childish manner’. And this gets to the heart of the Soviet authorities’ anger – how to react to music which seems so deliberately, provocatively facile, so ‘throwaway’ in its moods, so almost wilfully shallow? The answer lies, as one might expect, with how Shostakovich positioned himself so ambiguously in relation to the forces of authority. It will not surprise you to know that the work was banned in the Soviet Union in early 1948 (the year Shostakovich and his music were denounced for ‘formalism’ for a second time in his life in the Zhdanov Decree), a ban not lifted until long after Stalin’s death five years later. So, what should we make of this symphony, that Shostakovich himself called ‘a merry little piece; musicians will love to play it, and critics will delight in blasting it.’ In some ways I think it shares qualities with Prokofiev’s ‘Classical’ Symphony, notably in that it feels imbued often with the playful spirit of Haydn. Structurally it shares its five-movement form with the 8th Symphony, in which again the final three movements run together continuously. The first movement feels light and sparkling, and the nagging insistence of the two-note trombone, trying to set off some patriotic march, is repeatedly dismissed. The second movement is more thoughtful, with lots of eloquent woodwind solos. But it’s the final three movements which are hardest to be sure about. The third movement feels like it belongs in the circus, but then the mood shifts abruptly in the fourth movement, which could be tragic and desolate, but could equally be a parody of overblown pomposity. (Make what you will of the absolutely inscrutable bassoon solo!) This leads straight into the finale, swirling, clownish, spinning out of control and, after a slight pause, whirling on to a breathless end. So, who is the ‘real’ Shostakovich, and what does he have to say? As in so many other works, in the Symphony No 9 he wears an inscrutable mask, as part of his lifelong struggle with the worst aspects of totalitarianism. By avoiding the epic and the triumphalist, and yet avoiding the charge of being negative or depressing, I think we can at least say with some confidence that he’s waving two fingers in the general direction of those in power, who wanted a heroic celebration of victory but got instead something that belittled that power. As for a performance, YouTube is richly stocked with pretty impressive video recordings. And here’s another tricky issue to negotiate. The Russian conductor Valery Gergiev (once chief conductor of the LSO, and at the time of the Russian invasion of Ukraine the holder of major posts in Munich and at the Verbier Festival) has lost pretty much all his standing in the west as a result of his refusal to condemn the invasion and because of his perceived close association with Vladimir Putin. But … should we censor his recordings as a result? This seems to me to be a genuinely tricky issue, but in the end – although I’d have no truck with Gergiev’s political stances – his performances of this repertoire are generally very impressive. So here, conducting the Mariinsky Orchestra, is his recording: Shostakovich: Symphony No 9
Day 529: Piano Trio No 2 (Time: 27 minutes)
Next month, Ensemble 360 will be presenting a Shostakovich weekend - three short concerts and a ‘round table’ discussion. The music will be four of Shostakovich’s string quartets and, in the final concert, the Piano Quintet and the music for today (14/2/25), Shostakovich’s Piano Trio No 2. This is a quite extraordinary work, and if you don’t know it, I hope you’ll find it as compellingly moving as I do. It’s a piece with both a personal and public ‘back story’, and it was, perhaps unsurprisingly, one of the works banned in the Soviet Union when Shostakovich was in bad odour with the authorities in the late 1940s/early 1950s, a situation only alleviated after Stalin’s death in 1953. Shostakovich wrote two piano trios during his career. The first is a short single-movement work which was, startlingly, written when the composer was only 16 years old, initially to get him into Myaskovsky’s composition class at the Moscow Conservatory (though in the end, largely due to his mother’s influence apparently, he remained in Leningrad, as it was then). The second trio, though, is a mature work, started in 1943 and premiered late the following year. The public context is probably self-evident: the Soviet Union was beginning to turn the tide against the retreating Nazi invaders, and news about their treatment of subjugated people in Eastern Europe (and particularly of the Jewish population) was starting to emerge at around this time. This is most powerfully reflected in the fourth and final movement of this work, a ‘Dance of Death’ which employs a distinctive Jewish melody. Eric Levi, in the BBC Music Magazine, wrote: ‘In particular, Shostakovich was deeply affected by the stories featured in the Soviet press that SS guards at the death camps of Treblinka and Majdaenk had forced Jewish prisoners to dig their own graves and dance upon them. This discovery gave rise to the macabre musical imagery that haunts the Trio’s Finale.’ In fact, Shostakovich had an extensive fascination with Jewish musical idioms. If we believe (not everyone does) that ‘Testament’, the apparent autobiographical thoughts of Shostakovich that surfaced in the west in the late 1970s (Shostakovich had died in 1975) is authentic, then the passage where the writer talks about this issue is very revealing: ‘Jewish folk music has made a most powerful impression on me. I never tire of delighting in it; it’s multifaceted; it can appear to be happy, while it is tragic. It’s almost always laughter through tears. This quality of Jewish music is close to my ideas of what music should be. There should always be two layers in music. Jews were tormented for so long that they learned to hide their despair. They expressed despair in dance music. All folk music is lovely, but I can say that Jewish folk music is unique.’ In fact, Shostakovich’s ‘identification’ with Jewish suffering made it in some ways a proxy for his own struggle at the hands of Soviet authorities. However, there is also another personal ‘trigger’ for this work. In 1944 his close friend Ivan Sollertinsky died suddenly at the age of 41 of a heart attack. It seems to have affected Shostakovich deeply. He had already begun the first movement of the trio at the time, and determined to complete the work in his memory. The first movement opens eerily, with the cello playing harmonics very high up in its register. It’s like a mournful Russian folk song, taken up in canon (repeated identical entries – think of ‘Frère Jacques’!), before the rest of the movement unfolds into a piece of contrasting (often violently contrasting) moods. If the first movement is haunted by despair, the second movement feels manic, the kind of frenzied scherzo you find a lot in Shostakovich’s work. Interestingly, this movement, with its slightly deranged waltz-like middle section, was regarded as the perfect depiction of the late Sollertinsky by his sister. The third movement is a passacaglia, a form we’ve met before in these postings (compare the last movement of Brahms’ 4th Symphony, say, from Day 426), in which a repeated, unvarying bass line, here played relentlessly on the piano, is decorated by violin and cello, again playing in canon with each other. (One of the really startling features of this work is its use of older, Baroque forms, which gives the trio a deeply cohesive quality.) This movement leads directly into the finale, a macabre dance theme which builds into a frenzy before coming to an abrupt halt. Shostakovich then goes back to the opening theme of the whole work, and then the chord sequence from the third movement, before one final, exhausted echo of the dance theme. While one might query the legitimacy of Shostakovich’s right to see himself in the persecution of the Jewish people, it is undoubtedly true that this trio was the first of many works written in Shostakovich’s final three decades to (implicitly or explicitly) quote Jewish themes. (For another example, go back to the 8th String Quartet I explored on Day 108.) It’s not an easy work but, I’d suggest, it’s utterly compelling. As for a performance, there are actually quite a few on YouTube that I could happily live with. Out of the options, I’ve gone for this live performance at the Verbier Festival in 2022, given by a starry line-up of players: the familiarly underdressed Yuja Wang on piano, Gautier Capuçon on cello, and Leonidas Kavakos on violin. You’ll find it here: Shostakovich: Piano Trio No 2
Day 551: Symphony No 1 (Time: 33 minutes)
Today (15/8/25) I want to mark the 50th anniversary of the death of Shostakovich, which occurred on 9th August, 1975. Speaking purely for myself, it was the first time a composer whose work I’d come to love had died. In August 1975 I was 17, and as an A-level Music student I was happily exploring 20th century music and Shostakovich’s work had begun to make a deep impression on me. (I realise Stravinsky had died in 1971, but that had far less impact on me, given that I was only 13 at the time, and my then musical timeline stopped at Tchaikovsky. My bad, as they say.) It’s the sixth time Shostakovich has featured on this list, but today I thought I’d examine not a work of Shostakovich the established composer – all the previous postings refer to work he composed in the 1940s or later – but instead look at the work of a young composer just finding his voice. But what a voice! So, this is Shostakovich’s Symphony No 1, a piece of quite bewildering brilliance. And here’s your ‘starter for ten’ thought: we’re used (I’m working on the assumption here that the ‘we’ might actually include you, dear reader) to Shostakovich’s characteristic ‘mask-wearing’ behaviours from those fraught decades when he was denounced by the Communist authorities. The consequence of the attacks of the 1930s and 40s, the conventional view suggests, was that you could never tell quite what Shostakovich ‘meant’ in his music. Was he being ‘a good Communist’, writing heroic, patriotic music for the masses, or was he being ironic, generating a bitter critique of the system whose Orwellian jackboot was crushing the individual human spirit for ever? Or both, at the same time? Applying this to big works, like the Symphony No 5, allegedly ‘a Soviet artist’s response to just criticism’, can lead to strikingly divergent readings of the work, depending on whether you ‘hear’ it as conformist or not. But one of the delights of the Symphony No 1 is that you can hear all that ambiguity already in place, at a time when Shostakovich had had no brushes with authority, no dangers of being arrested in the dead of night and simply made to disappear. So, a bit of back story: Shostakovich entered the Petrograd (formerly St Petersburg, later Leningrad, later still St Petersburg again) Conservatory at the age of 13 in 1919. In 1924 the then 18-year-old needed, in order to graduate, to compose a symphony. He seems to have found it initially not to his liking: in October 1924 he wrote, ‘Now I’m writing a symphony … which is quite bad, but I have to write it so that I can be done with the conservatory this year.’ Besides, there were other, more pressing things going on in his life. In 1922 his father had died, and to bring at least a little money into the family coffers, Shostakovich spent a great deal of his ‘free’ time playing piano to accompany silent films. This pressure to compose to order, to match the largely crude emotional simplicity of the films’ narratives (now comic, now sentimental, now dramatic, and so on) gave him a taste for writing music that juxtaposed extreme, often grotesque, elements in vivid ways – and this fluency found its way into his Symphony No 1. Another influence – Mahler – reinforced this clashing of different sound worlds, since it’s one of the key characteristics of Mahler’s symphonies. By mid-1925 he had completed the work in a version for two pianos, and it was this that he presented to the Conservatory as his graduation piece. Grudgingly, it seems, he was allowed to graduate, and a year later, when the symphony had been orchestrated, it had its first performance. It’s hard to think of another work of such substance by an 18/19-year old which has remained in the repertoire of so many performers – Mozart was a prodigy, of course, but few of the works he wrote when under 20 see the light of day regularly; Beethoven or even Schubert had written little of note by the age of 20; probably Mendelssohn (the String Octet or the overture to ‘A Midsummer Night’s Dream’) is the only other composer whose teenage works regularly fill concert halls. The symphony is in the traditional four movements, but that’s probably the only traditional thing about it. The first movement suggests another influence on the young Shostakovich – that of Stravinsky, and particularly the Stravinsky who composed ‘Petrushka’, with its melding of banality and high art. The first movement of Shostakovich’s Symphony No 1 is very ‘Petrushkan’. Two themes – a toy-soldier march on clarinet and a puppet-ballerina waltz on the flute – vie for control of a movement which is tautly structured (it follows all the ‘rules’) but full of scrunching collisions of theme and style. The second movement feels very like it’s drawn from some of the stuff Shostakovich was accompanying in the cinema – a Keystone Cops chase sequence, and a kind of mock-solemn procession of pilgrims – before the whole thing is brought to an abrupt close by brusque piano chords. Interestingly, it seems as though at one point Shostakovich was going to give the work the title ‘Symphony-Grotesque’, and on the basis of the first two movements you can hear why. But then comes the slow movement, which might (but only ‘might’) seem like the exploration of genuine feeling, warm, humane and tender. Of course, this could just be another role-play, and the shift from the lyrical oboe theme to a kind of mournful lament makes it difficult to know exactly where we are, or what the emotional temperature might be. The movement leads directly into the finale, initially a mad scramble on clarinet and piano, but joined by themes from the slow movement and leading to – one might have guessed – an extremely ambivalent conclusion. At its first public performance the work was an immediate success, and within a year it had travelled around the world, announcing the arrival of this new, exciting, authentically ‘Soviet’ composer. Well, at least until, within a decade, the Stalinist authorities had decided that irony and ambiguity were not to their taste. There are a good many really fine performances of this piece on YouTube so my choice – the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra conducted by Paavo Järvi – is by no means obvious, but I like the way the contrasts of the work are enjoyed without being exploited. You’ll find it here: Shostakovich: Symphony No 1
Sibelius, Jean (1865-1957)
Day 77: Symphony No 5 (1st movement) (Time: 14 minutes)
Yesterday, I realised that I made a passing mention of Sibelius when discussing Mahler's approach to symphonic writing, and it struck me as close to unforgivable that I should get 11 weeks into this exercise and not yet have focused on Sibelius. So, let’s address that issue right now (7/6/20)! Jean Sibelius (1865-1957) is not just the greatest Finnish composer ever, but surely one of the greatest symphonists ever, his technique evolving from the Symphony No 1, which is heavily indebted to Tchaikovsky and Russian Romanticism, through to the Symphony No 7, with its tautly unified and condensed structure. I realise that in considering Sibelius the symphonist I’m bumping up against the frustrations of the 15-minute rule again, because it would be wonderful to send out a link to, and to consider the qualities of, a whole symphony. But if we have to observe the rules (mostly!), I’d like to select for today the first movement of the Symphony No 5. (Even making that choice sticks in the throat a bit, because it means overlooking the ecstatic final movement of the Symphony No 5 with its passionate and emotional ‘swan hymn’. (Go on, check it out – you know you want to!) Sibelius was a long-lived and immensely complex individual. He became the figurehead for Finnish music (and, by extension, Finnish independence from Russian control) in the late 19th century, almost instantly after the publication of ‘Finlandia’ in 1900. But there are other strands to his character that sat less easily with this image of patriotic fervour, and his symphonies withdraw a little after the ‘heroism’ of his Symphony No 2 in 1902, another immensely popular success. The 5th Symphony was initially premiered in 1915 but revised several times – the version normally played today, in three movements rather than the initial four, dates from 1919. The first movement of the final version is a blend of what had been the first two movements of the initial draft, and there is a lot of discussion about the exact nature of the structure that this final ‘hybrid’ movement has. Still, leaving musicologists to their debate, what’s inescapable in this music is the sheer sense of exhilaration of something shifting from its slowly ruminant beginnings (that initial horn theme) to vibrant celebration by the end of the movement. The transition into the faster music (you’ll know when you get there – it’s at about 8:20 in the version I’ve attached) is one of those moments that makes the hairs on the back of my neck stand up. It’s very special. There are a lot of videos on YouTube of the whole symphony, but rather fewer of the first movement only. I’ve gone for a recording by the Verbier Festival Orchestra (essentially a training orchestra for many of the world’s most talented young musicians) conducted by Esa Pekka Salonen. (It’s also easy to find their performances of the other two movements if this thrills you as much as it does me.) You’ll find it here: Sibelius – Symphony No 5 (1st movement)
Day 195: Symphony No 7 (Time: 23 minutes)
Sibelius has appeared only once before on this list (see Day 77), when we encountered the first movement of his Symphony No 5. Pete’s suggestion for today (8/6/21) is the last of his symphonies (at least the last one to survive whole), his Symphony No 7 in C, Op 105. My brief biographical survey of Sibelius’ career, when we considered the 5th Symphony, took us to the period around the end of the First World War. After the Finnish Civil War ended in 1918 and the country entered a period of relative stability, Sibelius resumed his position as Finland’s leading musical figure of the day, and assumed something of a public role, enjoying successful tours around Europe as a conductor of his own music. However, the obsessively self-destructive traits in his personality (notably his addiction to alcohol) became more marked too, which not only scarred his relationship with his wife but also dramatically slowed his creative output. In 1923 his Symphony No 6 was premiered, and within a year he had composed another symphonic work, premiered in early 1924 as his ‘Fantasia Sinfonica’ – the piece that eventually became his Symphony No 7. However, after this, he wrote almost nothing in the final 30 years of his life, apart from incidental music to Shakespeare’s ‘The Tempest’ and a final symphonic poem, ‘Tapiola’, inspired by the Finnish literary epic the Kalevala, both written in 1926. The years of silence leading up to his death in 1957 have remained enigmatic, and hint at a loss not just of confidence in his own powers, but many years of bleak depression. The saddest things from a musical perspective are the ‘bonfires’ of his own manuscript scores, according to his wife – among them the drafts for a putative Symphony No 8. Returning to the 7th Symphony, Sibelius’ concern over what to call the work reflects its revolutionary structure and formal development. When it was published in 1925 it bore the title ‘Symphony No 7 (in One Movement)’. In fact, the journey towards a single-movement structure took Sibelius a long time and several drafts, and he seems to have had particular trouble with the ending of the work. What unifies the symphony is its intense focus on the key of C Major (or C Minor) – all the symphony’s core moments are in these keys. There is an almost continuous shifting of tempo throughout, so that we have a constant sense of restlessness and exploration – one can split the symphony up into eleven distinct sections, but Sibelius blurs the boundaries between them in ways that hide any sense of externally-imposed structure. Consequently, most descriptions of the symphony stress its ‘organic’ development: the New Grove Dictionary describes ‘the transformational processes of the musical ideas themselves — a content-based form constantly in the process of becoming.’ Perhaps the symphony’s final moments are its most telling. For some these pages are ‘the grandest celebration of C major there ever was’; on the other hand, Simon Rattle observes of the same music: ‘It’s almost like a scream. It’s the most depressed C major in all of musical literature. There’s no other piece that ends in C major where you feel it’s the end of the world. Look at how carefully he orchestrates it so that it doesn’t sound like a victory, but as something you reach on the edge of death. You finally reach C major – and it’s over. It should be a struggle for the strings to achieve this last note with their last bit of energy.’ However you hear it, it’s an extraordinary, revolutionary, troubling work – it may be hindsight that makes us think it’s the last word on Sibelius’ symphonic journey, but it’s hard to know where he might have gone from there. As for a performance, I’ve chosen a BBC Proms video recording from 2011 given by the Halle Orchestra conducted by Sir Mark Elder. You’ll find it here: Sibelius: Symphony No 7
Day 196: Andante Festivo (Time: 6 minutes)
Having heard his Symphony No 7 last time out, courtesy of a suggestion from Pete Dutton, today (11/6/21) I want to propose a companion piece which dates, like the symphony, from the early 1920s, just before the composer’s 30 years’ silence rendered the last decades of his life so musically enigmatic. The beginnings of this story are not terribly promising. In 1922, a sawmill in the Finnish municipality of Säynätsalo celebrated its 25th anniversary. (Sawmills are big in Finland.) Its CEO, Walter Parviainen, requested a celebratory cantata from Sibelius to mark the occasion. Nothing if not contrary, Sibelius responded to the request with a short piece for string quartet called ‘Andante Festivo’. There is some evidence that Sibelius trawled his back catalogue in putting the music together – it contains resemblances to fragments of an incomplete oratorio from the early years of the 20th century. As a piece for string quartet, the work is a gentle, reflective composition, a continuously flowing melody that is serene without being bland. And that is where this story might have ended were it not for events on the other side of the Atlantic in the late 1930s. Sibelius was an avid radio listener, and was much exercised by the challenges of composing music that could be enjoyed on the limited audio equipment of the day, particularly by developing compositions in a ‘bass-heavy’ way. In 1939, the New York World Exhibition was held, and Sibelius was asked ‘to conduct a piece of music as Finland's greeting to the world in a radio broadcast to celebrate this event’. At this point, Sibelius went back to the Andante Festivo and re-scored it for full string orchestra and additional timpani. Sibelius conducted the live broadcast performance on New Year’s Day, 1939, apparently on the basis of only one rather sketchy run-through. It is the only known recording of Sibelius conducting his own music. Interestingly, where the string quartet version takes somewhere around five minutes, Sibelius’s recording takes just over six, and this slowing of the tempo, along with the thicker scoring, gives the piece a nobility, a kind of rugged grandeur, that I find deeply moving. (I’ve come to terms with it now, but the first few times I heard this recording I couldn’t get to the end without crying.) In its ‘strings and timps’ form, the work was played at Sibelius’s own funeral, which seems to me to affirm its status as music which both terribly sad, yet life-affirming in a rather solemn way. And, heading off-piste into the deeply personal, this is the music, and the recording of it, that I’d like to be played at my own funeral too. I realise that at that point I won’t be there, but it’s the sort of music I’d like whatever minimally-assembled group might turn up to remember me by. (I realise here that I have stumbled into a possible occasional series on this playlist: ‘the music you’d like to be played at your own funeral’. I doubt any of us are going to get the full state occasion approach to this event, so your passing is unlikely to be marked by a complete performance of Verdi’s Requiem, but if you have a piece of 5 minutes or so that fits the bill, do let me know and I’ll feature it in future postings.) Inevitably, given what I’ve written, the YouTube recording of Sibelius’s Andante Festivo that I’ve chosen is by the Finnish Radio Orchestra, conducted by the composer, on 1st January 1939. You’ll find it here: Sibelius: Andante Festivo
Day 577: Violin Concerto (Time: 36 minutes)
Later this month, the predictably Czech-sounding Janáček Philharmonic Orchestra, Ostrava, will be performing a largely Czech programme here in Sheffield, but also on the menu is one of the great violin concertos, the one by Jean Sibelius, and it’s this piece which is my choice for today (13/2/26). Sibelius has featured only three times on this list to date, which seems to me definitely not enough for a composer of his greatness. So far, I’ve considered a couple of the symphonies, which are after all the core of his output, and also the short piece for strings and timpani, ‘Andante Festivo’, the last of these for the purely self-indulgent reason that I’d like a recording of it to be played at my funeral! (My beloved may of course have other ideas, and I suppose I won’t be around to make suggestions…) Anyway, Sibelius’s only violin concerto – indeed, his only concerto for any instrument – marked a significant step in his musical development, and with hindsight it sounds like one of the last flourishes of Sibelius the ‘Romantic’ composer, before something more austere, and more unrelentingly Finnish, if you like, came to dominate his musical voice. He did start making draft sketches for a second concerto in about 1915, but abandoned them; much of that music ended up in his Symphony No 6. As you may know, Sibelius harboured ambitions to be a concert violinist as a young man, a goal he only finally abandoned in around his mid-20s: he wrote to a friend, ‘My tragedy was that I wanted to be a celebrated violinist at any price. Since the age of 15 I played my violin practically from morning to night. I hated pen and ink—unfortunately I preferred an elegant violin bow. My love for the violin lasted quite long and it was a very painful awakening when I had to admit that I had begun my training for the exacting career of a virtuoso too late.’ But though he gave up that idea, his fascination with the violin and its potential as a solo instrument remained, and found its expression in this concerto. He started work on it in 1902 and the piece had its first performance in early 1904. However (and this is not uncommon for Sibelius) that version was not the final one, and he revised the work over the following 18 months or so, and the revision had its first performance late in 1905. The differences between the two versions are not huge. In essence, the earlier version is about five minutes longer, the later cuts being in the first and last movements. It’s also the case that the earlier version is considerably more difficult to play (not that the piece as we hear it today is easy!), and it was the fact that the first performance of the early version didn’t go well (to be brutal, it seems that the soloist wasn’t up to the work’s demands) that led Sibelius to tone down the challenges. The concerto is in some ways one of the last ‘big Romantic’ concertos, in the vein of Tchaikovsky or Saint-Saens. However, not everyone liked it. Joachim, the celebrated violinist who premiered Brahms’ Violin Concerto (and much else for the violin in the latter half of the 19th century) described it as ‘abominable and boring’. What’s interesting about it, I think, is the way it combines the display quality of the late 19th century concerto with Sibelius’ characteristic intense seriousness – at least in his major works, for he wrote a lot of rather lightweight salon-type music too, though we rarely get to hear that stuff performed these days. When he was composing (and re-composing) it, Sibelius seems to have written in a state of high excitement. He told his (long-suffering) wife Aina, ‘I have got wonderful themes for the violin concerto,’ and subsequently she wrote to a mutual friend: ‘Jean has been on fire all the time, and this time there has once again been an “embarras de richesse”. He has such a multitude of themes in his head that he has been literally quite dizzy. He stays awake all night, plays incredibly beautifully, cannot tear himself away from the delightful melodies - he has so many ideas that it is hard to believe it. And all the themes are so capable of development, full of life.’ The concerto is in the conventional three movements, though in many ways its structure is unorthodox. In the long first movement the soloist introduces the main theme right at the start, rather than giving this to the orchestra while the soloist waits politely for this exposition to be completed. But the most controversial ‘rule-breaking’ feature is that the ‘development’ section (the bit in the middle of the movement where usually the themes which have been introduced are manipulated and played around with) is replaced with the cadenza for the soloist (which is normally placed just before the end of a movement for maximum ‘show-off’ impact). This first movement makes it obvious that Sibelius saw the concerto as essentially a ‘symphonic’ work, giving instrumental groups within the orchestra (clarinets, bassoons, trombones) a prominent role, rather than simply being an ‘accompaniment’ to the soloist. After this long, minor key first movement, the melancholy slow movement provides something of a respite, and the melody that dominates this still point at the centre of the concerto is rich and lyrical. The final Allegro is a kind of polonaise. Sibelius himself described the movement as ‘a danse macabre’. I feel a kind of obligation to note (because every discussion of this concerto does!) the British musicologist (and composer!) Donald Tovey at this point: he called the movement ‘a polonaise for polar bears’. Actually, and I think much more interestingly, he also wrote of Sibelius that ‘his forms are hewn out of the rocks of his native and Nordic mountains.’ For me, it’s this sort of rugged, solid, beautifully intransigent quality that best sums up both this concerto and Sibelius’ major works as a whole. YouTube carries lots of video recordings of this concerto by many of today’s leading soloists, and choosing which one to listen to will be largely a matter of personal taste. I quite like this version by the Radio France Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by Mikko Franck. The soloist is the American virtuoso Hilary Hahn. You’ll find the performance here: Sibelius: Violin Concerto
Day 590: En Saga (chamber version reconstructed by Gregory Barrett) (Time: 24 minutes)
Today (15/5/26) is the last of four postings that I’ve been putting together to mark this year’s Sheffield Chamber Music Festival (15-23 May) and I’m going to finish by considering a septet. The work in question is part of the programme for the last night of the festival, when Ensemble 360 will be playing a work by Sibelius, in a version which will be, allegedly, closer to its original scoring. This is his tone poem ‘En Saga’. Unless you have developed an interest in Sibelius’ music over time, it may be a surprise to you to know how much he actually wrote. These days, what we tend to hear are just the symphonies (and really only Nos 1, 2, 5 and 7 with any regularity), plus the Violin Concerto (see Day 577), ‘Finlandia’ and the Karelia Suite. In fact, Sibelius wrote something like 550 works (the exact number is tricky to define precisely, because Sibelius, and/or his publishers, had a tendency to group smaller works into composite publications). Over the years 2007-11, the Swedish music label BIS produced a comprehensive ‘Sibelius Edition’, aiming to record every note that Sibelius composed. It runs to 68 CDs, amounting to over 80 hours of music! So, there’s a lot more to Sibelius than we might generally assume. Why bother to tell you all this? Well, because the rather labyrinthine nature of Sibelius’ oeuvre plays its part in the back-story to ‘En Saga’. In 1890, when Sibelius was in his mid-20s, he went to Vienna to study composition and orchestration with Fuchs (see Day 268) and Goldmark (one day, folks…), and one of the earliest tasks he was set was to study Mozart’s writing for clarinet. This may seem like an obscure place to start a discussion of ‘En Saga’, but in the following 18 months Sibelius started work on a septet, almost certainly scored for flute, clarinet, string quartet and double bass. The exact nature of this proto-piece is the subject of much conjecture because the original manuscript has been assumed to be lost, but what is known is that it was re-worked over the next couple of years as the first version of the orchestral piece we know as ‘En Saga’. ‘En Saga’, as a title, might evoke Scandinavian or maybe Icelandic thoughts, given the literary tradition of these northern countries, but in fact a simple translation of the title would be ‘A Story’ or, if you want something a bit more poetic, ‘A Fairy Tale’. But, as you may know, Sibelius was fascinated all his life by the Finnish national text the ‘Kalevala’ – source material that eventually generated a dozen different works from Sibelius’ pen. The first of them, a sprawling symphonic structure for soloists, choir and orchestra, the ‘Kullervo Symphony’, was begun in Vienna and first performed in Helsinki in 1892. Its success prompted Sibelius’ friend (most of the time!) and conductor Robert Kajanus to ask Sibelius to write another ‘Kalevala’-based piece, but one that ‘would not make too great demands on the powers of concentration and comprehension’ of the audience (which Sibelius initially interpreted as a loaded criticism of the 80-minute long ‘Kullervo’). Whatever the intention behind Kajanus’ suggestion, Sibelius responded quickly – and the result was ‘En Saga’. This is odd amongst Sibelius’ eventually extensive collection of a dozen or so tone poems, in that it has no overt story attached to it. In fact, Sibelius went to some lengths to stress the very definite absence of a narrative for the work. The closest he came was much later, when he said that ‘It represents an expression of a state of mind. I had recently undergone several painful experiences, and in no other work have I revealed myself so completely.’ Now, a comment like that begs lots of questions, but what those painful experiences were, and in what ways he might have revealed himself in ‘En Saga’, are questions that (unless Sibelius scholarship uncovers some new source material in the future) remain enigmatic. It is, as one commentator whom I’m afraid I can’t put a name to called it, ‘an adventure in an inner landscape’. The work, in its full orchestral garb, had its first performance in 1893. Almost a decade later, in 1902, Sibelius was invited to conduct a performance in Berlin of some of his work, and for that occasion he returned to the 1893 version of ‘En Saga’ and made some radical cuts to its length (seemingly as much as four minutes when compared to the revised version that usually lasts around 18-19 minutes) and also revised its orchestration. The pressure to amend and subsequently check the proofs of this ‘new’ version seems to be the reason for the disappearance of the original manuscript of the chamber version of ‘En Saga’, since Sibelius refers in comments at the time to using some pages of the original manuscript because they needed relatively little change to be made to them. Does all this matter? Not really (so, sorry to waste your reading time!), except that it explains the act of ‘reverse engineering’ on the part of the American clarinettist and musicologist Gregory Barrett, who worked backwards, as it were, from the revised orchestral score to get to the chamber version Sibelius might have first had at the start of this story. Structurally the piece is actually quite simple. After a short introduction, the rest of the work is constructed in sections we might label ABCBCBCA – that is, an extended ‘middle section’ made up of the treatment of themes ‘B’ and ‘C’, which alternate with each other three times, and that whole portion wrapped around with a kind of ‘intro/outro’ ‘A’ section. The work’s changing moods – now brooding, now decisive, now anguished – don’t really need ‘a story’ to explain them (so feel free to invent your own!), though from the somewhat bleak way in which the piece closes, it doesn’t seem to conclude with a happy ending… If you want to hear what the familiar full orchestral version of ‘En Saga’ sounds like, there are lots of performances on YouTube, including this one by the WDR Symphony Orchestra, Cologne, conducted by Ariane Matiakh, which you’ll find here; but I thought – in the light of the imminent performance of this by Ensemble 360 – it might be interesting to encounter the chamber version, which you’ll find here, as played by the French performers of the Quatuor Zaide, alongside Irena Kavcic on flute, Tommaso Lonquich on clarinet, and Iztok Hrastnik on double bass: Sibelius: En Saga (chamber version reconstructed by Gregory Barrett)
Sigfúsdóttir, Maria Huld Markan (b1980)
Day 308: Oceans (Time: 10 minutes)
For me, one of the joys of this list is finding something completely new – a piece of music I’ve never heard before, by a composer I’ve never heard of before – which is where we are today (15/7/22). And so to another new name on the playlist, that of Maria Huld Markan Sigfúsdóttir (b1980). Actually, I thought I’d never come across the name before, but doing a bit of research before writing this posting (there’s work going into this stuff, folks!), I realised that though I hadn’t known the name, I had heard her playing. Sigfúsdóttir, on first violin, formed an all-female string quartet whilst studying at the Reykjavik College of Music in the last years of the 20th century. Over time, they adopted the name ‘amiina’ (trendy lower case, of course) and began to develop a performance tradition of playing alongside Icelandic pop and rock bands and other experimental ensembles – and this is where, I realise, I’ve come across her playing, because for about 12 years or so they played with the Icelandic ‘post-rock’ band Sigur Rós, whose music is a curious blend of classical minimalism and dreamy soundscapes, and amiina provided the backdrop to their work. One of the things I really like about Icelandic musical culture (at least, seeing it from the outside) is that there seems to be relatively little division into ‘high’ and ‘low’ culture about the way the music scene functions. Perhaps this is simply a consequence of Iceland’s geographical isolation and its small population (‘about the size of Leicester’, as football commentators insisted on telling us as Iceland humiliated England at the 2016 Euros). Whatever the reason, the overlap between ‘classical’ musicians and those whose focus is on more popular culture is clearly very fruitful. Which brings us back to Ms Sigfúsdóttir, who has become increasingly prolific as a composer of orchestral, chamber and electronic music over the past decade or so. Some of it is for familiar ensembles (works for string quartet for SATB choir); other pieces are very definitely not for such combinations (baroque string trio and tape, for instance, or a piece for saw, alto flute, bass clarinet, vibraphone and celeste). The piece Malcolm suggests we listen to is called ‘Oceans’; it was composed in 2018, and it’s scored for a reasonably conventional full symphony orchestra. The piece has been performed in concert by the Iceland Symphony Orchestra conducted by Daniel Bjarnason, and the same forces have recorded it on a very well-received compilation disc, ‘Concurrence’, alongside other pieces of contemporary Icelandic music. The ‘blurb’ for the ISO’s performance of the work informs us that Sigfúsdóttir’s piece was ‘inspired by the current state of the world’s oceans, particularly the discarded plastic items floating around, forming large, never-perishing islands of toys and household items of bygone times.’ The work has a kind of ‘filmic’ quality, I think. Malcolm’s email to me commented that it was ‘a lovely orchestral evocation of the sea, with gentle rises and falls’. If I had to find a comparable piece for this work from the more mainstream orchestral repertoire, I’d suggest it has some things in common with Sibelius’s tone poem ‘The Oceanides’, in its sense of swelling and retreating pulsation, and the feeling that the interlocking themes might clash, but never quite do. The performance of the piece I’ve chosen is, I think, the world premiere, given by the Iceland Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Daniel Bjarnason, in January 2019. You’ll find it here: Sigfúsdóttir: Oceans
Sigurbjörnsson, Þorkell (1938-2013)
Day 307: Heyr Himna Smiður (Time: 4 minutes)
Today (12/7/22), it’s another new name on the list, that of Þorkell Sigurbjörnsson. Sigurbjörnsson (1938-2013) was a prolific composer and also a pianist, teacher, conductor, administrator, and newspaper music critic in Iceland in the later 20th/early 21st centuries, though globally I suspect he is known largely for one piece, the one that Malcolm has suggested we consider. Wikipedia tells me that after study in America, Sigurbjörnsson returned to Iceland, where he had a varied career presenting a show on Icelandic public radio, teaching at Reykjavik College of Music, chairing the Icelandic Composers Society, and so on … and (it says there) being in the process Iceland’s most prolific composer. He had strong family connections with Iceland’s Lutheran Church (his father became Bishop of Iceland, and interestingly a number of Sigurbjörnsson’s sacred works are settings of his father’s poetry) and around 25% of his 350 or so compositions are on sacred topics. It is only relatively recently that many of his compositions have surfaced in print. The reasoning for this is simple: he wrote for the occasion, and when the occasion was over, the need for the piece was no longer present, and many of the pieces were not professionally recorded at their premieres. Consequently, a lot of his music still exists only as handwritten (and, apparently, not very legible) scores. The Icelandic hymn ‘Heyr, himna smiður’ (Hear, Heaven’s Maker [literally, ‘heaven’s smith’]) stands out as one of Sigurbjörnsson’s masterpieces and the most performed of all his works, especially at funerals in Iceland. The original version was written for SATB choir, probably in 1972. Shortly after his death, this hymn became wildly popular after a performance by Icelandic band Árstíðir in a video recorded in a train station in Germany circulated quickly through social media platforms and online articles. If you’re interested, you can find it on YouTube here. Interestingly, the hymn is apparently ‘Iceland’s favourite song’ – or at least it was voted thus in 2018 in a national poll conducted on behalf of the Iceland Symphony Orchestra to determine the country’s most popular composition. (Considering the competition from music from the likes of Björk, this is quite impressive.) The text dates from the early 13th century, and was written by Kolbeinn Tumasson of Viðimý, an Icelandic chieftain, who wrote it allegedly the night before a battle in which he was killed by Guðmundur Arason, then Bishop of Iceland. (Bishops, eh – what are they like?) The text is in three stanzas, and a loose translation reads: ‘Hear, smith of heavens./ The poet seeketh./ In thy still small voice/ Mayest thou show grace./ As I call on thee,/ Thou my creator./ I am thy servant,/ Thou art my true Lord.// God, I call on thee,/ For thee to heal me./ Bid me, prince of peace,/ Thou my supreme need./ Ever I need thee,/ Generous and great,/ O’er all human woe,/ City of thy heart.// Guard me, my saviour./ Ever I need thee,/ Through ev’ry moment/ In this world so wide./ Virgin–born, send me/ Noble motives now./ Aid cometh from thee,/ To my deepest heart.’ Sigurbjörnsson’s setting has, I think, a sort of self-consciously ‘old’ quality, to match its medieval text, even though a lot of the harmonies feel quite 19th century. It makes some use of the Aeolian mode, and the melismatic setting of the words (where one syllable is ‘stretched’ over several notes) gives something of the feel of Gregorian chant. I’m really pleased that Malcolm has chosen this piece, because it’s been a favourite of mine for some years. I first came across it on a CD on the BIS label called ‘Meditatio’, which is a varied collection of music for unaccompanied choir that I enjoyed so much that I bought my wife a copy for Christmas one year (that’s how this sort of thing is supposed to happen, isn’t it…?). However, Malcolm’s introduction to it was on an album by the ensemble VOCES8, called ‘Infinity’. You can hear their performance of the work here: Sigurbjörnsson: Heyr Himna Smiður
Smetana, Bedrich (1824–1884)
Day 287: 'Vltava' (from 'Ma Vlast') (Time: 13 minutes)
Today (26/4/22), the most famous piece by a composer new to this list (and how could it have taken so long?), Bedřich Smetana (1824-84) – actually Friedrich Smetana at birth, but adopting the more authentically ‘Czech’ version in adolescence – who is, by common consent, ‘the Father of Czech music’. Without him, we would have had no Dvořák, no Janáček, no Suk, no Martinů (or at least, not taking the forms of expression that their music adopted). In fact, there is a long and rich tradition of ‘Bohemian’ composers who flourished during the 18th and early 19th centuries in that area of the Habsburg Empire, so in that sense Smetana’s music did not emerge out of nowhere, but his compositions were the first to articulate a distinctively Czech nationalist voice in music, as part of a tradition in 19th century music that was the equivalent of, say, the work of Grieg in Norway, or Sibelius in Finland, or the ‘nationalist’ school of Mussorgsky, Balakirev, Borodin and so on in Russia. After a quietly provincial upbringing, Smetana made his way to Prague in his later teens, where his nationalist interests culminated initially in a brush with the authorities in the 1848 uprising. In the next decade he gained the support of that musical revolutionary, Franz Liszt, and wrote a considerable amount of piano music (largely collections of short dance pieces), but his life was scarred by family tragedies – the deaths of three daughters between 1854-6 and the diagnosis of his wife’s tuberculosis (she was to die in 1859). Disenchanted with Prague, Smetana left for Sweden, where he gained some success as a writer of ‘programmatic’ orchestral pieces (symphonic poems derived from Liszt’s models), but it was on his return to Prague in the early 1860s, arriving at a time when a slightly more liberal mood had replaced the earlier political repression, that Smetana found his moment. He wrote a ‘nationalist’ opera, ‘The Brandenburgers in Bohemia’, to considerable popular success. Then came the work that made his name, the opera ‘The Bartered Bride’, and by the end of the 1860s he was conductor of the new Provisional Theatre in Prague. However, at what should have been the time of his greatest triumph in the early 1870s his health began to fail him, notably the sudden and almost total deafness that laid him low in 1874. Syphilis was almost certainly the underlying cause. By the late 1870s he was experiencing symptoms of dementia, insomnia and hallucinations, and his last years were spent in an asylum. However, it’s also the case that in the final decade of his life he produced a series of musical masterpieces which have established his reputation – notably the autobiographical 1st String Quartet (with its anguished musical representation of the tinnitus he suffered), pieces for violin and piano called ‘From my Homeland’, and most famously of all the cycle of six symphonic poems ‘Ma Vlast’ (‘My Country’), written in the 1870s and premiered in 1882. These have assumed an authentically iconic place in Czech musical culture, the works opening the Prague Spring Music Festival every year since 1952, and speaking of national defiance in the face of external oppression – there’s a genuinely tear-jerking performance given by the Czech Philharmonic in 1939 as the Nazis invaded the country, and an equally powerful one in 1990 after the Velvet Revolution led to the Soviet withdrawal. The six pieces depict different aspects of the Czech landscape, culture and history. The most popular of them, and the one that is often played apart from the rest (as in the Hallé’s concert here in Sheffield next month) is ‘Vltava’, a depiction of the river that starts as two small springs and turns into the powerful watercourse that runs through Prague before, eventually, joining the Elbe. This piece evokes very powerful memories for me: as a 15-year-old, I first encountered it on my O-level Music syllabus, and it was the first time I’d really studied a piece of music with a programmatic (almost literally ‘illustrative’) content. Listening to it, you can hear very clearly the initial streamlets (on flutes) before the river finds its momentum in the work’s most famous tune. Then we pass folk-dancing villagers, a slow moonlit calm stretch, the St John’s Rapids (now, sadly, submerged under a reservoir) and finally the triumphant entry into Prague. It’s an old warhorse of a piece, I guess, but (for me, anyway) a joy at every listening. There are quite a lot of good video performances of the work on YouTube, though also a few that are stodgily slow. I’ve chosen one of the sparkier ones, given by the Bamberg Symphony Orchestra directed by the young Czech conductor Jakub Hrůša. You’ll find it here: Smetana: 'Vltava' (from 'Ma Vlast')
Day 386: String Quartet No 1 ('From My Life') (Time: 29 minutes)
This year’s Bradfield Festival is imminent, so today (9/6/23) I want to feature a piece from the opening concert, to be given by the renowned Doric String Quartet. We’ve had music by Smetana just the once on this list before – see Day 287 for the evergreen symphonic poem ‘Vltava’ – and for that posting, I sketched in a considerable amount of biographical detail, so I won’t repeat all that here... Except to say that the year 1874, in which Smetana’s health rapidly deteriorated, due to the impact of syphilis on his system, is crucial not just for what happened to Smetana personally and musically for the rest of his life, but also for the fact that it prompted what was to become his first string quartet. Smetana wrote very little chamber music, but what he did produce has very strong personal, emotional significance. There’s his Piano Trio in G Minor – written in 1856 and a response to the sudden death of one of his daughters. There’s a Second String Quartet – a product of Smetana’s very last years, when he was confined to an asylum, and which is a fragmented and disorderly (but somehow radiantly alive) depiction of his struggles to continue to create as his faculties disintegrated. And then there’s today’s work, which Smetana himself subtitled ‘From My Life’, making its autobiographical meaning very explicit. In 1874, at the age of 50, Smetana was, to use a cliché, at the height of his powers – by some distance the most respected composer in the Czech lands, Director of the Provisional Theatre in Prague, and a critical and popular success as a composer of ‘nationalist’ operas. But in that year, the collapse of his health was sudden and dramatic. He went from a muffled awareness of a rushing sound in his ears, and strange alterations in the pitching of octaves, to almost complete deafness, all in a period of about six months. He resigned his post at the opera house, retreated from Prague to the relative peace of the village of Jabkenice in the Bohemian countryside, and tried to continue his life as a composer. The results are by any standards extraordinary – the flowering of great works in the last decade of his life before his death in 1884 consists of, in effect, pretty much all the works by which his posthumous reputation has been sustained. And one of those works, begun in late 1876 and first performed a couple of years later (Dvorak played the viola on that occasion), is his String Quartet No 1. Now, traditionally chamber music is usually seen as ‘abstract’ music, and the string quartet is, it is often argued, the ‘purest’ of the various forms that chamber music takes. So for Smetana to call his quartet ‘From My Life’, and to make it ‘about’ aspects of his life, was to mark a radical departure. (Maybe this is a Czech thing – think of, in the years that followed, Dvorak’s ‘American’ quartet, or Janacek’s ‘Intimate Letters’ quartet.) Smetana wrote a substantial letter to a friend, Josef Srb-Debrnov, about this quartet, and I see no reason not to quote it at length. ‘My intention was to paint a tone picture of my life. The first movement depicts my youthful leanings toward art, the Romantic atmosphere, the inexpressible yearning for something I could neither express nor define, and also a kind of warning of my future misfortune . . . The long insistent note in the finale owes its origin to this. It is the fateful ringing in my ears of the high-pitched tones which in 1874 announced the beginning of my deafness. I permitted myself this little joke, because it was so disastrous to me. The second movement, a quasi- polka, brings to mind the joyful days of youth when I composed dance tunes and was known everywhere as a passionate lover of dancing. The third movement . . . reminds me of the happiness of my first love, the girl who later became my wife. The fourth movement describes the discovery that I could treat national elements in music and my joy in following this path until it was checked by the catastrophe of the onset of my deafness, the outlook into the sad future, the tiny rays of hope of recovery, but remembering all the promise of my early career, a feeling of painful regret.’ Although the quartet has the conventional four movements, it sidesteps ‘normal forms’, if you like, from the dramatic, rather declamatory viola phrase over oscillating strings that opens the work, which depicts the power of fate, through the very overtly nationalist polka of the second movement, and the tender description of his love for his first wife (another tragic death among many in Smetana’s family) in the third movement, before we arrive at the unnerving, persistent high E on the first violin in the last movement, depicting his tinnitus. There may be defiance in this last movement, but the return of the ‘fate’ motif in the subdued coda that ends the work is Smetana’s recognition of the fact that his life had changed for ever. There are a lot of performances of this work on YouTube, so if you don’t find the one I’ve chosen to your taste (the sound is a bit bright, I think) there are plenty of others. But I’ve gone for a recording made by the musicians who took the composer’s own name, the Smetana Quartet, which you’ll find here: Smetana: String Quartet No 1 ('From My Life')
Day 427: Piano Trio in G Minor, Op 15 (1st movement) (Time: 11 minutes)
We’ve heard from Smetana twice before on this list – the indestructible ‘Vltava’ (from ‘Ma Vlast’) on Day 287, and the rather anguished autobiographical String Quartet No 1 on Day 386. Today (7/11/23), the chosen work is also a product of events in Smetana’s life, and it too is a work born out of distress. This is Smetana’s only Piano Trio, Op 15. I wrote about Smetana’s life in quite a bit of detail in those earlier postings, but since both pieces previously added to the playlist come from the 1870s, when Smetana was both the most famous Czech composer of the time and also deep in the distressing throes of the mental collapse (caused by syphilis) that was to wreck the last 15 years or so of his life, my primary focus in those previous notes was on those closing years. Today’s work dates from 1855, so we are at a considerably earlier stage in Smetana’s development. Smetana was a 24-year-old in 1848 when Prague, like most of the other cities of the Habsburg Empire, was the focus of democratic revolution. Smetana was, briefly, involved in the uprising, though he avoided periods in prison, or worse. In the years that followed Smetana channelled his patriotism into the establishment of a Piano Institute, initially in Prague, to celebrate a distinctively Czech approach to music, and especially to composition – and Smetana backed this himself as a newly-established composer by producing substantial quantities of folk-influenced collections of Czech dances for piano. The early 1850 was, to start with, also a period of personal joy and happiness – he married a childhood sweetheart, Kateřina Kolářová, in 1849, and they became the parents of four daughters in fairly quick succession. However, in June 1854 the couple’s second daughter, Gabriela, died, and in September 1855 the eldest daughter, Bedřiška, died too. Even more terribly, the fourth daughter, Kateřina, who had been born only a fortnight before Bedřiška’s death, was to die the year after. If one might think things could surely not get worse, Smetana’s wife (and, very clearly, the love of his life) was diagnosed with tuberculosis in 1856, and she too was dead before the decade was out. Unsurprisingly, this crushing series of blows had a devastating impact on Smetana, and the Piano Trio was one of his responses to the experience. He began work on the Piano Trio in 1855, immediately after the death of Bedřiška, and the piece is dedicated to her, ‘in memory of our eldest child Bedřiška, whose rare musical talent gave us such delight; too early snatched from us by death at the age of four and a half years.’ Unsurprisingly, the work is suffused with a grief that Smetana sought to express in music. It’s in G Minor pretty much throughout, and when major keys are reached the feeling is largely of a kind of temporary relief rather than anything more secure. Many of the work’s themes have ‘falling’ phrases, as though the music were sighing or weeping. In fact, Smetana never revealed a ‘programme’ for this piece (as he did, for instance, with the String Quartet No 1, ‘From My Life’), so in a sense the desolation remains more abstract. In truth, there’s not much sunshine in any of the three movements of the work, but the first (which is what I’m about to post a link to) is the most tragic of the three. We begin, ‘espressivo’, on the solo violin, which sets the tone from the outset. There is, perhaps, a hint of something a little more consolatory from the cello’s second theme – allegedly this was an older melody Smetana had composed, and one that his daughter Bedřiška had particularly loved. As the movement progresses, there are hints of Smetana’s compositional influences: there’s a section for piano solo in the middle of the movement that sounds very like Chopin, and later a passage in a dotted rhythm that’s reminiscent of Schumann, who influenced Smetana’s early work considerably. However, by the end of the movement we are back in a stark mood of tragedy. (I’m not featuring the second and third movements today, but if you want to find a recording of the whole piece, what comes next is a lively scherzo with two contrasting central sections, and then a finale with a fizzing energetic opening - the theme taken from a piano sonata Smetana wrote a decade earlier as a teenager - and a contrasting lyrical cello theme, before a funereal section takes us back to the emotion of the work’s opening.) Smetana revised the whole piece several times after its first (fairly underwhelming) performance in December 1855, initially for another performance the following year, before it was finally published as late as 1880. Performances of the whole Piano Trio in G Minor are pretty common on YouTube, but it’s harder to get a decent recording of just the first movement. However, I’ve found a video of a performance given in Zagreb in 2007 by three female performers (not, as far as I know, an established piano trio), Susanna Henkel on violin, Monika Leskovar on cello, and Milana Chernyavska on piano. It’s a powerful performance, I think, and it’s easy enough to find their recordings of the other two movements if you want to experience the rest of the work. You’ll find the opening movement here: Smetana: Piano Trio in G Minor, Op 15 (1st movement)
Day 460: From Bohemia's Woods and Fields (from 'Ma Vlast) (Time: 14 minutes)
and
From My Homeland (12 minutes)
Today (1/3/24), we celebrate the 200th anniversary of the birth of the composer who is widely known as the father of Czech music. His birthday is actually tomorrow, 2nd March, but this is as close as I can get. We’ve had three pieces of Smetana so far on this list (see Day 287, above, for the evergreen tone poem ‘Vltava’, Day 386 for the autobiographical String Quartet No 1, and Day 427 for the equally personally-inspired Piano Trio, or at least the first movement of it). The notes I wrote for those occasions cover pretty much all I’d want to say about Smetana’s life, and the connections between key events in it and the music that emerged as a result. So for now, I’m just going to unpick the background to a couple of pieces. Firstly, probably the second most famous piece from his great cycle of symphonic poems that Smetana called ‘Ma Vlast’ (or ‘My Homeland’). As I wrote when exploring ‘Vltava’ (the most famous piece from … etc.), ‘Ma Vlast’ occupies a special place in Czech music, and its six separate movements highlight, for Czechs, significant aspects of the landscape, history and national myth of their homeland. A product of Smetana’s final decade, when deafness and dementia beset him, you’d never know what he was suffering just by listening to this radiant music. He originally conceived an orchestral work in four movements, and these four sections (‘Vyšehrad’, ‘Vltava’, ‘Šarka’ and ‘Z českých luhů a hájů’) were completed in 1874-5, and given a first performance in that form in 1875. Only later did Smetana add two more movements (‘Tábor’ and ‘Blaník’), and the whole cycle was then presented for the first time in 1882. The movement I wanted to home in on today is the fourth one, the one originally intended as the finale of a four-movement work. Its Czech title is variously translated into English as ‘From Bohemia’s Woods and Fields’ or ‘From Bohemian Fields and Groves’ among others, but whatever one chooses to call it, what’s clear from listening to it is the extent to which it exudes a deep and intense joy in the Czech countryside and spirit. Unlike most of the other symphonic poems in the cycle, this one tells no particular ‘story’. Instead it’s a kind of pastoral depiction, an evocation of the beauty of the Czech landscape amid the scents and breezes of a summer’s day. Smetana himself produced introductory notes for the work: ‘It is a painting of the feelings that fill one when gazing at the Bohemian landscape. On all sides singing, both gay and melancholic, resounds from fields and woods, the forest regions, depicted in the individual parts of the work.’ The opening is, I think, one of the most thrilling in 19th century music, a flood of sound, almost oceanic (an odd thought in relation to the landlocked Czech location) in its swelling intensity. There’s a musical complexity here that goes beyond mere picture-painting, as Smetana generates a lively, capricious fugue with lots of false starts, as though what we hear is the overwhelming creative power of nature breaking the confines of anything too orderly in the texture. Further down the line there is dance music, a kind of folk festival that becomes, by the end, something more like an intoxicated knees-up! It’s a work that’s a joy from beginning to end. YouTube has several notable performances, but I’ve gone for one by the Chamber Orchestra of Europe, conducted by Nikolaus Harnoncourt. You’ll find it here: Smetana: From Bohemia's Woods and Fields (from 'Ma Vlast). The other work I thought I’d choose to celebrate Smetana’s significant birthday is actually a pair of pieces, two movements for violin and piano which have the collective title ‘From My Homeland’ (in Czech, ‘Z domoviny’). Smetana wrote these in 1879-80, so we are by this point very close to the end of Smetana’s creative life (he died in 1884). Apart from three short piano pieces and four brief works for male chorus, the only significant work that post-dates ‘From My Homeland’ is the turbulent String Quartet No 2, which really does encapsulate something of the terrible ordeal of Smetana’s last years as the impact of syphilis made sustained composition almost impossible. ‘From My Homeland’ though, is, if you like, prime Smetana. He wrote of the two movements that make up the work, ‘They are written in a simple style, with a view to being performed in the home rather than at concerts….They are genuinely national in character, but with my own melodies.’ The first movement imitates Moravian folk music traditions, in the way it switches regularly from major to minor key, which generates a sense of yearning and, in the middle section, some turbulence before calm is restored. The second movement is a more complicated thing altogether, starting with something almost like an operatic recitative, before dramatic outbursts and more calm melodies appear and then seem to dissolve again. Whatever Smetana’s mental condition and his overall state of health at this stage in his life, this work shows his commitment to a joyous statement of national character which does not ignore or obliterate the shadows lying behind it but somehow absorbs these things. There are fewer video performances of this work on YouTube, but there’s a nice one by two Czech musicians, Jiří Vodička on violin, accompanied by Martin Kasík on piano. You’ll find it here: Smetana: From My Homeland
Soler, Antonio (1729-83)
Day 24: ‘Fandango’ (Time: 10 minutes)
I thought, having had quite an array of sombre and reflective music over the past ten days or so in the run up to Easter, it might be good to let our hair down today (15/4/20) (that’s clearly virtual hair for some of us) with something a bit alternative. So, this is the ‘Fandango’ by Antonio Soler, an 18th century Spanish composer whose work stands on the boundary between Baroque and Classical eras. However, the recording I’ve chosen, by the ensemble L’Arpeggiata under the direction of Christina Pluhar, gives it a jazzy and improvisatory feel. L’Arpeggiata are an interesting group. They started out doing ‘straight’ performances of ‘early music’, but over the years have branched out into an enormous range of different styles and treatments of music from 14th-21st centuries. There is a studio recording of Soler's ‘Fandango’ on the album ‘Los Pajaros Perdidos’ (which I very warmly recommend), but the option I’ve gone for in the end is a live version, which is also on YouTube. The sound quality and production aren’t as polished, but it gives a sense of how engaged they are in performance. You’ll find it here: Antonio Soler – ‘Fandango’
Spohr, Louis (1784-1859)
Day 431: Nonet in F, Op 31 (Time: 32 minutes)
History is, as I’m sure someone must have said before now, a mysterious thing – the influences on what gets recorded for posterity and what slips quietly into undiscovered obscurity are many and often, seemingly, accidental. The reason for this unwonted rumination is that today (21/11/23) we have a composer who was once regarded as a figure in German music to sit alongside Bach, Handel, Haydn, Mozart and Beethoven. The fact that Louis Spohr has, since well before his death, slipped out of those statusful ranks and become instead one of the footnotes in musical history is rather sad, I think, though one can see why it happened. Spohr (1784-1859) was fourteen years younger than Beethoven, thirteen years older than Schubert. You would think that that would put him into that familiar territory where ‘Classical’ music was very very gradually giving way to what we nowadays regard as the ‘Romantic’ era. With hindsight, the music of Beethoven and Schubert was evidently in the process of shattering the boundaries of ‘classicism’. On the other side of that divide, we can see in the music of, say, Mendelssohn, Schumann and Chopin that we are very definitely and securely in ‘early Romanticism’. But what of those ‘transitional’ people in the space between the two groups, especially if they outlived – as Spohr did – the ‘Romantics’ whose music rendered his out of date? In that collection, we’ll find Weber (who may well have gone on to greater things, had he not died so young), Hummel, Moscheles, Onslow – none of these big box office names now, even though they filled concert halls and salons across Europe in their day – and Spohr himself. Spohr first came to attention as a youthful prodigy on the violin, and in fact, he remained devoted to composing for the instrument: he wrote 18 violin concertos, many more than anyone else in this period in musical history. His Opus 1 (a violin concerto, funnily enough) dates from 1803, but he was soon pushing the boundaries of ‘classical’ form in some unusual ways. There are ‘one movement’ violin concertos, for example, and he was an early adopter of ‘programmatic’ music. His Symphony No 6, for instance, the ‘Historical Symphony’, has four movements which imitate the style of musical compositions from Bach’s day to Spohr’s own; the Symphony No 7’s four movements depict the four seasons. In that sense, we can see him as a kind of precursor of Liszt, even if they don’t come close to each other stylistically. All of this should, in theory, make Spohr an interesting and often revolutionary composer. But (and I’m sure you could tell there was one of those coming) his music is, in the end, just a tad predictable, and only occasionally do we encounter pieces in his output which still have the freshness of something new and arresting about them. Part of his ‘experimentalism’ was to compose pieces for unusual combinations of instruments, and this is how we get to my piece for today (and Ensemble 360’s concert this month) Spohr’s Nonet, Op 31, a work which dates from 1813. He wrote it for a violinist-turned-impresario, Johann Tost (the person for whom both Haydn and Mozart wrote string quartets in their time). Tost asked for a piece for the five conventional members of a wind quintet (one each of flute, oboe, clarinet, bassoon and French horn) and four strings (one each of violin, viola, cello and double bass). In his autobiography Spohr wrote, ‘I felt attracted by the difficulty of the task … and began work at once. [Tost] invited the finest artists in Vienna to his home in order to study it under my direction. It was then performed at one of the first musical parties at the start of winter and met with such unanimous applause that it was repeated frequently during the season.’ In fact, the piece seems to have become something of a calling card for Spohr. His autobiography contains another anecdote, of a trip to Paris, where Spohr intended to call on a M. Vogel, who was not at home, but ‘Mme. Vogel met me in a very cordial manner. When I told her my name her face became animated and she anxiously asked whether I was the composer of the Nonet, the opening theme of which she sang to me. As I smilingly replied “yes”, with an outburst of French vivacity she threw her arms around my neck and exclaimed, “Oh, how delighted my husband will be; he’s just crazy about your Nonet!”’ The piece seems to be one of the few that survived Spohr’s fall from fashion in the mid-19th century, a state of affairs exacerbated by the fact that he and his work were blacklisted by the Nazis on grounds of Jewish influence on his music and the ‘racial mixture’ of relationships in his opera ‘Jessonda’. The Nonet is in four movements, and that there’s more to this than just pretty tunes and decorative scoring is evident from the fact that Spohr uses the work’s opening four-note motif into three of the four movements. It’s not a work which plumbs many emotional depths, but it’s a hugely enjoyable piece brimming with vitality, and if nothing else it gives all the instruments their moments in the spotlight to show off their distinctive characters. There are quite a few recordings to choose from on YouTube, but I’ve gone for one by (as far as I can tell) an ‘put together for the occasion’ ensemble made up of players from two of Russia’s major orchestras, the St Petersburg Phil and the Mariinsky Orchestra. Their performance, in this video recording, dates from 2018, and you’ll find it here: Spohr: Nonet in F, Op 31
Stanford, Charles Villiers (1852-1924)
Day 302: Clarinet Sonata, Op 129 - 1. Allegro Moderato (Time: 8 minutes), 2. Caoine: Adagio Quasi Fantasia (6 minutes) and 3. Allegretto Grazioso (6 minutes)
Stanford (1852-1924) was one of the pillars of the later Victorian musical establishment in England. He was born in Dublin, and although he is best known these days as a composer of Anglican church music, there is a flavour of ‘Irishness’ running through much of his work, notably the Clarinet Sonata I’ve chosen to consider today (17/6/22). Stanford came from a well-to-do family, and though his father would have preferred him to pursue a career in the law, he was unequivocally backed in his musical studies. He made an immediate impression at Cambridge, notably as an organist. After graduation, studies in Germany followed, unhappily with Reinecke in Leipzig, but then more congenially with Friedrich Kiel (see Day 230!) in Berlin. The most significant development from this time was his wholehearted commitment to the Schumann/Brahms ‘traditionalist’ faction in Austro-German music (he didn’t reject Wagner or Liszt entirely, but did little to promote them in his teaching or to emulate them in his own music). Probably it was the urge to be taken seriously as an operatic composer that proved to be his greatest disappointment, though he also struggled to break through as a symphonist, despite writing seven of them during his lifetime. In fact, although he evidently composed consistently throughout his life, he was probably better known as an academic and teacher. By 1887, so still in his mid-thirties, he was Professor of Music at Cambridge, by which point he was also Professor of Composition at the newly-formed Royal College of Music in London. His list of pupils is like a roll-call of famous British composers of the next half-century: Vaughan Williams, Holst, Ireland, Bridge, Bliss, Howells and so on. He seems to have been, according to the general consensus, a ‘difficult’ teacher, conservative and dogmatic. (The caricature is that he fed his pupils on a diet of ‘Brahms and water’.) By the end of the first decade of the 20th century, his reputation was fading. He had no sympathies at all with ‘modern music’, scorning European developments by the likes of Debussy or Richard Strauss. Musically his reputation in England was eclipsed by that of Elgar, and by the time of his death in 1924 his work (apart from a rich body of Anglican choral music and the occasional part-song such as ‘The Blue Bird’) had pretty much disappeared. I have the sense that in writing all this, I’m not making much of a case for why Stanford deserves to be listened to, but I think his chamber music is always impressively constructed and argued and occasionally feels like the expression of a unique ‘voice’. There are eight string quartets, two string quintets, three piano trios, two piano quartets and a piano quintet, three violin sonatas, two cello sonatas, three late pieces for clarinet or horn with string quartet called ‘Fantasies’, and today’s piece, the Clarinet Sonata Op 129, dating from 1911/12. It’s in three movements, the outer ones particularly Brahmsian in their language. The piece begins with a straightforward sonata-form movement, but the second, titled ‘Caoine’ (‘Keen’) is an Irish lament, full of mournful clarinet runs, while the piano figuration imitates the Irish harp. The last movement (with its very Brahms-like marking ‘Allegretto grazioso’) is genial and elegant, before the piece ends in a mood of hushed tranquillity. There aren’t any terribly convincing performances of this on video on YouTube, so I’ve gone for an audio-only recording, given by the clarinettist (and latest member of Ensemble 360!) Robert Plane, with Benjamin Frith on piano. You’ll find it here, unfortunately in three separate links: Stanford: Clarinet Sonata, Op 129 - 1. Allegro Moderato, 2. Caoine: Adagio Quasi Fantasia and 3. Allegretto Grazioso
Day 467: Concert Variations on 'Down among the Dead Men', Op71 (Time: 27 minutes)
Exactly 100 years ago today (29/3/24), Sir Charles Villiers Stanford died at his home in London at the age of 71. By that point, he was both the ‘grand old man’ of Anglo-Irish music and also, rather painfully, an irrelevance to the post-First World War ‘modern age’. We’ve had one appearance by Stanford on this list to date – see Day 302 for his lovely Clarinet Sonata (both Brahmsian and also touchingly Irish in its mournful slow movement) – so another one is due. Given that I surveyed his life story in that posting, do refer back to it to find out more. But I thought that today I’d just home in on what was happening in Stanford’s life in the run up to the composition of the (fairly obscure!) work I’ve chosen here. So, picking up Stanford’s story in the later 1890s, at that point he was, in terms of reputation, most obviously ‘Stanford the Professor’, rather than a leading composer – Professor of Music at Cambridge, Professor of Composition at the Royal College of Music. Still, at that stage he had nevertheless already composed a great deal: five symphonies, at least five operas (some now lost), two violin sonatas, three string quartets, a piano concerto, two cello sonatas, a great deal of incidental music for the stage, many collections of songs for voice and piano, a substantial amount of Anglican church music, at least three oratorios and other large-scale religious choral works (the Mass in G, the Requiem and the Te Deum). In other words, an awful lot of music had been composed, if not necessarily published, by this stage. In fact, the final years of the 19th century were probably Stanford’s most fruitful time as a composer, even though his academic work consumed a lot of his energy. And this brings me to today’s piece, which has a somewhat cumbersome title: Concert Variations upon an English Theme, ‘Down Among the Dead Men’, for Piano and Orchestra, Op 71. When I was thinking about what to choose to commemorate the centenary of Stanford’s death, I wondered about selecting some of the Anglican church music, or the symphonies (now recorded several times over after decades of neglect) or the chamber music (ditto). But even more neglected than all these are Stanford’s works in ‘concerto’ form. He wasn’t by training a pianist, which might suggest why his piano concertos don’t really hold a place in the repertoire, but the ‘Concert Variations’ (which belong, chronologically, between the two piano concertos) take a different approach, not least because the melody is a traditional one, and what Stanford does with it is quite interesting. The source material is a drinking song, first published in the early 18th century but almost certainly older than that. The lyrics aren’t all that sophisticated, being in essence a celebration of drink, and particularly the connection between drink and opportunities for sex, and all the verses end with a rousing rejection of anyone who might deny the attractions of alcohol: ‘Down among the dead men, down among the dead men,/ Down, down, down, down;/ Down among the dead men let him lie!’ No ambiguity there, then! Stanford (an Irishman, don’t forget) had a strong attachment to folk songs all his life, and set or arranged them many times, mostly Irish ones, but also others from elsewhere in the British Isles. Stanford’s composition takes the form of an Introduction and Theme, followed by 12 Variations, the last of which forms an extended finale to the work as a whole. The work is a kind of cross between a piano concerto and a ‘symphonic’ set of variations (Stanford would have been familiar with pieces like Brahms’ ‘Haydn Variations’ or Dvorak’s Symphonic Variations). I’ve seen discussion of the work that suggests it’s a very complex combination of sonata form (the traditional formal structure behind the first movement of a symphony) and variation, and also other comments interpreting it as a ‘four movement’ structure – first movement, scherzo, slow movement, finale – like a symphony in miniature. Does any of this matter? Probably not, except to say that it’s not just ‘one thing after another’, and also not (as many sets of variations in the 19th century were) just an excuse for the soloist to show off. It was written for Leonard Borwick, apparently the leading British pianist of the day, and it certainly survived in the repertoire for a decade or so, championed by Percy Grainger (see Day 164!). After a sombre introduction, which makes use of a four-note falling theme that keeps recurring throughout the piece as a kind of cohesive device, the theme is first presented by the orchestra alone. The faster variations have an ‘Irish’, ‘jiggy’ quality to them at times, but set against these there are more poetic and meditative moments, notably in the penultimate ‘Lento’ variation. I don’t want to make any claims for this being a lost masterpiece or anything so grand, but I do think it’s a work that deserves more than an occasional outing, and at the very least it’s an example of Stanford at the peak of his career, before the 20th century came along and, rather sadly, made him almost instantly old-fashioned. Performances of a work so obscure are, unsurprisingly, rare, and YouTube has nothing on video, so this is an audio-only choice – even there, most of the options don’t allow me to give you a single link to the whole work, but isolate each variation in turn. However, there’s a recording of the Irish pianist Finghin Collins, performing with the RTÉ National Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Kenneth Montgomery, and it’s that performance that you’ll find here: Stanford: Concert Variations on 'Down among the Dead Men', Op71
Stenhammar, Wilhelm (1871-1927)
Day 160: Serenade in F, Op 31: Movements 4 – Notturno (Time: 8 minutes) and 5. Finale (10 minutes)
In the second of two postings featuring Swedish music, today’s subject would have been 150 years old this coming Sunday (7th February 2021), which seems as good a reason as any to mark his contribution to Swedish music. He is Wilhelm Stenhammar (1871-1927), who was probably the foremost Swedish composer in the first couple of decades of the 20th century. Aside from his compositional prowess, he would have been a major musical figure in his country because he took over the reins of the Gothenburg Symphony Orchestra, Sweden’s first professional ensemble, two years after its foundation, and was its principal conductor from 1907-22, during which time he championed contemporary Swedish music in ways that put it on the map across the rest of Europe. He was never in robust health, and he died of a stroke in his mid-50s. He did not leave an immense output of compositions, and there are evidently ways in which his music seems ‘transitional’: his earlier compositions, such as a very sprawling Symphony No 1 and similarly overblown Piano Concerto No 1, are lushly late-Romantic in style. However, the key event in his creative life was encountering a performance of Sibelius’ Symphony No 2, which set him on a more ‘nationalist’ and also more pared-down creative route over the next two decades. I’m just in the process of discovering his six string quartets, which are getting a lot of air-time on my Spotify account. They’re wonderful ‘halfway between Beethoven and Sibelius’ creations, and very sadly overlooked by chamber groups. However, the music I thought I’d feature for today 5/2/21) comes from his Serenade in F for Orchestra, Op 31. Now, giving a piece the title ‘serenade’ seems to be setting it up as something rather decorative but ultimately insubstantial, I reckon, but Stenhammar’s Serenade is a large-scale and emotionally varied work in five movements (originally six, but after its first performance in 1913 he withdrew the work, deleted one of its movements and rewrote a lot of the rest). In its revised 1919 version, this seems to me to be genial but not superficial. I’d echo one reviewer who called it ‘immensely civilised music’, fresh and spontaneous-sounding. I’ve chosen the final two movements for us to listen to. The fourth movement ‘Notturno’ is a lovely slow movement full of restrained lyricism, and the Finale bubbles over with good-natured happiness before seeming to disappear with a playful smile. As for a performance, there’s a really good one from the Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra conducted by the genial Herbert Blomstedt when he was a mere 83 years old! You’ll find the recordings here: Stenhammar: Serenade in F, Op 31 - 4. Notturno and here: 5. Finale
Stockhausen, Karlheinz (1928-2007)
Day 399: Stimmung (extract, and discussion) (Time: 9 minutes)
First today (25/7/23) a bit of background. At the end of last year I had a brief email exchange with the Rev Malcolm Lambert, once of this parish – and very definitely still of this playlist community. Amongst other things, we mused on the sorts of composer who wouldn’t appear on this list, for whatever reason. I wondered about Stockhausen, which led Malcolm into a brief reminiscence, about hearing a Proms performance of Stockhausen’s ‘Stimmung’ while he was a student in the late 1970s. He said, and I quote him, ‘I still think it’s beautiful’. Stockhausen is … interesting. That is, he was one of those composers whose approach to music was relentlessly challenging – experimental, for sure, but also restless and exploratory, not to mention, from time to time, absolutely bonkers. Karlheinz Stockhausen (1928-2007) was born near Cologne, and had a complex upbringing. His mother had a breakdown after the birth of her third child and was institutionalised. Later in life Stockhausen, having been told that she’d died of leukemia when he was twelve, found out that she was actually gassed by the Nazis, along with 89 others with mental health issues in her asylum, during the Second World War. (He dramatised this in a scene from one of the operas in his ‘Licht’ cycle much later.) After the war he studied music, and was quickly attracted to the developing experimental electronic music scene in Cologne. Stockhausen is one of those figures in modern music whose name has entered popular culture. You may know that his face appears on the cover of The Beatles’ ‘Sgt. Pepper’ album, and you can’t get much more ‘zeitgeisty’ than that. It’s been suggested that ‘A Day in the Life’ from ‘Sgt. Pepper’ in 1967, and ‘Revolution 9’ from the Beatles’ eponymous double album of the following year, bear the direct impact of Stockhausen’s ideas. In fact, lots of jazz and popular musicians claim the influence of Stockhausen on their work, some more plausibly than others: Miles Davis, Charles Mingus, Frank Zappa, Can and Kraftwerk, perhaps; Pink Floyd and The Who, perhaps less so. His musical output from the 1950s onwards is immense, and certainly nothing seems to have stopped him from engaging with works so ambitious as to be unlikely to get many performances. The most epic opus from his later years is his huge seven opera cycle ‘Licht’ (‘The Seven Days of the Week’). Maybe one of the most notorious is his ‘Helikopter-Streichquartette’ – actually a scene from the ‘Wednesday’ opera in his ‘Licht’ cycle. It’s a composition for the four members of a string quartet, flying in separate helicopters, and the sounds they play are recorded alongside the sounds of the helicopters in flight, relayed along with videos of the players in action into the concert hall where the ‘performance’ is taking place. (If you’ve seen any videos of this, it feels a bit like watching a scene from ‘Apocalypse Now’, only without Wagner in the background.) In the interests of balance, I should point out that quite a few 20th/21st century musicians have been less than enamoured with Stockhausen and his work. Sir Thomas Beecham, always one for a quotable quote, as I’ve noted before, was once asked ‘Have you heard any Stockhausen?’ – to which he allegedly replied, ‘No, but I believe I’ve trodden in some.’ So, moving on… ‘Stimmung’ is a work from 1968, and is scored for six amplified solo singers (three male, three female), whose voices are electronically manipulated. The title is rich in ambiguity. To quote Stockhausen himself, it ‘means "tuning," but it really should be translated with many other words because Stimmung incorporates the meanings of the tuning of a piano, the tuning of the voice, the tuning of a group of people, the tuning of the soul. This is all in the German word. Also, when you say: We're in a good Stimmung, you mean a good psychological tuning, being well tuned together.’ The work is based on the concept of vocal harmonics, or ‘overtones’ – the sorts of sound you might otherwise associate with vocal performances from the Mongolian steppes. Now, I’m not intending to get bogged down in the theory of all this, but put very very simply, any note produced will also generate ‘sympathetic’ harmonics higher up the scale, and these in their turn form the basis for other ‘patterns’ of harmonics. The whole piece is rooted in the note Bb (the one you’ll find in the lower half of the bass clef) and a selection of the overtones arising from it – F, Bb, D, Ab and C, going up the scale. The piece is in 51 different sections (what Stockhausen called ‘moments’), and there is enough freedom in the score for performances to differ from each other both in content and length. Each ‘moment’ is led by one of the singers – each male singer leads eight sections, each female singer leads nine. A programme note by the performers of ‘Singcircle’, who have presented this work many times over the years, says this: ‘Some of the other singers gradually have to transform their own material until they have come into “identity” with the lead singer of the section, by adopting the same tempo, rhythm and dynamics. When the lead singer feels that “identity” has been reached, he or she makes a gesture to another singer who leads the next section. Each model is a set of rhythmic phonetic patterns, often with actual words used as their basis, such as “Hallelujah” or “Saturday”. In 29 of the sections, “magic names” are called out. These are the names of gods and goddesses from many cultures - Aztec, aboriginal and Ancient Greek, for instance - and have to be incorporated into the character of the model. The erotic and intimate love-poems that are recited were written by Stockhausen “during amorous days” in 1967.’ (This last detail seems to me to be the least convincing. In translation they sound like the work of a teenage boy who’s just discovered William Burroughs.) Performances of ‘Stimmung’ typically last for 70-75 minutes, which makes the whole piece clearly unsuitable for this playlist. I agreed with Malcolm that it would be good to give a flavour of the whole thing, and then if anyone wants to explore further there are other links on YouTube. So, what you have here is an extract from a performance by the vocal ensemble Nordic Voices, but interspersed with a post-performance chat between the performers and Stockhausen’s daughter Christel. The video of ‘Stimmung’ suggests another feature typical of the work – the element of ritual or ceremony. It is typical for performers to dress similarly and to sit in a circle round a central light source. You’ll find the combined extract and discussion here: Stockhausen: Stimmung (extract, and discussion)
Strauss II, Johann (1825-99)
Day 150: Roses from the South (arr. Schoenberg) (Time: 10 minutes)
In the world of light classical music, New Year’s Day is pretty much synonymous with the music of ‘the waltz king’,
Johann Strauss II (1825-99), so I thought it only right that the landmark 150th posting on this playlist should be devoted to
a piece by the man himself. Strauss, as many of you will know, was but one member of a dynasty that held sway over the dance halls
and concert halls of 19th century Vienna (and beyond). Estimates vary, but he is credited with composing over 500 waltzes,
polkas and the like, as well as many operettas, some of which (like ‘Die Fledermaus’ and ‘Die Zigeunerbaron’)
have maintained their place in the repertoire. Although a lot of Strauss’s work might be regarded as a kind of popular market
‘note spinning’, there is no doubt that he raised this sort of dance music to something close to a prestige art form.
(It is well known that Brahms, on signing the autograph-fan – presumably a fashionable analogue to the more conventional
autograph book – of Strauss’ step-daughter, wrote out the opening bars of ‘The Blue Danube’, and then signed it
‘Unfortunately not by Johannes Brahms’.) Strauss's compositional career began in the 1840s, and he founded his own orchestra
as a challenge to that of his father Johann Strauss I, in a kind of competitive ‘dance off’. As the century wore on,
the younger Strauss’s music could be heard across the world, as he and his orchestra toured across Europe, Russia and even the USA.
The composition I’ve chosen to mark the occasion is the waltz ‘Roses from the South’. This piece, Strauss's Op 388(!),
was written in 1880. It is actually a medley of tunes from his earlier operetta ‘The Queen’s Lace Handkerchief’.
The piece is, for a popular Strauss waltz, rather subdued and contemplative, though it does let its hair down towards the end.
However, I thought that rather than share with you the composition in its conventional orchestration, it might be interesting
(and, for some of you, perhaps, an entirely new experience) to encounter the piece in an arrangement for chamber ensemble
by the theoretically very scary Arnold Schoenberg. (And don’t worry, Arnie fans – I will get some authentic Schoenberg
onto this list in the not too distant future.) Schoenberg (1874-1951) was, I guess it would be fair to say,
one of those composers at the start of the 20th century who contributed most to the creation of music that
dispensed with tonality (the conventions of melody and harmony that had underpinned western music for the previous 300 years)
and led it into a brave new world in which new forms and structures were necessary to keep chaos at bay.
It may not surprise you to know that in the first two decades of the 20th century Schoenberg and his followers often struggled
to find performers and an audience for these compositions, which led him, in the Vienna of 1918,
to found the Society for Private Musical Performances. The society ran for three years, always in a fraught financial state,
and one of the fundraising ideas that Schoenberg came up with was to set up a concert in 1921 in which there would
be arrangements of Strauss waltzes for an ensemble of string quartet, piano and harmonium. Alban Berg (another day, folks!)
arranged ‘Wine, Women and Song’, Anton Webern (possibly not) arranged ‘The Treasure Waltz’, and Schoenberg himself arranged
‘Roses from the South’. In this rather more domesticated clothing, the waltz is stripped down to its essentials.
The outcome, I hope you’ll agree, is endearingly quirky. I’ve chosen a recording by the Chamber Players of the
Boston Symphony Orchestra, which you’ll find here: J Strauss II: Roses from the South (arr. Schoenberg)
Day 484: The Blue Danube Waltz (Time: 10 minutes)
Today (28/5/24), I want to feature the first of a number of postings exploring the 125th anniversaries of the births or deaths of significant composers during June 1899. First, here is ‘the Waltz King’ himself, who died on June 3rd 1899, so the actual anniversary is next Monday. We’ve already had one appearance of the second Johann Strauss – actually Johann Baptist Strauss, if we’re feeling completist – on this list to date: see Day 150 for his somewhat subdued waltz ‘Roses from the South’, though I made the slightly subversive decision to select Arnold Schoenberg’s chamber arrangement of the piece. During that posting I summarised the basic outline of Strauss’s career and his rise to prominence as the key figure at what one might call the lighter end of the classical music spectrum during the 19th century. His breakthrough moment came, rather sombrely, in 1849 when his father, Johann Strauss I (possibly not a surprise if you were wondering what he might be called), died without warning of scarlet fever. This proved his son’s big break because before then, the younger Strauss had had to deal not just with parental disapproval of his choice of career – his father had an interesting line in motivation, having whipped his son into a somewhat bloodied mess as a child in order ‘to beat the music out of him’ (it didn’t work) – but parental rivalry as the respective Strauss orchestras of father and son vied for Viennese supremacy. It wasn’t plain sailing for the younger Strauss from then onwards, partly because he had a tendency to spread himself too thinly from time to time in terms of overdoing his musical commitments, with the consequence that he was prone to exhaustion and more than one nervous breakdown. Nevertheless, he was able to see off all potential rivals as Europe’s greatest writer of dance music (these days we know about Waldteufel in Paris or Lumbye in Copenhagen, but we don’t have their tunes embedded in our psyches in the same way that we’re aware of Strauss’s music), not to mention its greatest writer (with apologies to Offenbach and, perhaps, Sir Arthur Sullivan) of operetta too. I was wondering, therefore, about what to choose to illustrate the work of such a popular composer, and in the end I could find no reason not to go for his single most popular piece of music. But first, a bit about the waltz. The Viennese version of this particular dance craze swept Europe during the 19th century – it tended to be faster in Vienna than other European cities, and consequently it was regarded as the most shocking version that might ‘infect’ the young. I love this from ‘The Times’: ‘We remarked with pain that the indecent foreign dance called the waltz was introduced at the English court. It is quite sufficient to cast one’s eyes on the voluptuous intertwining of the limbs and close compression of the bodies in their dance. We feel it a duty to warn every parent against exposing his daughter to so fatal a contagion.’ Like so many parental warnings, it proved entirely futile. As for which Strauss waltz to choose, few have had the enduring popularity or – not wishing to seem sniffy – the critical respect of ‘The Blue Danube’. This is actually ‘By the Beautiful Blue Danube’, to be precise, and it’s Strauss’s Op 314 (he wrote a lot of waltzes). In my previous Strauss posting I quoted Brahms’s regretfully-signed remark, after jotting down the waltz’s opening theme, ‘Unfortunately NOT by Johannes Brahms’ on Strauss’s step-daughter’s fan. But Brahms wasn’t the only one; even Wagner is said to have been a Strauss admirer, however hard that is to imagine. ‘The Blue Danube’, to settle for the simpler title, started life actually as a choral piece, a setting of a pretty dreadful and meanderingly long poem by the now not very well-known Hungarian/Austrian poet Karl Isidor Beck. It was composed in 1866 and got its first performance in that choral version in early 1867. It wasn’t an immediate hit, but something seems to have nagged away at Strauss to refashion it. The purely orchestral version, which is what we’re used to these days, actually got its premiere in New York, where Strauss and his orchestra were touring, in July 1867, and the rest, as the cliché goes, is history. Actually it’s a little misleading to describe ‘The Blue Danube’ as ‘a waltz’. It’s actually – pretty much like all Strauss waltzes – a series of waltzes strung together, preceded by an extended slow introduction and concluded with a quite wonderful extended coda. There are actually, by most calculations, five waltzes here, each with its own contrasting ‘middle eight’, as it were. If you were ever tempted to see Strauss as not a ‘proper’ composer, just pay attention to the final three minutes or so of this piece. It’s clear why it has become more than just a popular favourite, played at every New Year’s Day concert in Vienna since time immemorial. In years since it’s turned up serenely three-fouring away in Kubrick’s ‘2001: A Space Odyssey’ and (one for the younger readers) in the not entirely tasteful recent Netflix series ‘Squid Game’. In one of those ‘where would we be without Wikipedia’ moments, I’ve recently found that it turns up in Mexico being sung at birthday parties, with the words ‘Queremos pastel, pastel, pastel’ (a demand for birthday cake!). As a piece of music, it’s pretty indestructible. YouTube is fairly well stocked with performances of this masterpiece, and from the options I’ve gone for this version by the Vienna Phil conducted by Zubin Mehta. You’ll find it here: Strauss: The Blue Danube Waltz
Strauss, Richard (1864-1949)
Day 187: Till Eulenspiegel’s Merry Pranks (Time: 16 minutes)
Richard Strauss (1864-1949) had an immensely long compositional career; he began composing somewhere around the age of six, and was still active at the time of his death, generally being credited as the greatest example of any composer still writing significant new work in his ninth decade. (I realise there’s a bit of competition for that accolade, but I think the claim is worth making.) Inevitably, with a composer who is productive for so long, there is a sense in which perspectives on Strauss’s compositional skills shifted during his lifetime. In his early years (up to his mid-thirties, say) he was regarded as an avant-garde composer in Germany, writing ground-breaking music for orchestra and, along with Mahler, representing the final expansive flourishing of late-Romantic composition. As he moved into the 20th century, opera took precedence over orchestral work, and two operas in particular, ‘Salome’ (1905) and ‘Elektra’ (1909) cemented his position at the forefront of ‘cutting edge’, often rather shocking, experimentation. What happened next is fascinating: his next opera, ‘Der Rosenkavalier’ (1911) is generally regarded as his greatest work for the opera house, but with it, and in the ten operas of the three decades that followed, Strauss seems to have largely stopped pushing at the boundaries, as it were, and well before his last years, he had come to seem essentially conservative – prolific, but in a rather tame ‘note-spinning’ sort of way. I’ll address his ‘Indian summer’, the work of the last 10 years of his life, next time. For today (11/5/21), I want to focus on the last dozen years or so of the 19th century, when Strauss became renowned for his exploration of the musical possibilities of the ‘tone poem’ or ‘symphonic poem’. These labels might need a bit of unpicking. ‘Pictorial’ music – that is, music evoking a place or a narrative or a painting or whatever – arrived with Romanticism, and free-standing musical compositions in that vein were a feature of the orchestral output of many 19th century composers certainly from the days of Mendelssohn onwards. The high point of the genre before the work of Strauss was probably the set of symphonic poems by Liszt, but Strauss took up the challenge in a series of vivid, virtuosic works that explored ideas from erotic passion and ennui (‘Don Juan’), to life and death (‘Death and Transfiguration’), to a re-telling of Cervantes (‘Don Quixote’), to an exploration of Nietzsche’s philosophy (‘Also Sprach Zarathustra’) and many others before the final peak of a day’s climb in ‘An Alpine Symphony’. Using larger and larger forces, these works exploit the possibilities of the orchestra like no others before them. The piece I want to home in on today is in many ways the most frivolous of them, the tone poem ‘Till Eulenspiegel's Merry Pranks’, which dates from 1895. I wanted to choose this one as an illustration of Strauss's playfulness as an orchestrator. It’s based on the medieval folk character Till and his misadventures poking fun at the pomposity and hypocrisy of the institutions of his day. There are two ‘Till’ themes, one on the French horn that occurs near the beginning, and one on the clarinet. The work is episodic in structure, detailing Till’s adventures: overturning a busy market, flirting with the girls, mocking the priests of the day, galloping his way out of every crisis, until he is captured by the authorities, tried and sentenced to death by hanging. Till's joking and pleading with the hangman do him no good, and eventually (a vivid squeal from the clarinet) he is hanged. But then, as silence falls, an echo of Till's theme is heard again and the piece gallops to an end in the expectation that even though Till is dead, characters like him will reappear in the future. The piece is well represented on YouTube, and out of the many options, I’ve gone for a performance by the Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra conducted by Lorin Maazel, which you’ll find here: Strauss, R: Till Eulenspiegel's Merry Pranks
Day 188: Four Last Songs (Time: 24 minutes)
Last time out, I went for the tone poem ‘Till Eulenspiegel’ as an illustration of Strauss, the young ground-breaking orchestral composer of the late 19th century. Today (14/5/21), I want to turn the spotlight onto the other end of his career, and home in on one of the works from Strauss's 'Indian Summer' in the 1940s. To pick up some aspects of the narrative from where I left off in the previous posting, Strauss's primary identity in the first four decades of the 20th century was as an opera composer. But in the 1930s, things became complex with the rise of the Nazi government in Germany. Strauss's role here has tarnished his reputation somewhat. Unlike many other composers who fled Europe in the 1930s, usually to the USA, Strauss stayed put, and indeed accepted positions of responsibility under Nazi rule – he became President of the new Reich Music Chamber in 1933, though only for two years until he was dismissed for writing abusive comments about Nazi philistinism in a leaked private letter. However, he never joined the Nazi Party, and it is crucial to remember that much of his activity in these years was to protect his Jewish daughter-in-law and two grandchildren from persecution, a feat successfully accomplished, though tragically many members of her extended family died in the Holocaust. However, perhaps a broader reading would be to see Strauss as aiming to be (perhaps rather naively) ‘apolitical’ during these years, retreating in his late 70s/early 80s into a private realm of programme-free music. The one real exception to this idea of ‘abstract’ music is his extraordinary piece for strings 'Metamorphosen', a searing lament for the loss of German and wider European culture during the war. But other than this, the late flowering of Strauss’s genius took the form of three concertos, some chamber music for wind ensemble, and the piece I want to feature today, his 'Four Last Songs' for soprano and orchestra. Strauss had always written for the voice, and especially the soprano voice, deeply influenced by the fact that his wife since 1894 was the renowned (and apparently rather volatile) soprano Pauline De Ahna. It does not appear that Strauss conceived of the songs as a cycle, and indeed there is evidence that he originally planned a number of other settings of poems by Hermann Hesse, as well as the lyric verse 'Im Abendrot' ('At Sunset') by the 19th century poet Joseph von Eichendorff. The poems had no settled order at the time of Strauss’s death in 1949, and the title ‘Four Last Songs’ and their order in performance was fixed on by Strauss's editor at the music publisher Boosey & Hawkes. The settings are, even without the biographical context of Strauss's death the year after their composition and the year before their first performance, nostalgic and valedictory. This mood was heightened by Strauss's almost conscious ‘myth-making’ tendency in the treatment of the final song, 'Im Abendrot', when the final line of the text where the soprano sings ‘Is this perhaps death?’ is ‘answered’ by the French horn playing the ‘transfiguration’ theme from Strauss's 1890s tone poem 'Death and Transfiguration'. Two years before his death, Strauss rather self-deprecatingly said of himself, ‘I may not be a first rate composer, but I’m a first-class second rate composer.’ This is unduly harsh, I think. The calm, the resignation and the richly-achieved serenity of these Four Last Songs are the work of a composer of the highest order. As for a performance, YouTube has many that could keep you entranced for hours. However, though I’m not sure it’s the best performance, the one I’ve chosen is by that force of nature Jessye Norman, from a concert given in 1979 by the Orchestre de la Suisse Romande, conducted by Wolfgang Sawallisch. You’ll find it here: Strauss, R: Four Last Songs
Day 201: Horn Concerto No 1 (Time: 15 minutes)
Welcome to the first of a couple of postings this week that I’ve called ‘Fathers and Sons’, to highlight compositional connections amongst family members. (And apologies for any entirely unintentional gender bias: if you know of interesting parent/child musical links involving women composers, do let me know!) So, today (29/6/21), the composer in the spotlight is Richard Strauss, and I particularly want to consider the musical links with his father Franz. Strauss (1864-1949) has appeared twice on this list before (see Days 187/188), but the music for today predates the pieces selected for our shared listening back then. Musical history is replete with composers regarded as child prodigies, and Strauss surely deserves to be on such a list. He is usually credited with starting composing at the age of six (a polka for piano, though in an early indication of a lifelong passion, there are also two songs for voice and piano listed as being composed in 1870). He was nine when he first composed for orchestra, and fifteen when he composed his first piece for soloist and orchestra. However, as a composer of concertos he really got into his stride in the early 1880s, first with a Violin Concerto that is still occasionally heard in concert (dating from 1882), and the following year saw his most popular composition to date, his Horn Concerto No 1. At this point, we should consider the influence of his father, Franz Strauss, who was principal horn player at the Munich Court Opera and professor of music in the same city. Franz influenced his son's early musical creativity in many ways, most obviously because the sound of the horn was a literal fact of day-to-day life in the family home, and it generated a love for the instrument that we can hear in so many of Strauss's compositions in the following decades. However, his father also gave him a secure grounding in the Austro-German classical composers (Haydn, Mozart, Beethoven, Schubert). Franz was musically intensely conservative – he had little sympathy for Wagnerian compositional fashions, and in the young Strauss's early pieces there is little evidence of any influence more ‘modern’ than that of Mendelssohn. There is no evidence that Strauss wrote the Horn Concerto No 1 for his father (and none to show that Franz ever played the work in public), but plenty to show that Franz was influential in the compositional process. The result is a piece which gives almost no indication of Strauss's future career, but it is by some distance the most performed horn concerto of the 19th century (there’s not a lot of competition, to be fair). Mendelssohn's sound world is probably most evident in the second movement Andante. The sprightly outer movements feature lots of Eb fanfares and arpeggios, highlighting the horn's traditional ‘hunting’ qualities. To me, despite the debt to Mendelssohn, it feels fresh and youthful, a work of bright and sunny optimism. There are a number of performances on YouTube, and from them I’ve selected this version for a chamber-sized orchestra, the Tapiola Sinfonietta, conducted by Emilia Hoving. The horn soloist is Katy Woolley. You’ll find the recording here: Strauss, R: Horn Concerto No 1
Day 473: Oboe Concerto (Time: 25 minutes)
We’ve had three previous postings before today (19/4/24) of the music of Richard Strauss (see Days 187, 188 and 201) so it’s about time we had some more. Of the previous pieces, only one – the sublime ‘Four Last Songs’ of 1948 – was a composition from the last decade of Strauss’s life, the so-called ‘Indian summer’ when he created a string of works of (for the most part) serene and seemingly effortless beauty. I wrote back on Day 188 about the problematical nature of Strauss’s personal and social history in his 70s and 80s, and the ways his relationship with the Nazi regime in Germany served to render ambiguous (to say the least) his position in musical terms during those years – so I won’t rehearse all that again here. Suffice it to say that in the years from 1942 until his death in 1949 you’ll find works which seem almost to withdraw from the angst of the modern world to achieve a kind of tranquillity that’s almost timeless. (There’s one big exception to that – the grief-stricken ‘Metamorphosen’, for 23 Solo Strings, dating from 1945, which lamented the destruction of almost all the historically significant opera houses of Germany in allied bombing raids during the 2nd World War, and the more general obliteration of Dresden. I’d sincerely hope to find space on this list for that extraordinary work before too long.) Anyway, these otherwise genial last works include the Horn Concerto No 2 (1942), the Sonatina No 1 for 16 winds (1943), the Oboe Concerto (1945), the Sonatina No 2 for 16 winds (1946) and the Duett-Concertino for Clarinet and Bassoon (1947). This flourishing of music for instrumental forces is curious. There’s no other phase in Strauss’s output – not even in his early years as a composer in the 1870s and 80s – where you find such a concentration of creativity in this field. Maybe it’s a sense of escape, away from the world of opera and other settings where words play such a part, and into something ‘purer’ or more abstract. I think too (and this is no big insight, since almost all commentators say it) there’s a sense in these late works of Strauss communing with the musical spirit of Mozart, since the adjective ‘Mozartian’ is so regularly appended to these pieces. The Oboe Concerto has a singular and almost accidental genesis. Since 1906, Strauss had been living, apart from the occasional period elsewhere, in the villa he had had built in the Bavarian town of Garmisch. In April 1945, the US Army moved into the area and secured it as part of the final push back against Nazi forces as the 2nd World War neared its end. By chance, in the army unit posted to that location, there was a corporal called John de Lancie. In civilian life before the war, de Lancie had been Principal Oboe of the Pittsburgh Orchestra. Discovering that Strauss was living nearby, de Lancie visited him and, as you do, asked him if he had ever considered writing an oboe concerto. Strauss’s reply was simple: ‘No’! But something seems to have been sown in that conversation, because by September of the same year, Strauss had fashioned a short, elegant concerto for oboe and small orchestra. (That last detail is another illuminating demonstration of how ‘late’ Strauss differs from his early 20th century heyday, when pieces for vast orchestras were more his line.) The work was premiered in Zurich in February 1946, and in 1948, just before its publication, Strauss developed and expanded its final movement into the version we know today. (An endearing aside: Strauss had wanted de Lancie to play in the American premiere of the piece, but after the war, de Lancie switched orchestras, from Pittsburgh to Philadelphia, where he was not the principal oboist, and consequently, protocol meant he didn’t get to play the work. Much later, however, in 1987, he did get to make a recording of the piece that he’d inspired more than 40 years previously.) The concerto is in the conventional three movements, with a broadly fast-slow-fast pattern, and the musical material undergoes a process of almost constant evolution, being spun (and, given the lyrical virtuosity of the oboe part, it really does feel like ‘spinning’ of the melody line) from very similar thematic units. It’s a challenging work for the soloist almost from the outset, and requires extraordinary feats of breath control (and plenty of ‘circular’ breathing). The first movement is otherwise dominated by the little fluttering figure heard right at the beginning on the strings, and this gentle burbling quality suffuses the movement. The second movement begins almost identically to the first, but offers the oboist some lovely soaring melodies. This leads directly to the last movement, bouncing and playful. There’s a cadenza for the soloist, and a couple of moments where Strauss (like his Viennese namesake) introduces some gentle waltzing material, before a final oboe flourish brings the work to an end. Performances on YouTube are, I think, of variable quality (or sometimes, as with an otherwise lovely recording by the Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra, incomplete), so in the end I’ve gone for a video version by the Orquesta Sinfónica de RTVE (the Orchestra of Spanish Radio and TV), conducted by Leopold Hager. They’re not, I think, a front-rank band, but they provide steady and supportive accompaniment to the very capable soloist, Lucas Macías Navarro. You’ll find this recording here: Strauss, R: Oboe Concerto. (And, as a little bonus, there’s an encore – one of Bartók’s tiny Duos for Two Violins, but played here by the soloist alongside the orchestra’s first violin.)
Day 506: Metamorphosen (Time: 26 minutes)
Today (6/9/24) my focus is on Richard Strauss, for the very good reason
that this Sunday, September 8th, will mark 75 years exactly
since his death at the age of 85. We’ve had four postings devoted
to his music before now (see Days 187, 188, 201 and 473), including two works –
the Oboe Concerto and the exquisite Four Last Songs – that were the product of
Strauss’s so-called ‘Indian Summer’, the last decade of his life in which the
creative juices continued to flow unchecked by advancing age. In my
previous postings about Strauss, the other issue I’ve dwelt on, apart from this
creative late flowering, is Strauss’s somewhat ambiguous relationship with the
Nazi authorities in the years after the mid-1930s. For some, this link
with always tarnish his reputation. For what it’s worth, I’d tend to view
Strauss as being complacent and naïve in this area rather than deeply morally
compromised. The point of bringing this issue up again here is because
the work I want to explore in this posting is, I’d claim, Strauss’s most
impassioned comment on the state of European civilisation during the Second
World War, and it’s a work that does not take sides in terms of the military
conflict convulsing Europe but rather laments the destructive impact of that
conflict on the continent’s centuries-old culture. For those who haven’t
guessed what it is already, this is his Metamorphosen for 23 Solo Strings.
If I were to characterise almost all the works Strauss wrote after his final
opera, ‘Capriccio’, I’d probably settle on an adjective like ‘Mozartian’.
They’re elegant, lyrical, mellifluous and largely serene. The odd man out
in this era is ‘Metamorphosen’. The background to the piece is both
straightforward and ambiguous. In August 1944 he was commissioned by Paul
Sacher (who performed the same service for so many composers in the 1930s-50s)
to write a ‘suite for strings’. In response, Strauss claimed to already
be working on an ‘adagio’ for strings, sometimes suggesting it was for 11
string players, and at other times saying it was for a septet. (The
septet version of this work exists and is occasionally performed in chamber
concerts.) However, the question of why Strauss wrote it is less
clear. One reading is that it was a response to the destruction he saw
around him in the early 1940s. In 1943 the Munich Opera House was
destroyed in an allied bombing raid, and this affected Strauss deeply – one of the
drafts of ‘Metamorphosen’ is headed by the comment ‘Lament for Munich’.
And the day before (or the day after – accounts vary) Strauss began work on his
final scoring of the piece, American bombers destroyed the Vienna Opera
House. Strauss finished the work in March 1945, and within three weeks
Hitler was dead. Strauss wrote in May 1945, ‘On May 1st the most terrible
period of mankind ended. The fruits of Germany’s 2000-year-long cultural
development were condemned to extinction.’ This all seems to point to the
piece being a lament for what was destroyed in the conflict. But there
are other things going on. ‘Metamorphosen’ (or ‘metamorphoses’) describe
the processes of change, which are, let’s face it, the driving force for pretty
much every living thing in existence. And Strauss was apparently deeply
immersed at the time in re-reading Goethe, who used the term to describe the
changes to our perspectives and beliefs that occur as we age. I don’t
want to suggest, though, that the work depicts anything so facile as beauty
emerging out of suffering, or suchlike. This piece is harrowing to listen
to, a cry of desolation and anguish. Near the end it quotes from the slow
movement, a funeral march, of Beethoven’s Symphony No 3, and above the score at
that point Strauss wrote ‘In Memoriam’. (There are other quotations or
half-quotations too: from Wagner’s ‘Tristan and Isolde’, where King Mark is
expressing his anguish at being betrayed, and from Strauss’s own earlier tone
poem ‘Ein Heldenleben’. These moments are like the flickering ghosts of
the past, half-recalled in the present.) And yet… I think what I
want to say is, and yet the piece is very beautiful, and deeply
consolatory, maybe because Strauss stares so hard and unflinchingly at the
suffering around him. One thing worth saying about the scoring: this
really is for 23 ‘soloists’ (10 violins, 5 violas, 5 cellos, 3 double basses),
and at some point in the piece every performer is the focus of attention.
Is it too simple to say that Strauss is showing how individuals matter, that we
all have our ‘voices’ – particularly at a time when such terrible destruction
was annihilating individuals by the million? I’m aware that in some ways
I’m portraying this as a bit of an ordeal to listen to. It’s really not.
Yes, it’s largely slow (though with a more animated middle section) and largely
sombre (though like others before him Strauss knew that you don’t have to write
in a minor key to make ‘sad music’, and much of the most poignant stuff here is
in the major). But it’s humane and, I believe, redemptive, and to embrace
it will touch you for the better. There’s an astonishing selection of
truly wonderful performances of this work on YouTube, so if you don’t like the
one I’ve chosen it’s easy enough to locate one more to your tastes. In
particular, in the world of video recordings, I’d be very happy to live with
any of them conducted by Semyon Bychkov, Kurt Masur or Esa-Pekka Salonen.
But for me (and maybe it’s the ‘democratising’ sense of this being for 23 ‘soloists’)
the most compelling is by the conductorless Norwegian Chamber Orchestra (the
‘director’, Terje Tønnesen, leads from the first violin). I’ve chosen
recordings by them before (see the almost frenzied version of Grieg’s ‘Holberg
Suite’ on Day 192), and the playing is nothing if not wholehearted. There
are some oddities – the ‘set’ they’re playing on is a strange back-lit affair
that looks a bit like a dilapidated music library store room, and they’re all
playing barefoot for reasons I can’t begin to unravel – but I think the
musicianship makes up for it.
You’ll find their performance here: Strauss, R: Metamorphosen
Stravinsky, Igor (1882-1971)
Day 55: Symphony of Psalms (3rd movement) (Time: 12 minutes)
I was looking back at the archive at close of play yesterday, and I realised with a bit of a shock that we’re almost eight full weeks into this, and there have been no pieces of music that are Russian/Soviet. So, something should be done about it – starting now! Today's recording, therefore, is some Stravinsky (1882-1971). I realise that his time in Russia was over by 1914, so he spent far more of his life not living there, but a deep, essential ‘Russianness’ pervades his music, even when he was going through the various radically different stylistic phases, like a kind of musical version of Picasso, that he composed in throughout his long creative life. I think this sense of a ‘Russian soul’, and a deep attachment to the sounds and rhythms of the Russian Orthodox Church, can be felt particularly strongly in his Symphony of Psalms, from 1930. The third movement is a setting of Psalm 150, a joyful song of praise, and it’s this movement I’ve picked out for today. I’ve chosen a performance by the Dutch Radio Philharmonic Orchestra and Broadcasting Choir, conducted by Ed Spanjaard. You’ll find it here (with Dutch subtitles!): Stravinsky – Symphony of Psalms (3rd movement)
Day 69: ‘The Firebird’ (closing scenes) (Time: 11 minutes)
Today (30/5/20), a suggestion from Malcolm, and it’s for the closing sections of Stravinsky's ballet ‘The Firebird’. I featured Stravinsky (1882-1971) a couple of weeks ago, but the rather austere style of the ‘Symphony of Psalms’ from 1930 might seem to be from a distinctly different world when compared to the flair and colour of Stravinsky's first major ballet success for the impresario Diaghilev and the Ballets Russes in 1910. The story of the ballet is based on a Russian folk tale concerning magic eggs, an evil magician and thirteen trapped princesses – and, of course, a questing prince. (There was lots of this sort of stuff about in Russian musical circles in the late 19th and early 20th centuries – see the plot lines for pretty much any Rimsky-Korsakov opera, for instance.) In fact, the fingerprints of Rimsky-Korsakov seem to be all over Stravinsky's score. Rimsky was Stravinsky's most influential teacher, and it could be argued that it was only after the production of ‘The Firebird’ that Stravinsky got Rimsky Korsakov out of his system – Stravinsky's next major work, the ballet ‘Petrushka’, sounds much more, well, like Stravinsky. Although Stravinsky made several different performing versions of ‘The Firebird’, both as a whole ballet and as a suite of extracts, what we have in the clip I’m sending out is actually the last three sections of the complete score. These are ‘The Infernal Dance of all Kaschei's Subjects’ (the spiky music of the opening of the extract), ‘The Lullaby of the Firebird’ (the languorous slower central section) and the finale: ‘Disappearance of Kaschei's Palace and his Spell, Return to Life of the Petrified Prisoners and [what else?] General Rejoicing’. Those whose journey into the world of classical music might have taken them via the circuitous route of prog rock might well recognise the opening of the final tableau. It was regularly used by the band Yes at the start of their gigs. (Perhaps their track ‘Cans and Brahms’ from the album ‘Relayer’ will provide the music for another day. Or perhaps not…) The performance Malcolm has chosen for us to listen to (and watch) is a live performance by the Vienna Philharmonic under the baton of that compositional enfant terrible, Pierre Boulez. (I love one of the comments below the video that describes him as ‘the Buster Keaton of conductors’. Spot on!) You’ll find it here: Stravinsky – ‘The Firebird’ (closing scenes)
Day 135: Octet (Time: 17 minutes)
Welcome to a week in the company of Igor Stravinsky, courtesy of a couple of choices from Pete (Dutton). Pete's choice for today (10/11/20) is Stravinsky's Octet. Stravinsky has featured twice before on this list (see Days 55 and 69), when we explored the final movement of his Symphony of Psalms, and the closing section of his ballet The Firebird. Stravinsky is perhaps less well known as a composer of chamber music, but it forms a distinct strand within his output, particularly once his compositional style shifted away from the epic orchestral forces needed for The Rite of Spring. Historically, octets have tended to be made up of one of three combinations of forces – either eight strings (a kind of ‘double string quartet’), as in the case of Mendelssohn's Octet (see Day 84!), or eight wind players, as in some of the Serenades and Divertimenti of Mozart, or a strings/winds combination, as in Schubert's Octet. In the twentieth century these conventions tended to be stretched a little, allowing other instruments to be foregrounded, as is the case in Stravinsky's piece. It is scored for a very strange combination of instruments – flute, clarinet, two bassoons, two trumpets, and tenor and bass trombones. At some point Stravinsky claimed that the idea for the line-up came to him in a dream – which may or may not be true. (There seems to be a lively connection between Stravinsky's dream life and his compositions, if his comments are to be believed – see The Rite of Spring, for another example.) Stravinsky completed the Octet in 1923, and it is one of the earliest works in what has become known as Stravinsky's ‘neo-classical’ period. On the Ladybird Book of Musical Concepts sort of level, one might describe neo-classicism in music as a broad trend in musical composition, generally focused on the period from 1919-39, when composers looked back to the forms and conventions of ‘classical’ music (1760-1830ish), although in practice there was also considerable interest in music of the baroque period too (1680-1760ish). What neo-classical composers were looking for in the 1920s and 30s was a turning away from the lush (over-)indulgence of late Romanticism, with its swooning orchestration and gradual collapse of tonality and formal order. Obviously, though, such composers weren’t just repeating the musical practices of, say, Bach or Handel or Haydn – instead ‘neo-classical’ composition tended to be ‘spiced’ with dissonant harmonies and irregular rhythms. Stravinsky's Octet is a brilliant example of this playfulness and subversion of expectation. The first movement, after its slow introduction, consciously (some would say deliberately ironically) employs something close to classical sonata form (a topic for another day – though I’m aware I’ve said that before, the previous time the idea of sonata form came up!). The second movement is a theme and variations – expect to encounter, amongst other things, a march, a waltz and a can-can(!) as the movement progresses. Finally there is a rhythmically-patterned rondo (again, a topic for another day!), in which there is much focus on the rhythmic pattern 12312312. For me, and for Pete in his email to me, one of the endless joys of this piece of music is the way it keeps throwing you off balance – rhythms slip in and out of unexpected patterns, and melodies and harmonies take you to by surprise even after repeated hearings. There are a number of video recordings of the piece on YouTube, and from them I’ve selected this performance by an ensemble of Spanish musicians (they don’t appear to have a collective name), conducted by Javier Fajardo. You’ll find it here: Stravinsky: Octet
Day 136: Violin Concerto (Time: 22 minutes)
Here is the second of this week's two instalments of music by Stravinsky, courtesy of choices by Pete Dutton. In fact, to be truthful, not completely by Pete, in that initially he wanted to pair Stravinsky's Octet (see last time out) with his ballet Apollo, but that combination overshot the 40 minute barrier, so I sent him a list of substitute options, from which he chose the music for today (13/11/20), Stravinsky's Violin Concerto. This, like the Octet, is a ‘neo-classical’ piece, dating from 1931. Stravinsky wrote it relatively quickly – his first thoughts date from the spring of that year, the score was completed by September, and the first performance was in October, conducted by Stravinsky himself. Stravinsky confessed to being no natural violinist, but he discussed his plans throughout with the Polish-American performer Samuel Dushkin, for whom the concerto was written, and who was the soloist at that first performance. In fact, Stravinsky's original idea for a unifying motif – a chord consisting of the notes D, E (a ninth above that), A (a further eleventh above that) – was, said Dushkin, unplayable, when the two met to first discuss the work … only for him to go home and try it out, and declare that it was possible after all. This chord comes at the start of each of the four movements of the concerto. The movements have baroque-style titles (Toccata, Aria 1, Aria 2, Capriccio), but these seem to have been added by Stravinsky after the music was completed, and in that sense their purpose is to point to the music's affiliation with eighteenth-century fashions, which, as we saw last time, is what ‘neo-classicism’ was all about. This isn’t music with any sort of ‘symphonic’ intent – there is no obvious attempt to ‘grow’ the music from motto themes, but rather to put together a colourful collage of the different elements. So, instead of the creation of anything emotionally ‘expressive’, what we have is music that is serene, ‘objective’, avoiding any kind of ‘message’. (Sorry about the rash of inverted commas there.) The two outer movements are faster, and they chug along in a motoric sort of way. They enclose the two Aria movements, which, as the title suggests, are song-like and lyrical. There are a number of attractive performances of this work on YouTube. From the options, I’ve chosen one by the exceptional violinist Patricia Kopatchinskaja (wearing an extraordinary outfit that, as one of the comments below the video points out, makes her look like she’s appeared out of one of Diaghilev's original Stravinsky ballets). She is accompanied by the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Andres Orozco-Estrada. You’ll find it here: Stravinsky: Violin Concerto.
Day 178: Circus Polka – For a Young Elephant (Time: 4 minutes)
This is the second of this week's postings commemorating the 50th anniversary of Stravinsky's death. And after the epic experience that is ‘The Rite of Spring’, today (9/4/21) we have a rather droll balletic footnote. Stravinsky and his family left Russia in 1914 at the outbreak of the first world war, and the October 1917 revolution meant they never returned. After some years in Switzerland, they settled in France in 1920, but the darkening political situation in Europe led to further upheaval, and in 1939 Stravinsky arrived in the USA (which was to remain his home until his death), eventually settling in California. At this point, Stravinsky, in his late 50s, was looking to put down roots in his new homeland, and one consequence of this is that he produced music for a number of commissions in contexts one might regard as perhaps stereotypically ‘American’. One such (which I promise to feature before too long) was the Ebony Concerto for clarinettist Benny Goodman and his band; another was to engage with the by then influential Hollywood film culture by opting to feature music from ‘The Rite of Spring’ in the 1940 Walt Disney cartoon ‘Fantasia’. But maybe the quirkiest of these commitments dates from 1942. The choreographer, the influential George Balanchine, had worked with Stravinsky since the mid-1920s. In 1941, Balanchine was commissioned by the Ringling Bros and Barnum & Bailey Circus to choreograph a ballet for the circus's famous performing elephant troupe. Allegedly, Balanchine's telephone conversation with Stravinsky about this went as follows – Balanchine: ‘I wonder if you’d like to do a little ballet with me.’ Stravinsky: ‘For whom?’ Balanchine: ‘For some elephants.’ Stravinsky: ‘How old?’ Balanchine: ‘Very young.’ Stravinsky: ‘All right. If they are very young elephants, I will do it.’ Stravinsky negotiated a generous fee with the circus management, dashed off a short instrumental piece in a couple of weeks, and thus we have his ‘Circus Polka: For a Young Elephant’. Quite surreally, the ballet was for fifty elephants (all decked out in pink tutus) and fifty ballerinas (ditto), and it was a resounding success, being performed 42 times in its initial run. Stravinsky's interest in rhythmic disruption might seem to provide the elephants with a bit of a choreographic challenge, but by the end the piece, quoting the first of the three Marches Militaires, D733, by Schubert, arrives at a triumphant conclusion. Working on the not entirely logical assumption that a piece of music for a young elephant might be enjoyably played by a young orchestra, I’ve chosen the YouTube video recording by the Aargau Youth Symphony Orchestra (Switzerland), conducted by Hugo Bollschweiler. You’ll find it here: Stravinsky: Circus Polka - For a Young Elephant
Day 177: The Rite of Spring (Time: 35 minutes)
Fifty years ago today (6/4/21), on 6th April 1971, Igor Stravinsky died in New York at the age of 89. I was a mere youth at the time (I’m well aware that many of you might have been considerably smaller than that!), but even as a teenager, I knew this event was a big deal, and that, the views of a few naysayers excepted, the commonly held belief was that the 20th century's greatest composer had just passed away. Obituaries and opinion pieces made much of the chameleon-like qualities of Stravinsky's music, the fact that he lived through, absorbed and generally transcended the fashions of several decades of musical change, so that he always appeared at the forefront of ‘modern’ music (with the possible exception of the developments of the electro-acoustic avant-garde emerging from Paris after the second world war). The passage of time over the past 50 years has done little to shift this view: some composers fall out of favour after their deaths, but Stravinsky has always remained as a kind of icon of the new, even if his most ‘shocking’ works are now staple items on concert programmes all over the world. Stravinsky has appeared four times before on this playlist (see Days 55, 69, 135 and 136), which has given a flavour of at least some of the many phases through which his career passed: the early very ‘Russian’ ballets illustrated by extracts from ‘The Firebird’; the ‘neo-Classical’ Stravinsky of the Octet and the Violin Concerto; the devout member of the Russian Orthodox Church exploring aspects of faith in his Symphony of Psalms. Given what I’ve just written about the range and variety of his output, it might seem perverse to try to tie Stravinsky down to one musical characteristic only, but for me, if pushed, I’d say his greatest influence on the future of music was his emphasis on rhythm: an (unhelpfully unattributed) quotation in the sleeve note of one of my Stravinsky recordings claimed he ‘was the only composer who raised rhythm in itself to the dignity of art,’ which seems to me pretty much spot on. So today I’ve chosen the most obvious embodiment of that, my ‘desert island’ choice if I could only live with one piece of Stravinsky ever, ‘The Rite of Spring’. This was the third of the ballets Stravinsky composed for Diaghilev's Ballets Russes company in the years before the first world war. Its premiere in 1913 has become shrouded in myth: there may have been a riot, of sorts, but then again retrospective ‘eyewitness’ accounts seem to employ a lot of imaginative embroidering of what might have happened. What is certain is that this work changed the musical world for good. For me, the brilliance of this composition lies in its synthesis of the complexity of ‘art music’ with something closer to the primitivism of folk culture: several of the work’s melodies are actual Russian and Lithuanian folk tunes, woven into a complex tapestry of mesmeric cross-rhythms and rapid changes of time signature. Its ‘plot’ is relatively simple: a group of ‘primitive’ people celebrates the sudden and brutal arrival of the Russian spring with a series of games and ritual dances, leading to the selection of one young woman who ritually dances herself to death before the tribe's ‘sages’ to propitiate the God of Spring. Although there have been many stagings of the work in the ballet world (and if you want to watch a performance that might have been close to the 1913 version, I’d recommend the one you can find here, though personally I find the Pina Bausch choreography more compelling: you can see the opening few minutes of her version here) ‘The Rite of Spring’ has had an established life in the concert hall for a century or so. The performance I’ve chosen is by the LSO and Sir Simon Rattle, given in 2017. I have a very vivid memory of a much younger Rattle with the CBSO playing this at the City Hall, back in 1981. His interpretation has ‘broadened’ a bit over the years, but this LSO version still packs a heck of a punch. You’ll find it here: Stravinsky: The Rite of Spring
Day 264: The Soldier's Tale (Suite) (Time: 16 minutes)
We’ve had six days’ worth of Stravinsky so far on this list (see Days 55, 69, 135, 136, 177 and 178) covering the major ballets and some of the ‘neo-Classical’ pieces from the 1920s and 30s. As you’ll know from previous postings, Stravinsky’s career breakthrough was the writing of the music for the ballet ‘The Firebird’ (see Day 69) for Diaghilev’s ‘Ballets Russes’ company, the consequence of the happy coincidence (for Stravinsky) of Diaghilev hearing some of Stravinsky’s early orchestral work (the Scherzo Fantastique and ‘Fireworks’) at a concert, and also the procrastination of Liadov, the composer originally lined up to write the ‘Firebird’ music, leading to Stravinsky gaining the commission instead. This was followed, as is generally known, by two more ballet scores for Diaghilev, ‘Petrushka’ (one day soon!) and ‘The Rite of Spring’ (see Day 177) in 1913, which was, by any standards, a piece which revolutionised the history of Western music. What’s interesting to explore today (4/2/22) is what Stravinsky did next. The following years were ones of personal and wider social turmoil. Europe was plunged into the chaos of the First World War. Stravinsky and his family were based in those years in various locations in Switzerland, and with the Revolution in Russia in 1917 not only was Stravinsky prevented from returning to his Russian home, but the economic disruption cut off his supply of money from royalties and opportunities for performances. One consequence of this was that Stravinsky produced a number of works on a much smaller scale than the epic scoring of ‘The Rite’, because of the difficulties finding funding for public performances. His stage work ‘L’histoire du Soldat’ (‘The Soldier’s Tale’) first performed in 1918, is probably the most well-known of these pieces. It’s a fascinating hybrid piece in its original form, ‘to be read, played and danced’ by an ensemble of three actors, one or more dancers, and seven instrumentalists. The scoring is for violin, double bass, clarinet, bassoon, trumpet, trombone and percussion. The story is essentially a version of a folk tale called ‘The Runaway Soldier and the Devil’, a kind of Faust-style narrative, in which the devil appears to a soldier going home on leave to visit his girlfriend, who persuades the soldier to exchange his violin for some money and a book which will allegedly foretell the future. Unsurprisingly, things go terribly wrong for the soldier: the people of his home village think he’s dead and reappearing as a ghost, and he is left with the devil’s money but no happiness. Subsequently, though, he realises that if he loses all the money the devil will have no hold over him, and in the end he recovers the violin, and plays it so beautifully for the king’s daughter, who is dying, that she recovers and the soldier is given her hand in marriage! Don’t fall for the ‘happy-ever-after-ness’ of it all, however. The moral of the story is that no one can have it all, and that one must learn to choose. As the narrator says over the ‘Great Chorale’ (Stravinsky playing homage to Bach!): ‘One happy thing is every happy thing: Two, is as if they had never been.’ The soldier, alas, ends up with nothing. The music for this extravaganza is like a magpie’s collection of quirky items from disparate sources: a paso doble, a tango, a waltz, a ragtime number, klezmer music, a take on Luther’s ‘Ein Feste Burg’, and lots and lots of percussion. However, in order to generate a wider range of performances, Stravinsky arranged the music of the original stage work for a variety of forces and ensembles, but one of the most common (and which Ensemble 360 will play in Sheffield this month) is a suite of five numbers from the score, arranged for violin, clarinet and piano – a version Stravinsky dedicated to the clarinettist Werner Reinhart, who had paid for the first stage production. These pieces are ‘The Soldier’s March’, ‘The Soldier’s Violin’, ‘Little Concert’, ‘Tango – Waltz – Ragtime’ and ‘The Devil’s Dance’. As for a performance, YouTube offers a link to this music played by a young trio of instrumentalists, the Ducasse Trio. You’ll find it here: Stravinsky: The Soldier's Tale (Suite)
Suk, Josef (1874-1935)
Day 341: Meditation on an Old Czech Hymn ('St Wenceslas') (Time: 7 minutes)
Josef Suk (1874-1935) is appearing on this playlist for the first time, and I’m sorry it’s taken so long. His is a fascinating if ultimately rather melancholy life, and he produced music initially exhilaratingly life-enhancing in the manner of Dvořák and then, after a series of domestic tragedies, pieces that were considerably more gloomy. He was born in what was then Bohemia, a province of the Austro-Hungarian empire (now part of the Czech Republic), and he seems to have absorbed musical skills almost instinctively. He studied music initially with his father, but entered the Prague Conservatory at the age of 11. A prolific composer throughout his teens and early twenties, he became a favourite pupil of Dvořák during the 1890s, and in some ways the protégé of the older composer. The two were close (Suk was often treated as a member of the family) and in 1898 he married Dvořák’s daughter Otýlie. It looked like the start of a brilliant career, and a number of Suk’s early works (largely for piano or chamber ensemble) seem to reflect that, with their colourful, folk-inflected melodies. Perhaps his most famous early work is his Serenade for Strings, Op 6. However, misfortune struck in the first decade of the 20th century, with two deaths in rapid succession - Dvořák’s in 1904 and his wife’s in 1905 at the age of only 27, leaving him with a young son and a gaping sense of loss in his personal life. Suk’s music has a definite sense of ‘before’ and ‘after’, turning on these pivotal moments. Partly this seems to have been, as it were, a purely artistic decision, a sense that to go on writing in the style of Dvořák would be inauthentic, a kind of creative dead end. But also, given his temperamental tendency towards melancholia, his musical worlds became darker from that point onwards. The most compelling example is the ‘Asrael’ Symphony he wrote in 1905-6, a symphony of mourning and tentative redemption which was a direct response to his personal tragedies. Thereafter, his music became more complex, with a distinct tendency towards modernism, in a range of major works for orchestra. Suk’s emotional life was also affected by his professional career: he was a founder member of the Czech Quartet (sometimes known as the Bohemian Quartet) in 1892, and he went on playing in this ensemble until it disbanded in 1933. This in itself wasn’t the issue – it was the constant touring in order to make a living, which made him desperately homesick, that was the problem. The work I’ve chosen for today (8/11/22) is Suk’s ‘Meditation on an Old Czech Chorale’ (‘St Wenceslas’). This dates from 1914, and exists in two forms, initially for string quartet, and then arranged by Suk for string orchestra. The original hymn tune, ‘Svatý Václave’ in Czech, dates back to the 12th century, and is a popular marker of Czech identity. It’s been used by a number of Czech composers over the years (it turns up in Dvořák’s ‘Hussite’ Overture, for example), and it’s in that context that we should see Suk’s composition. In the months before the outbreak of the First World War, the Czech Quartet were aware that they would have been expected to open their concerts with the Austrian national anthem (given Bohemia’s place in the empire), and although Haydn’s ‘Hymn to the Emperor’ (the melody we now know as the German national anthem) is a fine piece of music, it was felt to be an unpopular choice in Bohemia at a time of heightened cultural awareness. It was Suk’s intention in composing his ‘Meditation on an Old Czech Chorale’ to produce a kind of alternative national anthem. Given that the piece lasts about seven minutes and isn’t what you’d call rousing, it was perhaps always unlikely to catch on in that role. Nevertheless, as pure music, it’s one of Suk’s most touching compositions, with a tender simplicity and a sober and not at all ostentatious quality. Because of its roots in a melody strongly associated with Czech identity for centuries, it’s not surprising that the work, poignant and nostalgic, should have a firm place in Czech musical culture to this day, but even if we have no Czech affiliations, it’s hard to miss its tenderness and depth of feeling. There are a few versions of this work on YouTube, and from them I’ve chosen this video recording by the American-based Amphion String Quartet, in a performance given at the Lincoln Center in New York. You’ll find it here: Suk: Meditation on an Old Czech Hymn ('St Wenceslas')
Day 442: Serenade for Strings, Op 6 (Time: 31 minutes)
Josef Suk was born in a village in central Bohemia (then part of the Austro-Hungarian Empire) on 4th January 1874… which, as I’m sure you can work out for yourselves, means that next Thursday will be his 150th birthday. Suk has appeared just the once so far on this list (see Day 341 for his Meditation on ‘St Wenceslas’), and I filled in quite a lot of biographical detail back then, so please refer back to that posting. The key features of Suk’s biography are connected: on a personal level, there’s the ‘happy’ bit (Dvorak’s favourite pupil, Dvorak’s daughter’s husband) turning on the sudden deaths of Dvorak and daughter, and then 30 years of rather gloomy and brooding melancholy; and on a musical level, as a result, the ‘happy’ bit (a range of early works which exude the sort of ‘innocent’ Czech charm of Dvorak himself) turning on the sudden deaths of Dvorak and daughter, and then 30 years of music that gets increasingly darker and more complex. Like all oversimplifications, this does no service to a composer whose reputation has remained high in Czech lands but who has seemed to move in and out of fashion elsewhere in the nearly 90 years since his death. However, like all oversimplifications, it’s a handy way of navigating the music of this fascinating figure. For my choice today (29/12/23) – only in part selected because I didn’t think you deserved too much gloom in this quiet-ish spot between Christmas and New Year – I’m homing in on the early years of Suk’s career, and the work which is probably his most popular. In the first half of 1892, when Suk was an 18-year-old studying under Dvorak at the Prague Conservatory (an institution Suk entered at the age of 11), he had already been composing pieces (mostly for piano or small chamber ensembles) for several years. My earlier oversimplification suggests that these were ‘happy’ pieces, but that’s not entirely true, and Dvorak seems to have been aware of the shadows, if you like, filling in the background in these apprentice works. So, as the academic year came to an end, apparently Dvorak said to Suk, ‘It's summertime now, so go and make something lively for a change, to compensate for all those pomposities in the minor key.’ And, partly to please this ‘father figure’ who, six years later, was to become his father-in-law, Suk came back after the summer break with his Serenade for Strings in Eb, Op 6. The string serenade was a popular genre throughout the 19th and well into the 20th century. There are many extremely likeable ones out there that I’ve not got round to illustrating yet on this playlist, the most obvious being those by Tchaikovsky, Dvorak and Elgar, but if one were to construct a list of, as it were, the next level of popularity in works with this title, I’m sure Suk’s composition would be part of that group. Such works tend to major on charm, graceful melodies and an essentially ‘sunny’ disposition (though there are some – such as Korngold’s Serenade for Strings, see Day 295 – that are both attractive and complex at the same time). Suk’s essay in this genre owes a lot to the example of Dvorak, but one might hardly expect anything else. The work received its first performance in 1895 and almost instantly (helped by the fact that both Dvorak and Brahms recommended it for publication) it brought Suk much early success. It’s a work in four movements, but rather than start with a dramatic ‘allegro,’ the first movement, marked ‘Andante con moto’, offers a gentle, ‘singing’ introduction to the work’s sound world. Suk was never really wedded to Czech folk traditions in the manner of Dvorak, but the second movement has a distinctly ‘dance-like’ feel, with lots of playing with cross-rhythms (especially setting groups of three beats against groups of two). It’s in the third movement where things get properly emotional, at times passionately agitated, but equally at times almost heart-breakingly tender (and suffused by a kind of Slavic melancholy, maybe). We’re back in the ‘outdoors’, as it were, for the finale, a movement of bustling charm, before the temperature is lowered as the music seems to fade away, and then Suk rounds things off with a whirling and emphatic close. It’s a lovely work, I think, and one that ought to lift away any mood of post-Christmas torpor you might be feeling. As for a performance, there are a few good ones on YouTube, and from them, I’ve gone for this ever-so-slightly leisurely video recording made by the strings of the Hamburg State Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by that one-time (and, it has to be said, not terribly popular) principal conductor of the Halle, Kent Nagano. You’ll find it here: Suk: Serenade for Strings, Op 6
Day 579: Piano Trio in C Minor, Op 2 (Time: 17 minutes)
To open the concert to be given by Ensemble 360 here in Sheffield next month will be the Piano Trio in C Minor Op 2 by Josef Suk. Consequently, it’s this early piece of chamber music which is my focus for today (27/2/26). We’ve had two works by Suk on this list already – see Day 341 for the Meditation on an Old Czech Hymn and Day 442 for the Serenade for Strings – and those postings contain almost all the biographical information I’d want to include to understand Suk’s place in Czech musical history, so explore those if you want more background. For today, I just want to consider the context and content of this very early work by Suk, which is in some ways at odds with the picture of the composer and his work that I’ve painted in those two previous postings. One of the interesting things about Suk is the fact that he had a ‘voice’ of his own from quite an early age, and even though he came under the direct influence of Dvořák from the age of about 15, an influence that was deeply personal (he became a kind of honorary family member and at the age of 24 married Dvořák’s daughter) as well as musical, there’s evidence that before that initial contact Suk was already developing a musical identity of his own. Perhaps the best illustration of this is to be found in this very early Piano Trio – Suk was only just 15 years old when he finished the first version of it. It is, though, a bit of a challenge to pin down what that voice was like in this work because the trio underwent at least two substantial revisions, the latter very heavily influence by Dvořák. So, at its first appearance, Suk’s Piano Trio in C Minor had four movements. He wrote it, apparently, for a father and daughter (Dr and Ms Hersch) with whom Suk used to play piano trios at amateur gatherings. This was in 1889. The movement that disappeared entirely between Suk’s first and last thoughts on the work was a scherzo that seems to have blended folksy Czech rhythms with something a bit more like the third movement of Beethoven’s ‘Eroica’ Symphony. Anyway, Suk showed this first version to Karel Stecker, his composition teacher at the Prague Conservatory, who recommended some revisions – not just excising the Scherzo movement, but cutting a chunk of the first movement too. Eventually this revised version was performed in public in 1891, which seems to have been the point at which Dvořák took an interest, telling the still teenage Suk to ‘continue your seeking’. Later in 1891, Suk joined Dvořák’s composition class, essentially on the basis of this work, and yet more revision of the piece took place. Now the first movement got longer again (more development of its themes in the central section) and the slow movement acquired a more dramatic middle section too. But the main impact of Dvořák’s ‘encouragement’ was felt in the finale, which now acquired a livelier tempo and an all-round spark that made it more satisfying as a conclusion. So, the finished version of Suk’s Piano Trio shows very definitely the fingerprints of his father-in-law-to-be, and yet for all that there’s still evidence for some other identity – the one that would emerge a decade and a bit later after the terrible impact of the deaths of Dvořák and Otilie Dvořák, Suk’s wife – even when Suk was so young. For one thing, there’s Suk’s fondness for minor keys, evident right at the outset of this work in the strongly stated solemnity of the first movement’s opening theme. Even if things become more conventional from then on, it’s a movement that’s tightly argued and which retains its focus throughout. But it’s the slow movement, I think, that takes this piece furthest away from the influence of Dvořák. Instead, what we have is something that feels almost like a kind of habanera, rather than the folk dances of his Czech homeland. The movement leads towards a central climax and then back to something gentler to close. The final movement, perhaps more coloured by Dvořák’s influence than it had been originally, is a Vivace in 6/8 time, but even here there’s something else going on. It might just be me, but the rising-then-falling expansive march-like second theme feels much more like early Richard Strauss (or even, at a push, Elgar) than Dvořák. The conclusion shifts, perhaps inevitably, from C Minor to C Major, and we end in optimistic assertion. This isn’t, by any stretch, a lost masterpiece, but it’s more than just a student work, I think, and it shows us quite a lot of where Suk’s music would end up, even if it isn’t yet touched by tragedy. There are some video performances of Suk’s Piano Trio on YouTube, though none, I think, by any real front-rank performers. Still, the recording I’ve chosen, by the Korean-American group Ensemble Ari, is attractive and lively. You’ll find it here: Suk: Piano Trio in C Minor, Op 2
Sullivan, Arthur (1842-1900)
Day 565: Symphony in E ('Irish') (Time: 36 minutes)
>My posting for today (21/11/25) marks another anniversary – in this case, exactly 125 years ago tomorrow since the death of Sir Arthur Sullivan. Now, the response to encountering Sullivan’s music almost certainly depends on one’s exposure to G&S, particularly if that occurred at a young age, such as at school. There will no doubt be people on this list who detest the light operas of Gilbert and Sullivan on the basis of school productions of them – but equally I suspect there are those with a great fondness for them, on the very same basis. I’d have to confess to being in the latter category. My secondary school – a grammar school in Stockport – had a long-held tradition of performing G&S, and although I never got to frighten an audience by singing one of the main roles, I was used to getting ‘character’ parts in these works – Dick Deadeye in ‘HMS Pinafore’ for example, or the Judge in ‘Trial by Jury’. Also (and possibly another ‘could go either way’ experience) my parents made the annual pilgrimage to the Opera House in Manchester for whatever show the D’Oyly Carte company featured that year, so I saw most of the G&S oeuvre – in performances that seemed barely to have changed in decades – and although I’d never want to regard the experience as engaging with ‘proper’ music, they were, for me anyway, immensely enjoyable – comic and corny in equal measure. But if you have a G&S allergy, fret not – today we have Sullivan alone, and not in operatic mode. Exploring the music of Arthur Seymour Sullivan (1842-1900) is a first for this list. Sullivan – who became Sir Arthur after being knighted by Victoria in 1883 for ‘services rendered to the promotion of the art of music’ – has, to put it mildly, something of a mixed reputation musically. After Mendelssohn (who in any case died relatively early in Victoria’s reign), Sullivan was the Queen’s favourite composer. If one were being sniffy, one could argue that this confirms the essentially ‘middlebrow’ nature of Victoria’s tastes, but I’d tend to look on this more generously. Sullivan was by some distance the most popular and most performed of British composers in the second half of the 19th century; Parry and Stanford may occupy, as it were, the intellectual high ground, but Sullivan was the one whose music sold by the barrow-load. There was something inescapably direct about his compositions – because he wrote ‘potboilers’ and cheesy parlour songs, said his critics – that not only made him famous, but also made him rich, enabling him to mix with the upper echelons of society and live a life of some luxury. Manifestly talented as an adolescent, he won a scholarship at the Royal Academy of Music, with the funding extended so he could complete his studies in Leipzig. The music he wrote in his early twenties was very successful – incidental music to ‘The Tempest’, the masque ‘Kenilworth’ and a number of orchestral pieces including a Symphony in E (of which more below). He was desperate to succeed in the realm of grand opera, but, as we all know, it was his partnership with the librettist WS Gilbert that made his enduring reputation (and wealth) over two decades from the early 1870s. It would be fair to say that Sullivan himself was ambivalent about all of this, liking the material rewards but not the way his facility as a tunesmith and, one might say, the banality of much of his harmonic writing led critics to utter things like this contemporary remark: ‘Sullivan's unquestionable talent should make him doubly careful not to mistake popular applause for artistic appreciation.’ He was immensely prolific – not just the 14 D’Oyly Carte operettas with Gilbert, but another 10 ‘regular’ operas too, alongside the incidental music to half a dozen plays, and huge quantities of church music and parlour songs. Lots of this has stood the test of time, if not always of taste – such as the melody for ‘Onward, Christian Soldiers’, or the song ‘The Lost Chord’. Now, I’m not about to take sides when it comes to Sullivan’s position in the league table of British Victorian composers, but I would like to bang the drum just a little for a work he wrote in his early-to-mid-twenties, the Symphony in E, which has posthumously come to be called his ‘Irish’ Symphony. (In fact, he seems to have wanted to call it the ‘Irish’ all along, but was nervous about it initially because he thought it would be compared unfavourably with Mendelssohn’s ‘Scottish’ Symphony.) The inspiration seems to have arrived while he was on holiday in Northern Ireland as a 21-year-old. He wrote to his mother that, ‘the other night as I was jolting home through wind and rain … the whole first movement of a symphony came into my head, with a real Irish flavour about it – besides scraps of other movements.’ In the early 1860s it was a rare thing for anyone from these islands to contemplate writing a symphony – neither Parry nor Stanford got round to it until the later 1870s, and though I’d want to give an honourable mention to the symphonies of Alice Mary Smith, which are pretty much exactly contemporary with Sullivan’s, there were virtually no real traditions for Stanford to tap into. His musical mentors are Mendelssohn, pretty obviously, but you can hear Schumann and also Schubert in this music too – but, I’d like to claim, there’s a sort of freshness and even originality that are Sullivan’s own. (Bear in mind too that this symphony predates any by Brahms, Dvorak or Tchaikovsky, the usual symphonic landmarks of the later 19th century.) The symphony is in the familiar four movements, the first having a slow introduction before the main ‘Allegro ma non troppo vivace’. There’s some notably perky writing for the woodwind here (especially the oboe – always Sullivan’s favourite – and the clarinet) before the movement ends with a clear reference back to its opening. The slow movement is second, a warmly romantic construction that shifts easily between major and minor keys in the manner of Schubert. Of the four movements, it’s the Scherzo third movement that generally attracts the most praise, with its folk-like idiom and definite ‘Irish’ quality. The finale is perhaps the place where the debt to Mendelssohn is at its most obvious, but I think that in a lot of the melodies from this movement you can hear the opera composer Sullivan would become. After its first performance, ‘The Times’ reviewed it thus: ‘the best musical work, if judged only by the largeness of its form and the number of beautiful thoughts it contains, for a long time produced by an English composer.’ It disappeared from the repertoire after Sullivan’s death, but in the last three or four decades it has resurfaced, and there are now quite a few decent recordings of it, predictably all by British orchestras and British conductors. YouTube does not offer any video recordings, sadly, so we’re in audio-only territory again this time, and out of the options I’m going for this, a landmark recording by the Royal Liverpool Phil conducted by its then principal conductor Sir Charles Groves. You’ll find it here: Sullivan: Symphony in E ('Irish')
Sumera, Lepo (1950-2000)
Day 330: Piece from the Year 1981 (Time: 7 minutes)
Two postings ago, I chose music by the great teacher of Estonian 20th century composers, Heino Eller. Then, last time out, I featured music by one of his first pupils, Estonia’s greatest writer of symphonies, Eduard Tubin. Today (30/9/22), I want to feature music by his very last pupil, Lepo Sumera, whom Eller had been teaching for only two years at his death in 1970. At that point, Sumera (1950-2000) was only 20 years old, but he wrote about the impact that study with Eller had had on him, and one of Sumera’s first major compositions, in 1972, was ‘In Memoriam’, his very first orchestral piece and a tribute to his teacher. Sumera packed a great deal into his relatively short life; he died of heart failure, having had a history of cardiac problems, at the age of only 50. Much of his career was as a very public musician. Indeed, for some of the time, he was actually a politician too, being Estonia’s Minister of Culture from 1988-92 (actually technically the final Minister of Culture for the Estonian Soviet Socialist Republic and then, seamlessly, the first Minister of Culture for the newly-independent Estonia). He taught composition and orchestration at the Estonian Academy of Music in Tallinn from 1978 until his death, and was Chairman of the Estonian Composers Union for the last seven years of his life. After his study with Eller, Sumera went on to study with another leading Estonian teacher, Heino Jurisalu, and through the next 25 years or so, he made his mark both on the world of orchestral music (he wrote six symphonies, at least a couple of which you’ll find on YouTube) and electronic music. He was the first Estonian composer to work in the field of electronic composition and to use computers actively in his work. He also wrote chamber and choral music, the latter perhaps an inevitable consequence of being Estonian. In addition, he wrote more than 50 film scores, and one ‘multi-media’ opera, ‘Olivia’s Master Class’, in which paintings by one of the characters are displayed via video during the action. The folk-music tradition of his homeland was of fundamental importance to him, even though in some ways the outcomes felt experimental. There are minimalist tendencies to his work, not perhaps as obviously indebted to Steve Reich, Philip Glass and American minimalism, but in a similar way to Pärt and others who were taking minimalism into more contemplative areas. In finding out about Sumera, one of the things I’ve liked discovering is the extent of his sense of humour. He wrote a ‘Mushroom Cantata’, in which the text consists of Latin names for mushrooms! In 1981 he wrote two short piano pieces, called collectively ‘Two Pieces from the Year 1981’. The second of these, entitled ‘Pardon, Fryderyk!’, is a slightly subversive homage to Chopin, taking the form of an exploration of one of Chopin’s mazurkas but with a central section in which the pianist is instructed to tap out rhythms on the body of the piano or (though I’ve never seen this on video) to tap-dance the rhythms instead at that point! The first of the ‘1981’ pieces has no title, so it tends to be described as ‘1981’ (‘The Piece from the Year 1981’). I have read in more than one location that one of the key influences on its repetitive, hypnotic character is Sumera’s interest in Estonian runic song. (I’d like to be able to give you some more detail on that, but alas…) He seems to me to be a composer with an open heart and an open mind: there’s a lovely quotation from an interview he gave just before he died which reads: ‘Until now, I always try to cross the road with my eyes and ears open. So that I wouldn't go from point A to point B without seeing or hearing anything. I'm trying to take in whatever I can. You never know what the next moment will bring. And very often the next moment – oh, but this is what inspiration is all about!’ Sumera’s music is pretty well served on YouTube for a contemporary composer. There are a number of recordings, audio and video, of ‘The Piece from the Year 1981’, and out of them I’ve chosen, and not just for sentimental reasons, this performance by the composer’s daughter, Kadri-Ann Sumera. You’ll find it here: Sumera: The Piece from the Year 1981
Swann, Donald (1923-94)
Day 416: The Slow Train (Time: 3 minutes)
As tomorrow (30th Sept) marks the 100th anniversary of the birth of Donald Swann, I feel this is something that ought not to go unacknowledged. Donald Swann (1923-94) is famous these days essentially for one thing: his partnership with the comic wordsmith Michael Flanders. There is, however, considerably more to him (and his music) than that – even if (spoiler alert) it’s where we’ll end up. Swann was Welsh, born in Llanelli, but with a background somewhat more exotic: his father was Russian and his mother from what is now Turkmenistan. The not very Russian sounding surname is explained by the fact that Swann’s great-grandfather (actually called Swan – the extra ‘n’ was acquired sometime in the late 19th century) emigrated to Russia in 1840, Swann’s parents arriving back in the UK as refugees from the 1917 Russian Revolution. Moving to London, Swann went to Westminster School, which is where he met fellow student Michael Flanders, and where their comic musical partnership began. During the 2nd World War Swann was a conscientious objector (he was a lifelong Quaker) and worked with an ambulance unit in the eastern Mediterranean. Swann met Flanders again by chance in 1948, and they began a partnership that ran for about 20 years, performing revues and providing the words and music for other ‘light entertainment’ staples (from my childhood, at least), like Ian Wallace and Joyce Grenfell. However, there’s much more to Swann than the music-composing half of a patter song duo. Very little of his ‘serious’ music is in the public domain, but there are some substantial works out there awaiting rediscovery, notably a three-act opera setting CS Lewis’s novel ‘Perelandra’ (the second in the ‘Out of the Silent Planet’ trilogy, if there are those out there for whom CS Lewis’s sci-fi wasn’t part of your adolescent reading). Swann also wrote a song cycle, ‘The Road Goes Ever On’, setting poems from Tolkien’s ‘Lord of the Rings’. In the decade before he died he wrote a vast number of songs based on the poetry of Blake, Emily Dickinson, Christina Rossetti and other 19th century writers, recently published as ‘Last Songs’. There’s also, alongside the roughly 2000 songs he is estimated to have written over the course of his life, a small amount of instrumental music, including ‘Rhapsody from Within’ for recorder and piano, popularised by Piers Adams (of the subversive classical quartet ‘Red Priest’). However – and you could probably tell there was going to be a ‘however’ before too long – his lasting reputation is as the piano-playing half of the Flanders and Swann duo. Some of their songs, from the revues ‘At the Drop of a Hat’ (1956) and ‘At the Drop of Another Hat’ (1963) are straightforwardly comic and absurdist in a fashion that was popular in the post-war era (see ‘The Gas Man Cometh’ or ‘Madeira, M’Dear’). Possibly, like me, you may have memories of the programmes of comedy double act Armstrong and Miller (variously on Channel 4 and the BBC from 1997-2010) which included their parody – and I think it’s definitely a parody and not a pastiche – of Flanders and Swann, called Brabbins and Fyffe. (I’ve just spent a happy half hour on YouTube watching collections of these songs from Armstrong and Miller’s sketch shows…) But alongside the somewhat broad comedy of Flanders and Swann there are occasional gems of social commentary that strike a more poignant note, and for the musical choice today (29/9/23) I want to land on just one of those, the wonderfully elegiac ‘The Slow Train’. This was written in 1963 and is a melancholy reflection on the rather brutal hacking back of the country’s railway network in proposals now simply referred to as the Beeching Cuts. If you know Edward Thomas’s 1914 poem ‘Adlestrop’ (written, as it was, at a time when the world as it had been known was coming to an abrupt and brutal end in the impending war), you’ll be aware of ways in which ‘Slow Train’ plays on a similar sense of nostalgia for a vanished past, through a very particular and English sense of place. Though not every station named in the song was consigned to oblivion, the resonance of English place names helps to evoke that sense of a disappearing way of life. There are times, I think, when apparently ephemeral bits of popular culture can strike a note that echoes powerfully down the years. Flanders and Swann’s ‘Slow Train’ is one such piece. Naturally, the performance is by Flanders and Swann themselves, in an audio-only recording, though accompanied by some nostalgic images of the age of steam. You’ll find it here: Flanders and Swann: The Slow Train
Szymanowski, Karol (1882-1937)
Day 270: 'Sheherazade' (from 'Masques', Op 34) (Time: 10 minutes)
Szymanowski (1882-1937) is, by most people’s assessment, the greatest Polish composer after Chopin and before Lutosławski. His was an interesting life, though in the end one that concluded with his sense of being deeply unfulfilled as a composer. He was born into a family of cultured, aristocratic Polish landowners from what is now north-western Ukraine (and let’s hope it stays that way!), but which was, in the later 19th century, a relatively sleepy part of the western fringes of the Russian empire (history never stays asleep, does it?). He was a precociously talented pianist, moving to Warsaw as a teenager to pursue his studies in piano and composition. In the years before the First World War he moved around many of the cultural capitals of central Europe, picking up in the process a taste for much of the music of the avant-garde of the time. His writing during this period betrays some obvious influences – an early orchestral piece, his Concert Overture, sounds like a pastiche of Richard Strauss, but to his name we could add Stravinsky, Wagner, Debussy and Ravel, and the exotically heightened pianism of Scriabin. He spent most of the war years in Polish Russian territory, on the family estate, but it was ransacked during the 1917 revolution. During this period he was deeply influenced by middle Eastern and North African culture, by Greek and Islamic philosophy, and by the art and culture of Sicily, where he seems to have ‘come out’, as we now say, as homosexual, and conducted a number of passionate affairs. He had a largely unhappy time in newly independent Poland after the First World War was over, including a period spent as Director of the Warsaw Conservatory, a job for which he seems to have been temperamentally quite unsuited. But worse than this, his always fragile health broke down dramatically: he was diagnosed with tuberculosis in 1928, and periods spent recuperating at sanatoria in Switzerland merely served to stave off the inevitable. His last years in the 1930s were dogged by poverty, illness and despair, illuminated only by his late discovery of the richness and depth of Polish musical folk culture, which shaped some of his last works. From his wide-ranging output, there are many works that have now found a secure place in the mainstream repertoire: he is probably most renowned for his opera ‘King Roger’, but one might add to that his four symphonies, two violin concertos, two string quartets, the ballet ‘Harnasie’ and a quantity of solo piano music. Like Chopin, he wrote a number of mazurkas, but alongside these folk-rhythm based pieces there are two more substantial and exotic works – a set of three piano pieces called ‘Métopes’ (dating from 1915), and another set of three pieces called ‘Masques’ (written in 1915-16, and published just after the war). It is this latter work that Tim Horton is playing in early March, and from it I thought I’d select for today (25/2/22) the first movement of the set, called ‘Shéhérazade’. The set as a whole has a mythological theme – after the ‘A Thousand and One Nights’-influenced first movement, the second is ‘Tantris the Clown’, depicting an episode in the torrid relationship of Tristan and Isolde, and the last is ‘Don Juan’s Serenade’, ardent, clowning and bitter by turns. The ‘Shéhérazade’ movement was dedicated to the pianist Sascha Dubiansky, who gave the first performance of the work in 1916. It’s a study in languid orientalism, full of vivid recollections of Szymanowski’s travels in North Africa in early 1914, but also containing some more frenzied, even manic, passages. I think this is a piece characteristic of a certain type of composition by Szymanowski, the side of the composer’s music to which the rather synesthetic term ‘perfumed’ is often attached, a sound world somewhere between Debussy and Ravel on one hand, and late Scriabin on the other. As for a performance, there aren’t that many video recordings on YouTube, but from the ones out there I’ve chosen this extract from a recital by the Danish/Polish pianist Filip Michalak, which you’ll find here: Szymanowski: 'Sheherazade' (from 'Masques', Op 34)
|
T–V
|
T · U · V |
|
Tabakova, Dobrinka (b 1980)
Day 496: Suite in Old Style (Time: 19 minutes)
Today (9/7/24), we have a really interesting choice from Peter Wigglesworth, for a contemporary female composer who has had a string of works performed by major orchestras in recent years. Dobrinka Tabakova (b 1980) is usually described as either a Bulgarian or British/Bulgarian composer. She was born in Plovdiv, Bulgaria, but has lived in London since the age of 11. She has acquired an impressive reputation as a composer of music that is both accessible and also complex at the same time. I’ve not come across any music by her that was ‘difficult’ on first hearing, but all of the (relatively few) works I’ve heard have been very satisfying to return to. She studied at the Royal Academy of Music and also the Guildhall School in London, followed by a PhD in Composition at King’s College, London. She has worked with pretty much all the major British and European orchestras (she was the Halle’s Artist in Residence in 2022/23) and, for a relatively young composer, she has been commissioned to write pieces by a huge array of organisations (Royal Philharmonic Society, Radio 3, Three Choirs Festival, Wigmore Hall and others in the UK; organisations in the USA, France, Netherlands, Latvia, Bulgaria and others elsewhere) and won an equally spectacular range of prizes. She has written for many different combinations of forces, from chamber music (pieces for string trio, string quartet, wind quintet) to choral works (including the substantial ‘choral symphony’ ‘Immortal Shakespeare’) to orchestral works (‘Earth Suite’ is her most recent major work here) and to works for soloists with orchestra or smaller ensembles. Her music has always been, at its source, melodic in inspiration. She has written: ‘I started studying composition formally in the early 90s - a time when writing melodic pieces with a recognisable tonic or modal centre was mostly discouraged in academic circles, and I’m quietly proud of resisting any suggestions to change my convictions.’ She has described her compositional process in various ways, but I like this observation: ‘I can trace my own journey from improvising on the piano to writing full orchestral scores, and melody is present from the very first creative moments. Creating memorable and emotive themes is an important part of my creative process. But again, it is the context of the melody that is important to consider - the build-up, the background and density of material behind it and how different melodies interact. Developing the right environment for the melody and creating a cohesive structure are at the heart of beginning each new piece.’ So, what does Tabakova’s music sound like? Well, tonal but not anodyne, I’d say; it’s also music alert to the past without being simply a pastiche of older forms (try digging out her ‘Fantasy Homage to Schubert’); she writes with an ear to the ground when it comes to contemporary developments in jazz or blues (try the ‘Suite in Jazz Style’ for viola and piano); she also writes radiantly for choir (I was, as they say, stopped in my tracks by her ‘Nunc Dimittis’ from the ‘Truro Canticles’). Mr Wigglesworth has given me a free hand when it comes to what to choose, so I’ve gone for another of her ‘present inhabited by the past’ compositions, her ‘Suite in Old Style’ for Viola, Harpsichord and Chamber Orchestra. This is a relatively early work, dating from 2006. Its title suggests another link – to the late 20th century composer Alfred Schnittke, who was similarly haunted by previous musical sound worlds which he ‘recomposed’ in his work. Tabakova’s ‘Suite in Old Style’ has a sub-title: ‘The Court Jester Amareu’, which gives us yet another link – to the 18th century French composer Rameau (‘Amareu’ is an anagram), and Tabakova’s own website has this description of the work: ‘Written as homage to Rameau … this suite presents glimpses from everyday life at an 18th century aristocratic household: hunting, courting in the gardens, dancing and entertaining in opulent surroundings.’ The work is in three movements, ‘Prelude: Fanfare from the balconies and back from the hunting’; ‘Through mirrored corridors: The rose garden by moonlight’; ‘Riddle of the barrel organ player: Postlude, Hunting and Finale’. The BBC Music Magazine’s review of a recording of the work described it as a ‘polystylistic romp with oriental cross-currents’! YouTube has a number of available links for this contemporary work, and from them I’ve chosen this video performance by the viola player Maxim Rysanov (for whom the piece was written), and here he’s both soloist and conductor of the Spanish Radio and Television Symphony Orchestra: Tabakova: Suite in Old Style
Tallis, Thomas (1505-85)
Day 67: ‘Spem in Alium’ (Time: 9 minutes)
A few days ago, Thomas Tallis had a walk-on role as the provider of the theme on the basis of which Vaughan Williams then wove the ‘Fantasia on a Theme by Thomas Tallis’. Today (28/5/20), Tallis gets his own moment in the spotlight, and I felt it would be a satisfying thing to go for his epic choral masterpiece, ‘Spem in Alium’. Tallis (1505-85) was, amongst other things, exceptionally diplomatic when it came to navigating the religious winds of change that blew so violently through Tudor England in the 16th century. The general view is that he retained the Catholicism of his birth, but was also able to retain his head through the choppy waters of the rules of Edward VI and Elizabeth I, largely because of the versatility of his compositional styles – more florid in periods when Catholic tastes in music were in the ascendant, more direct (as in the theme that VW used, above) when Anglican voices ruled. He and his near contemporary William Byrd (who will surely feature if this list survives long enough) enjoyed Elizabeth's protection during the final 30 years or so of her reign as sanctioned publishers of polyphonic music. ‘Spem in Alium’ (‘Hope in any other’) was written some time around 1570, and it is exceptional in that it is in 40 parts – actually eight separate five-part ‘choirs’, which then blend together. Its composition is thought to have been prompted by the performance of a similarly multi-voiced mass by the Italian composer Alessandro Striggio , known to have been performed in London in the late 1560s. The text is an adaptation of an extract from the Apocryphal Book of Judith. Wikipedia offers the following rough translation of the Latin text: “I have never put my hope in any other/ but in Thee, God of Israel/ who canst show both wrath and graciousness,/ and who absolves all the sins/ of man in suffering/ Lord God,/ Creator of Heaven and Earth/ Regard our humility”. For those who don’t know this piece simply as music, there may be some who remember key sequences from the film version of ‘Touching the Void’ where it was used, and also those who go back far enough may remember an art installation in the Millennium Gallery by an audio artist called Janet Cardiff in the early years of this century. She grouped 40 loudspeakers in a large circle in bunches of five, with one speaker to each of the 40 parts of the motet, so that visitors could ‘walk through’ the sound as the piece was playing, focusing on individual voices or experiencing the waves of sound as the various ‘choirs’ in turn become foregrounded. I have to say it moved me to tears – the experience of being ‘inside’ the music was spine-tingling. There are lots of very impressive performances of this on YouTube, but I’ve gone for a performance ‘for our times’ by the choral group Stile Antico (overdubbed several times) performing it in a ‘socially distant’ way. It’s visually quite satisfying as well as, obviously, being utterly stunning music. You’ll find it here: Thomas Tallis – ‘Spem in Alium’
Day 251: O Nata Lux (Time: 2 minutes) and 'Gloria' (from 'Missa Puer Natus Est Nobis') (8 minutes)
Today (21/12/21), we’re in Tudor England, in the company of Thomas Tallis (1505-85). This giant of Renaissance choral music has made only one appearance on this list so far (see Day 67 for the sublime ‘Spem in Alium’), so another encounter is more than overdue. I wrote back then about Tallis’s careful navigation of the challenges of staying alive amid the turbulence of religious controversy in 16th century England, serving at court as a composer, singer and trainer of choristers at the Chapel Royal from the early 1540s to the late 1570s – that is, in the service of Henry VIII, Edward VI, Mary I and finally Elizabeth I. The generally accepted view is that he retained the Catholicism of his upbringing, but that survival during these times was due in no small measure to his prudence in going with the winds of stylistic change in ecclesiastical music sufficiently convincingly to keep at bay the threat of censure (or much worse) during those years when Catholics were at considerable risk. After Henry VIII’s break with Rome in 1534, church music became less florid stylistically, more ‘chordal’ – try listening to Tallis’s Mass for Four Voices, for example. When Edward VI ruled, the Anglican church embraced vernacular forms of worship, and Tallis produced many anthems set to English words, though he also continued to write using Latin texts. With the arrival on the throne of Edward’s older and vehemently Catholic sister Mary, church compositions shifted their musical ‘voice’ again, and Tallis wrote more elaborately, notably the ‘Christmas Mass’ ‘Missa Puer Natus Est Nobis’, of which more below. Finally (not that, at the time, I suspect it felt anything like ‘final’) with the Protestant Elizabeth’s accession in 1558, and the passing of the Act of Uniformity that year, re-establishing the Anglican liturgy and abolishing the use of more Roman Catholic rites, Tallis returned once more to a style that was less polyphonic, more concerned with plainness in setting, so that the words of sung texts should be readily comprehensible. His psalm settings for Archbishop Parker’s Psalter, one of which is the ‘theme by Thomas Tallis’ as elaborated on by Vaughan Williams in the early 20th century, show his ability to address the demands of his time. He appears to have written little after the mid-1570s, when he and his pupil William Byrd (see Day 86) published the joint collection ‘Cantiones quae ab argumento sacrae vocantur’ (roughly ‘Songs called from the sacred theme’), and it is this collection that contains the first of our selections for today, the Latin motet ‘O nata lux’, which has been suggested by the playlist’s invisible member Pete Dutton. This piece, for unaccompanied 5-part choir (SATTB), sets a 10th century text from which Tallis selects the first two verses only, which approximately translate as: ‘O Light born of Light,/ Jesus, redeemer of the world,/ with loving-kindness deign to receive/ suppliant praise and prayer.// Thou who once deigned to be clothed in flesh/ for the sake of the lost,/ grant us to be members/ of thy blessed body.’ Tallis’s setting is fervent and impassioned. I’d draw particular attention to its occasional and intensely meaningful clashing harmonies, notably its closing chords on the word ‘corporis’. Even if you’re not entirely au fait with what’s happening musically here in its semitone clashes, you can hear I hope how this depicts how painfully difficult it is, in some ways, to embrace becoming ‘members of thy blessed body’, often, in those days, literally a matter of life and death. It’s performed on this recording (audio only, I’m afraid) by the Tallis Scholars, directed by Peter Phillips. You’ll find it here: Tallis: O Nata Lux. To go alongside this little gem of a piece, I’ve chosen the ‘Gloria’ section from the ‘Missa Puer Natus Est Nobis’, Tallis’s 7-part setting of the mass. As mentioned above, this dates from Mary’s time on the English throne, and there is something a little ‘Spanish’ in sound world about Tallis’s music here (Mary being married to Philip II of Spain), not perhaps all that far from the ‘darker’ tones of the Catholic music of Victoria (see Day 246). The ‘Gloria’ from this mass is performed here by Ars Nova, Copenhagen, directed by Paul Hillier: Tallis: 'Gloria' (from 'Missa Puer Natus Est Nobis')
Tavener, John (1944-2013)
Day 21: ‘Fos 1 – Doxa’ (from ‘Ikon of Light’) (Time: 5 minutes)
Until his death in 2013, John Tavener was probably the most popular ‘classical’ composer in the UK, largely because of the popularity of a range of works, from the haunting ‘The Protecting Veil’, for cello and orchestra, through small-scale choral gems like his setting of Blake's ‘The Lamb’, to pieces that got mass popular coverage, like his ‘Song for Athene’, which was performed at the funeral of Princess Diana. Today (12/4/20 – Easter Sunday) Malcolm suggests an appropriate piece of Tavener's music, the opening movement, entitled ‘Fos 1 – Doxa’, from John Tavener's contemplative masterpiece, ‘Ikon of Light’. (Malcolm points out to me that ‘Phos’ is Greek for ‘Light’, making the choice entirely apt for today of all days, when we celebrate the triumph of light over darkness.) The performance is by members of the Duke String Quartet, and The Sixteen, conducted by Harry Christophers, and you’ll find it here: John Tavener – ‘Fos 1 – Doxa’ (from ‘Ikon of Light’)
Tchaikovsky, Pyotr Ilyich (1840-93)
Day 94: Symphony No 1 (3rd movement) (Time: 8 minutes) and
Symphony No 6 (2nd movement)
(Time: 9 minutes)
Today (24/6/20), a request from Jenny for a couple of examples of symphonic music by one of the late 19th century's most popular composers, Tchaikovsky. Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky (1840-93) is one of those few composers pretty much guaranteed to fill a concert hall. His music is vividly scored, emotionally volatile, melodically attractive and exceptionally memorable. It’s also true that in musicological circles his music has often been treated rather dismissively – insufficiently ‘Russian’ for his country's nationalist critics, who wanted him to be more like Balakirev, Rimsky Korsakov, Mussorgsky and the rest, but insufficiently ‘Western’ (for which read ‘like the Austro-German symphonic tradition’) for those who looked at his larger-scale pieces and found them formally undeveloped. Whilst you certainly wouldn't look to a Tchaikovsky symphony for the structural complexity you might seek in a Brahms one, to lament the absence of ‘symphonic argument’ seems to me to miss the point. Tchaikovsky had an exceptional facility for composing attractive works built on short, dance-based movements (his three great ballet scores are the obvious examples of this), where repetition and contrasts in orchestration provide the ‘argument’ of the music. However, his symphonies endeavour to marry this ‘local colour’ with the desire to articulate something of the emotional and psychological complexity of his personal life. And that, I guess, is another reason for Tchaikovsky's enduring popularity – he is the archetypal ‘tortured’ Romantic composer, wrestling with his homosexuality in a time and place where it was taboo, in public at least. It’s common to divide Tchaikovsky's symphonies into two groups – the first three are ‘cooler’, emotionally detached, occasionally overtly folk-based; the last three are passionate, tortured explorations of ‘fate’ in its various manifestations. (It helps that the latter group concludes with the ‘Pathetique’, with Tchaikovsky's mysterious death – cholera-based accident, suicide or whatever – following swiftly after.) But what is interesting about Tchaikovsky, even in his most melodramatic moments, is how the rhythms and spirit of the dance are present even at moments of deep emotion. Which brings me to Jenny's suggestions, for the third movement ‘Scherzo’ of the Symphony No 1 and the second movement ‘Allegro con Grazia’ (the 5/4 time ‘waltz’) of the Symphony No 6. I love the Symphony No 1, and really wish orchestras would programme it more often, rather than endlessly giving us Nos 4 or 5, and the Scherzo movement is a sparkling quicksilver affair. You can hear its connections to the lightly-scored world of ‘Swan Lake’ or ‘The Nutcracker’. The darker tones of the second movement of the ‘Pathetique’ still obviously inhabit the world of the dance, but this is ‘a waltz with a limp’, as it were. There are shadows in the background throughout – as befits, I guess, a symphony whose endpoint is inescapably death. You’ll find the third movement of the Symphony No 1, in a performance by the Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra, Amsterdam, conducted by Bernard Haitink, here: Tchaikovsky – Symphony No 1 (3rd movement) – and the second movement of the Symphony No 6, in a performance by the Vienna Phil conducted, rather more slowly than is common these days, by Herbert von Karajan, here: Symphony No 6 (2nd movement)
Day 254: 'December' (from 'The Seasons') (Time: 5 minutes) and 'January' (from 'The Seasons') (5 minutes)
It seems quite a surprise to me, looking back, that the music of Tchaikovsky (1840-93) has appeared only once on this list in the 253 editions posted out before today (31/12/21). As I wrote back on Day 93 (when I featured, at Jenny’s request, a couple of movements from his Symphonies 1 and 6), Tchaikovsky lays some claim to being the most popular composer of classical music, certainly as far as audiences of the past 100 years are concerned: his three ballets are staples of the art form, and his symphonies, concertos and other orchestral music can be pretty much guaranteed to fill a concert hall, and in financially challenging times for arts organisations that is obviously a very attractive thing. I have relatively little time for those who are sniffy about his music, who seem to regard popularity as in some way self-evident proof that if lots of people like something it must by definition not be very good. (For other examples, see Puccini as an opera composer, or Dickens as a novelist, say.) I suspect I am like many others who ‘discovered’ classical music as a young person, in that Tchaikovsky’s music was one of my first loves, and even if the ‘adult’ me is now somewhat embarrassed by my adolescent version listening to the ‘Pathetique’ Symphony in my room on a sunny afternoon with the curtains drawn, all the better to wallow in those emotions, I think I have sufficient distance from that time to be able to say that Tchaikovsky’s music can still move a listener in a way that nobody else’s work can get near. However, I want today to shift the focus from the ‘box office’ Tchaikovsky to a much less well-known strand in his output, his work for piano. Now, I don’t think anybody is likely to try to make a claim for the ‘greatness’ of this part of his oeuvre. Almost everything he wrote for piano, with the exception of a long (and, in truth, not very interesting) Piano Sonata, is in the form of ‘character pieces’, short descriptive movements collected together into marketable bundles (from eight of the first ten publications that Tchaikovsky chose to give an ‘opus number’ to, which are for solo piano, to his last set of piano works, which date from the same time as his work on the ‘Pathetique’), and almost all are designed for the amateur market, for the talented pianist playing in the salon or in the homes of the aristocracy. These pieces tend to have ‘decorative’ titles, often in (fashionable) French, and they are usually pictorially descriptive. Again, I’m aware that these observations don’t do much in terms of ‘bigging up’ this music, and in all honesty I don’t think this is the place to look for Tchaikovsky’s musical greatness – but charm, flair, elegance, a sort of restrained beauty: these you will find in abundance, in works that are also rarely merely ‘sentimental’. Often these pieces were commissions, composed to order, and largely a way of making money. Thus, in 1875, Nikolay Matveyevich Bernard, editor of the St Petersburg monthly music journal ‘Nouvellist’, asked Tchaikovsky for a set of pieces to be featured in the magazine each month in 1876. You might think it logical that the 12 pieces that ensued, named as they are ‘January’ through to ‘December’, might be known as ‘The Months’ or something similar, but they have rather oddly come down to us as ‘The Seasons’. (It feels like it might be a translation error, but apparently this is equally perplexing in Russian.) Apart from providing the music (and collecting the cash), Tchaikovsky left all the editorial ‘packaging’ to Bernard, which is why each movement has not only the name of a month as its title, but also a rather fanciful sub-title and a poetic epigraph culled from Russian literature of the day. As we reach the turn of the year, I thought it would be nice (even if it means listening to the last, and then the first, of the twelve pieces in this set) to hear ‘December’ and then ‘January’ from ‘The Seasons’, Op 37a. ‘December’ is sub-titled ‘Christmas’, and is preceded by some lines from the 19th century Russian poet Vasily Zhukovsky: ‘Once upon a Christmas night/ The girls were telling fortunes:/ Taking their slippers off their feet/ And throwing them out of the gate.’ (It probably makes a lot more sense in the original Russian!) ‘January’, sub-titled ‘At the Fireside’, comes with some lines from Alexander Pushkin: ‘A little corner of peaceful bliss,/ The night dressed in twilight;/ The little fire is dying in the fireplace,/ And the candle has burned out.’ YouTube doesn’t offer many performances of individual ‘months’ in video recordings, but I’ve found a couple of links to music that might offer you a charming soundtrack to the arrival of the new year. So, here is the young Russian-German pianist Olga Scheps playing ‘December’: Tchaikovsky – 'December' (from 'The Seasons'), and then here is the American pianist Paul Orgel playing ‘January’: Tchaikovsky – 'January' (from 'The Seasons')
Day 327: Symphony No 6 (1st movement) (Time: 18 minutes)
For a composer who’s a reliable box-office crowd pleaser, the fact that there are only two previous occasions when I’ve explored Tchaikovsky’s music on this list (Days 94 and 254) might be regarded in some quarters as amounting to neglect. In fact, on Day 94, I responded to a request from Jenny for a pair of symphonic movements – the 3rd movement of his Symphony No 1 and the 2nd movement (the 5/4 time ‘waltz with a limp’) of his Symphony No 6. So, why explore yet more of the 6th Symphony today (20/9/22), apart from the fact that it’s on the Hallé’s programme in a few days time? Well, for me at least it’s because it’s the greatest of his symphonies and arguably the most profound of his orchestral pieces in any genre. It’s also a work around which a substantial layer of rumour and counter-rumour has accreted, which makes its back-story an interesting one. The well-known facts are readily available: the symphony was written very quickly in the summer of 1893; on 28th October, it was first performed in St Petersburg with Tchaikovsky himself conducting; nine days later, on 6th November, Tchaikovsky was dead. After this, things get really very murky indeed, notably around the cause of Tchaikovsky’s death. The cause of death was initially given as cholera, allegedly by drinking contaminated water some days earlier. This is problematical for a couple of reasons: the timing of the alleged drinking in relation to the date of death doesn’t easily fit the expected course the disease might take; also, even though cholera was rife in St Petersburg, it was seen as a disease of poverty, and there was frank disbelief that someone of Tchaikovsky’s social standing could consume contaminated water, especially from the reputable restaurant where he was said to have drunk it. Unless of course … he drank contaminated water on purpose, and subsequently refused to see a doctor until it was too late. This is the starting point for interminable and entirely unprovable discussions about whether it was suicide (surely if one were going to commit suicide there are far more sensible ways to go about it), and if so whether it was because Tchaikovsky’s homosexuality had been ‘discovered’, and he’d been found guilty by some ad hoc ‘court of honour’ and instructed to do the ‘honourable’ thing. There are all sorts of sub-plots to this: allegedly Glazunov corroborated the suicide idea on the grounds that Tchaikovsky had been found guilty of seducing the son of the caretaker of Tchaikovsky’s brother’s apartment block, and his subsequent death had been ordered by the Tsar himself! Things have become more rather than less complicated in the years since, in part at least because the idea of Tchaikovsky being homosexual is largely denied in Russia, even to this day, so lots of potential sources remain unexplored. What has all this, you may ask, to do with his 6th Symphony? Well, the most obvious thing to say is that it’s a symphony obsessed with death. After early rehearsals some of his friends said to him variations on ‘you have written your Requiem’. There’s the fact that its structure is, by symphonic standards, curious – what feels like a finale (in fact, it tends to elicit enthusiastic applause from unwary audiences because it sounds so resolved and affirmative), the rousing march, is placed third, and the final movement, ‘Adagio Lamentoso’, is marked ‘morendo’ at the end, or ‘dying away’. It is completely and unambiguously lugubrious. Then there’s the sub-title, though I’m led to believe that in Russian the title means something closer to ‘Passionate’ rather than ‘Pathetic’ (in the traditional sense of ‘pathos-inducing’). And, in the first movement, Tchaikovsky quotes, in passing but seemingly unconnected to the symphonic argument around it, an allusion to a melody from the Russian Orthodox Requiem. Without the uncovering of some new, definitive evidence, all this debate about motivation and social context seems unlikely to be resolved. What we can say is that it’s a work of remarkable originality, and it surely pointed the way to the writing of Rachmaninov and Mahler in the subsequent generation of composers. I thought that I’d select the first movement for our listening pleasure. It’s a complex structure, from its growling bassoon introduction, through contrasting periods of nightmarish despair and hysteria and tender lyricism, before it dies away following the solemn tread of the cellos and basses to a kind of nothingness. In some ways it’s extraordinary that a work of such nihilism and despair should be such box-office gold, but there’s something about Tchaikovsky’s writing which goes straight to the heart, and (for me at least) though one might ‘grow out’ of Tchaikovsky as one leaves adolescence behind, he remains a communicator of passionate intensity. The first movement is played in this video recording by the Hallé Orchestra, conducted by Jamie Phillips, which you’ll find here: Tchaikovsky: Symphony No 6 (1st movement)
Day 355: The Nutcracker (Suite) (Time: 26 minutes)
I thought I’d end the current run of postings – a family wedding/holiday takes me out of circulation until late February - with something both extremely popular and also a little seasonal, this being precisely the time of year when one might encounter this music in the theatre or on TV. We’ve had a few pieces by Tchaikovsky on this list so far (see Days 94, 254 and 327) but nothing so far from his ballet music, so I thought I’d put that right today (27/12/22). Tchaikovsky wrote three full length ballets: ‘Swan Lake’, ‘The Sleeping Beauty’ and ‘The Nutcracker’. (There are also ballet movements in many of his operas, as was conventional at the time.) I’ve mentioned in previous postings about Tchaikovsky’s music that the idea of the dance and music for dancing is at the core of almost everything he wrote, so it’s unsurprising that his three ballet scores are the places where we find something pretty essential where Tchaikovsky’s music is concerned. Trying to define that ‘essence’ isn’t easy once one has got beyond the obvious – that Tchaikovsky had a seemingly inexhaustible urge to write melodies that are both memorable and able to carry emotional weight; that he orchestrated his music with a vivid sense of local colour (he was fascinated by unusual combinations of instruments, as we’ll see) and dramatic power; that his music plays very powerfully with rhythm, which has an obvious connection to the dance, where rhythmic patterns and repetitions are foundational; that he employs repetition constructively (and not just because he can’t think of what else to do!) to build drama and momentum. Tchaikovsky’s foremost biographer in English, David Brown, has observed that ‘Tchaikovsky was made for ballet.’ Though other composers around Europe were writing ballets in the years before and during the period from ‘Swan Lake’ (premiered in 1877) to ‘The Nutcracker’ (1892) – notably Delibes in France – there is no doubt that Tchaikovsky’s music in this field revolutionised what was thought possible, especially in shifting the perception of ballet as something merely decorative into something that could be a vehicle for emotional intensity. I think one of the things that marks Tchaikovsky’s music out is its intention always to engage with its listener both aesthetically (to be ‘beautiful’, if you like) but also emotionally. And in the ballets this translates into music that carries us forward through the storyline rather than simply giving us a string of sugary items for our amusement. However, my choice of music for today, the famous Suite of character pieces that Tchaikovsky put together from his ballet ‘The Nutcracker’, might seem to deprive us of that sense of emotional engagement. This is, after all, the ballet that, at its premiere, was advertised as being ‘a fairy tale’, with its (in truth) rather facile story of dolls coming to life on Christmas Eve, battles between toys and mice, and a nutcracker who turns into a handsome prince and carries the heroine, Clara, off to his enchanted kingdom. Act II pretty much dispenses with ‘story’ as a narrative driver entirely, instead giving us a series of exotic dances and ‘character pieces’. Curiously the ballet wasn’t an obvious success at its early performances, audiences being a bit taken aback by the overtly child-like focus. But, as the liner notes to my CD of this music observe, ‘the glory of the work is definitely its score, beautifully suited to the fairy-tale dream and the world of child wonder.’ Tchaikovsky extracted the movements that make up the Suite from the ballet several months before the entire work was performed, and in that sense it served as a kind of taster for its original audience of the complete work to come. The suite is in eight movements, starting with the Miniature Overture that opens the whole ballet. Then there is a series of six ‘character dances’, the March (in the ballet, it’s of toy soldiers) from Act I, the Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy (part of the sweeping ‘Pas de Deux’ just before the ballet’s close), and then five of the movements from the ‘divertissement’ in Act II – the Russian Dance, the Arabian Dance, the Chinese Dance, the Dance of the Reed Flutes, and then finally the Dance of the Flowers. YouTube offers several video performances of the whole ballet, and quite a few single movement extracts from actual ballet performances recorded in the theatre, but there’s not that much to choose from if you want a video of an orchestra playing just the suite. However, Sinfonia Rotterdam (a chamber orchestra based in Rotterdam, funnily enough) under its South Africa-born conductor Conrad van Alphen do a nice job of performing it here: Tchaikovsky: The Nutcracker (Suite) … with a repeat of the Russian Dance thrown in as an encore…
Day 411: Symphony No 5 (1st movement) (Time: 13 minutes) and Symphony No 5 (2nd movement) (12 minutes)
I thought, given that we’ve been quite a long way off the beaten track with a number of recent postings, I’d opt today (12/9/23) to explore at least a bit of what is evidently one of Tchaikovsky's most popular works, his Symphony No 5. The whole work is too long to fit inside the list's self-imposed ‘40 minute rule’ for a week's postings, so I'm going to home in specifically on the first two movements… which, as far as I'm concerned, are the high points of the symphony. (I tend to the view that the third movement feels like an off-cut from one of Tchaikovsky’s ballets, which dissipates the symphonic tension, and the finale is a bit hollow and ‘shouty’, and I've always thought the major-key coda tacked on the end of the symphony like a quick ‘happy ever after’ is just not convincing at all. Apologies if it’s your favourite bit…!) As you may know, Tchaikovsky abruptly and unexpectedly married one of his students in his late thirties, seemingly in an attempt to rid himself of what he evidently felt to be the burden of his homosexuality. The marriage was a disaster, provoking Tchaikovsky into a nervous breakdown, which might well have led to his suicide were it not for the entirely platonic and financially rewarding relationship he developed with Nadezhda von Meck, wealthy widow of a railway engineer, who supported Tchaikovsky for the next 15 years or so – on the condition that they never met! One of the first fruits of this new phase in Tchaikovsky’s life was his Symphony No 4 of 1878, with its heroic wrestling with Fate (very definitely with a capital ‘F’!). As the 1870s moved into the 1880s, and as Tchaikovsky’s psychological state became more stable, his music became (this is all relative: after all, it is Tchaikovsky we’re talking about here) cooler, more detached. Examples: the four Orchestral Suites (symphonies without the angst!), the Serenade for Strings, the 2nd Piano Concerto. In fact, a lot of Tchaikovsky’s creative energy in that decade went into opera (‘Eugene Onegin’, ‘The Maid of Orleans’, ‘Mazeppa’, and so on). Fully ten years elapsed between the 4th and 5th Symphonies, and the latter work was prompted by one of the frequent periods of existential doubt Tchaikovsky suffered about the quality of what he was writing, and whether he had ‘written himself out’. He wrote to his brother Modest that the best way to cure this would be to work on a new symphony – which he then did, at some speed (start to finish in under four months). He wrote positively about the experience to von Meck, particularly in relation to the fact that the symphony was more ‘potent’ than opera: ‘I have tried more than once to express in music the torment and delight of love… Words alone are not enough, and where they are powerless, a more eloquent language comes fully armed: music.’ In the 5th Symphony there may or may not be a ‘programme’, as there was with the 4th Symphony. Early in the work’s creation he wrote in his notebook that the introduction to the first movement was ‘to reflect complete resignation with regard to Fate’ – and followed this with what is generally regarded as an allusion to the central emotional and psychological problem of his homosexuality. A nice quotation I’ve been unable to attach a name to quipped: ‘If Beethoven’s Fifth is Fate knocking at the door, Tchaikovsky’s Fifth is Fate trying to get out.’ At the opening of the 1st movement, Fate is the foreboding low clarinet figure brooding away, evoking resignation if not despair. Tchaikovsky being Tchaikovsky, there are contrasts aplenty, particularly to a yearning melody that drives the movement’s central climax before the movement closes by circling back to its sombre initial mood. The second movement – the slow movement with the wonderful horn melody (eat your heart out, John Denver!) – is surely one of Tchaikovsky’s most beautiful, and yet powerful at the same time. Like the first movement, there is a central surging climax, brutally interrupted by the ‘Fate’ motif, but this time the music drags itself back to its feet, only to be stalled again by the same ‘Fate’ motif. How the movement ends – resignation? wistful frustration? – seems to me to be deliberately, wilfully ambiguous. YouTube has several recordings of the whole symphony (so if you want the whole lot, with the balletic third movement and the flag-waving finale, good performances are easy enough to find), but in terms of videos of just the first two movements, I think you get a convincingly ‘Russian’ performance from the Russian Philharmonic Orchestra (sometimes also referred to as the Moscow City Symphony Orchestra) conducted by Dmitri Jurowski. You’ll find the first movement here: Tchaikovsky: Symphony No 5 (1st movement) and the second one here: Tchaikovsky: Symphony No 5 (2nd movement)
Day 428: String Quartet No 2 (1st movement) (Time: 14 minutes) and String Quartet No 2 (3rd movement) (12 minutes)
Tchaikovsky has featured five times on this list so far (explore via the ‘Menu’), and for the most part those choices have reflected the more popular works in Tchaikovsky’s output. I think that for an obviously ‘box office’ composer, it is in fact the case that Tchaikovsky’s popularity is based on a relatively narrow set of pieces: Symphonies nos.4-6, the Piano Concerto No 1, the Violin Concerto, suites from the three ballets (‘Swan Lake’, ‘The Sleeping Beauty’ and ‘The Nutcracker’) and the fantasy-overture ‘Romeo and Juliet’. (I suppose there’s also the noisily unpleasant 1812 Overture too…) When it comes to chamber music, there are reasonably regular outings for the Piano Trio and, to a lesser extent, for the String Sextet, ‘Souvenir de Florence’. But not many people know that Tchaikovsky also wrote three mature string quartets, as well as a single movement quartet from his student days. They hardly ever feature on concert programmes, which seems to me to be a real shame, because they display an interesting side to the composer, revealing the same sort of intensity and passion as you get in the major orchestral works but constrained by working with a much narrower palate of musical ‘colours’. So, for me anyway, it’s good to hear this music and be reminded of its vivid qualities. Of the three numbered quartets, the String Quartet No 1 probably comes out of hiding most often, largely because of its slow movement, an ‘Andante Cantabile’ based on a Russian folk tune that allegedly moved Tolstoy to tears when he heard it. But the work being played by members of Ensemble 360 this month is the String Quartet No 2 in F, Op 22 – so that’s what you’re getting today (10/11/23). This dates from 1874, when Tchaikovsky was in his mid-30s. By this point ‘Romeo and Juliet’, the 1st String Quartet, the first two symphonies and another symphonic poem, ‘The Tempest’, were behind him, and Tchaikovsky was just beginning to make a name for himself both within Russia and to a lesser degree across Western Europe. The String Quartet No 2 is more or less contemporary with the 1st Piano Concerto, and there is no doubt that the latter piece outshone the former at the time, and has done since. Tchaikovsky was often beset by crippling levels of self-doubt during and immediately after the completion of many of his works, but this second quartet seems to have both flowed pretty effortlessly and pleased him enormously. He wrote to his brother Modest after its first performance: ‘I regard it as my best composition; none of my works flowed out of me so simply and easily. I wrote it practically at one go and was astonished that the public did not like it.’ ‘The public’ also included many of the leading Russian musical figures of the day. Anton Rubinstein wrote that the style was not that of chamber music and that he could not understand it. It did, though, go down well with some of Tchaikovsky’s more ‘nationalist’ contemporaries, notably Rimsky-Korsakov – although those responses might have been swayed by the energetically folk-like final movement. The constraints of this list’s ’40 minute rule’ mean that I can’t feature the quartet in its entirely, given that typical performances last over 35 minutes, and we’ve already had 11 minutes of Smetana this week. So, although this doesn’t provide you with much in the way of continuity, I’m going to home in on just two of the movements, the first and third. The opening movement is interesting particularly for the slow introduction, with its (most un-Tchaikovsky like) scrunching harmonies. Gradually, as the main body of the movement arrives, the music settles into a recognisable key, first D Minor and then the home key of F Major. One of the criticisms of Tchaikovsky’s quartets is that his more impassioned tendencies are constrained by the need to observe structural forms that don’t necessarily suit him, and it’s true that the rest of this first movement is quite orderly (almost Mozartianly so), but I do love the movement’s close, where the main theme returns but transformed into something beautifully lyrical and song-like. After a typical Tchaikovsky scherzo, all jagged irregular rhythms, the third movement is a slow movement that forms the impassioned core of the work. I think this is worth listening to just because, although it’s not technically all that subtle, it shows Tchaikovsky being able to plumb emotional depths without the more ‘technicolour’ resources of a full orchestra. It’s an elegiac movement, and with every repetition of the main theme the emotional charge and fervour increases. If you know the rather ‘world-weary’ mood of Tchaikovsky’s later opera ‘Eugene Onegin’, there’s a glimpse of that world here, I think. As for performances of the work, there’s one by the Atrium String Quartet, a Russian ensemble who have won a substantial array of competition prizes over the years. The video quality is a bit hazy here, but I think you can pick up clearly enough the intensity of the performance. So, here is the opening movement: Tchaikovsky: String Quartet No 2 (1st movement) and here is the slow movement: Tchaikovsky: String Quartet No 2 (3rd movement)
Day 537: Variations on a Rococo Theme for Cello and Orchestra (Time: 20 minutes)
Today (9/5/25), some reasonably well-known music by a very well-known composer, Tchaikovsky. Later this month, the Philippine Philharmonic Orchestra is making a visit to Sheffield’s City Hall, and from their programme, I’ve selected for discussion Tchaikovsky’s only attempt at anything like a ‘concerto’ for the cello, his Variations on a Rococo Theme for Cello and Orchestra. Before getting into that work and its context, it’s worth saying that ‘rococo’ is a little misleading here. In art and architecture, it refers, as many will know, to a heavily ornamented and exuberantly decorated style, fashionable in the mid/late 18th century. In music, though, the term usually refers to earlier 18th century works such as those by Couperin, Rameau and, a little later, CPE Bach. However, to Tchaikovsky it was associated with what we now see as the ‘classical’ period, and especially the works of Mozart. There – that’s tidied that up. We’ve had six previous appearances by Tchaikovsky on this list, but nothing so far for soloist and orchestra. The Variations on a Rococo Theme are interesting in (at least) two ways – as an example of Tchaikovsky’s fascination with and deep love for the music of the later 18th century, and as a surprising example of the contrast between what emerged from Tchaikovsky’s pen and what was going on in his life at the time. To deal with the latter issue first, it’s worth saying at the outset that we shouldn’t assume that there will always be a correspondence between a creative artist’s state of mind and the art s/he produces … but on the other hand Tchaikovsky is so evidently the archetype of the ‘tortured Romantic artist’ of the late 19th century that we almost expect what he wrote to be ‘confessional’ in some way. Anyway, in the late months of 1876 Tchaikovsky, 36 years old at the time, had decided that the best way to resolve the (homo)sexual problems that beset him was to marry. These days that might seem like a recipe for disaster (as it was) but then Tchaikovsky thought it might ‘cure’ him of the deep depression he was in. And (life and art corresponding, sort of) he’d just written his anguished symphonic poem ‘Francesca da Rimini’, with its theme of tortured, forbidden (though entirely heterosexual) love. In the middle of 1877 he married an infatuated student of his, Antonina Ivanovna Milyukova; they survived two months together before Tchaikovsky fled, fearing a complete nervous breakdown, and he subsequently attempted suicide. And just before and after this he was writing his Symphony No 4, which, if you know it (and even if you don’t) is very definitely about Fate with a capital ‘F’! And yet … between ‘Francesca…’ and the 4th Symphony there’s this extraordinarily contrasting piece, the Rococo Variations for Cello and Orchestra, begun in late 1876, finished early in 1877 – but which Tchaikovsky then didn’t get to enjoy because its early performances coincided with his flight from Russia to convalesce in Italy. It’s hard to imagine a piece less likely to have emerged from the pen of a neurotic, potentially suicidal Romantic composer than the Rococo Variations. The piece is calm, elegant, (emotionally) detached. If nothing else, it should cure us of the assumption that there’s only room in the human heart for one emotion at a time! So, why ‘Rococo’? Well, Tchaikovsky’s favourite composer was Mozart – Tchaikovsky called him ‘a sunny genius’, and wrote later, to his patroness Nadezhda von Meck: ‘You say my worship for [Mozart] is quite contrary to my musical nature. But perhaps it is just because—being a child of my time—I feel broken and spiritually out of joint, that I find consolation and rest in the music of Mozart wherein he gives expression to that joy of life which was part of his sane and wholesome temperament, not yet undermined by reflection.’ (You might wonder at that last bit – Mozart’s last years were surely often ‘undermined by reflection’. Anyway…) Tchaikovsky’s love for Mozart found its most overt expression later in his life when he wrote his Orchestral Suite No 4 (‘Mozartiana’), arrangements of relatively obscure bits of Mozart, but these earlier Rococo Variations celebrate the same spirit. The work is about 20 minutes long, and consists of a theme with eight variations. But here’s another issue: Tchaikovsky wrote the work for, and very willingly accepted the ‘help’ of, its dedicatee, the cellist Wilhelm Fitzenhagen, a fellow professor at the Moscow Conservatory. In fact, Fitzenhagen’s role seems to have gone beyond offering Tchaikovsky advice on cello technique; he undertook a series of performances of the work while Tchaikovsky was recuperating in Italy, and took it upon himself to edit the solo part further, to rearrange the order of two of the variations and to cut one of them entirely. Until the mid-20th century only Fitzenhagen’s version was heard, and even today it’s rare to hear Tchaikovsky’s original thoughts. (No idea which version will be in the Philippine Phil’s concert…) The piece is written for a ‘classical’ orchestra such as Mozart might have used: strings, two each of flutes, oboes, clarinets, bassoons and horns, and timpani. The ‘Rococo’ theme is actually Tchaikovsky’s own, and he subjects it to a range of treatments, sometimes skittish, sometimes lyrical, but full of charm and tenderness. Would you know it was Tchaikovsky if you heard it ‘blind’? I suspect so, just because of its lyricism – but we’re worlds away from the works he wrote immediately before and after it. YouTube has a good many really impressive readings of this work, including a lot of videos of concert performances. If you’re interested in exploring Tchaikovsky’s original composition, you can find that on YouTube too, but I’ve gone for this performance of Fitzenhagen’s slightly mutilated version, played by the Rotterdam Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by Elim Chan. The reason I’ve chosen it, though, is because the soloist, Pablo Ferrández, performed in a concert recently here in Sheffield and impressed me enormously, so I thought I’d give you all the chance to see (and hear!) why. You’ll find Tchaikovsky’s Rococo Variations here: Tchaikovsky: Variations on a Rococo Theme for Cello and Orchestra
Day 586: Symphony No 2 (Time: 35 minutes)
Early next month, the Hallé will be at the City Hall in a programme including music by Tchaikovsky, and he is my focus for today (17/4/26). If I said the work in question was one of Tchaikovsky’s symphonies, one might almost certainly expect it to be a performance of the 4th, 5th or 6th symphonies, because, let’s face it, it’s almost always true. (When it isn’t, it’s usually because the orchestra is playing the ‘Manfred’ Symphony instead.) The reality is that Tchaikovsky’s first three numbered symphonies almost never appear in the concert hall, which seems to me to be a great shame, not because they’re masterpieces – they aren’t, really – but because they offer another side to the composer than the ‘tortured soul’ we’ve come to expect, symphonically. And for me, particularly, the opportunity to encounter a performance of the Symphony No 2 is especially exciting, because this was the first of Tchaikovsky’s symphonies that I fell in love with. That might require a bit of explanation, so I should point out that I was 12 or 13 at the time, and with hindsight I suspect it’s probable that I simply wasn’t ready, emotionally, for the turbulence of any of the final three symphonies as a 12-year-old, not yet having encountered teenage angst, and what I really wanted was a really good tune or two, played as loudly as possible, and maybe even over and over again. In this respect, Tchaik 2 ticks all the boxes, as they say. As you may know, Tchaikovsky did not find composing symphonies to be an easy task, being daunted by the Germanic tradition in this field. He respected Haydn and Beethoven, but absolutely adored Mozart, whose late symphonies cast a long shadow. There were later 19th century composers in the Germanic tradition that he valued (and took ideas from), notably Mendelssohn and Schumann, but in truth the biggest stumbling block to overcome was the simple fact that ‘the symphony’ was not a form with any history in Russia at all. Glinka started, but didn’t finish, two of them. In the generation before Tchaikovsky, there’s Anton Rubinstein (who wrote six of them, that don’t sound very Russian at all), and among his contemporaries there’s Borodin (who wrote two – and the 2nd is particularly wonderful), Balakirev (who also wrote two) and Rimsky-Korsakov (three). What those last three composers shared was a belief that ‘the Russian symphony’ should draw its inspiration, in large measure, from Russian folk song, and its melodic and harmonic conventions. For Tchaikovsky, wanting to face westwards, as it were, to write a ‘European’ symphony at least as much as a ‘Russian’ one, squaring that particular circle was a hard task. He struggled with his Symphony No 1 in his mid-twenties, and its mixed response led him to revise it, over and over, for the next 20 years or so, and even then it was a piece he regarded as deficient, structurally, even if it was, he said, ‘a sin of my sweet youth’ for which he always retained ‘a soft spot’. However, it was to be six years before he tried the symphony as a form again, and this time, like his nationalist peers, he found inspiration in Russian folk song. This has led to the symphony acquiring a label which, in contemporary terms, is problematical. He wrote almost all of it in draft form in the summer of 1872, while staying on the estate of his married sister in the region of Russia that was then known as ‘the Ukraine’, or ‘Little Russia’. Obviously these days, when Ukraine is a separate sovereign nation, this might feel like a rather contentious label, but (wishing to avoid historical revisionism) back in the late 19th century the country we now know as Ukraine was, for better or worse, part of Russia, and in that sense, its folk melodies were ‘Russian’ ones, and Tchaikovsky’s use of them was, in the 1870s, very popular. The symphony was enthusiastically welcomed on its first performance, but (typical Tchaikovsky) he had second thoughts, and the version that’s heard these days, when we encounter it at all, is Tchaikovsky’s revision, first heard in 1881, which tidied up some of the clunky transitional passages and made ‘an enormous cut’ (Tchaikovsky’s own description) in the finale. What gives the 2nd Symphony its character, I think, is that you’ll find in it none of the angst-laden morbidity that features elsewhere in his symphonies (even the 1st, and the really rather dull 3rd, succumb to that at times), and the result is consistently genial and often playful. The first movement has a slow introduction, which uses the folk song ‘Down by Mother Volga’, before the main Allegro Vivo follows a more conventionally symphonic course. The slow movement isn’t really slow at all, but rather it’s a gentle march, which started life as the Bridal March in his rejected opera ‘Undine’, written three years earlier. There’s a central section that makes use of another folk song, ‘Spin, O my Spinner’ (catchy, huh?), that Tchaikovsky had encountered a little earlier when he was putting together an anthology, ’50 Russian Folk Songs’, that he had arranged for piano duet. The third movement Scherzo is quite like an extract from a Tchaikovsky ballet (especially the middle section, which foreshadows ‘The Sleeping Beauty’), and it’s a very rhythmically driven movement, with lots of use made of bars in 2/8 time played simultaneously against other instruments playing in 3/8 time. It’s the last movement, though, that’s the ‘folkiest’ of all, a set of variations (one might uncharitably say ‘repetitions’) on the folk song ‘The Crane’, which, apparently, Tchaikovsky first encountered on his sister’s estate, sung by the butler! There are some contrasts in the movement – there’s a quirky little syncopated dance tune that’s Tchaikovsky’s own invention – but essentially the finale focuses on the folk song theme, which is varied not so much in terms of developing the melody, but rather presenting it, or phrases from it, in different keys or played by different combinations of instruments. Eventually there’s a loud climax, a crash on the tam-tam, and then a helter-skelter ‘presto’ coda which takes us to a breathless conclusion. As I say, my 12-year-old self loved it. Now I can see it as a stage in Tchaikovsky’s journey towards finding a voice that would allow him to express something more personal, more intimate, but I still think it’s a work that’s lots of fun to listen to, and one that should see the light of day far more often than it does. As for a performance, YouTube is pretty well stocked, and out of the options I’ve gone for this one, performed by the London Symphony Orchestra, conducted rather unexpectedly (not his usual repertoire) by Sir John Eliot Gardiner. You’ll find it here: Tchaikovsky: Symphony No 2
Tchaikovsky, Boris (1925-96)
Day 553: Sinfonetta for String Orchestra (Time: 22 minutes)
Today (29/8/25), as you can see, is Tchaikovsky day. But… I’ve often thought that one of the most frustrating things, if you were a composer, must be to share a name with other, quite possibly more famous composers. If you were related, this would perhaps make matters worse. You don’t hear a lot of the music of either Leopold Mozart or Franz Xaver Wolfgang Mozart these days, and no doubt living in the shadow of a more famous son or father has a lot to do with this. In some ways it might be even worse to be a son (or other close relation) of JS Bach – though to be fair Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach managed ok, being much more famous in his lifetime than his now more illustrious father. But today’s composer bore no relation to his renowned 19th century namesake; he just happened to have the same surname. But as it’s his 100th birthday, in a manner of speaking, on 10th September, let’s hear it today for the quite-possibly-should-be-more-famous Tchaikovsky. That’s Boris Tchaikovsky, of course… Boris Tchaikovsky (1925-96) is from the generation of composers who made their mark in the Soviet Union in the years around the middle of the 20th century. I’d bundle Tchaikovsky along with people like Schnittke, Sviridov, Denisov, Weinberg and the very recently deceased Shchedrin in this respect. These are composers who grew up in the Soviet Union, for better or worse, but one of the things that I suppose links all of them is that the strictures of Communist Party cultural conservatism meant that their musical language was formed without recourse to the ideas of the avant-garde development going on elsewhere in the world in the middle years of the 20th century. Consequently, although their work is occasionally experimental, it is almost always fundamentally tonal, and employs traditional formal structures (the symphony, the string quartet, etc.). Tchaikovsky was born in Moscow. Neither parent was a musician by profession, though both were musical on an amateur level – his father a violinist and his mother a singer. In 1943 he entered the Moscow Conservatory as a composition student, and after Shostakovich joined the music faculty in 1946 Tchaikovsky became one of his students. However, after the 1948 purge that saw Shostakovich denounced as ‘formalist’, his students were directed to denounce their teacher, but Tchaikovsky refused, which shows at least some independence of mind. He graduated the following year, and from then on he effectively spent the rest of his life as a professional composer. There’s a nice quotation from his contemporary, the Russian poet David Samoilov, who said of Tchaikovsky: ‘The outward pattern of Boris Tchaikovsky’s life is simple. Its plot and content are in his works. He grew up, he studied, and what followed is music...’ He occupied a number of official positions in Soviet musical organisations: he joined the Committee of the Composers’ Union of the Russian Federation in 1968, and in the 1980s he joined the board of the Composers’ Union of the USSR. After the collapse of the Soviet Union he taught at the Russian Academy of Music, being still in post there when he died in 1996. In fact, though, he made his living largely through writing film music – he produced the scores for over 50 films and TV series, as well as incidental music for plays, whether staged or broadcast on the radio. However, alongside this more ‘functional’ music, if you like, he was also a prolific composer of concert music. There are four symphonies, four instrumental concertos, six string quartets, and then dozens of works for various combinations of chamber and orchestral forces, along with piano music and songs. A great deal of his music has now been recorded, so if you like what you find in the link below there’s a lot of other stuff out there to explore. So, what is his music like? Well, this quotation from a programme note for a concert given by the Kremlin Chamber Orchestra is perhaps disarmingly direct about how to place him in the context of his more famous predecessors: ‘In Boris Tchaikovsky's musical world, the passionate sweep of his namesake predecessor turns into a gentle, tender caress, the driven intensity of Shostakovich into restful pastoral, and the biting sarcasm of Prokofiev into charming humour.’ One might see his work as falling into two broad periods, largely governed by the ‘freezing’ or ‘thawing’ of Soviet party policy. His works from the 1950s are traditionalist, but with enough ‘spiky’ edges to have their own sense of vitality. But with the changing attitudes in the USSR in the later 1960s, his music became more experimental and dissonant. However, I don’t think you’d have any doubts, on hearing Tchaikovsky’s work, about its Russian roots. As for a work to mark Tchaikovsky’s imminent centenary, I thought I’d go for something gentle and genial. In fact, his Sinfonietta for Strings, dating from 1953, emerged at a tricky time for Soviet composers – the intense cultural oppression from 1948-53, and the uncertainty about what might happen next after Stalin’s death in the last of those years – so maybe its essential ‘conservatism’ is entirely understandable. Its four movements – ‘Sonatina’, ‘Waltz’, ‘Variations’ and ‘Rondo’ – employ a language that has lots of echoes of Shostakovich. A review of a recording of the work summarised it thus: ‘a mixture of unhurried lyricism, gentle good humour, [and] capable but lightly handled counterpoint.’ I’d point to the third movement as the most interesting, I think. It’s harmonically quite hard to pin down at first, and there are shifts of tempo as the music turns darker and more turbulent, before we get to a consolatory conclusion. As for a recording, YouTube has an aged video performance from the Soviet era, in which the Sinfonietta is played by the strings of the Moscow Radio Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Vladimir Fedoseyev. You’ll find it here: Boris Tchaikovsky: Sinfonetta for String Orchestra
Tcherepnin, Nikolai (1873-1945)
Day 379: Six Horn Quartets (Time: 14 minutes)
Today (12/5/23), I have an anniversary posting about a composer of whom, I suspect, hardly anyone will have heard. Not that that’s a reason to ignore him any longer… Nikolai Tcherepnin was born on May 15th, 1873, which means that this coming Monday would have been his 150th birthday. I suspect the event will be marked by a resounding silence on Radio 3, but we’ll see… Meanwhile, I may be able to fill in a few gaps in your knowledge of this guy and, at the end, introduce you to at least one of his pieces of music. It doesn’t pull up any trees, as they say, but that’s no reason for us not to take an interest. In fact, there’s more than one Tcherepnin in the musical history books. Nikolai (1873-1945) was the father of the (slightly better-known) composer Alexander Tcherepnin (1899-1977) … and if you’re really into family trees of composers, Alexander was in turn the father of Serge Tcherepnin (b1941) and Ivan Tcherepnin (1943-98), also composers. You will no doubt be thrilled to know that a body called The Tcherepnin Society exists, and its back-stories furnish me with much of today’s information. Nikolai Tcherepnin’s early personal history was not particularly happy: his mother died when he was a baby, his father’s new wife did not take to him at all, and in his childhood Nikolai’s father seems to have been particularly violent towards him. Paternal pressure pushed him towards studying law, but as is the case with many composers going against family wishes, Nikolai continued to compose, and after his law degree he studied with Rimsky-Korsakov and gained a degree in composition in 1898. His generation (compare, most obviously, Rachmaninov, born in the same year) embodies the kind of long, dying echo of Romanticism in music which ran well into the 20th century, regardless of modernist fashions. On a professional level, Tcherepnin was initially a musical academic, teaching at the St Petersburg conservatory, where his pupils included Prokofiev, who dedicated his Piano Concerto No 1 to him, and who credited Tcherepnin’s enthusiastic championship of Haydn and others with planting the ‘seeds’ for his ‘Classical’ Symphony. There’s a rather touching tribute to Tcherepnin from Prokofiev which is worth quoting: ‘Of all my teachers, Tcherepnin was the liveliest and most interesting musician. Although I didn't learn all I should have about orchestration in Rimsky-Korsakov's class, I made up for it in Tcherepnin's class. His talks about conducting were always meaningful; his talk about the future of music was no less interesting: he struck me as such an innovator that it made my head swim.’ He succeeded Rimsky-Korsakov as Principal of the conservatory in 1905, staying in post until the 1917 revolution. In 1918 he moved to Georgia, but when the Bolshevik revolution reached there too in 1921, he moved to Paris, where he spent the rest of his life. He was also a conductor, and founder of the Russian Conservatory in Paris, but deteriorating health forced a gradual withdrawal from public life, before his death in 1945. In musical terms, Tcherepnin’s early works inevitably reveal the influence of Rimsky-Korsakov, but after some fairly derivative attempts at what you might see as ‘classical’ forms (a string quartet, a symphony) he settled for writing programmatic and ‘illustrative’ music, for which he seems to have been temperamentally better suited. He wrote ballet music – his ‘Le Pavillon d’Armide’ was taken up by Diaghilev’s ‘Ballets Russes’ company, with great success – and he followed this up with further compositions in the same vein. Even after his self-imposed exile in Paris he continued to get his works performed in prestigious circles: Diaghilev’s company presented Tcherepnin’s ‘Dionysus’ and ‘Russian Fairy Tale’ in the early 1920s. In later life he wrote two operas, and (so it is claimed) his greatest work, the oratorio ‘The Descent of the Holy Virgin into Hell’ (1937). However, as the biographical text from The Tcherepnin Society website puts it, ‘Tcherepnin's best scores still suffer unjust neglect today; and … in his rather uneven output, the gold has yet to be separated from the dross.’ Quite. Still, most of his work has now been published (the ballets appear the main exception to this: only three out of twelve are in print), so maybe there’ll be a Tcherepnin revival sometime in the future… As for what to choose to illustrate this rather niche figure in the history of Russian music, I thought I’d go for a chamber piece for the rather unusual combination of four horns. So, today’s choice is the Six Horn Quartets, which date from 1910. In effect these are short, tonal character pieces. They have descriptive titles. The first movement is ‘Nocturne’, with long singing lines underpinned by the bass notes of the fourth horn. The second, ‘Ancient German Song’, is lyrical and pastoral. Third is ‘La Chasse’, an obvious tribute to the hunting horn idiom. The fourth movement is ‘Choeur Danse’, which has the feeling of a waltz. The penultimate piece is ‘Russian Popular Song’, starting with just a solo horn, but then filling out the texture in a melody that feels like it’s rooted in Russian folksong. The last movement is ‘Un Choral’, a setting of the Lutheran hymn tune ‘Wachet Auf!’ (‘Sleeper, awake!’) as made most famous in Bach’s cantata of that name. YouTube has a handful of performances of this piece, but there’s a particularly stylish video recording by four horn players from the Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra: Stefan Dohr, Andrej Zust, Stefan de Leval Jezierski and Sarah Willis. You’ll find it here: Tcherepnin: Six Horn Quartets
Telemann, Georg Philipp (1681-1757)
Day 52: Concerto for Transverse Flute and Recorder in E Minor (Time: 16 minutes)
Today (13/5/20), a suggestion from Malcolm, for a Baroque composer yet to feature in this list – the extraordinarily prolific Georg Philipp Telemann (1681-1757). In fact, some musicologists claim he’s the most prolific composer in history. It’s not unreasonable to claim that the familiar ‘big three’ composers of the Baroque era (Bach, Handel and Vivaldi) should really be a group of four, with the addition of Telemann. Certainly, of all the major figures of his age, his music is the least explored. What is also certain is that he was exceptionally professional and had a good eye for catering to the needs of the market. However, the criticism of his ‘note spinning’ is surely misplaced. He wrote lively, vivid works in every genre of his day, often with unusual combinations of instruments at their heart. Malcolm has suggested a concerto for Baroque flute and recorder. (It’s sad that the recorder became, during the 20th century, an instrument to be murdered by small children, rather than a virtuoso member of the wind section.) The concerto in question, for those completists among us, is the Concerto for Transverse Flute and Recorder in E Minor, TWV 52:e1. You’ll find the period instrument ensemble the Bremer Barockorchester, with flautist Felipe Egana and recorder player Anninka Fohgrub here: Telemann – Concerto for Transverse Flute and Recorder in E Minor
Day 170: Overture-Suite in Bb 'Les Nations', TWV 55:B5 (Time: 20 minutes)
Today (12/3/21), it’s the turn of Georg Philipp Telemann (1681-1767). In two days’ time, on Sunday 14th March, it will be his 340th birthday. (And before I go any further, I should point out that this is measured using the ‘Old Style’ Julian calendar – we have to wait until 24th March if we observe the anniversary according to the Gregorian calendar. For the sake of simplicity, here and elsewhere when it’s relevant, I’m settling for whatever the date was at the time of the event: so, when Telemann was born, it was 14th March!) Telemann has appeared once before on this list (see Day 52), at which point we heard one of his many dozens of concertos. As I noted then, Telemann is often reckoned to be the most prolific composer in history. He spent the bulk of his working life in Hamburg, where he was appointed Kantor of the city’s principal school and music director of its five largest churches. He appears to have had a particularly unhappy personal life, although one can detect little of this domestic grief in his music: his first wife left him soon after their marriage, and his second wife seems to have cultivated a lifestyle of extensive extra-marital affairs and gambling, and clearing these debts seems to have been one of the motivating factors for Telemann's extraordinary range of music publications, teaching guides and anthologies. His efforts as a music publisher have had a lasting effect: he was one of the first to assert the intellectual property rights of the composer. It has taken some time for Telemann to be given the respect which is due to him: as (relatively) recently as 1911, the Encyclopaedia Britannica commented, in contrast to the compositions of Bach and Handel, on ‘the vastly inferior work of lesser composers such as Telemann’. However, with the revival of ‘period instrument practice’ in the last 50 years, the exceptional range, colour and creative imagination present in his work has begun to be understood more fully. In terms of orchestral music, his preferred genre was the ‘Overture-Suite’, of which there are somewhere in excess of 100 in existence. This is essentially a suite of dance movements, preceded by a more substantial ‘overture’, typically with a slow introduction and conclusion, bookending a more lively central section. (Bach's four orchestral suites are also examples of this genre.) Out of these dozens of compositions, I’ve selected just one to represent Telemann's seemingly endless invention. This is, if we’re to go by the full title, the Ouverture des Nations, in Bb, for strings and continuo, TWV55: B5. I’ve chosen this largely because it’s a good example of a 17th/18th century fashion, for composing music in ‘national styles’ (you’ll find similar compositions by French composers like Lully and Rameau). So, this is, after the ‘Ouverture’ movement, Telemann the scene painter. The piece is in eight movements. After the Ouverture, there is a pair of minuets, and then six movements depicting ‘Les Turcs’, with the ‘Janissary music’ typical of the ‘Turkish’ style, with its heavy percussion; then ‘Les Suisses’, which is very sedate and stolid; then ‘Les Moscovites’, with its tolling bell, presumably depicting the bells of the Kremlin; then ‘Les Portugais’, which has a kind of Latin passion and temperament. The final two movements aren’t so much about travelling to various European locations, but rather about ways of travelling. So, we have ‘Les Boiteux’ (sluggishly plodding horses) and finally ‘Les Coureurs’, where the horses move at a much faster trot! As for a performance, there’s a nice audio recording of this piece by the conductorless Akademie fur Alte Musik, Berlin, which you can listen to whilst looking at a painting of a cat and several kittens clearly engaged in their own travel-related research! You’ll find it here: Telemann – Overture-Suite in Bb 'Les Nations', TWV 55:B5
Thomson, Virgil (1896-1989)
Day 112: The Plow that Broke the Plains (Suite) (Time: 14 minutes)
After Tuesday’s gently nostalgic experience, courtesy of Ennio Morricone's score for ‘Cinema Paradiso’, today (21/8/20) we have an entirely different filmic experience, and an entirely different musical one to go with it. I’ve chosen music by Virgil Thomson (1896-1989), a composer whose fame today rests largely on two film scores, for ‘The River’, a documentary about the Mississippi, and ‘The Plow that Broke the Plains’, a documentary about the terrible effects of the ‘Dust Bowl’, caused by uncontrolled farming on the great plains region of the USA. It occupies the same world as Steinbeck's ‘The Grapes of Wrath’. Thomson has often been put down as a kind of poor man's Copland, but I think that does him a disservice, not least in that it overlooks his role in cultivating that characteristic American sound in orchestral music in the first half of the 20th century, folk-like in idiom, and generating images of space, distance and rural simplicity. Thomson had a major role as a kind of cultural mentor during his lifetime. He lived the last 50 years of his life at the Chelsea Hotel in Manhattan, with his partner, the painter Maurice Grosser, at the centre of a kind of gay circle of artists, musicians and writers. ‘The Plow that Broke the Plains’ was a short documentary, screened in 1936. It was an attempt to raise awareness of the need for FD Roosevelt's ‘New Deal’ to offer relief and promote recovery after the Great Depression. Thomson wrote the score for the film, and later extracted a short six-movement suite from it, and it is this that I suggest we listen to today. Recordings of the piece are regularly associated with Leopold Stokowski, who recorded it twice, initially for the soundtrack, and the second time with his Symphony of the Air, in 1961. That is the recording used in this video, which is accompanied by stills from the original film. You’ll find it here: Thomson: The Plow that Broke the Plains (Suite)
Tippett, Michael (1905-98)
Day 214: Fantasia Concertante on a Theme of Corelli (Time: 19 minutes)
Sir Michael Tippett (1905-98) appears on this list today (13/8/21) for the first time. There was a period after the Second World War when he was discussed in the same breath as Benjamin Britten as Britain's leading composer, and after Britten's death in 1976 there was a sense that Tippett would fulfil that role. However, in the two decades or so since his death it would be fair to say that Tippett's reputation has slipped somewhat. Now, for many composers that sort of posthumous dip is not unusual, but the expectation might be that if Tippett's name were to recover one might have seen signs of it by now. As it is, his presence in the concert hall and the opera house is probably limited to a handful of works from relatively early in his career: the Second World War oratorio ‘A Child of Our Time’, the Concerto for Double String Orchestra from around the same time, the opera ‘The Midsummer Marriage’ from the mid-1950s, and the work I want to focus on today, the Fantasia Concertante on a Theme of Corelli. Perhaps it’s the case that Tippett's music has needed individuals or groups to champion its cause – Sir Colin Davis in the symphonic and operatic repertoire, the Lindsay String Quartet in the quartets, for example. The key to Tippett's work, I think, is his wholehearted embrace of the ideas of Carl Jung, particularly (and this is from the final section of ‘A Child of Our Time’) the belief that 'I would know my shadow and my light, So shall I at last be whole’, a concept that is evident even in the apparently ‘abstract’ music of the Corelli Fantasia. As you’ll know from my previous posting, Corelli was born in 1653, and in 1953 many organisations sought to mark his tercentenary. The Edinburgh Festival commissioned this piece from Tippett, which reflected his interest in 17th and 18th century music, notably its use of counterpoint (noddy definition: two or more musical lines sounding at the same time that are melodically independent of each other but harmonically consonant). Tippett, like Corelli, uses two violins and a cello as soloists, set against a main (though larger than in the Corelli) body of strings. Structurally the piece consists of seven variations on two themes (one slow, the other fast) from Corelli's Op 6 No 2, followed by a fugue which the composer and musicologist David Matthews, in my CD sleeve notes to this music, calls (and hello again, Mr Jung) ‘a long slow ascent from darkness into light’. I first came across this music in Peter Hall's wonderfully atmospheric film ‘Akenfield’ in 1974 (showing my age there). Ever since I’ve regarded it as being as compellingly and authentically English as any similar work for strings, such as Elgar's Introduction and Allegro or Vaughan Williams’ Tallis Fantasia, and it’s definitely a work I would rank alongside those in terms of quality. As for a performance, there’s a lovely one on YouTube by the conductorless string ensemble A Far Cry, given in Boston in 2015. You’ll find it here: Tippett: Fantasia Concertante on a Theme of Corelli
Tobias, Rudolf (1873-1918)
Day 383: Julius Caesar (Overture) (Time: 10 minutes)
Rudolf Tobias was born on 29th June 1873, which means that this coming Monday is his 150th anniversary. Not a lot of people know that – in fact, the mere writing/reading of this email has probably doubled the number of those in the UK who were aware of it, or indeed of Mr Tobias at all. You may recall that some time ago, I featured a short Estonian season, to explore the many other composers than Arvo Pärt who have been part of that country’s exceptional musical history. So, Days 328-30 explored just a little of the music of Heino Eller, Eduard Tubin (who also turned up on Day 344) and Lepo Sumera. That short list by no means exhausted the possibilities, and so Tobias’s anniversary today (26/5/23) allows me to add one more name to the roll-call of Estonian composers. Tobias (1873-1918) has some claim to being the first professional Estonian composer – or at least, the first to produce works of any substance, such as for symphony orchestra. (As with any claim to be the ‘first’ of most things, advocates for Johannes Kappel or Miina Harma – both born before Tobias – might object, but they have pretty much disappeared without trace.) However, Tobias and his slightly younger contemporary Artur Kapp (there are several Kapps, in a dynastic sort of way; I’ll feature them one day…) laid the foundations for symphonic music in Estonia, and there are two works in particular – Kapp’s ‘Don Carlos’ Overture and Tobias’s ‘Julius Caesar’ Overture – that gave that movement a push in the right direction. Estonian music before the Russian Revolution of 1917 was really quite ‘Russophile’ in orientation. The shift towards anything more distinctly ‘nationalistic’ started to gain momentum in the years before the First World War because composers took more interest in Estonian folk music, and became much more assertive after Estonian independence in 1918. However, Tobias quite literally predates that. He studied in St Petersburg with Rimsky-Korsakov, graduating in 1897 but remaining there until 1904. After that, he lived and worked in Estonia for four years, but then the rest of his life was pretty itinerant, moving from Paris to Munich to Dresden to Prague to Leipzig and finally to Berlin, where he died of pneumonia at the age of just 45. Tobias’s musical output runs to solo piano pieces, works for organ, short choral settings, a cantata (‘Johannes Damascenus’), an oratorio (‘Jonah’s Mission’), a piano concerto, two string quartets and a handful of orchestral works, of which really the only one to find even a little foothold in the repertoire is the ‘Julius Caesar’ Overture. This overture was written while Tobias was studying in St Petersburg, and it’s no surprise that it has a slightly ‘Russian’ quality as a result. His music shows almost no interest in more ‘modernist’ developments that were gathering momentum in the latter years of the 19th century. His models, apart from the influence of Rimsky, were Beethoven and Liszt. There’s a somewhat endearing note about Tobias on the website of the Estonian Music Information Centre: ‘Tobias was an optimistic and strong-willed, but impatient person. As a composer, he was able to generate numerous high-spirited ideas, but lots of them remained as plain sketches on the paper. Despite the setbacks, Tobias’ music radiates vitality and belief to [sic] the better future.’ Very little of Tobias’s music is recorded, even today, and so unsurprisingly we’re in audio-only territory for this performance of Tobias’s ‘Julius Caesar’ Overture, which is performed here by the Royal Scottish National Orchestra, conducted by Neeme Järvi: Tobias: Julius Caesar (Overture)
Tomášek, Václav (1774-1850)
Day 472: Requiem in C Minor, Op 70 - i) Requiem Aeternam (Time: 6 minutes) and ii) Dies Irae (5 minutes)
Today (16/4/24), we’re back on birthday duty once more, because tomorrow marks the 250th anniversary of the birth of a Czech composer whose star has faded somewhat, but whose work nevertheless marks an interesting shift in musical tastes in the early 19th century. So, I’d be surprised if any of you (unless you’ve sung in choirs for ages or played a lot of piano music) will have encountered the work of Václav Jan Křtitel Tomášek (1774-1850), or even have heard of the man himself. There are reasons for this, mostly to do with changing fashions and the way we retrospectively tell the story of the history of music, a consequence of which is that often composers who had seemed significant in their own day become written out of the narrative. As I get older (he said, trying to sound like age confers wisdom…) I’m becoming more and more interested in composers that one might describe as ‘liminal’, those who are neither one thing nor the other when it comes to the music they produce, but rather exist on the boundaries or transition points between one dominant musical era and the next. Every significant musical period – renaissance, baroque, classical, romantic, modern, post-modern – has its established names, those whose music perfectly reflects the conventions of that era, or perhaps those who by force of their originality drag musical fashions into a new phase – Beethoven shifting the dial from classical into romantic, or Stravinsky moving the sound world from romantic to modern. However, in the background, there are countless composers whose impact is nowhere near so revolutionary, but who nevertheless provide gradual shifts in the tastes of the times, paving the way for more powerful voices to dominate. All that waffle is by way of introduction to the position Tomášek occupies in early 19th century music. You can see from his dates that he was just four years younger than Beethoven, though he lived over 20 years longer – indeed he outlived not just Beethoven, but Schubert, Mendelssohn and Chopin – and listening to the music of those latter two, we’d have no difficulty identifying them as ‘romantic’ composers. In his day Tomášek was famous – ‘the Pope of Prague’ was the epithet that attached itself to him in his later years, in that he ‘ruled’ the musical world of that city, and of Bohemian music more widely, over a period of almost 40 years. Initially self-taught, he became famous as a teacher and cultural guardian, opening his own musical institute in Prague in 1824. Being an autodidact often seemed to mean he was opinionated (and indeed he was often crushing about music he despised – he was splendidly rude about Rossini!) but I particularly like the comment of the Canadian musicologist Kenneth Delong, who noted that ‘Tomášek's memoirs … reveal him to be deeply concerned about all things artistic and intellectual: a man of courage and idealism, unflinching in his pursuit of truth in music and in life.’ As for his music, Tomášek’s most influential role was in the development of shorter piano pieces in ways that influenced Schubert directly and Chopin indirectly. His catalogue of works reveals him writing sets of short pieces with titles like ‘Eclogues’ (seven sets of those – they are to Tomášek what ‘Songs without Words’ were to Mendelssohn), ‘Rhapsodies’, ‘Dithyrambs’ and so on. He also wrote a good many art songs, and there’s considerable overlap between his writing for voice and piano and that of Schubert, even down to setting the same lyrics on several occasions. He wrote three symphonies that have survived, all dating from the first decade of the 19th century. They sound like a cross between Mozart (in many ways Tomášek’s musical starting point) and Weber. In the final 20 or so years of his life there’s very little new music, but a great deal of teaching. However, overall, it’s not implausible to claim that he was the founder of the Czech early romantic style in music, whose music led inevitably to that of Smetana. I wondered about what to choose to mark this rather single-minded figure’s 250th birthday, and in the end I’ve gone not for piano music or songs – both of which are readily available on YouTube for anyone interested to dig a little deeper – but, because it feels like a very long time since we’ve had much choral music on this playlist, I thought it would be interesting to hear a couple of movements from his Requiem in C Minor, Op 70, which dates from 1820. Along with his Missa Solemnis (which dates from 1836) it was probably the work of Tomášek that brought him the greatest popularity in his lifetime. The prompt for the piece was a catastrophic flood that wiped out the village of Stran in Bohemia. It has a fairly conventional approach to the texts it sets – it’s in ten movements, starting with a ‘Requiem Aeternam’ and ending with an ‘Agnus Dei’ – and is written for the familiar forces demanded by such a work, four vocal soloists, mixed choir and orchestra. If you’re familiar with settings of the Requiem Mass from the late 18th/early 19th century – pieces by Mozart, obviously, but also maybe Salieri or Cherubini – there isn’t a lot to surprise you in Tomášek’s setting, but I think you can hear that we’re on the way towards the sound world of the mid-19th century here. Our ’40 minute rule’ means that there isn’t time for more than a couple of movements from the Requiem, but as a taster I thought I’d pick the first two, the familiarly portentous-sounding ‘Requiem Aeternam’ and the melodramatic ‘Dies Irae’. Inevitably, given the obscurity of the piece, we’re in audio-only territory, so what you have here are links to a recording by the Prague Philharmonic Orchestra and Kühn Mixed Choir, with four soloists: Tomasek: Requiem in C Minor, Op 70 - i) Requiem Aeternam and ii) Dies Irae
Tomkins, Thomas (1572-1656)
Day 162: O Let Me Live for True Love – O Let Me Die for True Love (Time: 4 minutes)
Today (12/2/21), we come to the second of Malcolm's choices to celebrate that most universal of abstract nouns, love, in the run up to Valentine's Day this weekend. This time we are in the company of Thomas Tomkins (1572-1656), a Welsh composer, born in St David's, but one who spent most of his creative life associated with Worcester Cathedral. He was, as you can see from the dates, extremely long lived, which is why he is often spoken about in the same breath as the Elizabethan madrigalists of the 1590s, and yet he survived to suffer the violence of the Civil War and the establishment of the rule of Cromwell in the aftermath of the execution of Charles I. The first time his name came to prominence was in 1601, when one of his madrigals appeared in the collection ‘The Triumphs of Oriana’, a volume put together by Thomas Morley to celebrate the then enduring rule of Elizabeth I. With the arrival on the throne of the Stuart monarchs he became a member of the Chapel Royal, and much of the rest of his creative life was spent in this dual capacity, a member of the Chapel Royal in London and organist at Worcester Cathedral. He seems to have been strongly associated, as an ardent Royalist, with both James I, and even more so with Charles I – Tomkins wrote most of the music for Charles’ coronation in 1625. With the deteriorating relationship between crown and Parliament leading to the outbreak of civil war in the 1640s, Tomkins suffered considerably. Worcester was one of the early sites of conflict: the cathedral was desecrated and subsequently closed, the choir disbanded, and the cathedral organ (the building of which Tomkins had overseen) destroyed, and Tomkins’ own home in the cathedral grounds was hit by cannon fire, rendering him briefly homeless. He died in relative poverty at the age of 84. In terms of his music, he is a bit of an anachronism – stylistically he has more in common with the music of, say, 1530-1580 than he does with that of 1650. His primary output consisted of secular madrigals and sacred verse anthems, though after the outbreak of the civil war he switched his attention to consort music (pieces for groups of viols) and keyboard pieces, such as the ‘Sad Pavan, for these distracted times’, which he composed immediately following the execution of the king in 1649. Malcolm has asked that we should listen to Tomkins’ madrigal ‘O let me live for true love – O let me die for true love’, which appeared in Tomkins’ 1622 collection ‘Songs of 3, 4, 5 and 6 Parts’. As far as I have been able to discover, Tomkins is responsible for words as well as music. The text is in many ways a conventional lover’s plea, but what makes this an interesting piece is that it is in two parts, the ‘O let me live…’ section, and a corresponding answering ‘O let me die…’ section. The text is as follows: ‘O let me live for true love,/ Fa la la la la (etc.)/ O let me live, yet let me live no longer/ Than that my life may make my love the stronger./ O let me live for true love,/ Fa la la la la (etc.)// O let me die for true love,/ Fa la la la la (etc.)/ Let not hope or old time come to end my woe,/ O let me die for true love,/ Fa la la la la (etc.)’ Tomkins' expressive and often chromatic harmony illustrates the text’s sense of yearning, living to love the unattainable, and wishing to die rather than let that true love grow stale. (I guess one also can’t help but note the erotic quibble on ‘die’ here, as elsewhere in Renaissance texts: this doesn’t quite have the, shall we say, orgasmic appeal of something like Dowland’s ‘Come again, sweet love doth now invite’, but the play on ‘dying’ must surely be delivered with a knowing wink.) As for a performance, Malcolm would like us to hear the contemporary vocal ensemble The Queen’s Six, who you can hear performing Tomkins' madrigal here: Tomkins: O Let Me Live for True Love - O Let Me Die for True Love.
Tubin, Eduard (1905-82)
Day 329: Symphony No 5 - 1. Allegro Energico (Time: 9 minutes) and 2. Andante (7 minutes) and 3. Allegro Assai (9 minutes)
We ended the previous posting in Estonia, in the company of Heino Eller, who has ‘legendary’ status as not just a leading early 20th century Estonian composer, but also as the teacher of pretty much every major Estonian composer of the last century. Today (27/9/22), I want to home in on one of the first of those figures, the great symphonist Eduard Tubin, whose symphonies span the years from the early 1930s to the early 1970s. Tubin (1905-82) was born in a small village on the eastern edge of Estonia, in an area that was at that date still part of the Russian Empire. He had a sort of classic ‘gifted child in poverty’ narrative (see also, for example, Nielsen) – I love the anecdote that his father, on realising his son’s gifts, sold a calf to buy Eduard a second-hand piano. He also used to play the piccolo to the family’s pigs while he was minding them. All very cute. His big break came as a 15-year-old when he joined Tartu Teacher’s College in 1920, and subsequently Tartu Higher Music School in 1924, where his teacher was Eller. In the decades up to the 2nd World War, he earned his living largely as a teacher, but also as a conductor of choirs, a culturally vital activity (see my previous posting for the importance of song in Estonia). By the early 1940s he had written three symphonies, substantially influenced by Estonian folk song, as well as a Violin Concerto and a considerable amount of chamber and piano music. However, it is at this point that the politics of war intervened. Estonia had been invaded by the Soviet Union in 1940 (a consequence of the 1939 Molotov/Ribbentrop Pact, which ‘gave’ the Baltic States to the Soviet Union in exchange for non-aggression arrangements with Nazi Germany), but when after Operation Barbarossa the Nazis attacked the Soviet Union in 1941, they also invaded the Baltic States. Estonia was overrun again by the Soviet Union in 1944, and this was the time when Tubin and his young family fled to exile in Sweden. There are differing accounts of Tubin’s experience and status in Sweden. Some versions see him effectively living in poverty and obscurity in Stockholm, working as a kind of clerk in the music library at Drottningholm, cataloguing and restoring old scores but essentially a lowly figure, with little notice taken of his continued compositional activity. Such breaks as he did get came from conducting a choir of exiled Estonians in Stockholm. Eventually, seeing no prospect of Estonia escaping from Soviet rule, Tubin took Swedish citizenship. He did return, briefly, to Estonia in 1961, for a performance of one of his ballet scores, but otherwise a large part of the reason for Tubin ‘falling through the cracks’ of musical history, if you like, is that the Soviet-ruled Estonian authorities largely ignored his post-exile work, and the Swedes, despite his citizenship, never really saw him as one of their own. The first significant work Tubin composed while in exile in Sweden was his Symphony No 5, and it’s this work that I want to celebrate today. Tubin’s associate, the critic Moses Pergament, commented after the first performance in 1947: ‘There can scarcely be any doubt that this symphony has been conceived and written as a depiction in sound of the Estonian national tragedy, a view in which the drama itself has been painted with the same force and artistic imagination as religiously coloured hope for the future and the inspiring prophetic vision of freedom.’ Tubin himself was more circumspect, even if it’s hard not to see the closing pages of the score as a kind of heroic vision. After this symphony Tubin’s work became less folk-based, more ‘international’ in voice (whilst remaining essentially tonal: Tubin was no avant-garde composer), but in the early years of exile there are understandably echoes of the land Tubin had lost contact with, notably in his use of the folk song ‘Meil aiaäärne tänavas’ (which I believe translates as ‘We have a garden in the street’) in all three movements, giving the work a clear thematic unity. As for a performance, YouTube has quite a number of audio-only recordings, notably by that great promoter of Tubin’s music, the conductor Neeme Jarvi, but although I’m often cautious about using orchestras made up of music students there’s a video recording of this symphony by the Symphony Orchestra of the Estonian Academy of Music and Theatre, conducted by Toomas Vavilov, that I think makes a good exception to this rule. It’s not a perfect or completely polished performance, but it engages with the music in a whole-hearted way and, amongst other things, it suggests that Tubin’s music (and Estonian music more broadly) is in good hands for the future. Unfortunately the recording has been uploaded via three separate links, but you’ll find them here: Tubin: Symphony No 5 - 1. Allegro Energico, 2. Andante and 3. Allegro Assai
Day 344: Prelude Solennel (Time: 9 minutes) and Ballade in the Form of a Chaconne on a Theme by Mart Saar (11 minutes)
Today (18/11/22), I want to mark the anniversary of a death – in this case, the 40th anniversary yesterday (17th Nov) of the death of the Estonian composer Eduard Tubin. I featured music by Tubin (his life-affirming Symphony No 5) as part of a recent short series of postings of music written by Estonian composers (other than Arvo Pärt) – see Day 329. That edition of the playlist elicited (by the standards of this list) some lively correspondence, most of it very positive and asking why we hear so little of this sort of music in the concert hall or on the radio. I have no answer to that, but what I can do is to post some more music by Tubin now, so that incrementally at least some of us will get to know a little bit more of what he wrote. I commented in that previous posting on the fact that Tubin’s life’s work really turned on the Soviet invasion of Estonia in 1944, at which point Tubin left for Sweden, where he lived until his death in 1982. I thought that to mark the anniversary of his death I’d feature two little-known works, a rather forceful orchestral prelude and a more intimate (and perhaps rather more complex) piano piece. First, his ‘Prelude Solennel’ for orchestra. This was written in 1940, in the early months of the Second World War when Estonia had not yet been invaded by Nazi Germany. The context, though, is very clearly one where Estonian society felt both immensely threatened by European events bigger than the country could withstand, and yet also passionately proud of the nation’s cultural identity. This is the setting in which Tubin’s composition was performed, for the first time, in 1940. Some commentators see this as a kind of Estonian equivalent of Sibelius’s ‘Finlandia’ – an affirmation, rooted in the moods and melodic inflections of Estonian folk song. While I don’t think this piece is in the same league as the Sibelius (it’s a bit ‘shouty’, really) you can, I think, pick up readily its blazing intensity. I’ve lifted this from a programme note for a concert given by the Vancouver Symphony Orchestra, but it gets close to the music’s intention, I think: ‘An oppressive, convoluted brassy unison ‘imprisons’ the theme. Escaping, it first becomes a rallying cry then, successively, a gruff, angry growl, a rabble-rousing battle-march, a welling song of hope and finally, impelled by an even angrier growl, a noble, stoic conclusion - surely, the perfect ingredients for a dish designed to stimulate the digestive juices of any lover of freedom, Estonian or otherwise.’ YouTube features a performance of the work that in itself was significant. It’s from 1992 when Estonia, along with Latvia and Lithuania, had just become independent once more, after the collapse of the Soviet Union. That year the manager of the pop group ABBA, one Stig Anderson, sold his music label Polar Music, and used the money to endow an annual prize (the Polar Music Prize) to celebrate one contemporary/popular musician, and one classical one. However, in this first year of the prize, the ‘classical’ award went not to an individual musician but to the three newly emerging Baltic states ‘… to support their national music culture, as a nucleus for the formation of performing rights societies in international co-operation.’ At the prize-giving ceremony a composite orchestra from these nations, the Polar Music Prize Orchestra, was conducted by Neeme Järvi, in a concert that opened with Tubin’s ‘Prelude Solennel’. You’ll find that performance here: Tubin: Prelude Solennel. My other choice of Tubin’s music today is a piano work that Tubin wrote immediately after going into exile in Sweden. The Estonian musician Mart Saar (1882-1963) was in his time one of the most popular composers in that country; his work is based very firmly in the nation’s folk music traditions. When Tubin left Estonia for Sweden in 1944 the works he wrote in the aftermath of that event resonate with a sense of longing for his homeland. His ‘Ballade in the Form of a Chaconne on a Theme by Mart Saar’ dates from 1945. The theme is from one of Saar’s songs. Somewhat less than cheerily, the words of the song describe seven tombs signifying seven periods of serfdom. (You can pick up fairly readily the oppressive context for Tubin’s piece.) The work begins with the melodic pattern of bass notes that will underpin the whole work. Tubin subjects the theme to a range of variations in mood, from the emphatic to the solemnly sacred, and several points in between. It’s performed in this video by a pianist we encountered when I put together the earlier Estonian season, Kadri-Ann Sumera, the daughter of the composer Lepo Sumera (see Day 330!). You’ll find her performance here: Tubin: Ballade in the Form of a Chaconne on a Theme by Mart Saar
Turina, Joaquín (1882-1949)
Day 301: Piano Quartet in A Minor, Op 67 (Time: 18 minutes)
Today (14/6/22), I’ve chosen a work to be given in Bradfield at the end of this month, and in so doing we add yet another composer to this playlist. Joaquín Turina (1882-1949) is, as his name might suggest, a Spanish composer. Born in Seville in southern Spain, the melodies and rhythms of Andalusian folk music run through pretty much all his oeuvre. Really the only break with that tradition came when he made the seemingly inevitable pilgrimage to Paris, the focal point for all Spanish musicians at the end of the 19th and start of the 20th centuries. There was already an established community of Spanish musicians, artists and writers in Paris when Turina arrived there in 1905, among them Albeniz (see Day 27) and Falla (see Days 154 and 240). Turina studied at the Schola Cantorum in Paris, a musically relatively conservative establishment shaped by the ideas of d’Indy (see Day 174) and Franck (one day very soon – the neglect is shameful!), but Turina was fascinated also by the sound world of Debussy (see Days 72, 113 and 242! Just demonstrating how generally wide-ranging this playlist’s connections are!). This context had a shaping influence on Turina’s first published work, his Piano Quintet, Op 1. However, the piece didn’t point the way to Turina’s future progress, since Albeniz, on hearing the composition, demanded: ‘You must give me your word that you will not write music like this again. You must base your art on Spanish popular song, on Andalusian music, because you are from Seville.’ It doesn’t strike me as the sort of ‘advice’ a young aspiring composer might want to hear, but much later in his life Turina observed: ‘Those words were decisive for me … they are a piece of advice I have tried to follow throughout my career.’ He graduated in 1913 and returned to Madrid where he spent almost all of the rest of his life, though spiritually his ‘home’ was much further south in Andalusia. This ‘andalucismo’, which might unsympathetically be seen as an over-reliance on Andalusian motifs to the point where they become clichés, might in our age of mass tourism and cultural stereotyping seem to count against Turina a little, but in his time he was simply a learned musician embracing his region’s folkloric tradition. Another of his comments might help here: ‘My music is the expression of the feeling of a true Sevillian who did not know Seville until he left it, yet it is necessary for the artist to move away to get to know his country, just as it is for the painter who takes some steps backwards to be able to take in the complete picture.’ The work by Turina which features in the Benjamin Frith Piano Quartet’s Bradfield recital is his Piano Quartet in A Minor, Op 67. It’s a mature work, dating from 1931, and it’s in three movements. You can hear in the work’s opening section the distinctly Andalusian feel of the melodies, mysterious and alluding to the ‘cante jondo’ (or ‘deep song’) of southern Spain. These motifs recur in the second and third movements too, giving the whole piece a recognisably ‘cyclic’ unity. Even more overtly folkloristic is the middle movement, in which both repeated chords on the piano and pizzicato patterns in the strings nod firmly in the direction of the guitar. As for a performance, there are actually quite a lot of decent video recordings of the work on YouTube, and out of them I’ve chosen this one by members of the WDR Symphony Orchestra Cologne and pianist Nenad Lečić, which you’ll find here: Turina: Piano Quartet in A Minor, Op 67
Day 445: Sinfonia Sevillana, Op 23 (Time: 25 minutes)
Today (9/1/24), I am commemorating the 75th anniversary of the death of Joaquín Turina (1882-1949), which falls on 14th January, this coming Sunday. We’ve had one posting about Turina already on this list – see Day 301 for his Piano Quartet, Op 67 – and when I wrote about that piece, I summarised the key developments in Turina’s life as a composer. The most important aspect of his identity was the fact that his Andalusian roots determined pretty much all aspects of his life. The consequence is that almost everything about his music is rooted in the melodies, rhythms, musical forms and patterns of orchestration that derive from the folk culture he imbibed along with the air he breathed. If we see the first major generation of Spanish composers that flowered in the later 19th/early 20th centuries being led by Granados and Albeniz, then the second one’s figureheads are Manuel de Falla and Turina. The difference between the two, I think, is that even though Falla’s music clearly sounds ‘Spanish’ (see Day 154 for the suite from ‘The Three-Cornered Hat’ or Day 240 for his ‘not quite a piano concerto’ that is ‘Nights in the Gardens of Spain’) he also reveals extensively his exposure to the early 20th century’s more ‘modernising’ influences, notably the music of Debussy and Ravel. Turina, on the other hand, put all that French influence aside very early on, and the result is something more unaffectedly ‘innocent’, I think. His music is by no means as complex as Falla’s, but what it lacks in sophistication of musical language it makes up for in local colour. All of which is a preamble to today’s choice, which is the composition that has become accepted as Turina’s major orchestral work – in fact, the longest single work he wrote for orchestra – the ‘Sinfonia Sevillana’, Op 23. This dates from 1920. At the time it was not just the biggest composition that Turina had created, but it was also the first significant work of its kind to be produced in Spain in the 20th century. But is it ‘a symphony’? Well, as with all such questions, it depends who you ask. There are those who say it’s more like a suite, in that the structural complexities one might expect of symphonic composition aren’t really present. On the other hand, it does employ a range of unifying devices, including recurring melodic and rhythmic patterns, that give the work the impression of being more than just a sequence of pretty melodies. There’s some very quotable stuff from Grove’s Dictionary of Music that I find quite illuminating: ‘In this Symphony the composer is found to have withdrawn from the impressionistic influences of Debussy and followed the cyclic form of César Franck. The fundamental theme, which changes character in each movement, gives unity to the whole. The theme at first is intimate and restrained, but then begins to expand and evolve in each of the three movements or pictures of Sevillan life —the city, the river, and the Fiesta. In this work Turina becomes the authentic troubadour of his native city; but it is not the flashy, pseudo-Seville that he brings to life in the Symphony, for no Andalusian composer has ever shunned more completely that Andalusia of parody than this gentle, austere master with his subtly inflected art. The Seville he evokes is the city that echoes with fragrant memories of cultures long since faded away.’ The work won Turina the Gran Casino de San Sebastian Prize. It is in three movements, which have descriptive rather than musical titles – an opening ‘Panorama’, offering a general evocative picture of Turina’s native city; then ‘Por el rio Guadalquivir’ (‘By the River Guadalquivir’), a sensuous and poetic movement with some subtle orchestration, describing the all-important river that runs through the city; and finally the explosion of rhythm and colour that is ‘Fiesta en San Juan de Aznalfarache’, in which the competing dances of the Zapateado and the Garrotin combine to ensure a brilliant finale. This isn’t really ‘programme music’ (you can’t really hear the depiction of situations and events in the way that you can in, say, Richard Strauss’s ‘Alpine Symphony’), but it’s music that’s alive to the moods and emotions of its locality without any (or perhaps, without very much) of the rather bombastic overstatement to which some of Turina’s later music was prone. If nothing else, it’s a heartening reminder of the warmth and vitality of Spanish sunshine at a time when most of us in the UK (and those on this list from further afield) are shivering in the depths of winter. YouTube carries a number of video recordings by Spanish regional orchestras of varying quality, and from the options available I’ve gone for this one by the Orquesta Sinfónica de la Región de Murcia, conducted by Andrés Salado Egea. You’ll find it here: Turina: Sinfonia Sevillana, Op 23
Van Eyck, Jacob (c1590-1657)
Day 495: Pavaen Lachrimae (after Dowland) (Time: 5 minutes) and Amarilli Mia Bella (after Caccini) (3 minutes)
The choice of composer for today (5/7/24) is from one of our regular contributors, Jenny Holt. I’m pleased by her choice for two reasons – one, that it introduces another composer to the list for the first time, and two, that it gives us the opportunity to listen to an instrument that, in truth, is often abused by its players, the only excuse being that they might be particularly young at the time. So, here is the music of Jacob van Eyck, for the recorder. Van Eyck (c1590-1657) was a Dutch nobleman, born into a predictably prosperous family in The Hague. Probably the defining thing about his life, apart from his music, was that he was born blind, but in terms of the career he carved out for himself, he certainly didn’t let that stop him. He was famous in his lifetime for two other reasons. For one, he produced the biggest collection of music for a solo wind instrument (the recorder, as you might anticipate) ever in Europe, at the time and still today – and we’ll come to that in due course. His other claim to fame was that he became an expert ‘carilloneur’, both as a player and as a technician repairing and developing the instrument. A carillon, for those unfamiliar, is a pitched percussion instrument played via a keyboard (and sometimes a pedal board too, as on an organ) and consisting of (at least) 23 tuned bells. Typically, these are to be found in bell towers, usually in churches but also in municipal buildings like town halls or university buildings. Van Eyck is credited with being the ‘inventor’ of the modern carillon, though the origins of the instrument go back much further. They were a big thing in the area we now know as Belgium, the Netherlands and north-eastern France. (Wikipedia - where else? - tells me that there are 56 belfries in Belgium and France that are World Heritage Sites, and that in Belgium the carillon is recognised as an ‘intangible cultural heritage’. Who knew?) Anyway, van Eyck is the musician/technician who put the carillon on the map, as it were, by developing a particular degree of renown when it came to playing, tuning, repairing or making carillons. In the early 1620s he was employed by the city of Utrecht to renovate the carillon of the tallest church tower in the Netherlands, and a year later he became the city’s official carilloneur, having responsibility for the management of all the bells throughout the city. He was a teacher too: he was the first to have built for him a small set of bells and attached keyboard for training future musicians. A particularly lovely quotation from the philosopher Descartes: ‘In Utrecht lives a blind man with a great musical reputation, who regularly plays bells... I have seen how he elicits 5 or 6 different sounds on each of the largest bells, without touching them, but only by coming close to their sound rim with his mouth...’ All this takes us some distance away from the recorder, which was van Eyck’s other great passion in life. He seems to have played the recorder throughout his life, becoming a renowned virtuoso on the instrument. He was both a collector of tunes from an immense and diverse range of sources (folk songs, psalm tunes, popular melodies of the day, dance tunes, famous melodies by other composers, pieces adapted from his other role in life, carillon melodies), and also a composer in his own right. Eventually he had put together on his behalf a collection – actually several collections – of such pieces under the overall title ‘Der Fluyten Lust-Hof’, which roughly translates as ‘The Flute’s Pleasure Garden’, or ‘Garden of Delights’. Flute? Well, it seems as though van Eyck’s preferred instrument was what he knew as the ‘blockflute’ and we know as the recorder – though as anyone who’s been to a concert by a recorder ensemble will know, there are recorders and recorders. Editions of ‘Der Fluyten Lust-Hof’ emerged from the mid-1640s onwards, with a grand compendium of 143 separate pieces collected together in an edition produced just prior to van Eyck’s death in 1657. One other fascinating feature of this collection is that it was – necessarily, given van Eyck’s blindness – not put together by the man himself but dictated to others. Some of the 143 pieces consist simply of a melody, but in most cases the melody is followed by sets of often elaborate and challenging variations on these themes. Allegedly the collection was aimed at amateur players – one can only wonder at the skills of the players of the time, given the virtuosity demanded by many of van Eyck’s compositions. As an introduction to van Eyck’s collection, Jenny suggests that we watch a video by the somewhat hyperactive recorder player (and member of ‘Team Recorder’) Sarah Jeffery, which you’ll find here. Then, here are two pieces of music from the collection. The first is a set of variations on one of the greatest hits of the era, Dowland’s ‘Lachrymae’ pavan. Van Eyck subjects the tune to a series of variations, which you’ll find played here by the Swiss recorder player Conrad Steinmann: Van Eyck: Pavaen Lachrimae (after Dowland). For a rather different experience, here is a set of variations on another tune from the collection, this one originally by the Italian composer Giovanni Caccini. The piece is called ‘Amarilli Mia Bella’, and it’s played in a rather moodily atmospheric promotional video by the French performer François Lazarevitch: Van Eyck: Amarilli Mia Bella (after Caccini)
Vasks, Pēteris (b1946)
Day 255: 'Lonely Angel' for Violin and Strings (Time: 14 minutes)
Today (4/1/22), we are in new territory for the playlist, featuring for the first time a composer from Latvia. This is Pēteris Vasks (b1946), whose journey towards his mature style is a not uncommon one for composers establishing themselves in the later 20th century. His father was a Baptist pastor in Latvia, a fact which had a significant influence on Vasks’ early career, in that until 1989 Latvia, like the other Baltic states, was under the control of the Soviet Union, and its repressive policy towards those with a Protestant religious background prevented Vasks from studying composition in Lithuania after an apprenticeship playing double bass in orchestras in Latvia. Like Arvo Part from neighbouring Estonia, Vasks began by composing overtly ‘modernist’ works, featuring avant-garde techniques such as pieces in which chance played a marked part in performance. However, the turning point in his compositional career came with the first performance of his Concerto for Cor Anglais in 1989, in which he incorporated aspects of Latvian folk music. His music is unlike Part’s, in that Vasks makes no overt references to Christianity in his compositions, but there is something of the same sort of ‘contemplative minimalism’ in these pieces, particularly those focused on issues to do with the environment, and man’s destructive impact on it. This striking comment probably best summarises his values: ‘Most people today no longer possess beliefs, love and ideals. The spiritual dimension has been lost. My intention is to provide food for the soul and this is what I preach in my works.’ Probably his best-known work is his Violin Concerto ‘Distant Light’. (I have a vivid memory of the great French violinist Olivier Charlier playing this in the atmospheric surroundings of Lisieux Cathedral whilst on holiday about 15 years ago.) The piece I’ve chosen for today is a composition Vasks describes as ‘a meditation’, called in Latvian ‘Vientuļais Eņģelis’ (‘Lonely Angel’), a sort of contemplative mini-concerto for violin and string orchestra. He wrote it in 1999, and has described its origin very precisely, inspired by a vision he had of an angel overlooking the world: ‘the angel looks at the world’s condition with grieving eyes, but an almost imperceptible loving touch of the angel’s wings brings comfort and healing. This piece is my music after the pain.’ The work is in essence a continuously unfolding melody for the solo violin, supported on a bed of sound contributed unobtrusively by the orchestra. The composition is performed on this video recording by the North Baltic Chamber Orchestra, directed from the violin by Sergey Ostrovsky. It should become clear to you that the balding, late-middle-aged man in the audience that the camera keeps homing in on is in fact Vasks himself, and he acknowledges the applause at the end of the piece. You’ll find it here: Vasks: 'Lonely Angel' for Violin and Strings
Vaughan-Williams, Ralph (1872-1958)
Day 59: Fantasia on a Theme by Thomas Tallis (Time: edited version - 8 minutes; complete score - 17 minutes)
Today (20/5/20), a suggestion from Zoe, which I’ve pimped a
little to give a bit more context. The suggestion is for Ralph Vaughan
Williams’ ‘Fantasia on a Theme by Thomas Tallis’.
Vaughan Williams (1872-1958)
was an immensely prolific English composer, from the same generation as
Howells,
Ireland,
Holst and
Delius.
He’s interesting – an agnostic who wrote much deeply-loved church music, a Londoner
(by adoption) who wrote music full of the English countryside and folk culture,
and the outstanding British symphonist of the first half of the 20th century.
The ‘Tallis Fantasia’ was written in 1910 (revised a number of times, finally in 1919)
for the Three Choirs Festival (held annually on a rotating basis at the cathedrals of Hereford,
Gloucester and Worcester).
The piece is based on a theme by Thomas Tallis (1505-85)
– whose work will feature again on this list in the not too distant future!
The melody is the third in a series of tunes written by Thomas Tallis for Archbishop Parker's
Psalter, a collection of new hymns and anthems to be used in service of the
newly-formed Anglican Church. I thought a little preparatory homework
might not go amiss at this point, so here is Tallis's initial piece, lasting
under two minutes, performed (aptly!) by the Tallis Scholars, directed by Peter
Phillips: Tallis: Third
Tune (from Archbishop Parker's Psalter). So, having listened to
that, here now is Vaughan Williams’ ‘Fantasia’. It’s one of his most
popular works. Along with ‘The Lark Ascending’ it regularly gets voted into
the top five or six when Classic FM indulge in one of their ‘Hall of
Fame’-style popularity contests. It has the very distinctive quality of
sounding both very old and very modern at the same time. The scoring, for
a string orchestra, but then a separate string quartet, and a third ensemble
made up of the leaders of each of the respective sections of the string
orchestra, gives VW the opportunity to play with string textures in some really
complex ways. Structurally, the piece is like a ‘Fantasy’ as it might have been
written by an Elizabethan composer like Dowland
– that is, a theme that recurs, whole, on a number of occasions,
but linked by free variations on fragments of that theme.
It’s both soaring and serene. Zoe has actually requested a slimmed-down version of the piece,
recorded remotely by its performers, the violinist Nicola Benedetti and fellow tutors
from the Benedetti Foundation (you may recognise Laura van der Heijden on cello
– she played both at the City Hall and the Crucible Studio during 2019).
It’s an edited version of VW's original, and about half the length of the full version,
but it’s very apt for our (semi-)lockdown circumstances. The Nicola Benedetti performance is
here: Vaughan Williams –
‘Fantasia on a Theme by Thomas Tallis’ – edited
And if that has whetted your appetite, you can listen to a performance of the piece in its entirety.
Yes, it’s 17 minutes long, but who cares? Here’s a lovely performance, showing that
you don’t have to be a British orchestra to ‘do’ Vaughan Williams.
It’s by the Toronto Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Peter Oundjian:
‘Fantasia on a Theme by Thomas Tallis’ – complete
Day 96: Norfolk Rhapsody No 1 (Time: 12 minutes)
Today (26/6/20), we have a suggestion from David for some more Vaughan Williams
(who last featured back on Day 59
with the ‘Tallis Fantasia’). So, if you want biographical details,
scroll up or click the link to go back to that posting.
The suggestion today is for VW's ‘Norfolk Rhapsody No 1’.
Vaughan Williams’ music is almost always deeply rooted in English folk song,
and the Norfolk Rhapsody emerged from his early immersion in this rich field.
He started collecting field recordings of English folksongs in around 1904,
following the example of Cecil Sharp, and his own compositions began either to
use direct quotations from folk material or to employ the sort of modal
harmonies that much traditional music uses. The Norfolk Rhapsody No 1
dates from 1906, and although Vaughan Williams was sufficiently dissatisfied
with his compositional technique at that time to want to go off and study with
Ravel (which he did, in 1908), the Rhapsody was one of his early successes.
Vaughan Williams apparently initially planned three Norfolk Rhapsodies, which
were going to form the movements of a folk-based symphony, but only the first
rhapsody has survived in the mainstream repertoire. (No 2 is missing its
ending; No 3 has just disappeared entirely.) It’s based on seafaring
songs, Vaughan Williams having collected most of the material from King's
Lynn's fishing community. The liner notes for my CD copy of this piece
tell me that he uses ‘The Captain's Apprentice’ and ‘The Bold Young Sailor’ in
the introductory section, and ‘A Basket of Eggs’, ‘On Board a Ninety-Eight’ and
‘Ward, the Pirate’ in the main body of the work. The music is gentle,
attractive and seemingly devoid of artifice, though that’s not to say there is
no skill involved. This is a piece in which we can hear Vaughan Williams
clearly beginning to find his mature voice. The recording of the work by
the LPO under Bryden Thomson (and illustrated by some attractive regional
landscape paintings) is here:
Vaughan Williams –
Norfolk Rhapsody No 1
Day 157: The Lark Ascending (version for Violin and Piano) (Time: 15 minutes)
This edition should start with an apology.
Back in mid-December, I got an email from Andy alerting me (so that I might alert all
of you) to a broadcast on BBC Four of the late Diana Rigg introducing a programme
about VW's ‘The Lark Ascending’. Alas, I forgot about it, and
the programme is no longer available on iPlayer. However, as Mr Milner
expressed some liking for the piece in question, I thought the least I could do
would be to focus on this enduringly popular work at some stage – and here it
is today (26/1/21).
Vaughan Williams has appeared twice before on this list (see Days 59 and 96),
and comments I wrote on both those occasions highlight the powerful roles that the
English landscape and English folk music played in the evolution of his output.
One of the things that consistently surprises me about Vaughan Williams is
how long it took him to find his feet as a composer.
‘The Lark Ascending’ is one of a handful of works of his that were written
before the First World War, and which began to establish his reputation,
but by the time it appeared, he was in his mid-40s. It seems to have taken him
a long time to shake off the influence of Germanic musical traditions (nurtured by
Stanford and Parry during VW's early training), and it wasn’t until he was in his 30s
that he began collecting English folk songs and discovered their uses compositionally.
Another powerful shaping force on his aesthetic outlook was English poetry, and
in particular he loved the verse of many Victorian poets (it’s salutary to note
that Vaughan Williams was ‘a Victorian’ for almost the first 30 years of his life!)
– Tennyson, Browning, the Rossettis and George Meredith, these days a
rather overlooked figure, but immensely popular in the second half of the 19th
century as both a novelist and a poet. Meredith's poem ‘The Lark Ascending’
dates from 1881, and it is both pastoral and devotional (in a non-doctrinal kind of way).
Vaughan Williams wrote these twelve lines from the poem at the head of his score:
“He rises and begins to round,/
He drops the silver chain of sound,/ Of many links without a break,/ In chirrup,
whistle, slur and shake.// For singing till his heaven fills,/ 'Tis love of
earth that he instils,/ And ever winging up and up,/ Our valley is his golden
cup/ And he the wine which overflows/ to lift us with him as he goes.// Till
lost on his aerial rings/ In light, and then the fancy sings.” There is a
nice quotation from Ursula Vaughan Williams (the composer's second wife) who
observed that VW ‘had made the violin become both the bird's song and its
flight’. The piece dates from 1914, though it did not receive its first
performance until 1920 – a different world both musically and, given the impact
of the First World War, in every other way. It’s hard now not to hear the
piece nostalgically, as an evocation of a lost pastoral world. Vaughan
Williams subtitled the piece ‘A Romance’, a term he used regularly for music of
slow contemplation. I wrote back on Day 59 that VW's ‘Tallis Fantasia’
sounds both very old and very new at the same time. I’m less sure that
‘The Lark Ascending’ sounds ‘new’. To my ears Vaughan Williams’ use of
modal harmonies (much of the piece is written either in the Dorian mode – a
scale of D to D on the piano's white notes – or the Aeolian mode – a scale of A
to A on the piano's white notes) gives this music a rootedness in a more
ancient past. These days we almost always hear the work in a later arrangement
that Vaughan Williams made for violin and orchestra, but I thought it might be
interesting to encounter it as he first intended it to sound, as a piece for
violin and piano. There are relatively few versions of the composition
with this scoring on YouTube, but I’ve selected one by the Romanian violinist
Sorin Alexandru Horlea, accompanied by the largely obscured Bianca Maria Matei
on piano. You’ll find it here:
Vaughan Williams: The Lark Ascending
(version for Violin and Piano)
Day 185: Five Variants of Dives and Lazarus (Time: 12 minutes)
Vaughan Williams has appeared several times on this list already
(see Days 59, 96 and 157),
and it might be clear from those selections how important English folk music was to him:
the ‘Norfolk Rhapsody No 1’ makes explicit use of folk songs collected by Vaughan Williams
and Cecil Sharp in East Anglia, and if there is no direct quotation in ‘The Lark Ascending’,
one can feel in its melodies and modal harmonic patterns the echoes of folk-songs past.
The music Pete has suggested for today (4/5/21) is the ‘Five Variants of Dives and Lazarus’,
which Vaughan Williams composed on the eve of the Second World War.
Vaughan Williams had been actively collecting folk songs since 1903; and by the late 1930s,
he had composed many pieces based on such tunes.
In 1932, he became President of the English Folk Dance and Song Society,
so it is clear how significant this source of music was to him.
Interestingly, in terms of his overall output, Vaughan Williams wrote some of his
most anguished and disturbing music in the 1930s (notably the Symphony No 4, of 1935),
and it’s easy with hindsight to see this sort of composition as a response to
the darkening mood of the decade.
But there’s a gap of about five years between the cantata ‘Dona Nobis Pacem’ in
1936 and his Symphony No 5 in its first version in 1941 when the normally
fertile imagination of the composer was quite subdued, almost certainly by the
shadows of war. One of the works that aimed to fill that gap was this
‘Dives and Lazarus’ piece, written for strings and harp, and first performed in
1939. He had used the tune before, in his English Folk Song Suite of
1923, and even earlier than that he had arranged the melody in the 1906 edition
of The English Hymnal, where it appears as the tune ‘Kingsfold’ (a village in
Sussex), setting the words ‘I Heard the Voice of Jesus Say’. The title of
the piece itself is interesting: Vaughan Williams called the various versions
of the tune ‘variants’, not ‘variations’, to draw attention to the fact that
this isn’t a ‘theme and variations’ work as such (which might put the emphasis
on the composer's skill in manipulating the original material) but rather
treatments of separate ‘variant’ forms of the tune as collected in different
localities around the country. VW himself hedged his bets a little here,
writing of the work that ‘these variants are not exact replicas of traditional
tunes, but rather reminiscences of various versions in my own collection and
those of others.’ As most of you will no doubt know, the parable of Dives
(the rich man) and Lazarus, the poor beggar, is taken from Luke's Gospel – in
the Vulgate, the unnamed rich man is referred to as Dives, which is Latin for
‘rich’. Poignantly, the work was performed at the composer's funeral
service in Westminster Abbey in 1958. As for a recording, I thought it
would be interesting this week to listen to archetypally English music being
performed by players from overseas. Consequently, the version I’ve selected
is by the American chamber ensemble Camerata Chicago, conducted by Drostan
Hall. You’ll find it here:
Vaughan Williams: Five Variants of Dives and Lazarus
Day 324: Serenade to Music (Time: 14 minutes)
Given the news of the Queen’s death yesterday, I’ve gone for something quietly contemplative today (9/9/22). We’ve had Vaughan Williams on four occasions on this playlist already (see above Days 59, 96, 157 and 185), and in the course of those selections I’ve picked out many of the mainstream favourites from his output – ‘The Lark Ascending’, the ‘Fantasia on a Theme by Tallis’, the ‘Five Variants of Dives and Lazarus’ and the Norfolk Rhapsody No 1. However, in today’s circumstances, I felt that one of Vaughan Williams’ most reflective and transcendent pieces might suit the mood. This is not funereal or melancholy, but rather a piece of lyrical beauty whose serenity is, I think, profoundly comforting. The composition in question is Vaughan Williams’ ‘Serenade to Music’, a setting of lines from Shakespeare’s ‘The Merchant of Venice’. In the 1930s, as the political and social mood across Europe was darkening, Vaughan Williams’ music occasionally reflected this era of turbulence – most obviously in his Symphony No 4 of 1935, with its dissonance and anger. However, after that work it was some time before Vaughan Williams wrote anything else of substantial length; with one exception (the cantata ‘Dona Nobis Pacem’, his passionately anti-war piece with its setting of one of his favourite poets, Walt Whitman, alongside the ‘Agnus Dei’ from the Mass and texts from the Bible) the next piece of over 30 minutes’ duration was the Symphony No 5 of 1941. Between those two dates we find not a great deal, at least not by the standards of Vaughan Williams’ usually prolific output. He spent some time revising his opera ‘The Poisoned Kiss’, there’s the ‘Dives and Lazarus’ piece I’ve featured already … but there’s really not much else, except in the realm of choral music. However, in 1938 there was one significant event that shifted Vaughan Williams’ focus from the storm clouds of impending war. Sir Henry Wood, who we know these days primarily as the founder of the Proms (still actually the Henry Wood Promenade Concerts, even though if anything it’s the BBC which has laid claim to their ownership), conducted his first concert in 1888. To mark 50 years since that event, Vaughan Williams wrote the ‘Serenade to Music’ as a tribute to him. In its original form it’s for orchestra with 16 vocal soloists, and in fact Vaughan Williams wrote each of the 16 solo lines with a specific named soloist in mind (their initials appear in the score alongside each relevant part). If you want to hear the first recording of the piece, with its original soloists and players, you’ll find it here. The lines from Shakespeare that Vaughan Williams sets are an edited version of Act V Scene 1 of ‘The Merchant of Venice’, in which there is a discussion about music – both terrestrial and the heavenly harmony of ‘music of the spheres’. The text appears on screen in the recording I’ve chosen, below. The first performance took place in October 1938, with Wood conducting the combined forces of the LSO, BBCSO and LPO, with soloists including Isobel Baillie and Heddle Nash. However, Vaughan Williams recognised the challenges of programming such a piece, when finding 16 equally first-rate soloists might prove unreasonably difficult. Consequently he swiftly produced four other versions, to suit different circumstances. There’s an entirely orchestral version, with a solo violin making the most of the soaring vocal lines of the original; there’s a setting for chorus and orchestra, distributing the original solo parts to the different sections of the choir; there’s a setting for choir with piano accompaniment. And then there’s the version which is, in practical terms, probably the best compromise if finding 16 soloists is a challenge: this is for four solo voices, along with a choir and orchestra. This tends to be the version which most often appears in concert today, and it’s a performance of this version that I’ve chosen for us to watch. It’s from the 2019 BBC Proms, and it’s played by the BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra conducted by Martyn Brabbins. The choral forces of the BBC Singers and the ENO Chorus are here backing the four soloists, Nadine Benjamin (soprano), Idunnu Münch (mezzo), William Morgan (tenor) and David Ireland (bass). You’ll find the performance here: Vaughan Williams: Serenade to Music
Day 333: Job - A Masque for Dancing (Scene 1: Satan's Appeal to God, and Saraband of the Sons of God; Scene 2: Satan's Dance of Triumph) (Time: 8 minutes)
Today (11/10/22) and in the next posting, courtesy of our invisible correspondent from Canada, Andrew Weaver, we are celebrating the 150th anniversary of Vaughan Williams’ birth, which occurred on 12th October 1872. Mr Weaver has suggested two pieces of music to mark this occasion, and as I am in complete agreement with him about the quality of the compositions under the spotlight, I’m very glad to hand over the musical reins of decision making to him this week. We’ve had five choices of Vaughan Williams’ music on this list, most recently on Day 324 when we heard the ‘Serenade to Music’. Next time there’ll be some symphonic Vaughan Williams, but for today we have a couple of short extracts from Vaughan Williams the ballet composer. This is not an extensive sub-set of his output, but the suggestion that he might write something about the Biblical character of Job drew from him some of the most visionary and powerful music he’d produced to date. 1928 marked the 100th anniversary of the death of the poet and artist William Blake, who painted 21 watercolours for his sequence ‘Book of Job’ in the years just prior to his death. It was these images that were the starting point for the ballet. Vaughan Williams proceeded with the score even before any plans for a staged performance were finalised. The project was offered to Diaghilev and the Ballets Russes, who turned it down. The work was first heard in concert in 1930, with the composer conducting, and the first staged performance took place a year later. Vaughan Williams insisted that the piece was not in fact a ‘ballet’, but a ‘masque for dancing’ (echoing the Elizabethan/Jacobean idea of the masque as a kind of ‘multi-media’ production combining movement, elaborate staging and effects, music and words – though in fact there is no speech in the finished piece). In fact the stage action is fairly static, with a considerable amount of mime as opposed to ballet in the conventional sense. Nevertheless, according to Vaughan Williams’ biographer Michael Kennedy, the result is ‘a perfect reconciliation of the various elements in [the composer’s] style: the lyrical ‘pastoral’ side, the folk-dance rhythms, the aggressive 20th century harmonies and syncopations, and the Purcellian splendour of a great ceremonial tune.’ Vaughan Williams dedicated the score to Sir Adrian Boult, who conducted the first recording of the work in 1946. ‘Job – a Masque for Dancing’ is in nine sections, and typically a full performance will last around 45 minutes, so today I’m selecting just two extracts for us to consider, the end of the first section, ‘Satan’s Appeal to God, and the Saraband of the Sons of God’, and the whole of the short second section, ‘Satan’s Dance of Triumph’. In the first of these extracts, God offers Satan the opportunity to test Job’s faith, before the Sons of God dance in homage to God. At the end of this first scene God steps down from his throne. In the wild and violent second scene, Satan dances before God’s vacant throne before sitting on it himself, worshipped by the Hosts of Hell. The movement ends with a kind of parody of the traditional ‘Gloria in excelsis Deo’ chant on the brass. The reason for choosing these extracts is that on YouTube there are several audio-only performances but very little by way of video. However, one video recording that does exist is of these short sections performed by the London Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by the then 83-year-old Boult in 1972. He cuts a somewhat stern figure on the podium, wielding a baton the like of which one tends not to see these days. There are also some startling 1970s haircuts on display, notably in the percussion section of the orchestra. You’ll find the performance here: Vaughan Williams: Job - a Masque for Dancing (Scene 1: Satan's Appeal to God, and Saraband of the Sons of God; Scene 2: Satan's Dance of Triumph)
Day 334: Symphony No 5 (Time: 42 minutes)
Last time out, our invisible Canada-based list member Andrew Weaver suggested music from ‘Job – a Masque for Dancing’, and today (14/10/22), he would like to hear something from a Vaughan Williams symphony. It’s a request which has encouraged me to break the ’40 minute rule’ (that no Tuesday + Friday postings shall exceed 40 minutes of music in total), but what are rules there for if not to be broken? (Discuss, as exam questions used to say.) So, if Vaughan Williams is now seen as one of the greatest composers this country has ever produced (and after a bit of a dip in his reputation in the couple of decades after his death, this statement isn’t generally challenged these days), I’d suggest that for all the seemingly eternal popularity of ‘The Lark Ascending’, the ‘Tallis Fantasia’, the setting of ‘Greensleeves’ and so on, it’s the symphonies that form the core of his output. Despite not producing his first symphony until he was 38 years old, which suggests a very long apprenticeship in other areas (for comparison, the composer usually alluded to when it comes to being hesitant about symphonic writing, Brahms, was 43 when his Symphony No 1 finally appeared, after a gestation of over 20 years, so Vaughan Williams is almost in that territory), his symphonies span nearly 50 years, and in that time his compositional style, not to mention the world around him, changed almost beyond recognition. The symphonies are immensely varied as a result, and trying to talk about the ‘best’ one, as though it were some kind of beauty contest, seems to me to be pointless. What one can say, though, is that they emerge out of a personal and wider cultural context in ways that are reasonably easy to recognise. The first, the ‘Sea Symphony’ (1910), is evidently a young(ish!) man’s work, born out of Vaughan Williams’ lifelong love for the poetry of Walt Whitman. The Symphony No 2, ‘London’ (1913) mingles musical fragments of London life with something much more like pre-First World War despair in ways that are emotionally very powerful. The Symphony No 3 (1921) is evidently a response to the First World War, its ‘Pastoral’ nickname a reflection not of the English countryside but the desolate killing fields of France and Belgium. The 4th Symphony (1935) may or may not reflect the darkening political situation in Europe, but its discordant anger suits its time. The Symphony No 5 (1943), coming as it did at the height of the Second World War, is either an escape from reality or a promise of benediction in a time of existential European crisis. Vaughan Williams was over 70 at its first performance, and it was seen in many ways as a valedictory piece, a composer bidding farewell in his old age. That being the case, the appearances of the numb-struck (post-nuclear?) Symphony No 6 (1948), the (literally) filmic Symphony No 7, the ‘Sinfonia Antartica’ (1952) and the two late symphonies of his ninth decade (No 8 from 1956, No 9 from 1958) were not at all what was expected. Different people will have their favourites – I find it difficult to decide between the 3rd, 4th and 5th – but Mr Weaver is in no doubt that it’s the Symphony No 5 that is the pinnacle of this symphonic journey, so I’m happy to go with that today and to select that piece for our shared listening. Apparently he began work on it as early as 1936, but the ‘writer’s block’ I’ve alluded to before (see Day 324 and the ‘Serenade to Music’) meant that progress was slow. It wasn’t just the distraction of impending military conflict. Vaughan Williams’ main musical preoccupation in these years was his opera (what he called his ‘morality’) ‘The Pilgrim’s Progress’ – a work that, extraordinarily, he kept plugging away at from 1909-51! But in the early 1940s, he feared that the conditions would never be right for its staging, and consequently a number of its musical ideas found their way into the new symphony that he himself conducted at the Proms in 1943. In 1952, when Vaughan Williams was asked to pick one of his symphonies for a concert to celebrate his 80th birthday, it was the Symphony No 5 he opted for, being as it is so interwoven with the music for his Bunyan work (which finds its way into the symphony’s first, third and fourth movements) and, seemingly, close to his heart. He dedicated the symphony ‘without permission to Jean Sibelius’ (Sibelius’s lovely response, ‘This Symphony is a marvellous work ... the dedication made me feel proud and grateful ... I wonder if Dr. Williams has any idea of the pleasure he has given me?’ is worth quoting, I think) and I’m very fond of the comment by music critic (and cricket reporter!) Neville Cardus, who wrote after its premiere, ‘The Fifth Symphony contains the most benedictory and consoling music of our time’. It’s a wonderful piece, from the tonally ambiguous opening ‘Preludio’ movement, via the uneasy Scherzo and the emotional core of the work, the third movement ‘Romanza’, to the final ‘Passacaglia’, ending the work where it began with its initial horn call, but transfigured. The music commentator Michael Steinberg’s summary seems to me to be spot on: ‘In peaceful meditation… the music arrives at its destination: a luminous D major close, hushed, beatific, with an ineffable sense of peace. Here, if anywhere in music, is transcendence.’ YouTube serves this symphony very well, but I’m particularly taken by the performance by the LSO and Simon Rattle, given in the slightly ghostly context of an empty Royal Albert Hall as part of the heavily truncated, Covid-disturbed Proms season of 2020. You’ll find it here: Vaughan Williams: Symphony No 5. And I hope I’ll be forgiven for breaking the ‘40 minute rule’. Surely, for a masterwork like this, it’s worth it?
Verdi, Giuseppe (1813-1901)
Day 70: ‘Tutte le Feste al Tiempo’ and ‘Si! Vendetta’ (from ‘Rigoletto’) (Total time: 12 minutes)
I’ve had a suggestion today (31/5/20) from Jenny for some opera. I’ve admitted to her already, but I should say to everyone that, alas, opera is just not my thing. I’ve tried, and there are exceptions (the three great Mozart operas, plus ‘Fidelio’, ‘Der Rosenkavalier’, ‘Peter Grimes’) but mostly it’s a bit of a closed book, and for the most part ‘the trained operatic voice’ leaves me pretty cold. My bad, as the youth used to say a couple of decades ago. Anyway, what it means really is that if you want opera on this list, you’ll need to do most of the spadework to get it. And to that extent, I’m very grateful to Jenny for suggesting two extracts from ‘Rigoletto’. Giuseppe Verdi (1813-1901) was the foremost Italian composer of the second half of the 19th century, and arguably, alongside Wagner (whose polar opposite, in many ways, he was as a composer) one of the two greatest opera composers of that century. Jenny makes the point to me, in her email suggesting these extracts, that what makes Verdi's music special is the way it has no truck with the whole ‘high culture/low culture’ debate which has done so much to make ‘classical music’ so misunderstood in the wider world. She writes: “I think it’s easy to forget that a lot of this music was, in its time, the popular music of the day (in so far as such a thing existed), rather than a particular genre with associations of ‘high’ culture versus some other kind of trendier pop music. A similar thought occurred to me when listening to Verdi's Rigoletto only the other day, which has a very hummable song at the end of Act 2 (I would say jolly, but it’s about exacting revenge...!). So if you fancy adding some opera, can I request these two clips? First, the touching reunion of Rigoletto and his daughter who ’fesses up to loving the Duke (evil philanderer of many an opera) and is comforted by her father in a beautiful duet here: Verdi – ‘Tutti le feste al tiempo’ (from ‘Rigoletto’) (this is what I love about opera) and then (which follows straight afterwards in the opera) Rigoletto's very tuneful song of vengeance here: ‘Si! Vendetta’ (from ‘Rigoletto’), just as evidence that it’s not all high twiddly singing – some of it you can basically sing along to!”
Day 388: Requiem - Dies Irae (Time: 2 minutes) and Sanctus (3 minutes)
Today (16/6/23), the choice of music is from the final orchestral concert of the 2022/23 season in Sheffield. There’s only been one opportunity to listen to Verdi on this list to date (see Day 70 for a couple of extracts from his opera ‘Rigoletto’), in large measure, as I’ve said before, because opera isn’t generally my thing. (But, at risk of repeating myself tediously, I’m very happy for there to be more operatic choices. You’ll just need to suggest them!) So, today, we have some non-operatic Verdi. Or do we (he asked, rhetorically)? Having listened to this piece several times over the years, I find myself tending to the view that, although it has ‘operatic’ tendencies, this is actually an authentic concert work – though absolutely not the sort of treatment of the text of the requiem mass that one might encounter in an ecclesiastical setting. Many composers have turned to this set of texts (sometimes by commission, sometimes as a personal response to some external event) since what is generally regarded as the first such setting, by Johannes Ockeghem in the later 1400s. In post-renaissance times, I suppose Mozart’s setting (see Day 141) started the trend that continued down through the 19th century and beyond, uniting such diverse composers as Cherubini (whose setting is really interesting and sadly overlooked I think), Berlioz, Dvořák, Fauré, Duruflé and, erm, Andrew Lloyd Webber, as well as Verdi. (Then there are other pieces with ‘Requiem’ in their titles but which diverge from the familiar text settings – Brahms’ ‘A German Requiem’ most notably, but also Britten’s ‘War Requiem’, for instance.) Anyway, for someone so wholeheartedly committed to anti-Catholic views as Verdi was, it might seem odd that he should, unbidden, choose to write such a piece, but the motive was more personal – in this case Verdi’s response to the death of the writer (and – like Verdi – Italian nationalist) Alessandro Manzoni in 1873. Verdi characteristically avoided attending Manzoni’s funeral, but just over a week later he did visit Manzoni’s tomb, and vowed at that point to write a Requiem Mass ‘to honour his memory’. The composition proceeded relatively briskly, and the first performance was given in 1874 on the first anniversary of the date of Manzoni’s death. There seems to be some debate about the extent of Verdi’s atheism, and there are grounds for seeing it as anti-clericalism rather than a wholesale rejection of Christianity. After writing the work and hearing it performed, he reflected: ‘I have done nothing but write note after note, to the greater glory of God. Now the music is done, and I am happy to have written it.’ His regular opera librettist, Arrigo Boito, observed, ‘In the ideal, moral, and social sense, [Verdi] was a great Christian. But one must be very careful not to depict him as a Catholic in the political and narrowly theological sense of the word. Nothing could be further from the truth.’ The Requiem that Verdi composed is substantial – it runs typically to over 80 minutes in performance – so I’m obviously going to be offering only limited extracts from the piece today. (There are plenty of full performances on YouTube if you want to chase them up.) But to give a flavour of the work as a whole I’ve gone for just a couple of short excerpts. First (and probably most famously) there’s the ‘Dies Irae’ setting. These are the opening bars of the ‘Sequence’ section of the Requiem. This is probably the section, depicting the Day of Wrath at the last judgment, in which Verdi most obviously gives voice to the dramatic (maybe even melodramatic) tendency in his writing. The brazenly theatrical ‘ffff’ bass drum thwacks in this section show no holding back when it comes to making an impact. In contrast to that, I’ve also picked out the ‘Sanctus’ section, a challenging eight-part fugue for double chorus. Introduced by a resplendent brass fanfare, this paean of praise (‘Holy, holy, holy, Lord God of Hosts, Heaven and earth are full of thy glory! Hosanna in the highest! Blessed is He who comes in the name of the Lord. Hosanna in the highest!’) almost shines in celebration. In terms of illustrations, I’ve gone for a performance given at the Metropolitan Opera House in New York on the 20th anniversary of the traumatic attacks on the Twin Towers of the World Trade Centre in that city in 2001. The Met Orchestra and Chorus is conducted by Yannick Nézet-Séguin. You’ll find the ‘Dies Irae’ section here: Verdi: Requiem (Dies Irae), and the ‘Sanctus’ here: Verdi: Requiem (Sanctus)
Victoria, Tomás Luis de (c1548-1611)
Day 246: Ave Maria (Double Choir) (Time: 3 minutes) and Victoria: O Magnum Mysterium (Time: 4 minutes)
The composer of the music for today (3/12/21) is Tomás Luis de Victoria (c1548-1611). I find it a bit shocking that I’ve got 246 ‘days’ into this epic endeavour without featuring Victoria’s music until now – by most assessments, he is, along with Palestrina (see Day 148) and Lassus (see Day 167), one of the three greatest composers of the counter-reformation era, and even if we expand that categorisation to include music written for the Protestant tradition (and thus allow Tallis and Byrd into the discussion), Victoria remains as one of the most powerful and expressive of late Renaissance composers. His life story is not particularly dramatic. He was born in the province of Ávila in central Spain, and entered Ávila Cathedral as a choirboy before the age of ten. His musical talents were evident very quickly, and as a teenager he was sent to Rome, funded by King Philip II of Spain, to study further – possibly, though it’s not certain, with Palestrina. What is certain is that when in 1571 Palestrina withdrew from his position as choirmaster at the Roman Seminary, Victoria took his place. As well as choirmaster and a burgeoning composer, Victoria appears to have been especially renowned as an organist. At around the age of 40 he returned to Spain where he took the post of chaplain to the king’s sister at the royal monastery in Madrid, where he remained until his death in 1611. As for his music, I’d suggest that where Palestrina is ‘smooth’ as a composer, writing pieces which generally sound blended and orderly (and, of course, exceptionally beautiful), Victoria’s compositions ‘feel’ more Spanish, somehow – there is passion, emotional turbulence, an intensity that often feels almost darkly mystical. Unlike Lassus, who wrote vast quantities of secular music as well as pieces for the church, Victoria’s output is solely devotional. His greatest large-scale work is undoubtedly his setting of the Requiem Mass, but for this seasonal series I’ve chosen two shorter pieces, his setting of the Ave Maria for double choir, and the meltingly beautiful ‘O Magnum Mysterium’. We have not had a setting of the Ave Maria (the ‘Hail Mary’) on this playlist before, though it has been put to music by many composers over the centuries. The text derives from the address to Mary by the angel Gabriel in the New Testament, to which is appended Elizabeth’s greeting to the pregnant Mary that subsequently occurs. It has slightly different forms in the various strands of Christianity, but consolidated its current state in Western Christian traditions by about the start of the 14th century. Musical settings proliferate from that point onwards. Victoria wrote this version for double choir (that is, eight lines of music for two choirs requiring SATB voices). Its power, I think, derives from the contrasts between passages which are homophonic (where the various parts move together, ‘chordally’) and other sections where the polyphony evokes a rich and complex emotional range. There’s a lovely performance of it (audio only) on YouTube by the Tallis Scholars, conducted by Peter Phillips. You’ll find it here: Victoria: Ave Maria (Double Choir) The other text I’ve chosen for today, the medieval ‘O Magnum Mysterium’, has featured twice before on this list – as one of Poulenc’s ‘Quatre Motets pour le Temps de Noel’ (see Day 145), and in the modern setting by Lauridsen (see Day 147). I discussed the text’s provenance and meaning in those postings, so you can refer back to them for more information. All I’d say about Victoria’s motet which sets these words is that it is extraordinarily beautiful – the ‘great mystery’ of the title is communicated with a sense of awe and wonder, right from the spine-tingling opening in which the voices enter in turn and then weave in and out of the texture, echoing and commenting upon each other, before the celebratory ‘Alleluia!’ with which the piece ends. There’s a wonderful performance of it on YouTube by the young English group the Fieri Consort, which you’ll find here: Victoria: O Magnum Mysterium
Vieuxtemps, Henri (1820-81)
Day 435: Viola Sonata (Time: 22 minutes)
If one were to go back about 150 years or so, there is no doubt that Henri Vieuxtemps, whose music I’ve chosen for today (5/12/23), would have been, for music lovers, a pretty recognisable household name. His life (1820-81) was essentially that of the mid-19th century travelling virtuoso, and he attracted the sort of acclaim otherwise reserved for players like Paganini, Wieniawski and Sarasate. His preferred instrument was the violin, though like many such performers (Paganini is another good example) he was equally proficient on the viola – and in fact Vieuxtemps was particularly interested in playing string quartets, in which context he always played the viola. He was born in what is now Belgium (then part of the Kingdom of the Netherlands) and made his performing debut at the age of six (as you do). By the time he was fifteen he had performed in most of the musical capitals across Europe. This itinerant lifestyle was one he pursued through most of his adult life, though he did reside in Russia for five years in the later 1840s as a court musician in the employment of Tsar Nicholas I. Later he toured the USA in the 1850s. His performing career was cut short in the early 1870s when he suffered the first of what would be four strokes, which rendered him increasingly helpless, spending his final years in a sanatorium in Algeria. However, there was more to Vieuxtemps than simply being a kind of performing circus act on the violin (or viola). He had aspirations to being regarded as a composer, and saw that as increasingly more important than his performing career. He wrote his first violin concerto in his mid-teens, and from soon after that his compositions clearly set him apart from other virtuosi whose creations were essentially vehicles to show off their prodigious technique. That’s not to say that his music does not present performers with challenges – it certainly does, as you’ll see below – but Vieuxtemps wasn’t interested in showing off for the sake of it. He attracted acclaim from the usual suspects in mid-19th century Europe: it was Schumann who compared Vieuxtemps favourably with Paganini, and Berlioz enthused about his compositions, calling his Violin Concerto No 2 ‘a magnificent symphony for violin and orchestra’. The great majority of Vieuxtemps’ works were composed for violin – seven violin concertos and over 60 pieces featuring the violin as a solo instrument in total. Sometimes you kind of know what you’re getting even without having to listen to the works – we can probably all pass if offered the chance to hear his ‘Souvenir d'Amérique, Variations burlesques sur "Yankee Doodle", Op 17’, for example – but what’s striking about Vieuxtemps’ list of works is how few of them fall into this sort of ‘box of tricks’ category. He wrote only one viola sonata (there’s a fragment of another that was left incomplete at his death), and it was begun in 1860, first performed the following year (in London, where he was touring at the time) and finally published in 1863. It’s a three movement work, with the first movement being the most substantial – a broad Allegro preceded by a Maestoso introduction. This opening section makes particular use of the viola’s lower register, evoking that dark, ‘woody’ quality that the instrument has. Once the main Allegro gets under way Vieuxtemps presents the performer with many challenges – the video I’ve chosen makes some of these look easy, but that’s because the performer I’ve chosen is one of the best around – with lots of staccato triplet passages. The middle movement is a ‘bacarolla’ (a gondolier song), and – for me anyway – there’s a distinct ‘Russian’ feel to this: it doesn’t seem all that big a leap from here to the music of Tchaikovsky, say. Finally there’s a sparking ‘scherzando’ movement, where predictably enough the virtuosity is let off its leash to a large extent, especially in the coda. Much of the interest in Vieuxtemps’ music disappeared at his death – in the decades after it he was often more noted as the teacher of the next generation of performers, like Ysaye, rather than as a composer in his own right, but the past 40-50 years have certainly seen a growth in interest in his writing. In the 19th century viola sonatas are not exactly thick on the ground, and you could make some claims for saying that the Vieuxtemps sonata is the first substantial work for these forces to have been composed. For a work of such (relative) obscurity, there are quite a lot of video performances of it on YouTube, with some front-rank soloists among them. I’ve chosen a recording by Michael Gieler, who has been Principal Viola of the Amsterdam Concertgebouw Orchestra for the past 30 years. He’s playing in this recital with the pianist Lauretta Bloomer. You’ll find the performance here: Vieuxtemps: Viola Sonata
Vignery, Jane (1913-74)
Day 273: Horn Sonata, Op 7 (Time: 18 minutes)
To open a concert given by Ensemble 360 in Sheffield later this month is a work from the now little-known Belgian composer Jane Vignery. And, as this is International Women’s Day, I could scarcely not feature a work by a female composer, so my musical choice for today (8/3/22) is Vignery’s Horn Sonata, Op 7. Jane Vignery (1913-74) – actually the name by which she published her compositions; she was born Jeanne Emilie Virginie Vignery – was not a particularly prolific composer, and was probably best known during her lifetime as a music teacher at the Royal Conservatory of Ghent. She inherited her musical interest from the maternal side of the family (both her mother and maternal grandfather were composers), and after initial study at the Ghent Conservatory, Vignery did what almost every aspiring composer of note in the 20th century did – she studied in Paris with Nadia Boulanger. She also had lessons with Paul Dukas, and I don’t think it’s too fanciful to hear the influence of his work on Vignery’s output. In her late 20s, she won a clutch of prizes, including a major award, the Prix Emile Mathieu, in 1942 for the Horn Sonata, Op 7. Ill-health forced her to give up ideas of life as a concert violinist in her early 30s, and the rest of her life was devoted to composition and to teaching. She died in a major train accident (a collision on the Brussels-Charleroi line in which 17 others also died) at the age of only 61. The Horn Sonata is in three movements, and throughout it reveals a distinctive personal voice, though there are echoes of Dukas and Ravel in there too. For me, the middle movement, a contemplative Lento Ma Non Troppo, is the most evocative. It is marked by a brooding lyricism, which rises to a stirring climax before sinking back into an uneasy dream world. It is preceded by a lively sonata-form Allegro first movement, in which the fanfare-like first idea is followed by a more lyrical second theme, and the Finale is a sparkling Allegro Ben Moderato. As for a performance, there’s a lovely one on YouTube given by David Cooper, Principal Horn with the Chicago Symphony Orchestra, accompanied by a sadly anonymous pianist. He introduces the work briefly before the performance, which you’ll find here: Vignery: Horn Sonata, Op 7
Villa-Lobos, Heitor (1887-1959)
Day 293: Five Preludes for Guitar (Time: 19 minutes)
Today (17/5/22), the composer is the Brazilian Heitor Villa-Lobos (1887-1959). He is probably deserving of the accolade of being the most important composer to come out of South America. He was also unbelievably prolific; and there’s no disguising that this makes some critics very sniffy about him – the basic criticism being that someone who wrote so much must necessarily be lacking some sort of quality-control filter. This is a popular criticism of many composers – it gets levelled at Martinů, for instance, or Milhaud, or (going back into the 19th century) at Liszt or Schubert, or (going further back still) at Telemann and even Mozart… though curiously not at Bach! The fact is that at his death, Villa-Lobos left over 2000 compositions to his name. Even now, over 60 years later, there’s still no comprehensive catalogue of his works, and ‘new’ pieces are still being found. Villa-Lobos was undoubtedly a trail-blazer, and his music essentially reflects the two presiding (occasionally conflicting) influences on his creative life: the indigenous music of Brazil (itself a multi-faceted concept, taking in the urban music of Brazilian popular culture as well as ‘native’ Brazilian styles) and the music of JS Bach. The most popular of his compositions these days is probably his set of nine ‘Bachianas Brasileiras’ – a title very difficult to translate into English beyond the rather literal ‘Brazilian Bachian-pieces’. (You may not know your way around the whole set, but almost certainly most of you will have heard ‘The Little Train of the Caipira’, the final movement of the Bachianas Brasilieras No 2, or the whole of the evocative Bachianas Brasileiras No 5, with its scoring for wordless soprano and an ‘orchestra’ of cellos.) Villa-Lobos had little formal training as a musician, picking up his knowledge instead by playing with street musicians in his native Rio. His father died when Villa-Lobos was only 12, and he earned a living for the family by playing in orchestras in local cinemas and theatres. In his twenties, he began researching in earnest the music of Brazil’s ‘interior’, and the raw energy and brutality of this music is evident in many of his compositions. That’s not to say that he abandoned the European traditions of classical music, though – just that he wanted to absorb and animate them in his own way. Like the rest of the musical universe, he went to Paris after the First World War (though, possibly uniquely, he doesn’t appear to have studied with Nadia Boulanger!), but even here there was an outspoken defiance about his approach; he once said of his time in Europe, ‘I have not come to learn, I have come to show what I have done up to now.’ In his later years, Villa-Lobos became slightly more of an establishment figure in Brazil, being closely associated with the populist dictatorship of Getulio Vargas from 1930-45. Later still, Villa-Lobos developed a rather grouchy persona, and it might be fair to say that in his last years an assumed cynicism and malicious wit turned into something more consistently misanthropic. Still, none of that, I think, should take away from the teeming vitality of his music. However, the piece Mr Dutton suggests that we listen to is not one of his sprawling scores for a vast orchestra, but a composition for the solo instrument probably more closely associated with Brazilian musical identity than any other, the guitar. Curiously, out of his hundreds of scores, Villa-Lobos wrote relatively little for guitar: there’s a Guitar Concerto (written for Segovia), the Chôros No 1 for solo guitar, a set of 12 highly virtuosic Etudes for guitar, a handful of short solo pieces mostly dating from very early in his career, and (today’s choice) his Five Preludes for Guitar, published in 1940, and dedicated to his second wife Arminda Neves d’Almeida. (She took his name when they got together, though whether he actually divorced his first wife does not seem clear.) Prelude No 1 in E Minor is melancholy in mood in its outer sections, enclosing a more upbeat middle section. No 2 is entitled ‘Melodia Capadócia’, after a rogue-like figure from Brazilian carnival, but again you can hear how his ‘street music’ is underpinned by something more Bachian. The third prelude is subtitled ‘Homage to Bach’, especially evident in its middle section. Prelude No 4, by contrast, is ‘Homage to the Brazilian Indian’; it’s probably the most serious and intense of the set. Finally, Prelude No 5 (‘Homage to Social Life’) is more animated, though Villa-Lobos’s rather snarky comment, that it’s written for ‘fashionable, affected young people, frequenting the concerts and theatres of Rio de Janeiro’, might imply that there’s a malicious wit underlying the vitality. YouTube offers an interesting compilation of performances of these five pieces, played on different guitars by four leading performers on the instrument. You’ll find it here: Villa-Lobos: Five Preludes for Guitar
Day 450: Fantasia for Saxophone, Three Horns and Strings (Time: 11 minutes)
We’ve had one appearance so far on this list by Villa-Lobos (see Day 293 for his set of Five Preludes for Guitar), and I thought it might be interesting today (26/1/24) to hear some of his music (of which, let’s face it, he wrote a considerable amount) that’s not for the guitar… but which nevertheless still has its roots in the sounds and rhythms of Brazilian folk music. Villa-Lobos wrote a great many concertos, though not all of them have the word ‘Concerto’ in their names. There are five Piano Concertos, two Cello Concertos, a Harmonica Concerto, a (well known) Guitar Concerto and a Harp Concerto. But then there are other ‘concerto’-style works with other titles, and he seems to have been particularly fond of the label ‘Fantasia’ to describe some of these: there’s one for violin and orchestra, one for piano and orchestra, one for cello and orchestra … and the work that Jess Gillam is playing next month in Sheffield, the Fantasia for Saxophone. Actually, if we’re being precise, it’s the Fantasia for Saxophone, Three Horns and Strings, and it dates from 1948. In effect, it is a small-scale saxophone concerto. Villa-Lobos was by training a clarinettist, and consequently he occasionally played the saxophone himself, particularly as a performer in street orchestras in Rio in his youth. The instrument appears in a significant number of his works, from chamber music pieces like the Nonet or two of the varied cycle of pieces to which Villa-Lobos gave the over-arching title ‘Chôros’ (14 numbered ones, for vastly different combinations of forces, plus another three works that have ‘Chôros’ in their titles): the Chôros No 3 is for clarinet, bassoon, saxophone, three horns and trombone (or for, erm, a male chorus … or for all those instruments and a male chorus – that’s the sort of composer Villa-Lobos was!) and the Chôros No 7 is for flute, oboe, clarinet, bassoon, saxophone, violin and cello … and optional tam-tam – there you go again! He also used the instrument a lot in orchestral pieces, notably in his Symphony No 4, which contains parts for, amongst other things, four saxophones. Still, the Fantasia for Saxophone is the only actual concerto he wrote for the instrument, in which it plays the starring role. Sometimes there are incidents in Villa-Lobos’s life that one can link to what is going on in his musical imagination, but for much of the time music seemed simply to pour out of him regardless. For example, when this work was composed he was diagnosed with bladder cancer and actually underwent surgery in New York, a city he visited regularly on his travels after the end of the Second World War – but I doubt you’d guess the personal drama from the character of the music itself. One of the interesting things (not necessarily the word performers might use) about Villa-Lobos’s compositions is how relatively little attention he sometimes paid to the actual practicalities of how to produce the notes he wrote in the score. Some of those issues caused difficulties in the early days after this piece was finished. Its dedicatee, the French player Marcel Mule, had known Villa-Lobos for over 20 years, but he never played the work, objecting to the seeming impossibility of playing the score’s highest notes on a soprano sax. Eventually Villa-Lobos transposed the work down from the key of F to Eb, and produced a version for the tenor sax – though it is normal these days for it to be played on the soprano sax, which is what Jess Gillam will do in next week’s concert. The piece is in three short movements, with a familiar fast-slow-fast pattern. The first movement, marked ‘Animé’, begins with a multi-rhythmic introduction (complex poly-rhythms are another of Villa-Lobos’s specialities), leading into a delicate tango. There is an expressive opening to the slow movement played on the solo viola, before the saxophone takes over in a movement that has the brooding mystery of a nocturne. The finale plays once more with rhythmic contrasts. For the most part, it’s in 7/4, though 4/4 passages in the middle of the movement add contrast, before the music drives to a virtuosic conclusion. YouTube has a number of video recordings of this piece on its books, though often shot from strange angles or with fairly amateur production values. It’s also the case that the musicians aren’t necessarily in the front rank of performers. However, I think this recording, by the Armenian State Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Dmitry Yablonsky, and with the talented young Singaporean saxophonist Samuel Phua as soloist, filmed in a (presumably Covid-related) almost deserted auditorium in Tel Aviv, does a reasonable job. You’ll find it here: Villa-Lobos: Fantasia for Saxophone, Three Horns and Strings
Villette, Pierre (1926-98)
Day 576: Hymne à la Vièrge Op 24, Ave Verum Corpus Op 3, Salve Regina Op 5 (Time: 11 minutes) and O Quam Amabilis es, Op 71(4 minutes)
Today (6/2/26), my contribution to our ever-developing appreciation of all things ‘classical’ is devoted to an anniversary composer. On 7th Feb 1926 – and so, as you’ll no doubt have already realised, 100 years ago tomorrow – the French composer Pierre Villette was born in Duclair, a small port on the Seine, in Normandy. I’ve sung only one piece of music by Villette in my life – a piece I’ll explore later – but I remember well its attractive, dreamy quality. Pierre Villette (1926-98) is not all that well known these days, and in fact there wasn’t really a time when his music was fashionable. If you’ve come across him at all, the likelihood is that it will be in relation to liturgical music in church. I’ve found a nice quotation from a piece extolling the memory of Villette, written a couple of years after his death on behalf of the music conservatoire in Besançon (of which Villette was director for around a decade from the mid-1950s). I like it because it shows just how resistant Villette was to the (musical) fashions of the 20th century: “Pierre Villette's music cares little for passing fads, which does not mean that it is backward-looking. A solid training in the disciplines of writing has anchored him in a tradition drawn from the sources of rigour. The obvious quality of this production lies in the care that presides over its production. A refined harmony, without excesses or anachronisms, using a subtle chromaticism, although clearly tonal or even modal, and above all a melodic imagination of great richness, of an obvious naturalness, constitute one of the clearest aspects. But it is obvious that an inner gravity most often presides over his creative process.” (That’s an online translation of the original French, which might account for its clunkiness, but I hope you get the sentiment behind it.) He was born into a musical family – his father played piano, organ and violin, and dabbled in composition; his mother was a pianist; other relations sang semi-professionally, or played in regional orchestras. Early studies with Duruflé (see Day 18 for a movement from his Requiem) were due to lead to enrolment at the Paris Conservatoire, but the war intervened, and it was the later 1940s before he completed his studies, though by then he had also written a fair bit of music, some of which you’ll hear below. However, another (and more long-lasting) career derailment was that Villette suffered from ill-health all his life, having one of his lungs removed in the late 1940s and spending considerable amounts of time in the Alps recuperating. His main professional appointments were as director of the Besançon Conservatoire (as already mentioned) from 1956-67, and – moving to the south of France for health reasons – as director of the Music Conservatoire d’Aix-en-Provence from 1967 until his death. He seems to have been a diligent teacher and administrator, and there are many devoted testimonies to his care for his students, not to mention points when his life overlapped with other (now more famous) musical names. In Paris, he was a student alongside Pierre Boulez (and how differently from each other they turned out!), and he ran a major music festival in Aix, rubbing shoulders with the likes of Dutilleux and Lutoslawski. What, then, of his music? He wrote a small amount of orchestral music, mostly as a young man. The only substantial piece that gets any performances these days is a Violin Concerto. There’s also, very improbably, an operetta, ‘Qu'il est bon, mon oncle Léon’ (written under a pseudonym!), and a very small amount of solo piano music. But the two fields in which he worked throughout his life were chamber music and choral music. I had hoped to illustrate at least something of the former strand in his output, but even YouTube reveals pretty much nothing of his chamber compositions. However, if you want music for voices, there’s lots of it about, so that’s what I’m going to focus on from here onwards. His first completed work for 4-part choir, a setting of the Latin hymn ‘Ave Verum Corpus’, was completed by 1944, when Villette was still a teenager. It has become one of his most-performed works. The liner notes for the CD of Villette’s choral music that I’ve come across describe how typical of future Villette compositions this work is. Though it’s clearly tonal (as all his compositions were) the harmonies are often chromatic, and there are particular moments where the word-painting is vivid and dramatic, such as where the hushed women’s voices at the end are echoed by the men, before the piece ends on an unresolved chord. (Simple definition: so that it doesn’t sound ‘finished’, and we don’t feel as though we’ve come to rest in a place that feels like ‘home’.) At the same time – 1944 – Villette also made a setting of the Salve Regina. This is a lovely, gentle piece. I particularly like the way he uses voices to refer poignantly to tears in the text. Moving on a decade or so, probably Villette’s most famous piece of choral music is his ‘Hymne à la Vierge’, written in 1955 and dedicated to his future wife, whom he met while convalescing in the Alps. As the title suggests, it extols the Virgin Mary. It’s a setting of a poem by Roland Bouhéret, and it has a lovely, almost innocent simplicity – a direct, even naïve melody in the soprano line, and interesting but not obtrusive stuff going on underneath in the other three parts. The final work of Villette’s I’d draw to your attention comes from much later in his life – from the early 1990s, in fact, when Villette was beginning to pare down his style to something even more ‘innocently’ beautiful. This is the motet ‘O quam amabilis es’, and I’ve chosen this because about 15 years ago, Escafeld Chorale, the choir I sing with, performed it as part of a Christmas concert, and it’s stuck with me ever since. It’s a setting of a text extolling the beauty and gentleness of Christ, and what I love about it are the soft, fleeting dissonances that punctuate its flow. As I said, above, YouTube is generously stocked with Villette’s choral music, so I’ve picked out two links for us to explore. First, here are the voices of the choir of West German Radio, directed by Peter Dijkstra. They perform, in this order, Villette’s ‘Hymne à la Vierge’ Op 24, his ‘Ave Verum Corpus’ Op 3, and finally his Salve Regina Op 5. You’ll find all the pieces here: Villette: Hymne a la Vierge Op 24, Ave Verum Corpus Op 3 and Salve Regina Op 5. And, in an audio-only recording I’m afraid, here is the late motet ‘O quam amabilis es’, performed by the Holst Singers, directed by Stephen Layton: Villette: O Quam Amabilis Es, Op 71
Vivaldi, Antonio (1678-1741)
Day 109: Sinfonia in C, RV 112 (Time: 4 minutes)
This week’s choices are curated (to use that inescapably fashionable word)
by Malcolm, and they consist of two pieces by Vivaldi, who, after 108 days
of not being mentioned, at last gets a moment (or two) in the spotlight.
Antonio Vivaldi (1678-1741), the ‘Red Priest’, as he is often popularly known
(due to the colour of his hair, not his political opinions!), is nowadays seen
as one of the three Baroque composers (alongside Bach
and Handel)
who most impressively reveals the style and technique of music written
in the first half of the 18th century. However, unlike the
other two, Vivaldi's music pretty much disappeared (with the exception of the
inevitable ‘Four Seasons’ concertos) until the early 20th century,
and really it has taken the revival of interest in ‘period instrument practice’
in the last 40-50 years to make it clear just what an innovator and
experimentalist Vivaldi was. When I was an A-level Music student, decades
and decades ago, the familiar cliché was that Vivaldi didn’t really write more
than 500 concertos – he just wrote the same one more than 500 times. Now,
when pretty much all his music is recorded and accessible, we know what a
disservice that does him. Vivaldi's life story has its quirks – he was
ordained in 1704, but seems to have suffered variably poor health, or at least
that is one reason given for him being allowed to withdraw from liturgical
duties almost immediately afterwards. His ‘day job’, as it were, was at
the Ospedale della Pieta, in Venice, an orphanage at which boys learned a trade
and left at 15, whereas girls were taught music, and the best of them stayed on
to perform in the orphanage orchestra. Most of Vivaldi's non-operatic
music was written for these forces, and there seem to have been some
phenomenally gifted young women in the orchestra. Malcolm's choice of
Vivaldi's music for today (11/8/20) is the Sinfonia in C, RV 112. The
term ‘Sinfonia’ gives us our more modern musical label ‘Symphony’, but in the
late 17th and early 18th century it could mean a range of things
– usually an orchestral piece, but without soloists (and thus, a
contrast with the ‘concerto’), and often a piece acting as the prelude or
introduction to an opera or cantata, or maybe just the first movement of an
instrumental suite. The Sinfonia in C, RV 112, appears to
have been written in the early 1720s, but as far as I know there’s no evidence
now for what occasion might have prompted it – so it exists today as a
free-standing short three-movement piece for small string orchestra and
harpsichord accompaniment. From the available versions on YouTube I’ve
gone for a performance by the Czech ensemble Barocco Sempre Giovane, a group of
young players performing on modern instruments but influenced by period
instrument techniques. You’ll find it here (complete with the rather
bizarre appearance of a harp given prominence centre-stage – presumably it was
going to feature later in the concert!):
Vivaldi: Sinfonia in C, RV
112
Day 110: Gloria in D, RV 589 (Time: 32 minutes)
Malcolm has made the selections for this week, and today (14/8/20) we have the second of his two choices of music by Vivaldi, the Gloria in D, RV 589. There is archival evidence that Vivaldi wrote three settings of the Gloria, though one of those has been lost since its first being catalogued. Of the two extant settings, the version in D, RV 589 is by far the more popular. It is in the repertoire of all amateur choirs that perform this sort of music – in fact, it was one of the pieces I sang at my very first concert when I initially joined a choir decades ago, and my current choir has performed it twice in the past ten years. It’s both tremendous fun and not terribly difficult – a good combination for amateur choirs! Originally scored for an all-female choir (and orchestra) at the Venetian orphanage where Vivaldi worked, you can now find performances of it by many different combinations of forces. As I mentioned last time, Vivaldi's work was pretty much ignored until the early 20th century, and although the Gloria in D is now very definitely his most popular choral work, its first known performance after Vivaldi's lifetime seems to have been in 1939, when a performing edition was put together by the Italian composer Casella. Its twelve sections offer a rich contrast in mood and emotion, from the jubilant opening ‘Gloria’, through the more expressive ‘Et in Terra Pax’, several movements for combinations of soprano and alto soloist, before ending with a satisfying double fugue in the concluding ‘Cum Sancto Spiritu’ movement. Both Malcolm and I have sung this with small choirs and not much more than chamber orchestra forces, giving a lighter and altogether more ‘bouncy’ feel to the piece, and I’ve tried to find a YouTube performance that observes that sort of experience. You’ll find the performance by the Israeli instrumental ensemble Barrocade, accompanying the Voces Musicales Choir of Estonia, here: Vivaldi – Gloria in D, RV 589
Day 168: Stabat Mater (Time: 22 minutes)
The musical selection for today (5/3/21) comes from Mo (one of our noble band of Invisibles on the list), who wants to hear Vivaldi's ‘Stabat Mater’ in a very specific performance. Vivaldi (1678-1741) was actually born 343 years ago yesterday, so a belated happy birthday to him! He has appeared twice before on this list (see Days 109/110), so I won’t rehearse elements of his life story that you can read for yourselves there. The background to the composition of Vivaldi's only setting of the ‘Stabat Mater’ isn’t terribly clear, though it seems to be a relatively early work, and a product of his time ‘on a break’ (as it were – he was fired in 1709, and re-hired two years later) from his post at the Ospedale della Pieta in Venice. During this interregnum, in 1711, he visited Brescia, where he was commissioned to write a setting of the Stabat Mater, and this received its first performance there the following year. Vivaldi sets only ten of the 20 stanzas of the original text, and musically it has been seen as a bit of a ‘copy and paste’ job, given that the music that Vivaldi wrote for the first three movements (stanzas 1-4) is then repeated wholesale for movements 4-6 (stanzas 5-7), before he produces new music entirely for the remaining three movements of the piece. The work is set for a solo alto and an ensemble of strings, so the sound palate is quite pared down. The setting shows even more restraint in that only with the final ‘Amen’ chord do we feel the brightness of a major key, the rest of the piece being in F Minor or C Minor pretty much throughout. The ‘Amen’ movement is also the only one not to be set to a slow(ish) tempo. The result is a kind of bleak and restrained beauty, something almost monochromatic, achieving its impact with an extreme economy of means. Mo wrote to me to suggest a recording by a performer with a very distinctive contralto voice. This is by Lina (or Lena) Mkrtchyan (or Mkrtchan or Mkrtchat – Westernised spellings of her name are quite fluid) with musicians that on YouTube are credited simply as ‘Chamber Orchestra’, conducted by Igor Zhukov. You’ll find it here: Vivaldi: Stabat Mater
Day 266: Violin Concerto in E, RV 269 ('Spring' from 'The Four Seasons') (Time: 11 minutes)
My choice for the playlist today (11/2/22) is Vivaldi’s Violin Concerto in E, RV 269, which in itself might not mean a great deal. However, if I said it was ‘Spring’ from ‘The Four Seasons’, I’m fairly confident that most of you would be able to hum the main tune from at least one of its movements without much trouble – and those who couldn’t do that would almost certainly recognise the piece instantly on hearing it. We’ve had three pieces by Vivaldi on the list before today (see Days 109, 110 and 168), focusing very largely on his choral output so far. In those postings I’ve written about aspects of Vivaldi’s life and composing career so I won’t repeat all that here. He was, even by general Baroque standards, an immensely prolific composer. He wrote more than 500 concertos, at least 230 of which are for violin. (He also wrote dozens of concertos for cello, for bassoon, for oboe, for flute, for recorder, for viola d’amore – like a violin but with extra, sympathetically resonating strings – for mandolin and for lute … and that’s before we get to all the multi-instrument concertos, which number around 70 in total.) One wonders where he found the time to write his 46 operas, or the 60 or more large-scale religious choral works. His best known employment was at the Ospedale della Pieta in Venice, but Vivaldi also had periods (usually when he’d fallen out with the management at the Ospedale) working at other musical centres in Italy. So it was that Vivaldi found himself in Mantua, in northern Italy, at the court of Philip of Hesse-Darmstadt, the Governor of Mantua at the time, working as the Maestro di Cappella in 1718. In the three years or so that Vivaldi was there, his most famous musical contribution to the history of Baroque music was made, the composition of the four concertos that make up what we now know as ‘The Four Seasons’. There is some debate as to the extent of the ‘revolutionary’ quality of these works. Instrumental and orchestral compositions that engage in ‘picture painting’ are a conventional feature of Baroque music (indeed, of music of all eras). These concertos were eventually published as the first four of Vivaldi’s set of 12 concertos, Op 8 – a set which also includes a concerto that depicts a storm at sea (Op 8 No 5), another portraying a hunt (Op 8 No 10), and yet another which rather enticingly illustrates ‘pleasure’ (Op 8 No 6)! Yet it is Op 8 Nos 1-4 that maintained Vivaldi’s reputation through the 150 years or so (1770-1920) when almost all his other music was neglected. Each of the ‘Four Seasons’ concertos depicts a season (not, I guess, a surprise!), preceded by a sonnet which the concerto then illustrates – or, some argue, it is the sonnet that illustrates the previously-existing concerto, rather than the other way round. Whatever, the three movements of the ‘Spring’ concerto are described in verse thus. The first movement Allegro depicts this scene: ‘Springtime is upon us. The birds celebrate her return with festive song, and murmuring streams are softly caressed by the breezes. Thunderstorms, those heralds of Spring, roar, casting their dark mantle over heaven, then they die away to silence, and the birds take up their charming songs once more.’ The dreamy second movement Largo is given a rather more pithy summary: ‘On the flower-strewn meadow, with leafy branches rustling overhead, the goat-herd sleeps, his faithful dog beside him.’ Finally, the dancing Allegro third movement shows us this rustic scene: ‘Led by the festive sound of rustic bagpipes, nymphs and shepherds lightly dance beneath spring's beautiful canopy.’ (Unsurprisingly, all that sounds lots better in the original Italian!) Finding a performance of the piece on YouTube that gets away from the monotony of old-school Vivaldi recordings (there’s a very dull one from Itzhak Perlman and the strings of the Israel Phil) without getting too idiosyncratic isn’t easy, but I’ve settled for the period instrument Netherlands Bach Society ensemble, directed from the violin by Shunske Sato. You’ll find it here: Vivaldi: Violin Concerto in E, RV 269 ('Spring' from 'The Four Seasons')
Volans, Kevin (b 1949)
Day 499: White Man Sleeps (Third Dance) (Time: 6 minutes) and Walking Song (6 minutes)
Today (19/7/24), I want to mark the imminent 75th birthday (it will actually fall a week today, on 26th July) of the composer Kevin Volans. He’s someone I’ve been aware of for many years, though his works don’t seem to be programmed all that often in concert. He is often described as a South African composer, and this is true, inasmuch as he was born in Pietermaritzburg in 1949, and lived in South Africa until he left for Europe to pursue post-graduate study in his early 20s. After that, as far as I can tell, he never based himself permanently in South Africa again, eventually coming to reside in Ireland from 1986 and becoming an Irish citizen in 1994. His ‘journey’ as a composer is an interesting one, taking him in several really quite distinct directions. His early work was very influenced by Stockhausen (see Day 399 for a snippet from ‘Stimmung’); he was a student in Stockhausen’s composition class in Cologne in the mid-1970s. However, this early identification with the European avant-garde did not last long, and with others from the same sort of background he advocated for a shift to what became called the New Simplicity movement. This is, and in other ways clearly is not, quite like the shift towards Minimalism that had been evolving in the USA from the early 1960s. What makes Volans’s music striking from this point onwards is its interest in other musical traditions and also in other art forms, notably painting. Although he’d grown up in South Africa he had (largely a consequence of the apartheid system) little direct awareness of indigenous Black South African music until, in the late 1970s, he was commissioned to take a number of field trips to the country to study, document and (eventually) to accommodate this music into his own musical language. There’s a really interesting quotation in which he describes this journey: ‘I planned a series of pieces which were graded (as a learning curve) from pure transcription (in the manner of Bach) through paraphrase (as in Liszt), quotation as object trouvé (Charles Ives) assimilation (in the tradition of Stravinsky and Bartók) to what was then called an "invented folklore" –what I thought of as a new music of southern Africa, or music for a new South Africa.’ This was, at the time, an overtly political act, and performances of his music in South Africa were regularly disrupted by pro-apartheid protesters. Through the 1980s and into the 90s you can trace in Volans’ music this gradual assimilation of Black African musical patterns, but it would be wrong to see his music as stopping there in terms of its ongoing development. Another interesting quotation: ‘Looking back over the music of the 20th century, I have been struck by how on the whole mainstream music has been very "busy"... Emptiness has not been a favourite mode of expression. By contrast, visual artists have repeatedly simplified their imagery and had regular "clean-outs". Malevich, Mondrian, Yves Klein, Rothko … and others immediately spring to mind... At the turn of the [21st] century I became increasingly interested in eliminating subject matter in my music as far as possible. My ideal would be the equivalent of the blank canvas. I am still a long way off achieving this: old habits die hard.’ You might think that the logical goal of this process would be to produce music that aspires to the condition of silence (let’s hear it for John Cage after all!), but Volans’ work continues to be nothing if not diverse. I thought I’d mark Volans’ 75th birthday by picking two of his works from that radically disruptive time in his creative life, the early 1980s. First, here is a movement from his piece ‘White Man Sleeps’, which dates from 1982. It’s probably most famous now in a recording by the Kronos Quartet, Volans having reworked the original as his String Quartet No 1. However, that first version was scored, strikingly, for two harpsichords, viola de gamba and African rattles/drums. The thinking behind the piece was to try to bring together the musical soundscapes of the Boer settlers in South Africa in the 17th century (hence the harpsichords and the viola de gamba) and of the indigenous populations (which is why the harpsichords are re-tuned, to resemble the tuning system of instruments of the mbira family). There are five movements in the work as a whole, and from them I’ve chosen the 3rd Dance, simply because it strikes me as one of the happiest and most celebratory pieces I know. The audio-only recording here is the original one made in the mid-1980s by Volans himself, on one of the harpsichords, along with Robert Hill (harpsichord), Margriet Tindemans (viola de gamba) and Robyn Schulkowsky (percussion). You’ll find it here: Volans: White Man Sleeps (Third Dance). Another of the works Volans produced during the 1980s, under the influence of Black African music, was a piece called ‘Walking Song’. This too (it’s a common feature in Volans’ output) was subsequently re-purposed, becoming part of his String Quartet No 2, but originally it’s a work for organ. However, I thought I’d provide a link to an arrangement for flute and piano, supported by a trio of hand-clapping percussionists. The performers here are Margreet Niks (flute), Toon Bierman (piano) and Bence Huszar, Aart Strootman and Arnold Marinissen (percussion). Once more, it’s an audio-only performance, but it’s accompanied by a quite striking video of landscape images. You’ll find it here: Volans: Walking Song
|
W–Z
|
W · X · Y · Z |
|
Wagner, Richard (1813-83)
Day 88: Tristan and Isolde (Prelude to Act 1) (Time: 14 minutes)
Just over a fortnight ago, when discussing the possibility that we might see Debussy's ‘Prélude à l’Après-midi d’un Faune’ as marking the beginning of ‘modern music’, I suggested a number of other ‘culprits’ one might point the finger at. One of those is the subject for today's email – the music of Richard Wagner. Wagner (1813-83) was a larger-than-life musician (composer, librettist, theatre director, conductor, and polemicist for some very striking cultural and political views) in his day, and his subsequent reputation (not remotely all his fault) has ensured that he remains a controversial figure even now. I have no intention at all of getting embroiled in discussions of, say, anti-Semitism, or Wagner's later adoption by Nazi ideologists, and how this has affected the way we understand and interpret his music. Instead, I want simply to focus on one piece of music, the Prelude to his opera ‘Tristan and Isolde’, and try to say a little about why it is so influential. Wagner wrote it in the late 1850s, though it didn’t get its first performance until 1865. On a ‘philosophical’ level, it’s heavily influenced by the ideas of Schopenhauer, but rather more personally it is shaped by the course of Wagner's love affair with Mathilde Wesendonck. It would be fair to say that after bar three of the Prelude, Western music was never the same again. Not wishing to get too bogged down with music theory, the key concept to try to get hold of is the idea of harmonic ‘suspension’, where harmonies don’t quickly and immediately ‘resolve’ into the chord we might expect. It’s possible to argue that Wagner actually creates a suspension that it takes the whole of the opera, three acts later, to resolve, with the ‘consummation’ of the relationship between Tristan and Isolde in Isolde's ‘liebestod’ (her ‘love-death’). It’s torrid stuff, and the whole opera is highly erotically charged with this sense of deferred yearning to reach some sort of, ahem, climax. In truth, hardly any composer of the following 100 years has been able to avoid being shaped by this music (Bruckner, Mahler, Richard Strauss, Schoenberg, for instance … all the way through to the film composers of the 20th century, like Bernard Herrmann or Erich Korngold), and many went through a ‘Wagner phase’ before reacting against it and finding a musical language that was in opposition to it (Debussy or Stravinsky, say). Anyway, what I hope you get from listening to this is a sense of the way the music expresses ‘yearning’, that continual striving for something just out of reach. There are lots of performances of this on YouTube, but I’m particularly taken by versions that take this music very slowly, and one of the most striking of those is by the BBC Phil and its then Chief Conductor Juanjo Mena, at the BBC Proms in 2012. You’ll find it here: Wagner – Prelude to ‘Tristan and Isolde’
Day 335: Siegfried Idyll (Time: 19 minutes)
There’s not been a great deal of Wagner on this list so far, largely (true life confession time) because although I know some people find his operas, and particularly the Ring cycle, to be the pinnacle of creative achievement, I must confess to finding it pleasurable in 15-minute chunks but wearisome beyond measure when you’re four hours into an opera and there’s still an hour to go. (My bad, as the young people used to say about 15 years ago.) Anyway, consequently the only Wagner I’ve subjected you to in the past has been back on Day 88 when we listened to the Prelude from ‘Tristan und Isolde’. It’s about time, then, that we had some more. Actually, having said Wagner opera isn’t my cup of cocoa, I am actually very fond of his music … until people start singing – and I have plenty of time not just for the overtures and preludes to his various operas, but also for the offcuts that emerged out of the fact that Wagner was clearly utterly immersed in the sound worlds he was creating. One such free-standing but clearly operatically-linked piece is the ‘Siegfried Idyll’. And, unlike some of Wagner’s other works (and their accompanying political/cultural commentary), ‘Siegfried Idyll’ is an essentially benign piece with an endearingly touching back-story. Well, I say ‘touching’ – but the back-story to the back-story is rather torrid. Wagner’s relationship with his first wife Minna broke down over his affair with Mathilde Wesendonck, but that too collapsed in the late 1850s and Wagner spent several years in wandering and exile (he had been banned from Germany for his political views – at that time left-wing rather than right – after the 1848 revolutions), only returning to Germany in 1862. His fortunes picked up in 1864 when Ludwig II became King of Bavaria and (I simplify) offered Wagner carte-blanche to do what he wanted to get his music written and staged (culminating in the building of the Festival Theatre at Bayreuth in 1876), and on a personal level too Wagner found love – albeit love with the conductor Hans von Bulow’s wife, Cosima. Only after Wagner’s first wife Minna died in 1866 and after Cosima had given birth to three of Wagner’s children did von Bulow grant Cosima a divorce in July 1870. Wagner and Cosima were married within a month, and that Christmas, on Cosima’s 33rd birthday (actually her birthday was 24th Dec, but she used to celebrate her birthday on Christmas Day) Wagner wrote for her a surprise piece of music, which had its premiere on the stairs outside her bedroom on Christmas morning. This was ‘Siegfried Idyll’. Siegfried was the name of their son, who was one year old at the time. The initial, not entirely catchy name for the piece was ‘Tribschen Idyll with Fidi's birdsong and the orange sunrise, as symphonic birthday greeting. Presented to his Cosima by her Richard.’ [Tribschen was the name of their house; Fidi was the Wagners’ pet name for Siegfried.] Cosima’s recollection of the occasion is frequently quoted, but it bears repetition: ‘Sunday, December 25, 1870: About this day, my children, I can tell you nothing—nothing about my feelings, nothing about my mood, nothing, nothing, nothing. I shall just tell you, dryly and plainly, what happened. When I woke up I heard a sound, it grew even louder, I could no longer imagine myself in a dream, music was sounding, and what music! After it had died away, R. came in to me with the children and put into my hands the score of his "Symphonic Birthday Greeting." I was in tears, but so, too, was the whole household; R. had set up his orchestra on the stairs and thus consecrated our Tribschen forever!’ The composition derived in part from an unfinished piece of chamber music, and Wagner subsequently used its main theme in the final duet of Brünnhilde and Siegfried in the opera ‘Siegfried’. Wagner’s original intention was that the score should remain unpublished, and simply be a private document of his love for Cosima and his new family, and in that original form it was written for only 13 players – one, Hans Richter (later a prominent conductor of the Halle Orchestra) on trumpet, which apparently he learned to play specially for the occasion. When money worries forced Wagner to publish the score, he developed it for larger forces, but that original scoring has a kind of purity and clarity that I like very much. The work is short, by Wagnerian standards – under 20 minutes, and apparently it used to be played much faster – but it has a sunny disposition, indeed a serenity, which is quite charming, I think. The ECO version in Sheffield later this month will be for a larger orchestra, but I’ve chosen a performance today (18/10/22) with the original chamber forces. It’s played on this video recording by players from the Oslo Philharmonic, led from the first violin by Elise Båtnes. You’ll find it here: Wagner: Siegfried Idyll
Day 369: Good Friday Music (from ‘Parsifal’) (Time: 14 minutes)
Today (7/4/23) being Good Friday, I have what is probably a fairly obvious selection of music for us to consider. We’ve had music by Wagner twice on this list to date (see Day 88 for the Prelude to ‘Tristan and Isolde’ and Day 335 for the Siegfried Idyll), so it’s probably about time we had some more. I’ve confessed in the past that I’m allergic to Wagner opera once the singers take charge, and consequently, what we have today – the ‘Good Friday Music’ from ‘Parsifal’ – is an orchestra-only chunk from the third act of Wagner’s opera. I should also say at the outset that, as with so much to do with Wagner, I’m going to tread as carefully as possible round the extra-musical stuff which has accumulated over the years, both from Wagner’s own writings and actions, and from the behaviour of others towards Wagner’s music after his death. So, the musical context is this. ‘Parsifal’ is Wagner’s final operatic work. In fact, he was determined to avoid calling his mature stage works for voices and orchestra ‘operas’ as such, the term suggesting to him things facile and meretricious, and, erm, French or Italian. Instead, he called his works ‘music dramas’, or, to hazard a bit of German, ‘Gesamtkunstwerk’ (or ‘total work of art’, a culmination of all art forms working in unison). In fact, Wagner described ‘Parsifal’ as (yet more German – sorry…) ‘Ein Bühnenweihfestspiel’, or ‘a festival play for the consecration of the stage’. It was written for performance at Wagner’s new state-of-the-art opera house in Bayreuth, and it had its first performance in 1882, just a year before Wagner’s death. Its ‘sacredness’ on the stage at Bayreuth can be gauged by the fact that it was not permitted to be staged anywhere else for more than 20 years after its first performance, a ban that would have remained far longer had it been possible to make it stand up in a court of law. Wagner’s last years saw him taking an interest in Christianity, albeit of a rather German Nationalist and anti-Semitic kind, and ‘Parsifal’, with its narrative about the Holy Grail (the vessel allegedly containing the blood of Jesus shed on the Cross), dramatizes that in some quite striking ways. The character of Parsifal (‘Parzival’ in the 13th century text which was Wagner’s primary source) is probably better known to us as Percival, one of the Arthurian Knights of the Round Table. His is the quest for the Holy Grail that the music drama explores. Wagner retrospectively imagined some rather creative inspirational moments in the genesis of this work: in his autobiography he claimed the inspiration for the work came to him on Good Friday morning, 1857, though subsequently in 1879, Cosima Wagner suggested her husband had confessed this was ‘far fetched … just a pleasant mood in Nature, which made me think “This is how a Good Friday ought to be”.’ However, it is true that Wagner had been thinking of producing a work on this theme for a full 25 years before it finally got its first performance. The Good Friday Music (actually, in the score, the ‘Good Friday Spell’) occupies the closing minutes of the penultimate scene of the opera. A minimal summary of the action up to and including this point is as follows: the complicated plot involves the knights who, at their castle in Spain, watch over the Holy Grail and the spear that pierced Christ’s side, the hardships that befall them in retribution for sins (particularly losing guardianship of the spear), and how Parsifal arrives in their midst and, following various travails, sets things aright, all against a background of mystical religiosity. The ‘Good Friday Music’ comes when, having achieved his principal task of regaining the spear, Parsifal is set to become the knights’ leader. He ‘gazes in gentle rapture on wood and meadow, which are now glowing in the morning light’, according to the stage direction. ‘How fair seem the meadows today!’ he sings; and a senior knight responds, ‘That is the magic of Good Friday, my lord!’ In its form as an orchestral work usually lasting just under a quarter of an hour, the voices are stripped out, and what we have is a piece with three key musical ideas – there is Parsifal’s own ‘leitmotif’ (or theme), a fanfare figure at the start of the extract; there is the ‘Good Friday’ theme itself, a rising/falling figure initially heard on the oboe; but more insistently there is the so-called ‘Dresden Amen’, a melody and its associated harmony composed by the now barely known Johann Naumann (1741-1801), a repeated rising chord figure (it emerges clearly from the musical texture at about 7’40” in the recording below) which gives the piece a sense of nobility and even maybe transcendence. There are, I’m aware, people who listen to this music every Good Friday, as though it’s an act of devotion. I’m not sure I’d want to go that far, but it is, I think, a pretty special piece of music, and one that repays repeated listening. As for a performance, YouTube is well stocked with audio-only recordings, and from them I’ve chosen this one by the Munich Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by the legendary Sergiu Celibidache, which you’ll find here: Wagner: Good Friday Music (from 'Parsifal')
Walker, George (1922-2018)
Day 137: Lyric for Strings (Time: 7 minutes)
This week, it’s another week of music by black composers, chosen as a result of some research primarily by David, inspired by Black History Month. So today (17/11/20), we have the last of his choices on this theme, music by George Walker. George Walker (1922-2018) was, Wikipedia tells me, the first African-American composer to win the Pulitzer Prize for Music, which he received in 1996 for a work for voice and orchestra called ‘Lilacs’. Unlike many black musicians in twentieth-century America, Walker doesn’t seem to have had to struggle to overcome racist barriers to get his music heard. Partly that seems to have been a consequence of being born into a ‘professional’ family (his father was a doctor), but also because he was admitted to the prestigious Oberlin Music Conservatory in Ohio at the age of 14. Further studies took him to the Curtis Institute in Philadelphia, from which he emerged as one of its first black graduates in 1945. As a performer, he chalked up some notable ‘firsts’ (first black soloist to appear with the Philadelphia Orchestra, for instance), and as an academic, he was professor and later head of department at a range of colleges and universities in the States. Musically, his compositions are stylistically quite diverse – he made seemingly equal use of twelve-tone serialist techniques (another day!), as he did of the conventions of jazz and popular music. The piece that David suggests we listen to has a history that offers a neat parallel with Samuel Barber's ‘Adagio for Strings’, in that that piece started life as the slow movement of Barber's String Quartet, Op 11. Similarly, George Walker's String Quartet No 1 was composed in 1946, and almost immediately he arranged its slow movement as a free-standing work for string orchestra called ‘Lament’. He later reworked it some more and gave it the title by which it is known today, ‘Lyric for Strings’. The piece was inspired by Walker's memories of his grandmother, who had died the previous year. The music alternates between lushly-scored passages for the whole ensemble and rather starker solo sections. Like Barber's Adagio, which is clearly the inspiration for this music, Walker's Lyric for Strings begins in a kind of mournful repose before reaching an impassioned peak of anguish, and then subsiding into a rather sombre sense of peace. As for the performance here, David wants to direct us to the BBC Proms in 2017 when the work was given by the Chineke! Orchestra conducted by Kevin John Edusei. You’ll find it here: Walker: Lyric for Strings
Wallen, Errollyn (b1958)
Day 92: ‘Mighty River’ (Time: 17 minutes)
Today (22/6/2020), there is a suggestion from David (a first – huzzah!) for a piece by the contemporary British composer of Caribbean origin, Errollyn Wallen. Ms Wallen (b.1958) was born in Belize, but came to the UK two years later. She is an eclectic composer, drawing on a vast range of influences. The Observer called her ‘the Renaissance woman of contemporary British music’. She founded her own group of musicians, Ensemble X, whose ideology is clear: ‘we don’t break down barriers in music… we don’t see any.’ She was made a CBE in the 2020 New Year's Honours List for services to music. The piece David suggests we listen to was written in 2017, marking the 200th anniversary of the Abolition of the Slave Trade Act in England. It’s called ‘Mighty River’, and it takes its inspiration from the ideas of William Wilberforce, exploring themes of slavery and freedom in ways that are very clearly pertinent to our times. The recording is by Orchestra X (an expanded version of her ensemble), conducted by Andrew Morley. You’ll find it here: Errollyn Wallen – ‘Mighty River’
Walton, William (1902-83)
Day 87: Symphony No 1 (1st movement) (Time: 15 minutes)
Today (17/6/20), I thought it would be good to consider something from Oldham’s finest
musical export, William Walton.
Walton (1902-83) found his calling early in life – becoming a chorister at Christ Church
Cathedral School in Oxford as a ten-year-old, and subsequently an undergrad at
Christ Church, Oxford, from the age of 16.
He was taken under the wing of the wealthy if eccentric Sitwell family, and early,
rather scandalous success with the performance piece ‘Façade’ put him on the musical map.
Looking back, he occupies a curious position in the history of British music.
There were some early successes (the Viola Concerto and the oratorio ‘Belshazzar's Feast’)
but in some ways, as the 1930s gave way to the 1940s, his reputation was overtaken by that
of Benjamin Britten, and in post-war British music he came to be seen as ‘yesterday's man’.
His musical style often suggests he's inheriting Elgar's ‘pomp and circumstance’
mantle, with ceremonial marches like ‘Crown Imperial’ and ‘Orb and Sceptre’,
set alongside an affection for ‘jazzy’ rhythms, the harmonies of neo-classical
period Stravinsky, and the legacy of Anglican church music.
He was a very slow composer, which in part explains the fact that there are
relatively few major compositions to show for a sixty-year career.
However, one of his major pieces (I'd probably go so far as to say, with due deference
to the symphonies of Elgar and Vaughan Williams, one of the major symphonies by an English
composer in the 20th century) is his Symphony No 1, first performed in 1935.
It had a very slow gestation – in fact, it was performed in 1934 without the finale.
It seems likely that the symphony is the fruit of Walton's rather tangled love life in the
early 1930s, its bitter and angry energy (in the first three movements) being the product of
the break-up of Walton's relationship with the German Countess Imma von Doernberg.
The rather more celebratory finale emerged from a period of ‘writer's block’,
when Walton had embarked on another relationship.
The movement I'd like to suggest we listen to is the first.
As a 16-year-old at an RNCM Orchestra concert with no experience of Walton's music to speak of,
I found this positively overwhelming. Its energy, violence, drive and
intensity never ease off, right from the motoric rhythms at the start.
There’s a lot of Sibelius in there, with slow moving themes over solid blocks
of harmony, but this does genuinely feel like an original musical voice.
Although most of the stand-out performances of this work tend to be by British
orchestras (though not necessarily British conductors – I'm thinking of Previn's
blistering recording of this during his years with the LSO), I thought
it would be interesting to see how a European orchestra handles it.
So here is the WDR Symphony Orchestra of Cologne, conducted by Semyon Bychkov:
Walton – Symphony No 1 (1st movement)
Day 297: Belshazzar's Feast (Time: 34 minutes)
Early next month, the Halle, along with the massed forces of the Sheffield Philharmonic Chorus, the Leeds Philharmonic Chorus and assorted hangers-on, will be rounding off the 2021/22 concert season at the City Hall with a performance of the work I’ve chosen for today (31/5/22), Walton’s oratorio ‘Belshazzar’s Feast’. I guess if you’re planning concerts and you want the final event of the season to go out with a bang, you could do worse than programme Walton’s score, with its baritone soloist, huge massed choirs, full orchestra and two extra brass groups, not to mention assorted percussion that probably necessitates a visit to the hardware aisles at B&Q. It’s about as over the top as you can get whilst still remaining within the bounds of reasonably good taste. It’s also, for those (can there be any?) who haven’t encountered it yet, extremely good fun. Walton has featured just the once on this list so far (see Day 87) when I programmed the first movement of his astonishing Symphony No 1. As I pointed out at the time, although Walton had a very long career (he started early: his choral anthem ‘A Litany’ emerged in pretty much fully-formed ‘Waltonese’ at the age of 15), he didn’t actually produce a lot of music, largely because he wrote very slowly indeed, often lacking certainty about the quality of what he had written. His most productive years were probably the late 1920s/early 1930s. From that period we get the entertainment ‘Façade’, the ‘Portsmouth Point’ Overture, the Viola Concerto, the Symphony No 1, and, dating from 1931, ‘Belshazzar’s Feast’. The text, taken mostly from the Book of Daniel (selected and organised by Walton’s poet friend Osbert Sitwell), with extracts too from Psalm 137 (‘By the waters of Babylon’), Psalm 81 and the Book of Revelation, offered Walton an opportunity to set words of vivid drama and colour. Initially, it was commissioned by the BBC in 1929. Given its final form, there’s a somewhat ironic humour to the fact that as originally planned it was supposedly for a small choir, soloist, and an orchestra of no more than 15 players! Plans for the first performance of the work were then taken up by the Leeds Festival, and it was scheduled for the 1931 event. The extra brass ensembles arrived courtesy of a suggestion from the conductor Sir Thomas Beecham (‘As you'll never hear the thing again, my boy, why not throw in a couple of brass bands?’). However, rather than disappearing into oblivion, the work took almost instant root in the concert schedules of many choirs and orchestras. Set against the rather stuffy world of Anglican church music, it felt vital, dynamic, rhythmically alive. It tells the story of the Jews in exile in Babylon, where the king Belshazzar throws a great feast, sacrilegiously using the vessels from the Temple in this wild party. In what is probably the most famous section, Belshazzar then encounters ‘the writing on the wall’, foretelling his demise (including the chorus’s exhilarating shout, ‘Slain!’) before the work ends in general rejoicing of the people of Israel at Belshazzar’s fall. It is almost certainly Walton’s most popular and most performed work, and although Walton’s position in the world of classical music shifted from ‘enfant terrible’ to something a little more ‘old school’ as the 1940s saw his reputation usurped by that of Benjamin Britten, ‘Belshazzar’s Feast’ seems always to have maintained its hold on musicians and audiences alike. It’s a surprise to find someone as seemingly far from Walton’s world as the uber-slick Herbert von Karajan remarking in 1947 that the work was ‘the best choral music that's been written in the last 50 years’, but it goes to show much this is a work of international and not just parochial repute. As for a performance, there are several video recordings on YouTube, and out of them (in large measure because of the almost impeccable tuning of the baritone soloist Bryn Terfel) I’ve chosen this recording, by the BBC Symphony Orchestra and Chorus, and the BBC Singers, conducted by Sir Andrew Davis back at the 1994 Proms – an old recording but for me hard to beat. You’ll find it here: Walton: Belshazzar's Feast
Day 588: Piano Quartet (Time: 28 minutes)
Today (1/5/26), another posting of music being played at this year’s Sheffield Chamber Music Festival, and this time it’s a piano quartet. Assuming the conventional combination of instruments for compositions with these titles, the difference between a piano quintet and piano quartet is – and try not to be too stunned by this revelation – that the latter requires one fewer player, and typically that means that instead of having a string quartet alongside the piano, we have a string trio (violin, viola, cello). Over the past 250 years or so, there have been quite a lot more piano quartets written than piano quintets, and that is evident these days in terms of performing groups – there are many more piano quartet ensembles than piano quintet ensembles (performances of piano quintets usually involve an established string quartet playing with a guest pianist) simply because they have a wider repertoire to choose from. Anyway, today’s piano quartet is the one by William Walton. It’s a very early work, and it reminds me that if we consider early 20th century English composers who hit their stride very young, as it were, the stand out figure is obviously Benjamin Britten. However, although he had fewer works under his belt at the end of his teens (and in fact fewer works under his belt, full stop), Walton too was something of a musical prodigy. Walton was often self-deprecating about his past. There’s a poignant comment he made in a TV documentary about his life, just before he died in 1983, in which he said, of his time as a boy chorister at Christ Church, Oxford, that by the age of 14 ‘I had to make myself interesting somehow or when my voice [broke] I [would] be sent back to Oldham,’ adding, ‘I was very lucky, I was so damned stupid, all I could do was write music.’ His Piano Quartet was written in 1918/19, so most of it emerged before his 17th birthday, although he revised it several times over the decades – in 1921, and again in 1924 before its publication, prior to its first public performance in Liverpool that year, and then yet again in 1974, prompted by a performance at the Aldeburgh Festival in 1973, although this final revision seems to focus largely on clarifying and simplifying the piano part in the last movement, rather than being a fundamental re-composition. The immediate stimulus for the work seems to have been the fact that he was impressed by a piece for the same forces by Herbert Howells, and thus Walton responded to the challenge of writing his own piano quartet. Later (more of his familiar self-deprecation), he said of the work that it was ‘my first composition to show any kind of talent; it was written when I was a drooling baby but it is a very attractive piece.’ As one might expect of any work written by someone in their mid teens (apart from Mozart, maybe) it’s a composition that reveals a lot about the impact of the composers Walton was aware of in the environment around him at the time: commentators have at various times written about the influence of Howells, Elgar, Vaughan Williams, Ireland, Bridge, Brahms, Fauré, Ravel and Stravinsky – but one thing’s for sure, and that is that you can hear a great deal of mature Walton in it as well. The Piano Quartet has four movements. The first is probably the one that most clearly shows his debt to Howells’ own piano quartet, particularly the rather modal (vaguely ‘folk song’) quality of the opening themes. The piano comes to the fore in more dramatic, staccato passages, but for the most part, there’s more lyricism and rather less of the rhythmic jaggedness that was to become Walton’s trade-marked style as the 1920s unfolded. You hear rather more of this rhythmic attack in the spiky ‘Allegro scherzando’ second movement, which also includes Walton’s first published use of fugal writing as a formal device. There are echoes of the main theme of the first movement; this turns up again in both the slow movement and the finale, and is part of Walton’s strategy to unify the work as a whole. If we’re playing ‘spot the influences’ here, I think I’d say the rhythmic quality is Walton’s own, while melodically it all feels a bit Elgarian. The influential composer in the ‘Andante tranquillo’ third movement, however, is Ravel: Walton quotes directly from the piano part to one of Ravel’s songs, and more generally the whole harmonic ‘feel’ of the movement owes a lot to Ravel. For me, this is the finest movement; it’s tender, gentle stuff, a little elegiac in places, and though there’s a darker, more brooding passage later (cello and viola play versions of the work’s opening theme), we end in stillness and calm. In many ways, though, the finale looks forward to mature Walton (and, if you’re looking for influences, the language of Stravinsky, and even Bartok, whose ‘Allegro Barbaro’ Walton had been studying at the time, apparently) with its choppy rhythms and off-kilter fugue. In a way that’s very familiar in the works of all sorts of composers, there are moments of stillness just before the close of the movement, and one last recall of how the whole work began, before the emphatic, whirlwind conclusion. YouTube has a number of decent performances of the work, and from them I’ve gone for this one by the Notos Quartett, a Germany-based ensemble made up of Sindri Lederer on violin, Andrea Burger on viola, Philip Graham on cello and Antonia Köster on piano. The video itself is a bit odd in places – some of the camera angles aren’t terribly sensitive to the music – but the performance is engaged and committed. You’ll find it here: Walton: Piano Quartet
Weber, Carl Maria von (1786-1826)
Day 115: Invitation to the Dance (orch. Berlioz) (Time: 9 minutes)
The thinking behind the link between today’s instalment and Friday’s was that I wanted to consider the music of Carl Maria von Weber, and ways in which it has been orchestrated or made the subject of re-composition by subsequent composers. That’s not to suggest that Weber (1786-1826) or his music are unable to stand up for themselves, but merely that his works have regularly been seen as a ‘stepping-off’ point for other composers. Weber is an interesting character, probably the most prominent of a whole bunch of composers who were, if you like, ‘first generation Romantics’, those who lived and worked across that great watershed that divides ‘classical music’ (roughly 1750-1830) from ‘romantic music’ (roughly 1810-1914 – recognising a) that there’s an overlap between eras as styles were evolving, and b) that the first world war seems a suitable end point, after which the musical world was never the same again). Other composers who occupy the same sort of position are people like Hummel or Spohr. So, even though Weber's death pre-dates that of Beethoven or Schubert, his style of composition was different from theirs – generally speaking less complex, with a more overt appeal to emotional directness. His music leads the way towards Mendelssohn, Schumann and Chopin. Weber had a chequered musical career, falling out with a number of patrons, frequently getting heavily into debt. He wrote a considerable amount of music for the piano, as well as a number of popular concertos (those for clarinet are still regularly in the repertoire), but his passion was for opera, and after a number of false starts – usually because he selected wholly impractical libretti – he made his mark with ‘Der Freischutz’, ‘Euryanthe’ and ‘Oberon’. The piece I’ve chosen for today (1/9/20) started life as a free-standing piano composition, ‘Invitation to the Dance’. If you want to see a performance of the work in this form, try this one by Peter Laul: Weber: Invitation to the Dance (piano version) Weber wrote it in 1819, and it is distinctive in that it’s the first recorded example of a ‘concert waltz’ (that is, a waltz to listen to rather than to dance). It also reveals that characteristic Romantic urge to be programmatic. So, it allegedly tells the story, in its slow introduction, of two characters at a ball, where the gentleman asks the lady to dance, there is some demurring and further persuasion, before the central fast section depicts the dance itself. Finally, there is a slow epilogue, in which the lady is thanked, she acknowledges it, and there is a formal parting. In 1841, for a performance of ‘Der Freischutz’ in Paris, Berlioz was asked to provide some additional music for a ‘ballet’ sequence, it being obligatory for Parisian performances of opera to include dancing for much of the 19th century. [By the way, it’s shocking that here we are on Day 115 and there hasn’t been any original music by Berlioz yet. I’ll put that right very soon!] Berlioz chose to orchestrate Weber's piano original for this purpose, giving it brighter and more colourful clothing, but not in any way ‘re-composing’ the piano version. This Berlioz orchestration rapidly took on a separate life of its own, and you are now far more likely to encounter a performance of this version of the music than Weber's piano original. There are a lot of lively performances of the piece on YouTube, and from them I’ve chosen this one by the Hong Kong Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by Perry So. You’ll find it here: Weber, orch. Berlioz: Invitation to the Dance
Webern, Anton (1883-1945)
Day 207: Im Sommerwind (Time: 12 minutes)
Today (20/7/21), I have another ‘summer’ composition, and it marks the first appearance on the list of Anton Webern (1883-1945). Of the triumvirate of ‘serialist’ composers at the heart of the so-called ‘Second Viennese School’ (to distinguish it from the ‘First’ one, of Haydn, Mozart, Beethoven and Schubert) who so radically reshaped the language of music in the early decades of the 20th century – Schoenberg and his pupils Berg and Webern – I suspect Webern is the most rigorous and extreme in his pursuit of precision of expression in his mature work. Lots of his pieces (and there aren’t actually that many anyway) are very short, very precisely annotated, and seem to inhabit a sound world in which what we hear is a kind of distilled essence of what, in other composers’ hands, might have lasted ten times as long. He was born in Vienna, and seems to have absorbed that city's (over)heated artistic mood from a young age. He had composition lessons from Schoenberg in the first decade of the 20th century, the first fruit of which was his Passacaglia Op 1, of 1908. In his later life, Webern was a complex figure, both musically and in his socio-political views. He was a fierce proponent of the view that Germanic music was superior to any other strand of European composition; however, in the rising Fascist context of 1920s/30s central Europe, he found his work labelled ‘degenerate’ and ‘proscribed’. (This does not seem to have stopped him occasionally expressing what seem to be superficially sympathetic views about Hitler and Nazism. As I say, he was a complex character.) There is a rather black irony in the manner of his death in 1945 – shot by a seemingly trigger-happy US Army soldier as he stood outside his home in the dusk, smoking a cigar. However, for today's piece, we should go back to 1904, for one of Webern's pieces of juvenilia, the orchestral tone poem ‘Im Sommerwind’ (‘In the summer wind’). Webern describes this as an idyll, and it was influenced by a poem by Bruno Wille, which in part can be translated thus: ‘All my restlessness, all confused thoughts / Are drowned in the lark's song / In the sweet sea of jubilation! / Submerged / the city's dust and arid fraudulence! Submerged / The tedious human rabble!’ This pastoral escapism is clearly audible in Webern's music – the rustling and chirruping of the natural world, depicted in a musical language which is very clearly late Romantic in utterance, even if, occasionally, in the juxtaposition of different instrumental ‘colours’ and the music's rather unstable tonality, we can glimpse fragments of the future direction of Webern's work. There is also a familial context to this piece. Webern's father inherited the family estate in the hamlet of Oberdorf in southern Austria when Webern was a child, and he made several extended visits to the locality before the estate was sold in 1912, after which he seems to have memorialised it as a kind of lost paradise. It is this place, as much as Wille's poem, that inspired the writing of ‘Im Sommerwind’. There aren’t a lot of video recordings of the work on YouTube, but this one, by the WDR Symphony Orchestra, Cologne, conducted by Jukka-Pekka Saraste, is lovely. You’ll find it here: Webern: Im Sommerwind
Weelkes, Thomas (1576-1623)
Day 368: 'O Jonathan, Woe is Me!' (Time: 3 minutes) and ‘When David Heard’ (4 minutes)
This week, in the run up to Easter weekend, I want to choose pieces which are, in their different ways, appropriate to the season. Also, today (4/4/23) I want to pick up on a suggestion from the invisible Pete Dutton, prompted by the fact that about four weeks ago we listened to ‘When David Heard’ by Eric Whitacre. I mentioned in that posting that this text had been set by many composers exploring music of grief, loss and mourning, and in particular it was a popular text in the hands of English composers of the late 16th and early 17th centuries, notably Thomas Weelkes and Thomas Tomkins. Mr Dutton’s response to this was to suggest that we listen to Weelkes’ setting, a masterpiece of concision in the shaping of emotion. And so here we are, with a posting devoted to Thomas Weelkes. Weelkes (1576-1623) had, one might say, an ‘interesting’ life. There are many Elizabethan/Jacobean composers about whom almost nothing is known. Weelkes is not one of those, but what is known of his life is patchy and, it has to be said, not particularly flattering. I’m not about to make a case for saying a composer’s life has to be worthy or noble for his music to be considered acceptable, and have no interest in promoting a kind of retrospective ‘cancel culture’. But in the case of Weelkes, we definitely have to separate the man from his music, and focus largely on the latter. It’s not clear when precisely Weelkes was born, but he was baptised in October 1576, and almost nothing is known of his first two decades. However, by 1598 he had been appointed organist at Winchester College, and he was well known as a composer of madrigals around the turn of the century. (I still remember studying Weelkes’ ‘As Vesta was from Latmos Hill Descending’, a madrigal from 1601, when doing O-level Music many many decades ago.) By 1602 Weelkes was organist and instructor of choristers at Chichester Cathedral, and also by this stage married. Then things started going downhill: he seems to have taken to drink, and began turning up late for services, worse for wear. A report from 1616 says Weelkes was ‘noted and famed for a comon drunckard and notorious swearer & blasphemer’, and he was sacked for being drunk in charge of an organ(!) and using bad language during the church service. He seems to have been reinstated but with no improvement in his behaviour. There’s a splendidly vivid complaint to the bishop about him from 1619, saying he’d been reported ‘dyvers tymes & very often come so disguised eyther from the Taverne or Ale house into the quire as is muche to be lamented, for in these humoures he will bothe curse & sweare most dreadfully, & so profane the service of God … and though he hath bene often tymes admonished … to refrayne theis humors and reforme hym selfe, yett he daylye continuse the same, & is rather worse than better therein.’ Although technically still in the employment of the Diocese of Chichester, he seems to have spent his final years mostly in London, and mostly drunk, before dying in 1623. Now, none of this recommends itself as the source of inspiration for music of exquisite beauty, but whatever his personal weaknesses Weelkes produced a string of exceptional vocal pieces in both secular and sacred vein, not to mention a large body of music for Anglican services. I thought that today I’d feature two short sacred madrigals by Weelkes to give some sense of his word-painting skills. First, a short setting of 2 Samuel 1;26: in the NIV this reads ‘I grieve for you, Jonathan my brother; you were very dear to me. Your love for me was wonderful, more wonderful than that of women.’ The context – David, about to be anointed King of Judah, hears of the deaths in battle of not just Saul but his son Jonathan, with whom David had formed a close bond – gives Weelkes the opportunity to write music of expressive lamentation. There is something of the Italian madrigal’s rather florid word-painting going on here, although it seems to me to be wrestling with the greater sense of restraint that one gets in English madrigals of the era. (Ignore that last sentence if the English/Italian madrigal contrast means nothing to you! I’ll explore it in another posting one day … perhaps!) We’re in audio-only territory here, with a recording by the vocal ensemble The Queen’s Six: Weelkes: 'O Jonathan, Woe is Me!'. And then here is what is probably Weelkes’ best-known sacred madrigal, the wonderful six-part setting ‘When David Heard’. The text is again from 2 Samuel, in this case 2 Samuel 18;33 – at which point David, in his turbulent relationship with his favourite son Absalom, is informed that the latter has been killed in battle against him, expressly against David’s instruction. I think this work shows Weelkes’ sensitive responsiveness to the words he is setting. The effect is often direct, unfussy and, I’d argue, quite thrilling in the way it yearns for what is lost, before, almost tenderly, there’s a hint of acceptance at the close of the piece in its transition from minor to major key, but not before what Harry Christophers, conductor of The Sixteen, describes as ‘the work’s lachrymose flow of harmonic suspensions and eloquent silences’. For a recording, I’ve gone for a video by the Dutch vocal ensemble Laurens Collegium, directed by Wiecher Mandemaker. You’ll find it here: Weelkes: 'When David Heard'
Day 432: As Vesta Was from Latmos Hill Descending (Time: 3 minutes) and In Nomine 2 (for 5 voices) (3 minutes)
Today (24/11/23) we’re marking an anniversary. Well, to be truthful, we’re looking forward to an anniversary, in that on Nov 30th it will be 400 years since the death of Thomas Weelkes, which seems a big enough number to be worth commemorating. We’ve had a brief encounter with the music of Thomas Weelkes once before on this list (see Day 368, when we heard two of Weelkes’ sacred vocal pieces, ‘O Jonathan, Woe is Me’ and the utterly marvellous ‘When David Heard’). Given that on that previous occasion we had music setting religious texts, I thought that this time round I’d pick up on a couple of pieces to show Weelkes in secular mode. Firstly, I want to consider what is probably Weelkes’ most famous madrigal, ‘As Vesta Was from Latmos Hill Descending’, a piece that I’ve been carrying round in my head for about five decades now, given that it was on my O-level Music syllabus. At that time, although I appreciated the word painting, I don’t think I had anything like the contextual understanding that would have allowed me to make sense of what Weelkes was up to. The piece appeared in 1601 as part of a collection of madrigals put together by the composer Thomas Morley called ‘The Triumphs of Oriana’. This was a volume of 25 madrigals, by 23 different Elizabethan composers, and it probably was, in some transparently sycophantic ways, a celebration of the rule of Elizabeth I (who at that point had been on the throne since 1558, and therefore was at that time the longest reigning female English monarch). The only demand placed on composers of these pieces was that they had to end with the words ‘Then sang the shepherds and the nymphs of Diana: long live fair Oriana!’ The lasting assumption is that the ‘Oriana’ of the title was Elizabeth herself, though I believe an alternative reading has recently been proposed which suggests that Oriana was Anna of Denmark, the wife of James VI of Scotland, who would become James I of England when Elizabeth died in 1603. Anyway, regardless of Oriana’s ‘real’ identity, these 25 madrigals are effusive in their praise of her, and of her rule over her court. Weelkes’ contribution to the collection is a splendid piece of illustrative vocal writing. The text is as follows: ‘As Vesta was from Latmos hill descending, She spied a maiden Queen the same ascending, Attended on by all the shepherds' swain, To whom Diana's darlings came running down amain, First two by two, then three by three together, Leaving their goddess all alone hasted thither; And mingling with the shepherds of her train, With mirthful tunes her presence entertain.// Then sang the shepherds and nymphs of Diana, Long live fair Oriana!’ Vesta was the classical goddess of hearth and home, and in the text she and her nymphs are descending Latmos Hill, when they encounter Oriana and her shepherds (this is all very pastoral) coming up the hill in the opposite direction. Vesta finds herself deserted as everyone flocks to Oriana’s side and a degree of pastoral frolicking ensues … before the eventual closing lines in praise of Oriana. Weelkes has varieties of fun with the words. Some of it is pretty obvious – vocal lines going down at ‘descending’ and going up at ‘ascending’. Then the ‘running’ bit gets long elaborate runs in each part in turn. At ‘two by two’ and ‘three by three’ voices enter in pairs and then threes, saving all six vocal lines for the key word ‘together’ … and then one voice only for ‘all alone’. Maybe the most interesting bit is the setting of the closing line praising Oriana, in which Weelkes takes the melody for ‘long live fair Oriana’ and repeats it 48 times, transposed in the all the ways open to him, and underpinned by extraordinarily long notes in the bass line. It is, as they say, a tour de force. It is sung here by one of the many incarnations of The King’s Singers in a concert performance (and followed by a few minutes chat about the ensemble): Weelkes: As Vesta Was from Latmos Hill Descending. For something completely different, here is a short piece of instrumental music by Weelkes. He wrote relatively little of this sort of thing, and most of what he did write is for the brooding sonorities of the viol consort. An ‘In Nomine’ was one of those very curious musical forms that was fashionable during the Elizabethan and Jacobean era, and which then disappeared, apart from a 20th century revival by British composers looking to root their music in a wider historical context. The originator of the genre was the Elizabethan composer John Taverner (not to be confused with the 20th/21st century John Tavener), who, in his Mass ‘Gloria Tibi Trinitas’ makes particular use of the plainchant of the same name during the Sanctus of the mass, at the words ‘Benedictus qui venit in nomine Domini’ (‘Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord’). His strategy here was so highly regarded by his contemporaries that it became a model for others – initially those writing Mass settings, but subsequently those writing purely instrumental music that adopted the same conventions, pieces that became known as ‘In Nomines’. The composer Christopher Tye (one day, folks – especially his ‘Western Wynde’ Mass!), for instance, wrote 25 of them. Thomas Weelkes, as far as I know, wrote two. This recording, of his 2nd In Nomine, is performed here in a multi-tracked video by a viol player called Jaap Noorman (of the Fries Lachrymae Consort – that’s ‘Fries’ as in Friesland, a modern-day province of the Netherlands, and not ‘fries’ as in ‘French fries’). You’ll find the recording here: Weelkes: In Nomine 2 (for 5 voices)
Weill, Kurt (1900-1950)
Day 533: The Threepenny Opera (Suite) (Time: 22 minutes)
Today (11/4/25), I want to turn the spotlight onto Kurt Weill, who, by happy/unhappy coincidence, has had two major anniversaries in the past few weeks. He was born on 7th March – in his case in 1900 – which means we’ve recently missed the 125th anniversary of his birth. However, on 3rd April, 1950 – thus 75 years ago last week – Weill died of a heart attack in New York, where (as an American citizen as of 1943) he was buried. Weill is one of those composers who straddles two distinct musical worlds, though his political/cultural ideology would have dismissed the division of ‘high’ and ‘low’ music as a false distinction designed to perpetrate class divisions. He was, especially in the first decade or so of his working life, what we would now regard as a composer of ‘classical music’; not a lot of this gets to see the light of day very often nowadays, but some of it (notably his excellent Symphony No 2) is very definitely worth seeking out. He was also (especially in the latter half of his life) a composer of what we might now regard as ‘musical theatre’, initially in Berlin, where his most famous collaborator was the playwright Bertolt Brecht, and later in Hollywood. I’m not about to get sniffy about the fact that these works are ‘only musicals’, and somehow not serious. Music is music is music, and you can get good and bad music in all genres. So, what’s worth saying about Weill? Well, he was Jewish, which largely accounts for his persecution by the Nazis in the early 1930s and his decision to emigrate to the USA (via a short stint in Paris) in 1935. He studied with Engelbert Humperdinck (the early 20th century composer, not the cheesy late 20th century crooner) and more importantly with Busoni (see Day 500). I’d suggest that you could regard Weill’s early compositions as ‘late Romantic’ in style, but the influence of Busoni gave his work a harder edge and fostered a slightly more impersonal ‘neo-classical’ style. More importantly, though, Weill was mixing with leftist writers, artists and performers in the early 1920s in Berlin, leading to musical collaborations with the playwright Georg Kaiser and, more popularly, Brecht. (This was also the milieu in which Weill met his wife, the singer Lotte Lenya – they married in 1926, divorced in 1933 and re-married in 1937; she tirelessly kept Weill’s reputation alive after his death in 1950.) Unlike Brecht, Weill never embraced communism, which led to the pair falling out, but not before works such as ‘The Threepenny Opera’, ‘Happy End’ and ‘The Rise and Fall of the City of Mahagonny’ had flourished – and then been banned by the Nazis. Weill’s work in America never quite hit the same heights, though he continued, especially during the 2nd World War, to compose music that he believed would be ‘socially useful’, working with lyricists like Oscar Hammerstein. As for how to mark the anniversaries of Weill’s birth and death, I’d really like to publicise his 2nd Symphony, and I’ll try to find an opportunity to feature it at a later date, but I can’t escape the fact that Weill’s most obviously popular work is his music for ‘The Threepenny Opera’, so that’s what I’m going to explore. Its impact on popular culture has been immense – its most famous number, ‘Mack the Knife’, has been performed by dozens of figures over the years, notably Louis Armstrong, Nina Simone, Frank Sinatra, Jim Morrison and The Doors, David Bowie, Steeleye Span(!), Robbie Williams and, erm, Sting. (Actually Sting’s version isn’t at all bad, and much closer in mood to the original score.) The starting point for the work was John Gay’s 1728 musical drama ‘The Beggar’s Opera’ (a 1970s revival of it was a feature of my secondary school performing days!), which, unlike Handel’s operas of the same time, employed low-life characters and popular ditties of the day. Gay’s work was revived to immense popular acclaim in London in the later 1920s, and Brecht saw and was immediately captivated by the work and its impact. Back in Berlin, he and Weill began a reworking of it, ‘Die Dreigroschenoper’, and musically Weill took his cue from 1920s Berlin cabaret, with its rather Europeanised take on American jazz. It was first performed in 1928, and over the next couple of years there was a kind of ‘Threepenny Opera frenzy’ throughout Germany, and indeed across the wider musical world. (It didn’t take off first time round in America, but in the 1950s it became the then longest-running musical show on Broadway.) Weill extracted eight items from the show’s original 21 pieces and turned them into a short suite. Its scoring reflects the cabaret-style sound of the original: pairs of flutes, high clarinets, bassoons and trumpets, along with trombone, tuba, piano, timpani and a wide range of percussion, banjo, guitar and accordion. The best-known item, ‘The Ballad of Mack the Knife’, follows the Overture, and then come ‘The Instead-of Song’, ‘Ballad of the Easy Life’, ‘Polly’s Song’, ‘Tango-Song’, ‘Canon Song’ and ‘Threepenny Finale’. A lot of the grit in the oyster of this work comes from the fact that originally the lyrics were pretty brutal and graphic, ‘sweetened’ by the cabaret-style music. Still, even without the words, you can sense, I think, some of the sinister quality of the setting of ‘The Threepenny Opera’. As for a recording, getting a symphony orchestra (or at least, a dozen or so members of it) to play this work does, perhaps, tame it a little, but I’m quite taken with this video recording by the State Philharmonic Orchestra, Hamburg, conducted by Ingo Metzmacher. It was recorded in rather sanitised lockdown conditions in 2021, but it’s none the worse for that. You’ll find it here: Weill: The Threepenny Opera (Suite)
Weinberg, Mieczyslaw (1919-96)
Day 398: Piano Quintet, Op 18 (1st movement) (Time: 9 minutes)
I want to turn today (21/7/23) to an extract from an almost exactly contemporary work to the Shostakovich symphony we heard last time, and by a composer with one of the most unstable names in music. Mieczysław Weinberg (1919-96) was born in Warsaw, Poland, into a Jewish family. His father was a professional musician in Jewish theatre circles in both Poland and what is now Moldova. Weinberg studied at the Warsaw Conservatoire from the age of twelve, but his musical development was brutally disrupted by the Nazi invasion of Poland in September 1939. The details of his escape eastwards are obscure, and it appears that the rest of his family did not flee with him – the consequence being that his parents and younger sister were murdered in Nazi death camps, and in fact Weinberg never saw any members of his wider family again. He pitched up at the Polish/Soviet border, and it is here that confusions about his name began to unfold. Apparently a Red Army border guard found his proper name too complicated, and labelled him simply ‘Moisey’ (a version of ‘Moses’). Subsequently, he entered the records (musical and administrative) as Moisey or Mossey or Moishe, and his surname evolved variously as Weinberg or Wainberg or even Vainberg. Even now, recorded music is released under a variety of spellings of his name, which makes cataloguing his work a fairly complex business. However, it appears that in the short term at least Weinberg wasn’t unduly troubled by this fluid nomenclature – what mattered to him was survival, initially in Minsk (now the capital of Belarus, but then well inside the borders of the Soviet Union) and then, as the Nazi push eastwards came ever closer, to Tashkent (in modern Uzbekistan). It is at this point that Shostakovich came into contact with him and his music – initially because Shostakovich was handed a copy of Weinberg’s newly-composed Symphony No 1. By 1943 Weinberg was living in Moscow, and there he and Shostakovich became firm friends and colleagues. In 1943 Shostakovich was 37, while Weinberg was 23; Shostakovich was an established composer, accepted (despite dangerous clashes with the Soviet authorities) as one of the leading figures of his time, while Weinberg had barely started his compositional career. It’s perhaps not surprising, then, that Weinberg’s compositions from that time are powerfully influenced by the older composer, but as the decades passed his work became more individual. The 1948 persecution of musicians and other artists affected Shostakovich and Weinberg equally – both had works banned from performance and were deprived of employment and income. Weinberg’s father-in-law, the actor Solomon Michoels, was murdered in one of Stalin’s purges, and Weinberg himself was imprisoned. Shostakovich took the extraordinarily brave step of intervening personally with Stalin’s feared secret service boss Beria to save him. It appears that only the fortuitously-timed death of Stalin in 1953 prevented Weinberg from languishing in a gulag; he was released the following month, and gradually rehabilitated, though life in the Soviet Union for Jewish people was never really secure. He died in 1996, having outlived the Soviet Union itself. Though his music was known there, very little of it appeared in the West until after his death, and indeed the ‘discovery’ of Weinberg and his music has really only taken off in the past 20 years. He was a prolific composer, the creator of 22 symphonies, 17 string quartets, a wide range of instrumental works (including sonatas for piano, for violin, for viola and for cello), several dozen film scores (often his only reliable source of income) and seven operas. It’s not difficult to hear the influence of Shostakovich in Weinberg’s music, though you can also hear Prokofiev, Mahler and above all Polish and Jewish folk music. (Many critics identify Weinberg as the source of Shostakovich’s own interest in Jewish music, which emerges powerfully in many of his major works.) In terms of choosing a piece by Weinberg to illustrate his voice, I’ve gone for one that marks both his debt to Shostakovich and also the emergence of something distinctive and personal in his compositional technique. It’s his Piano Quintet, Op 18. This was written in 1944, and had its first performance in April 1945 (which makes it almost contemporary with the Shostakovich symphony from my last posting). Like Shostakovich’s own Piano Quintet (from 1940), Weinberg’s work is in five movements, though structurally they otherwise have little in common. But the brooding first movement (which is what I’m focusing on) has something of Shostakovich’s sense of desolation – you don’t have to probe too deeply beneath its surface to feel Weinberg’s grief at the loss of his family, not to mention the sense of horror at the brutality of war itself. For me, one of the most striking features of Weinberg’s style is his gift for melody, often shaped by the patterns of Jewish folk music, and alternations of major and minor keys that give the work a ‘bittersweet’ quality. After an anguished middle section, the movement subsides to a reflective pianissimo close. I hope it might be for those who’ve never encountered Weinberg’s music until now the discovery of a new and interesting voice. Do look out the rest of the Piano Quintet, not to mention several of the symphonies, recordings of which have appeared in recent years. For a recording of the first movement of Weinberg’s Piano Quintet, I’ve chosen this video performance by the Szymanowski Quartet and the pianist Michail Lifits (and do note that unlike the previous posting in which there was a substantial intro to the video before the performance of ‘Shostakovich 9’ started, here the music of Weinberg’s Quintet begins straight away, even if it’s a few moments before we see the performers. Arty, eh?). You’ll find the recording here: Weinberg: Piano Quintet, Op 18 (1st movement)
You can also hear this piece performed in full here
Whitacre, Eric (b1970)
Day 361: When David Heard (Time: 17 minutes)
Today (10/3/23), I want to pick up our intermittent Lenten theme, and a suggestion from one of our invisible correspondents, Nigel Russell-Sewell, now resident in Newcastle but once music director of Escafeld Chorale, in which three members of this playlist sing. Nigel writes suggesting we listen to a substantial work by the American composer/conductor Eric Whitacre, whose music appears on this list for the first time. Whitacre (b1970) is one of the most-performed contemporary composers in the world today, a fact no doubt helped by some successful marketing of his music and the undeniably ‘rock star’ appeal of his image (not that there’s anything wrong with either of those things!). He played keyboards in a band in his youth, but had no musical training at all until he went to university, where he eventually joined a choir (apparently Mozart’s ‘Requiem’ was the first piece he sang), and this experience changed the course of his life in an instant. He became a composition graduate at New York’s Juilliard School, and has been writing and performing music pretty much full-time ever since. The vast majority of his compositions are for choir, mostly unaccompanied, though he has also written for wind ensemble and a quantity of music for film and TV (he co-composed the music for ‘Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides’, for example). Probably his big break was the appearance of his CD ‘Light and Gold’ in 2010. Since then he has appeared as both composer and conductor at music festivals throughout the world, and garnered many music awards in the process. What is his music like? Well, there are (inevitably) some differences of opinion here. At the complimentary end of the spectrum his work is regularly described as ‘radiant’ or ‘weightless’: ‘A highly significant composer with a very genuine gift for choral writing and one, moreover, with that priceless ability to communicate strongly and effectively with his audience,’ said ‘Gramophone’ magazine of an album of his work. Less charitably, ‘The Daily Telegraph’ reviewed his music at a BBC Proms performance in 2015 with the observation that it's ‘the sort of music Vaughan Williams might have composed in the Cambridge branch of Dunkin' Donuts.’ Treading carefully here, I'd say that if you like the music of Morten Lauridsen (see Days 147 and 358) or Arvo Pärt (see Days 33, 83 and 249), then the likelihood is that this music will appeal strongly. I've sung some of his music in my time, from the distinctly cheesy and sentimental ‘The Seal Lullaby’ to the much more compelling ‘Five Hebrew Love Songs’. Nigel's suggestion for today is one of Whitacre's longest works, ‘When David Heard’. The text, as most on this list will know, is from 2 Samuel, 18:33, and it narrates the deeply anguished response of King David to the death of his son Absalom (‘When David heard that Absalom was slain he went up into his chamber over the gate and wept, “My son, my son, O Absalom my son, would to God I had died for thee!”’). As a narrative of mourning and loss, it has a long history of being set by composers – two of my favourites are by the English Renaissance composers Weelkes and Tomkins. For Whitacre the prompt for this composition was both highly personal and deeply upsetting: a response to the death in a car crash of the son of one of his friends. There’s a short YouTube clip of Whitacre discussing this here. The work that emerged as a result is described by Nigel in his email to me as ‘powerful, reflective, challenging, devastating’, and you can hear exactly what he means. Whitacre has written of the experience of creating this music: ‘Setting this text was such a lonely experience, and even now just writing these words I am moved to tears. I wrote maybe 200 pages of sketches, trying to find the perfect balance between sound and silence, always simplifying, and by the time I finished a year later I was profoundly changed. Older, I think, and quieted a little. I still have a hard time listening to the recording.’ The structure of the piece, particularly in its contrasts of extreme density (lots of use of ‘cluster chords’) and silence, gives the music a searingly intense emotional arc, with evident demarcations on the journey of grief and lamentation. YouTube lists several video performances of this work, some more successful than others (often a matter of recording quality as much as performers’ competence). Out of the options available, I’ve gone for one by the Wichita State University Concert Chorale, directed by Michael Hanawalt. You’ll find it here: Whitacre: When David Heard
White, Robert (1538-74)
Day 274: Lamentations (for five voices) (Time: 22 minutes)
Today (11/3/22), I’m back on the Lenten trail with a lovely piece of Tudor choral music and a composer who may be new to some of you. One of the more unfortunate consequences of the fact that we now know and hear a lot of music by Thomas Tallis (see Days 67 and 251) and William Byrd (see Day 86) is that we tend to overlook the fact that in this great flowering of English Renaissance music there were many other exceptional composers, who as a result find themselves edged out of concert programmes or radio broadcasts. From as far back as Walter Frye and Walter Lambe at the end of the 15th century, there was a flourishing tradition of choral music in this country. Just picking names of those whose music I find compelling over the next century, I’d want to single out John Browne, Robert Fayrfax, William Cornysh the Younger, Nicholas Ludford, John Taverner, Christopher Tye, John Sheppard (a really, really fine composer!), William Mundy … and the composer of the music for today, Robert White. One of White’s misfortunes was that his life was relatively short (1538-74), and thus his output is more limited than, say, Tallis or Byrd. A CD that I’ve got of White’s music quotes a posthumous Oxford manuscript source as saying ‘Maxima musarum nostrarum gloria White; Tu peris, actemum sed tua musa manet’ (which I’m sure your Latin can cope with, but just in case, it means roughly ‘Thou, O White, greatest glory of our muses, dost perish, but thy muse endureth for ever’). In his time he was evidently a capable cathedral musician, being Master of Choristers at Ely, then at Chester, and finally at Westminster Abbey. Sadly, he died of the plague in 1574. A reasonable amount of his church music has survived, notably a setting of the Magnificat, four settings of the Compline hymn ‘Christe qui lux es’ and two settings of the Lamentations of Jeremiah, one in six parts and the other (today’s choice) for five voices, SSATB. The Lamentations have formed part of the old Catholic liturgy (Protestant England doesn’t seem to have had an equivalent) as part of the office to Tenebrae (literally ‘darkness’) during Holy Week. (I realise we’re a bit early here, but I’ve got a lot of pieces to fit in before Easter!) This nocturnal usage draws some sombre and darkly expressive compositions from a great range of Renaissance composers, and White is no exception. If you were to compare his setting with, say, ones by Palestrina or Lassus, there’s something distinctively English and Anglican about his writing, especially I think in the adventurous harmonies and the shifting between major and minor modes. White’s setting uses Lamentations 1; 8-13, adding Hosea 14; 1 (‘return, O Jerusalem, to the Lord thy God’) as a conclusive appeal, as was conventional in settings at this time. This is, I think, spellbinding grief-stricken music, conveying deep emotion. There are some excellent recordings of this work (audio only, I’m afraid) on YouTube, and from them I’ve chosen this performance by the Oxford Camerata, directed by Jeremy Summerly. You’ll find it here: White: Lamentations (for five voices)
Wilbye, John (1574-1638)
Day 461: Draw on, sweet Night (Time: 5 minutes) and Weep, weep, mine eyes (5 minutes)
Today (5/3/24) is the closest I can get to marking the 450th anniversary of the birth of the English madrigalist, John Wilbye, which falls two days from now. We’ve had quite a few postings of Elizabethan madrigal composers over the years that this list has been running (and far fewer Italian madrigalists, I’m sorry to say: it reveals something of my preferences in this field, I suppose … something that suggestions ‘from the audience’ would of course amend!). John Wilbye, however, is a new name to add to our list. Wilbye (1574-1638) is, one might say, something of a one trick pony (but what a trick!), in that he seems to have written nothing other than madrigals. There’s a single keyboard piece in a small anthology of early 17th century virginal works, and there are one or two settings of religious texts, but otherwise what we have from Wilbye are two books of madrigals, totalling some 75 short pieces in all, none of them more than five minutes long. We know very little about his life, which seems to have been a quiet affair, in the sense that he moved around very little, had in effect a single employment that lasted all his creative life, never married and, though he had contacts in London, seems to have lived out his days in rural seclusion in Suffolk. Not that it was a life without risk. His employers were the Kitsons of Hengrave Hall, near Bury St Edmunds. They were a recusant family, and it seems probable (though not absolutely certain) that Wilbye too was Catholic. Having arrived at Hengrave Hall sometime in the early 1590s, Wilbye remained there until the death of his patroness, Lady Elizabeth Kitson, in 1628. At that point, the house and its contents were bequeathed to Lady Elizabeth’s daughter, Mary Darcy, but it seems that Wilbye moved out of Hengrave and into the Colchester house of Mary Darcy, where he lived out his days until his death ten years later. It wasn’t entirely a life of quiet contemplation, however; he also spent time in London (the Kitsons had a town house there), and was on occasion employed by the music printer Thomas East, who made a valuable contribution to the English madrigal by being one of the principal publishers of such compositions. Wilbye published two books of madrigals, one in 1598 (at which point they were described as ‘newly composed’, which seems logical in that the composer would have been only in his early twenties at the time) and the other in 1609. After that, who knows? What we can say is that nothing else entered the public domain. Still, what he did compose is enough to ensure Wilbye a place at the top of the tree when it comes to the madrigal as a genre. As might be expected from a musical form that emphasised highly-wrought and emotionally extreme texts, Wilbye’s work is ornate and often deeply sensual. The texts he set spend a lot of time describing weeping, often the tears of a thwarted lover. I thought I’d mark this Wilbye anniversary by considering two of his most famous madrigals. First, here is ‘Draw on, sweet night’. It’s a stylised depiction of melancholy, the narrator welcoming the arrival of darkness as the best context to suit his desolate mood: ‘Draw on, Sweet Night, best friend unto those cares/ That do arise from painful melancholy./ My life so ill through want of comfort fares,/ that unto thee I consecrate it wholly.// Sweet Night, draw on! My griefs when they be told/ To shades and darkness find some ease from paining,/ And while thou all in silence dost enfold,/ I then shall have best time for my complaining.’ It’s a wistful piece, full of melancholy, highlighted by the moments in the madrigal when we shift from major to minor, always likely to generate a poignant sensation. It’s performed in this video recording by the very fine ensemble Voces 8: Wilbye: Draw on, sweet Night. And, for another of these lovely vignettes, here is ‘Weep, weep, mine eyes’. (You’re never in any danger of missing the point with Wilbye!) Here we are again full of the pains of love, a love thwarted which leaves the narrator longing for death as the only solace from this melancholy: ‘Weep, weep, mine eyes, my heart can take no rest./ Weep, weep, my heart, mine eyes shall ne'er be blest./ Weep eyes, weep heart, and both this accent cry:/ A thousand deaths I die, Flaminia.// Ay me, ah cruel Fortune! ay me./ Now, Leander, to die I fear not./ Death, do thy worst! I care not!/ I hope when I am dead in Elysian plain/ To meet, and there with joy we'll love again.’ There is, I realise, a predictable response to all this emotional wallowing, which would be to encourage the narrator to get a grip, and stop being such a wimp. But that’s to miss the point, which is the joy with which this melancholic gloom is celebrated. Not to everyone’s taste, maybe, but it’s a fine example of this strand in Renaissance music. The video this time is of the wonderful I Fagiolini, directed by Robert Hollingworth. You’ll find it here: Wilbye: Weep, weep, mine eyes
Wintory, Austin (b1984)
Day 311: ‘Nascence’ and ‘Apotheosis’ (from 'Journey') (Time: 9 minutes) and ‘I was Born for This’ (from 'Journey') (6 minutes)
This week is very definitely a leap into the unknown for me (which means the musical commentary in these emails will be a little more derivative than usual), because – courtesy of a suggestion from Peter Wigglesworth, who is almost certainly by some distance the youngest person on this mailing list – we are exploring music written for video games. Now, being of a certain age, my total lifetime's experience of video games adds up to hours and hours spent playing (and losing) games of ‘Super Mario Kart’ with my daughters on our trusty Nintendo N-64 during their teenage years. The music for those racetrack-based games was almost mind-numbingly repetitive, and not the sort of thing I’d ever consider inflicting on anyone outside of playing the game itself. But that game dates from 1992 … and things have moved on. So, let’s start by being a little philosophical, and asking: is this the right sort of music to grace this hallowed playlist? I want to suggest that the answer is yes, for two reasons: one, because ‘music is music is music’, and we've had choices previously on the list from the borderline between jazz and classical, and between folk and classical; and two, because this idea of writing music for a specific context has been part of what we might regard as the remit of ‘classical composers’ for centuries. Nowadays, we happily listen to, for example, incidental music written for plays (Beethoven and ‘Egmont’, say, or Grieg and ‘Peer Gynt’) without questioning whether the context is ‘acceptable’ when we're in a concert hall listening to an orchestra. In the 20th century, many composers wrote scores for films, and these again now form an unquestionable part of the ‘classical music’ world – we wouldn’t turn our noses up at a concert containing orchestral extracts from Bernstein’s ‘West Side Story’, I imagine, or Vaughan Williams’ ‘Scott of the Antarctic’. So, for me at least, video games are simply a more recent context in which composers might work. And yes, the music shorn of its game-playing context might then have to work harder to hold our attention, but that will simply be a means of separating what will last from what is ephemeral. Anyway, getting down off my soapbox, another more practical problem about music for video games is that because every experience of playing a video game is (slightly) different, the music has to be infinitely flexible, effectively a series of overlapping ‘cues’ depending on what the player is doing at the time. So, in the course of playing, one’s experience of the music might vary somewhat. However, at the point when ‘soundtracks’ for video games become available independently from their context (and this strikes me as very like listening to bits of ‘Peer Gynt’ when you're not in the theatre watching Ibsen), what we have is a free-standing piece (usually a suite of several pieces) of music. And so to the composer for today (26/7/22), Austin Wintory, who has composed music for somewhere in the region of 100 films and 50 video games in the past 15 years. Wintory (b1984) started writing for video games early in his career: his work on the game ‘Flow’ in 2006 was an early landmark. However, the music that has, as things stand, attracted the most attention is the score he wrote to the video game ‘Journey’, produced for the same company, which appeared in 2012, and which received a Grammy nomination. The game is essentially a quest-based narrative involving a journey to and up a distant mountain. I haven’t played this game, but my sense, reading about it, is that it’s an immersive, rather contemplative experience, and the music is a core part of the emotional impact of playing the game. Wintory describes the score he wrote, with a 'motto' theme on cello representing the player of the game, as ‘like a big cello concerto where you are the soloist and all the rest of the instruments represent the world around you.’ Earlier this year, Wintory's score ‘Traveller: a Journey Symphony’ was released in a recording by the LSO, but the original soundtrack recording was made by the rather smaller forces of the Macedonia Radio Symphony Orchestra of North Macedonia. In that state, we have just under an hour’s worth of music, divided into 18 sections. To give you a sense of the music’s evocative soundscape, I’ve selected the first and seventeenth portions: ‘Nascence’ and ‘Apotheosis’, but in a performance given by the West German Radio Orchestra, Cologne, under the British conductor Michael Seal. You’ll find it here: Wintory: ‘Nascence’ and ‘Apotheosis’ (from 'Journey'). In addition, the final section of Wintory’s score is a vocal piece, ‘I was born for this’, the lyrics of which (getting deep here) are extracted from a variety of literary and historical sources (Virgil's ‘Aeneid’, ‘Beowulf’, Homer's ‘Iliad’, the words of Joan of Arc, the Japanese poet and master of the haiku, Matsuo Bashō, and so on), giving a cross-cultural summation of, one might say, the experience of life’s journey. You’ll find it here, in a performance by the Swedish Radio Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Charles Hazlewood, with Sabina Zweiacker as the soloist: Wintory: ‘I was Born for This’ (from 'Journey')
Wiren, Dag (1905-86)
Day 581: Serenade for Strings (Time: 17 minutes)
Today (13/3/26), there’s another new name to add to the list of those I’ve considered over the past nearly six years(!), the Swedish composer Dag Wirén (1905-86). The reason for my choice is that later this month, the English Chamber Orchestra will be at the City Hall performing his Serenade for Strings. I’m confident that those of a certain age will recognise some of the Wirén piece, even if you couldn’t have attached his name to it. He’s a composer who has rarely featured on concert programmes or radio broadcasts, but I’m absolutely certain that he deserves his moment in the spotlight, and maybe if you read this lot and follow the YouTube link you’ll think so too. A number of the composers I’ve featured on this list are often regarded as ‘one-hit wonders’. I really don’t think Dag Wirén deserves to be in that category, even though I realise I’m perhaps encouraging it with today’s selection. So, who was Dag Wirén? Well, he belongs to a generation of Swedish composers who seem to have acquired the collective label ‘Composers of the Thirties’, simply because that decade of the 20th century was when they first came to prominence. But though there are links between him and others in this category, like Lars-Erik Larsson (one day, folks, one day…), it’s clear that as he aged Wirén became more and more his own man. In fact, as well as writing a relatively small amount of music, Wirén is also interesting because he’s so very quotable about music and the process of writing it. He was born into a music-loving but by no means privileged household, but his musical bent was evident from a very early age (conducting and writing music for his school orchestra, for example). He was initially an organ student, though he wrote nothing at all for the instrument and never played it in public, but his musical imagination really blossomed during the years 1931-4, when he lived in Paris and studied with the exiled Russian teacher Leonid Sabaneyev. A lot of his early music was influenced by those in vogue in Paris at the time – Stravinsky, Prokofiev, the composers of the group ‘Les Six’ (Poulenc and Milhaud in particular) – but very soon he turned away from ‘modern’ trends and evolved a musical style of his own. He was always, seemingly, a ‘Neo-Classical’ composer – a maker of brisk, lively music with no trace of Romanticism to wallow in. But when he returned to Sweden in 1934 he developed a considerably more functional approach to music-making. So, some quotable quotes. In 1945, asked to define his identity as a composer, he said, ‘I believe in Bach, Mozart, Nielsen and absolute music.’ I think it’s this focus on the ‘purity’ of absolute music that is key here. Music was there to do a job, of course, but it should stand on its own terms, almost contextless. He was fond of saying that his first desire was to entertain and to please, to create listener-friendly ‘modern’ music. He wrote in many of the, if you like, ‘absolute’ forms – the symphony, the string quartet, the sonata and sonatina, the concert overture. Interestingly, he also wrote ballet music, as well as scores for 11 plays and nine films (including those by Ingmar Bergman), but even here, where you might think context is pretty crucial, the music has a kind of detachment to it. Perhaps the neatest illustration of this is that he wrote the music for the 1965 Swedish entry to the Eurovision Song Contest(!), but he wrote the music first (absolute, you see!) and then his associate wrote lyrics to fit. His music, never very complex after his early 1930s flirtation with Stravinskyan neo-Classicism, gradually got more and more pared down with time. He said (and I’m sure this is self-deprecating irony), ‘When you have as few ideas as I have, you have to make the most of them.’ A lot of his later works are pretty monothematic, and employ a technique he described as ‘metamorphosis’, a kind of continual slow development of an idea as a piece evolves. Interestingly, he once met Sibelius, who said to him, ‘You don’t look like your scores’! Equally interestingly, Wirén stopped composing long before his death in 1986. A final nice quotation: ‘One should stop in time, while one still has the sense to stop in time.’ His Serenade for Strings, Op 11 is in four movements, a Preludium, an Andante Espressivo, a Scherzo and Trio and a March. The writing throughout is sparkling, with clean, unfussy lines, instantly approachable (I think) but absolutely not superficial. For instance, isn’t the climax to the second movement thoughtful and even profound, even though on the surface it seems to be simply (as in, innocently) beautiful? The finale is the movement you’ll know, if your television watching stretches back to that old BBC current affairs programme ‘Monitor’, for which this movement provided the theme tune. I should say, though, that although the movement is a vaguely militaristic march, it’s sunny good humour means we’re never inclined to take it solemnly. Lots of composers wrote fairly dark ‘music reflecting the times’ in the 1930s. I don’t think Wirén was one of them. There are a small number of video recordings on YouTube of Wirén’s Serenade for Strings. It’s clearly the sort of music that appeals to small-scale string orchestras. From the options available, I think you should find a lot of enjoyment from this performance by the New York Chamber Players, directed by Dongmin Kim. It’s a 2020 Covid-influenced performance, but I think the liveliness of the music still comes across. You’ll find it here: Wiren: Serenade for Strings
Wolf-Ferrari, Ermanno (1876-1948)
Day 408: The Jewels of the Madonna (Suite) (Time: 16 minutes)
Today (1/9/23), we’re in 20th century Italy, marking the 75th anniversary of the death of an Italian composer which actually fell on 21st January this year, at a time when the St Tim’s Classical Playlist was on its holidays in New Zealand. Still, better late than… and all that. Not a lot is heard these days of the Venetian composer Ermanno Wolf-Ferrari (1876-1948), and it’s also the case that if you look around on the interweb you can find quite a lot of abuse directed his way for the alleged unmemorability and general lack of inspiration of much of his work. This seems to me more than a little harsh. He’s hardly a great composer, but he did write some lovely (and memorable) stuff, even if he never really fitted into any fashionable musical niche except for a few years before the First World War. As you might infer from his name, he was of mixed German/Italian parentage. He was actually just plain old ‘Ermanno Wolf’ until the age of about 19, when he added his mother’s Italian maiden name to his father’s German one. (Even then, he seems not to have hyphenated the names; this came later, and much more haphazardly.) His father was a painter (as in ‘artist’, not as in ‘and decorator’) and until he was in at least his mid-teens our composer was keen to follow in his father’s footsteps. But gradually music won him over. However, he was no child prodigy, and even his studies were essentially those of an amateur. Nevertheless, being culturally very Italian indeed, it was his aim (after a handful of apprentice instrumental works) to write operas, and in the end he wrote 15 of them. His first big hit was ‘Cenerentola’ (‘Cinderella’), written when he was in his early 20s, and in the years before the First World War he wrote a series of comic operas based on the plays of the 18th century playwright Goldoni (his play ‘The Servant of Two Masters’ was a big hit starring James Corden, you may recall, when revived not long ago). This phase of Wolf-Ferrari’s life was about as successful as it got (and it was, it has to be said, a really very successful phase indeed: these comic operas were a hit right across Europe and beyond), but he seems to have been searching for something more substantial at the same time. Hence his first opera in the ‘verismo’ style of Puccini, Mascagni, Leoncavallo and so on, ‘The Jewels of the Madonna’, from 1911 – a piece I’ll come back to in a moment. Before the First World War his operas were performed as often as those of Puccini or Richard Strauss, and he seemed set to be one of the major figures of the operatic stage. If one were looking for a turning point in Wolf-Ferrari’s life, it came with the outbreak of the First World War, pitting as it did the two nations of his ancestry and identity against each other as enemies on the European stage. It seems to have had a deeply disturbing effect on Wolf-Ferrari, who essentially withdrew from much public and musical life, moving to Switzerland; the music largely dried up during these years, and when it started to reappear in the later 1920s it was more serious in mood than before – but also, given the revolutions that transformed musical life, it left him almost entirely out of touch with the times. There’s little evidence of modernism in his music, of any kind: no hints of Stravinsky, or Schoenberg, or the raw folk culture of Bartók. In fact, it’s hard to put a label on Wolf-Ferrari’s style. His operas sound ‘Italian’, of course; his instrumental and orchestral music has a sort of generalised ‘late Romantic’ feel. In the last decade of his life there were a couple of new operas, but much more orchestral and chamber music. I toyed with the idea of choosing a movement from his Violin Concerto of 1943, a much underrated work in my view, or one of the chamber works of the 1940s (try the String Quartet Op 23, or the String Quintet Op 24, or the String Trio Op 32 – all works that have been recorded in recent years), but in the end I thought I’d choose music from that melodramatic opera ‘The Jewels of the Madonna’, if only because pretty much the only piece of music of his that gets much exposure at all these days, the Intermezzo from that opera, forms part of the orchestral suite drawn from it. In fact, although back in 1911 it seemed like a departure for Wolf-Ferrari, and a step in the direction of the musical language of Puccini, ‘The Jewels of the Madonna’ isn’t all that ‘verismo’-like at all, apart from its rather melodramatic plot (love between the male lead and his adopted sister, plenty of anti-Catholic sentiment, and, ahem, an onstage orgy), but although it ends with the female lead drowning herself and the male lead plunging a dagger into his own heart, Wolf-Ferrari seems much more interested in character and motivation than in sensationalised or lurid musical language – there is none of the driving passion or the big, emotive orchestral sound-world of Puccini, say. The orchestral suite from the opera is made up of four movements. First we have a ‘Festa Popolare’ (‘Local Festival’) from Act III, which accompanies the rowdy mafia-style subcultural figures that drive the opera’s low-life scenes. Then we get the opera’s (and Wolf-Ferrari’s) most famous tune, the ‘Intermezzo’ that opens Act II, a big sweeping melody that generates an air of almost existential piety. The third movement is a ‘Serenata’ which occurs as the Prelude to Act III, an instrumental version of one of the opera’s songs. Finally we have the ‘Danza Napoletana’, and the wild dance of the Camorristi leading to the aforesaid orgy. Unsurprisingly, given the relatively obscurity of the composer, I’m afraid video recordings aren’t available, so once more we’re in audio-only territory. The Suite from ‘The Jewels of the Madonna’ is played on this recording by the Academy of St Martin in the Fields, conducted by Sir Neville Marriner. You’ll find it here: Wolf-Ferrari: The Jewels of the Madonna (Suite)
Zelenka, Jan Dismas (1679-1745)
Day 391: Regina Coeli in F (Time: 4 minutes) and Hipocondrie in A (9 minutes)
To start today (27/6/23), a little mental exercise for you. Try naming the great composers of the High Baroque period, that is, those whose mature musical output falls roughly between 1710-1750. I imagine we’d all have little difficulty with the really big beasts of the time: JS Bach, Handel, Vivaldi. And then? Well, Telemann, I’d guess, whose music is far more mainstream these days than used to be the case. And probably Domenico Scarlatti, on account of the endless richness of his keyboard sonatas. Then there are the French names from the period (Rameau, Forqueray, Couperin, Rebel). But after that it gets trickier. I’d want to make a serious case for Biber (see Day 12), Fasch, Weiss (for lutenists/guitarists), Roman (see Day 159), Quantz (coming shortly to a playlist near you) and Albinoni. But more than any of that final group I’d suggest one of the composers from the age we really ought to know better is Jan Dismas Zelenka (1679-1745). He was born in a little town south-east of Prague in what is now the Czech Republic, but which in those days was Bohemia, a kingdom that was part of the larger Habsburg Empire. He was the son of a musician and educated in Prague at the local Jesuit college. By 1710 he was working for the Elector of Saxony in Dresden, and apart from short periods of time spent in Vienna and on a tour of Italy, he remained in Dresden for the rest of his life, where his primary occupation was as a player of the violone (roughly approximating to the double bass) in the court orchestra. Almost all his output is of sacred music, of a rather floridly baroque Catholic kind. There is a undercurrent, in some of the discussion of Zelenka’s life story, of his frustration with his status in Dresden, and of the possible misanthropic nature of his character – but both of these issues seem nowadays to be explained by the prolonged uncertainty as to who was going to get the top musical job in Dresden after the demise of the ailing Johann Heinichen (another interesting composer who might feature on this list one day), a post Zelenka held in a provisional way before the permanent appointment of the more operatically-inclined Johann Hasse. Nevertheless, the perception stuck: the liner notes to one of my CDs of his music describe him as ‘a strange man: stubborn, reserved, melancholy, fervently religious – which appeared as bigotry to some – and totally ‘uncourtly’ in his manner.’ After his death in 1745 Zelenka’s music, as was the case for so many of his contemporaries, effectively disappeared, apart from in church contexts. The ‘Zelenka revival’ is often attributed to Smetana in the 1860s and 70s, who performed for his compatriot’s music a role similar to that played by Mendelssohn in the re-popularising of Bach’s works. And, in a way that means we now know many more 18th century composers and their music than we used to, Zelenka has benefited enormously from the advent of recorded music (and particularly the enthusiasm of some record labels for a kind of ‘completist’ approach to recording obscure repertoire) and from the ‘early music’/’period instrument’ revival of the past 50 years or so. So, what’s Zelenka’s music like? As mentioned, he wrote a lot of church music (20-plus settings of the Mass, in addition to four Requiems, and over 150 other shorter sacred pieces), and much of this music has one foot in the past – Zelenka was very fond of Palestrina – even if it’s also full of Baroque ornamentation. As a very, very short example of his sacred music I thought it might be interesting to hear one of his many settings of the Marian antiphon ‘Regina Coeli’. This one, in F, dates from 1726. Even in this short piece you can hear something of Zelenka’s harmonic inventiveness, and a tendency to appeal to the emotionally poignant sentiments in texts. One unusual feature of this setting is its scoring for three high voices, which gives the piece a bright and joyful sound, from the stately processional feel of the vocal lines at the start to the florid ‘Alleluia’ with which it ends. You’ll find it here, in an audio-only version I’m afraid, but you can follow the score if you wish, by sopranos Carolyn Sampson and Rebecca Outram, countertenor Robin Blaze, and members of the King’s Consort, directed by Robert King: Zelenka: Regina Coeli in F, Z134. However, although most of Zelenka’s catalogued works are for voices, there was also a phase early in his career when he wrote extensively for groups of instruments, combinations of forces that fall midway between chamber music and something more ‘orchestral’. These pieces are often characterised by eccentricities of scoring, or harmonic writing – and even, sometimes, of naming. Such is the case with the other work I thought I’d choose – a short piece scored for two oboes, two violins, viola, bassoon and continuo, which he called ‘Hipocondrie’. I don’t know any other composition named thus! From what I can gather, in the 18th century the word did not so much imply ‘hypochondria’, as in the modern sense of imaginary illness or excessive worry about one’s health. Rather it was a term used to suggest a temperament of melancholy, or depression, or even to describe someone suffering from migraine. None of which, in truth, really helps with why this particular work has this particular title. What one can say is that it’s structured a bit like a ‘French overture’ – that is a slow, rather stately opening, followed by something more animated and fugal, before concluding with a return to the rhythmic solemnity of its initial section, marked (very French!) ‘Lentement’. The music is, I think, quite enigmatic, and maybe the abrupt shifts between major and minor keys suggest something vaguely programmatic in the work’s title. Or maybe not. Anyway, the work is played here by chamber forces of the Adelaide Baroque Orchestra directed from the first violin by Ben Dollman: Zelenka: Hipocondrie in A,Z187
Zemlinsky, Alexander (1871-1942)
Day 231: Sinfonietta (Time: 21 minutes)
Today (12/10/21), it’s time to celebrate another impending big birthday, because in two days' time our current composer under the spotlight would have been 150 years old. Alexander Zemlinsky (1871-1942) – or sometimes Alexander von Zemlinsky, though as far as I know the ‘von’ is a fake-aristocratic marker invented by an earlier generation – is likely, if you file your CDs alphabetically (it may not surprise you to find that I do!) to be the person whose music comes at the end of your shelves. (I have music on CD by Zespedes, Zipoli and Zumsteeg(!), but the CDs in question are filed under other composers. Anyway, enough of that…) Zemlinsky is yet another of those composers to whom I’d attach the ‘ought to be better known’ label. If he has a reputation these days, it tends to be because he is the only person to give music lessons to Schoenberg, and he also became Schoenberg's brother-in-law, after Schoenberg married Zemlinsky's sister Mathilde. He was born in Vienna to a mixed Catholic/Jewish background, though he was raised as a Jew – and, inevitably, suffered because of it in his later life. His early work is hugely influenced by Brahms, and I toyed for a while with selecting a movement from one of his early symphonies, or the Clarinet Trio, but decided that lovely though that music is, it’s not Zemlinsky's ‘authentic’ voice. Zemlinsky gave music lessons not just to Schoenberg but to Alma Schindler, with whom he fell in love (she seems to have had that effect on many people), but she broke off the relationship and married Mahler instead – not that that ended well… For most of his working life he was a conductor of opera in Germany and Czechoslovakia, but after the Nazis came to power, he moved to Vienna and in 1938 to the USA. This final experience seems to have been a mixed blessing for many émigré composers – for all that Stravinsky and Schoenberg were feted there, there are others, like Martinu, Bartók and particularly Zemlinsky, who struggled for recognition. He died in relative obscurity in 1942. As for a music choice, I’ve settled in the end for a relatively late work, the Sinfonietta of 1934, the last work he wrote for orchestra. It has a rather spiky ‘neo-classical’ feel. If I were comparing it to anyone else's music, I’d say it has something in common with Hindemith or Korngold, or even maybe Kurt Weill. It’s nervy and agitated in mood, particularly in its outer movements. The middle movement, a more anguished ‘Ballade’, is closer in sound world to Mahler. It’s the emotional core of the work. A sad footnote: in 1942 Schoenberg wrote to Zemlinsky, ‘Just heard your wonderful Sinfonietta: hope it is the beginning of your American success.’ Zemlinsky suffered a stroke and died a few days later. As for a performance, there’s an attractive video recording on YouTube by the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Andrés Orozco-Estrada. You’ll find it here: Zemlinsky: Sinfonietta
Zéspedes, Juan García de (c1619-1678)
Day 252: Convidando esta la noche (Time: 5 minutes)
Today it’s Christmas Eve (24/12/21), so I’ve chosen music for the occasion, but by a composer whom I expect very few of you will have heard of, although it’s possible that you might have come across the piece in question without knowing who wrote it. For this selection we are in mid-17th century Mexico, in the company of Juan García de Zéspedes (c1619-1678) – sometimes ‘Céspedes’ in Spanish language contexts – one of an early generation of Mexican composers writing under the influence of the Spanish conquest of Central and South America. Whatever one thinks of the actions of the ‘conquistadors’ (and these days, I would submit, it’s difficult to make a case for bringing ‘enlightenment’ in European terms, given that it was a pretext for, often, mass genocide), one side effect was the curious development of what had been Spanish (and also Portuguese) Renaissance music as that music was taken across to the ‘New World’. I first became acquainted with at least a little of this material via a series of recordings made by the Birmingham-based early music group Ex Cathedra, under their music director Jeffrey Skidmore: ‘New World Symphonies’, ‘Fire Burning in Snow’, ‘Moon, Sun and All Things’ and ‘Brazilian Adventures’. (Consider that an enthusiastic recommendation, and something on which to spend your Christmas gift tokens, if anyone still gets such things!) What’s often startling about this music (whether composed by Spanish musicians who made the voyage across the Atlantic to work in churches, cathedrals and Jesuit missions in Latin America, or by native musicians whose training in ‘European’ music never quite extinguished the rhythms and melodies of the local cultures) is how fresh and direct it sounds. This is authentic ‘fusion’ music, the blending of European ways of composition with the dance music of the indigenous inhabitants of Central and South America. Very little is known about Zéspedes, certainly not his birthdate, though it seems likely that he was born in Puebla, which at that time was a thriving colonial outpost in southern Mexico. In the early 1630s, he joined the choir at the cathedral there, under the direction of the considerably more famous Juan Gutierrez de Padilla. Zéspedes stayed there for the rest of his life, taking over as music director of the cathedral in the 1660s. His output that has survived is relatively small. At one end of the spectrum are pieces in conventional European forms, such as his Salve Regina; at the other, there are secular songs using forms that reveal local cultural influences such as several labelled ‘guaracha’, a popular song (and dance) form of a fairly raucous and foot-stamping sort (and now probably more regularly associated with Cuban music). His piece ‘Convidando está la noche’ is a delight from beginning to end, a joyous song of contrasting slow and fast sections. The slow sections are more serious, with lyrics that evoke a traditional image of the newborn infant lying in the manger. The fast sections are marked ‘Duo guaracha’, indicating this animated style of music that might typically have instruments playing along. The overall effect is, I guess, a little like a hymn alternating with a jam session. Choosing a performance is really a matter of how ‘unbuttoned’ you want this music to be. At the ‘buttoned up’ end, I have heard performances by Renaissance vocal groups that take this pretty ‘straight’, with maybe the odd tentative handclap as the only nod towards ‘authenticity’. On the other hand, there are performances that use the music as the basis for rather freewheeling ‘noodling’ in the jazz style, with a mariachi band in the background! Steering a middle way between these two extremes is the performance I’ve chosen, by the legendary Jordi Savall, directing his ensemble Hespérion XXI, accompanying singers from La Capella Reial de Catalunya. You’ll find their recording here, accompanied by vaguely relevant photos of the Mexican city of Guanajuato: Juan García de Zéspedes: Convidando esta la noche.
 LATEST ENTRIES – See A-Z above for programme notes or follow the links below.
SUMMARY OF RECENT ADDITIONS to the A–Z: DAYS 531–590
Liszt, Franz (1811-86)
Day 531: Piano Concerto No 1 in E-flat Major, S.124 <— click here to view on Youtube
You'll find full programme notes for this relatively rare piano and orchestra piece from Liszt in the A–Z here.
Beethoven, Ludwig van (1770-1827)
Day 532: Symphony No 6 (Time: 42 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for this piece – Beethoven's ‘Pastoral’ Symphony – in the A–Z here.
Kurt Weill (1900-1950)
Day 533: The Threepenny Opera (Suite) (Time: 22 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for this, Weill's most obviously popular work – think ‘Mack the Knife’ – in the A–Z here.
Bliss, Arthur (1891-1975)
Day 534: A Colour Symphony (Time: 32 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for this piece – perhaps Bliss's most popular work – in the A–Z here.
Le Beau, Luise Adolpha (1850-1927)
Day 535: Elegie for Violin and Piano Op 44; Prelude Op 12 No 2; Romance for Violin and Piano Op 35; Cello Sonata Op 17; Prelude Op 12 No 7 (Time: 33 minutes)
A romantic portrait of Luise Adolpha Le Beau (1850-1927), a German composer who studied with Clara Schumann and Josef Gabriel Rheinberger.
See the A–Z entry above for the full story.
Fano, Guido Alberto (1875-1961)
Day 536: Piano Quintet (Time: 38 minutes)
See the A–Z entry above for detailed programme notes on this rarely-heard Italian composer.
Tchaikovsky, Pyotr Ilyich (1840-93)
Day 537: Variations on a Rococo Theme for Cello and Orchestra (Time: 20 minutes)
See the full entry in the A–Z above for detailed programme notes on this unusual cello ‘concerto’ by Tchaikovsky!
Mozart, Wolfgang Amadeus (1756-91)
Day 538: Quintet for Piano and Winds in E flat Major (Time: 25 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for this unusual combination of instruments from Mozart in the A–Z here.
Elgar, Edward (1857-1934)
Day 539: Piano Quintet in A Minor (Time: 35 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes on this rare Piano Quintet by Elgar in the A–Z here.
Bizet, Georges (1838-75)
Day 540: ‘L'Arlesienne’ - Suites Nos 1 and 2 (Time: 37 minutes)
Forget Ipanema, this short orchestral suite by Bizet is all about the Girl from Arles.
In fact, this selection forms part of 27 pieces of music which Bizet wrote for the staging of the play of the same name,
itself based on a short story by the Alphonse Daudet, which had appeared just a few years before, in the late 1860s.
For a detailed account, see the A–Z.
Haydn, Joseph (1732-1809)
Day 541: The Creation (Time: 37 minutes) <— Reminder: As always, you can click the piece title to listen on Youtube
You'll find full programme notes on Haydn's "The Creation" (1798) - our 541st playlist entry - here.
Brahms, Johannes (1833-97)
Day 542: Violin Sonata No 3 (Time: 21 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 542nd playlist entry here.
Fauré, Gabriel (1845-1924)
Day 543: Piano Trio (Time: 22 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 543rd playlist entry here.
Satie, Erik (1866-1925)
Day 544: Parade (Time: 15 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 544th playlist entry here.
Crotch, William (1775-1847)
Day 545: Symphony in F (Time: 24 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 545th playlist entry here.
Antheil, George (1900-59)
Day 546: Ballet Mecanique (Time: 15 minutes) and Jazz Sonata (Time: 2 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 546th playlist entry here.
Hol, Richard (1825-1904)
Day 547: Symphony No 1 in C Minor (Time: 24 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 547th playlist entry here.
Bach, Johann Sebastian (1685-1750)
Day 548: Italian Concerto (on harpsichord) (Time: 13 minutes) and Italian Concerto (on piano) (13 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 548th playlist entry here.
Orbón, Julián (1925-91)
Day 549: Tres Versiones Sinfonicas (Time: 22 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 549th playlist entry here.
Myaskovsky, Nikolai (1881-1950)
Day 550: Cello Sonata No 2 (Time: 21 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 550th playlist entry here.
Shostakovich, Dmitri (1906-75)
Day 551: Symphony No 1 (Time: 33 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 551st playlist entry here.
Coleridge-Taylor, Samuel (1875-1912)
Day 552: Clarinet Quintet (Time: 28 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 552nd playlist entry here.
Tchaikovsky, Boris (1925-96)
Day 553: Sinfonetta for String Orchestra (Time: 22 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 553rd playlist entry here.
Klami, Uuno (1900-61)
Day 554: Merikuvia (Sea Pictures) (Time: 24 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 554th playlist entry here.
Mozart, Wolfgang Amadeus (1756-91)
Day 555: Violin Sonata in E Minor, K304 (Time: 16 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 555th playlist entry here.
Chopin, Fryderyk (1810-49)
Day 556: Piano Trio (Time: 31 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 556th playlist entry here.
von Herzogenberg, Heinrich (1843-1900)
Day 557: Piano Quintet in C, Op 17 (Time: 29 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 557th playlist entry here.
Crusell, Bernhard (1775-1838)
Day 558: Clarinet Concerto No 2 in F Minor (Time: 24 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 558th playlist entry here.
Fibich, Zdeněk (1850-1900)
Day 559: Untitled (Time: 2 minutes), At Twilight, Op 39 (17 minutes) and Poème for Violin and Orchestra, Op 39a (arr. Kubelik) (4 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 559th playlist entry here.
Janáček, Leos (1854-1928)
Day 560: Lachian Dances (Time: 20 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 560th playlist entry here.
Berio, Luciano (1925-2003)
Day 561: Rendering (35 minutes)<— click here to listen on Youtube
You'll find full programme notes for our 561st playlist entry here.
Copland, Aaron (1900-90)
Day 562: Clarinet Concerto (Time: 16 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 562nd playlist entry here.
Schubert, Franz (1797-1828)
Day 563: String Quartet in D Minor, D810 (Time: 40 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 563rd playlist entry here.
Gounod, Charles-Francois (1818-93)
Day 564: Petite Symphonie for Winds (Time: 20 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 564th playlist entry here.
Sullivan, Arthur (1842-1900)
Day 565: Symphony in E ('Irish') (Time: 36 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 565th playlist entry here.
Moeran, Ernest (1894-1950)
Day 566: Symphony in G Minor (Time: 46 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 566th playlist entry here.
Hisaishi, Joe (b.1950)
Day 567: Merry-go-round of Life (from 'Howl's Moving Castle') (Time: 3 minutes), Viola Saga (movement 1) (12 minutes) and Viola Saga (movement 2) (10 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 567th playlist entry here.
Bristow, George Frederick (1825-98)
Day 568: Symphony No 2 ('Jullien') (Time: 44 minutes!)
You'll find full programme notes for our 568th playlist entry here.
Fibich, Zdeněk (1850-1900)
Day 569: Symphony No 2 (Time: 33 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 569th playlist entry here.
Bretón, Tomás (1850-1923)
Day 570: String Quartet No 3 - 1. Allegro comodo (Time: 10 minutes), 2. Andante (6 minutes), 3. Allegro no mucho (7 minutes) and 4. Allegro deciso (5 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 570th playlist entry here.
Hurlstone, William Yeates (1876-1906 )
Day 571: Fantaisie-Variations on a Swedish Air (Time: 37 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 571nd playlist entry - in your email inbox.
Mozart, Wolfgang Amadeus (1756-91)
Day 572: String Quintet in G Minor, K516 <— click here to listen on Youtube
You'll find full programme notes for our 572st playlist entry here.
Arriaga, Juan Crisótomos ... (1806-26)
Day 573: Symphony in D (Time: 28 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 573rd playlist entry here.
Grieg, Edvard (1843-1907)
Day 574: Piano Concerto (Time: 29 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 574th playlist entry here.
Gough, Orlando (b.1953)
Day 575: Birds on Fire [1] (Time: 6 minutes) and Birds on Fire [2] (8 mins) and Birds on Fire [3] (11 mins)
You'll find full programme notes for our 575th playlist entry here.
Villette, Pierre (1926-98)
Day 576: Hymne à la Vièrge Op 24, Ave Verum Corpus Op 3, Salve Regina Op 5 (Time: 11 minutes) and O Quam Amabilis es, Op 71(4 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 576th playlist entry here.
Sibelius, Jean (1865-1957)
Day 577: Violin Concerto (Time: 36 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 577th playlist entry here.
Dowland, John (1563-1626)
Day 578: Eight Pieces for Solo Lute (Time: 18 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 578th playlist entry here.
Suk, Josef (1874-1935)
Day 579: Piano Trio in C Minor, Op 2 (Time: 17 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 579th playlist entry here.
Britten, Benjamin (1913-76)
Day 580: Variations on a Theme of Frank Bridge (Time: 27 minutes) and Courtly Dances (from 'Gloriana') (11 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 580th playlist entry - in your email inbox.
Wiren, Dag (1905-86)
Day 581: Serenade for Strings (Time: 17 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 581st playlist entry here.
d’Indy, Vincent (1851-1931)
Day 582: Symphony on a French Mountain Air (Time: 27 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 582nd playlist entry here.
Schumann, Robert (1810-56)
Day 583: String Quartet Op 41 No 3 (Time: 31 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 583rd playlist entry here.
Danzi, Franz (1763-1826)
Day 584: Wind Quintet in Bb, Op 56 No 1 (Time: 13 minutes) and Quintet for Piano and Winds, Op 41 (25 mins)
You'll find full programme notes for our 584th playlist entry here.
Ravel, Maurice (1875-1937)
Day 585: Balero (Time: 14 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 585th playlist entry here.
Tchaikovsky, Pyotr Ilyich (1840-93)
Day 586: Symphony No 2 (Time: 35 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 586th playlist entry here.
Korngold, Erich (1897-1957)
Day 587: Piano Quintet, Op 15 (Time: 33 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 587th playlist entry here.
Day 588: Walton, William (1902-83)
Day 588: Piano Quartet (Time: 28 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 588th playlist entry here.
Brahms, Johannes (1833-97)
Day 589: Horn Trio in Eb, Op 40 (Time: 29 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 589th playlist entry here.
Sibelius, Jean (1865-1957)
Day 590: En Saga (chamber version reconstructed by Gregory Barrett) (Time: 24 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 590th playlist entry here.
COMING SOON to your inbox: DAYS 591–600
Bach, Johann Bernhard (1676-1749)
Day 591: Orchestral Suite No 3 in E Minor (Time: 23 minutes)<— click here to listen on Youtube
You'll find full programme notes for our 591st playlist entry - in your email inbox.
CCCCC, ffffff (17??-18??)
Day 592: piecetitle (Time: 37 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 592nd playlist entry - in your email inbox.
CCCCC, ffffff (17??-18??)
Day 593: coming soon (Time: 2? minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 593rd playlist entry - in your email inbox.
CCCCC, ffffff (17??-18??)
Day 594: coming soon (Time: 2? minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 594th playlist entry - in your email inbox.
CCCCC, ffffff (17??-18??)
Day 595: coming soon ... (Time: 2? minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 595th playlist entry - in your email inbox.
CCCCC, ffffff (17??-18??)
Day 596: piecetitle (Time: 2? minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 596th playlist entry - in your email inbox.
CCCCC, ffffff (17??-18??)
Day 597: coming soon (Time: 2? minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 597th playlist entry - in your email inbox.
CCCCC, ffffff (17??-18??)
Day 598: piecetitle (Time: 2? minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 598th playlist entry - in your email inbox.
CCCCC, ffffff (17??-18??)
Day 599: coming soon (Time: 2? minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 599th playlist entry - in your email inbox.
CCCCC, ffffff (18??-19??)
Day 600: piecetitle (Time: 18 minutes)
You'll find full programme notes for our 600th playlist entry - in your email inbox.
Recent additions to the A-Z can be found here.
|
|
|
Top
|